Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / Identity, Shame, and Racial Justice with Dr. Han Ren
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to Conversations with Nick Thompson.
- 0:06You may know me from Netflix Love is Blind, but on this podcast, we sit down with guests from all walks of life to hear their story, remove stigmas and uncover what makes them tick.
- 0:21Hello everyone and welcome to this week's episode of conversations with Nick Thompson.
- 0:25I'm your host, Nick Thompson.
- 0:27I've been thinking a lot about mental health lately with the holidays and my own personal experiences and journey coming in.
- 0:38It's been top of mind and I've been.
- 0:41really trying to learn a lot about myself, learn a lot about the stigma around mental health and wellness, more so than usual, I would say, as I dive into my own personal journey and evolving that and continuing that, but also the role that mental health plays in society.
- 1:02And being in the public eye, having a social media following, there's a lot of...
- 1:08scrutiny and there's a lot of challenges that come with being in the public eye.
- 1:16There's a lot of people that are keyboard warriors.
- 1:19They are cruel.
- 1:20They're cruel to each other.
- 1:23And it really came to fruition after gathering that social media following that
- 1:30One of the things that I really wanted to do was talk to some mental health professionals on the different types of mental health challenges that people are facing and some of the, uh, stigmas around more than just the top level.
- 1:48Let's talk about mental health.
- 1:50Okay.
- 1:50Well, we should talk about it more.
- 1:51Okay.
- 1:51Yeah.
- 1:52I agree a hundred percent.
- 1:54Um, and I think it's important that we share the way that we're feeling with our friends, with our family, with.
- 1:58Yeah.
- 1:59everyone so that we do normalize it.
- 2:01But as I've been working and talking with more people in this space on this podcast and in my personal life, I've really started to learn a lot more about the layers beneath the surface on mental health and what are some of the
- 2:21underlying causes.
- 2:23So Dr. Han came here as an immigrant when she was five years old and really had a lot of the normal mental health challenges that you have growing up when you're becoming a teenager, you're uncomfortable, you don't know who you are.
- 2:35But she also had to deal with some of the oppressed families.
- 2:40feelings that she would have being an immigrant.
- 2:43And really, as she grew older, and she'll talk about her mental health crisis as a teenager, but as she got older, she really started to realize that there are different types of mental health challenges that people with different identities tend to face.
- 2:58And I think we all probably on some level know that, but what she's really dedicated
- 3:10understand that the shame they feel based on sometimes their identity or their race isn't always going to be the same.
- 3:19What she wants to do is help people transfer that shame and really transfer that into a
- 3:27the pursuit of racial justice and end injustices.
- 3:31So she's an expert on integrating like anti-racism and self-care into mental health by understanding and helping others understand the role that their identity plays in their mental health and in their experience in society as a whole.
- 3:49After following her on TikTok,
- 3:52and seeing her Instagram reels.
- 3:55I really think that Dr. Han is doing outstanding work to decolonize mental health and really has a strong understanding of the psychology that comes from maybe being an immigrant or having a different identity or race than some of the other people in their life.
- 4:15So we're going to talk about...
- 4:17Her views, we're going to talk about what she's learned.
- 4:20We're going to talk about her personal experiences growing up as an immigrant.
- 4:24And we're going to talk a lot about the impacts of mental health and how we can all start to understand the impacts that someone's identity or race or origin story may have on mental health.
- 4:36And we're going to talk about ways that we can support one another.
- 4:40You can follow her on social media and she's really good at sort of breaking these down into layman's terms, but also has a content that's a little more dense and a little more understanding.
- 4:50But what I think Dr. Han's really good at is giving you a starting point to even start having this understanding or have these conversations because it's, it's not easy.
- 5:00It can be incredibly overwhelming.
- 5:02her lived experiences and her professional medical background, I think are a great combination to sort of bring these conversations together.
- 5:11So I hope you all enjoy this episode and we learn a little bit about the role someone's identity can play in their mental health and continue to have these important conversations.
- 5:21So we're removing stigmas around mental health and the different types of experiences people have and how it impacts them.
- 5:27So let's get to that show.
- 5:31Hello.
- 5:31Today I have Dr. Han Ren with us today.
- 5:34She is a licensed clinical and school psychologist, consultant, a public speaker who recently delivered a TEDx talk on transforming shame and guilt into the pursuit of racial justice.
- 5:47She's also partnered with Headspace and has a number of other talks that she's done.
- 5:52and publicly speaking.
- 5:53Additionally, Han is an educator of psychology, and she's focused on activism and enlightenment around connecting shame and guilt to racial injustices.
- 6:04Thank you for coming on the show today.
- 6:05How are you?
- 6:06I'm great.
- 6:07Thank you so much for having me, Nick.
- 6:09Yeah, thank you.
- 6:10I know we talked a little beforehand, but I've been listening to some of your work and recently started following you on social media as a recommendation, and it's really a...
- 6:21it's really a unique look at some of the ties that we have in our cultures and in our identities really that, um, you know, lead to shame and lead to these feelings of, of like inadequacy, I guess.
- 6:34So I'm really glad to have you on to talk about those today.
- 6:37Yeah.
- 6:38I'm, I'm so pleased to be here.
- 6:41I fangirling a little bit.
- 6:45There's no need for any of that.
- 6:48So what I like to do is kind of start off with a couple small talk questions.
- 6:53So first one I have for you is what is your favorite childhood TV show?
- 6:58Ooh, Full House.
- 7:02It was so wholesome.
- 7:03Oh, my God.
- 7:04Yes.
- 7:04Yeah.
- 7:05I used to go visit my dad.
- 7:08My parents are divorced, so I'd go visit my dad on Tuesdays.
- 7:11And when we were kids, it was always like, we got to be home by 7 for Full House.
- 7:14Yes, yes.
- 7:17I loved every episode had a lesson, a family moment.
- 7:22Kind of manufactured, but it was soothing to my childhood soul.
- 7:27I thought so too.
- 7:28You know what's funny though?
- 7:29Did you watch Fuller House?
- 7:31You know, I started and I couldn't get into it.
- 7:34Okay.
- 7:35The first season's rough.
- 7:36I totally nostalgia watched it.
- 7:38It became so self-aware of its ridiculous, contrived, like you said.
- 7:45So it was almost like a satire, I felt, as it went on.
- 7:49Oh, interesting.
- 7:51Yeah.
- 7:51Which was interesting because it had kind of some of the corny life lessons that you were alluding to.
- 7:56But then again, at the same time, it was like, well, it kind of knows it's being corny.
- 8:00So it's a little funny.
- 8:02Yeah.
- 8:02Or some adult jokes.
- 8:03Yeah.
- 8:04I might have to take another look.
- 8:06Yeah.
- 8:08So.
- 8:09One of the questions I like to ask people is what they wanted to be when they were growing up, but I heard through the grapevine that you wanted to be an astronaut.
- 8:16So I figured I would ask you if that's true, one.
- 8:20And then number two, why did you want to be an astronaut and when did you realize that wasn't your path?
- 8:27I, yes, I did want to be an astronaut.
- 8:30I just was always really into the idea of space, like vastness and the undefined and unexplored.
- 8:40I like the idea of floating in space.
- 8:43And then I realized.
- 8:44The things you love are the things that freak me out.
- 8:49I think it kind of freaked me out too, but like there was a little like the mystery of it, you know, the dark possibility.
- 8:57Um, but then I realized I'll probably be pretty lonely.
- 9:01Like just go into space instead of, you know, having friends and family and community here on earth.
- 9:10So, and also I didn't really love, you know, I took an astronomy class in college and I was like, Ooh, this is not it.
- 9:16Like I thought it was only my constellations.
- 9:17No, it's all physics.
- 9:18Yeah.
- 9:19it's all physics yeah well hey with the way we're trending maybe you can ride one of the uh the billionaires little fun trips fun trip ships up into space and pretend to be an astronaut for a few minutes yeah yeah maybe i'll do the plane where like does like the nose drop you know for like 10 seconds like i think that's that's about as deep into space as i want to go
- 9:43I think I'll stick to here in Chicago.
- 9:45They don't have it anymore.
- 9:46We have Six Flags Great America, which you probably know Six Flags.
- 9:49They had a – it was kind of virtual reality, but it wasn't.
- 9:54It was maybe more like an IMAX experience called Space Shuttle America, and it was just this immersive trip into space, and I think that's about the extent of my space travels already.
- 10:07I mean, that sounds fun too.
- 10:08Yeah.
- 10:09Yeah, exactly.
- 10:11So I hear you also are a fellow lover of black coffee.
- 10:15So I wanted to ask you, how do you like your coffee?
- 10:18Do you drink ice?
- 10:19Do you drink cold brew?
- 10:20Do you drink black?
- 10:21And what's your favorite?
- 10:23I really just love a black coffee in the mornings.
- 10:28And I will take a cold brew, but I'd like some oat milk in my cold brew.
- 10:32So it's no longer black if I'm drinking a cold brew.
- 10:35I don't know why.
- 10:35It's just something about it being cold.
- 10:39And there's a local...
- 10:41I guess it's like a roaster in Austin called Greater Goods.
- 10:45That's really good.
- 10:46And I recently discovered this coffee subscription on Drink Trade where you get like a new coffee shipment every month.
- 10:56Really?
- 10:56And what's that called?
- 10:57Drink Trade?
- 10:58Drink Trade.
- 10:59Yeah.
- 10:59And it's like different like kind of craft roasters.
- 11:02And you can, you know, get like different durations of subscriptions.
- 11:07That's very cool.
- 11:08We have, um, have you ever been to Chicago?
- 11:11No.
- 11:11Yeah, I grew up in Michigan, so I would go to Chicago quite often.
- 11:16Okay.
- 11:18That's something that's so cool about Chicago.
- 11:20And I know it's like this in a lot of cities, but we have so many small little roasters, little coffee shops.
- 11:26And there's this new one that opened up by me that I really like.
- 11:31They just bring in, like, all these different little cafes.
- 11:34And so they'll have, like, different types of coffee, different type of pastries.
- 11:37And it's just almost like this community that they're building in the neighborhood of different pastry shops, different coffee shops, different roasters.
- 11:45And it's so cool.
- 11:45Oh, I love that.
- 11:47It's like an eclectic, like, try something new place.
- 11:50Yeah.
- 11:51Yeah.
- 11:51That's exactly it.
- 11:52Yeah.
- 11:54So I already know the answer to this, but I thought it was funny.
- 11:58It gave me a chuckle.
- 11:59What type of dancer would you consider yourself?
- 12:01Oh, hella awkward.
- 12:03Offbeat.
- 12:05Awkward.
- 12:06Someone once told me that I have rhythm like a pine tree has strawberries.
- 12:11Ooh.
- 12:15That is still more than I have, though.
- 12:19into it you know like when I started a tick tock I thought like that's what you had to do on the platform like you just you had to dance in order to like do anything there and I'm like well I guess I'm gonna do this and it was it was fun it was just like not taking myself too seriously and just getting silly and moving my body and learning trying to learn you know something coordinated and laughing during it
- 12:46So were you hopping on the trends and stuff too?
- 12:49I mean, they're just silly.
- 12:50And I would always put some sort of psychological facts or tidbits over it in the print that goes over it.
- 12:59But it was just a fun thing that I did for a while.
- 13:02I haven't done any dance trends in quite some time.
- 13:06You know, I'm on TikTok now, and it's literally this week I signed up for a TikTok.
- 13:12I have like 15 followers.
- 13:13Welcome, welcome.
- 13:14Yeah.
- 13:16I, in 2020, like went on TikTok, and all I saw was people dancing.
- 13:21Okay.
- 13:21And it was like, this is so like a, this is the first time I'm noticing like Gen Z being different than millennials.
- 13:31Yeah.
- 13:31But then as you, you like go through it, it's like so many people are on it and taking advantage of these trends.
- 13:38I don't know if taking advantage is the right word, but like getting on there, it's like, I think it can be kind of fun.
- 13:43Yeah.
- 13:43Yeah.
- 13:44I mean, it really started off as like a pandemic boredom buster thing for me that, you know, kind of took on a life of its own.
- 13:53Yeah.
- 13:54So then I've got my last small talk question for you here is what do you prefer, TikTok or Instagram and why?
- 14:02Yeah.
- 14:02Ooh, you know, that's such a great question.
- 14:07I think these days I prefer Instagram.
- 14:10My audience on Instagram is older, a little more psychologically minded.
- 14:16There's less trolls on Instagram for me.
- 14:21And I also feel like
- 14:24Because you can write longer captions and the comments aren't so wonky, it's more conducive to building a community.
- 14:31And then things I post get surfaced to my followers more consistently.
- 14:37Whereas TikTok, if you're not posting every day, the algorithm punishes you.
- 14:42But then there's some times where you really hit it big there and the algorithm takes you to the moon.
- 14:48So it's less consistent there and it just seems more like...
- 14:53off the cuff silly there where I feel like there's more engagement for me anyways on Instagram.
- 14:59I think that makes sense.
- 15:00So you're convincing me to just get back off of TikTok as quick as
- 15:07There's benefits to both.
- 15:10I think the thing with TikTok for me is you can't just copy exactly what you do on other social media platforms.
- 15:20And to your point, I like the engagement that I get on Instagram.
- 15:24And I agree there's...
- 15:27And this is, I shouldn't say I agree.
- 15:29I assume there's more like-minded people that are engaging with me and my message on Instagram.
- 15:35But then again, it's like you want something to take off on the algorithm on TikTok because that can skyrocket your content, your message, or whatever that is.
- 15:44And that is a whole new audience that you may not reach on Instagram.
- 15:48For sure.
- 15:49Yeah.
- 15:50half a one, six of one, half a dozen of the other type of thing.
- 15:54Yeah, yeah.
- 15:55The audience has to be a little bit younger on TikTok.
- 15:58And like, but, you know, all of my most like kind of vitriolic things on social media have sprung off of TikTok.
- 16:08So, you know, I definitely have kind of a love-hate relationship with it.
- 16:13Makes sense.
- 16:15So with that, you have a very successful TikTok, you have a growing Instagram account, and you have a really good message that you're sharing.
- 16:25But where did all of this come from?
- 16:27Who were you growing up besides an aspiring astronaut?
- 16:31And you grew up in Michigan, but why don't you tell us a little bit about what you were like and how you discovered your passion in psychology and racial identity?
- 16:41Yeah.
- 16:41So I was actually, I was born in Shanghai, China, and I immigrated to the U.S. when I was five.
- 16:48And my parents had immigrated before when I was two, so I didn't have any memory of them when I came to the U.S. My grandparents raised me.
- 16:58And then when I came to the U.S., my grandparents didn't have a visa, so they couldn't come to the U.S. And I...
- 17:03basically moved in with these strangers who I had no memory of.
- 17:07Um, and it was a lot of that like immigration trauma.
- 17:09They were trying to make ends meet.
- 17:11My dad was a grad student.
- 17:12They, you know, my parents were actually going through a pretty contentious divorce at the time.
- 17:16And there was a lot of like attachment disruption in my youth that made me feel like this isn't normal.
- 17:22Like growing up shouldn't feel like this.
- 17:25And I just remember being very fearful and, um, you know,
- 17:31really shameful growing up.
- 17:32Everything felt like such a...
- 17:36heaviness and I couldn't take up space and you know just getting through life from that kind of start really made me super curious about the mind and relationships and psychology and and I think like a lot of therapists whether they admit it or not do come to this field as a way to better understand themselves their families and their own you know origin stories and so I
- 18:02When I had the opportunity to, you know, choose my major in college, I knew that this was something that was really fascinating to me.
- 18:09And I wanted to better understand myself, my family, and also help other people who may have had similar kind of racial identity development pathways and immigration stories.
- 18:20And, you know, just trying to make sense of who they are in this world when your early years are so fractured.
- 18:27Can I ask why your parents didn't bring you when you were two?
- 18:30There was a visa issue.
- 18:32Like back then, policy did not allow grad students to bring their children.
- 18:37They did allow to bring their partners, but it wasn't even at the same time.
- 18:42So my dad immigrated and then my mom immigrated maybe a year later.
- 18:46And then they had to really fight and advocate for policy change for grad students to bring their children.
- 18:53And so there's a lot of, there's a generation of these, like, satellite kids, whether, you know, they were born in the U.S. and then sent back to China to be raised by extended family members and then, like, coming back to join the parents when they were, you know, seven, eight, whatever.
- 19:07Or, in my situation, born in China and then were able to immigrate later.
- 19:10And clearly there's not, you know...
- 19:14vast knowledge of attachment issues and how that can lead to some psychological problems later on.
- 19:23And it's a very normalized thing within Chinese culture and a lot of Asian cultures.
- 19:30So that was going to be my next question.
- 19:31When you were, excuse me, when you were a young child or kind of starting to realize, hey, you know, you mentioned I'm not supposed to feel this way.
- 19:39I don't think being a kid is supposed to feel this way.
- 19:42Was there any community that you were able to find within, you know, the Asian culture or any type of culture where you could talk about these things as a teenager or whenever that was to really sort of like normalize it and realize, hey, I'm not the only one.
- 19:56You know, not really.
- 19:58I knew that, like, my friends had other, like, similar kind of immigration stories.
- 20:04But, like, I think mine was particularly dramatic because of this prolonged separation multiple times.
- 20:13And there's also so much shame and stigma in my culture around mental health.
- 20:20And around talking about mental health at all, there's so much desire to save face.
- 20:25And so it was, you know, not a conversation that people were used to having.
- 20:30So, you know, when I was a teenager, like I did go through kind of a mental health crisis at that time, which really propelled me into getting therapy and like, you know, actually pursuing some healing in a more traditional way.
- 20:45route, I guess.
- 20:47But it was because of a crisis point and not because of a normalization within our community.
- 20:55Oh my God.
- 20:55Well, I'm sorry to hear that you had that experience.
- 20:58Do you, was there a trigger to the crisis?
- 21:01Do you want to share anything about anything that someone might listen to and be like, oh my gosh, I've been there.
- 21:06I can relate to that.
- 21:08Yeah, I mean, starting high school was really rough, right?
- 21:11When you're trying to figure out who you are, your identity, in a new environment, you're trying to fit in.
- 21:18And then just not really feeling like I had that family support or social support to be able to do the things that my friends were allowed to do.
- 21:27My parents were pretty strict and kind of traditional in that way.
- 21:31And a lot of high pressure around achievement and grades.
- 21:36So all of that really kind of came to a head in my ninth grade year where I was like, I don't, I can't do this anymore.
- 21:42It's just really hard.
- 21:45Was this something, so the culture and the achievements and the getting good grades, where does that come from within the culture?
- 21:54Is it, is it like we were immigrants, we have to come and live the, you know, American dream or is it, is it something that just travels in the culture?
- 22:03Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 22:04I mean, yeah.
- 22:05emphasis on education is a really big part of the Asian American experience.
- 22:11And I think a big part of it is that that was the meal ticket out for a lot of East Asian immigrants anyways, you know, like Chinese, you know, Korean.
- 22:22One of the most common pathways was getting a grad school visa and then like coming here for grad school or like H-1B work visa and like,
- 22:32You know, kind of like the brain drain of immigration.
- 22:35And so the children of immigrants really grew up with that hardcore emphasis on education, achievement, hard work, success.
- 22:46And, you know, I've always said, like, every immigration story is a trauma story, because even if you like make it in the new land, you have to leave so much behind and you have to give
- 22:57up so much of who you were in order to survive in this new place.
- 23:02So the values that are really passed down to children of immigrants prioritize that of achievement, education, and hard work.
- 23:11And I have kind of like that 1.5 generation experience where, you know, I was born in China, but then really grew up here, where like, I was very much bicultural in that way, having,
- 23:27Right.
- 23:29And were you not allowed to talk about your challenges with your family before you had your your crisis point?
- 23:35I mean, I wouldn't say I wasn't allowed to talk about it, but I don't think I was heard, you know, and it was really looking back on it now.
- 23:43It's like they did the best they could with what they had and what they knew.
- 23:48And there's a lot of, you know, with the stigma, there's a lot of.
- 23:52I'm.
- 23:53more normalization of talking about somatic complaints.
- 23:56Oh, you have a stomachache.
- 23:57You're so tired.
- 23:58You're throwing up.
- 24:00Those physical health complaints were a lot more paid attention to and attuned to than any sort of mental health complaints.
- 24:10Mental health complaints.
- 24:10It's like you can see it.
- 24:12Yeah, yeah.
- 24:13And like, I mean, that permeates, you know, through Western culture as well.
- 24:17But it also just had the additional layer of like shame and stigma to like have any sort of mental health differences.
- 24:25It just meant like, oh my gosh, you're crazy.
- 24:27You need to be institutionalized.
- 24:28You know, there was no gradient and there was so much shame.
- 24:33Like, don't bring shame on the family to like admit that you have any challenges like that.
- 24:37Like, what would people think?
- 24:39Yeah, that is, I think that is so detrimental and I can imagine it being even more detrimental in, in your community, as you've said, having to basically start life over.
- 24:52So let's go.
- 24:53I'm curious to go back to your going into college.
- 24:58You realize psychology is where you want to go.
- 25:00I think your inspiration is.
- 25:05why don't you tell us your inspiration instead of I sum it up from what you've said already?
- 25:09What was your, your true inspiration?
- 25:12Yeah.
- 25:12I mean, I knew that my life path was unusual.
- 25:17Um, and I also felt really stifled in not having the freedom to name it.
- 25:22And especially as, you know, a Chinese American person and you look, almost,
- 25:27my early therapists were all white.
- 25:29Like this was not a field where there's a lot of representation, you know?
- 25:33And so I really thought about like, how cool would it be to be able to help other people who had similar experiences and really understand myself enough to be able to share this with others and normalize it.
- 25:49And that was really a huge motivator for me was to bring the normalization
- 25:58I think that's such a noble cause.
- 26:00And in general, like, I don't understand.
- 26:04And I'm guilty, right?
- 26:05Like, I never really talked about it until a few years ago.
- 26:09Like, no one knew my challenges.
- 26:12My family didn't know.
- 26:13No one knew.
- 26:14So I think...
- 26:16when you have an entire culture or entire society or entire community suffering from that, like you need to, first, I always say you need to name it number one, because otherwise it's just ambiguous.
- 26:27Ooh, that's good.
- 26:28I might steal that.
- 26:30So I think that's such an important thing.
- 26:34message that you're able to bring to the community and just in general, right?
- 26:38Because it extends into other types of community, other type of cultures, other types of people with different identities, I guess.
- 26:46So you talk a lot about shame and guilt.
- 26:51perfectionism, people pleasing.
- 26:53I think you've given a good background of where that comes from.
- 26:58What role do shame and guilt play within not just your culture, but the broader as well?
- 27:07I mean, I think shame and guilt are two of the most misunderstood moral, social emotions.
- 27:15They're also two of the most uncomfortable and stifling ones.
- 27:21Like, we just crumble into this vortex when we experience shame.
- 27:26And, you know, when we talk about it more emotionally,
- 27:30when we talk about it more these days, it's still in the context of like, well, let's get rid of this feeling rather than let's understand why we experience this.
- 27:37What can we connect this to our survival, the adaptive functions of having these emotions to our survival in groups and communities and then better understand the messages that these feelings can show us.
- 27:56Right.
- 27:56Right.
- 27:57which is really like moral development, conscious development, learning how to, you know, abide by the values of a group, which could absolutely be super protective to our sense of belonging and acceptance and finding our people.
- 28:14But also, you know, kind of stifling if elements that we feel this shame about or made to feel shameful about are not elements that we can change or that we,
- 28:28really feel is aligned to who we are when it comes to elements like identity.
- 28:34Yeah.
- 28:35Do you want to talk a little bit about identity?
- 28:38Like what's the role that you've seen identity play in shame and guilt and in mental health?
- 28:45Yeah, I mean, I think identity and just being more, you know, proud or like naming the elements of your identity has certainly taken, have had more like spotlight in the recent years.
- 29:01And I think it absolutely does shape the way that we experience the world because these features of our identity, you know, has...
- 29:13like axes of power, right?
- 29:14There's certain identities or certain like ends of the continuum of whichever identity factor you're talking about, like gender, race, sexuality, whatever it may be, there's a more traditional, conventionally accepted, you know,
- 29:28more held power element of it, and then elements that have less power.
- 29:33And then the way that you experience the world very much depends on these different axes and intersectionalities of identity that you carry.
- 29:42That's your positionality in the world, how people view you.
- 29:47And because of that, people are not treated
- 29:50equally and people don't have access to the same resources and the same rights and privileges.
- 29:56And we are definitely seeing that with policy of whole groups of people who are not
- 30:02being allowed the same rights for certain elements of their identity that are not even something they are choosing.
- 30:10That's why I, yeah, go ahead.
- 30:15So, I mean, just that, like, we can't talk about mental health in kind of this more systemic way without talking about the role of identity.
- 30:25Yeah.
- 30:26And I've noticed just from, I mean, literally from friends, from Uber drivers, from interactions like this, the role that identity plays in mental health, it is not really talked about.
- 30:42And I've had a couple of guests on where this has come up on a much lighter tone.
- 30:47And it's been in one of the reasons I thought when when Liz introduced us and told me I should talk to you about this.
- 30:55Like that was one of the things I was like, oh, this is kind of like a nice triangulation of some of these conversations.
- 30:59And I don't really know.
- 31:01I mean, I'm a.
- 31:03I'm a white guy.
- 31:04I have, of course, my own stuff, but you kind of have to learn the privilege that just comes with naturally having white skin in America.
- 31:18It is, you know, I think that documentary is called like the 13th or whatever that talks about like systemic racism and slavery to the prison, all that stuff.
- 31:28And that was an enlightening moment for me.
- 31:31And there's so many layers to this that people don't know.
- 31:36And I don't think it's from a bad place.
- 31:38And I don't think like...
- 31:41I don't think a white person should feel shame if they're trying to understand and be better.
- 31:48Mm-hmm.
- 31:49But how do you navigate that?
- 31:52Mm-hmm.
- 31:53Mm-hmm.
- 31:54And I don't know if that's even a fair question to ask you, but I'm like, how do you recommend people navigate all of the role that identity plays?
- 32:01Because it's such a dense topic.
- 32:03It's so difficult.
- 32:04It does range, I think, from culture to culture, too.
- 32:06Mm-hmm.
- 32:08Yeah.
- 32:09Gosh, so many layers to unpack here.
- 32:13You know, I think not knowing is absolutely a privilege.
- 32:17Not knowing is because you don't have to know.
- 32:20You haven't had the experiences of knowing.
- 32:23you know, discrimination, bias, or oppression because of these identities that you carry.
- 32:29So, like, going through life and not knowing is absolutely a luxury for a lot of folks.
- 32:34And then, like, once you start knowing, it can feel so icky, right?
- 32:39Like, oh, my God, like, people are experiencing something so different from me and based on factors that they don't.
- 32:46Couldn't even control or choose.
- 32:49Wow.
- 32:49It's so unjust and unfair.
- 32:51And then a lot of people feel this deep shame about that.
- 32:57And I think that's where people maybe exit this realm of work because it's so uncomfortable.
- 33:03They don't want to interrogate it.
- 33:04They're like, this is too hard.
- 33:06I don't want to make me feel guilty.
- 33:07guilty about who I am but I think it's so important to remember that who you are your identity as a person is a separate construct than these identity characteristics so like you are a white male but you are more than a white person and you're more than a male person and the right
- 33:30are not with the identity elements, but the systems of power and oppression that are associated that grant people inherent privilege.
- 33:40So patriarchy, white supremacy.
- 33:42You know, being a white person is very different than whiteness.
- 33:46And that is an element that's very hard for people to separate.
- 33:50And I think that really speaks to how big these constructs are.
- 33:54Like, okay, who am I if I'm not...
- 33:57a male, right?
- 33:58Like if I'm male, but you know, how do I separate the maleness from who I am?
- 34:03But you're also way more than a male.
- 34:07Right.
- 34:08And I think the way you said the shame, like I, I, I feel that shame.
- 34:15I have, I have experienced,
- 34:18And seen close friends and in some cases even family experience racism.
- 34:25And it's sometimes like this subtle thing too where you don't even really realize it's happening because it seems so subtle.
- 34:35In a sense, microaggressive micro quote unquote.
- 34:38Yeah.
- 34:38Every day.
- 34:39It's common.
- 34:40Right.
- 34:40Not that it's not harmful.
- 34:42It's so it's so like it is a little like I feel a little shame when I don't ever have to worry about that.
- 34:49And in a sense, it's like, how how could someone like me learn more or.
- 34:58Be a better ally.
- 35:00Yeah.
- 35:01And not just the mental health and talking about it and destigmatizing it.
- 35:05That's super important.
- 35:06But just how can someone learn more and be an ally?
- 35:12Yeah, I mean, there's so many great books out now about, you know, how to be an anti-racist, right?
- 35:19That's a book.
- 35:21But there's so many great pieces of literature and, you know, knowledge that are written by black and brown folks about this construct and, you know, ways that people can practice allyship and anti-racism.
- 35:39And like anti-oppressive things.
- 35:41you know, praxis in general.
- 35:44And then, like, getting to know people, like, actually getting to know people who are different than you.
- 35:49Like, most white people don't have friends of color.
- 35:53And I think that's pretty mind-boggling, you know?
- 35:55Like...
- 35:56forming true relationships where you are in community and there's reciprocity and you're sharing food and time and laughter.
- 36:05That's a great way to adopt the humanity and the causes of people who are different from you.
- 36:14Those are just some small and yet important ways to start.
- 36:19Yeah.
- 36:19No, I think that's outstanding.
- 36:21And I know for me personally, like I, and this is really, really amplified after, you know, my experience on Love is Blind is there's this core element of us all being human beings that is just lost.
- 36:38And it gives people an opportunity to...
- 36:41act in, uh, be a racist and it gives people opportunity to be cruel and mean and hurtful towards people.
- 36:49And I, I think like we're in a state right now where there's, it's, this is going to be a, this is a stigmatizing topic.
- 36:56This is going to be a stigmatizing podcast.
- 36:59It's going to upset some people and that's going to be triggering.
- 37:02It's going to be triggering and yeah, it's supposed to be uncomfortable.
- 37:08Exactly.
- 37:09Exactly.
- 37:09And that's the kind of discussions that I, for one, like to have because I want to remove stigmas and I want to empower people to be the best versions of themselves.
- 37:18And so how do we normalize this?
- 37:21Like, do I go talk to my my ethnic friends?
- 37:25Do I do I sit down and and actually ask them these tough questions or is that going to be triggering?
- 37:33You know, this is a great question because I think a lot of times, you know, white people who are friends with folks of color are like, oh, I don't want to put them in, like, a weird spot.
- 37:45And, like, you know, certainly don't ask them for labor, right?
- 37:50Don't be like, hey, can you teach me?
- 37:52Yeah.
- 37:52But...
- 37:54Do ask them about their experiences because I guarantee you they are very well aware of the differences of their lived experiences versus yours.
- 38:05And just because race has never come up in your friendship and in your dynamic does not mean that they are so comfortable with it or just unaware of it.
- 38:14I guarantee you they are aware of it already and maybe don't feel the psychological safety to bring it up or don't know how you will respond to it.
- 38:23For a lot of us, we don't want to take on that extra labor of dealing with fragility.
- 38:28I'm going to bring something up about our differences in race, and someone's going to start crying.
- 38:32I have to make them feel better.
- 38:33No, thank you.
- 38:35So the fact that you want to bring it up is a great thing, but bringing it up in a way that can be...
- 38:42from a place of curiosity and support and like, I want to learn and, you know, I will read the things.
- 38:49You don't have to educate me, like, but I would love to talk about this with you and find out how it aligns with your experience and, you know, what are some other things that I can do to like,
- 39:02better know how it is to be you.
- 39:05And then from there, I think, you know, we're so great on, like, diversity and, like, adding tradition in.
- 39:12And we're, like, you know, increasing our, like, experiences of traditions.
- 39:15Like, oh, we're going to celebrate Diwali now.
- 39:17It's Chinese New Year, right?
- 39:18Like, being very, like, kind of performative about, like, culture.
- 39:21That's exactly what it is.
- 39:22It's performative.
- 39:24Right?
- 39:24It's performative.
- 39:25Oh, I'm putting on these, like...
- 39:27Clothe, right?
- 39:28Right.
- 39:29But the most important part is how can you interrogate your own experiences to take the white supremacy out of your relationships and your interactions?
- 39:40And, like, learning, like, well, what does that mean?
- 39:42You know, what is white supremacy?
- 39:44Like, reading up on white supremacy cultural values and how they show up in day-to-day interactions and, you know, doing your best to...
- 39:54Notice that in your life and the places where you do experience privilege so you can feel gratitude and speak out against Oppressive practices and you know on for people who are with people who may experience more oppression
- 40:13What kind of role do you think that plays in the workspace or maybe outside of your friend group?
- 40:23Because I've had experiences I can imagine that that's a very difficult place to navigate.
- 40:31For sure.
- 40:33And, you know, I do do a lot of workplace, you know, corporate ERG types of talks around, you know, either Asian American mental health or like, you know, BIPOC mental health or, you know, anti-racism more broadly and just, you know, the equity inclusion work.
- 40:51Right.
- 40:53I think it really boils down to a top-down process.
- 40:59Like, is the leadership on board?
- 41:02Are they going to actually support policy changes that make their hiring practices, promotion practices more equitable, that calls out microaggressions and doesn't normalize it or sweep it under the rug,
- 41:23you know, traditionally, culturally, like, extroverted, gregarious, like, beat your own drum kind of ways.
- 41:29Like, these are the practices that are essential for actually having more equitable diversity, justice, inclusion in the workplace.
- 41:39Otherwise, it's all performative, which, like, you know, for some folks, like, that's still a step, right?
- 41:44You're still learning, you have some knowledge, at least, you know, even if you're not choosing not to practice.
- 41:48It's naming it, in a sense.
- 41:49Yeah, it's naming it.
- 41:51And that's a start.
- 41:54Yeah.
- 41:54Yeah, I think, you know,
- 41:57It's so easy for a company or an organization or whatever to come out and say, we are now doing diversity and inclusion.
- 42:09Oh, cool.
- 42:10Great.
- 42:10And then the average person is like, great.
- 42:12I want to work at a company that has that as a key value and a key focus.
- 42:16But again, it can be very performative.
- 42:19It's not actually...
- 42:24fundamentally doing policy changes or fundamentally driving actual awareness outside of, you know, the, the one sentence summary or the advertisement, or I like to say, throw it on a billboard, call it a day type of thing.
- 42:39So when you find organizations, and I don't want you to throw any of them under the bus, are there any that you've interacted with in your time, and you don't have to name them, I'm just curious, that really were just kind of putting on a performance?
- 42:53And you're coming in and you're sharing real, tangible information, tangible recommendations, and...
- 43:02It's more than they were looking for, I guess.
- 43:04Yeah.
- 43:05And I mean, I think, you know, to some degree, every organization is going to be imperfect in their implementation.
- 43:12And that's just part of the work.
- 43:16I think it's really helpful for me to know the transparency of it, right?
- 43:21Like, are you doing this because it's Asian Mental Health Month or Asian Pacific Heritage Month?
- 43:27It also happens to be Mental Health Awareness Month.
- 43:29Like, that's a very busy month for me.
- 43:31Yeah.
- 43:32And like you're just kind of checking the box or like are you bringing us in to talk about anti-oppressive, anti-racist praxis because you know that you should talk, you should learn about this from a person of color and you just want like information but you don't actually want follow up or, you know, ongoing consultation around implementation, you know, and how much money are you willing to invest in that, right?
- 43:59Exactly.
- 44:00And the irony of that is they're then coming to you for your identity to come and teach them about how they need to look past someone's identity.
- 44:07Yeah.
- 44:08Yeah.
- 44:08Yeah.
- 44:09Yeah.
- 44:10And again, like there's there is a little bit of an ick factor there.
- 44:14But it's also like when I think about it and I zoom out like, OK, this gets the conversation going and this.
- 44:22just builds more awareness, which is a step.
- 44:24But, you know, it's the dialectics of knowing that incremental change will never be enough.
- 44:30And incremental change is better than no change.
- 44:33So here we are.
- 44:35That's a good point.
- 44:36Yeah.
- 44:36That is a good point.
- 44:38So you talked about the four stages of learning in...
- 44:42one of your talks that I listened to.
- 44:44How do you implement that in your work to help educate, train, and teach people about really oppression?
- 44:55Yeah.
- 44:56I mean, we don't know what we don't know.
- 44:58And that's like the very first stage of learning.
- 45:00And this, you know, stages of learning can be applied to learning any new skill.
- 45:04When at the very beginning it is the, what is it?
- 45:09Unconscious incompetence all the way to unconscious competence, where you are just very naturally going about practicing this like second nature.
- 45:20People who have, you know,
- 45:22They feel like the 10,000 hour rule or whatever people who have really honed their skill and whatever it is It becomes second nature muscle memory and there's a wide range in between and I like to first like normalize that everybody is
- 45:38at a different stage, and everybody was a beginner or is a beginner.
- 45:43And the most important part is not like, oh, I have arrived.
- 45:47It's to be honest about where you are in this journey, so you don't tap out.
- 45:52I think the thing with anti-racism and anti-oppression is there are so many currents and waterfalls that push you downstream and you kind of have to swim upstream with it.
- 46:04That's a good point.
- 46:05Just easy to be like, you know what?
- 46:08Forget it.
- 46:08I'm just gonna, you know, tap out.
- 46:10And like, rest is important.
- 46:13Tap out for a minute, but tap out, get your bearings, and then tap back in.
- 46:17And knowing that like, it's okay if you haven't arrived.
- 46:20Most people haven't.
- 46:21I haven't arrived.
- 46:22But like, this is a lifelong, ongoing developmental practice.
- 46:28And it's also something that we have to do in community.
- 46:31you know, just the individuation or the individualization exceptionalism.
- 46:37Like those are such white supremacy cultural values.
- 46:39Like you aren't, you don't get a gold star.
- 46:41You don't get to like be special and do it by yourself.
- 46:44Like you have to do it with others and also know your why.
- 46:49Like, are you doing it so you can seem less racist?
- 46:51Like that's.
- 46:52actually not really going to further the cause, right?
- 46:54You got to do it because you realize that your liberation is tied up in everybody else's and, you know, all flourishing is mutual.
- 47:03Yeah, I think it's such a difficult area for a lot of people to navigate.
- 47:07Because I do genuinely believe the majority of people want to understand.
- 47:14They want to be really more inclusive.
- 47:19They look at their community of friends.
- 47:22Even if they watch the news and they see the most atrocious things that happen, it's just...
- 47:28People don't know how.
- 47:30They don't know where to start.
- 47:32And I think what you said is you don't know what you don't know.
- 47:36And it's scary.
- 47:37And it's a scary thing to think about how an entire culture can have this type of injustice, for lack of a better word.
- 47:50Yeah.
- 47:51I mean, start by reading.
- 47:53Read the 1619 Project and learn about the history of the nation.
- 47:59Read How to Be an Anti-Racist.
- 48:01So you want to talk about race.
- 48:03Do the Me and White Supremacy workbook.
- 48:07Like, there's so many great resources out there.
- 48:10And then from there, know that the shame, guilt, racism,
- 48:16discomfort and like, ooh, this is overwhelming and too much.
- 48:20That's normal.
- 48:22That's part of the process.
- 48:23That means you're doing it right.
- 48:25It is meant to be challenging to interrogate your privilege no matter what identities you hold.
- 48:32Yeah.
- 48:33And this is something that for people of color to do, too, because so many of us have so much internalized oppression, internalized white supremacy.
- 48:41Look at the skin bleaching creams all over the shelves of China, for example.
- 48:46Right.
- 48:46Like there's so much of this in a global context.
- 48:51you know, we are not alone with it.
- 48:54And we don't have to just accept that, okay, this is hopeless.
- 49:00But we also don't have to try to change it all overnight either.
- 49:04It's a process and it is meant to be uncomfortable.
- 49:11Yeah, I think there's a... And maybe you can, you know, comment on this.
- 49:17I feel like there is such a...
- 49:21a discomfort with being uncomfortable.
- 49:24And that is, that is the, I have it.
- 49:29I'm guilty as charged on a lot of things.
- 49:31Like I, you know, I talk with, with Liz, I am avoidant.
- 49:36I now know that I need to, you know, I need to work on that.
- 49:39Um, continue to work on that.
- 49:41But like, there's just such a, a level of, um,
- 49:45with being uncomfortable.
- 49:46And what role do you think that plays in kind of slowing down the process or even, you know, people being comfortable talking about it or starting somewhere, you know, even buying that book or buying that workbook?
- 49:59It's because it is a journey.
- 50:00So like, what role do you think the discomfort plays in all of this?
- 50:03Huge.
- 50:04Our society has really emphasized that, like, okay, it's negative to have certain emotions or to experience pain or strife.
- 50:13And, like, we have really made it a goal to just be, like, happy and productive and successful all the time.
- 50:21And, you know, from, like, fairy tales about happily ever after to, you know, these nice things.
- 50:28try it like, oh, we tied a bow on it and everything was resolved.
- 50:32Like, you know, we don't normalize that discomfort is a part of growth and it's not inherently bad.
- 50:40And emotions that are hard and uncomfortable, like anger, grief, sadness, those are all just data points.
- 50:48They're information.
- 50:49They're not inherently bad or negative.
- 50:51It's just uncomfortable.
- 50:53But even within mental health, we have labeled them like negative emotions.
- 50:58They're not negative.
- 50:59And so just the way we talk about all of this stuff really encourages people to bypass the discomfort and to just be like, ah, I have arrived.
- 51:08And that leads to so many problems because we don't really understand, like, what are we doing?
- 51:13Why are we doing it?
- 51:14And, you know, like what's like the inside out reasons versus the, you know, I want to be accepted and approved and look cool.
- 51:23So, you know, that plus like sense of urgency, we're like, okay, we resolve it really quickly and want to get there fast, you know, always moving forward, bigger, better.
- 51:32You know, it's this capitalistic viewpoints, too, that also harms true growth, which is iterative and nonlinear and slow.
- 51:44I'm glad you brought up the capitalistic thing because I felt like we were circling around it.
- 51:50Yeah.
- 51:51What role do you feel?
- 51:53I mean, so I'll be fully transparent.
- 51:57I am recently unemployed.
- 52:00I am going through a lot of the things you just described myself of...
- 52:05I don't have...
- 52:09I have a little imposter syndrome, right?
- 52:11I'm like, what am I supposed to be doing?
- 52:13I did everything I was supposed to do, and now I'm sitting here.
- 52:17I don't have health insurance as of yesterday.
- 52:19I don't have...
- 52:21Sorry, Nick.
- 52:22No, no, that's okay.
- 52:24But the point of that is...
- 52:27I don't feel productive sometimes and I'm working on that because it's not tied to like a dollar amount, you know, like an income.
- 52:37But you look at the things I've accomplished for myself in the last couple of weeks, there's not necessarily a monetary value.
- 52:44But there's a discomfort in that because I am not being, quote, productive.
- 52:50So what do you think capitalism, first of all, there's a role it obviously plays in identity and racial identity, I should say.
- 53:01Do you have any thoughts that you would like to share on that that can help people be more aware?
- 53:05I have so many thoughts on this.
- 53:07I mean, racism and capitalism are inherently tied together, right?
- 53:11Capitalism requires there to be haves and have-nots, and the haves are always going to be the ones of dominant culture, the ones with lighter skin, the ones with historic privilege, generational wealth, all of that.
- 53:24And so because of capitalism, there is this need to, like—
- 53:29suppress or be better than some group?
- 53:32And what is the groups that are going to be easiest to suppress?
- 53:36And that's where racism comes in.
- 53:38Race exists because of racism, because we need to be able to hold power over some people so there is a lording class.
- 53:46There is an elite group over the working class.
- 53:49And so therefore, capitalism and racism are inherently tied together.
- 53:55I think it's really, really challenging because you kind of have to be like anti-capitalist if you are going to be truly anti-racist.
- 54:04And we also require capitalism.
- 54:07And it's, you know, the system to survive.
- 54:10Like we have to eat.
- 54:11We have to make a paycheck and make a living.
- 54:14Yeah.
- 54:15So it is a very difficult dialectic for us.
- 54:19And like, there's no way this is going to be dismantled in our lifetime.
- 54:23But what are the steps for us to kind of understand this at least slowly, right?
- 54:28Like, how do we dismantle our internalized capitalism, even if we have to work for a paycheck?
- 54:34Like, how do we say like, okay, rest can be productive.
- 54:38Rest can be resistance.
- 54:45even if I never got out of bed today.
- 54:48And that's okay.
- 54:49Like we don't have to tie every single element of what makes us worthy or really any element of what makes us worthy to what makes us productive.
- 54:59That's very ableist as well.
- 55:02And I think to your point, it takes the definition of productivity and it ties it to basically making money for somebody else, for most of us.
- 55:12And that's an unfortunate situation to be in as a society because I like art.
- 55:20How hard is it for artists to make money?
- 55:22Totally.
- 55:23I've got plenty of artist friends that have their little Etsy shops and in order for them to...
- 55:29sell their paintings, they have to do that after their day job, their capitalism job.
- 55:36And I feel like it's such a detriment to all of society to have this sort of unregulated, unfiltered version of capitalism, which leads to, I think, contributes insane amounts to the mental health challenges that everybody has.
- 55:59When it doesn't matter how much you work, you still can't make rent.
- 56:02That's late-stage capitalism for you.
- 56:04When some people can just literally sit there and make millions of dollars in the last five minutes from just doing absolutely nothing because their money is making money for them.
- 56:15Yeah, there's a lot of inequities there.
- 56:21Yeah, I agree.
- 56:22And late stage capitalism is, um, we're, we're there in so many ways.
- 56:28And when I look, you know, I, I say this all the time, like there's homeless people everywhere in Chicago, they're all across the country.
- 56:35Um, and you know what?
- 56:36A lot of them, I don't know the exact amount.
- 56:38I think it's like 30% actually work.
- 56:40They have jobs.
- 56:41No, a lot of them do.
- 56:42Yeah.
- 56:43And they still can't find shelter.
- 56:47Exactly.
- 56:48And people will, you know, disparage them and cut them down because they then develop severe mental health issues or they become, you know, victims of drug addiction.
- 57:04And it's just it's an awful situation to be in.
- 57:08And it's disproportionately, you know, like I feel like it's just disproportionately.
- 57:17people that are, I mean, obviously mentally ill, but people that are just never given that sort of pick-me-up of having generational wealth is the word.
- 57:27Yeah, marginalized.
- 57:27Like people who are marginalized.
- 57:29Yeah, historically overlooked.
- 57:31Yeah.
- 57:32I mean, that's absolutely true.
- 57:34You know, if I was in that position, I'd probably want something to numb me out during the day too so I can get through it.
- 57:42Exactly, exactly.
- 57:45Um, so I want to be conscious of your time.
- 57:47Are you, do you still have a few minutes?
- 57:48Yeah.
- 57:49Oh, it's only four o'clock.
- 57:50Okay, cool.
- 57:50No, no, I got time.
- 57:51Yeah.
- 57:51I got totally four.
- 57:52Awesome.
- 57:53Great.
- 57:53Great.
- 57:54Um, so what is there, what would you like people to know about your work and what type of advice would you give to someone who wants to, um, um, um, um, um, um, um, um, um, um,
- 58:06you know, take this message to someone, whether it be their workspace, their diversity and inclusion committee, whatever that may be, or go have a conversation with a family member?
- 58:15Yeah.
- 58:16I mean, I think, you know, when I first entered mental health, it was very much to understand like the individual, like that was the perspective that I was given.
- 58:25And that's, you know, what I was brought up with.
- 58:29But coming from a very collectivist culture, I certainly wanted to apply more to a systemic community level.
- 58:35Yeah.
- 58:36But everything that I learned in grad school had such a, you know, pathologizing medical model, like individual lens.
- 58:44And what I have learned just even just from doing therapy, it's just like, you know, you can change the way you look at things.
- 58:52If you can't change your environment and you're living in a toxic system and your relationships aren't supportive, like, there's only so much you can do.
- 59:00And then you zoom that out beyond the family or the workplace and you kind of look at it from a more systemic place.
- 59:06Like, I'm so thrilled that mental health is getting the attention and spotlight it deserves, even though it's because people are not okay with it.
- 59:14We're all suffering, right?
- 59:15It's because people are not okay.
- 59:17That mental health is getting that spotlight.
- 59:19But what I don't... What's frustrating to me is that people are prescribing therapy and medications and like, cool, those are great, but we cannot just...
- 59:29Count on that.
- 59:30That's not enough.
- 59:32This is not an individual thing.
- 59:34This is a systemic systems level process and change that needs to happen for us to elevate the mental health of our entire society.
- 59:45There's no amount of therapy or medication that's going to make a person who is unhoused facing perpetual illness,
- 59:55violence and poverty to feel better about themselves.
- 1:00:00They need, you know, standards of care and basic income and living and housing and, you know, all of these things.
- 1:00:08The basic human needs.
- 1:00:10Yeah.
- 1:00:10And that's where I struggle.
- 1:00:12And this is where kind of my...
- 1:00:14like politics originates from, which I think does tie very closely to mental health is I think if we have a society and by the way, richest country ever, that's us, the United States.
- 1:00:26And I feel like if we could just get to a place where everybody is equal and has basic human needs met, you have a house, you have food, you have clothing and you have water and you have all of these things that.
- 1:00:43People who have it don't think twice about.
- 1:00:46Yep.
- 1:00:47But the people that don't live every day wondering where their next meal is coming from.
- 1:00:53Or live that day wondering, is someone going to be nice enough to drop a dollar in my cup when they're homeless?
- 1:01:01Or someone's wondering, am I going to get this job?
- 1:01:05This is just...
- 1:01:07It's a horrible way to live.
- 1:01:09And the fact that it puts so many normal people in this state of anxiety, this constant state of panic, this constant state of not being good enough or not meeting the standards of X at work or this person in my life or whoever it is.
- 1:01:27It just keeps us in this constant state of never feeling satisfied, never feeling like our needs are met.
- 1:01:35I mean, that's capitalism in a nutshell, right?
- 1:01:37Because you can have all of the luxuries and you still want more.
- 1:01:40You know, when we think about everything as like growth oriented, like at what cost, right?
- 1:01:46The planet's dying.
- 1:01:47There's no more place to grow.
- 1:01:48We can't expand to any more land.
- 1:01:51So now we're trying to colonize attention.
- 1:01:54Like it's, it's a lot.
- 1:01:58Yeah.
- 1:01:59We don't worry.
- 1:02:00We have Bezos.
- 1:02:02We have Elon.
- 1:02:03And they're going to go colonize Mars or just leave us here, one or the other.
- 1:02:07Oh, yeah.
- 1:02:08Yeah, I mean, it is so challenging when we think about this and then when we kind of apply our existing frameworks and solutions to it.
- 1:02:19Because the existing one is based on hyper-individualism and very much individualizes the problem where it's, okay, well, you are responsible for taking care of your own mental health.
- 1:02:32Only you can change yourself.
- 1:02:33viewpoint and the way that you look at the world and and right to some degree yes but also like we belong to each other and we have to take care of each other and you know actually uplift informed communities and develop systemic changes that allow us to better take care of each other
- 1:02:56I think that's beautifully said.
- 1:02:59And I want to thank you.
- 1:03:01This was, I'm not going to lie, I was a little nervous about this conversation because I want it to be thought-provoking and I want people to learn something.
- 1:03:10But, you know, there's a level of ignorance on my part, I guess, to say, just given some of the things we've talked about.
- 1:03:18And so is there anything that I missed that you want to share or think that we should talk about?
- 1:03:24Hmm.
- 1:03:25I mean, I can talk about so much of this forever.
- 1:03:28Yeah.
- 1:03:29Gosh, I think, you know.
- 1:03:32More than anything, it's if we can really get out of the mindset of like, we got to do this for ourselves and really think about like, what are the ways for us to extend collective care and community care?
- 1:03:47One of the things that I have seen throughout this whole pandemic, but like, even now, even as things are like quote unquote, back to normal or more normal, is that everybody is lonely.
- 1:03:57Everybody is isolated.
- 1:04:00The fabric of community is so frayed.
- 1:04:04People have deterioration of their social skills.
- 1:04:08People don't know how to do this.
- 1:04:10So please, get together with your people.
- 1:04:14Have these community conversations.
- 1:04:16Learn what it is that others need to better take care of each other so we have some fray.
- 1:04:22Frameworks of how to show up for each other in crises and how to build communities.
- 1:04:29Read books by black and brown collective liberation authors.
- 1:04:33There's so many that are around how to do this.
- 1:04:39We need to mainstream this because people are dying of loneliness.
- 1:04:47I agree.
- 1:04:47And I think it's getting worse, which is so unfortunate.
- 1:04:51And it's not even just because of the pandemic.
- 1:04:54I feel like we've been on this track and it just got accelerated.
- 1:04:56We're all just talking through text messages.
- 1:05:00We're talking through Zooms like we are right now.
- 1:05:05We're talking through emails.
- 1:05:08We're talking through social media.
- 1:05:10And there's this...
- 1:05:14thought that I've recently had just based on some of my habits I've been building that probably aren't the healthiest when it comes to social media and I was thinking to myself it gives you this false sense of community in a sense especially for someone who has a following like we have where you feel this responsibility or this desire to interact but the reality is it's like
- 1:05:43It's not the same as meeting someone in person.
- 1:05:46No.
- 1:05:46Parasofal relationships.
- 1:05:47Parasofal relationships.
- 1:05:50I haven't talked in a week to, well, that's a lie.
- 1:05:53Cause I did last Saturday.
- 1:05:54I haven't talked in person really to anyone all week.
- 1:05:59It's all been digital and it's such a like, it's been kind of like a, Oh, that's, that's kind of weird.
- 1:06:04Like I'm kind of feeling it a little bit.
- 1:06:06And I think that a lot of people are feeling it times a thousand and it's going
- 1:06:15There's the promise of the metaverse.
- 1:06:16There's all these like, you know, I know, I know that we could do a whole nother podcast on.
- 1:06:23And it's just, we're losing our connections to each other.
- 1:06:26But I think more importantly, we're losing it with ourselves.
- 1:06:30Yeah.
- 1:06:30And yeah.
- 1:06:31I know like if I'm not doing well or I'm struggling with something, and this is me personally, I'm not projecting this on anyone else.
- 1:06:39I know for me, like I, I shut down.
- 1:06:42Like I don't want to be around anybody.
- 1:06:43I don't want to talk to anybody.
- 1:06:45And then what does that do?
- 1:06:47Yeah.
- 1:06:47It gives you that sense of you get comfortable in that space and you shouldn't be comfortable.
- 1:06:53Yeah.
- 1:06:53No one can hurt me over here by myself.
- 1:06:55Yeah.
- 1:06:56Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:57I just think that that's.
- 1:06:58Yeah.
- 1:07:00Yeah.
- 1:07:01And it's going to cause long-term challenges if we don't stay connected to ourselves and then connect with other people.
- 1:07:07Connected to each other.
- 1:07:08Yeah.
- 1:07:08I mean, go hug someone, touch some grass.
- 1:07:12There's all this kind of right brain, mirror neuron, the energetic fields of other human bodies.
- 1:07:20Just go to a concert, go to a coffee shop, go be in the energetic presence of other humans.
- 1:07:28Because this is how we are hardwired.
- 1:07:31We need each other.
- 1:07:34Yes, we do.
- 1:07:35Thank you so much for that.
- 1:07:37One last question for you here.
- 1:07:41What is your, what strategies do you have that you yourself use to help regulate yourself in trying times and, you know, any of those things that work for you?
- 1:07:56Yeah.
- 1:07:57Physical movement is a huge one.
- 1:07:59Physical activity, getting a workout in, you know, just going for a walk with my dogs.
- 1:08:04Um, I'm an extrovert by nature, but I also know like the importance of human connection.
- 1:08:09So I really co-regulate with the people that I love and care about.
- 1:08:14And, um, I've also been very explicit.
- 1:08:16with them I'm like this is what I need when I'm struggling and I have been able to communicate and find a community which really is anchored in that reciprocity where we do show up for each other and support each other in the ways that are hard but sometimes it's like sitting in the muck with someone and I find that being in the presence of you know safe attuned
- 1:08:43humans really helps me.
- 1:08:45I also really like collective effervescence where, you know, you're just like at a concert or, you know, a...
- 1:08:53any sort of like group activity where everyone has a similar goal.
- 1:08:56It can be like a sports game, church, whatever, where you're just feeling like the vibes and energy of humans.
- 1:09:02I like to people watch.
- 1:09:03It's camaraderie, yeah.
- 1:09:04Yeah, camaraderie, yeah.
- 1:09:06And I think that's also just like a really nourishing thing for me as an extrovert is to like regulate with the energy of other people.
- 1:09:15I love that.
- 1:09:15And I love the fact that you said you communicate what you actually need.
- 1:09:19And I think that is something every person listening to this and every human can try and do better at, and myself included.
- 1:09:28Say what you need.
- 1:09:30Say what you don't need.
- 1:09:30It's uncomfortable sometimes.
- 1:09:31Yeah.
- 1:09:32But, you know, if you establish that from the get-go of, like, you know, I value you in this relationship enough to be honest about what I need and to ask you to share what you need, too, so I can show up for you as well, then it just sets the tone for, you know, frank conversations and honesty and feedback.
- 1:09:54I completely agree.
- 1:09:56That's outstanding.
- 1:09:57So now I'm going to give you an opportunity, if you have any questions you want to ask me.
- 1:10:03It's all yours.
- 1:10:03I have so many questions for you, Nick.
- 1:10:05Oh my gosh.
- 1:10:07Okay.
- 1:10:08So, how has your experience on this show shaped the way you approach relationships and dating?
- 1:10:18So it's interesting because I'll take a step back first.
- 1:10:23I had kind of stopped dating for the most part during COVID.
- 1:10:28It was a nightmare.
- 1:10:30It was worse than ever.
- 1:10:32It amplified some of the worst trends in dating.
- 1:10:36And what I thought, and I don't really watch reality TV.
- 1:10:40I watched season one after starting the interview process.
- 1:10:44For the show, which they reached out to me.
- 1:10:46I've said that before in other outlets.
- 1:10:49I didn't ever think that would be a path for me.
- 1:10:52But what I liked about the show and the concept or the whole experience was that...
- 1:10:59It eliminates a lot of my critiques of dating where it's the everybody's distracted by a million things.
- 1:11:06Nobody really gives anybody the time of day.
- 1:11:08Everybody's.
- 1:11:09Yeah.
- 1:11:09They ghost you.
- 1:11:10Yeah.
- 1:11:11Yeah.
- 1:11:11They ghost you.
- 1:11:12They don't, they don't really, um, like take the.
- 1:11:17The first couple of dates, they've got one today, one tomorrow, one three days after that.
- 1:11:22They're managing all these conversations, mixing people up.
- 1:11:25I mean, it's just disastrous.
- 1:11:28And I feel now like I'm not dating now.
- 1:11:32I'm barely like getting myself out of bed some days.
- 1:11:37And so it's, you know, it's interesting because I think it's going to be a different experience now.
- 1:11:42I don't.
- 1:11:45I don't think I will be on apps ever again.
- 1:11:47And we'll check in with me in six months and we'll see.
- 1:11:51But, you know, I think I'm really learning and focusing on fostering like real life relationships now, even with...
- 1:12:05Some of my social media following, like I'm actually like I've been talking to some of them like on the phone and just trying to get to like some of the people I DM with regularly or keep in touch with or or, you know, share things with like, you know, I just I just want to get to.
- 1:12:23Real human connection.
- 1:12:25And I think there's obviously value in social media.
- 1:12:29I think it allows you to communicate in ways that you would never be able to before.
- 1:12:34I would never be able to keep in touch with people around the world like I do now.
- 1:12:39Yeah.
- 1:12:39Yeah.
- 1:12:40I have international friends.
- 1:12:41I have friends in, in Europe.
- 1:12:43I have friends all over the place and I can't keep in, I can keep in touch with them now.
- 1:12:49So I think, you know, that's some of the good stuff, but I'm trying to spend more time, um, in real life with people.
- 1:12:56So I can't imagine, um, yeah.
- 1:13:00being in a bar or at a game or at dinner and going up and talking to someone.
- 1:13:05Cause I feel like that's a weird experience now, but I have a, I feel like that's going to have to be something that, um, It's coming back around.
- 1:13:15That's what I hear.
- 1:13:16People are so sick of the apps that they're like, Oh, someone came up to me at the club.
- 1:13:20Woo.
- 1:13:21You know, it's, it's more normalized for a while.
- 1:13:23I was real like side eye about that, but it's really coming back around.
- 1:13:28I know.
- 1:13:29I think that's ultimately a good thing.
- 1:13:31I really do.
- 1:13:32It's a problem.
- 1:13:33It's a problem.
- 1:13:33It's a problem.
- 1:13:33Connections.
- 1:13:35Totally agree.
- 1:13:36And I think like the apps, they have a place, they have a role and they obviously can work.
- 1:13:40So many people meet that way now, but I just think the way people approach it should change.
- 1:13:44Yeah.
- 1:13:45I know like, and again, I'm not, I'm not perfect, but like I would be on an app and there was one time I did the, I have three dates booked one time.
- 1:13:54And after that, I was like, I'm never doing this again.
- 1:13:57Because if I talked to, yeah, I talked to someone, I would go on a date with them.
- 1:14:02And if I liked them, I would tell them.
- 1:14:05I'd be like, Hey, I had a great time that I'd love to do it again.
- 1:14:07Or if I didn't, I would text him that and be like, Hey, I had a good time, you know, cause it's, it can be awkward sometimes.
- 1:14:14But I think just being intentional and clear, um, on your intentions and what your expectations are can go a very, very long way on an app or in real life.
- 1:14:24Yeah.
- 1:14:24Do you get recognized out in the world?
- 1:14:28It ebbs and flows, and every time I say that, I get recognized by five people the next time I go out.
- 1:14:34I literally said that to, I can't even remember who it was.
- 1:14:39I was at a coffee shop with a friend, and I'm like, yeah, I haven't been recognized in a while.
- 1:14:42And I got recognized by three people at the grocery store an hour later.
- 1:14:46Do you think that makes dating harder for you to be recognized?
- 1:14:52I would like to think it makes it easier, but I don't know.
- 1:14:56Would you date a fan?
- 1:14:56We'll find out.
- 1:14:58Huh.
- 1:14:58Interesting.
- 1:15:01I don't know.
- 1:15:01It's such a weird question.
- 1:15:04Next DMs are open.
- 1:15:07I know.
- 1:15:08I almost said that when you first asked.
- 1:15:10I was going to be like, maybe I'll just announce the DMs are open.
- 1:15:12There are people that slide and they're just like, I'm shooting my shot.
- 1:15:16And it's like, you know, good for you.
- 1:15:18Kudos to you.
- 1:15:20The internet is a wild, wild place.
- 1:15:23Yeah.
- 1:15:24It is.
- 1:15:25You live in California or you live in, you know, Canada.
- 1:15:29You live in Florida.
- 1:15:30I'm in Chicago.
- 1:15:31Like, I don't know.
- 1:15:32How's this going to work?
- 1:15:33Yeah, let's meet for coffee.
- 1:15:36It's so funny.
- 1:15:38Yeah.
- 1:15:40Oh, those are my questions.
- 1:15:41Thank you for humoring me.
- 1:15:43No, of course.
- 1:15:44Of course.
- 1:15:45It's my pleasure.
- 1:15:46Thanks again for coming on.
- 1:15:47Do you want to tell everyone where they can find you on social media and TikTok, Instagram, anywhere else, your website, all of that?
- 1:15:53Dr. Han Ren on TikTok, Instagram, and drhanren.com.
- 1:15:59Perfect.
- 1:16:00And those links will be in the show description.
- 1:16:02So make sure you check her out, give her a follow.
- 1:16:05And thanks again for coming on.
- 1:16:07Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:16:08This was so much fun.
- 1:16:13Thank you for joining me on another episode of Conversations with Nick Thompson.
- 1:16:18If you enjoyed the show, be sure to follow us and leave a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.
- 1:16:25Links can be found in the description below, and we can't wait to see you next time.