Latest / Friendship Room: Women, friendship & support / When Your Friend Is Infertile and You’re Holding a Baby | Friendship Room
Transcript
- The hardest part of loving someone through infertility isn’t the silence; it’s the noise you make by accident. It’s the way your world suddenly expands with life while theirs feels like it’s shrinking into a room with no windows. I want to start by telling you about a Tuesday morning three years ago. I was standing in my kitchen, wearing sweatpants that hadn’t seen daylight in a week, holding a baby who had just finished eating. He was content, his little fists unclenching, his eyes wide and innocent. And I was thinking about my friend Sarah. Sarah, who had spent the last eighteen months crying in parking lots, who had taken shots that made her skin feel like it was burning from the inside out, who had looked at ultrasound screens with a mixture of hope and terror that broke my heart every time she told me about them. I walked outside to get the mail, and I laughed. A real, belly laugh, because the baby had farted and the sound was ridiculous. And in that moment, as the sun hit my face and the smell of fresh grass filled the air, I felt this immediate, crushing wave of guilt. Not because I was happy for my baby—I was. But because I knew that somewhere, Sarah was waking up alone in a house that felt too quiet, carrying the weight of another failed cycle. Let’s sit with that for a second. That guilt is heavy. It sits in your chest like a stone. And if you are a mother navigating a friendship where your companion is struggling with infertility, you know exactly what I’m talking about. You start to shrink yourself. You stop posting photos. You whisper when you talk about your children. You walk on eggshells in your own home. But here is the truth that took me years to learn: your joy does not cancel out her pain. Your love does not diminish hers. They can exist in the same space, but it requires a level of intentionality that most of us were never taught. We tend to think that supporting a friend means stepping back. We think we need to become invisible so that our happiness doesn’t刺痛 (sting) them. So we mute our notifications. We decline invitations to playdates because we’re afraid the laughter will be too loud. We change the subject before they can ask how our pregnancy is going. I did this for a long time. I thought I was being noble. I thought I was being a good friend. But what I was actually doing was isolating myself. And isolation is the enemy of intimacy. When you remove yourself from their life, you aren’t protecting them; you’re telling them that your joy is dangerous. That your body’s success is a threat to their failure. And that is a lie. It is a lie that feeds the shame both of you are carrying. I remember calling Sarah one day, and she said, 'Please don’t tiptoe around me, Kaitlyn. I miss my friend. I miss the woman who talks too much and laughs too loud. I don’t want to be protected from your life. I want to be included in it.' That conversation changed everything for me. It forced me to realize that grief doesn’t vanish when we hide our light. Grief needs company. It needs witnesses. It needs to know that the world hasn’t ended, even if it feels like it has. So, I stopped tiptoeing. I started inviting her over. Not to show off the baby, but to just be there. To drink coffee while he napped. To let her hold him, if she wanted to, without making it a big deal. To let her say, 'I wish,' and then simply hold her hand. This brings me to a question I want you to carry with you today. What does your heart need to say right now? Are you saying it? Or are you swallowing it down because you’re afraid of hurting her? Because here is the delicate dance we have to perform. You cannot ignore the elephant in the room, but you also cannot force her to talk about it. You have to create a space where she feels safe enough to bring it up, or safe enough to ignore it completely, and neither option makes you withdraw. This is hard. It requires a radical presence. It means listening to understand, not to respond. When she mentions the baby, don’t pivot to your own story immediately. Don’t jump in with, 'Oh, mine used to do that too!' Pause. Acknowledge. Say, 'He really is funny, isn’t he?' Then wait. See where she goes. If she wants to share her pain, let her. If she wants to distract herself with gossip about work, follow her lead. The mistake many of us make is assuming that because we are happy, we are obligated to celebrate loudly. But celebration can feel like salt in a wound if the timing is wrong. Instead, aim for consistency. Show up. Be steady. Be the person who remembers that today is a hard day, and tomorrow might be harder, and next month might be the anniversary of a loss. Consistency over intensity. We talked a lot about rituals in previous episodes, but this is different. This isn’t about creating a new ritual; it’s about maintaining the old ones. Keep showing up to your weekly brunch. Keep texting her memes. Keep asking her advice about things that have nothing to do with babies. Remind her that she is still the wise, witty, wonderful friend you fell in love with, regardless of whether she carries a child in her womb. There is another layer to this, one that is often unspoken. The assumption that infertility is a monolith. That everyone experiences it the same way. Some women rage. Some women cry. Some women numb themselves with work or travel or shopping. Some women pray until their knees bruise. And some women, like Sarah, just feel empty. A hollowed-out feeling that has no name. As a mother, it is easy to project your own desires onto her. You might think, 'She would kill for a baby, so she must hate seeing mine.' But that’s not always true. She might love babies. She might love your baby. She might even want to hold him. But wanting and having are two very different landscapes. You have to check your assumptions. Ask her. 'Do you want to come to the park? Do you want to see the new onesies I bought?' Give her the agency to choose. Because infertility robs women of control. It takes away their ability to plan, to predict, to trust their own bodies. Reclaiming small choices—like whether to attend a birthday party or stay home—is a way of taking back power. And when you give her that choice, you are giving her dignity. You are treating her as an adult, not a victim. This is crucial. You are not her therapist. You are her friend. There is a difference. Therapists manage boundaries and outcomes. Friends share burdens and joys. You don’t need to fix her pain. You just need to sit with it. You just need to be there. And sometimes, that looks like silence. Sometimes, it looks like bringing her soup when she’s exhausted from treatments. Sometimes, it looks like defending her when others make insensitive comments. It looks like being the shield when the world feels too sharp. Let’s talk about the guilt again, because it’s the anchor that drags us down. You feel guilty for getting pregnant. You feel guilty for having a healthy baby. You feel guilty for not being able to help. You feel guilty for being happy. All of these feelings are valid. But they are not truths. They are emotions, swirling in the storm of shared history. You are allowed to be happy. You are allowed to love your children fiercely. You are allowed to post pictures on social media if you want to. You are allowed to laugh at a fart joke. None of this betrays your friend. Betrayal would be abandoning her. Betrayal would be pretending she doesn’t exist. Betrayal would be choosing comfort over connection. Choose connection. Even when it’s messy. Especially when it’s messy. I remember a time when Sarah got pregnant. It wasn’t with her partner. It was a surprise, a complicated situation that led to a loss shortly after. I was eight months pregnant with my second child. I didn’t call her immediately. I was scared. I didn’t know what to say. I waited three days. In those three days, I regretted every minute. I should have called. I should have said, 'I heard. I’m so sorry. I’m here.' Waiting for the 'right' words is a trap. There are no right words. There are only present actions. When I finally called, I didn’t offer platitudes. I didn’t tell her it would be okay. I just said, 'I’m coming over. Can I bring dinner?' She said yes. I brought lasagna. We sat on her couch. We didn’t talk about babies. We talked about a book we were both reading. We talked about nothing. And in that nothing, we found each other again. That is what support looks like. It’s not grand gestures. It’s small, steady acts of love. It’s showing up when it’s inconvenient. It’s staying when it’s uncomfortable. It’s remembering that she is more than her uterus. She is a whole person. She is a whole soul. And she deserves to be loved for who she is, not just for what she lacks. Friendship through infertility is a long game. It’s not a sprint. It’s a marathon that may last years. There will be good days. There will be bad days. There will be days when you feel close and days when you feel miles apart. And that’s okay. Distance doesn’t mean disconnection. Sometimes, the space between you is necessary for healing. Respect that space. Don’t push her to reconnect before she’s ready. Trust that the bond you share is strong enough to withstand silence. And when she is ready, she will reach out. Maybe it’s a text. Maybe it’s a phone call. Maybe it’s a request to meet for coffee. Meet her there. Bring your full self. Bring your joy, but temper it with empathy. Bring your sorrow, but mix it with hope. You are navigating two very different journeys, but you are walking parallel paths. You can see each other. You can wave. You can cheer each other on, even from afar. Just don’t forget to look back. Don’t forget to check in. Don’t forget that she is fighting a battle you can’t fully see. And remember, you are not alone in this room. Many women are walking this path. Many mothers are learning how to love their friends through loss. Many friends are learning how to hold space for pain they can’t fix. It’s a sacred, difficult, beautiful work. And you are doing it. You are showing up. You are loving deeply. And that matters more than you know. So take a breath. Let go of the guilt. Pick up the phone. Send the text. Show up. Be present. Be kind. Be there. That is all anyone ever asks for. Just to be known. Just to be held. Just to be loved. Thank you for letting me sit with you today. For listening. For caring. For being the kind of friend who shows up, even when it’s hard. You are doing better than you think. I’ll see you in the next episode. Until then, be gentle with yourselves. You are not alone in this room.