Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Illusory Truth Effect Shapes Office Beliefs
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, quick test for you. I say the phrase 'the early bird catches the worm'. Does that feel true to you? Luna: I mean, yeah, it's a cliché, but sure, it has a ring of truth. Lucas: Now I tell you that in the 1970s, a group of psychologists found that repeating a statement makes it more likely you'll believe it, even if the statement is completely false. That's the illusory truth effect, and it's not just about old sayings. It shapes what you believe about your coworkers, your boss, and even your own performance. Luna: That sounds like it belongs in our office politics wheelhouse. So how does repetition fool us exactly? Lucas: Look, the brain uses fluency as a shortcut. When something feels easy to process because you've heard it before, it incorrectly tags that ease as truth. Researchers like Lynn Hasher in 1977 demonstrated that repeated statements are rated as more true, even when they contradict known facts. And it gets worse with age — older adults are more susceptible, but honestly, we're all vulnerable. Luna: And in an office, that means the guy who repeats a rumor three times at the water cooler starts to sound credible, even if he's making it up. Lucas: Exactly. And this isn't just about gossip. It affects performance reviews, project decisions, even who gets promoted. If someone repeatedly says 'Sarah's not a team player', eventually that becomes the accepted narrative, regardless of evidence to the contrary. Luna: Before we dive deeper, I want to mention something. This show is ad-free, and that's only possible because a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It literally funds making this many episodes. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group, but it keeps us going. If you've found our career episodes useful, that's the place. We're glad to have you along either way. Luna: So back to the illusory truth effect. What's a concrete example from office life? Lucas: Take a colleague named James. In a meeting, someone mentions that James missed a deadline last quarter. It wasn't true — his project was delayed because a vendor shipped late. But the comment gets repeated in a hallway chat, then in an email thread, then in a performance review. By the third repetition, 'James misses deadlines' feels like a fact. Luna: And the crazy part is, even if someone corrects it, the correction doesn't stick as well because it's said once, while the false claim has been repeated three times. Lucas: That's the kicker. In a 2015 study, researchers found that even when people know a statement is false, repetition can still increase their belief in it. So the correction has to be repeated, too, and it often isn't. Luna: So how do you fight back if you're the one being mischaracterized? Lucas: First, don't just correct once. Politely restate the actual facts more than once, and if possible, do it in the same forums where the rumor spread. Second, bring a concrete counterexample to the table — a timestamped email, a project log, a witness. That's harder to ignore than a general denial. Luna: What about when you're the one hearing the repeated claim? How do you stop yourself from falling for it? Lucas: Ask a simple question: 'When did that happen, and who told you?' Force yourself to trace the source. If no one can point to a primary source, treat it as unverified. That breaks the fluency loop. Luna: And what if the false belief is about yourself? Like you've told yourself for years that you're bad at public speaking, even though you've given some decent presentations. Lucas: That's the self-narrative version, and it's insidious. Your own internal repetition is just as powerful as external repetition. You've rehearsed that story so many times that it feels as true as 'the sky is blue'. To break it, you need to deliberately repeat contradictory evidence — maybe a recording of a talk you did well, or a note from a colleague praising your clarity. Luna: So the fix isn't just 'think positive', it's 'repeat the counter-narrative'. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a darker side to this in office politics. Managers can use repetition to shape narratives intentionally — that's basically what a smear campaign is. They repeat a negative trait so often that it becomes the accepted reality, even if it's baseless. Luna: And that's why the illusory truth effect is such a powerful tool for influence. It's not about logic, it's about repetition. Lucas: Right. And it works even better when the repeated claim aligns with a preexisting stereotype. If a woman is labeled 'too emotional' or a younger engineer is called 'inexperienced', those get absorbed faster because they match cultural templates. Luna: That's a sobering thought for anyone who's been on the receiving end of that kind of label. Lucas: So here's a practical takeaway. If you're in a position to lead a team, you have a responsibility to actively challenge repeated claims. Encourage a culture where it's okay to ask for evidence, and clarify that 'everyone says' is not a source. That's one of the best antidotes to this bias. Luna: And if you're an individual contributor, you can be the one who asks 'where's that from?' when a rumor circulates. That one question can halt the repetition loop. Lucas: Remember, the goal isn't to be annoying or to challenge everything. It's to make sure important decisions — like who gets promoted or which project gets funded — are based on evidence, not on how many times a claim has been repeated. Luna: Do you have a story from your own career where you saw the illusory truth effect change someone's standing? Lucas: I remember a colleague who was branded as 'difficult to work with' after one tense interaction. That label followed him for years, even though he was actually pretty collaborative afterward. Every time he raised a valid point in a meeting, it was interpreted through that lens. He eventually left, and it was a real loss for the team. Luna: That's the tragedy — you lose good people because the fiction becomes reality. Lucas: So my challenge to our listeners this week: think of one negative belief about a coworker or about yourself that you've heard repeated more than once. Ask yourself, 'What's the actual evidence?' You might find that the belief is a ghost. Luna: And if you feel brave, try repeating the counter-evidence with the same frequency as the false claim. See what happens. Lucas: That's the experiment. And if you want to dive deeper into related biases, check out our episodes on the halo effect and the bandwagon effect. They're working partners to this one. Luna: Until next time, keep asking 'where's that from'.