Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Guest-Host Ben Hadley - Salespeople Spot Fraud And Get Paid, Drivers Ignore Screens, OpenAI Ads Hits $1B
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Tuesday, September 1st. Walking into September. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Kyle Mountsier. Ben Hadley's co-hosting with me. We're talking about fraud, screens, and OpenAI.
- 0:13[singing] The people really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. They consider once knowing me- And, and Ben celebrated when I said OpenAI. He was nervous about the first two.
- 0:23That's all that matters. And- That's what I said, "Is there any AI?" Like- Two, two weeks, two podcasts, B- Ben. How you feeling? [laughs] Dude, I feel back-to-back. I feel like, uh, I wish I didn't shave yesterday.
- 0:35[laughs] You know? Wait. Didn't shave? You want, you wanted a little scruffy- Yeah, dude, I was growing it out. You- I was like, "Ah, shoot.
- 0:42I should've just ke- I forgot" You for- you forgot Raise your hand if, if this event wasn't in your calendar, right? Like- Oh... it's the vehicle. Oh, see. Man has to call me out like that.
- 0:52I would've just not shaved yesterday- I don't wait, I don't wait to a calendar invite [laughs] That's cold-blooded, Ben.
- 0:57I would've, like, put a flannel on, gotten all lumberjacky- Gotten all manly and, and burly- Yeah, dude... and woodsman and stuff like that. Ah, not this clean cut- That's wild... quartered somebody. It's okay.
- 1:07It's okay. What am I doing? We need, we need some- sometimes we need people like you to help temper- Yes... this just- Temper the manliness... manly, the manliness. The yin and the yang. Yes. Mm-hmm.
- 1:17[laughs] Yeah, you- Hey, Ben, actually- Uh, thanks... one, one thing for the people, we're gonna be at...
- 1:21If anybody's gonna be at the NCM conference, uh, next week, the previously the, uh, the David Kane, uh, clients and friends, now the NCM clients and friends, we're gonna be, uh, our- The Ashley clients and friends...
- 1:33clients and friends. Uh, the, the- we're gonna be hanging out with the crew there. Whole bunch of incredible dealers, industry partners gonna be there.
- 1:41Uh, our company, Auto Genius, is also hosting the Sporting Kansas City event night. So if you don't have tickets, you don't know about it, let us know. We'll get you there. Uh, should be a fantastic event.
- 1:52You're gonna be talking about hospitality and the web and online and in-store and all of that. So wanna make sure the people know, you know? They, they can, they can catch some Ben on stage, you know?
- 2:03Dude, you can get it here. You can get it last week. We're just, it's gonna be everywhere. We're gonna be all over the internet. All over the internet. All right, let's get into it this morning.
- 2:11Uh, Cherokee Mitsubishi, good friend of, of the podcast, uh, Jonathan Dawson, is flipping the usual fraud pay plan logic.
- 2:18Instead of penalizing employees after a bad deal, it pays salespeople who flag suspicious customers before the store takes the risk.
- 2:25The goal is to keep commission pressure, uh, from discouraging employees from speaking up. Salespeople who raise a red flag help stop a deal, still receive their $125 base commission.
- 2:36Uh, they are rejecting roughly three to five questionable deals a month right now. Obviously, the stakes are growing across fraud.
- 2:43Point Predictive estimates the auto industry, uh, faced $10.4 billion in fraud risk in 2025, up 13% year over year and 79% from 2015. So massive increases. Um- Wow.
- 2:57Pay plan consultant Scott Woodward and Kevin Cohen said they had never encountered another pay plan that specifically pays employees for reporting sus- suspected fraud.
- 3:06Dawson said, "I'm not gonna penalize you for being honest or catching something that could have hurt the store." An interesting, uh, twist on a way to just watch out for this.
- 3:13Obviously, there's a lot of technology going into it but, but bringing the people into the mix. Interesting. Pretty cool. Uh, best part about that is paying on, uh, loss is always difficult to do because it's like, um,
- 3:30uh, at least in the vendor world, like you, you try to like subsidize churn. You're like, "Oh, I don't want anybody to cancel our product," right? Right. Yeah. It's like how do you know what they just did was actually,
- 3:42you know, preventative? Yeah. It's the same thing with like preventative care and healthcare. Like we never do it. We always do medicine post the, the symptoms and the illness- Yeah... not pre, right?
- 3:52You should, should just eat healthier. It's harder to eat healthier, um, so this sounds a lot like ea- eating healthier. Shout out Jonathan Dawson. I love it. Yeah.
- 3:59I, I think, you know, there, there's always gonna be a question mark when you bring in human judgment to, to risk aversion, right?
- 4:06That's why we have so much data in the industry and, and, you know, red flags reports and things like that. Uh- Yeah...
- 4:11but I think for me, again, uh, similar to you, the big story here is that someone would be willing to kinda go, "No, I, I know we're gonna take a loss. We're not gonna make a deal.
- 4:20I'm still gonna make sure my employees are, are paid fairly." And that probably goes across a lot of different mediums inside his stores and, and a lot of stores that we know.
- 4:28The ones that are, are willing to support their employees even through potential losses, uh, i- is, uh, is a totally like, it is, it is antithetical to what you would believe about such sales-driven organizations.
- 4:43So- Yeah... I love it. 100%. Yeah. All right, uh, moving to the next story. JD Power's latest tech experience index suggests automakers don't necessarily win by adding more visible tech.
- 4:54Owners were happiest with features that work quietly and reliably.
- 4:57The 2026 survey studied about 68,000 owners, so just a couple two tree, of new, uh, 2026 model year vehicles after 90 days, covering 40 technologies across convenience, connectivity, driver assistance, EVs, and smart vehicle features.
- 5:11Smart ignition delivered the highest overall satisfaction with just 2.4 problems per 100 vehicles. Passenger screens struggled though with adoption.
- 5:2035% of owners who had one said they had never used it, while just 6%, they used it every time they drove. More advanced te- uh, technology didn't automatically mean more satisfying.
- 5:32Conventional hands-on level two driver assistance systems actually scored better for execution and overall experience than level two plus hands-free system.
- 5:40JD Power's Doron Heickrey said, "The technology customers value most is often the technology they barely notice because it simply works." Yeah.
- 5:49Uh, is that like a long way of saying like, "Dude, less screens, more buttons"? Yeah, I think, well, I think it is, to me, yes. People want buttons. They want tactile. Bro, bring back buttons.
- 6:02It's, it's actually more to me, it's promise more, expect more Right? So, like, the, and, and I do this when I talk to people about their brand propositions, right? The more you promise in value from a brand, right?
- 6:16You say you do all these things and, and it's a laundry list of 23 things- Yeah...
- 6:21the higher the level of expectation, and therefore the risk of, like, aversion to the expectations, uh, if they weren't perfectly met, goes up and up and up.
- 6:32That's why the Carvana value proposition is so, uh, so clean, because it is so simple. It doesn't have, like, a laundry list of things that they're promising.
- 6:41And so the more and more you add promises in technology, the more demand you put on the customer to, like- Yeah, you've got a portfolio- Yeah... of promise risk. Yes, exactly.
- 6:52Like, any one of those can tank the entire, the entire portfolio. That makes sense. I mean- Yep... but I will tell you, man, like the, uh, you know, shout out, I'm...
- 7:03You know, I think everybody's still a little pissed at Scout, at least if you're a VW dealer.
- 7:07But the, uh, that was, like, the number one thing I was pumped about when, before they delayed the vehicles, was just adding, adding the buttons. Yeah.
- 7:16And in some sense, that's the opposite, which is, uh, rather than make-- You know, Steve Jobs always said, like, the, uh, way to do innovation is to figure out the nos, not the yeses.
- 7:27Sort of to that point, where you're like, "Hey, let's, like, trim this promise list down. Like, let's say no to a bunch of these because nobody really cares." Uh, same thing, like, with the buttons.
- 7:37Like, let's say no to a bunch of screens. Like, let's get back to the basics, basically, and execute the basics really well. To me,
- 7:45the one piece that you just said that I thought was really interesting, can you go back to that level two plus versus... What was that part on the autonomy part?
- 7:53Yeah, so basically, uh, like hand, hands-on driver assistance system. So anything- Yeah... radar cruise control or stuff, stuff like that. People preferred the level two driver assistance versus the level two plus.
- 8:04So two plus would be, like, radar cruise control versus cruise control. Yep. Yep. Yeah, so people still want control. That makes sense. Yep. Yeah. I mean- Dude, I turn off the radar cruise control all the time.
- 8:14It's so annoying. I'm- Don't tell, don't tell anybody... so Rivian right now, right? Sorry, Rivian. Sorry, dealers that loved it. Uh, I do hands-free all the... Dude, I'm all, all day. Yeah, but I think- Just...
- 8:27you're, you're, you're at level three, right? So you, you- No, it's like, I think it's two, two and a half. Really? It's not, like, taking turns. It can change lanes, right? It can change lanes. Yeah.
- 8:37It can change lanes, so that's three. Uh, so that- Oh... that's, that's a decision-making protocol.
- 8:42Level two plus is only, um, like additional level of security, so, like, radar cruise control as opposed to just cruise control, right? So cruise control is two. Two plus is radar cruise control.
- 8:53Level three is some level of decision-making capability. So I need to change lanes because I need to go around this person is level three. So- Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Well, uh, I like my level three. Yeah.
- 9:05I, and I think that's the thing. Like, that next layer obviously adds, like, a totally different level of value proposition that, that you're not expecting to go full level four, where you have to take your...
- 9:14Where you can completely... Well, the level four is not supposed to be completely, as I've heard, although Teslas are, you know, many people drive Teslas like that, so yeah. Speaking of hardware. [upbeat music] Stop.
- 9:28Segway. Time. All right, we're gonna get to the hardware part, but OpenAI's latest growth story isn't just advertising.
- 9:36The company says ChatGPT's ads already has reached $1 billion in annualized [chuckles] revenue run rate.
- 9:44Uh, while reportings as OpenAI's has also bought tenth of th- tens of thousands of Mac Minis and Mac Studios to help train their computer use agents. So, uh, uh, kinda interesting. Bunch of, bunch of revenue from ads.
- 9:57Bunch of, uh, bunch of that revenue being used to purchase hardware.
- 10:01ChatGPT ads, uh, th- got to that run rate mark in less than twen- 200 days, with tens of thousands of advertisers now using the platform, including a lot of dealers we know.
- 10:13Uh, they, uh, have shared performance examples.
- 10:16One e-commerce advertiser reportedly generated three times ROAS over 28 days, while a technology partner said more than 80% of ad-driven GPT traffic came from new customers, so net new customers.
- 10:28Meanwhile, the other side of this, so that's the completely software-driven side of this, uh, the Information reports, uh, the, uh, the company, The Information reports OpenAI has purchased tens of thousands of Mac Minis and Mac Studios for reinforcement learning and training computer use agents.
- 10:44So if you wanna know why you can't get an M5 Studio, you got OpenAI to blame.
- 10:48Uh, they're reportedly being used as dedicated machines without displays or keyboards, taking advantage of the siliconed unified memory and ability to run sustained isolated computer environments.
- 10:59The purchasers are, uh, not, still not replacing their NVIDIA scale training clusters. Uh, this is a reported narrower case focused on agents that need to interact repeatedly with operating systems and software.
- 11:10Wild stuff over there at OpenAI. Yeah, that's, like, the future literally is... I got, and, uh, shout out, uh, can we say his name? I don't know. I probably won't give him a public shout-out. But I had a dealer in Texas,
- 11:27uh, take my advice and buy a Mac Mini, uh, M5 so that you could run a local model, de-risk a bit,
- 11:41uh, of the, "Hey, I want my guys to use AI, but I definitely don't wanna leak, leak PII to the internet, teach-" Yep... them how to, like, take over our entire industry," et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Um,
- 11:54and, uh, and yeah, so he just spent, like, 20 grand on, [chuckles] like, a tough Mac Mini. But I can see that being at every single person's, uh, pretty quickly- Yeah...
- 12:05because it's basically, like, um, I think the pattern recognition would be Every person has sort of become their own individual sovereign company, and so every person sort of needs its own server.
- 12:18Uh, and, and I, I think you should, like, think about buying these Mac Minis for every one of your employees, or leasing them. 'Cause it's only like... I did the lease yesterday in a post. Uh- A couple hundred bucks...
- 12:29it's so funny that, bro, that you can lease a Mac Mini now is like... [laughs] The payment for leasing a Mac Mini is higher... It was $237, and there's, you know- He's about to say there's a few- That's nuts. Yeah.
- 12:47There's a few EVs that you can get for that, right? Like, get a car or a Mac Mini, one of the two. [laughs] Yeah, and here's the thing. Go through the... First, for fun, dealers, like go to Apple and do the, um...
- 13:00Say you have a trade. Like [laughs] it's, like, it's such a digital retailing experience as you're going through. It's like, "Hey, do you have a Mac to trade in?" Like, are you kidding me?
- 13:07So anyways, long story short- Asks you four questions and then gives you a value right there on the spot, and then you can trade that sucker. Yeah.
- 13:14I would go- My, my favorite is the fact that, like, that, that you still have to get that thing to them, and twice my Macs have broken on the way there, so they'd only have to pay for that joker.
- 13:25Twice they've broken on the way to- Yes... Apple? Like, in the, in the sealed box that they send you with, like, like, all the padding and all that stuff. Twice I've had screens break, and so my $800 is just, pff, gone.
- 13:39Yeah. Crazy. Yeah. Wild stuff. I wonder how long it's gonna take Carvana to get into the, uh, Mac Mini. You know? Like... Yeah. No? Is that not hitting?
- 13:49Like, it's like you go on Carvana and they're like, "Hey, do you have a trade?" And, like, one of the options is like, "I have a Mac Mini." And they're like, "Okay. Yeah. We'll take it."
- 13:56Well, because chips become such, so valuable. Yeah.
- 13:59I, I also think that the start of the story, like getting to that level of ad revenue, when early on there was so, there was so much talk about, like, with this, this, "We're not gonna do ads. We're not gonna do ads."
- 14:09And then it's just like, "We do ads, and here's..." It's like everything new is o- eh, everything old is new again, right?
- 14:17Oh, we build super high-powered computers and put them at our desktop because we need y- you know, like, a... We're in college, and, you know, like you're building a, a computer 'cause you need more RAM.
- 14:27You need all this stuff that can't fit in a laptop back then. Same, same run. Oh, you know, no, everything's decentralized. You don't need to worry about ads. It's just presented to you.
- 14:36The monetization model is through the user. Oh, nope. Yep, we're gonna run ads and charge you to get, uh, to, to pay for... To get paid for this. It's pretty wild. Ads is such a, like- Old is new again...
- 14:46I, I don't know. I feel, uh, I think they'll, I think they'll look back on ads in ChatGPT as a bad move actually. Yeah. Not saying don't buy them. But as long as, like, some of the other players, namely, like, Claude
- 15:04or any provider like a Perplexity stays pretty, p- pretty pure. Um, when we look at the conversion rates, as an example, at w- in the AutoGenius data, the conversion rates of AI traffic...
- 15:19When I say conversion, meaning like, like, close rates too, is way higher. Significantly higher. Very small fraction of your traffic, but, but converts really well.
- 15:31And so that tells me like, oh, it's because you trai- you trained and trusted this personalized thing you're talking to, and if it's making a recommendation, you believe it. Absolutely.
- 15:40Uh, but as soon as you dilute that with ads, I don't know. You know? Like- Yeah, it'd be interesting- I think-... to see what that conversion rate is.
- 15:47Uh, you know, uh, if the gap, if the disparity of the gap is similar or more deep than organic to paid traffic Google, right? Like- Yeah...
- 15:58we, we already know that there's a conversion rate gap between organic traffic at Google and paid traffic at Google.
- 16:03Do we see that similar or a deeper conversion rate gap between organic, uh, AI traffic versus paid, paid traffic? Ah, God. You know what? It's like I, I thought we were finally done with, like, the
- 16:16buy your own name debate in auto. No. You know? It's actually worse. Buy your own name is actually m- more intense within GPT. That's what I mean. Like, it's like- It's crazy... oh, great. We're, we're like...
- 16:27We're, we're restarting all of this. It's crazy. It's everything old is new again. 100%. Everything old is new again. Get the blocking and tackling right. Care for some people. Care for your employees.
- 16:37Uh, build brand trust, and make it simple for customers to trust you, come back to you, uh, so you can build a flywheel of repeat business. [upbeat music] That never goes out of style. That's right.
- 16:52[upbeat music] Dude, how long has it been-