Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / How Leaders Get What They Want Without Winning Arguments
Transcript
- 0:00If I win against you, what does that make you?
- 0:03Loser! You don't want to work with someone who makes you feel like a loser.
- 0:06In this episode, you learn what the most influential communicators do instead to get buy-in,
- 0:11build influence, and actually get what they want.
- 0:13Persuasion is shared action. It's shared because it's something that we voluntarily do with others,
- 0:18and it's action because it's about getting things done.
- 0:20We break down the neuroscience of persuasion, why facts rarely change minds,
- 0:24and the simple communication shifts that make others want to say yes to you.
- 0:29There's no one better to unpack this than Joshua Bandock.
- 0:32He's the author of How To Get What You Want.
- 0:34My name is Oliver Oust. I've helped over 300 CEOs master communications,
- 0:38and this is Speak Like A CEO, the show that helps you become a top 1% communicator.
- 0:46Your book is called How To Get What You Want, and to get what I want,
- 0:49I usually need to persuade someone, so how to go about it?
- 0:52You've got to understand what persuasion is, and then follow three simple steps that
- 0:56hope we can dive into today. Just kind of real quick, what persuasion is, two things that it's not.
- 1:03It's not about winning, because Oliver, if I win against you, what does that make you?
- 1:08Lose, I guess.
- 1:10Lose, I'm like, God, that's terrible, that's terrible, and you don't want to work with someone who
- 1:14makes you feel like a loser, and the second is that it's not about convincing someone to think
- 1:19just like you. So what is persuasion? Persuasion is shared action. It's shared because it's
- 1:25something that we voluntarily do with others, and it's action, because it's about getting things done.
- 1:30And this is a big mindset shift, and this is the best way to durable get what you want time
- 1:35after time, after time, and then you follow what I think are three simple, but not at all easy
- 1:41steps to do that.
- 1:42I love the three step framework in the book, because I think it makes something very complex,
- 1:46really simple to follow for all of us out there. And I'm sure I'm guilty of all the mistakes
- 1:50you call that in the book. You're trying to win arguments, bringing all the data and all that
- 1:54good stuff. But let's do one step at a time. The first one is the persuadism mindset, right?
- 2:00So adapt the persuadism mindset. What does that mean?
- 2:03A big thing that's a thing that the book is understanding how we're wired and how to navigate
- 2:08that wiring. So we're guilty of these things, and as far as everybody's wired this way.
- 2:12So what's the first big one? We are wired to think and talk all about ourselves.
- 2:19So we put ourselves in the center of everything, talking about ourselves generates the same sensations
- 2:23in our brain as sex and money. So it feels really good. And that means that we end up adopting
- 2:29what I call a me first mindset. Small problem with that. If you're dealing with something really
- 2:35tricky, really challenging, and I just make it all about me, it could offend you. So what you have
- 2:41to do is fight your wiring to think and talk about yourself and flip it around and put them first.
- 2:47So the persuadist mindset has a simple insight, not easy. It's about them, not you,
- 2:52because you're trying to persuade somebody else. You already know that you're right. So it's like,
- 2:58okay, well, cool. If I want somebody else to do something, then I have to understand them
- 3:05and understand what their goals are and how what I want to do aligns with their goals,
- 3:10because if my goals aren't your goals, we're not going to work together. But if I can understand
- 3:14your goals and show how what I want helps you meet some or all of them, you're way more inclined
- 3:20to work with me. You see me nodding because I'm in theory, this is 100% clear, right? In practice,
- 3:26not so easy to do, right? Because often I see people going on stage or starting a presentation,
- 3:32I'm sure their mindset is on, hey, I make this about the audience. And yet it doesn't quite happen.
- 3:36So where's the disconnect here between our good intention and then making it about ourselves?
- 3:41I think the disconnect comes in part by thinking that everyone sees things our way, and actually
- 3:47only one person sees things your way. And then how committed are you to listening and truly
- 3:53understanding of the other side on their terms? Because I can think I understand you, but then
- 4:00if I can't express that to you in a way that makes you nod and say, yeah, Josh gets me, or now that's
- 4:06not it. If I don't understand you on your terms, and I think that's the disconnect that a lot of
- 4:10people think they understand the audience, but it's not on the audience's terms. And even there's
- 4:15just like rastly little critter that gets in the way of so many things. Why? It's like, well,
- 4:22why do you think something? And we might actually see the same problem and we might want the same
- 4:26solution. But if your why is different, and I don't like your why, or I won't appeal to your why,
- 4:31and I fight your why, then even though we share problem and solution, we get stuck and we can't
- 4:36understand each other and we can't work together. Yeah. Makes no sense, right? The trep can be judgment,
- 4:41the trep can be I assume, I know what you think, or why you think certain things and none of that is
- 4:46helpful. In the book, there was a sentence that stuck with me, which is persuasion geniuses
- 4:52have a clear vision. Can you speak to that? Because I think that was that struck a quote with me.
- 4:57Thank you. Big, big, big, big picture, what anime's action? It's vision. Because if you're a
- 5:04leader, if you're a CEO, if you lead a team, or even if you're trying to lead your own life,
- 5:10you have to have a vision. You got to know where you're going. You have to see that clearly.
- 5:14You got to know what your north star is. Because if your team doesn't know whether it's a team of
- 5:19two or ten or ten thousand, if they don't know where you're going and you can't communicate that,
- 5:23then you're definitely not going to get there. Yeah. That makes no sense, right? We need that
- 5:28positive vision and to be full something, not just against something. I think that is often
- 5:32lacking in the political good-bait and the economic debate within organizations that we against
- 5:38something, but it's better to be full something. One thousand percent. And that kind of pivots us a
- 5:44little bit to the second part of the book, because the second part of the book is to use knowledge
- 5:52of how our brains work to our advantage. And this book has a lot of neuroscience and psychology.
- 5:59This part in particular is all neuroscience and psychology for starters. And you have two options.
- 6:04You either can understand and navigate our cognitive wiring, or you can ignore it. Definitely not
- 6:10ignore it. I see this a lot that, you know, a speaker communicator tries to fight the brain,
- 6:14works against human biology. And I would say let's work with human biology. But there was a sentence
- 6:20in that chapter, which again, really resonated. And it is our brains aren't wired for persuasion.
- 6:26And that was new to me. We're not. So there are three aspects of our wiring that make it really hard
- 6:33to persuade. And I'll tell you at the end how we fix this. The first, we think that persuasion is
- 6:40all about logic and reason and data. It's not all 8 billion humans on this earth are wired to
- 6:46feel first, then reason, which persuasion starts with feelings. Okay. Then the question is,
- 6:54what kinds of feelings you already alluded to this? We are wired to be negative. And negativity is
- 7:01not persuasive, positivity is. So you have to be for something. And we're wired to appeal to
- 7:07our own values, even if they offend somebody else. And the worst way to ever get somebody to
- 7:14work with you now or later is to offend their values. How do we fix this? You've got to flip
- 7:21your perspective and you've got to ask, what if I were on the receiving end of any of these things
- 7:27in total, you know, I would not feel so good. So it can be safe. That's the quick version of all
- 7:31this. Yeah. I love it. And reminds me of a quote by Thames and Webster. She said this on this
- 7:37podcast a couple of years ago, tell the people the story. They would tell themselves about the
- 7:42thing we are talking about. Oh, a million percent. That's the fourth chapter of these four in
- 7:48the middle part of the book. What is the best way to make powerful, emotional values based appeals
- 7:56and being for something? What is the best way to pursue a period? The single best tool that
- 8:00exists is stories. And part of what I tried to lead up to in that chapter is that one thing that
- 8:06we really never get is what kinds of stories because everyone knows the stories are persuasive.
- 8:13So what I unpack in the chapter is that the most persuasive stories are morally motivating,
- 8:19emotionally intelligent stories. So you have to think about what you want your audience to
- 8:24feel and how you're going to generate those positive feelings. You have to be four things.
- 8:31You have to appeal to their values so that they feel good. And then when we think about it,
- 8:35they feel even better. And then that story captures all of those things. And they remember that
- 8:40because I heard recently someone talking about what we remember from story versus data.
- 8:46We remember about 65% of what we hear from stories. And we remember like 5% of what we hear from
- 8:51data. So stories are just like infinitely more effective than data ever could be.
- 8:56Yeah. And yet often experts and myself included probably we use the data dump or there's a
- 9:01logic tsunami as we call it, right? It just doesn't seem to be the right tactic to persuade anyone.
- 9:08100% and look, nobody walks around and they're like, amen, yeah, you know, I feel first and
- 9:14I just kind of stop there. And a lot of people who are intellectually oriented, whether it's
- 9:18a CEO, an academic, someone works at a thing tank, a number of country or a market organization,
- 9:25whatever, they think, well, I'm logical. And so therefore that's how things are supposed to be.
- 9:30And it's like, well, first of all, it turns out that emotions actually enhance our reasoning.
- 9:35People who suffer brain damage and tragically lose the ability to emote, their reasoning is actually
- 9:42impaired. So it's actually emotions are really important. And still people fight this. And they
- 9:49think, well, the more logic, the better. 90% of presentations are forgotten within a day. And even
- 9:55the best ideas get ignored. Over the last 20 years, I felt hundreds of leaders prepare for stages
- 10:00like Ted and South by Southwest. And the difference is always the same. Top 1% communicators,
- 10:05they use a system. And this system is called the perfect presentation planner.
- 10:10Down at it now, it's free link in the description. We are born with feelings and emotions and we
- 10:15communicate along those lines. But we are we're trained to think logically and bury these.
- 10:21Yet this is what happens to be the most persuasive part. So how do I tell an emotionally
- 10:27intelligent, morally motivating story? Except that you have to start with feelings. How do you
- 10:32generate positive feelings? You have to be for something. So like in the opportunity space,
- 10:38like I said, that's one of the policy hats that I wear. And I am for opportunity and thriving
- 10:44and dignity through work and strong families, creating value for others, all these sorts of
- 10:49things. I'm not only against bad policies. Okay. And then how are you going to appeal to your
- 10:55audiences' values, even if they're not your values, which means you have to understand them.
- 11:01So research the organization. If you're given a speech, research them. Look at their language.
- 11:07Look at how they think about things. Have a pre-call. If you're given a keynote address or
- 11:12you're just talking to a new client is, hey, can you just give me a sense like what are your goals?
- 11:16What are your values as an organization? And make sure you don't offend them and then try to
- 11:21appeal to them. And a lot of intellectual oriented people are scared to make moral appeals.
- 11:27And morals drive everything that we do. So don't be afraid. If you know that there's a moral
- 11:33value that your audience holds just appeal to it authentically. Don't say things you don't believe.
- 11:38And appeal to it because it's really powerful. And we remember those things. And all that has to
- 11:43be couched in the arc of a story. Do you have a framework you can recommend for the arc of this story?
- 11:50You want to show through the hero's actions why this was such a powerful story. Let me give an
- 11:56example that I talk about in the book. I was a speech writer for the Air Force Secretary and we had
- 12:01the task of writing a speech to commemorate Sergeant John Chapman who was posthumously
- 12:10being awarded the Medal of Honor, which is the greatest honor that anybody who serves in uniform
- 12:16can receive in America. So what did I think about? Well, what is my audience, which is going to be
- 12:22a combination of men and women in uniform, other kind of military types, Sergeant Chapman's family,
- 12:28the president, was at one of the events, what are their values? Well, they're going to, for example,
- 12:33be interested in loyalty and patriotism, okay? And they're going to really want to hear about how great
- 12:39John Chapman was. So I talked about his merit, his hard work, proportionality, another value that
- 12:44people tend to have, and how much he cared about his country and how much he cared about the man
- 12:50that he went into battle to save, somebody who had fallen out of a helicopter, and how he wanted to
- 12:55protect our freedom, which is like, especially an American thing, freedom, freedom, freedom. So
- 13:00throughout the speech, I woven references to these things because we know that these sorts of
- 13:05things make somebody feel, and I talked about the courageous actions that Sergeant Chapman took,
- 13:11and we even had many stories inside the story, talking about how excellent he was. So it's like,
- 13:16it's, basically, show don't tell through a story and his actions, and then frame you in a way
- 13:22that resonates with the audience, and what we did there was we framed it in the star-spangled banner.
- 13:27So in America, we sing this at sporting events, oh, say can you see in the home of the brave,
- 13:33and it's some with an explanation point, but Francis Scott, he actually wrote it with a question mark,
- 13:39and so the framing of this speech was that it was not Evan and Dan, nor is it now that America
- 13:43will remain the land of the free in the home of the brave, and it's because of people like John
- 13:49Chapman that we, that we stay free, that we, that we maintain our freedom. So it was this arc,
- 13:57this meta-story, inside charts, and Sergeant Chapman's story, and a story about America kind of
- 14:03all tied together. Wow, I mean, that's very moving, and you obviously had a good inkling what the
- 14:09values of the audience are, and it's actually not that complicated, right? Because often you can
- 14:15guess, I'm a talk to, you know, boardroom for the business people, I'm a talk to you, you know,
- 14:20his workforce. Exactly. Often, values are even on the website of an organization, so often it's
- 14:25just literally a minute of thinking about it, and not skipping this step, and then making sure
- 14:29that it's not us who are the heroes in this story, but it's usually the audience. So we are guiding
- 14:34them. Super important, and I'm going to give your audience a couple of shortcuts to figure this
- 14:38out. So one shortcut is when you want to engage somebody, instead of asking what they think about
- 14:44something, ask how they feel about something, because that gives you instant access to what they
- 14:50really think, and they're unguarded in the answer, positive, negative, and what exactly.
- 14:56And then make sure that you understand their values, and one really good way to do this is to
- 15:02ask them what they think is fair. What would a fair outcome be, because in that, everybody cares
- 15:08about fairness. So those are two early things that if you can understand that, you're going to be
- 15:14at least pointed really quickly in the direction that your audience is going. Yeah, thank you,
- 15:19that makes a lot of sense. What's step three? Step three is to essentially adopt tested techniques.
- 15:28Three of them, I talk about negotiation, they need to go beyond words, and then maybe the
- 15:36funnest part of the block is to pass the granny test, in fact, to ace it. Negotiation, we're doing
- 15:42that all the time, and persuasion is foundational to that. I'll flag two things that I think are a
- 15:47little bit counterintuitive, that are super important. I used to think that persuasion was all
- 15:53about getting somebody to do something, and over the decade of researching and practicing all this
- 15:57stuff, I realized that it's much more about identifying barriers. What's stopping somebody,
- 16:05because they're not doing it now, and there's a reason for it. Why not? So in your conversations,
- 16:12it's really important to say, what would stop you from signing this contract? What would stop you
- 16:18from increasing what you buy from us? Whatever it is, the action you want them to take,
- 16:23what would stop them? And then listen, because you might think, oh, they're not signing this deal,
- 16:28because they don't have the money for it. And it could be, in fact, that maybe they just have
- 16:32a contract with another vendor that ends in six months, and then they can talk to you. Or it could
- 16:37be that they are so committed to this other vendor, because as a 20-year relationship, they will never
- 16:42sign with you. And if you don't understand what's stopping them, you don't know how to proceed.
- 16:46Yes, then it fizzles out, and it's like, oh, yeah, thanks for stopping by, and we get back to you,
- 16:51send us something by email, that sort of thing, right? And nothing happens.
- 16:54Exactly. And that's also where you bring feelings back into it. How do you feel about this?
- 16:59Oh, yeah, I feel good, but I got to think about it. Okay, well, what would stop you? Okay, well,
- 17:06I like it, but I've talked to my partner. Okay, they're not the barrier. The partner's the barrier.
- 17:11Or look, I love this. I just, I don't know if you have the money for it. Okay, it's a cost
- 17:15issue. What can you do there? And if you don't know what the barriers are, you can't remove them.
- 17:20And we just assume that, oh, that's the barrier. And it could be nothing even close to that.
- 17:25The other thing is that we like to talk about win wins, and what you're going to win from a deal,
- 17:31and human beings are actually wired to be much more concerned with loss.
- 17:36So this is the work of Danny Kahneman and Amos Tobirsky in particular, Danny Kahneman won
- 17:41the Nobel Prize for this work. We lost things five to 10 times as much as a gain. So if I take
- 17:51a thousand dollars or euros from you to make you feel whole again, I have to give you five to 10,000
- 17:58euros back. So what that means is that you want to present things in terms of losses.
- 18:04Instead of saying, well, hey, don't you want to increase your sales by 10% with our product,
- 18:10you could say something like, how would you feel about losing 10% per quarter without this product?
- 18:18And like, I'm losing something. Or you might say, look, I don't want us to lose out
- 18:23when the opportunity to work together. And right now I had the spot open, and my spots are
- 18:27filling up quickly. So I just don't want you to lose out. Oh my God, I don't want to lose out.
- 18:32So frame things in terms of losses, and people just respond to that totally differently.
- 18:37Yeah, without coming across as manipulative, right? Because they could react in. So I think there's
- 18:42always that, you know, there's that thin line. It has to be genuine. It has to be ethical.
- 18:45Oh my God, a million percent. People always ask me, what's the difference between persuasion and
- 18:51manipulation? And it's all about intentions. Think about the forest and star wars. Do you want to be
- 18:56Yoda or the emperor? Do you want to be Luke Skywalker or Darth Vader? When you have a knife,
- 19:02you can use that to prepare a beautiful meal for your family or to do somebody great harm.
- 19:06Don't manipulate. It's wrong. And it's going to come back to bite you. So bad news. And the
- 19:12authenticity you said that I want to underline that too, because if you're not authentic in what
- 19:17you say, people are going to know it. And when they find out they're not going to trust you,
- 19:21and you're probably never going to be able to earn their trust. So it's really bad idea to be an
- 19:26authentic. Absolutely. Any other technique you could share with us. We think that persuasion is
- 19:32all about the words that we say. Words are super important. I can say things right now that would
- 19:37deeply offend somebody. Okay, bad idea. And you need to go beyond words. Because when you go
- 19:43beyond words, you can both significantly enhance your effectiveness. And when you go beyond words
- 19:51in the ways that I'll talk about, you don't have to get the words perfect because people with all
- 19:56these other things are going to receive it perfectly. So a couple of things I'll just fight quickly.
- 20:00One is to be likeable. That doesn't mean someone's going to like you. Be likeable. The second is to
- 20:07watch your tone. Because if I say, Oh, that's a great idea. It's okay. Cool. Like I'm excited. And
- 20:14if I say, Oliver, that's a great idea. Same words, totally different tone for anybody seeing this
- 20:21on camera. I roll my eyes to which is a sign of contempt, which means watch your body language.
- 20:27Because so often somebody will say what we want to hear and you can see in their face, I don't
- 20:32know about that. What somebody's body language. And totally, totally, ton of voice, body,
- 20:38all that nonverbal stuff is so important, right? If I try to convince you that my solution for
- 20:43your problem is the best in the market, I have to project it. It's not enough to say,
- 20:48our solution is the best, right? That doesn't cut it. Yeah. The solution is the best in the market,
- 20:56but absolutely convinced of that. 100%. Whether your tone is
- 21:00tentative, I don't know. Maybe it's a good solution. Maybe not. Oh, that's no good.
- 21:05It is a breakthrough. You know, I'll encounter people and it's just like,
- 21:10right? Like, I don't want to engage that person. And actually, like you said earlier,
- 21:14reactants, your experience, reactants, just because somebody's tone is unwelcoming or maybe
- 21:19even antagonistic. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. Now, you mentioned the grainy test.
- 21:25The best one because all the stuff we talked about, adopting the perforator's mindset,
- 21:30using all the psychology to your advantage, is all for naught if you cannot ace the grainy test.
- 21:36The grainy test is super simple and it's not easy, which are granny understand what you're saying.
- 21:44And granny is not stupid. Granny is smart. Granny is just not an expert in things. And you
- 21:50would think, it's really easy. Well, in my previous life, I was an academic and I, I once attended
- 21:57a seminar with a grad student in his program. It was number one program in the field. This is
- 22:03a shooting star in his face. And he had presentation. And I'm sitting there like, I am beyond
- 22:08puzzled. I don't understand a word that he's saying. And I feel so stupid. And then a really famous
- 22:13professor in the room, as soon as the kid finishes his presentation, he raises his hand and I'm like,
- 22:20oh my god, he's just going to, you know, and then he says, I didn't understand a word that you
- 22:25just said. And I was like, oh, okay, so it wasn't just me. By contrast, this same professor,
- 22:30I saw him give a lecture once. And he said, and it sounded so arrogant. He said, my super power
- 22:36is that I make really complicated things simple. And I thought, you don't. And then an hour
- 22:41later, at the end of his lecture, I thought, yeah, you do. He told so many super complicated things,
- 22:48made them simple. My granny would have followed every single word. Simplicity is a super power
- 22:55cultivator. It is a super power. I was in a room recently where someone explained Claude Ai and
- 23:01you know, the one of the things he could do with co-work and so on. And then someone raised the
- 23:05hand and said, you just broke my brain, which was probably not the feet I'm looking for. But
- 23:11I thought it was very honest. And then half the room was just nodding. And so you're saying, you just
- 23:15broke my brain. So simplicity, super power, granny test, I love it. And it reminds me of something
- 23:22Paul Propster, former Chief Architect, NASA, said on this podcast a few weeks ago, which was,
- 23:27when they collaborated with Pixar, Pixar said it's about getability. Like, do people get it
- 23:33immediately? I love this never had it before. Getability. Like, do you get it? Granny test,
- 23:38awesome. Granny gets it. We're golden, right? Oh, it's gold. Look, if Granny understands,
- 23:44it means that you are crystal clear. And if you can bring clarity with all the things that we
- 23:50talked about, really making it about them and appealing to their values in an emotionally
- 23:56intelligent manner, oh my goodness, the sky is the actual limit. Yeah, if you confuse you, Louis,
- 24:02love it. Just this is so good. The books lovely. Tell us more about where can people get the book
- 24:08and find out more about you, connect with you, etc. Well, you can get the book anywhere,
- 24:12books are sold, Amazon, Barnes, Noble, wherever. And you can learn more about me checking out my
- 24:17website, Joshuaband.com or find me on LinkedIn. Those are all great ways to connect with me.
- 24:23Perfect. I will link to that of course. My final question is always, what's the best piece of
- 24:27communications advice? I think that each and every day we are faced in every interaction,
- 24:33personal and professional with a choice. Do I want to be right or do I want to make a difference?
- 24:39Being right is super easy, launch the logic tsunamis. Making a difference, that's what persuasion
- 24:44is and that's what the book offers you. An opportunity time after time after time to make a
- 24:49difference and ultimately get even more than you thought you ever could. Yeah, Josh, thank you.
- 24:55Amazing, Oliver, thank you. Thanks for watching. If you like this episode, please subscribe to
- 24:59the Speak Like A CEO channel. It means the world to me and it helps us keep bringing you world
- 25:04class insights and guests.