Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E018: Bitcoin's Custodial Landscape Through a Legal Lens with Gavin Feary
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972000? Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 0:27when we sell. Logan Only Ninja launches on
- 0:31TFTC. This is a very professional
- 0:33operation. Well, you say that he just ninja
- 0:36launched on you. Welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:39Thanks Logan. Very excited for this
- 0:44conversation. We're joined by Gavin Fiery from
- 0:46Winstead, prestigious law firm here in the state of Texas at
- 0:51the cutting edge of regulatory issues and compliance.
- 0:57Pertaining to Bitcoin in the company's building in the space,
- 1:00this is definitely a fresh perspective on this show, diving
- 1:04into the regulatory side of things, which I know many
- 1:07Bitcoiners don't like to think about, but it's becoming
- 1:10increasingly important, especially considering the
- 1:14landscape that we find ourselves in with the SEC beginning to
- 1:17crack down on a bunch of crypto projects and this SEC and CFTC
- 1:22sort of fighting for ground. In this space.
- 1:25But before we jump into the meat of the conversation, Gavin, why
- 1:29don't you just introduce yourself what you're doing and
- 1:33how you found Bitcoin, and then we can talk about a lot of
- 1:35really cool things you've been doing in the space for many
- 1:38years now. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:40Thanks so much for having me at at Winsted.
- 1:44I joined them in 2017. So we I sort of started in
- 1:49investment funds of the 22 year lawyer and have also done a fair
- 1:55amount of time working on Commodity Futures and and work
- 1:58with the CFTC. And so we looks like my dog's
- 2:03leaving right now. So, so basically there's a bunch
- 2:10of hedge fund managers in Fort Worth and back in 2017 we were
- 2:17helping them with their own portfolios and allocations to to
- 2:21Bitcoin and figuring out custody.
- 2:24And then by 2018-2019 we were launching funds and some of
- 2:30those are registered investment advisors or Texas.
- 2:35Exempt reporting advisors, so regulated entities and subject
- 2:39to the custody rule. So we had to kind of figure out
- 2:42custody. So it was kind of fun talking
- 2:46getting on a phone way back in 2017 with like Wensa Cesares and
- 2:50Zappo and and others, and trying to figure out how we were going
- 2:55to get the the investment funds Bitcoin.
- 3:01Or Bitcoin exposure, depending on how they did it.
- 3:04Get it all sorted. So Gavin, does that mean that
- 3:08whensys was part of your journey to Bitcoin, you were just
- 3:12finding out from one of the earliest Ogs that Bitcoin had
- 3:17value For these reasons? Or did you get into Bitcoin
- 3:19before that point? Yeah, I I did get thrown into
- 3:23it. I've been in house for
- 3:24Commodities Trader, so I I sort of had to deal with all
- 3:27different types of futures and spot commodities and interests
- 3:31outside of just the regular securities industry.
- 3:34So that was part of my part of my job for 6-7 years here in
- 3:37Texas and literally, you know. The week before I started, my
- 3:43boss said I got a project for you and he said bitcoins of
- 3:49commodity and you've got some work to do and I sort of at that
- 3:53point fell down the rabbit hole in terms of custody and how we
- 3:59can possibly satisfy the custody rule and talking with.
- 4:05And could you explain the custody rule for people who
- 4:07aren't familiar? Yeah.
- 4:09So it it's it's a rule that sort of has an 80 year history, but
- 4:14it comes out of foreign investment advisors specifically
- 4:18registered with SEC. And so it it comes out with out
- 4:22of a sort of Bernie Madoff type situation that human weaknesses
- 4:29as they are. You generally need to have the
- 4:32the assets cut somewhere else in a separate location from the
- 4:36person. The, the manager, the third
- 4:39party that's that's looking after your investment portfolio,
- 4:44so with a qualified custodian and then you have to have
- 4:48transparency periodically into that portfolio and maybe
- 4:52periodic verifications that the assets are really there.
- 4:57And so obviously there's no rule that gets around straight up
- 5:00fraud like in a Bernie Madoff situation necessarily, but there
- 5:05are. Technological things.
- 5:08Proof of reserves, for instance, That can help prove the assets
- 5:14are there. So the rule's been in place for
- 5:18many, many years. In fact, there's a new proposal
- 5:20to try and switch it up now. Yeah, and it's very interesting
- 5:26with Bitcoin specifically, because.
- 5:29Just of the nature of the protocol and the primitives that
- 5:32exist on the protocol that allow you to custody Bitcoin in a very
- 5:36unique way when compared to incumbent financial assets,
- 5:40whether it be stocks, bonds, commodity, futures, whatever it
- 5:43may be. And I think that's one of the
- 5:45most interesting things of this particular point in time in the
- 5:50context of regulators trying to understand Bitcoin and
- 5:53bitcoiners trying to explain how this thing works to regulators,
- 5:56is that we have. A brand new way to custody a a
- 6:01bearer asset in the digital age with Bitcoin in the way the
- 6:05private public signatures work. And I think that's one of the
- 6:09biggest frictions between the Bitcoin industry and regulators
- 6:13right now is that we're here screaming like, hey, there's a
- 6:16better way to do custody natively on the protocol.
- 6:20And you wanted you want us to do it in this sort of?
- 6:25Archaic fashion as laid out by the rules that were set 80 years
- 6:30ago. And so in your experience, I
- 6:32know you wrote a paper with Caitlin Long and Brian Bishop
- 6:36literally five years ago yesterday that you sent to the
- 6:39SEC trying to explain this. So what is your experience been
- 6:42like from your perspective trying to get regulators to
- 6:46understand like, hey, there's a new way to do custody with this
- 6:51asset? Gavin, before jumping in I
- 6:54actually wanted to just take one step back on the custody rule
- 6:57because I think it's important and at least from our my
- 7:00personal understanding the custody rule doesn't apply to
- 7:02spot Bitcoin applies to securities and and if if they if
- 7:08you can correct me if I'm wrong but if if that is true is it
- 7:11partial the confusion the past you know 5 plus years.
- 7:16More related to who wants oversight as what we'll talk
- 7:20about in this conversation, whether it's the CFTC or SEC or
- 7:24is it more from a just pure understanding because what we're
- 7:27talking about is a commodity, but it's digital in nature.
- 7:30So it resembles a security in the sense that it can evaporate
- 7:34overnight or like it can just be taken and then that's where the.
- 7:38Or a custody rule comes into play and this like not fully
- 7:42understanding that this is a digital asset, but it's a bearer
- 7:44asset that that's similar to a commodity.
- 7:46If you can touch on that before because I think it sets the
- 7:48framework for like what the letter was sent.
- 7:51Yeah. There we we were had
- 7:53conversations with with Fin Hub when it was produced the Valley
- 7:57of shirts Panic Division of investment management about how
- 8:00our clients would satisfy the custody rule and and there were
- 8:04sort of three big problems that that needed to be sorted out one
- 8:08was. Is Bitcoin funds and securities?
- 8:11Because the old rule applies to funds.
- 8:13So it kind of the question is can you spend it sounds a lot
- 8:18like funds, but traditionally commodities have not been fallen
- 8:23into that group. So is it funds and securities?
- 8:26That's one problem with that rule.
- 8:28And then another problem is who's a qualified custodian?
- 8:30Is a Trust Company enough under the definitions there?
- 8:34So that was another. Sort of longstanding question
- 8:38and there were questions about bankruptcy, remoteness even back
- 8:41then and and so funds and securities qualified custodian.
- 8:47The other thing it has an exception that kind of gets
- 8:50exposed by some of the early Bitcoin trading.
- 8:53So let's say you take your Bitcoin out of cold storage and
- 8:57you put it in someone's hot wallet and you transfer it to an
- 9:02exchange or a trading platform to get the trade done.
- 9:06The digital asset world, sort of, at least as things were
- 9:10done, exposes the fact that it leaves the custodian's hands
- 9:14when it goes out of the cold wallet onto some hot wallet for
- 9:19for the exchange in order for the trade to happen.
- 9:22So there was a there's a sort of authorized trading exception in
- 9:26the custody rule that says Okay, we can kind of leave the.
- 9:32We can leave the used to allow assets to leave that, but that
- 9:37exposes the fact that during that period there's no
- 9:41protection, there's no custodial protection for the asset.
- 9:44You're exposed to whatever exchange and whatever
- 9:48commingling is happening there. So those are kind of the issues
- 9:52we were dealing with. That last part is so interesting
- 9:57because. It it kind of shines a light on
- 10:00how with traditional assets that that just wasn't an issue of
- 10:03like the asset leaving the custodian and then being on a
- 10:06trading platform. I suppose it's probably handled
- 10:09with like it it some accounting thing of of it's being lent out
- 10:13from the custodian and still technically sitting at the
- 10:16custodian when it's being traded.
- 10:18But in digital assets, there's like a greater level of
- 10:20transparency and an actual physicality in the sense of like
- 10:24where it is, where this asset is sitting at any point in time,
- 10:27it's clearer. And that that in a way makes
- 10:32digital assets like a superior instrument in terms of
- 10:37accounting and trackability and all that in terms of the clarity
- 10:41of what's happening at any moment in time than we have had
- 10:44with the traditional asset world.
- 10:46Yeah, I guess another way to say that is, and correct me if I'm
- 10:49wrong here, Gavin, but the protocol is the clearinghouse at
- 10:52the end of the day. Yeah.
- 10:55No, that's that's that's fair. That might rub up against some
- 10:59of the traditional securities kind of establishment of rules,
- 11:02but absolutely, that's right. And so, so now maybe Gavin, it
- 11:11would be great to hear the story of how you know you you're
- 11:15starting to work with digital assets in your capacity as a
- 11:19lawyer. You know that your your boss
- 11:22puts this, puts this on your plate.
- 11:24And then Fast forward a little bit, you're you're in a room
- 11:27with Tour de Mr. Caitlin Long, some other folks trying to
- 11:31hammer out what you've learned, you know about like this is how
- 11:34it should be done and the regulators should be aware of
- 11:37this and how there's a better way.
- 11:40So how did that come about? And and and what was that, you
- 11:44know, what was that experience like writing that letter?
- 11:47Yeah. So this this 2018 we sort of put
- 11:51together a group I had been sponsoring with with Winstead a
- 11:56a sort of smart custody workshop that was on a Blockstream that
- 12:01that Brian Bishop had been put together with Christopher Allen
- 12:06who's a a cryptographer that that helped.
- 12:11Co-author the the TLS security standard so for you know a lot
- 12:15of payments right now still on the Internet he helped co-author
- 12:20that standard So he was looking into adversaries on for smart
- 12:25custody Bitcoin and so we were sponsoring that and and sort of
- 12:29at that event out of that event came getting to know Brian
- 12:34Bishop a little bit as well as Caitlin Long.
- 12:38And Angus championed to Crespi at Ian, he was that you know
- 12:42then at EMY. So that all and Tour de Meester
- 12:46of course was also sort of part of the the discussion.
- 12:49So we we we were working with tour on a fund at the time.
- 12:54So, so all of that came together with OK, the SEC is you know
- 12:59considering ETF's this is 2018. Hard to believe that it's still
- 13:04still the place but now. That what do they need to be
- 13:08thinking about? Because if they start treating,
- 13:12you know Bitcoin and in sort of fungible bulk or or they allow
- 13:16rehypothecation from the ETF or there's no way to receive the
- 13:20actual Bitcoin from the fund for instance, that would be nice.
- 13:25We even mentioned that and and just understanding that that.
- 13:31There is no lender of last resort in this case, so if
- 13:35you're this is before you know the meltdowns happened in other
- 13:40digital assets. But in terms of, you know,
- 13:44margin lending rehypothecation, there could be a lot of
- 13:48uncovered undetected uncover exposure if all if these assets
- 13:53are being rehypothecated and Bitcoin natively doesn't really.
- 13:58You need to have reserves to be able to meet your commitments
- 14:05because there's no way to print it.
- 14:10Yeah, it's incredible. I'm looking at an excerpt.
- 14:13One of the key point in bold is we believe that digital assets
- 14:16are unique asset class with unique strengths and abilities.
- 14:20And then followed by that as as a result of division of Labor,
- 14:22any economy will overtime develop services that it assist
- 14:26savers in keeping their assets secure.
- 14:29The institution of third party custody itself is about as old
- 14:32as civilization with earliest records dating back to 3300 BC.
- 14:38There's just so prescient, you know, reading that, especially
- 14:41being close to, you know, a day away from five years and still
- 14:44having these discussions and also just debating on custody
- 14:47and having. Intermediaries facilitate and
- 14:50trusted their parties. Given that, if if Bitcoin is to
- 14:54succeed, we're going to have trusted parties across the
- 14:56spectrum and how an economy ends up, you know, being created and
- 15:00delivering value across it. Yeah, absolutely.
- 15:05And and obviously a lot of the providers at that time were
- 15:09coming at it from a sort of omnibus account.
- 15:11Point of view and that from their point of view they're used
- 15:16to omnibus accounts and it facilitates you know sort of
- 15:19intraday off chain settlements and some other things like that.
- 15:23That we had a big debate back in 2018.
- 15:27You know other circumstances in which if you properly disclose
- 15:30it, or in which in which you can and can and should be having
- 15:35omnibus accounts even though Bitcoin is natively, natively
- 15:40segregated. And so we we sort of just having
- 15:43to kind of battle with that and we had some pretty good
- 15:46disagreements about it. Yeah, I think the other one
- 15:49that's most, I don't know if relevant but really hit home was
- 15:54you know you guys called out multi sig.
- 15:56And basically one other key bullet point was we should
- 15:58leverage the technology of this as a class to protect investors
- 16:01in ways not previously possible. I thought that was another
- 16:04really kind of key point that was recognized so early on and
- 16:08we're even seeing this today with the ETFs.
- 16:10They kind of hit on the opposite of what you guys described as
- 16:14the right way to create, you know, a product for the market.
- 16:18And it's similar to Jesse's piece and calling out you
- 16:21mentioned some of the uncovered calls, but then also just the
- 16:23central points of failure that exists with a single
- 16:26counterparty that we've seen the past, you know close to 15 years
- 16:29now in this industry. Yeah.
- 16:32One of the big things I've been surprised about, and this is
- 16:35sort of the risks that we warned about, is.
- 16:38Is people sort of assumed that because it was Bitcoin, you
- 16:41could just, you know, or or other digital assets, you could
- 16:44just, you know have a books and records that segregates at the
- 16:48books and records level. And then you can keep the, you
- 16:51know, keep the the actual assets or the keys in in different
- 16:57addresses and you can have multiple dresses that suit what
- 17:00you need. But those don't match even even
- 17:03necessarily what's what's a platform asset versus what's.
- 17:07A. A customer asset and it's
- 17:10pretty, pretty amazing to me that that that sort of is the
- 17:15was the modus operandi for for many of the exchanges was we'll
- 17:19do everything we need on books and records and then you have a
- 17:22complete disassociation with the actual wallet structure of where
- 17:26it's actually been kept and that that sort of was extremely you
- 17:32know. That it led to a lot of the
- 17:34dangers with with wallets being mislabeled and even with
- 17:38auditors coming in and looking at say what was in FTX, not
- 17:42knowing what wallet was belonged to what asset etcetera.
- 17:45But that that mindset that that you don't segregate by wallet
- 17:49address was kind of crazy to me. Yeah.
- 17:53It strikes me as a bit of a lag still that we're still living
- 17:56through with with the digital asset industry as a whole of.
- 18:00People are coming in and applying what has worked in the
- 18:03traditional world in terms of all operational aspects,
- 18:09custody, accounting being part of that.
- 18:13And you know, as a result of that like people are designing
- 18:17their, their systems, their custody and how they're
- 18:20accounting for individual client balances, not in line with
- 18:27what's possible with. With wallets and digital,
- 18:29digital addresses and you know, it's sort of too bad that like
- 18:36you guys put out this, this advice in 2018 and I don't think
- 18:41the regulators are there yet still you know five years later
- 18:45in terms of understanding that you know.
- 18:49That that an example of how digital assets allows a greater
- 18:53level of clarity and and transparency real time about
- 18:56where the assets actually sit and how that became a problem
- 18:59with the clearing houses example.
- 19:02You know that that plays out with custody too that we we have
- 19:05a greater level of fidelity and and granularity with accounting
- 19:09and and reporting that's possible here and people still
- 19:13haven't adopted that as to build these systems in a in a Bitcoin
- 19:17native fashion. Yeah, I mean that that's what's
- 19:21been so exciting and fascinating like you know Gavin reading that
- 19:26and looking at it and Jesse, Marty and myself, we talk a lot
- 19:29about custody and you know the maturation of this market.
- 19:32And we've been looking at this problem for a very long time and
- 19:35whether it's providing services, building tools and so it it over
- 19:38time, you know, I think it's a, it's a function of like proof of
- 19:41work and being in the market and recognizing whether it's FTX or
- 19:45seeing products and services that are delivering.
- 19:48What the protocol wants and that makes sense from a long term
- 19:51sustainability of like securing the asset or building a
- 19:54foundational business. And so it also makes sense if
- 19:58somebody comes in into the industry from traditional
- 20:00finance or coming in from Wall Street and they have a mental
- 20:04model of the world that's different.
- 20:06But what's really fascinating to be curious is like how did you,
- 20:08how are you able to come to that conclusion so quickly because
- 20:11you mentioned coming in 17, this is put on your plates, you're
- 20:13looking at it. You have to be I guess somewhat
- 20:15curious or maybe not curious, but it was your, it was your job
- 20:17that you were forced to do it. But then like to put that
- 20:20together within let's call it three to nine months I would
- 20:22imagine was the time frame that it was so obvious that this was
- 20:26the way it needed to be done. Like can you share kind of some
- 20:29of the like to the extent you can, I know it was five years
- 20:32ago, what was going through or was it really the the support of
- 20:34the team that was that helped you kind of see that vision?
- 20:37Yeah, yeah. So when you are you know when
- 20:40you're lawyering you and in your say you're launching the fund
- 20:43you you start with a set of documents that that you've used
- 20:47before and then you tailor them for the asset and and you know
- 20:51the risk factors that no one reads are you spend a lot of
- 20:54time on those risk factors hopefully because.
- 20:58That we see products, especially in other digital assets have
- 21:02gone full cycle, D5 funds etc, definitely gone full cycle.
- 21:08And those risk factors become kind of important at that at
- 21:12that stage. So a lot of it was, you know,
- 21:16there wasn't a place to go on the Internet to to pick up
- 21:20really good disclosures about about Bitcoin and about the
- 21:24Bitcoin network. So in a in a legal way I wasn't
- 21:28like Coinbase had public filings at that point so so we or
- 21:33anything anyone else so, so we really sort of I basically
- 21:38locked myself for three weeks and and wrote a bunch of risk
- 21:43factors for for a Bitcoin fund that we were working on and part
- 21:49of that I I think was I needed to understand you know how.
- 21:55The properties of the asset were just fundamentally different and
- 22:00and what that meant what, what, what sort of risks does that
- 22:04create. You know a lot of the failures
- 22:07we've seen in other markets with with the FT X's in Celsius
- 22:12etcetera. Like you know those customer
- 22:15agreements sometimes with complete Rd. maps to the fact
- 22:18that they were going to take the assets and and use them
- 22:21somewhere else, so. My journey really was OK.
- 22:28I need to get involved in understanding the adversary's
- 22:31self custody. When is it appropriate to have
- 22:33custodians? How is this not centralizing the
- 22:36risk by by having a qualified custodian creating a honey pot?
- 22:41So we were just trying to figure out all of those those issues.
- 22:46Yeah, you brought up the concept of qualified custodian.
- 22:50I think that's been the big topic.
- 22:52In the news the last six months with the bankruptcy of Prime
- 22:57Trust and the subsequent purchase of Prime Trust by or
- 23:03not Prime Trust, Fortress Trust by Ripple.
- 23:05And so you had prime trust was a qualified custodian leveraging
- 23:10the Nevada charter I believe and then Scott Purcell same person
- 23:14start prime trust went and started Fortress Trust in in
- 23:18these two. Instances that they were
- 23:21qualified custodians, they checked the box.
- 23:23However, it became abundantly, it has become abundantly clear
- 23:26that they actually didn't know how to secure these assets
- 23:31properly and it led to a loss of funds for their customers in
- 23:35both cases. Luckily for Fortress, Ripple
- 23:38stepped in and bailed them out and actually I don't even know
- 23:43if that's completely across the line yet.
- 23:45So I think that's yet to be determined, but.
- 23:48I think it gets to the point of, again, this sort of intersection
- 23:52of the incumbent regulatory structure and this new asset and
- 23:58something that bitcoiners and people that are looking to get
- 24:01into space need to be aware of is yes, you may have certain
- 24:05entities out there that check the qualified custodian box.
- 24:08But if you actually do the due diligence and look into how
- 24:11they're custodying the asset, in many cases they're not doing it
- 24:14correctly. So it's really.
- 24:17There, there's a lot of landmines that exist out there,
- 24:19people sort of having undeserved levels of confidence in their
- 24:25custodian with this new asset. And I I guess the question being
- 24:31is like how do we ensure that somebody who's checking the
- 24:35qualified custodian box is actually securing and custoding
- 24:39the asset properly? Yeah, that's right.
- 24:41And and because it was all new. A lot of the agreements and the
- 24:46systems that everyone was using were completely all over the
- 24:49board. So you had sort of massive
- 24:52people you know obviously with a lot of FOMO and and wanting to
- 24:57just sign any contract that that came their way to get the the
- 25:01yields that they could get. And you know it all played out
- 25:05over not really that many years as to you know some of the
- 25:11leverage, some of the. Sub custodians some of the those
- 25:16risks so again I'm not sure it got a ton of airspace but we we
- 25:22wrote to the SEC as part of a legal working group I'm part of
- 25:28because Wall Street blockchain is alliance and and it's a mix
- 25:33of of lawyers that's been talking to each other every two
- 25:35weeks for you know probably the same amount of time at least
- 25:39four years for me and. We sort of wrote a a a list of
- 25:44of things for the new SEC custody rule.
- 25:47The proposed one this, you know, they asked you know what are
- 25:50some of the things we should be looking at for a qualified
- 25:54custodian. So we sort of did a little bit
- 25:58of a of a of a list and I think the the problem is just that
- 26:03everyone's doing things in different ways and it's kind of
- 26:07hard for the SEC as being the. The one that is regulating
- 26:12investment advisors, there's a lot of custodians, traditional
- 26:15custodians that are really upset with the new proposed rule.
- 26:19I think 29 organizations like the FI Futures Industry
- 26:25Association and and is the and all these large trade
- 26:30associations wrote to the SEC about the rule and said look,
- 26:34you are. In trying to extend this rule
- 26:37for things like digital assets to try and change some of these
- 26:40concepts you're you're completely messing up
- 26:42traditional custodianship of other assets.
- 26:46And so that that's still that's still playing out and you can
- 26:52see you know custodians like why is the SEC regulating me, I'm,
- 26:56I'm not the investment advisor. And so there's that friction is
- 26:59still there is is who is regulating the custodians?
- 27:04Yeah, actually Logan, can you zoom us out because I think this
- 27:07is a really important conversation.
- 27:09There's three like key components if we can kind of dig
- 27:13into, there's QC and is it even qualified custodian, is it even
- 27:18required for an RRA or individuals because we're
- 27:23talking about spot BTC. If it's a investment funds
- 27:26trading derivatives, it's a different story but just spot
- 27:28Bitcoin. And then the second part is what
- 27:33to Marty's point is I think the qualified custody has confused a
- 27:39lot of individuals because they hear that term and they think of
- 27:42somebody like a prime trust is dealing is a qualified
- 27:45custodian, but they have the state charter in the recognition
- 27:48of the, you know bankruptcy remote, the legal rapper.
- 27:51But then they outsource the sub custody to an inferior solution
- 27:55versus somebody like a bit go who has a South Dakota trust
- 27:59charter but also has their internal world class custody
- 28:03similar to like a Gemini, right. Gemini has a New York State
- 28:07charter coupled with their and it's similar to the coin base.
- 28:10And so they're very different. And so people I think get
- 28:12confused on that. And then the last point is that
- 28:15new custody rule and I think that's been a conversation and I
- 28:18initially was very like concerned or skeptical of it as
- 28:21well. But then I became a lot less and
- 28:23you can tell me if this is incorrect after realizing that
- 28:26this falls under all assets. It's like alternative assets,
- 28:29real assets, real estate, alternative investments.
- 28:32And this is like it seems like a very like gross overreach from
- 28:35the SEC from a federal level onto state level and there would
- 28:40be so many people up in arms. It's much larger than digital
- 28:43assets that I can't imagine it ever gets actually enforced.
- 28:47So I know there's a lot, but maybe like working down if we
- 28:49can like talk through is QC actually required for spot BTC
- 28:53and then some of the like confusion between QC and custody
- 28:56and then maybe we can dive into like the enforcement and is it
- 28:59actually realistic Cuz I think that's on a lot of people's
- 29:02minds or they hear about it and they don't really have that like
- 29:04dispelled into those different like cohorts.
- 29:07Yeah, for sure. So the.
- 29:11Let's start with with what's the security and what's not a
- 29:15security. So, so there's kind of two
- 29:16different things going on. One is, is does this fall under
- 29:20the CFT C's jurisdiction? Does it fall, is it a security,
- 29:24so it falls under the SE C's jurisdiction, right.
- 29:27So there's that top level discussion or is it some other
- 29:29type of asset? And then because frankly,
- 29:33investment advisors, right, they invest in real estate, they
- 29:37invest in artwork. They invest in all kinds of real
- 29:40assets that that are not secured like securities at all.
- 29:45And so when it comes down to this custody rule, what they've
- 29:48tried to say is it used to apply just to fund and it still does
- 29:53because it hasn't the new rule hasn't come into effect.
- 29:55So this is just for a registered investment advisors and any
- 29:58state investment advisors that are subject to the custody rule
- 30:02and some exempt entities are like in Texas some.
- 30:06Some hedge funds are managers are subject to it. the IT used
- 30:12to be and it still is funds and securities does Bitcoin spend.
- 30:16So you can totally disagree about that.
- 30:18Bitcoin spends its funds if you don't keep it that simple.
- 30:21But traditionally commodities were not viewed as subject to
- 30:25the rule. So what you have now is a new
- 30:27rule, one of the parts proposed rule.
- 30:29One of the proposed rules is. Let's extend this to all client
- 30:34assets. And what's kind of funny is that
- 30:37people didn't notice, but in Dodd Frank, there was a new
- 30:41provision of the Investment Advisors Act, that statute that
- 30:44never has come and been used until now, that says safekeeping
- 30:49obligations of investment advisor apply to all client
- 30:53assets, not just funds and securities.
- 30:56That was part of Dodd Frank 1213 years ago, right.
- 31:00So, so now it's finally being kind of used and and as I
- 31:04mentioned these 29 trade associations have just written
- 31:09on September 12th of this year to to the division of investment
- 31:14management saying we don't like your rule because your
- 31:19requirement, your proposed rule because you first of all you're
- 31:22extending it to things like loans and.
- 31:26Real estate, artwork, precious metals, physical commodities.
- 31:31And you're trying to is the tail wagging the dog.
- 31:33You're trying to redo how that our traditional custodian models
- 31:38work in those areas. And the irony of this is partly
- 31:42that digital assets are the reason that that that one of the
- 31:47reasons that C C's been trying to grapple with.
- 31:51With the native properties of digital assets and whether how
- 31:55you bring it into the rule. So and if you take it at one
- 32:00step further like we didn't even bring up the fact that they're
- 32:03trying to not recognize the state charters as part of this,
- 32:06right, is like the South Dakota and they fall under the
- 32:09qualified custody or stripping them of that kind of like
- 32:14credential. Right.
- 32:16So I mean, you can imagine this rule kind of upsets all of these
- 32:19different businesses that work in certain ways.
- 32:21Like the rule says, for instance, the proposed rule says
- 32:25that you must have possession, that the qualified custodian
- 32:30must have possession and control, right.
- 32:33So the way they said, you know kind of for digital assets, they
- 32:37said okay, we think the possession and control is.
- 32:41The qualified custodian must participate in the change of
- 32:44beneficial ownership. So if you take private keys
- 32:47right you you, one of the requirements is one of those
- 32:50private keys or two, depending on how you read the the Rule 11
- 32:56key must. The qualified custodian must
- 32:58sign a transaction to participate in that change of
- 33:01beneficial ownership. So that creates a bunch of
- 33:03problems even in digital assets, right?
- 33:06If. If.
- 33:09You know there's some model where the asset goes to a hot
- 33:12wallet that the custodian doesn't control.
- 33:15So, so that's that rule is upsetting all these other people
- 33:19where there are other types of assets, precious metals, real
- 33:22estate, where is the qualified custodian participating in the
- 33:26change of beneficial ownership? What does that mean?
- 33:28Why are you making us rethink everything?
- 33:31So I don't think the answer is as close as people would like,
- 33:37you know? 29 trade associations asked the
- 33:40the rule to be withdrawn and they basically said, please take
- 33:43a look at how custody actually works before you come up with a
- 33:47new rule. That's basically what the letter
- 33:49says. And so it's it's ironic that
- 33:53that that digital assets are actually forcing, you know,
- 33:57well, maybe the qualified custodian should in theory
- 34:00participate in the change of beneficial ownership.
- 34:03You know, maybe they should, right.
- 34:05And so. You know, I don't think we've
- 34:07seen every the longer I'm in the space from writing that letter,
- 34:12the more you realize that this is a huge time frame of change.
- 34:18You know so. Well, and then that begs the I
- 34:22was gonna say that begs the question, should I mean, we've
- 34:25been talking about this in the context of asset allocators
- 34:28trying to bucket Bitcoin to a particular sleeve of their.
- 34:32Portfolio allocation, is there something similar on the
- 34:35regulatory side where you just need to separate this from all
- 34:38other assets and treat it completely differently?
- 34:43Yeah, I think it does beg the question of what what the
- 34:46division of Investment Management will do next.
- 34:48They have the regulatory authority on the deck front at
- 34:51Frank in my personal opinion. But do they?
- 34:55Do they have to rethink and say, well, what's custody?
- 35:00What works for custody in one asset isn't what works
- 35:03necessarily in another asset. So trying to find a unified rule
- 35:07is trying to make reality 20 different realities fit a rule.
- 35:13It's kind of hard to write that rule.
- 35:14Sounds like an impossible task. Yeah, it sounds like the dreamed
- 35:18up solution of a centralized planner trying.
- 35:21To come up. With a unified theory of
- 35:24everything, custody for all assets, it's impossible.
- 35:27Well, they did. They did put a lot of time into
- 35:30it and our conversations with them started 6-6 years ago and
- 35:34now we're just at the proposed rule stage getting criticized by
- 35:38various traditional custodians. So yeah, I think it does.
- 35:45To answer your question, Jesse, I think it means that all rules
- 35:49have to take into account the asset that they're trying to
- 35:54ensure it's. Reasonable.
- 35:58And and I wanted to tease out how it sort of feels like part
- 36:02of part of what Michael's #2 point there.
- 36:06And and what you were talking about, Gavin, is that qualified
- 36:09custodians don't necessarily have the, the competencies, the,
- 36:13the, the score, the core skills and competencies for for
- 36:17executing digital asset transactions.
- 36:21And many of them that have like dipped a tone to the space they
- 36:26are. Trying to bolt on those
- 36:28competencies to how they've done things for their whole careers,
- 36:32right, like the Scott Purcell example, the Prime Trust.
- 36:36This was just a growth area for a custody business.
- 36:40So they, you know, decided to say that they were, they were
- 36:44open for business to be a digital asset qualified
- 36:47custodian and without really having developed those skills of
- 36:52like what does it take to be a. A responsible skilled
- 36:56knowledgeable platform for that and and what are the risks
- 37:03inherent in all the surface area of attacks that you have to make
- 37:06sure you're accounting for And so like it didn't work for prime
- 37:11Trust and it didn't work for Fortress because they had this
- 37:13sort of bolt on approach to digital asset custody as opposed
- 37:18to someone like Bitco who has grown up in.
- 37:22A Bitcoin native participant in digital asset custody and has
- 37:28the chops to set up systems the right way.
- 37:33Yeah, it's a real, I was going to say it is a big gap in the
- 37:39space from we had Matt Mcclintock on.
- 37:41I don't know Gavin if you're familiar from Bespoke and he I
- 37:45consider you like top of your class and what your background
- 37:50coupled with digital assets and similar with him and trust
- 37:53planning. But even at his level when it
- 37:55comes to trust planning you have to get the assets out of the
- 37:58estate and going into a qualified custodian and right
- 38:01now that means giving it up to a third party and that's the best
- 38:03that we have. Well what happens if that their
- 38:05party goes out. He referenced I believe
- 38:07Anchorage and I know even bit go being world class like what
- 38:11happens in 10 years when you need to pass those assets on at
- 38:13the exchange. You know, the history of the
- 38:15past 10 years hasn't been good for exchanges, so it's a real
- 38:18problem. And just like how do you
- 38:19actually plan long term for the transition of these assets into
- 38:22your estate? Yeah.
- 38:23And I would just add like 1 little thing.
- 38:26I think that's driving a lot of frustration within the Bitcoin
- 38:29industry of people who grew up in this space and understand the
- 38:34primitives of the protocol intuitively much better than
- 38:37any. Qualified custodian does.
- 38:40And in the case of Prime trust, like, they made the biggest Bush
- 38:43league mistake that you could, which is they threw away the
- 38:46private keys that they previously had ownership over
- 38:49and we're allowing customers to send funds to wallets that they
- 38:53did, they destroyed the keys to, which is.
- 38:56Allegedly. But let's let's pretend like
- 39:00that's actually happened. If that did actually happen,
- 39:02like, again, that's like a Bush league mistake that any.
- 39:05Individual Bitcoin or knows like don't don't do that.
- 39:09The fact that a qualified custodian made that mistake is
- 39:11mind boggling. Yeah.
- 39:12And in that 2018 letter, we actually ended this was someone
- 39:16else's point, but they actually said, look, you actually need to
- 39:19hire qualified engineers like in the safety of a Bitcoin, you
- 39:25know, and I know it's about disclosure and then not
- 39:27necessarily that. Then here's the problem, right?
- 39:30If the problem is that the current law regulates investment
- 39:34advisors and. There's these rules about
- 39:36qualified custodians and then using them there's not really in
- 39:40the United States other than these trust companies and a very
- 39:44you know one or two federally charted before that got put on
- 39:48hold. Just just there's not really a
- 39:52comprehensive regime, if you like, for for regulating
- 39:56custodians and. I know that I can't tell you
- 39:59when federal regulation will will come, but that that
- 40:03actually is the part of some of the proposed federal regulation
- 40:06that certain custodians would be regulated and you know, by a
- 40:12federal entity. So whether that's the right or
- 40:15wrong, that's part of the problem.
- 40:18And to Jess's point, like that you can see it from a
- 40:22regulator's point of view, right?
- 40:24They're like okay. I know what a Trust Company is.
- 40:27You go hire a technology company that's totally separate, we'll
- 40:31kind of regulate your you as because we know what you are and
- 40:35then we'll make sure your contract looks kind of good with
- 40:37the technology company. And that way we don't really
- 40:41have to figure out the technology piece, right.
- 40:44So you can see why under the current law, that's the way they
- 40:48prefer things to go. Yeah, but from a pure like just.
- 40:52Pragmatic, logical, game theoretical perspective.
- 40:56It absolutely is insane, just like what we know.
- 40:59But then also like BlackRock is the premier example of this,
- 41:02like if it's all successful, that means Coinbase holds
- 41:05billions and billions, potentially trillions of
- 41:07dollars. That doesn't end up good for
- 41:09anybody. And we've seen this with like
- 41:11Block Five was a great example of those mismatches on like the
- 41:15liabilities versus and they were outsourcing, you know they sent
- 41:18it off to Gemini. But these like custodial
- 41:22agreements, like there's one thing to build it in house and
- 41:24have the competency and that's already like very scary because
- 41:28you, you know if you have any breach, any kind of individual
- 41:31inside that ends up going rogue. And ideally you have the, you
- 41:34know, permissions and the ceremonies in place to prevent
- 41:36that. But you still have that over
- 41:38your head. And then you extend it by giving
- 41:40up all of that, look what you referenced to a contract in a
- 41:42third party. Now you're hoping to God that
- 41:45they nothing happens with them, but they're also holding
- 41:47everybody else's assets and they're generally commingled.
- 41:51It's just not a sustainable, pragmatic way to think about how
- 41:54this industry will, like, grow. If it is to become, you know, 1
- 41:58trillion and $10 trillion, there has to be a better way.
- 42:02And and to you guys on the technology front, like one of
- 42:04the questions I like the risk factor I had to write back in
- 42:072018 was was, you know, short, the risk of short squeezes in
- 42:12the market. Like what is the question to
- 42:15you, like what happens when you know a trillion dollars needs to
- 42:20find Bitcoin and needs the actual asset.
- 42:24Imagine what the, you know, the liquidity issues that could play
- 42:29out worldwide. I don't know that to me not
- 42:31being, you know, I'm just a lawyer, but that seems like it's
- 42:37a big concern. It it actually is.
- 42:39We just talked about this as far as redundancies, right?
- 42:42Building the space you want redundancies across bank
- 42:44accounts, liquidity providers and making sure that you can
- 42:47always source the Bitcoin as the market takes off.
- 42:50You want to be able to never look at a client and say Oh
- 42:53yeah, you want your exposure and that you're going to have to
- 42:55wait or you have to find Bitcoin and that will happen.
- 42:57We, I mean, everybody always talks about this.
- 42:58It's like the. The mother of all short squeezes
- 43:00when everybody's trying to get through the door and it's like
- 43:02this big. And and Gavin, you're kind of
- 43:05projecting for the, you know what we, what we've seen over
- 43:08the last couple years, three years has been a decline of
- 43:12balances on on exchanges. And how far does that go?
- 43:18You know, does that just keep chugging along for another six
- 43:21years and then there's basically no Bitcoin on exchanges and then
- 43:25somebody gets caught in a in a massive short position they have
- 43:29to cover? Suddenly the price is gapping up
- 43:33because there's no willing sellers and you know the the
- 43:37price of Bitcoin might at that point be 100,000 and they can't
- 43:40find anybody to fill that amount of of Bitcoin necessary until
- 43:45you know 200,000. Like, that's the those are the
- 43:50the forces that collide here when you have a finite supply
- 43:54asset that nobody can print more of, and many people will
- 43:58continue to speculate against it.
- 44:00Already is so ready for that in his bones every this is a little
- 44:03inside. Every couple weeks I get a like
- 44:058:00 at night. The text it's like, I'm so
- 44:07bullish right now and one day the right it's gonna turn out
- 44:10the price just like rips and he's like I told you I.
- 44:12Felt well. Again, this points back to the
- 44:14beauty of the supply schedule. Many people neg it, but it was
- 44:19important. That's so she set it up the way
- 44:20he did so that the supply could proliferate and you could
- 44:23incentivize people to plug in minors and.
- 44:26Acquire Bitcoin. But I'm looking at the supply
- 44:28right now there's 19,490,993 Bitcoin on the market.
- 44:34So we're we have less than 1.6 million Bitcoin left to be
- 44:40dispersed to the market. And as Jesse mentioned, hardened
- 44:44hobblers who understand the value prop of Bitcoin have been
- 44:47pulling their their Bitcoin off the exchanges and so the free
- 44:50flow. Of Bitcoin on exchanges between,
- 44:53I believe, one and two million right now, maybe 2 and 3
- 44:56million. And that's not a lot of Bitcoin
- 44:59in the grand scheme of things. And so, yeah, I can definitely
- 45:01see a short squeeze happening sooner than people realize,
- 45:05especially if that trend of draining the exchanges continues
- 45:09inertest moving forward. And that's like the crazy
- 45:12psychological thing about this as time moves forward, we're
- 45:16approaching 15 years since the white paper launched.
- 45:18Like people? Fundamentally understand and
- 45:21grok what Bitcoin is and what it represents and its potential in
- 45:25the future more and more every day.
- 45:26And so they become more convinced in their strategy to
- 45:30huddle Bitcoin. And we've been saying it the
- 45:33last few weeks like this is the first time in human history that
- 45:36individuals been able to frontrun Wall Street.
- 45:40And that's going to be a fun lesson to watch play out as Wall
- 45:43Street learning they go, maybe we should have gotten in earlier
- 45:45and they're going to be buying at significantly higher prices.
- 45:48Kevin something that Marty just in what we're chatting about
- 45:51here made me think like how have you like what's your personal
- 45:55kind of perception of the the market and and just seeing it
- 45:59like we we talk a lot about like risk adjusted and you know
- 46:01getting into this space whether it's buying Bitcoin building it
- 46:04feels like we've just been in this like you know 20 roughly
- 46:0720K for practically 5 years it would hit you know top tick 20
- 46:12at at late 17 and. We've done a bunch of stuff
- 46:15between then, but you've seen first hand of people building a
- 46:18space, regulation, infrastructure, liquidity
- 46:21globally. Like how do you just like
- 46:25there's not really direct question other than like how do
- 46:26you see it from a fundamentals perspective and what's happened
- 46:30and what the difference is between from 18 or 17 to 2023
- 46:34going into 2024 and all the things that Marty just
- 46:37referenced with BlackRock and and the, you know, 19,000,000
- 46:40Bitcoin sitting in people's hands.
- 46:43Yeah. So I mean talking about the
- 46:45United States, first of all, you know, again, I'm just a lawyer.
- 46:49So but if you think about you know one of the reasons why
- 46:56division of investment management was so slow in the
- 46:58SEC too or or got guarded if you like on this the custody roll
- 47:03updates was that they realized that there didn't quite know
- 47:09what the bankruptcy remoteness treatment was of or at least
- 47:13they they didn't. There wasn't certainty and how
- 47:15quickly it will play out as compared to like a broker dealer
- 47:21or a commodities A futures Commission merchant.
- 47:23There's a bankruptcy regimes where kind of for smoothness
- 47:28suddenly these masses of customer accounts can get moved
- 47:31over to a different broker and there's the SEC knows what that
- 47:37treatment is. So part of the reticence is do
- 47:40we understand bankruptcy, remoteness and then also is it
- 47:43our job. And I think they kind of
- 47:45recognized that that you know that there are other federal
- 47:49regulators. You know you look at the OCC and
- 47:52the and the work that Brian Brooks did before it kind of got
- 47:55put on hold to to charter custodians basically thanks to
- 48:01their custodians and then some of the work to kind of stop
- 48:04states being able to charge their custodians like that.
- 48:09That process just talking about the United States has taken is
- 48:13not resolved and it's taken six years And during that time
- 48:18you've had like entities that were very sort of well regarded
- 48:24maybe not in the bitcoiner space.
- 48:27But we're we're large entities completely come and go.
- 48:32You know just just entities that everyone was doing business with
- 48:37outside of of, mostly outside of bitcoiners and those entities
- 48:42just don't exist anymore and and they look like they were ruling
- 48:46the roost for a while. So I think it's a lesson in
- 48:50realizing that the change takes a while and I, I, I, I keep
- 48:55coming back to I hate it. You know, I I did.
- 48:58I don't know if Parker was Lewis was the first person to come up
- 49:00with the gradually then suddenly expression.
- 49:03Do you know or does he get that from somewhere?
- 49:06What's the Hemingway reference? Isn't it?
- 49:08It's Hemingway. Sorry, we just gave him a.
- 49:11Lack of Hemingway saying how he went bankrupt.
- 49:14Yeah, how do you go? How did you go bankrupt?
- 49:16And he, a reporter asked him that and he answered well, two
- 49:19ways gradually then suddenly and so, so I kind of you see that
- 49:24we've seen that play out in this space, you know, a block 5
- 49:29Celsius. They suddenly grew here, Even
- 49:31the FTX, they grew huge. And then for reasons good and
- 49:35bad just went away over overnight.
- 49:39And so again in a bankruptcy context.
- 49:42So I think that you you're within the US you're you're
- 49:49going to need some more certainty and laws and and and
- 49:55Congressman probably to come up with some kind of and the
- 49:58industry some kind of acceptable regime that gives a bit more
- 50:01certainty to regulating custodians probably although
- 50:07that may be unpopular just so there's certainty and I think to
- 50:13answer your question like Michael like gradually then
- 50:16suddenly you know if you know there's a reason why spot BTF's
- 50:21have not been approved just because you know and I doubt
- 50:24it's because the difference between futures market
- 50:27surveillance and the spot Bitcoin surveillance.
- 50:30The stated reason it it's what are we unleashing if we approve
- 50:35one of these things and what's going to happen to the price of
- 50:40Bitcoin and do we want you know this is a regulator thinking do
- 50:43we want you know our country's citizens to have exposure to
- 50:49these to this asset they know and and and that's in my view
- 50:53that's sort of what's happening in in the reticence to approve a
- 50:58a spot Bitcoin ATF. With the pretty valid excuse of
- 51:05yeah, I I think it's largely driven by they don't want to to
- 51:10unleash this while finance is still the dominant player who is
- 51:13like flouting US regulators. And doing all all sorts of
- 51:19potentially illegal things. I think that's a very convenient
- 51:24excuse that they probably have rallied around as as a reason to
- 51:28not allow it yet. And that that's why I kind of
- 51:32like the building slowly approach that a lot of people in
- 51:35the Bitcoin spaces have used very, very sort of steps that
- 51:40seem you know, just seems slow right in some ways, but gradual
- 51:46building as opposed to these you know companies out of nowhere
- 51:50that come and go within a three-year cycle.
- 51:54And so I'm sort of bullish long long term, but long term might
- 52:00be longer than any of us want. Who knows when the suddenly part
- 52:04happens? We touched on it last week about
- 52:07private banking and I made this reference.
- 52:09We didn't go too far into it because it wasn't the topic of
- 52:11the. Conversation.
- 52:12But I feel like we're in an era of private banking because in my
- 52:14mind, all it means is you can fulfill your obligations.
- 52:18Your free banking. Yeah, what did I say?
- 52:19Private banking. Yeah, free banks, free banking.
- 52:24But similar, I mean similar concept, right?
- 52:26Private free, like the the idea that there is no Fed to backstop
- 52:29you. And so I think of finance is
- 52:31just a a free banking like they're fulfilling all the
- 52:34obligations on the liabilities and block 5 Celsius and all
- 52:37these firms haven't and the free market is ultimately like
- 52:40delivering on that. And you reference the
- 52:44evaporating with these firms. And that's the scary part of all
- 52:48this. As we've seen companies whether
- 52:50it's just like traditional tech and free money and what it
- 52:53happens to the quick cycle of somebody's life like in and out.
- 52:55And then Bitcoin and crypto is even faster.
- 52:58And that's what makes us it's like a catch 22, because people
- 53:00can't get into the space because they're afraid all their money's
- 53:02going to evaporate and then people come into the space and
- 53:05all their money evaporates. And that's what's like, so you
- 53:07know concerning about these ETF's and being centralized is
- 53:10because. They don't know that.
- 53:12All they know is being backstopped and the Fed saying,
- 53:14here's some extra liquidity and there are no bailouts in this
- 53:17space. And that's part of this
- 53:20conversation. We do it every week.
- 53:21It's like a lot of people are gonna get wrecked in this place
- 53:24because this is the first time we're experiencing something of
- 53:26a digital bearer token. And the 2nd, it's gone.
- 53:29It's gone forever. Yeah.
- 53:30And the funny like building on that, The funny thing is up to
- 53:35this point since the regulators. Seem not to understand what they
- 53:39should be doing and are moving extremely slow.
- 53:41The onus of regulation has been thrust on the free market and
- 53:46like on us as individuals like on TFTC rabbit hole recap like
- 53:51we were screaming about prime trust for years before it and I
- 53:53believe blew up we were screaming about block 5 Celsius
- 53:56FTX even. And So what we've found, like
- 53:59the best regulation within the space has been self regulating
- 54:03where it's. Creating informational resources
- 54:07and building a brand and the trust with an audience to say,
- 54:10hey, I like to think that I understand this space pretty
- 54:13well and who's doing custody right and who's doing custody
- 54:16wrong. And that has been the extent of,
- 54:18I would argue the most successful regulation is a self
- 54:21regulation of educating people about what this is and who they
- 54:25should be doing business with and.
- 54:26I think that's free banking. Like that's how free ranking
- 54:29exists, is like by reputation and where do you take your money
- 54:31and where you don't because you know that there's a fire.
- 54:33There might be a potential mismatch.
- 54:36One of the provisions we always draft and fund documents is the
- 54:39ability to redeem people in kind and say there might be
- 54:43situations and when a securities portfolio is just you know it,
- 54:49it's a portfolio that we can't recognize on to over three-year
- 54:53period. So we spin off an SPV and then
- 54:55we give it back you know, so you own the the actual assets
- 54:59through the SPV. And then we we redeem in kind.
- 55:02And I think one of the beauties of the ability to you know in a
- 55:08product where you can actually obtain, you know potentially the
- 55:12Bitcoin if you choose to go into an ETF or a fund and you can't
- 55:16actually obtain the Bitcoin. There's some complications
- 55:19there, taxes and and and that custodianship and transfers.
- 55:24And that that to me is like a mechanism of honesty, right,
- 55:28because you have to have the asset available and that's you
- 55:32know one of the things we came up with in the Texas law that
- 55:36that has come into effect that affects some some of the larger
- 55:40trading entities and custodians in in digital assets is you have
- 55:45to have that asset available to to to get it back.
- 55:51And I think the same thing is true that that that kind of
- 55:54honesty mechanism is ultimately like a good product design.
- 56:00I think that that's part of the like the free banking example
- 56:03here is the the winners emerge because they're trustworthy,
- 56:07because they've set things up right in the interests of the
- 56:10clients and and the reputation follows.
- 56:14And with Bitcoin we have the ability to implement these like
- 56:20these asymmetric setups the provide asymmetric leverage in
- 56:28terms of fulfilling custody specifically what we're trying
- 56:32to do with on ramp. But we've what we've spent a lot
- 56:35of time setting up multi institution custody that that
- 56:40takes Bitcoin's native multi sig properties.
- 56:44And maximizes security while minimizing counterparty risk
- 56:48because we have multiple institutions as key holders for
- 56:52the vaults that hold the Bitcoin, and that's not possible
- 56:56in the old world. It's possible in the new world,
- 56:59and in my opinion, it reduces the risk inherent in custody by
- 57:05an order of magnitude or two and in that free banking scenario.
- 57:11That proves out over time as a better model for for doing, for
- 57:16doing business, for clients to trust, because it leverages the
- 57:21technology in a way that you know holds up the interests of
- 57:26the clients at the end of the day.
- 57:28Yeah. And that's what makes like this
- 57:30whole space so interesting, whether it's building, investing
- 57:33in it or finding your counterparty.
- 57:36Because what Jesse just alluded to, this isn't just.
- 57:38Tied to on ramp like I think Unchained Capital is a great
- 57:41example of when we think about free banking on the lending side
- 57:46and being one of the last lenders, Bitco another one and
- 57:49how they collateralize the loans and also how the keys were
- 57:52segregated and always able to fulfill those obligations.
- 57:56Similarly with their custody product and holding only one
- 57:59key, they can't lose clients funds.
- 58:01It's it's, it's impossible. Now though the client can lose
- 58:04their funds they have to hold two or three, but it's still a
- 58:06much better model than holding you know with a coin base or
- 58:09another firm that you basically trusting unilateral control
- 58:11with. And similar to what we're doing
- 58:14on ramp, the the ability to, you know, have multiple institutions
- 58:18holding those keys, when you think about it just makes sense
- 58:21as a better model when you look at this asset.
- 58:23And what's again most exciting is the incumbents.
- 58:26Inherently will not most of them.
- 58:29I can't, we can't. It's an over generalization
- 58:31saying all of them, but I would say 90 plus percent cuz we've
- 58:33talked to them That model is completely antithetical to their
- 58:38whole like being from how they make money to how they think
- 58:41about the their industry and coming into this space even some
- 58:45of the best firms of the best names, they would never give up
- 58:48control of that asset. And so from a just a pure kind
- 58:52of opportunity standpoint of thinking that Bitcoin's going to
- 58:54be here, there's such a white space to create in it.
- 58:57Because again, just talking with Gavin and what we're discussing
- 59:00here from a game theoretical like logical perspective, this
- 59:04asset can't centralize with large entities because it's a
- 59:07recipe for disaster and it just opens up so much like you know,
- 59:11opportunity to engineer around it and develop products.
- 59:14That just makes sense to build that reputation as Jesse's
- 59:16referencing where you cannot mess things up singularly.
- 59:19That's not to say that things can't happen but it makes it a
- 59:22lot harder than what we've seen the past 15 years.
- 59:26Yeah. The other thing that the the new
- 59:30Texas Lord that that came into effects in September we kind of
- 59:34Texas Blockchain Council and and really worked with some of the
- 59:38regulators on and I helped on a a working group for it was just
- 59:44you know to your point Jesse just the fact that commingling
- 59:49isn't just as something that has to be solved at the books and
- 59:51records level it needs to be solved at a wallet level.
- 59:55So you you can't have without proper disclosure.
- 1:00:01At least you need to have the unspecified reasons you need to
- 1:00:07to have your wallet structure working so that there's no
- 1:00:11coming their customer funds platform assets.
- 1:00:14Except in limited situations. And so the new Texas law has
- 1:00:20that and has maintaining the customer funds in a way you you
- 1:00:25you can't maintain them in a way that you can't fully withdraw
- 1:00:27them, and you also can't use the assets of 1 customer to secure
- 1:00:34or guarantee the transactions of another customer.
- 1:00:37So obviously every law has its scope and application and
- 1:00:41questions about who it applies to but but that and then the
- 1:00:46requirement to have like auditability.
- 1:00:49You know accounting standards are kind of still catching up to
- 1:00:52what works and doesn't work reserves and does it what's its
- 1:00:57place and what's its function alongside other controls.
- 1:01:00But it it just seems like a good accounting standards are
- 1:01:06critical within the United States that that that to embrace
- 1:01:11like the properties of of Bitcoin and its auditability and
- 1:01:17then its native segregation. So to me, those are.
- 1:01:21Critical. So I have a accounting
- 1:01:25background and I think it's fascinating how digital asset
- 1:01:29space is still sort of catching up to why audits exist and like.
- 1:01:38You know, we we've, we've gone from a a world where there's no
- 1:01:41accountability in in terms of reporting.
- 1:01:44And then now you know the big exchanges, the the crypto
- 1:01:49casinos are pledging that in proof of reserves as this great
- 1:01:54innovation, this great breakthrough that they're going
- 1:01:57to provide this visibility to the reserves that they have when
- 1:02:01really that's 1/3 of an audit. You know that is that is proof
- 1:02:04of the assets on the balance sheet but not taking into
- 1:02:07account the liabilities or or or how the equity plays out there,
- 1:02:12which is comical. Comical to me from my accounting
- 1:02:15background because it the whole picture matters.
- 1:02:19The whole health of the business, the whole health of
- 1:02:21the balance sheet and the other financial statements.
- 1:02:24You have to see that all together in order to feel
- 1:02:27confident that you know the this is a.
- 1:02:32A going concern business and they are sound you know so in
- 1:02:37the example of like finance they have implemented proof of
- 1:02:41reserves, great, you've got, you've got assets but do those
- 1:02:45assets come from liabilities like are are are those are some
- 1:02:49of those borrowed assets that you owe to somebody, We don't
- 1:02:53know because that hasn't been you know a part of what the,
- 1:02:57what customers demand from. The businesses they they work
- 1:03:02with in the digital asset space yet and regulation is still sort
- 1:03:07of like catching up to that as well in terms of what is what is
- 1:03:11required of which digital asset businesses it's it's all just
- 1:03:16kind of funny that like there's 100 years, 150 years of learned
- 1:03:21wisdom about how to. Keep track of who's a healthy
- 1:03:27business and not in the accounting and audit space in
- 1:03:30particular. And we still haven't fully
- 1:03:33embraced that. And but it's, it's coming
- 1:03:35slowly. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:03:38Those accounting standards probably take 2-3 years to get
- 1:03:42created. Exactly.
- 1:03:43And we're seeing that right now with the, the updated FASB
- 1:03:46guidance, which I was just digging into this weekend, my
- 1:03:50latest writings on that. Micro Strategy and Michael
- 1:03:54Saylor have been advocating for this for three years, ever since
- 1:03:58they got into, you know, they went on a Bitcoin standard.
- 1:04:03Historically, Bitcoin is expected to be accounted for as
- 1:04:06an intangible asset, which means that when the price of it goes
- 1:04:10down, you have to mark down the value of your assets and record
- 1:04:14that as an impairment loss on your earnings statement.
- 1:04:19Which kills your your profits whenever the price of Bitcoin
- 1:04:23drops. But you're not allowed to record
- 1:04:26the the corresponding rise in price as a gain.
- 1:04:30So micro strategy is carrying a $2 billion loss on you know
- 1:04:35cumulative over the last three years on their on their earning
- 1:04:39statements and balance sheet. And they've been petitioning the
- 1:04:43whole time for Fadsby to update the guidance to do fair value
- 1:04:47accounting, which they are. They have now unanimously said
- 1:04:51can happen starting January 1st, 2024 and that's going to be a
- 1:04:56big, a big step forward for accounting of Bitcoin and micro
- 1:05:02strategy is going to be the big winner in that.
- 1:05:06Gavin, on the one of the things like personally and and I think
- 1:05:10the audience would be helpful is on the UCC ruling of the
- 1:05:13intangible assets and and. Where it started with Wyoming
- 1:05:17and it and I think Texas being I think probably 2nd and really
- 1:05:20the adoption of it. Can you share any of like the
- 1:05:26the recognition of Bitcoin as property and how that was big
- 1:05:30for Wyoming and where Texas like it has adopted that standard and
- 1:05:35what that means and I guess a little bit of like the
- 1:05:39background I was listening to? He was one of the guys that was
- 1:05:43familiar with this, I think in Wyoming and he basically went as
- 1:05:46far as saying that you shouldn't operate in a state.
- 1:05:49This was his words. You shouldn't operate in a state
- 1:05:51that does not recognize that the UCC ruling has Bitcoin as
- 1:05:54property. And I didn't fully, I mean I
- 1:05:57kind of directly understood it, but it'd be curious if you can
- 1:06:00kind of like help. Must understand that to the
- 1:06:02extent and I don't know if I'm putting you on the spot here but
- 1:06:04if you did extend. Yeah so I'm not a UCC expert but
- 1:06:09but one of the things that the custodians did when they wanted
- 1:06:14to obtain certainty under the law is they said I'm gonna put
- 1:06:20more or asset managers I'm gonna put the asset with a third party
- 1:06:27and I'm going to treat it under the UCC.
- 1:06:29Article 8 is like a securities in to me jury because I know
- 1:06:33what happens when you're securing a a an interest in in
- 1:06:39Bitcoin at that point a security interest and and then I kind of
- 1:06:43got around all of the uncertainties of Article 9.
- 1:06:47And so really Wyoming was you know way out there with with
- 1:06:51with Caitlin long and sort of saying well what is recognizing
- 1:06:55Bitcoin as property. You know obviously you can
- 1:06:57understand why a state like why Wyoming would be very in favor
- 1:07:03of property rights. But also just having certainty
- 1:07:07in that very boring mechanism that we are subject to every day
- 1:07:11where, you know, we get a car and it says there's a secured
- 1:07:15interest on the car if there's, you know, a loan, all the basic
- 1:07:20basic principles of of finance, you need the certainty.
- 1:07:25So Wyoming went out there and and Caitlin Long and others went
- 1:07:30to basically war with the Uniform Law Commission And and
- 1:07:34the other entity that if, you know UCC is like private law,
- 1:07:38it's like let's all decide how we're going to treat this and
- 1:07:45you know, we'll come up with the standard.
- 1:07:47You know, the Uniform Law Commission is not a government
- 1:07:49entity and then states can adopt it.
- 1:07:52And so it's a unique process where you say Okay state, does
- 1:07:56the state want to adopt this, this essentially a private law
- 1:08:00concept and say how do I get a proper secured interest in
- 1:08:04Bitcoin and do I recognize it as property.
- 1:08:07And so the Wyoming came up with a law and basically Caitlyn and
- 1:08:14others went to kind of war with the Uniform Law Commission about
- 1:08:19how they were thinking about things.
- 1:08:21And eventually there was a big swing internally in the Uniform
- 1:08:26Law Commission and the other entity that that kind of helps
- 1:08:30create standards in this private law.
- 1:08:32And so they came up with a definition of something called a
- 1:08:34controllable electronic record that that basically says, how do
- 1:08:41I get control over the asset? Do I go file a UCC statement?
- 1:08:44What do I do? And so they came up with a test
- 1:08:48that basically says you have to have the power to prevent
- 1:08:52someone else from using the asset, and you have to have the
- 1:08:56ability to avail yourself of substantially all the benefits
- 1:09:01of the asset. And there's a third requirement
- 1:09:07that is escaping me right now. But those there's these
- 1:09:10requirements that actually fit the way that multi signature
- 1:09:13works and digital asset works and is recognizes that you know
- 1:09:19like Marty says it's to some extent it's like a bear asset.
- 1:09:22So the definitions are kind of hard to understand and they
- 1:09:27create confusion. But it's just a critical
- 1:09:32mechanic. If you're going to be holding
- 1:09:35Bitcoin, for instance, and you want to secure, you want to get
- 1:09:39dollars. You don't want to sell your
- 1:09:40Bitcoin, You want to get dollars for for everyday expenses or or
- 1:09:46or whatever. And for those transactions to
- 1:09:49happen, you need this certainty. So you see the Wyoming let the
- 1:09:53way the sort of people who understood digital assets found
- 1:09:58their way into those private committees and then you know I
- 1:10:01forget the number if it's 20, some states are sort of behind
- 1:10:06that those laws and then so I hope that's answers your
- 1:10:12question. Yeah, I think that ties into
- 1:10:15some of the Texas stuff, but it'll let Marty go.
- 1:10:17But yeah the I think just the recognition like you reference
- 1:10:21with the prover deserves and knowing that kind of like back
- 1:10:24story of like Wyoming leading the way and then Texas you know
- 1:10:27starting to adopt some of it and taking further steps with the
- 1:10:29the prover reserves is helpful. Yeah, I wanted to really extend
- 1:10:35this conversation of how states are going to look at this and
- 1:10:38try to project forward like, Gavin, your opinion.
- 1:10:43Like how do you see this playing out in the future?
- 1:10:45I mean, just to give some context, when the federal
- 1:10:49government came out and was sort of postured like, hey, we're
- 1:10:53going to tell the banks not to bank crypto and Bitcoin
- 1:10:56companies, you had Ron DeSantis stand up in Florida and say,
- 1:10:59hey. Our state charter banks are open
- 1:11:02for business. If you're a company in the
- 1:11:04Bitcoin space that needs a bank account and you're within our
- 1:11:06state, you can use the state charter banks.
- 1:11:09And it seems like even outside of Bitcoin, that sort of
- 1:11:14posturing of individual States and their charter banks verse
- 1:11:18the Federal Reserve System is going to heat up, whether it be
- 1:11:22about the ability to give loans to fossil fuel companies or
- 1:11:26people beginning to have their transactions censored for.
- 1:11:29Doing things that the federal government doesn't like in
- 1:11:31states saying, hey, we think you should be able to do that.
- 1:11:34So you can do that within our banking system like moving
- 1:11:37forward, do you see this trend accelerating and the sort of
- 1:11:42juxtaposition of individual States and what they allow their
- 1:11:45individual, the banking sector within their states to do
- 1:11:50business versus the federal government.
- 1:11:53So, so you have like in Texas for instance the Department of
- 1:11:56Banking came out with guidance that you can custody a bank,
- 1:12:00state charted bank and custody Bitcoin.
- 1:12:03But has that really happened at large scale, not so much.
- 1:12:09And part of the reason is that that the banking system in the
- 1:12:13United States is so complicated as to what the state regulator
- 1:12:17does versus their federal regulators and the fact there's
- 1:12:21more than one federal regulator. So what the Federal Reserve does
- 1:12:27and whether or not you can give a state charted entity a a, a
- 1:12:33master account to be able to settle more frequently that sort
- 1:12:36of thing. There's still a massive
- 1:12:40dependence on the the various banking federal regulators and
- 1:12:44they are under the current administration not open in the
- 1:12:50same way that that they perhaps were with Brian, with Brian
- 1:12:54Brooks was at the OCC to embracing banks holding digital
- 1:13:01assets. And it's in part just because
- 1:13:03they don't understand it, you know, the risks, etc.
- 1:13:07And and whether it's whether any public blockchain is consistent
- 1:13:11with safety and soundness principles in banking, that's
- 1:13:15not something that the federal regulators have even conceded.
- 1:13:19So you could see some push to private blockchains because they
- 1:13:25they find that fits into their safety and soundness rules
- 1:13:28better than they understand with public blockchains.
- 1:13:33So you're going to see some major resistance without a
- 1:13:36change in administration in my view to at least at the federal
- 1:13:42level, the banking regulators really allowing the industry to
- 1:13:49move forward in the way that, you know now even some of the
- 1:13:52biggest institutions wanted to. Yeah, Jamie.
- 1:13:57Jamie Dimon Coin Marty. Is that the?
- 1:13:59That's the new thing. JDC is the new BTC.
- 1:14:02You heard of your first? Gavin, the the thing you
- 1:14:06reference with the state banks and banks in general seems very
- 1:14:09similar to like the SEC and the ETF.
- 1:14:12Because I know there's other regulations on the federal level
- 1:14:14with like custody and the one to one really parity with dollars
- 1:14:17to like that coin being held and it just feels like a kneecap in
- 1:14:19of the whole setup. I mean, what you reference is
- 1:14:22what you know Caitlin and Wyoming have run into with the.
- 1:14:26Custodia and basically getting access to the Fed window while
- 1:14:29they can operate at the state level and that's where they're
- 1:14:31in their lawsuit. So it sounds like until there's
- 1:14:33clarity there, maybe it's the ETF and then everything's all
- 1:14:37lights green. It it will be in that kind of
- 1:14:40like wait and see mode from these larger entities on how
- 1:14:43they're gonna get exposure or allow for exposure from their
- 1:14:46clients. Yeah.
- 1:14:47And and there was a, you know, albeit skeptical, but there was
- 1:14:51A and I forget the name of the V the the venture capitalist.
- 1:14:55But a famous venture capitalist gave some kind of equivalent of
- 1:14:57a a Ted talk recently about regulatory capture.
- 1:15:01And the example of like, you know the fact if if Elizabeth
- 1:15:06Warren goes after the assets for instance, suddenly her list of
- 1:15:12top ten donors include the largest digital asset companies.
- 1:15:18And that that's just that you have to understand these
- 1:15:21dynamics to understand how change is or is not going to
- 1:15:25happen. You know actively attacking an
- 1:15:28industry like writing to Texas about mining and Bitcoin mining
- 1:15:32etc Is has an effect of attracting donors which has an
- 1:15:38effect of increasing the and this is my personal opinion not
- 1:15:43not of the law firm increasing the the the sort of power of of
- 1:15:51you know in DC of the right people and so you you're not
- 1:15:56going to make change at the speed that you expect if if
- 1:16:02there are people that are making sure that their domain remains
- 1:16:06large and well funded. Yeah.
- 1:16:11However, this was sort of the the key insight of Sam Bankman
- 1:16:15freed in in pushing for the kind of change that he thought was a
- 1:16:20good idea. But.
- 1:16:24You know, your point is absolutely right.
- 1:16:26That like as Bitcoin succeeds in Bitcoin, companies and
- 1:16:30bitcoiners become a more prominent part of the the
- 1:16:34capital base and and industry that.
- 1:16:40Ability to exert influence grows in DC and that is a tailwind for
- 1:16:48better policy over time as Bitcoin's mechanics play out and
- 1:16:53hopefully it becomes a bigger. Part of the asset landscape.
- 1:16:57Can we do the Bill Gurley route where he said I was trying to
- 1:17:00get us far away from DC and let's say we're trying to let's
- 1:17:02forget about DC, Let's focus on Texas, right.
- 1:17:05Right. And that's what we have.
- 1:17:07We have a law in Texas now that addresses commingling and making
- 1:17:12sure funds are actually available in a way that Bitcoin
- 1:17:14actually works. So that's exciting to me and
- 1:17:19that's a great strength of being here.
- 1:17:22Yeah. And I mean on the Texas thing,
- 1:17:24it's not a accident we're all based in Texas soon to be one
- 1:17:28other individual on this call. But like Gavin, like you know,
- 1:17:32you you talked about politics and like how it works and it's
- 1:17:35been public. You know Lee was recently on
- 1:17:38with Nick Carter talking about Winstead and and TBC and some of
- 1:17:41that like to the extent you can share some of those dynamics
- 1:17:44like why you think you know Texas Wyoming's also part of it
- 1:17:49and there's like this natural kind of inclination for.
- 1:17:52You know, freedom and and sovereignty, but like how that
- 1:17:54ties in to also some of the work that's being done, you know, on
- 1:17:57the political side, the mining like just if you could share any
- 1:18:00of that dynamic because I'm personally as a native Texan,
- 1:18:03very interested and just excited that like have led this way.
- 1:18:07It feels like it's not going anywhere.
- 1:18:08You know we have the bullion depository up in, you know,
- 1:18:13North Austin that sits there and I think it's the only state
- 1:18:16sovereign bullion depository. So we're heading in this right
- 1:18:18direction. And so we think about building a
- 1:18:20business like it makes sense to be here.
- 1:18:22But you're at the forefront of it sitting in there be curious
- 1:18:25to kind of hear like what's going on and how you think we
- 1:18:27got here and and where we're going.
- 1:18:29Yeah. So when some of the early events
- 1:18:34that I that I attended obviously were like that that consensus
- 1:18:39event was pretty big that that that back in 2018-2019.
- 1:18:44And I remember seeing Gideon Powell who is does a lot of work
- 1:18:50in Bitcoin mining in in Texas. You know stand on the stage in
- 1:18:55New York with 8000 people and just said look bitcoin's coming
- 1:18:59to Texas and and talk about it and it seemed like a really
- 1:19:02typically brash and bold and and kind of wonderful moment.
- 1:19:08And then you know that was all before all of the changes with
- 1:19:12with China and and a lot more Bitcoin mining to coming to
- 1:19:16Texas and creating an environment that that supports
- 1:19:21mining where there's this kind of exchange with the the energy
- 1:19:25grid to try and stabilize the grid and this unique ability of
- 1:19:29miners to to to switch off at at peak demand times that that
- 1:19:35that's a whole another unique part of of Texas.
- 1:19:40And I think that you know I'm I'm still on my calls with with
- 1:19:46you know with the Wall Street Blockchain Alliance in New York
- 1:19:49you know New York DC lawyers for the legal working group.
- 1:19:52So I can keep up to speed and and we can exchange ideas on on
- 1:19:56kind of legal issues and there's been several weeks when they've
- 1:19:59just said look Texas, wait, it's all about Texas this week like
- 1:20:02what's going in Texas because. There, there's so much activity
- 1:20:06around mining that obviously Marty and Y'all can speak to
- 1:20:10really well, but that's also fantastically uniquely Texas.
- 1:20:16Yeah. And I think just bringing the
- 1:20:18mining aspect into this really adds like a layer of complexity
- 1:20:22for regulators, right? Because you have this digital
- 1:20:24bearer asset that many people view as money, some people view
- 1:20:28as property at a cruising value and then you have this
- 1:20:31connection to the physical world which manifest.
- 1:20:34Via the mining industry, which is very energy intensive and
- 1:20:38figuring out how to separate the the bearer instrument from the
- 1:20:41mining activity and like how do you tackle this behemoth that
- 1:20:48has been thrust on the world is again something I think slows
- 1:20:53down the process on the regulatory side.
- 1:20:55And I think really points to why you're seeing states leading the
- 1:21:01way, particularly here in Texas, because Texas understands
- 1:21:03energy. Obviously, we have ERCOT, which
- 1:21:06is very unique within the United States and it's becoming
- 1:21:09abundantly clear that Bitcoin mining is an additive positive
- 1:21:16positive value add to the grid system and that's why they're
- 1:21:21moving 1st. And we're seeing this begin to
- 1:21:23happen in other areas like Tennessee and Appalachia where
- 1:21:26the TVA is beginning to realize that Bitcoin miners are helping
- 1:21:29out there. But yeah, that's been my theory.
- 1:21:32For a while that states are going to lead the way,
- 1:21:34particularly in the mining industry, the energy rich states
- 1:21:37that really understand intuitively how the energy
- 1:21:41sector works and how you pull molecules out of the ground and
- 1:21:44turn them into electricity that allows you to turn your lights
- 1:21:47on. They're going to understand this
- 1:21:48quicker, and that's actually pulling this into the broader
- 1:21:53conversation we've been having for the last.
- 1:21:55Hour and a half almost, is that it gives me a lot of comfort
- 1:21:58knowing that these states are leading the way here and
- 1:22:00hopefully they can create the precedent that the federal
- 1:22:02government can say, all right, maybe you guys got this figured
- 1:22:05out. We won't get too involved with
- 1:22:07it. Yeah, and there's real there's
- 1:22:09real money and recognition we're long overdue for.
- 1:22:13We got to get a Gideon and our friend Griffin Habe.
- 1:22:16Maybe we could do a double on the mining side here in Texas.
- 1:22:21If you know we talk a lot about meetups and in Bitcoin and
- 1:22:24getting together. I think Houston meetup probably
- 1:22:25is one of the most special and different because when the
- 1:22:28market in the the I don't even know if this is politically
- 1:22:31correct or friend Griffin Havey will say checks it happened as
- 1:22:36the miners were leaving China and heading to Texas.
- 1:22:39Houston that that. That between Houston and Midland
- 1:22:43and the amount of native Texans that recognize, oh, there's no
- 1:22:47such thing as stranded energy and just fully embracing it, not
- 1:22:50even fully understanding that like, oh, I need to hold this
- 1:22:52long term. It's what I can transition
- 1:22:54physical oil and gas into this thing that I can get dollars
- 1:22:58for. The second they heard, it was
- 1:23:00like, oh, game on. And I've never seen it happen
- 1:23:03that quickly and then you that translates to politics and all
- 1:23:07of it because of the majors show up to these meet ups, they're
- 1:23:09still there. We know that they're looking at
- 1:23:11multi sig, they're looking at mining and all the things.
- 1:23:13And so that like entrenchment, to Marty's point, just sets the
- 1:23:17foundation for this not to leave and then to be like ripe for
- 1:23:20kind of innovation and continue to grow independent of anything
- 1:23:23at a federal level because now you're messing with actual
- 1:23:25individuals that are paying taxes to the to the state.
- 1:23:29And and Marty, I don't think it had ever really hit me before.
- 1:23:32You just mentioned, yeah, I most people probably don't even know
- 1:23:36that, that there are three grids in the country in the
- 1:23:40continental US There's there's the West, the East and Texas and
- 1:23:46that's, that's it. And because of that, because
- 1:23:49Texas has its own grid and has has to balance and and deal
- 1:23:53with, you know, grid stabilization issues on its own
- 1:23:56that that becomes a. A more pressing issue for Texas
- 1:24:01specifically to solve. And so Bitcoin mining becomes a
- 1:24:08solution that makes sense quicker, right and is more
- 1:24:11quickly embraced as part of how that problem is solved.
- 1:24:15And so I I've never really put two and two together before that
- 1:24:18like beyond the you know seasonality and and energy mix
- 1:24:24that. Texas has in the history that
- 1:24:26Texas has with energy, there's this, this pressing need to to
- 1:24:30solve the decentralization that Texas has with its energy grid.
- 1:24:35And here comes this decentralized energy solution
- 1:24:39that that can be a part of that. So interesting, yeah.
- 1:24:48And I've also kind of I just love going to see like Psycho
- 1:24:53facility that like you know Gideon built or someone else
- 1:24:57built and actually see how how it works and and and I still
- 1:25:00don't know much about the stranded gas and how you know
- 1:25:03that gets turned into the electricity that feeds the the
- 1:25:07the units that are right there. But that's.
- 1:25:10Yeah, I still think that the most badass video of of Bitcoin
- 1:25:15mining I've ever seen was was posted by Marty and it's a
- 1:25:19shipping container in the snow at night.
- 1:25:22With these machines whirring away and then the camera pans
- 1:25:26outside to, you know, a flare right there on the oil field.
- 1:25:30And it's this is how it happens this, this, this translation of
- 1:25:34that stranded energy in this remote and for hostile
- 1:25:38environment into energy in in, you know, digitally connected
- 1:25:42world. It's wild.
- 1:25:46Now you guys got me getting all nostalgic about Great America
- 1:25:48combining, but. No, it's beautiful too.
- 1:25:52When you see like particularly upstream on an oil gas well pad,
- 1:25:57like the visual, like the instant visual satisfaction of
- 1:26:01turning on us a Gavin, you ask like, how do you actually
- 1:26:04produce the electricity? There's generators, you bring
- 1:26:06them on and you pipe the gas that would have been going to a
- 1:26:09flare stack to the generator. Maybe if it's a bit dirty or you
- 1:26:12got to scrub it up first before you throw it through the
- 1:26:15generator. But then simple terms here's.
- 1:26:17Diverting that gas from a flare stack to a generator producing
- 1:26:20electricity, the mining with it on the back end.
- 1:26:23And so you have that direct efficiency gain with the
- 1:26:26reduction of flare and actually getting value out of that gas
- 1:26:29that you were just literally setting on fire moments ago.
- 1:26:33And then to your point, like how do you produce the electricity?
- 1:26:36That's another thing that I'm very confident about is that
- 1:26:39Bitcoin mining is going to create the incentives to have
- 1:26:42better generators at the end of the day, because uptime.
- 1:26:45It is of the utmost important. So when you talk about like the
- 1:26:47positive externalities that emanate from Bitcoin mining,
- 1:26:51whether it be behind the meter to do some load balancing for
- 1:26:55the greater upstream to do flare reduction, it's going to create
- 1:26:59these crazy efficiencies in many different areas.
- 1:27:02And that's just on the mining side.
- 1:27:03We're not even talking about the digital asset that creates
- 1:27:06capital efficiencies that creates.
- 1:27:09Efficiencies in terms of sending money globally, like the fractal
- 1:27:12nature of how Bitcoin improves systems in the physical world
- 1:27:15and digital is pretty insane when you sit down and really
- 1:27:20begin to understand what's happening.
- 1:27:22And then it's global. Like we know Latin America,
- 1:27:25Middle East right now, but Jesse's point about.
- 1:27:28The GAM video I think of when you reference that, I think of
- 1:27:31the the China stuff like there was a two that ring out where
- 1:27:34it's like a village in the middle of nowhere with the water
- 1:27:38using it into like this weird like.
- 1:27:40In the. Jungle, small generator.
- 1:27:42Yeah, in the jungle. And that's like making more
- 1:27:44money than they probably would make it in that local economy.
- 1:27:47And then the other one was just like, we think about anybody
- 1:27:50ever banning or all the stuff with Bitcoin, it's like.
- 1:27:53It's China and they still have whatever percentage of the hash
- 1:27:55rate. And then they had these like
- 1:27:57modular setups where they have like spotters to look when
- 1:28:00people are coming and then they just like literally close the
- 1:28:02gate on the, you know, the truck or how it's set up and then you
- 1:28:05just take off and you go to the next location.
- 1:28:06It's like there is no stopping any of this.
- 1:28:08It's just you either embrace it or you don't.
- 1:28:11Yeah, and and you guys got me excited about.
- 1:28:15What like gridless compute is doing in in Africa of
- 1:28:18implementing infrastructure in places where they haven't had a
- 1:28:21grid because there hasn't been an economically viable business
- 1:28:24case for for installing energy production.
- 1:28:27But now there's Bitcoin mining and so you've got all this
- 1:28:30hydropower and in in parts of Africa that you can set up a a
- 1:28:36micro hydropower energy producing unit and and for now
- 1:28:42the bulk of that energy is going to Bitcoin mining.
- 1:28:45But now there's energy in that location.
- 1:28:48And so if industry wants to set up there and say, well we'll pay
- 1:28:51you a little bit more for that energy that you're now
- 1:28:54producing, they can. And then you're bootstrapping
- 1:29:00industry and economies in a place that hasn't had that
- 1:29:04catalyst before. It's, it's beautiful, yeah.
- 1:29:10And I think one of the, you know, this is where like the
- 1:29:13boring stuff working to regulators is important because
- 1:29:18you know. Full circle here.
- 1:29:20Texas just taxes just came up with a tax incentive for using
- 1:29:26flared gas for onsite Bitcoin mining.
- 1:29:29And so there's not, you know, reducing taxes.
- 1:29:32So that sort of stuff is important.
- 1:29:36It's essential that adds a massive.
- 1:29:39Tailwind to what is a good economic force and it should be
- 1:29:43how, you know states especially we talked about how Texas has
- 1:29:48this particular need to incentivize this, this solution
- 1:29:52for grid stabilization and that's how you do it.
- 1:29:56And states can lead the way in incentivizing these things that
- 1:29:59are good for their energy system and the whole economy of the
- 1:30:04state. And Texas is leading the way
- 1:30:06because it has the greatest need for it.
- 1:30:10Yeah, it just reminded me of like Gavin and you know Jesse
- 1:30:14and I like building this business.
- 1:30:16You come across different individuals and I referenced
- 1:30:18Mcclintock in that same spectrum on the legal side where it's
- 1:30:23always fascinating to have like an expert but then an expert
- 1:30:25that's curious because that's when you like mirror what their
- 1:30:28personal interests and then the curious and then they find it
- 1:30:30and you find like just world class operators individuals and
- 1:30:34thinking about Winston and what you just reference like a is
- 1:30:36there even a would you. Like top five you guys have to
- 1:30:40be there and like legal firms in the in the world that understand
- 1:30:43this space partially because we're still so early but that's
- 1:30:45that's not it's also indicative of like what you guys are doing.
- 1:30:49But then two is like how much does that have to even do with
- 1:30:51being in Texas? Like could you have been able to
- 1:30:53operate or have this like free ranging thought or taking on the
- 1:30:55clients that you do if you were based in I don't know California
- 1:31:04Well I you know I I do love the fact we were like 300 lawyers at
- 1:31:09at Owensted and and so it's not like we have you know 10/15/20
- 1:31:14people sitting around doing only digital assets.
- 1:31:16How we do have a lot of people working on energy and a lot of
- 1:31:19people working on real estate a lot of people working on
- 1:31:22construction and all of that is is you know the stuff of of
- 1:31:27Bitcoin miners. And so I like that.
- 1:31:31Yeah, I think we're you know that that places as well And
- 1:31:34then probably you know there's plenty of you know crypto law
- 1:31:39firm practices that are you know more focused on web three and
- 1:31:44things like that in other parts of the country you know in in in
- 1:31:49Silicon Valley and then in New York and DC.
- 1:31:52So I do like the the kind of unique Bitcoin mining and
- 1:31:58Bitcoin centric practices. You know, obviously projects
- 1:32:03come in the door that are other things.
- 1:32:06When you have 300 lawyers, however, that's that's it's
- 1:32:10always centrally been, you know, Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining that
- 1:32:14keeps us, keeps me busy outside of straight investment fund
- 1:32:18launches. Yeah, Bitcoin seems already hard
- 1:32:20enough from a regulatory and legal perspective to manage.
- 1:32:23I can't imagine having 1000 cryptocurrencies.
- 1:32:25And how do you think about? Custody and securities and
- 1:32:28what's a token and all the. Other stuff, right, Exactly.
- 1:32:32I mean that gets to an interesting point I'll just
- 1:32:35touch on briefly, but I think that's another thing people
- 1:32:37don't understand that bitcoins, native sig or excuse me, native
- 1:32:40multi sig properties are sort of unique to Bitcoin.
- 1:32:44But you can't do that with Ethereum and many other the
- 1:32:47popular cryptocurrencies. Which I imagine that sort of
- 1:32:51muddies the water when you're trying to create regulation
- 1:32:54around this, because it's even within quote UN quote crypto.
- 1:32:56Bitcoin is very different from a primitive's perspective to the
- 1:33:01other protocols. That's actually a really great
- 1:33:03point Maria. I sort of think like we end up
- 1:33:06you end up seeing qualified custody and arrangements or
- 1:33:09opinion letters around you know multi cig and some of the stuff
- 1:33:13we're in a multi institution. Probably quicker than we we
- 1:33:16would initially expect because it's uniform to, it's applicable
- 1:33:20to any, any custody arrangement, any exchange, any new business
- 1:33:26that would do it versus what we talk about year of like if
- 1:33:28you're building you know a crypto exchange or custody
- 1:33:31arrangements around it. It's all pretty proprietary to
- 1:33:35the to the infrastructure provider or the third party
- 1:33:37you're opting into. And so it's a lot harder to
- 1:33:39like, create the right framework so you can actually.
- 1:33:43Get that legal qualified custody wrapper around the actual
- 1:33:46underlying technological you know physical custody it's it's
- 1:33:53probably also you know it's it's the regulator's understanding
- 1:33:59you know the the nuances of even what Bitcoin is versus other
- 1:34:04digital assets like that that's that's a hard that's still it's
- 1:34:10still not easy to to achieve because that they have their own
- 1:34:14interests and their own people giving donations and their own
- 1:34:17you know so so that's complex and then yeah the work that
- 1:34:24Y'all are doing to to help everyone understand.
- 1:34:29So, yeah, I don't know, I I just think that sometimes in in the
- 1:34:34regulation, you know, to make things happen you have to
- 1:34:38sometimes you know, have strength in strength in numbers.
- 1:34:45So I think there's times when you need to your interests are
- 1:34:48aligned, and times when they're not so.
- 1:34:53And we wanna be respectful of your time.
- 1:34:56I know we've gone a bit over and you are an extremely busy
- 1:34:59lawyer, so you probably need to get back to your to your job,
- 1:35:04but before you wrap up, I guess just to tie things together
- 1:35:08moving forward. What should our audience expect
- 1:35:14from the regulatory perspective? From your opinion?
- 1:35:17Like it's just going to continue to move as slowly as it has.
- 1:35:20Do you think the regulator is going to overstep?
- 1:35:21Do you think we have some time to really educate them?
- 1:35:25How should people be approaching the particular problems that
- 1:35:29exists from a regulatory compliance perspective?
- 1:35:35Yeah. So you have to be realistic
- 1:35:39about making sure your business model of works with the current
- 1:35:42laws in order to have success. And sometimes that might mean
- 1:35:46being more focused in what you're doing and staying that
- 1:35:48way for a while. So that's probably the biggest
- 1:35:51lesson because you know it change the whole gradually then
- 1:35:56suddenly it, you know six years talking about the custody rule
- 1:36:00and we're still at a proposed rule that stage that change
- 1:36:05happens. You know it happens slowly and
- 1:36:09there's a lot of interests in deceive to make sure that
- 1:36:13frankly coins that could be censorable are a little bit more
- 1:36:17attractive to federal regulators in some ways.
- 1:36:23But understanding the security risks of that and implications
- 1:36:27and bitcoins unique properties in my is it all my personal
- 1:36:32opinion or you know absolutely critical.
- 1:36:37I just think that don't expect the custody rule to come into
- 1:36:41effect tomorrow. Don't affect, expect that the
- 1:36:45regulation that the federal regulation, it will come.
- 1:36:47It's just a question of when that actually solves who's
- 1:36:51looking after and regulate actively regulating spot Bitcoin
- 1:36:56custody and spot Bitcoin trading that will change.
- 1:36:59But I think we've seen it takes, it takes a long time and there's
- 1:37:03gonna be a lot of businesses that go full cycle in that time
- 1:37:07if they don't build slowly and well.
- 1:37:14Sage advice. Focus.
- 1:37:16Focus is good. Move slow.
- 1:37:19Do things the right way in the meantime.
- 1:37:23Us in the industry will be self regulating and calling people
- 1:37:25scammers and trying to hurt people towards the the good
- 1:37:30actors in the space which are hard to find.
- 1:37:32There's a lot of noise out there.
- 1:37:34Michael, Jesse, anything to wrap up with.
- 1:37:36I just. Want to thank Gavin for being
- 1:37:38gracious with his time and coming on.
- 1:37:40There's a lot of information. This is a an awesome show.
- 1:37:42I think to look back on her as in Evergreen, to just talk about
- 1:37:45where we're where we're at, where we came from, where we're
- 1:37:48at and then potentially where we're headed.
- 1:37:49So appreciate it, Gavin. Thank you.
- 1:37:52There's a lot of, there's a lot of Bitcoin podcasts, but very
- 1:37:55few of them have on like lawyers who know what they're talking
- 1:37:58about and can really dig into the law.
- 1:38:01So for the listeners who made it this far, I hope you guys
- 1:38:03enjoyed the rolling up the sleeves of a of a seasoned
- 1:38:07Bitcoin lawyer here that to really show us the ropes.
- 1:38:11Thank. You guys, thank you Gavin.
- 1:38:15That's all we got this week. We'll be back next week.