Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 261. Meetings With a Point: How to Design For Better Decisions
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: What if people actually thanked you for the meetings you ran?
- 0:07My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:10Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:12Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:16Today I look forward to speaking with Rebecca Hinds.
- 0:18Rebecca's expertise is in the future of work and how to help make work better.
- 0:22She founded the Work Innovation Lab at Asana and the Work AI Institute at Glean.
- 0:27Rebecca is the author of your Best Meeting Ever: Seven Principles for
- 0:31Designing Meetings That Get Things Done.
- 0:34Welcome, Rebecca.
- 0:35I'm super excited for our conversation.
- 0:37This is a topic that's really important to me.
- 0:39Rebecca Hinds: Thanks so much, Matt.
- 0:40I'm really looking forward to the conversation.
- 0:42Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 0:42Rebecca Hinds: Let's do it.
- 0:43Matt Abrahams: Awesome.
- 0:43I wanna start by sharing a secret about something that just happened.
- 0:47I had a meeting cancel and I was thrilled.
- 0:49I know I'm not alone.
- 0:51I'd like to begin by level setting.
- 0:53Why do people dislike meetings so much and why are meetings so broken?
- 0:57Rebecca Hinds: It's such a great question because it's not so much that people hate
- 1:01meetings, it's people hate bad meetings, and we have too many bad meetings.
- 1:06Often we love a good meeting, and there are a few things that energize us and
- 1:10inspire us more than a good meeting.
- 1:12The problem is those are too rare in so many organizations.
- 1:16And so, we've developed what I call a meeting suck reflex, where there's
- 1:21this visceral reaction that we have to the phrase meetings, the idea
- 1:26of a meeting, going to a meeting.
- 1:28And that's again, rooted in the fact that we know bad is stronger
- 1:32than good, negative emotions and experiences have a much greater
- 1:36impact on us than positive ones.
- 1:38And because of this, there's this aura of negativity around meetings.
- 1:42And when you look at some of the research, it's fascinating to see
- 1:46that when people rate their meetings in public, they tend to rate them
- 1:51much more negatively than in private.
- 1:53And that's because there's all this social conditioning around
- 1:56the idea of a meeting as negative.
- 1:58Matt Abrahams: I, I know we're gonna talk about things we can do to make meetings go
- 2:00better, but I'm wondering if we just call them something else, does that make us
- 2:03feel a little better if we just say, Hey, let's have a collab or a standup, instead
- 2:08of actually using the word meeting?
- 2:09Rebecca Hinds: Rooted in a lot of this is this default reaction
- 2:13we have to schedule meetings.
- 2:16So it's a paradox, right?
- 2:17Because we know they're inefficient, we dread them on so many occasions,
- 2:22and yet our knee jerk reaction is to use them whenever we have a
- 2:25problem, whenever we need alignment, if we're unclear on next steps.
- 2:29And so part of this is we're so accustomed to using a meeting as a
- 2:33communication tool, even when we have other things called Slack or Asana that
- 2:40often are much more efficient ways to communicate, we default to the meeting.
- 2:44And there are a whole host of different psychological reasons
- 2:47why we're so obsessed with using meetings in our workplaces.
- 2:51Matt Abrahams: In the consulting work I do, one of the first things
- 2:53I'll do is a communication audit of a company, and the first place I go is,
- 2:57what are the meetings you're having?
- 2:58How many meetings?
- 2:59Who's going to those meetings?
- 3:00Because as you said, there's sort of a default knee jerk reaction to fixing
- 3:04any communication problem, and there are certainly places where meetings make a
- 3:07lot of sense, but people throw meetings as like a bandaid to fix a bigger problem.
- 3:12So let's solve it.
- 3:13What are some ideas, top three ideas, for example, that we
- 3:16could use to improve meetings?
- 3:18Rebecca Hinds: Sure.
- 3:19So the premise of the book, Your Best Meeting Ever, is the idea that we need
- 3:23to be treating meetings as a product.
- 3:26Meetings are the most important product in our entire organization, and yet
- 3:31they're also the least optimized.
- 3:33And so the first step is recognizing we need to be much more intentional
- 3:37about how we're designing meetings.
- 3:39We can schedule them with just a couple clicks.
- 3:42That doesn't mean we should be.
- 3:43And so that intentionality is really important and I think the first step.
- 3:47Matt Abrahams: Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
- 3:49Rebecca Hinds: Exactly.
- 3:50Because they're so expensive.
- 3:51They're the most expensive communication tool we have.
- 3:55No other communication tool requires everyone to be synchronously in
- 3:59person, coordinating schedules, real time conversation.
- 4:03They're immensely expensive, not just in terms of, you know, the payroll
- 4:06costs, but also in terms of the mental load that they often consume.
- 4:11Matt Abrahams: That idea of expense is really interesting because when we
- 4:14just do it because it's easy, but when you think about the cost, not just
- 4:18financially, but in time and focus, it really is one of, as you said, the most
- 4:23expensive way to bring people together.
- 4:25Are there other things we can do besides being intentional?
- 4:27Rebecca Hinds: Yes.
- 4:28Often I'll be brought into an organization when meetings are just so
- 4:33broken that these surface level fixes aren't going to work, and certainly
- 4:39meeting audits aren't going to move the needle in terms of truly resetting
- 4:43the culture within the organization.
- 4:45So I've ran many, of what I call, meeting doomsdays.
- 4:49So a meeting doomsday is essentially a 48 hour calendar cleanse where you delete
- 4:54your recurring meetings for 48 hours.
- 4:57Ideally, you do it as a team, and ideally, in the best case,
- 5:00you do it as a organization.
- 5:02And after those 48 hours have elapsed, employees are instructed to
- 5:07rebuild their calendar from scratch.
- 5:09So determine which meetings are worth bringing back to the calendar and in
- 5:13whatever design they think is gonna be most valuable for the work at hand.
- 5:17So think about the length, think about the cadence, think about the attendees,
- 5:21and rebuild your calendar from scratch.
- 5:24And we find that type of full reset is much more powerful than a meeting audit
- 5:30because it empowers you to wipe the slate clean, start with a fresh slate.
- 5:34You're not in the mindset of defending the meetings already on your calendar.
- 5:39You're really starting from a fresh slate.
- 5:41Matt Abrahams: I love this idea of a calendar cleanse.
- 5:43Are there certain criteria you advise people to follow as they're thinking
- 5:47about building back their calendars in terms of importance, frequency?
- 5:52What are the questions we should think about?
- 5:54Rebecca Hinds: In the book, I talk about this idea of the four DCEO rule, right?
- 5:57What actually deserves to be a meeting.
- 6:00We have so many status updates on our calendar, broadcast meetings,
- 6:04information exchanges that shouldn't be on our calendar, and so the four
- 6:08DCEO test is essentially a two-part test to determine whether a meeting
- 6:13should exist on your calendar.
- 6:15So first is the four D test.
- 6:17A meeting should only exist if the purpose is to decide, debate, discuss,
- 6:22or develop yourself or your team.
- 6:25Now you'll notice what's not on that list.
- 6:27Broadcast updates, boss briefings, information exchange, status updates.
- 6:32Those don't pass the four D test.
- 6:34Now, even if the content of a meeting passes the four D test,
- 6:38it still needs to pass the second part of the test, the CEO test.
- 6:42So a meeting should only be scheduled if the purpose meets
- 6:45one of the following criteria.
- 6:47So it should be complex.
- 6:48The content should be complex enough where we can't efficiently
- 6:53exchange it in advance.
- 6:55It really does require bringing everyone together, synchronously,
- 6:59to bounce ideas off of each other, iterate, build on top of one another.
- 7:03E, is it emotionally intense?
- 7:05So if it involves managing emotions or interpreting emotions, you're giving
- 7:10hard feedback or a performance review.
- 7:12It's no longer just about facts, it's about feeling.
- 7:15Empathy is really important, reading body language.
- 7:18And then, O, is it a one-way door decision?
- 7:21So this comes from Amazon and Jeff Bezos, where they essentially said
- 7:25one-way door decisions are decisions where once you walk through the door,
- 7:30it's very difficult, if not impossible, to go back the other direction.
- 7:34And in those cases, the cost of misalignment is so high, it's so risky,
- 7:39where often you wanna have a meeting to ensure at everyone's on the same page.
- 7:44Matt Abrahams: Everybody knows I love a good acronym, and
- 7:46this is a very useful one.
- 7:48So the four Ds, decide, debate, discuss, or develop employees,
- 7:52and that's not enough.
- 7:53Even if you meet that bar, then it's is it a complex decision?
- 7:57Are emotions involved?
- 7:58And is it a one-way high stakes choice?
- 8:01If it meets those criteria, then we put it on the calendar.
- 8:05Rebecca Hinds: Then we put it on the calendar.
- 8:06But we do so very intentionally and we think about various
- 8:09dimensions of the meeting.
- 8:11I think there are four in particular that are important to think about.
- 8:14One is the length.
- 8:15We often default to 30 to 60 minute entries on our calendar.
- 8:19A lot of that is because those are the default settings of these calendar tools.
- 8:23We need to think much more intentionally about the length of meetings.
- 8:27The cadence is also important.
- 8:29So one of the things we see consistently with these meeting resets and
- 8:33doomsdays, people will start to think carefully about whether that weekly
- 8:37meeting needs to be a weekly meeting.
- 8:39Can it be a monthly meeting?
- 8:40Can it be a quarterly meeting?
- 8:42And so the cadence is really important.
- 8:44The attendees, so thinking about who absolutely needs to be in the room.
- 8:49Often we tend to over invite.
- 8:51And agenda items.
- 8:53So think very carefully about the items you're putting on the agenda, because that
- 8:57can be another source of meeting clutter and meeting bloat within organizations.
- 9:01Too many agenda items or agenda items that don't really move the work forward.
- 9:06Matt Abrahams: I really like that thought process as well.
- 9:09Let's look inside a meeting.
- 9:10You talked about agendas.
- 9:12Do you have any advice on how to structure agendas?
- 9:15Clearly you said not too many items.
- 9:17I have a personal pet peeve.
- 9:18I really don't like when meetings start by reviewing the previous meeting.
- 9:22'Cause I often don't like having been in the previous meeting.
- 9:25So to remind me of that meeting now sort of sets me in a negative place.
- 9:28I do understand that reviewing previous work is important,
- 9:31but maybe not the first thing.
- 9:32Do you have suggestions for what happens in the meeting?
- 9:35Rebecca Hinds: Well, again, I think that's a form of information exchange
- 9:39and probably can be handled effectively asynchronously before the meeting.
- 9:43So my favorite strategy for agendas is to think about each agenda item as
- 9:48a combination of a verb and a noun.
- 9:51Often agenda items are laundry list items that are thrown together haphazardly.
- 9:56There's research to suggest that about 50% of agenda items I think
- 10:00are recycled from the previous week.
- 10:02So again, we're not being intentional about how we're designing the meetings.
- 10:06So instead of saying team discussion, frame it as a verb and a noun.
- 10:11Decide this noun, align on this.
- 10:14And that also has the added benefit of determining whether that actually
- 10:19needs to happen in the meeting.
- 10:20Because if you can't transform something into a verb, it probably
- 10:24doesn't deserve to be in the meeting.
- 10:25We know that disproportionately more time is spent on the
- 10:29earlier items in the agenda list.
- 10:31So, put your most important topics, typically, up on the agenda item list.
- 10:36Sometimes you might want to have some sort of less cognitively taxing item to warm
- 10:42people up, but in general, you also should think about the ordering of agenda items.
- 10:47Agendas also suffer from what's called the law of triviality, which means
- 10:51that essentially we're more inclined to spend disproportionately high
- 10:56time on the things that are easier.
- 10:59The agenda items that are less cognitively taxing.
- 11:02So another word for this law is called bike shedding.
- 11:06And that term bike shedding comes from an old story around two agenda items that
- 11:13were essentially different in terms of the cost associated with the agenda items.
- 11:19One was a nuclear power plant that was millions of dollars.
- 11:22And the second was a bike shed that was, I think a thousand dollars.
- 11:25It was in Britain, so it was in pounds.
- 11:27And essentially what they found is most of the conversation focused
- 11:31on the bike shed because it's much easier to start to think about,
- 11:36okay, what colors should the wall be?
- 11:38Should there be a light in the bike shed?
- 11:40Versus the nuclear power plant is much more cognitively taxing.
- 11:43It's much easier to skip that item, default to the person who has the
- 11:48best proposal, and avoid those tough conversations around the
- 11:51risky and cognitively taxing topics.
- 11:54So again, this intentionality is really important when we think
- 11:57about agenda items as well.
- 11:59Matt Abrahams: You taught me about bike shedding, but I've seen it happen
- 12:01in the meetings I've been in where we spend time on the trivial matters.
- 12:04So I heard a couple things there.
- 12:06I love the idea of leading with a verb, and I think this is
- 12:09important not just in agenda items, but in how you title meetings.
- 12:12Because you can set people's expectations just in the meeting title.
- 12:15And people have heard me say this before, I think the calendar invite is the most
- 12:19underutilized expectation setting tool.
- 12:21You can do it by what you call it, as you said earlier, about
- 12:24how long the meetings are.
- 12:25And this idea of thinking about cognitive effort for the agenda item.
- 12:29So what I heard you say is perhaps start with something that's less cognitively
- 12:34burdensome at first, just to get things moving, but then pretty soon after
- 12:38the more intense or important issues, and then save the ones that might be
- 12:42a little less intense for the end.
- 12:44Rebecca Hinds: In general, yes.
- 12:45Again, thinking about systems thinking, it's also important to
- 12:49consider, you know, have you had a heavy meeting day prior to that?
- 12:53Are you already cognitively taxed?
- 12:55Is the meeting happening at the beginning of the day or after lunch, or at
- 12:58the very end of, you know, a Friday?
- 13:00And so thinking holistically also about, okay, what is the context
- 13:04that people are walking into as they're walking into this meeting?
- 13:07Matt Abrahams: That is such an important point.
- 13:09We tend to fixate on our meeting and not the experience
- 13:13of the people in the meeting.
- 13:14And if this is my fifth meeting of the day and this is important
- 13:18work, maybe it's better to move the meeting to the following day.
- 13:20So as architects of meetings, we also have to consider how our participants
- 13:25are coming to us, and that I think amen and exclamation point to that.
- 13:30Many people might have heard at companies like Amazon, and I think
- 13:34Twitter did it as well, where everybody shows up with a written document
- 13:38and the first part of the meeting is reading the six pager or whatever.
- 13:41Do you have thoughts on that?
- 13:42I can see the benefit of alignment, because the reality is I ask my students
- 13:46to do homework and some show up having done it and some don't, and then all of
- 13:49a sudden I'm teaching a class where not everybody's on the same page, literally.
- 13:52What do you think about that?
- 13:53Rebecca Hinds: I think in general it's a very healthy practice.
- 13:56We see so many instances of people showing up unprepared for the meeting,
- 14:00and what they've done there is they've raised the bar in terms of what
- 14:04actually deserves to be a meeting.
- 14:05You can't schedule the meeting unless the memo has been written
- 14:09and is thoroughly thought through.
- 14:11And these are memos that often take days or even weeks to produce.
- 14:16And Jeff, you know, his mentality was if you couldn't take the time to flesh out
- 14:22your thoughts in a memo, you don't deserve to hijack people's time in a meeting.
- 14:27Now, I don't think every meeting should start with a
- 14:29written six page narrative memo.
- 14:31But I do think for the ones where there needs to be context setting,
- 14:35where it involves a lot of complexity, it can be a really healthy practice.
- 14:39The other thing that Amazon did with this memo culture is the study hall.
- 14:44So you would start the meeting independently reading the memo,
- 14:47making notes and if you read the memo, left your notes, and you had
- 14:51nothing left else to contribute, you were invited to leave the room.
- 14:55And I think that's another healthy practice because it again, starts
- 14:58to be more intentional about how we're designing the meeting with an
- 15:02asynchronous component that people can participate and then leave before
- 15:06they're wasting time synchronously in a meeting where they've already contributed
- 15:10their thoughts and perspectives.
- 15:12Matt Abrahams: I had not heard of the study hall idea, but I really like it.
- 15:15I am very excited to put into practice a lot of these things you've said.
- 15:19I do think that everybody's meetings can benefit.
- 15:22Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 15:25One I'm gonna make up just for you, and two, I've been
- 15:27asking people for a long time.
- 15:28Are you up for that?
- 15:29Rebecca Hinds: I'd love it.
- 15:30Matt Abrahams: I'd like to give you a catharsis moment.
- 15:32Share with me what is one of the things that just bothers
- 15:35you the most about meetings and maybe provide a solution to help.
- 15:39Rebecca Hinds: So I think what we've talked about in terms of using meetings
- 15:43as a default solution and the duct tape for all of our problems in the
- 15:49workplace, I think what annoys me most is showing up to a meeting where it's
- 15:53clear there hasn't been design and intentionality going into that meeting.
- 15:58And so I think tools like the four DCEO test, treating meetings like a product,
- 16:03thinking about user-centric design, who is the audience, can be effective at
- 16:07helping to minimize that tendency, that we know is human nature, to use meetings as
- 16:12this cure all solution in the workplace.
- 16:15Matt Abrahams: I had a catharsis just listening to you say that.
- 16:17It was like, yes, those all, we need to fix all of that, so thank you.
- 16:21Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 16:25Rebecca Hinds: We talked about Jeff Bezos at Amazon, and when it comes to meetings,
- 16:29I have been really inspired by everything he's done over many years, decades.
- 16:34And his influence continues to be felt at, at Amazon where we
- 16:38did that collaboration cleanse.
- 16:40I think him raising the bar in terms of what deserves to be a
- 16:44meeting, he thought very carefully about the design of meetings.
- 16:47So often he would leave a chair empty in the physical meeting room to
- 16:53symbolize the customer, the idea that we should always be thinking about
- 16:57the customer voice in our meeting.
- 16:59That's inspired a lot of my thinking around hybrid and virtual meetings
- 17:02and creating some physical presence of the remote folks in the physical room.
- 17:06He famously had the two pizza rule, as well, where you shouldn't
- 17:10schedule a meeting if there are more attendees than two pizzas can fill.
- 17:14And so I think that intentionality is something that I admire among various
- 17:19communicators, but in particular, various leaders at Amazon, including Jeff.
- 17:23Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing all those things, the chair to
- 17:25represent the customer, reminding yourself who the true beneficiary
- 17:29of the meeting is, really important.
- 17:31My final question for you, Rebecca.
- 17:33What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication
- 17:37recipe for meetings or beyond?
- 17:39Rebecca Hinds: We've discussed the importance of matching the communication
- 17:42tool to the purpose, and I think that holds for meetings certainly, but it
- 17:45holds for all of our communication.
- 17:47Think about the purpose of the communication, the intent
- 17:50of the communication, and match the tool to that aim.
- 17:54Second, intentionality, as we've spoken about, we need to be approaching
- 17:58communication as something that is intentional, is intentionally designed.
- 18:02That's more and more important, the more expensive the communication tool is.
- 18:06But absolutely, just because communication is effortless doesn't mean
- 18:11it needs to be in our organizations.
- 18:13And then third, user-centric design, right?
- 18:15It's easy to come into a meeting thinking about, what do
- 18:18I need to say in the meeting?
- 18:20It's much more important to think about what do others need to understand
- 18:24and walk away with from the meeting.
- 18:26That user-centric design, designing for the audience, just as you would a product,
- 18:30is a hallmark of great meetings, and I think great communication in general.
- 18:34Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 18:35Tailoring to an audience is critical.
- 18:37Making sure the tools fit the purpose and being intentional in in general.
- 18:41And thank you for intentionally sharing your advice for us.
- 18:46I know my meetings will be better as a result of what we've discussed,
- 18:49and I hope everybody listening will improve those meetings.
- 18:51Thank you so much.
- 18:52Rebecca Hinds: Thanks Matt.
- 18:53That was fun.
- 18:55Matt Abrahams: Thanks for joining us for another episode of Think
- 18:57Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 19:00To learn more about communication and meetings, please listen
- 19:03to episode 124 and 125.
- 19:06This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 19:10Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 19:14Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 19:18Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 19:20Follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram, and check out fastersmarter.io
- 19:25for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.
- 19:29Please also consider joining our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community
- 19:32at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 19:35You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards,
- 19:38our AI coaches, and book club.