Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Negotiate a Starting Salary Before You Have an Offer
Transcript
- Lucas: You're in the second round of interviews. Things are going well. And then the recruiter asks: 'What salary range are you looking for?' You haven't even seen an offer yet. What do you do? Luna: That moment is so loaded. Most people either lowball themselves or say 'I'm flexible' and lose all leverage. Lucas: Exactly. And conventional wisdom says 'never be the first to name a number.' But in practice, that advice can backfire. If you refuse to give a range, some employers will just assume you're out of their budget and move on. Or they'll anchor low themselves. Luna: So what's the better move? Because I think a lot of us have been trained to dodge that question until we have an offer in hand. Lucas: The better move is to prepare a range before you ever step into the first interview. Not a single number — a range. And you base it on real market data, not what you wish you earned. For example, a marketing coordinator in Chicago who's been in role for two years might look at salary surveys, Glassdoor, and comparable job postings. She finds the median is around fifty-five thousand, the seventy-fifth percentile is about sixty-five. So she sets her floor at fifty-eight and her target at sixty-two. Luna: That's really specific. And then when the recruiter asks, she says something like 'Based on my research and experience, I'm targeting a range between fifty-eight and sixty-five thousand.' Lucas: Exactly. Notice the top of her range is above her actual target. That gives her room to negotiate down to sixty-two and still feel good. And she adds a phrase like 'but I'm open to discussing the full package based on responsibilities and growth opportunity.' That signals flexibility without caving. Luna: I like that because it frames the conversation as collaborative. You're not making a demand; you're sharing your research. And it invites them to respond with their own range. Lucas: Right. And here's the key — she says this in the second round, before any offer. That's actually the sweet spot. Too early, and you haven't built enough value. Too late, and they've already set a number in their head. The second or third interview is when they're already invested in you and more willing to adjust. Luna: You mentioned market data. What if someone is switching industries or doesn't have great sources? How do you build a credible range? Lucas: Good question. You can use free tools — levels dot fyi for tech, Glassdoor, LinkedIn salary, even the Bureau of Labor Statistics for more traditional roles. You can also talk to three people in similar roles at comparable companies. Not your future boss — that's awkward. But a former colleague or someone in your network. The goal isn't perfection, it's being in the ballpark. Employers respect that you did your homework. Luna: And what about the fear that naming a range will take you out of the running if it's too high? Lucas: That fear is real, but it's often overblown. If you're reasonably within ten to twenty percent of what they budgeted, they'll usually come back and say 'Our range is actually fifty to fifty-five — can you work with that?' Then you have a real conversation. If they ghost you over a salary range, they probably weren't going to be a good employer anyway. A well-run company will negotiate. Luna: So the worst case is you find out early that the role isn't a fit. That saves everyone time. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually a positive outcome. I'd rather learn in round two that we're ten thousand apart than after four rounds and an offer. Luna: We should also talk about what to do if you have competing offers or other interviews. Does that change the conversation? Lucas: It does. If you're in process with another company that pays higher, you can say 'I'm also considering a role at a company where the compensation band is higher, but I'm really excited about this position because of X. Is there room to get closer to that range?' That's honest and leverages your options without being aggressive. Luna: That's a great script. I've heard people say 'I have another offer for sixty-five' but that can sound like a threat. Your version keeps it about your enthusiasm. Lucas: Exactly. You want them to want you, not feel cornered. The best negotiators make the other side feel like they're getting a great deal too. Luna: I think a lot of listeners get tripped up on the very first question — 'What are your salary expectations?' — especially in an online application form where they force you to put a number. What do you do there? Lucas: That's a tough one. If there's a text box, I often put a range like '55,000–65,000' or 'negotiable.' If it's a required field with a dropdown, I pick the highest option that still feels reasonable. The key is, that field is not a binding commitment. It's an HR filter. You can always revisit the number in person. But never put a number so low that you'd resent it if they offered it. Luna: And if you're early in your career — say, a recent grad — is it okay to not have a number at all? Lucas: It's okay, but it's not ideal. Even a recent grad can research the typical starting salary for their major and city. For example, an entry-level accountant in Dallas might see a range of fifty to fifty-five. You can say 'I'm looking for something in the low to mid-fifties, but I'm most focused on finding the right fit.' That shows you've done the work. Luna: I want to circle back to something you said earlier about adding flexibility. Can you give an example of the exact phrasing you'd use right after stating your range? Lucas: Sure. 'I'm targeting a base salary between fifty-eight and sixty-five thousand, but I'm open to discussing the full compensation package — including bonus, equity, and benefits — as well as the growth trajectory of the role.' That way, if they come in at fifty-eight but offer a great bonus structure, you can still say yes. Luna: That's really helpful. It keeps the door open and shows you're reasonable. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the mindset we want listeners to have. You're not fighting for every dollar. You're building a career relationship that starts with transparency. Luna: Before we wrap this part, I want to say something that might resonate with our listeners. We talk a lot about career tactics on this show, and it's because we genuinely believe that better career skills lead to better lives. And a big part of why we can keep doing this — no ads, no sponsors — is that a group of listeners supports us through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small number of people, but it makes a huge difference. So if you've gotten value from episodes like this one, that's one way to keep it going. Lucas: Yeah, that's exactly right. And it's not about pressure — it's about knowing that the show is listener-funded and ad-free because of that support. So thanks to anyone who's chipped in. Now, back to salary negotiation — let's talk about what happens after you state your range. How do you handle the pause? Luna: The silence. That's the worst part. Lucas: It is. But you have to resist the urge to fill it. After you state your range, just stop. Let them respond. If they say 'That's a bit above our budget,' you can ask 'Can you share what the budgeted range is?' And then you have a real number to work with. Luna: And if they say 'We can do sixty,' but it's at the bottom of your range, what then? Lucas: You can say 'Thank you, I'm excited about the role. Based on my experience and the market data I shared, I was hoping for something closer to sixty-three. Is there any flexibility on the base, or could we look at a signing bonus or additional vacation time to bridge the gap?' That keeps the conversation moving forward. Luna: I love that you bring up non-salary levers. Total compensation is more than base pay. Lucas: Absolutely. Especially at startups or smaller companies, equity, flexible hours, professional development budgets, even a title bump can be worth real money. And sometimes they're more willing to give on those than on base salary because they don't hit the budget the same way. Luna: So the overarching strategy is: prepare early, use a researched range, state it confidently, and then negotiate the whole package. And all of this happens before you even have a formal offer. Lucas: Exactly. And the beauty of doing it early is that by the time the offer arrives, the salary conversation is already ninety percent done. You're just confirming the details. That reduces anxiety for everyone. Luna: I think that's a powerful takeaway. One last question: what if you mess up and give a number that's too low early on? Can you recover? Lucas: You can, but it's tricky. You can say 'After learning more about the role and its responsibilities, I realize my initial range was based on a different level of scope. Given the seniority of this position, I'd be targeting something closer to sixty-five.' That's honest because you genuinely learned more. But it's easier to just get it right the first time. Luna: Fair enough. Alright, I think we've given listeners a solid playbook. Let's leave them with one actionable step. Lucas: Before your next interview, spend twenty minutes researching a realistic salary range for that role in your city. Write it down. Then practice saying it out loud — 'I'm targeting a range between X and Y.' It feels awkward at first, but it gets easier. And it could be worth thousands of dollars over your career. Luna: That's the kind of homework that pays off. Thanks for the great advice, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to everyone listening. We'll be back next time with another career question.