Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 140: The Seine River's Past & Present with Mary Winston Nicklin
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:08I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. In times of turmoil, and there
- 0:13has been plenty of it in the year 2024, in and out of Paris,
- 0:17we naturally seek sources of calm.
- 0:20We seek constants. And in Paris, there's perhaps
- 0:23nothing that recenters Parisians more than the Sen.
- 0:27The city's most iconic waterway has shaped its mythology long
- 0:30before there were tourist boats and selfie taking travelers.
- 0:34Today, the significance of the Seine River is front and center
- 0:37again, thanks to the Olympics and a billion euro cleanup
- 0:40project. To talk about all of that, I'm
- 0:43joined by my friend and fellow journalist Mary Winston Nicklin,
- 0:46who reported National Geographic's cover story on the
- 0:49Seine earlier this year. We recorded this conversation at
- 0:53a cafe near the river with the occasional chatty pedestrian or
- 0:56delivery person passing by. I hope this only adds to the
- 1:00color of our discussion. Mary, welcome to an off site
- 1:08recording of the new Paris. Love it, thank you for having
- 1:11me. We are sitting.
- 1:13Where are we sitting? We are sitting at a cafe looking
- 1:17toward the sand. We are basically as close as we
- 1:20can be without being on the riverbanks, right?
- 1:23Yeah. The trees are changing color,
- 1:25which is beautiful to see. Finally.
- 1:27Yeah, it's really slow nowadays. I find we slow as in later.
- 1:32You know what I mean? You know, it's just late.
- 1:34We've still got our palm. Trees.
- 1:36We have these bizarre palm trees lining the Pon Louis Philippe
- 1:41from the Olympics and very close to us.
- 1:45We have influencers or some sort of photo campaign for God knows
- 1:51what with an oversized croissant.
- 1:53It is so. Bizarre, I've never seen this
- 1:55before. No.
- 1:56Well, but you know Paris is a backdrop for.
- 2:00It's true photo shoots. And series and all sorts of
- 2:02things, but. We're just curious if it's good,
- 2:04can we go try it? Something tells me it probably
- 2:07won't be also after all those hands have touched it.
- 2:10There you. Go.
- 2:12OK, so we're here in this location because I wanted to
- 2:15talk to you about the set. You or a journalist, you have
- 2:20written some massive features for the Washington Post, for
- 2:25Afar and most recently for a National Geographic.
- 2:28And this was the cover story. So as your friend, I think this
- 2:31is. Huge.
- 2:33That's really cool of you. Thank you so much.
- 2:35And it it was. It came out in July.
- 2:37It was the August issue. August issue.
- 2:40And it took. It was a good year project
- 2:43actually our our photographer Thomas van Houtreva photographed
- 2:48the sun for more than a year. And our the whole, the whole
- 2:52point of the project really was to dive deep into the history
- 2:57and culture of the river to give it context before the Olympics.
- 3:04Because the river really served as center stage for the
- 3:06Olympics, the opening ceremony, and also because of the giant
- 3:10cleanup project equivalent to 1.5 billion that people have
- 3:13heard so much about. So that was our timely hook.
- 3:17But it was really, you know, a deep dive into the history and
- 3:19culture, which I love because for me, I mean, the sun is like,
- 3:23it's like Paris in terms of just so many stories.
- 3:28And that's what we're going to get to because I really want to
- 3:30understand where this mythology comes from.
- 3:32And and also, I mean, we walk by the sun.
- 3:36I mean, maybe not daily, but regularly.
- 3:39And I don't think we think about everything that it has to do
- 3:42when has done for the city and for its people.
- 3:45And so this clean up project is really, you know, part of
- 3:49hopefully a new era. But if we get into your story,
- 3:55you write that the sin has been a conduit of civilization and
- 3:58French national identity personified endlessly.
- 4:02We think of the river today in terms of Paris present, but it
- 4:05goes so far beyond that, physically and historically.
- 4:08Can you talk about that mythology?
- 4:11So where did it come from? Sure.
- 4:13So first, I think it's important to look at the the history of
- 4:16the river, because this history isn't the longest in France, nor
- 4:20is it the mightiest. But some of the most defining
- 4:25historic moments in the country's development happened
- 4:30on the Sun. So it's history.
- 4:32And then we'll get into culture. So I mean, the the city itself
- 4:36would not be Paris without the sun.
- 4:39And then you have you have events like the Viking invasion
- 4:43of France of Normandy, which a lot of people don't realize,
- 4:46which I hadn't realized was so formative in the development of
- 4:50the country. I mean, we still have Viking
- 4:52place names cartographically on our maps.
- 4:56On Fleur, It's, for example, a Viking place.
- 4:59And so the Vikings had this outsize influence.
- 5:01And I think the Vikings themselves are such a
- 5:03fascinating subject because, you know, there are a lot of
- 5:05stereotypes about these warring peoples, but they were actually,
- 5:08you know, travelling through the rivers as far away as Iran.
- 5:15And, you know, there was a big cultural exchange.
- 5:17And so the Vikings brought a new way of thinking of France when
- 5:20they developed Normandy, basically.
- 5:22So that was the early 10th century when the first Duke of
- 5:27Normandy, he was a Viking chief and his ancestors went on to
- 5:32conquer England. So, you know, the Vikings played
- 5:36an outside role. Joan of Arc was burned at the
- 5:39stake, her ashes thrown into the sun.
- 5:43I like to think about, you know, Richard the Lionhearts, his
- 5:46Chateau, Chateau Gaillard, which is outside.
- 5:50It's not too far from Paris in Normandy.
- 5:53It's actually just, sorry. It's absolutely beautiful.
- 5:57It's up on a clifftop overlooking the river.
- 6:00The, the you can see the white cliffs in the distance.
- 6:04And when that Chateau fell, that was the end of the Anjan Empire.
- 6:08Anjan Empire, which is the Plantagenets.
- 6:11This was an entire dynasty that was stronger, more powerful than
- 6:16France at that moment in time. So Eleanor Rakuten's
- 6:19descendants, Richard the Lionheart, this this Kingdom was
- 6:23more important to for me than France was at the time.
- 6:26So when that fell to Philip Auguste, that was huge for the
- 6:29Franks, right? So there are all these formative
- 6:32moments that have happened on the banks of the sun.
- 6:36And then when we get into the culture, that's a whole nother
- 6:40topic. Basically, cultural movements
- 6:43like Impressionism were born from the sun.
- 6:46The painters who were escaping Paris, escaping Houseman's
- 6:50renovations of Paris, the artist, the painters were.
- 6:52Yeah. And the sun was this, you know,
- 6:55endless inspiration. And what was so interesting in
- 6:58their work was sort of this fusion of industry and nature
- 7:02that I think of when I think of the sun today, the most
- 7:05urbanized river in France. There's these constant, sort of,
- 7:10you see often this contrast between nature and industry,
- 7:13this coexistence and the Impressionist, you know, that
- 7:16the painting that launched the entire movement was the
- 7:20Smokestacks Against the Sunrise in Lahav, the Claude Monet
- 7:23painted. Which is also where the sun
- 7:27connects. To I mean exactly.
- 7:28It goes far beyond Paris, so the.
- 7:30Yeah, so the Impressionist movement is just one example of
- 7:33many cultural. I mean, you have New Wave
- 7:35cinema, there's a an A mill called the Moulin Dante, which
- 7:40is where a lot of it's sort of an artist retreat now.
- 7:44And this is where Truffaut filmed Julie and Jim.
- 7:48Like this is where this is where a lot of that, you know.
- 7:52So you have New Wave cinema, you've got the Impressionists,
- 7:55you've got not too far from Fontainebleau, you have Django
- 7:59Renard, the classical guitarist who?
- 8:03Also has a festival every year which I went to this year.
- 8:06And I was it. Was amazing and you know, you
- 8:07get the sense that it it's a way to start seeing how the past
- 8:12informs so very deeply the present and the future.
- 8:17But at what point did the send become commercial?
- 8:20Because you wrote about Osman and you just mentioned Baron
- 8:23Osman as being something that the OR someone and, and his
- 8:27innovations that the artist wanted to flee.
- 8:31But his sewer system that he developed or he put someone in
- 8:34charge of, you know, actually executing was hugely important
- 8:39in the chronology of events. And yes, if you hear noises,
- 8:43it's because we are outside and there are trucks and people
- 8:48unhappy in their cars when other cars are blocking anyway.
- 8:51So at what point did it become commercial, and why was this
- 8:56ultimately the sewer system? Why was it a huge innovation,
- 8:59but one that was ultimately bad for the river's health?
- 9:01I found that so fascinating. Right, interesting.
- 9:03So to answer your first, the first part of that question,
- 9:06which is commercial, which I think of also as river
- 9:08transport. And if we're to talk about that
- 9:11aspect of the river, that commercial aspect of the river,
- 9:14it's been since the earliest days of humans living on the
- 9:18river really. I mean, the notes, which were a
- 9:20group of boat, a Guild of, of boatsmen in the early days of
- 9:27Lutessia, that that's what they did.
- 9:30That's why they were powerful because they had control of the
- 9:34river commerce and river transport.
- 9:36And one of the symbols of Paris is an actual pillar that they
- 9:39gave to the emperor. You know, this pillar that you
- 9:43can see in the Clooney Museum. So that shows sort of the
- 9:46importance of the river commercially since, you know,
- 9:51the early centuries. So that's interesting.
- 9:54I definitely didn't think of it in that, in that way.
- 9:56But regarding the sewer system, so that's an entirely different
- 9:58question. So the river, if we look at the
- 10:01river's health today, so basically we love the river, but
- 10:05we've also hated it overtime. Not hated it, but we've dumped
- 10:10in it. Right, which is a disrespect.
- 10:12For it, right? But if you look at, I mean, it's
- 10:15fascinating to look at the archaeological record of what's
- 10:18been thrown in the river, what's been found in the river, because
- 10:21this shows great veneration. Like, you know, the Knights, The
- 10:25Crusaders going off to the holy lands would throw talismans and
- 10:28good luck talismans before they started out on their journeys.
- 10:32There were offerings like that, but you also have trash, you
- 10:35know, and I spent a lot of time with the pompier who are
- 10:38stationed on their floating fire department down near Lamani.
- 10:42I loved when you told me this is what you were doing.
- 10:44You're like, I cannot, I cannot come out.
- 10:46I have to hang out with the firemen.
- 10:48I loved it. Oh my God, I loved it.
- 10:50We, I spent a couple days with these guys and they find a lot
- 10:53of stuff still, you know, dumped in the river.
- 10:55Like what kind of horrible things?
- 10:58Well, aside from bodies, which I'm sure.
- 11:01That's happened. That has happened.
- 11:04You know, things like your stupid e-cigarrete, whatever.
- 11:08The vapor, Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, whatever they're
- 11:11called, right The the. Yeah, the EE.
- 11:14Cigarette, yes. Things we're not smokers,
- 11:17clearly. No, what else?
- 11:20Digital camera batteries, like things that are just like,
- 11:23annoying, but they've also found things like armed, you know,
- 11:27guns from World War Two and oh wow.
- 11:29Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's a whole collection and
- 11:32the and the. Yeah, yeah, there's a whole
- 11:34collection of those kinds of things.
- 11:35That is wild. So wait, back to, oh, OK, so
- 11:39over time, we have used the river as a dumping ground.
- 11:43But this, this didn't matter really historically when the
- 11:46population was low, right? But what you have in the 19th
- 11:49century with the dawn of the Industrial Revolution is this
- 11:51huge. I mean, I think it doubled.
- 11:53It was like 1 to 2 million in a matter of years in the 19th
- 11:56century. And Paris was suffering these
- 11:59cholera outbreaks. I mean, it was really, really
- 12:01filthy when you think about what Houseman had to handle.
- 12:05I mean, the city's sanitation was, it was, it was serious.
- 12:09It was really, really, really unhealthy.
- 12:11Yeah, people, people forget that part of, I mean, maybe they
- 12:14don't, but I think when you're walking through Paris, I, I find
- 12:16it interesting to remember all of the very unseemly and, and
- 12:21really appalling moments in its history where the population was
- 12:24being, you know, just annihilated by, by virus and by
- 12:27illness. Disease, absolutely.
- 12:29And what we think of as charming today, like the winding medieval
- 12:33streets, which I love, I can't get enough of.
- 12:35But it was really, really unhealthy, really unhealthy
- 12:39damp. And anyway, Houseman opened it
- 12:41all up. He brought in, he had, you know,
- 12:44he had his engineer Belkhong, who brought in fresh water and
- 12:48also devised a sewer system. Now, here's had a sewer system
- 12:52since Roman times. And if you go down the sewer
- 12:54museum, you can see this. I mean, they were building on
- 12:56vestiges over time. But the, the most important
- 12:59sewer system, what we still use today was built in the 19th
- 13:02century. And this was really
- 13:03revolutionary at the time. But what what it does and what a
- 13:06lot of sewer systems do is it collects wastewater and rain
- 13:13runoff into the same system. So it was not doing what the
- 13:17we're going to get to the new system, obviously, but it does
- 13:19not do what we realized needed to be done.
- 13:22You cannot put those two in the in.
- 13:24The right I mean, today we also see the virtues of collecting
- 13:27right water, right? Sure, for other purposes.
- 13:29Exactly but not. For the health of people.
- 13:31Right. But at the time this was amazing
- 13:33because they could cart, cart away.
- 13:36I that's not the right word. I can, you know, you can direct
- 13:40the sewage away from the citizens in Paris, which had
- 13:45immediate impact on the health of the city.
- 13:47However, it will actually, I should say, a lot of waste was
- 13:50still used as fertilizer at this point in time.
- 13:53So people from for centuries understood the merits of saving
- 13:58and recycling stuff. And today we still recycle a lot
- 14:00of the stuff at the at the treatment plant.
- 14:03It's fascinating. They're really high tech and
- 14:04they try to reuse as much material as possible.
- 14:06OK, that's really cool to see. But so a lot of this waste was
- 14:10collected and put on the plains of Sandini, where there were a
- 14:13lot of farms to feed the city of Paris.
- 14:16Right. I have to remember that long
- 14:17before it was basically the most densely populated, you know,
- 14:21suburb around Paris, it was farmland.
- 14:23Yeah, right. Yeah, Yeah.
- 14:24That's. A remarkable and you can still
- 14:26see traces of it today. There's market gardeners that
- 14:29supplied the city, but I should add back to the sewer system.
- 14:32So some of that waste was collected, but then a lot of it
- 14:35was also dumped downstream. Did they not have the
- 14:42understanding of what would happen if they did that?
- 14:45I just think, who could have predicted how many millions of
- 14:48people live in the Paris? Regions.
- 14:50That's terrible, right? That's what I think.
- 14:52You're sort of you're making decisions based on what you have
- 14:56the ability to know. Exactly.
- 14:58But but then again, you know, you think about how Paris always
- 15:00saw itself as this grand power. I don't know, maybe maybe I'm
- 15:04completely off base to think in thinking that that their
- 15:07ambitions were for it to be a highly populist capital.
- 15:12But maybe that's maybe that's completely false.
- 15:14Well, it's all, I mean, I think about it being, you know, the
- 15:18capital of Europe from the Middle Ages.
- 15:20So it's always had this powerful, but whether I don't
- 15:23know, am I reporting? I didn't find any, you know,
- 15:25the, the, the, the reasons why we dumped downstream and thought
- 15:29that was OK to put our mess downstream.
- 15:31I don't know the answer to that, but my guess is we didn't think
- 15:35that the consequences were as serious as sure I see today.
- 15:39So when did those consequences start to become very apparent?
- 15:42Well, so the real the health and that's another question I know
- 15:45you have between the words health and clean when we talk,
- 15:48right? Right.
- 15:49So that was such a fascinating distinction you made.
- 15:51For me too, it really is. So if we think about the health
- 15:55of a river, we're talking about what's living in it, the species
- 15:59living in it. So the real terrible it, it
- 16:05wasn't until I'd say the 1960s when it things were dire, when
- 16:09there was virtually nothing left living in the river.
- 16:13This was not necessarily from our sewage, wastewater, but
- 16:16factory dump, you know. Something right.
- 16:19So that was the other part of it's not just, you know, what
- 16:23doesn't get sort of divided up or, or removed in the sewage
- 16:28system. It's also then you have these
- 16:30factories and the and and big business coming in.
- 16:33So this, this is so toxic. The discharges these factories
- 16:38were putting into the river, so toxic.
- 16:40And there was no oversight of this stuff back in the day.
- 16:43I mean all over the world. Right.
- 16:45Not just Paris, right? It's worth.
- 16:46So I think there's a real reckoning.
- 16:48I mean, we think about when the environmental movement really
- 16:50started. We're talking 1960s.
- 16:52I look at Rachel Carson spoke of Silent Spring is really a wake
- 16:55up call for the state of the environment that really had long
- 16:58term sort of effects. I think the word pollution as we
- 17:01use it today wasn't really coined until the 1960s or the
- 17:08the way, yeah, the way we think about the way.
- 17:09We know about it, right? Right, right.
- 17:11So this the the river, it was really bad.
- 17:13I mean, you'd see the just just imagine like dead fish and just
- 17:19like scum floating on the surface of the water, like just
- 17:22really, really awful. And that carried on well until
- 17:26today, right? That was for decades.
- 17:29So some of the people I interviewed for this story, I
- 17:31mean, who grew up here on The Sun, I mean, they just remember
- 17:33it being a cesspool. Who did you?
- 17:35Absolutely. Are you talking?
- 17:36About the residents that you interviewed.
- 17:37Oh. Yeah, residents, but also
- 17:39scientists and stuff. Yeah, who have just grown up in
- 17:42this area. So it was just really gross.
- 17:44So back to what it means to have a healthy river.
- 17:47What's what's living, what's living in the river?
- 17:49So at that time, it was nearly biologically dead.
- 17:52We can say we only had a couple species of fish that could
- 17:56resist pollution, that could live.
- 17:58There's no oxygen in there. There's not.
- 18:00I mean, they can't live in this environment.
- 18:02And so it really, it was in the early 1990s when EU legislation
- 18:08put into place, you know, rules across Europe.
- 18:13Wastewater has to be treated, basically.
- 18:16So that was 1991 I remember from your story.
- 18:19And what did? What else did it entail?
- 18:22So it's basically, I mean, as I understand it's, it was rules
- 18:28for collection, treatment and discharge of wastewater.
- 18:32So I just don't think that there had been any.
- 18:35I don't have the technical in terms of that kind of
- 18:40information, but it was really a mandate that this stuff had to
- 18:43be taken care of, right? So we already.
- 18:46Right. So I think this this was this
- 18:49was huge. This was a huge thing.
- 18:53It was the beginning, as I say, as the, you know, the tide
- 18:56started to turn for the health of the river at that point in
- 18:58time. And now today we have something
- 19:02like nearly 40 species of fish living in that Paris region.
- 19:07But is that just? Since this cleanup project or
- 19:11was that sort of before? Is that since 1991?
- 19:14Well. So there have been strides on
- 19:17the plan to clean up the river, which we talked about during the
- 19:21Olympics a lot. A lot of people, a lot of TV
- 19:25viewers, especially in the United States, thought that the
- 19:27the whole point of the plan was just for the Olympics.
- 19:29No, no, for me, this is really, this is a long term plan that
- 19:32was put in place nearly ten years ago.
- 19:34Yeah. You talk about 2015 and the
- 19:36plural vinyad that led to the Olympics and then they like
- 19:41ample. I mean, it sort of accelerated
- 19:42with the Olympics. Exactly.
- 19:43So the Olympics was really an accelerator.
- 19:45And it was also, I mean, you know, one of the deputy mayors
- 19:49says that it, it's speeded up by 10 years, he guessed.
- 19:54Wow. And it was part of the winning
- 19:56bid. Oh sure, yeah.
- 19:57I mean, they knew they had to pitch that as part of the.
- 20:00Yeah, for sure. I mean, it never been done
- 20:02before. And I think, I think Paris
- 20:03really did an amazing job. But So what does that entail
- 20:07then? Because I mean, we hear about
- 20:08the cleanup program and now that we're now that we're far removed
- 20:13from the Olympics, it's worth reminding people because I think
- 20:16it got lost in a lot of the Olympics coverage.
- 20:19So it. Was frustrating for me because I
- 20:21saw a lot of negative coverage. I mean, there were reporters
- 20:24talking about the color of the water as an indicator.
- 20:27I'm like, no, no, no. That has to do with sediment
- 20:29after rain. It actually doesn't have to do
- 20:31with the help of the water. There was also some scare
- 20:35mongering, mongering with some headlines, I think back in
- 20:38February about, you know, dire test results.
- 20:44And I'm thinking to myself, the river, the whole point is it's
- 20:48we're not swimming in February, right?
- 20:50February is when we have our most rain.
- 20:52Rain is when we get the bad bacteria.
- 20:54I mean, that's anyway. And so the clean up plan is
- 20:57supposed to make sure that we can treat that properly.
- 21:01Right. So the clean up plan which is
- 21:03which has been happening since 2015 is a mass mobilization of
- 21:07upstream townships and also Paris in a couple different
- 21:13ways. One is infrastructure upgrades,
- 21:16right. So we have this dual sewage
- 21:20system historically, where storm water and wastewater are
- 21:23funneled into the the same place.
- 21:25In times of heavy rain, our sanitation system would open the
- 21:30valves into the sun so that we wouldn't have overflow into the
- 21:32streets, right? So that's when you get the bad
- 21:34bacteria and the E coli, which can make the river unhealthy,
- 21:38right? And that's what we're cleaning.
- 21:39That's what cleaning the river means.
- 21:40But also unhealthy bad bacteria for water for.
- 21:45Swimming. Or just for because it's this
- 21:47word, right? Clean versus healthy.
- 21:49If E coli gets in the water, that's got to be bad.
- 21:52For I think it's really the factory pollutants that are like
- 21:56gotten really bad. So back so this this massive
- 21:59mobilization effort with the upstream townships, a lot of
- 22:02houses had not been hooked up to the sewer system, believe it or
- 22:06not, on the Marne and right. So these houses, it was
- 22:10grandfathered, fathered in had been, you know, dumping their
- 22:13sewers directly into the OR worthy of that you had Paris
- 22:16house boats. Right.
- 22:17I thought about those, yeah. That had to be hooked up.
- 22:19They were not hooked up necessarily before.
- 22:21Crazy to think about, but sort of the bigger efforts were at
- 22:26treatment plants. CAP, which manages the whole
- 22:29sort of Parisian system, has done incredible technological
- 22:33upgrades. There are a lot of new
- 22:34collectors and the tank that I write about in this story, so
- 22:37which I went down inside and it's just, it's just pretty
- 22:40phenomenal. There's a tank on the Left Bank
- 22:42that can hold the equivalent of 20 Olympic sized swimming pools
- 22:45of rainwater stormwater when those big massive downpours
- 22:49happen, thus preventing it from getting flooded into our sewage.
- 22:52System and then what happened the same.
- 22:55So that is slowly filtered back after the rains have subsided,
- 22:59slowly filtered back into the sewage system and it goes to our
- 23:02treatment plants. Wow, right.
- 23:04So it's a really, it's really technical.
- 23:06And I tell you, when I was down there, I was having all these
- 23:09epiphanies about France as this country of engineers.
- 23:13I mean, I think this is one of my biggest takeaways from doing
- 23:15this story from the beginning of time, really human, the human
- 23:18habitation along this end. We've engineered this river like
- 23:22almost to death, right? Think about the bridges, the
- 23:26locks, the cays upstream. We have a bunch of lakes
- 23:31constructed to keep Paris from flooding.
- 23:36That's another topic we can get into.
- 23:37Yeah. But anyway, over the course of
- 23:39history, we have engineered this river in a crazy way.
- 23:42And now finally, we're using human engineering to go in the
- 23:45different direction to bring it back to life.
- 23:48So this, for me, this was like the most incredible take away.
- 23:51And to see it was 40, more than 40 engineers who worked on this
- 23:54project, it seems 40. Yeah.
- 23:57And hundreds of people working in there.
- 23:59And Paris is just. So if you look underground, how
- 24:02densely? That's the other thing people
- 24:04don't realize is, you know, we see, we spend our time above
- 24:08ground and I guess if you've been to the catacombs or you've
- 24:11been to maybe even the sewage museum, right, or the, you know,
- 24:14you can tour, you can tour this sort of thing.
- 24:16But for the most part, aside from the metro, we're not really
- 24:19spending any time we like uncovering the other side of our
- 24:24lives here that operates. And it's, you know, behind the
- 24:27scenes and it layers underground in terms of metro sewers,
- 24:34electrical cables, heating. It's like, it's like the further
- 24:37you further down you go, the further you get into history.
- 24:41Absolutely. Sort of.
- 24:42That's my initial real. And most often, the
- 24:44archaeological digs that happen as a result of this stuff is so.
- 24:48Cool. Sure, they must discover.
- 24:50Things so I asked the guys for this project and they didn't it
- 24:53was in a particular area that hadn't really been it was
- 24:56outside of sort of the the the Roman areas of of the the Latin
- 25:01Quarter. But in general, yeah, I mean,
- 25:04any hotel to dig in a swimming pool, you know, you often.
- 25:07Find come up with things for sure.
- 25:09Come up with really cool stuff now.
- 25:11That you say that maybe that's why certain hotels have opted
- 25:14against a swimming pool, not just for the issue of space,
- 25:17Totally. Because maybe.
- 25:19It sets you back many months, sometimes a year, when you have
- 25:21to call in the. It's like, look at the Rome
- 25:24right now is preparing for the Jubilee, you know, next year and
- 25:29mass construction everywhere. And I know that they get delayed
- 25:33because like you, you knock one thing and you discover something
- 25:37completely historic that not, you know, needs to be analyzed
- 25:42and preserved. So, you know, we're, we're
- 25:44working within such, I mean, just such a just such a it's
- 25:49like a history book come to life.
- 25:51And you have to, yeah, you have to operate within that and, and,
- 25:54and be mindful because you can't just sort of forge ahead.
- 25:57Yeah. But to your point, you mentioned
- 25:59rainwater and flooding. So you mentioned flooding and
- 26:02the cistern at Gardo Sterlitz, that's where the tank is that
- 26:07you visited, correct? Yes, it's near the hospital
- 26:09there. Can that tackle issues like
- 26:12flooding? Can it tackle climate change
- 26:14issues? No.
- 26:15So I asked them so, So this, this was one of the, the, my
- 26:19biggest discoveries researching this story.
- 26:22The cleanup project. We still have work to do.
- 26:24I don't want to say it's perfect.
- 26:26I don't know. We still have work to do it.
- 26:30However, if you look at where the sun was right ten years ago,
- 26:35it's remarkable. I mean, when Arthur's your man,
- 26:38the son of Anne Hidalgo swam the entire length of the river in
- 26:412021, he found the sun was healthy.
- 26:45He was taking readings a couple kilometer every couple
- 26:48kilometers, a long way. He only found like 4 readings of
- 26:52bad bacteria like they were out of that were.
- 26:54And this was back before, you know, any of the cleanup project
- 26:58news went public or anything like that.
- 26:59Like we've made significant strides.
- 27:01And just as an aside, our friend Sarah Lieberman wrote a story
- 27:05following Arthur back when he was doing that swim.
- 27:07And I'm going to include the article in the show notes in the
- 27:10description if you want to if listeners want to read.
- 27:12Yeah, he's a tremendous guy. I mean, you're just a.
- 27:15Fascinating. Story.
- 27:16Yeah, it's an awesome story. Really, really cool story.
- 27:19But he he was motivated by environmental reasons for doing
- 27:22that swim really to call attention to in his words, the
- 27:25sin isn't just a trash can. And that's how I I shouldn't be.
- 27:29One to begin with, no. No.
- 27:32SO you had asked about flooding, flooding.
- 27:37So for me, realizing that this cleanup project was has had
- 27:41tremendous progress and that cities around the world have
- 27:45been watching this. There are other cities that wish
- 27:47to embark on cleanup projects. Washington, DC comes to mind.
- 27:51And they're, I think it's twice as expensive as the sun project
- 27:56so far, what they've been putting into it.
- 27:57Really. Oh, or over time it will be.
- 28:01It's over a 20 year period. So it's.
- 28:03Yeah. But there are other cities that
- 28:06are are looking and inspired by this.
- 28:08And I think it's a real, it's a, it's a very positive
- 28:11environmental message for me in this bleak environmental news
- 28:16scape. Yes.
- 28:17But that doesn't mean that if you know, what we're starting to
- 28:20see over the last couple of years is that maybe for Western
- 28:24Europe and Paris in particular, much like what we're seeing this
- 28:27year with Spain that climate change, what that looks like for
- 28:30us is heavier storms and a lot more rain.
- 28:34And so these tanks are not going to be able to accommodate.
- 28:38No to the. Degree that we might be exposed
- 28:40to it, right? So that was not their intention
- 28:43at all. And I, I point blank asked the
- 28:45engineers, no, absolutely not. It can't handle it.
- 28:48So those lakes that I mentioned, flooding has always been a
- 28:52historic Paris problem. We've had flooding since, you
- 28:55know, like. Biblical floods.
- 28:57Right. Yes.
- 28:58But what was it, 1910, right? Yes.
- 29:00And we still see some of the marks, you know, edged on city
- 29:05walls, city fountains, where those water levels came in 1910,
- 29:10like it was, I mean, in the vintage postcards are
- 29:12extraordinary, seeing these people boating across street,
- 29:15down streets. So when I was researching this
- 29:19story, what I realized is that the dangers of flooding with
- 29:23climate change are really actually the bigger sort of
- 29:28scarier subject. So, and the reason actually that
- 29:33we had issues starting the Olympics with some of the events
- 29:37postponed because the water leading.
- 29:39So water, the bacteria levels were too high when they did the
- 29:44water readings. Paris 2024 and World Triathlon,
- 29:48we're following the protocols about what it could be.
- 29:50The reasons that we had some issues was because of the rains.
- 29:53And this is climate change because usually we have dry
- 29:57summers. Historically we get our yes.
- 30:00And what climate change has unleashed is freak downpours of
- 30:04intense, intense. And that is what is totally
- 30:10unpredictable. I mean, we've just seen it in
- 30:12Spain. Exactly.
- 30:13That's what I mean. I mean, and we saw it here this
- 30:16time last year. Northern France was already
- 30:18getting pummeled and these villages are going to become
- 30:21uninhabitable. Exactly.
- 30:22Condemned. Yes, so the bigger issue for me,
- 30:25so the lakes that have been engineered outside of Paris
- 30:29upstream to hold back the scent to to basically regulate the the
- 30:35river water level, right. Is that going to be sufficient?
- 30:39So they're actually there was a fascinating film director that I
- 30:42interviewed for this piece who his his film, his documentary
- 30:46film is called translated when the scent overflows and
- 30:49basically reassuring. I know when he started
- 30:53researching the topic, he thought it was a classic sort of
- 30:56subject send flooding. But what he realized is that
- 31:00there are entire institutions, there are groups of engineers
- 31:04working for the RATP, all these other organizations working on
- 31:08worst of nightmare scenarios like what do we do?
- 31:11Because it could and it will happen in terms of, you know, a
- 31:16deluge of rainwater. And we need those minds to fix.
- 31:22Exactly solve this so that so so for me, the the scent is really
- 31:26facing an uphill battle when it comes to climate change.
- 31:28Climate change is the bigger scary story, yes.
- 31:34So what I like is that you gave us a lot of positive things to
- 31:37think about and to talk about because you were correct that,
- 31:41you know, this cleanup came at a time when people were looking
- 31:44for negative things to cover about the Olympics.
- 31:47And I certainly wasn't the biggest champion of the Olympics
- 31:50before it kicked off, right? But I, I at least knew enough
- 31:54because, you know, I live here. And so I was, you know, I was
- 31:56able to sort of see the benefit of of this cleanup.
- 32:00But for a foreign audience, I think it's important to
- 32:04reiterate how important this project was definitely and
- 32:08remains. On that note, can I can I say
- 32:11it's not just fish species, but we've also seen an incredible
- 32:16increase in the number of nesting birds on the sun,
- 32:18interesting population of seals in the estuary that hadn't been
- 32:22there some years ago. So it's, it's brought back to
- 32:25life and really made this an ecological corridor as it's
- 32:27always been historically. Why does this matter?
- 32:30Why does biodiversity matter? Because it's, it's very air we
- 32:34breathe and water we drink. I mean, as human, I mean, this
- 32:36is all important for our ecosystems, right?
- 32:39So for me that biodivert the story, the return of the
- 32:42biodiversity of of of the sun, it's it's really important.
- 32:46It's about our survival. Essentially, and also, I mean if
- 32:49you take it from a cultural standpoint, people have been
- 32:51swimming in the sun forever. So the fact that we should be
- 32:53able to swim next year in the summer.
- 32:56So that is still ongoing. That plan is ongoing.
- 32:58Yes, it's there will be 3 places to swim and I plan to swim.
- 33:01I mean they're going to test the water daily.
- 33:03I trust it, OK. And this is another sort of
- 33:07response to climate change that the city is putting in well we
- 33:10need. A way to cool there right for.
- 33:12Sure. In the city that doesn't use air
- 33:14conditioning, we need a place to go.
- 33:16Yeah, cool. Assuming that we do get heat
- 33:19waves again, we've had spurts, you know, a few days here and
- 33:24there, but we haven't had the true heat wave.
- 33:25We had, you know, a few years ago right in Paris where it
- 33:29lasted over a week over 40°C. You know that that is not to say
- 33:331 is less destructive because they both are.
- 33:36But I think everyone assumed, oh, that's the path much of
- 33:40France is taking. But in fact, in the last couple
- 33:42of years, it's been rain. So I think the idea is we don't
- 33:46fully know, right? But we need to be prepared for
- 33:48everything. If listeners can look at the
- 33:51scent in a new way when they visit Paris, what would you
- 33:54suggest they pay attention to? Well, I love Arthur Germans, you
- 33:59know it's not a trash can. This river is the vital
- 34:03lifeblood not just of culture and a civilization, but for an
- 34:08ecosystem when they're. Looking at it, just remember
- 34:11that it it serves this bigger purpose when you're walking
- 34:15around now, what do you think of besides the engineers behind it
- 34:18and all of that, how did it change your relationship to the
- 34:22river? I think reporting this story
- 34:23River. For for those of us who live
- 34:25here and a lot of visitors, I mean, the sun is just, I've
- 34:28always found it a very calming sort of steadfast source.
- 34:32And I think this made me really think about it as a living thing
- 34:36too, that all the stuff living in there.
- 34:38I mean, I love that there's a giant catfish living underneath
- 34:42the it's an invasive species, but it's the mascot of the
- 34:45firemen. Where is it living?
- 34:47Under the under their floating fire station.
- 34:50You're kidding. They call him Roget.
- 34:52Yeah. It's like, you know, I I love
- 34:54thinking about what's living in there and the and the divers
- 34:58there are divers and both the police and the and the papier
- 35:02who go down there all the time. And it's just, it's thinking
- 35:04about this being, yeah, a living sacred entity too.
- 35:09If we think about as early as mythology as as a river goddess.
- 35:15So these are all things people can think about maybe.
- 35:18Yeah, just take a moment to think about that when when
- 35:20they're they're strolling along the sand and, and looking and
- 35:24and thinking perhaps, oh, it's just a river.
- 35:28It's not just a. River, right?
- 35:30Well, it's also, I mean, we gravitate to this and we can't
- 35:32help it. People take selfies.
- 35:33We come, we do boat rides. That's the thing we do as
- 35:35tourists here. And it's thinking about how this
- 35:39city improbably years ago when Chirac said I'm going to swim in
- 35:43the sand, he couldn't believe it.
- 35:44It was finally a mayor on another side of the political
- 35:46aisle that fulfilled that promise.
- 35:49Look at what can happen politically when you put your
- 35:52mind to it. We can achieve great things.
- 35:56We can, you know, clean up a river that was so filthy and
- 35:59disgusting that no one would. I mean, I look at it now and I,
- 36:02I think it looks great. Yes, there's some floating gross
- 36:06things sometimes, but, you know, but for the most part, it's
- 36:10like, wow, isn't that? Isn't that?
- 36:13Great. And isn't it phenomenal what we
- 36:14can do when we put our minds? Yeah, totally.
- 36:17And investment towards something, yeah.
- 36:18Exactly. Can benefit, yeah.
- 36:22Mary, what incredible reporting. Seriously, what a phenomenal
- 36:26story. And for those who want to read
- 36:29the story, you have to track down this issue of National
- 36:32Geographic from August. Yes, there is an online version.
- 36:36I know that's not the complete version.
- 36:37You know, it was obviously trimmed for web.
- 36:39But really everything Mary just said is part of the story.
- 36:43So you've already gotten to hear from the source more about the
- 36:46river than maybe you knew before.
- 36:48And go forth and and think about all of it on your next visit.
- 36:53Thank you so much for being here.
- 36:54It's a real treat. Thank you.
- 36:57That's the show for today. Thanks for listening.
- 37:00As always, if you're streaming this on Spotify, be sure to
- 37:03check out a little poll that awaits you pertaining to this
- 37:06discussion. Just Scroll down on the episode
- 37:08page within the app and vote. And if you enjoy the show, I'd
- 37:12love it if you'd subscribe, share with a friend, and pick up
- 37:15the books that inspired it. The new Paris and the New
- 37:18Parisien. Until next time, Abioto.