Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Managing a Potential Crisis: Preparing for Public Scrutiny While Staying Civil
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome everybody to today's presentation which
- 0:06is managing a potential crisis, preparing for
- 0:09public scrutiny while staying civil. I have to
- 0:12say other than artificial intelligence. This
- 0:15seems to be a very timely topic for everybody
- 0:17that watches the news with the Baldonis herds
- 0:21and depths of the world. So this is a very timely
- 0:24program. My name is Keith Cooper. I am the vice
- 0:27chair of the BHBA entertainment law section,
- 0:31not the whole BHBA. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:33our speakers. We have Anthony Storm, Terry Fon,
- 0:36and the Honorable Craig Carlin. I will introduce
- 0:39them. In order, Terry. specializes in strategic
- 0:43communications, litigation support, crisis, and
- 0:47reputation management. He joined Steric and Company
- 0:51in 2000 after working as a litigation attorney.
- 0:54During his tenure at Citric, he worked on complex
- 0:59crisis litigation and business matters, representing
- 1:03and advising clients that include publicly traded
- 1:06companies and private businesses, non -profit
- 1:09organizations, corporate executives, government
- 1:11entities, lawyers, law firms, and private equity
- 1:14firms, in addition to high profile celebrities,
- 1:17performers, and professionals. athletes. He's
- 1:20also worked with several national retailers,
- 1:22apparel companies, municipalities, and government
- 1:25officials on a variety of public relations issues.
- 1:29Anthony Storm is a founding partner at Storm.
- 1:32I hope I'm pronouncing this right. Correct me
- 1:34if I'm not. Pellian, Storm Pellian, LLP, and
- 1:38is known for his expertise overseeing electronic
- 1:41security issues related to divorces for public
- 1:44figures. This includes taking steps to prevent
- 1:48disclosure of private information and minimizing
- 1:51the harm if a disclosure occurs. Mr. Storm entered
- 1:54the family law arena following his tenure as
- 1:57a clerk for the United States Attorney's Office.
- 1:59Very litigated criminal matters for the federal
- 2:01government. He was also recognized for outstanding
- 2:04service, receiving awards from both the United
- 2:07States Attorney's Office and from the Los Angeles
- 2:10County District Attorney's Office. Finally, we
- 2:13have the Honorable Craig D. Carlin. Judge Carlin
- 2:18has been retired for a couple of years, is now
- 2:21a mediator, arbitrator, and referee with ADR
- 2:25Services, and has mediated an estimated 500 or
- 2:28so cases, so hardly any. Judge Carlin is an invaluable
- 2:32asset to trial lawyers due to his impassioned
- 2:35commitment to studying and mastering every aspect
- 2:38of a jury trial over the last 32 years. Judge
- 2:41Carlin's experience is evidenced by a track record
- 2:44of trying countless cases to verdict, both as
- 2:47a litigator and a judge. His passion for jury
- 2:50trials enables him to be exceptionally effective
- 2:52and effectively, I'm going to try it again, an
- 2:55exceptionally effective settlement officer. Having
- 2:58served as a judge for the Los Angeles Superior
- 3:00Court West District for over 20 years, he approaches
- 3:03all cases with the knowledge and expertise gained
- 3:07from presiding over thousands of general jurisdiction
- 3:10civil matters of every imaginable variety. I'm
- 3:14going to go one thing off script. I want to give
- 3:17a shout out to Rin Santiago, who's been instrumental,
- 3:20by the way, in putting all of these panels together.
- 3:23So thank you to Rin. And now with that, Let's
- 3:26get started. Gentlemen, please take it away.
- 3:30Thank you, Keith. Very much appreciate your time
- 3:32and efforts in helping to put this together.
- 3:34Thank you, Rin, as well as the rest of the staff
- 3:37at the Beverly Hills Bar Association. We have
- 3:39a great panel here tonight. We're really, really
- 3:43fortunate to have both Judge Carlin and Terry
- 3:46Fawn here. Terry is, in my opinion, second to
- 3:50none. when it comes to crisis PR. His firm, Citric,
- 3:54is very well known nationally, handles extremely
- 3:58high -end prestigious cases, and he's really
- 4:00the fixer, the guy to go to when there's a crisis
- 4:04PR issue. Judge Carlin, I've known for many,
- 4:07many years. He is an unbelievably fair and just
- 4:12bench officer now at ADR Services. I think we're
- 4:15lucky to have them both here. This is going to
- 4:17be a great program. Briefly, I'll start with
- 4:20what we're really going to be talking about tonight,
- 4:23what we're going to hit. Our core themes that
- 4:27we're going to deal with are how do we maintain
- 4:30civility with opposing counsel, the parties,
- 4:34and the judiciary, even when there's scrutiny
- 4:37on the case? How do you get prepared to address
- 4:40media, leaks, and public attention? We'll talk
- 4:45about media guidelines. We'll talk about strategy,
- 4:48whether you want to go on on the offensive or
- 4:51be on the defensive. If you can control the narratives
- 4:55before other people do, that's usually probably
- 4:58a good thing. I know Terry told us when we were
- 5:00preparing, if you don't tell your story, they
- 5:03might tell it for you. And I thought that was
- 5:05a very powerful, insightful statement. We're
- 5:09going to balance legal strategy with public perception
- 5:13and reputation management. What happens when
- 5:17there's litigation, when there's no other course
- 5:20and it's imminent? Do you still have an alternative?
- 5:24Can you mediate? Can you arbitrate? What tactics
- 5:28can you take to keep your case out of the limelight?
- 5:33What does the court think about these extra -traditional
- 5:35statements? And always, of course, this is a
- 5:37civility program. You got the ABCs. Always be
- 5:42civil. For those of you out there might remember
- 5:45Glenn Gary, Glenn Ross, always be closing, but
- 5:47we'll do always be civil here. We have the duty
- 5:50of candor, the duty to be civil. Judge Carlin
- 5:55will talk about how those duties and how you
- 5:58act really impacts the decision making from the
- 6:01bench. So with that, I'm going to hand it over
- 6:05to Terry for a little bit. And we're going to
- 6:07talk about how do you prepare for media scrutiny?
- 6:10Well, thank you, Tony. It was very kind of you
- 6:12to have those nice words about me. It's nice
- 6:16to join the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 6:18this presentation. I am a lawyer. I'm not practicing
- 6:21any longer, but I use my legal background to
- 6:24help litigation support cases, which is a big
- 6:27part of my practice. And when we're approaching
- 6:31a litigation matter or potential litigation matter,
- 6:34we like to address it just like an attorney would
- 6:37with a new case and try to understand the facts
- 6:39and issues. What are the objectives our clients
- 6:41are trying to achieve? Every case is unique unto
- 6:44itself. And there are matters where there might
- 6:48be an advantage to be proactive with the communication
- 6:51strategy and potentially use litigation pleadings
- 6:56or other. means to get a story out there or to
- 7:01establish a narrative prior to litigation commencing.
- 7:04And there's various tactics and strategies that
- 7:06can be deployed that we'll get into in a little
- 7:09bit to discuss. And then if it's something that
- 7:12you're hoping or there's a possibility of keeping
- 7:16it more civil and private and potentially resolving
- 7:20an issue through settlement negotiations or arbitration,
- 7:25we can work. on a responsive strategy and hold
- 7:29or prepare what we call holding communications
- 7:33materials where you get your statements or other
- 7:38communications documents prepared with an eye
- 7:40towards litigation. Everything that we do with
- 7:44the litigation support context, we work very
- 7:48closely with the attorneys. The legal matters
- 7:51almost always take precedence over the PR. and
- 7:56communications needs and so we tend to defer
- 7:59to legal counsel and take guidance from them.
- 8:03Another factor that we will discuss some points
- 8:05tonight, but I want to touch upon it, is taking
- 8:09steps to preserve attorney -client network privileges.
- 8:12There's specific laws. It differs in different
- 8:17jurisdictions. But in California, the key is
- 8:19that the attorneys are involved with every step
- 8:22of the way and that they're hiring a firm like
- 8:24ours or an individual like myself. to help them
- 8:27provide legal counsel to the client. So just
- 8:30like an attorney might not be an expert on accounting
- 8:33issues and hires a forensic accountant, and that
- 8:37work product would need to be privileged and
- 8:39confidential, our advice on how to handle media
- 8:42and communications needs would likewise fall
- 8:45under those arguments for privilege. But it's
- 8:49something that you have to be cautious about
- 8:51and diligent to make sure that you don't violate
- 8:55privilege. one of the things that I always seek
- 8:58to avoid is becoming a witness in the case or
- 9:01being deposed. I've actually, we've been very
- 9:05successful in the past in very high profile cases
- 9:08involving some professional athletes where we
- 9:11were successful in challenging subpoenas from.
- 9:16Major League Baseball to get our records. And
- 9:18so that's something that was several years ago,
- 9:21but it's something that because we took the steps
- 9:24to formalize how we were engaged and worked through
- 9:27the attorneys that were able to defeat that subpoena.
- 9:31So Terry, the attorneys are essentially like
- 9:33the generals and you're working under the litigation
- 9:37umbrella. Yes. So oftentimes what you do may
- 9:42be covered by privileged. You're not the type
- 9:44of expert that probably gets designated for trial,
- 9:48obviously. So you shouldn't be deposed. You shouldn't
- 9:52be subpoenaed for information, although I'm sure
- 9:55it can happen. But in the sense of when things
- 9:59happen and you anticipate coverage, what strategic
- 10:05things might you think about doing? to try to
- 10:10ameliorate any bad press. Yes. So the first thing
- 10:13is gathering the facts and understanding the
- 10:15issue. So if we get a call from an attorney who
- 10:19is facing a threat of litigation, we try to understand
- 10:24the parties. opposing counsel, say we're representing
- 10:31a defendant or a potential defendant, understanding
- 10:33what the claims might be. If there's been a threat
- 10:36of litigation and some kind of attempt to negotiate
- 10:40it, sometimes a draft complaint will be sent
- 10:44over. And so we'll take a look at that and try
- 10:48to get our arms around what the... the facts
- 10:53are, what the legal issues are, and then work
- 10:54with the attorneys. What's your response going
- 10:57to look like? If it's filed in court, there's
- 11:00usually a 30 -day or whatever period before an
- 11:03answer is due. And so we can work on having some
- 11:08kind of statement that would contain the same
- 11:12type of arguments and facts that would be included
- 11:15in responsive pleading, whether it's a demur
- 11:19or an answer or something like that. And we work
- 11:23with attorneys all the time to help them craft
- 11:26pleadings, whether it's a responsive pleading
- 11:29or a complaint, to make it more media friendly
- 11:31so that an introduction is not just... going
- 11:34to lay out the legal case, but it will have enough
- 11:37factual information and written in a way that
- 11:40a journalist can pick up sound bites and easily
- 11:43understand without having to comb through dozens
- 11:48of pages, depending on how complex litigation
- 11:50is, of statements of fact. Reporters like to
- 11:54be We give what we call guided reading. If we're
- 11:58dealing with a reporter on background, trying
- 12:00to show them the most salient point of a pleading
- 12:04and try to have them understand something, especially
- 12:08if it's complex litigation. Tony, might I ask,
- 12:12Terry, do your cases come to you from only lawyers
- 12:14or do clients themselves, celebrities, high profile
- 12:18individuals call you directly? More often than
- 12:24not, it's through legal counsel, but there are
- 12:26a number of cases where either an executive at
- 12:32an organization or a board member or an individual
- 12:35can reach out to us directly and ask for our
- 12:38services. And if it's with an eye towards litigation,
- 12:42we oftentimes say, let's get the attorneys on
- 12:43the call and have that conversation before we
- 12:47get too substantively involved. Go ahead. So
- 12:51if it's a case where litigation is going to be
- 12:54expected, as opposed to, I assume you handle
- 12:58PR nightmares, which aren't litigation necessarily
- 13:01related. They're just a clothing company has
- 13:06a pair of pants that are much more see -through
- 13:08than people think. If everybody understands what
- 13:11I'm talking about, and so what's the PR team
- 13:13do? That's not really going to be litigation.
- 13:15That's more managing the situation. That's a
- 13:20situation I've handled in the past and invariably
- 13:25there's some kind of legal issues. So I've represented
- 13:29a parallel company that started out as general
- 13:32PR and then it turns out that the FTC might be
- 13:36looking into their or other companies are looking
- 13:38at government investigations. And so when things
- 13:41escalate like that, we might set up a new engagement
- 13:44with a law firm that's representing them on that
- 13:46matter. So that separates from the general PR
- 13:50representation. They come to you. Are you asserting
- 13:54the privilege on their behalf? So you will never
- 13:58act as a lawyer. I am not acting as a lawyer,
- 14:01but it does help that I am. It's it's a. I'm
- 14:05not acting as an attorney, but I'm still a lawyer.
- 14:08I'm a member of the California State Bar, so
- 14:10I'm providing counsel, but it's it's quasi. It
- 14:14can be quasi legal counsel, but I'm also careful
- 14:18to say I'm not acting as your attorney, so it's
- 14:20it's a gray area. So I think the big point is,
- 14:24you know what we really didn't interrupt. I'm
- 14:26sorry. You just want to ensure that the PR and
- 14:28the legal strategy are aligned and there's consistent
- 14:31messaging across the board. Right. And what I'm
- 14:33fascinated by is someone who's read thousands
- 14:35of complaints and responsive pleadings is how
- 14:38much involved you are in that process and the
- 14:41messaging that will take place and how important
- 14:44that is in a case. And I think lawyers and PR
- 14:47professionals like myself were storytellers.
- 14:50And so it's something that can be synergistic.
- 14:53We're not changing the substance, but we might
- 14:56try to fine tune it, especially if it's a high
- 14:58profile matter. It's something that we want to
- 15:00use the media to our advantage to make it more
- 15:03media friendly. And I'm sure in some of the complaints,
- 15:07for instance, or pleadings you've seen where
- 15:09the introduction really is sort of thrown away.
- 15:12And that's a really instrumental part of a pleading,
- 15:16in my opinion, from a public relations standpoint,
- 15:19that you use it if it's something that we want
- 15:23to be proactive or even responsive. there's benefits
- 15:28to put something in a pleading as opposed to
- 15:31put in a press release or a statement. It's gonna
- 15:32be taken a lot more serious. You have litigation
- 15:35privilege. The press has, there's additional
- 15:38advantages for the press, taking quotes from
- 15:40a pleading as opposed to somewhere else. And
- 15:43so there's all these different factors that make
- 15:46it beneficial for the PR side to use to work
- 15:49synergistically with the legal counsel and the
- 15:52legal process. Like what we've all seen, I think
- 15:55was the... Baldoni Lively case, which nobody
- 15:58here I think is involved with, but at least that
- 16:00I'm aware of, where they start their pleading
- 16:03with something akin to, I reluctantly file this,
- 16:08and I don't think it's a story that should have
- 16:10to be told, but then they go on and tell their
- 16:12whole story in this pleading that they're saying
- 16:15they shouldn't really have to tell, but the idea
- 16:17is get the sound bites out there for people to
- 16:20pick up. Filing something intentionally to get
- 16:22your message out so you know it's going to get
- 16:24picked up. Some really inside baseball in that
- 16:27case, and it was something that was litigated
- 16:30and resolved. But the pleading was provided to
- 16:37the New York Times prior to it being filed. It's
- 16:42something that we, or let's just say generally
- 16:45is done by PR professionals to give it to a reporter
- 16:49prior to something being filed. It's called an
- 16:54embargo. And you can provide something on an
- 16:57embargo -based report so they can start getting
- 16:59the story prepared, doing some of the background
- 17:02research, even talking to attorneys or other
- 17:05people to prepare their story. And the embargo
- 17:09would typically be lifted once the court Filing
- 17:13is confirmed. So back in the day, you used to
- 17:16get a conformed stamped copy. Now you wait for
- 17:18the electronic confirmation. And that's something
- 17:21that's a little bit more sophisticated strategy,
- 17:23but you tee it up so that what we call it leads
- 17:26to your reporter, whether it's the New York Times
- 17:28or Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, LA Times,
- 17:31a prominent news organization that others will
- 17:34follow. We call that a lead steer and so that's
- 17:37a tactic that can be deployed if you want to
- 17:39be aggressive if you're going to be on a proactive
- 17:42side and so you use that pleading to tell the
- 17:44story and in the Baldoni case they alleged that
- 17:48it was defamatory because the litigation privilege
- 17:53didn't apply because it was provided to a journalist
- 17:56prior to the the case actually being filed. So
- 18:00you've got to be strategic about what goes into
- 18:02those filings, obviously. Everything's going
- 18:04to be, everything in the public record is public.
- 18:09I mean, by definition, public record is public.
- 18:11We know that you have to balance transparency
- 18:14and privacy. Famous quote from Louis Brandeis,
- 18:18Justice Brandeis, he said, sunlight is the best
- 18:21disinfectant. Oddly enough, he did it in a book
- 18:23before he was on the court called Other People's
- 18:27Money. about a critique of the financial industry,
- 18:30mostly JP Morgan. But people have a right to
- 18:35freedom of the press. We know Congress shall
- 18:37make no law abridging freedom of the press. We
- 18:41know Code of Civil Procedure 124 says, accept
- 18:45as provided in the family code, which has certain
- 18:48exceptions when you can close a courtroom. Every
- 18:52court's going to be public. There's a ton of
- 18:54cases in the materials that support that. So
- 18:57what do you do if you want to keep a case private?
- 19:00How can you go about doing that? We see all these
- 19:03cases in my family law industry. We hear conscious
- 19:07uncoupling and all these things that we just
- 19:10assume everybody got along well, not realizing
- 19:12how much work actually went into crafting those
- 19:15statements and getting to a settlement before
- 19:18it even started. It's really hard to close a
- 19:24courtroom. I'm sure Judge Carlin can tell that
- 19:27a public has a right to be there. There has to
- 19:29be a real least restrictive means to abridging
- 19:37the ability to hear or see what's going on in
- 19:40the courtroom. Doesn't really happen that often.
- 19:44But I have been involved in cases involving children
- 19:47where the courts been able to do that I've been
- 19:50involved in cases where the courts have issued
- 19:52gag orders. It's it's extremely rare And there
- 19:57are certain things you can do if you want to
- 19:59keep your case private They're not always successful
- 20:03But you certainly we can talk about it. I know
- 20:07in family court There's like I said, they have
- 20:09authority to close the courtroom It's just highly
- 20:13unlikely. You can have a confidential marital
- 20:16settlement agreement in family law. The first
- 20:18case that did that was Flynn, which was Errol
- 20:21Flynn. They filed what we now commonly refer
- 20:24to as a short form judgment and says, it basically
- 20:27says we're getting divorced and our agreement
- 20:30is in a different document that they hold on
- 20:33to for enforcement. People can try filing things
- 20:36under seal. It's pretty tough. need a pretty
- 20:41compelling reason to seal something. Sometimes
- 20:44you can file under a pseudonym. We used to see
- 20:46that often with appellate cases that were just
- 20:50done by initials when there was a parentage case.
- 20:55If you want to file under a DOE, you'll need
- 20:58a request for order to affirm it. You really
- 21:02need to have a showing that there's no least
- 21:05restrictive means to protect the party other
- 21:08than keeping their name confidential. But really
- 21:12what we need to do is plan for the leaks because
- 21:16when we have these high profile cases, ultimately,
- 21:20somehow the word often gets out. It may not be
- 21:23through the public record. It's often just through
- 21:26some person who gives a tip. So I think contingency
- 21:31planning is really, really important. Doing more
- 21:34than practical things like marking a debt position,
- 21:37confidential, filing in another county if you're
- 21:40able to doing that. I'm sure Terry has crafted
- 21:45agreed upon narratives when things have settled
- 21:49prior to having the statements really being made
- 21:52and figuring out who's going to make those statements.
- 21:56So there are a lot of things we can do and we'll
- 21:59talk about them. Terry, I don't know. what your
- 22:04sense is and what your experience is in keeping
- 22:07a lot of these things out of the media. Because
- 22:11I mean, by the time you're involved, the story's
- 22:14leaked. But there are things you can do that
- 22:17I know we've discussed when something goes out,
- 22:20whether it's options that you can talk about,
- 22:23whether you want to, for instance, have a press
- 22:25conference, issue a statement. I'll let you opine
- 22:29more about some of those things. What might a
- 22:34person do when they're trying to plan for an
- 22:39action that they know is going to become public?
- 22:42Sure. There's different stages of litigation.
- 22:44When there's a threat of litigation, things that
- 22:49have been negotiations have failed. And then
- 22:54one of the things actually, before we get into
- 22:56those specific guidelines, I'd love to hear from
- 22:58Judge Carlin about his impression, especially
- 23:00when something is an arbitration, those are pretty
- 23:03strict and confidential. But I've been involved
- 23:06in cases where even though there's an arbitration
- 23:08clause, one party might file something with an
- 23:13attempt to get their bite at the media apple.
- 23:15before it's kicked to the arbitration. I'm curious
- 23:19to hear what Judge Carlin has to say and think
- 23:22about when that might happen if one of the parties
- 23:24sort of goes outside of a confidential arbitration
- 23:27and either leaks things or gets things in the
- 23:29media. It happens all the time where someone
- 23:32will file a civil action when there's an arbitration
- 23:34provision, and then the defendant is forced to
- 23:38come into court and move to compel arbitration
- 23:40under 1382. As you know, that's a standard act.
- 23:45Sometimes it's done for strategic reasons, as
- 23:48you're suggesting. Sometimes people don't really
- 23:51know what the arbitration provision is or don't
- 23:54think it applies. There were a ton of cases that
- 23:57were filed in civil court relating to sexual
- 24:01harassment or sexual assaults in the employment
- 24:03context. I had at least three of those cases
- 24:08myself, if not more, where the defendants wanted
- 24:11to arbitrate and I declined to send those cases
- 24:16back to arbitration, finding that being sexually
- 24:21harassed or worse, sexually assaulted by your
- 24:24boss isn't part of the employment contract. And
- 24:28subsequent to my rulings, the Supreme Court came
- 24:31down the same way. So luckily, I read the tea
- 24:34leaves right, or at least I should say luckily,
- 24:37my common sense turned out to be correct. And
- 24:40so in those cases, there were employment arbitration
- 24:43provisions. But ultimately, those were deemed
- 24:45unenforceable. And so I mean, I've had a published
- 24:49case involves the Fast and the Furious that's
- 24:53published. It's been out for a while where there
- 24:55was a question about the arbitration provision.
- 24:58And in that case, you could read it online. Same
- 25:02thing where one side wanted the arbitration provision
- 25:05to apply and the other didn't. Those are fair.
- 25:07I mean, that's fair game when lawyers want to
- 25:09come into a courtroom and actually test whether
- 25:13the arbitration provision applies, whether or
- 25:16not it's unconscionable. You know, all of those
- 25:19are fair games. Fair game. What you're talking
- 25:21about is the lawyer who knows there's a binding
- 25:23arbitration provision that's enforceable, but
- 25:25still files the complaint because they want to
- 25:28use the litigation privilege to say what they
- 25:30want to say without fear of any retribution.
- 25:33Does that happen? Probably. Are there any types
- 25:38of sanctions or other issues that can be dealt
- 25:40with within an arbitration if a party engages
- 25:43in that kind of action or activity? I think you
- 25:48run the risk. Judges are always concerned about
- 25:50chilling free speech, chilling the use of the
- 25:54courts, which is a fundamental right of our citizens.
- 25:57So I don't know of a case where that's happened.
- 26:01I'm sure 128. 128 .5 motions have been brought
- 26:04in those contexts, but I'm not aware of it happening.
- 26:09You know, I have a I have a published slap case.
- 26:12Are you familiar with slap motions? Absolutely.
- 26:15Right. So, you know, those are used all the time
- 26:17in these cases. I have a published slap case
- 26:20where the. Defendant in a criminal case was charged
- 26:27with assaulting his I think it was his wife and
- 26:31daughter. and ultimately went to trial in Malibu,
- 26:34and it was a 12 -0 not guilty. And the court
- 26:37made a finding of factual innocence. So it wasn't
- 26:40just a not guilty, meaning the case wasn't proven
- 26:43beyond a reasonable doubt. The judge in the matter
- 26:46found factual innocence, which is unbelievably
- 26:49rare. So the court then, that husband, sued his
- 26:54ex -wife and I forget who the other family member
- 26:56was, came to me and a slap motion was brought.
- 27:00and it was relating to whether or not the calling
- 27:04of the police was proper in that case. He alleged
- 27:07it was improper. And by calling the police, he
- 27:10was arrested and all this happened. And I actually
- 27:14ruled in that case that you have an absolute
- 27:16right to call the police, but you don't have
- 27:20a right to lie to the police. And there was no
- 27:23case out there, but I just, again, thought I
- 27:26can't tell people not to call the police, and
- 27:28I never would do that, just like I can't tell
- 27:29people not to file complaints. But if you're
- 27:32going to call the police, it is actionable if
- 27:35you're lying. And here, there was enough because
- 27:37of the finding of factual innocence that the
- 27:40call was untrue. And so I guess that's how you
- 27:43sometimes want to thread the needle as a judge
- 27:45to make sure everybody has their day in court.
- 27:49every now and then, you know, you got to set
- 27:51those limits. It's just hard. And I don't know
- 27:53what the remedy is for a scathing complaint that
- 27:56lays someone out. It seems unfair is the reality.
- 28:01I'm not sure what the solution is. Yeah. Especially
- 28:03when it's going to be a kick to arbitration.
- 28:05And I've been involved in some of those cases
- 28:07where a complaint is filed and it's from my point
- 28:12of view filed for media consumption. And the
- 28:15motion to compel arbitration has given us a small
- 28:19platform to counter, and we have to be very careful
- 28:22because if we go too far, now we're actually
- 28:26setting ourselves up to have our motion to compel
- 28:30arbitration denied. But in one particular case,
- 28:34it was very high profile and involved in talent
- 28:36agency and an agent accused of wrongdoing. We
- 28:40were very strategic and careful and came about
- 28:43a page and a half introduction to lay out, to
- 28:46put some facts in the account of the narrative
- 28:48and the motion to compel arbitration was granted.
- 28:54The case went out of the media scrutiny and once
- 28:58it was resolved, everyone was able to move on
- 29:02with their business. Back to what Tony was asking
- 29:05about the different platforms and ways to be
- 29:08able to communicate with the media. Very generally,
- 29:12Press conferences, I think, are the most well
- 29:14-known and most, if you see it on TV shows, it's
- 29:16something that happens all the time. There's
- 29:19plaintiff's attorneys who are really well -known
- 29:21for doing press conferences. The Gloria Allreds
- 29:24of the world or the Tony Busby's. And that's
- 29:28something that can be very, very effective on
- 29:30the plaintiff's side. I don't personally like
- 29:33press conferences. I think they're harder to
- 29:36control. It's more a free -for -all and you really
- 29:39lose some control. and we've worked with the
- 29:43reporters to get some questions to them that
- 29:47will be hard for attorneys to answer. So a press
- 29:50conference is one way to get your narrative out
- 29:53there. You can put out press releases or statements.
- 29:56Those are really good for response. If you don't
- 30:00have a pleading, for instance, a complaint is
- 30:02filed and... legal counsel is not prepared to
- 30:06file a response on the same news cycle. So you
- 30:08can put together a statement that has enough
- 30:11information that it's not a no comment, something
- 30:14that I tell clients all the time, you can plead
- 30:17the fifth in the court of law, but you can't
- 30:19plead the fifth in the court of public opinion.
- 30:21And so if you have a no comment, you tend to
- 30:24look guilty. So if something can be said that
- 30:26goes beyond, we can't comment on petting litigation,
- 30:29it can be helpful. Along those written statements,
- 30:33what we like to do with permission of counsel,
- 30:36if there's something that we can be done, that
- 30:39can be done with the media, especially trusted
- 30:41media to talk to them in different ways, whether
- 30:44it's off the record and off the record is something
- 30:47that you specifically define with journalists,
- 30:49because different journalists have different
- 30:50understandings, but off the record to me, It
- 30:53means that it doesn't go past that conversation.
- 30:56They can talk to their editors or something about
- 30:59it, but it's not going to be something that's
- 31:02going to ask of some other interviewee or outside
- 31:06or the other side in a litigation. But we use
- 31:09that tactic to try to undermine if something's
- 31:14not true and provably false. and there's some
- 31:17kind of documentation, you can talk to a reporter
- 31:20and lead them to where the evidence lies to show
- 31:23that these allegations are untrue and potentially
- 31:26kill a story or at least alter it without commenting
- 31:29on the record. And you can provide also what
- 31:32we call a background and that's or not for attribution.
- 31:36And that's something. that we can engage with,
- 31:39oftentimes a lawyer talking to a reporter to
- 31:42give them guidance about a specific situation,
- 31:44facts or legal issues that will be attributed
- 31:48directly to the attorney or to us, it would be
- 31:51a source familiar with the matter. And that way
- 31:54it's a little bit more cautious than doing something
- 31:57on the record. But those are several of the different
- 32:00ways you can engage both either proactively or
- 32:03reactively to a litigation event. power of social
- 32:08media, influencers, gaming the algorithm. Do
- 32:13you see people trying to do that today? It seems
- 32:16like everybody's, it seems like you can have
- 32:18a trial by Twitter these days. Everyone is now,
- 32:21thinks they're a PR expert and is reporting off
- 32:24their cell phones outside of courtrooms. It is
- 32:27the dark art of social media. It's something
- 32:30that is, has to be accounted for. And it's...
- 32:35Something that we're very cautious about doing,
- 32:38I know that there have been some cases where
- 32:40there have been accusations that haven't been
- 32:43proven that social media was ginned up to create
- 32:46a certain momentum against a particular party
- 32:52to litigation or in favor of a particular party
- 32:56litigation. The hope is that that will affect
- 32:59the legal. case. It certainly hurts on the reputation
- 33:03side and you have to account for it. But it would
- 33:06be a terrible result if that was ever to come
- 33:09out in litigation. And I can't even imagine what
- 33:13the consequences would be if a party extrajudicial
- 33:17statements are risky enough and could upset and
- 33:20look forward to hearing from Judge Carlin on
- 33:22this. But extrajudicially, if I'm holding a press
- 33:25conference while litigations are to commence,
- 33:27that could raise eyebrows for a judge. but if
- 33:29it's somehow discovered that this, like in the
- 33:32Baldoni case, that there were publicists or bot
- 33:36armies or trolls that were being paid to influence,
- 33:40not just for public perception, but potentially
- 33:42influence a jury, that's something that could
- 33:47have devastating ramifications for a party litigation.
- 33:53In terms of Los Angeles, I sat in Santa Monica,
- 33:56which is the West District. I handled a number
- 34:01of high profile cases, including several jury
- 34:03trials involving people that everybody in this
- 34:05room knows. The jurors, shockingly, surprisingly,
- 34:11don't get affected by this. They're so much better,
- 34:16and I'm speaking from my years in this district.
- 34:20They're so much better at forgetting about stuff
- 34:23that we tell them to and taking their job seriously
- 34:26than most people think. I think what happens
- 34:28with the justice system is you get a few bizarre
- 34:31outcomes or a few verdicts that really throw
- 34:35everyone and don't seem to make a lot of sense,
- 34:38whether it's, you know, we can all think of verdicts
- 34:40where bizarre things have happened and where
- 34:43we scratch our heads and say, how did that happen?
- 34:4699 % go as you expect. And I can tell you that
- 34:50In all but one of the cases I tried, and we're
- 34:53talking 100, 100, 200, 300, all but one of them
- 34:58came out exactly within the range that I expected,
- 35:02which should surprise most people. They actually
- 35:06get it right. The one that didn't come out right
- 35:09was fixed or fixable. And the only reason it
- 35:12didn't come out right was everybody was so crazy
- 35:16on that case that it was like a TV show. And
- 35:20so I get why the jurors kind of struggled with
- 35:22it. But they do such a good job, juries. I have
- 35:25the utmost respect. And we can weed them out.
- 35:29You can figure it out. And you know, that's what
- 35:31Vaudier is for. But I have a question for you,
- 35:34Terry. In the old days, there was an expression
- 35:37that no news is bad news for a celebrity or a
- 35:41famous person, that anything that's said that
- 35:43gets you in the press is publicity. And publicity
- 35:47is a good thing. We can talk more about what
- 35:51I see from the bench, but I have a slightly different
- 35:54take today because of the internet, because of
- 35:57social media. I do think that some of these wars
- 36:01are not beneficial. Does that make sense, what
- 36:05I'm trying to ask? I'm just curious your take.
- 36:07Absolutely. And, you know, the saying like, you
- 36:10know, all press is good press. Right. No, it's
- 36:15certainly not in modern media, it's certainly
- 36:21not the case. And some of the best work we've
- 36:24done has been to kill stories. And so that a
- 36:27story never sees the light of day. And that's
- 36:31something that we are very proud of, happy that
- 36:33our contingency documents, contingency communications
- 36:38plans. sit on the, I say sit on the shelf, but
- 36:41sit in our files on our computer and never gets
- 36:43out there. And that's something that our clients
- 36:47and the lawyers and the entire teams have been
- 36:49very happy we'll be able to strategically advise
- 36:54and engage with the media to make something go
- 36:57away without it being published. And so, especially
- 37:01in the MeToo era, the following areas where allegations
- 37:07can, it's spread around the world. It's the old
- 37:11adage, the lie can get all over around the world
- 37:16before the truth gets its shoes on. I forget
- 37:18if that was Eisenhower or whoever's quote that's
- 37:22attributed to, but things move very, very fast
- 37:25is the point. And so once something's out there,
- 37:28you have a very limited time to respond before...
- 37:33a story can take a life of its own and it's accepted
- 37:36as fact and so getting prepared and there's a
- 37:43saying I use all the time attributed to the great
- 37:46coach John Wooden, be quick but don't hurry.
- 37:49So you want to get your facts in order and get
- 37:51your information straight and be able to respond
- 37:55as quickly as possible but we've come in many
- 37:57cases where statements were issued that were
- 38:00not accurate or misleading and potentially perceived
- 38:04as a cover -up, and cover -ups can be worse than
- 38:07the underlying allegations. And so you want to
- 38:10be quick and react quickly, but you don't want
- 38:12to correct so quickly that you make the problem
- 38:14worse. A well -crafted message, I think, can
- 38:18go much further. Whether or not you win in court,
- 38:21you end up losing in the court of public opinion.
- 38:24And I think that's the problem. We see it all
- 38:29the time in family law. You're right, but you
- 38:32still lose. It's mutually assured destruction,
- 38:34and all you're really doing by the end of it
- 38:36is trying to mitigate your losses. Tony, question
- 38:39for you. When you have a client in general, a
- 38:43client that wants to just take out the other
- 38:46side and not be civil, how do you advise a client
- 38:50that's hell bent on destroying their adversary
- 38:53or their family or whoever they're litigating
- 38:57with? How do you deal with that situation? You
- 38:59need client control, and those are the clients
- 39:01that I try to steer clear of. Sometimes we get
- 39:04these clients that just wants to shame the other
- 39:07party, and attorneys who do it as well. But by
- 39:10the way, there's a rule again, rule of professional
- 39:14responsibility about shaming. Attorneys shouldn't
- 39:17be doing it. I think it could be wrong, but I
- 39:21think it's RPC 4 .1. But that sort of attitude
- 39:25isn't to anybody's benefit. When it's done by
- 39:28council, it could be sanctionable. We see this
- 39:32all the time where people just try to destroy
- 39:35each other. I had something today that seems
- 39:40like the dumbest thing in the world. I mean,
- 39:42it's just people who are not even married, just
- 39:48breaking up. And they're going back and forth
- 39:51with these ridiculous allegations. threatening
- 39:54restraining orders against each other for no
- 39:56reason. And it's not a case I've been involved
- 39:59with. I know we're not allowed to speak about
- 40:02that, but it's just a consult today. And I'm
- 40:04thinking, this is absurd. This gets in front
- 40:08of a judge, and they think it's frivolous, an
- 40:11entire waste of time. Nobody benefits to it.
- 40:15In my cases, the kids are the ones who get hurt,
- 40:17whether even if... Even if nobody wins, there's
- 40:20less resources available for the children that
- 40:22are always going to remember their parents fighting.
- 40:26It's an awful, awful situation. And I think it's
- 40:30important to remember there are no winners. You
- 40:33just are mitigating what you're going to lose
- 40:35at the end of the day. So working with counsel
- 40:38for the adversarial side who sees things in a
- 40:42similar light can keep it civil and benefit both
- 40:46clients. by not making something public? Hundred
- 40:49percent. I mean, we've had I've had cases where
- 40:52we just settle before anything is filed. We go
- 40:56to a private judge prior to filing. We work it
- 41:00out civilly. I've had cases where they're very
- 41:04high asset cases where we had to on our local
- 41:06form that requires the address. We just put a
- 41:08zip code for jurisdiction because we need to
- 41:11keep these cases. Their address might be You
- 41:15might not want somebody knowing where they live.
- 41:17Maybe there's, in that particular case, there
- 41:20were some threats on family members and kidnapping
- 41:25threats to their kids. So when an opposing council
- 41:31goes in and then files their pleadings and puts
- 41:33in their home address, it's detrimental to everybody.
- 41:38The important thing is to make sure that everybody's
- 41:40on the same page. and working collaboratively
- 41:43to get this done. Sometimes I feel like you're
- 41:45in these cases where you're triaging a patient
- 41:49and you're trying to stitch them up while the
- 41:51other person is trying to kill them. Go ahead.
- 41:56Here's what I would say. The abuse or the payback
- 42:02that you're talking about, what you want to tell
- 42:05your clients is you're going to show up in front
- 42:07of a judge like me. I sat in family law for a
- 42:09year and a half. I spent most of my career in
- 42:12civil, but just a year and a half in family law.
- 42:17Think about what's on a judge's calendar right
- 42:19now. I don't know the family law numbers. I can
- 42:21tell you civil in the West District, there are
- 42:241 ,000 to 1 ,300, 1 ,400 cases. Can you imagine
- 42:29what a judge thinks when a judge is tasked with
- 42:33that many cases trying to get the right outcome,
- 42:37trying to do the right thing in every case, follow
- 42:41the law, make sure you're fair and get it right.
- 42:44And the judge has to read through all of this
- 42:47garbage. It doesn't help you. And so while it
- 42:52may feel good for your client and your clients
- 42:55thrilled and laughing that they were able to
- 42:57say X, Y and Z horrible things about the other
- 43:00side, they're really hurting themselves because
- 43:03at the end of the day, the judge will look at
- 43:05that and not be happy. And whenever there's cases
- 43:10like that and close calls, it's not going to
- 43:12nurture your client's benefit because judges
- 43:13know what's going on. We've seen it too many
- 43:17times. And so if the goal is a successful outcome,
- 43:20that's just not how you get there. Credibility
- 43:23is everything too, Craig. I'm sorry? Credibility
- 43:26is everything. So when somebody - That's correct.
- 43:28Yeah. Yeah. I mean, look, you're going to need
- 43:32something from the court. And let's just call
- 43:35it like it is as a lawyer. Something is gonna
- 43:38happen because we all live. You're gonna have
- 43:41a spouse who has an illness. You're gonna have
- 43:44a car that breaks down. You're gonna have a child
- 43:46who needs you. Something is gonna happen. You're
- 43:50gonna have a computer that breaks down or a printer
- 43:52that doesn't work or your internet goes down.
- 43:55You're going to need to come into a courtroom
- 43:57where your word matters or you're gonna be in
- 44:00deep trouble. And if you blow it, on all of this
- 44:03garbage such that the court doesn't trust you
- 44:05on anything. What happens when you really need
- 44:08something and the court can look at you? If you're
- 44:12an honest person and say, Mr. Storm's telling
- 44:14me the truth. He's an officer of the court. I
- 44:16don't believe for a second that he would mislead
- 44:18me. His car broke down. Let's move on to counsel.
- 44:22And that's what you want in a courtroom. You
- 44:24don't want someone who misleads and pulls fastballs
- 44:27and tells you half truths because then everything
- 44:29becomes suspect. We're too busy. The judges who
- 44:34are still there, and me when I was there, too
- 44:35busy to play these games. Sorry about that, Tony.
- 44:40What do judges do when you have a high -profile
- 44:42case? Do you take steps to avoid the media coverage,
- 44:49or is it something that you monitor or look at?
- 44:54What's the process for a judge when you're involved
- 44:56in a high -profile case? Great question. I didn't
- 45:00have the 12 or 1300 cases they have today. I
- 45:02had 700, which was massive. So I don't even know
- 45:05how they do it today. With my 700, if I have
- 45:08a media case, it's one of 700. In my docket of
- 45:13700 cases, I probably had somewhere between 20
- 45:17and 40 high profile people involved. I could
- 45:21go through a litany, whether it's music industry,
- 45:23athletic world, coaching world, TV, any politician,
- 45:27whatever it is, we always had, because we're
- 45:29in the West District, a huge number. They take
- 45:33the same amount of work as every other case.
- 45:36Even though the media is interested, the demur
- 45:39takes as much time. The cross -complaint, the
- 45:41motion for summary adjudication, et cetera, everything
- 45:43takes as much time. And so they don't get special
- 45:47treatment. Your question about what would I do
- 45:50with the press? I was one of the old fashioned
- 45:54dinosaurs, even though I took the bench younger
- 45:57and left, you know, younger, even though I did
- 45:59years on the bench. I wasn't a big fan of cameras
- 46:03in the courtroom because I think people behave
- 46:05differently. And my goal is to get the right
- 46:08outcome. And I had pressed in the courtroom all
- 46:10the time. I had the. the people drawing pictures,
- 46:13the artists. I've had reporters in there. They've
- 46:16been in there so much that they would say hello
- 46:17to me. And, you know, it was I knew who they
- 46:20all were. I didn't like the cameras because people
- 46:24behave differently and then it makes it harder.
- 46:26And so that bothered me. The other thing I don't
- 46:28like is grandstanding. If you've ever seen Charlie
- 46:33Brown with the scene where the kids go to the
- 46:36classroom, does everybody remember what the teacher
- 46:38sounds like? That's what it actually sounds like
- 46:43when you get two lawyers just yelling at each
- 46:45other back and forth and under the rules, you're
- 46:49to address the court. So the conversation is
- 46:52between you and me. It's not, for example, between
- 46:54you and Tony, if you were in a courtroom. And
- 46:57what happens all the time on these high profile
- 46:59cases is the lawyers just wanting the ones who,
- 47:03you know, some of them, many of them are phenomenal.
- 47:05but some of them will go at each other and it
- 47:07just doesn't help the cause. Do judges ever just
- 47:10say a case in front of you or another judge is
- 47:13on the front page of the New York Times or LA
- 47:15Times and it's there on your kitchen table? Do
- 47:18you avoid it? Do you read it? What are the...
- 47:21My case? You say a case that you're working on.
- 47:24I don't read it. I don't think it's appropriate.
- 47:28It's probably an ex parte communication. In LA,
- 47:32it's almost impossible. I mean, I have handled
- 47:35cases where I am watching the news and all of
- 47:37a sudden there it is. And I will turn it off.
- 47:41But it takes a moment to figure out it's your
- 47:44case. And then you're like, oh, they're talking
- 47:46about my case. Then you turn off. But none of
- 47:50that affects a sitting judge, at least. And there
- 47:52are some cases I've worked on, especially in
- 47:54the criminal context, where cases all over the
- 47:59media before something's actual filed, right?
- 48:01Before there's even an arraignment and someone's
- 48:03arrested. And so that's a different kind of representation
- 48:06working with the criminal counsel. Cause now
- 48:08you're talking about someone's Liberty interest
- 48:11at stake as opposed to a civil financial hit.
- 48:15And so those are very difficult, but also it's
- 48:19very important. to try to get something out there
- 48:23to profess some kind of innocence. And so those
- 48:27cases can be very difficult to manage. But working
- 48:30very closely, we are in particular diligent and
- 48:34not doing anything that would compromise our
- 48:37case, especially on the criminal side. So Tony,
- 48:40we should probably talk a little bit about 1001,
- 48:431002 since it's. a really big deal. In 2017,
- 48:49in response to the allegations against Harvey
- 48:52Weinstein, the California legislature adopted
- 48:551002 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Thereafter,
- 49:00in 2018, SB 820 was passed, which is CCP 1001.
- 49:06They have named the STAND Act, the Silence No
- 49:10More Act, SB 331 amended the stand act and included
- 49:17more offenses. The gist of these provisions is
- 49:23NDAs are prohibited in many circumstances now.
- 49:28And so I'm not here to debate the wisdom of this.
- 49:35There are certain people who have engaged in
- 49:37certain conduct that they and their conductor,
- 49:42it's just reprehensible and the whole world should
- 49:44know so that nobody is hurt again. The problem
- 49:48comes from what happens when allegations are
- 49:50made against somebody who's not, really didn't
- 49:53do anything, isn't responsible. It's kind of
- 49:59one of those nonsense complaints against a celebrity
- 50:03and they can't settle if the complaint's filed
- 50:06with an NDA. and it makes it much harder. So
- 50:09there's a lot of thought that needs to go into
- 50:13these cases and the timing of how to get things
- 50:17done. I think that these sections ideally would
- 50:22be amended somewhat, but I don't know that the
- 50:24legislature will do that. That's their call,
- 50:26but it is something to be aware of because a
- 50:30lot of high profile people will not settle a
- 50:33case when they've been accused of something reprehensible.
- 50:38if the case is filed and they can't kind of,
- 50:42you know, get a, you know, we've agreed to mutual
- 50:44terms, you know, it was a misunderstanding or
- 50:46whatever, that's just gonna go to trial now.
- 50:48And it's a big, big issue to be aware of, because
- 50:53I know that some of the alternatives to courtrooms
- 50:56is pre litigation mediation, which I handle all
- 50:59the time on cases like this, and or arbitration.
- 51:03Arbitration is interesting because these cases,
- 51:07and the statutes talk about civil actions and
- 51:09or complaints to, for example, certain state
- 51:13agencies and employment cases, et cetera. I'm
- 51:17not sure how arbitration would play out in that,
- 51:19but my hunch is it's going to be covered because
- 51:21you're going to have to go at some point to court
- 51:23to get the award confirmed. And then it's a court
- 51:27case. So it's tricky. And just be aware of it.
- 51:31Oftentimes, you can get victims are better off.
- 51:35settling pre -litigation because they can control
- 51:37their fate and destiny a lot more. Might potentially
- 51:42even get better settlements, but it's something
- 51:44to be aware of. It gets me to where I was going
- 51:47to get to anyways. I imagine you see these cases
- 51:51getting mediated or arbitrated prior to them
- 51:55filing a number of times because of these statutes.
- 51:59But what I'm wondering, we see arbitration clauses
- 52:02all the time that people ignore and they go and
- 52:06file. If somebody has an employment agreement
- 52:10and they're accused of sexual harassment, which
- 52:13would be covered by 1001, do you think that arbitration
- 52:17clause in their employment agreement would be
- 52:19enforceable? No. I had mentioned earlier that
- 52:22I found them enforceable multiple times. I was
- 52:25affirmed every time in the Supreme Court on a
- 52:28published case finally said the same. So no,
- 52:31I don't think so because I don't think that's
- 52:32part of your employment contract that you're
- 52:33going to have a supervisor touching you improperly
- 52:37or anything worse. That's crazy. And that's what
- 52:39I found and felt. So you can't compel arbitration
- 52:43in that situation. The answer is correct. I don't
- 52:51think that's happening. But what happens when
- 52:54you go to arbitration and then have to file in
- 52:57Superior Court to get the award confirmed? You
- 53:00now have an action theoretically. I don't know
- 53:02that there's any case law out there. I'm just
- 53:03highlighting this issue because this is all relatively
- 53:07newer, but it's something that lawyers in this
- 53:09space have to navigate. Remember. We've kind
- 53:13of talked about sexual assaults because that's
- 53:16with the Harvey Weinstein situation that caused
- 53:19this law to come about and some other high profile
- 53:22individuals. Celebrities have litigation just
- 53:25like regular people. They have neighbor disputes.
- 53:28I can't tell you how many world famous people
- 53:31I've had in my courtroom on neighbor disputes,
- 53:34something their next door neighbor did in terms
- 53:36of building, cutting their trees down, what have
- 53:38you. Some of these have been in the newspaper
- 53:41we've read about, but They get in car accidents.
- 53:44They have medical and legal malpractices. They
- 53:47have business disputes. So it's not just things
- 53:51that are covered by 1001, 1002. But anytime a
- 53:55celebrity is in a courtroom, if I'm not mistaken,
- 53:58there are people who go through each night's
- 54:00filings and look for who's been filed on. And
- 54:03if someone world famous's name comes up, they're
- 54:08gonna pick up the case and see it. And oftentimes
- 54:10those are better handled kind of, you talked
- 54:15about off the record, I'll call them pre -litigation
- 54:17mediation. Let's get a deal done, but it does
- 54:19take two to tango. But they do happen all the
- 54:22time, these deals, you've just got to, both sides
- 54:24have to be aware. And I think victims sometimes
- 54:28also aren't real thrilled with going through
- 54:31the public process. You probably Terry know about
- 54:34that and Tony. You know, someone who's been victimized
- 54:37oftentimes wants to settle it quietly and that
- 54:40should be their choice. And so it's a tricky
- 54:43balance between we don't want to hide bad predators.
- 54:47You know, we don't want to hide these predators
- 54:48from the world. But at the same time, we also
- 54:51want to balance the victim's right to anonymity
- 54:53and to be able to move on with his or her life.
- 54:55And so that's why pre litigation mediation and
- 54:58arbitrations are beneficial. You can arbitrate
- 55:02even if you don't even have an arbitration provision.
- 55:03You can reach a step and go. People don't think
- 55:06about that. Judge Carlin, in our last few minutes,
- 55:09we have another five minutes here. I think we're
- 55:11touching on a really important topic, and that's
- 55:14mediation and mediation confidentiality. I hope
- 55:20that people who are watching know that anything
- 55:23that happens in mediation stays in mediation.
- 55:26But it's a tool that can be used and you can
- 55:30expound a little bit on this. more than I can
- 55:33as a retired bench officer, about how you can
- 55:37use mediation and keep some, maybe not the sexual
- 55:41harassment issue that has to be disclosed and
- 55:44you can't do an NDA, but there's so many other
- 55:47issues and disputes that can be properly and
- 55:50effectively resolved in a private mediation before
- 55:53filing. When you look at 1001, 1002, it lays
- 55:57out what can and can't be protected. But there
- 56:00are a lot of situations where pre -filing can
- 56:04be addressed in mediation. One of the benefits
- 56:06is I've talked to victims and just listened and
- 56:12let them tell their story. And there's a huge
- 56:15cathartic effect that allows the case to move
- 56:19forward because they've been heard. And the irony
- 56:22is other than a jury trial, they're not going
- 56:25to be heard like that one on one with someone
- 56:28sitting there within five, 10 feet of them actually
- 56:31listening, actually taking notes, asking questions,
- 56:34engaging them. And of course, in a way that's
- 56:37really protective of their sense, you know, very
- 56:41sensitive and protective of their privacy. And
- 56:44some victims want to say very little and just
- 56:46want to say he hurt me. And others want to say
- 56:49a lot more. And they want to tell you every detail.
- 56:51And I always tell them, you know, You determine
- 56:56how comfortable you are sharing what you want
- 56:58to share. I don't want you to be uncomfortable
- 57:01here. This is not about that. This is your forum
- 57:03to speak your mind. And you'd be amazed how many
- 57:07people feel so much better at the end of a session.
- 57:12People don't think of mediation as therapy, but
- 57:14I will tell you, for a lot of people, especially
- 57:17victims in this space, in this arena, it's hugely
- 57:21therapeutic if it's done correctly. And it allows
- 57:24deals to happen and allows them to move on with
- 57:26their life. We all know what happens in a courtroom.
- 57:31And I never issued a gag order. But victims,
- 57:37you know, the media frenzy happens, as Terry
- 57:39knows. And so, yeah, the suspect, the defendant
- 57:43can be the subject of the full force media press.
- 57:47Unfortunately, so can the other side. And I'm
- 57:50sure you've been called in, Terry, on those situations
- 57:52too to help alleviate the stress, but it's hugely
- 57:55stressful, especially for a victim who isn't
- 57:58a celebrity and isn't used to the press everywhere.
- 58:02So yeah, there's a huge benefit. It is confidential.
- 58:05Like I said, we can do confidential settlements.
- 58:07We can do everything confidential. As long as
- 58:10it falls within these two sections of the code,
- 58:12you have to be... able to do that, we're not
- 58:15going to do anything illegal. It's got to be
- 58:17correct. It's got to be legal. Otherwise, it's
- 58:19not enforceable. So even if a mediator wanted
- 58:21to just say, no, there's an NDA, court's not
- 58:23going to enforce it down the road. So you got
- 58:26to do it by the book. You know, one thing to
- 58:28be good, Tony. No, I just want to tag on just
- 58:31to be mindful in our last couple of minutes of
- 58:34evidence code 1125, which most people don't realize
- 58:36that technically, if there's been no contact
- 58:40with the mediator for 10 days. Mediation ends.
- 58:43So it's important when entering into these mediations,
- 58:46you be aware of those statutes and probably waive
- 58:49them because mediations typically take more than
- 58:5110 days. Right. And so when he says it ends,
- 58:54the key is the privilege ends with it. And there's
- 58:58I have everyone go through me, send the documents
- 59:02through me, send the proposals through me. So
- 59:04the privilege is there. And when you come to
- 59:06me, you're going to waive the 10 day rule, 10
- 59:08day rule that's in the in the evidence code as
- 59:12part of the initial intake process because of
- 59:14this. I've had mediations take a day and I've
- 59:18had them take a year and a couple of months and
- 59:20everything in between. So excellent point. Thank
- 59:22you. Are we any last point? Do we have questions?
- 59:30Yeah, we do have questions. I think we're at
- 59:33our hour, but we can do one or two. Will they
- 59:36let us take one or two? Let's hit it. One question
- 59:40we have is, is there any way to avoid publicity
- 59:45of award confirmation by having the award include
- 59:50findings by an arbitrator or need for sealing?
- 59:54Will that matter? I think what the question is,
- 1:00:02can the Superior Court's order confirming the
- 1:00:07arbitrators award be kept secret. And I've never
- 1:00:12done that. I've never heard of anyone doing that.
- 1:00:14And I'm not, I don't expect a court ever would
- 1:00:17do it. Judgments are all public and it's in essence
- 1:00:20a judgment. And so I don't know how that would
- 1:00:23be. I can't think of it. If anyone can figure
- 1:00:26it out, send a message to the three of us and
- 1:00:30I'll certainly review it. And if you're right,
- 1:00:32amazing. The only time where I've kept judgments
- 1:00:36out, and it's really not a judgment, it's a settlement
- 1:00:39agreement. A settlement agreement that might
- 1:00:42be referenced in a publicly filed judgment for
- 1:00:45enforcement purposes that then becomes admissible.
- 1:00:48But it's - Here's the solution. In the arbitration,
- 1:00:52if an award is entered, pick the dollar amount,
- 1:00:55a million dollars, $500 ,000, whatever the number
- 1:00:57is, pay it. Yeah. There's just no need to have
- 1:01:01it confirmed. Now, the other side could stick
- 1:01:04it to you, but I'm assuming they're going to
- 1:01:06arbitration. They're working with you, but that's
- 1:01:08the answer. Just pay it and it doesn't need to
- 1:01:10be confirmed. Pay and keep civil. Correct. Always
- 1:01:13be civil. Do we have one more, Tony, or no? I
- 1:01:17think we're out of time on the questions, but
- 1:01:20this was really, really terrific. I thought this
- 1:01:23was engaging. A great CLE. Really, truly thank
- 1:01:27you, Judge Carlin, for making the time. how busy
- 1:01:31you are, and thank you, Terry, for doing this
- 1:01:35today. I know you're in huge demand, and I really
- 1:01:38appreciate you both being here today for this
- 1:01:41CLE. Tony, thank you, and the Bar, Beverly Hills
- 1:01:43Bar, and Terry, thank you. Pleasure meeting you,
- 1:01:45Terry.