Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Loan Participations Are Big Business with Bill Paton of Alloya Corporate Credit Union
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Reel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited today to be here with Bill Peyton from Alloa Federal Credit Union.
- 0:07Bill, how are you today?
- 0:09I'm doing
- 0:09Bill Paton: great, mark.
- 0:10Thanks for having me.
- 0:10Treichel: Alright.
- 0:11Interesting times.
- 0:12Hey, I had you on the podcast one other time.
- 0:15I know we talked about capital markets back then, and we're gonna talk
- 0:18about some nuances related to that.
- 0:20But I saw on LinkedIn you were making reference to a loan participation program.
- 0:27That had just passed $3 billion in transactions that a lawyer has, and
- 0:31I thought it would be good to talk about that program and how it's been
- 0:35working for a lawyer and how it's been working for your client, credit unions.
- 0:39Yeah.
- 0:40I,
- 0:40Bill Paton: Appreciate you reaching out and yeah, we recently last
- 0:44month crossed the $3 billion mark in, in terms of transactions.
- 0:49On our PLA platform.
- 0:51We've gone over 4 billion in total for the program.
- 0:55Just and it's a really interesting kind of history of what happened there,
- 1:00and I think that's the most, most important part of the entire program.
- 1:04But just real quick probably like eight years ago, a lawyer.
- 1:10Used to purchase corporate, federal credit unions were able
- 1:13to purchase loan participations.
- 1:15It was called Part five Authority that they had, and they could purchase
- 1:20participations from credit unions.
- 1:22That was taken away during the crisis.
- 1:25But we still had a lot of credit unions that had the need to sell participation.
- 1:31So we had gotten a phone call from a credit union.
- 1:33Just saying, Hey, we know you have a large network of credit unions that own you.
- 1:38Can you help us?
- 1:40And so we just brokered a deal and then that became another deal
- 1:44and then that became a third deal.
- 1:46And I remember going into my boss at the time and saying, Hey, I
- 1:51think we have something here.
- 1:52Do you mind if I kinda mess around with it a little bit?
- 1:56And he said, sure.
- 1:57Just don't do anything stupid.
- 1:59Always good advice, which is great career advice.
- 2:03And while I can't say I didn't do anything stupid I do think that the the benefits
- 2:08certainly outweighed the risks in that.
- 2:10And we had did a, about a billion dollars.
- 2:13But during that timeframe our CEO Todd Adams.
- 2:16Said, Hey, we, there's really something here, and I think we can
- 2:20do more than just brokering deals.
- 2:22And that's needed.
- 2:23And there are pe there are a lot of people that do that.
- 2:25And they're really good at that.
- 2:26And he really wanted to create a end-to-end solution created
- 2:30by the credit union industry.
- 2:33And so that's what we did.
- 2:34And they invested a lot of time, a lot of resources so credit
- 2:38to him, our senior management team and our board for doing so.
- 2:41And it's really the first.
- 2:43End to end loan participation solution created by the credit union industry.
- 2:49Industry.
- 2:50There are others and they're very good too.
- 2:52I but this is the first created by the industry.
- 2:54And so yeah, so we've done, like I said, a billion dollars before
- 2:58that, 3 billion now and growing.
- 3:01We've got.
- 3:02Over 500, I think maybe even closer to 600 credit unions on the system.
- 3:08Right now.
- 3:08There's new ones coming every single day and it's it's great and it plays
- 3:13really well into the core corporate hemisphere, I think is the right words.
- 3:18Corporates, maybe you know better than I do.
- 3:21So let me ask you this 'cause because I don't think anybody really knows.
- 3:25Corporates we believe were created in the late sixties or early seventies.
- 3:30We don't know when
- 3:33Treichel: that sounds right?
- 3:34I might have to, yeah, I'd have to go back.
- 3:36The best way to check that might be NNC a's annual reports, which are on PDFs.
- 3:42They used to be very well organized on NCAA's website.
- 3:46I was looking.
- 3:47Messing around looking for a year the other day and couldn't find it.
- 3:51But that's probably the best way to check.
- 3:53If you guys couldn't find it, I would say that there's probably an
- 3:57annual report that references it.
- 3:59I'll
- 4:00Bill Paton: I'll definitely have to do some digging.
- 4:01That'll be a fun research project.
- 4:04But corporates are created really to do two things, right?
- 4:06They're created to provide liquidity for credit unions and to help them access
- 4:10the Fed when the banks effectively.
- 4:13Combine together and get them out of the banking space.
- 4:16And so we continue to do that today just in different ways.
- 4:21And loan participations is a perfect example of being able to provide liquidity
- 4:26when they need without having to draw on a line of credit and also additionally
- 4:32invest in great assets and system assets.
- 4:35I.
- 4:36When they have the additional capital, and the additional liquidity.
- 4:39So it's really a credit union.
- 4:41It's a really a credit union solution to, those problems.
- 4:45And we love it and we're heavily invested in it and we'll continue to be.
- 4:48So yeah we're super proud of it.
- 4:50And really what it's done for our company and we live for the industry,
- 4:53Treichel: A couple things I wrote down here as you're chatting.
- 4:55So 600 credit unions on the system.
- 4:58You've got the portal.
- 4:59I think in the old days maybe when you were helping be a matchmaker, that might
- 5:04have been more of a hard copy type set up.
- 5:08And now you've got this portal and so 600 credit unions on it.
- 5:11I'm assuming that means you have some that are on there to buy
- 5:13some that are on there to sell.
- 5:15Any kind of a mix you could relate relative to that and Yeah.
- 5:19Had any thoughts on on the portal and how that all works and Yeah, in that?
- 5:24Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:25So
- 5:25Bill Paton: using the term matchmaker great term.
- 5:28That's really what we did prior, and we still do that.
- 5:31So of the 600 credit unions, let's say.
- 5:35It's four to one, four and a half to one buyers, to sellers.
- 5:41The but it's, and it's, I think a lot of people when they think about
- 5:44this they say it's participation have historically been, and this is a, it is a
- 5:50fun thing to go and look at the numbers.
- 5:52Historically, it's been like a larger credit union.
- 5:55Type of a play, over the last 20 years.
- 5:58This is not a new solution.
- 6:00It's been around for a very long time.
- 6:02But what's been really interesting is to see how the smaller credit unions
- 6:07have started to utilize it, right?
- 6:09And so we have a credit union that is 14 or $15 million that sells some
- 6:15mortgages to us because they serve.
- 6:17A very specific sag.
- 6:19And those sag, the couple people need mortgages, but it's only $15 million.
- 6:24So you throw a couple mortgages on that kind of really
- 6:27chunks up the balance sheet.
- 6:28And then we have, 20, $30 billion credit unions that sell
- 6:33through us on a regular basis.
- 6:35And it's great because that system is agnostic to size
- 6:38and it helps however, right?
- 6:40And so there is the matchmaking or marketplace side of things.
- 6:45And there is the system was really built with the NCUA guidelines, right?
- 6:52The requirements for participations in line.
- 6:56So if you're a buyer, when you go through our process, you don't even know that
- 7:00you're going through the process, but you can't actually complete the deal
- 7:04without doing all of the requirements that the NCA says you have to do.
- 7:07What you gotta look at.
- 7:09The underwriter, the originating credit unions due diligence package.
- 7:13You gotta look at the loans, you gotta make notes.
- 7:16Whatever it is, you gotta have an agreement in place.
- 7:18And we have one single agreement.
- 7:20We actually, it's created by credit unions.
- 7:22We locked 12 credit unions, six buyers and six sellers in a room.
- 7:26I'm not joking about that.
- 7:27We locked them in a room and said hey, you guys gotta come up.
- 7:30We have a relative framework.
- 7:32You guys gotta figure out the rest of it.
- 7:34And they did, and it's partial it's not partial to either side.
- 7:38A lawyer is a party to it as well.
- 7:40So as a credit union ourselves as a depository ourselves,
- 7:45we have a balance sheet.
- 7:46And so we will help facilitate the flow.
- 7:49So today, when credit unions have a lot of liquidity, you don't
- 7:54really need somebody to step in.
- 7:56But when liquidity is needed and credit unions aren't buying like they normally
- 8:00would like today a lawyer will step in and we actually can help put, we can put
- 8:06some of those loans on our balance sheet to help to sell in credit union offload
- 8:10those loans and feel comfortable that they're not gonna, that they can meet
- 8:13their liquidity and balance sheet needs.
- 8:15So those are just some things.
- 8:16Yeah.
- 8:16Those are high level talking points about
- 8:18Treichel: it.
- 8:19I'm sorry.
- 8:19And the NCA compliance, so I'm assuming that would deal with the third party
- 8:23due diligence requirements, correct?
- 8:26Yeah.
- 8:26And the,
- 8:27Bill Paton: yeah, so we don't go through and I don't want anybody
- 8:30to say, Hey, a lawyer is doing the due diligence with you.
- 8:32Correct.
- 8:32We're not but everything that you need to be able to do is there, right?
- 8:38So when you go and see a package.
- 8:41Everything that you need is there.
- 8:42Now you can request more for sure.
- 8:44But everything that is needed to fulfill those requirements will be there for you.
- 8:48The sellers required
- 8:49Treichel: to it's like filling out anything line.
- 8:51Correct.
- 8:51You need the, you need to put something in these five spa buckets, and then the buyer
- 8:56goes and looks at that bucket buckets, and then they make their own decisions
- 8:59based on their own due diligence.
- 9:01But you have the portal there so that they.
- 9:04They can do it.
- 9:05Okay.
- 9:05Yeah.
- 9:05Got it.
- 9:06Bill Paton: And again, because we are a depository and part of
- 9:10the, what corporates do, right?
- 9:12Facilitate the flow of money from institution to institution, that
- 9:17all happens automatically, right?
- 9:19So there's no more wires, things of that nature.
- 9:22That's all done through our payment rails already.
- 9:25And so that really helps reduce some of the backend headaches.
- 9:29And then where we really shine is on that monthly reporting.
- 9:34So we do a lot of the reporting.
- 9:36So again, once a deal closes, that's the fun part of it.
- 9:40The not so fun part is what happens when it closes, right?
- 9:43It's.
- 9:44It's, you have to send your reports to investors.
- 9:47You have to send your payments to investors.
- 9:49All that is done and it's done automatically because of what we are.
- 9:53There are fintechs that do similar things, but they can't do it
- 9:55because they are not a depository.
- 9:59Now they've done a great job figuring other ways around that.
- 10:03But because of what we are we are able to have that and have that happen.
- 10:07Got it.
- 10:07Automatically.
- 10:08Treichel: So yeah, it's the credit union advantage, if you will.
- 10:11Yeah, it is.
- 10:12Types of loans, are there any do business loan commercial signature?
- 10:16Yeah, completely
- 10:17Bill Paton: agnostic.
- 10:18We've done some fun ones.
- 10:20So ATM like the ATM.
- 10:24Machine, right?
- 10:25Some of those we've done airplane loans.
- 10:29We've done power pressure washers.
- 10:32We've done huge commercial deals.
- 10:34I'll say, the vast majority of our stuff is plain vanilla.
- 10:37We serve right, so plain vanilla auto loans, mortgages,
- 10:42recreational, some signature loans.
- 10:45But we get fun and have some.
- 10:47Some interesting things across our paths.
- 10:49That's actually fun.
- 10:50I'll see something come through and I'll say, Hey, send me that package.
- 10:53I wanna look at these loans a little bit more.
- 10:55Just 'cause I, it's been a while since I've been on the underwriting
- 10:58side of things and fun to see what type of loans come about.
- 11:01So
- 11:02Treichel: that's that's great.
- 11:03And, yeah the pendulum swings on when credit unions do or don't
- 11:05have liquidity and then even.
- 11:07If credit unions don't there's, don't have it.
- 11:10There's some that do.
- 11:11And if credit unions in totality do have it, there's some that don't.
- 11:15So that, that goes back to the the matchmaker type concept.
- 11:19Have you just curious anecdotally in some of my conversations with credit
- 11:24unions I'm seeing where NCA is saying, Hey, your loan to assets are too high,
- 11:28your loans to share pick some barometer of, of liquidity that relates to loans.
- 11:33I've seen credit unions get beaten up in that regard.
- 11:36Have you, I'm imagining you've had people calling saying, Hey, NCA, saying
- 11:40I'm my liquidity's getting a little tight, so I wanna sell some loans.
- 11:43Is are those kind of conversations happen?
- 11:46Bill Paton: Yeah.
- 11:46It's been happening for years, right?
- 11:47So I've been in my position I was an underwriter right when I started,
- 11:52so I've been here for 18 years.
- 11:53That's been happening forever.
- 11:55The super interesting thing is it's different from region to region.
- 11:58So certain regions will have different parameters.
- 12:01I'm shocked over here.
- 12:03And I won't say which ones.
- 12:04I'll just say it does vary from my experience.
- 12:07This is purely my experience.
- 12:09It does vary and sometimes it'll vary from examined or examiner and
- 12:12whatever they're looking at, right?
- 12:13Yep.
- 12:14And but yeah, it, that happens constantly.
- 12:17What we have noticed more than anything.
- 12:20They won't say, Hey, your loan to share ratio or your loan to
- 12:24asset ratio is getting too high.
- 12:27You need to sell these loans.
- 12:28They'll say, Hey, you've got your liquidity.
- 12:30You've got your loan to assets are X and that's historically been okay for
- 12:35you, and you've got your lines of credit and you've got your non-member deposit
- 12:39ability and you're able to raise, certificates of deposit or what have you.
- 12:43You have your outlets, but what you don't have is your ability to sell loans.
- 12:49We want you to get set up to be able to do so whether that's through a lawyer
- 12:54or a competitor or what have you, or just simply you have it internally set
- 13:00up so that you know if you need to sell do and in fact right now we're going
- 13:06through with the credit union to sell a $250,000 pool, which is, truth be told,
- 13:11that is so small for this credit union.
- 13:13It's probably not worth.
- 13:15A lot of people's time, except for that's what they wanna be able
- 13:18to do so that they know they're ready to sell when they can sell.
- 13:22And yeah, that's what I'm saying.
- 13:24It's not so much a, Hey, you've hit 95% sell, 5% of your of your loan to assets.
- 13:30So sell 5% of it to get under that 90% threshold is more we want you to get
- 13:35ready to be able to do I'm viewing it as.
- 13:39They're looking at another liquidity source.
- 13:41Treichel: Sure.
- 13:42Bill Paton: No, exactly.
- 13:43And they might want 'em to start selling.
- 13:45I wouldn't be surprised for 'em to say, Hey, sell it one once a year.
- 13:48Kind of like testing your line of credit.
- 13:49Treichel: Yeah, no, that makes sense.
- 13:50Makes a lot of sense.
- 13:52Very good.
- 13:53So Bill, is there anything that I should have asked you about this program that
- 13:57you wanted, that you want to make sure you mention or any, anything else under
- 14:02the sun, interesting times right now.
- 14:04Any, anything else you want to touch on other than this program, but
- 14:08anything on the program first, and then anything else you wanted to chat about?
- 14:11Yeah,
- 14:12Bill Paton: I'll I'll say this we are super.
- 14:15Excited and proud of our platform and we have big things for it.
- 14:20But it is just one thing that we do, right?
- 14:22And I think it's a great compliment to credit unions and the system at large,
- 14:26but it's not the only thing we do.
- 14:27Anything that credit unions are looking for liquidity investments, capital
- 14:32in general look to your corporate.
- 14:34And I won't just say a lawyer, look to your corporate first.
- 14:37And if you're not a part of a corporate.
- 14:39Understand that it can do a lot for you that you may not even know.
- 14:43So I'll just give a kind of a pitch to the overall corporate structure.
- 14:47We do a lot more than people think.
- 14:48We can.
- 14:48I.
- 14:49And then two, I'm going to respectfully decline Any any thoughts what is
- 14:54going on in this hectic turbulent world right now as I am not the
- 14:59expert in any way, shape, or form?
- 15:00Very good.
- 15:01Very good.
- 15:02Treichel: Got it.
- 15:03Got it.
- 15:03And bill if someone's listening to this and they, they're a member of your
- 15:07corporate or another and they wanna chat with you about this program and maybe
- 15:11potentially join your corporate what's the best way for them to reach out and
- 15:15chat with you about this or anything else?
- 15:18Yeah
- 15:18Bill Paton: LinkedIn is always great.
- 15:19So it's William and then P-A-T-O-N.
- 15:23At on LinkedIn and then you can hit, you can shoot me an email.
- 15:27It's bill dot PATO n@alawyercorp.org.
- 15:34So that's A-L-L-O-Y-A.
- 15:37COR p.org.
- 15:39I know it's a mouthful, but that's the that's the email address and I'm not
- 15:42going to give out my cell phone number because I can't imagine what types of text
- 15:46messages I'll be getting from some people.
- 15:47So yeah the LinkedIn email's great.
- 15:50And yeah, thanks.
- 15:51Thanks for having me.
- 15:52You got it.
- 15:52Really appreciate it.
- 15:53Treichel: This has been fun.
- 15:54It sounds like a great program.
- 15:55Another tool that credit unions can have in their toolbox and.
- 15:59I'm glad it's working so well for credit unions and lawyer.
- 16:01Bill, thanks so much for your time today.
- 16:03Bill Paton: Appreciate it, mark.
- 16:04Thanks.
- 16:04Forward talking soon.
- 16:06Treichel: You got it.
- 16:07And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 16:09As always, I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 16:11Mark Tril, signing off with flying colors.