Latest / Rachel Oates / Candace Owens Lied And Lost In This Jubilee Debate
Transcript
- 0:00OK, Hi everyone. Welcome back to a new video.
- 0:02We're just recording audio only today and I hope that's OK.
- 0:05If you're listening on Spotify, hi.
- 0:07If you're listening or watch on YouTube also hi.
- 0:10Today we're going to be talking about someone that I've been
- 0:11wanting to talk about for a while but just haven't for some
- 0:13reason. And that is Candice Owens.
- 0:16And she was recently on, I think it's like a Jubilee video where
- 0:19it was like her debate in 20 Liberals or whatever it is.
- 0:22And I definitely have a lot of feelings about the Jubilee
- 0:26videos, which I'll touch on later in this video.
- 0:28And I don't necessarily think they are the most educational.
- 0:33I don't necessarily think they're the most helpful.
- 0:35I think they are quite rage baity and they just want to make
- 0:38people on both sides quite angry.
- 0:41And they don't really do anything to further the
- 0:42conversation. But I do think this video
- 0:45brought up some interesting points that are worth talking
- 0:49about. They're worth fact checking.
- 0:51They're worth having a discussion about and trying to
- 0:53turn this into something actually educational.
- 0:56So I'm going to be responding in this video to the first half of
- 0:58this debate, which is the first two claims that Candace made.
- 1:02If you want to see a second-half of this and see me responding to
- 1:05the second-half of that video, then please let me know down in
- 1:07the comments. Because in the second-half of
- 1:09the video, she makes crazy claims like how we're living in
- 1:11a matriarchy. So if you want to see me respond
- 1:13to that, please let me know. In the meantime, hi, Thank you
- 1:16so much for being. Yeah.
- 1:17It'll be wonderful. If you want to subscribe, if you
- 1:20end up liking this video, if you have been here before, check
- 1:24you're still subscribed. That's always really good.
- 1:26And you can follow me over on Instagram at Rachel Oates with a
- 1:290 if you want to see more of my everyday life and some fun stuff
- 1:31that I've been doing recently. But for now, let's just jump
- 1:34into responding to this video. Yeah.
- 1:36My first claim is that the sexual revolution has devalued
- 1:40women and made them infinitely less happy.
- 1:44Okay, so first up we need to define what this sexual
- 1:46revolution is. And for this I think we can
- 1:49maybe define it as the time period between mostly the 1960s
- 1:52and 70s, but also a little bit before and afterwards, when
- 1:55birth control became more readily available and people
- 1:58could use it with less shame and stigma.
- 2:00This allowed women and men, but honestly mostly women and people
- 2:03with uteruses, to have more control over who they had sex
- 2:06with, when, where, why and how. It allowed them more control if,
- 2:11over if and when they had kids. It allowed them more control
- 2:14over how many or how few sexual partners they had.
- 2:17The sexual revolution allowed more open talk about sex in
- 2:21general, meaning people would be more educated about their
- 2:23bodies, the bodies of others, about consent, about how to
- 2:27practise sex safely and healthily, about pleasure and
- 2:30choice. It was about reducing shame and
- 2:33stigma so more people could make the choices that they wanted to
- 2:37make and not just what society told them they should be doing.
- 2:40This did lead to some people having more premarital sex, more
- 2:44sexual partners, having sexual partners of different genders
- 2:47and so on. But none of this was forced on
- 2:49people. It was a choice people could now
- 2:51begin to make more freely. If you still wanted to wait
- 2:54until marriage, you could. If you still only want one
- 2:57sexual partner, you could. There was nothing saying saying
- 3:00hey, you have to be promiscuous and do this and this and this
- 3:03and this. It was all about choice.
- 3:06It also opened up a lot of choices for people that Candace
- 3:09Owens seems to forget with society not pushing the get
- 3:12married young, save yourself until marriage and pop out all
- 3:15the babies you can anymore. This did benefit people who
- 3:18wanted multiple partners, for example, but it also benefited
- 3:21people who didn't want any partners at all.
- 3:24Asexual people were starting to become more accepted.
- 3:27Although I admit even today we have a long way to go still and
- 3:30if people didn't want to have any kind of sexual relationship,
- 3:33they didn't have to anymore. Ultimately the sexual revolution
- 3:36was about education and choice and I don't see that as a bad
- 3:39thing at all. Actually there's a great little
- 3:41summary that comes from Kristen Anderson in her book Modern
- 3:44Misogyny. Anti feminist propaganda in a
- 3:46post feminist era. She writes feminists in the
- 3:491960s and 70s fought for, amongst other things, control
- 3:53over their bodies, the right to control their reproduction, the
- 3:56right to love who they want, the right to extricate themselves
- 3:58from abusive relationships. The woman's liberation movement
- 4:01fought for the release of women from conventional morality
- 4:04around sex, which had confined them to either idealise chastity
- 4:08on one hand, or contempt or contemptible promiscuity on the
- 4:11other. Feminism allowed for the
- 4:13possibility of women engaging in sex for their own pleasure,
- 4:17rather than for the two previous allowed reasons for sex to
- 4:20reproduce or to please her husband.
- 4:23However, she also brings up the fact that there's an argument to
- 4:25be made in some ways that misogynists have taken women's
- 4:27freedom and used against them to objectify them further, to
- 4:31overly sexualize them without their consent and so on.
- 4:34That is something we will be discussing later in this video,
- 4:36but not right now. For now, we're just talking
- 4:39about the direct consequences of the sexual revolution in the 60s
- 4:42and 70s. A woman's right, or a person
- 4:45with a uterus right to choose how she expresses her sexuality
- 4:49and what happens in their own body.
- 4:51I think what Candace is trying to argue here is that now women
- 4:54have a choice and aren't as easy to control and shame.
- 4:57Candace Owens and other misogynists are not happy about
- 4:59that because ultimately their goal is to control women and to
- 5:03shame them into submission. But that doesn't mean that
- 5:05having freedom of choice is inherently dangerous or harmful
- 5:08for women or that'll make them miserable.
- 5:10Having a choice does not devalue someone.
- 5:13It's quite the opposite. Having choice over what happens
- 5:16to your body is not going to make people less happy.
- 5:19Again, quite the opposite. Now, I'm speaking generally that
- 5:22because are there some choices that a woman can make that will
- 5:25be dangerous and therefore result in her being less happy?
- 5:29Yes, of course, just like there's some choices a man can
- 5:31make that can be dangerous. For example, whether a man or
- 5:34woman chooses to have unprotected sex with a partner
- 5:37that they don't know the health status of he Oh, I said status
- 5:40is the status of my turn, American.
- 5:42Oh, God, sorry. When they choose that he or she
- 5:45or they are potentially putting their body at risk by opening
- 5:48themselves up to disease like sexually transmitted infections
- 5:51and so on. If they choose to have
- 5:53unprotected sex when they don't want pregnancy, that could be
- 5:56harmful or bad or irrational, right?
- 5:59I think I think we can all agree on that.
- 6:00I can see that. An unwanted SDI or an unwanted
- 6:03pregnancy, that might make someone less happy.
- 6:05I see that, but again, this doesn't devalue a person.
- 6:09A person isn't lesser than someone because they might have
- 6:12an illness or a need for medical treatment.
- 6:14And the issue here, the unhappiness, stems from a person
- 6:16making an uninformed or irresponsible or irrational
- 6:19choice, something which millions of people do in all kinds of
- 6:22situations every day. Because humans are irrational
- 6:24beings, right? The issue there is with the
- 6:28irrationality of humans, not with a woman or person with a
- 6:31uterus having the right to choose what they do with their
- 6:34own body. The issue is with people's
- 6:37individual choices, not with people having freedoms at all.
- 6:41Take a different example. Imagine a man makes a dangerous
- 6:44and irrational or uninformed choice to eat a piece of meat
- 6:47which has expired, and he then has to face the consequences of
- 6:50that, which are likely going to be food poisoning, and let's be
- 6:52honest, that's going to make him pretty unhappy.
- 6:54He will face those consequences, but he will also still be able
- 6:58to receive health care and be looked after by the people
- 7:00around him and won't have to deal, and won't have to deal
- 7:04with people arguing that all men should be on diets dictated by
- 7:07the government. Because they clearly can't be
- 7:08trusted to make the right choices about their own bodies,
- 7:10can they? All that being said, the sexual
- 7:13revolution didn't dictate that everyone should be making
- 7:15irresponsible choices with their body.
- 7:17It just offered women the chance to make any choice about their
- 7:21own body. So not all women are going to be
- 7:23making irrational or harmful choices.
- 7:25Some are going to be making smart, informed, well thought
- 7:28out choices that are right for them.
- 7:30The women who choose to have safe sex.
- 7:31The women who choose to have consensual encounters.
- 7:34The women who plan for pregnancy or plan to prevent pregnancy.
- 7:37The women who choose to wait until marriage.
- 7:39The women who are asexual and choose not to have sex.
- 7:42The women who are able to be with partners of whatever gender
- 7:45they're attracted to. And so on.
- 7:47These are the rational choices that plenty of women can now
- 7:50make for themselves amongst others, thanks to the sexual
- 7:54revolution. And I don't see how any of these
- 7:56choices would lead to someone being devalued or unhappy.
- 7:59But I mean, let's, let's focus on that devalued claim for a
- 8:02second. Again, what does that even mean?
- 8:04I feel like Candace is probably referring to the fact that some
- 8:07of the choices that some women make are the ones which Candace
- 8:10and other misogynists don't want them to do.
- 8:12So Candace and the other misogynists shame these women
- 8:15for doing them. They shame them for making these
- 8:17choices. They begin to treat them as
- 8:20lesser than them. But this doesn't mean women are
- 8:23actually devalued. It means that these people are
- 8:25misogynists and need to sort their life out and start
- 8:27treating other humans better. The issue here is with Candace
- 8:31and the misogynists, not the women who are just living their
- 8:33lives. Again, let's go back to a food
- 8:36example. I personally really hate sweet
- 8:39corn. Right, Hate it.
- 8:40Even the smell disgusts me. So if I see a person go out of
- 8:43their way to all the sweet corn, I might think to myself, oh God,
- 8:46that's that's something I'd never do.
- 8:48I can't even understand why person would want to do that.
- 8:51But I'm watching you do it happily and I'm feeling quite
- 8:54confused about it. But just because you're choosing
- 8:58to eat a food that I don't like, does that suddenly mean you lose
- 9:02value as a person? No, no, of course it doesn't.
- 9:07So why? Just because you see someone
- 9:08making a choice about their sex life that you wouldn't do, how
- 9:11does that change their value as a person doesn't?
- 9:16It absolutely doesn't. As long as the person is engaged
- 9:19in consensual acts, communicate with her partner, being open and
- 9:22honest isn't endangering anyones physical health, knowingly and
- 9:26so on. Why should whatever choice they
- 9:28make affect their value as a human?
- 9:32It doesn't. And if you think it does, that
- 9:35is a problem with the person assigning the value.
- 9:37If you are assigning value to people based on their sexual
- 9:40preferences, that is a problem with you and not the person
- 9:43who's just making choices for themselves.
- 9:45So are women still being shamed for their sexuality and choices
- 9:49and bodily autonomy? Yes, but that is something which
- 9:53needs to change amongst misogynists and those doing the
- 9:55shaming. Yeshu is not with women who are
- 9:58just happy making their own choices.
- 9:59As Meredith Rawlson writes in her book Slut Shaming,
- 10:02Horophobia and the Unfinished Sexual Revolution, women won't
- 10:06be free until their sexuality in whatever manifestation is not
- 10:11shamed and stigmatised. It's not someone's sexuality
- 10:14which devalues them, but individuals and misogyny
- 10:17assigning a value to them. And besides, if you want an
- 10:20example of why the sexual revolution has been good to
- 10:22women, just look at how kind of someone introduced herself.
- 10:25Hi, my name is Candace Owens. I am a podcaster, a mother, a
- 10:28wife and also the author of the upcoming book Make Him a
- 10:31Sandwich. And today I am surrounded by 20
- 10:34feminists. The fact that she could choose
- 10:37to define herself by her job first, mother second, is thanks
- 10:41to feminists and in part specifically the sexual
- 10:45revolution. The fact that she was able to
- 10:47choose her own husband, was able to decide if, why, how, and who
- 10:51she had kids with at all was thanks to the sexual revolution.
- 10:56The fact that she's able to sit here and debate these topics at
- 10:59all is, you guessed it, thanks to the sexual revolution.
- 11:02Another thing that came with this time period and the sexual
- 11:05revolution is that, yeah, divorce rates did increase
- 11:08because it became less stigmatised to divorce.
- 11:10And again, I don't see how that's a bad thing because it's
- 11:13because it has been proven time and time again that people are
- 11:16happier and healthier when they leave bad relationships than
- 11:19when they and are single than when they are forced to stay in
- 11:23an unhappy or unhealthy relationship.
- 11:26Women could now leave abusive partners and husbands and get to
- 11:29safety. They could leave men who made
- 11:31them unhappy or cheated on them. They didn't have to stay.
- 11:35But of course no one was forcing people to divorce.
- 11:38If the relationship was happy and healthy, people stayed in
- 11:41it. Having the choice is not a bad
- 11:43thing. Having the choice did not make
- 11:45people unhappy or devalue them. The woman, the feminist who
- 11:48replied to Candace Owen here. She brought up this point and
- 11:51Candace responded with a straight up lie.
- 11:53My question for you is, statistics show that 60% of
- 11:57women who are murdered are murdered by their intimate
- 12:01partners, murdered by someone that they are in close relations
- 12:04with. That's according to the UN from
- 12:072023. So how is it that, you know,
- 12:11women are are so valued, you know, quote unquote in the home
- 12:14and yet that's the place where they're at the most danger?
- 12:18Still not sure how this correlates to whether or not.
- 12:20Sexual revolution increased woman's ability to leave the
- 12:23house, woman's ability to control their own reproductive
- 12:26capabilities, woman's ability to, you know, control their own
- 12:31like capacity within the workforce in regards to their
- 12:34own sexual capacity. So it is the very fact that,
- 12:38like, the sexual revolution happened that made our access to
- 12:41the workplace much more, or just the public sphere in general,
- 12:45much more easy. So like, without the sexual
- 12:49revolution, women would be much more confined to the place where
- 12:52they're at the most danger. Isn't that true?
- 12:55So you think that just so I'm trying to understand your
- 12:57argument here, you think that if we didn't have the sexual
- 13:00revolution, less women or more women or?
- 13:03Women would be murdered for sure.
- 13:05OK, I disagree with that. I mean, this, she's straight up
- 13:08wrong here. But this isn't quite the light.
- 13:09We'll get to that in a second. I just want to bring up some
- 13:12more stats here for a second. So according to research
- 13:14compiled by Kristen Anderson, she writes, men are nearly four
- 13:17times more likely than women to be murdered.
- 13:20But men are also seven times more likely than women to commit
- 13:24murder. Women are more likely than men
- 13:27to be victimised by someone they know than by a stranger for all
- 13:31measured silent crimes except robbery.
- 13:34Specifically, female murder victims are more likely to be
- 13:37killed by an intimate partner than a man.
- 13:39For instance, in 2010, 39% of female homicide victims were
- 13:43killed by an intimate, whereas only 3% of male homicide victims
- 13:47were killed by an intimate in the United States.
- 13:49One study of more than 5000 American College students found
- 13:52that 28.5% had experienced an attempted or completed sexual
- 13:56assault either before or since entering college.
- 14:00Sexual assault of women is also common in already physically
- 14:03abusive relationships. 68% of physically abused women were
- 14:07also sexually assaulted by their intimate partners.
- 14:09And finally, women are more than twice as likely to be stalked as
- 14:13men. One out of every 14 American
- 14:15women will be stalked at some point in their lives, and around
- 14:1987% of the stalkers will be men. According to the US Department
- 14:23of Justice, 4 out of five stalking victims are women.
- 14:26So the sexual revolution played a huge part in allowing women to
- 14:29escape these abusive and dangerous situations.
- 14:32And it's sad that there's still plenty of us who have been
- 14:34through this and continue to go through this everyday, like
- 14:36myself included. But just know that without
- 14:39feminism, without women being able to divorce their partners,
- 14:42without the sexual revolution and so on, these stats would be
- 14:45even higher. More women would be killed and
- 14:48abused and harassed and assaulted.
- 14:50And we know this because in countries where women are not
- 14:53allowed to initiate divorce or a woman's or where a woman's
- 14:56sexuality is still policed to the extreme, or where victims
- 15:00aren't allowed to speak up and get help and those who do the
- 15:03abusing have no chance of being prosecuted.
- 15:05In those countries, women still die an alarming rate.
- 15:09I'm going to throw a lot of stats at you here, but they're
- 15:11important. UN Women reports that globally,
- 15:1481,000 women and girls were killed in 2021 and around 45,000
- 15:18of them, that's 56% died at the hands of an intimate partner or
- 15:22family member. Meanwhile, the Femicide census
- 15:25tells us that every day, every single day, 137 women and girls
- 15:29across the world are killed by a family member or intimate
- 15:32partner. According to the United Nations
- 15:34Office on Drugs and Crime, it's estimated that around the world,
- 15:37a woman or girl is killed every 11 minutes in its own home.
- 15:40And it's it, well, sorry, in their own home.
- 15:43And it's even worse in certain countries.
- 15:45Concern Worldwide reported that the Democratic Republic of Congo
- 15:48ranks as the worst country for intimate partner violence, with
- 15:51half of all Congolese women over 15 reporting experiencing
- 15:55physical violence. Women Kind reports that in Iran
- 15:58alone there are 400 to 500 honour killings taking place
- 16:03every year, almost always by male relatives.
- 16:06In Latin America and the Caribbean, twelve women and
- 16:09girls are killed every day. However, 98% of cases go
- 16:13unprosecuted. El Salvador has the highest rate
- 16:16of femicide in the world according to 2017 data from the
- 16:20United Nations was 13.9 out of every 100,000 women murdered.
- 16:25Meanwhile, Jamaica has the second highest rate of femicide
- 16:27in the world according to the UN, with 11 out of every 100,000
- 16:30women murdered in 2017. In India, dowry related killings
- 16:35equal 25 equal 20 femicides a day, with nearly 7000 dowry
- 16:40deaths per year in 2020. Do I need to go on?
- 16:44And sources for all that are in the source document link below.
- 16:48And it's not just about women being able to sweep around and
- 16:50do whatever they want. It's about women being able to
- 16:53choose their own relationships and half bodily autonomy and be
- 16:55able to safely leave dangerous situations.
- 16:58And while we've come a long way in some parts of the world, we
- 17:00clearly, clearly have a long way to go in others.
- 17:05And the answer to this isn't, well, we should police who women
- 17:07have sex with more, and if they take birth control, we should
- 17:09police her too. No, the answer is to stop
- 17:11misogynistic violence against women by being more aware of it,
- 17:14doing more to stop it, and actually prosecuting the people
- 17:18who do it. A woman isn't unhappy and
- 17:20devalued because she chooses to stick a coil inside her or take
- 17:24a pill. A woman is unhappy and devalued
- 17:27when she is shamed, harassed, assaulted and murdered simply
- 17:31for existing. And none of that is the fault of
- 17:34the women for existing, for making choices, for doing what
- 17:38is right for them. Here we go this way.
- 17:41I still don't think it has anything to do with the claim
- 17:44that women are infinitely less happy because of the sexual
- 17:46revolution, which has. I think you'd probably be less
- 17:49happy if you're being murdered. Anyone.
- 17:55Disagree. OK, Yeah, I don't.
- 17:56OK, OK. There is definitely a
- 17:58correlation between personal relationships and domestic
- 18:01violence. And just to be clear, if we're
- 18:03talking about just like a monogamous relationships, the
- 18:05most violent relationships that are on the books are between
- 18:08lesbian partners. Yes, when people are intimate,
- 18:11that's not that is actually true.
- 18:13The statistic you're talking about is people who have faced
- 18:15domestic violence. Lesbians, yes, are more likely
- 18:17to have faced domestic violence, but that's because they're
- 18:19typically came from relationships with men in.
- 18:22Lesbian relationships are the most violent relationships that
- 18:25we have on the book, but we can they can Fact Check that claim.
- 18:28This is the outright lie. She is completely wrong and
- 18:32misunderstanding the studies done on this.
- 18:35The other woman tried to call her out on this but she just
- 18:36wasn't listened to it by Candace and Candace is just completely
- 18:40wrong. I literally have a whole video
- 18:42about this if you want to check it out.
- 18:43Again LinkedIn the source document.
- 18:45But to summarise, women are overwhelmingly the victims of
- 18:48domestic violence. Men are overwhelmingly the
- 18:50perpetrators. When studies have been done
- 18:53asking people what relationship are you now in?
- 18:55How do you now define your sexuality and have you ever been
- 18:57victim of domestic violence? They are not asking is your
- 19:00current partner violent? So what this meant is that
- 19:05because women are more likely to be victims, when you have two
- 19:07women in a relationship, it's more likely that at least one of
- 19:10them will have been a victim in the past.
- 19:12So when gay men, lesbians, bisexual people and straight
- 19:16people were all asked, have you ever been a victim of domestic
- 19:19violence, this also included past relationships, and a lot of
- 19:23these people had been in past relationships with people of
- 19:26other genders than what they were in a relationship with now.
- 19:28So this meant that yes, some lesbians used to be in
- 19:30relationships with men, some gay men used to be in relationships
- 19:33with women, and bisexual people have had relationships with
- 19:35people of both genders. So when we consider that women
- 19:38are more likely to be victims of domestic violence and lesbians
- 19:42have two women in the relationship, that's twice as
- 19:44likely that one of them will have been a victim in the past.
- 19:46It is just basic maths. A lot of the lesbian and
- 19:49bisexual women in the study that Candace Owens is referring to
- 19:52were talking about domestic violence they faced for men in
- 19:55past relationships, not from their current female partners.
- 19:59This is something that homophobes choose to actively
- 20:02ignore. If you want the stats and
- 20:04sources and all of this in particular, I'll leave my
- 20:06original video LinkedIn the source document.
- 20:08But to give you a little summary, Women's Aid found in
- 20:122024 that the overwhelming majority of alleged perpetrators
- 20:15of domestic violence are men. 94.4% of perpetrators in their
- 20:20studies were men. One study of 96 cases of
- 20:24domestic abuse recorded by the police found that men are
- 20:26significantly more likely to be repeat perpetrators and
- 20:29significantly more likely than women to use physical violence,
- 20:32threats and harassment. In a six year tracking period,
- 20:35the majority of recorded male perpetrators, 83%, had at least
- 20:39two incidents of recorded abuse, with many having a lot more than
- 20:42two and one man having 52 repeat incidents.
- 20:48Whereas in cases where women where women were recorded as the
- 20:50perpetrator of the majority. Whereas in cases where women
- 20:53were recorded as the perpetrators, the majority, 62%,
- 20:57only had one incident of abuse recorded and the highest number
- 21:00of repeat incidents for any female perpetrator was 8.
- 21:03The study also found that men's violence tended to create a
- 21:06context of fear and control, which was not the case when
- 21:09women were perpetrators. So Candace is lying, but what
- 21:12she says next is absolutely insane.
- 21:15In summary, she thinks domestic violence is inevitable in
- 21:18relationships because people are driven by anger, but then goes
- 21:22on to imply that women are more likely to be miserable.
- 21:24If men don't want to be with them or if they have to work,
- 21:27then they would be trapped in an abusive relationship.
- 21:29But yes, absolutely, it makes perfect sense that you are more
- 21:33likely in general when you are in a relationship because people
- 21:36are driven by anger by people that they know, whether or not
- 21:39we're talking about boyfriend and girlfriend, girlfriend and
- 21:42girlfriend, you know, a husband and a wife, a husband and a
- 21:45husband or a wife and a wife. Yes, of course the instances of
- 21:49domestic violence are going to take place when you're inside of
- 21:51a home. But the sexual revolution,
- 21:54encouraging women to give up their goods for free, which is
- 21:57what I'm speaking about, and encouraging men not to marry
- 22:00these women or to have long term relationships.
- 22:02What I am saying is a direct contributor to their
- 22:05unhappiness, because women are giving up their goods for free
- 22:09and women are now entering the workplace, and that does not
- 22:11actually make them happy. As a woman who is currently
- 22:15single and honestly a little bit lonely, but also as a woman who
- 22:18has been a victim of domestic violence, I will happily take
- 22:24not fearing for my life on a daily basis, but occasionally
- 22:26feeling a bit lonely over being back in an abusive relationship
- 22:30any day of the week. And As for work, it does make me
- 22:34happy and we should be allowed to choose to work if we want.
- 22:37If Candace really believes work makes women so miserable, then
- 22:40why does it just stop working herself and be happier?
- 22:43And I'm sorry, but can she please stop calling my sexual
- 22:45experiences my goods? I'm a woman, not an object.
- 22:49I don't have things for sale. My body is not for sale when I
- 22:52choose to be intimate with a partner or not.
- 22:54I'm doing that because I want to share an experience with someone
- 22:56or not. My body, my sexuality, my
- 22:59pleasure is not something which has monetary value, it's not
- 23:01something I'm trading with. I'm not asking you give me this
- 23:04and I'll give you this. The only thing being traded, if
- 23:07you will, is I'd like to make you happy and you make me happy
- 23:09in this moment and we get to know each other.
- 23:11When I have a conversation with a friend, I'm not bargaining or
- 23:14selling or trading or giving something up, am I?
- 23:16I'm enjoying a shared experience of socialising and so are they,
- 23:19and I choose to have a romantic or sexual relationship with
- 23:22someone. I'm choosing to enjoy a shared
- 23:24experience with them and so are they.
- 23:25Nothing more, nothing less. The idea of sex being
- 23:28transactional or something women give or lose as opposed to being
- 23:32a shared experience is nothing but outdated misogynistic
- 23:35nonsense. Meredith Ralston questions this
- 23:38herself when she writes Sex is natural for men.
- 23:41Sex for women is suspect. What is about sex that
- 23:43supposedly sullifies or dirties or makes us or dirties women, or
- 23:48makes us damaged goods? What is it about sex that
- 23:51implies such shame, disgrace and ruin?
- 23:54Women ashamed for their sexuality and not encouraged to
- 23:56explore their bodies or their pleasure.
- 23:59And I have to ask, why is me choosing to have sex with
- 24:01someone seen as me losing or giving up something?
- 24:04But not if that part is a man. Why are they not losing or
- 24:07giving up something? Why can't we use the same
- 24:10argument about men? He gave it up for free so why
- 24:13would I want to be in a relationship with him?
- 24:14I got what I wanted and don't need anything else from him.
- 24:16Right. I'm sure Candace Owens would
- 24:18come out with some nonsense about sex being different for
- 24:21men and women and something about men and women wanting
- 24:23different things from each other, but again, they're just
- 24:25harmful, outdated stereotypes that are unhelpful.
- 24:28Can she not see that every single individual is different
- 24:31and each person wants something different at different times in
- 24:33their life with different people under different circumstances?
- 24:37If I choose being to met with a man at this point in my life,
- 24:39it's because I want to experience that with him,
- 24:42nothing more. It's not a bargaining chip.
- 24:44It's not me losing something. It's not me saying, hey, I'll
- 24:46let you see this part My body if you give me XY and Z in return.
- 24:50It's simply saying, hey, I think you're really damn cool, you're
- 24:52attractive. I want to share this amazing
- 24:54experience with you and get to know you more.
- 24:56That's generally something that makes me feel happy and
- 24:58fulfilled. And I don't see how Candace
- 25:00could look at a woman like me making her own choices, knowing
- 25:03her own values and needs, being safe and responsible, and think,
- 25:06oh, she must be secretly miserable.
- 25:08And I view her as less than me, and that's just wild.
- 25:11That's nothing more than perhaps projection on her part because
- 25:15she can't understand different people wanting different things.
- 25:18Or maybe she's miserable in her own sex life.
- 25:20I don't know. Some of us are comfortable in
- 25:23our bodies, our sexualities, and expressing our needs and wants
- 25:26and desires. And that's absolutely OK.
- 25:29The next person who responded to her had some amazing points and
- 25:31I just want to show you this clip of what they said.
- 25:35I've no critiques here, I just thought it was a good point I
- 25:37wanted you to hear. It, you know, how do we place
- 25:40value on human beings in general?
- 25:42And so when we think about, you know, placing value that comes
- 25:45from a place of power, right? So I think was selected the
- 25:48Victorian era. You have this dominant group of
- 25:51people coming from white supremacy deciding who gets to
- 25:54have a proper status in the world.
- 25:58And so that is already like placed taking human beings and
- 26:01devaluing them. And So what the sexual
- 26:04revolution did was to help people seek out empowerment
- 26:08which increase value no matter the gender.
- 26:11So when it comes to sexual revolution, let's look at one
- 26:13contribution is sex education. And I have absolutely seen the
- 26:17positive outcome with the sexual revolution and sex education and
- 26:20seeing people empower themselves.
- 26:22And with that comes safety when it comes to decreasing STI's,
- 26:27abuse, sexual assault, again, people get to empower themselves
- 26:31of all genders. Yeah, no, no's love this.
- 26:34Good on them. Like I say, I think they brought
- 26:36up some damn good points and Candace, to be honest, barely
- 26:38had anything to say in response of them making a couple of
- 26:40snarky comments about how they're non binary so how can
- 26:43they know? So how can they know about like
- 26:47what makes women happy blah blah blah, even though like literally
- 26:50understanding and teaching feminist theory is part of their
- 26:52job. So of course in and clearly this
- 26:54was transphobia on Candace, this part because I mean, one, it's
- 26:57gross to see and two, she starts the next section like this.
- 27:01Hello, I'm Xena. Xena, very much like your name.
- 27:05Thank you so much, nice to meet. You can we start with the
- 27:06beginning. Do you identify as a female?
- 27:09I identify as a woman, yeah. OK.
- 27:10And three, she didn't ask any of the men this question, she only
- 27:14targeted the one vocally non binary person so.
- 27:18So a woman's worth is tied to her sexuality.
- 27:21It's not, it's not tied to, well, absolutely, if you're
- 27:23going to be having multiple partners, you are going to be
- 27:25devaluing yourself. You're worthless as a human
- 27:28being. Not as a human being, just, you
- 27:30know, in terms of trying to have a partnership in a productive
- 27:32relationship. Certainly men are not going to
- 27:34be clamouring to have a relationship with somebody when
- 27:37there's the market. So I'm growing them.
- 27:40A man's response to your actions is what defines your worth,
- 27:42right? Exactly what I was saying in the
- 27:44beginning. Right and it's ridiculous.
- 27:45If a man is going to dehumanise a woman in this way then surely
- 27:48the problem is with him and not the woman he's judging?
- 27:50This is just something that I keep hearing over and over and
- 27:53it makes no logical sense in my head.
- 27:55I don't understand how you can see someone as being worth less
- 27:58because they enjoy a shared romantic experience.
- 28:01I don't see someone as being worth less than me because they
- 28:03enjoy skiing or eating celery or sharing a bottle of wine with
- 28:06someone. So why would I think less of
- 28:08someone for enjoying sex? I think when it comes to that
- 28:10sort of thing, you can as an individual be like in a partner.
- 28:13I want someone who shares my values and so for example, I'm
- 28:17100% monogamous. I don't want multiple partners.
- 28:20So when I'm looking for a partner, I want to find someone
- 28:22who shares that value who is also monogamous.
- 28:25But that doesn't mean I look down on people who are
- 28:26polyamorous and think they have less value than me and must be
- 28:29miserable. Similarly, I'm allosexual, so I
- 28:32want a partner who is allosexual.
- 28:33That doesn't mean I see asexual people as having any different
- 28:37kind of value to me. It just means all values don't
- 28:40align and we wouldn't make good partners.
- 28:42I just can't get my head around this idea that consensual,
- 28:45harmless behaviour dictates a person's value.
- 28:48Like, surely if someone is lovely enough to have people who
- 28:51want to be with them, would that not imply that they clearly have
- 28:54a value because people want to spend time with them and share a
- 28:57wonderful experience with them Now?
- 28:59I'm not, I'm not crazy. You're right.
- 29:01I guess it all comes back to this idea that woman's sexuality
- 29:03is evil and something to be ashamed of and suppressed and
- 29:07that is such, again, outdated and harmful.
- 29:10Yeah. Well, yeah, I would say that I
- 29:13would argue that at the what makes women actually happy is
- 29:17family. So if you're interrupting.
- 29:20So I'm just to connect the dots for you.
- 29:21When women are having sex with multiple partners, it devalues
- 29:25them for men, right? Yes.
- 29:26So. Men define a woman's worth.
- 29:28Well, I would say both of them kind of define one another's
- 29:30worth because I think the ultimate goal for people to be
- 29:32happy is actually family. Again, I disagree.
- 29:35This may be true for her, but again, if it is, why is she
- 29:39bothering to work when she should be at home with her
- 29:41husband and kids? But it's not true for someone
- 29:44like me. For example, I would not be
- 29:45happy at all if I was forced into having kids because you
- 29:48know, I never want them. And if I was forced into being
- 29:51like a stay at home wife, like I'd be miserable because that's
- 29:53not something I want for myself. But if women do want that, they
- 29:56can still absolutely 100% do it. No one is stopping them.
- 30:01I'm sorry but like no other person should define your value.
- 30:03Only you get to do that for yourself.
- 30:06I know I want a partner who sees my value and appreciates it, not
- 30:09someone who defines it for me. And I think there's a huge
- 30:11difference there. And similarly, I want a partner
- 30:14that I see value in and I can never tell someone else they're
- 30:16worth. That's just controlling and
- 30:18cruel and bordering on being abusive, to be frank.
- 30:20OK. So you're saying in all cases a
- 30:23woman is going to be more fulfilled in regards to family
- 30:26like that's? Exactly what I'm saying.
- 30:27And this is going to work in all cases.
- 30:28You're saying there's no individual case in which a woman
- 30:30can feel, you know, fulfilled without being tied to other
- 30:35people. In the case of.
- 30:37I think there could be an exceptional case for everything.
- 30:40I think there are exceptional cases.
- 30:42And there you go, she admits her exceptions to even what she
- 30:46believes. So surely the solution is to
- 30:48offer the choice to women and not just force them into a role
- 30:51which you know will absolutely not be right for some of them.
- 30:55But I think that if we all start trying to be the exception as
- 30:58opposed to recognising the rule, which is that people in life are
- 31:02more fulfilled when they achieve a family unit and when they have
- 31:06children, women in particular especially having aspiring to
- 31:09children. Again, untrue, and many studies
- 31:12have found that unmarried women without kids are among some of
- 31:14the happiest groups of people. Again, that's something I spoke
- 31:17about in plenty of videos in the past.
- 31:19This clip has a woman saying to Candace that the sexual
- 31:21revolution led to women being objectified less, which has led
- 31:23to a decrease in sexual violence against women, and Candace
- 31:27responds with this. So you think that in today's
- 31:29society, because this is this is pretty wild for me.
- 31:34In the 1950s, you're saying women were more objectified than
- 31:38today. In the land of only fans, the
- 31:41Kardashian clan and women that are essentially putting up their
- 31:45boobs and butts for free on Instagram.
- 31:47You're saying we are now we finally have achieved less
- 31:51objectification where women can't even get onto an
- 31:54advertising. You can't even advertise a bag
- 31:57without them having to be naked in order for them to get a
- 31:59career as a model. You're saying, oh great, we've
- 32:02achieved actually less objectification.
- 32:05So, you know, this is something I actually think is a reasonable
- 32:08point from Candace, I'll give her that.
- 32:10But where I disagree with her is that she's implying the sexual
- 32:13revolution is what directly led to women being overly sexualized
- 32:17and objectified, and that it's feminist fault, not not
- 32:20misogynists. I have a whole lot to say about
- 32:24this. It's damn complicated.
- 32:26OK, first let's look at these claims about sexual violence.
- 32:29I'm not sure if the rates of sexual violence have actually
- 32:32gone down, because it's super hard to track, and obviously
- 32:34there are different rates around the world.
- 32:36I would argue that in many countries, but not all, sexual
- 32:39violence has become less acceptable.
- 32:42Sexual violence against men is taken more seriously than ever
- 32:45and their charity is now helping all victims of sexual violence.
- 32:49Police take reports more serious than seriously than before, but
- 32:52still not seriously enough. Marital rape is now illegal, but
- 32:56as I said, that didn't happen until 1991 in the UK, so it's
- 32:58all fairly recent. Said there are still scarily low
- 33:01conviction rates for perpetrators of sex crimes.
- 33:04Rates of criminal reporting are still way too low.
- 33:07As Sonia Rocher writes in her memoir, Groomed, when you report
- 33:10a sex crime, it often feels like you're the victim that's on
- 33:13trial rather than the accused. She wrote about her experience
- 33:17and how the prosecution questioned every single thing
- 33:19about her, like she was groomed at 15, and they questioned her
- 33:22past, her lifestyle, her relationships.
- 33:24But none of this was done to the man who groomed and raped her
- 33:27when she was just 15. Her private Diaries from that
- 33:30time was seized by the lawyers of her abuser and he had access
- 33:34to them all. He personally read all of her
- 33:36private thoughts from that time. He read all of her recent and
- 33:39past text messages and emails about her feelings on this
- 33:42matter. And she had absolutely no
- 33:43privacy or protection because despite being the victim when
- 33:46she was a child, she felt like she was the one on trial where
- 33:50she didn't get access to any of that from him, she wrote.
- 33:54My case hadn't even hit court yet, but nonetheless I felt a
- 33:57strong pressure to remain silent and a feeling or an
- 34:00understanding the S or abuser was being shielded.
- 34:04Much of the process seemed to be geared around protecting his
- 34:07well-being and his rights. He was presumed innocent, yet
- 34:11should I not be presumed innocent too?
- 34:13Where was my right to justice, to having my case resolved in a
- 34:16timely matter? I'd experienced an extraordinary
- 34:19invasion of privacy. I had to prepare to bear the
- 34:22brunt of humiliating bullying behaviour.
- 34:24Why was his right to silence so much more important than my
- 34:28right to be protected from further trauma?
- 34:30Implicit in all of this was that I brought this upon myself, that
- 34:33I chose to do this and therefore I would have to suffer the
- 34:35process. But I didn't choose to be a
- 34:37victim, and reporting a crime is what a person aware of a crime,
- 34:40victim or not, is meant to do. So was I being silenced?
- 34:45I was certainly allowed to speak.
- 34:46I hadn't signed any Ndas, but I'd entered a system where
- 34:49speaking out came at such an extraordinary emotional cost
- 34:52that staying silent was was a far more attractive option.
- 34:56I handed my diary over to the person who abused me and his
- 34:58legal team. I and I handed over my
- 35:00statement. I handed over other extremely
- 35:02personal pieces of evidence which would be shared amongst
- 35:05God knows who. I had prepared to have my
- 35:07history pulled up and be cross examined on all of this.
- 35:10I had to provide the names and phone numbers of family and
- 35:13friends so they could be called upon to be cross examined about
- 35:15my sexual history. My 15 year old self and my
- 35:19current motivation would be sliced into slivers and placed
- 35:22under the microscope. Every part of me examined and
- 35:25questioned with the aim of undermining me.
- 35:27Him. He was not required at any stage
- 35:30to speak or provide anything he didn't want to provide.
- 35:33In his police interview he was asked the names of his band
- 35:35members, all of whom I'm certain will Remember Me, but he refused
- 35:39to provide their names as was his right.
- 35:42None of this would be allowed to be held against him in court,
- 35:45she goes on to write. Many victims of sexual violence
- 35:47who go through the criminal justice system describe the
- 35:49courtroom process as re traumatising.
- 35:52Some victims say it's more traumatising than the initial
- 35:54abuse. It's not just in the courtroom,
- 35:56though, that the complainant is attacked.
- 35:58The most brutal treatment may come from the public and the
- 36:00media. So really, is any wonder that
- 36:02people don't speak out and seek legal consequences In some ways,
- 36:06sexual violence is still far too normal and too easy to get away
- 36:10with. But that argument aside, let's
- 36:13discuss this idea of women being sexualized today versus the
- 36:151950s. I would actually argue, and this
- 36:17is surprising, that Candice's right to some extent.
- 36:20Women in the media often extremely over sexualized and
- 36:23sometimes have no choice but to commodify their sexuality and
- 36:26their body in order to succeed in certain careers or even just
- 36:30make basic income for themselves.
- 36:31But what Candace misses completely is that there is a
- 36:34huge difference between a woman embracing her own sexuality,
- 36:37owning her sexuality, feeling empowered by her sexuality, and
- 36:41having other people sexualize them against their will.
- 36:44A woman embracing her sexuality is empowering.
- 36:47A woman being sexualized against her will is not.
- 36:50That's harassment. Take another example.
- 36:52A woman who has many options but chooses to do sex work and finds
- 36:55it enjoyable and empowering can be a great thing.
- 36:58But a woman being forced into sex work by someone else or out
- 37:01of monetary necessity when she has no other choice and doesn't
- 37:04want to do it is harmful. These can be two women doing the
- 37:08exact same actions and work, even being paid the same, but to
- 37:13one it's empowering and to the other it's harmful because
- 37:16choice and consent matters. Another example, a woman decides
- 37:20to become a nude model and has men viewing her image sexually,
- 37:23and she may feel empowered by this.
- 37:25But a woman who has her private nude images leaked may also be
- 37:29viewed sexually by men but feel nothing but disgust and by
- 37:32embarrassment, shame and violation.
- 37:34Again, these are technically the same acts, men looking sexually
- 37:37an image of a woman, but what makes it different is choice and
- 37:41consent. So again, we have to look at who
- 37:43is choosing to sexualize these women.
- 37:45Is it the women themselves or is it others forcing it upon them?
- 37:48Whether something is empowering or violating can be complicated,
- 37:52and in some cases an act can be both at the same time.
- 37:55I don't think it's a matter of either it's all OK or none of
- 37:57it's OK as Candace tries to make out.
- 37:59And I'll remind you again, a woman choosing to say I would
- 38:02like to sleep with this person on this occasion does not mean
- 38:05she's consenting to being sexualized by any person at any
- 38:08time. I would agree with Candace that
- 38:10women are absolutely still objectified and sexualized today
- 38:13and that that often happens without the consent of those
- 38:16woman, women or in some cases children involved.
- 38:19And yes, I'm looking at all those disgusting people who
- 38:21count down to when celebrity girls turn 18.
- 38:24You are disgusting. Do better.
- 38:26But again, surely Candace has to realise the objectification
- 38:29comes from men and misogynists and their harmful attitudes
- 38:32towards women, right? It's not feminists doing that.
- 38:36She can't blame feminists for the actions of misogynists.
- 38:39How can she not see that? The next clip is super revealing
- 38:41though in regards to Candace and her mindset.
- 38:44Since 1950s, since the sexual revolution, women have gotten
- 38:48exponentially more freedom and more choice.
- 38:52And for me as a mother and as a woman, having the freedom to
- 38:57choose what I do to make my own destiny makes me infinitely more
- 39:02happy than, say, back before the sexual revolution, when I
- 39:06couldn't get a bank account, couldn't get a home loan,
- 39:09couldn't work outside the home, couldn't travel around without a
- 39:11man, couldn't control my own reproduction.
- 39:15So I feel that happiness, personally.
- 39:17My belief is tied to our ability to have freedom.
- 39:21And I think that in the United States, protecting freedom and
- 39:25our individual freedoms is what's going to lead us to
- 39:28happiness. Did.
- 39:30You go to college. Absolutely.
- 39:31Did you? Yes, I did.
- 39:33So you have a degree. Absolutely.
- 39:34Now, when you went to college, did you go to college because it
- 39:38was simply something that you wanted to do, or did you think
- 39:40that I have to go to college because in order to get a job I
- 39:43have to have a college degree? I went to college for art
- 39:46because I was fascinated with art.
- 39:48OK. Just answering my question, did
- 39:51you go to, was that the only reason I went to college or did
- 39:53you think that I might want to do something in art so I have to
- 39:55go to college like for my career?
- 39:57I went to school because I wanted to expand my horizons.
- 40:01I mean, I think that's why most people go to university.
- 40:04That's actually, that's actually not true.
- 40:06A lot of I, I went and I think a lot of people go because there's
- 40:08a, a pressure that if you don't go to college, you're going to
- 40:11be a failure. The choice.
- 40:12I think the woman speaking to her brings up some fantastic
- 40:15points and Candace's response is simply, well, I never felt like
- 40:18I had a choice of my own life life.
- 40:20And that maybe suggests why she wants to take choice away from
- 40:23other women. Which is really damn sad, isn't
- 40:25it? I just can't wrap my head around
- 40:27a woman feeling powerless in her own life.
- 40:29So her reaction is 1 is to want to make other people feel
- 40:32powerless too? That's just damn cruel.
- 40:35It's like she can't actually fathom what it's like for a
- 40:37woman to actually be making her own choices and being happy
- 40:39about it. And that's really damn sad in a
- 40:42way. It doesn't excuse the harm she's
- 40:44caused to so many people through her work, but it does make me
- 40:47pity her and explain it a bit. Everything's a choice, so OK,
- 40:51taking away choices doesn't make people happier.
- 40:53Taking away I'm actually I'm happy.
- 40:55I'm disagreeing with you on the idea that people are feeling
- 40:58more free by financial pressure. I think financial pressure makes
- 41:01people feel remarkably less free.
- 41:02So you want? No bank accounts.
- 41:04Again, women not to have credit cards.
- 41:05I'm not saying that women shouldn't have access to credit
- 41:08cards or banking accounts. You're putting words in my
- 41:09mouth. So why don't you respond to the
- 41:11words that I'm saying? Well, less financial pressure.
- 41:13If I don't have a bank account, that's a lot less financial
- 41:15pressure, I guess, right? Financial pressure in terms of
- 41:17most people that go to college and I'm I'm counting myself
- 41:21among them. It's because typically in order
- 41:24to get the job that you're being sold is going to make you
- 41:26infinitely happier and infinitely more free.
- 41:28It just requires a college degree and.
- 41:31Yeah, so here she's falling into this trap I see so many
- 41:33conservatives fall into. They have a problem with
- 41:36capitalism because that's what she's talking about here.
- 41:38It's capitalism, but they don't want to admit that it's
- 41:40capitalism, so they blame it on women.
- 41:42Feminism. This happens so damn often.
- 41:44Look at my videos on Ali Beth Stuckey, Rachel Wilson, Lauren
- 41:48Chen, and the guys on the Whatever podcast.
- 41:50It's all the same story. They complain about working and
- 41:53money and pressures, and it's like, OK, so you have an issue
- 41:55with capitalist society exploiting its workers.
- 41:57Yeah. And they're like, oh, no, no,
- 41:59no, no. I'm going to find a way to blame
- 42:01this on women. And it makes no logical sense.
- 42:04And I am saying that financial restraints and debt doesn't make
- 42:08people feel more free. Let's.
- 42:10Eliminate the debt. Let's eliminate colorship.
- 42:12Maybe we should have free college here in the US.
- 42:14That sounds great. Great idea, Candace.
- 42:16I love that idea. OK.
- 42:17Love it. Champion.
- 42:20Champion for the people. Girl very nice.
- 42:25This was actually really funny and I loved how she twisted this
- 42:27back on her. I thought this was brilliant.
- 42:29But also surely Candace realises that there are different kinds
- 42:32of freedom, right? Like how I'd rather be in debt
- 42:34than have no control over my body's sexuality, day-to-day
- 42:37life and reproductive rights. That's an easy choice to me.
- 42:40But again, Candace needs to stop conflating capitalism and
- 42:43feminism. Sure, they're interlinked in
- 42:45some ways, but they're not the same, and you can't blame one
- 42:48group of people for the actions of another.
- 42:51My second claim is that no career will give women as much
- 42:54joy and fulfilment as raising the children.
- 42:57I'm sorry, but do any of us actually need to discuss this?
- 42:59It's ridiculous. As a child free woman, I can
- 43:01tell you that there are a few things in life which will bring
- 43:03me as much pain, pressure, mental turmoil, physical pain
- 43:07and genuine unhappiness as being forced to have children.
- 43:10I do not like children, I don't know how to look after children,
- 43:13I don't want to be around children, I have no desire to
- 43:16have children, and my body is physically not made for carrying
- 43:18children because of my anatomy and my uterus issues.
- 43:22If I got pregnant, it would likely kill me or the baby or
- 43:25cause irreparable harm to my body.
- 43:28How is that supposed to bring me joy?
- 43:30And having children isn't just about you.
- 43:32It also affects your partner, your family, and of course the
- 43:34children you bring into this world.
- 43:37I thoroughly believe that all children brought into this world
- 43:40should be thoroughly wanted, and to force someone to come to this
- 43:43world with parents who don't want them and can't look after
- 43:45them is unfair on every single person involved.
- 43:48Mostly the children. The children that apparently
- 43:51conservatives like Candace, someone care so much about.
- 43:53Except clearly they don't. Again, though, why does she care
- 43:57so much about what other women do with their bodies?
- 43:59She's got her kids and they supposedly make her happy, so
- 44:02why does she care what I or anyone else do with our
- 44:04uteruses? It doesn't affect her at all,
- 44:06does it? But if her kids make her so
- 44:08happy and jobs are so awful, I ask again, why is she working
- 44:12right now? Get back home to your kids and
- 44:14shut up. Like a good little woman is
- 44:16supposed to do, apparently. Unless, of course, you want to
- 44:19admit that women can find happiness in more than one
- 44:21place, and that women should have a choice of how they spend
- 44:24their time, and that women can be mothers and work and do so
- 44:27much more if that's what they choose.
- 44:31Yeah, it's inherent because it's biological.
- 44:33So I think when we think about things that are inherent, I
- 44:35think biology is a good thing to start with, right?
- 44:38Sure, and again, my biology says I'm not made for carrying
- 44:40children, so I guess inherently, despite being a woman, I would
- 44:45not be happier having kids in the job by her logic, right?
- 44:48I do not think that saying women can decide whether or not they
- 44:53want to go to work or have children is problematic.
- 44:56What I'm saying to you is that women will get the most
- 44:58fulfilment from having a family. So she's just twisting things
- 45:02here because she's clearly OK with choice.
- 45:04She's making a choice herself, but she's projecting what may
- 45:08perhaps be her own values onto other women, and that's not OK.
- 45:12What about women who suffer from postpartum depression or
- 45:14postpartum psychosis? Are they happier?
- 45:17What about women who suffer complications during pregnancy
- 45:19and end up with severe scarring, having hysterectomies or other
- 45:23complications? Are they happier?
- 45:25Women who die in childbirth, are they happier?
- 45:28Women who are forced to carry the child of someone who raped
- 45:30or abused them? Children who are forced to birth
- 45:32children as a result of rape? Women who have babies and
- 45:36children who die? What about women who never want
- 45:38a kids who are forced to have them and hate every moment of
- 45:40their lives and regret everything about being a parent?
- 45:43Are they happier? She might say there are these
- 45:46exceptions. And yes, some of these cases are
- 45:48rare, but they're not as rare as they should be.
- 45:51And even if they are rare, they're things we absolutely
- 45:53have to think about. Just because a woman is in a
- 45:55minority, it doesn't mean their opinion doesn't matter.
- 45:58Their experience doesn't matter. It does, and it is just as valid
- 46:02and just as important. Pregnancy and childbirth put an
- 46:05immense strain on a person's body, and it's not something any
- 46:09person should be forced to go into lightly.
- 46:12But it is utter insanity for me to reflect on that and say that
- 46:17I would have rather published Blackout than to have my three
- 46:19children. Well, why is it rather, you see
- 46:21what I'm saying? It's it's it's not rather, I'm
- 46:23just saying. That's your claim.
- 46:25It will it. Will be more fulfilled, yes.
- 46:28She says that for her personally, she'd rather have
- 46:30kids in her book. OK, but I'd rather have written
- 46:33my books than have kids. And I can say that with 100%
- 46:36confidence too, so I don't see why her opinion apparently
- 46:39matters more than mine. And so women who are neglecting
- 46:42that, who are neglecting the pathway to, you know, strive
- 46:45toward family because they think their career is going to hug
- 46:48them at night or they think that when they're on their deathbed,
- 46:50their career is going to come up next to them and say, you were
- 46:54so great to me. Well, sorry, but my career is
- 46:56not going to risk killing me, is it?
- 46:57I'm pretty sure I'd rather be on my deathbed at 90 surrounded by
- 47:00friends, reminisce, reminiscing about all the cool things I've
- 47:02done with my life than on my deathbed at 33 because an
- 47:05unwanted pregnancy is killing me and I'm regretting that I was
- 47:08forced into this choice and now a kid has grow up without a
- 47:11mother even if it survives. And OK, let's take my health
- 47:14issues out of this for a moment. I would much rather regret not
- 47:17having kids because it only hurts myself than risk
- 47:21regretting having kids and damaging that child in the
- 47:23process. Plus, how damn offensive is this
- 47:27to infertile people who do want kids?
- 47:29It's like saying to them, oh sorry mate but you'll never
- 47:31actually have a fulfilled life and you'll only be filled with
- 47:34regrets. You got to deal with it.
- 47:35Which is obviously not true at all.
- 47:38Obviously it can be super hard for people with fertility issues
- 47:40who want kids, but plenty of them go on to have super
- 47:43meaningful and fulfilled and amazing lives, and it's
- 47:45offensive and incorrect to imply that they won't or can't.
- 47:49The thing is though, and this this may be controversial, this
- 47:51is kind of what I was talking about in the beginning.
- 47:54This is kind of why I'm not really a fan of these videos,
- 47:56because in order to be click baity and controversial, people
- 47:59like Candice Owens of whoever's in the middle, including people
- 48:02I generally agree with, have to make big vague blanket
- 48:05statements that are inflammatory.
- 48:07And I don't think these kinds of videos are really helpful or
- 48:09educational to anyone. It's more about oh let's shock
- 48:12people and show various groups ganging up on others to show how
- 48:15certain people are dumb. Like like this claim right that
- 48:18Candace is making it is vague. It's purposefully controversial.
- 48:23But if I said one of my own beliefs in the same format, it
- 48:26would also be full of flaws and problems.
- 48:29So if I said something like my claim is I believe everyone is
- 48:32happier when they have the freedom to make their own
- 48:34choices. Sounds reasonable on the
- 48:36surface. I think a lot of you would agree
- 48:37with me. But even that is filled with so
- 48:39many damn flaws because it doesn't take into account when
- 48:43people make bad choices, irresponsible choices, dangerous
- 48:45choices. A person who chooses to keep
- 48:49taking heroin would arguably less happy and have a low
- 48:52quality of life than a person who is forced into rehab by her
- 48:56family and gets sober and goes on to live a happy life.
- 48:58Right? But then we could also argue
- 49:00that a woman who chooses to go into rehab for herself is
- 49:03happier than than a woman who is forced to go to rehab.
- 49:07So it's all complicated. And of course there's
- 49:09exceptions. There's nuance, it's complex is
- 49:12what I'm trying to say. And even if we account for all
- 49:14this, there might be some people who bring in philosophical
- 49:17arguments about like, well, do we even have free will in the
- 49:191st place? Or is it all an illusion?
- 49:20Is everything predetermined? Like, you know, so obviously my
- 49:24general point would be that the general population is happier
- 49:28when we allow mostly freedom of choice for people over their own
- 49:32bodies and lives and well-being. But of course, law should still
- 49:35be in place to protect people as a whole.
- 49:37And then even then when we start talking about that, it gets
- 49:40complicated again because who decides what should or shouldn't
- 49:44be a personal freedom? Who decides what the laws are?
- 49:46How do we decide how to enforce these?
- 49:48It's so damn complicated. And that's one of the reasons
- 49:51I'm not a fan of this kind of debate format.
- 49:55I know some people love it and can be extremely good at it, and
- 49:57no shame for them, but for me it's just not really enough time
- 50:00to dive into the nuance of an issue and explore it in an
- 50:03interesting or useful way. But that rant aside, let's get
- 50:06back to the video. Have children.
- 50:09I mean, you are actively doing that right now.
- 50:11And I want to be very clear because I'm actively doing it
- 50:13right now. I would be someone that you
- 50:15would call an exception because I get to work from home.
- 50:17I get to wake up in the morning. I don't have a boss, right?
- 50:19I don't have to go into the office from 9:00 to 5:00.
- 50:22I get to then therefore spend the entire morning with my
- 50:25children. OK, but surely you can see that
- 50:26this is not an argument for banning women from the
- 50:29workforce, but instead an argument for allowing parents to
- 50:31have more flexible working hours and conditions, more support and
- 50:36social care. It's not an argument against
- 50:38feminism. Again, it's an argument against
- 50:40capitalism and an argument for social care.
- 50:44And also, sorry, but exceptions do matter too.
- 50:48If we revoke the rights for women that Candace and others
- 50:50want us to revoke, does she not realise that while she might see
- 50:54herself as the exception now, she wouldn't be then.
- 50:56She'd still be banned from working, from earning money,
- 50:59from having her own bank account, from being safe from
- 51:01sexual violence, from having control over her own body and
- 51:04health. She sees that right?
- 51:06It's giving. Not like the other girls but way
- 51:09more short sighted. Taught that being a woman is not
- 51:12enough and that you have to also aspire to be a man.
- 51:14And that's the irony. It's like a psychological
- 51:16conditioning. What feminists went out and did
- 51:18and said is that in order for women to have value, women need
- 51:20to be like men. And I'm saying that actually
- 51:23women and men are biologically different.
- 51:25There are differences in our behaviour.
- 51:27There are differences in our desires.
- 51:29And I think evidence of the feminist movement, by the way,
- 51:31shows us that because even when women enter into the college
- 51:35education, the pathways of career that we choose are
- 51:40different from men because we're biologically different, right?
- 51:43Yeah, I couldn't disagree more. Now, I'm not going to pretend
- 51:45there aren't any biological differences, because of course
- 51:48there are. But I said before, and I'll say
- 51:49again, humans of different sexes are more similar than they are
- 51:53different. Outliers exist, of course, but
- 51:56they're the exceptions, not the rule.
- 51:58And I think we need to look at more factors in just biology
- 52:00when looking at things like career paths, right?
- 52:02I think that's obvious. Look at socialisation, family
- 52:05presses, who? The education and system appeals
- 52:08to. I've spoken before and I think
- 52:11it's my Rachel Wilson book review video about how STEM
- 52:14academic resources are still catering more for young boys
- 52:17than girls, which suggests why maybe more boys choose those
- 52:20fields, even if a lot of the time the girls are outperforming
- 52:23them academically. Kristen Anderson writes about
- 52:26this in her book Modern Misogyny, saying much has been
- 52:29made in the last two decades about getting girls more
- 52:31interested in math and science. Unfortunately, school materials
- 52:34do little to encourage girls interest in these fields.
- 52:37Like most materials, life science textbooks show pictures
- 52:39of males more than females. Males are positioned in active
- 52:42roles more frequently than females, and the accomplishments
- 52:45of women are less likely to be featured.
- 52:47High school chemistry textbooks also show more pictures of males
- 52:50than females. But what about the other claims
- 52:53from Candace? Are women trying to be men?
- 52:56No, they're just being adults. They're just people who do
- 53:00regular things that adult people do.
- 53:03I don't work hard and pay my bills because I want to be a
- 53:05man. I do it because I don't want to
- 53:06be homeless and living on the street.
- 53:08I chose this career particularly not because I thought, oh so
- 53:11many Youtubers, I could be a man You YouTube too.
- 53:15I chose it because I enjoy it. Candace, did you write a book
- 53:19because you wanted to be a man like those male authors?
- 53:23No, you did it because you had something to say.
- 53:24Because that's what people do. This idea of regular women
- 53:28wanting to be a man is what's devaluing, not women having
- 53:31choices in the 1st place. I shouldn't have to give up
- 53:33anything about my femininity in order to be an independent
- 53:36adult. And and to suggest that I do is
- 53:39so damn misogynistic. It's just nonsense.
- 53:43Having success or not having children or I don't know, doing
- 53:46things around the house or whatever.
- 53:47Like DIY doesn't make me or anyone else any less of a woman.
- 53:53And so I think and you keep bringing up the 1950s, which
- 53:56because. It was right before the.
- 53:57Fact. I just don't know if that's the
- 53:58period of time that you want to go back to.
- 54:01No, it's. Just I'm just going back to the
- 54:02first wave of feminism. You want to undo progress that's
- 54:05been done, so I'm curious as to what decade you'd be comfortable
- 54:09living in, especially as a black woman.
- 54:12OK, so we're going to park aside the race politics.
- 54:15So I want to I want to focus on. OK, then, as a woman, what
- 54:19period of time do you want to go back?
- 54:20To I found this bit really interesting because I'm sorry,
- 54:22but this just shows Candace's ignorance.
- 54:25When we're talking about feminist issues, we absolutely
- 54:27just cannot ignore or put aside issues to do with race, just as
- 54:32we can't ignore issues facing trans women, women with
- 54:34disabilities, women of different sexualities, and so many other
- 54:37groups. Understanding that feminism
- 54:40needs to be intersectional is essential to understanding the
- 54:43need for feminism in the 1st place.
- 54:45Raffia Zakari defines white feminism as a white feminist is
- 54:49someone who refuses to consider the role that whiteness and
- 54:52racial privilege attached to it have played and continue to play
- 54:56in universalizing white feminist concerns, agendas and beliefs as
- 55:00being those of all of feminism and all of feminists.
- 55:04You do not have to be white to be a white feminist.
- 55:06It's also perfectly possible to be white and a feminist and not
- 55:10be a white feminist. Term describes a set of
- 55:12assumptions and behaviours which have been baked into mainstream
- 55:15western feminism rather than describing the racial identity
- 55:18of its subjects. And it seems to be, in my view,
- 55:22that Candace Owens in this sense, could almost be described
- 55:25as a white anti feminist in her unwillingness to understand the
- 55:28interconnectedness between race and gender.
- 55:31As Raphael goes on to write, the assumption that women of colour
- 55:34and white women all stand at the same disadvantage, disadvantages
- 55:38against men, is flawed. As Raphael goes on to write, the
- 55:41assumption that women of colour and white women all stand at the
- 55:44same disadvantages against men is flawed.
- 55:47All white women enjoy white racial privilege.
- 55:50Women of colour are affected not simply by gender inequality, but
- 55:54also by racial inequality. And this is something that we
- 55:57absolutely 100% cannot ignore in this discussion.
- 56:01We can't just read it to the side because it's always there.
- 56:04Raffia's book Against White Feminism is an interesting read
- 56:07and if you want to find out more about it, again I've links
- 56:11straight in the video description and all sources to
- 56:13buy it. I have stated before I have a
- 56:15few issues with this book. She has a few issues around
- 56:18shaming sexually active women, misunderstanding asexuality, and
- 56:22there are a few factual inaccuracies about historic
- 56:25events, especially in the UK, which lead to me disagreeing
- 56:28with a few of her conclusions because the facts backing them
- 56:31up are wrong. However, overall it's a good
- 56:34book. I agree with her premise.
- 56:35I think she brings up some damn good points and as a white
- 56:39woman, it's, it's uncomfortable to read as it should be because
- 56:42it's making me question my own experiences, my own thoughts, my
- 56:46own ideologies, how I speak about these topics and I, I
- 56:50think that's really damn important.
- 56:52One of my favourite books on intersectional feminism, though,
- 56:55which I don't have those issues with, is Mickey Kendall's Hood
- 56:57Feminism, Notes from the Women that movement forgot.
- 57:00In that book, she points out that since its inception,
- 57:03mainstream feminism has been insisting that some women have
- 57:05to wait longer for for equality. That once one group, usually
- 57:09white women, achieves equality, then that opens the way for all
- 57:12of the women. But when it comes right down to
- 57:14it, mainstream white feminism often fails to show up for women
- 57:18of colour. When the obstacles you face vary
- 57:21by race and class, then so too do your priorities.
- 57:24After all, for when who's struggling to keep themselves
- 57:27housed, fed and clothed, it's not a question of working hard
- 57:30enough. They're leaning in, but not in
- 57:33search of equal pay or having it all.
- 57:35Their quest for equal pay starts with equal access to education
- 57:38and opportunity. They need feminism to recognise
- 57:41that everything that affects women is a feminist issue,
- 57:44whether it be food insecurity, access to transit, schools, or a
- 57:47living wage. And I can't help but feel like
- 57:49Candace Owens just needs to listen to people like this more.
- 57:51She can't just put race politics aside because everything is
- 57:55connected and it is important here.
- 57:58Next up, I just want to play this clip because it's perfect.
- 58:00Again, no notes. I may get angry I guess, when
- 58:03you mention that someone should have a children or you're trying
- 58:06to impose a lifestyle onto people that you want to live.
- 58:09Which I think is kind of funny because as someone who's anti
- 58:11feminism, you practise it more than most women do.
- 58:15I mean, every time you get on your podcast, every time you
- 58:17collect a cheque, you're practising feminism.
- 58:20OK, that's what you think. No, that's what it is.
- 58:22Because without feminism you wouldn't be able to exist.
- 58:24Yeah, people keep saying I hate when people say that, but it's
- 58:26just the truth shows that you you haven't done the research to
- 58:29even understand where the. Or you don't know history.
- 58:31The only person here who hasn't done the research is Candace
- 58:34Owens herself. For example, Candace talks a lot
- 58:37about wanting to go back to like the 1950s, but does she not
- 58:39realise that as a black woman she would have literally not
- 58:42been allowed to vote then? Leah Goodlow writes of this bit
- 58:45of history. Despite the ratification of the
- 58:4819th Amendment, many women in the United States still could
- 58:51not vote. White primaries, erstwhile
- 58:53literacy tests, and threats of violence blocked hundreds of
- 58:56thousands of Southern black women from casting ballots in 13
- 59:00states. Poll taxes impeded voting for
- 59:02access for poor women of all backgrounds, but any woman there
- 59:05who lacked an independent income found herself vulnerable to
- 59:08disenfranchisement if her husband or father refused to pay
- 59:11the tax. Most Native American women
- 59:13remained ineligible to vote until the 1924 Indian
- 59:18Citizenship Citizenship Act. Both voting rights and women's
- 59:21rights were more fully realised in and around 1965, when the
- 59:26Voting Rights Act established effective federal oversight of
- 59:29elections and forged the strongest protections yet for
- 59:31American voters of all backgrounds.
- 59:35After its passage, African Americans in southern states,
- 59:37the larger group of persons stood no, I thought in Rights in
- 59:39the United States flocked the polls, electing African American
- 59:43candidates to local and state offices and transforming social
- 59:46movements, political parties and policy agendas.
- 59:50So like I say, before 1963, Candace would probably been
- 59:53excluded from this basic right. So the fact that she wants to
- 59:56pretend she can distance herself from feminism and her race and,
- 1:00:00you know, race, politics or whatever she wants, like, it's
- 1:00:02just ignorant. It's completely ignorant.
- 1:00:05Because it means that you don't understand that a bunch of
- 1:00:07government officials in the CIA funded the feminist movement so
- 1:00:11for all. So I'm not going to address this
- 1:00:12bit here, but I will say this comes up a few times in Rachel
- 1:00:16Wilson's book, along with some absolutely wild conspiracy
- 1:00:18theories about feminists being double worshippers and joining
- 1:00:22man murdering cults. So if you're interested, you
- 1:00:24might want to check out that video too.
- 1:00:25It's also linked to the source document.
- 1:00:27But with this, I'm just going to leave this video here for today.
- 1:00:30There's still about an hour of this kind of science debate
- 1:00:32left, but I just wanted to see if any of you guys would be
- 1:00:35interested in watching this before I go ahead and make that.
- 1:00:39I'm trying to stop making my videos quite so long and
- 1:00:41exhausting myself. So if I do make this, I'm going
- 1:00:44to do it in parts. The next parts are wild, though.
- 1:00:46Like I said, she talks about we live in a matriarchy.
- 1:00:48It's just absolutely ridiculous. And so if you want to see that,
- 1:00:51please let me know down in the comments.
- 1:00:54In the meantime, if you like this video, please don't forget
- 1:00:56to give it a like. If you would like to help
- 1:00:58support my work, you can do by either by merch.
- 1:01:00I've got some really cool new designs available.
- 1:01:02I've got my new book, which is actually probably out now as
- 1:01:05you're watching this, which is very exciting.
- 1:01:07I haven't done the announcement video yet, but I think it's
- 1:01:08going to be out at this time, which is fun.
- 1:01:10It is called outside. It is available as a hardback
- 1:01:13physical book or an ebook book. And if you buy the hardback
- 1:01:16because it's a little pricey to print, then you also will get a
- 1:01:19download link to a free audiobook version.
- 1:01:22Or you can just buy the audiobook version on my website
- 1:01:25too. Yeah, OK.
- 1:01:27Right. I think, Oh, you can also spot
- 1:01:29my channel through Patreon, which is really fun.
- 1:01:30And at the higher tiers there you get exclusive stickers and
- 1:01:33art prints and photography prints and cool stuff sent out
- 1:01:36to you. So I really, really love that
- 1:01:37about Patreon. And yeah, that's I think we done
- 1:01:40for today. So thank you so much for your
- 1:01:41time. I appreciate you so much and
- 1:01:43I'll see you guys again soon. Bye.