Latest / The Vegan Report / Jane Goodall VS. David Attenborough. With Alex Ventimilla | Ep. 95
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan
- 0:02and today we compare two different approaches
- 0:06to advancing the environmental cause from two
- 0:09vegan giants, Jane Goodall and David Attenborough.
- 0:14Both have released documentaries focused on the
- 0:17climate crisis, animal welfare, and their personal
- 0:21journeys into activism. Jane Goodall's documentary,
- 0:25The Hope, is available on YouTube. David Attenborough's
- 0:29A Life on Our Planet is on Netflix. You'll find
- 0:33the links in the episode notes. To discuss this
- 0:36topic, I'm joined by the amazing Alex Ventimiglia
- 0:39-Sanchez, professor in the Department of English
- 0:42and Film Studies at the University of Alberta.
- 0:45We talked about the stereotype of the ecological
- 0:49Indian, the apocalyptic predictions environmentalists
- 0:54love to make, the collapse of humanity's birth
- 0:57rates, the role of plant -based diets and animal
- 1:01welfare in the environmental cause, and much
- 1:04more. It was a real pleasure talking with Alex.
- 1:08Enjoy the episode, and don't forget to follow
- 1:11the show for more like this. Also, share the
- 1:15joy of this episode with the vegans you know.
- 1:18By the way, if you missed it, go check out last
- 1:21week's Wednesday episode. The Vegan Report is
- 1:24now releasing episodes every Wednesday on the
- 1:28science of activism. I don't usually watch documentaries.
- 1:44I avoid them. I feel like they are not in depth
- 1:49enough and they're more like pieces of propaganda,
- 1:53to be honest, than anything else. But for, you
- 1:58know, to record this episode, I went and watched
- 2:02the two documentaries and I'm looking forward
- 2:05to our conversation. Yeah. Well, first off, thank
- 2:09you for having me back. I had a really good time
- 2:12last time, and I look forward to this episode.
- 2:18The one thing, I know where you're coming from.
- 2:21For me, documentaries are essentially my job
- 2:24now, in the sense that studying them is what
- 2:28my dissertation is about. That's what my research
- 2:30is about. And so I've developed a love -hate
- 2:35relationship with these films. And that wasn't
- 2:38there before. I started watching them. or I started
- 2:42researching them because I grew up watching documentaries
- 2:44or what a lot of people call documentaries. I
- 2:47think we're going to talk about that today because
- 2:51what makes a documentary and what makes it a
- 2:58piece of propaganda, as you said, as opposed
- 3:00to something else and what that something else
- 3:03then becomes is relevant to any discussion of
- 3:07people like David Attenborough and more recently
- 3:11Jane Goodall as she began to appear in more of
- 3:15these films. But yeah, thank you for having me
- 3:17back and I look forward to our discussion. Of
- 3:20course, amazing. I wanted to start with highlighting
- 3:25how Jane Goodall and David Attenborough had a
- 3:31friendship. I think a decade long friendship.
- 3:35They also collaborated. on lots of conservation
- 3:40projects. And I thought it was worth mentioning.
- 3:46They're also both of them, you know, British
- 3:48of a certain age, and activists in that, you
- 3:55know, in the last stages of their life, which
- 3:58is also fascinating. I'm sure you know, lots
- 4:03of retired people, they don't It's not often
- 4:09that you see someone in their 80s or 90s displaying
- 4:15that level of energy and passion and conviction
- 4:19and speaking up for a cause they hold dear. So
- 4:26yeah, fascinating resemblance between the two.
- 4:31Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I think one of the first
- 4:33things that we need to establish, and I think
- 4:35the way in which you're opening your that this
- 4:38episode is a good way to establish that, is that
- 4:41we need to divorce or separate our understanding
- 4:48of Atomorrow and Goodell as people, right? And
- 4:54what the films that they partake in, or they
- 4:57partook in now, past tense, is and what they
- 5:02actually accomplish, right? Because I think it's
- 5:06undeniable that both Goodall and Adam Burrow
- 5:10had always the best intentions in mind, right?
- 5:13Their activism is truly admirable, right? You
- 5:19look at the work that both of them undertook
- 5:24over the course of their lives and when it started,
- 5:27right? Particularly when it started because as
- 5:29you mentioned, right? So both of them are British
- 5:32and that's important already because Britain
- 5:37has traditionally understood itself when it comes
- 5:41to issues related to ecology or even animals.
- 5:48Britain has understood itself as a nation of
- 5:51animal lovers. This was even something that they
- 5:55talked about openly during World War II, for
- 5:57example. And so they come from this one particular
- 6:03nation that has always had a passion for for
- 6:06issues related to animals and in nature. And
- 6:09it goes back way before that. I mean, Darwin
- 6:12is British. Sir Richard Owen is also British,
- 6:17another famous paleontologist. Excuse me. So
- 6:21yeah, Britain has this long -standing fascination
- 6:23with the natural world, which has its problematic
- 6:27roots. Because it all goes back to to imperialism
- 6:31and colonialism right they start like discovering
- 6:33all these quote unquote exotic places and they're
- 6:36fascinated by the wildlife in those places right
- 6:38so i think that's that's part of the origin of
- 6:41of of this fascination with the natural world
- 6:43but so they both come from that history right
- 6:46and and they come from a particular time like
- 6:49you were saying which is there you know nowadays
- 6:51we would say they're both boomers right they're
- 6:54from the baby boomer generation but that's important
- 6:57too because As David Attenborough talks about
- 7:01in his what I would consider his first true documentary,
- 7:06which is a biopic, David Attenborough, A Life
- 7:08on Our Planet, he mentions that the reason why
- 7:11he was able to have the career he had was because
- 7:15his coming of age and his becoming a television
- 7:18figure, a television personality coincided with
- 7:22the invention of commercial air travel. So a
- 7:26lot of things kind of converge and come together
- 7:29that allowed them to have the careers that they
- 7:33had. Jane Goodall had a similar experience, right?
- 7:35It is only at that point in time that she joins
- 7:39that PhD program that women were allowed and
- 7:44encouraged to become researchers, right? And
- 7:47it was only at that time that they were able
- 7:49to travel Abroad and even then right with an
- 7:53asterisk there because yes, you may know she
- 7:55had to go with her mom, right? She had to be
- 7:57chaperoned because otherwise it would have been
- 8:00seen as inappropriate for a British woman to
- 8:02go by herself to the African wilderness, right?
- 8:07So so yeah, they're they're they're lives And
- 8:12and the work that they have done I wouldn't say
- 8:17it's coincidental, but it becomes possible because
- 8:21of a number of historical developments that I
- 8:24think also kind of inform the way they see things.
- 8:27They inform the way in which they began their
- 8:31careers and the transformations that they undertook
- 8:34as their careers unfolded. About the comment
- 8:38on how British people are animal lovers. It's
- 8:44funny, I had the conversation recently with a
- 8:48foundation called the Battersea Foundation, and
- 8:52they're based in the UK. And they have been fighting
- 8:56for animal welfare for 160 years, 160 years.
- 9:04And I thought about that number and it down on
- 9:08me that it their organization was older than
- 9:12Canada itself. That's one interesting way to
- 9:16think about it. Yeah. Yeah, that's true. Yeah.
- 9:19No, like I said, it's a historical phenomenon.
- 9:23I think, like I said, it has its roots in certain
- 9:27more problematic and darker aspects of British
- 9:30history. But the truth of the matter is that
- 9:33some good has come of it. I think, for instance,
- 9:37the the beginning of the conservation movement
- 9:40can be thought of as an offshoot of the examples
- 9:45to collect specimens, which is how it all began.
- 9:52And yeah, and later on, Adam Borough's career
- 9:55is because Adam Borough is the more, let's say,
- 10:01Mediatic figure right he is the one who whose
- 10:05career largely revolved around the media and
- 10:09so um hit that that. His the beginning of his
- 10:17career right is. permitted by the invention,
- 10:21like I said, of air travel. But even before that,
- 10:23he starts his career in broadcasting because
- 10:26suddenly Britain has a television system, right?
- 10:29Like a public television system, right? And they're
- 10:32trying to come up with programming that people
- 10:34will like, right? And so as a nation of animal
- 10:38lovers, they think, well, why not shows about
- 10:41animals, right? And Adam Borough's first shows
- 10:44were actually him. bringing animals into television
- 10:48studios, right? Kind of like what you see nowadays
- 10:50with on late night shows like Conan O 'Brien's
- 10:54or Stephen Colbert's, right? They bring experts
- 10:58to the show with animals and they talk about
- 11:03these animals, right? And I think, I don't know
- 11:06if you've ever talked about this on your podcast,
- 11:08but there is a serious issue there, right? In
- 11:13fact, I know you don't like documentaries, but
- 11:15there is a documentary. Boy, I'm going to look
- 11:20it up in a second, but there's a documentary
- 11:22that talks about this industry, the industry
- 11:25of people or that revolves and supports people
- 11:29who are promoted as animal experts and they go
- 11:35on television and they bring these animals and
- 11:36they talk about them and they talk about them
- 11:39as you know, like ambassadors. They promote these
- 11:43animals as ambassadors for their species and
- 11:45how, you know, they do this to promote conservation
- 11:47and such. But in reality, there's an entire industry
- 11:51that supplies them with animals, right? And that's
- 11:55still happening today. So that's actually how
- 11:57Adam Laura's career begins, right? And I think
- 11:59it's telling that that sort of stuff is something
- 12:03that he walked away from early on, right? That
- 12:05he decided not to bring the animal to the studio,
- 12:10but rather to take the studio and the crew, the
- 12:14camera crew and everyone else out into the wilderness,
- 12:17right? Which is, I think, a less problematic
- 12:22practice because it doesn't require you to bring
- 12:25an animal that's been essentially kidnapped or
- 12:30else bred in captivity to a studio where it feels...
- 12:34absolutely out of place and terrorized. And you
- 12:36see it a lot in these shows today. They bring
- 12:39like a leopard cub, for example. And you can
- 12:42see the fear in their eyes. They're not meant
- 12:45to be in there. But that's actually how Adam
- 12:47Burrow's career began. Goodell never did that
- 12:50because she became a celebrity later on. And
- 12:54so it was only after her actual scientific work
- 12:57that she began to appear in nature documentaries.
- 13:01So she never engaged in anything like that. But
- 13:04but it's funny to think that that um, but yeah,
- 13:07like it was that demand for for images of animals
- 13:11that that catapulted Adam Borrow into like a
- 13:14career in broadcasting. And that it actually
- 13:17began in a way that today we would find appalling
- 13:19as people who care for the welfare of animals.
- 13:23Let's spend a moment to talk about the platforms
- 13:26where we can find those documentaries. So right
- 13:31now the David Adam Borrow documentaries on Netflix.
- 13:37The Jane Goodall documentary was on Disney Plus,
- 13:40but it is available for free on YouTube. I think
- 13:44they did that. The National Geographic YouTube
- 13:47channel did that to mark her passing. So is there
- 13:53any pertinent information to grasp from that
- 14:00choice of platforms? Well, there's lots and again,
- 14:04I think we have to make a distinction here because
- 14:08Excuse me because they have significantly different
- 14:11careers when it comes to their appearances in
- 14:15the media, right Jane Goodall Only really became
- 14:24a media personality towards the tail end of her
- 14:27scientific career, right? And most of those shows
- 14:31in which she appeared were not necessarily about
- 14:36her going to these places where she had worked
- 14:40with chimpanzees, although there are a few, quite
- 14:43a few shows that or programs or else feature
- 14:48length documentaries that do show her in the,
- 14:55in Gombe. for example, with the chimps that she
- 14:57actually studied or else traveling around promoting
- 15:02conservation, which is what you see in Jane Goodall,
- 15:05The Hope. They talk about her work as an activist
- 15:08rather than as a scientist. And so we see her
- 15:11traveling from place to place promoting these
- 15:14causes. That's essentially the role that she
- 15:20has performed. whenever she's being on television
- 15:25or on documentaries. And so her platforms have
- 15:28been different. Historically, these programs
- 15:33have been produced largely for television. You
- 15:38don't really see them at the movies. Occasionally,
- 15:41you do. For example, Jane Goodall, The Hope did
- 15:44screen at a number of documentary festivals or
- 15:47film festivals. But for the most part, she's
- 15:50a television personality. And that's true also
- 15:54for Adam Borough, but in a significantly different
- 15:57way. So, and the reason why I'm talking, I'm
- 15:59going to get to the point of Netflix and Disney
- 16:01Plus, but I think it's important to start with
- 16:03a history of their media appearance, especially
- 16:06with Adam Borough, because even though there
- 16:10are a number of issues with them being on Disney
- 16:12and particularly on Netflix, I think there is
- 16:18a significant silver lining and then being on
- 16:23those platforms. So let me go back to Adam Borough's
- 16:26career. So like I said, it starts with the establishment
- 16:30of a public broadcasting system in Britain, which
- 16:37later becomes the BBC. And so the BBC and David
- 16:42Adam Borough have a long -standing relationship.
- 16:47I believe over six decades, they worked together.
- 16:54In many ways, David Attenborough had a sort of
- 16:59exclusivity deal with the BBC for that period
- 17:03of time in that he would occasionally appear
- 17:05in other productions. He's been featured in American
- 17:08productions, for instance, as voiceover. But
- 17:11the bulk of his work was produced by the BBC,
- 17:17particularly what later became the BBC's natural
- 17:20history unit. So the BBC, because of this demand
- 17:24for images of animals and exotic landscapes and
- 17:27all that, they actually create their own secondary
- 17:31studio entirely dedicated to what they call natural
- 17:34history programming. And David Attenborough is
- 17:37the flagship. He is front and center whenever
- 17:40there is a significant production. Most of these,
- 17:42again, are initially for television. But in the
- 17:4690s and early 2000s, there was a shift. Because
- 17:49suddenly, and I think part of my research, one
- 17:53of the arguments that I'm making, is that this
- 17:56shift is motivated by a sudden interest in the
- 17:59environment. that comes about not just in Britain
- 18:02anymore, but also in the United States and around
- 18:04the world. And that this interest comes about
- 18:07because there is this sudden discourse of climate
- 18:10change, right? We're talking about climate change
- 18:12and we're talking about how the world is changing,
- 18:14right? And all of these places are going away.
- 18:17Later we start talking about mass extinction,
- 18:19which is what I'm most interested in. But so
- 18:21suddenly there's this huge demand for natural
- 18:25history programming. or wildlife films, as some
- 18:29scholars, myself included, call them. These are
- 18:32not, I would argue, these are not documentaries.
- 18:36I would argue that they are constructs. These
- 18:39are films in which David Attenborough, by his
- 18:44own admittance, he would go out and try to film
- 18:50as much behavior as possible, and then stitch
- 18:53that behavior into a story. So they would, for
- 18:57example, record a number of cheetahs or a number
- 19:00of lions doing different things, hunting, sleeping,
- 19:03whatever, usually not the same individual because
- 19:06tracking these animals is hard. And so they would
- 19:09record as much behavior as possible and then
- 19:13stitch that together into a story about one particular
- 19:16cheetah or one particular pride of lions. But
- 19:19in reality, what you're watching is a number
- 19:22of different individual animals. performing behaviors
- 19:24that are proper to the species. And so you can't
- 19:28really say that these are documentaries, first
- 19:31off, because the narratives are entirely fictional.
- 19:36The stories did not unfold as you see them on
- 19:39TV or later on, on IMAX, for example, when Planet
- 19:45Earth comes about, for instance. Planet Earth
- 19:47definitely screened in theaters, especially IMAX
- 19:52theaters. So it was not just television anymore.
- 19:55This was proper cinema, so to speak. But at the
- 19:57same time, we can't really call them documentaries.
- 20:01And there is a reason for this. So even though
- 20:05Attenborough has always promoted conservation,
- 20:12the Natural History Unit at the BBC And there
- 20:18are a number of records in which producers explicitly
- 20:21say this, right? They essentially forbade him
- 20:25from getting political. And what that meant was
- 20:28that he could talk about how these are animals
- 20:31that are endangered. He could mention that saving
- 20:36them was important, but he could not go into
- 20:39any sort of detail as to how this could happen.
- 20:43Right. So nothing about legislation. Right. Nothing
- 20:46about what practices people could engage in.
- 20:50Right. And nothing that seemed to doom and gloom,
- 20:54as they called it. Right. That phrase actually
- 20:56comes from a producer in the natural history
- 20:58unit who told him nothing doom and gloom, please.
- 21:01Essentially. Right. So so David Attenborough
- 21:05and his and all of his films have historically
- 21:08been apolitical in the sense that they don't
- 21:12tackle any of these serious political questions
- 21:14that come about when you talk about conservation
- 21:17or animal welfare. None of that is visible in
- 21:21planet Earth, for example. They don't talk about
- 21:23what's actually causing polar bears to go extinct.
- 21:26They say it's climate change, but how do we fix
- 21:29climate change? Well, we're not going to talk
- 21:30about that because people don't want to talk
- 21:33about that. People just want to look at pretty
- 21:34pictures of polar bears. So the reason why I
- 21:39don't call them documentaries. And most documentary
- 21:42scholars also feel uncomfortable referring to
- 21:44these films as documentaries because, well, they're
- 21:47not political, they're not historical, and they're
- 21:50mostly fictional. So that's a long preamble to
- 21:56what happens with a life on our planet and David
- 22:02Attenborough, a life on our planet. So those
- 22:04are two different things. So a life on our planet.
- 22:07is a wildlife film series, right? I think it's
- 22:12a five -part series. And that was just like your
- 22:16typical wildlife film, right? Like Planet Earth.
- 22:19So it's just nice pictures of beautiful landscapes,
- 22:23usually about a particular species. And again,
- 22:25right? It's usually not one individual animal
- 22:28that they're filming. It's a number of individuals.
- 22:30And they just turn that into a story about one
- 22:33individual. So again, not a documentary. But
- 22:35that is accompanied or that is released hand
- 22:38in hand with David Attenborough, A Life on Our
- 22:41Planet, which is a standalone documentary. Now,
- 22:46this is significant because one of the reasons
- 22:51why David Attenborough steps away from the BBC
- 22:56and the natural history unit at the BBC and goes
- 23:00to work with Netflix for the very first time,
- 23:03right? is that Netflix gave him essentially the
- 23:07green light to talk about these more political
- 23:09issues, right? So whereas the BBC was like, still
- 23:13Adam and today, I think they're changing, slowly
- 23:15changing, slowly becoming more political, right?
- 23:18But the reason why Adam steps away from that
- 23:22and he goes on to make a life on our planet and
- 23:25then his biopic is because Netflix allowed him
- 23:29to talk about the more serious issues. And Adam
- 23:33Borrow felt like it was high time that we did,
- 23:36right? Because he had begun to talk about these
- 23:39matters in conferences or public appearances
- 23:43and such, but he could still not talk about anything
- 23:47related to, for example, their relationship between
- 23:51climate change and factory farming, right? he
- 23:55was essentially just heavily discouraged from
- 23:58talking about that in his natural history films
- 24:02or the wildlife films that he narrated, right?
- 24:06And so because he felt like it was imperative
- 24:09that we started talking about these and that
- 24:12he used his media persona to talk about these
- 24:16issues, he steps away from the BBC momentarily
- 24:19because he's still working with them, right?
- 24:21But he goes and works with Netflix. which again,
- 24:24produces a life on our planet and allows him
- 24:28to talk about these issues for the first time.
- 24:31And it is in David Attenborough, a life on our
- 24:33planet, that we first hear him actually endorse
- 24:37a plant -based diet for the very first time.
- 24:43Because again, this is a contentious issue that
- 24:45nobody wanted him to talk about, but he is like,
- 24:47well, enough is enough. We have to talk about
- 24:50what are some serious possible solutions to the
- 24:54ecological crisis, right? Because as he details
- 24:56in that film, he has seen it firsthand, right?
- 25:00The fact that he has been able to travel to all
- 25:02these places and literally watch them disappear
- 25:08over the course of his lifetime, right? Well,
- 25:12of course it motivated his activism, but what
- 25:16good is your activism if you cannot use the biggest
- 25:19platforms that you're given? to actually promote
- 25:22causes that would address these issues. So that
- 25:26is why his departure from the BBC to produce
- 25:33these Netflix documentaries, I think there's
- 25:37that silver lining that for the very first time
- 25:39we see somebody of his caliber, right? When it
- 25:42comes to conservation and you know, like. popular
- 25:46science and all that stuff talk about these issues
- 25:48more seriously. And also, again, I propose of
- 25:53the things that we share, which is veganism.
- 25:56First time he promotes a plant -based diet. I
- 26:00think that's hugely significant. But of course,
- 26:03there's the other side of this. Netflix is not
- 26:06an ecologically friendly company in any ways.
- 26:09So they use huge data servers which consume lots
- 26:12of resources. the fact that all of this is still
- 26:17behind a paywall means that his activism is limited
- 26:21by, you know, the number of people who actually
- 26:23afford to get Netflix. Or in the case of Jane
- 26:25Goodall, Disney Plus or any other platform that
- 26:28she is given, right? Because there are a number
- 26:31now of documentaries that talk about her life,
- 26:33that talk about her activism and in which she
- 26:36promotes certain practices that are political,
- 26:39like veganism, right? Or perhaps donating to
- 26:42particular organizations or not. engaging in
- 26:45consumerism, great ideas, good ideas, ideas that
- 26:49could potentially allow people to make a significant
- 26:54impact when it comes to conservation and animal
- 26:57welfare, but that, again, are behind a huge paywall.
- 27:00And so their reach is limited by the fact that
- 27:04these are still financed by companies. So if
- 27:09we're going to take anything from this, is that
- 27:13In many ways, there are limitations to the power
- 27:17that they had even or they have still, right?
- 27:21As media figures that promote conservation, animal
- 27:24welfare, plant -based diets more recently, right?
- 27:29There are serious limitations and these limitations
- 27:31are placed there by the industries that platform
- 27:34them as public figures. So there's a bit of a
- 27:38contradiction there and it's difficult to...
- 27:41to make sense of it, to reconcile that, right?
- 27:44Because I think we would hope that somebody like
- 27:49Jane Goodall or David Attenborough would find
- 27:52ways to not depend on these companies. But unfortunately,
- 27:55that is not the case, right? And that perhaps,
- 27:59personally, that's what I find the most doom
- 28:01and gloom aspect of this whole industry. The
- 28:04fact that you have people that are admirable.
- 28:07Right. But who nevertheless depend on companies
- 28:10that are far less than admirable. Let me push
- 28:16back on that point, because if they want to record
- 28:23high quality documentaries, they need funding.
- 28:27So they need to sell that. that product at some
- 28:33point, you know, to justify the production costs.
- 28:38And then there's also the fact, you know, from
- 28:41the perspective of distribution. Well, if they
- 28:47made that documentary free, would that really
- 28:52have attracted more eyeballs? I feel like people
- 28:58for some weird marketing reason, will often overlook
- 29:04free stuff and pay more attention to things that
- 29:10have a price tag on. And so if you want lots
- 29:17of people to watch your documentary or get your
- 29:21book, better sell that book than just put it
- 29:27out there for free. Yeah, I think Like I said,
- 29:32I think there are a number of contradictions
- 29:34that need to be addressed. And perhaps we can't
- 29:40really resolve. Because you're 100 % right. What
- 29:45I'm saying is that, again, that's why I wanted
- 29:48to start by saying that none of what I'm going
- 29:50to say today is Me reproaching them directly
- 29:55right i have i have nothing but admiration for
- 29:58people like good old and Adam borough it's more.
- 30:02What i was trying to suggest is that the landscape
- 30:07the media landscape that that platforms figures
- 30:11like them and other activists. Is is problematic
- 30:15right i mean i understand your point and i think
- 30:18i would agree there's a reason why there's a
- 30:21huge. pushback against publicly funded television,
- 30:27for example, right? Here in Canada, we have the
- 30:30National Film Board, which is also facing cuts
- 30:33and usually finances Canadian directors so they
- 30:38can make their films. A lot of them are documentaries,
- 30:40right? So yeah, like these public institutions
- 30:45are being... dismantled right and without these
- 30:50public institutions and there's also no real
- 30:52alternative and you're absolutely right I think
- 30:54unfortunately there's a premium on commodity
- 30:57right so so that if you have to pay to watch
- 31:01this film the assumption is of that film is better
- 31:03right than anything that I'll get for free and
- 31:07I think again because the media environment is
- 31:10such that yeah in fact these companies private
- 31:13companies actually need to make revenue and actually
- 31:17need to make money, they do have more resources.
- 31:19And so the end product is usually better. But
- 31:22again, the contradiction that I'm addressing
- 31:26here or the number of contradictions that I'm
- 31:27addressing here are just ethical conundrums that
- 31:30we need to make sense of as individual consumers.
- 31:33Do we sign up and create a Netflix account or
- 31:40a Disney Plus account in order to watch these
- 31:42films that may? change my mind, right? And especially
- 31:46people like you and I who are already in one
- 31:48way or another engaged in activism to some extent,
- 31:53or at the very least who've already made certain
- 31:55choices in order to, you know, to make things
- 32:03better for the environment and animals, right?
- 32:07Do we really still need to consume these products,
- 32:10right? I think they're great products for people
- 32:14who may not be particularly conscious about their
- 32:19environmental and ethical choices, but it's also
- 32:25hard to justify, right? Like for me personally,
- 32:27I love these films, like I've said, right? I
- 32:29really love these. And I have a Disney, I'm sorry,
- 32:33I have a Netflix account, right? I also have
- 32:36Amazon Prime. So it's not like I'm innocent here.
- 32:39What I'm trying to say is that Unfortunately,
- 32:47even figures as, again, as admirable and as environmentally
- 32:53conscious as Attenborough and Goodell could not
- 32:56escape the media industry, right? They needed
- 33:01them. And again, the media industry is not, I
- 33:06think a lot of us could agree, is not an ethical
- 33:10industry. At least environmentally speaking,
- 33:13it's not, right? And so I think in that sense,
- 33:18you encounter a bleaker landscape because it's
- 33:22like, well, there's no other way other than through
- 33:26these companies, right? And what would happen
- 33:29if, say, in Jane Goodall, The Hope or Alive on
- 33:33Our Planet, Adam Borough or Goodall said, Oh,
- 33:37and also another thing you could use to reduce
- 33:39your environmental footprint is don't sign up
- 33:42to Netflix or Disney Plus, right? Do you think
- 33:46they would still be platformed? So they're still
- 33:49kind of like on a leash, right? And so that's
- 33:53kind of the problem that I'm trying to point
- 33:54out. But again, right, as somebody who studies
- 33:57documentaries and who started studying them,
- 34:00because I think these films are Potentially,
- 34:04they have lots of potential for political activism,
- 34:08for catalyzing ethical considerations in the
- 34:11public. I think there's a lot of good in them.
- 34:15But again, it's a mangle of contradictions. And
- 34:19I think it's good to be aware of these things.
- 34:23Definitely. We need to put them on the map and
- 34:26discuss them at the very least. Also, I think
- 34:31it's a generational thing for both of them to
- 34:35bet on the big mainstream media platforms. I
- 34:43would have loved to see David Attenborough or
- 34:48Jane Goodall launching their own YouTube channel
- 34:52or podcast or something of the sort, taking their
- 34:57independence from that. big media machine, but
- 35:01I think it's a hard sell for someone from their
- 35:05generation. Yeah, I think you're right. That's
- 35:10sort of what I had in mind, right? Because I
- 35:12know of other public figures who, again, nobody's
- 35:16perfect. We're all part of this big machine one
- 35:19way or another, right? We haven't figured out
- 35:21a way to live outside of it unless you're one
- 35:26of them. of the grid type of people, right? So
- 35:30we're all part of the grid and so we're all guilty
- 35:33of one thing or another. But so other figures
- 35:36like Richard Dawkins, for instance, right? He
- 35:39now has a kind of podcast on YouTube, right?
- 35:44So he's not dependent on these big media platforms
- 35:51anymore because now he's reaching his audience
- 35:53through a more modern type of medium that bypasses
- 35:59that media industry. Yeah, it would be cool if
- 36:02David Attenborough had a podcast, right? Like,
- 36:05who wouldn't listen to it? We all love his voice,
- 36:07right? We all love listening to him narrate how
- 36:10lions kill a gazelle. So wouldn't it be good?
- 36:13I think lots of people would love to listen to
- 36:16him talk about things that we could all do to
- 36:19solve the ecological crisis and to live a more
- 36:23environmentally ethical life. But yeah, no, you're
- 36:28right. I think it's a generational thing to a
- 36:30large extent. It's also just, well, this is tied
- 36:33into that generational aspect, right? I mean,
- 36:36Jay Goodall just passed away. David Attenborough,
- 36:39who knows how much longer he's got, right? He's
- 36:42old. I believe he's turning 100 now. So imagine
- 36:46a 100 -year -old man who's still traveling, who's
- 36:50still making all these films, and still speaking
- 36:52at all these conferences, on top of that asking
- 36:54him to turn on his laptop and be on a podcast
- 36:57for 30 minutes a day or 30 minutes a week or
- 37:00whatever. I think, yeah, it's a non -realistic
- 37:02expectation, but I agree that perhaps other media
- 37:08platforms that are not part of the larger media
- 37:13industry may offer an alternative, right? But
- 37:16again, when it comes to animals, right? Let's
- 37:20go back to the example of Britain. When it comes
- 37:23to animals, even the people that understands
- 37:27itself as animal lovers, an extension of that
- 37:33love, and I'm not even sure that love is the
- 37:35right word, but an extension of that desire to
- 37:38be close to animals is always going to be consuming
- 37:41images of animals, right? And so somebody who's
- 37:45got a podcast or a YouTube channel may not be
- 37:48able to deliver. the sort of images that people
- 37:54want to consume. So, you know, again, I think
- 37:58there are lots of things to consider here, but
- 38:02the possibilities are there. And, you know, there's
- 38:06lots of really cool content on YouTube right
- 38:09now on TikTok as well that promotes this sort
- 38:13of ecological consciousness that people like.
- 38:17Goodell and Attenborough have been promoting
- 38:19for decades. So there's hope. I mean, that's
- 38:23the whole point of Jane Goodell's documentary,
- 38:26right? That she doesn't think it ends with her,
- 38:28that she thinks that there's lots of things to
- 38:30look forward to and that there are many possibilities
- 38:36that people have not yet considered or that are
- 38:40still being developed that hopefully will take
- 38:42us to a place where where more people live a
- 38:48more environmentally conscious life. I want to
- 38:53discuss a difference, a substantial difference,
- 38:57I think, between the two documentaries. You asked
- 39:01the question, is it intended for us, you know,
- 39:07as an audience, people who know about the ecological
- 39:10crisis, who are vegans and all of that? Well,
- 39:15it is for the public, those two documentaries.
- 39:21I don't think they had like our profile in mind,
- 39:24you know, specifically making those. But the
- 39:31David Attenborough one was like ecology 101.
- 39:38It for me, it was a bit boring, I have to say.
- 39:42Um, he was covering like the basis of, you know,
- 39:47what you should do for the environment. The plant
- 39:50-based portion of the documentary, that was the
- 39:53surprising, uh, stuff, you know, that you don't
- 39:57expect to see, um, in, in that kind of, uh, documentary.
- 40:03But the Jane Goodall one was just on another
- 40:08level, you know? Um, and I want to give. an example
- 40:12of that. They discussed, they decided to cover
- 40:18how she struck a deal with an oil company to
- 40:24create a chimp sanctuary and started talking
- 40:29about the importance of reaching out to the perceived
- 40:32enemy and the ethical aspect of that conversation.
- 40:40And I thought, wow, now we're taking, you know,
- 40:44we're looking at people as intelligent beings
- 40:47and taking them seriously and truly going into
- 40:54an in -depth understanding of what it means to
- 40:58make a difference and care for the environment.
- 41:03Yeah, absolutely. No, thank you for bringing
- 41:04that up. I think, yeah, like so far we've been
- 41:08talking about these two films as being fairly
- 41:10similar. And I think if you think about them
- 41:14as being films about certain people, right, as
- 41:17being to some extent biopics or perhaps just
- 41:21relying on public figures to promote an ecological
- 41:25cause, then they're similar, right? But you're
- 41:28right. I think Alive on Our Planet is a decidedly
- 41:34biographic type of film, right? It goes along
- 41:38a history of, or the history of Attenborough's
- 41:43life and career, right? And yeah, you're right.
- 41:46The stuff that they promote towards the end.
- 41:48It is, as you mentioned, Ed, I think that's a
- 41:53really good way to put it. It's ecology 101,
- 41:55right? It's ecology for people who are not And
- 41:59I think you're right in pointing out that Jane
- 42:02Goodall's documentary engages more intricate
- 42:13questions that come about when we're talking
- 42:16about ecological issues, right? And the example
- 42:18you're using, I think, is great because we...
- 42:25deep thinking of each other, especially here
- 42:29in North America, I think North America has become
- 42:33excessively polarized, right? To the point where
- 42:37people think of each other as enemies, right?
- 42:40And so watching someone who is decidedly an ecologist,
- 42:47right? A conservationist, an animal rights activist,
- 42:51someone like Jane Goodall, watching her go and
- 42:54talk to an oil company, oil executives, people
- 42:58who we tend to think of as the devil on our side
- 43:04of the aisle. I think that's truly something
- 43:08that we need to praise, that we need to admire
- 43:12and that we need to replicate at the level of
- 43:16our lives because it's gotten to the point where
- 43:19people can't even be friends with somebody who
- 43:22holds a political viewpoint that is opposite
- 43:25to your own right and watching her go and talk
- 43:29to the people who have been you know desecrating
- 43:33the places that she wants to protect for decades
- 43:35right and she goes and strikes a deal with them
- 43:38and always so amicably right i think something
- 43:41that we can all agree on is that Jane Goodall
- 43:44is such a nice was such a nice lady right she
- 43:46was a kind person. And so to be able to engage
- 43:50them, as you were saying, right, as intelligent
- 43:53people, as people who are still people, and thus,
- 43:57you can appeal to their senses to their intellect
- 44:00to their emotions, right? I think that's something
- 44:03that's highly commendable. Something else that
- 44:05I have admired about Jane Goodall, the hope,
- 44:07for example, was was the extent to which she
- 44:11deal or there's there's this You know, and I
- 44:14know people are kind of pushing back against
- 44:16it, but the inclusivity of the documentary, right?
- 44:19You might recall that that segment when they're
- 44:21talking with an ecological and environmentalist
- 44:25activist group of comprised primarily by of of
- 44:30Muslim girls, right? I mean. You don't see that
- 44:35sort of environmentalism in most other documentaries,
- 44:39right? It's usually something that I talk about
- 44:40in my research is that there's usually this figure
- 44:43who I call the eco -hero, right? And the eco
- 44:46-hero has a type, right? You see it in Attenborough.
- 44:49You see it in Al Gore, for example. There's other
- 44:53figures like Jeff Corwin or the Cradd Brothers.
- 44:56It's usually a straight white male, right? So
- 44:59here you have, you know, a straight white woman
- 45:03from Britain, yeah, but talking about environmental
- 45:07activism as it occurs in other places, right?
- 45:11Coming from a different perspective, perspectives
- 45:13that we do not associate with ecological activism.
- 45:17So I think that's another, that just goes to
- 45:21show how much more effort was put in that documentary
- 45:24to emphasize that this is an issue that concerns
- 45:28us all, not just the privileged liberals of the
- 45:32global north. Yes. And that's, you know, why
- 45:41I the Jane Goodall documentary truly inspired
- 45:46me. And I was surprised by that reaction. I gained
- 45:51a new appreciation for her. I recorded the whole
- 45:56episode, you know, Talking about her life celebrating
- 46:00her legacy But yeah, the truth is, you know,
- 46:03I gave the mic to people who knew her For whom
- 46:10she was important, but I don't really know Jane
- 46:13Goodall. She never really impacted my life that
- 46:16much but Watching that documentary but also listening
- 46:22to Having a conversation with people for whom
- 46:28she meant a lot, truly gave me an appreciation
- 46:32for her and her amazing life. In the documentary,
- 46:40she never really gives a direction of what you
- 46:50should be doing to end this climate crisis or
- 46:55to help the environment. She's there just to
- 46:58inspire and to be an ambassador, a model to follow.
- 47:04And that's it. You know, she, she leave you with
- 47:08that inspiration and it's up to you to decide,
- 47:11you know, what kind of stuff, um, what kind of
- 47:15activism you want to pursue. But the David Attenborough
- 47:20one, you know, he had some bullet point after
- 47:25bullet point of what we need to do, he has the
- 47:30answer. And I felt like this was a weaker position
- 47:35for a documentary about the environment because
- 47:42it doesn't speak to the reality of everyone.
- 47:49And also then you can attack those ways of making
- 47:56a difference. And the debate is no longer about
- 48:03the climate crisis, the problem, or having to
- 48:07do something, but what is the best thing to do
- 48:12for the planet? So they open themselves to that
- 48:17discussion. Yeah, well, you're touching upon
- 48:20something that I think people are inevitably
- 48:25going to disagree on, or at least they may be
- 48:29surprised by some of the research that goes into
- 48:34the different approaches that you're mentioning,
- 48:36right? So, as you put it, the Hope Jane Goodall's
- 48:45documentary is what you would say in my field
- 48:49less prescriptive right so it doesn't tell you
- 48:53do this and this and that it's not a problem
- 48:55solution documentary it's a bit more observational
- 48:58right and and the you know one theoretical understanding
- 49:04of of simply observing as opposed to prescribing
- 49:08a solution is that because it's more open right
- 49:13because there is no definitive answer being offered
- 49:16to the viewer the viewer can essentially build
- 49:24their own impression of what they could do, right?
- 49:29Perhaps even come up with ideas or solutions
- 49:32that even that the filmmaker or that the people
- 49:36that's being filmed would not have thought of.
- 49:40So that sort of open. not just open -endedness,
- 49:43but that openness to possibilities as opposed
- 49:45to foreclosing all that and prescribing a number
- 49:48of bullet points, as you put it. It's funny,
- 49:52because a documentary like David Attenborough's
- 49:54A Life on Our Planet, it actually has become
- 49:59a bit of what I consider a mode, a documentary
- 50:02mode, like a sub -genre. It's a number of films
- 50:05that do the same thing. And it all started with
- 50:08an inconvenient truth, which literally ends with
- 50:12a PowerPoint presentation. Well, it's actually
- 50:13a whole PowerPoint presentation, but like the
- 50:15last PowerPoint is like a bullet point of solutions,
- 50:19right? So it's funny that you put it that way
- 50:20because that's literally the origin of that sort
- 50:22of strategy, right? You lay out the problem and
- 50:25then you bullet point the solutions, right? Or
- 50:29at least that was the first time that this was
- 50:31implemented in an environmental or regarding
- 50:34environmental issues. With a documentary like
- 50:38Jane Goodall, The Hope, there isn't that, right?
- 50:40It's like you were saying, you watch her do her
- 50:43work, you observe her activism, her engagement
- 50:46with other people, and then the film just kind
- 50:49of encourages you to think about what you could
- 50:51do. In fact, that's the one thing that perhaps
- 50:53she does say you should do, right? Think of what
- 50:56you can do to make this world a better place,
- 51:00to work towards solving the environmental crisis,
- 51:03right? But it doesn't tell you how to do it.
- 51:07And then there's, you know, an inconvenient truth
- 51:10or a number of other documentaries that are like
- 51:13this. And of course, David Atomoros, right? Which
- 51:16literally ends with a list of things you could
- 51:18do or you should do perhaps, right? Now, like
- 51:22I was saying, I think for the longest time, documentary
- 51:26scholars and I think like you were saying, perhaps
- 51:29the common perception of people is that the the
- 51:34more open format is perhaps the better one in
- 51:40the sense that it's not, like we said, it's not
- 51:42prescriptive, that it's open to possibilities
- 51:45that are unforeseen by the filmmaker or the activist,
- 51:48right? That you are essentially asking people
- 51:51to think for themselves and come up with whatever
- 51:53they can, right? And so there's a number of possibilities
- 51:57that might come about. However, In the few empirical
- 52:01studies, studies in which they've actually asked
- 52:05people to watch different films and then followed
- 52:08up to see which ones actually had a bigger impact
- 52:14on people's behavior, again, the number of studies
- 52:18is limited. But at least two have decidedly found
- 52:24that the prescriptive documentary had a bigger
- 52:26impact on people's behavior. So that when you
- 52:29have a film that tells you do this and this and
- 52:31that, there's a higher chance that you will actually
- 52:34change your behavior in accordance to what you're
- 52:37being told. So for these studies, the one thing
- 52:41that I remember that I think is important to
- 52:43keep in mind is that these were studies that
- 52:47were trying to randomize the population as much
- 52:49as possible. So they were not looking for people
- 52:52who watch documentaries or people who are environmentally
- 52:56conscious, but people from all walks of life,
- 53:00right? And so perhaps to people like you and
- 53:02me who are already environmentally inclined,
- 53:05right? Who are constantly thinking about the
- 53:07wellbeing, not just of people, but also of animals
- 53:09and ecology at large. To us, it may seem like
- 53:13being told what to do, especially when those
- 53:15things that we're being told to do are things
- 53:17that we probably already do, right? That seems
- 53:20less productive than an open documentary that
- 53:23is not prescriptive, but perhaps still evokes
- 53:27hope and the desire for ecological change. But
- 53:32for the general population, the opposite may
- 53:36be true. Being told straightforward solutions
- 53:40may actually be more conducive to behavioral
- 53:43changes, proecological change. So again, that's
- 53:47another contradiction that's hard to navigate,
- 53:49because I think you're right. I do think that
- 53:53something like what you see in the tail end of
- 53:57alive on our planet is reductive, right? And
- 54:00it kind of, it's a bit patronizing, and perhaps
- 54:05it doesn't seem particularly effective, but it
- 54:09may actually work better on the general population.
- 54:14Yeah, patronizing is a great word to describe
- 54:17it. And I do think you're right. And this is
- 54:20my bias speaking. Yeah, and The thing is with
- 54:30the solutions that David Attenborough proposes
- 54:35is that there is a discourse right now about
- 54:40if you go and look up solar panels or wind energy.
- 54:54You'll get into a whole, you know, debate about
- 54:58those things. And it is not clear, you know,
- 55:04how much they're, you know, effective in fighting,
- 55:08you know, the climate crisis. A good example
- 55:13is, you know, wind power. Wind power is horrible
- 55:18for wildlife. Like that's a fact. It can be.
- 55:22Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Now, you're not telling
- 55:25that to people who are watching your documentary,
- 55:28but they will find out. And then once they find
- 55:32out, they'll start thinking, well, if they're
- 55:37wrong on that, then are they also wrong on the
- 55:41climate crisis stuff? Right. Like you're not
- 55:46serving your cause here. Yeah, I agree. So I
- 55:50do agree that that is perhaps I would actually
- 55:56say that is almost certainly the most questionable
- 56:05aspect of this particular strategy. The lack
- 56:09of additional information, the lack of context
- 56:12that comes with these solutions. So often, it's
- 56:16good that you mention things like solar panels
- 56:18and wind power. Something that you see in a film
- 56:25like this one and others, Raise an Extinction
- 56:27is a great example. I don't know if you've ever
- 56:29seen that film. It's essentially, again, another
- 56:35documentary very much like An Inconvenient Truth
- 56:37or David Attenborough's Life on our Planet, but
- 56:41it's specifically about mass extinction. So you
- 56:44see it in a lot of these films, that they offer
- 56:46a number of solutions and a lot of these solutions
- 56:48have to do with some sort of... technology that
- 56:51will change things, right? So I call this techno
- 56:55-solutionism, right? And it's not my term, but
- 56:58it's what we, like some people call it that,
- 57:00right? And so there's this idea that like, if
- 57:02you just embrace the newer technologies, then
- 57:05that'll solve the problem, right? And you're
- 57:07right. I mean, there are still ongoing discussions
- 57:10about whether things like solar panels are a
- 57:14good long -term solution because they're also...
- 57:17ecologically corrosive, right? The materials
- 57:19you need to mine, you know, all of that stuff
- 57:21with wind power, right? People like you and I
- 57:25care about wildlife and the wellbeing of animals.
- 57:27And so to what extent can we say that this is
- 57:32an ecological solution when you have like scores
- 57:35of birds and bats literally, you know, with their
- 57:39lungs literally exploding or collapsing because
- 57:42of the changes in air pressure that occur around
- 57:44these turbines. And again, right? And the elephant
- 57:50in the room that's still not being addressed
- 57:52is just using less, consuming less, right? And
- 57:55again, I think it's because consumption is essential
- 57:58to even the production of these films, right?
- 58:00You need to produce them and you need to sell
- 58:02them and you need people who consume them, right?
- 58:05And that's why I do fixate on, again, the silver
- 58:08lining of this particular film and... and perhaps
- 58:14other documentaries that do this, is that the
- 58:17one solution that we know that almost certainly
- 58:20would have a huge impact on solving the climate
- 58:23crisis, which is plant -based diets, right, is
- 58:26for the very first time included in a film featuring
- 58:30somebody like David Atomorrow. And so now we
- 58:34have other documentaries that sort of tackle
- 58:37this more. more directly. But they don't have
- 58:40that persona that will draw the masses to watch
- 58:43them. You might have seen or heard of Eating
- 58:46Our Way to Extinction. And it's a fantastic film
- 58:51that shows us just how detrimental to the environment
- 58:55is the consumption of meat and animal products.
- 59:01But it lacks that central figure that draws the
- 59:04masses. And this is why figures like good old
- 59:07in Attenborough, speaking out about their veganism
- 59:10or their plant -based diets or lifestyles is
- 59:14so important because they do have that pull that
- 59:17you otherwise don't have. So again, I agree with
- 59:21what you're saying. I think that perhaps emphasizing
- 59:24some solutions other than others and focusing
- 59:27a little more on what makes them actual real
- 59:30solutions instead of just listing a number of
- 59:33things that if not properly contextualized, may
- 59:38actually lead to more damage. Focusing on one
- 59:41or two things that we know for a fact are actually
- 59:43going to make an impact. I think that might be
- 59:46a good compromise between the two forms that
- 59:48we're discussing here. Between the bullet points
- 59:52at the end and perhaps something a little more...
- 59:55properly contextualized and dedicated to better
- 1:00:00informing the public about things that actually
- 1:00:02do make a difference. One thing that I wanna
- 1:00:05mention is related to this, right? And I don't
- 1:00:08know how you feel about this. I know that my
- 1:00:10position is perhaps not the most standard position
- 1:00:14amongst people who are... animal activists or
- 1:00:20vegans or ecological activists. But I think that
- 1:00:24one potential solution to some extent that never
- 1:00:30gets mentioned in these films is still the possibility
- 1:00:34of nuclear power, which even when you take the
- 1:00:39meltdowns that have occurred, it doesn't appear
- 1:00:44to be as corrosive as fossil fuels, or even some
- 1:00:49of the alternatives like solar power. And again,
- 1:00:52the reason why you can't have that as a potential
- 1:00:54solution in a documentary that features someone
- 1:00:57like David Attenborough is because that's going
- 1:01:00to put a lot of people off. So again, the demands
- 1:01:03of the market kind of get in the way of people
- 1:01:06exploring solutions that are unpopular. And that
- 1:01:12was what was happening to veganism. And it seems
- 1:01:16to be changing somewhat, but only time will tell
- 1:01:19whether it'll change significantly and whether
- 1:01:22other figures of the caliber of Goodell and Atomboro
- 1:01:26will come about and promote the cause, promote
- 1:01:32plant -based diets, promote forms of energy that
- 1:01:35perhaps are scary or less popular, but could
- 1:01:38actually offer solutions to the problems that
- 1:01:41we have. Thank you so much for mentioning nuclear
- 1:01:47energy. I think it's amazing. And not only is
- 1:01:54he not talking about it as a viable alternative,
- 1:01:58but the very first scene of the documentary is
- 1:02:01him in a Ukrainian city that has been abandoned
- 1:02:05because of a nuclear catastrophe. That's right.
- 1:02:09I mean, that's right. Sorry. Sorry. You know
- 1:02:11what? I forgot about that. Just now. I don't
- 1:02:13know why I didn't mention that. But it's crazy
- 1:02:16because it plays to the fear mongering that has
- 1:02:19occurred around nuclear power. But also what
- 1:02:22I find ironic is that, and you probably know
- 1:02:24about this, he bravely mentions it in the documentary,
- 1:02:27right? That ended up actually being better for
- 1:02:30the animals. So I mean, I don't know. Like Chernobyl
- 1:02:33is now essentially a wildlife preserve and you
- 1:02:36see animals there that had not occurred in Eastern
- 1:02:38Europe. for centuries, right? I don't know, just
- 1:02:41just the thought again, just an afterthought,
- 1:02:43but a thought worth worth entertaining, I think.
- 1:02:46Yes, nuclear energy is very safe. It's like that
- 1:02:50same rational fear of taking a plane. Similar.
- 1:02:56Yeah, it's very similar. You're right. There
- 1:02:59are more risk involved in taking your car out.
- 1:03:03And I'm I'm a greedy vegan. I I'm happy that
- 1:03:08he mentioned veganism as a solution, but I wish
- 1:03:13it was his first point, also his second point,
- 1:03:17his third point, like every... Exactly. Yes.
- 1:03:21And not just because I think it's the most impactful
- 1:03:24thing you can ask for someone to do, but also
- 1:03:29because I feel it's more effective to focus on
- 1:03:33one thing, one solution. Sorry, continue. I was
- 1:03:39just agreeing with you emphatically because I
- 1:03:41agree. That's what I was trying to say, right?
- 1:03:43That perhaps just focusing on one issue that
- 1:03:45actually does make a difference as opposed to
- 1:03:47listing a number of issues without proper context
- 1:03:49is perhaps a better way to go. Just focus on
- 1:03:53the one thing we know actually works. And again,
- 1:04:00if we're talking about how these films and this
- 1:04:04industry came about because initially a country,
- 1:04:08but increasingly, people around the world understand
- 1:04:11themselves as animal lovers. Shouldn't we start
- 1:04:14by perhaps, you know, not eating them? The thing
- 1:04:19also about animals, you know, since we're on
- 1:04:22the topic of veganism and caring for animals.
- 1:04:27In the Jane Goodall documentary, it is the welfare
- 1:04:32of animal is front and center. of the piece.
- 1:04:38But the David Adamboro approach is, I think,
- 1:04:45the widely adopted approach in the environmental
- 1:04:50community, which is, you know, a certain desire
- 1:04:58to protect Earth, like the concept of Earth,
- 1:05:01or the beauty of Earth, or you know, that idea
- 1:05:07of a beautiful world. And it's all very abstract.
- 1:05:15Yeah. What do you make of that difference? Well,
- 1:05:20I think, I think, again, it'll depend a lot on
- 1:05:25who you're talking about. One, one. One author
- 1:05:36that I have read over and over again over the
- 1:05:41course of my research, I can't remember if it's
- 1:05:45Dinesh or Devesh, his first name, Chakravarti.
- 1:05:49Originally a historian from India, but increasingly
- 1:05:52engaged in conversations about climate change.
- 1:05:55And one of the things that he has sort of spent
- 1:05:59some time thinking and writing about is the inability
- 1:06:02of people to understand themselves as a species
- 1:06:07on a planet, right? How abstract those ideas
- 1:06:11are. But again, right? I think that depending
- 1:06:16on who you're appealing to, that changes. I think
- 1:06:21other theorists and authors have talked about
- 1:06:27how in places like the United States and the
- 1:06:31global North in general, but particularly in
- 1:06:33And in places that have had a history of space
- 1:06:39exploration, right? So the Soviet Union too,
- 1:06:41right? There is a sense of being a citizen of
- 1:06:48Earth, right? Global citizenship kind of. And
- 1:06:51that that informs their environmentalist thinking.
- 1:06:57In other places, that doesn't exist, right? Because
- 1:07:00your... perception of yourself and of your friends
- 1:07:04and family and society is limited by your senses.
- 1:07:08Like you don't see yourself, you don't hear yourself,
- 1:07:11you don't feel yourself as part of a species
- 1:07:15on a planet, right? So in those circumstances,
- 1:07:20I think that appealing to perhaps a more direct
- 1:07:24relationship with something that we all have
- 1:07:26a connection to, which is animals, right? And
- 1:07:32it's on the surface is more, perhaps more conducive
- 1:07:40to behavioral changes, to attitudinal changes,
- 1:07:44you know, changes in behavior, like perhaps more
- 1:07:47ecological consciousness. But it is also true
- 1:07:51that most people, and you and I know this very
- 1:07:55well, right? Most people don't truly comprehend
- 1:07:58that their stake is or was a living being, right?
- 1:08:02Because there is that same kind of distance between
- 1:08:05the living being and that food on your plate,
- 1:08:09right? So it's a similar situation. Obviously
- 1:08:13there are some differences, right? But because
- 1:08:15there is that distance, that dissociation still
- 1:08:18there to some extent, right? I do agree that
- 1:08:21Goodall has always... put the welfare of animals
- 1:08:27first and foremost, right? And I think something
- 1:08:30that you might have, I think you mentioned this
- 1:08:33in your podcast, right? That she actually talked
- 1:08:35about how, you know, chimps were not even her
- 1:08:38favorite animal, right? Because chimps were too
- 1:08:41much like people. Chimps were violent, you know,
- 1:08:43they were aggressive, unpleasant creatures. Actually,
- 1:08:46her favorite animals is the dog or was the dog,
- 1:08:50right? So, I think that the fact that her entire
- 1:09:01career revolved around protecting that creature
- 1:09:04that she didn't even particularly like is perhaps
- 1:09:09more inspirational, right? And it's a better
- 1:09:12way of getting people to think about their own
- 1:09:13relationship with animals that perhaps they don't
- 1:09:16like, but that they can recognize as sentient
- 1:09:20beings, right? As creatures that... think and
- 1:09:23feel and have relationships, right? Unfortunately,
- 1:09:27I think that that may in itself, that may not
- 1:09:31lead to change, right? Because again, you can
- 1:09:34have that sort of understanding about the squirrel
- 1:09:36in the park, right? Or perhaps the cat on your
- 1:09:39couch. But because there's that distance between
- 1:09:42the food that you buy in the supermarket and
- 1:09:45the animal that it used to be, that may still
- 1:09:48be kind of disconnect, right? You may still not
- 1:09:52see that as an animal that is worthy of, you
- 1:09:55know, your kindness, of your respect. I don't
- 1:09:59know. I think there's, you know, pros and cons
- 1:10:03to both approaches. I do think that the prospect
- 1:10:06of global citizenship appeals to a lot of people.
- 1:10:10I think especially here in Alberta, for example,
- 1:10:13I see I see lots of my students are more receptive
- 1:10:16to that idea than to the idea of not eating meat.
- 1:10:20So, you know, I think it'll depend on the cultural
- 1:10:23context, but I think there's definitely pros
- 1:10:25and cons to both. Interesting. Let me ask you
- 1:10:31kind of a weird question. I love those. What
- 1:10:36do you think? Well, wait until you hear it. What
- 1:10:41do you think is the perception or was the perception
- 1:10:46of Jane Goodles and David Attenborough of their
- 1:10:52fellow human beings. Because, you know, in both
- 1:10:57documentaries, humanity is not portrayed in the
- 1:11:04best of light, although more so, I think, with
- 1:11:09the Hope documentary. But, you know, it's something
- 1:11:18I wonder, you know, do they love their fellow
- 1:11:22human beings? Are they getting a bit misanthropic,
- 1:11:25maybe? Yeah, you know, I think that, you know,
- 1:11:31we're speculating here, right? I think both of
- 1:11:36them understand people. I don't know about love.
- 1:11:42I don't know about respect, with Goodel specifically,
- 1:11:47right? You can infer that she has a certain distaste
- 1:11:52for some human characteristics, right? And you
- 1:11:55can infer this because, again, she'll say something
- 1:11:58like, oh, yeah, chimps can be very unpleasant
- 1:12:00creatures because they do this and this and that.
- 1:12:04And so they're actually very similar to us, right?
- 1:12:07The implication there. the implication there
- 1:12:10being that she thinks that those are unpleasant
- 1:12:12characteristics that people possess, right? And
- 1:12:16so we can sort of infer that at the very least
- 1:12:21she understands that people like chimps, our
- 1:12:25closest cousins, right? We have some evolutionary
- 1:12:30baggage, right? That we have some tendencies
- 1:12:33that make us unpleasant. We're not the kindest
- 1:12:38creatures out there, because we are apes that
- 1:12:42form hierarchical societies, and that hierarchy
- 1:12:45is determined violently. Adam Moro, likewise,
- 1:12:52he doesn't really talk. You've already put it.
- 1:12:56beautifully right he talks in the abstract a
- 1:12:59little more right he talks in terms of ecology
- 1:13:01and the planet and humanity right so he doesn't
- 1:13:05deal with the individual as much as good old
- 1:13:08does right good old talks a lot about her personalities
- 1:13:12right the personalities of certain apes the personalities
- 1:13:15of certain animals and thus she understands that
- 1:13:18people too have different personalities likes
- 1:13:21and feelings right Adamor doesn't really talk
- 1:13:24about that much, so I think we're speculating
- 1:13:26even further, but I think one thing that I take
- 1:13:29away from the few times that he's spoken politically,
- 1:13:33such as this documentary that we've been discussing,
- 1:13:36but also other interviews, right? I think he
- 1:13:39understands that people have, for lack of a better
- 1:13:49understanding, that people have other concerns.
- 1:13:51that people are interested in the natural world,
- 1:13:56but only in a passing way. And so he's trying
- 1:14:00to get us to think more about it. I remember
- 1:14:03this one quote. He once said that people have
- 1:14:10the uncanny ability to change the environment
- 1:14:13for the benefit of their population, but that
- 1:14:17perhaps it's time for us to change the population
- 1:14:21to the benefit of the environment, suggesting
- 1:14:24that fewer people would be better for Earth,
- 1:14:27right? And so some people think that that sort
- 1:14:31of position is misanthropic, right? That you
- 1:14:33want fewer people on Earth, that means you don't
- 1:14:36like people. But I think because he thinks in
- 1:14:38the abstract, he thinks in terms, or at least
- 1:14:41he usually talks in terms of these broader ecological
- 1:14:44concepts. he also kind of sees people that way.
- 1:14:49As a whole, we have these tendencies that we
- 1:14:51need to change. And so that would mean a smaller
- 1:14:55population, a plant -based diet. But perhaps
- 1:14:57he doesn't really think too much, or at least
- 1:14:59he doesn't talk too much about how individuals
- 1:15:03perceive these ideas. So again, perhaps not misanthropic,
- 1:15:09but definitely I do think there is some At least
- 1:15:14again, based on what I see, I think there is
- 1:15:18a disconnect between how he thinks about the
- 1:15:21world and what people's experience is. Yeah,
- 1:15:26and again, I think with Jane Goodall, again,
- 1:15:30misanthropy, perhaps not the best term, but I
- 1:15:32do think she's well aware of the fact that as
- 1:15:35a species, we have some issues. You're right
- 1:15:40to raise the... the topic of reducing the number
- 1:15:48of humans on the planet. I think if they are
- 1:15:53misentropic, or let me put it this way, I think
- 1:15:57their most misentropic episodes are when they
- 1:16:05talk about that, about reducing human populations.
- 1:16:10Now, Jane Goodall doesn't talk about it in her
- 1:16:13documentary, or at least maybe I missed it, but
- 1:16:17I did hear her in an interview say something
- 1:16:22of the sort of, if we could reduce the human
- 1:16:27population, like drastically, but in the most
- 1:16:31humane way, like make people disappear with the
- 1:16:35magic wand. I would be for that. And I think
- 1:16:41that for, you know, someone from the public hearing
- 1:16:47that feels a bit, you know, crazy and also scary.
- 1:16:52Yeah. Yeah, that's, that's one idea that That
- 1:16:59is, you know, again, another one of these controversial
- 1:17:01measures, right? And again, it's telling that
- 1:17:04Adam Borough does not shy away from this one,
- 1:17:06but he does shy away from things like nuclear
- 1:17:09power. And again, for the longest time, he shied
- 1:17:11away from veganism, right? So imagine that veganism
- 1:17:15and nuclear power are somehow worse than, you
- 1:17:18know, the desire for fewer people. But anyway.
- 1:17:23But yeah, like, you know the population the question
- 1:17:26of the population the global population is is
- 1:17:29is is controversial it always has been If you
- 1:17:33don't know the history of the club of Rome, you
- 1:17:35may want to look it up They were the first sort
- 1:17:38of like a group of intellectuals to propose our
- 1:17:41reduction in the human population like an intentional
- 1:17:44reduction of the human population and then they
- 1:17:46were hugely controversial at the time and they
- 1:17:48remain so their ideas remain so and and I you
- 1:17:53know Ironically, even as we debate the merits
- 1:17:58of lowering the number of people on Earth, and
- 1:18:02even as people, even here in academia, I always
- 1:18:06think about what I read, the stuff that other
- 1:18:11authors who are far more prominent than I'll
- 1:18:14probably ever be have said about things like
- 1:18:16population. And one of the questions that they
- 1:18:19ask is, well, who exactly which is sacrifice,
- 1:18:23right? Because one of the theories about the
- 1:18:26discourse of our population is that it's covert
- 1:18:29racism, right? That it's basically saying we
- 1:18:31need to stop all these people from the third
- 1:18:34world from reproducing, right? And I think in
- 1:18:38some cases, it certainly sounds that way, right?
- 1:18:42And so perhaps there are some ideological issues
- 1:18:44that we need to be aware of when talking about,
- 1:18:46well, OK, let's reduce the population. Whose
- 1:18:50population exactly would you start with and why,
- 1:18:52right? But even as we're talking about this and
- 1:18:57even as most people still kind of feel some sort
- 1:19:00of resistance against or push back against the
- 1:19:03idea, it's happening already. I don't know if
- 1:19:05you are aware of this. This is a conversation
- 1:19:07that this is something that I follow almost as
- 1:19:10a hobby. It started about a decade ago, because
- 1:19:14I was curious about this one report that I read
- 1:19:16coming out of the UN, and I've been following
- 1:19:19it ever since. And so that original report basically
- 1:19:22said that growth projections for the global South,
- 1:19:25so Latin America, Africa, South Asia, certain
- 1:19:30parts of Southeast Asia, that they had been way
- 1:19:33overestimated, and that the growth was actually
- 1:19:38going to be far slower than they had anticipated.
- 1:19:40Okay, this was 10 years ago. From then until
- 1:19:44now, that same projection, that same revision
- 1:19:50has accelerated. So about four years ago or five
- 1:19:53years ago, the UN put out another report that
- 1:19:56basically said, actually, it looks like we're
- 1:20:01heading towards a peak in population because
- 1:20:03population growth in Africa and all these places
- 1:20:05is... decelerating to the extent that it's actually
- 1:20:09going to flatten, it's going to plateau. And
- 1:20:12so they projected a peak population of about
- 1:20:1414 billion people by the year 2100. And then
- 1:20:21two years ago, another one, and they said, actually,
- 1:20:24again, we way overestimated the growth of the
- 1:20:27Global South, and now it looks like we're gonna
- 1:20:29peak at around 10 billion by 2080. And the latest
- 1:20:33report, which was released earlier this year,
- 1:20:37again, revised it, continued the trend, and now
- 1:20:40there is a strong possibility that the population
- 1:20:42will peak at around 9, between 9 and 10 billion,
- 1:20:47but in 2050. Again, it's just a strong possibility,
- 1:20:52nothing's certain. But after that, we see a population
- 1:20:56decline. When we're talking about peaks, we talk
- 1:20:58about the highest point, and then it declines.
- 1:21:01So now we're heading towards an almost certain
- 1:21:04reduction in the population. for the first time
- 1:21:07at some point in this century. So the population
- 1:21:11is now almost certainly going to start going
- 1:21:14down at some point this century. And people are
- 1:21:16talking about it everywhere. People are talking
- 1:21:19about how nobody's having kids anymore. Nobody
- 1:21:23can afford to have kids anymore because everything
- 1:21:25is so expensive now. And my theory, my hypothesis
- 1:21:29is that this is all a reflection of the fact
- 1:21:31that the system in which we now live cannot,
- 1:21:37can no longer sustain growth, right? And of course
- 1:21:40it makes sense because as both Goodall and Atomboro
- 1:21:43have talked about, a finite planet cannot support
- 1:21:49indefinite growth, right? We live on this kind
- 1:21:54of rock that is a spaceship and it's limited,
- 1:21:58right? And so we cannot keep on growing indefinitely
- 1:22:01and it looks like we may be reaching the limits
- 1:22:04of growth. under the system that we live in.
- 1:22:08So, you know, population reduction is not something
- 1:22:10people want to hear. A lot of people are terrified
- 1:22:13of it. But now it looks like an almost certain
- 1:22:16thing. So, you know, it's worth thinking about.
- 1:22:21Talking about racism, there is a point I wanted
- 1:22:25to raise concerning native populations. And so
- 1:22:30in the David Attenborough documentary, they present
- 1:22:37a native tribe and they describe them as the
- 1:22:42ideal, sustainably living lifestyle. And that
- 1:22:49made me a bit uncomfortable because it reminded
- 1:22:53me of the, the noble Indian trope. You know,
- 1:22:59you had so many Europeans. thinking, writing,
- 1:23:04talking about the American Indian as this ideal
- 1:23:09of freedom and of such a wonderful, you know,
- 1:23:14lifestyle. And I also don't know if this is truly
- 1:23:19rooted in reality. There have been theories that
- 1:23:24native populations have caused the extinction
- 1:23:27of megafauna in Australia, but also in North
- 1:23:30America. What do you make of that trope that,
- 1:23:35you know, the native people were so in such harmony
- 1:23:42with nature and were like the ideal, the model
- 1:23:46of living an environmentally friendly lifestyle?
- 1:23:51Yeah, you know, that's, that's a good point,
- 1:23:53right? Um, it, it ties in quite a bit with, with
- 1:23:59the question about questions about population
- 1:24:01and like whose population would have to uh you
- 1:24:05know decelerate and grow and and and you know
- 1:24:09some some some presumed racial implications of
- 1:24:11those questions but in regards to what happens
- 1:24:15in a life uh on our planet and the David Attenborough
- 1:24:18documentary and again we should contrast how
- 1:24:21similar ideas are represented in both films,
- 1:24:27The Hope and A Life on Our Planet, because it's
- 1:24:28done differently, but let's stick to Atomboro
- 1:24:30first. So again, right, I would take us back
- 1:24:32to the beginning of Atomboro's career. So part
- 1:24:35of his body of work includes a number of very
- 1:24:41early films that were what you call ethnographies,
- 1:24:47right? So these are films in which Atomboro or
- 1:24:51otherwise a group of ethnographers alongside
- 1:24:56a film crew, usually again, right, financed by
- 1:24:58the BBC or another public broadcasting corporation,
- 1:25:04they would go to these exotic places to document
- 1:25:09dying cultures, right, like what we're understood
- 1:25:12to be dying cultures. And so they would record,
- 1:25:15you know, their practices and their habits and
- 1:25:18all that. And even then, right? Or perhaps more
- 1:25:25so than today you could see what you're talking
- 1:25:27about, right? You could see this back then a
- 1:25:32lot more explicit but today implicit supposition
- 1:25:37of Indigenous peoples as somehow more in tune
- 1:25:42with nature. Now I think, you know, the first
- 1:25:47part of your question was to what extent is this
- 1:25:49true or accurate, like historically accurate,
- 1:25:52right? And I would say that, you know, if you
- 1:25:57compare the environmental impact of any other
- 1:26:02society to contemporary Western societies, well,
- 1:26:06of course, like most other societies were vastly
- 1:26:10more sustainable than, you know, Western late
- 1:26:13capitalist industrial societies, societies, right?
- 1:26:16So I think, you know, but in that sense, it is
- 1:26:19undeniable that those tribes or those societies
- 1:26:24and other places, both contemporary and historically,
- 1:26:28were far more sustainable than ours. Now, the
- 1:26:32question is, does that make them an ideal model,
- 1:26:34right? And I would say no. So first off, you
- 1:26:39mentioned, for instance, in the case of North
- 1:26:41America, and you know, this is something that
- 1:26:44I could potentially get in trouble for, but I'm
- 1:26:47happy to speak openly about it because I actually
- 1:26:50do raise the point whenever the opportunity arises,
- 1:26:53which is that nowadays, and because of, I think,
- 1:27:00as a result of the renewed oppression against
- 1:27:04Indigenous peoples here in North America and
- 1:27:06elsewhere around the world, right, there has
- 1:27:10been this sort of impetus to foreground this
- 1:27:16their traditions, their cultures, as you said,
- 1:27:20right? More environmentally sustainable, more
- 1:27:22ethical, matrilineal as opposed to patriarchal,
- 1:27:28right? About community, I suppose about the individual.
- 1:27:31And in some cases, that is true in one way or
- 1:27:34another, but speaking specifically about sustainability,
- 1:27:38right? I think I was just actually reading our
- 1:27:42report about this recently, about the extinction
- 1:27:45of megafauna in North America, because that was
- 1:27:49a contentious issue for the longest time. What
- 1:27:51drove the mammoth, and the North American camels,
- 1:27:55and the giant sloths, and all of these other
- 1:27:58creatures that used to thrive here in North America,
- 1:28:00and actually also in South America, what drove
- 1:28:03them extinct? The two prevailing theories were
- 1:28:08uh, the overkill theory, which is that, well,
- 1:28:11you know, humans arrived in North America roughly
- 1:28:13the same time as, um, these creatures, uh, disappearance,
- 1:28:18right? And so they disappear around the time
- 1:28:20when people show up. And so that's, that's like
- 1:28:23a bit of a coincidence. The other one being,
- 1:28:25you know, just some sort of climate change either
- 1:28:27because of, um, the, the most recent proposition
- 1:28:31was that abrupt climate change is a result of
- 1:28:34some kind of extraterrestrial impact, right?
- 1:28:37To some asteroid or comet or whatever. And there
- 1:28:39seems to be some evidence to support that there
- 1:28:41was an impact at around that time as well. But
- 1:28:44it doesn't seem to be enough to take out the
- 1:28:47latest report that I read in regards to this
- 1:28:50idea that perhaps it was some sort of abrupt
- 1:28:53climate change as a result of some sort of impact,
- 1:28:55right? The evidence is not there. If there was
- 1:28:58an impact, it was relatively small and it wouldn't
- 1:29:01make sense that it only affected certain parts
- 1:29:05of the world and not the entire world. So it
- 1:29:07does seem as if at least to some extent to the
- 1:29:10arrival of humans into what is now North America
- 1:29:13was the cause of their extinction, which tells
- 1:29:16us that even if later descendants of these people
- 1:29:22became perhaps more environmentally sustainable,
- 1:29:25that wasn't always the case. At some point, they
- 1:29:28most definitely had a severe impact on their
- 1:29:33ecology. And actually, one of the most compelling
- 1:29:37arguments I've heard about this is that, as you
- 1:29:40mentioned, this is not a North American phenomenon,
- 1:29:42right? It also happened in Australia. But as
- 1:29:44I was saying, it also seems to have happened
- 1:29:46in South America. It seems to have happened in
- 1:29:50Europe, right? Where the mammoth also went extinct
- 1:29:52and the animals that fed upon animals like that,
- 1:29:55like the saber tooth tigers and cave lions also
- 1:29:57went extinct. And it seems to have happened in
- 1:29:59Asia. with similar species, right? Again, mammoths,
- 1:30:05woolly rhinos, saber -toothed tigers, all of
- 1:30:07these animals go extinct. And their extinction
- 1:30:11seems to more or less coincide with the arrival
- 1:30:14of people. But I think the most compelling piece
- 1:30:18of evidence or the most compelling argument that
- 1:30:20I've heard that supports the idea that wherever
- 1:30:22people went, extinctions followed, right? Is
- 1:30:27that the one continent where this didn't happen,
- 1:30:30was Africa, where we evolved. So it seems to
- 1:30:34me that those animals were able to continue their
- 1:30:38existence because they evolved with us alongside
- 1:30:42people. And so they knew what people wear. They
- 1:30:44knew to beware of the upright monkey with a spear,
- 1:30:49whereas other animals didn't. And so they went
- 1:30:51extinct. So anyway, so that is one thing. But
- 1:30:57as I was saying, even if that is true, the possibility
- 1:31:00does exist. And in fact, it is demonstrable that
- 1:31:04their descendants lived in greater ecological
- 1:31:08balance than us. So that a tribe in North America
- 1:31:13or in Australia or in Southeast Asia typically
- 1:31:17didn't overrun its environment the way that contemporary
- 1:31:23Western societies do. The example that you cite
- 1:31:27from the movie, from David Attenborough's documentary,
- 1:31:31right? He specifically refers to a tribe from
- 1:31:34Papua New Guinea. Now, what, again, right? You
- 1:31:39have to think about what is included and what
- 1:31:41is being left out. And you've already talked
- 1:31:43about this in relation to like how by talking
- 1:31:45about a number of, as you put it, Ecology 101,
- 1:31:49right? By introducing all of these talking points.
- 1:31:52you leave a lot of the context out, right? And
- 1:31:55so one of the things that is being left out when
- 1:31:57they talk about a tribe in Papua New Guinea,
- 1:31:59not overrunning its environment and not consuming
- 1:32:03more than the environment can provide. Well,
- 1:32:07it is also true that other factors that perhaps
- 1:32:10we don't think are desirable, right, play into
- 1:32:14this dynamic. So for instance, the average lifespan
- 1:32:18of a tribe span in Papua New Guinea is significantly
- 1:32:22shorter than ours, right? And that's not just
- 1:32:24because they live out in the elements, but also
- 1:32:28because they don't have access to medicines.
- 1:32:30Their diets are considerably poor, right? In
- 1:32:34the sense that there's less variety, there's
- 1:32:36a certainty. And so occasionally they do suffer
- 1:32:39from emancipation and starvation, right? Children
- 1:32:43die of illnesses all the time still in those
- 1:32:45places. not to mention inter -tribal conflicts,
- 1:32:49which again, it's not to say that they have it
- 1:32:51and we don't. Obviously, we fight amongst ourselves
- 1:32:54all the time. There's countless Western or modern
- 1:32:57wars happening around the world right now. But
- 1:33:00when your populations are considerably smaller,
- 1:33:03or rather when your society is not based around
- 1:33:08perpetual growth, there are other factors that
- 1:33:14that play in and allow for that sort of set of
- 1:33:17relations to continue. And in this case, we have
- 1:33:19to consider whether, okay, well, the reason why,
- 1:33:22if the reason why, or one of the reasons why
- 1:33:24people in what we consider, quote unquote, primitive
- 1:33:28societies, manage to strike a balance with the
- 1:33:33natural world. One of those reasons is that they
- 1:33:36don't have access to medicine. And so their population
- 1:33:39is limited by illnesses, for example, right?
- 1:33:42then perhaps we want to consider whether they
- 1:33:45are a good model in all regards, right? Not that
- 1:33:48they aren't in at least some of those, but that
- 1:33:51context or that sort of model is not going to
- 1:33:54be applicable to contemporary societies because
- 1:33:57we expect other things from life, right? And
- 1:33:59I think that raises a number of other questions.
- 1:34:03So yeah, I do think that there is this tendency
- 1:34:07once again to uphold these societies that are
- 1:34:13still not Western, that are still not quote unquote
- 1:34:16modern as we call ourselves, right? And kind
- 1:34:20of like put them on a pedestal and think or talk
- 1:34:23about them as if they were models for us to follow.
- 1:34:26And I think in some regards perhaps that is true,
- 1:34:30but in other regards it's not, right? And so
- 1:34:31again, having access to the full context and
- 1:34:37not just bits and parts is important, right?
- 1:34:42So, and you know, just to briefly return to the
- 1:34:44difference between the two documentaries and
- 1:34:46the hope, again, right? Goodell also travels
- 1:34:49to exotic locations, right? What we would refer
- 1:34:51to as exotic locations. But I think, again, there
- 1:34:55is this sort of emphasis on the fact that even
- 1:34:58people in those societies recognize the need
- 1:35:01for change, right? And I think that's something
- 1:35:04that is perhaps a little more productive in the
- 1:35:08sense that rather than thinking about how we're
- 1:35:10different, it encourages to think about how,
- 1:35:13okay, yeah, perhaps there are some differences,
- 1:35:15but we're all in the same boat. And they are
- 1:35:18recognized despite their remoteness and despite
- 1:35:20the fact that perhaps their beliefs are different
- 1:35:23from ours, right? They recognize the need for
- 1:35:25change on a grander scale. And so I think perhaps
- 1:35:29that's sort of like more relational understanding
- 1:35:34of people from societies that are different from
- 1:35:39ours is Yes, there's something strange about
- 1:35:47how we fantasize of a world beyond modernity.
- 1:35:55So, you know, freed from modernity, where we
- 1:35:59could be one of those, you know, so -called primitive
- 1:36:02tribe part of that. But at the same time, we
- 1:36:07are scared of that prospect. Um, you know, we
- 1:36:11look at them and we think, you know, this is
- 1:36:14the result of us going through horrible world
- 1:36:18war and, you know, we'll end up with sticks and,
- 1:36:22and yeah, that's, that's how we model, you know,
- 1:36:27um, society's failure. Um, and I want to tie
- 1:36:32this to, um, the apocalyptic message we often
- 1:36:38get from environmentalists. And in the David
- 1:36:44Attenborough documentary, they had this scene,
- 1:36:48they filmed that horrific landscape of burnt,
- 1:36:55just this burnt, you know, trees, burnt forest.
- 1:37:01And then they were in the middle of the burnt
- 1:37:03forest. There were tornadoes. I don't know if
- 1:37:07you remember that. Yeah, I do. I thought it was
- 1:37:11so hilarious. Like, where did you find that footage?
- 1:37:15How did you, you know, film that footage? Where
- 1:37:19is that horrific place? And they showed that
- 1:37:24while talking about our future, you know, if,
- 1:37:28if we continue on this path, this is what awaits
- 1:37:31us, you know, a burnt forest inhabited by tornadoes.
- 1:37:41And, and, you know, this is not efficient. I
- 1:37:44don't know who is in their team, you know, production
- 1:37:47team, but they should know that the first thing
- 1:37:52that The first argument that people bring against
- 1:37:56climate change and believing in the climate crisis
- 1:37:59or doing something is look at the long record
- 1:38:04of failed predictions from environmentalists
- 1:38:08and scientists. They thought we would end up
- 1:38:11in a cold age. They were wrong. They thought
- 1:38:14we were going to... be the victim of a worldwide
- 1:38:19famine. They were wrong. They thought that New
- 1:38:23York would be, you know, underwater. They were
- 1:38:27wrong. And so stop, you know, with the prediction
- 1:38:31business. Just focus on the present, you know,
- 1:38:35and the effect of climate change on our current
- 1:38:39reality. Yeah, I think it's a dangerous business
- 1:38:44to predict the future. Yeah, no, I think you're
- 1:38:47right and I know that You know, I've probably
- 1:38:52committed that mistake today right when talking
- 1:38:55about about the population issue because to a
- 1:39:00lot of people the possibility of the human population
- 1:39:06decreasing as opposed to increasing is an apocalyptic
- 1:39:11premise right they think of films like Children
- 1:39:15of man, for example, right? I don't know if you're
- 1:39:17familiar with it. It was a great film where like,
- 1:39:20you know, it takes place in this dystopian society
- 1:39:22where it's been 20 years since the birth of the
- 1:39:25last person, right? Some sort of pandemic has
- 1:39:27made us all infertile. And so it's been 20, 20
- 1:39:30something years since the last person, or since
- 1:39:33the birth of the last person, or since a birth,
- 1:39:35a human birth, and everybody, like, you know,
- 1:39:38the population's aging, there are no babies.
- 1:39:39And so the prospect of extinction is there, right?
- 1:39:42So a lot of people, when... when people like
- 1:39:45myself talk about population projections and
- 1:39:49the fact that the population seems to not just
- 1:39:51be stabilizing but heading for a peak and then
- 1:39:54decline, that sounds like an apocalyptic premise.
- 1:39:59And it is true that these are just projections.
- 1:40:02Any projection that people make about population
- 1:40:05or climate change or biodiversity loss, which
- 1:40:08is something I'm interested in, they're always
- 1:40:11going to be just highly educated guesses, but
- 1:40:18still guesses in the sense that you never have
- 1:40:21access to all the data, right? And that's not
- 1:40:24just because data collection is limited, which
- 1:40:27it is, right? You cannot possibly collect all
- 1:40:30the data in the world, right? It's that analogy
- 1:40:32of like drawing a map so detailed that you capture
- 1:40:34everything. Could you fit that in the world?
- 1:40:36Well, of course not, right? This could have to
- 1:40:37be the size of the world. Same with data, right?
- 1:40:40You can try to collect as much data as possible,
- 1:40:43but there isn't enough human computational or
- 1:40:46even storage power to actually analyze it all
- 1:40:49and simulate it in a way that will predict things
- 1:40:53that are 100 % certainty, right? So it's impossible,
- 1:40:57like predicting the future is already impossible,
- 1:40:58but it gets even worse when one fails to consider
- 1:41:03the unexpected, right? So for instance, you talked
- 1:41:06about how there were predictions about almost
- 1:41:11certain famine, right? I think I believe these
- 1:41:14that the latest sort of iteration of this particular
- 1:41:20prophecy, so to speak, came about in the 50s.
- 1:41:24And about a decade or two decades later, we have
- 1:41:28the Green Revolution. There's this new sort of
- 1:41:32understanding of how to grow crops in a more
- 1:41:35or less indefinite way. And so suddenly, there's
- 1:41:39more than enough food for everyone. So a technological
- 1:41:46development essentially throws that theory out
- 1:41:49the window, right? It's like, well, now actually
- 1:41:51turns out we're now going to get harm, you know,
- 1:41:53we're not going to starve. In fact, we're going
- 1:41:54to produce more than ever. Okay. Right. There's
- 1:41:56also the story about, um, or the, the, this,
- 1:42:00this prediction that like towards the end of
- 1:42:03last century, when the last, actually now two
- 1:42:06centuries ago, right? Towards the end of the
- 1:42:0719th century, there were so many horses in London
- 1:42:09that people predicted that, you know, within
- 1:42:1120, 30 years, the city was going to be buried.
- 1:42:14And what they didn't predict was the rise of
- 1:42:16the car, the automobile, and how that did away
- 1:42:19with horses. So when I talked about how I am
- 1:42:23skeptical of what I call technosolutionism, this
- 1:42:26idea that technology will offer solutions, I
- 1:42:30have to say that in awareness of the fact that
- 1:42:37in the past, that has been true. A lot of problems
- 1:42:40that we have had in the past have been done away
- 1:42:44with because some sort of technological development
- 1:42:50came about that nobody expected and solved that
- 1:42:52problem. But what is also true is that solving
- 1:42:55one problem with technology has almost always
- 1:42:58resulted in new technological problems or new
- 1:43:02problems as a result of that technology. So to
- 1:43:05go back to the example of the horse and the car,
- 1:43:08well, of course, the use of cars became one of
- 1:43:11the main drivers of what we now call climate
- 1:43:14change, right? So we solved one problem, but
- 1:43:16we created another, which is potentially worse,
- 1:43:19right? Who knows? The same with the Green Revolution,
- 1:43:23right? Suddenly we can produce pretty much as
- 1:43:26much food as possible, right? But what does that
- 1:43:28do? Well, that enables some companies to grow
- 1:43:33food for a particular purpose, which is more
- 1:43:35profitable. And in this case, that facilitated
- 1:43:38the rise as of factory farming, right? Because,
- 1:43:41all right, if we can grow as much food as possible,
- 1:43:44but the most profitable food to sell is meat,
- 1:43:47then let's just grow infinite amounts of, you
- 1:43:50know, cattle feed to feed the cattle, right?
- 1:43:53So that didn't end up like solving all problems
- 1:43:57related to famine and starvation, right? It actually
- 1:44:00just created excess in one part of the world
- 1:44:02and other parts of the world are still suffering
- 1:44:05from the issues that they had. 20, 30, 40 years
- 1:44:08ago, or even centuries ago, right? So technology
- 1:44:11solves problems, yeah, sure, but it also creates
- 1:44:14new problems. So when we're talking about these
- 1:44:16apocalyptic predictions, right, some of them
- 1:44:19are going to be just flat out wrong, whether
- 1:44:22because the data was not in at the time of that
- 1:44:24prediction, or because of some sort of technological
- 1:44:27development. But being wrong doesn't necessarily
- 1:44:30mean that it's going to be better either, right?
- 1:44:33So just because we I think we cannot and mustn't
- 1:44:38assume that what fear -mongering activists tell
- 1:44:45us right like oh you know New York's gonna be
- 1:44:47under 20 feet of water by the end of the century
- 1:44:49we don't have to believe that we probably shouldn't
- 1:44:52just believe them right because they don't know
- 1:44:54any more than perhaps a little more than we do
- 1:44:56but they don't know you know they're not certain
- 1:45:00about those things but it is also true that like
- 1:45:03What we do know is that the lifestyle that we
- 1:45:07currently live in western society, that we currently
- 1:45:10experience in western societies in the global
- 1:45:12north, right, this lifestyle of like exes, of
- 1:45:15living beyond our means, right, that will inevitably
- 1:45:19create problems. We don't know what those problems
- 1:45:22are, we don't know what the end result of those
- 1:45:24problems is going to be, right, but we know that
- 1:45:26it cannot go on forever. So yeah, I agree that
- 1:45:29that that we probably shouldn't put too much
- 1:45:32faith in those apocalyptic predictions, right?
- 1:45:35But we should be aware of the fact that these
- 1:45:37predictions are based on data that we do have,
- 1:45:40right? And that does point to a number of problems
- 1:45:43that we're already experiencing, right? So for
- 1:45:45instance, you mentioned that scene in a life
- 1:45:50on our planet. It's actually one of the scenes
- 1:45:53that I enjoy the most, partly because I think
- 1:45:58they did a fairly good job at sort of relating
- 1:46:02how one issue will cascade into a number of other
- 1:46:06issues, right? Specifically speaking, how climate
- 1:46:10change will result in the shutting down of certain
- 1:46:13ecological systems and a mass extinction of species,
- 1:46:16right? I think that that is well connected. But
- 1:46:18you're right in pointing out that like the number
- 1:46:21of, you know, that, well, actually there's two
- 1:46:25things that I want to mention here. So the one
- 1:46:27thing is that, I think you're pointing out that
- 1:46:32this sort of imagery, right, apocalyptic imagery,
- 1:46:37like this prophetic sort of dream, nightmare,
- 1:46:41right, I think it's political productivity is
- 1:46:49questionable. Like just how much does it motivate
- 1:46:51people or does it perhaps demotivate people?
- 1:46:55So there have been some empirical studies about
- 1:46:57that. it seems to be pretty evenly split, interestingly
- 1:47:01enough. Some people look at that and say, OK,
- 1:47:03we got to do something, right? And some people
- 1:47:05look at that and say, we're toast. So people
- 1:47:10either fall into despair or will become highly
- 1:47:15motivated to do something about these things.
- 1:47:20So you can question the political productivity
- 1:47:23of that sort of fear mongering. I'm sorry, interesting
- 1:47:28side note. Remember I told you that people have
- 1:47:31sort of compared which or they've done empirical
- 1:47:36analyses of like what kind of film seems to motivate
- 1:47:39people most, right? If it's just a film that
- 1:47:41observes but doesn't actually promote causes
- 1:47:43or a film that promotes causes. Well, there was
- 1:47:46a bit of a control group in one of those studies
- 1:47:49and they had them watch The Day After Tomorrow,
- 1:47:53which is like the most exaggerated implausible
- 1:47:57version of climate change, right? Turns out that
- 1:48:00one actually motivated people the most. Which
- 1:48:03is ridiculous, right? Because people would confess
- 1:48:07knowing that this was all fictional, but apparently
- 1:48:11those fictionalized, exaggerated representations
- 1:48:15of what could happen, or probably what could
- 1:48:19never happen, seem to have actually motivated
- 1:48:23people most because they stayed with people.
- 1:48:26Right. People remember those dramatic scenes.
- 1:48:29And so the next time they, you know, they were
- 1:48:31leaving their office, they thought about those,
- 1:48:33you know, like, blizzards in the middle of Los
- 1:48:37Angeles. And they were like, Oh, no, I better
- 1:48:39turn the lights off. Right. So it's it's ironic.
- 1:48:43It's it's it's unpredictable. Right. Again, right.
- 1:48:46It's impossible to tell exactly what's going
- 1:48:48to click with people. Right. What's going to
- 1:48:50motivate them. So, yeah, the the the apocalyptic
- 1:48:55imagery and and now in documentaries as well
- 1:48:58right like in my life on our planet we we don't
- 1:49:01really know how it affects or we can't really
- 1:49:04make generalized assumptions about how it will
- 1:49:07affect people right some people will see that
- 1:49:09and become motivated some people will see that
- 1:49:11and fall into grief or despair right um what
- 1:49:16what does seem to be true is that the more the
- 1:49:21more images like that people become exposed to,
- 1:49:26the higher the chance of them falling into what
- 1:49:29is increasingly called ecograve, right? Ecological
- 1:49:32grief. That perhaps is not just watching at one
- 1:49:35time, but the fact that now we're constantly
- 1:49:37bombarded by these images of, you know, these
- 1:49:40apocalyptic images that are related to ecological
- 1:49:44problems that we have. But unfortunately, you
- 1:49:47know, I think that is something that perhaps
- 1:49:49is worth thinking about because So this particular
- 1:49:53scene that you mentioned, the one where there's
- 1:49:55fires and dust devils, these little tornadoes.
- 1:49:58So that's not AI. That was something that actually
- 1:50:02seems to happen sometimes in Australia. And that
- 1:50:06apparently is happening more and more because
- 1:50:08of climate change. You might recall that a couple
- 1:50:10of years ago, all of Australia was on fire. There
- 1:50:12were those images of koalas literally burning
- 1:50:15to death. And that sort of imagery is becoming
- 1:50:23more common precisely because these problems
- 1:50:26are already affecting us. Like some of these
- 1:50:29predictions, quote unquote, have actually come
- 1:50:32true, right? You may recall that last year, Jasper
- 1:50:35National Park here in Canada burnt up, right?
- 1:50:38A place that people would perhaps think would
- 1:50:42be better prepared or that would be protected
- 1:50:45in some ways, right? the conditions were such
- 1:50:47that it was impossible to do anything about it.
- 1:50:50It was really hot that year. There was what people
- 1:50:52called a heat dome. There was initially hardly
- 1:50:55any snow in the winter. The forest was extremely,
- 1:50:59exceedingly unusually dry. And so it burnt up.
- 1:51:02And so it is getting to the point where some
- 1:51:04of those dire predictions, again, not all, and
- 1:51:08not to make any definitive claims here, but some
- 1:51:11of them seem to be coming true. I read a report
- 1:51:14earlier today that something that was predicted
- 1:51:17about 10 years ago in another documentary that
- 1:51:19I watched in Chasing Coral actually did happen
- 1:51:22this year, which is that essentially all coral
- 1:51:25reefs around the world experienced leaching.
- 1:51:28It used to be that it was localized, and this
- 1:51:30year every single reef experienced leaching.
- 1:51:34And so that is a definite step towards the extinction
- 1:51:37of that entire coral reef ecosystem, because
- 1:51:39if it happens two, three years in a row, they're
- 1:51:42gone. There aren't that many of them. They're
- 1:51:44highly localized. two or three years, we may
- 1:51:46not have coral reefs anymore. So again, predictions
- 1:51:50are one thing, but it is important to be aware
- 1:51:53of the fact that some of the things that people
- 1:51:56have been talking about on predictability and
- 1:51:58weather and not knowing how it will affect ecosystems
- 1:52:01and ourselves, that seems to already be something
- 1:52:04that we need to deal with in the present. So
- 1:52:08yeah, again, not to say Not to scare people.
- 1:52:13Again, I think you're right in pointing out we
- 1:52:15shouldn't be constantly thinking about or speculating
- 1:52:18about the future because we can't. We can't know
- 1:52:20for sure, right? But it's good to be aware of
- 1:52:24the fact that some of the things that people
- 1:52:26have been talking about and that we now witness
- 1:52:28on a regular basis, like fires and stuff like
- 1:52:31that. Well, you know, as people have been saying,
- 1:52:34part of a new normal. And it's a new normal that
- 1:52:37is going to be really difficult to deal with.
- 1:52:42And just to add a detail about that, not all
- 1:52:46regions will be affected equally according to
- 1:52:53estimates. the global south will be affected
- 1:52:59more than the north. In fact, I remember a chemistry
- 1:53:02class in college where the teacher talked about
- 1:53:06the benefits of climate change for Canada. Yeah,
- 1:53:10how we would, you know, get rid of our winter.
- 1:53:14And so we would be able to cultivate land all
- 1:53:19year long. And, you know, since we have so many
- 1:53:24lakes and and rivers and all of that, we won't
- 1:53:29have to worry about droughts. Yeah, no, you're
- 1:53:36right. Unfortunately, some people think about
- 1:53:40it that way. During my first year here in Canada,
- 1:53:44so 2019, there was a bit of a scandal because
- 1:53:51somebody, which I don't think was ever identified,
- 1:53:56Somebody gave the okay for the creation of this
- 1:54:02one billboard featuring a cow and the University
- 1:54:08of Alberta logo, and it read, climate change
- 1:54:14will lengthen the growing season, boosting beef
- 1:54:20production. That was all it said. And it was
- 1:54:24a big deal because, well, first off, the official
- 1:54:26position of the university, regardless of whether
- 1:54:28they actually follow through or not, the official
- 1:54:30position is that the climate crisis is something
- 1:54:33that needs to be addressed, right? So saying
- 1:54:35something like that is, it doesn't square with
- 1:54:37the university's philosophy to begin with, right?
- 1:54:40But it was, I mean, again, I didn't follow up
- 1:54:45on the story. I was new, so I just thought it
- 1:54:46was ridiculous and didn't really follow through.
- 1:54:48But now in hindsight, I realize of like, what
- 1:54:52they were doing, right? Essentially doing what
- 1:54:54your professor seems to be, well, seems to have
- 1:54:57done or said, right? Which is, don't worry about
- 1:55:01climate change. It's actually gonna make things
- 1:55:02better for us, right? And here in Alberta, for
- 1:55:05people who don't know, beef is a big freaking
- 1:55:07deal, right? They love their beef here. Alberta
- 1:55:10is essentially like the Texas of Canada, right?
- 1:55:12So they love their barbecues, they love their
- 1:55:14beef, they love their burgers. And so, hearing
- 1:55:18or reading that climate change will actually
- 1:55:20allow us to eat more and cheaper beef was like
- 1:55:24music to the ears of most Albertans, right? So
- 1:55:28it was a PR disaster for a hot second there.
- 1:55:36And I think you have to question what sort of
- 1:55:38what might have motivated somebody to give the
- 1:55:41okay to this billboard. And of course, eventually
- 1:55:44it was taken down after a couple of weeks, but
- 1:55:46it was there. And again, I think some people
- 1:55:50unfortunately do think about what they stand
- 1:55:53to gain, even as millions of people are forced
- 1:55:57from their homes because they become essentially
- 1:56:00places where nobody can live anymore. That's
- 1:56:03already happening in some places. around the
- 1:56:07world I remember I remember going to this one
- 1:56:12event in Amsterdam and I'm gonna shoot myself
- 1:56:14right now because I can't remember who it was
- 1:56:18but if I'm not mistaken he was some sort of he
- 1:56:22was a journalist and he was a big -name journalist
- 1:56:25I can't remember who it was though and and what
- 1:56:28he was there to talk about was how through his
- 1:56:32many years as a correspondent in the Middle East,
- 1:56:36he had learned that the reason why, or one of
- 1:56:40the main reasons why so many people were fleeing
- 1:56:43that area and why that particular part of the
- 1:56:47world has become so hotly contested, no pun intended,
- 1:56:51is because it's becoming increasingly difficult
- 1:56:53to live in that area because of climate change.
- 1:56:56Resources are scarcer than they used to be. water
- 1:56:59is scarce as well. I remember he specifically
- 1:57:02talked about the civil war in Syria and how many
- 1:57:08of the villages that were most militant, who
- 1:57:11felt like they could no longer stand the regime
- 1:57:14anymore, were the villages that had suffered
- 1:57:18from several years of drought without any sort
- 1:57:22of help from the government. And that while he
- 1:57:24acknowledged the fact that Assad's government
- 1:57:27Could have done something he also realized that
- 1:57:30like what they could have done was, you know
- 1:57:32Comparatively very little because there was very
- 1:57:35there's very little you can do when it just won't
- 1:57:37rain, right? So, um, so the fact that that's
- 1:57:41already something that's exacerbating that political
- 1:57:43political stability of a place like the Middle
- 1:57:46East right and that's only going to get worse
- 1:57:48in another because it's going to Start happening
- 1:57:51in other parts of the world. Well, you know,
- 1:57:54that's something we should all be worried about
- 1:57:55is even if you're somebody who believes in borders
- 1:57:58and you know is a patriot and only really cares
- 1:58:00about Canada because guess what those people
- 1:58:02are going to look for another place to go to
- 1:58:04right and so um thinking that way thinking that
- 1:58:09that that you may actually benefit from climate
- 1:58:12change is myopic you're not looking at the whole
- 1:58:15picture you're not thinking about how other things
- 1:58:18that you may not think are related to climate
- 1:58:20change or if are going to get worse, right? Precisely
- 1:58:27because they were affected by something that
- 1:58:30you thought was good for you. Yeah, Assad should
- 1:58:34have done something performative, like a ceremony,
- 1:58:39like the old pharaohs would do or the old Chinese
- 1:58:42emperors, you know, to attract. Yeah, I mean,
- 1:58:47again, right? I think, I think not to say that
- 1:58:50he could have actually done anything like no
- 1:58:53regime on earth can make rain happen right but
- 1:58:57i mean when you are when when when you're at
- 1:58:59the mercy of of your overlords right and then
- 1:59:03you you're not happy with your situation you
- 1:59:05blame them right and as sad was guilty of very
- 1:59:08many crimes right so this is you know perhaps
- 1:59:10only it is only fair that eventually he was ousted
- 1:59:13but but it is true that like it's going to be
- 1:59:17difficult for governments to justify their power
- 1:59:20if they cannot provide the basic necessities
- 1:59:23that their people need and that in a play in
- 1:59:26a world where resources are strained and where
- 1:59:29you can no longer rely on weather patterns to
- 1:59:33you know grow your crops for example it's going
- 1:59:36to be really hard to provide for people in some
- 1:59:40parts of earth right and so that is only going
- 1:59:43to breed more instability that's always the comment
- 1:59:47I gave to preppers, I think they're called. Yeah,
- 1:59:52right. It's, it's like you're gathering all of
- 1:59:55that food and you're preparing yourself for the
- 1:59:59big day. But what about your neighbors? You know,
- 2:00:02they're aware that you're stocking up. Yeah,
- 2:00:05that's right. That's a great analogy, actually.
- 2:00:08But what about your neighbor? If your neighbors
- 2:00:09know that you're stuck piling food, right? Yeah,
- 2:00:14great analogy, actually. I'm going to steal that.
- 2:00:16I'm going to steal that. Yeah, steal it away.
- 2:00:19And, you know, it's not only them as a threat,
- 2:00:22you know, they're going to steal your food, but
- 2:00:24it's also the moral, you know, are you really
- 2:00:28going to let them starve? Yeah. Yeah. That's,
- 2:00:33that's the part that always baffles me, right?
- 2:00:35Because, you know, not to, not to get lost in
- 2:00:39the weeds here, but people who think that way,
- 2:00:43tend, in my experience, they tend to fall within
- 2:00:46one, they lean towards one side of the political
- 2:00:50spectrum, right? And it's usually the same political
- 2:00:52spectrum that tends to ally themselves with like,
- 2:00:58you know, Christianity or religion, right? And
- 2:01:02this high morality. And then they say these things
- 2:01:07about letting their, essentially letting their
- 2:01:10neighbors starve, right? I can't square that
- 2:01:13in my head. I don't I don't know how that works.
- 2:01:14But anyway, that's neither here nor there. Yeah,
- 2:01:18they should study history because the mob will
- 2:01:21write will will appear and at the gates and won't
- 2:01:28be pretty. That's right. Alex, this has been
- 2:01:33a very pleasant conversation. I've learned so
- 2:01:36much. And thank you. I'm so grateful you exist.
- 2:01:40When are you going to write a book? I've been
- 2:01:44doing that for the past six years. So the first
- 2:01:50thing that I have to finish is the project that
- 2:01:52I've been working on as my doctoral thesis, which
- 2:01:56is specifically about ecological documentaries,
- 2:02:01my interest or what I decided to dedicate my
- 2:02:08PhD work to. is essentially trying to understand
- 2:02:13these different modalities of environmental documentary.
- 2:02:19We've been talking about what I think is one
- 2:02:21of the main modalities, which is something like
- 2:02:27David Attenborough's A Life on Our Planet, which
- 2:02:29is just this one central figure who tries to
- 2:02:32walk you through whatever ecological problem
- 2:02:35they're talking about and then they offer you
- 2:02:37a number of solutions. And like I told you, I
- 2:02:39think that goes back or perhaps the first film
- 2:02:43to do that in relation to an environmental problem
- 2:02:46in a meaningful way, in a way that actually made
- 2:02:49an impact in the popular culture was An Inconvenient
- 2:02:55Truth. So that's one mode. Then there's another
- 2:02:58mode that's more related to just endangered species,
- 2:03:01for example. A good example of a film like that
- 2:03:05is the one that I talked about before, like chasing
- 2:03:07coral, chasing coral specifically about coral
- 2:03:09and the problems that coral is facing and how,
- 2:03:13perhaps how, what kind of efforts may lead to
- 2:03:17rescue or to saving that species, right? And
- 2:03:20then there's the kind of film that I'm currently,
- 2:03:23well, the one that I'm currently writing about
- 2:03:25because I'm trying to finish my dissertation
- 2:03:27and this is like the last chapter in there. It's,
- 2:03:30you know, these are films that again, just kind
- 2:03:33of observe a certain environment or ecology,
- 2:03:37right? A good example, a recent example is honey
- 2:03:39land, for example, which is about this one woman
- 2:03:43who is supposed to be the last wild beekeeper
- 2:03:53in all of Europe. So instead of like keeping
- 2:03:57domesticated bees, she keeps wild bees, and so
- 2:04:01it's supposed to be more ecologically explainable.
- 2:04:03So there's a number of different ways in which
- 2:04:08directors, right, documentarians will try to
- 2:04:11promote environmental causes, and I'm looking
- 2:04:13specifically at the ones that have to do with
- 2:04:15biodiversity loss in some way. We share the fact
- 2:04:21that we're vegan, right? But for me, veganism
- 2:04:23goes beyond food choices, right? I think that
- 2:04:27that if we truly extend these feelings of compassion
- 2:04:32and empathy and try to create an ethical framework
- 2:04:38that extends beyond the human, then we have to
- 2:04:42consider not just what we eat, but also how we
- 2:04:47conduct ourselves as a species or as a society
- 2:04:50and how it affects creatures that are living
- 2:04:53increasingly precarious lives. So that's sort
- 2:04:57of what I'm studying. And that's what my first
- 2:04:59book, if you want to put it like that, will be
- 2:05:01about. It will just be about documentaries that
- 2:05:04have to do with extinction and biodiversity laws.
- 2:05:08And then later on, I think I'll try to tackle
- 2:05:10other issues. But let's just say that doing a
- 2:05:14PhD is kicking my butt. So it might be a little
- 2:05:18wild. But I think, yeah, you know. As I work
- 2:05:23on this, I try to put things out here and there.
- 2:05:27I think you found out about me because of this
- 2:05:29one thing I wrote about axolotls. I can't remember
- 2:05:34if it was that or if it was something else. I
- 2:05:37try to write stories. I try to write about things
- 2:05:41that have to do with animals and particularly
- 2:05:44animals that are endangered but also in some
- 2:05:47ways closely related to people. people tend to
- 2:05:52make this mistake, or there's mistaken assumption
- 2:05:54that like wild animals and domestic animals are
- 2:05:56two different things. And that one is closer
- 2:05:58to people than the other. But you'd be surprised.
- 2:06:01Like, again, I you know, it's even hard to determine
- 2:06:04whether an axolotl is a domesticated or a wild
- 2:06:07species, right? So those are the kind of questions
- 2:06:11that I'm interested in the most. That's all great
- 2:06:15stuff. Be brave. I mean, I wish you good luck
- 2:06:22for the PhD and of course, you're always welcome
- 2:06:26on the show. I'm so happy to introduce your voice
- 2:06:29to my audience and at the same time, I'm preparing
- 2:06:33you for your future book tour. Yeah, you're right.
- 2:06:38Actually, I should be thanking you for that.
- 2:06:40You're welcome. So thank you again, Alex. Thank
- 2:06:46you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 2:06:49to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 2:06:52Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 2:06:56thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 2:06:59next Tuesday for a new episode.