Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of R Kelly (2019 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07So Berto, what do you know about the R. Kelly scandal? You
- 0:10know what? Not much? I know. I know who R. Kelly
- 0:14is. I like his music a lot, actually, and I certainly knew
- 0:18about the whole pe incident back in the day. And then recently, all
- 0:23of a sudden I heard that he might he's going to jail or he's getting
- 0:26all these things super accused. And then I saw an interview with the two
- 0:30girls that live with him, and that's you know, that's about it.
- 0:34Well, I thought we'd get into it and see what we come up with.
- 0:36What do you say, Let's do it. This is the Psychology in
- 0:40Seattle podcast, and I am your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I am
- 0:45a therapist and a professor. Sometimes I say that so fast. I wonder
- 0:49if people yeah, So, I thought i'd enunciate this time. Who are
- 0:52you Umberto? So is psychology and Scattle named like like sleepless and Seattle.
- 0:58Oh God, my name is Umberto Castagne and I'm a luthier. So Robert
- 1:06Sylvester Kelly born nineteen sixty seven, Chicago, did you know how you should?
- 1:12I wish this was a video podcast. You should have seen that was
- 1:15hilarious. Kirk went to reach for the mouse, but the mouse had scooted
- 1:19it over magically, and so he's handed this little move the mouse movement,
- 1:23but with no mouse in it. It was hilarious. It's not so funny
- 1:26if you're not seeing it, I guess. So did you know that he
- 1:33is one of the best selling musical artists ever in the United States? I
- 1:37didn't, but I am not surprised. I am. So if you would
- 1:41have asked me, you know, who was our Kelly, I'd be like,
- 1:44oh, he had like one song. I mean, I believe I
- 1:48can fly alone. Well, I would have been like, yeah, he
- 1:51was a one hit wonder he And then if someone was like, what about
- 1:53Ignition, I'd be like, oh, yeah, I remember, I remember
- 1:56that song kind of. But like, he has sold over some five million
- 2:00records worldwide during a time when you actually sold actual records or CDs, physical
- 2:06products. He's the most successful R and B male artist of the nineteen nineties.
- 2:12That makes sense, not to me. I had no awareness of him.
- 2:15So, I mean, did you follow the whole in the Closet series?
- 2:20Not? No, not until I started this deep time. So like,
- 2:24I'm so not an R and B fan. And not a hip hop
- 2:29fan. That I had just no awareness of this entire world. And anytime
- 2:32I would have heard r Kelly even I believe I can fly. Like I
- 2:37can't even sing that song to you, you know what I mean, Like
- 2:39I believe I can fly. I believe I can touch the skies. See
- 2:46that's more. You've already done more than I know. So in the nineties,
- 2:51I didn't have cable TV. I didn't have any friends who listened to
- 2:55R and B. Everyone I knew, everyone I knew listen to you know,
- 3:00the Smashing Pumpkins. Well I didn't. I wasn't an Oasis fan.
- 3:07I guess Radioheadah, of course we listened to the Beatles, the Smiths,
- 3:12depeche Mode. We were massive music fans, and not just this didn't penetrate
- 3:16the wall for you, just complete a complete bubble, you know, just
- 3:21like completely out of my awareness. And so as I'm researching this, I
- 3:25was like, oh my god. He was nicknamed the King of R and
- 3:28B. He won several awards. He sang that at the opening ceremony of
- 3:34the two thousand and two Olympics. Yeah, well, so for me,
- 3:37the reason this wouldn't be so surprising is because if you asked me to name
- 3:39the top ten R and B artists of the nineties and probably early two thousands,
- 3:44I'd be like, well, there's R Kelly, you know. Okay,
- 3:49So you were just like slightly off from me. Yeah, because of
- 3:53course people who grew up in that in that bubble, they don't know they
- 3:57know like one Smashing Pumpkin song exactly, okay. So his hits were that
- 4:00I looked up So I Believe I Can Fly, three Grammys, Bump and
- 4:03Grind. So I looked up all these songs, and I had only ever
- 4:08heard I Believe I Can Fly, in ignition all these other massive hits.
- 4:12I had never heard a single note from Bump and Grind. Your Body's Calling
- 4:16Gotham City, if I could turn back the hands of time, the world's
- 4:20greatest and I'm a flirt. I mean, have you ever heard any of
- 4:24those songs? I've heard of half of those. I hadn't heard of it.
- 4:27And then of course trapped in the closet, so you have seen it,
- 4:30all of it. It's so amazing. Did you see it when it
- 4:32came out? Yeah, when it was still kind of coming out. Yeah.
- 4:35It If I had never even heard of this thing, but I watched
- 4:39the entirety of it yesterday. It's it's like the room. Yeah yeah,
- 4:46was he serious? Oh ish yeah, yes, ish. I mean obviously
- 4:50it's done tongue in cheek, like over the top soap opera style. But
- 4:56his music is serious. The music's good. The music isn't good. It's
- 4:59the same song over all. Again, it's very well produced. He sings
- 5:02very nicely, but the song is it's it's you and I are songwriters.
- 5:09Sure, if I wrote a song that was like really quick so I could
- 5:14put a story to it, I would write a song like that. It's
- 5:17very repetitive. It has the same cadence, sure, and it's just like
- 5:27and then the crescendo at the end, you know, ever gets old.
- 5:30So it seems like he's mostly being serious. Isn't going to come out of
- 5:34the closet. And I mean it's like it's so intense. Yeah, So
- 5:38let's so let's uh, let's review uh this story here because I just want
- 5:43to if you haven't seen it, I just want to. I just want
- 5:45to. I watched the whole thing and took notes. I'm only going to
- 5:48talk about like the first like bit like the first third twenty one parts or
- 5:53something. Yeah. So he he's having sex with a woman in her house.
- 5:59She'sddenly says her husband's coming home. And you really just have to watch
- 6:03it because it looks like a parody. There's so many twists and turns.
- 6:09Well, so we'll get to it. So he so her her husband's coming
- 6:12home. He he, you know, gets convinced to hide in the closet.
- 6:15That's where the whole thing comes from. The husband finds him and me,
- 6:19and meanwhile R. Kelly is narrating the entire story. He's looking around,
- 6:25he looks in, he looks in the cabinet, he has a he
- 6:29has a confused face. He smells something like that's literally the lyrics. Then
- 6:35the husband finds to the closet and I'm hiding in the closet and he's walking
- 6:39to the closet. Is he going to open the door of the closet.
- 6:42Yeah, that's literally the song. Uh. He he pulls out a gun.
- 6:46There's lots of talk singing. The wife is pleading, you know.
- 6:49The husband, over a span of a couple of minutes, eventually introduces his
- 6:55male boyfriend. Right. So, so now the wife's not. Now the
- 6:59wife's switch just from pleading and apologizing to now she's angry, and R Kelly
- 7:05still has his gun out, and he's very confused about the whole thing,
- 7:09like, oh, this is totally wacky. I mean, the thing that
- 7:11the gestolt I got from it was like R Kelly was so guilty himself and
- 7:16so ashamed or something or trying to convince you know this the because if you
- 7:24just said, like, if you said this whole thing in one sentence,
- 7:27what would it be, Like, what's the story the plot? I guess
- 7:32maybe he's not so guilty after all, because everyone's got their own dirty little
- 7:36secrets exactly. Okay, So then everyone so everyone's basically everyone is cheating on
- 7:45everyone. Okay. So then the guy comes out, and then R Kelly
- 7:48leaves, and then a cop pulls him over, and then R Kelly goes
- 7:54home, and then he's like, I think my wife's cheating on me,
- 7:57but she's not. And then let me just read some of the lyrics here.
- 8:01This is a video he's singing there on the bed they're having sex.
- 8:05Then I said, this is him saying. Then I said, baby,
- 8:09we must slow down before I bust a vessel in my brain and she said
- 8:13please, don't, please, no, don't stop. And I said,
- 8:16I got a cramp and then she said, please keep going, and I
- 8:20said, my leg is about to crack. Then she cries out, oh
- 8:24my goodness, I'm about to climax, and I said, cool climax,
- 8:28just like go on my leg. She says, you're the perfect lover.
- 8:33And I said I can go no further. Then I flipped back the cover.
- 8:37Oh my god, a rubber, rubber, rubber rubber, so his
- 8:43wife. So he just came with his wife and then he finds out that
- 8:50she had been having sex with someone else because there's a rubber there right.
- 8:52So just to recap, he starts a story having sex with the woman.
- 8:56He finds out she's married. The husband comes home. There's a fight,
- 8:58and then the husband said, I'm actually cheating with this man. He goes,
- 9:01he gets pulled over. He goes home, he has such with his
- 9:03wife. The wife reveals, you know, there's this rubber. I guess
- 9:07I used rubberson she she reveals she's been cheating. She says something odd about
- 9:13someone. They start laughing, which is totally confusing. The cop hears the
- 9:16noise inside the house. He comes inside, there's a confrontation. Turns out
- 9:20the wife is cheating with the cop. The cop leaves. The cop goes
- 9:24home to his wife. The cop is suspicious. There's a fight. The
- 9:28wife has a lover in the closet, and it's a midget. He uses
- 9:37the word midget. I'm not using the word midget, but he uses,
- 9:39and so it says, you know, it's a midget, midget, midget,
- 9:45like that's it. And then there's a fight. Because everyone every segment
- 9:48ends in a cliffhanger, right, yeah, I guess if that's what you're
- 9:52gonna w a twist, I should say twist, which is almost universally.
- 9:56The next person in this story is cheating on the midget. Poops is pants,
- 10:01by the way, And that's actually kind of a plot point that carries
- 10:03over into different chapters. And so I've just described to you just like the
- 10:09first twenty five percent. Okay, So he also wrote, you gotta admit
- 10:13this had never been done in history god and hopefully never will again. I
- 10:18mean, I'm surprised this doesn't have a cult following like The Room does,
- 10:22right, because it is one of it is it is probably more entertainingly bad
- 10:28than the room is. Yeah, I mean it, yeah, I don't
- 10:31know, it's I remember me at the time, he and this ex friend
- 10:35of mine we used to we watched it all and we would laugh the hell
- 10:37out of it. I mean it seems like because if when you compare it
- 10:41to other videos he was making at the time, it's not that far off
- 10:46from other things he was making. So I could totally imagine him thinking this
- 10:50was like a serious project he was working on. Sure, but but yes,
- 10:54but the content was I mean, you know, the parody for sure,
- 10:58right, Yeah, I guess. So he wrote and produced many hits,
- 11:03like probably more than he actually did himself. For example, he wrote
- 11:07the Michael Jackson song you Are Not Alone, which was nominated for a Grammy.
- 11:13The video has which I've never seen because this was again during a Michael
- 11:16Jackson time when I wasn't really paying attention to his career, and so I
- 11:24you know, you are Not Alone. The video is with Lisa Marie Presley,
- 11:28so it must have been in that short zone when MJ was married to
- 11:33Lisa Marie Presley. It's a very disturbing video given what we know about Leviy
- 11:37in Neverland, and actually the first shot of Lisa Marie, because Lisa Marie
- 11:43is basically naked, I remember this, and Michael Jackson is in her sort
- 11:48of in the scene together. The very first shot of Lisa Marie, she
- 11:54looks like a little boy, because Lisa Marie is not very curvy person,
- 12:01okay, or at least from the video, and she's kind of muscular and
- 12:05kind of and she has boyish features in a lot of ways. So you
- 12:11wonder like, was that part of the thing maybe I always thought that was
- 12:16like one of these arranged marriage or you know, publicity marriages. Yeah.
- 12:20Anyway, so lots of success for R. Kelly. Okay, So I
- 12:26don't have time to go in on the details, and as always, if
- 12:30I get a little detail wrong, I don't want to fucking hear it.
- 12:33This isn't your podcast of history. This is an opportunity to get the general
- 12:37restault of the facts, and then we'll talk about whether what the psychology of
- 12:43R. Kelly is what we're getting to. So his childhood, he was
- 12:46poor. We all know that he had no father around. We all know
- 12:50that he claims he was sexually abused by an older female who was ten years
- 12:54older than him from the age of eight until he was fourteen, so she
- 12:58would have been eighteen to twenty four. He claims that he was sexually abused.
- 13:03That would explain a lot, Yeah, but he also lies a lot,
- 13:05so hard to know. He claims he was shot in the shoulder to
- 13:11steal his bike by other kids in the neighborhood. And he claims that at
- 13:15the age of eight, his girlfriend was pushed into a river by some bullies
- 13:18and then she drowned and died. Yikes. So if any of these things
- 13:22are true, that's pretty awful. That is unbelievable. But it's just hard
- 13:26to know because from what I read, it was like him claiming I don't
- 13:28know anyway. Skipping forward to nineteen ninety four, he's twenty seven years old,
- 13:33he meets Aliyah. Aliyah is that hey Brown's name? Is that the
- 13:37artist? Yeah? Oh yeah again. She died right, Yeah, she
- 13:41died in a plane crash. But he wrote her first hit when she was
- 13:48fourteen or fifteen years old. They had fallen in love. He was twenty
- 13:52seven. They got married. By the way, he's twenty seven, she's
- 13:54fifteen. They got married, Wow, and she claimed the marriage certificate that
- 14:01she was eighteen, so it's like, well r Kelly was lied to,
- 14:05But one of his in the documentary, one of his assistants or entourage guys,
- 14:13says that r Kelly asked him to get fake documents to say that she
- 14:20was eighteen because everyone knew she wasn't eighteen, And the guy's like, I'm
- 14:26not really proud of that, and I'm like, yeah, you think,
- 14:30but anyway, they he wrote her first hit, Ain't Or and worked on
- 14:35her first album age Ain't Nothing but a number was the name. I remember
- 14:39that. Yeah, yeah, it's about a young girl who was trying to
- 14:41get an older guy to have sex with her. No relation. So around
- 14:48this time it wasn't just her at what he was many other girls that he
- 14:52was and teenagers who he was tricking by saying he was going to put him
- 14:56on the next album and he would have sex with them. So his his
- 15:00abuse of children, goes Zmo was consistent, was way back yet nineteen ninety
- 15:05six. I believe I can fly space jam, which I've never seen,
- 15:09which, of course, which of course defines our age, right because everyone
- 15:13younger than us has seen it like a lot, right right, Because it
- 15:16was like bugs Bunny and MJ and R Kelly doing the music. Oh my
- 15:22gosh. Yeah. During this time, a woman sued him, claimed that
- 15:26she was sexually abused by him years ago, and he settled for a quarter
- 15:30of a million dollars. So right away he was having to pay out money,
- 15:35which he did many, many times, similar to Bill Cosby two thousand
- 15:39and two, the famous pea video. Have you ever seen the video?
- 15:43No, neither of I. I've heard of it, and I've seen parodies
- 15:46of it. Oh, I haven't seen it either, But apparently it's a
- 15:50long video, it's not short. And you see his face, you see
- 15:54her face. She's fourteen and they're having sex, and he also like peas
- 15:58in her mouth. But is this a like a real video or was it
- 16:02a yeah? Okay, so it was found like they were filming it like
- 16:07a sex tape essentially. Yeah. So he made hundreds, if not thousands
- 16:11of sex tapes from a very from a very young from a very early period
- 16:15of time, and presumably he would whack off to them later or something,
- 16:21and he also used them at some point to blackmail people like if you,
- 16:25if you talk, I'm gonna release this, And according to the documentary,
- 16:29if I remember, right, like some one of his young girlfriends came across
- 16:36the video and was so upset by it, like gave it to the press
- 16:38or I can't remember the exact thing, but that's how the elite think,
- 16:42so I think. So I'm not don't quote me on that. But anyway,
- 16:45so he is indicted and he goes to trial, and that, if
- 16:52I remember right from the documentary, it took like six years to actually have
- 16:55the trial, which is ridiculous. And the alleged victim didn't you know,
- 17:03and the parents said, that's not me. She's like, that's not me
- 17:06in the video. So yet her bestrid or her friend, her coach and
- 17:11all these other people like, yeah, that's her. Well, like,
- 17:14you know, we talked about this in the MJ episode, and just in
- 17:18general, I would not be surprised at all if many of the girls thought
- 17:26that this was love or that they were special and that, you know,
- 17:30and so then of course they wouldn't want to implicate him or be or be
- 17:34shamed or whatever, you know, and the stigma of coming out and revealing
- 17:42that you know, you had sex at all, let alone at the age
- 17:45of fourteen with an older man, let alone that you had someone p in
- 17:48your mouth because you were being terrorized. So I just want to point out
- 17:52that's our fault, that our society stigmatizes that sort of thing and keeps people
- 17:57quiet and lo and behold are hell was left? You know, was off
- 18:02the hook. A year later, he's arrested for child porn. The cases
- 18:07dropped for somewhird reason, lots of different cases over the years, which we
- 18:11won't go into, but then skipping forward in more recent years, twenty seventeen,
- 18:15he's accused of three set by three sets of parents by holding their daughters
- 18:18in an abusive cult. So people are like, not only is he having
- 18:23sex with kids, but now he's like developing a cult with actually like adult
- 18:26women. And when I heard this partil like eighteen year olds. Yeah,
- 18:33but so I think he was like, this is complete speculation, obviously,
- 18:37but I think he's like, well, if I have sex with a minor,
- 18:41then it's much more clear that I'm doing something illegal. But if I
- 18:47actually break down the personality of someone who's eighteen or higher, then everything's on
- 18:52the up and up. Like I can't be caught, you know, like
- 18:56even if even if they break up with me and leave me and get out
- 19:00of my circle. And they claim that I'm being abusive, It's just like,
- 19:04well prove it, you know, and I have millions of dollars to
- 19:08pay for lawyers, Like, I'll be fine, and that's just me speculating,
- 19:12and I'll get like people that look really young, you know. Anyway,
- 19:18So this is very similar to the Nexium guy. So when he started
- 19:23out, he would do things that were untoward, but then fast forward twenty
- 19:29years and he has like a sex cult. So it's very similar with our
- 19:32Kelly. It's like he started out with sort of like regular horrible sexual abusive
- 19:37behavior and then eventually graduated to actually like because he learned probably how to brainwash
- 19:44people over the years, you know, and what systems he had to put
- 19:47in place to actually fully control these women's lives. Twenty eighteen BBC air to
- 19:53documentary and then there was more talk, more allegations, and then hashtag mute
- 20:00r Kelly came out to Boycott's music. He responded that these people were attempting
- 20:04to lynch a black man who has made extraordinary contributions to the African American culture.
- 20:11And by the way, it was led by black women because the vast
- 20:14majority of his victims, if not all of them, were African American women.
- 20:19More allegations Washington Post article, blah blah blah. Then this lifetime docu
- 20:25series comes out, Surviving R. Kelly. Have you seen it? No?
- 20:27I have not. It is not as good as Leaving Neverland is.
- 20:33It's actually kind of bad in sciences. Is like they use that sort of
- 20:37classic music that was probably invented in the nineties where you know, sort of
- 20:42it's like scary, like in Leaving Neverland. They don't really pull any of
- 20:48those kinds of tricks. No, Actually, the music you hear is mostly
- 20:51the music and the scenes that they show you, right, it's just like
- 20:55a very subtle, subdued like interview with the characters. Surviving R. Kelly
- 21:03plays like a It's almost like it's directed by a reality TV show director,
- 21:07you know what I mean. It's it's it has some really kind of cheesy
- 21:12transitions and stuff, but which you know, it's lifetime, so what are
- 21:15you gonna do? But anyway, similar to Leaving Neverland, Surviving r.
- 21:22Kelly is mainly focused on the victims talking about what happened. Again, extremely
- 21:29convincing. Are these gals that were in the cult and got out. Are
- 21:32these abuse victims from years ago? No, most of them are abuse victims
- 21:37from a long time ago. Or his wife is actually in the documentary a
- 21:41lot too, saying that she was physically abused and controlled. Because I think
- 21:45the cult thing has only been the past few years and those people, yeah,
- 21:53or they're sort of traumatized by the whole thing and they're not willing to
- 21:56come out. So I saw one interview with two of them. I don't
- 22:00know how many they are, and those two were fully on his page defending
- 22:04him staunchly. That kind of right. So he the allegations are physical abuse,
- 22:11humiliating them, forcing them to perform sexual acts on him in public with
- 22:15each other. Like there's these really graphic descriptions of him making like two fourteen
- 22:19year olds have sex with each other, and stuff. Very controlling with the
- 22:23physical abuse. He would make people stand when he entered the room. He
- 22:30would make them be on a cell phone plan, he would make it so
- 22:33they couldn't talk to other people without his permission. He made them dress a
- 22:37certain way. He also wouldn't let them eat food. Great, he would
- 22:41only let them eat food during He would like punish them and say like,
- 22:45if you're good today, I'll get I'll give you food. So like the
- 22:48next guy, right, he wanted them as skinny as possible. Yeah,
- 22:52he determined when they could go to the bathroom, like the women would say,
- 22:56or because because in order to go to another part of the house it
- 23:00was sort of a threat to him because he needed everyone. He needed like
- 23:04this woman to stay in one room, you know what I mean, And
- 23:07she's like, I need to go to the bathroom, so she would have
- 23:10to like call one of his bodyguards. Oh my god, who would talk
- 23:14to R Kelly And then R Kelly would like send a bodyguard or something.
- 23:18He would starve them. He would videotape them having sex, you know,
- 23:22to suppose whack off. But he would also like use the videos to blackmail
- 23:26them and say, like, you know, if you if you don't keep
- 23:30quiet, he would he wouldn't let on tour. He was very controlling too.
- 23:34He wouldn't let the dancers talk to the musicians talk to the you know,
- 23:40the women talk. You know. He kept like he was controlling of
- 23:44everyone because presumably he was like if people start talking, this will be bad
- 23:48for me. I'm sorry, I'm now regretting enjoying in the closet. So
- 23:55let's take a break and we get back. Let's talk about a psychology.
- 23:57What do you say, burtles? So Berto? If R Kelly wrote a
- 24:06song telling people to become a patron of the podcast, what would it sound
- 24:08like in the vein of in the closet? Yeah? For you see a
- 24:15page on the internet and you think should I contribute? You're gonna contribute it?
- 24:19And you think I'm gonna contribute? About how much am I gonna contribute?
- 24:23And then you say I'm gonna give it up? My god, that
- 24:32was like the best improv you've ever done. That was like I thought R
- 24:36Kelly was right here. I was about to indict the man right across from
- 24:41Okay. So, become a patron of the podcast, you get access to
- 24:45all of our best episodes in which Berto doesn't sing okay. So there's many
- 24:49settlements. He has many settlements where girls accuse him of sexual abuse and rape
- 24:57and also gives him cash, gives them settles out of court, and all
- 25:02these cases involve a gag order essentially where non disclosure right where they can't talk
- 25:07about it or else they have to give their money back. This this convention
- 25:11Stormy Daniels kind of thing. Yeah, this convention has got to stop,
- 25:15Like this is this can't this is wrong? Like that shouldn't be an allowed
- 25:21outcome of one of those lossits No, Like I could get like, okay,
- 25:26what is going to stop this lawsuit? Could I just give you a
- 25:27million dollars? Let's just stop the lawsuit now? Okay? Like that makes
- 25:32sense to me. But to stipulate that this human being cannot talk about their
- 25:37experience is just anti constitutional in my in my view, it's anti law.
- 25:45Like why Like, I mean, the only reason why you would ever allow
- 25:49that to be part of a settlement is because you're trying to hide something.
- 25:55You're basically bribing someone to not reveal that you have broken the law. I
- 26:02mean, I mostly agree with you, I could see. So imagine for
- 26:04a second a case that really was you know, someone had a concert,
- 26:11this scal comes back, say, she's of age, she's not a minor.
- 26:15They they make love, and then she accuses him of rape and he
- 26:22really didn't. I mean, it seemed consensual all that stuff, right.
- 26:26They go to the trial and then he just doesn't want to deal with it.
- 26:30So he's like all right, well, find this sucks. I hate
- 26:33you, but how much you need? Fifty grand? Okay, but you
- 26:37can't talk about this because as soon as the rumor's out, people are going
- 26:41to think I did this and I didn't do a fucking shit. So part
- 26:44I'll give you fifty grand, you don't talk about this. I don't think
- 26:48that that should be allowed. Even if he didn't do it, like,
- 26:51let the public decide, then I probably wouldn't give you fifty grand, right,
- 26:53It'd be like fine, well then if you're going to talk about it
- 26:56anyways, then I'm not going to give you fifty Great, then go to
- 26:57court and let it play out. You know. So he uh was indicted
- 27:04for aggravated criminal sexual abuse. There was video evidence. Uh, this is
- 27:10recently. He pleaded not guilty. The judge set a one million dollar bond.
- 27:15He was released after two days. So this is so. This is
- 27:18recently. So he's been apparently there's a number of victims coming forward with a
- 27:23lot of evidence saying that he was aggravated criminal sexual abuse. So he might
- 27:29he might go to prison at some point in the year. When you post
- 27:32bond, When you post bonds, do you ever get that money back or
- 27:37part of it or yeah, I think the idea goes is that you get
- 27:41all the money back. It's just it's like collateral essentially. Right now,
- 27:45a lot of people can't afford the bonds, so they get a a blowan
- 27:52and they have to pay the end like the dog. Yeah is that them?
- 28:00But then they so that to make sure they don't flee because now they
- 28:03have no incentive to come back because they they send the enforcer like the dog.
- 28:07I see. Yeah. So then R Kelly appears on CBS this morning
- 28:15and he cried unconvincingly. Did you see that part? Oh? I did
- 28:18see that. You know, it was the kind of crying you can only
- 28:23go one of the two extremes, either that this person has been so fully
- 28:29wronged that he's so traumatized and actually small parentheses. It is possible that in
- 28:36that moment he it was in fact channeling whatever abuse he did suffer in reality
- 28:41when he was young. But the but not to excuse his behavior. But
- 28:47you know, it's like that doesn't excuse anything. It's just right. He
- 28:49definitely was, in my observation a channeling or acting like a child. Yeah,
- 28:56he was throwing a tantrum. Yeah, the way a four year old
- 29:00would, right, and either he was regressing because of stress, or he
- 29:06was calling on a certain part of himself that has worked with other people but
- 29:11isn't going to work with in that situation. Yeah, and some of the
- 29:14things he was saying, I can already imagine it. I guarantee that,
- 29:18in fact, there have been parents who've thrown their girls at him in the
- 29:23hopes of making money because people are horrible. I also guarantee, though,
- 29:27I know you know that he's he's had so much female attention that I feel
- 29:33like in his mind it's like, you don't get it. I'm the good
- 29:37guy here. I've helped all these people. They throw their daughters at me
- 29:41like they're using me, like I you know, like that kind of thing,
- 29:45kind of like a Michael going like, what all I've been doing is
- 29:48helping these kids? And yeah, yeah, and you know, things like
- 29:52that happen. But when you take all of the reports, right and they
- 29:59just keep coming. Same with Bill Cosby, same with Michael Jackson, same
- 30:03with Kevin Spacey, same with Harvey Weinstein, You're just like, okay,
- 30:08so we're led to believe R. Kelly that all these people with all the
- 30:15consequences of society, with all the death threats, with all the stigma,
- 30:19with all the shame that society heaps on these people, with all the accusations,
- 30:25you know, the disruption to their life, the media attention. You're
- 30:29gonna tell me, like all of these people got together and including your wife,
- 30:33by the way, and decided that because they want to make a little
- 30:37bit of money, which they might not ever get, they're going to like
- 30:41make up this story. Well, and it's been so consistent that goes and
- 30:45there's been criminal charges, you know, like the whole picture is just one
- 30:48grand conspiracy. Well, here's the hypothesis. The hypothesis is, look,
- 30:52I'm rich and famous, this is what happens. Okay, let's test that
- 30:57then, wouldn't we expect a very high percentage of celebrities have the same problem,
- 31:03right, Bill Gates, Paul Allen, the musicians. Yeah, let's
- 31:08just stay with the musicians. So it's like, no, you know,
- 31:14there's only a handful of people that have the accusation gestalt that you have.
- 31:21So he cries unconvincingly, which really propels him into this limelight because now like
- 31:25he's on all the talk shows, everyone's laughing at him. And they also
- 31:29interview two women who are supposedly in the in his sex cult. The parents
- 31:33are saying that they haven't been able to talk to their kids in you know,
- 31:37in years or something, and these two girls are saying they love him,
- 31:42and they're accusing their parents and family of lying and they wanted to get
- 31:47money and they're with him. They defend him, and they start getting emotional
- 31:51too, Like one of them starts really yelling, like, how dare you
- 31:55You know? She's really going crazy. Now, here's the thing. If
- 31:57this is on the up and up, and these two women are totally fine
- 32:01and free to move, there's no shame in two women and one man being
- 32:07in a polyamorous relationship. There's nothing wrong with that. So so if if
- 32:12it's true, then great, it doesn't deny all the other shit that he's
- 32:15done. And I did think the interviewer seated her high ground when she started
- 32:19going in that direction, by the way, because she started asking the one
- 32:22It's like, well, what do you do sexually? And it was like
- 32:24and the other gal rightfully, even though the context rightfully, she was like
- 32:29that's not of your business, right and like, yeah, no, she's
- 32:31an adult. Now you've just made it like given them an out right,
- 32:37Like I thought that was unfortunate because if it had been more about like how
- 32:39did you how did this start? What? You know, like why aren't
- 32:44you talking to your family? Right? Right? All these kinds of things.
- 32:46But as soon as you're like, well, what do you do sexually,
- 32:47it's like, look, now you're trying to get ratings, and I'm
- 32:51an adult and I don't need to tell you about my sex life right now.
- 32:53From from again the gestalt of all the data, right And there's actually
- 32:58at the end of the documentary on lifestyle what's the channel called something the life
- 33:08wise, the god damn it Lifetime, the one of the mothers actually manages
- 33:17to extract one of the young women in his in his cult by like doing
- 33:23detective work, figuring out what hotel they're in. And it's a really it's
- 33:28actually the best sequence in the whole documentary. They filmed the whole thing,
- 33:32and you know, and anyway, so they managed to get her out.
- 33:37A couple days later, she goes back, oh no, but then she
- 33:42gets out again, but she's not talking to but she's not talking to the
- 33:45press at all. As of the recording of this from what I understand,
- 33:52so when we look and when we look at all that, like you just
- 33:54look at all the data, you're just like, well, maybe these two
- 33:58women happen to be on the up and up, but something, there's a
- 34:00lot of other girls who are, you know, they have all the hallmarks
- 34:05of being in a cult. Well, and one of them's eighteen, the
- 34:07other one's like twenty or something. Yeah, And I mean I remember being
- 34:13that age. We've all talked about this so many times, Like you don't
- 34:16have decades of perspective at that age, so it's easy for people to be
- 34:23like, yeah, you know, I just turned eighteen. I'm an adult.
- 34:27I know exactly what everything is, right. We have this weird As
- 34:30I was watching this, you know, documentary, I was thinking, how
- 34:32weird is it that like the day before your eighteenth birthday you're treated like you're
- 34:37eight years old, right, that in relation to a thirty five year old
- 34:43man. Right, But as soon as you're turn eighteen, suddenly you're you're
- 34:46fine, You're totally mature and you're not exploitable, right, and everything's fine.
- 34:52It just seems strange, But of course the law needs that kind of
- 34:57cut off. So the conclusions a are to me, you know that,
- 35:02and this is all based on Internet and you know, documentary information, so
- 35:07god knows if it's true. I mean, R Kelly could not even exist
- 35:10in the real world, and I wouldn't know because I don't I've never met
- 35:14him, So you know, this is all just this is all just me
- 35:19looking at the Internet having barely no knowledge of R. Kelly until two days
- 35:24ago. For all you listeners know, we're not real. Yeah, but
- 35:29there's a lot of arrows pointing towards the conclusion that he's a classic abusive and
- 35:32sadistic psychopath. And as sexual status, he has a very common profile for
- 35:38an intimate partner violence perpetrator. He looks for vulnerable partners who have you know,
- 35:44young women who are probably personality wise a little susceptible to it. He
- 35:50uses his vulnerability to get women to take care of him. So that's something
- 35:52that you probably don't know from the documentary. He there's these sort of repetitive
- 35:58stories because he couldn't read and write, and so he would cry about that
- 36:01to women. It's like what Michael Jackson would do that too, where he
- 36:06would cry and he would you know, appear vulnerable, right, so that
- 36:09sucks people in, right. Then he slowly institutes control over the victim,
- 36:15like through iterative process. He doesn't just slap him on the first date,
- 36:17you know, he uses intimidation and aggression, slowly ramping up. He separates
- 36:23the victim from their support system, particularly their family. He gets control their
- 36:29cell phone and their communication methods. He slowly controls every aspect of their life,
- 36:32from their food intake, their phone, where they hang out, when
- 36:36they go to the bathroom, whether they stand when they have sex with him.
- 36:40He uses blackmail like videotaping confessions. So he's similar to the nexium guy.
- 36:45He would make them videotape confessions as well, or at least that's the
- 36:50allegation. By the way, all this is one of the songs is confession?
- 36:52Right? Is it this in my confession? So, by the way,
- 36:57all this is allegations. You know, there's hasn't been demonstrated in court.
- 37:00Apparently he uses humiliation to break down their defenses. He lies, he
- 37:07denies responsibility, He cycles between abuse and recovery, and when confronted, he
- 37:13uses a lot of smoke and mirrors to distract people by accusing the victims of
- 37:17lying by using emotional manipulation, by using any method possible, like even possibly
- 37:22using the race card, saying that people are being racist towards him. This
- 37:28is classic. The reason why I can just rattle all that off is because
- 37:31this is happening all the time. I've treated perpetrators and victims in almost identical
- 37:37situations. They just happen to not be super famous. This sort of thing
- 37:43is happening down the street, This is happening in your family. It might
- 37:47even be happening to you out there somewhere. And so this is very mundane
- 37:52in my world. It's not very sensational. The only sensational part of it
- 37:55is R. Kelly just happens to be super famous. But when you add
- 38:00up all the super famous people in the world that we know of and you
- 38:05say, well, zero point three percent are going to be intimate partner violence
- 38:09perpetrators, then you're going to have the you know, R. Kelly's pop
- 38:14out. There's it's it's expected. In the same way that if you take
- 38:19a thousand celebrities, like a percentage of them are going to die from heart
- 38:22disease, a percent are going to die from stroke, a percent are going
- 38:27to die from accidents in the same way that inimate partner violence. It's not
- 38:30like it skips over famous people. And if it was going to be like
- 38:32that, the fact that he's rich and famous makes it easier for him to
- 38:37start cults. Well, and it exactly, and it makes it easier for
- 38:40him to do it in plain sight. It also but honestly, a lot
- 38:44of perpetrators get away with it anyway because the victims. So that the victims
- 38:49in this situation have a little bit of advantage because when they speak out,
- 38:52they get attention, like someone will at least now that they it's newsworthy,
- 38:57it's newsworthy someone. And then they instantly get a bunch of people reaching out
- 39:00saying I'm a victim too. They all the other victims in the world.
- 39:05They tweet about it. No one cares, and so they're really alone,
- 39:07you know. So, so R Kelly is the same as Usher, right,
- 39:13because Confessions is by Usher, by Kelly so berdo why would someone do
- 39:21this? Why does R. Kelly do this? It's so destructive? So
- 39:27yeah, So, I mean two thoughts I have. One of them is
- 39:30as far as the age, I do think he probably was In fact,
- 39:34w is there's some reason why he's attracted to that specific age range. That's
- 39:38one. The second part is I think he like he started being able to
- 39:45get away with it, and the more he could get away with it,
- 39:49the more he thought that he would never not be able to get away with
- 39:52it. But is that the foundation, No, No, I think at
- 39:54first it was an impulse. Like I said, I do think that him.
- 40:00You know, at some point in his life he was a sixteen year
- 40:02old, super good looking, super talented kid who would have girlfriends fawning at
- 40:07him. Right, all of a sudden, he's nineteen, you know,
- 40:12doing very well, still very good looking, Scott money, and he still
- 40:15has the same girls fawning around him. But his attraction level seems to be
- 40:20grounded around the fourteen year old range. And then he's twenty five, then
- 40:23he's thirty, and then that attraction never graduates. Right. It's like I
- 40:29just saw an article about how Leo has only dated. The youngest women he's
- 40:32dated are twenty five years old, right, and he keeps going between twenty
- 40:37one and twenty five. Right, So I saw the same graph. Yeah,
- 40:40he's had in the past, you know, fifteen years, like say,
- 40:45eight girlfriends yeah, and as soon as they're they because he meets them
- 40:50when they're before twenty five, right, like when they're twenty or twenty two,
- 40:53and as soon as they're twenty five they break up. Yeah, so
- 40:58either he breaks up with them or they break up with him. But that's
- 41:00there's some weird cutoff that he's never dated someone over twenty five. And the
- 41:07chart goes like that. He goes up to turn it right, thum dumps
- 41:08back down to twenty one. Yeah. So but my point is we don't
- 41:13raise too much of an eyebrow because he's still relatively young and you know,
- 41:17they're all over, they're drinking age at least, and all these things.
- 41:21But in our Kelly's case, of course we because it's like these are fourteen
- 41:23year old girls, right, But his attraction got rooted there. So that's
- 41:28the first part. And then as far as why he started, you know,
- 41:31abusing them and hitting them and all these things, I think I think
- 41:36there's trauma that he is playing out. Yeah. So it's an interesting question,
- 41:40and you answer, you provided a pretty strong hypothesis that's convincing. The
- 41:45fact is is podcast listeners out there. I'm going to answer this question why
- 41:50does our Kelly do this? We don't know. We don't know why anyone
- 41:53does anything, let alone why someone does something as weird as this, because
- 41:57it's really shooting yourself in the foot if you want to have sex, he
- 42:00could have sex in the same way that Bill Cosby could have had sex with
- 42:06whoever he wanted to have sex with. He doesn't need to drug people like
- 42:12people probably would have had sex with, particularly when he was young and not
- 42:15married, do you know what I mean? Like like Michael could have had
- 42:17a string of eighteen year old guys right like it who look really young and
- 42:23look beautiful. All yeah, Like so now granted, as we just said,
- 42:30is that actually okay, it's not illegal, so it it there's why
- 42:37would someone do this. It's such a shot in the foot, like if
- 42:43you over and over, yeah, if you want sex, there's a way
- 42:46to get it with in totally sanctioned ways. And also why would you repeatedly
- 42:55do so it's it's it's it's totally against everything. And also, like the
- 43:00other need we have is for attachment, So that's always something that's sort of
- 43:01left out, is that we need companionship and love and what men are taught
- 43:12to get that through sexuality. So they might not cuddle, but they'll have
- 43:16sex, right when really all they want to do is just to have some
- 43:21physical warmth. They don't necessarily need to have sex anyway. So there are
- 43:23a number of different hypotheses. One is that he is he has sadistic personality
- 43:29disorder. There's a lot of evidence of this. I mean to pee in
- 43:32someone's mouth, to hit them, to keep them incarcerated, essentially, Right,
- 43:39That sadistic personality disorder is marked by you actually get pleasure from harming other
- 43:49people, either sexually or otherwise. Right, and who records like a twenty
- 43:55some part series with all the same melody over and over that same The other
- 44:01hypothesis is that this is a compulsion, meaning that he doesn't actually super want
- 44:07to do it, but it's an itch that he has to scratch for some
- 44:10compulsive reason. And there's some evidence of this. One of his bodyguards or
- 44:16colleagues or something. In the documentary talks about how R. Kelly went to
- 44:22him and said, I can't stop videotaping me having sex with these young girls.
- 44:28This is a problem. I need to stop, Like, can you
- 44:30help me stop? Now? That's just one report who knows, who knows
- 44:35what he meant by that? Was he just going like, oh my god,
- 44:38was the button stuck? He's like that it can't stop the tape?
- 44:42Yeah, So was it a compulsion? Maybe there's certainly a lot of cases
- 44:47of sexual assault individuals, people who commit sexual assaults who are definitely acting on
- 44:55a compulsion where they have a more they're not said they don't get pleasure from
- 45:01harming other people, but it's just like this itch that they can't stop,
- 45:06but they have to scratch it. Another hypothesis is that it's learned behavior,
- 45:10you know, given that he was sexually abuse, just like, well,
- 45:13this is just what you do. This is what sexuality is. What's wrong
- 45:16with exploiting other people? That's what I learned. Another one that people will
- 45:22say that you alluded to as like a secondary cause, which is because he
- 45:25can, right, because he has power, Which is a silly idea to
- 45:30think of it as a foundational thing because plenty of people can and don't because
- 45:35no one wants to harm other people. And that, yeah, that one
- 45:37I really meant more of like the scale of his abuse is like, you
- 45:42know, if I guess to your point, maybe it really doesn't matter so
- 45:46much. But clearly, if someone lives in a big mansion with a lot
- 45:52of secret rooms and bodyguards and you can't people can't peer in the windows that
- 45:57you can hide who comes and goes, it really facilitates a lot of shady
- 46:00behavior. You know, where you live in an apartment next to neighbors,
- 46:06you know they might actually start smelling the dead bodies in your fridge. Yeah,
- 46:10so that's another whole thing is all the people who knew about what was
- 46:15happening should be implicated as well. Right, they actually facilitated it in a
- 46:20lot of instances. And the last factor that I think is actually very much
- 46:24likely, it's the new way that I kind of see all these people is
- 46:30through an attachment theory lens, which is that he grew up without a very
- 46:36secure attachment, probably with very disorganized attachment style, and everyone needs attachment,
- 46:42and he when you have problems with attaching, you don't trust other people,
- 46:46you don't love yourself, you might end up resorting to these very odd,
- 46:52narrow behaviors to get your attachment needs met. But ultimately they only work kind
- 46:58of and he might have said, well, I'm just gonna have sex with
- 47:02these so because another factor that you can think of in terms of why someone
- 47:06would have because you're like, well, he's attracted to that age. Another
- 47:08possibility is that he's attracted to people that he can control. Yeah, yeah,
- 47:14right, And younger people are easier to control, And why does he
- 47:16want to control them? Well? Is it a sadism thing? Or is
- 47:21it a security thing? Because the younger the person, the more able you
- 47:24are to make sure they don't leave you. Sure, And anyway, so
- 47:30why did he get away with it for so long? Burdow? What are
- 47:32some reasons here? We've already named one, which is that he had a
- 47:36lot of resources, right, I think he is beloved and his music is
- 47:43beloved by a lot of people, and just like with Michael and others,
- 47:46we just don't want to believe it, man, We don't want our heroes
- 47:50to be like this. Right, any other reasons you can think? There's
- 47:53also I guess maybe you know this idea of these girls must want it,
- 48:02you know, like they must be complicit because they you know, yeah,
- 48:07they're young, but they must want it because he's a famous How could they
- 48:09not want to be with r Kelly? Oh god, I see what you're
- 48:13saying. Okay, so you're saying, like an onlooker would say, yeah,
- 48:16she must want it. Like like I could imagine some people say how
- 48:20you were literally saying they must want Oh no, no, I'm saying like
- 48:22some some people might say, well, yeah, it's not good that they're
- 48:27underage, but let's who are we kidding? He's our Kelly. Who wouldn't
- 48:30want to be with R Kelly? Right? Good? Yeah. Other factors
- 48:34I would say is misogyny and hip hop in general, right and R and
- 48:38B. I mean if you just watch the videos, yeah, you're just
- 48:43like, well, yeah, of course our Kelly's doing stuff like that.
- 48:45I mean, that's what they all do. He's flaunting it with like this
- 48:49is the same thing with Michael and stuff. It's so in your face actually,
- 48:52because like the one you were saying about Aliyah, the video is and
- 48:55the song is about that, right right, And the documentary kind of goes
- 49:00into that. Another thing that the documentary goes into is the some African Americans
- 49:06in the documentary they're talking about how for the black community he was a hero
- 49:09to them and they didn't want to believe. You know. It's like with
- 49:15OJ, remember, like we don't want OJ brought down, he's one of
- 49:19our heroes. Yeah, at the height of the interests of the media,
- 49:23they would do polls and they would find that two thirds of black people thought
- 49:27oj was innocent, whereas two thirds of white people thought he was guilty.
- 49:32Also, stigma to the victims not wanting to come forward in the families.
- 49:37So that's another factor that's our fault as to why this would have gone on
- 49:42for so for decades. Also, there's a movement I can't remember the exact
- 49:46phrase, but it's something to do with like female black lives Matter or young
- 49:51girl black lives matter. Because if these were all white girls, can you
- 49:54imagine the response from our society would have been like, yeah, I would
- 50:00have been. I mean. The other factor is that this started at a
- 50:06time where information didn't get out like it does now, right exactly. So
- 50:12I thought we would go over the dark tetrad the four different personality traits that
- 50:17we use to measure evil behavior in people. So there are four different personality
- 50:22traits that are as sociated the cute from hell Raiser, right exactly. So
- 50:28they all correlate with each other, but they are distinct personality traits. The
- 50:31first one is psychopathy, which is essentially the absence of empathy, the indifference
- 50:37of feelings for other people, the lack of remorse. It's not necessarily sadistic,
- 50:43though, it's just like you're just sort of indifferent to other people's feelings.
- 50:47Does he have this personality trait? I don't know. He's been very,
- 50:54very productive and successful, so, you know, a lot of the
- 50:58things we've discussed before it psychopathy, like well in the dark tech trad language,
- 51:02it's not the full her psychopath. It's it's just it's mainly absence of
- 51:07empathy. Oh, I see, I don't know. Maybe a bit certainly
- 51:13for his victims in that sense, but I would say one hundred percent you
- 51:17would say, oh yeah, like two, you haven't seen the documentary.
- 51:22So the way the women talk about the way he treated them, he indicates
- 51:28he did not care about their feelings. Fair enough, I guess I just
- 51:30don't know, Like, you know, what his what would his family say,
- 51:32would other people around him say? What? You know? What would
- 51:36be the general consensus, Well, the general consensus from all the women,
- 51:38and there's dozens of women in the documentary is that in the beginning he's really
- 51:43nice, but it always it always takes a turn. Number two is narcissism,
- 51:49which essentially is the concept of narcissistic personality disorder totally how so, I
- 51:55mean so I think, as we've said before, it goes with it territory
- 52:00of being on a stage. But I mean, this guy, he made
- 52:04a twenty some part series of like, I don't know, to me as
- 52:09far as performers and artists go, if I was ranking them, I would
- 52:14rank him pretty high because he's a brand name, you know, in a
- 52:17way, and he's it doesn't even I believe I've heard him speak of himself
- 52:24in the third person, So I don't know, I'd say, yes,
- 52:29that's harder to say. Honestly, you and I are not on these two.
- 52:34Narcissism is it's not just being a famous person, it's an overall personality
- 52:40trait is he's self centered. Yeah, but you know, narcisism is like
- 52:46grandiose and that kind of thing. I mean, you saw that crying performance,
- 52:51right, Like, yeah, but that's not narcissism. That's manipulation,
- 52:53which is our next one, which is machiavellianism, which is named after Nikolo
- 52:59mcaven who wrote about politics I believe in Italy, which is the personality trait
- 53:05of being manipulative making plans. It's not like impulsive, it's like ahead in
- 53:09advance, I'm going to do these things to manipulate. Again, not necessarily
- 53:15sadistic or overtly harmful. It just means you're really you, you scheme ahead
- 53:20of time. You know, is does he exhibit that? Well? The
- 53:23fact that he's like compartmentalized people and like he has these rules about what they
- 53:28do, and then he like has convinced people over time to be in this
- 53:31cult seems like that. Yeah, it seems like a fair dose of it
- 53:37for sure. In order to particularly have a cult, like you really have
- 53:42to like have a scheme. But that's what I was saying, Like to
- 53:45me, narcissism fits too, because who has a cult? And who who
- 53:50turns around being asked about these victims into your the victim? I am the
- 53:54victim here? Do you see what I'm saying? Yeah, I just don't
- 53:58think you're using the working definition narcissism that they're getting at in the dark tet
- 54:01trad And the fourth one is sadism. So this is really the kicker of
- 54:07the evil behavior. So you can be you can have a lack of empathy.
- 54:10But you can be a psychopath, you can be narcissistic, you can
- 54:14be machiavelia, and you can have macuvelism, and those are called the dark
- 54:19triad. But none of those actually involved pleasure in harming other human beings.
- 54:23So you could have a good dose of the dark triad and never actually do
- 54:29dark behavior. It's associated with dark behavior because Bundy was a tet trad for
- 54:32example, right, because he actually really enjoyed harming other human beings. He
- 54:37he from an early age he was like, I have a desire to rape
- 54:43and kill, like the empathy he had. Yeah. Yeah, So so
- 54:49he's a much better case of because he's like delusionally grandios you No, that
- 54:53makes sense. And then he he planned very much all the time, and
- 54:59he was clear, Yeah he planned how to how to break out of how
- 55:02to break out of prison. We got to do an episode about that documentary.
- 55:06But anyway, so does he does r Kelly exhibit sadism? Yes he
- 55:13does. Right, So when you rape people and all, especially repeatedly,
- 55:17in all likelihood, you're doing it because you actually get off. Yeah you
- 55:22you when you for sexual sadists and sadists in general, when you are having
- 55:31sex with someone just the way that most people have sex. Uh, you
- 55:37actually don't get any pleasure from that. You pretty much only get pleasure if
- 55:42there's an element of you overpowering or harming other people. You are dominating them
- 55:49and they know they're being dominated and it's against their will, you know,
- 55:53or there's some element of that in there, And he repeatedly did that.
- 56:00Do you know where the word sadism came from? Burta Marquis de Sade?
- 56:04Yeah, yeah, do you know his story? Uh? Yeah. In
- 56:07fact, have you ever heard of the movie Salo? Yeah? I have
- 56:12not been able to actually watch all of it because it is Yeah, it's
- 56:17like the worst movie to watch traumatic wise. Well, yeah, you know
- 56:22what happened to me, Like I used to be able to watch movies like
- 56:25that pretty detached, and when I watched The Reversible, for example, it
- 56:31was really like oh grotesque and stuff, but I was like, I can
- 56:35watch this. Something happened to me as I got a little older and I
- 56:38started empathizing more or something, and I was like I just can't. This
- 56:45is too much. Yeah, that's evidence of maturity. So we tend to
- 56:51think of ourselves as like, oh, I'm twenty five. I'm mature.
- 56:54Yeah, no, you're not. There are so many markers further development beyond
- 57:00the age of twenty five, thirty five, forty five, and one of
- 57:04them is empathy, giving to other people, caring about the world, and
- 57:10upon watching images of harm to other people, even if they're fictional, it's
- 57:17much harder for mature people to handle that, you know, not always,
- 57:22but in general. So you just matured, Berto. So let's end with
- 57:30identifying other musicians who also had a thing for young people, so we can
- 57:35shame them as well. Who can we point out burto pretty young thing?
- 57:39I want to Well, we've talked about Michael Oh my god, I hadn't
- 57:43even thought about that pyt one of the best songs. I mean, I
- 57:50hadn't even thought about that. Yeah, oh my god, oh my yah.
- 57:59Yeah that his way is human nature kind of about something. Well,
- 58:06human isture was actually written by the guy from a Toto Oh okay, yeah,
- 58:10really, yeah, hilarious. That's a great song. Other musicians with
- 58:15young people, huh Aerosmith, did he really? I don't know, I
- 58:22don't know how young they were, but I mean his videos and you know,
- 58:24stuff like that, So well, Paul McCartney had a song called well
- 58:30she was just seventeen and you know what I mean, that's true, but
- 58:34he was twenty one at the time. And actually he wrote that one.
- 58:37He was probably eighteen, Yeah, he was probably, but but oh,
- 58:40I was gonna say so. Remember rag Doll, Yeah, rag Doll living
- 58:45in the movies Hot Tramp, Daddy's Little Cutie. Yeah, so fine,
- 58:51never see me leaving in the back door? Well, I remember when we
- 58:53read the lyrics, Yes, that other Aerosmith's song Loving and Eleant No,
- 58:58no, it was it was well I think it might have been walked this
- 59:02way if I remember, right. And oh, anyway, Jerry Lee Lewis
- 59:07married his thirteen year old cousin. Oh right, Elvis started dating Priscilla when
- 59:14she was fourteen, right, I just read that the other day. Oh
- 59:16you know why, man? What about isms? Someone on Facebook was like,
- 59:22well, if you're gonna go after our kill, you better start hating
- 59:24Elvis too, And then they posted that thing. I was like, well,
- 59:27I didn't know that, sure, I mean, I wouldn't be opposed
- 59:30to that. It's a little different in that he didn't have a pattern and
- 59:34he wasn't raping people definitely, and Priscilla herself would has come forward and say
- 59:40like, I'm fine with it. I'm also going to say something that we
- 59:44need to remember. And it's not that, hey, because because a thousand
- 59:49years ago it is okay to do human sacrifice, human sacrifice is still okay.
- 59:52No, it's just that if all of a sudden we were transported back
- 59:58in time and we're meeting some one on the streets and we're talking about our
- 1:00:00lives and they go like, oh, yeah, last weekend, I sacrificed
- 1:00:04a couple people on the altar. If we were like, oh my god,
- 1:00:07you're a psychopathic monster, we would be misunderstanding the reality of the time.
- 1:00:12And in the South in the fifties and forties and before that, it
- 1:00:17was not uncommon for people to get married at a younger age, or at
- 1:00:21least to date at a younger So that doesn't mean we wouldn't have wanted to.
- 1:00:24Hey, let's maybe we can educate these people to not do that,
- 1:00:28right. But yeah, so I'm not saying, hey, that's totally fine,
- 1:00:31just very different. It's not apples and apples. Well, let's just
- 1:00:35say, as an analogy, in one hundred years, one thousand years,
- 1:00:39which I could totally see happening. Our age of consent bumps up to like
- 1:00:44the age twenty two. We live to be one hundred and fifty years old.
- 1:00:46We understand that, like nineteen isn't really that old, so we're like,
- 1:00:51you know what we're gonna you can't get married until you're twenty two.
- 1:00:53We don't want it. You know, we've had cases of like nineteen year
- 1:00:57olds getting tricked. And yet someone's like, did you know Bardo when he
- 1:01:00was forty four married an eighteen year old? Right? So? Or that
- 1:01:05at eighteen and that two nineteen year olds got married. You know, My
- 1:01:08parents, for example, were nineteen with they so. Gary Puckett had a
- 1:01:15song, young girl in nineteen sixty eight, Right, young girl, get
- 1:01:19out of my mind. My love for you is well out of line.
- 1:01:23But it's one girl. You're much too young girl, But he does know
- 1:01:30it's out of line. Let's listen to the verses. Though, with all
- 1:01:34the charms of a woman, you've kept the secret of your youth. Ooh,
- 1:01:39you led me to believe you're old enough to give me love. And
- 1:01:44now it hurts to know the truth beneath your beneath your perfume and your makeup.
- 1:01:49You're just a baby in disguise. And though you know that it's wrong
- 1:01:52to be alone with me, that come on look is in your eyes.
- 1:01:57Oh man, So hurry home to your mom. I'm sure she wonders where
- 1:02:00you are. Get out of here before I have time to change my mind,
- 1:02:04because I'm afraid we'll go too far. Yeah. Then that song was
- 1:02:08such a hit. It was like number one in the UK, number two
- 1:02:10in the United States. The next year, he released another song called This
- 1:02:15Girl is a Woman Now and Lerisco This girl walked in my This girl walked
- 1:02:22in dreams, played in a world of her own. This girl was a
- 1:02:25child existing in a playground of stone. Then one night her world was changed.
- 1:02:31Her life and dreams were rearranged, and she would never be the same
- 1:02:37again. This girl is a woman now, and she's learning how to give.
- 1:02:40This girl is a woman now. She found out what it's all about
- 1:02:45and she's learning learning to live. Wow, I wonder what he's talking about.
- 1:02:52What about Brown Sugar? So that Yeah, there's a number of songs
- 1:02:54we can play to that have a lot of that kind of thing. So
- 1:03:00there's kind of a tradition on some level of musicians. Again, when you
- 1:03:05take thousands of musicians and you and you, and you know, two percent
- 1:03:08of them have this issue, you're going to see it pop up. I
- 1:03:13don't know if Gary Puppett Puckett was that way. Who knows. Again,
- 1:03:17times are different back then. Uh you know there fact that Young Girl was
- 1:03:22a number one hit in the UK, number two United States and there wasn't
- 1:03:25a single question as to whether these lyrics were okay. I mean, I
- 1:03:31would say that that song was just a you know, just and it's right
- 1:03:37there, Young Girl Get out of my mind. That song was a regular
- 1:03:42repeat customer on classic music stations. I'm guessing until present day. What about
- 1:03:47Thank Heaven for Little Girls? I don't know who does that one. I
- 1:03:52don't know jar part you, I don't know who's saying it originally, Thank
- 1:03:55Heaven Gerard Party. So in conclusion, what I'll say about R. Kelly
- 1:04:01is that I don't know what's really happening. I'm not an investigator, I'm
- 1:04:05not a journalist, I'm not a lawyer. I'm not him. I'm not
- 1:04:09one of the victims. But after watching the documentary, which is you know,
- 1:04:13seems credible, it seems that he has been systematically abusing people basically right
- 1:04:18out in the open, with a lot of people knowing about it, and
- 1:04:23you know, particularly girls age twelve to seventeen, and now he's moved on
- 1:04:28to adults to control them. And it's really quite scary right now, there
- 1:04:32are probably people in his world who are really quite afraid, really quite afraid
- 1:04:39to come out. It's not it wouldn't be surprising that in the future we
- 1:04:42learned that those two women who were defending him, you know, ten years
- 1:04:45from now, they come out and they say, the only reason why I
- 1:04:47was doing that was because he had dirt on me that I legitimately thought I
- 1:04:53was going to get in trouble for. He said. He told me,
- 1:05:00and I totally believed him, that he had paid a hitman to kill someone
- 1:05:03who had died, and he showed me the news report this person died because
- 1:05:08they you know, I wanted them dead. I have the money, I
- 1:05:12have the man power. I know. You know, you don't think I
- 1:05:15can kill someone. You don't think I know people who can kill people.
- 1:05:18I know people I could kill you. I could kill your family, and
- 1:05:21I'll get away with it because that's who I am. Like if someone does
- 1:05:27that, which is not that unusual for someone like that to do, then
- 1:05:30all bets are off. You can't say anything to anybody because if he can
- 1:05:35kill you anywhere in the world, and he can kill all the people you
- 1:05:39love anywhere in the world, what are you going to do. The other
- 1:05:43thing is the stock It's like the mob right. The other thing is Stockholm
- 1:05:45syndrome, which you haven't talked about. When you are especially again when you're
- 1:05:50young, and they protect you, know, they sort of separate you from
- 1:05:54everybody, then you start believing the hype, you know, and the same
- 1:06:00way that sexual abuse victims, they'll you just convince yourself like, Okay,
- 1:06:04this is good, you know, because you have a choice. It's like
- 1:06:09I either question this and experience a lot of fear and pain, or I
- 1:06:13just give over to it and believe that, believe everything, and lo and
- 1:06:16behold. I feel a lot better because I don't have to question what's happening
- 1:06:19to me. I don't know if that's happening. I suspect that's what's happening,
- 1:06:25and I really really hope that there's some solution and respite so we can
- 1:06:30end the wave of destruction that this man has been perpetrating on the world.
- 1:06:34I really really hope that our legal system can finally, after twenty five years,
- 1:06:41finally do something about this. Yeah, man, I am so sad
- 1:06:46that there's you know, it seems to be a lot of cases that are
- 1:06:50coming out that are on the one hand, ruining things that we thought were
- 1:06:56pure or great. But the more important part is how many victims there have
- 1:07:00been, you know, that's just sad. Yeah, And many of them
- 1:07:06have come forward, They've they've gone to court, there's been videotapes, there's
- 1:07:13you know, and it's just like, how does this happen? I just
- 1:07:16don't understand. And the only thing I can think of is like our society
- 1:07:21is just set up in such a way that it just allows this sort of
- 1:07:25thing to happen, you know, And I just it's really upsetting because it's
- 1:07:30not just these victims. There are millions upon millions of people currently being abused
- 1:07:36in situations like this right now, and they don't have an easy way out
- 1:07:42of that. I mean, you know, I've worked with people who have
- 1:07:46been in much lesser severe domestic violence relationships and they feel like they can't get
- 1:07:51out because when you have someone that if it's if you're one of those people
- 1:07:57who's watching the news and the documentary and you're like, well, I don't
- 1:08:00understand, why don't the women just walk away? The issue is like when
- 1:08:04somebody exhibits to you that they're capable of taking it to another level by implication,
- 1:08:13you just know that if you do something that really pisses them off,
- 1:08:17they're going to escalate up another ladder that's even higher, and you just doesn't
- 1:08:23take a genius to figure out what's at the top of that ladder. It's
- 1:08:26murder, it's dismemberment, it's killing everyone. You know, people do that.
- 1:08:31It's not unheard of, especially a person like r Kelly, where it's
- 1:08:34like you have all this money and you know who, I don't know if
- 1:08:38he's making those kinds of threats. But in my experience, you don't even
- 1:08:42have to make those kinds of threats. When you exhibit that you're willing to
- 1:08:45take it to a very strange, aggressive place. There's this implication there of
- 1:08:49just like you know, like just as a microcosm of this, when abusive
- 1:08:56people are trying to intimidate but they're trying to avoid actually put hands on what
- 1:09:00they do is they will break an object. You know, they're in a
- 1:09:03fight with their spouse and the husband picks up a chair and throws it against
- 1:09:08the wall. Well, it's like you said, well, you know,
- 1:09:10he's just abusing a chair. The implication is clear. If you don't stop,
- 1:09:15this is going to be your head. That is a clear threat.
- 1:09:17And actually in Washington State that's considered a crime, even though it's an assault
- 1:09:23for usually, so even though you actually haven't put hands on the person,
- 1:09:28the implication which is so great because it's so clearly intimidated, and so imagine
- 1:09:35what you could do beyond that on a day by day basis and never actually
- 1:09:42have to, you know, overtly threaten someone. The implications are there.
- 1:09:46And when you are in a state of terror and uncertainty and all you have
- 1:09:51to do is just comply to make your fear go down fifty percent, then
- 1:09:58that's what you're going to do, especially when you have a society that isn't
- 1:10:02set up to help people like this. And another factor that just pops into
- 1:10:06my head is because of mistreatment to African Americans by the legal system and by
- 1:10:12the justice system and by the law enforcement system, I wonder how many of
- 1:10:17these African American women are just like, well, I'm not going to go
- 1:10:19with the police. You can't trust them. They don't have a good track
- 1:10:23record with me and my family, so you know, I've got to do
- 1:10:27this on my own. Actually, there's this scene in the documentary where I
- 1:10:30was like, oh my god, because like, if you allow me,
- 1:10:35is the mom goes into the hotel where she has heard that her kid is
- 1:10:41inside. She goes up to the room. The manager actually like, let's
- 1:10:45leads her up there in this like like totally random and they're filming with on
- 1:10:48cell phones. They get up there, she actually reunites with her daughter in
- 1:10:54the doorway and she's like, you know, you got to come with me,
- 1:10:58you know. And the daughter's just kind of like in his daze,
- 1:11:00and she's looking at the cameras and she's just like, oh my god,
- 1:11:03and she's like, you know, I gotta go, and so she goes.
- 1:11:09The mom comes downstairs. She's crying. She's like, I can't believe
- 1:11:12I finally saw my little baby. I finally saw her. You know,
- 1:11:15I just need her to get out of there. She looks so scared.
- 1:11:17Wow. R Kelly somehow calls the cops on them and tells the hotel people
- 1:11:24to not let him in. The mom is having like another phone conversation with
- 1:11:30the with the kid on the hotel phone at the front desk. The mom
- 1:11:35is like, at this point, it's like, well, the cops have
- 1:11:40kicked them out of the hotel and there's not a lot the mom can do.
- 1:11:43At this point, She's like, you know, if I go up,
- 1:11:45if I enter the hotel, they're going to kick me out. My
- 1:11:47daughter is right up there. And at this point, I'm like, get
- 1:11:53a lawyer, you know, get a lawyer, call the police, get
- 1:11:58get a team of law abiding system people and approach the you know, get
- 1:12:05a DV expert, call a domestic violence advocate, they know, legal people,
- 1:12:12you know, get a team. But you know what, she didn't
- 1:12:15do that. She's just like, no one's gonna do that to me.
- 1:12:17And she just like storms into the hotel and I'm like, oh no,
- 1:12:21like you're going to go to jail, you know what I mean, Like,
- 1:12:26this is not what you should be doing. Heartbreaking, Yeah, but
- 1:12:32she got her out right. So but anyway, in that moment, I
- 1:12:35was just like, you know, with all my privilege of trusting the system.
- 1:12:42I would call the system, but to someone who doesn't trust the system
- 1:12:45for good reasons, you got to take matters in your own hand, and
- 1:12:49it basically means you're let you have less power because you end up, you
- 1:12:55know, the cops show up. You're creating a scene. Yeah right,
- 1:13:00anyway, did we already do final word for you, Bertle? No?
- 1:13:05Yes I did. Actually I said that I was sad that there were so
- 1:13:08many victims, which is funny, I'm laughing, haha. Well that doesn't
- 1:13:13for that episode of Psychology and Shadow. Thanks for joining us out there.
- 1:13:15Please take care of yourself because you deserve it.