Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Why Are The Georgia Bulldogs Ranked Ahead Of Ohio State And Michigan?
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:06here has always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony? It
- 0:14has been a contentious week on the internet between Ohio State people and Michigan people,
- 0:21even by the normally lofty standards of Ohio State, Michigan and Pete Michigan
- 0:25people on the internet. So, Tony, I feel like in this episode
- 0:29of the Buckeye Weekly Podcast, the Michigan Monday episode, I feel like we
- 0:33need to take a second and try and unite people. I'm a united of
- 0:37Tony. I want to bring people together. Tony, Why in the hell
- 0:42is Georgia ranked number one? I recognize that the AP pole is stupid and
- 0:46meaningless. What is the argument for ranking Georgia number one? The argument for
- 0:52ranking Georgia number one, Tom, and this is these are what the voters
- 0:56think in terms of the AP I don't know what the coaches think in terms
- 0:59of the voters. They're thinking, well, I put Georgia at one to
- 1:03start the season, and I don't like being wrong, So I'm going to
- 1:07keep Georgia at number one, or else I'll look wrong, and I don't
- 1:12like looking wrong. So I'm going to keep them at number one. That's
- 1:15it. It does feel like the case for ranking Georgia number one in twenty
- 1:21twenty three centers almost entirely around Georgia in twenty twenty one and Georgia in twenty
- 1:26twenty two. Rather famously, those are not years in which the performance of
- 1:32a team is supposed to factor into their ranking. In twenty twenty three,
- 1:34and again it doesn't matter at all. And I'm sure what the coaches are
- 1:38thinking is I'm going to screw up overtime strategy for some reason, because that
- 1:41seems to be what the coaches are always thinking this year. But I mean,
- 1:45I think the reason that this is a relevant question on this particular episode
- 1:49of this particular podcast is I think there's a particularly strong case to be made
- 1:53for ranking Michigan number one. If you look at just overall power ratings,
- 1:57a lot of the computer rankings. You know, Michigan has i will say,
- 2:00for the eighth straight week, not played anyone yet, but boy howdy,
- 2:04has Michigan beaten the ever living crap out of all of the nobody as
- 2:07they have played and at some point beating the soul out of everyone you play,
- 2:12even if they are bad, does start to mean something. And I
- 2:15think we passed that point a week or two ago. And if you look
- 2:17at the Power ratings, I'm just going to use the Kelly Ford Power rating.
- 2:21Kelly Ford does the Calculated Risk podcast for US along with Tyler Shoemaker.
- 2:27He has two separate sets of ratings that he talks about on that show.
- 2:30One of the Power ratings, which is just how much better are you purely
- 2:34than the average Big ten or the average FBS team. So this is a
- 2:39purely predictive thing for looking It is not a resume metric. It's just how
- 2:45good can you be expected to be? Michigan number one in his rankings,
- 2:49twenty seven point seven points better than the average FBS team. Wellhis state number
- 2:53two, twenty seven point two point better than the average FBS team, Penn
- 2:57State three, Oklahoma four, Florida State five. Okay, totally, I
- 3:00would have no problem with Michigan being number one in the polls right now.
- 3:05In his most deserving rankings, which is a resume based ranking looking back,
- 3:08not predictive, looking back at who have you beaten in? How much have
- 3:13you beaten them by? Ohio State is number one in that one, Florida
- 3:16State, number two, Oklahoma three, Washington. For Michigan falls all the
- 3:20way down at number eight in those because while they have beaten these souls out
- 3:23of everyone they have played, they have not played anyone, so they're number
- 3:27eight in that one. So again, I would be fine with Michigan being
- 3:29number one. I'd be fine with Ohio State being number one. I'd be
- 3:30fine with Florida State being number one. If you want to do this as
- 3:32a resume thing and you want to say, looky, they've had you know,
- 3:36good win over Duke, good win over LSU earlier in the year,
- 3:39you want to make them number one, that's fine. I just I cannot,
- 3:44for the life of me, make a coherent argument for Georgia other than
- 3:47well, exactly what you said. I had the number one earlier, and
- 3:51I don't like to admit that I'm wrong. Yeah. Plus, it's like,
- 3:53well, they're going to start playing ranked teams eventually, so you'll see,
- 3:58you'll see that I'm right. And the thing that I hate about the
- 4:01rankings people who do the rankings when they're trying to prove that they're right or
- 4:05they're trying to predict how a team is going to finish up. Then it
- 4:10just becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. And I get so annoyed at things like
- 4:14that, as annoyed as I can get about something as meaningless as college football
- 4:19polls. But this information still goes somewhere. It still goes into the ether
- 4:24where it is then drawn up through the roots of the College Football Playoff Committee,
- 4:29And like, some of that gets on them, and it's hard for
- 4:31them to shake. Even though tom as we will talk about in the coming
- 4:34weeks, four weeks on end, they throw out the rankings each and every
- 4:40week, and yeah, yeah, they always look the same. They sure
- 4:44do, don't they. Yeah, that is next Tuesday, on October thirty
- 4:48first, that will be the first college Football Playoff rankings reveal. We have
- 4:51not done any kind of official conversation because we are great at advance planning.
- 4:56But in previous years, Tony, I know, we don't wan a base.
- 4:59As I said, I want to base this year's rankings off of previous
- 5:00year's performances. I don't want to base this year's editorial calendar off of previous
- 5:04year's editorial calendars. But we do typically do a live show on Tuesday during
- 5:09those those playoff rankings reveals. So we'll probably be doing that next this time
- 5:12next week, and I think there is a particularly compelling case for when that
- 5:16happens, for Michigan to be number one, if you want to go buy
- 5:19one set of metrics, based on the way that the committee has typically talked
- 5:25about the way they reached those conversations that the decision. I'm expecting, assuming
- 5:29Ohio State beats you know, so many handle their business this weekend in Madison
- 5:32and beat Wisconsin, I'm expecting the Ohio State or Florida State probably to be
- 5:39number one, just because they typically look at a you know, resume based
- 5:43thing, and so I would assume it would align fairly closely with that.
- 5:47So you know, they'll say, you know, Ohio State beat Notre Dame
- 5:50on the road and beat Penn State at home, and so they have the
- 5:54strongest case, or Florida State, you know, the case I laid out
- 5:56earlier, one of them. But you know, I'm certainly expecting Michigan to
- 5:59be in thee before probably number three. I'm guessing too. Maybe I mean
- 6:03it, we'll find out next week. But you know, either way,
- 6:08you know, you can look at any of these metrics you want to and
- 6:11everything sort of says, yeah, Ohio State Michigan both both pretty good this
- 6:15year and both probably going to play a game of some significance on the Saturday
- 6:19after Thanksgiving in n Arbor. Yeah, and since they do play each other,
- 6:25I would be pretty surprised if they have Michigan ranked ahead of Ohio State
- 6:30because Ohio State, we don't know where the teams are going to be ranked
- 6:34when the rankings come out. Like right now, Ohio State has a win
- 6:39over number ten Pence State and number fourteen Notre Dame. We don't necessarily know
- 6:45where they will be in ten days or whatever. But Michigan's not going to
- 6:51have anything they play. They're off this week, then they have Purdue.
- 6:57Now I will tell you they are Michigan right now is two against teams that
- 7:00are also receiving votes. Rutgers has received two votes, UNLV has received a
- 7:06vote. Boy, if you had told me two months ago that the strength
- 7:15of I mean, like, those are two teams that are having good seasons,
- 7:18and I you know, I mean I think that a lot of that.
- 7:20I am not expecting Rutgers to be receiving votes for much longer Rutger's schedule
- 7:25was pretty backloaded in terms of the good teams are going to play UNLV.
- 7:29I mean, UNLV, like Barry Ottoman, has not a good good job
- 7:32that they're bowl eligible. I think already for the first time in I heard
- 7:36someone say the year I was twenty ten or to that. I mean,
- 7:40it has been a hot minute since UNLV has been bowl eligible. And they're
- 7:44bowl eligible on October you know, on October twentieth or whatever it was October
- 7:47twenty first. That is a good good job. So yeah, I mean,
- 7:53you know that that's not a win that's going to show up on the
- 7:55great Wins. I'm not expecting UNLV to show up on the top twenty five
- 7:59rankings of the first College Football Playoff rankings, nor am I expecting to see
- 8:03Rutgers there. But yeah, those are better wins than they looked like at
- 8:07the time. But they're also that, you know, it's like trying to
- 8:11hang a real heavy picture on a real real small nail, Like that's not
- 8:15going to that's not going to support your college Football Playoff case. But you
- 8:18know, I mean it's it's something and we'll definitely talk about the committee more
- 8:22and more. But I think when the Committee looks at an eight no Michigan,
- 8:28they're going to see the game control and the dominance and all of that
- 8:31is there. But you also have to look and see why is that there?
- 8:35And that's where things start to fall apart for what I think would be
- 8:39Michigan's argument, and I think I think it will fall apart, and especially
- 8:43if Ohio State goes and wins at Wisconsin. I would be based on the
- 8:48way we've seen the Committee do things in the past, they like to reward
- 8:52those wins, at least initially before they start changing their narrative to whatever they
- 8:56want it to be. But out of the gate, you know, I
- 9:00would be surprised. And if out of the gate Ohio State isn't at the
- 9:03top or Michigan is above them, it'll all sort itself out. But it
- 9:05will definitely make me raise my eyebrow based on based on what exactly other than
- 9:11we don't really watch scores. We don't look at the final scores, you
- 9:15know, we don't look at the margin of victory. Well you what are
- 9:20you looking at? Then? If you're ranking Michigan number one, yeah,
- 9:24And I mean, let's just Tony preempt the conversation that happens in these comments
- 9:28on these videos every single week. Yes, Michigan is a very good football
- 9:33team. Yes, it is quite possible Michigan is the very best football team
- 9:35in the entire United States of America in the Year of Our Lord twenty twenty
- 9:39three. Yes, it is entirely possible that Michigan will beat Ohio State this
- 9:41year. Yes, it is entirely possible that I'm expecting that there is a
- 9:46better than fifty to fifty chance that Michigan is going to beat Ohio State this
- 9:48year. All of these things can be true if Michigan is ranked fourth or
- 9:54fifth in the College Football Playoff, you know, initial rankings, that really
- 10:00doesn't matter at all. It is going to be a function of, Hey,
- 10:01you played a bad non conference schedule, and your conference schedule, the
- 10:05quality opponents are real backloaded. And you know, you can blame Michigan State
- 10:09for some of that, because Michigan State was supposed to be at least a
- 10:11halfway decent team. And then and then your head coach did some stuff,
- 10:16and then and then you put Hitler on the scoreboard, and then you scored
- 10:20zero points, and you know a lot of that had to do some of
- 10:22that anyway, Tony zero points had to do with Michigan, and there is
- 10:26some self inflicted stuff there too, with the rest of Michigan State's here and
- 10:31you know, the schedule is what it is. If Michigan had played UNLV
- 10:35at the beginning of the season, I don't think we'd be having any of
- 10:37these conversations. But they opted not to do that, or sorry UCLA at
- 10:41the beginning of the season they did play UNLV. If they played UCLA at
- 10:43the beginning of the season, I think this conversation is just like, well,
- 10:46but their conference schedule's backloaded. But you know, at least they have
- 10:48that quality win out of conference you don't, So we're having the exact same
- 10:54conversation every week. But again, yes, Michigan is very good. Yes
- 10:58it's there's a good chance that Michigan is the best team in the country.
- 11:01Yes, it's a good chance that Michigan beats Ohio State this year. For
- 11:05as people have pointed out in the comments, I was not aware of this,
- 11:07Tony. That would be the third straight year that that happened. If
- 11:11it does happen. I did pull up a stat a chart on opponent offense
- 11:16adjusted EPA per play and opponent adjusted EPA per play on defense, and the
- 11:22chart basically is the further you are to the top and to the right,
- 11:26the better you are. And the two teams that are in the top,
- 11:30you know, they have it kind of broken down by sectors and the only
- 11:33two teams in the top sector are Ohio State and Michigan. And Ohio States
- 11:37defense is a little better than Michigan's and Michigan's offense is you know, substantially,
- 11:41not incredibly, but you know, significantly better than Ohio States. So
- 11:46you know this, this feels like, hey, these are two pretty good
- 11:48teams, and no matter how you want to how do you want to slice
- 11:52it, there are two teams that have kind of gotten there in a little
- 11:54bit of a different way. Michigan's been more dominant, Ohio State's played better
- 11:56opposition and still been undefeated. But yeah, I think this is going to
- 12:01be a pretty darn good football game coming up Thanksgiving weekend, NBA fans,
- 12:07the Waight is Over Basketball is back in DraftKings sportsbook and official sports betting partner
- 12:11of the NBA is celebrating with an unbeatable offer. New customers can score two
- 12:13hundred dollars instantly in bonus bets for throwing down five dollars on the NBA winner
- 12:16lose, it doesn't matter, You'll start the season with an instant dub.
- 12:18And with DraftKings parlays, everyone's got a shot at even bigger basketball wins.
- 12:22String together multiple bets from the same game, or build your parlay across multiple
- 12:24games for a shot at making your payday even sweeter. Basketball is more fun
- 12:28when you're in on the action. Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app now and use
- 12:30code huddle up. New customers can get two hundred dollars and bonus bets instantly
- 12:33for betting just five dollars only on Draft Kings Sports Book with code huddle out.
- 12:35The Crown is yours. Gambling problem called one hundred gambler or visit www
- 12:39dot twenty hundred gambler dot net, New York Call eight seven seven eight hope
- 12:41and why, or text hope and why. In Connecticut, help is available
- 12:45for problem gambling. Call eight aight eight seven eight ninety seven seven seven seven
- 12:48or visit CCPG dot org. Please play responsibly on behalf of boot Heel Casino
- 12:50and Resort, Kansas licensee partner Golden Nugget Lake Charles, Louisiana, twenty one.
- 12:54Over age varies by juristiction, void and Ontario Honess. Bets expire one
- 12:56hundred and sixty eight hours after issuance. CE sportsbook dot drf Kings dot com
- 13:00slash Basketball see Sportsbook dot draft Kings dot com slash Basketball. Terms for eligibility
- 13:03and deposit restrictions, terms and responsible gaming resources. Talking about the Michigan defense,
- 13:09and they threw a shut out forty nine to nothing against actually outscored Michigan
- 13:13State. The defense did seven to nothing in that one thanks to Mike Sander's
- 13:16still seventy two yard pick six is second pick six of the year. But
- 13:20I think last week I went and just detailed in terms of total offense where
- 13:26Michigan's opponents ranked, just to give people an idea that when we say they
- 13:31haven't played an offense yet, to express and show and prove that it wasn't
- 13:37that they haven't. And people are like, you know, well, you
- 13:39know, total offense is not a great stat. It's not a great stat.
- 13:43I'm not I'm just using it to show informationally, where are the teams
- 13:50that they have ranked, where they have played where they are ranked. I'm
- 13:54not saying one team is better than another, you know, like people like
- 13:56to use analytics to do that. This isn't I'm not saying any of these
- 14:01teams are better than Michigan, for instance. But what I did put that
- 14:05number out, people are like, well, you got to take Michigan's performance
- 14:07out of it, you know, because you know clearly Michigan has turned what
- 14:11would normally be a tremendous offense every week other than the one week they play
- 14:16against Michigan into a bad offense. And so what I did, tom is
- 14:20I did what I did, go through and looked at all eight of their
- 14:22opponents, took out Michigan's performance against that and looked where they would rank offensively
- 14:30in terms of total offense. Without that Michigan performance, East Carolina would be
- 14:35one hundred and twenty eighth in the nation. UNLV would be nineteen, you
- 14:39know, so there you go. Bowling Green would be one hundred and eighteen.
- 14:43Rutgers would be one hundred and third in the nation. Nebraska would be
- 14:46one hundred and sixth in the nation, Minnesota one hundred and thirteenth. Indiana
- 14:50tied at one hundred and thirteenth, and Michigan State would be ninety fifth,
- 14:54and so these without Michigan having anything to do with these games with with those
- 15:00opponents, that's where those teams would rank offensively in total offense nationally. So
- 15:05when we talk about how they have not played anybody, this is one of
- 15:09the things we're talking about. But also they have been fantastic on defense.
- 15:13They are doing what a fantastic defense would do against eight seven terrible offenses and
- 15:20one overmatched offense. So they have done exceedingly well. They are giving up
- 15:24less than a touchdown per game. They have given up tom I believe five
- 15:28touchdowns this season, and I went through at cfpstats dot Com and looked at
- 15:33the number of touchdowns given up through the first two months of the season.
- 15:39You can go all the way back to two thousand and nine. I can't
- 15:41find another team that has given up only five touchdowns in the first two months
- 15:46of the season. So Michigan's defense is doing something that nobody has done in
- 15:52the past fifteen years. I don't think it's entirely because this is the best
- 15:56college football defense of the last fifteen years. In fact, I know it
- 15:58is not. But where is it top ten, is the top twenty,
- 16:03I don't know, but it is not so much better than every other defense
- 16:06that it has done. It is capable of doing something that nobody else has
- 16:08done without a ton of help from the offenses that they have played. Yeah,
- 16:14and that's you know, there's another way to measure this that I've talked
- 16:17about on this show in the past, and that's the College Football Nerds dot
- 16:21com. They have a metric that I really like, and they look at
- 16:25a yards per play basis on rushing, yards per play basis on passing,
- 16:30what the opponent's average and what you held your opponents to as compared to their
- 16:33average against all the other teams so that that team has played. And Michigan
- 16:38in terms of rushing defense has held their opponents to twenty six percent fewer yards
- 16:42per carry on the ground than opponents that ranks fifteenth in the country in that
- 16:47metric, Ohio State to twelfth, so very similar. Both have been very
- 16:49good against opposing rushing attacks. Michigan against the pass, they are eleventh in
- 16:56yards per attempt against, but they are only three percent better because house those
- 17:00opponents have been so bad passing the ball. They're only three percent better than
- 17:03the average opponent for their opponents, So that puts in fiftieth in the country.
- 17:10Ohio State is second in the nation, thirty four percent better than,
- 17:14you know, than opponent averages in other games. Some of that has to
- 17:18do with just exactly how bad opponent other you know, their opposing teams have
- 17:22been, because if you're throwing for five yards per attempt or whatever against everyone,
- 17:26it is very hard to be substantially better than that you were going to
- 17:29do. Michigan State was eight just an absolute dumpster fire on offense on Saturday
- 17:33night, and they threw for four point six yards per attempt. I mean,
- 17:37there is a certain unless you weren't playing literally Iowa, there is a
- 17:41lower bound for how low those numbers can go. So you know, I
- 17:45don't think Michigan is really the fiftieth best pass defense in the nation, but
- 17:49this does kind of go to the point that you really have not gotten tested.
- 17:52And we talked about this last week in the lead up to the Ohio
- 17:56State Penn State game. Penn State's defense was, you know, by the
- 17:59top line numbers, the number one defense in the country, and they did.
- 18:02They played well against Ohio State, but also they weren't the number one
- 18:06defense in the country against Ohio State, and you know Ohio State had you
- 18:10know, put up twenty points, but had a couple other times they were
- 18:11in the red zone and you know, could have kicked the field goal,
- 18:15could have put up some more points than that. So, you know,
- 18:18Michigan is very very good, very very good, especially on defense. But
- 18:22Tony I think also we got to talk about JJ McCarthy because he feels like
- 18:26he's kind of taken the next step. Yeah, he is to me the
- 18:30best player in the country right now in terms of quarterbacks. And if you
- 18:33want to argue Marvin Harrison, we can do that because at this point it
- 18:37is looking like the Heisman Trophy is going to be won November twenty fifth in
- 18:41ann Arbor, depending on who shows up more between McCarthy and Harrison. But
- 18:47right now, he is playing as good as we've ever seen him. Now
- 18:52we could talk about how the defenses some of the conversation, they're not really
- 18:56playing any top opponents, but the level of play that he's at right now,
- 19:02I can't wait to see what Penn State does with them, because we
- 19:06saw a Penn State defense that Marvin Harrison was getting open. Other receivers were
- 19:11getting open. I don't think it was a shut down defense, but they
- 19:17were. They caused issues. So I'm interested to see how what JJ McCarthy
- 19:22can do with that, with his escapability, with the way that he can
- 19:26keep plays alive, with the way they used to both of their tight ends.
- 19:29They really unleased the twelve personnel package with aj Barner and Colston Loveland in
- 19:33this one, Barner I think ninety nine yard receiving and Loveland was somewhere around
- 19:37seventy something with two touchdowns and three touchdowns total between the both of them.
- 19:41But he is in such control and the amount of confidence they had that led
- 19:47to his one sack like an eight yard loss, because he figures I can
- 19:49just get out of anything. So like you can do that against Misikin State.
- 19:55Can you do that against Penn State? Does that get you into trouble?
- 19:56Can you do that against Ohio State? Does that get you into trouble?
- 20:00Right now, I believe he might now be the Heisman front runner in
- 20:03terms of the betting sites and the numbers. Overall numbers may not be what
- 20:11you have come to expect, but he people are gonna now be watching him,
- 20:15and they're gonna see plays, and he does seem to have Heisman moments
- 20:18each week, and he creates plays and he's a playmaker. And if everybody
- 20:22else is coming down and JJ McCarthy is going up, like this is no
- 20:26longer Caleb Williams Trophy to win anymore. No, it is certainly not Caleb
- 20:30Williams Trophy win. I you know, Caleb Williams and Drake May both took
- 20:34a pretty significant shot to their chances. I think over the weekend, McCarthy
- 20:38is the favorite right now plus two forty, Michael Pennock's second at plus three
- 20:42hundred, Jaden Daniels third at plus three seventy five. Then a pretty big
- 20:47drop off to Jordan Travis, Dylan, Gabriel Bonix, and Marvin Harris and
- 20:51Marvin Harrison plus two thousand, the only non quarterback on that list. So
- 20:55yeah, I mean it's when you look at McCarthy again, like you said,
- 21:00the numbers are not incredible. He's not putting up Andre Ware numbers or
- 21:03anything like that. He's not putting up CJ. Stroud numbers, but he's
- 21:07putting up you know, he has been very very efficient. He's been very
- 21:11very effective. He makes plays with his legs when he needs to. He
- 21:15really didn't need to against Michigan State. That was, you know, kind
- 21:17of one of those things where you know, he has he has made plays
- 21:19when he needed to in Michigan State. That game was over so early that
- 21:22it was kind of like, well, there's no reason for him to take
- 21:25any shots there, But you know, he is just he has made it
- 21:27work with a whole bunch of different guys. And what I think is most
- 21:30impressive to me about it, Tony, is Michigan has really not run the
- 21:34ball this year. They have not been, which is bizarre to say.
- 21:37They Blake Koram fifteen carries fifty nine yards three point nine yards per carry,
- 21:42Donovan Edwards six carries fourteen yards two point three yards per greay Donovan Edwards cannot
- 21:47get it going right now. Lake Koram has been you know, he feels
- 21:51like he has won one yard touchdown every game and you know, finishes with
- 21:56the stat line that's otherwise really unspectacular, and you know, maybe that gets
- 22:00going at some point, but it just it feels like that the run game
- 22:03just hasn't been there. So a lot of it has been on McCarthy and
- 22:07even you know, this was a game where he didn't have Cornelis Johnson three
- 22:11catches twenty six yards long of eleven, Donovan Everards three catches twenty three yards,
- 22:19Roman Wilson, who has been one of his top targets, two catches
- 22:22fifty yards, but just there was not anything out of the out of the
- 22:26wide receivers. Really that was impressive. But as you said, twelve catches
- 22:30for one hundred and seventy eight yards and three touchdowns for the tight ends,
- 22:33you know, and it's it's not just the tight ends. You know,
- 22:36Colston Lovelin has had a big year, but there has been there have been
- 22:40you know, the Roman Anthony game, there has been you know, Cornelius
- 22:42Johnson has a big day. There has been Colston Lovelin has a big day.
- 22:48But the one thing that's kind of tying this all together is JJ McCarthy.
- 22:51And it's just other than the Bowling Green game, which is just looks
- 22:55like an incredible outlier right now where he threw three picks and he hasn't,
- 22:56I don't think thrown a pick. And other than that, also season,
- 23:00he's just been very efficient, very effective, kept them moving down the field.
- 23:03And you know, I mean they they have not played incredible opposition,
- 23:10but you know they are in the same stat that I was taught citing for
- 23:12the defense, you know, relative performance compared to what your opponents typically give
- 23:17up in a yards per attempt. Michigan ten points one six yards per attempt.
- 23:22They are forty seven percent better, forty seven percent better in yards per
- 23:26attempt than opponent averages. That's fourth in the country. Air Force number one,
- 23:32one hundred and thirty five percent better. So if you can run start
- 23:33running the triple option, you will you'll be better at Tony. There are
- 23:37only other than air Force. There's only two teams better than Michigan in terms
- 23:42of relative performance in terms of opponent yards per averages. One is LSU at
- 23:48fifty percent. Which team is number three at forty eight percent one percent better
- 23:52than Michigan. Is it the Ohio State University? It is the Ohio State
- 23:56University Tony. I'm starting to think that gave after Thanksgiving might be a pretty
- 24:00good one. Watching JJ McCarthy, I went and charted his in the pocket
- 24:10passes and his outside the pocket passes. In the pocket, he was sixteen
- 24:14of twenty two for two hundred and four yards and two touchdowns. Outside,
- 24:15he was five of five for eighty three yards and two scores. He's just
- 24:19incredibly deadly once whether it's a designed rollout or it's even worse for the opposition,
- 24:26it's a scramble, because not only is he great at it, but
- 24:29his receivers are really great at it as well. And that's tight ends,
- 24:32that's running backs, that's receivers. Like everybody understands where they need to be
- 24:37and there's a high level of communication there once things start to break down,
- 24:42so continues to be impressive. He was twenty of twenty six in the first
- 24:48half for two hundred and seventy six yards and then through one pass in the
- 24:52second half and in the third quarter which was a touchdown, and that passed
- 24:55didn't come into like midway through the third quarter because Michigan had the Michigan State
- 25:00got the ball first up, threw a pick six and got the ball again
- 25:03and drove a little bit. But one of the craziest stats of the season
- 25:07right now, JJ McCarthy is fourth on his team a number of fourth quarter
- 25:12passes. That is, of all the different ways we've said, Michigan has
- 25:18not played a lot of close games because they haven't played a lot of good
- 25:21opponents. Boy, that's pretty remarkable. And you know, I mean anytime
- 25:26you have that, I think everyone sort of goes, well, are they
- 25:29going to be able? You know, are they gonna be ready for a
- 25:30four quarter game? And I you know, I think they're going to play
- 25:33a four quarter game against Penn State to at least some degree when they have
- 25:36to go to state college in a couple of weeks. But you know,
- 25:38they're certainly rested and and you know, we talked earlier about Michigan not you
- 25:44know, the running backs not really having a big, a big year Michigan.
- 25:49Last year, the running backs play corm had an enormous year to the
- 25:52point where he was in Heisman contention. But then all of those twenty five
- 25:56and twenty eight and thirty carry games added up and he ended up getting banged
- 26:00up and you know, got hurt against Illinois and then barely played against Ohio
- 26:04State. You know, he may not be having a huge year, but
- 26:08he's gonna be fresh. And that's true for pretty much everyone on this Michigan
- 26:11team. They are pretty healthy because they haven't had to go four quarters and
- 26:15Jim Harpall has been rotating so many guys through you just you've got guys who
- 26:21are playing quarterback. I'm like, who, Like, that's they had?
- 26:25They had the it was Jaden Dinegal had two passes, two for two for
- 26:30seven yards. And I'm like, what who that's not? That's not Davis
- 26:34Warren, that's not Jack Tuttle. I mean, you're they are really getting
- 26:40down the depth chart. And that was a road game against an in state
- 26:42you know, an in state rival, so and he's doing that all over
- 26:47the place. They've rotated down the defense, they've rotated in the running back
- 26:51room. That has been a very intentional thing for the for them this year.
- 26:55And I don't know if that's just trying to get everyone involved or just
- 26:57trying to keep everyone fresh, healthy and engage. Whatever it is. I
- 27:00mean, whatever it is, it's working. I do wonder what happens the
- 27:06first time they have their backs against the wall, because the last time they
- 27:08had to happen, they lost to TCU. So coaches like to have that
- 27:14bit of experience, that adversity, and there's been absolutely zero adversity for this
- 27:18team so far, and so you don't necessarily know how they're going to handle
- 27:22it. Until they get there, they may handle it just fine, but
- 27:25I bet he would have. Jim Harbat would have liked to have known beforehand,
- 27:30be like have because we've seen it in the past. I strug the
- 27:33one possession game against Rutgers or Nebraska or Maryland, where it just you have
- 27:38that experience. And so far this year their experience has been, well,
- 27:44it's a one score game going into halftime, and now we're going to score
- 27:47four straight touchdowns. There's really been no adversity. So it's just something to
- 27:53watch. Now. The schedule, as you said, it's very very backloaded.
- 27:56It's two teams basically, and I think both of those teams can provide
- 28:02some adversity or should provide some adversity, and we'll see what they do with
- 28:06it. Now back to the running game. Only one of Blakekorm's carries on
- 28:11only one of his fifteen carries went over five yards. He had a seventeen
- 28:15yarder. But in terms of like the success rate, he had seven straight
- 28:19successful runs and like four of them were five yards. It's like boom right
- 28:23in row five five five five, and so like nine of his fifteen yard
- 28:29nine of his fifteen carries were hit. The success rate number were successful.
- 28:33Three of six of Donovan Edwards were and he again, there's no good numbers
- 28:38coming from Donovan Edwards this season, but I was just surprised by that number.
- 28:44And now the passing, the receiving aspect of his game is still a
- 28:48significant weapon and they will continue to use him. But the running games,
- 28:56it's similar to Ohio State's running game in that you're still going to run it.
- 29:00It's not as effective as you would like. Ohio State can get by
- 29:04because they have Marvin Harrison. Michigan can get by because they have JJ McCarthy.
- 29:10And what happens if you take one of those away? If you can
- 29:15clearly, I think a receiver is easier to take away than a quarterback.
- 29:18But they're able to overcome the shortcomings, and at this point in the season,
- 29:23you are what you are now. With Michigan they are what they are,
- 29:26Ohio State being what they are. I've dealt with injuries at running back.
- 29:32I wouldn't characterize the KILEL. Mullings injury as significant as what Ohio State
- 29:37is dealing with with their running backs. But I think I'm done waiting for
- 29:41Michigan to be able to run the ball. I think this is what they
- 29:45are unless JJ McCarthy gets even more involved with it and hit some big ones.
- 29:48And if Blake Korb doesn't hit a big one, this is pretty much
- 29:52what they're going to be. Like one hundred and twenty yards and three yards
- 29:57maybe four yards of carriyon might be good enough for now, but shoot,
- 30:03it might be good enough to it at all, because I don't think there
- 30:03are are any great teams this year. Yeah, I'm interested to see what
- 30:07that rushing offense looks like when they play at Penn State in a few weeks,
- 30:11because you know, I look at McCarthy's number of carries and I recognize
- 30:15it. Last week we talked about the fact that he was running the ball
- 30:17too much and taking too many hits. They didn't run him this week,
- 30:21and that's fine, and that's you know, probably smart. I think you
- 30:26might see the old Urban Meyer quarterback run usage thing going because I think they're
- 30:32going to feel like they're going to have to run the ball at some against
- 30:34Penn State. And if you're not able to generate a ton just with Korum
- 30:38and Edwards, you might need to work McCarthy more into that game in Urban
- 30:42Meyer. For the Michigan folks who might not remember this particularly well. When
- 30:47J. T. Barrett was Ohio Sted quarterback, for example, J T.
- 30:49Barrett would have three carries against Rutgers, and he'd have two carries against
- 30:53Bowling Green, and then they'd play Penn State and he'd have eighteen carries.
- 30:57I'm not expecting JT. J J McCarthy to have eighteen carries against Penn State.
- 31:03But if JJ McCarthy went from three carries against Michigan State to ten carries
- 31:07against Penn State or nine carries against Penn State, I don't think that would
- 31:11surprise me at all. And if he's able to present that plus one in
- 31:17the run game, maybe that opens some things up for for Korum and Edwards,
- 31:22you know inside, maybe that opens things up more just for you know,
- 31:26get him out of the edge and just you know, hit someone downfield
- 31:30as defenders kind of suck up to stop him. In the run game,
- 31:33it feels like you're gonna see more JJ McCarthy running and then it's just a
- 31:38matter you know, this was the case with J. T. Barrett too.
- 31:41Just just stay healthy, don't don't get do you get your you get
- 31:45your butt out of balance, you get your butt down on the ground,
- 31:47and you slide. Don't take that big hit because it feels like, you
- 31:52know, the one really obvious thing that could derail this whole Michigan season is
- 31:56if JJ McCarthy gets hurt. You know, no disrespect to Jack Tuttle,
- 32:00but you know, I'm not gonna lie. I have not watched a lot
- 32:04of Jack Tuttle because Jack Tuttle is kind of the human victory cigar, where
- 32:07you know, as soon as Jack Tuttle's in the game, okay, the
- 32:08meaningful portion of this game has been is over. I don't expect Jack Tuttle
- 32:15to light anyone up in the air. So if Juju Befrithy gets hurt,
- 32:17I think that's the one thing that could really be a big, big problem
- 32:22for Michigan. But I also expect them to keep him as safe as they
- 32:25possibly can, and I'm sure it has been communicated to him to get out
- 32:29of bounds and to get down and to not take any unnecessary hits, even
- 32:32when they do probably need him to run more against teams like Penn State.
- 32:37I have been shouting all season long that Michigan is going to lose at Penn
- 32:40State, and after getting a good first hand look at Penn State over the
- 32:45past week, I would like to amend my shouting too. I think Michigan
- 32:52is going to beat Penn State. And here are a number of reasons why
- 32:55I don't think Penn State's going to be able to run on Michigan. Expect
- 33:00them to get after Drew Aller quite a bit in the past game. I
- 33:04don't expect Drew Aler to be able to make them pay for some mistakes in
- 33:08coverage because until I see that happen, I'm going to assume it won't.
- 33:14And the passes that Kyle McCord missed that were open to receivers this past week,
- 33:19I expect JJ McCarthy to hit. Now he doesn't have Ohio State's receivers.
- 33:24JJ McCarthy doesn't, but from what I saw from Penn State's secondary,
- 33:29they should still be okay. And also the coverage we saw Kate still have
- 33:32a big game. Coleston Levelin is really really good and if you're going to
- 33:37focus on him, A J. Barner just put up ninety nine yards on
- 33:40Michigan State, not that he's going to do that every single week. But
- 33:44he's a solid number two Big ten tight end and has been for a number
- 33:47of years. And so I feel like where Ohio State failed to pound it
- 33:53in, I think Michigan State or Michigan will and I wouldn't be surprised if
- 33:58it's a you know, Ohio State. Probably I should have won like thirty
- 34:01to seven, not letting that last one get in and then also converting on
- 34:07the mist field goal and the touchdown at the two yard line, so I
- 34:12could see something, you know, twenty seven to ten something like that.
- 34:15And my thoughts on Penn State have really kind of I don't have high expectations
- 34:22for them in that game, but it is life on the road in the
- 34:27Big ten at Penn State. I assume that's a big new and I don't
- 34:30even know what the situation on that one is, but Jim Harble has not
- 34:36had the best success on the road other than the last two years where he's
- 34:38had all of this success on the road, and so we'll see what kind
- 34:43of advanced scouting they have done and go from there. The Penn State Michigan
- 34:50game is at noon in Happy Valley, so that's, you know, that's
- 34:53a nice little bonus for Michigan and not have to play at night there that,
- 34:58you know, I think Penn State, I'm with you. I watched
- 35:01Penn State in person and kind of went, oh, well, turns out
- 35:06they have not played great opposition so far, and you know, theoretically it's
- 35:09possible that that could happen to Michigan too the first time they really get tested.
- 35:14But it doesn't feel like that's probably going to be the case. Again.
- 35:17Like I said earlier, you can play crappy opposition for a while,
- 35:22and I kind of go, yeah, okay, I'll withhold judgment until you
- 35:24play someone real like if you're doing too crappy opposition what Michigan has been doing
- 35:28at crappy opposition, at some point it starts meaning something. It's like Florida
- 35:31State back in the day and the ACC when they would just murder everyone,
- 35:35and it was like, well, eventually you win enough thirty point games against
- 35:39Lousey Conference opposition that it starts to really, you know, be a pretty
- 35:43good indication that yes, you are in fact legit. And it feels like
- 35:45we've crossed that line with Michigan. But yeah, we'll see, we'll see
- 35:49what it looks like in Happy Valley in a couple of weeks. But yeah,
- 35:52I'm with you. The Drew Eller performance in person, the lack of
- 35:58explosive running plays in person, the lack of wide receiver talent. They did
- 36:02nothing there said this is a team that is going to be the first one
- 36:07to get to the end goal against the Michigan defense all year. That is
- 36:12still that is still we're still waiting for an end goal situation against the Michigan
- 36:15defense. I would have missed that if it had happened in any of the
- 36:20fourth quarters this season, because I haven't seen in one of them. But
- 36:23apparently that is still the case, So I think that will do it for
- 36:27this episode. I want to thank you all for joining us. As always,
- 36:30we invite you to find us at bucket huddle dot com. If you're
- 36:34not yet a member, join up see how things are going over there.
- 36:37Plenty of recruiting stuff coming down the pike because of the huge Penn State visit,
- 36:40lots of recruits chiming in with their thoughts on what they saw, and
- 36:45of course plenty of behind the scenes stuff talking about the team and the upcoming
- 36:50schedule and things like that. So if you haven't yet joined us see what
- 36:53you think of it. Of course, find us at YouTube dot com,
- 36:55slash Bucket, Huddle, Hitt the that'll be notified whenever we go live.
- 36:59Gor It thumbs up on this one. Subscribe if you haven't, and of
- 37:01course, if you're listening on any podcast platform, a five star writing interview
- 37:06is always appreciate it. So with that, I want to thank you all
- 37:09for tuning in and we will talk to you guys later