Latest / OICs Wide World of Options / Wide World of Options: Volatility Products: What Are They and What Might They Mean to Investors?
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Options Insider Radio Network, the home of the Options Podcast.
- 0:06For more quality options programs, visit theoptionsinsider.com or search for Options Insider Radio Network
- 0:14in your podcast provider of choice.
- 0:17Listeners can also access all of our programming through our mobile app available on the iTunes
- 0:22and Google Play stores.
- 0:23Select programs are also available via livestream at mixler.com/options-insider.
- 0:31That's mixlr.com/options-insider.
- 0:36Don't forget to follow along with your favorite programs and submit your own questions for
- 0:40the hosts at twitter.com/options, stocktwits.com/options, facebook.com/theoptionsinsider, or via questions
- 0:52at theoptionsinsider.com.
- 1:04This is the Options Industry Council's Wide World of Options.
- 1:08Before we start today's show, listeners should know that options involve risk and are not
- 1:12suitable for all investors.
- 1:14Individuals should not enter into an options transaction until they have read and understood
- 1:18the disclosure document, characteristics and risks of standardized options, available by
- 1:22visiting theocc.com or by contacting your broker, any exchange on which options are traded,
- 1:29or the Options Clearing Corporation at 125 South Franklin Street, No. 1200, Chicago,
- 1:34Illinois 60606.
- 1:37The Options Industry Council is an industry resource provided by the Options Clearing
- 1:41Corporation, collectively OCC.
- 1:43These strategies discussed are strictly for illustrative and educational purposes only,
- 1:48and are not to be construed as an endorsement or solicitation to buy or sell securities.
- 1:52Commissions, fees, margins, interest and taxes have not been included in any of the examples
- 1:58used in this show.
- 1:59These costs impact the outcome of all stock and options transactions.
- 2:03Consult your tax advisor about any potential consequences.
- 2:07OIC was created in 1992 to educate investors and their financial advisors about the benefits
- 2:13and risks of exchange traded equity options, and the Wide World of Options radio show is
- 2:18one of several resources investors can utilize to learn more about options.
- 2:23Other resources OIC offers include webinars, articles and self-guided options related coursework.
- 2:29For more information, check out www.optionseducation.org.
- 2:35Now here's your host, Mark Benzoquin.
- 2:37Hello everyone and welcome to OIC's Wide World of Options.
- 2:47I'm your host, Mark Benzoquin.
- 2:49For November, OIC has a pair of webinars lined up discussing volatility products, namely
- 2:55volatility indices, futures and ETFs.
- 2:59And to help highlight our upcoming presentations, I'm happy to welcome Ed Tom of CBOE's Market
- 3:05Intelligence team.
- 3:06Ed, welcome and thanks for joining us today.
- 3:09Thanks Mark.
- 3:10Ed, to be fair, before we get started, why don't you take a minute, tell us a little
- 3:14bit about yourself and your involvement or your experience in the world of options.
- 3:19Sure.
- 3:21So this is my 35th year in Wall Street.
- 3:24I basically spent my entire career working with equity derivatives and quantitative strategies.
- 3:31I started off at JP Morgan and then moved on to Salomon Brothers.
- 3:37I spent 20 years at Credit Suisse where I was the global head of equity derivatives
- 3:43and quantitative trading strategies.
- 3:47And the last eight years I spent at different hedge funds and most recently at Ellington
- 3:54where I was there for three years working on the downside equity convexity strategy.
- 4:03Okay.
- 4:04And now you're with CBOE, Market Intelligence.
- 4:07Tell me a little bit about that, please.
- 4:09So basically that's the derivatives research arm of CBOE where we basically provide market
- 4:17commentaries on volatility moves and different volatility strategies and products.
- 4:23Okay, excellent.
- 4:24Thanks.
- 4:25I appreciate the background information.
- 4:28Speaking of CBOE or CBOE as they're now known, as a representative from one of the exchanges
- 4:33that offer various volatility products and seeing as how we're going to be talking about
- 4:39volatility products in our November webinars, I was hoping that you could walk me and our
- 4:45audience around some of the concepts surrounding volatility products.
- 4:49So let's go ahead and start at the beginning and let's assume that we're talking to an
- 4:57investor that really has no idea about volatility products, what they are and how they work.
- 5:01But they do know about options.
- 5:03So when it comes to volatility products, it's a little bit different, right?
- 5:08There is no stock that we're looking at.
- 5:12How do volatility products work in that sense?
- 5:15Can you be bullish or bearish on volatility?
- 5:18Yeah, you can.
- 5:20So basically like taking a step back, volatility is essentially a measure of the stability
- 5:26of the markets.
- 5:28And in general, there's an inverse relationship between the performance of the markets and
- 5:35volatility.
- 5:36So if, let's say, the markets rise, generally, volatility falls.
- 5:42And if the markets start crashing, then volatility rises exponentially.
- 5:50So basically, that's a general relationship.
- 5:55And that remains intact, I would say, about 85% of the time.
- 6:00And there are products to basically take expressive views on volatility.
- 6:04Yeah, there's a saying that one of my colleagues likes to use that the market goes up on a
- 6:08staircase and down in an elevator.
- 6:12Things crash.
- 6:13The market goes down much quicker than it goes up.
- 6:16So I understand that inverse relationship between volatility.
- 6:21So with that in mind, what are volatility products?
- 6:25Again, there isn't a stock.
- 6:27There is no XYZ volatility company out there.
- 6:30So what are volatility products?
- 6:33How do they measure?
- 6:34How do they work?
- 6:37Can you shed a little light on that?
- 6:39Yeah.
- 6:40So basically, I think to start off with, we need to first discuss the industry benchmark
- 6:49for volatility, which is the VIX.
- 6:52So what the VIX is is basically a measure of three things.
- 6:56It basically measures the volatility of the markets due to economic fundamentals.
- 7:02It also layers on top of that the relative demand for puts versus calls on behalf of
- 7:10portfolio managers.
- 7:12And finally, the third component is the additional premium that traders accord to a potential
- 7:18tail risk, a tail shock.
- 7:21So in combination, that's essentially what the VIX is.
- 7:25All right.
- 7:26And the VIX, while it isn't the only volatility game in town, so to speak, as you had mentioned,
- 7:33it is an industry standard.
- 7:36So talking about volatility without specifically talking about the VIX is kind of a hard thing
- 7:44to do.
- 7:45So what does the VIX measure?
- 7:49Or better yet, how does the VIX measure?
- 7:51So there's a value, right, that volatility index.
- 7:54There's a value each day.
- 7:56It's trading at X. How is that X, A, calculated, and B, what is it telling investors?
- 8:06So I think to understand the VIX, we first need to kind of like take a look at how options
- 8:12are priced.
- 8:13So options are priced using five parameters from the Black-Scholes model.
- 8:19And the one parameter that is not super transparent to most investors is volatility.
- 8:25Right, not observable.
- 8:27Everything else, stock price, strike price, interest rates, dividends, those are all observable,
- 8:32quantifiable, volatility, that's the guesswork.
- 8:36Exactly right.
- 8:38So basically, how volatility comes about is we observe the current price of a particular
- 8:48option.
- 8:49We plug in all the known parameters, including strike, tenure, et cetera, and then implied
- 8:57volatility is essentially the number that basically solves the Black-Scholes equation
- 9:04for that particular price.
- 9:07So basically, what the VIX is, is a weighted average of implied volatilities across the
- 9:13entire S&P strike chain.
- 9:16Okay, so it's the average price or it's the average volatility level across all 500 components
- 9:27of the S&P?
- 9:29Well, so we're looking at the S&P as a whole, and we're looking at all the listed strikes
- 9:39for any particular maturity.
- 9:42So the VIX will be very close to the average level of the implied volatility of the S&P
- 9:50for any particular expiry.
- 9:52Okay.
- 9:53Prior to the creation of the VIX and prior to the creation of other volatility products,
- 10:01how did traders gauge volatility?
- 10:06Meaning that now that we have the volatility indices, it fulfills a certain need in the
- 10:13market.
- 10:15What filled that need prior to the creation of these?
- 10:19Or better yet, what was that need that led to the creation of these volatility products?
- 10:24Yeah, so prior to the creation of VIX, traders used to refer to Realize Volatility, which
- 10:30is basically like the same calculation that one uses for calculating standard deviation.
- 10:38But the problem with Realize Volatility is that it's descriptive, meaning that it's backward
- 10:44looking.
- 10:47And there was a need for a measure that was a little bit more forward looking.
- 10:54So that's how the VIX came into being because implied volatility layers on some expectations
- 11:02or predictive components on top of Realize Volatility.
- 11:05Okay.
- 11:06All right.
- 11:07I understand that.
- 11:08Let me shift gears for a second.
- 11:12And let's look at some of the other indices, for example, the S&P.
- 11:16Again, a benchmark index that people use.
- 11:22There is no stock.
- 11:23There is no S&P 500 stock.
- 11:26How does, when it comes to a volatility index, how does that work?
- 11:30There's a futures contract as well, I assume.
- 11:34Not I assume.
- 11:35I know that there is a futures contract as well.
- 11:37What does that futures contract-- if I buy a futures contract in a commodity such as
- 11:45oil, I know that at the end of that term of the contract, I'm going to end up with, what,
- 11:505,000 barrels of oil in my backyard if I let that contract go through to expiration.
- 11:58What do volatility futures, what is the end game, or how do those work?
- 12:05So I'm glad you bring up oil futures because I think that's a very good analogy.
- 12:10So when we look at, let's say, S&P futures, that's a very simple type of future to understand
- 12:17because it's known as a cash and carry instrument, meaning that if you buy the spot and then
- 12:23you basically invest that money into-- sorry, you sell the S&P spot and then you invest
- 12:30that money into the bank, at some future point in time, you know exactly how much the value
- 12:37of that holding would be worth.
- 12:40And that will be basically the price of the S&P future.
- 12:45But with VIX futures, there are a couple of different other components that are added
- 12:50to the cost of the future based off the current price of VIX.
- 12:58And a good portion of the premium that is accorded to VIX futures is based off of the
- 13:07expectation of traders of what volatility will look like at some future point in time.
- 13:15And also the demand for volatility at that future point in time.
- 13:24So basically, there's a mathematical component and there's also a supply and demand component
- 13:33that is accorded to VIX futures.
- 13:35OK.
- 13:36And when it comes to VIX futures, they're a little bit different than a typical futures
- 13:42contract in the sense of back to S&P, for example, those are quarterly futures.
- 13:48I think they're listed in what, December, March, June, and September.
- 13:54Those are the four quarterly futures for the S&P.
- 13:57But with the VIX and other volatility products, I believe it's different.
- 14:02There's monthly contracts.
- 14:03So for example, what I find interesting is if you're trading a time spread, a calendar.
- 14:10If we had a March, April calendar or diagonal in a volatility product such as the VIX, we
- 14:20would have-- the March option would be tied to a March future and the April option would
- 14:28be tied to an April future.
- 14:30Do I understand that correctly?
- 14:33That's correct.
- 14:34That's right.
- 14:35Yeah.
- 14:36So how traders have been expressing, let's say, the upcoming presidential elections.
- 14:42They basically trade a calendar spread on either the October, November term structure
- 14:51or they trade the November, December calendar spread.
- 14:57OK.
- 14:58And that brings up a good point. For a investor interested in trading a volatility product,
- 15:08are they mostly looking to capture differences in volatility, changing volatility?
- 15:14Or might they just buy some calls on a volatility ETF or an index just as they would stock
- 15:23XYZ with the expectation that volatility is going to increase?
- 15:27So for that average investor, is that kind of a way that they might take advantage of
- 15:35volatility and trade the VIX or trade a different volatility product?
- 15:40Or are there maybe other reasons?
- 15:42Are there other things that they're hoping to accomplish?
- 15:44Yeah.
- 15:45So basically, I think that in general, your statement is correct.
- 15:52But the tricky thing about trading VIX futures is that the benchmark isn't the current level
- 16:01of VIX, but rather what traders have already priced into that future price of VIX.
- 16:08So for example, right now, the current level of spot VIX is 17.
- 16:15OK.
- 16:17So one might think, OK, well, you know what? I think that the November elections will cause
- 16:25an uptick in market volatility.
- 16:29So I'm thinking to buy November X-free VIX options.
- 16:38The problem is that at this point, volatility traders have already priced in an additional
- 16:44premium for November.
- 16:47So the November futures contracts might be higher than 17.
- 16:53So let's just say that it's 20.
- 16:55So in order for an investor to actually profit from a view on November VIX contracts, the
- 17:08VIX futures need to rise above 20.
- 17:11So basically, it needs to exceed the level that's already being priced into the markets.
- 17:17OK.
- 17:18OK.
- 17:19So are you saying that that's kind of like maybe even a break-even point, that it needs
- 17:24to be above or below that point in order for the trader to profit?
- 17:28Yeah.
- 17:29So basically, if you plan to unwind prior to X-free, that is true.
- 17:35Yes.
- 17:36OK.
- 17:37So if you hold to X-free, then the effect is a little different.
- 17:41Then the thought is that, OK, well, then the benchmark really is spot VIX.
- 17:48But for most investors, one tends to trade to basically monetize their gains pretty much
- 17:58immediately after the event.
- 18:01OK.
- 18:02Speaking of spot VIX, you had mentioned spot VIX.
- 18:07You had mentioned it's currently trading around 17 or so.
- 18:11Do I have-- well, let me ask you this.
- 18:14Typically when I think of implied volatility, right, not a volatility product, but the concept
- 18:19of implied volatility we talked about earlier, if implied volatility is 17%, it's telling
- 18:25us that according to how the market is pricing this particular option, they're expecting
- 18:32a 17% move up or down in that underlying over the next 12 months.
- 18:41That's kind of an idea of implied volatility.
- 18:44With the VIX trading 17, as you had mentioned, does that concept still kind of hold true?
- 18:51Is it saying that the market is expecting a 17% swing as evidenced by that VIX number,
- 19:00or is it telling us something completely different?
- 19:03Yeah, I think that that's close enough.
- 19:06But I think a better way for most investors to grasp the idea of a 17 VIX is basically
- 19:17to use something called the Rule of 16, which is basically a way to convert an annualized
- 19:23volatility number into a daily move.
- 19:27The square root of trading days in the year, typically 252, comes out to roughly 16, hence
- 19:33for our listeners that are wondering what we're talking about, hence the Rule of 16.
- 19:38Yeah, exactly right.
- 19:40So basically, the rule of thumb is that an annualized volatility level of 16 equates
- 19:46to about a 1% move per day.
- 19:51I think for most investors, that's an easier way to kind of translate the current level
- 19:57of VIX to a more understandable move.
- 20:02Okay, understood.
- 20:04Thank you.
- 20:05So volatility indices, volatility futures, we've got ETFs on volatility.
- 20:13These are all different products, but all really kind of try to accomplish the same
- 20:18thing, which is providing investors a vehicle in which to hopefully profit on whatever their
- 20:24forecast may be.
- 20:26And one of the interesting things, again, getting back to implied volatility is that
- 20:32because it's not quantifiable, it's not observable, as you had mentioned, that is a point of contention
- 20:39amongst investors.
- 20:40If you think volatility is 20%, and I think it's 25, we each have our different models,
- 20:46whether they're proprietary algorithms that we run or what have you, whatever our pricing
- 20:51models tell us, if you think it's 15, I think it's 20, or you think it's 20, I think it's
- 20:5625, the difference in volatility, the difference of our opinion is going to be reflected in
- 21:01what we think of the fair value of that option contract.
- 21:05Now the volatility products, again, back to the VIX, for example, does that work similar
- 21:11to where, well, the VIX is trading 17, I think it should be much higher, or I think it should
- 21:16be much lower.
- 21:18So because of that, it's going to affect my pricing models, and therefore it's going to
- 21:24maybe form a strategy, a trading strategy where I'm buying or selling.
- 21:31Are there those differences of opinions in the VIX as well, or vol futures, vol ETFs,
- 21:40does it kind of work that same way, where you think one thing, I think something else,
- 21:44and therefore we've got to trade, or am I completely off the mark on this?
- 21:50It totally does.
- 21:51So basically, I think that for most investors, it's easier to kind of express a view on where
- 22:03the S&P is going to be at some point in the future.
- 22:09And whatever that level is, there's a certain market for the probability that the S&P goes
- 22:19to that particular level.
- 22:21That level, basically the probability is impounded into the implied volatility with that particular
- 22:28strike.
- 22:30And if you were to basically visualize all those implied volities by strike, we would
- 22:41form what's called the S&P implied volatility skew.
- 22:46And all the differences in opinions basically changes the implied volatility skew, which
- 22:56again, taking a step back, is basically the differences of demand for different puts versus
- 23:07different calls along the S&P strike chain.
- 23:11So the skew can rise and fall depending upon traders' views of the likelihood of a downside
- 23:20shock or an upside rally in the S&P.
- 23:24And basically, the way that the skew kind of behaves will be an aggregation of all those
- 23:35different opinions amongst volatility traders.
- 23:38Excellent.
- 23:39Okay.
- 23:40Well, thank you.
- 23:41That makes sense.
- 23:42Ed, excellent information.
- 23:43I really appreciate it.
- 23:44Thank you for sharing that with us.
- 23:46And thanks for agreeing to guest on the show.
- 23:48Much appreciated your time.
- 23:50Thank you.
- 23:51Okay, great.
- 23:52Thanks, Mark.
- 23:53And folks, that's going to do it for today's episode of Wide World of Options.
- 23:57Special thanks to our guest, Ed Tom from CBOE, and taking the time to sit with us and talk
- 24:02options and for his insight into the world of various volatility products.
- 24:09Please join us next time when we're going to be back with a whole new show, featuring
- 24:13more industry names, market concepts, and of course, trusted options education.
- 24:19In the meantime, be sure to visit the events section of our optionseducation.org website
- 24:25to register for our upcoming webinar events and feel free to explore the rest of what
- 24:30OIC has to offer while you're there.
- 24:33Thanks again to all of our listeners and supporters.
- 24:35And as always, please feel free to send us your questions via email at options@theocc.com
- 24:42or you can live chat with us on our website.
- 24:45Take care, everyone, and we'll be talking with you again very soon.
- 24:48Thank you, Bob.
- 24:49You've been listening to the Options Industry Council's Wide World of Options.
- 24:55If you have questions about anything you've heard on today's show, email options@theocc.com
- 25:01or visit www.optionseducation.org and chat with OIC's investor education team.
- 25:08Interested in connecting with OIC on social media?
- 25:12Subscribe to the OIC YouTube channel.
- 25:14Like them on Facebook.
- 25:15Follow them on Twitter at options.edu.
- 25:18And follow their page on LinkedIn.
- 25:21Thanks for listening and be sure to tune in to the next episode of Wide World of Options.
- 25:29You're listening to the Options Insider Radio Network, the home of the Options Podcast.
- 25:35For more quality options programs, visit theoptionsinsider.com or search for Options Insider Radio Network
- 25:43in your podcast provider of choice.
- 25:46Users can also access all of our programming through our mobile app available on the iTunes
- 25:51and Google Play stores.
- 25:52Select programs are also available via livestream at mixler.com/options-insider.
- 26:00That's mixlr.com/options-insider.
- 26:06Don't forget to follow along with your favorite programs and submit your own questions for
- 26:10the hosts at twitter.com/options.
- 26:13Facebook.com/theoptionsinsider or via questions at theoptionsinsider.com.