Latest / The Philanthropists / Craigslist Founder Craig Newmark: Why He’s Giving Away His Fortune
Transcript
- Quanda: Welcome to The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith Hanley: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Quanda: Today's guest is Craig Newmark, founder of Craigslist and founder of Craig Newmark Philanthropies. meredith: In 1995, Craig started what became Craigslist, and he stepped back from its day-to-day operations in 2000. Since then, he's devoted himself full-time to philanthropy, a giving pledge signatory who has said he's given away roughly 90% of what he made from monetizing the site. Quanda: And his giving spans a genuinely wide range. He's committed a hundred million dollars to a cyber civil defense network fighting scams and cyber threats. He's one of the most consistent funders of trustworthy journalism in the country, supporting outlets from ProPublica to Mother Jones to the journalism schoon at CUNY, City University of New York, that now carries his name. He pledged $100 million in 2023 to organizations supporting veterans and military families. He funds programs like Girls Who Code that open doors for women in tech. And he's a dedicated supporter of Pigeon Rescue. meredith: He also sits on the boards of the Center for Public Integrity and Blue Star Families, among many others, and serves on advisory boards in a number of universities and institutions, including being a founding member of my Georgetown University McCourt School of Public Policy Advisory Board. Quanda: Craig, welcome to the philanthropists. Craig Newmark: Hey, it's my pleasure being here. I am on the board of a number of nonprofits, but I've been disengaging, particularly from Center for Public Integrity, which no longer exists. my total commitment to fighting scams and cyber attacks is 200 million, and I'm more than halfway paid up on that. Quanda: Craig, that's incredible. And you know, when Meredith and I were reflecting on how to structure our conversation today, we thought we would start with a list. I know everyone probably wants to start with the list. In 1995, you're emailing friends about arts and tech events in San Francisco. And somehow that becomes Craigslist. Can you take us back? Like what were you actually trying to do and how did he how did it evolve? into what we know as Craigslist today. Craig Newmark: In ninety-five, I was still new to San Francisco, but people on the internet, even back then, were helping me out. And I figured I should give back a little bit. I was hearing about events now and then which basically were about arts and technology, like Joe's Digital Digital Diner and the Anon Salon. So I figured I'd start telling people about what I heard. People started cluing me in about other things, and I just took it from there. Started with a simple CC list, maybe 10 or 12 people listened to people, they made suggestions, and the thing just kept growing word of mouth. The first milestone that occurred, middle of ninety-five, was that at about 240 email addresses, the CC list I was using broke. And I had to use a listserv. Now I'm I'm a nerd, a pretty literal guy. I was going to call it San Francisco Events. It was still almost all events. But there were people around me, smarter than me, who said I had inadvertently created a brand. They were calling it Craigslist. They explained to me what a brand is. they were right. And I let them name it that. And just kept plugging away. There were other milestones along the way, but the deal is I just kept an eye on things even when I turned over management to Jim Buckmaster. meredith: Amazing. well, I thank you for that, as I imagine many others do, because it was it was actually probably Craigslist was probably my first foray into into using the the Interwet net on a regular basis, especially as I Craig Newmark: Yeah. meredith: was coming into college and having to get things for apartments and whatnot. So thank you for that. I wanted to ask you about How you categorize yourself? Because I I think it's really interesting you and I have known each other for a while and I've you always said like the size of of your wealth that this generated was wildly overstated in the press. And that without like litigating the numbers, how do you think of yourself as being categorized by rich as as normal standards from from Craigslist, from this side project that you started? Craig Newmark: Well, I really am a nerd with different affect and values than most people. And also I was very strongly influenced by my Sunday school teachers, Mr. and Mrs. Levin. They taught me to treat people like I want to be treated. They helped me understand to know when enough is enough. And all that kind of I took really seriously. Only explicitly in the last few years, but I realize what they taught me back then does run everything I've done. recently I read something which articulates how I really do feel about things. some Roman guys each said in their different ways, this is Roman Empire guys, the only wealth which you're gonna keep forever. is the wealth you give away. And I guess that's been my guiding principle. without thinking about it, because I internalized it, also I figure I should be my brother's keeper, my sister's keeper. Also, to some large extent, I should be about selling my possessions and give and feeding the poor. not so much literally as that's been my day-to-day since I decided to monetize Craigslist at all. The deal is to monetize very little, because people make better use of what they pay us. They can make better use of it for their lives, their businesses, than I could. So instead of going into the I guess the Robberbaron model. making huge amounts of money questionably, and then giving away a small fraction of it to build museums and libraries, which I do appreciate. But figuring that you want to let keep people keep the money they're earning. This decision was in 99, when I had to decide to make Craigslist into a company and how much should I monetize? That's when bankers and VCs Wanted to throw billions of dollars at me that I didn't need. And I figured I would just minimize monetize minimally, and meredith: Mm-hmm. Craig Newmark: that's worked out. As a result, Craigslist has helped tens of millions of Americans just get through the day. And Craigslist has shown 10 million millions of Americans that the internet could be useful. If it's made easy enough to use. Quanda: So what's really striking though, is that the company that you built has barely changed from, you know, the way you left that is amazing to me that it's been able to kind of stay in its current form and it's really endured for so long. And and it also strikes me that like Craigslist hasn't really changed, but you've changed dramatically. you know, you really went from building something to, you know, giving it away and and that's pretty that's pretty commendable. Craig Newmark: Craigslist has stayed the same in two big two big ways. One is that our value system under Jim has stayed the same. We do view ourselves as a kind of a community service, helping people out. It's also stayed the same more or less in terms of its interface, because regular people, regular users of the site, say keep it simple and fast. We do have people like designers who would like to redesign it without thinking that people want it to be simple and fast. And I listen to them, Jim listens to them, and they forget to listen to regular people. As for me, as I've considered the the revenue from in different ways. From my equity in the company, I'm thinking, I don't really need that. I don't know, I'm not certain what to do about it. But a few years ago, people who know finance and taxes told me that the best thing I could do to make a statement about my commitment was to put all of my Craigslist equity, my shares, Into a nonprofit foundation, a 501c4. And that way all the revenues that I would make from the company have to go to chip to nonprofits. And I since I made that decision shortly before my 70th birthday, I call that the Septigenarian Fund Quanda: Ha ha. Craig Newmark: because I'm not very imaginative, but I do have a sense of humor. meredith: Think that is a defining factor for you, Craig. And I'm so grateful for it. I don't think enough people, I think too many people take themselves seriously in a way that you don't, which is lovely. And and it's had an effect on how people think about what they're doing. So thank you. Craig Newmark: This is my pleasure. Quanda: Craig. Craig Newmark: I'll be keeping the faith. meredith: Good thank you. Quanda: Craig, before we kind of transition into talking about some of your giving specifically, we do wanna kind of stick with your origin story a little bit. I mean, you've referred to yourself even on the on on our discussion today as an old school nerd, and you said part of your approach to doing this type of work has been finding people who are really good at their jobs that can tolerate your sense of humor. I mean where where does that perspective come from? How how do you bring people into your ecosystem? Craig Newmark: well there's a few questions built in there. my origin was predicted by doctor Seuss in nineteen fifty with his book If I ran the zoo, where he introduced the nerd. Quanda: Okay. I'm gonna have to go read that one. I don't think that's in the box yet. meredith: I was like, I don't Yeah, I Craig Newmark: Okay. meredith: don't think Craig Newmark: Well meredith: Moira and Madeline have that book, Craig, so we're gonna have to get that one. Craig Newmark: there is a picture of the nerd on my website if you need to take a look. But meredith: Okay. Craig Newmark: I was born a couple years later. And frankly, I grew up root being really good at technology and math, but my social skills really sucked and continue to suck until this day. Now I can ch I've changed my superficial behavior. But when you think I'm exhibiting social skills, I'm faking it. What you're seeing is a simulation. And since I know something about delegation, I've now delegated my the practice of my social skills to my celebrity spokespuppet, the Count Van Count. This Muppet has much more personality than I do. He has considerably more charisma than I have, and he's just he has better people skills than I do. And meredith: What does Eileen say about all of this? Craig Newmark: she tolerates my sense of humor. She may think a lot of it's funny, but it's more fun for her to give me some crap. meredith: I love it. That's a good marriage should be. you've talked a lot about humor, finding good people, trusting them, getting out of the way, and that runs through how you ran Craigslist, then to how you think about your philanthropy now. So is that like talk to me about that? Like how did you come up with that framework, that philosophy about find trust. Get out of the way. Craig Newmark: my deal is that well, I take my Sunday schools, Sunday school lessons pretty seriously. Like one thing is that if you want to treat people like you want to be treated, you just you try to provide the best customer service you can, knowing that if you're serving tens of millions of people on a minimally monetized site, that's going to be tough. The best way Craigslist does that is by keeping things as simple as possible so that you people don't need much help doing things. And I continue that even in my philanthropy mode. I help a lot of people doing things like well, helping people apply for grants properly. like in some cases, I'll tell people in more detail what I'm looking for. And of course reminding them to sign their applications so Mabel won't get annoyed with them. That's your greatest danger. meredith: guilty sometimes. Craig Newmark: well my problem really is that sometimes I don't notice it and then Mabel will be a miffed with me, in which case I have to buy her more Hello Kitty crap. I have a a drawer full of it awaiting her visit tomorrow. literally. meredith: And tell us who Mabel is, for people who don't know. Craig Newmark: Mabel is the financial person for both Craigslist and myself. We keep her busy. She's meredith: Yeah. Craig Newmark: self taught and better at her job than professionals, because this is a passion of hers. That goes back to your question. My Sunday school training and the training that derives from that, both Old and New Testament. This is all reinforced by my rabbi. meredith: Right. Craig Newmark: This guy a Leonard Cohen, meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: who is the guy who told me to take a look at the New Testament, even though he and I are both very Jewish. Quanda: it's interesting, Craig, because when you brought up Mabel, it made me want to kind of skip a skip ahead a little bit and go directly to how you run Craig Newmark philanthropies. you outsource a lot according to, you Craig Newmark: Yes. Quanda: know, public records. I mean, you're outsourcing the accounting function, the legal function, the communications function. I mean, that is almost the opposite of how most large foundations and and even large donors operate. Why why why have that approach? Why build it that way? Why is your philanthropy so different? Craig Newmark: The big reason is that I've realized all my success is contingent upon working with people who are better at their jobs than I could be. so what I've done is I've located people in areas that I believe in, people who are themselves better at building networks, and then gave them a lot of money and delegated a lot of my decision making to them. I mean, that's the history of Craigslist with Jim Buckmaster running things. that's very much how I'm handling nearly everything to do with military families and vets. Blue Star Families has this network of chapters and outposts which help military families, particularly when they get relocated, which happens a lot. Bob Woodrow Foundation has the Got Your Six network, which has a network of over 400 nonprofits who are actually good at helping vets. across the whole country. When it comes to fighting scams and cybersecurity, that's tougher because there's a great deal to all this. And there I find to some large extent I'll I have to involve myself a lot because this gets really technical and I need to to get fairly technical in order to do due diligence, which meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: is what I spend my time on. However, the biggest part of this mission is not technical, it's getting everyone in the country involved. Hence the Take Nine campaign, which is about getting people to do the basics, because the basics both basically protect your stuff against attacks and it protects you against scams. And when you protect yourself in these ways, you're protecting your home, your family. You'll be protecting your job and you'll be protecting the country. However, I'm not the guy to get the word out here. We need a guy who's much better at communicating than I am, who has some real ris, as the kids say, because I totally lack charisma. And hence the count found count, I've basically have him exercising the social skills that I lack. meredith: I wanted to just ref reflect and comment about how you run Craig Newmark philanthropies because it is like you efficient and deliberative, but then you you actually just move you move money faster and more efficiently than any other philanthropist in the country. It's pretty remarkable. And for those listeners who haven't had the pleasure of working with Craig Newmark Philanthropies. It is the least barrier to entry. And Craig is incredibly r and his team are incredibly responsive. and again, you just give away more money more efficiently without all of the bureaucracy that a lot of other big philanthropies deploy or employ. I I wanna commend you for that. It's Pretty remarkable. Go ahead, sorry. Craig Newmark: Well, there my deal is I'm an engineer to my core and meredith: Right. Craig Newmark: a customer service rep to my core. meredith: Right. Craig Newmark: So I required the most streamlined process possible. And so I get help. Sometimes I need more help than usual because I can't quite figure out the request. or I have to figure out how it turns into my long-term planning. long-term is a big deal. I'm 73, and I figure I've 10 to 20 years left, and I have to spend money at the right rate. I have to figure out how I'm gonna do due diligence conceivably into my 90s. Now I've because I've engaged the the count. Well, he's been doing this for 2,500 years. So he's got a lot of experience with estate planning. Me, I figure, well, when I'm no longer around to do due diligence, I could, of course, just haunt grantees, meredith: There you go. Yeah. Craig Newmark: maybe use Ouija boards, or in the age of AI, I could train a chat system to be me. The downside meredith: Yes, yes. Craig Newmark: of this. is that if he gets good enough and if he reads science fiction or watches The Terminator, meredith: Yeah. Right. Craig Newmark: he may realize he may not need me around and I may only get in his way. So that factors into my estate planning. meredith: Well, let's hope your AI doesn't do that. But it as long as it has your sense of humor, is as long as we train the models to have your sense of humor, it'll be it'll be enjoyable at the very least. So I wanted to ask one question about the giving pledge. So you signed recently, even though you had been giving at serious levels and and and at higher levels than many of those who had signed it before you. So what made recently the right moment and like why what did it mean to you personally to do that? Craig Newmark: I this is petty, but I got over my literal streak. Remember, I'm a nerd, very literal, because meredith: Hmm. Right, right. Craig Newmark: it was kept people kept calling it the billionaire's pledge. meredith: Right. Craig Newmark: Never been a billionaire, although some of my half-assed investments will get my total there someday, but I've given away the bulk of it. And so my deal was I realized, hey, I need to get over this literal crap. And I could I only know how to lead by example. I'm not a real leader. So I figured I would I would sign up for the thing, even though you know, I'm not a billionaire, but I figured I would give away at higher levels than a lot of people. And depending on how you measure it, I'm either very well on track to give away. a a very large percentage of my wealth by my passing, that is the passing of my physical body, Craig GPT might keep going on. meredith: You will you will continue to haunt us. Yeah. Quanda: We help he we hope he does. Craig Newmark: and so even though the amounts of money I've given away will never be comparable to actual multi billionaires, percentage wise I'm already there and will do meredith: Yeah. Craig Newmark: better. meredith: Yes you will. Absolutely. Quanda: And and let's talk about that a little bit, Craig. I mean, cyber civil defense. you've made a hundred million dollar commitment to the broader network. So Aspen Digital, the Global Cyber Alliance, the Institute for security and technology, and the Shadow Server Foundation, of everything you find, is this your biggest bet and and why? Craig Newmark: the collection of bets are my biggest bets. I've contributed 200 also to trustworthy journalism, to military Quanda: Right. Craig Newmark: families and vets, and to fighting scams and cyber attacks. And I guess those are pretty big bets. I do know that beyond my current commitments, I will be k going on, because my current commitments for the most part go through 2028. I already I already have an idea of what I'll be doing beyond that. I haven't disclosed those because I don't want to get people too excited. Also, our economy is a little fragile right now. And I'm trying to be care pretty careful about capital preservation. meredith: So w Go ahead. Craig Newmark: I I have contributed substantially to pigeon rescue, but that total amount is no more than a couple hundred thousand. meredith: I love the white pigeons that come around your neighborhood and that come into your yard. They're so pretty. I wanted to say about y you've talked about fighting scams as something you take really personally and that it quote really pisses you off. And can you tell us about that for a moment? And that something that's yours or someone close to you? that has made this more of a policy interest and informed your your philanthropy. Craig Newmark: on a gut level, there were people trying to run scams through Craigslist. Not as much has been reported. That's been great, greatly exaggerated. We found someone paid to greatly exaggerate it. But the deal is it's a real problem. I take my site personally. I know it's not my site really, but I feel that way. And so I feel like I'm personally attacked. But also as well as well thou shalt not bear false witness. There's also thou shalt not steal. So my Sunday school moral compass is up in my up in my case, and that's real. meredith: So the scam fighting is definitely a center of gravity, but it's not the only thing you fund. you anticipate your shifting your focus or you're still solidly within supporting military and veterans and so forth and so on? Craig Newmark: Solidly with military families and vets, solidly scam fighting and cybersecurity. very focused now when it comes to trustworthy journalism. Most of it has to do with supporting the CUNY J School. You know, has my name on it. And a lot of that is that CUNY has always been about providing opportunity to people who would never get it otherwise. So They told me that they wanted my name on the school. It would help them be more effective. They were right. And for me, the best motivation for doing that was that I thought it was pretty funny, particularly since it's right around the corner from the New York Times building. also the biggest thing in Quanda: T tell us more tell us more about the irony there. Craig Newmark: Well, let's say that there are people in journalism, in schools and elsewhere who want to hold Times does really good journalism. There are people I work with who wanted to do even better journalism, like more fact checking. And I don't know, it just felt on a gut level like it was kind of funny. For me though, The big my biggest bet on trustworthy journalism is Wikipedia, where facts go to live, because journal basically Wikipedia contains the journalism of our times, typically higher quality than most everywhere else. They're more careful in terms of their process about what they'll put on pages, and well. Everyone, wherever you're doing news, you're going to get things wrong sometimes. Most newspapers will not fix errors in good faith. Wikipedia always does. Sometimes it's tough. They meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: need to improve some of their processes. But because of their editor community, it works. Now, I support other things like when my heritage is involved. I support the Ford, which is probably the best paper reporting on anti Semitism. Quanda: And so Craig, you've made all these big bets on journalism with ProPublica, Mother Jones, and Pointer Institute, in addition to the support you just mentioned for CUNY's J School. I mean, what is your great hope for journalism? Craig Newmark: I hope that they tell the truth hard enough, effectively enough, to save American democracy. Quanda: That that's that's a big one, just that. meredith: Just that. Just that. Quanda: but but a w a worthy Craig Newmark: but I Quanda: a worthy goal, Craig. Craig Newmark: I learned in high school history and civics in nineteen seventy that a trustworthy press is the immune system of democracy. That's also where I learned my commitment, my obsession with the Bill of Rights, treating everyone equally under law, or at least trying to. I should add that I know we need to do better as a country, and I help in very, very small ways. meredith: Well, I I love that I mean, well, I think you're always very modest. So I think your what you consider small ways are will have an outsized impact. I love that you are supporting journalism, future of journalis journalists through the the school at CUNY. I I love that you are supporting veterans and military families, you know, with over a hundred million dollars pledged. through scholarships and student programming, as well as various other aspects of veterans and military spouses and families throughout their sort of career and life journey, including Georgetown's McCord School of Public Policy, which I am so grateful to have the opportunity to work with you on, where you support the Newmark scholars as policy students who are veterans and military spouses, move from one form of public service into the next form of public service. What drew you to veterans and military connected students specifically? Is that I think you've talked about your family having been in the military. I know yourself have not, but tell me about that. Craig Newmark: I grew up in Morriston, New Jersey during meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: the 50s, when patriotism was a thing. It was expected. And a lot of it was expected of me because, well, my dad fought in the Pacific during World War II. he fought behind a desk, but so do I. My mom learned bookkeeping. So the bookkeeper could, I guess, like pick up a rifle and go overseas. But in Marstown, well, that's where Washington and the Continental Army spent a couple of hard winters. meredith: Yes. Craig Newmark: They made they almost didn't make it. And so there were memories of the Revolutionary War all around town. meredith: Right. Craig Newmark: In my in my teen years, I lived near the Washi Washington's headquarters. which was the Jacob Ford Mansion, and I lived in a housing project called the Jacob Ford Houses or something like that. meredith: Really? Huh. Craig Newmark: So, and there was a statue of Washington where I waited for the school bus. So the city, the town never lets you forget. meredith: That's pretty amazing. Quanda: That's fine. meredith: And very interesting because that's where I'm taking Madeline and Moira this weekend when I pick Madeline up in Philadelphia to do Washington's headquarters, do the American Revolutionary War Museum and then do headquarters in in New Jersey and then Valley Forge before we head back home. So thank you for the extra tip there. Craig Newmark: Say hi for me. meredith: I will. Quanda: Like another organization that you have funded is Girls Who Code and you do have a history of funding organizations that provide access to tech for women and girls. Can you just talk a little bit about how that fits in your overall portfolio? And and is this from your early days? you know, essentially being a tech startup, or is this giving more influence by what you see in like the landscape today? Craig Newmark: I guess it's motivated by my idea that I should be fair to everyone and do a little to provide opportunities and help to people who might never give a break. Reshmal meredith: Yeah. Craig Newmark: Sajani did a great job starting that up. meredith: Mm mm. Craig Newmark: Now it's she had there's other management there like Tariqah. And the deal is that. She's doing something which really means something and gets results. For girls across the country, they get a serious introduction to technology. So that, well, some of them may go after careers in tech. Others may feel more comfortable with tech that they'll use in other areas. This is a bigger and bigger deal, particularly considering the unknown role AI will play in all our lives. meredith: Sure. Craig Newmark: So these are really big things. And my ideal is that I should do some things to genuinely help people out. meredith: Yeah, I and I love that, you know, I love that you fund people. Like when you develop a relationship with someone, you stick with them. So Reshma was, you founded Girls Who Code, Tariqa took it over, and now Reshma's doing wonderful things in a different in a different construct for supporting women at a different port of part of their lifespan. So thank you for sticking with her in that. And then there's pigeon rescue, which is such a departure Craig Newmark: Ha ha ha ha. meredith: from everything else, but having had the privilege of visiting your home and and how you have the courtyard set up and for the pigeons to come in and all and all of the the feeders everywhere. So tell me like how did that start and that was that a San Francisco thing and then you literally migrated to New York for it or was that a New York thing that you do by coastal now? Craig Newmark: it's something I think I started when I lived in Detroit. I meredith: even before. Craig Newmark: put up put up one of those window feeders that stick meredith: Mm-hmm. Craig Newmark: to the window with suction cups. And that was great. I mean, I guess I've always been interested in seeing a little nature cross the boundary. maybe it has to do with the school psychiatrist in sixth grade. He tried to get me interested in bird watching and chess. meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: Way back, it didn't help any because he wanted me to develop some social skills. but maybe those things stuck with me. Anyway, I put up feeders in Detroit when I moved for a year to Pittsburgh, did some of that, and then I moved to San Francisco. the place we have here is really good. Because among the animals that cross the boundary, we got a lot of birds. We have a coyote or two named Larry. Quanda: wow. meredith: you named it. Craig Newmark: we have a bunch of raccoons, also named Larry. We have a we seem to have now a baby hawk or two, oddly enough, Larry. And so we do have a number of species running around. Sometimes we're f we're smart, we move fast and we get photos. Although there's a great horned owl, probably a pear, which hunt near us, and we've never been able to see them because they're nocturnal. meredith: That is true. I Quanda: Right. meredith: I I think again, I think you're underselling yourself on the the social aspects of bird watching because I remember you used to post pictures of your backyard bird photos. I don't know if it was I'm pretty sure it was a hummingbird that kept coming to you often, or there was some bird that came back often. And then you Craig Newmark: Okay. meredith: would post it and then actually Kwanda was pretty amazing. Like there was like a number of people that would comment on a regular basis and that became their bird watching was through how Craig would post Craig Newmark: Ha ha. meredith: his pictures. So though those of us who didn't have the benefit of a backyard, with all these creatures named Larry, we got to follow through Craig. So I think I think it is a social thing. Craig Newmark: My my deal is, yeah, I did post pictures of our favorite visitor. That was Ghostface Killer. we are very fond of Ghostface, but he's up that's a pigeon. He meredith: That's a pigeon? Okay, gotcha. Quanda: Pigeon, okay. Craig Newmark: he hung around for five years, which is the lifetime of a feral pigeon. We miss him, but he did leave behind a lot of progeny. As far as we can tell. He was working on his fifth wife when he passed. And meredith: Ha ha ha. Craig Newmark: there are a lot of birds who have plumage similar to his, and they're having babies. meredith: Yes. Craig Newmark: Nowadays in San Francisco, we do have a lot of hummingbirds, and they do come over to take a look. when sometimes during the right season, when I leave the front door. But also I have a couple hummingbirds, maybe the same one, that will find me in the back of the house, like in the office here or I'm wearing watching TV, and the hummingbird will come up to the window and look. They're shockingly Quanda: It's great. Craig Newmark: smart considering how tiny their brains are. Of course, meredith: Yes. Right, no kidding. Craig Newmark: I think the same thing of myself. meredith: Right. All of us, humans in general. I mean, it's a it's a thing. Well, I I will say that I have never thought of pigeons besides like, what was it, Mary Poppins, who the fed somewhere the woman fed the pigeons or something. but we have two pigeons in my backyard now and my kids named them Bert and Ernie. So while we don't have a Larry, we definitely have we do have a pair here for sure. So thank you. Quanda: Craig, this is this has been such awesome conversation. what's interesting for me is they all come back to the same instinct, right? digging into what might be the unglamorous work, and then, really making sure that organizations and individuals can keep doing the important work that needs to be done across cybersecurity and access to technology and pigeons. So it's been very helpful to kind of hear your perspective on what you fund, why you fund it and how you fund it. So it's been truly, truly illuminating. Craig Newmark: folks, thanks, I appreciate it. meredith: I wanna talk about one last sort of genre of work that you've done before we get into our signature questions, Craig. So you alluded to earlier about your patriotism and how important democracy the future of democracy is and how you've invested in certain ways through your philanthropy and and wanting to defend the country and the institutions. you And you've said this before in in your writings without being read as partisan. So I wanted to ask you without going too off the deep end here, like is that getting harder for you to do and how do you navigate that? Craig Newmark: I dabbled in a little bit of politics in the distant past. I realized that politics is no country for old nerds. And I just would be much better off, and the world would be much better off if I just kept my mouth shut in that regard. meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: I do have some beliefs. I'm basically a practitioner of what we learned from the founding fathers. including Lincoln. meredith: Mm. Craig Newmark: That's modified, but what I learned from Old and New Testaments, we do need to help people out. So my small government concerns are mitigated by my by my concerns that we really do need to to help people out now and then. We do need to be our brother's keeper or sister's keeper, whatever that means literally. We do need to sell our stuff and feed the poor. Whatever that means literally. I really do need Bible study to help me understand these things better. maybe I'll ask Craig GPT for help. meredith: Don't we all? I think what comes through loud and clear is that having core principles, values, and navigators, people who have taught you how to navigate the world based on a philosophy and is is core to how you live your life, but also how you you live your philanthropy. and and Quando and I have talked about this a lot that you know, philanthropy, the the the root Latin word i is around the love of humanity, the love of people. And so that comes from, you know, a core philosophical base, believing in something. And you bring that you bring that forth no matter what you're talking about. And I and I think it's really important when we're talking about democracy at this point. So thank you. Craig Newmark: My pleasure. meredith: So ask every guest, a question that gets underneath your public story and into again your philosophy of giving, which I kind of just referenced. So first question is what's one belief that you hold about giving that most people would disagree with? And why are you so sure about it? Craig Newmark: in practice, support for crime fighting because you'd think that the government should be responsible for it, but these days they don't have the funding for it or they need a lot of forensic assistance. And the deal is someone like me can step up and help out with serious forensic assistance. But also sometimes funding. I've been a little shy about talking about this for a decade since I've gotten the most crap in my life when I wasn't prepared to defend myself against bad actors, some of whom were paid to misinform people. We've identified two such parties. meredith: That's really interesting. Yeah. I mean, and crime fighting or f supporting crime fighters has definitely over the last six years, definitely during the pandemic, has been a a topic that's been politicized. So I could see why you'd be c cognizant of not talking about it publicly, but agreeing that it does need to be supported. Craig Newmark: Well, the deal is to do real stuff which winds up treating people fairly. We got equal protection under the law. And as Americans we need to live up to that the best we can. And then after that we do a little better. meredith: Agreed. Yeah. Quanda: I love that philosophy. All right, Craig. So now we are at our kind of signature lightning round. It's called Three Questions and a Tip. So I'm gonna ask you three questions and then you give us a quick response. So, you know, a line or two. then I'll just move on to the next question. And then at the very end, I'll ask you your perspective. and you can give our listeners some advice. So are you ready? Okay. The first question is: what's the most unexpected act of generosity you've ever witnessed? And what did it reveal to you? Craig Newmark: I keep forgetting if it was the Patagonia guy who put all his equity into a C four fund. I was thinking about that when he announced it, and that triggered me to actually go ahead and do that. for that matter, the way Mackenzie Bezos is spending money. is doing a lot of good for the world and that influences Quanda: Absolutely. Craig Newmark: me similarly. Quanda: That's great. Thank you. the second question is, what's something people do in the name of generosity that may look meaningful on the surface, but often misses the point? Craig Newmark: there's some people who don't check to see if who their funding is for real, if they're good at their job. And that's problematic. I've stumbled in my in some regards in because I've made some big contributions to people who sound like they could do the job, usually with Ivy League repetition reputations. But then I found out they weren't up to it. The money wasn't wasted. It just wasn't as effective as I'd like it to be. frankly my disappointments have been with the fancier schools. yeah, I there are three three Ivy League schools. Well, one the jury is still out, and one has kind of failed. I do know of one which has been compromised by bad actors, but I'll probably keep my mouth shut. Quanda: We'll respect that. We'll respect that. the third question is what's a belief that you hold about giving that you wish more people felt comfortable saying out loud? Craig Newmark: basically if you got a lot of discretionary income, you don't need to buy all the luxuries you can. You can give some of it away, like to help the people who protect us, or to feed people who need a break. because you do need to get job training to people who need to feed themselves. But while they're getting that training, their families need help. Quanda: Absolutely, Craig. Now the final question is is a tip. So if someone is listening to this conversation today and they really want to be more intentional about their giving, maybe the way you've been intentional about your giving, but they're unsure as to where to start, what would you offer them? Craig Newmark: I can only recommend the organizations that we've already vetted, which is to say look at people who are doing good work who you could trust. in general, in the context of all this is always good communications. The problem is that a successful enough nonprofit is a good target for bad actors who want to mi who want to get attention. So they'll often manufacture misinformation to get attention and sometimes to hurt a group. That is a big problem right now. It's getting much worse with generative AI. And so my team and I are starting to think about that because I believe a lot in the future of AI, but the big guys have to start working on how they will counter planted misinformation like SEO and stuff like that, or actually adversarial information placed there by foreign military bad actors that is actually a real problem right now that we're not talking about too much right now because we don't want to tip them off and we don't want to cause panic. meredith: I wanted to close with two more questions and my first one is what is your giving teaching you right now at this moment? Craig Newmark: Most fundamentally my giving is telling me that I'm doing the right things with my life. meredith: Yeah. Hmm. I love that. Quanda: So powerful. I do. And I mean, Craig, if someone wants to make an impact on their communities, be it their time or their treasure, maybe they have the ability to make a greater charitable contribution to causes and organizations, but they're kind of waiting for the right moment. I mean, what would you say to them? Craig Newmark: they have to think about their own values and decide what they want to help with, but then they have to make sure they're finding an organization which is actually good at the job, and they're not also that the organization is not a scammer, which happens. And some of these things are tough. There are no end of legitimate causes to help out. I've focused on a few because I could only help with very limited resources. Frankly, those limited resources are my personal bandwidth and the amount of money which I've made, which is increasing even with my half-assed investments. I just have to pace out the money because in an ideal world. as I was passing the last of the monies will be spent. But I as as you've heard, I am spending some time with an estate plan. And I just meredith: That's great. Craig Newmark: hope that cr I hope that Craig GPT lets me live. meredith: Live on. And if not the ghosts and the Quanda: And with that meredith: ghosts will That's amazing. Thank you so much for your time. It's a pleasure to see you. I hope you and Eileen get some time this summer to relax and do some bird watching. Craig Newmark: Thanks. I'll try to figure out what relax means, but it's all meredith: Yes. Craig Newmark: just get back to work now. meredith: Right. Quanda: Thank you for joining us for this episode of The Philanthropist Personal Journeys of Giving with Purpose. If this conversation stayed with you, we hope you'll share it with someone in your own life who is thinking deeply about generosity, legacy, impact, or what it means to truly show up for others. You can also watch full episodes and exclusive content on our YouTube channel and follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram for behind-the-scenes reflections and upcoming conversations. And if this podcast is meaningful to you, please subscribe, review, and share. It really does help us grow this community. We would like to extend a special thanks to Lumina Foundation for their support and our good friends Jack Pompey and Connor Ellis of Goodpoint NYC for producing this episode. Meredith Hanley: To continue the conversation with us directly, email us at hello at the philanthropistpodcast.org. We generally want to hear what these stories are stirring in you. Quanda: I'm Quanda Allen. Meredith Hanley: And I'm Meredith Hanley. Until next time, give with purpose, give with joy, and give in a way that changes you too.