Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Andor (2022-2025): Every Person Necessary
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:32We're sitting here in my attic room. It's quite
- 0:36warm. There isn't much insulation, so on a late
- 0:40July day, this space can bake. There's a box
- 0:44fan to the side, and the navy blue curtains are
- 0:47closed. But don't worry. We're not in the dark.
- 0:52These curtains have little holes punched into
- 0:55them, the shapes of stars and moons. They're
- 0:59cast over the floor, our bodies and our faces.
- 1:04Little shining freckles of light. I love movies.
- 1:10That's what I've talked about with you during
- 1:12our visits together so far. But I also appreciate
- 1:16the kind of long -form cinematic storytelling
- 1:19you often find in television. Most of the time,
- 1:24I want to talk to you about movies specifically.
- 1:29But now seems like a really relevant time to
- 1:32talk to you about some prestige TV, specifically
- 1:36the Disney Plus streaming show Andor. Andor is
- 1:41a difficult thing to explain. It's a Star Wars
- 1:45show, a prequel series to a prequel spinoff of
- 1:49a nearly 50 -year -old movie. And if that makes
- 1:53you want to groan and bury your head in your
- 1:55hands, I understand. This is a bizarre thing,
- 1:59but it's also some pretty amazing art that gave
- 2:04me a lot to think about. And now, just a few
- 2:08months after its series finale, before it picks
- 2:11up at least a couple of Emmys, seems like just
- 2:14the right time to share my thoughts with you.
- 2:19I love Star Wars. It's a franchise that has had
- 2:24specific, tangible influence on me as a person
- 2:28and on my imagination as a writer. Someday we'll
- 2:33talk about the films, specifically The Empire
- 2:36Strikes Back, but this is where I have to reveal
- 2:39that my first Star Wars wasn't the original trilogy.
- 2:44It was what was then called the Expanded Universe.
- 2:48The collection of novels by various authors that
- 2:52vaguely connected to each other, both continuing
- 2:55the story of the original characters and adding
- 2:58new ones that redefined what Star Wars could
- 3:01be. Is Star Wars a metaphysical pondering on
- 3:06the nature of consciousness? Or is it a collection
- 3:09of aliens and space weirdos pulling off heists
- 3:12to screw over authoritarian supply systems? Is
- 3:17it thrilling stories for kids about space wizard
- 3:20school? Or is it an adult melodrama about moral
- 3:24ambiguity? All of these were Star Wars to me.
- 3:29But that's definitely not the case for everyone,
- 3:32and is, again, what makes Andor a very weird
- 3:37thing. So before I can tell you why I haven't
- 3:42been able to stop gushing about Andor for literal
- 3:45months to anyone who would listen, I have to
- 3:48help you understand what it even is. In 1977,
- 3:55director George Lucas released a movie called
- 3:58Star Wars, what we now call Episode 4 or A New
- 4:02Hope. I know you've seen this movie. Even if
- 4:06you haven't seen this movie, You've seen this
- 4:10movie. Its impact on pop culture is immeasurable.
- 4:15In storytelling style, in iconography, in music,
- 4:19in film language, and special effects. It changed
- 4:24movies and storytelling forever. And here's what
- 4:30makes it special. Star Wars is epic, mythic fantasy.
- 4:37It's about a hero rising from nowhere to take
- 4:41on evil. It's about space wizards fighting each
- 4:44other with magic weapons. It's about the conflict
- 4:48between pragmatism and spirituality. This is
- 4:53timeless, archetypal stuff. But what makes it
- 4:58unique is that it tells these stories not with
- 5:01magic and whimsy and a dash of fairy. but in
- 5:05space with computers and robots and starships.
- 5:10This is a world of technology, lighted buttons
- 5:15and vector screens and analog knobs. But unlike
- 5:19previous entries of science fiction, none of
- 5:22these doodads are sleek or clean or shiny, except
- 5:27the bad guy stuff. No. Star Wars is grimy. It's
- 5:33filthy. It's worn down and scuffed and scratched.
- 5:38We spend a whole scene in a trash bin, wet and
- 5:43stinking and sloshing around piles of junk. And
- 5:47this is the juxtaposition that made Star Wars
- 5:51stick out from everything else that came before
- 5:54it. We have this archetypal, highly imaginative
- 5:58story contrasted with an incredibly gritty, grungy
- 6:02world. ideals with a realistic setting where
- 6:07people sweat and rely on technology with similar
- 6:11aesthetics to 1970s computers and gadgets. There's
- 6:17nostalgia for the stories the audience grew up
- 6:20on and the groundedness that a post -Watergate
- 6:24adult world could buy into. And so Star Wars
- 6:28became this thing, this unstoppable, culture
- 6:32-making, culture -breaking thing. And then in
- 6:372012, George Lucas, the director and driver of
- 6:41this entire juggernaut of a franchise, sold it
- 6:44to Disney. They got to work right away. First...
- 6:49They wiped the slate clean by throwing out the
- 6:51entirety of the expanded universe and rebranding
- 6:55it as Star Wars Legends. And then they started
- 6:59building out their own sequels and spinoffs and
- 7:01expanded storytelling. One of the first projects
- 7:05pitched to the new producers of the franchise,
- 7:08even before they had started to put together
- 7:11the bones for their next main Star Wars series,
- 7:14was a movie that was eventually called... Rogue
- 7:18One. The idea here is, what if instead of this
- 7:23juxtaposition between mythic storytelling and
- 7:26a gritty grounded world, you just had a grounded
- 7:30story inside of a grounded world? And it would
- 7:34be new because the contrast had become the norm.
- 7:39It had lost its novelty. Divorced from its main
- 7:44characters, the plot of Star Wars is about the
- 7:47bad guys looking for stolen plans to a superweapon.
- 7:52Rogue One asks, OK, how did the plans get stolen
- 7:57in the first place? Who pulled off that heist?
- 8:01And the answer is not the shiny heroes who stepped
- 8:04out of a storybook. That work would be done by
- 8:09people with blood and dirt on their hands. Pragmatists,
- 8:14not spiritual figures dabbling in the metaphysical.
- 8:18It would be Han Solo all the way down, spies
- 8:22and criminals and assassins doing the hard, dirty
- 8:26work that let Luke Skywalker shoot a proton torpedo
- 8:30and save the day. This isn't Mrs. Miniver telling
- 8:34a story about the home front fathers who rode
- 8:38out in their boats to rescue the trapped soldiers
- 8:40at Dunkirk. This is the Dirty Dozen about murderers
- 8:45becoming soldiers. And its last act is incredibly
- 8:49successful at that. The climactic Battle of Scarif
- 8:54is phenomenal, pulling off a level of suspense
- 8:57and investments that's remarkable, especially
- 9:00since this is a direct prequel to A New Hope.
- 9:04We know they're going to be successful. We know
- 9:07the plans are going to be found and relayed.
- 9:12That will be the only thing getting off this
- 9:14planet. And what we suspect is revealed to be
- 9:18true. Not one member of Rogue One, of our intrepid
- 9:23heroes, makes it out alive. That's a spoiler,
- 9:27and yet it's not a spoiler. It's the nature of
- 9:32that story. In Return of the Jedi, a woman called
- 9:36Mon Mothma, a single -scene rebel leader that
- 9:40reappears in Rogue One, delivers an intelligence
- 9:43briefing where she utters the sentence, Many
- 9:46Bothans died to bring us this information. While
- 9:51Rogue One is about a separate mission, the fact
- 9:54that Mon Mothma makes only her second Star Wars
- 9:57film appearance, deleted scenes in Revenge of
- 10:00the Sith don't count, telegraphs. that this whole
- 10:05crew is going to die. Watching this film in the
- 10:10theater as each one of them gave their lives
- 10:12in desperate acts to make the mission succeed,
- 10:15I found myself weeping. I also found myself wishing
- 10:20that any of the first two -thirds of this film
- 10:22had actually helped me get to know any of these
- 10:25characters. I learned more in their dying seconds
- 10:28than in the previous 90 minutes. Rogue One has
- 10:33an exposition problem. Predominantly, it has
- 10:36a show -don't -tell problem, as in, it spends
- 10:40a lot of time telling us about who each of these
- 10:43people are and does a very bad job of showing
- 10:46us. There's a pilot who theoretically defects
- 10:50because of the mentoring he received from an
- 10:54Imperial officer double agent. We know this is
- 10:57why he changed sides, because it is told to us
- 11:00in an intelligence briefing. We also know he's
- 11:04a pilot because he says that to himself over
- 11:07and over again. We never see an interaction between
- 11:11him and the officer. We never see him do much
- 11:15of anything except be tortured and fly a ship.
- 11:19There's our protagonist, Jyn Erso, whose criminal
- 11:22resume is also read out to us in an intelligence
- 11:25briefing. We're told she's cynical, hardened.
- 11:29In an infamous deleted line used in the trailer,
- 11:33she says, This is a rebellion, isn't it? I rebel.
- 11:37And yet all of her actions are idealistic, softened
- 11:43by the very presence of actress Felicity Jones.
- 11:48Messiest of all is Cassian Andor, the most senior
- 11:51of the supporting players. He is introduced to
- 11:55us literally killing a man in cold blood, an
- 11:59informant who had just delivered him crucial
- 12:01intelligence. Plot -wise, he's also supposed
- 12:05to be a threat to Jyn once she stops being a
- 12:08valuable asset. And yet he's constantly giving
- 12:13hopeful, idealistic speeches. As for the roots
- 12:17of this character, instead of being shown the
- 12:20origins of the disconnect between his actions
- 12:22and his speech, we're given a single line of
- 12:25backstory. I've been in this fight since I was
- 12:28five years old. An utterly baffling statement
- 12:31considering that the Empire is only 19 years
- 12:34old, and Diego Luna, baby -faced as he is, does
- 12:39not look 24 at 33. Luna is, in fact, the most
- 12:44interesting thing about this character. On the
- 12:48page, he's a Han Solo clone, but give him a Mexican
- 12:51accent and an adorably charming demeanor and
- 12:54he becomes something else. And yet, when Disney
- 12:58announced that Cassian Andor would get his own
- 13:01eponymous prequel show about the character's
- 13:04origins, the fandom collectively groaned. Did
- 13:08we really need to see what happened to Diego
- 13:11Luna at five? And did we really need to see it
- 13:15spread out over multiple episodes? Since Disney
- 13:19acquired Star Wars, the story became burdened
- 13:24with canon and continuity. Instead of the old
- 13:28model of the expanded universe, both continuing
- 13:32the story of the original characters and adding
- 13:35new ones that redefined what Star Wars could
- 13:38be, Disney Star Wars was a cinematic universe,
- 13:43a la Marvel in Space, stories as both chores
- 13:47and advertisements for the next thing. And so
- 13:51we couldn't imagine any version of this show
- 13:54that wasn't streaming content slop. Andor is
- 14:00not that. Andor is something different. And or
- 14:09is, in fact, hardly even about Cassian himself.
- 14:15Rather, it is a show about the ripple effect
- 14:18of Cassian's existence and his choices. Perhaps
- 14:23you've heard of the butterfly effect, that the
- 14:26flapping of a butterfly's wings can cause a tornado.
- 14:30This is a show that miraculously manages to convey
- 14:35that. In the first scene of the first episode,
- 14:39Cassian is somewhere he should not and cannot
- 14:43help to be, and makes a terrible, necessary choice.
- 14:48This choice sparks an investigation, which puts
- 14:52him on the run, which puts him in the path of
- 14:55the rebellion, and deeply affects his community.
- 14:58Their actions impact others throughout the galaxy,
- 15:02a slow -building great chain of action and consequence.
- 15:08In this chain, there are no weak links. Each
- 15:13life touched, each choice made, matters. We don't
- 15:20get to see any complete stories. Like in Rogue
- 15:24One, we get to know some characters just before
- 15:27their deaths. Others we see on just the start
- 15:31of their journeys. Still others, at the terrifying
- 15:35middle, their final chapters often left hanging
- 15:38in the air. There's a line said twice in Rogue
- 15:44One, passed from Cassian to Jyn. Rebellions are
- 15:50built on hope. In that film, it starts as part
- 15:54of the muddying character motivations. repeating
- 15:58as part of the rallying speech that leads into
- 16:02the phenomenally constructed final act. In this
- 16:06show, we find it was passed to Cassian by an
- 16:11ordinary young man, a bellhop at a once prestigious
- 16:15hotel, trying to keep the faith in the midst
- 16:19of horrifying circumstances. He's a nobody, not
- 16:24even given a name. And yet he is essential, passing
- 16:29on an earnest axiom that, unknown to him, will
- 16:33inspire a courageous suicidal mission that will
- 16:37lead to the destruction of the Death Star and
- 16:40the beginning of the end of the Empire itself.
- 16:45A few weeks ago, we in the United States observed
- 16:49the Fourth of July, our Independence Day, marking
- 16:52our own rebellion from a tyrannical empire. We
- 16:56have many heroes whose names we remember, whose
- 16:59acts we celebrate. But much of our mythology
- 17:02is actually nameless. We don't know who fired
- 17:07the first shot of the American Revolution at
- 17:10the Battle of Lexington and Concord. We don't
- 17:14even know which side. The British said it was
- 17:17the American militia. The militia said it was
- 17:20the British. Townspeople, eyewitnesses gave mixed
- 17:24reports as well. Some historians wonder if there
- 17:29weren't simultaneous shots. Whoever it was, his
- 17:33name and his motives have been completely lost
- 17:36to time. Conflict there wasn't inevitable. If
- 17:42there wasn't a shot, there may not have been
- 17:45a battle. There may not have been an actual war.
- 17:50The Boston Tea Party is also an event we know
- 17:53surprisingly little about. It was largely carried
- 17:57out by the Sons of Liberty, but we have no idea
- 18:01who they were. Samuel Adams is a known figure
- 18:05who may have been involved, but that's actually
- 18:08debated. We don't know who was there. We can
- 18:13guess why many wore Mohawk costumes, but we don't
- 18:18actually know why. Not for certain, anyway. We
- 18:24don't know who designed our flag, the iconic
- 18:27stars and stripes. According to legend, it was
- 18:31Betsy Ross, but that narrative is highly contested.
- 18:35There were quite a few flag makers in the area
- 18:37at that time in that place, and we honestly have
- 18:41no idea which woman developed the final design.
- 18:45There's no paper trail. Just a story told by
- 18:49Betsy Ross's grandson when he was an adult, with
- 18:52something to gain by it, with details that don't
- 18:56add up. So this woman, whose work heavily influenced
- 19:01this major national symbol, does not have her
- 19:05work recorded at all. In the grand scheme of
- 19:09things, this is pretty recent history in a place
- 19:13with pretty good records and accounts. built
- 19:16on enlightenment values of observable science
- 19:19and philosophy. And yet, so much is unknown.
- 19:25This is to say nothing of the regular old people
- 19:28living their lives in the midst of a war, making
- 19:32a thousand tiny choices, all influencing each
- 19:35other without any record. With very few exceptions,
- 19:41We humans cannot know the full extent of our
- 19:45impact on the world. We literally cannot see
- 19:49what is happening. We have absolutely zero perspective
- 19:54on the full consequence of our choices, on the
- 19:57great chain of action in which we are a part.
- 20:00It can be really easy to dismiss our existence
- 20:04as unnecessary, as small. But we honestly have
- 20:10no idea. In Andor, there are two alien fishermen
- 20:14checking their nets who give a ride to two strangers.
- 20:20They're just being kind. They have no idea what
- 20:24brought these men to them, and they have no idea
- 20:27what they will do. Someday, when they hear of
- 20:31the Death Star's destruction, they will still
- 20:34have no idea of the part they've played in such
- 20:37acts. They just helped two men in a desperate
- 20:41situation. This whole show is an exercise in
- 20:47dramatic irony. We know that every action of
- 20:52these characters, however insignificant, is the
- 20:56foundation to epic mythology. There are grand
- 21:01heroes saving the day because many Bothans died
- 21:05to bring us this information. But the thing I
- 21:09cannot stop thinking about, the reason I cannot
- 21:13stop talking about this prequel show to a prequel
- 21:17spinoff of a 50 -year -old film, is that we literally
- 21:20cannot have the perspective of dramatic irony
- 21:24in real life. We cannot know. And yet, we do.
- 21:35When my oldest child was a baby, we lived within
- 21:38walking distance to a Starbucks. She was so small,
- 21:42couldn't say anything, couldn't even walk yet.
- 21:46But she had the most beautiful smile. And I watched
- 21:50people come in to get their coffee, haggard,
- 21:54beleaguered. I don't know who any of them were,
- 21:58where they came from, what was happening in their
- 22:02lives. But my baby would smile at them. And I
- 22:07would watch their whole day change as they smiled
- 22:11back. By just being there, my baby touched so
- 22:17many lives. And she was there because I desperately
- 22:22needed to get out of the house. A single choice
- 22:25with tiny consequences. Part of a great chain
- 22:30of action. I don't know what that action led
- 22:35to, but it led to something. Every person is
- 22:42connected. Every person is necessary. Each one
- 22:48of us is affecting the other, tiny ripples spilling
- 22:53out into vast waves. Each one of us matters,
- 22:58not just the Luke Skywalkers. or the Princess
- 23:02Leia's, but the fisherman, and the bellhops,
- 23:07and the child who can do nothing but smile. And
- 23:14I hope that you remember that today. Thanks for
- 23:21coming.