Latest / Politics By Faith w/Mike Slater / Suicidal Empathy and The Monkey Who Ripped Off A Man's Face
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Politics by Faith.
- 0:04It's where we take the news of the day.
- 0:05We bring it to the Bible so we can walk away with peace and perspective.
- 0:08New headlines every day,
- 0:09but Ecclesiastes says there's nothing new under the sun.
- 0:12So thanks for being here to get the true story
- 0:13and if you could subscribe on our YouTube page,
- 0:15that'd be wonderful.
- 0:16Youtube.com/at
- 0:18Politics by
- 0:20Faith.
- 0:20The story of the day,
- 0:21suicidal
- 0:23empathy.
- 0:24We talked to Gad Sad the other day
- 0:27on the Sirius XM show.
- 0:28He has a new book called Suicidal Empathy.
- 0:30The thesis is very simple.
- 0:32It's that empathy
- 0:33is good,
- 0:34and I wanna
- 0:35challenge that a little later in the show,
- 0:37so bear with me,
- 0:38but
- 0:38his premise is that empathy is good.
- 0:42But
- 0:43too little of it and you're a psychopath,
- 0:45we don't want that.
- 0:46Too much of it though,
- 0:48and you're a woke fool.
- 0:51Who
- 0:52will let criminals on the street after committing 50 crimes,
- 0:55not criminals,
- 0:56a criminal on the street after committing 50
- 0:57crimes until he then murders a young woman,
- 0:59and then maybe then you'll still
- 1:01let him out again.
- 1:02We shared the story the other day of
- 1:04a
- 1:05man who murdered two women
- 1:07just like straight
- 1:09Silence of the Lambs style,
- 1:11two different times.
- 1:12So,
- 1:12so murdered a woman,
- 1:13then
- 1:13was let out of jail,
- 1:14murdered another woman,
- 1:16then was let out of jail again.
- 1:18And was placed in a woman's homeless shelter because now he claimed to be a woman.
- 1:22And the
- 1:23person who ran the women's homeless shelter or who
- 1:25worked there said maybe it's not a great idea to
- 1:27put this man in a woman's homeless shelter on
- 1:28account of the fact that he keeps killing them.
- 1:32And then he went on and killed
- 1:34a third woman.
- 1:35The New York Times wrote a story
- 1:36about why,
- 1:37how it's possible that this person was let out of jail
- 1:402 times
- 1:41and went on and ultimately murdered
- 1:433 people,
- 1:44but there's many examples of
- 1:46suicidal
- 1:47empathy.
- 1:49And it's in line with Aristotle.
- 1:50So Aristotle wrote all these virtues,
- 1:53uh,
- 1:53courage,
- 1:54ambition,
- 1:55modesty,
- 1:56humor,
- 1:57um,
- 1:58honesty,
- 1:59friendship,
- 2:00temperance.
- 2:02Uh,
- 2:02self-control,
- 2:03a couple of,
- 2:03a couple of other ones,
- 2:04I'm missing a few,
- 2:05and he talked about having the right balance
- 2:07of these things,
- 2:08and you can have a deficiency of them,
- 2:10and you can have an excess of them,
- 2:11and you wanna try to find that golden
- 2:14mean
- 2:14of them.
- 2:15Uh,
- 2:15so generosity being generous is a virtue,
- 2:18but a deficiency of this,
- 2:20and you're stingy,
- 2:21and if you're excessive,
- 2:23then you're wasteful,
- 2:24and,
- 2:24and you don't wanna be any of those things.
- 2:25I think courage is the easiest to see,
- 2:27courage is the virtue.
- 2:28If you're,
- 2:29uh,
- 2:29if you have a deficiency of it,
- 2:31then you are,
- 2:32um,
- 2:33a coward,
- 2:34and if you have excess of this,
- 2:35then you're rash
- 2:37and,
- 2:37and violent,
- 2:38and you don't want that,
- 2:39you want
- 2:41to be right in the middle,
- 2:42the right balance of it all,
- 2:43you want courage.
- 2:44And Gad's point just is adding empathy to that list.
- 2:47Again,
- 2:47if you don't have it,
- 2:48you're a psychopath,
- 2:50but if you have too much of it,
- 2:51then you're woke
- 2:52and potentially suicidally
- 2:55empathetic.
- 2:56I wanna share a story here.
- 2:58It's a horrific story.
- 3:00Uh,
- 3:00Kat Rosen Rosenfield at the Free Presses.
- 3:04The first person who,
- 3:05who I've ever heard the story from,
- 3:06and every word of it's true.
- 3:07So here's the deal.
- 3:10Saint James Davis,
- 3:12who was a NASCAR driver way back in the day.
- 3:15And uh he and his wife,
- 3:17Donna,
- 3:18well,
- 3:18Donna couldn't have a child,
- 3:19she had cancer and she had a hysterectomy and she couldn't have a baby.
- 3:23And they heard the story about a poacher in Tanzania,
- 3:27who killed a mother chimpanzee.
- 3:33The chimp the,
- 3:34the mom chimpanzee had a a one day old baby chimpanzee.
- 3:37So the Davis family adopted the baby chimpanzee,
- 3:40and they treated it like a human baby.
- 3:42They dressed it up in human clothes,
- 3:44toilet trained it,
- 3:45took showers,
- 3:46lived in the house,
- 3:47the whole thing.
- 3:48This is 1967.
- 3:5010 years later,
- 3:50the chimpanzee bit a woman,
- 3:52and the woman sued,
- 3:54uh,
- 3:54but
- 3:56nothing really came of it.
- 3:57Uh,
- 3:57a couple of years go by and the monkey is now kept in a cage in the house,
- 4:00and we're talking full-grown chimpanzee,
- 4:02like 5 ft tall,
- 4:03150 pounds,
- 4:04twice as strong as a human,
- 4:05and vicious because it doesn't have a soul
- 4:07and it's a wild animal.
- 4:09So living in a cage and then he escaped.
- 4:11Police arrived,
- 4:12a bunch of police couldn't keep this thing down.
- 4:14Could you imagine
- 4:15trying to
- 4:16tackle a chimpanzee
- 4:17and attacked a police officer.
- 4:18It was a whole thing.
- 4:19They finally got the monkey.
- 4:20All right.
- 4:20So now the monkey's living,
- 4:22uh,
- 4:22I think the monkey then bit another person.
- 4:24They kept,
- 4:25they kept giving the monkey back to the family.
- 4:26So the monkey,
- 4:27the Davis family ultimately,
- 4:28because they thought this was their baby.
- 4:31So that they,
- 4:31uh,
- 4:32the,
- 4:32the monkey had to be given to this animal sanctuary,
- 4:34sanctuary,
- 4:35but they kept visiting the baby.
- 4:37And then one day they brought
- 4:39the,
- 4:39the by baby,
- 4:40I mean the chimpanzee.
- 4:41So one day they brought
- 4:43A birthday cake
- 4:45And they Moe was the name of the monkey,
- 4:47Moe,
- 4:48and they visited Moe
- 4:50at the sanctuary for Moe's thirty-ninth birthday.
- 4:54I'm,
- 4:55I've,
- 4:55I'm,
- 4:56there's they get a bit more people in the meantime and there were more lawsuits,
- 4:59right,
- 4:59but they,
- 4:59and they kept paying out to protect poor Moe,
- 5:01so they arrived
- 5:02with,
- 5:03uh,
- 5:03toys
- 5:04and candy hearts and chocolate milk and Moe's favorite
- 5:07cake.
- 5:09So they're feeding Moe through the cage,
- 5:11when 2 other monkeys escaped.
- 5:15And they both attacked
- 5:17The man,
- 5:18Saint James.
- 5:19They ripped off both of his testicles,
- 5:22they ripped off his nose
- 5:24and his lips,
- 5:25they ripped them off,
- 5:26ripped them off his body.
- 5:27They ripped off his,
- 5:28his
- 5:29buttocks,
- 5:30his gluteus maximus,
- 5:31ripped it off,
- 5:32they destroyed his left foot and most of his fingers.
- 5:36Someone at the sanctuary grabbed a gun,
- 5:37shot one of the monkeys in the head.
- 5:39The other monkey started dragging his body
- 5:42into the,
- 5:42the cage
- 5:43to keep attacking it.
- 5:45Ultimately the guy shot that monkey too.
- 5:49There's a lot more to the story.
- 5:51The guy had needed 60 surgeries.
- 5:52He ended up dying like a decade or so later,
- 5:55and then
- 5:56she had all of her money stolen from a caretaker who had her sign a new will,
- 5:59and then her house was stolen by a motorcycle gang.
- 6:01It's this whole crazy thing.
- 6:03But the two points here that are relevant to suicidal empathy is Moe the monkey.
- 6:10While
- 6:12Dad
- 6:13was being attacked,
- 6:15watched the entire thing.
- 6:17Sitting there
- 6:19Eating his cake
- 6:22So while these two humans loved this monkey so
- 6:25much and did everything they could for this monkey,
- 6:27the monkey didn't feel anything towards them.
- 6:31Or as Kat Rosenfield wrote,
- 6:33I share a deep and unique bond with this wild animal.
- 6:37And as such will never come to harm.
- 6:40This is the narrative of the suicidal empath,
- 6:43or at least one narrative.
- 6:44There's others.
- 6:44Perhaps you've heard of a woman insist
- 6:46that the emotionally maladjusted boyfriend who beats her
- 6:48is just reenacting his childhood trauma,
- 6:51repeating a cycle of abuse that
- 6:53that began with his father or his father's father,
- 6:55or that the guy who steals a car,
- 6:56robs a liquor store is doing it to feed his sister's starving family,
- 6:59or that the assassin who gunned down a father of
- 7:01two on the street was expressing his justified anger against capitalism
- 7:05and corporatized healthcare.
- 7:07Suicidal empathy tells us
- 7:10that what looks to the casual observer like violence and disorder.
- 7:13It's not just understandable,
- 7:15but perhaps even
- 7:16noble.
- 7:17And worthy of compassion
- 7:19If not outright
- 7:21approval.
- 7:24One of the most remarkable
- 7:26parts of the person who is suicidally empathetic.
- 7:30Is that for many,
- 7:31it never stops,
- 7:32ever.
- 7:33This husband and wife,
- 7:35Saint James and Donna.
- 7:36The husband who had his entire body ripped to shreds.
- 7:39They continued to visit Moe.
- 7:42It eventually escaped from another animal sanctuary and ran off into the woods.
- 7:45I'm not kidding,
- 7:46ran off into the woods in San Bernardino,
- 7:49California.
- 7:50And the owners are so worried for him,
- 7:51they never found him.
- 7:52They never found Moe ever again.
- 7:54The the owners were so worried for him
- 7:56that they would fly helicopters over the forest
- 7:58to try and find him,
- 7:59or maybe thinking they could scare him out of the woods,
- 8:01so that they could
- 8:02rescue him and take him home.
- 8:05And the man who was mauled said,
- 8:06it's a real quote,
- 8:08we just would like to have him back
- 8:10where we can live as a family again.
- 8:16That is suicidal empathy.
- 8:18And it is rampant
- 8:19in America on the left.
- 8:24I'll share a story on Sirius XM
- 8:26of a woman who was attacked by a black man
- 8:29in the New York City subway.
- 8:30She did not cooperate with police about
- 8:33being attacked,
- 8:34and it wasn't long later
- 8:36when
- 8:36this man
- 8:39was male,
- 8:39he's not a man,
- 8:40he's a male.
- 8:41When he pushed a 76 year old man
- 8:43down the subway stairs and killed him.
- 8:46And she said,
- 8:46I regret 100%.
- 8:49Not cooperating with police and I actually feel really bad
- 8:52that a man lost his life.
- 8:53But check out this line.
- 8:54Maybe a part of me was just like,
- 8:56this is a 23 year old woman,
- 8:58maybe a part of me was just like,
- 9:00I don't want to put another black man in jail.
- 9:07So she let this guy
- 9:09free and he went on to murder someone.
- 9:12Now,
- 9:13uh,
- 9:13Gad's book is Suicidal Empathy,
- 9:15and,
- 9:15uh,
- 9:16I recommend the read,
- 9:16I haven't read the whole thing.
- 9:17I've read bits and pieces here,
- 9:18uh,
- 9:19but I recommend it
- 9:20cause he's a good storyteller,
- 9:21and brings in good
- 9:22points.
- 9:23Uh,
- 9:23he is an
- 9:24evolutionary psychologist though,
- 9:26so obviously,
- 9:27his analysis has some
- 9:28major shortcomings.
- 9:29Um,
- 9:30I'm reminded of Toxic Empathy
- 9:32by Alibeth Stuckey.
- 9:34Uh,
- 9:34she takes it from a Christian perspective.
- 9:37Her point
- 9:39is similar,
- 9:39right?
- 9:39We're talking about empathy,
- 9:40but
- 9:40it goes too far and it becomes toxic,
- 9:42and,
- 9:42and she says any
- 9:44empathy that
- 9:45ultimately leads people to suggest sin.
- 9:48Or that someone keeps sinning
- 9:50is toxic.
- 9:52She makes the point that God is love,
- 9:54so everything he says.
- 9:57is perfect
- 9:59and done in perfect love.
- 10:00You can't out love him,
- 10:02so the most loving thing you can do will always be
- 10:05to agree with God.
- 10:07Let me read this
- 10:09Section right here
- 10:11She says
- 10:14If we love those around us,
- 10:16we will be vessels of his goodness and order.
- 10:20That means advocating for the life of an unborn child
- 10:22is loving.
- 10:23Recognizing the beauty of the male-female binary is loving.
- 10:27Honoring the sacred,
- 10:27life-giving definition of marriage is loving.
- 10:30Protecting a nation's sovereignty for the good of its citizens is loving.
- 10:33Punishing the wrongdoer for the sake of the innocent
- 10:36and weak
- 10:37is loving.
- 10:38The flip side of these things,
- 10:39murder,
- 10:39mutilation,
- 10:40perversion,
- 10:41lawlessness,
- 10:41and chaos
- 10:43only yield disorder,
- 10:44disordered,
- 10:45harmful outcomes.
- 10:46God's ways are better.
- 10:48The most loving thing we can do
- 10:50is agree
- 10:51with them.
- 10:54But this idea of empathy
- 10:56is,
- 10:56is interesting,
- 10:57uh,
- 10:58not in,
- 10:59in the Bible.
- 11:00Empathy is feeling what other people feel.
- 11:03It can be a useful tool,
- 11:05I suppose,
- 11:06but the most important thing is truth.
- 11:09And the most important thing is love.
- 11:12And the Bible is very clear on these things.
- 11:151 Corinthians 13 read at every wedding,
- 11:16Love is patient,
- 11:17love is kind,
- 11:18love does not envy or boast,
- 11:19it is not arrogant or rude,
- 11:21it does not insist in its own way,
- 11:22it is not irritable or resentful,
- 11:23but check this one out,
- 11:24it does not rejoice at wrongdoing,
- 11:27but love rejoices in the truth.
- 11:30And Ephesians 4:15 says we are to speak the truth
- 11:34in
- 11:34love.
- 11:39Feeling someone's pain
- 11:41might be a a useful practice.
- 11:45But it doesn't necessarily put you any closer to knowing the truth.
- 11:51It doesn't put you any closer to knowing what's right or wrong.
- 11:53It's all based on
- 11:55feelings,
- 11:55and we should be very
- 11:56wary of that.
- 11:58And it's quite obvious,
- 12:00it could be hard in the moment,
- 12:01but with a little distance and thinking,
- 12:03it makes perfect sense why this is
- 12:05problematic.
- 12:05Someone might be a drug addict.
- 12:07And you can have empathy for the pain
- 12:10that they're feeling during a withdrawal.
- 12:13But that doesn't
- 12:15mean
- 12:16that the right thing
- 12:17to do is to give them more drugs.
- 12:19That,
- 12:19that may be what they're,
- 12:20they're feeling pain.
- 12:21We're gonna relieve the pain,
- 12:23give them what they want.
- 12:24Drugs,
- 12:25are you,
- 12:25is that the right thing?
- 12:26Of course not.
- 12:27So empathy doesn't lead you closer to the truth.
- 12:30Empathy,
- 12:31empathy doesn't lead you.
- 12:33To love
- 12:36Because if you're
- 12:39Basing,
- 12:40if you,
- 12:40if you are supposed to engage in empathy
- 12:42and therefore feel how another person's feeling.
- 12:45But that other person's feelings
- 12:47can be
- 12:48the result of sin or the result of a deceitful heart.
- 12:52Now you're being led not only by your deceitful heart,
- 12:55but by their deceitful heart.
- 12:57And that's not
- 12:58what we're looking for.
- 13:00Because
- 13:01the Bible says the heart is deceitful above all things.
- 13:07Let me quote Charles Spurgeon here.
- 13:08He gave an amazing sermon on.
- 13:11Uh,
- 13:11Mark,
- 13:12uh,
- 13:14He said,
- 13:14our Lord Jesus Christ says all these evil things come from within.
- 13:19For from within,
- 13:20out of the hearts of men proceed evil thoughts.
- 13:24The source from which these rivers of pollution proceed is the natural heart of man.
- 13:28Sin us a Spurgeon,
- 13:29I love Surgeon.
- 13:30You wonder why I quote Spurgeon all the time.
- 13:32Sin is not a splash of mud
- 13:35upon man's exterior.
- 13:37It is a filth generated
- 13:39within himself.
- 13:41So we need to watch out,
- 13:42not to empathize with people who are being led themselves
- 13:46by deceitful hearts.
- 13:50Mark 7:20
- 13:52and he said that which comes out of the man
- 13:55that defiles the man,
- 13:56for
- 13:56from within,
- 13:57out of the heart of men proceed evil thoughts,
- 13:59adulteries,
- 14:00fornications,
- 14:01murders,
- 14:02thefts,
- 14:02covetousness,
- 14:03wickedness,
- 14:03deceit,
- 14:04lasciviousness,
- 14:05an evil eye,
- 14:05blasphemy,
- 14:06pride,
- 14:06foolishness,
- 14:07all these evil things come from within
- 14:09and defile.
- 14:11The man,
- 14:11uh,
- 14:12I'll make this final point here.
- 14:13A lot of people will say this has become a popular thing in Christian circles,
- 14:15which I
- 14:16would suggest needs further thought,
- 14:18is,
- 14:19um,
- 14:19it's OK if you think a thing as long as you don't act on it.
- 14:23Thinking it is not sinful,
- 14:24just make sure you don't act on it,
- 14:25you hear this a lot with
- 14:26homosexuality.
- 14:28You can think about it,
- 14:29you can think it's OK if someone thinks it,
- 14:30but as long as they're not doing it,
- 14:31as long as you don't practice it,
- 14:32then it's OK.
- 14:33And I'd like to push back on that,
- 14:34not just for homosexuality,
- 14:35but for everything.
- 14:37And I'll end this with a quote from Spurgeon
- 14:40about Mark 20,
- 14:40that verse I just read,
- 14:41or Mark 7 verse 20.
- 14:43Notice,
- 14:44Spurgeon says that in this awful catalog.
- 14:47This horrible list
- 14:48of the unclean birds
- 14:50that find a cage within the human heart,
- 14:54begins with things that are lightly regarded
- 14:56among men.
- 14:57It starts with,
- 14:58what was the first one,
- 14:59for from within out of the hearts of men proceed what?
- 15:01It goes on a whole list here.
- 15:03Murder,
- 15:04theft,
- 15:04fornication,
- 15:05all these things.
- 15:05What's the first one though?
- 15:07Evil thoughts
- 15:101 may cry,
- 15:11we shall not be hanged for our thoughts.
- 15:15I wish that such idle talkers would remember
- 15:17that they will be damned for their thoughts.
- 15:21And then instead of evil thoughts being less sinful than evil acts,
- 15:25it may sometimes,
- 15:25that's what most people think,
- 15:26right?
- 15:26Evil thoughts are less bad than evil acts.
- 15:28It may be sometimes,
- 15:29it may sometimes happen that in the thought,
- 15:31the man may be worse than in the deed.
- 15:35He may not be able to carry out all the mischief that lurks within his design.
- 15:39And yet
- 15:39in forming the design,
- 15:41he may incur all the guilt.
- 15:44Thoughts are the eggs of words and actions,
- 15:47and within the thoughts lie compacted and condensed all the villainy
- 15:50of actual transgressions.
- 15:52If men did more carefully watch their thoughts,
- 15:55they would not so readily fall into evil habits.
- 15:59Men first indulge the thoughts of evil and then the imagination
- 16:02of evil,
- 16:03but the process does not stop there.
- 16:05Picturing it before their mind's eye,
- 16:06they excite their own desires after it.
- 16:09Those grow into a thirst and kindle into a passion.
- 16:11Then the deed is speedily forthcoming.
- 16:16It was long in the hatching.
- 16:19But in a moment it comes forth to curse a whole lifetime.
- 16:22Instead of fancying that evil thoughts are mere trifles,
- 16:25let us regard them as the root of bitterness.
- 16:28The still in which the poisonous spirit is manufactured,
- 16:30our Savior here puts evil thoughts first in the catalog of evil things,
- 16:36and he knew well their true nature.
- 16:39My point is,
- 16:40if people's evil thoughts
- 16:42are bad.
- 16:44Then we shouldn't put empathy
- 16:46as such a virtue
- 16:48to begin with.
- 16:49I don't want to put myself
- 16:50in the,
- 16:50the,
- 16:51the evil thoughts of another person.
- 16:54And think that that's somehow a noble enterprise or exercise
- 16:58or thing I should be doing.
- 17:00Instead,
- 17:00I want to stand firmly on the word of God.
- 17:04Guided by
- 17:05not someone else's thoughts,
- 17:07but by the Holy Spirit.
- 17:09Stand on the word of God.
- 17:11Be guided by the Holy Spirit that is within
- 17:14you.
- 17:16YouTube.com/ at
- 17:17Politics by faith to subscribe
- 17:20to our
- 17:20podcast on YouTube.
- 17:21YouTube.com/atpolitics by faith.
- 17:23Spread the word.