Latest / The Events of 1848, Especially in Their Relation to Great Britain / Part 2
Transcript
- 0:01Section two of the Events of eighteen forty eight, especially in their relation to
- 0:06Great Britain, by Richard Monckton Milns. This LibriVox recording is in the public
- 0:12domain Part two. Whether political disposition is so faulty, it is difficult to
- 0:19say that the whole blame of the failure of the transaction lies with either side.
- 0:24Whether any conciliation of the Italians, any concessions to their national feelings,
- 0:30would have succeeded in identifying their political interests with those of the Empire, cannot
- 0:35now be determined. But at any rate, no such attempt was made.
- 0:40German and Slavonian functionaries in offices of trust, German and Slavonian troops in the
- 0:45garrisons were the rule Italians. With the exception. There was indeed no eagerness
- 0:51on the part of the Italians to serve the government, either in civil and
- 0:55military employment, and soon, indeed it became a degradation to do so.
- 1:00The higher ranks, not too energetic by natural disposition, fell into a life
- 1:04of desponding inactivity. And except at Venice, where the habits of occupation in
- 1:08the public service had never been given up, and where a deeper poverty supplied
- 1:14an additional stimulus. No men of worth and education frequented the offices of the
- 1:19state, nor were the foreign officials men of a special mark or position.
- 1:23But the clever and genial Italian spirit was everywhere submitted to that of the ordinary,
- 1:30heavy German functionary. The strictest censorship enclosed the press, the most communicative
- 1:37of people, was shut out from the intelligence of the rest of the active
- 1:40world. Literature was emptied of all her high and serious purposes and reduced to
- 1:47subsist on a low material knowledge, and the formal religion. Primary instruction was
- 1:55generally and liberally afforded, but the fuel was denied to foster the flame.
- 2:00And the peasants who knew how to read at twelve years of age had forgot
- 2:05how to do so at five and twenty. Among the nobility, which is
- 2:08a large class, all political influences tended to degrade and demoralize. They were
- 2:15excluded from all the objects of intellectual labor and honest ambition by the best,
- 2:20as by the worst parts of their nature, by their patriotism and their passiveness,
- 2:25by their indolence and their independence. The administration of justice was of the
- 2:31rudest kind, not only without publicity the only permanent safeguard, but conducted almost
- 2:38entirely by written evidence and without the confrontation of witnesses, the judgments were perhaps
- 2:45as good as such imperfect forms permitted. And indeed, if it be once
- 2:49assumed that the north of Italy must necessarily be held by military occupation, there
- 2:53is no ground for charging the Austrian government with a special harshness or wanton cruelty.
- 3:00Restrictions and occasional violences were incidental to the mode of government and hardly admitted
- 3:06of mitigation without a total change of the relations of the countries. It may
- 3:12indeed be fairly asked why the peace, which proposed the re establishment of right
- 3:16throughout Europe should have delivered these countries over to a new and repulsive subjection.
- 3:23The position was new for the Duchy of Milan, as a fief of the
- 3:28Roman Empire, held a totally different place from the province kept down by military
- 3:31force. In those disturbed times, the relation of the emperor was formal and
- 3:38protective. The representation of his power was confined to a viceroy and a few
- 3:44offices, and the practical government was in the hands of the Italians themselves.
- 3:50Since that time. The Sisalpine Republic, the Department of All Honor, and
- 3:53the Kingdom of Italy were forms of government imposed indeed by foreign power, but
- 4:00their administration was in the hands of Italians, and there was no restraint on
- 4:03the expression of national sentiment. Napoleon was, it is well known, as
- 4:10desirous of the national development and power of Italy, as he was suspicious of,
- 4:14and indifferent too, that of Poland. I say nothing of Venice,
- 4:19whose memories were not only of independence but of substantial power, whose traditions were
- 4:25not only of freedom but of sway. The abortive attempts of eighteen twenty one
- 4:30only embittered the hostility. The tortures of such men as Gonfaloniere and Silvio Pelico
- 4:38rankled in the hearts of thousands. No glittering surface of material prosperity could even
- 4:44conceal the brooding hate. The gay corso and the brilliant theater scarcely masked what
- 4:50lay below. The society of the upper and middle classes of Milan was inaccessible
- 4:57to the Austrian officer. However, person amiable intermarriage between the nations was most
- 5:02rare, and gallantry indecorous. This was a state of things not to be
- 5:10affected by the construction of good roads and handsome bridges, by improvements in irrigation
- 5:15and agriculture, or the maintenance of charitable institutions. The heavy taxation took away
- 5:23all notion of gratitude for boons like these, or if felt at all,
- 5:28it was solely by those who looked to daily labor for the subsistence of life.
- 5:34The peasantry of Lombardy, remembering the havoc that war had made of late
- 5:39years of fertile land, looked with respect and good will on any form of
- 5:44power that promised to secure them from future invasion and tumult, and with terror
- 5:48on the possible disturbers of that tranquility. The miseries of warfare fall on the
- 5:55heads of the laboring classes, so palpable and so unredeemed, and the advantages
- 6:00of victory appear so remote and so uncertain, that it is not to be
- 6:05wondered at how much a rural population will endure before a levee en mass attests
- 6:13their rage and their resolution. And thus, amid all the efforts and sacrifices
- 6:17of the late rising in Lombardy, those have shown the most apathy who had
- 6:23least to lose, whilst the Boromeos and the litters have shaken off their sloth
- 6:28and shared the enthusiasm and the disasters of the student and the artisan. In
- 6:34these considerations I have not alluded to the effects on France of her restricted frontiers
- 6:40and her diminished authority in continental Europe, and have not done so because,
- 6:45on the whole the anticipations of those who wished well to France have been as
- 6:48yet fulfilled. Internal political life and social developments have, to a surprising extent,
- 6:56taken the place of the passion for glory and the lust for dominion.
- 7:00The inhabitants of the left bank of the Rhine have shown no desire to return
- 7:04to the French connection, and notwithstanding much political sympathy and a general friendly feeling,
- 7:11any indication of conquest on the part of France has been met by the
- 7:15Germans with enthusiastic indignation, and both statesmen and soldiers capable of reflection now entertain
- 7:23considerable doubt whether one bank of a river inhabited by a heterogeneous and discontented population
- 7:29would not of itself be a dangerous and ineffective frontier, to say nothing of
- 7:34the cost and bloodshed by which alone it could be obtained. The rapidity also
- 7:41with which France resumed her rank in Europe, although her efforts took a bad
- 7:46and unnatural direction, was no doubt of use in healing her wounded pride and
- 7:51appeasing the bitter feelings which might have excited her to the notion of writing herself
- 7:57in the face of Europe, and the general record nition of the Revolution of
- 8:01July headed by England was the most satisfactory proof that the old banded enemies would
- 8:07or could no longer interfere with the internal affairs of the French people, but
- 8:11that they might continue as they would the work of eighty nine, provided they
- 8:16remained at home. Even Russia was content with an attitude of surly surveillance,
- 8:22and the still more sudden and novel change which has taken place in France has
- 8:28met with a ready acquiescence from all the powers of Europe. The Republic enters
- 8:33by right into the circle of kings and emperors, and no trace remains on
- 8:39the surface of the political world to show that ever combined Europe wished to dictate
- 8:43to France the form of her government or the name of her rulers. France,
- 8:48in truth, can now owe no grudge to the treaties of eighteen fifteen.
- 8:52She is herself again. The late disturbances in Germany have had so little
- 8:58to do with territorial distribution that, although closely related to the circumstances of the
- 9:05War of Independence, yet they cannot be strictly regarded as connected with any compact
- 9:11to which England is a party. The engagements whose violation or retardation have issued
- 9:18in the revolutions of eighteen forty eight and the present disorganized condition of Germany were
- 9:22between the sovereigns of that nation and the people who restored them to their thrones.
- 9:28The broken faith of the late King of Prussia has discredited the word of
- 9:33his honest son, and how every German prince who pretends to rule will have
- 9:35to meet those very demands from a deceived and distrustful people, which, if
- 9:43granted to the enthusiastic loyalty and confiding love of eighteen fifteen, would have smoothed
- 9:48down every difficulty of transition from one form of government to another, and have
- 9:52established on the safest common basis those institutions that will now have to force their
- 9:58way through the crevice of a convulsed society, and which will only stand firm
- 10:03at last on a ground of sodden ruins. In the more complicated case of
- 10:09the Austrian Empire, who can say to what height of prosperity and contentment it
- 10:13might not have risen under a federative system, which should have developed the principle
- 10:18of popular representation on local administration according to the needs, the capabilities, and
- 10:26the character of the several provinces, reserving to the central government the privilege of
- 10:31rectifying partial errors and directing the interests common to the whole. With a judicious
- 10:37central authority in the place of Congress, the United States of Austria, perhaps
- 10:43even including Lombardy, might have been a great nation instead of a collection of
- 10:48small states, with the sole headship of a great army repressing and terrifying all.
- 10:58It is not improbable, if the real nature and extent of the influence
- 11:01exercised by Prince Metanik over Austria, ever, comes to be clearly known,
- 11:07that it will be seen that he was not insensible to the importance of such
- 11:11a combination, and that if he had been allowed to act more independently of
- 11:16the Emperor Francis and after his death of the imperial family, the provincial liberties
- 11:22would have been fostered, instead of being kept down, and instead of being
- 11:26driven as he ultimately was, to the wretched policy of playing off race against
- 11:31race and class against class. He might have been hailed as the founder of
- 11:35a really united empire, as it was. The sole province which successfully asserted
- 11:43its independent nationality was Hungary, where the discrepancy of race between the nobility and
- 11:50the people converted liberty itself into an arm of tyranny and a weapon of offense,
- 11:56and which is now paying the bloody penalty of a freedom monopoli by a
- 12:00portion of the nation. For all these issues, England is so far responsible
- 12:07as her influence that the Congress of Vienna extended, and no more. After
- 12:11so long an experience, it is very easy to suggest some line of policy
- 12:16which might have induced a safer and wiser settlement. But when it is remembered
- 12:22with how many ambitious and even revengeful passions Lord Castlereagh had to deal, it
- 12:26does not appear certain that the clearest conviction on the part of the English government
- 12:31of the ill results of these portions of the arrangement would have stood in the
- 12:35way of their adoption. Indeed, the papers lately laid before Parliament give evidence
- 12:39of a strong desire on the part of Lord Castlereagh to obtain all the recognition
- 12:45of Polish independence that he possibly could, and the conduct of the English government
- 12:48in the later reactionary negotiations of Tropo and Laidback was avowedly opposed to the principle
- 12:54which at Verona obtained its complete expression, that wherever a revolution breaks out,
- 13:01any European power may interfere to suppress it. The decided refusal of England to
- 13:07join that singular compact, which under a religious and almost mystical formula, masked
- 13:16the most audacious return to unalloyed absolutism. The Holy Alliance must have prepared the
- 13:22courts for the independent attitude she afterwards assumed, and for the protests against the
- 13:28abrogation of the Sicilian Constitution and the French intervention in Spain. But mister Canning's
- 13:33line of action was still more distinct, and the recognition of the South American
- 13:39republics, the establishment of constitutional government in Portugal, and the independence of Greece
- 13:46remained historical monuments of some continuous sympathy in England for the freedom of other nations.
- 13:54The ready acceptance of the Revolution of July by Tory ministers took this policy
- 13:58out of the Ranger Party aims and stamped it as national and necessary. It
- 14:05cannot indeed be asserted of any English administration since the war that it has avowedly
- 14:11and systematically supported the anti popular cause in Europe, and the faults with which
- 14:16some may be charged are of omission, not of commission. Therefore, now
- 14:22to throw the moral influence of England into the scale of arbitrary authority, to
- 14:26support, even by words, the cause of military force against the expression of
- 14:33national feeling and the development of representative institutions would be a departure from the foreign
- 14:39policy which has, as it were, forced itself on all our public men
- 14:43for the last thirty years, and a derogation from the position which England is
- 14:48bound to adopt, namely that of being the open friend of such orderly freedom
- 14:52as we ourselves enjoy, even as our own early Protestantism made us the vindicators
- 15:00of religious liberty throughout the world. Why then, though ready to acknowledge the
- 15:05advantage of such institutions, and even to perceive the useful operation of them in
- 15:09other countries. Do we look on the processes and changes by which they are
- 15:13acquired with no favor, and are rather inclined to confound them in one common
- 15:18reprobation, Is it not that the peculiar felicity of the method by which our
- 15:24liberty has been acquired, the coordinate progress of our means of intelligence under our
- 15:30political franchises, the fair proportion which the power of different classes of the community
- 15:35has here always borne to its real worth. The entire absence of strange and
- 15:41unsympathetic interference, have, as it were, spoiled our judgment for deciding on
- 15:46practical political problems in less favored nations. When a member of the English aristocracy
- 15:54reads of a foreign noble as well educated, as sensitive of shame, and
- 15:58at least of as polished manners as himself, being dependent in all the circumstances
- 16:03of his existence, in the disposal of his property, in the place of
- 16:07his residence, in the destination of his family, on the capricious will of
- 16:11a sovereign, however wise and just and liable, if he opposes that will,
- 16:17to be exiled to a penal settlement, or degraded to the condition of
- 16:21a private soldier, he would naturally shudder with indignation, and would think hardly
- 16:26any price too dear to pay for liberation from such a servitude. When an
- 16:33English traveler comes to be intimately acquainted with some highly informed and accomplished Italian gentleman
- 16:40of independent means, who tells him with what delight he should visit Paris,
- 16:45but that there is no chance of his government, and that a foreign one
- 16:48giving him a passport and permission to go there, the question would force itself
- 16:53on his mind, why is this man, this bondsman? And why am
- 16:57I free to go where I please? When an Englishman of the middle classes
- 17:03is told that a man whose social position and moral claims resemble his own,
- 17:07in a country separated from us by a mere strip of sea, and which
- 17:11professes the full enjoyment of constitutional liberty, had no voice in the representation of
- 17:18his country, was forced to send his son to a university whose opinions he
- 17:22disapproved, and could not himself attend any religious meeting which was not in connection
- 17:29with some body recognized by the state, He would not wonder at that man,
- 17:33not caring to defend that government when in peril, and looking forward to
- 17:37organic change of the constitution, rather with hope than with fear. And if
- 17:44the English artisan so accustomed to the intervention of the wealth of the state between
- 17:48himself and destitution, that he regards it as a right, not as a
- 17:52boon, and complains of the mode and amount of relief, without the thought
- 17:57ever passing through his mind, that it could be altogether withdrawn if he hears
- 18:03that in other nations, even in those which the distinctions of classes have given
- 18:08way far more than in his own, and where the words of equality and
- 18:12fraternity are ever on the lips, not only no right to subsistence or to
- 18:18the work that should procure it is admitted on the part of those in power,
- 18:23but that solely the precarious charity of pious individuals stands between the pauper,
- 18:30however innocent, and starvation. He could hardly avoid feeling that even his respect
- 18:37for law might not resist that temptation, but that he would try if his
- 18:42own strong arm could not force the willingly inoperative rich to do something for the
- 18:48forcidly inoperative poor. And so by the common law of human sympathy it would
- 18:56and ought to be. But in reality it is so little so that no
- 19:02one would be surprised to hear that no woman praise the energy of the autocrat.
- 19:06The gentlemen approved the precautions against the spread of popular opinions, the shopkeeper
- 19:11abused the apathy of the bourgeois, and the artisan express a hope that if
- 19:17those fellows made a row, they might get what they deserved. Truth is
- 19:23that order with us is found reconcilable with improvement and progress, and every disturbance
- 19:30of it injures the cause in which it occurs. Order has never reigned with
- 19:36us as at warsaw. Order means ports full of ships, shops full of
- 19:41customers, factories in full work, and political confusion abroad injures commerce, and
- 19:45at home stagnates trade. For some rare important objects long agitated in the minds
- 19:52of the people, some external demonstration of popular force has been permitted. But
- 19:59we have seen what indignation has been aroused at the bare suspicion that the government
- 20:04could have sanctioned such an instrument in the case of the Reform Bill, even
- 20:10though two branches of the Constitution were there agreed, and the resistance came from
- 20:14a portion of the third. And there is no doubt that the feeling of
- 20:19the agricultural classes on the repeal of the Corn Law was much exacerbated by the
- 20:26notion that the Minister had yielded rather to the pressure of the League than to
- 20:30argument or circumstance. We cannot be sufficiently thankful for the temper that makes political
- 20:40agitation repulsive to the habits of the English people. And this not because it
- 20:45is the chief security of our domestic peace, but because it permits the stream
- 20:51of improvement to flow on almost unchallenged. Our revolutions are made before we recognize
- 20:57them. Unjust privileges are quietly subtracted, Irritating distinctions are imperceptibly removed by such
- 21:06means as railroads under penny postage and the repeal of legal restrictions. And where
- 21:11all are better soon no one feels himself the worse. This source of tranquil
- 21:18power is no doubt increased by the conviction that, when the crisis demanded it,
- 21:22we also have fought, and are ready to do so again. But
- 21:26not likely and not prematurely. I do not know that anything in history affects
- 21:32me more than the instances in which the English people have voluntarily endured palpable present
- 21:38evil for the sake of permanent good, the refusal of the dissenters to accept
- 21:45of the dispensing power of James the second rather than invest the sovereign with unconstitutional
- 21:52authority, and afterwards, the long retention on the throne of kings ignorant even
- 21:59of the language and offensive to the morals in intellect of the country. To
- 22:03the exclusion of a race native, a genial but dangerous to public liberty,
- 22:08are examples of civil prudence such as perhaps no other nation can exhibit, and
- 22:14to which we owe more than we can tell. We have indeed no right
- 22:19to judge other nations by this standard, because we owe this advantage quite as
- 22:23much to circumstances as to the national temperament. For where else as the outward
- 22:30frame of institutions represented so justly the mental progress of the people, where else
- 22:37have the tree and the bark so continuously grown together. In France, the
- 22:42philosophy of the eighteenth century found itself compressed within the forms of the sixteenth and
- 22:48shattered them to pieces. The controversy of ideas that agitated the breasts of Voltaire
- 22:55and Rousseau became the agony of the nation. In the struggle of the Giron
- 23:00and the Mountain, and under other names. The contest still continues. In
- 23:07Germany. The discrepancy between the worlds of thought and of action has been still
- 23:11more striking. Notwithstanding the solemn example of France and the singular opportunity for reuniting
- 23:19the people to their institutions offered by Providence at the conclusion of the War of
- 23:23Independence, the external mold has been rather contracted than enlarged, while thought has
- 23:32expanded with an audacity and of freedom without parallel. As long as the philosopher
- 23:38did not attempt to realize his speculations, he had the full range of heaven
- 23:45and earth. No restraint of faith or veneration lay upon him, no limit
- 23:49of expediency or possibility tested his schemes, no practical failures forced him to humility.
- 23:56But the policeman and the censer stood close outside, and the instant he
- 24:02attempted to act, punished and coerced him. Then came the day when,
- 24:08without notice or warning, these thinkers found the political destiny of Germany placed in
- 24:14their hands. And these ready writers were told to realize their dreams. Hence,
- 24:19of course, infinite confusion, ceaseless misunderstanding, inconsistency without end, Hence
- 24:26the student the man that studies in open struggle with the soldier, the man
- 24:32paid to act. Hence the divisions and dissensions which have accompanied the establishment of
- 24:37the constitutions in a great part of Germany, and which in one portion has
- 24:41permitted the dangerous preponderance of an alien and antagonistic element, had commenced a contest
- 24:48of races in which political forms may not improbably be absorbed and nullified, and
- 24:56society reduced to its first conditions of aggression and defense. The long usage of
- 25:03the representative system has produced in England a healthy and peaceful political activity which we
- 25:07have no right to expect to see at once organized in other countries, and
- 25:11to persist in withholding from them all sympathy on that account is an absurd injustice,
- 25:18for a little consideration would show us that the direct and primary advantages of
- 25:23that system are sufficient not only to justify an interest in the country's endeavoring to
- 25:27obtain them, but to render its consolidation there the chief object of the friends
- 25:34of peace and order in Europe. I think we may justly regard all governments
- 25:41as holding rule by the fear, the apathy, or the consent of the
- 25:45government. Mere fear can never long hold any large number of men in subjection
- 25:51to a single tyrant space itself is a great security against systematic oppression. In
- 25:59the old time, when the city was the state, the personal power of
- 26:03the one manner was something which would be inconceivable to us if we had not
- 26:08lived in the times of Napoleon and O'Connell. But in such cases, admiration
- 26:15and love modify and elevate the sentiment, and terror is converted into all.
- 26:22Now there is nothing necessarily degrading in any submission to an authority believed to be
- 26:26true. For while there are, no doubt, many forms of reverence incompatible
- 26:33with any moral or intellectual elevation, there is nothing servile in the obedience paid
- 26:40to one who is conscientiously held to have the right to demand it. And
- 26:45it is the doubt or the disbelief of that right which alone legitimizes resistance against
- 26:51power. Thus, ancient despotism had always a theocratic character, and even now
- 26:57in the heart of the Russian earth, the czar is divine. But the
- 27:03real government by fear is that of organized armies, huge machines of human violence,
- 27:10swayed by the will of an unloved sovereign or an obnoxious class, and
- 27:15placing the subject in the alternative of passive obedience or injury to his person,
- 27:22his family, his property, his life. Of this nature are the military
- 27:30occupations of Poland and Lombardy, and the Christian portions of the Turkish Empire,
- 27:34and such would be English dominion of India were not the armed force there almost
- 27:40wholly identified in race, habits, and interests with the people, and thus
- 27:45by no means likely to oppress or injure them. From the debasement of this
- 27:51subjection, there is no escape, and the degradation is not confined to any
- 27:56a special form of government. Spain under the Inquisition sank into moral ruin,
- 28:04France under the Terror, lost the great spirit of the revolution and descended to
- 28:11the Directory. And England would similarly have fallen had she submitted to the Star
- 28:18Chamber court or to the Irish troops of James the second. Indeed, it
- 28:25generally happens that continued fear so weakens the capacity of mankind that it is succeeded
- 28:32by an apathy, which takes hope itself away and leaves life to the mercy
- 28:37of the appetites of the hour. This recklessness of politics may indeed spring from
- 28:45other and very different causes, and some of them reconcilable with a very advanced
- 28:49state of society combined with religious fatalism. Such apathy is the predominant condition of
- 28:57mind throughout the East, where the violences of government are passively submitted to,
- 29:03like the visitations of nature, where a capricious passion is like a partial shower
- 29:08of rain, and where the existence of evil is accepted in political life as
- 29:15in the order of creation. A similar apathy is produced in civilized countries,
- 29:21where the natural wants of men are fully supplied, their appetites indulged, and
- 29:26their attention exclusively directed to sensual objects. This is the passiveness which permits revolutions.
- 29:36It has neither the will nor the courage to make, and which is
- 29:40only aroused by some terrible onset, like that of last June in Paris.
- 29:45But Vienna was the very type of the political apathy which it was the policy
- 29:51of such governments as Austria to encourage. And of all the marvels of eighteen
- 29:56forty eight, it is I think the most unaccountable that the political sleep of
- 30:00that luxurious capital deepened as it was, by the kindness and familiarity of its
- 30:07rulers, should have been broken by the Jericho trumpets of liberty, and that
- 30:11the walls of absolutism should have fallen even there. Such examples would indeed seem
- 30:19to afford irrefragible proof that no form of personal government, however paternal, is
- 30:26in these days proof against the spirit of revolution. It may seem to have
- 30:32the full consent of the people, but an unpopular minister, or a change
- 30:36in the government of another country, or a crisis of distress, may give
- 30:41to perhaps a small minority of the nation, the power to upset in a
- 30:45few hours. A dynasty in France and a system at Vienna, that large
- 30:52network of functionaries to whose tenacity Austria owes the semblance of unity which she is
- 30:57preserved in all her distracts, did not prevent revolution there any more than the
- 31:03National Guard did at Paris. For both had become indifferent to the actual order
- 31:10of things, and in that indifference they followed where in the natural order of
- 31:14things they should have led, and found themselves in hands much more distasteful to
- 31:18them than those they had let fall. By a tardy activity. They might
- 31:25rescue themselves, but the power which they had not saved, was gone forever.
- 31:33Enders Section two read by Brin Roberts, Kingswinford, October twenty twenty three,