Latest / Bloomberg Law / Religious Rights Case of Christian Postal Worker
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: So I'm happy that we all combyying together.
- 0:14Speaker 3: So what were the Supreme Court justice is agreeing on
- 0:18Speaker 3: or kumbayaing together to put it? In Justice Elena Kagan's words, Well,
- 0:23Speaker 3: there seemed to be consensus that the minimum standard's set
- 0:26Speaker 3: in nineteen seventy seven that's made it relatively easy for
- 0:30Speaker 3: businesses to deny workers' religious accommodation requests is too minimal.
- 0:35Speaker 3: Here's Justice Neil Gorsuch.
- 0:37Speaker 4: I think there's common ground too that deminimus can't be
- 0:41Speaker 4: the test in isolation, at least because Congress doesn't pass
- 0:46Speaker 4: civil rights legislation to have deminimous effect. Right, we don't
- 0:51Speaker 4: think of the civil rights laws as trifling, which is
- 0:54Speaker 4: the definition of deminimus. The law says since time immemorial,
- 0:58Speaker 4: you know that the law does not concern its with trifles.
- 1:01Speaker 3: In this case, a Christian US postal service worker when
- 1:05Speaker 3: he sued for religious discrimination. He lost at both the
- 1:08Speaker 3: trial court and appellate court levels. Refused to work on
- 1:11Speaker 3: Sunday to deliver Amazon packages, and the rural post office
- 1:15Speaker 3: could not accommodate his religious requests. So the real question
- 1:19Speaker 3: for the justices was coming up with a test to
- 1:22Speaker 3: determine when accommodating the religious views of an employee would
- 1:26Speaker 3: mean an undue hardship for the employer. Here's how Justice
- 1:29Speaker 3: Brett Kavanaugh posed it.
- 1:31Speaker 2: Do you understand undue hardship? I understand that term in
- 1:35Speaker 2: the original statute to reflect a balance between two important values,
- 1:40Speaker 2: one religious liberty and the other the rights of American
- 1:44Speaker 2: businesses to thrive. And to thrive, you have to be
- 1:47Speaker 2: able to make money.
- 1:50Speaker 3: My guest is Richard Garnett, a professor at Notre Dame
- 1:53Speaker 3: Law School and the director of the Program on Church,
- 1:56Speaker 3: State and Society. Rick tell us what the focus of
- 1:59Speaker 3: the justice was in the oral arguments.
- 2:02Speaker 1: The Supreme Court's oral arguments focused on the interpretation of
- 2:07Speaker 1: one of the federal civil rights laws, Title seven. And
- 2:10Speaker 1: one of the things that Title seven does is it
- 2:12Speaker 1: forbids religious discrimination in the workplace. And another thing that
- 2:16Speaker 1: it does is that it requires at least some employers
- 2:20Speaker 1: to provide reasonable accommodations. Is the word the statute uses
- 2:24Speaker 1: two employees who have special religious needs. And what had
- 2:28Speaker 1: happened almost fifty years ago now in nineteen seventy seven
- 2:31Speaker 1: was that the Supreme Court, in the case called Hartisan,
- 2:34Speaker 1: had interpreted this religious accommodations language in a very narrow way,
- 2:39Speaker 1: and a nutshell version is that the Court said that
- 2:42Speaker 1: if accommodating a religious employee would impose anything more than
- 2:46Speaker 1: a minimal cost on the employer, then an accommodation is
- 2:50Speaker 1: not required. And you know, interestingly, at the time, some
- 2:53Speaker 1: of the Court's more liberal justices, like Justice Marshall, dissented
- 2:56Speaker 1: from that, and over the years scholars have pointed out
- 2:59Speaker 1: that that's seventy seven ruling really seems inconsistent with the
- 3:02Speaker 1: language of the statute, but it's been in place for
- 3:04Speaker 1: a long time. And what the Supreme Court was focusing
- 3:06Speaker 1: on in its arguments was how to come up with
- 3:09Speaker 1: a test for religious accommodations that lines up better with
- 3:14Speaker 1: the language of the statutes. So it's not really a
- 3:16Speaker 1: case about the First Amendment itself. It's about this statute
- 3:20Speaker 1: that Congress passed, you know, part of the Civil Rights
- 3:22Speaker 1: Act again, and how to correct a mistaken interpretation to
- 3:26Speaker 1: better bring the work of the courts in line with
- 3:29Speaker 1: the language of the statute. And interestingly, and this was
- 3:31Speaker 1: something that Justice Gorsa and some of the other justices
- 3:33Speaker 1: pointed out there was a fair bit of consensus among
- 3:36Speaker 1: the justices that the nineteen seventy seven court had made
- 3:40Speaker 1: a mistake, that they narrowed the statute too much. What
- 3:43Speaker 1: the arguments focused on was how best to implement Congress's
- 3:48Speaker 1: goal of protecting religious exercise in the workplace while at
- 3:51Speaker 1: the same time taking account of employer's interests and other employees' interests.
- 3:58Speaker 3: Just going outside the argument from MoMA, the Supreme Court
- 4:01Speaker 3: had repeatedly declined to revisit religious accommodation standards. In other case,
- 4:08Speaker 3: why take this case where the post office had offered
- 4:12Speaker 3: some accommodations to the worker, and times the postmaster himself
- 4:16Speaker 3: did deliveries on Sunday because he couldn't find workers, some
- 4:19Speaker 3: workers quit, So it seemed like this was well above
- 4:24Speaker 3: a deminimus standard. I wonder why they took this case.
- 4:27Speaker 1: Yeah, And I don't have a firm theory on that.
- 4:29Speaker 1: I mean, over the years, a number of justices and
- 4:33Speaker 1: in a variety of cases, a number of justices have said, look,
- 4:35Speaker 1: we really need to revisit this. And so this is
- 4:38Speaker 1: a question, the statutory interpretation question that's been on their
- 4:41Speaker 1: radar screen for a while, and this particular case in
- 4:45Speaker 1: the lower court in the Third Circuit, you had a
- 4:47Speaker 1: pretty detailed and clear disagreement among some of the judges
- 4:51Speaker 1: and sort of it teed up the legal question pretty
- 4:54Speaker 1: well if you want. It could well be by the
- 4:56Speaker 1: way that the Supreme Court corrects the nineteen seventy seven
- 4:59Speaker 1: decision puts out a different rule, but that this particular
- 5:02Speaker 1: employee still ends up losing. That that could happen. But
- 5:05Speaker 1: right now the issue really is kind of the justices
- 5:08Speaker 1: trying to decide should we promulgate a new standard that
- 5:12Speaker 1: lines up with the statutory language better and tell the
- 5:15Speaker 1: lower courts and tell employers follow this new standard.
- 5:19Speaker 3: The worker's attorney was urging the court to adopt a
- 5:23Speaker 3: standard similar to that of the civil rights laws, like
- 5:28Speaker 3: the Americans with Disabilities Act. Right, tell us about that argument.
- 5:32Speaker 1: Yeah, so the statute uses the term reasonable accommodation, and
- 5:36Speaker 1: you know, we lawyers are familiar with the use of
- 5:38Speaker 1: the term reasonable, but it's not self defining. What mister Street,
- 5:42Speaker 1: who's the lawyer for the employee here, was saying, Yeah,
- 5:45Speaker 1: let's analogize this standard in the Title seven Religious discrimination
- 5:49Speaker 1: provision to some other non discrimination laws like the Americans
- 5:54Speaker 1: with Disabilities Act, and that statute has clearer language which says, look,
- 5:57Speaker 1: employers have to accommodate employees who need it unless the
- 6:02Speaker 1: accommodation would impose you know, a significant or a substantial hardship.
- 6:07Speaker 1: So that's kind of the language that the lawyer for
- 6:09Speaker 1: the employee was after. And one of the things that
- 6:11Speaker 1: the justices were trying to get their heads around was, well,
- 6:15Speaker 1: is that feasible or would that impose too much cost
- 6:18Speaker 1: on employers potentially? And could it in some circumstances impose
- 6:22Speaker 1: excessive burdens on other employees. So again, the justices all
- 6:26Speaker 1: seemed to agree that this nineteen seventy seven rule, which
- 6:29Speaker 1: really watered down the statute and made it the case
- 6:32Speaker 1: employers almost never had to accommodate employees. They wanted them
- 6:35Speaker 1: move away from that. But they were each of them
- 6:36Speaker 1: in different ways. They were all sensitive to the fact that,
- 6:39Speaker 1: you know, not every accommodation can be granted, So how
- 6:42Speaker 1: do you come up with language that'll provide clear guidance
- 6:44Speaker 1: but also you know, take account of all the competing factors.
- 6:48Speaker 3: Even though, as you mentioned, Justice Elena Kaigan even said
- 6:51Speaker 3: that there was some level of kumba yang between the
- 6:55Speaker 3: justices on the bench. But with regard to that making
- 6:58Speaker 3: the standard like the Americans with Disabilities Act, it seemed
- 7:01Speaker 3: like the three liberals were against that. They said that
- 7:05Speaker 3: this case is based on statutory interpretation and it's up
- 7:08Speaker 3: to Congress to decide that.
- 7:11Speaker 1: Yeah, and I think some of those judges, but again,
- 7:13Speaker 1: not only do the liberal justices asked questions along this line,
- 7:16Speaker 1: were wary of importing language into Title seven that isn't
- 7:21Speaker 1: actually in that text and that might be more demanding. Now.
- 7:24Speaker 1: The one response to that is, well, you know, the
- 7:26Speaker 1: words in the nineteen seventy seven case deminimus aren't in
- 7:28Speaker 1: there either, And instead the language you have in the
- 7:30Speaker 1: statute is reasonable accommodation and undue hardship. So I think
- 7:34Speaker 1: mister Street, the lawyer for the employee, argued, Look, Congress
- 7:38Speaker 1: did speak. Congress enacted a statute that said accommodate employees
- 7:41Speaker 1: unless doing so would impose an undue hardship. We're not
- 7:44Speaker 1: asking the court to rewrite what Congress did. We're asking
- 7:47Speaker 1: the court to give effect to what Congress did. The
- 7:49Speaker 1: concern that you mentioned, and I think Justice Kagan mentioned
- 7:52Speaker 1: as well, is well, look, Congress has known about this
- 7:55Speaker 1: nineteen seventy seven case for a long time, and if
- 7:57Speaker 1: Congress wanted to, they could give us clearer guidance about
- 8:01Speaker 1: how to implement this statute. And so I think that's
- 8:04Speaker 1: one reason why she was nervous about just pulling language
- 8:06Speaker 1: from another statute, because she thought, well, let's wait and
- 8:09Speaker 1: see if Congress wants us to do that.
- 8:11Speaker 3: How critical to the decision is it that Justices Amy Cony,
- 8:15Speaker 3: Barrett and Brett Kavanaugh suggested that this request from the
- 8:19Speaker 3: postal worker would have unduly burdened his coworkers by requiring
- 8:24Speaker 3: them to cover his hours on Sundays.
- 8:26Speaker 1: Yeah. I took him to be raised in an issue
- 8:28Speaker 1: which is going to come up in a lot of
- 8:29Speaker 1: accommodations cases, right, which is, if we're asking whether an
- 8:33Speaker 1: accommodation would impose an undue hardship on the employer, don't
- 8:37Speaker 1: we also have to consider the burden that the accommodation
- 8:40Speaker 1: might put on other employees. Now, there have been some
- 8:44Speaker 1: lower court cases where employers have denied accommodations and they've
- 8:47Speaker 1: just said, well, you know, we can't afford to accommodate
- 8:49Speaker 1: employee A, because that might make employee be sort of
- 8:52Speaker 1: resentful of it. And I don't think the justices thought
- 8:55Speaker 1: that was a very persuasive argument. But if you do
- 8:58Speaker 1: have an on the job situation where an effort to
- 9:01Speaker 1: accommodate employee A really is difficult and would impose again
- 9:07Speaker 1: undue hardships not only on the employer's bottom line, but
- 9:09Speaker 1: also on other employees, I think that's a factor that
- 9:12Speaker 1: Justices Kavanaugh and Barrett wanted to make sure it was
- 9:15Speaker 1: part of the mix.
- 9:18Speaker 3: And so how do you think it'll come out.
- 9:20Speaker 1: I think the Court, I suspect this will be unanimous,
- 9:24Speaker 1: to be honest, will acknowledge that the nineteen seventy seven
- 9:27Speaker 1: hardest and ruling and the dominimous language doesn't really comport
- 9:31Speaker 1: with the statute. And it does sound like there might
- 9:34Speaker 1: well be some division among the justices about what kind
- 9:36Speaker 1: of a standard the Court should supply, whether it's more
- 9:39Speaker 1: accommodationist or more deferential to employers. And then I don't
- 9:44Speaker 1: think the Court will resolve for itself whether this particular
- 9:47Speaker 1: employee should win. I would expect instead that the case
- 9:50Speaker 1: would go back and proceed in line with the new standards.
- 9:53Speaker 3: You know, I'm just wondering. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- 9:58Speaker 3: said that the lower courts haven't you used Title seven's
- 10:01Speaker 3: deminimous cost test. Is that true?
- 10:04Speaker 1: Well, there's some dispute about this, right, some argued, and
- 10:07Speaker 1: I should say that I joined a brief that argued
- 10:10Speaker 1: this that when you look over the full array of
- 10:14Speaker 1: Title seven cases involving religious accommodations, that a whole lot
- 10:18Speaker 1: of courts have denied accommodations when those accommodations would impose
- 10:22Speaker 1: really small costs. At the same time, the EEOC argued,
- 10:25Speaker 1: as you pointed out, and I think Justice Kagan made
- 10:27Speaker 1: this point also, and certainly the Solicitor General did that
- 10:30Speaker 1: even with that deminimous language, at least in some cases,
- 10:33Speaker 1: employees have secured accommodations. So this might be one of
- 10:37Speaker 1: those things where how you see it depends on where
- 10:39Speaker 1: you start from. But in my view, it's pretty clear
- 10:42Speaker 1: that employees have not been getting accommodated to the extent
- 10:46Speaker 1: that Congress envisioned when it passed Title seven.
- 10:49Speaker 3: Thanks for being on the show, Rick. That's Professor Richard
- 10:52Speaker 3: Garnett of Notre Dame Law School in a case with legal, economic,
- 10:57Speaker 3: and political ramifications, the Supreme Court issued a mixed decision
- 11:02Speaker 3: over whether the United States can bring criminal charges against
- 11:06Speaker 3: Turkey state owned Hawk Bank over allegations that helped Durand
- 11:10Speaker 3: to evade economic sanctions by laundering billions of dollars through
- 11:14Speaker 3: the US financial system. The Justice has rejected Hawkbank's primary
- 11:19Speaker 3: argument that federal law prohibits prosecutions of foreign governments and
- 11:24Speaker 3: the companies they own. Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who made his
- 11:27Speaker 3: view clear during the oral arguments, wrote the opinion for
- 11:30Speaker 3: seven of the justices.
- 11:32Speaker 2: I think it's pretty bizarre for this Court to tell
- 11:35Speaker 2: the President of the United States, as a matter of
- 11:38Speaker 2: his national security exercise, that even though the Constitution doesn't
- 11:43Speaker 2: prohibit what you're doing, even though a statute doesn't prohibit
- 11:46Speaker 2: what you're doing, this Court's going to prohibit your exercise
- 11:50Speaker 2: of national security authority. That talk about big steps, it is.
- 11:55Speaker 2: That's huge.
- 11:56Speaker 3: But the opinion left the bank with an out, sending
- 11:59Speaker 3: the case back to the second Circuit, where Hallbank will
- 12:02Speaker 3: have a chance to make an argument for sovereign immunity
- 12:05Speaker 3: from prosecution under the common law. Two Justices Neil Gorsuch
- 12:09Speaker 3: and Samuel Alito said they would have ruled definitively that
- 12:12Speaker 3: the prosecution of Halkbank can go forward. Joining me is
- 12:16Speaker 3: an expert on constitutional law, Harold Krant, a professor with
- 12:19Speaker 3: the Chicago Kent College of Law. So how start by
- 12:23Speaker 3: explaining Halkbank's arguments here?
- 12:27Speaker 4: Well?
- 12:27Speaker 5: Haulk Bank argued is the second circuit in the Supreme
- 12:30Speaker 5: Court that they could not be subject to criminal jurisdiction
- 12:35Speaker 5: in the United States courts, and they focus on a
- 12:37Speaker 5: provision in the Foreign Sovereign's Community to Act, which was
- 12:41Speaker 5: enacted in nineteen seventy six and four in Starned Immunity
- 12:45Speaker 5: Act most clearly relates to civil proceedings and confers partial
- 12:51Speaker 5: immunity on foreign instrumentalities for suits in the federal courts,
- 12:56Speaker 5: but in one provision it does talk more generally, suggesting
- 13:01Speaker 5: that foreigness mentalities will be immune from any kind of
- 13:04Speaker 5: jurisdiction in the US courts. So the Supreme Court had
- 13:07Speaker 5: to determine whether that one provision in the Foreign Sovereign's
- 13:11Speaker 5: Muniact conferred immunities in criminal cases as well as in
- 13:15Speaker 5: civil and the Court concluded that given all of the
- 13:18Speaker 5: other provisions of Oren Cyberg's Muniact, which were plainly targeted
- 13:22Speaker 5: only at civil activities of foreigness frutalities that they would
- 13:27Speaker 5: construe a Foreign Cerberus Muniact in that manner and only
- 13:30Speaker 5: to focus on civil activities of foreigness and mentalities and
- 13:34Speaker 5: not cover at all any kind of potential criminal jurisdiction and.
- 13:37Speaker 3: Tell us about the line above the justices in the case.
- 13:40Speaker 5: The decision was seven to two, but the dissent disagreed
- 13:45Speaker 5: with the analysis under the Foreign Cyber's Muni Act, but
- 13:48Speaker 5: would have reached the same type of conclusion, which would
- 13:51Speaker 5: be that it's very likely that Hawk Bank will be
- 13:54Speaker 5: found to be not immune by the Second Circuit on
- 13:58Speaker 5: reman from the Supreme Court, But they would arrived at
- 14:01Speaker 5: that conclusion in a different manner than the seven justices
- 14:05Speaker 5: the majority by saying that the Foreign Sovereignties uniac applies,
- 14:09Speaker 5: but that Hawk Bank falls within the commercial activity exception.
- 14:13Speaker 3: So the opinion gives Haulbank a possible out, sending the
- 14:17Speaker 3: case back to the Second Circuit where the bank will
- 14:20Speaker 3: have a chance to argue for sovereign immunity from prosecution
- 14:23Speaker 3: under the common law. But didn't that argument already fail
- 14:26Speaker 3: in the Lower courts.
- 14:28Speaker 5: So what's bizarre about the majority opinion is that it
- 14:32Speaker 5: remands the case back to the Second Circuit to determine
- 14:35Speaker 5: whether any common law immunities would immunize hawk Bank from
- 14:40Speaker 5: the criminal trial. But in the end of the opinion,
- 14:44Speaker 5: the Second Circuit already said that even if the Foreign
- 14:46Speaker 5: Sovereigny's uniac didn't apply, and we had to look at
- 14:49Speaker 5: common law immunities, we would find that hawk Bank is
- 14:52Speaker 5: not immune for two separate reasons. So it's a little
- 14:56Speaker 5: unclear why the Supreme Court remanted this case back the
- 15:00Speaker 5: Second Circuit, and the two justices in descent sort of
- 15:03Speaker 5: berated their colleagues for leaving the Second Circuit scratching its
- 15:08Speaker 5: collective heads about what it's supposed to do now, because
- 15:10Speaker 5: it had already ruled pretty clearly on the common law
- 15:14Speaker 5: munity issue and explain.
- 15:15Speaker 3: The common law immunity issue for us.
- 15:18Speaker 5: So, even if there's no statutory immunity for hawk Bank,
- 15:23Speaker 5: in other words, that the Foreign Sovereigns Communities Act did
- 15:25Speaker 5: not protect them or cloak them with immunity, they might
- 15:28Speaker 5: still enjoy some common law immunities from suit given the
- 15:32Speaker 5: fact that they are a foreign newsru mentality, so they're
- 15:34Speaker 5: part of the foreign government. The Second Circuit combed those
- 15:38Speaker 5: authorities and said, there's two reasons to think that any
- 15:42Speaker 5: kind of immunity that existed at common law, they may
- 15:45Speaker 5: have been adopted by the United States, et cetera, wouldn't apply.
- 15:48Speaker 5: The first is because there is a line of precedent,
- 15:51Speaker 5: which was mentioned in the concurring opinions in the Supreme Court,
- 15:55Speaker 5: which hold that it's the executive that gets to make
- 15:58Speaker 5: it the decision as to whether foreigns some mentality should
- 16:01Speaker 5: be hauled into court for criminal purposes, that that's really
- 16:05Speaker 5: a political issue, and that court should defer to the executive,
- 16:09Speaker 5: meaning the precedent, in determining whether prosecutions should pursue. There's
- 16:13Speaker 5: another line of decisions that say that foreigns some mentalities
- 16:17Speaker 5: have never been immune from criminal jurisdiction as long as
- 16:21Speaker 5: the crimes arise out of commercial activities, which everybody has
- 16:27Speaker 5: held that they did in this case because it was
- 16:29Speaker 5: a banking effort to shield billions of dollars of Iranian
- 16:34Speaker 5: oil revenue. So on those two grounds, the Second Circuits said,
- 16:38Speaker 5: you know, in either one of this, there's an exception
- 16:41Speaker 5: for common law immunity if the President says, go ahead
- 16:44Speaker 5: and prosecute, and if the actions arose out of commercial activities.
- 16:48Speaker 5: So those are the two common law immunities so far
- 16:51Speaker 5: that there have been exceptions, and the Second Circuit has
- 16:54Speaker 5: already articulated them, so presumably they will do so again
- 16:58Speaker 5: upon Remand if the.
- 17:00Speaker 3: Second Circuit rejects this, as we expect they will, since
- 17:04Speaker 3: they've done it already, can this go to trial?
- 17:06Speaker 5: Then absolutely it'll go for trial, and Hawk Bank stands
- 17:10Speaker 5: to lose stands and be fined a tremendous amount if
- 17:14Speaker 5: they are found to be in fact liable for trying
- 17:18Speaker 5: to basically shield all of this Iranian oil money despite
- 17:22Speaker 5: our sanctions that we had applied to Iran.
- 17:25Speaker 3: Is there a possibility that they could work out a
- 17:28Speaker 3: deal with the US government about a penalty to pay.
- 17:33Speaker 4: Yeah.
- 17:33Speaker 5: Plea barkins are always possible, and indeed pre bargains, as
- 17:36Speaker 5: you know, are frequently entered into avoid the cost and
- 17:40Speaker 5: uncertainty of a major trial like this. So if the
- 17:43Speaker 5: Second Circuit does reject the immunity claim by Hawk Bank,
- 17:48Speaker 5: it's likely they will consider some kind of plea agreement
- 17:52Speaker 5: which might then avoid the ugliness of a protracted trial,
- 17:56Speaker 5: leaving the end result unclear for Hawk, but also in
- 18:01Speaker 5: meshing or emboiling us in continuing friction with the Turkish government.
- 18:05Speaker 3: I just want to note that Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation
- 18:09Speaker 3: analyst Elliott Stein estimates that it's seventy percent likely that
- 18:14Speaker 3: Hulk Bank will fail to get immunity and wind up
- 18:17Speaker 3: paying a penalty that exceeds one billion dollars. Now, there's
- 18:21Speaker 3: never been a criminal prosecution of a state owned bank before,
- 18:25Speaker 3: so is this decision then precedent setting?
- 18:28Speaker 5: Well, this is the first time the Supreme Court is
- 18:31Speaker 5: ever plainly and unequivocally said that the Foreign subverigers and UNIAC,
- 18:35Speaker 5: which again was agreed to in nineteen seventy six, only
- 18:38Speaker 5: applies to civil cases. That Congress was not concerned about
- 18:42Speaker 5: criminal cases when it enacted this statute, and it was
- 18:46Speaker 5: only focused on twitter contract actions against foreign instrumentalities. So
- 18:52Speaker 5: that is the clear president setting feature of this case.
- 18:55Speaker 5: Most people thought that the Foreign muniac did not apply
- 18:58Speaker 5: to criminal activities, but people weren't sure, and there were
- 19:01Speaker 5: some different sort of dicta in lower court decisions. So
- 19:05Speaker 5: that's been put to rest, and we know that the
- 19:08Speaker 5: foreign carverge maniac only addresses civil conduct.
- 19:12Speaker 3: This is a case that didn't go down ideological lines.
- 19:15Speaker 5: Not at all. And indeed, the two concurring justices Justice
- 19:19Speaker 5: of course, that justice you know, Alito, are obviously usually
- 19:23Speaker 5: voting along with Justices Kavanaugh and Thomas, but they split
- 19:28Speaker 5: in this case.
- 19:29Speaker 3: So how let's turn now to another case where there
- 19:32Speaker 3: was no ideological split. The Supreme Court unanimously said that
- 19:36Speaker 3: companies and people facing agency investigations or complaints by the
- 19:41Speaker 3: SEC or FTC can go straight to federal court with
- 19:45Speaker 3: some constitutional challenges. So following the trend of the Supreme
- 19:50Speaker 3: Court to ham in the administrative state.
- 19:53Speaker 5: And again it's a decision which did not reflect ideological lines.
- 19:57Speaker 5: Although I agree with you, it follows a trend of
- 20:00Speaker 5: the justices to terrain in the power of the administrative state.
- 20:04Speaker 5: Those were continuing at a very heavy pace. The case
- 20:07Speaker 5: concerning the question about whether individuals and companies we are
- 20:10Speaker 5: subject to enforcement orders by administrative agencies can in the
- 20:15Speaker 5: midst of those proceedings stop and file a lawsuit in
- 20:20Speaker 5: district court to get the district court to rule on
- 20:24Speaker 5: what is termed structural challenges to the agency. Issues such
- 20:29Speaker 5: as the fact that the agency is unconstitutionally structured under
- 20:33Speaker 5: Article two of the Constitution, or that Congress delegated too
- 20:38Speaker 5: much authority to the agency under Article one of the Constitution,
- 20:42Speaker 5: or the fact that they are entitled to a jury
- 20:45Speaker 5: trial because the issue at stake relates to something that
- 20:49Speaker 5: was subject to jury trials at the time but founding.
- 20:52Speaker 5: So obviously, there's a whole panoply of these challenges that
- 20:55Speaker 5: are pending around the country. And prior to the case
- 20:59Speaker 5: Exxon that the Supreme Court decided, every lower court case said,
- 21:03Speaker 5: this is crazy to interrupt these administrative proceedings to allow
- 21:06Speaker 5: a list of some unknown constitutional questions to be aired,
- 21:10Speaker 5: because it just means it's more of a ping pong
- 21:13Speaker 5: ball between the Court of Appeals and the District Court
- 21:16Speaker 5: and the agencies. And let's group all these claims in
- 21:18Speaker 5: one together and have them aired if the party loses
- 21:23Speaker 5: before a court, and the court will then be able
- 21:25Speaker 5: to assess both statutory, procedural and constitutional claims together. Indeed,
- 21:31Speaker 5: who in Justice Cavanaugh was on the DC Circuit, he
- 21:34Speaker 5: similarly ruled that these challenges have to be grouped together.
- 21:38Speaker 5: You don't want to interrupt an administrative process while it's
- 21:41Speaker 5: going on to give the incentive to the parties to
- 21:44Speaker 5: raise these constitutional challenges. But surprisingly, in my mind, the
- 21:48Speaker 5: unanimous Supreme Court has held that we don't know what
- 21:51Speaker 5: a special claim is. They didn't give very good guidance
- 21:55Speaker 5: to the lower courts. But if you raise this certain
- 21:58Speaker 5: kind of constitutional challenges to an administrative agency, you can
- 22:02Speaker 5: go write to district court and have that adjudicated prior
- 22:05Speaker 5: to completion of an enforcement proceeding against your company or
- 22:09Speaker 5: against an individual.
- 22:10Speaker 3: What I don't quite understand is, so you have these
- 22:14Speaker 3: challenges that are constitutional challenges, so there are challenge is
- 22:18Speaker 3: that anyone can bring up? So doesn't this mean that
- 22:22Speaker 3: everyone who gets sued by the SEC or the FTC
- 22:25Speaker 3: is going to bring up these challenges and try to
- 22:28Speaker 3: take it to district court.
- 22:31Speaker 5: It's an absolute invitation for anyone subject to FDIC or
- 22:37Speaker 5: THEDA or the SEC, FDC and so forth to figure
- 22:42Speaker 5: out some kind of challenge because delay means money, and
- 22:46Speaker 5: so if your client is subject to some kind of
- 22:50Speaker 5: losing of a license or a permit or something else,
- 22:54Speaker 5: you know that time is money, and so it's a
- 22:57Speaker 5: wonderful incentive to go and figure out some kind of
- 23:00Speaker 5: So called constitutional claim that's never been raised with force
- 23:03Speaker 5: been raised by other parties, because that will then force
- 23:07Speaker 5: the district courts to schedule those arguments and gain possibly
- 23:11Speaker 5: delay for your client, and delay is money. So it's
- 23:15Speaker 5: a very impractical decision. But I think that you're right
- 23:19Speaker 5: to know that this goes along with the decisions that
- 23:23Speaker 5: are certain inscribing administrative authority. That the legal issue turns
- 23:27Speaker 5: on the question of what's Congressional intent when Congress sets
- 23:30Speaker 5: up the scheme with review of the administrative agency's final
- 23:34Speaker 5: decision in the Court of Appeals, did it intend to
- 23:37Speaker 5: implicitly preclude interlocutory or non final challenges to agency authority.
- 23:43Speaker 5: That's a legal issue, and I think it's pretty clear
- 23:46Speaker 5: in thinking about the final judgment rule that Congress has
- 23:49Speaker 5: imposed in the federal courts that when kind of sets
- 23:51Speaker 5: up these review mechanisms, it intends non final challenges to
- 23:56Speaker 5: be only decided when the review of the entire case
- 23:59Speaker 5: goes the Court of Appeals. But the Court decided otherwise unanimously,
- 24:04Speaker 5: and indeed Justice Gorcius says that we as the Court
- 24:08Speaker 5: have an unflagging obligation to exercise jurisdiction unless Congress very
- 24:13Speaker 5: very clearly tells us we shouldn't do so. And so
- 24:16Speaker 5: he's suggesting that all of these administrative review schemes unless
- 24:20Speaker 5: Congress says, and no other challenge shall be cognizable in
- 24:24Speaker 5: court prior to review on off the final decision, unless
- 24:27Speaker 5: Congress says that that just courts can entertain challenges to
- 24:31Speaker 5: administrative agencies. And what's striking about that is that simply
- 24:36Speaker 5: not the way our federal court system is set up.
- 24:40Speaker 5: Because individuals who lose summary judgment motions or companies that
- 24:45Speaker 5: lose motions to dismiss can't get those challenges, even if
- 24:49Speaker 5: they're very similar to the ones that are at play
- 24:52Speaker 5: in the Exxon case itself, they can't get those into
- 24:55Speaker 5: court of appeals until after they go through the trial
- 24:58Speaker 5: of all of their claim it's more efficient. That's what
- 25:01Speaker 5: Congress is determined. But the Court has said that even
- 25:04Speaker 5: though Congress has structured the system of appeals in that
- 25:07Speaker 5: way in the federal courts, that it has a very
- 25:10Speaker 5: different idea for the administrative agencies, that it didn't want
- 25:15Speaker 5: to give administrative agencies the same kind of respect that
- 25:18Speaker 5: district courts have.
- 25:20Speaker 3: Why are the conservatives on the Court so intent on
- 25:27Speaker 3: trying to dismantle the administrative state to give more power
- 25:31Speaker 3: to the judiciary.
- 25:33Speaker 5: I think there's a number of sort of paradoxes here.
- 25:36Speaker 5: I mean, the Court has been very accepting of strong
- 25:40Speaker 5: executive authority, but very suspicious of administrative authority. And I
- 25:45Speaker 5: guess the positive aspect of their decisions is that they
- 25:49Speaker 5: were trying to prod Congress to take more responsibility for
- 25:53Speaker 5: policy decisions that affect us all, as opposed to delegating
- 25:57Speaker 5: or allowing administrative agencies to reach such important decisions. That
- 26:02Speaker 5: is the positive part about the suspicion of administrative agency power,
- 26:06Speaker 5: because the administrative agencies do exercise these powerful policy preferences
- 26:10Speaker 5: or do reflect those policy preferences in a way that
- 26:13Speaker 5: affects all of our business and private laws, from the
- 26:16Speaker 5: pandemic to export controls to emissions of carbon dioxide. But
- 26:21Speaker 5: there is a problem because the problem is if Congress
- 26:24Speaker 5: doesn't go into the weeds and craft all these policies
- 26:28Speaker 5: with great care, the question is who's going to pick
- 26:31Speaker 5: up the slack. And so our government has been shaped
- 26:34Speaker 5: for the last seventy five years in a way that
- 26:37Speaker 5: encourages Congress to delegate to agencies and the Court is
- 26:42Speaker 5: in the process of trying to pull that back and
- 26:45Speaker 5: to say that if there's going to be any kind
- 26:47Speaker 5: of important rules, those rules should come from Congress and
- 26:52Speaker 5: not from these administrative agencies. So it's a view of
- 26:57Speaker 5: going back to the way the country was seventy five
- 27:00Speaker 5: five years ago, and there is some merit to it.
- 27:03Speaker 5: But if one doesn't have faith that Congress will take
- 27:06Speaker 5: up the challenge and exercise all of these important roles
- 27:11Speaker 5: that the Court wants it to play, then we're going
- 27:14Speaker 5: to be left in a situation where we're not being
- 27:18Speaker 5: governed by any entity very effectively.
- 27:21Speaker 3: I mean, I'm just wondering why the liberals went along
- 27:23Speaker 3: with this decision. Are they just throwing up their hands
- 27:27Speaker 3: and saying, we can't fight this anymore.
- 27:30Speaker 5: It's a great question why the liberal justices on the
- 27:33Speaker 5: Court decided to cut back the power of administrative agencies
- 27:38Speaker 5: in the Exxon case. It may be that they were
- 27:40Speaker 5: afraid that there would be a worse decision if they
- 27:42Speaker 5: didn't go along with their majority colleagues in this case.
- 27:45Speaker 5: That's one hypothesis, or for another, they may have thought
- 27:49Speaker 5: that it's healthy to air all of these constitutional challenges
- 27:53Speaker 5: the agency authority. And finally, when the courts reject most
- 27:57Speaker 5: of them, then that will be less room for disagreement
- 28:01Speaker 5: in the future, and then administrative enforcement actions can proceed
- 28:05Speaker 5: without this kind of ping pong balls in terms of
- 28:08Speaker 5: being hauled into court on these constitutional actions. But there
- 28:12Speaker 5: are dozens, if not hundreds of cases that are pending
- 28:15Speaker 5: now in which these constitutional questions have been raised, and
- 28:19Speaker 5: so these were the next five years you will see
- 28:22Speaker 5: just a courts having to decide case after case of
- 28:26Speaker 5: these innovative challenges to administrative agency authority. And that can't
- 28:31Speaker 5: be in a good and the short term for the individuals,
- 28:34Speaker 5: the courts or for the administrative agencies.
- 28:37Speaker 3: Thanks so much, Hal. That's Professor Harold Krent of the
- 28:39Speaker 3: Chicago Kent College of Law. And that's it for this
- 28:42Speaker 3: edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always
- 28:45Speaker 3: get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 28:48Speaker 3: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 28:51Speaker 3: www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and
- 28:56Speaker 3: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 29:00Speaker 3: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and
- 29:03Speaker 3: you're listening to Bloomberg