Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Emergency PODCAST: President Trump Sued by Harper & Otsuka over Firings
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trico with an emergency episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04President Trump has been sued over the firings at NCUA being sued by.
- 0:09Todd Harper being sued by Tanya Ska, both former NCA board
- 0:13members and who were let go.
- 0:16Earlier this month.
- 0:17I'm going to walk through a little bit of their legal filing, a little
- 0:20bit of what my take on it is.
- 0:22Again, I'm not an attorney.
- 0:23I'm not a lawyer.
- 0:24I've spent a lot of time with attorneys and lawyers at NCUA, so I understand
- 0:29some of what makes them tick.
- 0:30I did a little bit of research on the case, did a little bit more
- 0:33research, and that's what you're going to hear from me today.
- 0:39All right, so we're gonna break this down into three categories, the legal and
- 0:43constitutional framework of the lawsuits.
- 0:47Then we're gonna dive into NCA specific structure and functions and how it relates
- 0:51to the lawsuit, and then we're going to dive into some of the litigation strategy
- 0:56and broader implications of this lawsuit.
- 1:00This is a slide from one of my recent PowerPoints and one of my recent podcasts.
- 1:06By the way, I've presented this to several leagues across the country credit union
- 1:11leagues, and if you're with a league and interested in hearing any of this
- 1:15or having any of this presented to your members, feel free to reach out at the
- 1:19contact information at the end of this PowerPoint slide, and at the end of this
- 1:23podcast and the end of this YouTube video.
- 1:26All right, this kind of walks through what has happened at NCUA, and I've
- 1:31got two screens going here, so you might see my eyes darting over.
- 1:34But in February of 2020, the NCA board agenda mentioned that Todd
- 1:39Harper was going, or that a board member was gonna be named Vice Chair.
- 1:42It's my understanding and again, on the left I have timeline,
- 1:45truth, rumor, and intuition.
- 1:46I've heard.
- 1:47Some of this is truth, some of it is rumor, and some of it's
- 1:50based on all my time at NCUA.
- 1:52I did hear that Helpmann was asked to remove that item from the agenda.
- 1:56They did that.
- 1:57That was followed by Har Harper Ska taking on excuse me, that
- 2:01was followed by Helpmann.
- 2:03Changing the overdraft and NSF reporting that had been put in place by Harper
- 2:08for billion dollar plus credit unions.
- 2:10That was followed by Harper and ska issuing statements
- 2:13vehemently against that, saying What's wrong with transparency?
- 2:16Transparency is a har, transparency is a hard word to argue about.
- 2:20Then there were closed meetings, a couple closed meetings to get
- 2:24NCAA's downsizing plan approved.
- 2:26By the way, they're going to be talking about that at the May board meeting
- 2:31according to the agenda that came out in a statement that came up from Halman.
- 2:36All right, so they have the downsizing going on it first.
- 2:39Didn't it get approved?
- 2:39Then it got approved by a two to one vote, I'm told.
- 2:42And then NCUA announces they're going to have a briefing on this, and
- 2:46then Doge arrives at NCUA and then allegedly Doge is unhappy with I.
- 2:51The lack of following presidential orders, if you will, particularly as it
- 2:56relates to having staff back on site.
- 2:59I'm hearing that some things have been decided, and they're going to be forcing
- 3:03the union staff back on site also.
- 3:05So April 15th, Harper Noka were fired via email that came from a statement.
- 3:11Email reference came from a statement that ska made and that is reiterated
- 3:14here in the lawsuit into a canceled their board meeting that NCA after a
- 3:19couple days comes out with a statement to staff saying that a quorum is one.
- 3:23The Federal Credit Union Act requires a quorum for the NCA Board to act.
- 3:28They're saying if there's only one.
- 3:29Then a quorum is one, and then NCUA on April 23rd, a couple days ago, announces
- 3:35they are reopening succession planning and the simplification of insurance
- 3:39rule, which would require a board action, meaning that halman plans to act as
- 3:44a board member of one, theoretically.
- 3:46All right, so that's a little bit of background on how we got here, and then.
- 3:49Reporting this on April 29th.
- 3:51This will go up on April 29th.
- 3:53Yesterday they filed, they ska and Harper filed a lawsuit against president
- 3:59Trump, Scott Besant, Larry fao, and others in the chain of command.
- 4:04Although I wouldn't, I would argue FAOs not in the chain of command, but
- 4:08he probably had to take some actions at NCUA, like taking away their access
- 4:12to their computers, taking away access to their email, taking away access
- 4:16to the building that a staff member would have to do, which is probably
- 4:19why his name is in the lawsuit.
- 4:21All right, next slide Is the NCOA specific structure, and excuse me.
- 4:29Next slide, the legal and constitutional framework.
- 4:32So we're gonna walk through the constitutional show,
- 4:34go Showdown beginning.
- 4:36We're gonna what at pleasure means versus independence in the 1978 restructuring.
- 4:42We're gonna talk through the Humphreys executor precedent, protecting
- 4:45independent agencies unitary executive versus congressional design, the
- 4:50narrowing path of agency independence.
- 4:52Robert Swan versus Bill Clinton that's also NCUA.
- 4:56And the 50 year of 50 years of.
- 4:59Of respect for fifth term fi for fixed terms that have
- 5:02been in place at the agency.
- 5:04So first up case background and context.
- 5:07So this newly filed lawsuit, Harper v Trump Challenges presidents Trump's
- 5:12un unprecedented removal of two national Credit Union administration
- 5:16board members earlier this month.
- 5:18This marks the first time in NCAA's 50 year history that a president has
- 5:23removed board members during their fixed.
- 5:26Terms, and that's key, creating a constitutional
- 5:29showdown over executive power.
- 5:31These removals allegedly came with no explanation or cause delivered through
- 5:36identical one sentence emails from the White House presidential personnel office.
- 5:43So second bullet the 1978 restructuring and implied the implied removal
- 5:49protection Congress significantly restructured the NCUA in 1978,
- 5:55replacing a single administrator who explicitly served at the pleasure of
- 5:59the president with a multi-member board.
- 6:03This deliberate removal of.
- 6:06Pleasure language combined with fixed terms and other structural elements
- 6:10forms the basis of the plaintiff's.
- 6:12Plaintiff's argument that board members have implied removal protection.
- 6:18The complaint specifically cites Senator McIntyre's statement that the
- 6:22amendment was intended to transfer management from a single administrator
- 6:27serving at the presidential.
- 6:30To a board with fixed terms.
- 6:32If you've listened to my other podcasts, I often talk about how
- 6:35an NCUA rule is a three act play.
- 6:38You have the proposed rule and the preamble to that.
- 6:41You have the final rule, which is proposed and voted on, and you have the preamble
- 6:46and you have the actual language of the.
- 6:51Of the rule that gets approved and what they're, in my opinion saying
- 6:55here is there were statements by Senator McIntyre, which shows the
- 7:00intent of why they made that change.
- 7:02That change.
- 7:02And I'll tell my clients sometimes that, for example, you wanna understand
- 7:06why the commercial loan rule reads like it does read the preamble.
- 7:09They'll say what their intent is, so they're there.
- 7:11I think cleverly showing that the intent was to take away presidential power by
- 7:17creating this board as opposed to saying that they can just be flat out terminated.
- 7:22The Humphreys executor precedent, I.
- 7:25And independent agency precedent.
- 7:28So in 1935, Humphrey's executor case established that Congress can limit
- 7:33presidential removal powers for officials at independent agencies
- 7:38that perform quasi legis legislative.
- 7:41Quasi-judicial functions.
- 7:44This precedent has protected independent regulatory agencies for nearly a century.
- 7:49Though recent Supreme Court cases have begun to narrow its application,
- 7:54the plaintiffs are relying heavily on this precedent, arguing that the
- 7:58NCA structure and functions place it squarely within the Humphreys framework.
- 8:04So that's what Harper and Otsuka are arguing.
- 8:10So the unitary executive theory versus congressional authority.
- 8:15So this case represents a clash between the unitary executive theory,
- 8:19which holds that the president must have authority to remove officials
- 8:23who exercise executive power.
- 8:26And by the way, that's what the press Secretary said.
- 8:28He's the president, he can fire whoever he wants.
- 8:31Previous podcast, I had her exact quote on that.
- 8:34And Congress's authority to structure independent agencies.
- 8:38So lemme repeat that.
- 8:39This case represents a clash between the unitary executive theory and this
- 8:44theory holds that the president must have authority to remove officials who exercise
- 8:49executive power and Congress's authority to structure independent agencies.
- 8:54Recent Supreme Court cases have trended towards expanding presidential authority,
- 8:59making this case particularly significant.
- 9:02This theoretical conflict has profound implications for administrative
- 9:06governance and the separation of powers in modern American government.
- 9:10So I think that's why they're suing, right?
- 9:12They're saying, Hey, we don't think you can do this.
- 9:14We think you can, and it's gonna take a probable long journey to
- 9:18resolve all this which creates other issues, which we will get to.
- 9:23So recent Supreme Court precedence that I've referred to, I'm gonna
- 9:27take a sip of my spring water.
- 9:31Although I may need something a little stronger if we have more
- 9:33of these emergency podcasts.
- 9:35So the recent Supreme Court precedent cases like SEAL A law versus CFPB in
- 9:412020 and Collins versus Yellen, Janet Yellen, that is have narrowed Humphrey's
- 9:47executor suggesting greater presidential removal authority over agency heads who
- 9:54exercise significant executive power.
- 9:57The NCA case could test the boundaries of these recent precedents in the context of
- 10:02a multi-member financial regulatory board.
- 10:06Of course, that multiple re multiple.
- 10:10Member Financial regulatory board is the NCA Board, which typically has
- 10:14three board members, typically two of the par of the party in power.
- 10:18But that got all mucked up a couple rounds ago.
- 10:21So the situation was you had two Ds and one R with an R in the
- 10:25White House, which is probably what triggered some of this some of the
- 10:29reasons for why they were fired.
- 10:31Despite the fact that they had a one sentence apparently had a
- 10:34one sentence firing that didn't really go into any of this.
- 10:39This nsu, a TE case could test the boundaries of these recent precedents
- 10:44in the context of a multi-member financial regulatory board.
- 10:47The current Supreme Court has shown a willingness to revisit longstanding
- 10:52precedents regarding administrative agencies and executive power.
- 10:56This Supreme Court has an appetite to take a look at this.
- 10:59They seem to whittle away at the independence of the agency and
- 11:03create more power for the President.
- 11:04We could be heading for a showdown on this topic at some juncture.
- 11:09So the role of Swan Robert Swan versus Clinton as president.
- 11:13So I was at NCA when Robert Swan got fired by Bill Clinton.
- 11:17I was in the division of Special Actions at the time, I believe.
- 11:21So the DC circuit's decision in Swan versus Clinton examined NCA Board member
- 11:28removal authority, but ultimately, it only assumed removal protection
- 11:33without definitely ruling on it.
- 11:36This creates an interesting presidential situation where the most directly
- 11:40relevant case avoided a final determination on the core issues, leaving
- 11:46significant room for interpretation.
- 11:48Plaintiff cites SWAN as supporting their position while the government, Trump would
- 11:54likely emphasize its non-binding nature.
- 11:58So they assumed that there were removal protections for swan.
- 12:03They didn't address it, and then they went on to explain why it
- 12:06was okay for Swan to get fired.
- 12:08I don't wanna get into too much detail here, but Harper and Otsuka
- 12:13are saying this helps their case.
- 12:16I would say the fact that it only assumed that they had a case that Swan had a
- 12:21case means it doesn't help them as much as they think or hope that it will.
- 12:26And there's probably other stronger items that we'll walk through here
- 12:30or have already walked through that are actually a better defense or a
- 12:34better offense, for the plaintiffs.
- 12:38So the role of historical non-REM removal.
- 12:43The role of historical non removal precedent, the complaint emphasizes
- 12:49that during the board's nearly 50 years of existence, so that's the
- 12:52NCA Board's been around for 50 years.
- 12:55The president has never removed a member whose terms has not yet expired.
- 13:00This administrative precedent could play an important role in the court's
- 13:04analysis as historical practice often informs interpretation of constitutional
- 13:09boundaries between branches.
- 13:11The unprecedented nature of these removals highlights the
- 13:14cases exceptional significance.
- 13:18So it's interesting they say that's that history means something to me.
- 13:22They have the authority in never having used it doesn't
- 13:24mean that they couldn't use it.
- 13:27And I'll make a credit union based comparison.
- 13:30NSU a says that they can remove officials.
- 13:32The Federal credit Union acts as they can.
- 13:34Their policies and procedures establish ways on which they should do that.
- 13:38Behind the scenes, they've never used that.
- 13:40They'll only remove the entire board.
- 13:43Y why just remove one when you can re remove all easier.
- 13:46So they've never used that rule.
- 13:48But they claim that they can use it at any point in time.
- 13:51So if I was the Trump administration, I'd be saying yes.
- 13:53So what, they've never done it in 50 years.
- 13:55We'd never had a situation like this where it needed to happen.
- 13:58And I think, again, I don't think that's necessarily in my
- 14:01mind, a very powerful argument.
- 14:06All right, so next slide.
- 14:08Moving to the next slide, the NCOA specific structure and functions.
- 14:13So let's talk about the plaintiffs Harper and Otsuka, Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka.
- 14:18The removed NCA Board members at hand are suing in both personal
- 14:22and official capacities to be in straight in reinstated Harper.
- 14:27Previously appointed by Trump and later designated as Chair by Biden had
- 14:31been leading initiatives on financial stability and consumer protection.
- 14:36Otsuka, a more recent appointee had been focusing on.
- 14:40Underserved communities access to financial services, and this
- 14:44is according to their writeup.
- 14:46Both were removed despite having years remaining on their statutory terms,
- 14:50Harper, until 2027 and Otsuka until 2029.
- 14:56Now I'm gonna digress here a little bit.
- 14:58So Todd Harper actually had two terms, and the Biden administration changed
- 15:02the definition of what a term was.
- 15:05Essentially, they said if you didn't have six full years, you get two terms, which
- 15:10has never been how it was interpreted.
- 15:12Oh, by the way, we're up above, they're arguing that this has
- 15:14never happened in 50 years.
- 15:15What had never happened in.
- 15:1650 years was somebody succeeding themself, Harper succeeding himself
- 15:21and getting another six year term.
- 15:22We've had board members come and go and come back.
- 15:25We've never had them run for longer than six years.
- 15:28And I, I, to me that's not what the act, but no one has challenged that.
- 15:33And at the time that it happened, I remember trade associations and
- 15:37discussions with credit unions saying, Hey if somebody pursues
- 15:41that, you could argue that anything that Todd Harper voted on wasn't I.
- 15:46A legal vote by the board, and we'll get into that a little bit because I think
- 15:50that has ramifications for discussions as it relates to Houtman and him potentially
- 15:56making making, taking action as a sole board member, claiming that they have
- 16:03that power, claiming that one is a.
- 16:06A quorum.
- 16:07Whether that's right or wrong, who knows?
- 16:10All right.
- 16:10The NCA structure and role in financial regulation, the argument is that
- 16:15NCA is a core financial regulator.
- 16:18They're, they have a seat at the table at fs o.
- 16:20It might be at the kids' table, but they do have a ta a seat.
- 16:24All right, so the NCA structure and role in financial regulation.
- 16:28The NCA stands alongside the FDIC and Federal Reserve as a core financial
- 16:34regulator overseeing credit unions that serve 142 million Americans and
- 16:38safeguard over 2 trillion in assets.
- 16:41Its three member board with fixed staggered terms and bipartisan
- 16:45requirement was designed by Congress to insulate credit union's
- 16:49oversight from political pressure.
- 16:51This independence is particularly crucial during financial instability as
- 16:56demonstrated during the 2023 liquidity crisis mentioned in the complaint.
- 17:05I'm guessing that was the best argument they could come up with because credit
- 17:09unions didn't really have a liquidity crisis when compared to what happened
- 17:14at Silicon Valley Bank, signature Bank, which were liquidated over a weekend.
- 17:19And oh, by the way, in my opinion they bailed people out beyond
- 17:23the $250,000 insurance limit.
- 17:25But again, that's a story for another day.
- 17:27I have podcasts out there on that topic and why I think that was a boondoggle
- 17:31and that it was unprecedented assistance.
- 17:34But that's the argument.
- 17:36The, I can putting my, my, I've been around lawyers a lot.
- 17:40They said, you need to explain how you are crucial.
- 17:43And that happened when both of them were there.
- 17:46So they make the argument that.
- 17:48I think SKA was there in 2023 as I'm getting texts about this as I chat.
- 17:54All right, so we talked about n NCAA's structure and role in financial
- 17:58regulation, which they're saying they have, this is something they
- 18:01have to claim as part of the case.
- 18:04So executive functions versus regulatory independence.
- 18:08A central question in the case is whether the NCUA performs substantially
- 18:12executive functions favoring pr, which favors presidential control, or primarily
- 18:19quasi legislative and quasi-judicial functions, which would favor independence.
- 18:26The Trump administration would likely characterize the N C's supervisory
- 18:30activities as executive in nature while the plaintiff's position.
- 18:35As a, as similar to the FTC and other independent financial
- 18:39regulators, the complaint specifically highlights the NNC a's rulemaking.
- 18:43Consumer protection and market oversight functions as paralleling
- 18:47the FTCs protected role.
- 18:51And they wanna parallel the FTC because of the past Supreme Court case that
- 18:56went forward as it relates to the FTC.
- 19:00One of the things that I thought about is the N-C-F-N-C-U-S-I-F ownership structure.
- 19:04I.
- 19:05So the N-C-U-S-I-F is owned by insured credit unions themselves
- 19:09rather than the federal government.
- 19:11This creates a unique structure that strengthens the argument
- 19:15for n NCAA's independence.
- 19:17This industry funded model distinguishes it.
- 19:20Distinguishes it from agency agencies directly controlling
- 19:25federal funds and suggests a quasi-independent regulatory role.
- 19:30The mutual ownership structure also emphasizes the agency's role
- 19:34as an overseer of a self-insuring system rather than a direct
- 19:39administrator of federal resources.
- 19:42Now, the caveat to that would be if the fund gets wiped out, the.
- 19:46Taxpayer is liable ultimately.
- 19:49So I think that you can argue both sides of that.
- 19:52But ultimately, treasury would ha would have to, taxpayers would have to
- 19:56fund it if the insurance fund was so insolvent that credit unions couldn't
- 20:00fund it themselves by recapitalizing it.
- 20:03So it would be catastrophic, but it's theoretically possible.
- 20:08Now the central liquidity facility would be an argument in support of the
- 20:12Trump side, so the central liquidity facility and executive authority.
- 20:16The NC a's central liquidity facility can borrow from the Federal financing
- 20:20bank, creating a direct connection to treasury and federal resources.
- 20:24This relationship could strengthen the argument that the NCA exercises
- 20:29some executive functions that require.
- 20:32Presidential oversight, particularly during financial crisis, the
- 20:37administration could argue this borrowing authority involves economic policy
- 20:42decisions that should align with the President's overall financial strategy.
- 20:46Now, as I'm thinking this through, if I.
- 20:50If I was helping one side or the other, which I've done in some lawsuits that
- 20:54impacted NCUA, I would be saying, Hey, what has NCA board members, what has
- 20:59Todd Harper said in front of Congress as it relates to the powers of the
- 21:02central liquidity facility and what they can and what they can't do?
- 21:06I would look for language that was utilized in front of Congress
- 21:10if I was the Trump side to try and say, Hey, here's why.
- 21:14The central liquidity side of it.
- 21:16Makes this something that is creating a direct connection to the treasury and
- 21:21that also strengthens the argument that NCAA exercises some executive functions.
- 21:26I think that'd be a pretty strong argument, but I would try and
- 21:28use their own words against them.
- 21:29I would go search those statements by Harper.
- 21:32Not that anybody from the Trump administration is listening to this, but
- 21:35if they were, that would be my suggestion.
- 21:38Alright, the quorum crisis.
- 21:42Agency paralysis.
- 21:43Do I need to change slides here?
- 21:46I think I do.
- 21:48Let's see.
- 21:48The CLF, the Quorum Crisis and Agency Paralysis.
- 21:55Oh no.
- 21:56Here we go.
- 21:56We're operating without a quorum.
- 21:58So the re, the removal of two board members has left the NCUA
- 22:02without the statutory quorum required for board actions.
- 22:06While the administration might argue that a single remaining member constitutes
- 22:11a quorum in emergency situations, the plaintiffs contend this would
- 22:15circumvent Congress's multi-member design and bipartisan requirements.
- 22:20If you only have one, you only have one party in there.
- 22:23That would be the argument.
- 22:24This paralysis has real world implications for the credit union system's regulatory
- 22:29oversight, potentially affecting millions of Americans who rely on
- 22:32credit unions for financial services.
- 22:36What's the sound of one hand clapping?
- 22:38That's a line in a Van Morrison song.
- 22:42A deep dive, a deep cut if you will, but NCUA has come out publicly and
- 22:47said that one board member can act and that is their longstanding position.
- 22:53It's their longstanding position in my opinion, their delegations
- 22:56say that the board can act on anything that's essential.
- 22:59A one member board, but that's a delegation approved by the board.
- 23:03The Federal Credit Union Act says that you need a quorum.
- 23:06So a quorum will be decided perhaps at some day by the Supreme
- 23:10Court as it relates to this.
- 23:13Okay.
- 23:13Financial stability and public.
- 23:15Interest implications beyond the constitutional questions.
- 23:19The case raises serious concerns about financial system stability.
- 23:23The complaint emphasizes that independent financial regulators
- 23:27were designed for good reason.
- 23:29A stable financial system depends on independent regulators who act
- 23:33free from political interference.
- 23:35The outcome could affect how financial regulators navigate future
- 23:39crises and potentially impact.
- 23:41Packed market confidence in regulatory independence.
- 23:46Time will tell as it relates to this.
- 23:48All right.
- 23:49Going to our second to last slide, last substantive slide is the
- 23:56litigation strategy and broader implications of all of this.
- 24:01So the legal strategies and multiple claims the plaintiffs
- 24:06have filed six different counts.
- 24:09Including statutory violations, administrative procedure act
- 24:13claims, and constitutional separations of power arguments.
- 24:17This multifaceted approach gives the court several potential grounds on which
- 24:21to decide the case without necessarily resolving all constitutional questions.
- 24:28The complaint strategically includes a.
- 24:31Claims for Dec Decla declaratory judgment.
- 24:36The complaint strategically includes claims for declaratory judgment, injunct,
- 24:41injunctive, relief, mandamus, whatever that is, and equitable remedies to
- 24:46maximize potential avenues for relief.
- 24:49So they're pursuing this on constitutional basis.
- 24:53They're pursuing this on Administrative Procedure Act claims.
- 24:56It's basically a full court press.
- 24:58Throw everything against the wall and see what sticks.
- 25:01So I wanted to do a little research on the legal firm that they hired.
- 25:06And my guess is, oh, by the way, I'm thinking somebody's funding this.
- 25:09Some group is funding this for Harper Notes because the cost of
- 25:12this are gonna add up quickly on the plaintiff's side and the agency I.
- 25:17And everybody listed will be represented by the US Attorney's Office, and
- 25:21they can assign an army to that.
- 25:22And there's no cost to these individuals who, by the way, are not
- 25:25being sued in their personal capacity.
- 25:27They're being sued in their official capacity.
- 25:29But US Attorney's Office is an army and somebody is funding this and I'm imagining
- 25:35while it might be partially ska and partially Harper, that somebody, with deep
- 25:40pockets, who wants this constitutional issue addressed is funding this so the
- 25:45small but in influential legal team.
- 25:48The plaintiffs are represented by Holwell, Schuster and Goldberg, LLP which is called
- 25:54a boutique litigation firm specializing in high stakes, constitutional
- 25:58and complex commercial disputes.
- 26:01They were founded by a former judge.
- 26:03Federal judge in 2012.
- 26:05This relatively small firm is taking on a case with potentially far
- 26:09reaching implications for presidential power and regulatory independence.
- 26:15Their specialized expertise in constitutional litigation may be
- 26:19more valuable than the resources of a large firm in this context.
- 26:23So they have a niche, they found the right people to, they're in the
- 26:28right niche for what's going on here.
- 26:30And they seem to, have done some of this before, which is good for Harper
- 26:35and Ska, but again, they're going up a against an army against the US Attorney's
- 26:39Office and they're going up against Supreme Court that it leans to the right.
- 26:44So it'll be interesting to see what happens here.
- 26:47So I don't know about the timeline.
- 26:49I did a little bit of research and what I found out is that cases like this
- 26:53typically take three to five years to reach Supreme Court decision if it.
- 26:58Progresses through all levels of appeal and given the cases constitutional
- 27:03significance in involving presidential power and independent agency
- 27:07structure, it might receive expedited consideration at some of the stages.
- 27:12So does that mean trimming three to five years to three,
- 27:15or does that mean trimming.
- 27:17Three years to one, or is that gonna be something like the exporting of
- 27:22illegals that gets, go past, go get all the way to the Supreme Court quickly?
- 27:26I don't know.
- 27:27It's gonna be interesting, but if it's three to five years, that creates
- 27:31some challenges in many ways as well.
- 27:34Also the composition of the Supreme Court by the time the case reaches it
- 27:38will be crucial as the court has been incrementally reshaping administrative
- 27:41law doctrines in recent years because they're more on the right, they're making
- 27:45decisions more with presidential power, and so they may want to get this there
- 27:50sooner than later, which might get it.
- 27:52Quicker than the three to five years.
- 27:55So who knows, maybe that means less than a year time will tell implications
- 27:59for other independent agencies.
- 28:01The outcome could significantly impact the structure and independence of
- 28:05numerous federal agencies beyond the NCUA, including other financial regulators.
- 28:09The FCC.
- 28:10FTC and independent boards and commissions across the government.
- 28:15A ruling expanding presidential removal powers could fundament fundamentally
- 28:20reshape the administrative state agencies with similar multi-member
- 28:24structures and fixed terms without explicit removal protections would be.
- 28:28Particularly vulnerable.
- 28:30So it, it would impact other agencies.
- 28:33But beyond beyond that, the, let's talk about within the walls of NCUA.
- 28:38What's going on at NC A right now is they have a restructuring going on and
- 28:4420% of staff have left or committed to leave by the end of the year.
- 28:49That's a big number, and these staff that are leaving are core, long-term folks
- 28:54that were either eligible to retire.
- 28:56Or could do early retirement.
- 28:58So they're losing a lot of corporate knowledge.
- 29:00That's gonna create some havoc at the agency and already is.
- 29:04It's going to create maop morale problems and already is.
- 29:08And when the dust settles, what will the new NCOA look like?
- 29:11Who knows?
- 29:12I have stated in previous podcasts.
- 29:15That NCUA staff has a lot of talented people at every level.
- 29:19So people will rise up to the challenges and rise up to be promoted.
- 29:23But they also have some inabilities of hiring right now
- 29:26under the Trump administration.
- 29:27So it's gonna be a little chaotic at NCUA right now.
- 29:32But let's go back and discuss the my first slide from my previous PowerPoint
- 29:37where I talked about the fact that Hopman.
- 29:41Says he can act on regulation.
- 29:42This lawsuit says they can't.
- 29:44Helpmann says that he is going to reopen the comment period on regulations that
- 29:50have been approved by the past board.
- 29:51Let's talk about succession planning.
- 29:55Trump has said We want to get rid of 10 rules for every one that you put in place.
- 30:00Last administration, it was two rules for every 10.
- 30:02This time it's 10 for everyone.
- 30:04I don't see how, when putting regulations in place, I see him
- 30:07looking to get rid of some regulations.
- 30:10I see.
- 30:11I see him trying to show the administration that he is a good
- 30:14soldier and I think that's why.
- 30:17First they came out saying they could take action, then they said they're
- 30:20going to reopen the comment period, which is tiptoeing into him taking
- 30:23actions as a board member of one.
- 30:26If they end up canceling those regulations, which I'm gonna assume
- 30:30that's where they're heading with succession planning that would create
- 30:36a situation where, how does this suit.
- 30:38Play out.
- 30:39As I mentioned earlier, if there had been suits saying Harper didn't have
- 30:43the authority to be in for two terms instead of one term, which I think
- 30:47would be a pretty good argument, could you unravel everything that had come
- 30:50before it so you could see, in my opinion if Harper and Ska win that.
- 30:58Or they decide that a quorum is not one, and HELPMANN cannot act that there could
- 31:03be some things that were canceled and pulled away that would go back in place.
- 31:08So that's un, that's unknown.
- 31:11It's like the unknowns that we have with the tariffs right
- 31:13now, which is making the market.
- 31:15Shaky, which is making small businesses shaky, which is making other countries
- 31:19saying, Hey, what, when the dust settles, what are the rules gonna be?
- 31:24NCUA staff, with all these other morale problems they've got going
- 31:27on with the downsizing, I could see people say, Hey, you know what, it
- 31:32Harper and SKA had the right to sue, but this could be what pushes, another
- 31:371, 2, 3, 4, 5% of staff out the door.
- 31:39So I think that number will go up.
- 31:41They're gonna go, you know what?
- 31:43This is this is beyond the pale for what those career folks might wanna deal with.
- 31:49And I think it will have, I think these lawsuits, while they may be
- 31:53appropriate and they may win, I think it's ripping a scab off for the staff.
- 31:58And it's gonna burn a lot of energy, a lot of energy that's not focused on the
- 32:02safety and soundness of credit unions.
- 32:03So this is a political battle.
- 32:06This is a personal battle.
- 32:07It may be viewed.
- 32:09They never underestimate the power of self-deception.
- 32:11People look for facts that support their position.
- 32:14People on both sides of the aisle are going to argue for what they want
- 32:19to, and credit unions and NCA staff are stuck in the middle of this.
- 32:25And the sooner it can be resolved, the better so that the healing can begin so
- 32:31that the new agency, whatever that might be at the end of all this, can come about.
- 32:36And I, in my.
- 32:38Presentations to some of the leagues.
- 32:40I did say, Hey, we'll have to see if these folks sue Harper and ska that
- 32:44is, and now they've decided to do it, and they've, they seem to have a
- 32:49firm that knows what they're doing.
- 32:51I think it's getting funded by somebody, as I mentioned.
- 32:54And the reality is there's gonna be a lot of scabs ripped off between
- 32:57now and when this is resolved.
- 32:59I think it's a sad state of affairs that the industry has to deal with this, and
- 33:03you can, whatever side of the aisle on you can put point blame to either side, and
- 33:08the credit unions are stuck in the middle.
- 33:09The staff are stuck in the middle.
- 33:11I'm disappointed from that perspective and I'm just going to leave it at that.
- 33:16I hope you enjoyed this emergency podcast with some of my takes, some of
- 33:21what I've done via research, and some of this was verbatim from that filing.
- 33:26As always, I wanna thank you for listening or if you're on YouTube.
- 33:29I wanna thank you for watching.
- 33:31This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.