Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / MAFS UK Scandal EXPOSED | The Dark Psychology of Reality TV | Tim Wilson
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Katie Duke, and I've been a nurse for over 20 years.
- 0:04Listen, I used to think that I was my most stylish in my 20s, but honestly, style and confidence only get better with age.
- 0:11And that is why I love figs.
- 0:14These scrubs are beautiful, comfortable, and they are built to last.
- 0:18They're not those boxy, scratchy uniforms that we all started out in.
- 0:22No, no, no.
- 0:22These fit perfectly.
- 0:24They feel amazing.
- 0:25And the quality is just wow.
- 0:29My favorite color?
- 0:31Burgundy.
- 0:31It's chic.
- 0:32It's timeless.
- 0:33And it's even the same color as my apartment.
- 0:36Because I'm kind of obsessed with it.
- 0:37And I love adding custom embroidery to make my scrubs as personal as my style.
- 0:42And since I work in telehealth, my embroidered figs even double as my ID badge.
- 0:46It's never too late to reinvent yourself or your scrubs.
- 0:50Get 15% off your first order at wearfigs.com with the code FIGSRX.
- 0:55That's wearfigs.com, code FIGSRX for 15% off your first order.
- 1:00The married at first sight, the love at first sight thing.
- 1:03was the MacGuffin.
- 1:04So this relationship is the MacGuffin to see how the reality TV show can stimulate anxiety, the range of emotions that actually the audience is interested in.
- 1:15The audience isn't interested in whether you get married.
- 1:17The audience is interested in the disaster.
- 1:20Are you going through life blind?
- 1:22This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 1:25On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more.
- 1:36All to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 1:42Hello, everyone.
- 1:43Today, I have Professor Tim Wilson with us today, and he was the winner of the Circle UK back in 2018-2019.
- 1:52And we're here to talk about the complete debacle and fiasco of the Married at First Sight UK allegations of
- 2:03Three people within the cast members have now alleged that there's been assault on them from their partners and that production and the channel was aware of these allegations.
- 2:18went through with filming and aired the show before recently pulling it off of their streaming service after the police opened up an investigation into these alleged cases of assault.
- 2:30So, Tim, I want to have you on here because you've pleased.
- 2:34It gets worse than that, I think, because I think one couple were literally pulled out of the show completely because the girl protested and that meant...
- 2:44She was shoved off.
- 2:45So if you say anything, you get punished.
- 2:48And that is the reality of reality TV.
- 2:50There are so many levels to this.
- 2:52And I mean, you know better than me because you were on the American version of Married at First Sight.
- 2:58And I was just on the thing called... Love is blind.
- 3:01Love is blind.
- 3:01Isn't that the same as Married at First Sight?
- 3:03They're similar.
- 3:04You see your person here.
- 3:06You don't see him on Love is Blind.
- 3:07But the whole idea is you get married.
- 3:10And the creator of the show, in my view, probably has some stuff he's trying to work out for himself in terms of marriage because all of his shows have that element to it.
- 3:20But yeah.
- 3:21The creator of the circle is somebody that I realized I'd met.
- 3:26when he was at Oxford, and I knew the people in his house, and I went into his house, and we would have met, but for some reason, he didn't remember me, and I didn't remember him, so obviously, we were highly immemorable at that time, but we liked each other, we liked each other, and what he's been doing, and what that production company has been doing, is churning out basically the same
- 3:48the same show again in different variants.
- 3:49So they did Circle, and now they've done a much more successful game called Traitors.
- 3:54But it's basically the same formula, which is, you're trying to work out who is telling the truth and who is not telling the truth, which is fascinating.
- 4:02But that is just the game.
- 4:04Hitchcock had this phrase, I don't know whether you know it, but he talked about the MacGuffin.
- 4:09So the MacGuffin is what Indiana Jones is looking for.
- 4:14for the Temple of Doom or the Ark of the Covenant.
- 4:20We're not interested in that thing.
- 4:22We're interested in the next fight and the next escape.
- 4:27His journey to get there.
- 4:28His journey, why he's doing it is the MacGuffin.
- 4:32And why we were in these reality shows, the game element was the MacGuffin.
- 4:37So I think in a way the married at first sight, the love at first sight thing was the MacGuffin.
- 4:43So this relationship is the MacGuffin to see how...
- 4:46The reality TV show can stimulate anxiety, the range of emotions that actually the audience is interested in.
- 4:53The audience isn't interested in whether you get married.
- 4:56The audience is interested in the disaster.
- 4:58And these television programmes are convinced that...
- 5:03A disaster, a catastrophe is good viewing.
- 5:06Actually, the early reality TV shows...
- 5:08I love your dog, by the way.
- 5:10I was going to say, you can hear him, I assume.
- 5:12Don't edit him out.
- 5:13He's lovely.
- 5:14I won't edit him out.
- 5:16Good.
- 5:16But are we going to see him?
- 5:18Hello?
- 5:18Come on.
- 5:20I usually bring him in here when I'm filming.
- 5:22How lovely.
- 5:23Here he is.
- 5:25He's delightful.
- 5:28What's his name?
- 5:30His name is Grayson.
- 5:33Grayson is superb.
- 5:35Wonderful.
- 5:35One of my friends in the States has just lost a dog and is devastated.
- 5:40Yeah, I know.
- 5:41It's awful.
- 5:42When you lose an animal, they're part of your family.
- 5:44I've lost both my cats and it was so distressing.
- 5:47So distressing.
- 5:48I will get other animals when I'm a little more stable, but it is awful.
- 5:53You miss having them around.
- 5:58I think about it all the time.
- 5:59And he turns eight this year.
- 6:01I think about it all the time.
- 6:03And he shows he's very healthy.
- 6:06We just had a vet visit a month or so ago.
- 6:08He's very healthy.
- 6:11His health is younger than his age, according to the vet.
- 6:14She said I would have guessed without knowing he was maybe three, four years old.
- 6:18But you think about it because I've lost dogs as a child growing up and stuff.
- 6:22Yeah.
- 6:23Just it's the worst.
- 6:24So my heart goes out.
- 6:25And you take care and you're careful with them.
- 6:29I was very careful with my cats.
- 6:32The most alarming thing I did was to take one of them onto the show.
- 6:36And I was pleased.
- 6:37I did.
- 6:38He loved it.
- 6:39And when we came off, he was constantly sidling up to the television and trying to get in the television again.
- 6:45He understood that much, I think.
- 6:47Yeah.
- 6:48And he loved the attention.
- 6:50He could sense it.
- 6:53my dog was the same way with the filming and there was one I have a picture of it we were filming in my condominium my apartment and there was a camera guy lighting he literally went on the couch and sat in the middle cushion which was the center of all the cameras and all the lighting and he just sat there and I took a picture of it because I'm like he's been ready for this he needs this attention he's ready to put on a performance of a lifetime show everyone how good of a boy he is
- 7:21Yeah, no, Bay was there for a month and he just luxuriated in it and he had fans, of course.
- 7:31But he was, whereas my other cat was very, very old and I was terrified that I'd come out of the show and that she would be dead.
- 7:40And in fact, there was a celebrity who came onto the show and was mean to me about my older cat, really mean.
- 7:48And I cried for 24 hours.
- 7:51Your emotions are so pushed in these things, as you know.
- 7:54Oh, yeah.
- 7:56Well, you're a pressure cooker and your emotions are heightened and you're making decisions that are life altering with limited sleep.
- 8:06Your everyday structure of life and your support system is gone.
- 8:09Did you have alcohol as well?
- 8:11Yeah, there was a lot of alcohol available almost the entire time.
- 8:15And were they filming you at 3 a.m. in the morning?
- 8:19At times, yeah.
- 8:20I mean, we would get started.
- 8:22I can't remember exactly.
- 8:23I want to say we'd be mic'd up, COVID tested, because we were in the middle of COVID, probably like 8.30, and then 1, 2, 3 o'clock in the morning is when you get to go back.
- 8:35It's all intentional.
- 8:36And in my case, I had a mic on day and night.
- 8:40But they would make me stay in bed until about 11 or 12 o'clock.
- 8:44And one of my colleagues had a clock on the bottom of a weighing machine.
- 8:52And so she was able to confirm that the times which I thought were happening when we were filming were genuine.
- 8:58We were genuinely filming at three o'clock in the morning.
- 9:00And certainly when we were doing decisions, they wanted those decisions done at three o'clock in the morning when we were tired, weak, distracted.
- 9:09And they were just pliers with cocktails.
- 9:12And I'm a bit of a lighthead anyway.
- 9:18Three cocktails.
- 9:19I'm anybody's.
- 9:20They always wanted to know, why did you block?
- 9:24What was it?
- 9:24A brook.
- 9:26And the answer was, I was told repeatedly, oh, you've said that she should go, Tim.
- 9:31You should act on it.
- 9:32You should follow this through.
- 9:33Otherwise, you're a hypocrite.
- 9:35You've said that she should go.
- 9:36And I thought since it's something that's preyed on my mind.
- 9:39I never said it.
- 9:40I never said it.
- 9:43They literally make you think.
- 9:45Yeah.
- 9:46Yeah.
- 9:47And it's this voice of God that you're not allowed to talk about.
- 9:50You're not allowed to say.
- 9:51There's this voice constantly with you.
- 9:54Of course, you feel very close to that voice because suddenly you've got God in your room and he talks back.
- 10:03I saw a fellow the other day from the American series who came to Oxford and received his degree.
- 10:09And he's so lovely.
- 10:11And he's so calm and centered.
- 10:14And it's very rare.
- 10:17It's very rare that you get somebody who is so centered in reality TV.
- 10:22But he also projects vulnerability, which is, of course, why they wanted him.
- 10:28Yeah.
- 10:29And then, yeah, I mean, I think when I, people sometimes ask me if I would go back, I think that's a silly question.
- 10:36Do it again.
- 10:36We talked a little bit about that, but when people ask me what I would do differently, if I had the context of how this all played out, you know, hindsight's always 20, 20, but I definitely, I think I would have been more, I still would have stayed authentic, but I think I would have been just a little bit more
- 10:56of a character of myself and not bring, yeah, because that vulnerability is what would get me and I would be vulnerable and I would be authentic, but like, I think I would hold back a little bit because yeah, I think that's just what I would do.
- 11:13The holding back would make you less telegenic, of course.
- 11:16Exactly.
- 11:17What I felt, there was a point in the filming that when I got into the show, I sort of performed Tim and,
- 11:25And then there was this point when Richard Madeley, Madeley or Mabley, Madeley, I think, attacked me.
- 11:31And I was so devastated.
- 11:33It transformed me.
- 11:37And I sort of realized I went through a process and I became the televisual me.
- 11:44And it wasn't so different.
- 11:46It was just that I was aware of me.
- 11:49Yes.
- 11:49In a different way.
- 11:50I was aware of everything.
- 11:52Yes.
- 11:54So I was aware of how the edits were taking place.
- 11:57Absolutely.
- 11:58I could see my scenes.
- 11:59You could see the storyline playing out.
- 12:02Yeah.
- 12:02Yeah.
- 12:03And I'd been told.
- 12:03Because they have that.
- 12:05Yes.
- 12:05Every morning they have a storyline session.
- 12:07I presume they write a script.
- 12:09And I was told.
- 12:10We had a storyline supervisor who wrote the script and kept track of things that were said according to what they wanted the storyline to be.
- 12:18And they will prompt you until you say what they want.
- 12:21And if you say stuff that they're not interested in, that's all edited out.
- 12:25So I remember when I was cast, I said that I'd just been given a new job.
- 12:29And I'd been moved from the chair of education to the chair of theology.
- 12:36And I was going to hold a big conference.
- 12:39And I was attending a conference in St. Petersburg.
- 12:42at the end of the month.
- 12:43And so when they called me and they said, you know, are you free this month?
- 12:47I said, well, I am, but I'm not free at the end of the month.
- 12:49And they said to me, oh, don't worry.
- 12:51You're the old fart we'll get rid of within two weeks.
- 12:55And I thought, that's fine.
- 12:56I can do that.
- 12:59And then I lingered and I stayed and I stayed.
- 13:01And I realized I wasn't going to go to my own.
- 13:06I wasn't going to go to the conference in St. Petersburg.
- 13:09And I wasn't going to go back to my own conference.
- 13:11And when I came out of the show, a fellow from the government contacted me who I was friendly with.
- 13:16And he said he'd been talking to...
- 13:20to the home office or the foreign office.
- 13:24And people there had warned him that I shouldn't go back to Russia because I was overexposed.
- 13:31And I thought that was quite interesting advice.
- 13:34And I thought if I don't take that advice seriously, then if there is danger, I can't turn around and say, please help me.
- 13:40So I took it seriously and I never went back.
- 13:41That's scary.
- 13:43And of course, Putin by that point was out of control.
- 13:46So I think I made the right decision.
- 13:48Yeah, I think so too.
- 13:53But I continued.
- 13:54I had some students who were writing theses and things.
- 13:57And I continued to monitor their work and to process their work and to support them.
- 14:03So I did a lot of work after 2019.
- 14:08a lot of work as a professor.
- 14:09So I feel, you know, they've got their money's worth, really.
- 14:13And they, oh, their payment was dreadful.
- 14:20I had to go through all this nonsense of getting a card in whatever bank it was.
- 14:26And that took about a year.
- 14:28And during that time, they didn't pay.
- 14:29And when they finally paid, it was such a pittance.
- 14:32And I just thought, this isn't worth it, really.
- 14:34It's now worth it.
- 14:36So I didn't take that much encouraging not to go back.
- 14:39But it was, yeah, it was right.
- 14:41But back to Married at First Sight.
- 14:42The point is, I've been right since I came out of the show recently.
- 14:46since I came out of my show, I'd been writing again and again and again to the government saying this is a problem.
- 14:54And Boris Johnson, I can't remember if it was Boris Johnson or whether his predecessor, had called a committee session in Parliament to look into the deaths on Love Island and another one, the Jeremy Kyle show, which was particularly gruesome.
- 15:15And there have been suicides.
- 15:16Well, you know, and I know, because we've talked about this before.
- 15:20I think the last time we talked, the tally was about 50, 52 or 55 suicides on record in both the States and the UK.
- 15:29And in any other business, that would have stopped the business.
- 15:32But this business is so lucrative.
- 15:34It's too big to fail.
- 15:36Yeah.
- 15:37And and so the United States and Britain have both set up these sort of rules, partly because and they've also set up this fantasy about what they think is the problem is.
- 15:47And the problem that they put out is that people have a bad edit and then they can't deal with the loss of fame or the acquisition of fame.
- 15:56And they go a bit loopy.
- 15:57That is not the problem.
- 16:00As you know, let's talk about that for a minute, because I think the problem is the thing called loss of agency.
- 16:07And you lose your sense of self.
- 16:11And that's what happened to you, isn't it?
- 16:13Yeah.
- 16:14So I agree.
- 16:15I think it is agency.
- 16:16You lose your sense of self or you're competing.
- 16:20And I actually interviewed with Dr. Isabel Morley about the psychology behind this from UCANN.
- 16:25Yeah.
- 16:26And so the challenge with that is you're in constant conflict of like who you are versus who they're trying to make you be.
- 16:35Yes.
- 16:35And so when those conflict with each other and there's the power dynamic, that's when you lose your agency.
- 16:43And when you lose your agency, well, I talk about autonomy.
- 16:47You lose your autonomy.
- 16:48And so to tie this back to Merit at First Sight and these allegations of assault on these three women –
- 16:55I think to myself, what's horrible is that all they really can do is report the red flags, the abuse, the assault, whatever.
- 17:04But they can't leave.
- 17:07They've lost their autonomy.
- 17:09Or they're thrown out.
- 17:12Or they're thrown out.
- 17:13They find that in reporting this, they are a failure.
- 17:17They have failed at this MacGuffin, at this game.
- 17:22It is outrageous.
- 17:24And the point is, you have been flagging up a show which is very similar, and I've been flagging it up, and Britain is too arrogant.
- 17:32It says, oh, Ofcom is going to look after.
- 17:34Ofcom couldn't look after itself.
- 17:37Let alone.
- 17:38And the ministry that deals with this has been staffed by twits for so long.
- 17:43They had a woman called Nadine Dorris who wrote books.
- 17:47She wrote these extraordinarily bodice ripping books about nurses in the north.
- 17:53And I read all of them, by the way.
- 17:55When I had cancer and I was in hospital, I took my entire set of Nadine Dorris books and I read through them.
- 18:01vigorously.
- 18:02And that was after the show.
- 18:05She's a page-turner, but it's rubbish.
- 18:07And when she was a minister, she was useless.
- 18:10And I thought, given the fact that she's written this mush...
- 18:15She might understand cheap entertainment, but she doesn't.
- 18:19She doesn't.
- 18:20And she was part of the problem.
- 18:22She couldn't deal with it.
- 18:23And it's a ministry which could be, which is very important because, you know, the arts are a great export.
- 18:30Can you explain what it is?
- 18:31America.
- 18:32What?
- 18:32Say again?
- 18:33Can you explain what the agency is, like what it's supposed to do?
- 18:36Agency is – so when you're walking around in the street, you have agency.
- 18:41You feel – I use the word agency.
- 18:44You use the word autonomy.
- 18:45Autonomy is about self-control.
- 18:48You are controlling yourself.
- 18:49You are in charge of yourself.
- 18:51They intertwine.
- 18:53Like when you lose agency, you're –
- 18:56So the point is that when you're in the arts, you always surrender your agency for the sake of the larger project.
- 19:04And it's generally done through a director or through a company.
- 19:09And you're in a safe space.
- 19:11It's why people go to drama school to learn how to trade that agency.
- 19:15and how to get it back afterwards.
- 19:17And sometimes you get it back from the love of the audience, but that is also a danger, the danger of feeling that you are famous.
- 19:24In a way, that's an irrelevance, but in reality TV, it becomes relevant because that is all you know.
- 19:32So in reality TV, you have no director that you can deal with, that you can confide in.
- 19:37You have no company that can support you.
- 19:40And your family and friends are fed a completely fake reality that this is what they see is the edit.
- 19:47They don't see the, and we can't call it a rehearsal.
- 19:53It isn't.
- 19:54And you don't see the reality until it's screened.
- 19:59So it's a surprise to see what comes out on the television.
- 20:03But by that point, you have already surrendered your agency and trying to get it back is like, I don't know.
- 20:12My show was in 2018, 2019.
- 20:15And I think it took me a good three to four years to recover.
- 20:20And during that time, I had cancer.
- 20:22And I wrote a piece for one of the newspapers.
- 20:24And I said that the 18 months after the show were the worst 18 months of my life.
- 20:30It was worse than being held at gunpoint, which happened to me a few times in Greece.
- 20:34And I thought that was a good line.
- 20:36And then I had cancer.
- 20:38And when the cancer was removed, when the tumor was removed, the consultant said, oh, it's about 18 months old.
- 20:44And I thought, that's interesting.
- 20:46It was like an elongated carrot, which is what I think of the circle now.
- 20:53I think I had a lucky escape.
- 20:56I think I was very fortunate.
- 20:58You know, but it's a lot to pay for entertainment.
- 21:02That makes it very gladiatorial.
- 21:04I almost gave my life for this program that did not respect me.
- 21:08The real problem is that the show is predicated on control and deceit.
- 21:13And that's why your agency goes.
- 21:15But of course, you feel that you're involved in this thing.
- 21:18So you surrender it as well.
- 21:19It's not stolen from you.
- 21:22And in most cases, you slowly give it up.
- 21:25In some cases, you applied to be on the show.
- 21:27And so it's sort of your responsibility.
- 21:29In most cases, in my experience, people have telephoned you.
- 21:33I was telephoned and a lot of pressure was put on me to say yes, because I was a fit for the character they were looking for.
- 21:39And they thought that they could control me.
- 21:41They said I'd only be wanted for about two weeks.
- 21:44In fact, I think they realized I was good television and they kept me for the whole thing.
- 21:49But that wasn't what I think they intended.
- 21:51As we spoke earlier, they almost certainly have a script and you're conforming to the script.
- 21:57You just don't know what the script is.
- 21:59And that's great.
- 22:00If they get the right set of characters, they can produce amazing drama because you're living it.
- 22:06You don't need to learn the words.
- 22:07They come automatically because you're put in the environment where those words happen.
- 22:11It's the ultimate in method acting.
- 22:14But then there's a toll.
- 22:17And the toll is that you lose your agency.
- 22:19You lose your control.
- 22:21You lose your sense of self.
- 22:23And sometimes this means that, you know, power goes to your head.
- 22:27Sometimes it means that you just feel diminished.
- 22:29And sometimes it means that you're sort of lost and you make stupid mistakes.
- 22:33And the real problem, I think, is that after the show...
- 22:37You're given psychiatric support and PR support by the same company, and the company doesn't know when to switch off its control button.
- 22:44So it lives by control, and it continues to control you.
- 22:49And you, as this being, that is this child that has surrendered agency, like a little child surrenders agency to its mother, you surrender your agency to this parent figure.
- 23:01You deeply trust whoever they present.
- 23:05And it changes with the day.
- 23:06But, you know, it changed with the day when you were in the show.
- 23:08And you trusted the company.
- 23:11And then the company throws these...
- 23:13They used to say that to us, trust the process.
- 23:16And then the company throws these malevolent people who are not being particularly malevolent.
- 23:20It's just that they are continuing to control.
- 23:23You actually want to find your freedom and find your feet.
- 23:26And you're not getting the...
- 23:28They're controlling, but they're not giving you the full support.
- 23:30So I had this person who used to do a sort of checklist.
- 23:34She would go down the list, and one of the questions was, have you had suicidal thoughts?
- 23:38And I always said no, until one day I just said yes, and she just continued.
- 23:43And I thought, that is significant.
- 23:45And various people...
- 23:46did have suicidal thoughts and attempted suicide.
- 23:50And thankfully they called me and they said that they'd called the hotline and nothing happened.
- 23:54And it got so stressful for me.
- 23:56I called the hotline and I never told them why I called the hotline.
- 23:59I've never told anybody why I called the hotline.
- 24:02And I called this hotline.
- 24:04And they said, you're not employed by the studio, so we don't support you.
- 24:08And for 10 days, they offered me no support.
- 24:14And on the 10th day, they called me and they said, oh, we found that we do actually support you.
- 24:17What would you like?
- 24:18And I said, oh, you know, really, just go away.
- 24:21Yeah.
- 24:22I remember at one point, I wrote immediately to the company.
- 24:26Sorry.
- 24:27The guy, no, I was just going to say the guy that was following up with me literally admitted to me he was checking a box.
- 24:34And this is one of the things I talked about with Dr. Isabel too was these things need to, these mental health support, they need to be independent of production.
- 24:44Absolutely independent.
- 24:44Because.
- 24:45Yes.
- 24:45Yeah, because they have a mandate to do no harm, ethical guidelines to advocate for their clients.
- 24:52And when you blur the line on who's the client, it's a very challenging situation.
- 24:56And you've also got these people, psychologists, psychiatrists.
- 25:00We don't really know what a psychologist is.
- 25:02It could be almost anybody can be a psychologist.
- 25:06It's a grand name which is given to such a range of skills.
- 25:10There are real psychiatrists.
- 25:12I know one.
- 25:13One of them was my student who ended up being one of the people who actually does all the tests and monitors these things.
- 25:18But he didn't take on the show I was on because he said it was predicated on deceit.
- 25:23We've talked about it since.
- 25:24But it is extraordinary.
- 25:26The psychologists are there.
- 25:28They come into the show.
- 25:29They sit down with you if you're having a bad day.
- 25:32And they switch off, they go through this big pallava, switching off the microphones.
- 25:36So we're, so we're, whatever you say is confidential.
- 25:40It's confidential as hell.
- 25:42It's not confidential at all.
- 25:43I'm sure they jabber away, jabber away afterwards.
- 25:46And you, and you think...
- 25:47How did they know that?
- 25:48That's something I told the...
- 25:50I'm sure the room is mic'd.
- 25:52Of course the room is mic'd.
- 25:54I remember... Did you have the problem of having to go to the loo on camera?
- 25:58Not on camera, but I did leave my mic on one time and they heard me cough and knocked on the door.
- 26:03It was very uncomfortable.
- 26:04So I started turning my microphone off when I'd go to the bathroom.
- 26:08No, well, in my case...
- 26:10They had a camera in the bathroom.
- 26:12That's insane.
- 26:13It literally was a bathroom.
- 26:14I'm not using the American euphemism here.
- 26:16Yeah.
- 26:17No, because they...
- 26:19So they wanted to film as if we were having a shower...
- 26:24I was so uncomfortable.
- 26:25And if you went to the loo, you had to tell them what you were going to do so they'd know which position to put the camera in or whether to switch off the microphone.
- 26:35And so I just thought, there's no way I'm giving them medical details.
- 26:38So I converted it all into political characters.
- 26:41So if one was going in there for a fairly rapid visit, it was a Whiddicombe, who was this rather ridiculous MP at the time.
- 26:49I've just lost my ear.
- 26:52And if it was something that took a little bit more effort, it was a sedentary experience, that was a Farage.
- 26:58I don't know if you know Mr. Farage over there.
- 27:00No, I don't think so.
- 27:01He's a sort of friend of Trump.
- 27:03He's a sort of Trump child.
- 27:05Okay.
- 27:06And I thought, yeah, Farage.
- 27:07And that did actually get into the edit at one point.
- 27:10So I'm rather pleased that Farage has become a synonym for...
- 27:15Taking a dump.
- 27:16Yes, isn't it?
- 27:17It's very good.
- 27:19And then I decided that once or twice I came out and somebody said, they've always said, oh, that was quick.
- 27:25And I said, oh, it was just a bit of Mrs. May.
- 27:27A lot of hot air.
- 27:28Yeah, but you get no privacy.
- 27:30And that is partly how they...
- 27:32how they wrest your agency from you.
- 27:34So when I was teaching teachers how to teach, I would always say that you go into a classroom and you get the children to do something that they would do naturally, but you give an order for it.
- 27:44And so you're doing things which you do naturally, like going to bed, like going to the loo, but everything, or eating, but everything is controlled.
- 27:52You get permission for everything that you actually are going to do anyway.
- 27:56And you start to recognize the authority.
- 27:59The authority is the voice of God.
- 28:00It's not called the voice of God for nothing.
- 28:03And you start to adore your voice of God.
- 28:06I did.
- 28:06I had two of them.
- 28:07And on the days when my two voices of God were absent and I had somebody else, they were lovely.
- 28:13But I felt bereft because it wasn't the person I was used to.
- 28:17And they made silly mistakes.
- 28:18And I made stupid mistakes because I was relying on this thing.
- 28:22that wasn't really reliable.
- 28:25It's like a false voice of God.
- 28:29It is a false voice of God.
- 28:30And I kept friends with one of the voices of God for quite a while.
- 28:34And then I think he was told not to talk to me by the studio.
- 28:39That's a real thing.
- 28:40I've been through that too.
- 28:42But, you know, it...
- 28:44You're working with the studio.
- 28:46The studio actually offered me a production job, which they offered it to me three times.
- 28:50But I think that was to try and keep me quiet.
- 28:52I could be.
- 28:54Oh, yeah.
- 28:55Yeah.
- 28:56That's the thing.
- 28:57I wouldn't have done anything.
- 28:58They just wanted a name there.
- 29:00But they wanted my name in production.
- 29:02So I would then be bound by an NDA.
- 29:04NDA.
- 29:05NDA.
- 29:06NDA.
- 29:07Yeah.
- 29:07Non-disclosure agreement.
- 29:09Yeah.
- 29:10Because the NDA I signed wasn't very, very effective.
- 29:14And I'm not sure I signed an NDA because I was rushed in so fast, I barely knew what was happening.
- 29:20That's by design too.
- 29:21They force you to make the contract signing decisions, all of this stuff super, super quick to really force you to not think it through, not have it reviewed, all of that stuff.
- 29:32It's all by design.
- 29:34They want you in a heightened state of your nervous system being dysregulated so that you're easily going to make decisions
- 29:43Or you're quickly going to make decisions that aren't necessarily thought out.
- 29:47And you're going to do them under the guise of like a fake time constraint.
- 29:51But they arranged a thing on my program where they had two people who then presented themselves as one individual.
- 30:00But those two people were put in a room on their own to have a relationship, which they duly did.
- 30:08That seems like pimping.
- 30:10And I'm afraid...
- 30:13Yeah.
- 30:14Isn't that part of what I think the problem is with what happened with the married at first sight is you're forced into these relationships.
- 30:23You lack agency.
- 30:24You don't have the autonomy to walk away.
- 30:26And there's this dynamic where this is TV and you're almost performing a little bit.
- 30:32And there's this, well, you're my wife.
- 30:35You're my husband.
- 30:37And it creates this weird dynamic.
- 30:38Whereas when you first meet someone, if they...
- 30:41When you first meet someone and you get a red flag, you can walk away.
- 30:45You can leave.
- 30:45You cannot not go on that second date, third date, whatever.
- 30:49Here, you're forcing them to be in this dangerous environment and they can't leave.
- 30:55Yeah, but it's worse than that, I think, because the you're my wife, that line has been quoted and quoted and you were just doing an NBC interview.
- 31:04Have I got that right?
- 31:04Or have I?
- 31:05Yeah, I did.
- 31:05Yeah.
- 31:06Yeah.
- 31:06No, no, no.
- 31:07You're right.
- 31:07NBC Universal.
- 31:08Yep.
- 31:09Yeah.
- 31:13And you're my wife.
- 31:15That sounds like almost the worst story in the various stories.
- 31:18And it is.
- 31:19It's pretty bad.
- 31:20Except, and I want to defend the man.
- 31:23I know it's indefensible.
- 31:25I want to defend the man for just, I want to see it from his point of view.
- 31:29And I want to give him a defense.
- 31:31And I don't know whether he'll watch this.
- 31:33I don't expect he will.
- 31:35But the, you're my wife, he is using the language of control because that is the language that's been used to him.
- 31:43He is poodling the, or he's channeling the reality TV ethic.
- 31:50Yeah.
- 31:51So it's not that surprising that he says this and that he bullies.
- 31:55A bully is always bullied.
- 31:59And that's what you've got, I'm afraid.
- 32:02I think you're right.
- 32:03It's so horrible.
- 32:04And they're looking for these characters.
- 32:07Sorry, go on.
- 32:08I wanted to ask you a couple questions specifically about this.
- 32:12The first one I want to ask you is,
- 32:14And I think I experienced this, which is why, and I think we're similar in this way.
- 32:19What comes up for you when you see a story like this, that is just a level above the normal atrocities we see every day in reality TV.
- 32:28But this one, like there's serious allegations still.
- 32:31Yes.
- 32:32But reports of, of literal, like sexual assault and rape, which now I said those things, I've got to put a trigger warning on this video, but there's.
- 32:42legitimate allegations.
- 32:45Yeah.
- 32:46No, no.
- 32:46Those allegations are criminal allegations, of course.
- 32:49So we have to use the word allegedly and so on.
- 32:51But the point is, I just see these as an extreme version of what is already there.
- 32:56And that's the problem.
- 32:56So I've just given a defense for this man, in a way.
- 33:00What he did, I think, if he did it, was inexcusable.
- 33:04But at the same time, I can see how he did it.
- 33:07I can see how all that he's a particular type who was cast, which is the responsibility of the company as well.
- 33:16Yes.
- 33:18And people are responsible for what they do, but the level of responsibility that you can actually maintain in these reality TV shows is very small.
- 33:30And I think this is a situation where this fellow is going to be...
- 33:36I would imagine there will be an effort to try and say, well, he is the aberration.
- 33:40Actually, he is simply the...
- 33:42He is simply the manifestation of all that is wrong.
- 33:47In the same way as when those 52 to 55 people have killed themselves, that is the manifestation of all that is wrong in reality TV.
- 33:55But for those 55 people, there are many others who have attempted suicide or who have felt so miserable.
- 34:02Their lives are changed and not for the better because the television companies are determined that nothing will be bigger than they are.
- 34:13So if you are successful on these shows, you are suppressed.
- 34:17Absolutely.
- 34:17You are exactly right about that.
- 34:19And I think it kind of goes back to what you were saying, what we were talking about earlier, too, is there is a lack of care here in general.
- 34:30But when you look at creating a safe space for these people to build these unrealistic engineered relationships and you don't have like the safety protocols in place.
- 34:43I think that is a reflection of the production companies because they're only going to do what you force them to do, right?
- 34:50And when they're incentivized to produce good TV and not provide safe working conditions...
- 34:59you're going to get all sorts of crazy.
- 35:01And when they run these background checks and they run these psychological evaluations, I think it proves that they're not using them to determine safety and fit for a show.
- 35:13They're using them to make sure that they get good drama.
- 35:17And you've got extreme character in the UK.
- 35:20Exactly.
- 35:21And it has to escalate over and over.
- 35:22And you've got the UK who claims they have the gold standard in quality of care.
- 35:28happening, and they probably do, which is its own problem.
- 35:32That's terrible.
- 35:33You probably do have the gold standard.
- 35:35Well, it's probably better than any others.
- 35:37But this scandal demonstrates it's not good enough.
- 35:40And it's not good enough because they didn't actually do the research.
- 35:42They didn't take the evidence in the committee.
- 35:44So, you know, in my ideal world, not only would the psychological support be offered by a completely independent
- 35:54company, which has no link at all with the production company.
- 35:58But in order to go on to these shows, you would be given an agent or a manager who, again, is completely independent, who is yours, and who would be with you for 18 months or two or three years.
- 36:11and would then hand you on to other agents or whatever.
- 36:14So you know there's somebody who's got your back because that's what you don't have.
- 36:19And the Channel 4 people, I spoke to people right at the top of Channel 4 and they were saying, oh, we've tried...
- 36:27agents before and and passing people on to agents i said that's not really what i'm talking about and they didn't get it because they wanted their own they wanted to push their own interpretation of my words yeah in the same way as they want to push the idea that the problem with reality tv is a bad edit and people who are disappointed with how they're a bad apple yeah yeah and this guy's a bad apple
- 36:54The problem is the lack of agency.
- 36:56The problem is a lack of proper support and independent support.
- 37:02And yes, the government would say, oh, well, the production company needs to pay for this psychological support or all this stuff.
- 37:11Yeah, that's fine.
- 37:12But the company needs to pay for outside support that has no connection whatsoever.
- 37:19and no responsibility to the production company.
- 37:25And I don't know how you get that in place, but it needs to be in place by law.
- 37:31I agree.
- 37:32I think what we need to do is we need basic labor protections that have made their way into the regular entertainment, or I should say traditional entertainment industry like Hollywood.
- 37:43We need mental health and professionals and psychologists
- 37:48by their profession that hold them accountable for their licensure.
- 37:51We need these types of things because production isn't going to change until we force them to.
- 37:57And the way I think we can force them to is through regulation and through duty of care, but not them, not their duty of care, the duty of care of the people that provide the care.
- 38:08Yeah, exactly.
- 38:09And, and, and, and so your organization, you can, which we really ought to have a similar version in the UK, we talked about this before.
- 38:17But the, this organization is telling people who are going to go on to these shows, what to expect.
- 38:25is preparing them.
- 38:26Yes.
- 38:27So when I was on the show, I was told, first of all, I wasn't allowed to talk to my family about it.
- 38:31I wasn't allowed to talk to anyone else about it.
- 38:33And when the contract was presented, I was told that I could talk, I could get advice from a professional.
- 38:41Who is a professional if I'm not allowed to talk to anybody?
- 38:45And I did actually find an agent who would give me advice.
- 38:47Someone told, yeah, someone told me one time, like, Nick, you're the expert on this.
- 38:52I'm like, I don't know.
- 38:53There is no expert on this.
- 38:54They're like, no, you're the expert on this stuff now.
- 38:56And I was like, oh, I guess I'm the labor rights and mental health reality TV expert now just because I talk about it and learn about it and train people about it.
- 39:06it it's you're right you're right there's no experts and nobody the so-called experts literally don't know so the agents don't really understand what happens the ordinary agents don't understand what happens and the uh an ordinary joe in the street has no idea in fact they would say how could you possibly be on this show it's not safe how do you know what they're going to do to you you must be mad and you think actually
- 39:34I understand about performance.
- 39:35I understand about taking the stage.
- 39:37And I don't have any problem with that.
- 39:39And throughout four weeks...
- 39:42There were one or two moments where I felt, oh, I shouldn't have done that.
- 39:45But for the most part, I performed, and I was very comfortable with performing.
- 39:50What I could never have anticipated in a month of Sundays was that this control, which I experienced in the show, would continue afterwards.
- 39:59And it was that.
- 40:00Nobody warned me about that.
- 40:02And nobody could.
- 40:03How could anybody warn me?
- 40:04Because who would know?
- 40:05And I struggled with it.
- 40:09The only people I could talk to were people in the show.
- 40:13And most of the people in the show, you know, it's a weird bond.
- 40:18You're the only ones that went through it.
- 40:20Yeah.
- 40:21I was going to say, that's exactly what I was going to say.
- 40:23Like the relationships you make with the people on the show, those become your most important relationships because you like went through it together.
- 40:31And it,
- 40:32You all had experience and everybody had their own trauma that came out of it, but also no one understands.
- 40:39Yes and no, because the circle is very odd.
- 40:42Because my relationship, my relationships in that show were not with the people on the show with me because I didn't meet them.
- 40:50My relationships in the show were with the runners and the producers and all of those disappeared.
- 40:55And I had very deep relationships with those.
- 40:57And then the audience thinks, oh, my goodness, you've got this huge relationship with all these individuals who you're on camera with.
- 41:04No, I didn't.
- 41:04Those relationships formed in the few days after the show.
- 41:08And they formed very fast because they had to form because we needed support.
- 41:13Exactly.
- 41:14Yeah.
- 41:14And you kind of fall into it with one another, you know.
- 41:17I'm so sorry.
- 41:19Oh, that's okay.
- 41:23I don't know how to stop that.
- 41:25I'm so sorry.
- 41:26Oh, for goodness sake.
- 41:27Can I just answer this?
- 41:29Hello?
- 41:29I'm recording.
- 41:31Can we talk in 10, 15 minutes?
- 41:33Sorry.
- 41:34Are you able to edit that out?
- 41:36Or do we leave it in?
- 41:38I marked it.
- 41:39I'll edit that out.
- 41:40Don't worry.
- 41:40I'm sorry.
- 41:43Yeah, I have like 10 minutes because I'm supposed to be on another call right now.
- 41:47We have to pull this together.
- 41:49And it's a lot of work to edit.
- 41:53It's going to be fine.
- 41:56One of the things I am doing is I'm writing to Parliament again.
- 42:01And I really want to recommend you.
- 42:03I want to recommend that Parliament reconvenes the committee.
- 42:07It's called the DCMS committee.
- 42:09It's got an acronym, Digital Culture, Media and Sport.
- 42:13They bung all these together because they don't know what to do with them.
- 42:16And it's generally run by an idiot.
- 42:18This particular one is called Lisa Nandy.
- 42:20So I will write to my own local...
- 42:22Member of Parliament.
- 42:24We've already spoken about this about two years ago, and he said he would keep it on file.
- 42:29I think now is the time, and I think we have to reconvene this committee, which was truncated by Boris when he called an election, reconvene it so that we can actually, we can take evidence from people like you, like me, who have experienced this, so that
- 42:45So that proper regulations can be drawn up, not this nonsense which Ofcom pedals at the moment, which is just window dressing, a window dressing more than that which serves production.
- 42:56And production lobbies very hard to have this control.
- 43:02Production has worked so hard on the propaganda to convince people that the problem with reality TV is fame, the loss of fame of people who can't deal with it, people who had a bad edit.
- 43:14That is not the problem.
- 43:16And until we can challenge reality TV,
- 43:19that conclusion adequately.
- 43:21We will not get a solution and there will be more deaths and there will be more horrific stories like this one.
- 43:28But I need you to come over here and fight this one and I will come over there and help you as much as I possibly can.
- 43:36This is because reality TV can only get bigger because it's cheap enough to be made and production companies need cheap television and it's popular and there's no reason why it couldn't be good.
- 43:48But it requires casting carefully.
- 43:53And at the moment, it's not cast carefully.
- 43:55It's cast quickly.
- 43:57And the casting company are simply looking for characters who fit into a particular mold.
- 44:02And then they're pushed to their extreme.
- 44:04And then production will say, oh, well, we've ticked all the boxes.
- 44:10Yeah.
- 44:12And that's where that's the state of where we're at right now.
- 44:14And I feel like the changes that we need to see, you can boil it down across all shows, whether it's the circle, dating shows, marriage shows, whatever those are.
- 44:25And it comes down to to your agency and autonomy, basic labor rights.
- 44:31and mental health support, not mental health warfare or psychological warfare.
- 44:37You mentioned labor rights.
- 44:39Of course, one of the things that production companies will go on about if you talk to them, and I have done, is they say, well, did you enjoy being on the show?
- 44:48You looked as if you were having a great time, as if it's fun.
- 44:51Actually, the reality needs to be admitted.
- 44:53The people who are on these shows are working jolly hard.
- 44:56We are doing a job.
- 44:58We are entertaining.
- 44:59And we should be represented by unions.
- 45:03Why not?
- 45:04Why not?
- 45:05Because if we are on television and making money for the television companies, we should be represented.
- 45:13That is exactly right.
- 45:15And that's why I think that reality cast members should have the same types of rights as a SAG actor or actress or whatever that looks like.
- 45:25I think that we have the infrastructure in place.
- 45:27We've just got to get the organization around it.
- 45:31And I don't know what it's going to take to wake up reality cast members to actually come together because it's going to take a group.
- 45:39It's not going to happen for me and you.
- 45:42And we can get little wins, but it's going to take a movement.
- 45:45And I just think there's also a lot of other things that need a movement.
- 45:49So many of these people have been on the shows and they are wrecked afterwards.
- 45:53Yeah.
- 45:54And many of them you don't see.
- 45:56Yeah.
- 45:57No, no, no.
- 45:58And those, you know, which we need to have.
- 46:01One of the things about SAG Afro and Sean Austin and all these lovely people.
- 46:06In the UK, we've got this thing called equity.
- 46:10which is based on the American equity too.
- 46:12But it didn't start until the 1930s.
- 46:16Before that, we had a thing called the Variety Artists Federation, and they had a principle that anybody who was performing for a paying audience should have representation, whether they were being paid a lot or not.
- 46:29And equity access or doorkeeper...
- 46:34And so even if you're a before-paying audience, if you haven't got the qualifications, you don't get into equity.
- 46:41I'm in equity, but it doesn't make any difference.
- 46:43Other people I know are not.
- 46:46And I remember talking to, I think his name is Jason Fleming or somebody, and he's been there for ages.
- 46:51And his line was, well, reality TV people are just being themselves.
- 46:58And that is partly true, but it's very hard work just being yourself.
- 47:01Mm-hmm.
- 47:03And it requires being yourself, being Nick or being Tim is a character.
- 47:08And it requires decisions.
- 47:10And it requires performance.
- 47:12And we are actually highly skilled by the time we get through the program.
- 47:17Very true.
- 47:18And it's so... And to be disrespected in that way by somebody who should be supporting us is astonishing.
- 47:27And we have to change that way of thinking as well.
- 47:30Yeah.
- 47:30Yeah.
- 47:31I completely agree.
- 47:32I completely agree.
- 47:34Well, Tim, I'm very grateful for the work you're doing in the UK.
- 47:37I'm glad that we were able to chat today because this is just, you know, I said earlier to someone else, I'm like, this is starting to feel like another day, another dollar when we hear these horrific stories of people being abused, being traumatized or whatever.
- 47:53And I hope that
- 47:56I'm hopeful, I guess, that there's going to be some change at some point.
- 48:01And I think having this big MAPS scandal gives you and the work you're doing trying to get parliament to look at all of this stuff.
- 48:09And, you know, I'm happy to come over and do anything that I can to help out with it as well.
- 48:13I think that getting these changes, you've got to almost keep banging your head against the wall until something sticks.
- 48:26allegedly, it's a moment for action, right?
- 48:30Like a lot of UCAN activity coming up, interviews and stuff.
- 48:34And it's not my place to always be, or it's not really my place at all to comment on people's experiences.
- 48:41But I do know that there's a lot of work to be done.
- 48:44And I'm grateful that you're doing it.
- 48:45I'm doing it.
- 48:46Dr. Isabel's doing it.
- 48:48We've got lots of people that UCAN and good people around the world that are trying to solve this problem.
- 48:53or at least solve parts of it.
- 48:54And so I'm grateful that you're doing that and willing to share what's going on.
- 48:58Well, I'm so proud of the work that you're doing over there.
- 49:01And I wish we could start.
- 49:02Same to you.
- 49:03You can hear.
- 49:04And it's so necessary.
- 49:06And whatever they say in Britain about having the gold standard of care, it's simply not true.
- 49:11Anyway, Nick, thank you.
- 49:12I can't think of a better way to end it.
- 49:13Thank you.
- 49:15Bye-bye.
- 49:15Bye-bye.
- 49:16Thank you.
- 49:17Bye-bye.
- 49:21Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 49:24If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 49:28For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 49:35Don't go through lifeline.
- 49:37Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.
- 49:41Is your home wish list just sitting in your cart?
- 49:44Well, get ready to hit checkout because Wayday at Wayfair is here.
- 49:47Save up to 80% off everything home during the biggest sale of the year.
- 49:51Whether you're refreshing the living room, upgrading the bedroom, or finally tackling that home project you've been putting off, now's the time to save big.
- 50:00Shop Wayfair's Wayday sale and get up to 80% off now till October 26th.
- 50:04These deals won't last.
- 50:06Go to Wayfair.com today.
- 50:08Wayfair, every style, every home.