Latest / Politics with Paul / Do Winning Candidates Have a Voter "Mandate"? | Politics with Paul #116
Transcript
- Paul Rader: Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of political science and civics. I'm your host, Paul Rader. Today is about whether winning candidates have a mandate, quote unquote, from the voters. A common refrain that candidates who win an election have, more so from presidents and governors, since they represent a wider range of people, but it's not just limited to them. These candidates use this refrain to justify attempts to implement all their policy views, this idea that they have a voter mandate. The logic goes that all the voters elected me, so they must like all my ideas to elect me, and so I must enact all my ideas into reality to be a good steward of the people's will. In other words, the candidate believes that their election victory means voters have chosen the candidate to do whatever. Ever the candidate wants to do policy-wise, and that they agree with everything they say, because why else would they choose them? And the parties as a whole do this a lot too when they get a big series of wins, such as when they capture the presidency and both chambers of Congress. And I find this line of thinking to be incredibly arrogant and one of the more grating things that politicians say or do when they win elections. It's something I've criticized multiple times. in this podcast and on social media. But it does speak to wider discussions on what it means to be representative of the will of the voters and holding election officials or elected officials accountable and how effective our system is at giving us sufficient choices when we go vote. So let's discuss this voter mandate in these contexts and what it means for American governance. And just what is the big deal about getting upset about this voter mandate idea. But first let's explore the idea of the voter mandate and why, specifically why it's such faulty logic. Because it doesn't hold up whether it is a close election, a blowout, a race with only one candidate, however you cut it up, it just does not make any sort of sense. It's very Nice to think about if you're the candidate who wins or you're somebody who thinks that this candidate that one can do no wrong. Yeah, of course you want to believe that they should do whatever they want to do because you're such a big fan of them, which can be its own problem. Or if you are that candidate, of course you want to be able to implement all your policy views. If you didn't believe in that policy view, you wouldn't espouse it. Well, I guess there are some politicians that lie about their policy views, but that's beside the point. This idea of a voter mandate just does not make sense. Let's look at it in a context of a close election victory. So maybe it's a five-point difference, the winning candidate won 52% to 47%. Or maybe it was just even a handful of votes. Maybe it was decided by four or five or six votes. That tight race suggests that there is considerable debate within the district as to who should win. If it's even a handful of votes deciding the winner, let's think for a moment about what if those votes never happened. Would the mandate have suddenly shifted to the second place candidate? So if the first guy won with 500 votes compares to the other guy with 495, and then suddenly ten of those votes disappeared, or suddenly the voter mandate completely the other way, and the candidate who didn't win but would have won if ten of those votes weren't there, suddenly now he or she have the mandate. It just it just doesn't make sense. Because clearly there are people that are voting against you. And just because somebody chose you doesn't mean that they want you to do everything you want. It's just that they think the other candidate is the worst candidate. Maybe that they don't hate the candidate they didn't vote for. They just don't think that they're a fit for the office. Whatever the case is does not mean that they want the person they voted for to do all the things that they That the candidate says they want to do. If there's a blowout victory, let's say if it's 90% to 10%, 95 to 5%, there are still people that didn't vote for you. And even if there were over even if there was overwhelming support in your favor does not mean that they all want you to do every single thing that you say you want to do. Or what if it's a one candidate race? Well, surely if there's only one person running and there's only one person you can choose, then that means all these people want the candidate to do everything they want to do. After all, If somebody else wanted to step up to the plate and oppose them, then they would have. Well, see, you're the only person, so people have to choose you unless they can protest with a write-in vote, which some people do. But also it having one candidate in the race is really it speaks more to a lack of desire for people to run for that position. And maybe that's because there's a lack of public awareness about that position. Some very local level races People have no idea that it's even there. It's not a total endorsement of the one person who does run. Or maybe they just didn't feel like they were specifically somebody who should run, but they were hoping somebody else would challenge for the position. And if that one candidate is heavily favored enough, it doesn't mean that everybody else supports them. It just means some people won't. Bother trying to compete because they just can't, whether they just don't have the name recognition or the money or the connections. No matter the results of an election, it is ridiculous to assume that everybody that voted for that winning candidate wants that candidate to do 100% of what they say they want to do. People constantly lament the lack of good choices in elections. Now, whether they are right or wrong about there not being good choices in a given contest. That's irrelevant for this discussion because if they feel that way about all candidates in a contest, then clearly they're not giving any of these candidates a mandate. Even with the parties becoming increasingly uniform over time, they still don't agree on everything. Democrats are thinking more and more like every Democrat does, and Republicans are thinking more and more like every Republican does. But there's still differences there. There are still liberal Republicans, there are still conservative Democrats. They're dwindling, but they are still there. And you, for example, this schism between socialist democrats and non-socialist democrats. At the end of the day, they both favor the same party, but they certainly don't agree on everything. Are socialists going to be giving a mandate to the non-socialist Democrat that they voted for? No. Are the non-socialist Democrats giving a mandate to the socialist democrats they voted for? No. They're voting for them because they're Democrats. And when The Republican Party was still starting to move towards Donald Trump. There were people who were never Trumpers, people who were very much against Donald Trump, and you still have a few of those, but they are mostly quiet. Most of them at the end of the day were gonna support a Republican too, but it even if they ultimately voted for Donald Trump, it wasn't a mandate. And also there's just too many issues that are involved in these elections for all the candidates' supporters to be one hundred percent on board with everything that candidate wants to do. And sometimes even strong supporters will let that candidate know, hey, I really don't want you to support or oppose this particular policy. They aren't necessarily gonna be on the same page about gun control, abortion, economy, LGBTQ issues, public safety in general. You can find all sorts of different avenues where they could have some difference, especially on these broadest of issues where there's a ton of nuance that seems to be conveniently ignored, the many facets of gun control or abortion, or the economy, which is probably the broadest issue that you can come up with. And even for the loud minority that seems like they're on board with 100% of what that candidate wants to do, they're a loud minority and They are very hyperpartisan and they participate more regularly in elections, but they are not the majority of people who ultimately support that candidate. And asserting a voter mandate, quote unquote, gets even more ridiculous when a candidate wins an election without even getting a majority of the vote, because a lot of elections, the winner gets the plurality and they don't have runoffs. Or you win. An election that has a low turnout. Even presidential elections in America struggle with voter turnout. So even if you win a majority of the vote of people who participate, there are still a ton of people who are registered voters that just don't bother to go vote at all for anybody. Or maybe they voted on other races, but they left their presidential choice blank. And also, how many times have we seen buyer's remorse? Where and voters swinging a different way the next election because they didn't get what they expected from a winning candidate. Now, whether they should have expected some of those policies from a candidate, that's beside the point. The point is they didn't give a mandate to that candidate. And certainly that mandate didn't last for all of those years by the time they could vote on that office again the next election because they were already tired of that candidate. But besides the theoretical aspect of whether that voter mandate idea holds up, the voter mandate doesn't work in practice either. Because no matter how much a candidate wants to implement all the policies they want, they don't get to. Not even presidents who control or whose party controls both chambers of Congress. Donald Trump, even with the US House and US Senate being Republican. He has not gotten everything that he wants, and he has very much let Republicans who have pushed back on him know about it and has eviscerated them often in the media. Barack Obama, every s so often, had issues with his party when the US House and the US Senate were Democratic. It's no guarantee even when you control both chambers of Congress, or if you're a governor and you control both your state and your party controls both the state house and the state senate. You still run into problems too. In Florida, despite it being despite the state government being solidly Republican over time, there have been several notable instances, even this year, for example, where Republicans In both state legislative chambers and Ronda Santis did not see eye to eye on certain things, more so both chambers of the state legislature. But Just because you have a unified government doesn't mean that you don't run into this issue. So anybody who wants to implement their supposed voter mandate just doesn't get to. Because even in a government that is dominated by one party, like many state governments are, you have to cut deals with other officials, especially if you are in the legislative branch. Now, if you are in the executive branch, like you're a president or you're a governor, whether you should or you shouldn't. You have the capability of running a little bit more roughshod on the legislative branch. Whereas if you're one legislator, it's a lot harder for you to try to run over other people, even if you're in a position of leadership, because if you push too hard, the rest of your party, the rest of that chamber can vote you out of that position of leadership. Legislators trade favors all the time. Like if you support my bill or provision for a bill. I'll pass one of yours. And that's not necessarily illegal. Now, there might be some quid pro quo that they do that's that's not legal, but that's not always the case. They d but they trade favors all the time. And if you are in a leadership position, you have to balance even more interests across even more policy areas. And if you try to be stubborn and just push all your policy beliefs no matter what, because you think you've got a voter mandate, you're not going to be effective. A lot of your bills you sponsor. Won't get passed. Others, even in your party, will hate you and they will act in retribution by killing amendments you support to other bills, sometimes just out of spite. They won't let your bills get to the floor to even be heard, which they need in order to actually even be voted on. They might give you the worst legislative committee assignments because they find you belligerent and obnoxious because you won't play ball, even if they are your own party. And then when you're not effective, Voters will say, well, you're not fighting for us. You're not getting anything done. W what's your record? You haven't gotten any bills passed. At least not anything that I care about. And then you'll likely lose the next election. And no matter how much you win by as a candidate, you represent a wide range of voters, not just the people that voted for you, constituents that didn't vote for you. And some candidates will pay lip service to that fact and they'll say, I represent everybody. I I won this election, but I represent everybody. Yet they'll still turn around and say that they have a voter mandate. But a lot of times that's just lip service. And since these other people didn't vote for you, you cannot possibly have a voter mandate because not everybody wants you to implement all your policies. And for the relatively few people that do want you to do whatever you want, well, they're also just not thinking hard enough. If they really thought about it, and they really actually tried to be thoughtful, they might push back on something that you support if you are one of these candidates that has this supposed voter mandate. But Getting past that theory and practicality portion, now let's look at those contexts we brought up in the intro. And first of all, I want to talk about voter mandates in the context of how representative of the will of the people government is when you have this idea of the voter mandate. And there are four models of representation. If you've seen a couple of previous episodes, you might be familiar with them, or even if you haven't, you might have heard them before. I talked about these in particular in episode eighty-seven and briefly in last week's episode, these four models of representation that are typically posited. Whether we believe in a voter mandate or not, we need to stack it up against these models of voter representation. So number one is the delegate model, which is the idea that the elected official is a direct mouthpiece for the constituents and should act strictly according to voters' beliefs. You also have number two the trustee model, which is the idea that the elected official is entrusted to use their own judgment and knowledge to make the best choice for constituents. Then you have the politico, the third one, which is a hybrid between delegate and trustee. So sometimes they act as a delegate, usually on high salience issues that constituents are highly invested in, and then other times they act as trustees, and that's typically these low salience, more technical issues that constituents aren't that invested in. And then You just have the simple number four partisan model, which is that the elected official is expected to vote and act along party lines. And they have all have shortcomings or holes. And I don't want to go too much into them, but in the context of voter mandates, some of them are particularly relevant. So for the delegate model, some of the issues are that there's a lot of different constituent opinions, and it's not always easy or possible to get full public opinion opinion. So which voters should the elected official cater to? And are the voters always going to be knowledgeable about the issue? the trustee model. Voters expect some measure of being directly listened to. After all, they voted for that elected official. So they want that official to somewhat act on their wishes at least. So when should the elected official be simply trusted to do the right thing? And can't a trustee's judgment and knowledge also be faulty? They're humans just like the voters are. The politico model How do you determine when an issue requires a delegate's touch versus a trustee's touch? When do you find this line between this is a high salience issue versus a low salience issue, this is a more technical issue, this is a less technical issue, this issue is that has more investment from the electorate versus this one? And couldn't this be seen more as elected officials being calculating and trying to tow the line for election purposes? An N partisan model. Hyperpartisanship is one of the biggest reasons American politics is in the mess that it's in. And it outright it outright disregards the losing segments of your pop population. The one and by losing segments means the ones who didn't vote for you, who typically are a different partisan affiliation. So if you're a Republican, it's Democrats and independents and third parties. And if you're a Democrat, it's Republicans and independents and third parties. And when you stack these models of representation up against this idea of the voter mandate, it might sound like the delegate model because delegates do all the that the voters want. And according to the voter mandate idea, the voters want the delegate to or want want the elected official to do what the elected official wants. But then one could argue that it's the trustee model in disguise, because the voters want the candidate to do all that the candidate wants to do. So it depends on the lens that you look at it through. And depending on what that candidate or elected official wants to do, they might start employing what looks more like the politico model or the partisan model. When you start to get into this voter mandate, besides, implementing all of the the elected official wants to do, can that possibly change throughout their that elected official's tenure where they start to get more information or they find that one side of an issue is more politically expedient and they start to change their views then? Now that voter mandate can start looking like several different models of representation there. And is it the candidates and elected officials being led by the voters, or are the voters being led by the candidate? So just like how the voter mandate idea has its flaws, so do all of these models of representation. But these are models, they're not meant to explain every single instance. And now let's think about voter mandates in the context of whether we have sufficient choices in elections, which a lot of people think we don't. What if you're the only candidate in the race? Well, that's the complete opposite of choice. It's more like a Hobson's choice. You either take this candidate or you leave it. It's just you gotta accept it or you just sit it out, unless you get the chance to write in somebody, which you don't always. But it doesn't mean everybody supports you, especially if it's a more local race. A lot of people may not know about it. They may not be interested in the race. They may not think that they have the technical know-how. that comes with that race, with that office. And some people may want to run for that position, but they think they have no shot against it or no shot at it against the one candidate who runs, because they aren't as well known, they aren't as well funded, etc. But then even if you have more than one candidate, that doesn't mean there are enough choices to represent the span of interest in a district, state, or the whole country is two enough. Is three enough? Is four, five, six sixty? Consider the fact that there are a lot of independent voters in this country, yet there are few independent candidates that run or have a realistic shot at winning. And you also have these primary systems that are often designed to hamper candidates outside the two main parties and even candidates in the two main parties that can't hope to compete. And ballot access is often onerous to these kinds of candidates, even being up for a vote in the first place, let alone. getting on the ballot and then being able to generate enough noise that people pay attention to them and think that they have a shot. But what about multi-member districts? Those tend to have a lot more candidates just because there are more seats available. And these districts are you live in a district and there's actually multiple seats that you can vote on. So typically you actually get more than one vote. So if it's a multimember district that has three seats up, you typically will have three votes to cast. amongst that list of candidates. So multimember districts and state legislatures, which aren't common. They're quite uncommon. And Louisiana's unique majority vote system where if you for people run to the primary and if you have more than fifty percent of the vote, you automatically win that election. But if nobody wins fifty percent of the vote, the top two vote getters then move on to a runoff. Those often have more candidates running. But that doesn't always mean enough distinct choices either. Sometimes it's still just Democrats and Republicans running, and they mostly band together anyways, and people people will just vote for all the Republicans together and all the Democrats together, unless there happens to be too many that you could possibly vote for. But even then That's not necessarily distinct choices. And because votes are split up even more across this higher number of candidates, even though you tend to be able to vote for more candidates as well, it further erodes this credibility of the voter mandate argument. So no matter how many people run, whether it's one candidate or one hundred, you cannot possibly have a true voter mandate. And then lastly, maybe the most important aspect of this conversation is when it comes to government accountability. It's an incredibly arrogant, obnoxious, cocky idea to think that winning an election means the electorate is giving you the keys to implement all the things you want. It doesn't hold up theoretically, it doesn't hold up in practice, but it's also problematic because it's largely driven by ego. And political political incentive. It behooves winning candidates to act like they have this huge momentum on their side that all these people are supporting me, so why shouldn't you? And it's this way to try to convince other voters and politicians that don't agree with that candidate that they should get in line. Otherwise, you're gonna get left behind. And for the more rabid partisans and ideologues that vigorously back that candidate, not to mention major donors, you are incentivized if you are this candidate to not concede any ground to opposition. Because even if you, as this candidate, don't really want to put out this idea of a voter mandate, you have all these other people that support you that want you to grind other people into the dust. And that You should be telling them they need to get in line. And any politician can fall for this trap. Doesn't matter if you're a Democrat, doesn't matter if you're a Republican, doesn't matter if you're an independent, anybody can fall into this trap. Even independents who are generally more nebulous than Republicans or Democrats. If any one of us thinks that we can't fall into this trap, it's just that that's also arrogant, but also it's just not true. And that's not to be cynical, and that's not to say, that we're all selfish people. That's not what that means. It's just you have to acknowledge how human nature can get the best of any of us, no matter how good natured we are. But while it's smug and cocky for an elected official to believe they have this mandate from the voters to do whatever they want, what if we, as the voters, have not pushed back enough on the idea? Yes, these politicians that say they have a voter mandate, they have a responsibility to not act in that fashion, to not say that they have this kind of mandate. It's something that they have to be held accountable for too. But we also have to hold ourselves accountable by saying, well, have we actually sufficiently pushed back on politicians? Have we allowed politicians to claim a voter mandate for too long? Because whenever a politician uses those words, or not those specific words, but they might use some sort of language that clearly clearly indicates that they think the voters want them to enact all their policy views, who pushes back on them? It's mostly the most ardent opponents of that candidate. But they're not doing it because they or a lot of them are not actually pushing back on that candidate because they truly believe that they're saying or behaving in a way that is unbecoming. of an elected official. They're pushing back on that candidate because they don't like that candidate or they don't like that candidate's viewpoints. Because they didn't vote for that candidate. Much more rarely does this pushback come from supporters of that candidate claiming the voter mandate and more irregular voters. Because too often we don't criticize members of our in group for things unless we really have to Or there is incentive for us. Or we'll say, well, that's not representative of our group very dismissively. And that's true for every political group there is. And every one of us can fall into that trap. True accountability comes when we are willing to critique our own favored groups and people. Not just people we dislike, not just people we don't agree with. It comes from when we are willing to push back against people we otherwise support. It's like that idea of how a true friend is going to tell you how things are, tell you, tells you like it is. There is something similar to that when it comes to supporting these candidates. Where there's this just like there's this incentive for politicians to say that they have a voter mandate when they win, there's also an incentive for us to not push back on them when. They are somebody we otherwise support. And that's okay to s it's to support them. But if they start to think like they can just do whatever they want, or that they were told by the voters that they can do whatever they want, we should hold them accountable for that. We should tell them, hold hold up a second. You need to take a step back. This is not what that means. You have a lot of people that you have to represent. And even the people who did who did support you, they don't want you to do everything that you did. Lots of people, quote unquote, hold their nose whenever they vote for somebody. Or even if they're not holding their nose, but they're like, I'm not really enthused about his or her opinion on XYZ issue. Happens all the time. And you really if you aren't disagreeing with at least one thing that that candidate says they support. Or you don't at least partially disagree with at least one thing, then you're probably aren't thinking hard enough. You're just going with the flow and you're not really trying to think things through. So let's try holding all politicians, regardless of our views, regardless of who we support, accountable when they claim they have a voter mandate. Recognize when it happens, especially when they don't actually use the word mandate, because it might be a little less obvious. But basically you can get a sense of th from their words whether they think that they're that they should just be able to run roughshot over people or that people aren't really going to stand up to them or that people shouldn't stand up to them. And even if you voted for this person, make sure they know they do not have free reign and that there will be people that truly will hold them accountable no matter what their policies are, will say you do not have a mandate to do whatever you want. And it's also very arrogant to think that you've got everything figured out that you should implement all your policy views. Yes, you have these views because you are You're not going to hold these views if you don't actually believe in them. At least you would expect that they're not going to hold a view or say that they hold a view that they don't hold. Some politicians can lie about that. That's beside the point. But regardless, if they say that, well, I'm going to be able to do whatever I want because the people want me to, it's never the case. We should always push back on that. There is one other thing I should point out. despite all my grievances about this idea about voter mandates, maybe you don't think it's a big deal. Maybe you don't like it either, but you don't have such a Visceral reaction to when somebody says that they have a mandate or that voters want them to do all the things they want to do. So what's what's the big deal about saying that you have a voter mandate? You might be thinking, so what if a politician's flapping their gums about what the voters supposedly entrusted them to do? They're just they're just getting lost in a moment. They're just wanting to fire up their supporters. It's like whenever your favorite sports team wins and you just get lost and you're talking all this trash to everybody else. It doesn't necessarily mean you mean it. You're just Just getting caught up in everything and all the fanfare. But words and actions mean more when you are an elected official. Even when it's something that seems innocuous, that seems like it's not a big deal. The importance is heightened because you are an elected official. You are automatically supposed to be held to a higher standard. Fairly, of course, you shouldn't just pick and choose who you hold to a higher standard because of their political opinions. But every elected official is supposed to be held to a higher standard. Their words and their actions should be more scrutinized. Now that doesn't mean we have to react strongly to everything they say or do. We these days we react way too strongly to everything. Everything's a crisis. Not saying that this is a crisis here. But many times this assertion of a voter mandate is an insight into what an elected official really thinks and feels. It doesn't matter that they're euphoric about winning their election. It doesn't matter if they want to talk a little trash or whatever the case may be. We have enough of a problem where politicians say things and think they shouldn't be held accountable for them. Or they try to hide what they've said so that they're not held accountable. There's enough arrogance in politics, and if we don't push back on them more, they're going to keep trying to cross the line. And we need to push back on them equally across the board. Because no, pushing back on those we don't agree with is not enough. That's expected. That's not actual accountability. Because you're just doing it because of the difference in views, not what proper behavior and language should be. And so we should push back more on this assertion of voter mandates to keep these egos in check, to make sure elected officials don't overstep their bounds. Or at least they think twice before they do it. Words and actions matter. And we should be more equal in how we hold politicians accountable for their words and actions across the board. You do not have a voter mandate ever. A lot of voters may want you to do all the things you say you want to do, sure, but you have a lot of people that you have to represent. From the people who are your most ardent supporters, to the people who are generally enthused about you but don't like everything you have to say, to people that hold their nose and vote for you, to people who might even just be voting on a whim. And if it was another day, they might not vote for you, but today they will vote for you. And then all of the people that are against you, whether it's just a little bit, whether it's a lot, whether it's Completely would never consider you. All those people are your constituents when you are an elected official for that district or that state or for the country. And don't ever forget it. And us as voters, we shouldn't never forget that either. When we win, quote unquote, there are other people who didn't succeed. It doesn't mean that they shouldn't ever be listened to. Doesn't mean you need to implement everything that they want to, but they should be listened to because when the shoe is on the other foot. Shouldn't you expect a little bit of respect in return? Maybe we can all do with a little bit more respect both for others and expecting it back. And that's going to end things for today's episode of the Politics with Paul podcast. As always, thank you so much for listening. Please please like, comment, share, subscribe wherever you are listening to this, and every little bit of support helps. my links in the show notes, my five-day educational email course about how we can all more effectively mitigate toxic polarization, a lot of the mistakes we make when it comes to trying to Depolarize politics that can actually accidentally make polarization worse, my book on political independence, my other writings on medium.com, and then my other links: my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my website, and my email. So thank you again for listening. And we will see you next time.