Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / AI & the Guilds: What's Next?
Transcript
- 0:03It appears we are here. Hello, everybody, whomever
- 0:06is here today. My name is Keith Cooper. I am
- 0:09the vice chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:12Entertainment Law Section in today's panel. is
- 0:17going to be welcome to AI and the guilds. What
- 0:20is next? As a preliminary note, I am struggling
- 0:26with English today. I'm going to mention that
- 0:29we are now, the entertainment law section is
- 0:31now sponsored by Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company.
- 0:34And a couple of things about that is for five
- 0:37decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company has
- 0:40been the only California -based company to continuously
- 0:42provide lawyers throughout the state with professional
- 0:45liability insurance coverage. This is something
- 0:48that they are experts at. Their experience also
- 0:51are complemented by the fact that they are directed
- 0:54by a group of dedicated lawyers. They do offer
- 0:57special rates and competitive premiums for a
- 1:00wide range of insurance practice, a wide range
- 1:03of practices. areas, including entertainment
- 1:05law, and you can see more at lawyersmutual .com.
- 1:09And now I'm going to introduce our speakers today.
- 1:12It is my pleasure to introduce Jonathan Handel.
- 1:16He practices transactional entertainment and
- 1:19technology law at Feed Finkel in Los Angeles.
- 1:22He also practices independently and works as
- 1:25a freelance journalist and media commentator.
- 1:29He has extensive experience representing clients
- 1:32across the entertainment and tech industries.
- 1:35He is the author of several acclaimed books on
- 1:38entertainment, labor relations, and industry
- 1:40dynamics. He's a former professor and research
- 1:44fellow and has been widely recognized for his
- 1:47expertise, commentary, and contributions to both
- 1:50legal and media discourse. Also, is David Sraga
- 1:55Now, before I get into his background, I will
- 1:57mention David is also the secretary of the entertainment
- 2:01law section. He's also a mediator specializing
- 2:04in entertainment media and intellectual property.
- 2:07He has 20 years of legal experience in Los Angeles.
- 2:10His background actually includes working as both
- 2:12an entertainment and IP litigator. He's the former
- 2:15founder of KSW LLP and a senior in -house executive
- 2:20at Miramax, NBC Universal, Universal Pictures.
- 2:25He is also a Yale and USC graduate. He went to
- 2:28USC. I still don't hold it against him. He's
- 2:31still a good guy, nevertheless. He brings deep
- 2:34expertise in, I'm a Bruin. Okay, what can I say?
- 2:37He brings deep expertise across film and television
- 2:40industry. He's negotiated deals with celebrities,
- 2:43rights holders, producers, financiers, distributors,
- 2:45and major streaming platforms. So with that,
- 2:49David, Jonathan, take it away. Thank you. And
- 2:54thank you everybody for being here. My university
- 2:57affiliations weren't mentioned, but I'll simply
- 3:00say that I don't hold against David that he went
- 3:04to Yale. He's done very well for himself as a
- 3:10Gaelic. We can only guess. We can only guess
- 3:13what your alma mater is. We can only guess. We
- 3:16can only guess. I had the opportunity to go back
- 3:19there and talk about the entertainment industry
- 3:22and entertainment law to the students. And I'll
- 3:25just put in a plug to all of you will reach a
- 3:28certain point in your careers that it's very
- 3:30rewarding to go back to whatever your alma mater
- 3:32is and speak to the students about the industry.
- 3:36This is an industry that is very dynamic and
- 3:39very change and changes very quickly as we saw
- 3:41this morning. And David, I think maybe it would
- 3:45make sense for me to start with a few remarks
- 3:47on the Netflix Warner deal from the likely perspective
- 3:52of the guilds. And I'll be clear, I don't speak
- 3:56for any of the guilds, even though I was previously
- 3:57at one point on the legal staff of the Writers
- 4:01Guild and more recently for a couple of years
- 4:04was outside special counsel to SAG -AFTRA. Yeah,
- 4:08certainly. It's been a big day in the industry.
- 4:11And I just also want to say thank you to Keith
- 4:13and to the Beverly Hills Bar for the introduction
- 4:14and the opportunity to participate today. And
- 4:16for our supporters at Lowers Mutual, we also
- 4:18have some fantastic folks over there we work
- 4:20with. I want to say to you also, Jonathan, it's
- 4:23a pleasure to be on this panel with you today
- 4:25and having this conversation. Coming from the
- 4:27studio perspective and having worked in -house
- 4:28for many years, a tremendous aspect of what we
- 4:32do in order to be effective in our deal -making
- 4:34and to get these productions off the ground is
- 4:37working with labor lawyers that we have internally.
- 4:40But there's also some really fantastic folks
- 4:41that we work with in private practice and you
- 4:43are one of them. Obviously, your reputation is
- 4:46stellar. I'm sure many of us have seen you on
- 4:49TV many times as a commentator. community, and
- 4:52you're a real subject matter expert when it comes
- 4:55to this. So I'm happy to have this conversation
- 4:56with you today. And as you mentioned, today has
- 5:00been a big day in the news with the Netflix Warner
- 5:01Brothers deal being announced. The broad strokes
- 5:04being that Netflix is going to acquire the Warner
- 5:06Brothers and HBO Studios, as well as the HBO
- 5:08Max platform for I think $83 billion, I think
- 5:11was the number. And maybe you can talk to us
- 5:15today about what the guilds are going to think
- 5:17of that, since we are here today to speak about
- 5:19guilds. Absolutely. The DGA has already said
- 5:24publicly in a variety of, I believe, deadline
- 5:28reporting, actually. Pardon me if I got that
- 5:30wrong. But what I didn't get wrong is what they
- 5:33said, which is that this deal, quote, raises
- 5:36significant concerns for the DGA. The reason
- 5:40that the DGA is concerned, and that I expect
- 5:42that the Writers Guild and SAG -AFTRA will be
- 5:45concerned, is multi -fold. One is that a reduction
- 5:49in the number of buyers in the community and
- 5:52the industry reduces the opportunities for talent
- 5:58and reduces the leverage of talent and of labor
- 6:02as such. It's going to be very interesting to
- 6:06see how this plays out in the upcoming negotiations.
- 6:09The upcoming negotiations will extend, as we'll
- 6:13talk about in a moment, from early spring through
- 6:18the end of June. The deal, on the other hand,
- 6:23if it passes regulatory scrutiny in the US and
- 6:26the EU, and I expect some stormy waters, frankly,
- 6:30the deal is expected to take 12 to 18 months
- 6:33to close. So there's a slight difference in the
- 6:36timeframes there, but not, you know, not such
- 6:39a great difference when you consider that the
- 6:42deals that are being talked about are most likely
- 6:44three -year deals. Although some folks have raised
- 6:49a question as to whether perhaps the studios
- 6:51might seek a five -year deal in this instance.
- 6:53If so, that would be very, in these negotiations,
- 6:56I should say, that would be very unexpected and
- 6:59unusual. But the reduction in number of buyers,
- 7:02the reduction in leverage, and the bulking up
- 7:06of what is already the largest scripted television
- 7:10channel in the world, and scripted television
- 7:12operation in this business. Uh, and I say scripted
- 7:16because the uh, the largest streaming operation
- 7:19is actually not netflix. It's youtube But of
- 7:22course, most youtube content is not uh, is not
- 7:24scripted. Um Those those factors uh are key to
- 7:32understanding why labor would not be comfortable
- 7:35with uh continued growth and of of netflix non
- 7:40-organic growth acquisition, uh, and also The
- 7:45fact that Netflix is a very pro streaming, not
- 7:49so very interested in theatrical company, whereas
- 7:52Warner Brothers, of course, is both is a streaming
- 7:56operation, yes, and a television operation, yes.
- 8:00And not talking about the television, I'm talking
- 8:01about television production, the cable television
- 8:04networks are not part of this deal. And the deal
- 8:07that goes through would be with would not include
- 8:10the spun off cable networks or to be spun off.
- 8:15But of course, the other thing that Warner Brothers
- 8:17is, is a movie studio, theatrical movie studio.
- 8:21And Netflix, even unlike some of the other streamers,
- 8:24which have been more accommodating to theatrical
- 8:27release, Netflix has been very, you know, pro
- 8:31streaming. Now they've said that they're going
- 8:32to continue to release theatrically through the
- 8:34Warner Brothers. Operation label whatever it
- 8:39becomes if the deal goes through but I expected
- 8:43the gills will have concerns along those lines
- 8:44as well I mean, I think you I think you've hit
- 8:48it on the head there in terms of what the issues
- 8:49are You know, whenever we speak with our friends
- 8:50and the talent representation community in particular
- 8:53They're always very concerned about the trend
- 8:55towards consolidation and vertical integration
- 8:57between the studio and the platform businesses
- 8:59and You get into these competitive bidding situations
- 9:02and things like that when there are fewer doors
- 9:04to knock on and they're fewer bidders the value
- 9:07proposition gets tighter for them on the talent
- 9:09and the author and creator side as well. I think
- 9:12you've also hit an interesting sort of an interesting
- 9:16aspect of just the creative conversation that's
- 9:19going on, particularly when you talk about the
- 9:20DGA and really theatrical filmmaking is really
- 9:24the heart and soul of so many of the DGA members
- 9:28are committed to and believe in. And I think
- 9:31that there has been some interesting reporting
- 9:33in the trades already about sort of some of the
- 9:35commentary from Netflix kind of cutting in both
- 9:37ways about, you know, their commitment to continuing
- 9:40versus, you know, how much they really see the
- 9:43theater going experience as being part of what
- 9:46the future is going to be. So I think it's going
- 9:48to be very interesting to see where the rubber
- 9:49hits the road on this. Well, it's a hard conversation.
- 9:52I had a conversation 15 probably about close
- 9:56to 15 years ago with John Fithian, who at the
- 9:59time was the head of what was called NATO, the
- 10:01National Association of Theater Owners, now Cinema
- 10:04United. I refer to it as the NATO without tanks.
- 10:10And I said to John, I know how many screens there
- 10:13are in the US, and how many are there in China,
- 10:16and how many are there worldwide, cinema screens?
- 10:18And he said, probably 125, 150. thousand. And
- 10:22I pulled my cell phone out of my pocket and said
- 10:24nothing except, how many screens of any sort
- 10:27are there worldwide? And he gave me a very, you
- 10:29know, sort of nasty look and said, look, the
- 10:31theatrical experience will never be replicated
- 10:33by anything else. And maybe so, but the fact
- 10:37of the matter is that, you know, especially younger
- 10:39generations, people are willing to watch all
- 10:42sorts of content on cell phones, on laptops,
- 10:45on PCs, on TV screens that increasingly are 85
- 10:49inches and even on projection screens that are
- 10:52larger and that are cheaper than they ever were
- 10:54before. You know, theatrical killed the live
- 11:00stage star. I mean, live stage was once a thriving
- 11:02business around the country. Now it's a thriving
- 11:04business in New York and London's West End and
- 11:07in touring companies. Everything else is supported
- 11:09by, you know, largely by philanthropy and grants.
- 11:17So what is the future of theatrical, right? Yeah,
- 11:20this is a conversation that's been going on,
- 11:22right? This is a trend. This is a post -COVID
- 11:24trend that the theaters have been dealing with,
- 11:26having worked at Universal Pictures myself. There's
- 11:28some phenomenal people over there who are so
- 11:30dedicated to this experience as well and provide
- 11:32an incredible platform for directors and artists.
- 11:35And it's going to be an interesting conversation
- 11:38to see develop and see what the strategy for
- 11:39the business really looks like. So maybe we should
- 11:43just jump into where we are with today's topic,
- 11:45which is to talk about the upcoming guild negotiations.
- 11:47Here we are. It's the end of 2025. The last deals
- 11:53were closed and we ran through 2023, I should
- 11:56say. So we've got the next round of negotiations
- 11:58coming up and maybe before. You know, we get
- 12:00into sort of the prescriptive quality of this
- 12:03program today to talk about what's next with
- 12:04AI and the gills. Maybe we should set the stage
- 12:06a little bit for what was agreed to last time,
- 12:09provide our audience with some context about
- 12:12what the key aspects were of the deals that were
- 12:14negotiated from 2020 to 2023 time period. Sure,
- 12:20sure. And actually, I realize there's a question
- 12:23and answer that we didn't address, which is questions
- 12:25and answers. Uh, if we have time at the end of
- 12:29the presentation, we will take q and a through
- 12:31the q and a box Uh, that's on the mostly bottom
- 12:35of your screen in uh in zoom If you have a burning
- 12:39question that you want to ask during the presentation
- 12:42Uh, you can ask it at any time and we may or
- 12:44may not get to it until until later in the presentation
- 12:47Yeah, we'll keep an eye on it, but we will we
- 12:49will keep an eye on that and an eagle eye more
- 12:52than likely um 20 so 2023 2023 started in 2022,
- 13:00if I remember correctly. In any case, the DGA
- 13:02went first, as they usually do. And their contract,
- 13:08like the others, didn't expire until the middle
- 13:10of 23. But they like to do deals substantially
- 13:14in advance, or liked to. We'll get to that in
- 13:20a minute. The Reuters Guild went second, as is
- 13:24typical with them. Their contract expired slightly
- 13:27earlier than the others, May 1st rather than
- 13:29June 30th. They negotiated and then struck. SAG
- 13:35-AFTRA then negotiated and struck, as we know.
- 13:40What were the issues? Minimums were, as always,
- 13:43a key issue, but particularly given the inflation
- 13:46that surrounded COVID. Pension and health, which
- 13:49we refer to typically as P and H. Some folks
- 13:52like to say pH and W, with W being pension, health,
- 13:55and welfare. SAG -AFTRA, for example, got an
- 13:59increase in the earnings caps that relate to
- 14:02the pension plan. So only the way the pension
- 14:05and health plans work, and this is important
- 14:06to understand, is that the companies make a contribution
- 14:11that is a percentage of the compensation that
- 14:15the actor, writer, or director is receiving.
- 14:18That percentage varies slightly among guilds
- 14:21and very slightly among contracts within the
- 14:23guild, but right now it's about 21 % for each
- 14:26of them, give or take, in most cases. And the
- 14:32thing is, though, with the unions, particularly
- 14:34with SAG -AFTRA, there's a cap on how much of
- 14:37your earnings the companies make a contribution
- 14:40on. So in the case of SAG -AFTRA, that cap was
- 14:43relatively low and hadn't been increased in over
- 14:4540 years. That meant results in less money paid
- 14:49out by the studios to the pension and health
- 14:52plans or to the pension plan in particular here
- 14:54at SAG in this instance. But it also results
- 14:58in less money being received by the pension and
- 15:01health plans if there's a cap. And The cap got
- 15:06sag after got an increase in the cap which was
- 15:08very much needed for the solvency and you know
- 15:11for the health I should say actually of the of
- 15:14the pension plan residuals are screaming Especially
- 15:18was a was a big a big issue Many of you know
- 15:22that I've done a chart of the residual system
- 15:24residuals depend largely on what medium something
- 15:26is made for and what medium it's now being released
- 15:29in and The so that suggested a grid. I've done
- 15:32a color coded chart that you can see a bit of
- 15:35at jhandle .com slash residuals. But the one
- 15:40cell of that chart has come to be the cell that
- 15:43means the most. And that's the cell where high
- 15:45budget content is made for streaming and plays
- 15:49on the streaming platform that it was released
- 15:51on, either domestically or foreign or both. The
- 15:58DJ got improvements in the streaming residuals
- 16:01formula. And notably, the writer's guild got
- 16:06further improvements in that formula. And SAG
- 16:09-AFTRA got further improvements still. After
- 16:12negotiations were over, a number of months later,
- 16:16the DGA got the benefit of what the other two
- 16:17unions, the increases that the other two unions
- 16:20had gained. They caught up. They were given the
- 16:25benefit of those. of those contractual provisions.
- 16:28That's right. But this was an unusual circumstance,
- 16:31because usually we see what's referred to as
- 16:33pattern bargaining, where the pattern set by
- 16:36the union that goes first, by the DGA in that
- 16:38instance, is the pattern that's accepted by the
- 16:40other two unions. Here, it was almost more like
- 16:42stair -step bargaining, where each of the other
- 16:45two unions built on the preceding one or two
- 16:48unions. We'll come back to that in a minute,
- 16:51very notably. Writers rooms various guaranteed
- 16:56employment issues for writers were were significant
- 16:59Last round I don't think that we're gonna see
- 17:01much change maybe a tweak or two around the margins
- 17:04But I don't think we're gonna see much change
- 17:06in when it comes to writers rooms in in this
- 17:10round and of course as as people know AI issues
- 17:16were huge the there were a multiplicity of issues
- 17:22relating to generative AI, replacing a director
- 17:25with an AI bot, replacing something of an issue.
- 17:31More so was, could generative AI replace screenwriters
- 17:34with AI written scripts? Could generative AI
- 17:38either do digital replicas of existing performers
- 17:41or create completely synthetic performers? And
- 17:44what is the... the fate of the business going
- 17:47to be, the fate of the acting profession, the
- 17:49writing profession in particular going to be.
- 17:52Those issues were very, very highly debated,
- 17:57obviously generated the most headlines. It's
- 18:00much more headline worthy to debate whether the
- 18:04profession is going to exist at all than to debate
- 18:07whether the increase in minimums, which is always
- 18:10a key issue. is going to be 2 .5 % or 3%. Those
- 18:16issues feel more wonky than the AI issues do.
- 18:20It's interesting because I think there's, I think
- 18:23baked into all of what you just described and
- 18:24thank you for that is. The negotiations are really
- 18:28a reflection of the evolution of the business
- 18:29itself in many ways, right? I mean, I think,
- 18:32you know, when it comes to like the pH and W
- 18:35we were talking about, you know, for folks who
- 18:36aren't doing these deals every day, I mean, this
- 18:39is 21 % that the studios pay to the town on top
- 18:42of the fees. So if you're paying somebody $300
- 18:44,000 to write a script, there's another 21 and
- 18:47a half percent on top of that that's being paid
- 18:49by the studio into the fund. You know the cost
- 18:53obviously the cost of an of insurance and health
- 18:56care going up in our economy these days this
- 18:58is sort of a uniquely American issue because
- 19:01of the fact that we have private insurance whereas
- 19:03many of the countries would have other countries
- 19:04that have guilds don't even have this type of
- 19:06consideration because of the presence of socialized
- 19:09government sponsored health care as well and
- 19:12then when you talk about the writers rooms again
- 19:14from the studio perspective you know this is.
- 19:17This is the change in the business where we're
- 19:19seeing a movement away from these, you know,
- 19:2122 episode broadcast shows to streaming shows
- 19:24where you get maybe eight to 10 episodes. And
- 19:26it's really fundamentally shifted the economics
- 19:29of this programming and what writers were being
- 19:31hired to do and how they were able to survive
- 19:33and make their livings. On the residuals front,
- 19:37you know, I think a lot of us probably heard
- 19:38in the news about Suits, you know, and this is
- 19:40a show that sort of had a resurgence on Netflix
- 19:42and it was tremendously popular and some of the
- 19:45talent were coming out and saying, well, we're
- 19:46not seeing... in our paychecks, right? So I think
- 19:48there has been a big push to have the agreements
- 19:50reflect and catch up to the reality of how the
- 19:53business is working. And now AI, I think, is
- 19:55filtering into that in all the ways that you
- 19:57just described as well. So before we get into
- 20:01sort of talking more specifically about the AI
- 20:03issues, and where we're heading into 2026. Maybe
- 20:07you could sort of talk a little bit more about
- 20:08the structural considerations of how this negotiation
- 20:11is gonna go. I know that you have your ear to
- 20:14the ground and lots of folks that you talk to
- 20:15in the industry and some interesting perspectives
- 20:18on how these negotiations might go as we move
- 20:20into this next season. Yeah, the key thing, one
- 20:24of the key things here is in that regard is if
- 20:29you put your ear not to the ground, but to the
- 20:32window and listen, of what you will hear other
- 20:37than traffic and perhaps a few birds chirping
- 20:39is crickets. You will not hear the DGA negotiating
- 20:45right now. You will not hear them pre -negotiating.
- 20:49You will not see any announcements that will
- 20:51have a DGA deal by the end of December, as we
- 20:54often do. And that's because, and this has not
- 20:57been previously reported, the DGA is not going
- 21:00first this time. The DGA, although they ultimately
- 21:04got what the other two unions got in streaming
- 21:09residuals, felt, you know, I'm always a little
- 21:15cautious when I ascribe to other union, you know,
- 21:19to a union what their feelings are. But I'll
- 21:22say from the standpoint of an observer, it seems
- 21:27clear that the DGA is uh was not happy that having
- 21:34been told in the room this is all we can give
- 21:36you on streaming residuals and this is an improvement
- 21:38they did get significant improvements and this
- 21:41is all there is to then discover that the unions
- 21:44that went later the unions that are more boisterous
- 21:47that are a little less restrained in their approach
- 21:50negotiating style and in fact in this last round
- 21:53were significantly less restrained they struck
- 21:56The dja has struck once in its 90 year history
- 21:58and that was for 15 minutes or five minutes some
- 22:01people say Plus another three hours on the other
- 22:04coast because of the time difference. I mean
- 22:05literally um The dja, I think was missed Uh and
- 22:11was not happy to see that having been told this
- 22:15is all we can give that somehow there was more
- 22:18to give And so they're not going first this time.
- 22:20They're going last um The writers guild is still
- 22:24going up against their May 1st expiration deadline.
- 22:28And so that means that SAG -AFTRA is most likely
- 22:31to go first. The likely order here is SAG -AFTRA
- 22:35probably starting in mid -February, negotiating
- 22:37for 30 days or so. The Writers Guild starting
- 22:42in mid -April, negotiating for, you know, again,
- 22:47roughly 30 days. There'll probably be a week
- 22:50or so break between the end of the SAG. negotiations,
- 22:54the beginning of the Riders Guild negotiations.
- 22:56And then the DJ probably mid or late May, in
- 23:00advance of the June 30th deadline. They do not,
- 23:06and what I'm hearing certainly is, they do not
- 23:08want to be in this position again, that they
- 23:10were in last time where they, in effect, had
- 23:14to go back to the studios after those strikes
- 23:19were settled, and say, we want what you gave
- 23:22them. Now, the studios that they were talking
- 23:31to, the AMPTP, the Alliance of Motion Picture
- 23:34and Television Producers, which is actually an
- 23:36alliance of studios and streamers, not really
- 23:39of producers per se, that is the organization
- 23:43that jointly negotiates on behalf of the studios.
- 23:45And it's composed of a president and various
- 23:48staff members. but a small number of people,
- 23:53and the labor VPs from the eight negotiating
- 23:58companies. There are eight companies, the five
- 24:01traditional studios, we still have five right
- 24:03now, and Apple, Amazon, and Netflix, that makes
- 24:09eight. Everyone else, whether you're as big as
- 24:12a Lionsgate, or whether you're a dentist in Chicago
- 24:17who's making a movie, Because you have a ranch
- 24:20and outside of peoria that you can film on and
- 24:22friends who are actors Uh for everyone else if
- 24:25you're making a movie that's under union agreement,
- 24:28uh, it's take it or leave it So it's it's eight
- 24:31companies. They operate by consent on a consensus
- 24:34model very important so if six companies in the
- 24:39amptp are willing to You know take a position
- 24:42they're willing to agree to a particular guild
- 24:45proposal or they have a particular proposal they
- 24:47want to make on foreign streaming, let's say,
- 24:51or whatever. That's not enough. All eight of
- 24:54them have to be on board before they'll agree
- 24:58to something. That makes negotiation difficult.
- 25:02But interestingly, the president, who is the
- 25:04chief negotiator for the studio alliance, has
- 25:08changed. It's no longer Carol Lombardini. She
- 25:13spent a number of decades at the AMPTP. Widely
- 25:17respected. with I'm sorry widely respected for
- 25:21many why widely respected widely respected spent
- 25:24many years as the number two and Was promoted
- 25:27was the number one widely respected? The new
- 25:31leader Greg Hessinger is a name that some people
- 25:34on this and a person that some people on this
- 25:36call know well and that other people Will not
- 25:39recognize but what's interesting about Greg among
- 25:41other things. He's also respected on both sides
- 25:46of the aisle, as it were. Greg, for a number
- 25:49of years, was the national executive director
- 25:52of AFTRA. And for about six or seven months before
- 25:57a political reversal, was the national executive
- 26:01director of SAG. This is obviously before SAG
- 26:04and after Merge, former SAG -AFTRA. So he should
- 26:09have some, you know, particular insights. And
- 26:14we're hoping it will ease the conversation even
- 26:16further with SAG -AFTRA because he's been there
- 26:20and made some of the same arguments and discussions.
- 26:24And the consensus structure, the ANPTP, interacts
- 26:28with the fact that now we have a wide diversity
- 26:31of companies that have to come to a consensus
- 26:34before a deal point is agreed to. So at one point,
- 26:38it was six traditional studios Now it's five
- 26:41studios, some of which have streaming businesses,
- 26:44others of which don't, some of which are in play,
- 26:48others of which aren't, one of which was just
- 26:50acquired, Paramount, you know, go on and on.
- 26:54You go down the list and each of these companies
- 26:56is almost its own animal, and yet somehow they
- 27:00have to come to a consensus. Well yeah you know
- 27:04sort of coming from my background and now as
- 27:06a mediator and a negotiator where you're working
- 27:08with you know diverse parties and you're trying
- 27:09to align their interests to get them to agree
- 27:11these are critical issues. I think there's I
- 27:14think there's a an opportunity here to be optimistic,
- 27:17it sounds like, you know, one of the most important
- 27:19things when you're dealing with diverse parties
- 27:21is, is for them to be able to relate to each
- 27:23other, right? And having been in each other's
- 27:25shoes on things like the Greg Hessinger is somebody
- 27:27who is going to have a perspective, obviously,
- 27:29on what's going on in the other room that hopefully
- 27:31can can be very helpful to building rapport and
- 27:33trust and having these types of conversations.
- 27:36But I think you're again touching on a an industry
- 27:38wide issue here, which is that when you have
- 27:41the AMPTP now composed of companies that have
- 27:43some very different business. models in some
- 27:46senses. Obviously, this came up in the last negotiations
- 27:49when talking about the streaming residuals. A
- 27:51lot easier for the studios, or the traditional
- 27:53studios, distributors, I should say, to not worry
- 27:57as much about that when Netflix and the streaming
- 27:59platforms are the ones who are going to be paying
- 28:01them. But ultimately, they did get it hashed
- 28:04out. And look, it's a great piece of news that
- 28:09you've shared with us today in terms of how we
- 28:10think these negotiations are going to go. Again,
- 28:12from a negotiation perspective, when you have
- 28:14these timing issues to coordinate, it makes things
- 28:18much more complex. That's great. That's great
- 28:21piece of information. Thank you for that. So
- 28:23maybe we should sort of jump into where we are
- 28:26with 2026. I know there's maybe a few big picture
- 28:28non -AI issues just to keep in mind. And then
- 28:31we can maybe turn really the thrust of our attention
- 28:33to where we are with AI. I mean, I know we're
- 28:35always talking about minimums and the pension
- 28:38health plans and residuals. But I think certainly
- 28:40what sounds like the pension health issue is
- 28:42going to be a big one coming up. And I think
- 28:44they probably dovetail with the AI issues as
- 28:47well in terms of some creative solution making.
- 28:50Well, it's you know, all of these issues. I mean,
- 28:53I want to start with minimums minimums is the
- 28:55least sexy issue, but it's 25 it can be 25 %
- 29:00or more According to some sources even 75 % but
- 29:06I've got I got pushback from other sources on
- 29:08that. So I'll have to leave it at big and bulky
- 29:12and under You know and under sexed as it were
- 29:16as far as headlines go The issue with minimums
- 29:22is this. Historically, the guilds get about a
- 29:26point or so above inflation, and inflation is
- 29:30relatively low right now, which suggests that
- 29:33probably the studios would be looking at most
- 29:37to pay about 3 % per year as the increase in
- 29:42minimums. But if you are going out to lunch after
- 29:48this webinar, or if you went to the grocery store
- 29:52earlier in the week and you're eating your brown
- 29:54bag as you watch, you know that it doesn't feel
- 29:58like inflation is low. It feels just incomprehensible.
- 30:01It's that much for that? When did that happen?
- 30:05And we are all still experiencing sticker shock
- 30:09from COVID and post -COVID and now tariff. supply
- 30:16chain disruptions and commerce disruptions. And
- 30:20now COVID was, you know, five years ago, that
- 30:26was before the 2023 negotiations. But those negotiations,
- 30:32although SAG -AFTRA got some increases that were
- 30:37higher than expected, those negotiations did
- 30:39not fully make up for, you know, the back to
- 30:42back nine and eight and a half percent. annual
- 30:46inflation rate that we saw during COVID. And
- 30:49so people are still really suffering from that
- 30:53when it comes to housing prices. And again, actors,
- 30:57for example, I mean, really the whole industry,
- 31:01the largest part of it, obviously Atlanta has
- 31:04become very big, but the largest part of it lives
- 31:06in LA and New York, which are two of the three
- 31:08most expensive cities in the country. So minimums.
- 31:12definitely an issue. There's an interaction with
- 31:15P &H, which is that the P &H contribution, that
- 31:1921%, for example, the way that gets, if it goes
- 31:23up to 21 .5%, let's say, or 22 % in the next
- 31:26round, the way that gets funded is that, let's
- 31:31say the studios and the unions agree to three,
- 31:33three and three for each of the three years of
- 31:35the agreement for the basic wage increases. And
- 31:39then one of the union says, we need to increase
- 31:41our P &H funding a bit. Well, they'll divert
- 31:440 .5 % of the increase in one of those years,
- 31:49typically the first or second year, to P &H.
- 31:52And so the actual increase in minimums might
- 31:54be, for one union, might be 333. And for another
- 31:57union, might be 2 .533. For another, might even
- 32:02be 2 .5, 2 .53. And that gets us into the PNH
- 32:09issue. Specifically, as Variety has reported,
- 32:14several days, just several days ago, earlier
- 32:15this week, I think, the Writers Guild health
- 32:19plan is particularly stressed. The health plan
- 32:23is in poor financial straits. And that, there
- 32:32are multiple ways of addressing that. One of
- 32:34them is increasing the contribution to the health
- 32:39plan. Now, you'll remember I said P and H right
- 32:41now is typically at about 21%. Well, P and H
- 32:47are dating, but they're not married. They keep
- 32:51separate bank accounts. P gets money and H gets
- 32:54money. So how much that 21 % goes to pension?
- 32:57How much goes to health? Well, it depends on
- 33:00the guild, depends on the union. Different unions
- 33:03have different Financial requirements for the
- 33:07pension plan and for the health plan different
- 33:10pension plans and different health plans are
- 33:11in different financial Circumstances right now
- 33:14and Plus if you add for that reason if you ask
- 33:17me that question today and I looked up the answer
- 33:20if you had asked me that question ten years ago
- 33:23or five years ago or three years ago or 15 years
- 33:26ago the answer is different every year the distribution
- 33:30can change even between even during the space
- 33:33of a three -year contract because the overall
- 33:35amount being contributed, you know, stays the
- 33:38same subject to, you know, permissive diversion
- 33:42of 0 .5 % or whatever is agreed upon. There are
- 33:46a lot of levers in the health plan to deal with.
- 33:50A lot of them are levers that you're familiar
- 33:53with, even if you're not an actor, writer or
- 33:56director, but instead get health insurance from
- 33:59your employer or even from a university. What
- 34:03are those levers? Um, what are the first of all,
- 34:06one of them is one of the benefits We don't pay
- 34:08for x we do pay for x What are the co -pays co
- 34:12-insurance and deductible? How much is your deductible?
- 34:15And once you've met your deductible, we the plan
- 34:17will pay for things that we do cover 80 No, we'll
- 34:21pay 70. No, we'll pay 75 40 of visits to see
- 34:27the doctor used to be 25 used to be 15 might
- 34:29be 50 in your plan Um out of network coverage
- 34:33if you're not with a doctor with a covered doctor.
- 34:35Do we pay at all? Do we pay 60 50 percent 35?
- 34:40Um Do we pay do we cover vision? Do we cover
- 34:43dental? But unique to union health plans in an
- 34:47industry where people don't work full time There
- 34:51are there is One other lever that is very controversial
- 34:56Very the adjustment is very controversial and
- 34:59yet is very fundamental. And that is qualification
- 35:02levels. So if you work for Google, if you work
- 35:07for, you know, ING bank, if you work for some
- 35:12insurance company, if you work for whoever you
- 35:14work for, typical job, you work for a studio
- 35:17as an exec or as a staffer. As long typically
- 35:21as long as you work 20 hours a week. It's the
- 35:24same as if you work 40 hours a week or 50 hours
- 35:27a week, you're entitled to whatever insurance
- 35:29they offer their employees. That's how qualification
- 35:34works. But how does that work for actors, writers,
- 35:38and directors? Actors, if I work 20 hours a week,
- 35:41I don't have a job job. What are you talking
- 35:43about? I'm an actor or I'm a director or a writer.
- 35:47There it's based on total amount of covered income
- 35:51you made in the year or in four quarters. not
- 35:55to get too deep into the weeds, but let's call
- 35:57it in a year. And the amount differs on different
- 36:00guilds, but if you don't make, if you fall $100
- 36:03short of the qualifying level, yes, the company
- 36:07made contributions on your behalf. Let's say
- 36:09the qualifying level is 40 ,000 and you made
- 36:1239 ,000 that year. Well, 21 % of 39 ,000 is $7
- 36:19,900 roughly. The companies that you work for
- 36:23during the year contributed $7 ,900 to the pension
- 36:27and health plan of your guild because of that
- 36:29work that you did. But you don't get any health
- 36:32insurance at all because you didn't meet the
- 36:34$40 ,000 qualified. Basically, you've got to
- 36:36earn it out every year in order to maintain your
- 36:38coverage. It's actually every four quarters and
- 36:41then there's a quarter that's playing and then
- 36:42a very complicated sort of thing. But basically,
- 36:45the easiest way to think of it is, yeah, if you
- 36:47didn't earn that level, In the year, then you're
- 36:52not going to get coverage the next year and you
- 36:54might be entitled to buy Cobra coverage and you're
- 36:57certainly entitled to go on to the You know Obamacare
- 37:01the ACA health exchanges outside of the guild
- 37:04system altogether, but you're not gonna get killed
- 37:06health insurance And that's the way all three
- 37:09of the above -the -line guilds Work and the IOTC
- 37:13is it's similar. It's slightly different on so
- 37:17Here's the thing. Why have a coverage level at
- 37:19all? Why have a qualifying level? Why you set
- 37:21it at $5 ,000? So if you're acting enough that
- 37:25you're in $5 ,000 in this business, you know,
- 37:27maybe that's not, maybe $10 ,000, whatever. Someone
- 37:30that got a connection to the business. Why not
- 37:32set it there? Well, the trouble is if you set
- 37:36it at that low level, you haven't changed the
- 37:38amount of money flowing into the plan. because
- 37:42no matter what level of income you make in that
- 37:45year, 10 ,000 or 40, 39 ,000, whatever, that
- 37:4921 % applies. So the amount of money flowing
- 37:51in the plan doesn't change, but now you have
- 37:53more people eligible and you say, well, that's
- 37:55great. More people eligible, they get health
- 37:56insurance. Well, health insurance doesn't come
- 37:58from the tooth fairy or by magic. It comes from
- 38:01the money that primarily the money that the companies
- 38:04are paying that year. There's also some investment
- 38:07income. So how are we going to accommodate this
- 38:10sudden influx of new people? Well, I guess we
- 38:14have to cut benefits. Wait a minute. I work in
- 38:17this business a lot. He only works $10 ,000 a
- 38:20year. That's scarcely anything. They're scarcely
- 38:22an actor. But I make $100 ,000 a year in this
- 38:26business, and now you're cutting my benefits
- 38:28again? And you're trying to tell the companies
- 38:32that we've got to raise that 21 % to 22%. So
- 38:36no, you've got to keep that qualification level
- 38:38up. But if you keep it up, you have a lot of
- 38:40union members who are unhappy because they don't
- 38:42qualify. So it's a it's a very very Explosive
- 38:48lever it's it's explosive. It's a thorny issue.
- 38:51I mean You know again, I think based into what
- 38:53you're saying. It's a lot of things that are
- 38:55going on that in many ways tie back to ai, right
- 38:58because what we're talking about is you don't
- 39:01have to go that far to see the people are having
- 39:03a hard time out there in the creative community,
- 39:05right? I mean, we all hear about the big money
- 39:07people at the top of the heap of these big deals,
- 39:10but I go to pick up my kid from school and the
- 39:13other parents are writers who haven't worked
- 39:16for a year. These are really talented folks who
- 39:17have worked on fantastic shows and they're trying
- 39:20to write spec scripts and they're struggling
- 39:22to find these new opportunities. So they're not
- 39:25getting paid, costs are going up. The funds are
- 39:30dealing with this potential insolvency problem,
- 39:32if there's not enough money coming in. The amount
- 39:35of production has gone down in the business post
- 39:38-COVID, right, and the strikes. And for actors
- 39:42in particular, and crew, the amount of business
- 39:44in LA has gone down even further than the shrinking
- 39:47of the overall pie. Right, so that's gone down.
- 39:50Obviously, there's some new legislation in California
- 39:52with tax credits that's designed to... Thinking
- 39:53is having an effect. It's helping, yeah. Well,
- 39:56that'll help, right? We'll see some good news
- 39:58on that. But people are getting pinched who are
- 40:01actually doing the work. The studios themselves
- 40:03feel like they're under pressure, right? I mean,
- 40:06the streamers - They're all getting bought by
- 40:07tech companies. Yeah, the streamers aren't ordering
- 40:09as many shows. They're making more shows themselves.
- 40:12They're acquiring companies like Warner Brothers,
- 40:15right? They're all under pressure from Wall Street
- 40:19to generate profits. So it feels like the margins
- 40:21are getting tighter. And where's this money going
- 40:24to come from? And now we have this conversation
- 40:26about replacing talent with AI. And so you can
- 40:29imagine why it's such an important issue for
- 40:33the actors maybe more than the directors the
- 40:34last time around, the writers maybe more than
- 40:36the directors last time around to strike over
- 40:38because for them it's a different kind of threat
- 40:41in terms of replacement of their images and replacement
- 40:43of their written work. I think it all converges
- 40:47and now we're talking about these plans. It used
- 40:50to be a thing where you get your SAG card and
- 40:52then you can get benefits, but somebody's got
- 40:54to pay for that is what you're saying. These
- 40:56plans are getting more expensive and the money's
- 40:58going to come from somewhere. These are existential
- 41:02issues for the guilds and for their membership
- 41:04that I think have to be addressed and these are
- 41:06complex. It comes back to, from the mediator's
- 41:10perspective, we need to talk about a way to to
- 41:15make the pie bigger for everyone so that we can
- 41:17solve these problems collaboratively. This is
- 41:19something Ken Zifron talked about recently when
- 41:21he spoke to the Beverly Hills Bar about this
- 41:24issue. And look, there's a fundamental interdependence
- 41:27between the studios, the AMP, PTP, the streamers,
- 41:31the guilds, the talent, relying on each other,
- 41:34right? So there has to be a collaborative solution
- 41:36-making approach to this, I think, in order to
- 41:39work through these things. there does, but getting
- 41:41people to pay more for entertainment product
- 41:44and more people to watch professional entertainment
- 41:46product rather than, you know, kitty cats on
- 41:49parade is, uh, you know, and what, and I mean,
- 41:53the era where people were the only way to watch
- 41:56a movie was to pay the, you know, what in today's
- 41:59dollars is 20, $25 for a ticket. Uh, you know,
- 42:02that, that era disappeared with rental VHS, with
- 42:06purchased DVDs, with purchased Blu -ray and You
- 42:10know now with with straining where that a little
- 42:13less than that $20, you know $19 gets you the
- 42:16entire netflix catalog for a month. Um, you know,
- 42:19there's no there's no going back to an era that
- 42:24uh this industry through scarcity enforced by
- 42:28technological limitations and copyright restrictions
- 42:31uh created business models that were you know,
- 42:35very very lucrative and for a wide range of people
- 42:39and we're not going back to the euro. I do want
- 42:42to say, since you mentioned the S word, I don't
- 42:44think we're going to see strike this by anybody,
- 42:49this negotiating round. This is just too... First
- 42:53of all, it's very rare that the guilds would
- 42:56strike two cycles in a row. What's typical is
- 43:00three to four cycles go by as they did. We had
- 43:03strike in 2007, then in 23, that's... you know,
- 43:06three, three, four cycles, whatever it is. We
- 43:10had the last Hollywood strike before that was
- 43:131988. There was a commercial strike sag commercial
- 43:17strike in 2000. But in terms of Hollywood, it
- 43:20was 20 again, 20 years, you know, four, four,
- 43:24maybe even five cycles. There were multiple sequential
- 43:27strikes in the 80s. But that's that was unusual.
- 43:31I want to mention pension levers. briefly. And
- 43:37then another bit of news. Pension levers. The
- 43:43pension plans are funded through long -term investments
- 43:46as well as the contributions that are made in
- 43:50any given year. And so the health of the stock
- 43:54market and these are stocks and bonds and alternative
- 43:57investments and so forth. The savvy of the professional
- 44:03investors. all of that make a difference. The
- 44:06levers include things like the pension contribution
- 44:10rate, the caps, the actuarial assumptions you
- 44:13make on what the future is going to look like,
- 44:16and the so -called accrual rate, which is a complicated
- 44:20actuarial variable that basically controls how
- 44:26rich a pension is going to be, how robust a pension
- 44:31is going to be. for a given level of income.
- 44:34Pensions are very different, by the way, from
- 44:36IRAs and 401ks. I'll leave it to you to, you
- 44:40know, if you're not familiar with those differences,
- 44:42to Google, because they work in extremely different
- 44:45ways, but ways that are very complex. Now, because
- 44:49of that complexity, it's very hard to merge pension
- 44:54plans. SAG and AFRA merged, the unions merged
- 44:57in 2012. Their television contracts, which was
- 45:01where they overlapped, merged in 2014, took two
- 45:05years. And the next cycle for their television
- 45:09contract, for there to be a merger of the contracts.
- 45:12The health plans of the two unions didn't merge
- 45:16until 2017, a date that I actually first reported
- 45:20as an exclusive in the Hollywood Reporter when
- 45:23I was writing for them. And that was five years.
- 45:26four and a half, five years after the merger
- 45:29of the unions. But the pension plans, the SAG
- 45:32pension plan and the after retirement plan have
- 45:35not merged. It began to look like there was going
- 45:40to be no movement towards merger at all. And
- 45:44that is largely because the mathematical, actuarial,
- 45:50statistical and economic way That pan the retirement
- 45:56plans pension plans are structured is so complex
- 46:00that you can't just go on the money together
- 46:02and say well This one had twice the money of
- 46:05this one. So this one gets twice the benefits
- 46:07and it does not Arisa issues, right really that's
- 46:10not even to get to the legal issues under Arisa.
- 46:13That's right just the mathematical issues of
- 46:17What would it mean to merge? You know to retirement
- 46:21plans however However, what I can report is a
- 46:28step in this direction. Again, this has not been
- 46:30previously reported. The plans are composed of,
- 46:36a pension plan conceptually is composed of two
- 46:41things. It's composed of a big bank account,
- 46:43so to speak, a big brokerage account really,
- 46:46with lots of investments. And it's composed of
- 46:49a staff that do a lot of things. like run computer
- 46:53models, send out checks or electronic payments,
- 46:58govern the thing, do accounting, do HR. Well,
- 47:03why can't you merge those things, those back
- 47:06office functions? Actually, you can. And the
- 47:10trustees of the SAG pension plan and of the AFTRA
- 47:14retirement fund are currently at work. towards
- 47:20finding a way to merge the two plans together,
- 47:25even still having to maintain separate brokerage
- 47:27accounts. So it's a very slow process. I mean,
- 47:30it's been 13 years since the unions merged, almost
- 47:3514 years, but this has not been previously been
- 47:40reported. The trustees are working on merging
- 47:42and that merger would of course would reduce.
- 47:45uh like any consult corporate consolidation is
- 47:48intended to reduce operating costs and reducing
- 47:51operating costs on a pension plan are certainly
- 47:54you know certainly a good thing at least more
- 47:56money for benefits sounds like it'll be helpful
- 47:58right right excellent excellent well thank you
- 48:01for that another really fantastic uh tidbit from
- 48:04you here today on that um So maybe we've got
- 48:09about, I think, 10 minutes or so, 15 minutes
- 48:11or so left. And maybe we could just jump into
- 48:13what we're looking at as we move into the next
- 48:15round with some of these AI issues for the various
- 48:18agreements. I thought maybe we would just jump
- 48:20into the performer agreements. Sure. And maybe
- 48:25if it would be helpful, we could talk about what
- 48:27was agreed last time. Maybe I could run through
- 48:29some of the high level points in terms of what
- 48:31was agreed to last time. And I think what's really
- 48:34interesting is to hear your perspective on what's
- 48:37been agreed to since then in terms of some of
- 48:38these other agreements that are out there as
- 48:40predictors for what we may be dealing with. Right.
- 48:43Before we do that, I want to simply say on residuals,
- 48:47I would expect some incremental improvement in
- 48:49streaming residuals, but no huge changes. And
- 48:53there are guild -specific issues for each of
- 48:55these guilds. You know, what about stunt performance,
- 48:57what about stunt, et cetera, et cetera. There
- 49:00will be a whole bunch of issues to be negotiated,
- 49:04especially for SAG -AFTRA. But let's move on
- 49:06to AI. Sounds good. So the last time around,
- 49:09in terms of the performer agreements, what were
- 49:11some of the top level things that were agreed
- 49:13to? The most important thing was that for employment
- 49:16-based digital replicas, if you hire a performer
- 49:18to be in a film or a television series, and you're
- 49:21going to create a digital replica of this actor,
- 49:24you are only allowed to do that with clear and
- 49:26conspicuous consent in a written contract. And
- 49:30compensation. And compensation, exactly right.
- 49:35And the studio has really responded to this.
- 49:36The contracts look different as a result of this.
- 49:38There's new practices that are in place. It has
- 49:40to be used in the same production. And if you
- 49:43wanted to use that digital replica in a different
- 49:44production, consent and separate bargaining for
- 49:48separate compensation was required. It couldn't
- 49:50be pre -obtained unless it was part of a multi
- 49:52-series or multi -film kind of deal. When it
- 49:56came to things that were independently created
- 49:58digital replicas, where you're creating a digital
- 50:01replica that looks like a real performer, but
- 50:02not actually imaging them and taking their photo
- 50:04in order to create that, the agreement provided
- 50:07that they had to obtain clear and conspicuous
- 50:09consent, again, in a signed writing prior to
- 50:11the exploitation, with a reasonably specific
- 50:14description of how you intended to use that independently
- 50:18created replica. When it came to digital alterations
- 50:22of those replicas and of images of performers,
- 50:25Once again, clear and conspicuous consent was
- 50:28required along with reasonable specificity of
- 50:31what you're going to do. There were some important
- 50:33exceptions that were sort of a continuation of
- 50:35how the business was already working. You know,
- 50:37if you're going to use it for dubbing purposes
- 50:39or to do visual face alterations, mouth alterations
- 50:44for things like that. alterations in post, a
- 50:47continuation of currently existing technologies.
- 50:50That's not what we're really talking about. Then
- 50:53we get into this really interesting area of synthetic
- 50:55performers. We've heard a lot about this recently
- 50:56in the news with like the Tilly Norwood type
- 50:58performer that's been announced. It kind of breaks
- 51:02into two different distinctions. One, if it's
- 51:03based on someone real. Again, you have to get
- 51:06their consent and bargain if you want to create
- 51:08something that looks like Tom Cruise, let's say,
- 51:10is the most extreme example. when it came to
- 51:16synthetic performers based on someone who's not
- 51:19real, it was kind of kicked down the road a little
- 51:22bit, the issue of how are we gonna deal with
- 51:24this? And what was agreed to was you had to give,
- 51:27a producer had to give SAG after a notice and
- 51:29an opportunity to bargain in good faith about
- 51:32using that performer in place of a real person
- 51:35in a human role. The big loophole is it doesn't
- 51:39apply to non -human roles, right? Aliens, robots,
- 51:42things like that. But there's some overlap, right?
- 51:44Because oftentimes humans are being used in those
- 51:46roles, those motion captures. So there's some
- 51:49gray areas there. But that's sort of where things
- 51:51were left. And we do see this sort of coming
- 51:53into the conversation now about these synthetic
- 51:56performers. And so. Maybe Jonathan, you can speak
- 51:59to us about what's been agreed to since then,
- 52:01because there's been like a verticals agreement,
- 52:03a commercials agreement. I think they may sort
- 52:05of help us read the tea leaves on where this
- 52:07is going, especially when it comes to use of
- 52:09synthetic performers. Well, that's exactly right.
- 52:12One of the secrets about SAG -AFTRA that's not
- 52:17so secret is that the TV theatrical contract
- 52:21every three years is not their only agreement.
- 52:23And we've had a number of other agreements, of
- 52:26which the two that you mentioned. provide interesting
- 52:30bits of background. I'll start with the commercials
- 52:34agreement. Synthetic performers cannot be used
- 52:39primarily or materially, to quote the language,
- 52:43for reasons of economy. If there's an actor available,
- 52:48but if they can't find the right look, they can
- 52:52use a synthetic performer. And if they violate
- 52:56this, They have to pay the equivalent of what
- 52:58a human performer would have been paid, both
- 53:01session fees and use fees, residuals, into the
- 53:06P &H fund, interestingly, since there isn't an
- 53:08actor to pay it to, because by definition, there
- 53:12isn't an actor that violated the provision. So
- 53:15that is a creative area where you say, OK, what
- 53:19are we going to do with this? Well, now, you
- 53:22might say, oh, so the union got into the P &H.
- 53:24Well, wait a minute. Remember, the companies
- 53:28make contributions to the P &H fund, the 21 %
- 53:32that I was talking about. So by having the companies
- 53:35pay this penalty, but they don't pay it to the
- 53:39union, so the union gets fat and happy and the
- 53:41companies say, we don't want to make the union
- 53:42fat and happy. It goes into the P &H fund, which
- 53:45then reduces pressure on the companies the next
- 53:48round. um to increase contributions increase
- 53:51that 21 to 22 or whatever it might be so it's
- 53:55a very creative solution the money goes to a
- 53:58place where both labor and management get benefit
- 54:02uh and by the way these funds are governed 50
- 54:0550 by boards of trustees that are 50 50 labor
- 54:07and management but i mean this all ties back
- 54:09to what you've been talking about for us during
- 54:11this entire seminar which is that there's so
- 54:13much pressure on On these funds because of the
- 54:17reduction in production and the and the increase
- 54:19in health costs and the stock market Now we have
- 54:23this convergence because now we have this concern
- 54:26about well, you're you're you're effectively
- 54:27using synthetic performers instead of hiring
- 54:29real people It's not a perfect solution, right?
- 54:32Because in theory, the unions still want a real
- 54:34person to be hired, right? But I mean, they're
- 54:36sort of trying to thread the needle here. And
- 54:39the solution is, at least we can take that money
- 54:41and put it into the fund that's going to support
- 54:43solvency and providing health and welfare to
- 54:46these actual real people who aren't given the
- 54:49opportunity to do the work and pay it to themselves.
- 54:51Not a perfect solution, but a creative one, I
- 54:53think, that balances those tensions. That's right.
- 54:56Now, what was also, and there were some other
- 54:58you know, if they're using it, not just to save
- 55:01money and so on and so forth, we don't want to
- 55:02get lost in the weeds. But training data was
- 55:04the other interesting thing that was kicked down,
- 55:07that can was kicked down the road before. But
- 55:11here the results and proceeds of covered services
- 55:13cannot be used to train generative AI systems
- 55:16without union consent. So that is the beginning
- 55:21of the union saying that you can't use, you know,
- 55:27covered work. for, you know, as training data.
- 55:30Now, what about in an area of scripted production,
- 55:33verticals, the verticals agreement, these are
- 55:35micro dramas that are that play vertically on
- 55:37your, on your cell phone. And that are, you know,
- 55:42two, three minutes each and become a huge business
- 55:46in China and becoming a big business here. The
- 55:50verticals agreement is interesting because it's
- 55:52a promulgated agreement. In other words, it's
- 55:54an agreement that SAG -AFTRA drafted itself and
- 55:56didn't negotiate with any studio or company or
- 55:59producer. So it shows us what the union wants
- 56:03and what the union thinks it can get that still
- 56:06that the union feels is still reasonable, but
- 56:09without the constraint of you got to persuade
- 56:11the other side or consensus of the other side
- 56:13to agree to. As far as synthetic performers go,
- 56:19producer can't use a fully synthetic performer
- 56:22in place of a performer who would have been engaged
- 56:24in a human role without first getting bargaining
- 56:27and getting the consent of the union. So it's
- 56:30just absolutely prohibited. The union would presumably
- 56:35want payment, probably somewhat along the lines
- 56:38of what we saw in the commercials agreement.
- 56:41Digital replicas, all copies of digital replicas
- 56:43have to be deleted within 90 days of the final
- 56:47edit. And they have to take commercially reasonable
- 56:50steps to ensure the security, the data security
- 56:53of any digital replica. And in training data,
- 56:58no content, audio or video, can be used for machine
- 57:01learning, including model creation. Period. Full
- 57:03stop. End of story. So here's where we're seeing
- 57:06an evolution of the guild's position from what
- 57:09we have to have a good faith conversation about
- 57:11it to you can't do it without our consent when
- 57:13it comes to using these synthetic performers.
- 57:15And obviously this is an issue that's gonna run
- 57:17through the other agreements as well because
- 57:19there's a creative issue here. I mean, we've
- 57:20all seen Guillermo del Toro accepting awards
- 57:23for the latest Frankenstein film and talking
- 57:26about how he feels about not wanting to use AI.
- 57:28And there's, I think a lot of these things with
- 57:30directors and things that get worked out at the
- 57:31relationship level, right? But I think as a fundamental
- 57:33matter, writers, you know, do actors want to
- 57:37even be in these performances and in these projects
- 57:40if other synthetic actors are going to be used,
- 57:42right? There's a lot of pushback on this Tilly
- 57:45Norwood story, obviously, from a lot of performers.
- 57:47I think that's a really interesting evolution
- 57:49that we've seen in their position. I think that
- 57:52the training data issue is one that is fantastically
- 57:56interesting as well, that's going to weave through
- 57:57each of these negotiations very clearly. I mean,
- 58:01we see all these students going on right now
- 58:02about training data. And let me mention something
- 58:06particularly interesting about Training Data
- 58:08and the Writers Guild. The other two unions,
- 58:11the directors and the actors, if film footage,
- 58:16TV footage, whatever, is reused, they get a residual.
- 58:20With the writers, if film footage that they wrote
- 58:23gets reused, they get a residual. But there's
- 58:25a different kind of residual that's not called
- 58:27a residual that the writers also get. Because
- 58:30the writers actually oversee two kinds of things
- 58:34that can get reused, not just the ultimate footage,
- 58:37but the writers also contributed to something
- 58:39that we call a screenplay or a teleplay that
- 58:41the footage was then based on. What if a screenplay
- 58:45gets reused to make a stage play or to make a
- 58:49remake or to make a sequel? Well, in many circumstances,
- 58:55or what if a television series has a spin -off
- 58:57series? Same kind of situation. In many circumstances,
- 59:02writers are entitled to what's called separated
- 59:03rights. It's a completely different title. It's
- 59:06not called residuals. It's called separated rights.
- 59:08But it gives them certain controls over those
- 59:10reuses at all and gives them certain compensation
- 59:13and bargaining rights. And there are ways of
- 59:16defeating certain of those rights by paying them
- 59:18enough upfront. It's very complicated. But the
- 59:21point is that writers already have precedent
- 59:23for saying, when we make stuff that gets reused,
- 59:28It doesn't have to be the final footage that
- 59:30gets reused. We still, under some circumstances,
- 59:33get compensation. Well, guess what? If the final
- 59:37footage, or if, say, if a screenplay, if a screenplay
- 59:42gets reused as training data, you're reusing
- 59:44the screenplay. We already have separated rights.
- 59:47If you reuse the screenplay to make a stage play,
- 59:49you don't get to do that. I get to do that for
- 59:51the first three years, and blah, blah, blah,
- 59:53and back and forth, and reversions, and all sorts
- 59:55of things. But I get money for it. So if you're
- 59:58going to use me for training data, maybe I want
- 1:00:02the right to prohibit that altogether. And if
- 1:00:04not prohibited, maybe I say, fine, you're reusing
- 1:00:07the screenplay, even a screenplay perhaps that
- 1:00:09you never produced, but that you bought. I want
- 1:00:13to get paid for that. So it's an issue that casts
- 1:00:17a shadow on all three negotiations, but the shadow
- 1:00:21has different and very complex shapes that differ
- 1:00:24among actors, writers, and... directors. Yeah,
- 1:00:28I mean, what I hear you saying is from a Guild
- 1:00:29perspective, there's already a conceptual framework
- 1:00:31that's in place built into these agreements that
- 1:00:34provides for compensation for reuse of the actual
- 1:00:38film footage itself or the underlying creative
- 1:00:40material that's the seed and the basis for a
- 1:00:42derivative production, like a remake, a sequel,
- 1:00:45a spin -off or something like that based on a
- 1:00:47film or a TV series. I mean, I think that it's
- 1:00:50a really interesting concept and the real challenge,
- 1:00:53I think, for the But the guilds is going to be
- 1:00:56the flip side of that is that these generative
- 1:00:58AI large language or large learning models, they
- 1:01:02ingest a tremendous amount of material in order
- 1:01:04to create these tools that we use to generate
- 1:01:07new screenplays or new backgrounds or new audio
- 1:01:10visual content. But it doesn't necessarily look
- 1:01:15anything like or a whole lot. But it doesn't
- 1:01:17have to. If you think that's an argument, it
- 1:01:20doesn't look like my script, then don't ingest
- 1:01:21my script. Fine. You say you want to adjust my
- 1:01:24script? Well, then pay me. You want to adjust
- 1:01:26my footage? Then pay me. Don't tell me that just
- 1:01:29because you ingested a million other people's
- 1:01:31that I don't get anything. Now, yeah, I don't
- 1:01:34get the level that I would get if it was just
- 1:01:36based on me and it looked like me and it was
- 1:01:38let alone an infringement type thing. There is
- 1:01:42another hard part to this though, which is that
- 1:01:45the background law is unsettled. Right now third
- 1:01:48parties are ingesting Pre -existing material
- 1:01:51and not paying anyone for it. They're not paying
- 1:01:54the studio and they're not paying the creatives
- 1:01:56The courts have not yet decided nor has congress
- 1:01:58decided and it'll take several years for anyone
- 1:02:01to decide definitively Whether that is fair use
- 1:02:05and can continue to be done Without paying anybody
- 1:02:08or whether it's not fair use in which case if
- 1:02:10the studios have to get paid By a third party,
- 1:02:13then the studio should pay the creatives as well.
- 1:02:15It's going to be the union position But it's
- 1:02:17been hard for the union to say to the studios
- 1:02:20You got to pay us but some willy -nilly infringer
- 1:02:23type bad TV guy in our point of view In doesn't
- 1:02:28have to pay you because of course say he doesn't
- 1:02:30he or she doesn't have to pay. Yeah There's a
- 1:02:32lot of hard argument to make there's a lot of
- 1:02:34layers here. Yeah for sure The real question
- 1:02:36is is what is the what is the appropriate? compensation
- 1:02:38model for something like this when we're talking
- 1:02:40about this type of new technology and how it's
- 1:02:43going to be implemented and then of course another
- 1:02:45interesting layer is You know, we're talking
- 1:02:48about the guilds potentially taking the position
- 1:02:50that you can't use these types of tools within
- 1:02:52productions, and you can't ingest material. Well,
- 1:02:55again, it's consent. So there's a lot of these
- 1:02:58tensions back and forth. Right, it's consent,
- 1:03:00compensation, and the background question, will
- 1:03:02there be compensation and consent rights at all?
- 1:03:06Right, absolutely. Well, look, I mean, I think
- 1:03:07we have come to the end of our hour here, so
- 1:03:10I think we need to wrap it up. But I think we
- 1:03:12really have hit on what the key issues are going
- 1:03:14to be as we move into this, right? I mean, synthetic
- 1:03:16performers, training, use of these underlying
- 1:03:19materials, how do we deal with the costs of these
- 1:03:22funds increasing? And also the new technologies
- 1:03:26that we're seeing and the new formats within
- 1:03:28the verticals and things like that too. I don't
- 1:03:32see any questions in the Q &A, so I think we
- 1:03:34probably can wrap it up at this point. And I
- 1:03:38just want to say, again, thank you so much for
- 1:03:39your perspective on this material, for your investigative
- 1:03:43services, and breaking a few stories for us here
- 1:03:46today in terms of what we can expect. I think
- 1:03:48we'll probably see some of this reflected in
- 1:03:50the trades pretty soon. And thanks again to the
- 1:03:53Beverly Hills Bar, to Lowers Mutual for supporting
- 1:03:55us, and to all of our audience for participating.
- 1:03:58Anything else I forgot, Jonathan? You want to
- 1:03:59add a closing remark? Of course I do. I want
- 1:04:02to thank you for being a wonderful co -panelist
- 1:04:05and for being here. You kept us on the straight
- 1:04:08and narrow and perhaps after SAG does their deal,
- 1:04:13SAG -AFTRA, we'll be back. Yeah, well, you know,
- 1:04:17I think that, you know, talking about hopefully
- 1:04:19there won't be any strikes is a very optimistic
- 1:04:21place to leave this. You know, again, as a mediator,
- 1:04:23my perspective is always going to be there's
- 1:04:25a collaborative way to address these things.
- 1:04:27It's great to know that the top level folks can
- 1:04:30get into the room and talk to each other and
- 1:04:32work things out if that's what's necessary. And
- 1:04:34hopefully, like I said, there's a way to make
- 1:04:35the pie larger, right? So that we can have a
- 1:04:37win -win resolution of these issues for everyone
- 1:04:39in an industry that means so much to this town
- 1:04:42and to the world community and really affects
- 1:04:46people's lives on a day -to -day basis here.
- 1:04:48So thanks again for all the work you do as well.
- 1:04:51Thank you. Thank you, everybody. Thank you, everyone.