Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 123: On The New French Wine with Jon Bonné
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to The New Paris.
- 0:08I'm your host, Lindsay Trimuda. I've been waiting to talk about
- 0:13the new book by today's guest for years, actually, ever since
- 0:17I met him some seven years ago when he was already hard at work
- 0:20researching it. Jon Bonet has worked as a
- 0:23journalist for three decades and currently serves as the managing
- 0:26editor at Rezi. He is particularly for wine
- 0:29lovers, best known for his wine reporting and two essential wine
- 0:32books, The New California Wine and the New Wine Rules.
- 0:36That one has sold more than 50,000 copies and been adapted
- 0:39into numerous languages. But his latest essential wine
- 0:44book is called The New French Wine.
- 0:46It came out earlier this year, and it is truly his most deeply
- 0:49researched shade of that tells the groundbreaking tale of the
- 0:53world's greatest wine culture at a moment of profound change.
- 0:57What follows was recorded several weeks ago when I had the
- 0:59great honor of leading a discussion with John about this
- 1:02immense project at the American Library in Paris.
- 1:05I hope you enjoy it. So I think the best place to
- 1:10start is this idea of the new, because we have clearly done a
- 1:16thing on in both of our works where, you know, it's a bold
- 1:20choice. It elicits some questions.
- 1:24I know why I chose the word we. Found our brand.
- 1:26We found our brand. Although I gotta I guess I gotta
- 1:29keep it going but I know why I chose that word for for my work.
- 1:34What does it represent for this project?
- 1:37And and and you know, 'cause essentially it sets up the whole
- 1:40thesis of your book. So.
- 1:41So can you explain that the new? Sure.
- 1:45So I mean, it's a joke, but it's not a joke.
- 1:48It it is sort of the brand like new California wine, new wine
- 1:51rolls, new French wine. You know, the next one will be
- 1:55coming soon. Hopefully we'll talk about that
- 1:59scoop. But I mean some of it is just as
- 2:04a journalist you think about news value, you think about what
- 2:07is actually worthy of writing a significant project about.
- 2:12And so that sort of defines for me.
- 2:15That defines the way that you create a scope for a very big
- 2:21thing. But.
- 2:23You know, with wine, I mean part of it is like with wine people
- 2:25sort of are sort of like, oh, like let's do a book on Chianti,
- 2:29let's do a book on, I don't know, Rioja.
- 2:31Like, I mean a lot of the same ground gets trod.
- 2:36That's never been my thing. And I think for my own curiosity
- 2:42and, you know, sort of intellectual need, I always am
- 2:46looking for what is different. But when it came to France, I
- 2:51think it's interesting, it started as very much the new in
- 2:54France, at least in wine, is going to be very much on the
- 2:57fringe. It's going to be all kind of
- 3:00weird little projects, natural wines, you know, funky stuff
- 3:03sort of off. I'll be hanging out in the
- 3:06Ovaron doing my thing. And what became very clear, and
- 3:11you and I have talked about this a lot, is that what was
- 3:14happening was huge and transformative and very much a
- 3:18mirror. Of the fact that France was and
- 3:22is becoming a new place. And so even compared to sort of
- 3:25you know my going back to the same word over and over again, I
- 3:29think this project, it became immediately, maybe not
- 3:33immediately clear. It became clear that in order to
- 3:37tell the story of the new French wine I was going to have to tell
- 3:41the story of the new French everything else ish, which you
- 3:45know, which you have done as well.
- 3:48But it's interesting because new does not suggest that somehow
- 3:51you lose the past but you really need to understand and examine
- 3:55the past to be able to to follow the shift and see how really you
- 3:59know the evolutions are happening and and obviously that
- 4:02goes towards something else. I really want to talk about and
- 4:05and people should know also this is a 2 volume book.
- 4:08It is it has narrative in one book and an entire chronicling
- 4:13of the producers in another. So this is not by any means you
- 4:17know, lightly researched or lightly explored.
- 4:22I mean the ever since I've known John, he's been working on this
- 4:25book and we'll get into that too.
- 4:27But so you draw on something that I think is very important
- 4:31and and I I have been very driven by as well in my work,
- 4:36which is this recurring theme of myth versus reality both not
- 4:42only for the country but wine culture.
- 4:44And, you know, there was a New York Times story that came out
- 4:47this morning that you and I were talking about or texting with a
- 4:52bit of frustration about that basically could have felt like
- 4:55it was written in the 1940s, which was essentially that Paris
- 5:00is so inspiring that what was it was like the artistic.
- 5:04It was, it was, it was sort of a traveler's guide to the places
- 5:07you could go in Paris that had inspired famous artists, so.
- 5:11Picasso used to get drunk here, and I think we did this here,
- 5:15except we've seen that about 7 billion times, and it was
- 5:19presented as though it was new. And it's sort of a regurgitation
- 5:22of everything that is, you know, old and entrenched in this
- 5:26romantic history. So it seemed like a very timely
- 5:30example of, you know, what we see happen over and over again.
- 5:33So can you talk about why you examined this idea of the myth
- 5:36and what that means in terms of wine?
- 5:39And everything else honestly. So, so it's interesting.
- 5:41There's there's two parts to kind of the to to the myth of
- 5:44France. There is the part that that is
- 5:48an externality. There's the part that Americans
- 5:51and the rest of the world sort of bathe themselves in and and
- 5:54admire and and you know that that inspires and makes them buy
- 5:58lots of busi tan and lavender sachets and all the things.
- 6:02So, but there's also an an enormous part of it that is
- 6:07that. There is the myth of France that
- 6:10the French also believe in and that they also perpetuate.
- 6:13And those two are completely symbiotic, which is to say that
- 6:19the French have a very, very clearview of how they think the
- 6:23past has come to bring them to this moment.
- 6:26And they said, I mean you look everywhere, they they bathe in
- 6:29history or a very specific telling of history.
- 6:33And it is It is a strong national myth.
- 6:38And and and the, I apologize if I'm diving farther into your
- 6:42questions but I mean the the title of the first chapter which
- 6:45is Patrum 1 or what's oldest new again is very much in terms of
- 6:49this idea of Patrum one. And it doesn't.
- 6:51I mean, it's history kind of, it's patrimony kind of, but it
- 6:54doesn't actually really translate in the sense that the
- 6:57word itself you mean? The word that that there's not
- 7:00the this in, I think the Anglophone world, there's not
- 7:03this. This fixation on the the kind of
- 7:05moral tie to the past, whether real or fictional.
- 7:10And so myth became very important in terms of a
- 7:14identifying sort of how the French view their own world and
- 7:19specific to wine and the ways in which the, the, the, the famous
- 7:23wines of France, the famous Appalachians of France are, you
- 7:27know, they are built on quality. They are built on terroir.
- 7:29They are built on, you know, on the extraordinary.
- 7:34Discovery of how good a thing tastes from this place but at
- 7:38the same time they're also they are very much kind of convenient
- 7:43half truths in their way and and literally if you if you look at
- 7:46the way that an Appalachian law is written the Caiodes charge so
- 7:50this is like the the E now approves it it goes into French
- 7:54legislative text it is officially encapsulated in law
- 7:58the history of every Appalachian not just for one for all for any
- 8:01Appalachian control. Is written into French law.
- 8:04So whatever the the the official trade group decides is their
- 8:07history is in is it is it is codified and that is you know
- 8:12that is not something that happens anywhere else in the
- 8:15world, no other wine region. No, I mean they they have very
- 8:18specific production standards. But this, this kind of this,
- 8:21like this, this storytelling aspect is just not, it's not
- 8:26baked into the culture in the same way.
- 8:28So one of the things that I found kept recurring as I was
- 8:31going from region to region was scraping away at the, you know,
- 8:36the the official story and finding that that everything to
- 8:41use the favorite French word of all time.
- 8:44Everything is complicated. Everything is more complicated
- 8:49than it would appear. And that there are many
- 8:52different sides to the story that these things that we take
- 8:54as eternal truths and wine that such as.
- 8:57I mean, pick any Appalachian, Pick your favorite Appalachian.
- 9:00Pick your favorite wine. Like, you know, is it Jeremy
- 9:03Chamberton? Is it, is it cow or is it is it
- 9:07Moloi? Like maybe you could trace some
- 9:12semblance of a history back to, let's say, the.
- 9:17I don't know Second Republic if you really tried.
- 9:21But on balance, like the wines as they exist today, or even as
- 9:24they existed when the Appalachians were created, which
- 9:27again didn't start till 1936, really doesn't resemble the
- 9:32larger history of these places. And so when when the the the
- 9:36powers that be in one place or another get upset that there's
- 9:40troublemakers who want to seek the new.
- 9:43In fact, what was? What was true over and over
- 9:46again was that these, these quote UN quote new things were
- 9:49simply iterations of wines, were grape growing or techniques or
- 9:56culture that had existed in the past.
- 9:58And so again, this sense of patrimony where you know
- 10:01everything in the present is connected to the past was in
- 10:04fact totally true. It just half of it was true and
- 10:07half of it was myth. Wow, you definitely.
- 10:11Did. Sorry, that was very, very
- 10:13elaborate. No, no.
- 10:14But you, you, you. This connects perfectly to what
- 10:16I wanted to talk to you about too, which was the issue of the
- 10:18Appalachians, right. Because this is quite unique as
- 10:21you as you've said. But it's also a system that's
- 10:24quite difficult for young, not well, not even necessarily
- 10:28young, but just wine makers who want to do things a bit
- 10:30differently, notably natural wine makers.
- 10:33It's very difficult for them to navigate in this system.
- 10:36How does that play out, you know, in practice for for wine
- 10:40makers like that? And also, I think you also talk
- 10:43about how there's been an attempt to have another set of
- 10:46rules for natural wine making, which is also complicated
- 10:51because by definition it's supposed to be sort of free from
- 10:54all these rules. So yes, although it very much
- 10:58depends on where you are, which is to say so, so the Appalachian
- 11:02controller system. Again, is is is very formalized
- 11:06and the way that it was constructed and it was
- 11:08constructed really over a 30 year period, there were about 6
- 11:11successive laws and it wasn't constructed for some grand noble
- 11:16idea of what the Patrum wine of wine was.
- 11:19It was created as an anti fraud mechanism because in the years
- 11:24both, both during but after Phylloxera which was the great
- 11:28blouse that really destroyed a lot of the French vineyards.
- 11:31Everywhere in the in the wine, in wine producing France it was
- 11:33rampant, rampant frog. So maybe you would find grapes
- 11:37from elsewhere. Maybe you would bring them from
- 11:39Algeria or somewhere else in the colonies.
- 11:41Maybe maybe you would just mix up some prune juice and some
- 11:46spices or whatever else. Or so the Appalachians were,
- 11:49were literally started as a method of saying we want you to
- 11:51make wine like actual wine. Kind of from the place that you
- 11:56know that you're that you're in, like if you're in champagne, you
- 11:59should make champagne. Except even then again, that's
- 12:01why I took so many different rounds.
- 12:02They didn't say you have to use grapes from here.
- 12:05You just, you know, it's like, well, you actually have to, you
- 12:07know that eventually they got to that.
- 12:09Then they were like, well, you have to use certain grapes.
- 12:11Then they were like, you can only produce a certain number.
- 12:13And so this started in 19 O 7 and it went to 1936.
- 12:18So the creation of the Appalachian system, you know?
- 12:22And now we see it as this great preserve preservation tool for
- 12:26tradition. But it was literally it was a
- 12:27way to to get farmers to stop committing.
- 12:30Not just farmers like Nugos like you know anyone who's in the
- 12:34wine trade to to stop committing fraud.
- 12:36The way it works today is that Appalachians are governed by
- 12:40their their ODJ, their office directional generale I think.
- 12:45So that's the syndicate that like.
- 12:47Controls each appellation and then the E now which is the the
- 12:50governing body, the governmental body that overseas it all.
- 12:53They're sort of there to sign off on what the Odaj is, what
- 12:57the Sandicats believe they want in terms of rules, they kind of
- 13:01govern it. They approve whether new
- 13:03appellation gets created etcetera.
- 13:04But it's very much built around local control.
- 13:07This very long chapter that goes into why and why the the courts
- 13:12had to get involved and the guy who created the Shatanif
- 13:15appellation and Sandicat. Basically sued his way
- 13:19successively through numerous lawsuits up to the court of the
- 13:22Casse Young, which is the Supreme Court.
- 13:26And yet, And then they were always told that France is not
- 13:28litigious. So point simply being that the
- 13:33way the Appalachians function is very, very bureaucratic and what
- 13:38could possibly go wrong if you're a young winemaker and you
- 13:42have a bunch of guys who've been in the Appalachian for 40 years?
- 13:46Who have a very specific way they want to farm.
- 13:47They love their roundup. They don't want to you know they
- 13:51they this crazy organic thing. You know, I mean, I'm, I'm being
- 13:54extreme, but there is a very formal and very codified and and
- 14:01somewhat calcified system in place to ensure that the
- 14:04Appalachians quote UN quote protect themselves.
- 14:07But then how does the new? So, So what has happened over
- 14:11and over is that you know? Natural wine in particular, but
- 14:14it doesn't even necessarily have to be natural.
- 14:15It's just it's new people who come in, they don't necessarily
- 14:19have local connections. They are, you know, they are
- 14:22from a different generation. Maybe they want to make natural
- 14:25wine and the wine is a little different than the Appalachians
- 14:29are used to. And the thing to remember is
- 14:31that most Appalachians have a tasting committee.
- 14:33And this is something interestingly that Josh Chirac
- 14:36signed off on in I think 1974 as one of the additions to the
- 14:40Appalachian laws is that. Everyone who wanted to to win
- 14:45the the, the agremo like the approval for to have an
- 14:49Appalachian wine had to put their wine before a tasting
- 14:52committee. Now, who's on the tasting?
- 14:54Yeah, that was going to be my next, you know?
- 14:56So you got a bunch of guys who like they like how Sanceras
- 14:59tasted with their, you know, their added yeasts and their
- 15:01this and their that and their high yields and something comes
- 15:04along with a little different. Or maybe you know, you like your
- 15:09truck hit one of their vines. Or maybe you weren't nice in
- 15:11them at the blue lingerie. Or, you know, like you.
- 15:14So a bit of a mafia. Yeah, you built your wall too
- 15:16high, whatever it is. So, so I mean, there's a lot of
- 15:19pettiness in the Appalachian system as it's set up in some
- 15:22places. In some places you see it works
- 15:24very well. But it was interesting.
- 15:27When I was doing research, I thought again the things I
- 15:31thought I knew when I started. I thought that all these like
- 15:34natural wine makers who were moving their wine into Van de
- 15:37France. So that's when you just you sort
- 15:40of you take what is theoretically the lowest
- 15:42possible designation for your wine, and Van de France is
- 15:46supposed to be complete crap table wine, right?
- 15:49It's. Table wine.
- 15:50Yeah, it used to be Van de Tableau.
- 15:51Now it's Van de France because the EU.
- 15:54So at least you know it's it's it's French crap instead of
- 15:56Spanish crap. But you know.
- 16:02They they did it not because they were making a statement.
- 16:06Typically they were heartbroken at having to leave Appalachians.
- 16:11It was that they, you know, their wines were rejected too
- 16:15many times or they, you know, they were kicked out or I mean
- 16:21and the thing, the thing to remember is each time typically
- 16:23that you submit your wine, you have to pay a fee.
- 16:27So they would see over and over again that, like, you know, they
- 16:30would submit their wine three times and maybe they would get
- 16:32it on the third time and maybe they wouldn't get it at all.
- 16:34And it wasn't like huge. It was like, I don't know, €100
- 16:38a time. But you're just like, you know,
- 16:39these aren't people with a ton of money.
- 16:41And you're like, to your point, this, this starts to feel kind
- 16:44of like a racket. So this all is happening.
- 16:47All of the changes that you were uncovering happens really in
- 16:52lockstep with the changes. And so the changing
- 16:55socioeconomic realities across France, I mean you literally,
- 16:58every time I would talk to you, you'd be like, I'm driving
- 17:00through Auhonge, I'm driving through, you know, some region
- 17:04and you're, you know, I know you were researching during the
- 17:07Gilets Joan protests, right. So I remember you telling me,
- 17:09you know, up there there at the roundabout here.
- 17:12So you saw over the many years, and we'll talk about that too,
- 17:16the many years that you were researching this book, a lot of
- 17:19broad shifts. So to what extent did that play
- 17:23a role in all of this research? And can you highlight maybe some
- 17:27of these shifts that had the most impact you think on the
- 17:30wine production or at least as a mirror to what is what's
- 17:32happening in wine? So yeah, the Gilet Jone, which
- 17:36is the sort of the backbone of the Languedoc chapter, is what
- 17:40we used to call in newspapers. Good copy.
- 17:43I mean, that was a mess, but it was good for my narrative, I
- 17:47guess. In in the sense that the
- 17:48Languedoc is a hot mess and the Gilejon were a hot mess and they
- 17:51were expressing themselves very visibly in their barbecues at
- 17:55the roundabouts and you know, like taking down the Vinci toll
- 17:59booths and whatever. So again, it became really clear
- 18:02at some point that what was happening in each of these
- 18:05regions was in some way a reflection of the economic and
- 18:09cultural changes in those regions.
- 18:11Sometimes for the good, sometimes for the bad Languedoc
- 18:14and the Gilejon being a good example, the.
- 18:17The bourgeoisie and the Chinese investors and the banks and
- 18:22insurance companies in the Medoc being another where we started
- 18:26the Bordeaux chapter this way and finally it felt like it was
- 18:28just too much of A downer. But one of the most poignant
- 18:32moments for me in in in the course of travelling was I was
- 18:36in Poyac. Poyac is this.
- 18:38This is where Chateau Latour. Chateau Lafitte Rothschild.
- 18:41Chateau Mouton Rothschild. Like you know, most of the first
- 18:44gross in Bordeaux are. And Poyak is is kind of a it's
- 18:49kind of a bummer of a town like it's I was there over the summer
- 18:52briefly. I saw that.
- 18:54Yeah it's it's poverty rate is 50% higher than the national
- 18:57average. Like they're finally starting to
- 18:59renovate some of the the downtown in the port.
- 19:01But it's like at best you could call it a working class town.
- 19:03But I mean I was literally was like at the Enter Marche getting
- 19:06gas and like there were a bunch of dudes who were kind of rough
- 19:09trade around. I was like, I grew up in New
- 19:12York. I'm.
- 19:13You know, there's not a lot of things that scare me, but I
- 19:14actually like while I was out pumping the gas, I locked my car
- 19:17door. I was like, they may get me, but
- 19:19they're not getting my notebook. But I was just like, this is
- 19:23insane. This is 600 meters from Chateau
- 19:25Lafitte. Is that great wealth?
- 19:28Yeah, great wealth. I mean, and and what became
- 19:30clear was like none of the wealth was trickling down.
- 19:33For the most part. The Crew Class A have all gotten
- 19:36tax exemptions because they're job creators.
- 19:39So. You know this, I mean we we're
- 19:41not talking about like out in you know out in the Cantal or
- 19:45Karez like the real hardscrabble friends for phone.
- 19:47We're talking about Playac, like this is 40 minutes from
- 19:51Bordeaux, which is a prosperous city.
- 19:53This is a place that has the more the most sort of created
- 19:57wealth of anyone town anywhere. And it's it's kind of a crappy
- 20:01place. And so how does that reflect the
- 20:04wine? Well, I mean what became clear
- 20:07was like that that was emblematic of how difficult it
- 20:11is to have change in the Medoc and how like Margot was in fact
- 20:16doing much, much better at at its progressive values than
- 20:19Poiak. I mean next sort of just about
- 20:22next appellation down because you know there was just there
- 20:25was a cultural shift. The flip side being you take
- 20:28somewhere like the Pei Nonte right around Nantes.
- 20:31Where Nantes, I did not expect to be what it was, which is this
- 20:34very young, prosperous city, very green.
- 20:37Very green, very culturally progressive.
- 20:39And you see how not just Muscaday, which is the the kind
- 20:44of best known local wine, but but the coto doncini, like all
- 20:47of the wine regions around. But Muscaday in particular is
- 20:50going through this tremendous progressive revolution that very
- 20:53much reflects the way that Nantes is a city and the people
- 20:56in Nantes are supporting. Their local produce and they
- 20:59see, they see the need for great French wines to evolve.
- 21:04And again you have, you know, you have this local, you know
- 21:07this, this local support great Neo Bistros, young chefs, a a
- 21:11culture of France that is very 21st century, that is less
- 21:16homogeneous, that is less sort of, you know, middle-aged and
- 21:19white that is moving and same thing in some way with Lyon and
- 21:25Beaujolais. Or frankly, bone in Burgess.
- 21:29I was just going to ask you about Burgundy because obviously
- 21:31Burgundy is not. Is has always been a favorite
- 21:34wine region for a lot of American wine drinkers, I think,
- 21:38but kind of, that seems to me. Yes and no.
- 21:42It no, because it seems to me there are a lot of international
- 21:44wine makers who have set up there.
- 21:46I mean, the thing with Burgundy is, for a long time, at least
- 21:49for Americans, it was considered like too complicated to
- 21:51understand. And there was just the the the
- 21:53Burgundians didn't really engage with international trade.
- 21:55Still don't like to open their doors to visitors?
- 21:59Well now for for a different reason.
- 22:01It used to be because they were like, you know, farmers who had
- 22:04no money and had like maybe been to the like 2 local villages but
- 22:08had no idea what was going on in the world.
- 22:10Now it's because they're so well known and so revered that like,
- 22:14they have no wine to pour for anyone.
- 22:16I guess same that effect but very, very different reasons.
- 22:19It is interesting that you know the the part of Burgundy that's
- 22:22hard is the prices have become ridiculous.
- 22:24And even now, I mean, the Burgundians are more aware of
- 22:27this than anyone, and they're frustrated because they
- 22:30understand that if they don't find a way for a new generation
- 22:34to actually drink Burgundy at some level, then everyone will
- 22:39move on. And that the people.
- 22:41Who have made the wines that expensive, which are who they
- 22:43call the collection or the collectors not the amateur or
- 22:47like the the real fans. They're not loyal customers like
- 22:50that's not a sustainable market and and and it's interesting you
- 22:54know, just I just got back from there last night.
- 22:56Every single person in Burgundy you talk to they're very clear
- 23:00that they have a moral responsibility to be making more
- 23:03affordable like basic wine. You know, you could be in von
- 23:06Romani, you could be in the Cote de Couchois wherever like it is
- 23:10this understanding that like. A wine region succeeds because
- 23:14people can drink it all the time and when you go to bone you see
- 23:17the same thing. It is very international.
- 23:19It is surprisingly open for a a wine region that did not it was
- 23:23not historically open and welcoming out welcoming like
- 23:27there's great food there's great third wave coffee like it's it's
- 23:30a it's it's very engaged with the with the outside world and I
- 23:35mean not just throughout France but like.
- 23:38Singapore and Tokyo and RGB and those are the people who are
- 23:42coming and trying to buy. Yeah, with with some success.
- 23:46Or in some cases those are the people who are coming to
- 23:48Burgundy and establishing themselves and starting to make
- 23:51wine. And the fact that you can show
- 23:52up as someone with no land, with no pedigree, with no sort of
- 23:56history. And within a few years at the
- 23:58very least become a Micronogos. Like, you know, sort of buy
- 24:01grapes in different places and make a little bit of wine.
- 24:03And then eventually, hopefully like find a little plot of your
- 24:06own like. This place that was considered
- 24:08sort of the most closed and literally cloistered and, you
- 24:12know, monastic and mysterious of wine regions.
- 24:15It's astonishing how welcoming they are to anyone today who
- 24:20wants to come and try their hand at, at, at, at doing a thing.
- 24:25So that's quite a big shift obviously.
- 24:27I mean you're you've already named a a few shifts across
- 24:30France, obviously there are plenty we could keep talking
- 24:33about that are. Just go region by region.
- 24:35I I mentioned earlier that you have been working on this for a
- 24:38very long time. It's been like 9 years.
- 24:41I don't know if you'll, I mean I I think you'll probably be able
- 24:45to detect that when you see it and you hold it in your hands
- 24:48and you start reading the the different sections.
- 24:51But this is, this is just how how did you do this Like what
- 24:55Truly? Because I I mean, I've
- 24:56researched, you know, complicated projects before, but
- 24:59this just seems like I would just run scared and be like take
- 25:03the advance money back. I can't do this.
- 25:05Just. So how did you what was your
- 25:07process? Well, there were I at least a
- 25:11dozen times when I was like, So what did I get paid as an
- 25:14advance? And how bad would my life be if
- 25:16I just sent them back? A check went even deeper into
- 25:18debt. Yeah, I don't know.
- 25:21I mean, probably by being too stupid to to have said no in the
- 25:25first place. Well, I should preface this by
- 25:27saying you, you live part time in in Paris, so you come back
- 25:30and forth you've had. But I didn't.
- 25:32When? When I started this book.
- 25:34No. But you were already coming.
- 25:35This isn't like a new place of research for you.
- 25:39So I guess the the better question is how did you organize
- 25:42the research Once you had decided that you were too far in
- 25:45and you were you were going to produce this thing, how did you
- 25:47organize yourself? You've also in your question
- 25:51answered why I'm not writing the new Italian learning stuff like
- 25:54oh what do you could do next? I'm like I'm not going to a
- 25:56place that I don't know and doing another thing like this
- 25:59because that would that would be even stupider.
- 26:02How did I organize? So again, I thought this was
- 26:04going to be like a two year project and this literally
- 26:06started because I had just done the new California.
- 26:09It was 2014, my editor at 10 speed, Emily.
- 26:14We went out for to, you know, for for drinks, for wine at a
- 26:19natural wine bar in Oakland. So never agreed to do anything
- 26:24at a natural wine bar in Oakland.
- 26:26That is my take away. Well, I have loads of other
- 26:28questions about that. So like, you know, probably 1-1
- 26:31or two too many glasses of unsulfured gamete in and we're
- 26:36talking about like what what should I do next?
- 26:37Etcetera. And she's like, what about
- 26:39France? And I was like, yeah, that's a
- 26:41great idea. And I so we talked about it.
- 26:44I was like, this is, you know, like, again, like we'll look at
- 26:46the fringe and there's lots of cool stuff around the edges and
- 26:49like couple years bang it out, you know, it'll be really
- 26:52fascinating. It'll be a chance to go see some
- 26:55parts of France. But what became really clear
- 26:59after a couple of three trips that there was an enormous
- 27:02amount to process that I was going to have to go everywhere.
- 27:06So in terms of process, like the literal process, this is going
- 27:10to be the most unromantic answer ever.
- 27:12Like. I built a database, I literally
- 27:15built like a Google Form that I could just start putting lots of
- 27:18information into and just copiously gathered notes and
- 27:22thoughts and ideas and started planning trips very quickly
- 27:26made, you know, learn some lessons about logistics, like
- 27:29make a map before you start booking appointments because you
- 27:33think you know where places are. But like, this was, this was
- 27:36after the JIRA. And I was like, yeah, it's a
- 27:38tiny little wine region, you know, just.
- 27:40Book stuff. Whenever I can see people and
- 27:43you know, it's fine. Like, I understand the French is
- 27:44very particular about appointments.
- 27:46And after, like literally between every appointment I
- 27:49would be driving 40 minutes and I was like screw this.
- 27:52Oops, do you like, you know, you make a map and you start
- 27:55thinking, OK, this this day is my my, like this day is my
- 27:59morgon day. This day is my sued Beaujolais
- 28:03Day. This day is, you know, whatever.
- 28:05And you or I? Yeah, I'm not doing this
- 28:09project. Yeah, come on, it's literally
- 28:12two years easy, two years. But you know, I I started to get
- 28:18a little bit more organized, but I but honestly, I would have to
- 28:20do about five to six weeks to research for every three-week
- 28:22trip. Wait.
- 28:23Say that again. I would have to do about five to
- 28:25six weeks research for every three-week trip.
- 28:30I mean when you see the book again, you will not be surprised
- 28:32by that information. And also it's funny you talk
- 28:34about a two year, like bang out a book in two years.
- 28:37It's still very complicated. I mean, I find it's like the, I
- 28:41mean my body was like broken after both of these experiences.
- 28:44So I don't know how you maintained yourself and, you
- 28:49know, through nine years of this, but you really were
- 28:51committed. Yeah, aside from the like 40,000
- 28:55times I was just again like I've done.
- 28:57But honestly, some of it became, you know who gets?
- 29:02In a very, in a very real way, who gets the experience that I
- 29:06got, Who gets to go see that many parts of France?
- 29:10Who I I think I counted I the course of this.
- 29:12I visited 72 departments. And you know who who gets to see
- 29:16all these places? Who gets to like spend this much
- 29:19time with, with people who are like out there doing the real
- 29:22work and lots of long nights and Airbnb's and whatever it was a
- 29:28lot. But at the same time, you're
- 29:29just like I would remind myself over and over again.
- 29:32Who gets this experience? I get to do this thing and see
- 29:35this thing that like no one gets.
- 29:38I mean I think even people who write sort of the the grand
- 29:41treatises about this is what's happening in France now.
- 29:44Like, you know, maybe they go to a few regions but or a few
- 29:47departments but like it just. I mean the scope of it was
- 29:50completely insane, but at the same time it was also like I
- 29:54will A never have this chance again in my life to get to cover
- 29:57this much ground. But B like this is, you know, if
- 30:00you really, truly love. France, if you if you love
- 30:03French culture, if you love French gastronomy, French wine,
- 30:05any of it like this is. I mean, it's ridiculous to say
- 30:08it's a once in a lifetime opportunity, but it's just like
- 30:11this was like getting to the meat of it.
- 30:13And so, yes, it was completely too much.
- 30:15But on the other hand, it was, it was me satisfying this huge
- 30:20curiosity. Well, and so Eric Asimov of the
- 30:23New York Times featured the book this summer.
- 30:26And one of the things he said at the end of his review was he was
- 30:29very curious to see if he would see obviously or if any of us
- 30:34will see what the French have to say about this book.
- 30:36And it is not currently in French.
- 30:38I don't know if that is in the works.
- 30:39I mean, it would probably cost them so much money to translate
- 30:42this book, but. When I win the lottery, Right.
- 30:45But have you had feedback from French wine writers or French
- 30:49producers who grasp what you have attempted to do?
- 30:55Very. Modestly.
- 30:56I'm not expecting French wine writers to love it.
- 30:59Because it would be very much in the French ethos to to nag in
- 31:05the way that the French only the French can nag someone who
- 31:08actually had like done the work they hadn't done.
- 31:11And it is interesting that one of the main complaints that
- 31:14Vigneron have about the French wine press is that they just
- 31:18they're like, well the the way they put it is they never leave
- 31:20Paris. But if they do and and this is
- 31:22just endemic, I mean you know this of of like how French media
- 31:25works. They don't.
- 31:26Like a writer doesn't take an assignment unless basically the
- 31:29Sandika has essentially agreed to and usually paid for that
- 31:34article in some way. Yet there there's a lot that we
- 31:36could talk about in terms of the ethics of certain French
- 31:39journalistic standards, but also just sort of a lack of really
- 31:44going, going, you know, the extra mile.
- 31:47But I think part of that has to do with how poorly they're paid.
- 31:50But you're right there is. It's a.
- 31:51It's a different. Way of functioning all the way
- 31:53up to, I mean the the example I was used like you mean you don't
- 31:56run a story about Macron without clearing quotes with the Elysee.
- 32:00Oh, well, yeah, that's. You know, this is very there's a
- 32:02whole lot of liberty, except for the parts where there aren't.
- 32:05So I mean, you know, it's too reverential.
- 32:08If there is positive response that is great, but I you know I
- 32:11can understand where there's there, would there would be
- 32:13reasonable frustration. The Vigneron who have read it or
- 32:17have seen it are generally, you know, they're happy.
- 32:20They it's interesting. Even on this trip they tend to
- 32:22like they they don't really care about the narrative chat book,
- 32:25which of course is the one that I put all the work into.
- 32:28They're curious to look through the producers and see who else
- 32:30is there because that intense sense of belonging that the
- 32:35French have and the sense of kind of clubbiness and
- 32:38affiliation and having to see if you're, like, in the right
- 32:41crowd, all they care about is. Not even what I ever said about
- 32:44them but like who else is there and like were they featured with
- 32:47the right people. But you know look there there
- 32:50are also people like I'm thinking of like Ivo Messonnat
- 32:52who who has to men Bollargus in in the Loire was very kind to
- 32:56invite me as the speaker to the the pole donju this summer and
- 33:00he gets it. I mean, he has done a lot of
- 33:03this research, but I think it's the people, it's the the the
- 33:07Vigneron who I think have fought that fight and who realized that
- 33:11they. Are not alone.
- 33:14And I think you know, seeing that there is this framework
- 33:17that explains all of the pain that have endured like they like
- 33:21it. So that actually is fulfilling
- 33:23to me because, right, And you're recognizing them?
- 33:25Yeah, yeah. I mean they they feel C, right?
- 33:28So I have two final questions. I can't overlook the passage on
- 33:33natural wine because we are living in this moment in the
- 33:35last 8 to 10 years where it has just exploded alongside
- 33:40pastronomy, which is, you know, the food movement that has
- 33:44really, really shifted the dining landscape in Paris.
- 33:47And you and I regularly discuss this, but I like what you've
- 33:50it's funny what you call the culture around natural wine.
- 33:54You call it sandbox insularity, and I think that merits a bit of
- 33:59discussion. What do you mean by that?
- 34:01So that's a really good follow on to what I was just saying
- 34:04exactly, which is that. There is this innate French
- 34:08desire and tendency to want to belong and there is I think
- 34:13probably or perhaps because of the ICT, you know.
- 34:16So if you take away kind of 1 identifying principle, which is
- 34:19your religion, people will look for other ways to identify.
- 34:22And so what's your sports team? What trade union are you part
- 34:26of? I know picket.
- 34:28That's two good examples. Yeah, but, but, So there is
- 34:31this, this very strong sense of I was going to say inclusivity,
- 34:34but it's not inclusivity. Affiliation.
- 34:37And so one of the ways that I I went at Natural Wine and that
- 34:41was for sure the hardest chapter to write.
- 34:42Because it's not not because of the writing, but because it took
- 34:45me so long to find the right analogies and to dump things
- 34:48like, oh, it's just punk, which it's not.
- 34:51I mean it's maybe in a little way, but actually it's a really
- 34:55bad analogy. And I ended up talking a lot
- 34:57about modern art and the Refusee and the Salander Refusee and
- 35:00that kind of gave me a framework and again the way that you know
- 35:03that. You are completely an outcast
- 35:05and unacceptable in French culture until one day you are
- 35:08beloved and then it's always been that way.
- 35:11And yes, of course Nanay and Van Gogh and and and Monet were
- 35:15geniuses and we always knew that, except for the part where
- 35:19the Academy, de Bozaro basically just, you know, kicked them to
- 35:22the curb for 30 years. So, so natural wine is that.
- 35:26So natural wine is very much that, but The thing is that.
- 35:29It is in part the inability for natural wine to be given a seat
- 35:34at the table. But it's also, and this is my
- 35:36point was it's the inability of natural wine makers to
- 35:40understand the ways in which they have transformed the system
- 35:44because they are so into hanging out with each other and smoking
- 35:47their cigarettes, you know, outside in the cold and just
- 35:52like growing down that they can actually see the ways in which.
- 35:57There is a larger world that's willing to engage with them
- 36:01because they're so. I mean there's a weird
- 36:03persecution complex. So it's a that they're like
- 36:06there is this need for belonging and they aligning themselves
- 36:10with other natural wine makers. But only certain natural wine
- 36:13makers and I'll I'll spare the long example of domain Weinbach
- 36:18and I'll just ask because I know you you have more questions, but
- 36:22it's not just like. Oh well, these are, these are
- 36:25the rules you have to follow. Even though, yes, in 2019 there
- 36:28was an approved Seneca for natural wine and there is a a
- 36:32Ven Meto nature, I think, designation that the E now now
- 36:36controls to the point of like everyone ends up as part of the
- 36:39establishment and ends up like following the rules in the end.
- 36:44Which is bizarre for a movement that's supposed to have no
- 36:46rules, but it's not at all inclusive.
- 36:48It's very much like, you know. Do you like, hang out and do you
- 36:51listen to MC Solar and all the vintage hip hop?
- 36:55And do you? Are you?
- 36:56We're Stussy. Yeah, exactly.
- 36:58Yeah. Do you have, you know, like are
- 36:59we Bros or not? So that would be the quote, UN
- 37:03quote, sandbox insularity. Well, there's lots more to
- 37:07unpack about natural wine. You'll just have to read that
- 37:10chapter. But I'd like to conclude with
- 37:12something we we've just spent this time talking about the new
- 37:15France and and what is the new French wine?
- 37:19What do we do, though, with the old France that everyone knows
- 37:23and apparently loves? To the ground, No.
- 37:29I mean, so this, this goes very much back to to your question
- 37:33about myth. You know what's interesting
- 37:36about the new French wine? But honestly, the new French
- 37:38Everything is that. When it exists in its best form,
- 37:43it is entirely an evolution of what has come before.
- 37:47Which is to say we could pull sort of nearly any of the wines
- 37:50in the book out and I could give you a very detailed explanation
- 37:55on why. It is simply the progression
- 37:58from a wine and a a culture and a a tradition that existed 50
- 38:03years ago or 100 years ago or 150 years ago and.
- 38:06It's one reason that in the first chapter of the book I
- 38:09highlight three key bit of cultural texts from the 19th
- 38:11century, like Jules Guillaud, who's one of the most famous
- 38:15ampleographers and wine researchers and sort of
- 38:19everything researchers of his of his day kind of did what I did,
- 38:23but even even more detail, he spent like 7 years compiling A3
- 38:27volume book about every single wine tradition in France.
- 38:31And so whether it's that, whether it's pastronomy, whether
- 38:35it's art. The thing that I am optimistic
- 38:39about is that all of these things that come are not net
- 38:43new. They are very much built on the
- 38:45best of French tradition and to the point of myth and the way
- 38:48that people get mired in this. My my example to you before was
- 38:52Midnight in Paris, which I like a lot, is a movie, but is
- 38:55literally just kind of bathing in the worst cliches about how
- 38:59Americans believe in in France. Is that?
- 39:02There's nothing wrong with embracing the new by seeing how
- 39:06it has moved on from the old. But it is also acknowledging
- 39:10that the old is just that it's old.
- 39:13And if you don't see the way that things move on, then you
- 39:18you enter very dangerous territory.
- 39:20Like, say, if you want to, I don't know, make America great
- 39:22again. I knew you were going to say
- 39:24that. So yeah, we don't want to keep
- 39:25France great again. We want to keep it evolving.
- 39:29John, thank you so much. That's the show for today.
- 39:33Thanks for listening. As always, if you're streaming
- 39:36this on Spotify, be sure to check out a little poll that
- 39:39awaits you pertaining to this discussion.
- 39:41Just Scroll down on the episode page within the app and vote.
- 39:46And if you enjoy the show, I'd love it if you'd subscribe,
- 39:48share with a friend, and pick up the books that inspired it, The
- 39:52new Paris and the new Parisian. Until next time, Abiento.