Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Is It Realistic To Expect A Quarterback Signee To Ever Become A Starter?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with tub or tub. How's it going, Oh, Tony,
- 0:12it's good. We're in early February now, which is typically a completely
- 0:17dead time, and yet again there's more stuff to talk about with the Ohio
- 0:21State football program and college football in general. And I am starting to think
- 0:27that the sport with the shortest actual season of any major North American sport is
- 0:33the only one that does not actually have an off season. What what is
- 0:38the off season is? It? May like, is it July? July
- 0:44is when July is when all the coaches go on vacation after the camps are
- 0:47done. That's when the coaches go on vacation for like the first three weeks
- 0:52of j Yeah, because then it's basically last week at June after the camps.
- 0:57Fourth of July week. You maybe get one more after that one after
- 1:00that, and then boom, we're talking about big ten media days and all
- 1:04that starting around July twentieth or so, and then boom, this season's going.
- 1:08So it's like the three weeks at the end of June and early July
- 1:12I think is really about as close as you get because there are still official
- 1:17visits in June, if I recall, and so maybeah, I guess that's
- 1:23why some head coaches are trying to become coordinators or go off to the NFL.
- 1:29But so yeah, a lot has happened. We talked to Ryan Day
- 1:33on Wednesday for over an hour and time when I covered a lot of that
- 1:37on Thursday's Buckeyestborrow Warning Show. It's funny to try to recap over an hour
- 1:45of things that Ryan Day says in like thirty or forty minutes, and I
- 1:49don't know that we've ever had him for that long, for over an hour.
- 1:53You know, we've seen like forty five minute scheduled appointments like get in
- 1:59the big media days that's that's a forty five minute thing. Or sometimes his
- 2:04pressers weekly will go forty or something like that. But this was a full
- 2:07hour and there was plenty to talk about. One of the things that we
- 2:10did not touch on at first no news on Bill Obrien as we are recording
- 2:15this, but let's discuss dominic kirks. We didn't get a chance to do
- 2:20that. The lone signee yesterday for our High State just the worst February signing
- 2:25Day, perhaps in school history, only one guy, but a guy that
- 2:30they wanted and kind of needed to fill out the defensive line class as much
- 2:35as they could, and Ohio and who just it was interesting to follow this
- 2:40live on signing Day back in December, where kept hitting Twitter looking for Dominant
- 2:46Kirks and the people who are covering Washington to see if the letter F and
- 2:52ten come in yet and just never did. And you know, Mark's on
- 2:54the fire like, oh, it looks like he's gonna hold off, and
- 2:58so you're you're putting two and two together and Tom four has happened for sure.
- 3:04Four finally happened, and even more specifically than four to three happened,
- 3:08which is the three defensive line lineman that they added to this class. Wednesday
- 3:15was National Signing Day, which I literally forgot it was National Signing Day until
- 3:19about halfway through the press conference when someone asked to Dominic Kirks and I went,
- 3:23oh, yeah, that's right, I forgot. That's this day that
- 3:25used to be the tent pole of the college football offseason is now essentially forgotten
- 3:31because all the signings happened on early signing Day for the most part. And
- 3:35there was a point on early signing Day while we were sitting in that very
- 3:38same room talking to Ryan Day, just as we were on Wednesday, when
- 3:42on early signing Day it looked like, Okay, they've got Eric Mensa,
- 3:45who's the defensive tackle they flip from Virginia Tech, and that might be it.
- 3:50They had had Justin Scott flip his commitment to Miami. They had other
- 3:53guys who they thought Marquise Lightfoot for example, who they thought they might get
- 3:57who ended up going to Miami. And there were some real legitimate questions around
- 4:01Edward Houston whether he was going to sign with Ohio State or Alabama. And
- 4:05you know, there was a point on early signing Day when it was it
- 4:10looked like Ohio State might get just one defensive lineman in this class, and
- 4:15that was going to be a real disaster for them, and to sort of
- 4:17salvage it with adding Edward Houston or maintaining keeping Edward Houston, I guess on
- 4:24early signing Day, and then saving you know, saving the fact that they
- 4:28were kind of swooping in late and landing Dominic Kirks as well. All of
- 4:31a sudden, this goes from a class that you know, Mark, Mark
- 4:34and Kevin did a show where they were grading the classes that would have been
- 4:38an F class to only get one guy in for the whole position group to
- 4:43save that and then I think it ended up about a B or something like
- 4:46that in their grades. That's that's pretty darn good. That is That is
- 4:49getting your you know, getting your big report in right under the deadline by
- 4:54the end of the quarter and then boom it shows up as a bee when
- 4:57the report card gets shows up in the mail and Mom and Dad none the
- 5:00wiser Dominic Clark or Dominic k Kirks rather six four two fifty five something like
- 5:06that. A tweeterer in terms of where he will end up. I know
- 5:10Marcus calling him a tackle, so we'll see how that goes. But you
- 5:15get he had a defensive ended Edric Houston defensive tackle and Eric Mens and a
- 5:18guy who I've compared to like Draymond Jones, who was a high school defensive
- 5:24end grew into a tackle but was a talented pass rusher as an interior guy.
- 5:30Maybe that's what Dominic Kirks will become down the road. So that was
- 5:35the recruiting portion of signing day for Ohio State back to Bill O'Brien. As
- 5:42we still wait on this, the other name that keeps coming up with is
- 5:46if Bill O'Brien leaves is Chip Kelly. And one of the things I wanted
- 5:53to say Tom is that when Ryan Day was talking about Bill O'Brien yesterday and
- 5:58talking about all of the things that he did for has already done for the
- 6:01program in terms of coming in and looking at terminology, evaluating talent, seeing
- 6:08how Ohio State does things and why they do things, and why don't you
- 6:12do it these this way? Why don't you do this this way? That's
- 6:15all incredibly valuable for Ohio State and Ryan Day. But if they do lose
- 6:21Bill O'Brien, I think you can get the same thing from Chip Kelly,
- 6:26who has seen a bunch of stuff like he can come in and say why
- 6:30is it this way? I like this, this is good. We can
- 6:31enhance this. So the the hire of Bill O'Brien, it's not a long
- 6:35term thing for Ohio State, If they had to go to Chip Kelly,
- 6:39wouldn't be a long term thing for for Ohio State. To me, I
- 6:43kind of view it as just bringing in somebody to audit the program, and
- 6:48how's it looking, what would you like, what do you like, what
- 6:50do you don't like? And also both of those guys really good play callers,
- 6:56so I know it would be bride Day does not want to lose Bill
- 7:00O'Brien, and nobody has said that Chip Kelly is the next guy. And
- 7:03I know there are people who are for it who are against it. I
- 7:08just think you could get a lot of the same stuff from Chip Kelly that
- 7:10you get from Bill O'Brien. Well, if you're trying to bring in a
- 7:14veteran play caller who's sort of seen it all over the last ten to fifteen
- 7:18years and has been around the game and is going to bring in sort of
- 7:23that veteran presence and the guy up in the press box who can be the
- 7:27Kevin Wilson replacement. These are all guys who are you know, Kevin Wilson,
- 7:32Bill O'Brien, Chip Kelly. Those are all guys who have I mean
- 7:35different backgrounds, but also not that different backgrounds. You know, Kevin Wilson
- 7:41was a spread run guy with the background at Northwestern in Oklahoma, and he
- 7:44had been a head coach had a Power five program in Indiana. Chip Kelly
- 7:48Spread, you know, Spread largely run a based offense, who had been
- 7:54a Power five coach at Oregon. I think you're sort of filling the same
- 8:00basic role there, and different guys have different strengths and all that. And
- 8:03you know, Chip Kelly is such an interesting name to have around this because
- 8:09number one, he is literally a sitting Big ten head coach as we speak.
- 8:11And I think there's been plenty of, you know, plenty of reporting
- 8:15about the fact that he's not happy with some of the things that have happened
- 8:18at UCLA and they had, you know, he had a very very good
- 8:22offense in twenty twenty two. I think they were fifth in the country and
- 8:24rushing or something like that. He has had some really really good offenses there.
- 8:28And then it is just sort of, you know, a lot of
- 8:31the other stuff that people are not thrilled with in NIL and some of the
- 8:35boosters there and is he getting the support that he wants and needs and all
- 8:39that kind of stuff. You have some of those frustrations sort of maybe driving
- 8:43him potentially driving him to switch positions, switch jobs, giving up a position
- 8:48as a coach head coach at a prestigious university in one of the really two
- 8:54power conferences that are left. That's not a position you would think guys would
- 8:58give up. Jeff Hafley. Walking away from Boston College is one thing,
- 9:01walking away from UCLA is quite another. But he may just sort of be
- 9:05in the fresh start kind of mold, and he was. He's been linked
- 9:09to some NFL positions as well, so we'll see. But Tony beyond just
- 9:13the head coaching, you know, head coach to offensive coordinator thing, which
- 9:18we've seen MAC coaches do and we've seen you know, Sean Lewis just just
- 9:24left. Sean Lewis left Kent State and got you know, things like that.
- 9:31Beyond that, you have this interpersonal dynamic where Charles Charles Kelly, which
- 9:37is what it says on his birth certificate, Chip Kelly is what he what
- 9:39it says when everyone talks about him, Chip Kelly. He is, you
- 9:45know, was sort of a mentor for Ryan Day and is you know,
- 9:46close to Ryan Day. So Ryan Day came up under Chip Kelly as a
- 9:52young assistant. So now you'd be sort of flipping the roles there and Ryan
- 9:56Day would be the head coach and Chip Kelly would be the assistant. You
- 10:01know, they are much more familiar with the dynamics of their relationship and friendship
- 10:03than I am. But I think that certainly is an interesting dynamic to you
- 10:09know, if Bill O'Brien does leave and if chip Kelly is the guy,
- 10:13I think that's certainly going to be an interesting interpersonal relationship to see those roles
- 10:18kind of flip. It will be in how they not just get along,
- 10:24but that outside view, the language where sometimes the difference of it is good.
- 10:31The perspective and things like that is good. How different are they?
- 10:35You know, if Rian Day has come from chip Kelly's tree, how different
- 10:41would they be Because you do want some ability to be seamless, but you
- 10:46also want some ability to grow. And it'll be interesting to see how that
- 10:50goes in terms of what he could bring to Ohio State, like he is
- 10:54one of the great offensive minds in college football over the last twenty years,
- 11:00even the last four years at UCLA. The last two years the Bruins have
- 11:03led to big the Pac twelve and rushing the two years before that they were
- 11:07first or second, so they have that going for them, and they led
- 11:11to Pac twelve in rushing this year with some iffy quarterback play and Ohio State
- 11:16looking for some improvement in the running game, which I think they will have
- 11:20regardless of who the offensive coordinator is. The rest of the coaching staff Tom
- 11:28I thought it was interesting. We talked a little bit about this on the
- 11:33morning show that Ryan Day, talking about the assistant coaches and the abilities all
- 11:39of the everything that you have available to you at Ohio State, whether it's
- 11:41talent, just the resources and resources for the players. They said that if
- 11:50you can't do it at Ohio State, you can't do it anywhere. And
- 11:52that's what he tells his assistant coaches. If you can't do it at Ohio
- 11:54State, you can't do it anywhere. And then you see, it's just
- 12:01like the Peter principal where guys reach a certain level and they can't go above
- 12:05that and they should be knocked back down. Because when you fire coaches or
- 12:07you don't let them, you've declined to resign them or anything, you're pretty
- 12:16much confirming that, well, I thought you could do it here, but
- 12:20you can't, and you're kind of kind of dissing yourself. Basically, I
- 12:26hired that guy and he wasn't able to do it. But is he wrong
- 12:30when he says that because you look Parker Fleming as of yet, I don't
- 12:33think has a job Perie ell Yano. We'll get a job, I assume,
- 12:37but he has not yet. Now, this all may come after signing
- 12:41day because coaches meetings, coach the conference happened a few weeks back, but
- 12:46there may be some movement after signing day. But what do you think about
- 12:50that? Is he wrong when he says that if you can't do it at
- 12:54Hwai State, you can't do it anywhere. I think you're as set up
- 12:58for success at Ohio State as you are anywhere in the country. I mean
- 13:03there you maybe have places where you want to say it's incrementally more, incrementally
- 13:07less, like Alabama or Georgia over the last decade or something like that.
- 13:11Sure, I mean you might be as set up for success as you are
- 13:15at those places. But if you can't do it with the talent you have
- 13:20at Ohio State, and not just the this guy can go up and catch
- 13:22the football, but also the way Ohio State recruits with a focus on character,
- 13:28with a focus on you know, makeup and discipline and work ethic and
- 13:33all that kind of stuff. You know, if you can't make Marvin Harrison
- 13:37a successful wide receiver, Well, you're probably not going to be able to
- 13:41do it with someone who's not quite as good and not quite as driven and
- 13:45all that kind of stuff. You know, Brian Hartline, for whatever portion
- 13:48of Marvin Harrison's career you want to give Brian Hartline credit for, Brian Hartline
- 13:52has earned every bit of that credit. And you've seen it with so many
- 13:54other guys that you look at Brian Hartline and go, yeah, that guy.
- 13:58That guy definitely can do it at Ohio State, and I could probably
- 14:01do it just about anywhere else he went. If you are not able to
- 14:05do it at Ohio State, working with the level of talent you have,
- 14:09working with the level of resources you have, whether we're talking about strength,
- 14:13conditioning, nutrition, just resources in terms of facilities, whatever it is,
- 14:20if you can't do it there, I think Brian days exactly right. If
- 14:22you can't do it there, you really can't do it anywhere. And as
- 14:24you were talking, I was sort of thinking through in my head how many
- 14:28guys who have not done it at Ohio State have gone on and done it
- 14:31and really succeeded and thrived in some place subsequent to that cause you know,
- 14:37you go back and it's like, sure, Nick Saban. Nick Saban did
- 14:39not do it at Ohio State and it turned out to be pretty okay.
- 14:43Pete Carroll did not do it at Ohio State and turned out to be pretty
- 14:45okay. That's forty years ago. So more recently, I don't know.
- 14:50Do you want to put Tim Beck in this success pile. I'm not sure
- 14:54I do. He's a head coach now at Coastal Carolina. He didn't do
- 14:56it at Ohio State. But go through the you know, the the the
- 15:00offensive or defensive assistants who've been let go or encouraged to go. Look somewhere
- 15:05else. Go through the last decade and tell me how many of the guys
- 15:09who didn't leave on their own have been wildly successful other places. I mean,
- 15:16Bill Davis, Tavor Johnson. You know, Kerry Combs I think is
- 15:18doing okay. Cary Combs's issue was never as a position coach. It was
- 15:22as a coordinator. So carry Combs has resumed being a good position coach.
- 15:26Matt Barnes I don't think is done tremendously at Memphis. Ed warrener never really
- 15:33you know, he ed Warner when he was at Michigan, was still using
- 15:35recruiting graphics with all of his Ohio State players on them, you know,
- 15:39Tim Beck. I mean, who else? Who am I missing? I
- 15:43mean there's just been Al Washington. Al Washington left Ohio State and you know,
- 15:48sort of left Ohio State of his own volition, got to got to
- 15:52Notre Dame, forgot to count, how to forgot how to count to four,
- 15:54and now might be a finalist for the Boston College job. I mean,
- 15:58is there anyone I'm missing? I'm just kind of trying to do this
- 16:00off the top of my head. But you know, you've got a lot
- 16:03of a lot of guys who were former Ohio State assistant coaches who are now
- 16:08doing like what we're doing right now, and it's like, well, that's
- 16:11probably not a you know, tremendously huge validation. Yeah, Matt Barnes is
- 16:17now also the co defensive coordinator in the safeties, coach a Mississippi State after
- 16:21two years o Memphis, which were you know, not spectacular and you know,
- 16:26not even in terms of maybe Greg Chiano, but he was well established
- 16:32before, so I don't even know that that really, you know, And
- 16:34then is it I was wondering is this a and internal hires versus external hires.
- 16:40But all of the names you mentioned have both been internal and external.
- 16:42Like this year, Corey Dennis and Parker Fleming both internal. Corey Dennis ends
- 16:48up grabbing an analyst role at Utah, which you are the quarterbacks coach at
- 16:53Ohio State. That should lead to something more significant, and you know,
- 17:00if you compare it to you know, Nixa Siliano back in two thousand and
- 17:03eight nine whenever, like he I don't know that he ever showed up with
- 17:08another coaching job. But also Perry Aliano was an external hire and he only
- 17:14lasted two years or one year or whatever it was, And so I don't
- 17:18know that it really I don't know if there's a correlation between internal external.
- 17:22Sometimes sometimes you just get things wrong and nobody's perfect and they're hiring Nick Saban
- 17:27has never been perfect, and his coaching hiring sometimes he's knocked it out of
- 17:32the park and sometimes he hasn't. It's just and urban Meyer the same thing.
- 17:36When you consider his first coaching staff. We won't go into all of
- 17:41the names, but defensively he had Everett Withers and Sheridan and Bill Sheridan and
- 17:48Bill Sheridan lasted a month and a half and Evert Withers that was not a
- 17:52very good defense those those couple of years with him as the defensive coordinator.
- 17:56So you know, you don't always get these things right. Obviously, the
- 18:02key, I think Tom is to know what you've got it wrong. And
- 18:06that was also something Ryan Day talked about on Wednesday that at Ohio State,
- 18:11when you lose, people tend to overreact, and so part of his job
- 18:15is not overreacting, it's just reacting, and so it can look like he's
- 18:19being a little patient. At times are overly patient, and sometimes they are
- 18:25also extenuating extenuating circumstances, like Kerry Combs as a defensive coordinator during a COVID
- 18:30year, You're like, how much is this bad defense on him? When
- 18:34your secondary your safeties are Marcus Williamson and Marcus Hooker, Like is this bad
- 18:41play calling? No, not entirely, But then you get to the next
- 18:44year you're like, you know, I didn't. I wasn't feeling good about
- 18:48it last year. Now this has confirmed it, just like Ryan Day finally
- 18:51had confirmation last year that I need to stop calling plays. How do you
- 18:56think he does that knowing when it's time, because the Perry Aliando thing seems
- 19:00pretty quick, the Parker Fleming thing seems very nuts. Yeah, I mean,
- 19:07and you can put Corey Dennis in there. And Corey Dennis was a
- 19:11five year assistant. He was the quarterbacks coach for Ohio State for five years.
- 19:15And I think it was very hard from the outside to know how much
- 19:21credit does Corey Dennis deserve for the fact that Justin Fields looks like Justin Fields
- 19:25and c J. Stroud looks like c J. Stroud. And you know,
- 19:29is he responsible for the fact that Kyle McCord doesn't look like those two
- 19:32guys or is that just Kyle McCord's issue, or you know, because you've
- 19:36got Ryan Day, who is a quarterback guy by trade, you have Todd
- 19:38Fitch, who is but works behind the scenes and is a name that I
- 19:41think a lot of Ohio State fans would know, but he is someone who
- 19:45is significant in the development and recruitment of quarterbacks. So you know, how
- 19:51much do you want to assign to Corey Dennis in terms of credit or blame
- 19:55for the quarterback position? And I never really had an answer for that.
- 20:00And sometimes I feel like you have to wait to see, Okay, what
- 20:03does the industry think of this person when the person is on the open market
- 20:07and when you go when you're an analyst, you go from being the quarterbacks
- 20:11coach at Ohio State for five years and you're not an offensive coordinator in the
- 20:15MAC or even the offensive coordinator at Indiana or a lower level con you know,
- 20:21go be the offensive coordinator at Texas Tech whatever. Like Picke at Georgia
- 20:25Tech, his alma mater. He didn't get any of those jobs. He
- 20:29was on the market for what like a month, give or take, So
- 20:32it was you know that that to me is kind of like, okay,
- 20:34that's sort of an interesting, interesting barometer on the return there. But he
- 20:41was there for five years, so you know, is that too quick?
- 20:44Is that not quick enough? Because the results were good, but you know,
- 20:47not consistent. Then you've got a factor in the how the other positions
- 20:51on this coaching staff factor and you only have ten of them. So yeah,
- 20:55Eliano felt quick. Parker Fleming, you know, a year ago,
- 20:59felt like, why on the good Lord's Green Earth is this guy getting a
- 21:03two year contract extension based on what? And so yeah, it's I think
- 21:08it's something that every coach goes through. You look at Alabama and you know
- 21:12Nick Saban, greatest coach of all time. No one knows defense like Nick
- 21:15Saban. He called he hired Pete Golding as his defensive coordinator and it was
- 21:19a disaster. And so if Nick Saban can't get a defensive coordinator, hire
- 21:23right one hundred percent of time. No one's going to do that. So
- 21:26I think it's unfair to expect a coach to always get it right. I
- 21:30think you have seen over the years, Ryan Day was willing to cut bait
- 21:33on some folks when the Urban Meyer to Ryan Day transition happened. He's been
- 21:38willing to cut bait on some other folks, you know, at different times,
- 21:45with Kerry Collums for example, So Matt Barnes. So you know,
- 21:48I think in the midst of a game people want someone fired in the middle
- 21:53of the third quarter. It's like, well, that's never gonna happen.
- 21:56You're not gonna You're not going to hire a new defensive coordinator from outside the
- 21:59program in the middle of the season. That's stupid. No one would,
- 22:03you know, no one with any sense would suggest that. But it's easy
- 22:07to be upset and mad about something in the middle of a game and think,
- 22:08Okay, why have you not done it yet? But at this point,
- 22:12I think you've seen enough changes that he's not Kirk ference He's not just
- 22:18going to be wetted to the exact same coaching staff for fifteen years in a
- 22:22row. That's you know, he's not that. He's not George Steinbrenner firing
- 22:26manager four times in the middle of the season. But he's not Kirk Ferrens
- 22:29either. So at this point I think you have to kind of give Ryan
- 22:32Day credit for making the move that he feels like he has to make when
- 22:37he feels like he has to make him and you know, we'll we'll see
- 22:41how he finishes, you know, finishes up the this hiring cycle, because
- 22:45he currently has one opening and might have a second. Yeah, well,
- 22:48in terms of firing a coach mid game, mid third quarter, we will
- 22:55see what happens when there is a head coach Keevon Pope and if things go
- 23:00poorly at any point in the game, what happens there And if dare to
- 23:06dream if something like that where to happen, Just remember Tony, it's filled
- 23:11with two seeds. Thank you. Tom. Now here's I think that's gonna
- 23:22be maybe the topic the title of the show, because here's a question that
- 23:25I have for you. I've been thinking about this. Is it realistic anymore
- 23:30to expect the quarterback that you sign in as signing class to ever start for
- 23:36your school with the need to have one every year, the transfer portal,
- 23:44the nil space, is it ever realistic to say, hey, Ohio State
- 23:49signed two guys this year. It's is it realistic to say that Julian's saying
- 23:53is going to start at Ohio State ever become a starting quarterback? Because if
- 23:59you go back every quarterback that Ohio State has signed under Ryan Day he signed
- 24:04going into and we're not gonna count the two. This year, he signed
- 24:07seven quarterbacks who have had an opportunity to win a starting job. Two of
- 24:14those guys have won starting job c J. Stroud and Kyle McCord. Of
- 24:18his seven quarterbacks, it's unlikely that both of the guys that he signed this
- 24:25year will do so. And so you just look at the way the game
- 24:30is. You look at all of the transferport transfer portal quarterbacks. If you
- 24:33go through and maybe this is a summer project, the top twenty quarterbacks in
- 24:38each class over the last shoot, maybe ten years, how many of them
- 24:44finished their career at that school? Because if we're talking top twenty quarterbacks,
- 24:49how many finished at their school? I'm guessing less than fifty percent? Am
- 24:56I is that wrong? And back to the other question, Tom, I'll
- 24:59let you go, But is it realistic? Well, let's start with the
- 25:06broader question about number that'll finish their careers at their school. I'm doing this
- 25:11for memory, so I'm probably not exactly right. But as of a year
- 25:15or two ago, if you went back and looked at like the twenty twenty
- 25:18recruiting class, twenty nineteen recruiting class, of the top ten quarterbacks in the
- 25:22class, I think two of them were still at the school where they had
- 25:27initially signed. That's amazing when you think about it, because these are supposed
- 25:33to be the best of the best, And if you signed the number six
- 25:36quarterback in the class, you're looking at that person and saying this is going
- 25:41to be a two year starter and then a top ten pick in the NFL
- 25:45draft. Like that's just sort of the assumption, and it, you know,
- 25:48it very rarely gets to happily. Ever after there I mean, Yet
- 25:52it happened for CJ. Stroud, it did not happen for Justin Fields,
- 25:56it did not happen for Kyle McCord. Is very very rare that that really
- 26:03does happen. And it's quite possible that Ohio State's quarterback this year will be
- 26:07Will Howard and they won't be someone who started his career at Ohio State.
- 26:11I think broadly based on how you know, based on the patience level of
- 26:17quarterbacks. If you're going into your third year and you're not a starter,
- 26:21odds are you're looking at the portal. You're thinking pretty strongly about the portal.
- 26:25That's just you know, that's not any one person. That's just look
- 26:29across the country. That tends to be the trend. You know, Jack
- 26:32Miller was at Ohio State for twenty twenty, twenty twenty one and then hit
- 26:37the portal. That's just a kind of the time frame that you're generally talking
- 26:41about. I think that was maybe the Matthew Baldwin timetable as well. He
- 26:44was at Ohio State for two years and then hit the portal. That's you
- 26:48know, quin Ewers was sort of the exception to the rule. But you
- 26:51go through and if you're not the starter after two years, you're probably in
- 26:56the portal. If you're not the starter after three years, you're almost certainly
- 26:59in the port And there are guys who will leave after one year and you
- 27:03can only start one quarterback. So yeah, Ryan Day has brought in an
- 27:07incredibly talented group of quarterbacks over the last few years. I mean, going
- 27:11back through the years, Justin Fields brought into the transfer port was a five
- 27:15star. C J. Stroud was a five star, Cole McCord was a
- 27:18five star. Tamartell was I think a five star as well. You know
- 27:22before that Devin Brown five star. Julian's saying five star, Erin Nolan five
- 27:27star. That's up to seven. I might be forgetting someone somewhere in the
- 27:30middle there, but that's all the five stars, plus you got some high
- 27:34four stars like Jack Miller and guys like that. Who are you know,
- 27:37top one hundred kind of players. How many quarterbacks have actually started for Ohio
- 27:41State since two thousand and twenty? Justin Fields for two years, c J.
- 27:45Stroud for two years, and Kyle McCord for one year. So automatically
- 27:49that's just three out of seven. And that's just the five stars, So
- 27:53no, I think. I think if you're just looking at a class,
- 27:56you're not necessarily going to be able to predict this is the guy who's going
- 28:00to start. But you've got, you know, you have a much better
- 28:04chance of not starting at whatever school you end up going to. And let
- 28:08you know, unless you're the five star guy who goes to Syracuse or something
- 28:11like that, you have a much better chance of not starting than if you
- 28:17you know, then you do actually being the starter at your class. And
- 28:19I just pulled Syracuse out of nowhere, and then I just went, oh,
- 28:22hey, I know a five star quarterback who's playing at Syracuse right now.
- 28:26So that's gonna end up being true this year probably, But I was
- 28:30not thinking of anyone in particular when I pulled Syracuse out of the air.
- 28:33It is pretty wild. And you know, Justin Field's all time great prospect.
- 28:41He never started at Georgia, and it's like, you know, you
- 28:45feel so good about this, and you get you've got the future set up
- 28:48and he's there for one year. The numbers will go even further down if
- 28:52we just talk about quarterbacks who commits, because now you add an Emery Jones,
- 29:00Wan Mathis brock Glen into those names. So now you're talking about ten
- 29:03quarterbacks who have committed. The high school quarterbacks who've committed to Ryan Day.
- 29:07Two of them have won the starting job and that was a period of just
- 29:14three years. And so it's, you know, you Olive stand has gotten
- 29:19their quarterbacks lined up, but they've got three five star guys on the roster
- 29:26right now, and they're probably starting a former two or three star guy from
- 29:32Kansas State, and it's it's just it's an interesting situation because I've always followed
- 29:40recruiting, always enjoyed recruiting because one of the things I like about college football
- 29:45is just the churn and like you're gonna get to see new stars. And
- 29:48so somebody commits, you're like, oh, I can't wait to watch that
- 29:51guy. And for most positions you will eventually get to see them. At
- 29:55quarterback, you're like, it would be nice if we would one day get
- 29:57to watch that quarterback. And to me, it is very much now like
- 30:03the major league draft, the Major League Baseball draft, where the first round
- 30:07picks, you have no idea if those guys are ever going to show up,
- 30:10if they're ever going to be any good. You draft a high school
- 30:12or it might be four years and we'll see you draft a guy that is,
- 30:15you know, a senior or whatever, a junior, and you're like,
- 30:18he could be here in two years and he could be really good or
- 30:22will never make it past Double A. And you can't put really any hope
- 30:27in having a first round Major League Baseball player eventually be part of your major
- 30:33league team, just like you really can't you can put hope in it.
- 30:37You can't. I don't think you can expect any single quarterback that you get
- 30:42committed to you to eventually be a starter, because go through and predict for
- 30:49me accurately which of these quarterbacks are going to start for you. And a
- 30:52lot of it also has to do with timing. Joe Burrow his time in
- 30:56the Ohio State coinciding one year behind Dwayne Haskins, like that was unfortunate for
- 31:03Joe Burrow. You just you never know how recruiting is the dearth of talent.
- 31:07You know, obviously, when you're recruiting as well as you are at
- 31:11Ohio State right now, the quarterback position, it's going to be more difficult
- 31:15to play there. Back in the day, it wasn't it wasn't not too
- 31:18long ago. Tom thirteen fourteen fifteen years, fourteen years, thirteen years,
- 31:25Tom, Sorry, I'm bad at math. Joe Bowsman was Ohio State starting
- 31:27quarterback. There was a former minor league baseball player now that we're talking about
- 31:32first rounders that they had to rely on, and you know, their far
- 31:37cry from that now. But you as fun as recruiting is and as nice
- 31:42as it is to land all of these quarterbacks, it's obviously better to have
- 31:45as many as possible so that you can one day get through that. But
- 31:51man, it's just it's just something I've been thinking about where you know,
- 31:56you've got Aaron Nolan, you've got Julian saying and the odds are are better
- 32:00by signing too that one of them will be the starter. But I don't
- 32:05know that the odds are good. No, I don't think the odds are
- 32:09well the signing to the odds are better than fifty to fifty that one of
- 32:14them probably ends up being the starter at some point. But you know,
- 32:19to your point about the Major League Baseball Draft, Tony, do you know
- 32:22how many number one overall picks in the Major League Baseball draft going back to
- 32:25the first year nineteen sixty five. How many of the number one overall picks
- 32:30in the Major League Baseball Draft have made the Hall of Fame? It feels
- 32:35like one, but I don't know that any have. Yeah, Ken Griffy
- 32:39Junior did, Okay, Joe Maher just did. Carol Baines probably shouldn't have,
- 32:44but did, so we're going to give that a two and a half.
- 32:46But you know, you go through the list and there's there's a Steve
- 32:49Chilcott over Reggie Jackson, and there's a you know, there's a Tim Fowley,
- 32:55and there's a Sean Abner, and there's a Paul Wilson, And did
- 33:00all of these players get picked by the same team? Tony? I don't
- 33:01know why you would bother asking me that question. We're not here to talk
- 33:06about the Mets and they're miserable failings. We're here to talk about college football
- 33:08anyway. Sorry, I just got that guy started looking at that and saw
- 33:12Steve Chilcott's name and got triggered. Sorry. H No, I think I
- 33:15think you're looking at a better than fifty to fifty chance that either Aron Noland
- 33:20or Julian Saying ends up starting for Ohlehouse date at some point, But the
- 33:27odds are probably better than fifty to fifty that one of them is not at
- 33:30Ohio State by the time the twenty twenty six season starts, because you're at
- 33:35the third you know, the third season. Then so if Will Howard starts
- 33:38this year and then next year, it's you know, whoever you wanted to
- 33:43who do you you can it could be uh, you know, whoever pick
- 33:46your name for next year, whoever is not that guy. Odds are that
- 33:51guy is maybe in the transfer portal already. And if not, if it's
- 33:53not Lincoln Kinghols next year, maybe Lincoln Kinghols is in the portal or it
- 33:58just you go through the names. If it's not Devin Brown this year,
- 34:01who knows if Devin Brown playing for the buck Eyes this this fall. I
- 34:05mean, there's just there's so you know, the these are such talented players
- 34:10that if they're not going to start at Ohio State, there are plenty of
- 34:13other places in the country that they very well may get a chance to start.
- 34:16And so you just the odds are you know, of all of these
- 34:22guys, of the five guys on the roster right now, I think the
- 34:24odds are that you know, no more than three ever start a game,
- 34:29and probably at least three don't finish their careers at Ohio State. Yeah.
- 34:35I never thought of this over under before, but like, yeah, over
- 34:38under of two and a half of the quarterbacks on the Ohio State roster who
- 34:42are starting a game. Anybody can do Capibal cord Didad as a true freshman,
- 34:45you know, but starting a season. Devin Brown started a game last
- 34:50year. Starting a season is to be the the qualifier there, and it's
- 34:55like two and a half of these guys, I would not feel good about
- 35:01the over I'd feel more likely that the underhits just because they're all also here
- 35:06together, which makes it difficult to separate them. Next year, the room
- 35:13is gonna change considerably. Again, We'll be fascinating to find that out.
- 35:16Ryan Day said on his radio show on Wednesday on signing day. Right now,
- 35:22they're just operating that a third of your roster changes every single year,
- 35:27and that's start of the way it's been. But I think it's even more
- 35:30so. I'm thinking like forty percent of the roster at this point in terms
- 35:35of guys leaving, guys going. It's and the quarterback position is just uniquely
- 35:44unique to itself as in terms of the playing time, and that's why you
- 35:49can have recruit all these guys you want, but sometimes you need a veteran
- 35:52and you go get a veteran, and I think that's in luxury for programs
- 35:55like Ohio State. Yeah, you're gonna lose some of your five stars,
- 36:00but when you do, you can go get somebody that has done started twenty
- 36:02seven games in their careers, won a conference championship. And ash has played
- 36:07well against Missouri, So that's a unique thing. So Tom, anything else
- 36:13before we get out of here. No, I think we've I think we've
- 36:15covered it now. I'm just my head is spinning on trying to figure out
- 36:20like number of percentage of quarterbacks on each of the past rosters who ever started
- 36:23a game at Ohio State, and trying to think when has there been one
- 36:28that's been higher than fifty percent? Because you know the JT. Barrett and
- 36:32Cardil Jones years, you know, you probably you had probably one year when
- 36:37Dwayne Haskins was on the roster with those guys, right, was that sixteen
- 36:42he was on the fifteen team? Was he on the fifteen team? Now?
- 36:46Yeah? Burrow was, Yeah, Well he didn't start a game at
- 36:50Ohio State. He started Beamest plenty of other places, but not at Ohio
- 36:52State. Yeah, it's you go back and it feels like you look at
- 36:55it right now and it's like, well, all of these talent guys,
- 36:59certainly a bunch of them going to have going to have great careers at Ohio
- 37:00State. And it's just the unique nature of the quarterback position and how how
- 37:07you know, the roster got sort of screwed up with Quen you weres reclassifying
- 37:12and that throwing everything off a little bit. And yeah, it's interesting that
- 37:15that it feels like, boy, all of these guys are can't miss prospects
- 37:20and they're in a Ryan Day offense with Ryan Day coaching them, and oh
- 37:22boy, they can't miss. And then you know, odds are they may
- 37:27not miss, but they may not hit at Ohio State either, you know.
- 37:30And maybe the percentages aren't all that different because back in the day you
- 37:35had more quarterbacks so and they stayed longer as opposed to now you you might
- 37:39have few fewer. Another project for the summer toime, remind me, I'll
- 37:45get a spreadsheet going and we'll we'll take a look at that and we'll see
- 37:47what we can do there. So that will do it for this episode.
- 37:51One to thank you all for joining us. As always, please go ahead
- 37:52and hit the bell to be notified when we drop videos when we go live
- 37:57because there's springball is less than four weeks away. Of course, also subscribe
- 38:00to the channel if you have not yet thumbs up on this would be great
- 38:04as well, and of course if you are listening to this via your podcast
- 38:07platform with choice, we always do appreciate the five star ratings and reviews,
- 38:12and as always you can find us at buckeyehuddle dot com where we are chatting
- 38:16on the message board talk a stop behind the scenes as we always do there,
- 38:21so join up and check that out. So we invite you there.
- 38:23So thank you all for tuning in and we will talk to you guys later