Latest / The Confessional Booth / The Role of Secrecy: What We Hide Owns Us
Transcript
- Marie Wagner: Welcome to the Confessional Booth. I'm your host, Marie Wagner. I am a certified sex love and relationship coach and I am a de-armoring practitioner. The Confessional Booth is a space where we bring voice to what has been hidden, where we explore the things that shape us beneath the surface. And it's a place where shame and other internal blockages begin to lose their grip. As a result, we can start to experience more freedom, energy, joy, pleasure, and to ultimately feel more fully ourselves. In today's episode, I want to start with the question what happens to the parts of ourselves that never find a voice? What happens to the secret we were told to never reveal? What happens to the grief we never speak about, the desires we never admit, the boundaries we never set, the anger we were never allowed to express, the experiences that felt too painful, too confusing, too embarrassing, or too overwhelming to put into words. Most of us have been taught either directly or indirectly. That if we do not talk about something, eventually it will go away. You might have said this to yourself, or you might have heard it in the outside world. Time heals all wounds. Just move on. Don't dwell on it. Stay positive. Focus on the future. And while there is certainly value in resilience and moving forward, there is also a cost. When parts of our experience remain hidden for too long. Because what is unspoken does not simply disappear, it often moves underground. And once it moves underground, it begins influencing our lives in ways we may not immediately recognize. This is where I think the work of Carl Jung, psychoanalyst, becomes incredibly relevant. Jung spoke about what he called the shadow. The shadow is not necessarily the dark or evil parts of ourselves, as people sometimes assume. The shadow is simply everything that has been pushed outside of conscious awareness, the parts we reject. The parts we suppress, the parts we learned were unacceptable, the parts that did not fit the image of who we believed we needed to be in order to be accepted by our caretakers. And one of Jung's most well-known observations was that what remains unconscious does not stop affecting our lives. As he famously wrote, until you make the unconscious conscious, It will direct your life and you will call it fate. I think about that often when I work with people around intimacy, relationships, sexuality, and personal growth. Because so many people feel trapped in patterns they cannot explain. They find themselves repeatedly attracted to unavailable partners. They struggle to communicate their needs. They have difficulty receiving love. They overwork. They people please. They avoid conflict. They disconnect from their bodies. They feel anxiety around intimacy. And often they believe these patterns simply appeared out of nowhere. But when we begin exploring the deeper layers, we often discover there are entire chapters of their story. That have never been given language. However, it continues influencing behavior from beneath the surface. In many ways, secrecy is one of the primary ways the shadow is maintained. Anything we cannot talk about gains a certain kind of power over us. Not because it is powerful. ⁓ But because it remains outside conscious awareness. And when something remains hidden, we lose the opportunity to examine it, challenge it, understand it, or integrate it. This is one of the reasons I believe secrecy and shame are so deeply connected. Brene Brown has spent years researching shame, and one of her observations is that shame. Thrives in secrecy, silence, and judgment. I think this is important because shame rarely grows stronger through expression. It grows stronger through concealment. When we carry something alone, we often become the sole interpreter of its meaning. There is nobody there to offer perspective, nobody there to challenge the story. Nobody there to remind us that we are human. Instead, the mind begins filling in the gaps, and the stories we create in isolation are often much harsher than reality. A teenager experiences rejection and concludes they are unlovable. A child is criticized and concludes they are inadequate. Someone experiences sexual shame and concludes there is something fundamentally wrong with their desires. These conclusions become internal truths, even when they are based on incomplete information. Over time, the original experience becomes less influential than the story attached to it. This is where secrecy becomes so Detrimental. Not keeping something private is inherently unhealthy. ⁓ Privacy secrecy are not the same thing. Privacy is a healthy boundary. Secrecy often carries fear. Privacy says I choose who has access to this. Secrecy says this cannot be seen. That distinction matters. Many people have never been taught the difference, and because of that, they carry experiences in complete isolation for years, sometimes decades. The body, however, does not keep secrets in the same way the mind does. The nervous system records experience. When something overwhelming happens and we do not have the resources, support, or safety to process it, the experience often remains unfinished within the system. The body continues preparing for a threat that no longer exists. The muscles remain braced, the breath remains restricted, the nervous system remains vigilant, the mind remains preoccupied. This is one of the reasons trauma is often misunderstood. Trauma is not simply the event itself. Trauma is often the residue that remains when the experience could not be fully processed. And when experiences remain unprocessed, They frequently become difficult to talk about. Words disappear. Memories become fragmented. The body remembers what the conscious mind struggles to articulate. People will often tell me they know something happened. They know it affected them, but they cannot quite explain why it still feels present. That makes perfect sense from a nervous system perspective. The body speaks a different language. Than the intellect. The body communicates through sensation, through tension, through contraction, through activation, through avoidance, through attraction, through behavior, through pleasure, or through pain. This is one reason why people can spend years trying to think their way through a problem. While the body continues carrying the burden, the intellect understands something. The nervous system has not yet caught up. James Hollis, a famous Jungian psychoanalyst, speaks beautifully about this when he discusses the unlived life. He suggests that many of us spend years adapting ourselves to the expectations of family, culture, and society. become who we think we should be. We become who others need us to be. We become who we believe will be accepted. in the process, parts of our authentic self are left behind. ⁓ Over time, these neglected parts begin demanding attention, not because they are trying to sabotage us, because they are trying to be included. I see this all the time in conversations around sexuality. Someone says they don't know what they want sexually, and often that is true. But sometimes the deeper truth is that they have never been allowed to ask themselves. They learned early that their desires were inappropriate, selfish, embarrassing, too much, not enough. So they stopped listening. Years later, they They genuinely struggle to identify their wants because the channel of communication between mind and body have become disconnected. The question is no longer, what do I want? The question becomes, Am I allowed to want that? And that is a very different conversation. John Bradshaw, author of The Shame That Binds Us, describes shame as an identity wound, not I made a mistake, but I am the mistake. And when shame reaches that level, expressing ourselves becomes risky because every expression carries the possibility of exposing the part of ourselves we fear is fundamentally flawed. If I tell you what I want, will you judge me? If I tell you what happened to me, will you reject me? If I tell you how I really feel, will you leave? If I reveal this hidden part of myself, will I still belong? These questions live underneath many of the struggles people face in relationships. Difficulty expressing desire is rarely just difficulty expressing desire. Difficulty setting boundaries is rarely just difficulty setting boundaries. Beneath them often sits a deeper difficult. Fear, a fear of losing connection. Because human beings are wired for attachment. We are wired for belonging. And anything that threatens belonging can feel dangerous, if not life-threatening, to the nervous system. This is why so many people become experts at managing perceptions. They learn how to present themselves, how to perform, how to accommodate. How to anticipate the needs of others, how to avoid discomfort. And from the outside, these strategies can appear highly functional. Internally, however, they often create profound loneliness. Because connection requires authenticity and visibility. At some point, we have to allow ourselves to be known. Not perfectly or not all at once and not without discernment, but enough that the people around us are actually relating to us rather than relating to our performance. One of the things I have come to appreciate over years of studying sexuality, relationships, trauma, and the body is that the human nervous system does not distinguish particularly well between what is physically dangerous and what is socially dangerous. If a child learns that speaking honestly leads to criticism, ridicule, punishment, withdrawal of affection, or emotional abandonment, the body records that experience. The next time honesty becomes necessary, the nervous system may respond as though there is a danger present. You can often see it happening in real time. Someone wants to say something, their throat tightens, their jaw locks, their chest constricts, their breathing becomes shallow, their heart rate increases, their stomach clenches. They suddenly lose access to the words they knew they wanted to say moments earlier. From the outside, it can appear as hesitation. Internally, the nervous system is mobilizing for protection. This is why so many people struggle to ask for what they want, whether that is in relationships, sexuality, family dynamics, friendships, or the workplace. The difficulty is often not a lack of clarity. It is a physiological response to perceived risk. Somewhere in the body there is a memory that says speaking up is dangerous. Being honest is dangerous. Having needs is dangerous. Expressing desire is dangerous. And so the body attempts to keep us safe by preventing the expression. Let me give you a few examples of what this could look like. A man who cannot tell his partner what he wants sexually and notice his throat closing every time he tries. A woman who says, I'm fine, while her shoulders are elevated, diaphragm restricted, and nervous system activated. Someone who was repeatedly shamed for anger as a child and now experiences migraines, jaw clenching. And difficulty setting boundaries. Someone carrying sexual shame who disassociates during intimacy despite deeply wanting connection. The tragedy is that the same adaptations that once protected us can eventually prevent intimacy, connection, authenticity, and growth. The nervous system begins prioritizing safety over aliveness. Predictability over truth, protection over connection. And this is where secrecy becomes detrimental. Because while the secret may protect us from short-term discomfort, it often creates long-term consequences. The unspoken grief continues to live in the body. The unexpressed anger continues to create tension. The unnamed desire continues to seek expression. The unresolved trauma continues to influence behavior. The unsaid truth continues to shape relationships. Over time, many people become disconnected from their own internal experience. Not necessarily because they lack self awareness, but rather they have spent years adapting to survive. This adaptation often shows up ⁓ through chronic muscle tension, habitually ⁓ breathing, digestive issues that worsen during stress, difficulty relaxing during intimacy, ⁓ receiving pleasure, difficulty. Maintaining eye contact during vulnerable conversations. These are just a few examples. There can also be a hypervigilance around other people's reactions, an inability to fully settle into the present moment. The body is constantly preparing for something, constantly scanning, anticipating, or managing. And while these adaptations are intelligent responses to past experiences, they require enormous energy to maintain. This is why so many people feel exhausted without understanding why. The nervous system and especially the primal brain and the amygdala complex are working over time. When truth finally begins to emerge, something remarkable often happens. Not because a story itself changes or because the past suddenly disappears. But because the nervous system receives new information, the body discovers that expression does not necessarily lead to abandonment and vulnerability does not automatically lead to rejection. The breath deepens, muscles relax and soften, the jaw relaxes, the chest ⁓ ⁓ The shoulders go back, the heart rate begins to settle. People often describe it as feeling lighter. And while that description sounds metaphorical, there is a physiological reality underneath it. There's less bracing, less guarding, less muscular contraction, less autonomic activation, and more energy becomes available for connection, creativity, pleasure, and presence. Psychologically, people often report greater clarity, greater self-trust, increased confidence, and a stronger sense of identity. Physiologically, they often experience greater regulation, improved emotional resilience, deeper breathing, improved capacity for intimacy and orgasm, and a greater ability to remain present during difficult conversations. In other words, healing is not simply a change in mindset. It is a change in the relationship between the mind, the body, and the nervous system. This is one reason I believe giving voice to what has been hidden is so powerful. The goal is not confession just for confession's sake. The goal is integration. Because what remains hidden often continues demanding energy, and what is finally acknowledged no longer needs to fight so hard to be heard. That is true psychologically, relationally, and physiologically. This is the Confessional Booth. If you like this episode, please rate it and subscribe and refer it to anyone you know who might benefit. To find out more about what I offer, head over to my website mariewagner.ca and Marie Wagner on Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn, and the Marie Wagner Coach on Instagram. Thanks for being here.