Latest / The Line Podcast / On The Line: Are we the digital baddies?
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_03: Hello, beautiful ladies and gentlemen.
- 0:01SPEAKER_03: I'm your host, Jen Gerson, and I am here on the line with Michael Geist.
- 0:06He is a University of Ottawa professor and basically Canada's
- 0:10go-to dude on digital
- 0:12SPEAKER_03: law and privacy issues.
- 0:14SPEAKER_03: He and I talk about lots of things.
- 0:16We talk about the Americans getting upset with us about our
- 0:19fairly terrible digital laws.
- 0:22He talks a little bit about Tumblr Ridge and the desire to
- 0:26regulate AI chatbots
- 0:27SPEAKER_03: through the Online Harms Act.
- 0:29SPEAKER_03: And we talk about the dreadful hypocrisy of C4,
- 0:33and that's the desire by political parties to exempt themselves
- 0:36from privacy
- 0:36SPEAKER_03: legislation.
- 0:37SPEAKER_03: That's today on On The Line.
- 0:52This episode of On The Line is brought to you by the Forest
- 0:55Products Association of Canada.
- 0:58SPEAKER_00: Government can't control the global markets,
- 1:00SPEAKER_00: but they can control the efficiency of our own regulatory system.
- 1:03It's been over 150 days since the Red Tape Review and Canada's
- 1:07forest products
- 1:07SPEAKER_00: sector is ready to move from intent to outcomes.
- 1:10We're advocating for practical fixes like reducing duplication
- 1:14and improving
- 1:15SPEAKER_00: coordination so we can get projects built at the speed of business.
- 1:19SPEAKER_00: With greater regulatory efficiency,
- 1:21SPEAKER_00: we can better compete with the Americans and Europeans,
- 1:24SPEAKER_00: grow jobs,
- 1:25SPEAKER_00: bring more of Canada to the world,
- 1:28SPEAKER_00: and secure a stronger Canadian economy.
- 1:31SPEAKER_00: Let's get to work.
- 1:32SPEAKER_00: Visit www.fpac.ca to see more.
- 1:39SPEAKER_03: Hello, Professor Michael Geist.
- 1:41SPEAKER_03: Nice to see you again.
- 1:42SPEAKER_03: I haven't spoken to you in so long.
- 1:44SPEAKER_01: It's been a little while.
- 1:45SPEAKER_01: It's nice to see you too, Jen.
- 1:46SPEAKER_03: Nice to see you too.
- 1:47SPEAKER_03: So look,
- 1:48SPEAKER_03: I have a confession to make is typically speaking,
- 1:51SPEAKER_03: digital law in Canada is one of my wheelhouses.
- 1:55And I admit,
- 1:56I have been completely thrown off by events over the last
- 2:01couple of weeks.
- 2:02SPEAKER_03: And I feel extremely out of the loop.
- 2:04SPEAKER_03: So I'm having you on on the line,
- 2:06SPEAKER_03: mostly to help me get caught up on what I need to be paying attention to.
- 2:09There have been a few items on the digital file that have been
- 2:13in the news.
- 2:13SPEAKER_03: There's been the trade priority report.
- 2:16SPEAKER_03: There's the Online Harms Act and where that sits.
- 2:18SPEAKER_03: And there's been some interesting privacy provisions in C4,
- 2:21SPEAKER_03: which I believe the Senate struck down.
- 2:23SPEAKER_03: So I just want to start right from the top here.
- 2:26Let's go into it,
- 2:27assuming that our audience doesn't know anything about any of
- 2:30this stuff.
- 2:31SPEAKER_03: And I'll try and keep it as spicy as humanly possible for them,
- 2:34SPEAKER_03: because we all know everybody loves digital law in Canada.
- 2:36SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 2:38SPEAKER_03: I think the most important thing,
- 2:39SPEAKER_03: and you mentioned it when we were just offline,
- 2:41SPEAKER_03: and this had completely gone off my radar,
- 2:43SPEAKER_03: the U.S.
- 2:44SPEAKER_03: released its trade priority report that focused on two specific issues,
- 2:49SPEAKER_03: one of which was agriculture,
- 2:51SPEAKER_03: and we will not be getting into that today.
- 2:53SPEAKER_03: But the other one is focusing on Canada's digital laws.
- 2:58SPEAKER_03: Michael, can you explain to me what the Americans are concerned about?
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: So this is part of their trade policy agenda report,
- 3:09SPEAKER_01: identifies,
- 3:10SPEAKER_01: as you say,
- 3:10SPEAKER_01: their various priorities.
- 3:12SPEAKER_01: And it didn't get a lot of attention,
- 3:14SPEAKER_01: but in some ways,
- 3:15they're not hiding the ball here in terms of trying to identify
- 3:18what are the key
- 3:20SPEAKER_01: U.S.
- 3:20SPEAKER_01: issues with respect to Canadian trade.
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: And of course,
- 3:23the context that's important for people to bear in mind here is
- 3:26that all of this
- 3:27comes within the broader framing of the renegotiation of the
- 3:31USMCA or KUSMA.
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: which is scheduled to start this year.
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: And there are,
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: a lot of questions as to whether or not that will happen,
- 3:39SPEAKER_01: how it will happen.
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: Mexico's really tried to push forward with that,
- 3:43SPEAKER_01: but Canada has so far put less on the table,
- 3:46SPEAKER_01: at least that's according to the reports we've seen.
- 3:49SPEAKER_01: But what makes,
- 3:50SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 3:50this interesting and somewhat surprising that people haven't
- 3:53paid much attention is
- 3:54SPEAKER_01: that within that context of looking at Kuzma,
- 3:57SPEAKER_01: the U.S.
- 3:58SPEAKER_01: identifies just two issues with the United States.
- 4:00SPEAKER_01: One is agriculture-related, as you mentioned, dairy in particular.
- 4:04SPEAKER_01: But the other one is concerns, the U.S.
- 4:06SPEAKER_01: says,
- 4:07about what they describe as discriminatory and restrictive
- 4:10digital measures,
- 4:11SPEAKER_01: including the Online Streaming Act.
- 4:14SPEAKER_01: Okay, so...
- 4:16Can we just explain to our audience exactly what the Online
- 4:20Streaming Act again for
- 4:21people who have not been completely on the ball with Canadian
- 4:24digital reality?
- 4:25SPEAKER_01: Yeah, no, of course.
- 4:26And so the Online Streaming Act that some might remember as
- 4:29Bill C-11 back when it
- 4:31SPEAKER_01: was the subject of a considerable amount of debate was...
- 4:34was part of a trio of attempts that the government had under
- 4:39Justin Trudeau to
- 4:40SPEAKER_01: invoke new kinds of digital regulation.
- 4:42SPEAKER_01: There was the Online News Act that,
- 4:45SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 4:45SPEAKER_01: led to Facebook or Meta blocking news links from its platforms.
- 4:50There was the Online Harms Act that we may get into a little
- 4:53bit later that did not pass.
- 4:55SPEAKER_01: And then there was this Online Streaming Act and the basic...
- 4:59provision or the core part of that really envisioned the large
- 5:02streaming services,
- 5:03SPEAKER_01: the Netflix and Amazons and Disneys of the world,
- 5:06SPEAKER_01: to both pay into a system to help fund the creation of Canadian content,
- 5:11SPEAKER_01: as well as help support what's often referred to as discoverability,
- 5:14help make Canadian content more prominent or discoverable on
- 5:18their platforms.
- 5:19SPEAKER_01: Now that legislation passed.
- 5:21SPEAKER_01: It is currently before the CRTC.
- 5:23SPEAKER_01: It is taking a long time at the CRTC,
- 5:26the CRTC being the broadcast and telecom regulator that now is
- 5:29effectively an
- 5:30SPEAKER_01: internet regulator when it comes to these issues as well.
- 5:33SPEAKER_01: And so the CRTC is taking a long time to flesh out precisely the
- 5:38SPEAKER_01: how much they're going to be required to pay.
- 5:40Some of the streaming services have in the meantime challenged
- 5:43some of this law
- 5:45SPEAKER_01: altogether at the courts.
- 5:46The federal court has been taking quite a long time to come up
- 5:50with its decision.
- 5:51SPEAKER_01: So it's possible we could have the court strike it down.
- 5:54It's possible the CRTC could come up with some reasonable
- 5:58number that the streamers
- 6:00SPEAKER_01: say,
- 6:00SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 6:01SPEAKER_01: no big deal,
- 6:01SPEAKER_01: we'll cut the check.
- 6:03SPEAKER_01: Neither of those things seem particularly likely, though.
- 6:06SPEAKER_01: And so the U.S.
- 6:07has become increasingly vocal about the prospect of pushing
- 6:10back on this and
- 6:12presumably demanding that Canada rescind that legislation as
- 6:16part of any sort of
- 6:17SPEAKER_01: new trade deal with the U.S.
- 6:19SPEAKER_01: and Mexico.
- 6:20SPEAKER_03: And did they name the C-18 the Online News Act as well specifically,
- 6:24SPEAKER_03: or was it just the Streaming Act?
- 6:25SPEAKER_01: They don't.
- 6:26SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 6:26SPEAKER_01: what they do say,
- 6:27SPEAKER_01: just to give that specific quote,
- 6:29SPEAKER_01: they refer to discriminatory and restrictive digital measures.
- 6:32SPEAKER_01: The law that they specifically cite is the Online Streaming Act,
- 6:36but it is framed in a sufficiently broad manner that you could
- 6:42envision them
- 6:43SPEAKER_01: talking about some of the other laws as well,
- 6:45SPEAKER_01: particularly what was once Bill C-18,
- 6:47SPEAKER_01: that Online News Act.
- 6:49SPEAKER_03: So,
- 6:49SPEAKER_03: Michael,
- 6:50SPEAKER_03: I've got a bit of a problem here,
- 6:51SPEAKER_03: and that is,
- 6:52SPEAKER_03: on one hand,
- 6:53SPEAKER_03: I'm not best pleased with America at present.
- 6:56SPEAKER_03: And on the other hand, all the things that America hates, I also hate.
- 7:00SPEAKER_03: So this puts me in a real bind.
- 7:04SPEAKER_03: Can we explain?
- 7:04SPEAKER_03: I mean, I think you've been on the front lines with C-11.
- 7:06SPEAKER_03: I was very much on the front lines on C-18.
- 7:09I think both of us have testified at the House and committee
- 7:12against these laws,
- 7:13SPEAKER_03: suggesting that they were...
- 7:15extremely problematic and more likely to cause more problems
- 7:18than they were certain to solve.
- 7:20I mean,
- 7:20I certainly think that that prediction proved to be prescient
- 7:23with C-18.
- 7:24SPEAKER_03: C-11 is a bit messier, though.
- 7:26SPEAKER_03: Can we explain a little bit about why we hated C-11 again?
- 7:32Yeah,
- 7:32so the focus back then was primarily on sort of some of the
- 7:37discoverability pieces.
- 7:39So this notion that platforms would be required to tinker with
- 7:44their algorithms or
- 7:45SPEAKER_01: otherwise engage in different kinds of things.
- 7:47SPEAKER_01: Activities to make certain content prominent.
- 7:50SPEAKER_01: And at the time,
- 7:51one of the real concerns was this legislation also incorporated
- 7:55social media
- 7:56SPEAKER_01: content.
- 7:57SPEAKER_01: At first it was out, then it was back in.
- 7:59The government said it wasn't really interested in regulating
- 8:01social media content,
- 8:02SPEAKER_01: whether that's podcasts like this or...
- 8:05SPEAKER_01: other sorts of YouTube type activities or TikTok,
- 8:09SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 8:10all the range of different things that individual creators can
- 8:13make and post.
- 8:15SPEAKER_01: Government said they weren't really interested in this,
- 8:16SPEAKER_01: but they left it open as a potential source of regulation.
- 8:21SPEAKER_01: The government,
- 8:23SPEAKER_01: once it passed,
- 8:24SPEAKER_01: included that possibility,
- 8:26SPEAKER_01: but then they instructed the CRTC to leave it alone.
- 8:29SPEAKER_01: At the moment,
- 8:31SPEAKER_01: I think that issue has become less the issue,
- 8:33SPEAKER_01: at least with respect to the United States.
- 8:35SPEAKER_01: The bigger issue right now is just a financial one,
- 8:38because one of the other elements here was that they expected
- 8:41these streamers to
- 8:42SPEAKER_01: pay.
- 8:43SPEAKER_01: And the concern potentially from a consumer perspective was,
- 8:46SPEAKER_01: well,
- 8:47SPEAKER_01: if you demand additional payments from services that it should be noted,
- 8:52SPEAKER_01: already spend a lot of money in Canada for production.
- 8:56that is this going to actually result in new money or are they
- 8:59simply going to
- 8:59SPEAKER_01: reallocate some of their existing funds?
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: Are they going to be eligible for the funding?
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: And this is where I think the U.S.
- 9:05SPEAKER_01: is particularly unhappy.
- 9:07SPEAKER_01: So is this going to be a system where the U.S.
- 9:09SPEAKER_01: is required or U.S.
- 9:10SPEAKER_01: streaming services are required to pay into a system to support others,
- 9:15but are themselves not eligible to apply it or make use of some
- 9:19of that money that
- 9:20SPEAKER_01: feels,
- 9:21SPEAKER_01: to use the U.S.'
- 9:21SPEAKER_01: 's words, somewhat discriminatory?
- 9:24SPEAKER_01: If you've got laws that say everybody has to pay,
- 9:27SPEAKER_01: but not everybody can be a beneficiary,
- 9:29and we're particularly going to exclude foreign entities from
- 9:32being potential
- 9:33SPEAKER_01: beneficiaries.
- 9:34There's a bit of a taxation without representation energy
- 9:37happening there,
- 9:37right?
- 9:38SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 9:38SPEAKER_01: I think that's it.
- 9:39SPEAKER_01: So I think that's where the rubber hits the road from the U.S.
- 9:43SPEAKER_01: perspective,
- 9:44SPEAKER_01: is that they're out there saying,
- 9:46SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 9:46SPEAKER_01: if the Canadian model gets adopted broadly...
- 9:50SPEAKER_01: There's a scenario whereby we get a lot of U.S.
- 9:54streaming services or other digital entities that are required
- 9:58to pay into foreign
- 10:00country systems aren't necessarily getting anything back and
- 10:04there's not an
- 10:05SPEAKER_01: unlimited pot of money.
- 10:06SPEAKER_01: And so at the end of the day, the U.S.
- 10:07SPEAKER_01: potentially loses out in a number of different ways.
- 10:10SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 10:12SPEAKER_03: I actually hate to say this, but I think that's a legitimate point.
- 10:16SPEAKER_01: Oh, I do too.
- 10:18SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 10:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah, no, of course.
- 10:19SPEAKER_01: I think it is a legitimate point.
- 10:21SPEAKER_01: And,
- 10:21SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 10:21I think it's one thing to say that we're going to create this
- 10:26so-called level
- 10:27SPEAKER_01: playing field,
- 10:27SPEAKER_01: which is what the government often referred to.
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: That was sort of the line that drove much of this legislation.
- 10:32SPEAKER_01: We need a level playing field.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: Canadian broadcasters pay into these systems.
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: Why shouldn't foreign streamers pay into the systems as well?
- 10:40problem is that certainly those that have been lobbying for
- 10:43this legislation and
- 10:44SPEAKER_01: then the government want a level playing field in terms of money in,
- 10:48SPEAKER_01: but don't want a level playing field in terms of money out.
- 10:52SPEAKER_01: And it's a legitimate argument to say,
- 10:53SPEAKER_01: well,
- 10:54SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 10:54if you're going to require us to pay in much the same way as
- 10:57Canadian entities,
- 10:58then we should be beneficiaries in much the same way as
- 11:01Canadian entities.
- 11:02I'm extremely upset right now because I feel like if things
- 11:05were not so pear-shaped
- 11:06SPEAKER_03: between the US and Canada generally,
- 11:09we could be using these arguments rationally to peel back bad
- 11:12legislation or
- 11:13SPEAKER_03: legislation that's just not been thought through.
- 11:16But because the relationship between the US and Canada is so
- 11:20sour right now,
- 11:21SPEAKER_03: we're going to stick to our guns on the worst possible policies.
- 11:25SPEAKER_01: Yeah, well, we'll see.
- 11:27SPEAKER_01: You know, it's certainly possible that that happens.
- 11:31SPEAKER_01: We didn't on the digital services tax.
- 11:34SPEAKER_01: True, true.
- 11:35SPEAKER_01: Although,
- 11:35SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 11:36there may be some amount of regret and hindsight about caving
- 11:41as quickly as Canada
- 11:42SPEAKER_01: did on the DST,
- 11:43SPEAKER_01: although I also think that was generally the right thing to have done.
- 11:46SPEAKER_03: Yeah, but we didn't get anything out of it, now did we?
- 11:48SPEAKER_01: No, and so that's why there may be some that say, listen, it's not.
- 11:52SPEAKER_01: Why are we going to really replay this again?
- 11:54SPEAKER_01: I would say,
- 11:56SPEAKER_01: though,
- 11:56SPEAKER_01: that Canada's willingness to put this on the table,
- 12:00SPEAKER_01: and I say this without,
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: any knowledge,
- 12:02SPEAKER_01: just speculation,
- 12:03but Canada's willingness to put that kind of legislation on the
- 12:06table would
- 12:07SPEAKER_01: presumably be a much more clear-cut quid pro quo.
- 12:11SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: In the case of digital services tax,
- 12:14SPEAKER_01: it was,
- 12:14SPEAKER_01: well,
- 12:15we'll take this away so that you don't walk away from the
- 12:18negotiating table.
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: In this instance,
- 12:20SPEAKER_01: it is presumably going to be,
- 12:22we want to ensure that our steel industry or our lumber
- 12:25industry or our dairy
- 12:26SPEAKER_01: industry continues to be beneficiaries of...
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: market access and other kinds of policies that we have.
- 12:33And so we're willing to sacrifice some of these additional
- 12:37revenues that might go
- 12:38SPEAKER_01: into this cultural sector in return for the benefits there.
- 12:43SPEAKER_01: And it may be that government says,
- 12:45SPEAKER_01: hey,
- 12:45SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 12:45SPEAKER_01: at the end of the day,
- 12:46you are making different kinds of contributions or find some
- 12:50mechanism to address
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: it,
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: or perhaps just use tax dollars to say we'll pump more money into the
- 12:55The system to make up for the perception that there's some now
- 12:59lost revenue that
- 13:00SPEAKER_01: would have otherwise come from these digital laws.
- 13:02SPEAKER_03: Well, that's what we need.
- 13:03SPEAKER_03: More Canada taxpayer supported content.
- 13:07SPEAKER_03: Look,
- 13:07I just really deeply resent being in a position where I'm being
- 13:11forced to defend
- 13:12SPEAKER_03: the Online News Act and Canadian butter in the name of patriotism.
- 13:16Like,
- 13:16I'm really unhappy that that's the timeline that I mean,
- 13:19don't get me wrong.
- 13:19I understand the terrible irony of it,
- 13:22but I just I'm very upset about it.
- 13:25SPEAKER_03: So the other thing I just wanted to point out,
- 13:26SPEAKER_03: specifically with C11,
- 13:27SPEAKER_03: and I think you pointed this out when the debate was happening,
- 13:30is that it's not like the American and global streaming giants
- 13:35weren't investing in
- 13:36SPEAKER_03: Canadian content before C11.
- 13:39SPEAKER_03: In fact,
- 13:41SPEAKER_03: just by virtue of private investment,
- 13:43SPEAKER_03: we were seeing a renaissance on this file,
- 13:46SPEAKER_03: weren't we?
- 13:47SPEAKER_01: No, we were seeing huge amounts invested.
- 13:50SPEAKER_01: Canada is one of the leading countries worldwide in terms of production.
- 13:54SPEAKER_01: It's what is referred to as foreign location service production.
- 13:58And it's one of these somewhat odd areas where we do see huge
- 14:02amounts spent.
- 14:03SPEAKER_01: But for the purposes of some groups,
- 14:06SPEAKER_01: they would prefer that we don't pay much attention to that at all.
- 14:09SPEAKER_01: It drives jobs.
- 14:10SPEAKER_01: It drives investment.
- 14:12But the argument is it doesn't drive the creation of what is
- 14:15referred to as Canadian content.
- 14:17And so then that gets us into this whole debate of what exactly
- 14:20is Canadian content.
- 14:22SPEAKER_01: The CRTC actually did hold some hearings on that and tried to refresh the
- 14:26definition a little bit in terms of expanding the scope of what
- 14:30might be considered
- 14:31SPEAKER_01: Canadian.
- 14:32But part of that problem has long been that there are
- 14:35productions that have no real
- 14:37connection to Canada other than ticking the right boxes that
- 14:40get certified as
- 14:41SPEAKER_01: Canadian,
- 14:42whereas there's other content that feels very Canadian in terms
- 14:46of the story,
- 14:47SPEAKER_01: who authored the story,
- 14:48SPEAKER_01: some of the people participating in that,
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: where it was filmed,
- 14:51SPEAKER_01: but under certain circumstances still doesn't qualify as Canadian.
- 14:56SPEAKER_01: And that's actually a big part of that has been
- 14:59SPEAKER_01: sort of highlighted by these large streaming services who will often be,
- 15:04or at least have shown a willingness to fund production in
- 15:08Canada that is Canadian
- 15:10SPEAKER_01: in many respects,
- 15:11SPEAKER_01: the storyline,
- 15:12SPEAKER_01: the actors,
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: the people working on the production.
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: But the streaming services will say, hey, we're a global player.
- 15:19We want to have the rights and we want to have the rights to
- 15:21exploit this on a global basis.
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: And CanCon rules,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: Canadian content rules have long said,
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: well,
- 15:27SPEAKER_01: if you want that,
- 15:27SPEAKER_01: then you're not Canadian,
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: notwithstanding all the other indicia that you've got.
- 15:34SPEAKER_03: Well,
- 15:34SPEAKER_03: I know what will definitely fix this problem,
- 15:37SPEAKER_03: Michael,
- 15:37SPEAKER_03: and that's the federal government stepping in and micromanaging it more.
- 15:41That's always the solution to complicated,
- 15:45nuanced problems in the Canadian cultural industry.
- 15:49SPEAKER_03: It's just more box ticking exercises,
- 15:52SPEAKER_03: more taxpayer dollars,
- 15:54and more nuanced and detailed rules about what constitutes
- 15:58Canadian content.
- 15:59SPEAKER_03: This will solve everything.
- 16:01Yeah,
- 16:01no,
- 16:01the government would say,
- 16:02listen,
- 16:02we're not deciding some of this stuff.
- 16:04SPEAKER_01: We leave it to our regulator, the CRTC.
- 16:06SPEAKER_01: Great.
- 16:07SPEAKER_03: Better yet.
- 16:08SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: I mean, some of them would say that's not improving the situation at all.
- 16:12We're actually moving this into an area that feels to many even
- 16:16less accessible and
- 16:17SPEAKER_01: more opaque in terms of how some of those rules are established.
- 16:21I'm also going to have to really,
- 16:22really be upset if Donald Trump manages to overturn C-18.
- 16:27SPEAKER_03: I'm really going to have some problems.
- 16:31SPEAKER_03: That's just, even the thought of that is bringing up the marches for me.
- 16:35SPEAKER_03: Michael, it's March in Alberta here, and I'm just staring into the abyss.
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 16:39SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:40SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 16:40the truth is that those package of laws that I made reference
- 16:45to a little bit
- 16:47was really the foundation behind much of those laws was all
- 16:50about making these big
- 16:51SPEAKER_01: tech companies pay.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: I mean, and the government at the time, I think, saw this as both
- 16:57SPEAKER_01: Good policy and good politics.
- 16:59SPEAKER_01: You know, you wanted to fight with these companies.
- 17:01SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 17:01SPEAKER_01: now you're fighting with Donald Trump,
- 17:03SPEAKER_01: which may still be good politics for in some instances,
- 17:06SPEAKER_01: but whether or not it's good policy in the broader scheme of things,
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: certainly our country,
- 17:11SPEAKER_01: but many countries seem a bit afraid to,
- 17:14SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: at least at a minimum,
- 17:16they're looking to pick their battles as opposed to fight it on
- 17:18everything because
- 17:18SPEAKER_01: you're certainly not going to win.
- 17:20SPEAKER_03: Well,
- 17:20SPEAKER_03: let's look at the other side of the coin here,
- 17:22SPEAKER_03: because we can talk about Canadian absurdity until the cows come home.
- 17:26SPEAKER_03: There's the supply managed dairy cows, no less.
- 17:32But what is motivating the Trump administration to fixate on
- 17:37these particular files?
- 17:38SPEAKER_03: Because,
- 17:39SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 17:39I understand they actually have a reasonably good argument for
- 17:44discrimination in
- 17:45C-18 or just the cluster F that turned out to be C-18 and why I
- 17:53can't post my known
- 17:54SPEAKER_03: news articles on my Facebook page anymore.
- 17:56SPEAKER_03: But these aren't...
- 17:58SPEAKER_03: huge issues in the context of the American economy, right?
- 18:03SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 18:04whether or not Netflix has to pay a few million dollars into a
- 18:09CanCon fund that an
- 18:11SPEAKER_03: independent American filmmaker can't access.
- 18:16SPEAKER_03: Like, there's an unfairness to that.
- 18:18SPEAKER_03: But that's not...
- 18:20actually going to be a major issue to an American economic big
- 18:25picture framework here.
- 18:26SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 18:27SPEAKER_03: an independent filmmaker in America probably has access to radically more
- 18:32SPEAKER_03: resources,
- 18:33networks and capital than a comparable Canadian filmmaker has
- 18:37by virtue of the size
- 18:38SPEAKER_03: of the respective markets.
- 18:40SPEAKER_03: So what is the politics that you think is happening?
- 18:43SPEAKER_03: Why do the Americans care about these issues so much?
- 18:46SPEAKER_03: Why is Donald Trump so fixated on Canada's terrible butter?
- 18:51SPEAKER_03: You know?
- 18:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 18:52SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 18:52SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 18:53SPEAKER_01: I don't know that anyone's in the...
- 18:55I'm certainly not someone who's in a good position to explain
- 18:57some of the kinds of
- 18:58SPEAKER_01: choices or motivations that lie behind Donald Trump.
- 19:02SPEAKER_01: I will say that it feels like from a policy perspective,
- 19:06SPEAKER_01: that kind of intersection between Trump and policy,
- 19:09there are a whole series of different policies or issues that
- 19:12kind of are spinning
- 19:13SPEAKER_01: around.
- 19:14And on any given day,
- 19:16your issue might be the one that hits in terms of where the
- 19:21wheel stops.
- 19:22SPEAKER_01: And in the context of these particular issues,
- 19:25SPEAKER_01: let's say on streaming,
- 19:27SPEAKER_01: it's hit on a couple of occasions,
- 19:29SPEAKER_01: right?
- 19:29SPEAKER_01: Where all of a sudden...
- 19:31You get a tweet or whatever they call a post on True Social
- 19:35where Donald Trump
- 19:36SPEAKER_01: starts talking about the loss of production,
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: film production in the United States,
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: and that he is going to put a tariff on all foreign productions,
- 19:46SPEAKER_01: which he has said in the past.
- 19:47No one quite knows exactly what that even means or how you
- 19:51would go about implementing it.
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: But,
- 19:53SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 19:53SPEAKER_01: he's appointed some people like Sylvester Stallone and John Voight,
- 19:56SPEAKER_01: I believe,
- 19:57SPEAKER_01: in the United States to be
- 19:59SPEAKER_01: voices of the Hollywood interest.
- 20:01So it's an issue that clearly interests him to a certain extent
- 20:06and to the extent
- 20:07SPEAKER_01: to which some of these policies overlap with that,
- 20:10SPEAKER_01: that may help explain it.
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: Or it may just be that within the
- 20:14SPEAKER_01: The USTR, the U.S.
- 20:16Trade Representative's Office that represents the United States
- 20:18on trade-related
- 20:19SPEAKER_01: issues,
- 20:20SPEAKER_01: they look at that Canadian landscape and they look at,
- 20:23SPEAKER_01: well,
- 20:23what are some of the issues that have been irritants for some
- 20:25of our stakeholders
- 20:26that they've raised that we think we could actually get some
- 20:29wins on that would
- 20:30SPEAKER_01: then allow the president to declare victory?
- 20:33SPEAKER_01: And perhaps this is one of them.
- 20:36I'm just not loving the degree to which the Americans are
- 20:39paying attention to us anymore.
- 20:40I really like going back to being their oft ignored,
- 20:43pleasant,
- 20:44fluffy little hat.
- 20:46SPEAKER_03: And they just forgot we existed.
- 20:47SPEAKER_03: That was a happier place for everyone, I think.
- 20:49SPEAKER_03: And I really wish we could move back to that.
- 20:54SPEAKER_03: Michael, I want to talk about the Online Harms Act.
- 20:56SPEAKER_03: Again, this is something that I started to launch in on.
- 20:59SPEAKER_03: You started to launch in on.
- 21:00SPEAKER_03: It was,
- 21:01SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 21:02one of the final trademark pieces of legislation of the Trudeau
- 21:07era and then
- 21:08SPEAKER_03: eventually died on the order papers.
- 21:11SPEAKER_03: Can we just go back and do a quick rehash?
- 21:13SPEAKER_03: Online Harms Act.
- 21:14SPEAKER_03: How do we how do we sum that one up?
- 21:15SPEAKER_03: And it's possible because it's a pretty extensive piece of legislation.
- 21:21SPEAKER_01: It was.
- 21:22And I actually think in some ways,
- 21:23the fact that it was so extensive was its undoing.
- 21:26And so you had the justice minister at the time,
- 21:29Marie Farhani,
- 21:31who put forward this bill.
- 21:32This was designed to be really the biggest and most important
- 21:36of the three that
- 21:36SPEAKER_01: we've been talking about.
- 21:37SPEAKER_01: And so it took a long time.
- 21:39It took a long time in part because the government had floated
- 21:42a number of
- 21:42SPEAKER_01: different possibilities for what it was thinking about and
- 21:46SPEAKER_01: They faced quite a lot of criticism.
- 21:47SPEAKER_01: They had a minister who was supposed to lead on this,
- 21:50SPEAKER_01: Stephen Guibault,
- 21:51back when he was at Heritage that proved to be a sort of
- 21:55charitably ineffective
- 21:56SPEAKER_01: communicator on some of these digital issues.
- 21:58SPEAKER_01: And so they decided to pull back.
- 22:01And ultimately,
- 22:02they brought this forward and it was several bills in one.
- 22:06There was an element that dealt specifically with internet
- 22:09platforms and the
- 22:09SPEAKER_01: responsibility they would have with respect to harms that would occur.
- 22:13SPEAKER_01: And it narrowly defined the harms,
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: frankly,
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: to things that are by and large already included in the criminal code.
- 22:19SPEAKER_01: So it was specific kinds of, I think, recognizable harms.
- 22:23And it did take what I think most would say is a hard line
- 22:26position with the platforms.
- 22:27SPEAKER_01: It simply said, listen, you've got a duty to act responsibly.
- 22:31SPEAKER_01: When it comes to this, you can't simply do nothing.
- 22:34SPEAKER_01: And we are going to work to identify what that might be.
- 22:37SPEAKER_01: We're going to require you to be far more transparent.
- 22:40We're going to have penalties if you fail to live up to these
- 22:42kinds of standards.
- 22:44SPEAKER_01: And I have to say that if it was limited just to that,
- 22:46SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 22:46SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 22:47SPEAKER_01: it would still face some criticism.
- 22:48But by and large,
- 22:49I think a lot of people were of the view that you could work
- 22:52with that.
- 22:53The mistake that was made in the context of online harms was an
- 22:56attempt to bring in
- 22:58SPEAKER_01: other pieces of legislation and reform them as well.
- 23:00So there are criminal code provisions in there that I think a
- 23:04lot of people were
- 23:04really concerned about in terms of the prospect of
- 23:07criminalizing certain kinds of
- 23:08SPEAKER_01: speech.
- 23:09And then there was the Human Rights Act reforms as well that
- 23:13that I think a lot of
- 23:14SPEAKER_01: people were worried would,
- 23:15SPEAKER_01: especially in the current environment,
- 23:17get weaponized with large numbers of complaints that were going
- 23:19to be filed over
- 23:21SPEAKER_01: Internet based hate and things like that.
- 23:23SPEAKER_03: And so what constitutes.
- 23:25SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 23:26we could do a complaint about Stephen Gabo's anti Alberta hate
- 23:30crimes pretty easily
- 23:31SPEAKER_03: under that legislation.
- 23:32SPEAKER_03: Let's put it that way.
- 23:34SPEAKER_01: These are hard issues to sort through.
- 23:36And I mean,
- 23:37some of these problems are real,
- 23:39but the government struggles with those.
- 23:42SPEAKER_01: Fair enough.
- 23:43SPEAKER_03: I was just joking.
- 23:44As I said that,
- 23:46I was literally picturing my comment section just basically
- 23:48like,
- 23:48Jen Gerson.
- 23:49SPEAKER_03: No, no, I was making a joke.
- 23:50SPEAKER_03: I was making a joke about how Stephen Gabot doesn't like Alberta.
- 23:53SPEAKER_03: It's fine.
- 23:53SPEAKER_03: It's fine.
- 23:54SPEAKER_03: All good.
- 23:54SPEAKER_01: All good.
- 23:56SPEAKER_01: But,
- 23:56SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 23:58it's funny in part because the fears were that you never know
- 24:02what might get
- 24:03SPEAKER_01: captured by this.
- 24:04SPEAKER_01: So,
- 24:04SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 24:05some might take it seriously in part because some of the
- 24:08examples that get raised
- 24:09SPEAKER_01: from time to time might feel just as ludicrous as,
- 24:12SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 24:12SPEAKER_01: a politician criticizing or really disliked in a particular place.
- 24:26SPEAKER_01: And the government,
- 24:28SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 24:29SPEAKER_01: woke up way,
- 24:30SPEAKER_01: way too late,
- 24:31SPEAKER_01: just with months left before Trudeau resigned and saying,
- 24:34SPEAKER_01: okay,
- 24:34SPEAKER_01: you know what,
- 24:35SPEAKER_01: fine,
- 24:35SPEAKER_01: we'll split the bill and we'll focus firstly on the responsibility piece,
- 24:40SPEAKER_01: and later we can deal with some of these other issues.
- 24:42SPEAKER_01: But by then it was far too late.
- 24:43SPEAKER_01: And so the bill just died.
- 24:45And now we find ourselves back having a discussion yet again on
- 24:50there are real harms.
- 24:51SPEAKER_01: We're seeing it crop up in a number of ways, and these are real harms.
- 24:55SPEAKER_01: And the question is, well, what are we prepared to do about them?
- 24:59SPEAKER_03: So is there a possibility that the Online Harms Act,
- 25:01SPEAKER_03: as it was envisioned under Trudeau,
- 25:03is going to get put back on the table here or are they going to
- 25:06get a little bit
- 25:07SPEAKER_03: smarter and start piecing some of these bits of legislation out?
- 25:11SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 25:11SPEAKER_01: Well, so I'm tempted to, well, I would say this.
- 25:17I think that they are likely to not repeat the mistake that
- 25:22they made with the last
- 25:23SPEAKER_01: online harms.
- 25:24And so it would surprise me if they brought back the criminal
- 25:26code and the Human
- 25:28SPEAKER_01: Rights Act pieces in that legislation.
- 25:31But that doesn't mean they aren't going to seek to expand what
- 25:34they did or plan to
- 25:36SPEAKER_01: do within the context of online harms.
- 25:39SPEAKER_01: So they may take some away, but they may add at the same time.
- 25:43SPEAKER_01: And part of that and part of where we see that playing out,
- 25:47SPEAKER_01: at least over the last little bit,
- 25:48has been in the aftermath of the Tumblr Ridge tragedy and talk
- 25:53about using online
- 25:55SPEAKER_01: harms legislation to deal with AI chatbots.
- 25:59SPEAKER_01: So you could see that possibility of saying,
- 26:01SPEAKER_01: okay,
- 26:01SPEAKER_01: on the one hand,
- 26:02SPEAKER_01: we'll slim it down in terms of dealing with responsibility,
- 26:04SPEAKER_01: but the other hand,
- 26:05perhaps try to expand what we're doing in terms of who gets
- 26:09covered by this and
- 26:10SPEAKER_01: some of the kinds of things that we're trying to do here.
- 26:12SPEAKER_03: And let's go into that a little bit more here.
- 26:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 26:18This is probably worth pointing out here is that in the wake of
- 26:22the Tumbler Ridge
- 26:23SPEAKER_03: shooting,
- 26:24it was discovered not only that the RCMP had returned guns to
- 26:29the presumed
- 26:31SPEAKER_03: perpetrator,
- 26:32SPEAKER_03: Jesse Van Rutzler.
- 26:34But also that it had been discovered that some very alarming
- 26:38content had showed up
- 26:39SPEAKER_03: in the perpetrator's chat.
- 26:42SPEAKER_03: I believe chat GPT content.
- 26:45SPEAKER_03: This content was so alarming that it was flagged for human oversight.
- 26:50SPEAKER_03: Humans within the parent company then looked at this stuff,
- 26:53SPEAKER_03: said,
- 26:53SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 26:54SPEAKER_03: that's a little messed up,
- 26:55SPEAKER_03: but didn't choose to report that to the RCMP at the time.
- 27:00SPEAKER_03: This is a really,
- 27:01really interesting use case here because it's hard to assess
- 27:05whether or not the
- 27:08SPEAKER_03: parent company of ChatGPT.
- 27:09SPEAKER_03: Is it just Chat?
- 27:10SPEAKER_03: What is that?
- 27:10SPEAKER_03: OpenAI.
- 27:11SPEAKER_03: OpenAI.
- 27:12SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 27:13It's hard to determine whether or not OpenAI acted responsibly
- 27:17without knowing the
- 27:18SPEAKER_03: actual specific content that was put into the chatbot.
- 27:23SPEAKER_03: So was a human judgment call here appropriate or not appropriate?
- 27:27SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 27:29SPEAKER_03: But we do know in the wake of this news coming out,
- 27:32SPEAKER_03: and I believe it was a Washington,
- 27:34SPEAKER_03: no,
- 27:34SPEAKER_03: Wall Street Journal.
- 27:35SPEAKER_01: Wall Street Journal.
- 27:36SPEAKER_03: It was a Wall Street Journal scoop that got this.
- 27:39It started to raise real concerns about whether or not there
- 27:41needs to be some
- 27:42regulatory process for when alarming content is flagged for
- 27:47government review.
- 27:50SPEAKER_03: Michael,
- 27:50this raises all kinds of concerning flags for me as someone who
- 27:54uses ChatGPT as her
- 27:56SPEAKER_03: personal therapist and actually finds it very useful in this regard.
- 28:00SPEAKER_03: No.
- 28:01SPEAKER_03: Firstly,
- 28:02can the government get into my ChatGPT and figure out what is
- 28:07rooting through my
- 28:07SPEAKER_03: noggin right now?
- 28:09What are the existing rules and what concerns do we have about
- 28:13a more regulatory approach here?
- 28:15SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 28:16SPEAKER_01: Well...
- 28:17SPEAKER_01: Okay,
- 28:18SPEAKER_01: to the first question,
- 28:19there's no clear-cut rule that regulates AI chatbots any more
- 28:23than there is one
- 28:24that regulates what you put into a search bar and ask Google
- 28:29some of the same kinds
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: of questions or,
- 28:31SPEAKER_01: frankly,
- 28:32jot some of the same kinds of content down in a text message or
- 28:35email or even in a
- 28:36SPEAKER_01: document and upload it to Google.
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: cloud provider or another intermediary.
- 28:41SPEAKER_01: The reality is that almost everything we write nowadays is digital.
- 28:45SPEAKER_01: It is stored in the cloud or at least traverses
- 28:49through cloud infrastructure and lands in the hands at
- 28:52different moments of
- 28:55SPEAKER_01: different large intermediaries.
- 28:56The issue as to whether or not those intermediaries should
- 28:59actively be monitoring
- 29:01SPEAKER_01: all of this content and looking for flags,
- 29:04my own view is that's both incredibly scary if we were to move
- 29:08in that direction.
- 29:10That's a level of surveillance that I don't think many would be
- 29:12comfortable with.
- 29:13And I have to say that it's not entirely clear to me what the
- 29:16difference is between
- 29:18putting something into a Google search bar and putting
- 29:21something into a AI chat bot
- 29:24SPEAKER_01: and engaging in some of the discussion.
- 29:26SPEAKER_01: In fact,
- 29:27SPEAKER_01: now,
- 29:27SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 29:27SPEAKER_01: with Google,
- 29:29oftentimes you are engaging with a chat bot because Gemini
- 29:31often gives you some of
- 29:32SPEAKER_01: the initial results as well.
- 29:35SPEAKER_01: So I have some concerns about just generally this notion of,
- 29:38SPEAKER_01: well,
- 29:39SPEAKER_01: we need to regulate this kind of sort of surveillance and reporting,
- 29:44SPEAKER_01: but it seems to me,
- 29:45SPEAKER_01: it's not clear to me why it would just stop at an AI chatbot.
- 29:48SPEAKER_01: You asked, though, does the government have the ability to gain access?
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 29:52government or law enforcement has the ability to gain access
- 29:55the way they could in
- 29:56SPEAKER_01: any other circumstance.
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: they can get a potential court order saying,
- 30:00SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 30:01SPEAKER_01: we want access to this information.
- 30:04SPEAKER_01: It could be that in some circumstances,
- 30:06SPEAKER_01: the intermediary,
- 30:08SPEAKER_01: in this case,
- 30:09SPEAKER_01: OpenAI,
- 30:09SPEAKER_01: but it could be others,
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: may have policies in place that they,
- 30:13SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 30:14SPEAKER_01: they make it clear to their users that in certain circumstances,
- 30:17SPEAKER_01: they may report some of that behavior.
- 30:21SPEAKER_01: One of the issues that has come up in the aftermath of this is,
- 30:24SPEAKER_01: well,
- 30:25SPEAKER_01: as you mentioned,
- 30:25SPEAKER_01: well,
- 30:26SPEAKER_01: what's the appropriate moment to report?
- 30:30SPEAKER_01: What are the standards that you use?
- 30:33SPEAKER_01: And I think,
- 30:33SPEAKER_01: frankly,
- 30:34SPEAKER_01: you can go a long way in saying,
- 30:36SPEAKER_01: well,
- 30:36SPEAKER_01: this ought to be way more transparent.
- 30:38SPEAKER_01: There should be answers to these questions,
- 30:39SPEAKER_01: and we should be able to know what those answers are.
- 30:42SPEAKER_01: That,
- 30:42SPEAKER_01: though,
- 30:42is not quite the same as what we've started to see come out of
- 30:45the government,
- 30:46SPEAKER_01: which is to really increase the rhetoric around saying,
- 30:50SPEAKER_01: well,
- 30:51SPEAKER_01: no,
- 30:51SPEAKER_01: we want a whole lot more disclosures.
- 30:53SPEAKER_01: And that to me is pretty troubling.
- 30:56SPEAKER_01: I have to say that you're right.
- 30:57SPEAKER_01: We don't know what they knew.
- 31:00But it feels like from a process perspective,
- 31:02their process was,
- 31:04I must say,
- 31:04pretty okay.
- 31:06The standard that you would have for kicking someone off your
- 31:09platform is not the
- 31:10same as the standard that you would have for reporting them to
- 31:12the police.
- 31:14SPEAKER_03: And that's appropriate.
- 31:15SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 31:16SPEAKER_03: Yes, that's correct.
- 31:16SPEAKER_01: Of course.
- 31:17SPEAKER_01: So people may violate...
- 31:19SPEAKER_01: the community terms or guidelines that you've established and you say,
- 31:22SPEAKER_01: listen,
- 31:23SPEAKER_01: we're going to kick you out if you do that.
- 31:25That doesn't mean you report them to law enforcement,
- 31:28it just means you kick them out.
- 31:29SPEAKER_01: And so in this case,
- 31:29a person appears to have violated at minimum some of their
- 31:34standards or their
- 31:35SPEAKER_01: terms,
- 31:35SPEAKER_01: and so they did kick the person off the platform.
- 31:40That is still not,
- 31:42doesn't get us to,
- 31:43well,
- 31:43you should have reported it to the police as well.
- 31:45SPEAKER_01: And, you know, they had a process at the time.
- 31:48SPEAKER_01: They felt that it was not appropriate to report.
- 31:51SPEAKER_01: It's hard to know if that was right or wrong.
- 31:53SPEAKER_01: You know,
- 31:54SPEAKER_01: at the moment,
- 31:54SPEAKER_01: in hindsight,
- 31:55SPEAKER_01: of course,
- 31:55SPEAKER_01: we wish perhaps if it had made a difference,
- 31:57SPEAKER_01: it would have been good to have reported.
- 31:59SPEAKER_01: But they followed a process that,
- 32:01SPEAKER_01: I must say,
- 32:02seems generally pretty reasonable other than the fact that it's
- 32:06hard to know what
- 32:07SPEAKER_01: exactly happened.
- 32:08the standards are and the process is because there's just not
- 32:10enough transparency here.
- 32:12SPEAKER_03: How much transparency is there about the warrant process at this point?
- 32:16SPEAKER_03: Like if national security,
- 32:20national police force decides these 20 people are interesting
- 32:26to us for any kind of
- 32:28SPEAKER_03: reason,
- 32:29whether or not we think they're criminal or we think that
- 32:30they're engaged in
- 32:31SPEAKER_03: national security risk or whatever,
- 32:33they apply for a warrant to keep an eye on what they're saying
- 32:36to AI or they apply
- 32:37SPEAKER_03: for a warrant on what they're sending out digitally.
- 32:41How much transparency is there over that process to make sure
- 32:45that privacy is being
- 32:46SPEAKER_03: maintained and respected?
- 32:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's a really good question.
- 32:51SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 32:51SPEAKER_01: it's a process that in some circumstances is going to be by design pretty
- 32:56SPEAKER_01: secretive,
- 32:56SPEAKER_01: right?
- 32:57SPEAKER_01: So in some instances, there are investigations.
- 32:59There may be prohibitions on disclosing the investigation as
- 33:03part of the order that's obtained.
- 33:05SPEAKER_01: It might involve national security.
- 33:06And so it's pretty clear you're not going to be disclosing
- 33:08anything associated with that at all.
- 33:11SPEAKER_01: Some people know about some of what takes place,
- 33:14but oftentimes there isn't a whole lot of transparency
- 33:17associated with it.
- 33:19SPEAKER_01: That said,
- 33:20SPEAKER_01: some of the larger platforms do have annual transparency reports where,
- 33:24SPEAKER_01: at least in aggregate terms,
- 33:26SPEAKER_01: they will disclose the number of requests they've received.
- 33:29SPEAKER_01: They may break it down based on kind of subject matter and the like.
- 33:33SPEAKER_01: They may talk about compliance.
- 33:35SPEAKER_01: How many times did they disclose?
- 33:37SPEAKER_01: How many court orders did they receive?
- 33:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 33:40SPEAKER_01: We do get some amount of information associated with this.
- 33:45SPEAKER_01: It may not be an issue that we have time to talk about today,
- 33:47but the government's lawful access rules would be another
- 33:50digital issue that will,
- 33:52SPEAKER_01: at some point in time,
- 33:52SPEAKER_01: come back.
- 33:53SPEAKER_01: It was included,
- 33:55SPEAKER_01: or I guess technically still is included,
- 33:57SPEAKER_01: in Bill C-2,
- 33:58SPEAKER_01: which is not going forward.
- 33:59SPEAKER_01: They moved the border issues into a different bill, Bill C-12.
- 34:03SPEAKER_01: But,
- 34:04SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 34:04one of the real concerns there was that the government was
- 34:07expanding this vision of
- 34:09law enforcement being able to demand this kind of access to
- 34:13well beyond just
- 34:15communications players and other intermediaries to anyone who
- 34:17provides a service.
- 34:19And one of the things that I pointed out as part of that was
- 34:21that one of the
- 34:23effects would be that you would lose the effectiveness of the
- 34:27transparency
- 34:27SPEAKER_01: reporting that we do have.
- 34:30As long as these requests are going to wireless providers like
- 34:35Bell and Teleson
- 34:36SPEAKER_01: Rogers or going to Google or Meta,
- 34:39SPEAKER_01: then you're going to get some kind of transparency reports,
- 34:41SPEAKER_01: at least in aggregate.
- 34:43But if now we're starting to cover hotels or car rental
- 34:46companies or whomever,
- 34:49they're not going to put out transparency reports and suddenly
- 34:51many of the requests
- 34:52SPEAKER_01: are going to be lost altogether.
- 34:54SPEAKER_03: That's interesting.
- 34:55SPEAKER_03: Okay.
- 34:55SPEAKER_03: So how concerned do I have to be about this?
- 35:00SPEAKER_03: just as a journalist, normal person?
- 35:03SPEAKER_03: How much concern do I have to have about my privacy online as a Canadian?
- 35:09SPEAKER_01: Well, I think we have a lot of
- 35:12SPEAKER_01: things that we need to be concerned with when it comes to privacy,
- 35:15SPEAKER_01: both the inadequacy of some of our privacy rules,
- 35:18SPEAKER_01: as well as some of the proposals the government has put forward,
- 35:21SPEAKER_01: at least with respect to privacy and political parties.
- 35:24SPEAKER_03: We're going to get into that in just a minute.
- 35:27SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that would be good.
- 35:28We can get into that too,
- 35:29because it's another one that's been under the radar a little
- 35:30bit.
- 35:32SPEAKER_01: On this issue,
- 35:33I think there is reason for concern generally in terms of where
- 35:37does the government
- 35:38SPEAKER_01: land sort of the AI regulation plane,
- 35:42SPEAKER_01: which has become a bigger and bigger vehicle,
- 35:45SPEAKER_01: so to speak,
- 35:46SPEAKER_01: as it sort of now incorporates online harms,
- 35:49SPEAKER_01: as we've just been talking about,
- 35:50and incorporates a lot of economic policy in terms of an
- 35:53innovation policy from an
- 35:54SPEAKER_01: AI perspective.
- 35:56SPEAKER_01: It certainly includes data governance and privacy there as well.
- 35:59SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 36:00SPEAKER_01: It's not clear how we're going to sort through all of these issues,
- 36:03SPEAKER_01: but,
- 36:04SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:05tragedies like Tumblr Ridge can have the effect of driving
- 36:09politicians to move in a
- 36:11SPEAKER_01: particular direction for people to say,
- 36:13SPEAKER_01: this is horrible,
- 36:13SPEAKER_01: so we need to do something.
- 36:15SPEAKER_01: And sometimes that can lead to some pretty bad policy.
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: And I do have some concerns that what we've seen so far...
- 36:23Some of it feels just a bit performative in terms of
- 36:26politicians demanding that
- 36:28they meet with the executives and talking about the demands
- 36:31that they'll make of
- 36:31SPEAKER_01: those executives.
- 36:33SPEAKER_01: And so that sort of stuff just feels like performance.
- 36:35But at the end of the day,
- 36:36and I wrote this in a piece that I did on all of this,
- 36:39The minister responsible for AI shouldn't need a meeting with
- 36:42corporate executives
- 36:43to understand what their standards are when it comes to these
- 36:46kinds of issues.
- 36:48SPEAKER_01: So there is a real problem here.
- 36:50SPEAKER_01: My concern is the government is going to focus not on fixes,
- 36:54SPEAKER_01: though,
- 36:55at least with those problems and turn their attention to other
- 36:58kinds of issues that
- 36:59SPEAKER_01: will themselves raise some real issues and concerns.
- 37:01You're saying that the government might focus more on optics
- 37:04than on effective
- 37:05SPEAKER_03: policy and governance,
- 37:06perhaps in line with their respective stakeholders' desires and
- 37:09interests?
- 37:10SPEAKER_01: They just might.
- 37:12SPEAKER_01: They just might.
- 37:13SPEAKER_03: Great.
- 37:15SPEAKER_03: Michael, I want to talk a little bit about Bill C-4.
- 37:19SPEAKER_03: This one is also very much under the radar, but is interesting.
- 37:23SPEAKER_03: Can you explain it for us?
- 37:25SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 37:25So Bill C-4 is ostensibly just a bill that deals with some
- 37:31taxation policy.
- 37:33SPEAKER_01: The title the government used for it,
- 37:35SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 37:35SPEAKER_01: is sort of Affordability Measures Act or something like that.
- 37:38SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
- 37:39SPEAKER_01: So there's a whole series of tax-related issues in there.
- 37:42SPEAKER_01: And then buried at the very end of the bill,
- 37:45SPEAKER_01: this is a bill in four parts,
- 37:47SPEAKER_01: and the very last part,
- 37:48SPEAKER_01: part four,
- 37:49SPEAKER_01: involves political party privacy.
- 37:54SPEAKER_03: I mean, that makes perfect sense to me.
- 37:55Let's absolutely put some provisions about political party
- 37:58privacy in a taxation bill.
- 38:00SPEAKER_03: Nothing about that is a suspect at all.
- 38:03SPEAKER_01: Yeah, not at all.
- 38:04SPEAKER_01: And you might want to know that as they were putting this out,
- 38:08SPEAKER_01: and you'll recall this legislation,
- 38:10SPEAKER_01: along with some of that early legislation,
- 38:12SPEAKER_01: came right after Carney was elected last June.
- 38:16SPEAKER_01: So there was this sense that the government said,
- 38:18SPEAKER_01: well,
- 38:18SPEAKER_01: we've got to expedite a whole series of bills because the U.S.
- 38:21SPEAKER_01: threat requires us to pass a whole bunch of stuff.
- 38:24And so this was one of those bills and said,
- 38:26hey,
- 38:26we need to do these affordability measures.
- 38:28SPEAKER_01: We're going to rush through this legislation.
- 38:31SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 38:31SPEAKER_01: as it happens,
- 38:32there is a case right now in British Columbia that involves
- 38:35political party
- 38:36SPEAKER_01: privacy.
- 38:37SPEAKER_01: And wouldn't you know,
- 38:38SPEAKER_01: part four would have the effect,
- 38:40SPEAKER_01: at least in the government's view,
- 38:42SPEAKER_01: of voiding that case.
- 38:44SPEAKER_01: Government lost the case at the trial level.
- 38:47SPEAKER_01: It's now before the BC Court of Appeal.
- 38:49SPEAKER_01: And so the goal of this legislation,
- 38:51SPEAKER_01: at least in part,
- 38:53SPEAKER_01: is to try to short circuit that case altogether.
- 38:56SPEAKER_01: And one of the reasons that we know that,
- 38:59SPEAKER_01: and this,
- 38:59SPEAKER_01: I must admit,
- 39:00SPEAKER_01: every time I mention it,
- 39:00SPEAKER_01: I still can't really believe it,
- 39:02SPEAKER_01: is that not only have they,
- 39:04SPEAKER_01: in part four,
- 39:05given pretty close to carte blanche to political parties in
- 39:08terms of what they do
- 39:09SPEAKER_01: with their personal information.
- 39:10So the standards that they would set for any private sector
- 39:15organization in Canada
- 39:16SPEAKER_01: are nowhere near what they are setting for political parties.
- 39:19But they,
- 39:19in the legislation,
- 39:20say that this is retroactive to the year 2000s.
- 39:24SPEAKER_03: Oh, no problem at all.
- 39:27SPEAKER_03: Great.
- 39:27SPEAKER_01: 26 years of retroactivity.
- 39:30So any privacy violation that may have taken place over the
- 39:33last two and a half
- 39:34SPEAKER_01: decades no longer is applicable because of this legislation.
- 39:39SPEAKER_03: Is that kind of just an admission of guilt right there?
- 39:42SPEAKER_03: Like, oh, shoot, we've maybe been forking it for 25 years.
- 39:47SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 39:48SPEAKER_01: Well, they know they're in trouble in the BC case.
- 39:51The BC case basically says that BC privacy law can apply to
- 39:56federal political parties.
- 39:58And political parties have been quite happy with a system
- 40:01whereby no privacy law
- 40:02SPEAKER_01: applies to them because the two main federal privacy laws that we have,
- 40:06SPEAKER_01: one is the Privacy Act,
- 40:07SPEAKER_01: which applies to the federal government.
- 40:09SPEAKER_01: Political parties are separate from the government.
- 40:12SPEAKER_01: That's not the government.
- 40:12SPEAKER_01: So the Privacy Act doesn't apply there.
- 40:15SPEAKER_01: The other is PEPIDA, the private sector privacy law.
- 40:18which applies to commercial organizations and the political
- 40:22parties fall through
- 40:23the cracks there as well because they are not technically a
- 40:25commercial organization
- 40:26SPEAKER_01: in the same way,
- 40:27although they certainly have some indicia that one might say
- 40:30they may function that
- 40:31SPEAKER_01: way in some respects.
- 40:32SPEAKER_01: But Privacy Commissioner said, no, that doesn't apply either.
- 40:36SPEAKER_01: And so the parties have been very happy with a system whereby...
- 40:40SPEAKER_01: No real laws apply other than the Elections Act,
- 40:42which includes a few provisions that talk about some amount of
- 40:47transparency with
- 40:47SPEAKER_01: respect to people's privacy,
- 40:49but don't establish the same kinds of standards that you would
- 40:52typically see
- 40:53SPEAKER_01: elsewhere.
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: And so the government sticks this into C4 at the very end.
- 41:00SPEAKER_01: They don't even mention it when they put forward the bill.
- 41:03They they proceed to to try to put this through in the House of
- 41:08Commons at the
- 41:10committee level where they spent a total of 30 seconds
- 41:13discussing the privacy
- 41:14SPEAKER_01: elements at committee on this bill.
- 41:17SPEAKER_01: They refuse every request.
- 41:18And there were multiple requests to appear before the committee
- 41:22to talk about the
- 41:23SPEAKER_01: privacy elements to say,
- 41:24SPEAKER_01: no,
- 41:24SPEAKER_01: we are not interested in any of that.
- 41:26SPEAKER_01: Literally just 30 seconds to say that this is in the bill.
- 41:30SPEAKER_01: And now it's, as we could talk about, has gone to the Senate.
- 41:33And the question is whether or not the government is just going
- 41:35to push this
- 41:36SPEAKER_01: through now over some objections of the Senate itself,
- 41:39which actually did take the time to take a closer look at what
- 41:42all of this might
- 41:42SPEAKER_01: mean.
- 41:44SPEAKER_03: So the Senate is doing its job.
- 41:46SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
- 41:46SPEAKER_03: Thank you, the Senate of Canada.
- 41:48SPEAKER_03: Look, here's a question.
- 41:50SPEAKER_03: I just want to ground this, what this actually means.
- 41:52So would the types of things that they would be getting away
- 41:55with that they
- 41:56SPEAKER_03: wouldn't get away with under other types of legislation,
- 41:59SPEAKER_03: the example,
- 42:00SPEAKER_03: list sharing,
- 42:01SPEAKER_03: for example,
- 42:01SPEAKER_03: we know that list sharing in political domains is absolutely rampant,
- 42:07SPEAKER_03: even though it's technically not allowed.
- 42:10Let me tell you that I could make some very inappropriate
- 42:13metaphors about how
- 42:14SPEAKER_03: widely political lists are shared.
- 42:18SPEAKER_03: So would that be an example?
- 42:19Would there be other examples about privacy norms that have
- 42:23become established in
- 42:24political circles that would not be considered acceptable in
- 42:28either commercial or
- 42:29SPEAKER_03: government contexts?
- 42:30SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 42:30SPEAKER_01: So I'll try to answer this in a couple of ways.
- 42:33SPEAKER_01: First,
- 42:33I'll say that essentially what the legislation does do is say
- 42:38you've got to have a
- 42:39SPEAKER_01: privacy policy.
- 42:40It doesn't say what you have to do for the most part in that
- 42:43privacy policy,
- 42:44SPEAKER_01: but you've got to have one.
- 42:45SPEAKER_01: So,
- 42:45SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 42:46the short answer to your question is if the privacy policy says
- 42:49that you can do it,
- 42:50SPEAKER_01: then you can do it.
- 42:51SPEAKER_01: And,
- 42:52SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 42:53SPEAKER_01: the government has said,
- 42:53SPEAKER_01: well,
- 42:54SPEAKER_01: we need some common standards,
- 42:56but effectively they're not creating common standard at all
- 42:58because they're
- 42:59basically leaving to each party to establish whatever they want
- 43:01in their privacy
- 43:02SPEAKER_01: policy.
- 43:03SPEAKER_01: by and large.
- 43:04SPEAKER_01: And so you end up with the parties deciding for themselves what they are
- 43:09comfortable with in terms of collection use and potential
- 43:13disclosure of personal
- 43:15SPEAKER_01: information.
- 43:16Now,
- 43:16I should note that there was,
- 43:17this is really at least the second attempt to deal with this.
- 43:20There was another bill,
- 43:22Bill C-65,
- 43:26back in the last parliament,
- 43:28that sought to deal with this.
- 43:30SPEAKER_01: And it didn't pass.
- 43:32SPEAKER_01: But it actually did have some stronger provisions in there.
- 43:35SPEAKER_01: It wasn't good, but it was less bad than this one.
- 43:40So,
- 43:40for example,
- 43:41so you ask,
- 43:41what are some of the kinds of things you can envision?
- 43:44The other one involved things like security breach disclosure
- 43:46requirements.
- 43:47So what happens if you have people's information and you're
- 43:50subject to a breach?
- 43:51SPEAKER_01: The other legislation talked about
- 43:54SPEAKER_01: having to disclose that so that people are aware of it.
- 43:56SPEAKER_01: This legislation doesn't make that a requirement.
- 43:59SPEAKER_01: The other legislation created prohibitions on selling your data,
- 44:04on the prospect that you could take those lists and potentially
- 44:06sell them to
- 44:08SPEAKER_01: others.
- 44:08SPEAKER_01: That prohibition is now out in C4.
- 44:12SPEAKER_01: So they've gone from putting it in a bill about the Elections Act,
- 44:17SPEAKER_01: which is nominally the right place to put it,
- 44:20SPEAKER_01: to now putting it in a bill about tax policy,
- 44:24SPEAKER_01: not wanting to discuss it,
- 44:25SPEAKER_01: making it retroactive,
- 44:27SPEAKER_01: and weakening the already weak provisions that were there.
- 44:30SPEAKER_03: Well, you know, Michael, just remember, rules are only for bad people.
- 44:33Well,
- 44:35they're certainly not for political parties,
- 44:37I'll tell you that much.
- 44:38SPEAKER_01: Believe it to decide whether or not they're bad people or not.
- 44:41They're on the side of the angels,
- 44:42so don't worry,
- 44:43we can definitely trust them.
- 44:45SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 44:46SPEAKER_01: you should know,
- 44:46SPEAKER_01: Jedza,
- 44:47that the sort of part of the debate by senators that sought to
- 44:50defend this was to
- 44:52SPEAKER_01: argue that,
- 44:52SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 44:53SPEAKER_01: our democracy is at stake,
- 44:54SPEAKER_01: that political parties are essential to democracy.
- 44:56SPEAKER_01: And so they need this kind of information to be able to function.
- 45:00SPEAKER_01: So we ought not to be using these rules to constrain what they're doing.
- 45:04SPEAKER_02: Rules are for thee, not for me, sir.
- 45:07SPEAKER_02: Absolutely.
- 45:07SPEAKER_02: For thee and not for me.
- 45:09SPEAKER_02: Yes.
- 45:09SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 45:10Well,
- 45:10Michael,
- 45:10thank you so much for coming on and chatting with us on On The
- 45:12Line.
- 45:13SPEAKER_03: I really do hope to have you again soon.
- 45:15And we shall stay in touch and stay with our eyes to the prize
- 45:22on Canada's digital policy.
- 45:24SPEAKER_03: Do check us out www.readtheline.ca.
- 45:28SPEAKER_03: And if you have not already, please do like and subscribe.
- 45:30SPEAKER_03: It helps the channel so much.
- 45:32SPEAKER_03: Thanks again.
- 45:33SPEAKER_03: And I'm Jen Gerson.
- 45:33SPEAKER_03: And this was Michael Geist on On The Line.