Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Swiss Family Robinson (1960) : A Prototype for the Blockbuster
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia, and I love movies. We're sitting
- 0:32here in a nook of my attic room, a window between
- 0:36us looking out onto my backyard. It's a magnificent
- 0:41spring day, the kind that makes some people insist
- 0:44that spring is their favorite season, when it's
- 0:48really just that May is their favorite month.
- 0:51It's 76 degrees out and sunny, but the humidity
- 0:55is still pretty low. The window is open, and
- 0:59a fresh breeze is making the curtains dance.
- 1:02Outside, the grass is technicolor green, and
- 1:06the trees are full of leaves. Everything feels
- 1:10alive and abundant. There's a magic about May,
- 1:15a sense that the whole world lies before you
- 1:19as a possibility. I suppose this partially comes
- 1:23from the indelible impact of the end of the school
- 1:26year, the full trees eliciting a Pavlovian excitement,
- 1:30a whole summer of new or different experiences.
- 1:35As a child, it meant that my job was reading,
- 1:38carrying stacks of books home, ready to conquer
- 1:41the summer reading program early and get all
- 1:44the best prizes. But even as an adult, new plans
- 1:48begin to form. Maybe I could eat lunch outside.
- 1:52Maybe we could take evening walks every week.
- 1:56Maybe we could actually go on an adventure. Until
- 2:01May, spring weather is capricious, meaning that
- 2:05every plan is up in the air, liable to be cancelled
- 2:08due to snow. But in May, there's a sense of stability,
- 2:13which opens up to possibility. So it's really
- 2:17quite appropriate that May is the beginning of
- 2:20the so -called summer movie season, the time
- 2:24of year we most associate with blockbusters.
- 2:29The idea of the blockbuster is traced back to
- 2:32two films, 1975's Jaws and 1977's Star Wars,
- 2:39which means that it's half a century old. Wild,
- 2:43considering that we still associate it with new
- 2:46films, when the invention of talkies was closer
- 2:50to that time than the blockbuster is to us. The
- 2:54concept of a blockbuster is technically just
- 2:58related to audience. How many people saw this
- 3:01film? How many times did they go back? How much
- 3:05money did they spend? It must be a crowd -pleaser,
- 3:09what's called a four -quadrant film, appealing
- 3:12to both men and women older and younger than
- 3:1625. There have been all kinds of blockbusters.
- 3:20Comedies, family films, romances, horror. But
- 3:24when you think of the blockbuster, you probably
- 3:28think of an effects -heavy action movie with
- 3:31a romantic subplot. Frankly, this is what Hollywood
- 3:35aims for when it's trying to make a blockbuster.
- 3:39Which explains a lot. The soulless, failed blockbusters
- 3:45that release every summer rely on these ideas
- 3:48but miss something else. A sense of adventure,
- 3:53that thrill of discovery, the pursuit of curiosity,
- 3:57whether that is in learning who these characters
- 4:00are or what world they inhabit, and watching
- 4:05them invent solutions and solve problems. Like,
- 4:10Jaws gets labeled as a horror movie, a monster
- 4:14movie. Well, the first half is, but then it becomes
- 4:19a seafaring adventure, and it's our delight to
- 4:23get to watch these three very different men learn
- 4:26how to connect to each other, make a plan, discovering
- 4:30what they don't know, all before finding a solution
- 4:34to the problem. It's not a case of the first
- 4:37half of the film being better than the second,
- 4:40either. People talk about Quint with the same
- 4:44delight and nostalgia that they do about the
- 4:47kills in the first half, and he really isn't
- 4:50in the film at all until the adventure gets going.
- 4:54But of course, you may say, Jaws is the first
- 4:58blockbuster. We didn't get a real sense of what
- 5:01they would become until Star Wars. Much has been
- 5:05written about Star Wars and its influences. Of
- 5:09course, there's science fiction, because it has
- 5:12robots and spaceships and aliens, especially
- 5:15the Flash Gordon space opera side of things.
- 5:19But there's also Dune, the very real sense of
- 5:23groundedness and its world -building, alongside
- 5:26the metaphysical discussions influenced by Spice
- 5:30and the political implications of a galactic
- 5:33empire. There's a good deal of director Akira
- 5:37Kurosawa in Star Wars, definitely his film Seven
- 5:41Samurai, but particularly Hidden Fortress. That's
- 5:46a wild watch, because you can see a lot of the
- 5:50archetypes Star Wars maps onto, including two
- 5:54peasants on whom C -3PO and R2 -D2 are practically
- 5:58rotoscoped. Lots of genre snobs will argue that
- 6:03Star Wars is a western, especially with how much
- 6:06Han Solo is a space cowboy and Luke is the farm
- 6:10boy going to the big city. But there's one film
- 6:14that absolutely no official film critics credit
- 6:18as being part of the Star Wars soup that I am
- 6:21convinced definitely is. And that would be the
- 6:251960 Disney film Swiss Family Robinson, directed
- 6:30by Ken Anakin. I see that look on your face.
- 6:35Yeah, that name. Lucas has denied this as the
- 6:40origin of the name Anakin Skywalker. He said
- 6:44that he pulled the name from Sanskrit, which...
- 6:48would line up with a lot of the mythology, Joseph
- 6:51Campbell influences on Star Wars. But it is a
- 6:56weird coincidence. Frankly, a lot of this is
- 7:00weird coincidences. Swiss Family Robinson was
- 7:04released when George Lucas was 16, and though
- 7:08Fritz, Ernst, and Roberta are meant to be in
- 7:11their late teens, this is definitely a kids'
- 7:14movie. And it seems a stretch that he would have
- 7:17watched it. But I have found an interview George
- 7:22Lucas gave where he specifically referenced adventure
- 7:25stories as an influence on Star Wars. Huck Finn,
- 7:30Treasure Island, Kidnapped, and the film Swiss
- 7:34Family Robinson. So I feel I have permission
- 7:38to share with you all the weird coincidences
- 7:41I've logged with this film and Star Wars, and
- 7:45why I think it's worth examining in the context
- 7:49of the blockbuster. What can we learn from a
- 7:53corny, campy Disney film? How can we see what
- 7:57Lucas saw in it? And how can we use that to breathe
- 8:02life into an ecosystem of stale, corporate summer
- 8:06movies? In 1719, British novelist Daniel Defoe
- 8:13published Robinson Crusoe, a first -person narrative
- 8:17that, among other things, tells the story of
- 8:21a man who is the lone survivor of a shipwreck
- 8:23off the coast of Venezuela, who has to build
- 8:27a life for himself on a deserted island. It is
- 8:31kind of the origin of this plot. And it was incredibly
- 8:35popular. Audiences were fascinated by the relatively
- 8:39grounded way Defoe relayed the story, the real
- 8:43nitty -gritty details for what it would take
- 8:46to order one's life after a disaster, scrape
- 8:49out a living in an alien ecosystem, and process
- 8:53the psychological realities of living alone.
- 8:56The book was so popular that it sparked an entirely
- 9:00new genre. The Robinsonod. Part survival fiction,
- 9:05part adventure fiction. It's the castaway novel,
- 9:09but the name helps its audience find it. And
- 9:15that's how we get 1812's The Swiss Family Robinson.
- 9:20Robinson is not their last name. Robinson is
- 9:25the genre. A 2026 version of this title would
- 9:29be The Swiss Family Castaway, like the movie.
- 9:34A lot of Robinsonod stories are solo adventures.
- 9:38That makes a lot of sense, right? It's about
- 9:41having to survive without resources or without
- 9:45community, without infrastructure. But this story
- 9:49is about a family unit immigrating from Switzerland
- 9:53to Australia. They are stranded on a ship when
- 9:57the crew abandons it in the face of a terrible
- 10:00storm, which drives them to an unknown island
- 10:03in the South Pacific. The family unit is a mom
- 10:06and dad and four sons. They take the supplies
- 10:10from the ship to the island, set up camp, and
- 10:14eventually build a treehouse. ends up being a
- 10:18temporary shelter as the mom gets hurt and decides
- 10:21she'd rather live in a cave. They are there for
- 10:25ten years, meeting various animals, doing various
- 10:28tasks, and I cannot express this to you enough,
- 10:33this book is incredibly boring. Robinson Crusoe
- 10:38is written in first person, and he spends a good
- 10:41portion of the story explaining things to you,
- 10:44the reader. Because of how many characters are
- 10:47in The Swiss Family Robinson, it's told in third
- 10:51person, and most of the book is the father explaining
- 10:54things to his children or lecturing them on morals
- 10:58and virtues. It is an entire novel of exposition.
- 11:04You've heard the epithet, the book is always
- 11:07better? This is an exception to that rule. In
- 11:131960, films were required to start with credits.
- 11:17But unlike other contemporary films that had
- 11:21the credits as a separate entity or over B -roll
- 11:24footage, these credits serve as a prologue. We
- 11:30begin with the ship tossed in the storm, driven
- 11:33by wind, dark storm clouds in the background
- 11:36with the credits projected over top. And then,
- 11:40partway through, We get a short scene. We hear
- 11:45the family yelling for help, the two older sons
- 11:48and their father banging on the locked door,
- 11:51shutting them in their cabin. Mother grabs her
- 11:54youngest son and begins to pray. More footage
- 11:58of the ship, with credits, as it heads for a
- 12:01cluster of rocks. We hear a terrible sound, and
- 12:05then we get another short scene. She's hit something,
- 12:09explains father. And then we're back to the ship,
- 12:13wrecked on the rocks as the credits finish out.
- 12:19This makes an incredibly efficient use of credits.
- 12:23The adventure has already begun. Where is the
- 12:26ship? Why is this family locked in their cabin?
- 12:30Why is no one coming to help them? How will they
- 12:33get out of this situation? All of these questions
- 12:36are the promise of discovery. Your curiosity
- 12:41is piqued. You want to go on this adventure with
- 12:44this family. You've also already experienced
- 12:48the thrill of the sublime, another frequent aspect
- 12:51of adventure. There will be danger ahead. Are
- 12:55you ready? Okay, now for weird coincidence time.
- 13:01How does Star Wars begin? Yes, without credits.
- 13:07George Lucas got kicked out of the Director's
- 13:09Guild for that. But the actual scene? It begins
- 13:13with a ship being chased by a much larger ship,
- 13:18exchanging gunfire, and then we go on to the
- 13:21smaller ship, watching everyone in turmoil as
- 13:25our initial point -of -view characters navigate
- 13:27their way through the chaos. I'm not saying this
- 13:31is a copy of a 1960s Disney movie. I'm saying
- 13:36that both are based on the premise that you should
- 13:39jump into the action as quickly as possible to
- 13:42pull your audience into an adventure. There's
- 13:46the promise of discovery. Why is that ship being
- 13:49chased? What did they do wrong? How did these
- 13:52robots get thrown into this mess? The sense of
- 13:56danger. That Star Destroyer looks so huge. It's
- 14:01existentially huge. An instant emotional connection.
- 14:06I think a lot of failed blockbusters try to do
- 14:10this with a cold open, but they forget that the
- 14:14promise of discovery only works if you actually
- 14:17discover something interesting and equally exciting.
- 14:22Curiosity is only good if it's satisfied. A hook
- 14:26is only as good as what it pulls you into. But
- 14:30a cold open for the sake of a cold open isn't
- 14:34worth it. You need both the curiosity and the
- 14:40result. Swiss Family Robinson doesn't follow
- 14:45the usual three -act structure with an inciting
- 14:48incident a third into the film and a lowest point
- 14:52two -thirds in. What it does have are three distinct
- 14:56parts threaded together. Part one covers the
- 15:00building of a raft, traveling to the islands,
- 15:03collecting supplies, setting up camp, and building
- 15:06the iconic treehouse. This is the part of the
- 15:10film most connected to the book, a good deal
- 15:13of which focuses on the animals they bring from
- 15:16the ship and the ones they encounter on the island.
- 15:20Here, Father is our protagonist. We watch him
- 15:25rally up his sons to make camp, decide to settle
- 15:29on the island rather than just wait on the beach
- 15:31for a ship, and build a state -of -the -art 1950s
- 15:36house in a tree out of bamboo and string, complete
- 15:39with running water, a fridge, and a sunroof in
- 15:42the bedroom. As boring as all of that sounds,
- 15:46this film succeeds because it understands how
- 15:50to turn the ordinary into an adventure. Rafting
- 15:54to shore is a whitewater rapids adventure. Will
- 15:58the captain's dogs be able to swim to them, or
- 16:01will their weight capsize the raft? Collecting
- 16:05supplies is an adventure. They spot another ship,
- 16:09but it's actually a ship full of p***. Pirates,
- 16:11the very ship that chased them into the storm
- 16:14in the beginning. When they travel back to the
- 16:17mainland with the ship's animals, they face the
- 16:19threat of sharks. And even showing off their
- 16:23new home includes the excitement of discovery.
- 16:27Frankly, the tour of the house is really cool.
- 16:31It's the solving a problem part of adventure.
- 16:35There's so much excitement in the set design
- 16:38and its reveal of every little part of this building.
- 16:41No wonder they put it in Disneyland as an attraction.
- 16:45It doesn't need to be a ride. Just a walkthrough
- 16:49is pretty cool. There aren't any weird coincidences
- 16:53between this and Star Wars, but it's still clear
- 16:57that Lucas learned the same lesson, that even
- 17:00the ordinary should be an adventure. Take our
- 17:04introduction to Luke. It's a simple scene of
- 17:07a boy and his uncle shopping for supplies. But
- 17:11the way this scene unfolds, it feels like an
- 17:15adventure. Threepio and R2 don't know why they're
- 17:19stopping, and that sparks curiosity. We watch
- 17:23the Jawas unload them with a lot of questions
- 17:27about what exactly is happening. Then we see
- 17:30Uncle Owen and Luke and we begin to understand.
- 17:34But instead of a simple scene of purchasing droids,
- 17:37we have a little bit of a story as another unit
- 17:41is picked instead. A deviation that has inspired
- 17:45so much curiosity that it led to an actual canon
- 17:49short story. Too many blockbusters leave in the
- 17:54scene where the character gets into his car,
- 17:56because it's product placement, but don't let
- 17:59that ordinary be an adventure. Or they make the
- 18:03mistake of skipping the ordinary under the assumption
- 18:06that it's boring, without taking the time to
- 18:10let the ordinary be the adventure. Part two of
- 18:17Swiss Family Robinson takes a turn into plot.
- 18:21Older sons, Fritz and Ernst, leave on a trip
- 18:24to circumnavigate the island. Partway through,
- 18:28they run into the same pirates, who have kidnapped
- 18:31a ship captain and his grandchild, a cabin boy.
- 18:34They free the grandchild, but the captain negotiates
- 18:38to be taken as ransom. Their canoe struck against
- 18:42the rocks and the ocean, the boys have to walk
- 18:45home. Along the way, they discover that the grandchild
- 18:49is actually a girl named Roberta. This chunk
- 18:53of the film makes the bold choice to change protagonists.
- 18:59In part one, Fritz and Ernst are very much supporting
- 19:03characters, there to fill out the story. Fritz
- 19:06doesn't have much of a personality, and Ernst
- 19:10is there as comedic relief, eager and bookish,
- 19:13a know -it -all who doesn't, actually. But in
- 19:16part two, we get to know them more intimately.
- 19:19Instead of just a string of adventures, we are
- 19:23on a journey of discovery for who these people
- 19:25are. Learning their wants and strengths and weaknesses
- 19:29is just as much a part of the adventure as running
- 19:32from pirates or navigating the jungle. We also
- 19:37get the girl into the mix. While Roberta is a
- 19:41damsel in distress on paper, the number of times
- 19:44she's just supposed to burst into tears, actress
- 19:48Janet Monroe gives her an active presence. She's
- 19:52skittish and awkward before her identity is revealed,
- 19:56and her actions to the discomfort of the situation
- 19:59is frankly more relatable to an audience who
- 20:03is both thrilled and a little disgusted at the
- 20:06idea of crawling through mud or interacting with
- 20:09violent wildlife. Unlike Temple of Doom's Willie
- 20:14Scott, she largely swallows her screams. Later,
- 20:20she displays a confidence with the use of a firearm
- 20:23and courage in the face of violence. She's not
- 20:28quite a Princess Leia, but she's definitely a
- 20:31stepping stone on the way. And speaking of Princess
- 20:35Leia, it's time for another weird coincidence.
- 20:39During part two, while wading through a river,
- 20:42Fritz is attacked by a green anaconda, which
- 20:46pulls him underwater. Roberta screams and scrambles
- 20:50up the riverbank as Fritz shouts, Ernst, the
- 20:53knife, the knife, while he struggles with the
- 20:56snake. The boys fight with the creature until
- 20:59both emerge, shaken, cut, and having lost their
- 21:04compass. am convinced that Lucas used this scene
- 21:10as inspiration for the trash compactor creature
- 21:12in Star Wars. It's not an exact copy, but it
- 21:18feels rotoscoped, capturing the chaos, the thrashing
- 21:23water, the bizarre comedy. Shoot it! Where? Anywhere!
- 21:28The girl trying to stay out of the way, and it
- 21:32all being over rather suddenly. Lucas also uses
- 21:38a shift in protagonists. Luke doesn't even arrive
- 21:42in the movie until almost 20 minutes in. Han
- 21:46Solo until 45. Leia only gets a handful of words,
- 21:51mostly her recorded message, until she takes
- 21:54control of the story at an hour 15. All of these
- 21:58character entrances come with the promise of
- 22:01discovery and a delightful story shift. Each
- 22:05introduction kicks the story into a higher gear
- 22:09of adventure, the complication of the character
- 22:12dynamic fueling the excitement. This is only
- 22:16worth doing if the characters aren't cardboard
- 22:19thin. James MacArthur might be a bit of a wooden
- 22:23actor, but his character Fritz has enough interest
- 22:27on the page to fuel the story anyway. Meanwhile,
- 22:32Star Fox in the Super Mario Galaxy movie looks
- 22:35cool, and people say he's cool, but there's no
- 22:40sense of discovery, nothing to uncover in his
- 22:43dynamic with literally any character in that
- 22:46film. It's the reveal and the depth that makes
- 22:51an audience sit up and lean in. Part 3 is a war
- 22:58film. Fritz and Ernst and Roberta bring father
- 23:02news of the pirates, and he deduces that they
- 23:05will return. They all prepare for how they'll
- 23:09protect themselves from the attack, and then
- 23:11we see the battle actually play out. Swiss family
- 23:15versus pirates. Now feels like an appropriate
- 23:20time to actually address the pirates, and my
- 23:25conflicted feelings on them. As a 90s kid, these
- 23:29pirates felt very fresh and interesting. They
- 23:33were pretty much the only pirates I grew up watching
- 23:35who weren't British. They're Asian, which means
- 23:39their ship has a distinct style, and so do their
- 23:42outfits. I didn't grow up in the wake of World
- 23:47War II and the Korean War. on the precipice of
- 23:50Vietnam, when the yellow peril warped racist
- 23:54depiction of Asians as superstitious savages
- 23:58was a primary depiction. My cultural soup had
- 24:03its own problems. Mystical Orientalism shows
- 24:07up in so many 80s and 90s kids' movies. But I
- 24:12didn't understand that most of the extras in
- 24:16Swiss Family Robinson are in yellow or brown
- 24:18face, and that the captain's dialogue is unnaturally
- 24:23broken English. But the actor who plays the pirate
- 24:29captain, Sessu Hayakawa, does an amazing job.
- 24:34He's terrifying and clever and campy. Reminds
- 24:39me a lot of Geoffrey Rush's performance as Captain
- 24:43Barbossa in Pirates of the Caribbean. I wish
- 24:47he could have been given better dialogue and
- 24:50a less racist cast because he is such a formidable
- 24:54villain for this kid's adventure movie. But back
- 25:00to part three. Father quite literally stands
- 25:04on the battlefield and sketches out the methods
- 25:07the family will use to defeat the pirates. Methods
- 25:11we watch them build and prepare. Yet the actual
- 25:15execution of each booby trap and weapon is so
- 25:19satisfying that nothing is spoiled by knowing.
- 25:23In fact, knowing what will come next is a build
- 25:27of suspense, an incredibly satisfying piece of
- 25:31dramatic irony, as we know what will come next,
- 25:34and the pirates don't. George Lucas understood
- 25:39this satisfaction, and it's a big part of Star
- 25:42Wars. We get a whole scene where the General
- 25:45tells the exact plan to the pilots for destroying
- 25:49the Death Star, complete with visual depiction.
- 25:53and it spoils nothing for the battle to come.
- 25:56Part of this is that the visual display is all
- 25:59crude vector graphics. It's so different from
- 26:03the actual battle that nothing is spoiled. But
- 26:07we get the setup of how small their target is,
- 26:10and despite Luke's confidence, we begin to wonder
- 26:14if they'll actually pull it off. but because
- 26:17we don't know what their ships will look like
- 26:20flying in space or the actual dangers of the
- 26:23Death Star battle, all of which become shockingly
- 26:26real to us as the battle begins. Bad blockbusters
- 26:31may add a planning scene with the assumption
- 26:34that the point is to explain what's about to
- 26:37happen. That isn't the case. The point is to
- 26:42build anticipation. I don't think it's wrong
- 26:46to skip the planning or to layer it all on top
- 26:50of each other. Ocean's Eleven is amazing at that.
- 26:53But I think it's easy to forget the excitement
- 26:56of setting up a plan and watching it play out.
- 27:00To see young Francis explain how he's going to
- 27:03catch his tiger and then watch the tiger fall
- 27:06into its pit where it leaps out to chase the
- 27:09pirates late into Act 3. I can't prove. how much
- 27:14of Swiss family Robinson is in Star Wars, or
- 27:18by proxy, the last 50 years of blockbusters.
- 27:22It might just be a coincidence that the weapons
- 27:26the Ewoks used to defeat the stormtroopers in
- 27:29Return of the Jedi use the same log and stone
- 27:33construction that our Swiss family uses. Maybe
- 27:37this was just a subconscious influence, like
- 27:41Ken Anakin's last name made the Sanskrit name
- 27:45stick more firmly in Lucas's head. I just can't
- 27:50get over how much adventure is in the blockbuster's
- 27:54DNA, and how much of that genre or its spirit
- 27:58has been forgotten by men in boardrooms. But
- 28:04you know a good adventure when you see it. And
- 28:08I hope we'll see more of them here, on the cusp
- 28:11of summer. Thanks for coming.