Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Fairness On Cross-Examination
Transcript
- 0:31Michael Mulligan: Well, first of all, the fact pattern, like many of these uh murder cases, is never a good state of affairs given where they clearly ended up at uh the end of things.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: Uh, but this was a case involving uh murder or charge of murder, conviction for second-degree murder of a uh woman who was uh killed by strangulation was the uh forensic uh evidence.
- 0:52Michael Mulligan: Uh there was also a charge of doing an indignity to human remains, uh, which is also not a good uh fact pattern.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: That's a separate offense, by the way.
- 1:02Michael Mulligan: Um, and uh in this case, the accused pled uh guilty to that, uh, given the fact that the body, I think, had been cut into eight pieces, and he made a statement about ordering some lie to dispose of the body, which uh I think would uh squarely uh tick off those boxes.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: The lie thing, by the way, and maybe this is the only kind of uh dark humor that uh criminal lawyers would get to enjoy, but there was a uh lie as a substance that can be used to dispose of bodies.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: Oh.
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: Um and uh there is a local, I guess it increases the rate of dis you know they would uh uh uh uh be uh consumed if if buried.
- 1:38Michael Mulligan: Uh there's a local case actually from a number of years ago.
- 1:41Michael Mulligan: I had no involvement with it, but the accused in that case unfortunately mistook Lyme for lye and used the latter Lyme, which apparently is a preservative for bodies.
- 1:50Michael Mulligan: So, anyways, in this case, the fellow ordered lye.
- 1:53Michael Mulligan: Um so he at the beginning of the trial he pled guilty to the indignity to the human body, but not guilty to the murder count.
- 2:01Michael Mulligan: Uh, and uh he eventually wound up uh testifying, uh, and he provided uh in his evidence uh an explanation for uh how the death occurred, and his explanation included uh him saying that he is engaged in consensual sexual activity with the deceased um and that uh she had died by accident in the course of uh some of the activity they were involved in.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: Um, part of the challenge for him was that the uh forensic evidence from the forensic pathologist is that it would take a significant period of time uh to asphyxiate somebody such that they would die.
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: And so this fellow's explanation for what went on, he claimed that he was intoxicated and his memory only had bits and pieces, and he couldn't remember exactly how that transpired.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: That's part of how he presented his story.
- 2:50Michael Mulligan: Now, he was cross-examined by the Crown, and I should say this is a trial which was judge alone, which is now possible in murder cases if both the crown and the defense agree.
- 2:59Michael Mulligan: So it was a judge alone murder trial, and his explanation was that he had uh consumed alcohol and some unknown drug, and that that uh must have impaired his memory uh about uh how exactly it is he wound up accidentally killing this woman.
- 3:13Michael Mulligan: And the crown cross-examined him about various things, sort of challenging his uh truthfulness and his story, but did not, apparently, in the course of an otherwise extensive cross-examination, suggest to him that he was lying about being drunk or impaired by drugs.
- 3:31Michael Mulligan: And the argument about that, and this was one of the key points on this appeal, comes from this case called Brown and Dunn, which originally was a civil case, British one, but the law has been incorporated into the law in Canada and it applies to criminal cases as well.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: And that Brown and Dunn principle uh stands for the proposition that a a lawyer on the other side, when they are if they're going to be uh suggesting some other version of events or arguing in cross-examination that some other combination of things happened, uh, there would be some obligation to put that to the person in cross-examination, to challenge them with whatever you know theory they are going to be putting to the judge uh or arguing happened, so that the person has an opportunity to respond to it.
- 4:17Michael Mulligan: It's sort of the idea of sort of a matter of fairness there, right?
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: If you're uh alleging that the uh, I don't know, let's say the uh key witness uh wasn't in the room and in fact was standing outside with their glasses off, right?
- 4:29Michael Mulligan: If that's what your submission is going to be, you would have an obligation as a lawyer to put that to the person when you're cross-examining them, right?
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: Hey, I suggest to you you weren't even in the bank when the robbery occurred, or you know, you left your glasses in the car, rather than just saying mump saying nothing about that, and then popping up at the end saying, Well, you know, I say this person had their glasses on, they weren't even in the room, right?
- 4:51Michael Mulligan: Which would then leave the other side to be able to hold on.
- 4:53Michael Mulligan: Had you just asked me about that, I would have, you know, pointed out the picture of me with the glasses on, or I would have uh, you know, called some other witness to say I wasn't in the room, right?
- 5:02Michael Mulligan: I I could have dealt with that.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: And so one of the man's arguments on the appeal was, well, look, you just never suggested uh to him, suggested to the accused, that he wasn't drunk.
- 5:14Michael Mulligan: Uh and that was uh uh one of the things which was relied upon by the crown in submission.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: So and so, hey, Brown had done, he had this obligation to do that, and he didn't do it.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: And so the argument was that the uh appeal should be allowed or there should be a new trial, because he wasn't treated fairly, because he never had that challenged, and then the crown stood up at the end and said he was fibbing about being drunk um and being on drugs.
- 5:37Michael Mulligan: Uh and I must say there was some basis for concluding he might be fibbing, because in one of his various statements to the police, along with the comments about the lie, he claimed to not drink alcohol.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: But leaving that aside, he wasn't challenged on it.
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: Now, the Court of Appeal looked carefully at it and confirmed that that rule at Brown and Dunn principle does apply, right?
- 5:57Michael Mulligan: Uh and it's an important it's a principle that is uh one necessary for fairness, for sort of the you know kind of scenario I've suggested.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: You're putting some other theory, making some submission at the end, it's only fair you put that to the person so they can respond to it, right?
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: But here, uh the uh Court of Appeal pointed out uh that you need to look at all of the uh the case in its entirety to figure out was there some unfairness?
- 6:21Michael Mulligan: Was this something that you know he didn't have a chance to respond to it, like, hey, here's a picture of me with the glasses on, or whatever the case might be.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal found that there wasn't a breach of that uh principle of fairness in this case, uh, because the issue about whether he was intoxicated was he was clearly aware of it, he made statements about it, he was challenged uh in cross-examination in a broad way about his credibility and everything he had to say.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: And so, given that, um, it wasn't necessary for the crown to put to him the specific uh claim uh that he wasn't uh drunk or uh didn't wasn't on drugs and that uh that was uh simply fabricated to uh allow him to make up a story about how he could have been choking somebody for some extended period of time and not remember doing that.
- 7:10Michael Mulligan: Um and so that's the principle from the rule in Brown and Dunn, and that's how it applies.
- 7:15Michael Mulligan: And there can be cases where that there is unfairness if you don't uh, as counsel, confront the person so they have a chance to respond to whatever your particular theory might be or other evidence you might be calling.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: Uh, but here that just didn't happen uh because he was aware of that issue and he was challenged in terms of his credibility generally, and he wasn't deprived of some opportunity uh to respond to that uh because he was uh well aware of those issues and generally challenged.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: So that's the rule in Brown and Dunn.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh turned out not to be a problem here, but certainly something that uh Crown Defense need to keep in mind uh when they're challenging witnesses to make sure you put to them uh an alternative theory so that uh they have a chance to respond to it.
- 8:19Adam Stirling: Uhhh on a peel.
- 8:21Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: Quite a bit.
- 8:24Michael Mulligan: So this this dates back originally, the event dates back to 2016.
- 8:28Michael Mulligan: Uh and it occurred in Vernon, and the fact pattern was that this woman, the who was the charged with this, was a passenger on a bus.
- 8:36Michael Mulligan: Um, and she's clearly somebody with mental illness.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: We'll come to that in a moment.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: Uh, but there was a four-year-old child on the bus who was sitting with the child's great-grandmother.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: Uh, and as the great-grandmother and child were about to get off the bus, uh, this woman went up and grabbed the wrist of the child and said, No, you're not taking him.
- 8:54Michael Mulligan: He's my child.
- 8:56Michael Mulligan: Um, another passenger intervened, pried the woman's hand off the ch uh the four-year-old, uh, and the uh four-year-old got off the bus with the grandmother or great grandmother.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: The the uh woman took a swing at the passenger who pride his hand off her her hand off, missed, uh, and then herself got off the bus, that is to say, the woman who was charged, and she phoned 911 and told the operator, My little son got taken today, I don't know where he went, but he was on the bus.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: So that was the activity.
- 9:26Michael Mulligan: Um and she was charged with uh offenses including assaulting the child by grabbing the child's wrist and and attempting to abduct the child.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: So those were the charges.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: Now, the judge f ultimately concluded that she had done those things, but found her to be not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder.
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: Uh and the the evidence uh before the judge included uh that she had a treatment-resistant form of schizophrenia, uh, and that uh she believed things, including that she had telepath uh she was telepathic, that she had healing powers, and that she had given birth to multiple angel babies and for some reason a cat.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: Uh and so on that basis the judge, I think, had no trouble finding that she was not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: She believed that this child was hers, I guess, as a result of this uh this disorder.
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: Uh now this woman has now has been in a secure uh psychiatric facility since 2018.
- 10:27Michael Mulligan: So we're not talking eight years on.
- 10:30Michael Mulligan: Um and the notable thing about that is that if somebody was not mentally ill or not mentally ill to the point where they were not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder, um, and they were convicted of assault by grabbing a child's wrist uh and even attempting to abduct abduct the ch abduct the child, right?
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: It's unlikely that they would receive a prison sentence of more than eight years in prison, such that they would still be sitting in prison for that.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: But when you're found to be not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder, you can then wind up in custody indefinitely, uh, unless the what's called the review board, uh sort of a panel determines uh that you would uh not amount to a safety concern for the public.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and if they conclude that you're a significant threat to the safety of the public, you may just never get out.
- 11:21Michael Mulligan: Um and so this woman's been in there now for it looks like about eight years.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: Um, and while the board found that she'd been making uh progress, right?
- 11:30Michael Mulligan: She seemed to be generally doing better, uh, had concluded that her sort of plan for release, uh, you know, staying in a motel, suggesting that you know maybe her father or friends would tell her if she was having a psychiatric uh episode was not sufficient, uh, and that she would still remain a potential danger to the public.
- 11:49Michael Mulligan: And so they just ordered her to just stay where she where she is and where she has been now, I guess we'll be going on to year nine now.
- 11:57Michael Mulligan: Um and so she appealed that uh decision to the Court of Appeal.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Uh but as with many appeals, the standard is a pretty deferential one, right?
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: Really, it's to assess the Court of Appeals assessing, you know, is this an unreasonable decision?
- 12:12Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal said no, seems to be a basis for that, and so dismissed the appeal, and so there she remains.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: And so it I think is really a uh uh important for listeners to understand, because we you do hear about these things from time to time, saying, oh, the person was found to be not criminally responsible, and it may cause some people to think, well, geez, nothing happened to that uh person.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: Uh you know, I can't believe we have such a lax uh system.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: Uh, but this is an example of how that is simply not the case.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and so, well, for somebody who might otherwise be convicted of murder, for example, uh an indefinite period of detention in a psychiatric facility might be less punitive, you can have circumstances like this one, well, where the underlying offense is, of course, serious, right?
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: That would be very frightening for the great grandmother and the child, there's no doubt about that.
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: Yes.
- 13:03Michael Mulligan: Uh, but you would not expect the person to receive uh a sentence of that length and with no end um if they weren't somebody uh who was suffering from this sort of a serious mental illness.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Uh but uh where that is the basis to avoid the criminal conviction, uh the net result can be spending potentially the rest of your life uh in a secure psychiatric facility, and that's where this woman is, it would appear, for the foreseeable future, uh, because she's been diagnosed with this treatment-resistant uh mental illness.
- 13:34Michael Mulligan: Um and unless the uh review board is uh persuaded uh that she would not represent a safety concern for the public, uh there she will remain.
- 13:43Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's ladies from the Court of Appeal uh on uh how somebody who's not criminally responsible as relative mental disorder uh can be just held in custody pretty well indefinitely uh unless the review board concludes that you're safe.
- 13:58Adam Stirling: Conviction for offenses relating to a home invasion upheld on appeal despite being based on circumstantial evidence and quote, material in a court file, close quote, referred to by the trial judge, but not made an exhibit in the trial.
- 14:12Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 14:14Michael Mulligan: This is I think uh really interesting.
- 14:16Michael Mulligan: First of all, the fact pattern, right?
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: Again, it's a really serious uh offense.
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: It was uh two people who were charged as co-accused, one of them was the person appealing here.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: Um the and uh the they were charged with this whole series of very serious offenses related to this home invasion, uh, which apparently occurred with shotguns, including shooting uh two people that were in the home, they survived and stealing various things from the home.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: Very serious conduct, without question.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: Uh but first of all, uh the entire case was premised on circumstantial evidence.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: The men were masked, um, and there were no confessions or anything of that sort.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: So the entire case was first of all premised on a combination of things like uh DNA analysis of DNA found in the masks, right?
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: Uh which of course could establish somebody was you know in contact with the thing or their DNA got on it, but you don't know when or what the circumstances were of that.
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: Um, and then some evidence about things like um cell phone towers and like these cell phones that were connected to these two people, like they weren't in their names, but there was evidence about them being connected to them, and there was technical evidence, uh, as sometimes you see about things like, you know, what tower was this particular uh, you know, cell phone connected to at relevant times to try to give some general location data.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: Uh and then finally, another interesting element of this case is that one of the two accused, the person who was the person appealing the conviction, was not present for the trial.
- 15:48Michael Mulligan: Um and so that may raise some questions for listeners.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: How can that happen?
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: Uh but what happens is that if you have somebody who is not present and a judge is persuaded that the person has absconded, which would be a different thing from they forgot the court date or they got the wrong time or their who knows, right?
- 16:06Michael Mulligan: But has actively absconded, there's provision for a judge to order that the trial proceed without them even being there.
- 16:14Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that was the case with this accused who was then now the appellant in this most recent decision from the Court of Appeal.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: So he wasn't even there for the trial.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: Uh but despite the fact that he wasn't there, uh the judge was satisfied ultimately based on the circumstantial evidence, so things like the DNA match on these masks, uh, the general cell phone information connecting them, and a very general description from the uh two victims of this home invasion.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: They gave a description like one person was short and one person was tall.
- 16:49Michael Mulligan: You know, that's kind of the extent of it.
- 16:50Michael Mulligan: And they gave even things like inconsistent evidence about uh, for example, what the people were wearing, or in this case, like what these masks looked like, like the evidence between the two of them was inconsistent and didn't match uh, you know, the things they were doing this DNA testing on.
- 17:06Michael Mulligan: And so it's that kind of a case, right?
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: And the issue, like in any criminal case, is the judge persuaded beyond all reasonable doubt.
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: And it's not always to say that circumstantial cases are weak cases, right?
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: Because human uh, you know, uh evidence is often quite fallible.
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: Sometimes a circumstantial case can be uh uh more clear uh than otherwise.
- 17:27Michael Mulligan: But here the judge had to put all these things together.
- 17:29Michael Mulligan: But here's the really interesting point, one of the issues on the appeal.
- 17:33Michael Mulligan: One of the basic premises in uh uh criminal cases um is that decision should be made based on evidence that is presented at the trial.
- 17:44Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: You you don't have uh the jury or judge off there, you know, doing some freelance uh, you know, Google research uh or hopefully you know driving out to the scene and poking around on their own, coming to some conclusions about what might have happened.
- 17:58Michael Mulligan: Um and from time to time uh it comes out that those kind of things actually occur.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Like you have uh oddball cases where things like jurors decide they're gonna go out and do their own inspection of the scene or start doing their own research about some forensic point or something, which is going to ordinarily be disastrous for uh how that case hangs together.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: But here, the judge in the judge's reasons, in addition to trying to knit together all those things about what do you make of the cell phone evidence about where these things were at different times and you know what can you conclude about uh the uh you know DNA and the meaning of that.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: The judge also, uh, in uh I think it was his reasons, made reference to the fact that uh he had r taken a look at some of the material in the court file.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: He said, further, my review of the materials in the court file, as well as the evidence presented during the seven four hundred seventy-five application, that's the one about the absconding person, those were things that the judge relied upon in coming to the conclusion tying the accused to one of these phones.
- 19:04Michael Mulligan: And so the problem was here, or the argument on appeal is well, hold on a minute.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: That's wasn't evidence in the trial, and the judge didn't make what was the material in the court file exactly that they were looking at, and is that permissible?
- 19:17Michael Mulligan: Or is this just like the judge going off and doing a little bit of internet research or taking a drive-by in their car coming to some conclusions about what might have happened?
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the that's what the Court of Appeal, one of the things they were struggling with.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: And, you know, they could you know voice those general principles that we've just talked about in terms of, you know, you make decisions based on evidence, not based on other things.
- 19:41Michael Mulligan: But uh there is some authority that courts are permitted to make reference to things in their own files.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal was okay with the idea that the uh a judge might refer to materials in the court file.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: Here, one of the challenges but the the law that permits that, looking at the court's own file, one of the things that they has been said on uh by appeal courts in the past is when you're doing that, or a judge is doing that, you should then mark the thing that you're referring to as an exhibit.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: Like in in criminal cases, if something's uh like a document or a letter or a photograph or something is shown referred to, it'll be taken by the clerk, marked with like uh uh, you know, a number on it, a tag's put on it, and that's done in part so that, for example, if there were an appeal, you the court of appeal will be able to look at, okay, well, what was decided here?
- 20:33Michael Mulligan: Did the judge you know look at that thing properly or understand it or misinterpret it or what went on here?
- 20:38Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that didn't happen.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: And so here, you know, for example, what the judge was looking at was it appeared some document that had the name of somebody on it that helped connect up the cell phone to this absconding accused.
- 20:53Michael Mulligan: And so it wasn't quite right, and the Court of Appeal found, well, look, you know, really the concern here is it wasn't marked as an exhibit, but given that there is authority to look at the court file itself, uh the uh Court of Appeal wasn't prepared to interfere with what otherwise the Court of Appeal found to be a sound conviction.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest for the Court of Appeal in terms of dealing with the circumstantial case and whether it's uh proper or not uh for a judge to, on their own accord, start flipping through the court file to see what else in there might uh connect the accused to the particular offense.
- 21:24Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, thank you so much, Michael.
- 21:28Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:29Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:29Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.