Latest / My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story / My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 35: The Brother's City

Transcript

My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 35: The Brother's City · My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story

0:00
Thank you for carrying me somewhere I could remember.
0:03
Mira carried you. I just bought the tickets.
0:07
You stopped pushing me, she said, in the empty
0:11
room. That's what got me onto the plane. My Playful
0:17
Wife. Episode 35. The Brother's City. Written
0:21
by Mia. We flew south on a Tuesday. Into the
0:27
brother's city, and somewhere over the middle
0:30
of the country, I watched my wife fall asleep
0:33
against the window with her mouth slightly open
0:35
and her hands finally still, and understood that
0:38
being carried was its own kind of medicine. She
0:43
had not slept like that in months. The whole
0:46
of the third collection had lived in her shoulders,
0:48
and then the empty room had lived in them, and
0:51
now, at 35 ,000 feet, with nothing required of
0:56
her, No deadline beneath her and no roll waiting
0:59
at the other end. She had simply gone, mid -sentence,
1:03
into the deep clean sleep of a person who has
1:06
been, for the first time in a long time, relieved
1:10
of being herself. Mira had booked the seats.
1:13
Of course she had. Mira books everything. Mira
1:16
had booked this entire visit and half of our
1:19
last one and would, I knew, book the next before
1:21
we had unpacked from this one. And she had put
1:24
us by the window on purpose, the message attached
1:27
to the ticket reading, she should sleep on the
1:29
flight, make her doctor's orders mine. And so
1:33
my wife slept against the southbound window,
1:35
off duty. anonymous, nobody's maker, and I did
1:40
not wake her even to point out the river, because
1:42
the sleep was more beautiful than the river,
1:45
and I have learned which is which. There is a
1:48
tenderness available to you when someone you
1:50
love is asleep that is harder to give them awake,
1:53
because the sleeping person asks nothing of you,
1:55
and so you get to love them with no transaction
1:58
in it at all, no being thanked, no being needed
2:01
back. I sat in the small humming dark of the
2:04
cabin and looked at the unguarded face of my
2:07
sleeping wife. The face, she does not show the
2:10
buyers or the press or even most days, fully
2:14
to me, and I felt the particular ache of being
2:17
trusted enough to be slept beside, which is,
2:20
when you think about it, one of the largest trusts
2:23
a once frightened animal can extend to another.
2:28
My brother met us at the airport, and I want
2:31
to record what that is like, still, even now,
2:34
because there were years when it would have been
2:36
unimaginable, and a thing that was once unimaginable
2:40
should not be allowed to become ordinary without
2:43
someone marking that it happened. There were
2:46
years. I will not relitigate them here. The war
2:50
is over, and the dead should be left where they
2:53
lie, when my brother and I did not speak. Years
2:57
of the blade, I have called it in the notebooks,
2:59
the long cold season when every rare phone call
3:02
between us carried an edge under the politeness,
3:05
a thing sharpened and kept ready so that even
3:08
how are you arrived with a point on it. We had
3:10
hurt each other in the specific irreparable way
3:13
that only people who started out loving each
3:15
other completely can manage, the way that requires
3:18
intimacy as its raw material, and we had then
3:22
spent the better part of a decade each being
3:24
right about it. separately in our separate cities,
3:27
getting righter and lonelier by the year. That
3:30
is the particular trap of the family wound, that
3:33
you can be entirely in the right, and it does
3:36
you no good whatsoever. With a stranger, being
3:40
right is the end of the matter. You are right,
3:42
you part ways, you move on. With a brother, there
3:45
is no parting ways, only a longer or shorter
3:48
silence. And so your rightness sits inside you
3:51
for years like a swallowed stone, and you nurse
3:54
it, and it keeps you company, and it is the loneliest
3:58
possible companion, because the only person who
4:01
could take it from you is the very person you
4:04
are right about. I had carried my stone a long
4:07
time. I do not even remember now, if I am honest,
4:11
the exact shape of it. That is the thing nobody
4:13
warns you about the great family grievances.
4:17
that you can outlive your own memory of their
4:19
particulars and still go on dutifully carrying
4:22
the weight. And then, across the two years that
4:27
the balcony morning set in motion, because that
4:30
morning did not only remake my marriage, it loosened
4:34
something in me that had been clenched against
4:35
everyone, not only Celonie. The blade had gone
4:39
out of it. Slowly, a call at a time. I had stopped
4:44
needing to be right about the old thing, somewhere
4:47
in the work of learning to stop needing to be
4:49
right about everything, and he had met the stopping,
4:52
tentatively, the way you put a hand out toward
4:54
an animal that used to bite, and somewhere in
4:57
there the calls had lost their edge, and then
4:59
their wariness, and then, astonishingly, become
5:02
just calls, a brother ringing to complain about
5:05
traffic, to ask after a cousin, to say nothing
5:08
much for twenty minutes on a Sunday, which is
5:11
the... Highest form of reconciliation there is
5:14
the saying of nothing much because you only spend
5:17
20 minutes saying nothing much to someone you
5:20
have decided to simply have in your life again.
5:23
He met us at the airport and he hugged me and
5:26
the hug was an ordinary hug and the ordinariness
5:30
of it was the entire miracle. There was a version
5:33
of us, the blade version, in which this hug could
5:36
not have happened. in which we would have shaken
5:39
hands like colleagues and held our bodies at
5:42
the careful angle of men managing a truce. Instead,
5:46
my brother put his arms around me in an arrivals
5:48
hall in a southern city and thumped my back twice
5:51
in the wordless idiom of our family and took
5:54
Celonie's bag off her shoulder without being
5:56
asked, and it was nothing. It was the most ordinary
5:59
thing in the world, and I had to look at the
6:02
floor of the arrivals hall for a second because
6:04
the most ordinary thing in the world had been.
6:07
Not so long ago, the most impossible. I have
6:11
come to believe that this is where most of the
6:14
real reconciliations in a life actually happen.
6:17
Not in the big scene, the tearful clearing of
6:20
the air that the films promise us, but in a hug
6:23
in an arrivals hall that simply, quietly, declines
6:26
to be careful. Forgiveness, the real kind, rarely
6:31
announces itself. It arrives disguised as ordinariness.
6:36
It looks like a man taking your wife's bag off
6:38
her shoulder without being asked. You spend years
6:41
imagining the dramatic confrontation that will
6:44
finally resolve the thing, and then the thing
6:47
gets resolved instead by a hundred small, uncareful
6:50
gestures, and you understand, too late to have
6:53
spared yourself the waiting, that the confrontation
6:56
was never going to be the cure. The ordinariness
6:59
was the cure. Here is what I did not expect in
7:06
his city, that I would have to learn him again
7:08
from the beginning. I had assumed, getting on
7:12
the plane, that I was going to visit my brother,
7:14
a known quantity, the person I have known longer
7:17
than I have known anyone alive, longer than Celony,
7:20
longer than my own adult self. Who knows a man
7:24
better than the brother he grew up beside? And
7:27
the answer, I discovered over the first two days
7:30
in his city, is... Almost anyone. Almost anyone
7:35
knows him better than I do, because almost anyone
7:37
is meeting the man who actually exists, and I
7:40
have been carrying around for 40 years a version
7:43
of him fixed and pinned at about the age of 15,
7:46
the rival, the one our parents compared me to,
7:50
the boy who borrowed my things and broke them,
7:52
the specific antagonist of my specific childhood.
7:55
I had filed him under that completely decades
7:58
ago, and then never reopened the file. Because
8:01
why would you reopen a file you are certain is
8:04
complete? This is the deepest grain there is,
8:08
I think, the grain of family, though with the
8:10
grain reading of the people you grew up beside.
8:13
You cut your siblings straightest of all. The
8:16
cloth of a brother gets laid down square and
8:18
stable in childhood, and then never recut, so
8:22
that you can be 50 years old, both of you, and
8:25
still meeting at the angle of who you were at
8:27
15. Two middle -aged men performing an ancient
8:30
sibling choreography that neither of the actual
8:33
present -day people would choose. I had done
8:36
it to him for 40 years. And now, in his city,
8:39
off the deadline, awake on purpose, I made myself
8:43
do the hard thing, the bias cut, the diagonal
8:47
-to -my -assumptions reading of my own brother.
8:49
I made myself meet the man who was actually in
8:52
the room. And the man who was actually in the
8:56
room was a revelation. He was gentle in a way
9:00
the 15 -year -old had given no sign of. He was
9:03
funny. Quietly, dryly, in a register I had apparently
9:08
been too busy being his rival to ever hear. He
9:11
had built a life of real and unflashy substance
9:14
in this city, a good steady working life, a home
9:18
with books in it and a balcony he tended, and
9:21
he was, I saw, watching him move through his
9:24
own rooms, a contented man, which was the single
9:28
most disorienting discovery of all, because in
9:31
the file I had kept, the 15 -year -old file,
9:34
he was the one who got everything and was never
9:37
satisfied. And the actual man in front of me
9:39
had built something modest and was deeply at
9:42
peace in it. And I had missed the entire becoming,
9:46
decades of it. I had a whole brother I had never
9:50
met standing in plain sight because I had been
9:53
too certain I already knew him to look. It frightened
9:57
me a little, honestly, sitting in his contented
10:00
house, because if I could be that wrong about
10:03
a brother, a person I had grown up three feet
10:05
away from, what was I confidently wrong about
10:08
everywhere else? How many people in my life had
10:11
I sealed shut decades ago, filed, and stopped
10:14
reading? The certainty that lets a man move efficiently
10:18
through the world is built almost entirely out
10:21
of out -of -date dossiers on the people in it,
10:23
and most of us never reopen a single one and
10:27
call the resulting blindness knowing them well.
10:33
Saloni and Mira took to each other in about four
10:36
minutes, which I had hoped for and could not
10:39
have arranged. They had met before, at the wedding
10:43
and at our place, and on the long video calls
10:45
Mira orchestrates, but they had never had this,
10:49
three unhurried days in the same house with nothing
10:52
to perform. And I watched over those days, the
10:56
particular pleasure of seeing the person you
10:58
love be loved, easily, by someone whose good
11:02
opinion you value. Mira is the organizer, the
11:05
books the tickets won. the one whose competence
11:08
is a form of tenderness. She expresses love by
11:12
removing logistics from the lives of the people
11:14
she loves, by making sure the seats are good
11:17
and the fridge is full and the visit happens
11:20
at all. And Selene, who had spent two years being
11:24
the one who makes the thing, the one in charge,
11:27
the deadline bearer, simply set all of it down
11:30
in Mira's competent house and let herself be
11:33
organized, be fed, be told when dinner was, be
11:37
relieved of every decision. I watched my deadline
11:41
-bearing wife become, in the South briefly, a
11:44
person with no deadlines at all, and I watched
11:47
Mira fuss over her exactly the way the fallow
11:50
needed to be fussed over, and the two of them
11:52
found, by the second evening, the shorthand of
11:56
women who have decided to be sisters, and I sat
11:59
at the edge of it. My place, the edge, where
12:03
I do my best living. and watched two families
12:06
that had once been at a blade's distance frayed
12:08
quietly into one. There is a specific gladness
12:12
I am learning that is only available secondhand,
12:15
the gladness of watching the people you love
12:18
be happy with each other in a way that has nothing
12:20
to do with you. I had brought these two women
12:23
into rooms together before, hoping they would
12:25
get on, the way you hope. And now I got to sit
12:29
at the edge and watch the hoping be exceeded,
12:32
watch them invent in three days a friendship
12:34
I had not engineered and could not have, and
12:38
feel the clean, uncomplicated pleasure of being,
12:41
for once, completely unnecessary to the joy in
12:45
the room. There was a moment on the second night,
12:48
late, when the women had gone to bed, and my
12:51
brother and I sat on his tended balcony in the
12:54
warm southern dark, not saying much. that I will
12:57
keep most of, the way I keep the things that
13:00
turn out to matter. We did not re -litigate the
13:03
war. That was the whole grace of it. There was
13:07
a version of the evening, the version I might
13:09
have insisted on a few years ago, in which I
13:12
needed us to go back over the old wound, to portion
13:15
it correctly, to extract an acknowledgement,
13:18
to be told at last that I had been right about
13:20
the thing I had been right about. And I felt
13:23
the old pull of it, the prosecutor's pull, and
13:26
I let it go because I have learned that there
13:28
is a kind of peace that can only exist if you
13:30
agree never to audit it. The war was over. We
13:34
had both survived it. We were two middle -aged
13:37
men on a balcony in the dark with our wives asleep
13:40
inside and the whole long blade cold decade behind
13:43
us. And the most loving thing available to me
13:46
was to not pick the scab of it. to let the reconciliation
13:50
be load -bearing precisely, by never testing
13:53
how much weight it could hold. So we talked about
13:56
nothing much. We talked about his balcony plants
13:59
and a cricket match and our mother's knee. And
14:03
the nothing much was the entire cathedral of
14:06
it, the saying of nothing much to a brother I
14:09
had spent a decade not speaking to, and I was
14:12
awake for every unremarkable word. I think a
14:16
great deal of love, in the end, is just attendance.
14:19
The simple fact of having been present, awake,
14:23
in the room, for the unremarkable hours, which
14:26
turn out to be nearly all the hours there are.
14:29
The dramatic hours take care of themselves. Nobody
14:32
sleeps through a crisis. It is the ordinary balcony
14:36
nights, the nothing much, The long, flat middle
14:40
of a life shared with someone that you can miss
14:43
entirely while sitting physically right inside
14:45
them and that you can never afterward get back.
14:48
I had already missed a decade of my brother's
14:51
ordinary hours. I was not, that night, going
14:55
to miss the balcony. I wrote it in the fifth
15:01
notebook that night, on the narrow guest bed,
15:04
Saloni breathing slow and Southern beside me.
15:09
The brother's city. He met us at the airport
15:12
and hugged me like it was nothing, and the nothing
15:15
was the miracle. Three days in his life, and
15:18
I've understood I never knew him. I've been carrying
15:22
the 15 -year -old version, the rival, filed and
15:26
pinned 40 years ago. Never recut. You cut your
15:29
siblings straightest of all. The family grain
15:32
is the deepest grain there is. Made myself run
15:36
the bias cut on my own brother. Meet the man
15:39
actually in the room. He's gentle. He's funny
15:42
in a register. I was too busy being his rival
15:45
to hear. He built a modest, contented life, and
15:49
I miss the whole becoming. A whole brother in
15:52
plain sight. I never met because I was too sure
15:56
I already knew him. On the balcony tonight, I
16:00
did not relitigate the war. Let the peace be
16:02
load -bearing by never auditing it. We talked
16:06
about nothing much. The nothing much was everything.
16:11
And below it, the working line. The people you
16:15
are surest you know are the people you have most
16:18
stopped seeing. Certainty is the enemy of sight.
16:21
I have run the bias cut on my wife and it saved
16:24
my marriage. Tonight I ran it on my brother and
16:28
got a brother back. Tomorrow run it on whoever
16:31
you are surest about. The surer you are, the
16:34
more there is that you've stopped looking at.
16:37
Family is just the place where the certainty
16:39
is oldest and the not looking has gone on longest.
16:43
Awake means recutting even them, especially them.
16:50
In the morning, Celonie was different. I noticed
16:54
it the way you notice weather. Not a single event,
16:57
but a change in the whole air of her. The clench
17:00
was gone. The southern days had done what no
17:03
amount of my careful witnessing in the empty
17:06
deli room could quite do. They had unhooked her,
17:09
fully, from the roll. Here she was not the maker,
17:13
not the woman with the ruined centerpiece and
17:16
the next collection already breathing down her
17:18
neck. Here she was just a wife visiting a brother's
17:21
house, a guest with no deadlines, a person being
17:25
fussed over by Mira and teased by my newly discovered
17:29
brother and carried, gently, by everyone, through
17:32
three days in which nothing was required of her
17:35
but to be present and fed and rested. She came
17:39
to the breakfast table on the third morning with
17:41
her hair loose and her shoulders down and a looseness
17:45
in her face I had not seen since before the December
17:47
room, and she put her hand on the back of my
17:50
neck on her way to the chai. The old gesture,
17:53
the small proprietary sentence, except this time
17:57
it had no tiredness in it, only ease, and she
18:01
said, lo, just for me. I forgot I was a person
18:05
and not a deadline. Thank you for carrying me
18:08
somewhere I could remember. Mira carried you.
18:13
I just bought the tickets. You stopped pushing
18:17
me, she said, in the empty room. That's what
18:21
got me onto the plane. You know that, don't you?
18:24
You sat down in the empty with me instead of
18:27
trying to drag me out of it. And that's the only
18:30
reason I was able to stand up on my own. I'd
18:33
have planted my feet against a push. I always
18:37
do. She squeezed the back of my neck once. You're
18:41
learning, old man. I have a good teacher, I said.
18:46
She talks about cloth, mostly. I have to listen
18:50
on the bias. And tonight there is the dinner.
18:55
The four of us, at last, at a table in his city,
18:57
the thing we promised on a deli morning two years
19:00
ago, and that seemed, when we promised it, like
19:03
a sentence written in a language we did not yet
19:05
speak. The four of us, two healed couples, two
19:09
braided families, one table. I do not know yet
19:13
what the dinner will be, but I know I intend
19:15
to be awake for it. Every minute cut diagonal
19:19
to every assumption I carried south, because
19:22
the great evenings I have learned ask exactly
19:25
as much attention as the terrible ones, and I
19:28
have nearly run out of practice excuses for sleeping
19:31
through my own life. To be continued in episode
19:46
was episode 35 of My Playful Wife. If this story
19:51
is staying with you, the next episode is already
19:54
waiting. Subscribe so you don't miss it. The
19:58
complete book is on Amazon and early episodes
20:01
plus bonus chapters are on my Patreon. Links
20:04
are in the description. I'm Mia. Thank you for
20:07
listening.