Latest / Phil and H Travel - Is It Worth It? Top Travel Destinations Explored! / Finding True Solitude Kayaking Acadia's Coast
Transcript
- 0:00All right, close your eyes for a second.
- 0:01I want you to do a little visualization exercise with me.
- 0:04It's February. It's probably Gray outside where
- 0:07you are and you're planning that big summer vacation.
- 0:10Escape. The escape?
- 0:11Exactly. And you want something iconic,
- 0:14You want New England, You want Maine.
- 0:17So what's the image that pops into your head right now?
- 0:20Oh, I can tell you exactly what it is.
- 0:22I mean, the tourism boards and the marketing departments have
- 0:26been perfecting this image for, what, 70 years now, right?
- 0:29You are picturing an LL Bean catalog that is just, you know,
- 0:33sprung to life. You see a perfect white
- 0:35lighthouse sitting on this dramatic rocky bluff.
- 0:39Totally. And there are those pink granite
- 0:40rocks everywhere. The pink granite for sure.
- 0:43And most importantly, you see yourself.
- 0:45You're in a kayak. Yes, and in my mind the water is
- 0:48just glass. It's perfectly calm.
- 0:51It's shimmering. I'm probably just wearing AT
- 0:53shirt, maybe a baseball cap. Effortless.
- 0:55I'm paddling effortlessly. There's a seal, you know,
- 0:58popping its little head up just to give me a cute nod.
- 1:01And then scene change. I'm sitting on a dock eating a
- 1:05lobster roll that didn't cost me a second mortgage.
- 1:08It is a beautiful dream, it really is.
- 1:10It's also what we in the industry, we call it the
- 1:13Instagram lie. The Instagram lie, I like that.
- 1:16Because while that perfect day can't happen, I mean it does
- 1:19exist. Aiming for that as your baseline
- 1:22expectation is just setting yourself up for our source
- 1:25material today calls a logistical gauntlet.
- 1:28That phrase, logistical gauntlet, it really jumped out
- 1:30at me from the page. We are doing a deep dive today
- 1:33into what we're calling the Acadia Extension, right?
- 1:36This is the whole world of coastal kayaking in Maine,
- 1:39specifically in the area around Acadia National Park.
- 1:43And the source material is just fascinating because it isn't a
- 1:45brochure at all. It reads more like a like a
- 1:49survival manual mixed with the Loveless.
- 1:51It's a huge reality check and we need to, you know, shatter that
- 1:55LL Bean image pretty early on here.
- 1:57We are not talking about a leisurely paddle on a lake in
- 1:59the Poconos. This isn't a lazy river float in
- 2:02Texas. We are talking about the North
- 2:04Atlantic Ocean. Let's dig into that phrase used
- 2:07environmental severity. That sounds, well, it sounds
- 2:12intense it. Is intense and people just don't
- 2:15have a frame of reference for it.
- 2:16The water temperature in Maine, even in the middle of August,
- 2:20when the air is, say, 80°, the water itself is sitting at about
- 2:2555°F. 65 so that's what, 12 Celsius?
- 2:28About that. And that is dangerously cold.
- 2:31That's cold enough to induce an immediate physiological shock if
- 2:34you fall in unexpectedly. And then you add the tides and
- 2:38again, people think they know tides.
- 2:40They don't. We're not talking about a gentle
- 2:41rise and fall of a foot or two. We are talking about 12 foot
- 2:45tides. A. 12 foot vertical change in
- 2:48the water level. That's higher than a basketball
- 2:50hoop. Every six hours, it moves
- 2:52billions of gallons of water. That kind of movement creates
- 2:55currents that can rival whitewater rivers, except
- 2:57they're happening in the open ocean.
- 2:59And it completely, totally alters the landscape.
- 3:02An island you can walk to at 10 in the morning might be
- 3:05surrounded by a mile of water at 4:00 in the afternoon.
- 3:08And this brings us right to the core paradox of this whole
- 3:11topic. I mean, everyone knows Acadia
- 3:13National Park is just exploding in popularity.
- 3:16It's the most overcrowded park in the entire Northeast.
- 3:19You literally have traffic jams on the hiking trails.
- 3:22It's become a victim of its own success.
- 3:23Totally. And yet the source argues that
- 3:27this exact same region offers total absolute isolation.
- 3:31You can be the only only human being for miles around.
- 3:34But of course, there's a catch. There's a huge catch, and that
- 3:37catch is the skill gap. That isolation you're talking
- 3:40about. It exists, but it's behind a
- 3:42wall. And the price of admission isn't
- 3:44the $30 park pass for your car, right?
- 3:47The real price is having the skill to actually leave the
- 3:50dock, to navigate in fog, to handle those tides, and to deal
- 3:54with that dangerously cold water.
- 3:56If you can pay that price in skill, you get the solitude.
- 3:59If you can't, you're stuck in that traffic jam on the Park
- 4:02Loop Rd. with everyone else. So today our mission is to
- 4:05figure out if that price is worth paying.
- 4:09We're going to break down this Acadia extension through the
- 4:12eyes of four very different travelers.
- 4:15I've got the backpacker, the mid range couple, the family and the
- 4:20luxury traveler. A full spectrum.
- 4:22And we are in going to give you a definitive verdict on whether
- 4:25you should book this trip or, you know, maybe just stay on
- 4:28land and eat some blueberries. And to frame this whole
- 4:31discussion, we've pulled out three, let's call them
- 4:34contrarian surprises. These are three major points
- 4:37from the source material that really go against almost all the
- 4:40standard travel advice you'll ever hear about Maine.
- 4:42OK, let's hear them #1. The best kayaking is not
- 4:45actually in Acadia National Park.
- 4:47That feels wrong. I mean, Katie is the brand name.
- 4:50It's why people go. It's the brand, absolutely, but
- 4:52it's not the best water and we'll get into exactly why that
- 4:55is. OK #2.
- 4:56You likely should not bring your own boat.
- 4:59Even if you're an avid kayaker and you've got a beautiful boat
- 5:01at home, the advice is to leave it there.
- 5:05That seems counterintuitive. I assume that's a logistics
- 5:07thing. It's a huge logistical argument
- 5:10that saves a ton of headaches. And #3 which I'm still trying to
- 5:13wrap my head around. It's my favorite one.
- 5:16The fog is actually the best part of the whole experience.
- 5:18OK, you're going to have to sell me on that one because that just
- 5:21sounds terrifying. I stand by it.
- 5:23If you know what you're doing, the fog is magical.
- 5:26If you don't, yes, it's terrifying, so we'll get there.
- 5:30All right, let's start with the context.
- 5:31Why are we even talking about this now?
- 5:33What is the current state of tourism in Maine that makes this
- 5:38idea of an escape to the water so, so appealing?
- 5:42Well you really have to look at the post COVID travel boom.
- 5:45It changed everything. Acadia National Park
- 5:49specifically, has seen his visitation numbers just
- 5:52skyrocket. I've seen the pictures.
- 5:54We are talking about millions of people cramming themselves onto
- 5:57Mount Desert Island, which, when you look at it on a map, is not
- 6:01that big of a place. I was reading about the traffic
- 6:03on the Park Loop Rd. and the description sound like the LA
- 6:06freeway at rush hour. That's not an exaggeration.
- 6:09It is urban level congestion, but in a wilderness setting and
- 6:14Bar Harbor, which is the main gateway town, it just becomes
- 6:17this massive bottleneck. You have cruise ships that are
- 6:20dumping thousands of passengers ashore for the day.
- 6:23You've got RV's the size of buses trying to navigate these
- 6:25little streets. You have families and minivans
- 6:28and the whole atmosphere just becomes frantic.
- 6:30You go there to relax, but the first thing you feel is stress.
- 6:33Exactly. You end up hunting for a parking
- 6:35spot for 45 minutes. You're standing in line for
- 6:37popcorn. You're dodging selfie sticks on
- 6:40what's supposed to be a quiet trail.
- 6:42It's that classic loving a place to death phenomenon.
- 6:45Yeah, we see that in so many national parks now.
- 6:47You do, and this creates a very specific psychological state in
- 6:52the traveller. The source has a great name for
- 6:54it, the Escape from the Escape. The escape from the escape.
- 6:57Think about it, You plan this whole vacation to escape your
- 7:01job, your stress, your daily grind.
- 7:04But then the vacation itself becomes incredibly stressful, so
- 7:08you find yourself standing on a crowded shore surrounded by
- 7:11people, and you look out at the ocean.
- 7:13And the ocean looks empty. It looks peaceful.
- 7:16It looks silent, it looks pristine, and you think to
- 7:19yourself, if I can just get out there, I'll finally find the
- 7:22peace I was promised. That assumption is what drives
- 7:25thousands of people to the water they view.
- 7:27The ocean is just, you know, blue land that Miller's using.
- 7:31But as we've already established, the ocean is not a
- 7:33playground, it's a genuinely hostile environment.
- 7:37And that's where that Instagram lie becomes actually dangerous.
- 7:41You see all the photos of the perfect blue sky and that golden
- 7:44hour light. But the photos don't tell you
- 7:46about the water temperature. They don't show you the current
- 7:48ripping around a headland. The source really emphasizes
- 7:52that the North Atlantic is volatile.
- 7:54The weather can change in 20 minutes.
- 7:56It requires a level of respect that a lot of casual tourists
- 7:59just don't have because they've been trained by vacations to the
- 8:02Caribbean or Florida, where the water is warm and forgiving.
- 8:06This water is not forgiving. There's also a big
- 8:09organizational shift happening on The Maine coast that I wasn't
- 8:12really aware of before reading this.
- 8:14Can you unpack the role of MITA for us?
- 8:17Yes, MIT, that's The Maine Island Trail Association.
- 8:22And if you're going to understand modern kayaking in
- 8:24Maine, you absolutely have to understand MITA.
- 8:29So historically, Maine has thousands of islands.
- 8:32I mean, just a staggering number.
- 8:34Some are state owned, but a huge portion of them are privately
- 8:37owned. For generations, there was this
- 8:39loose, unwritten maritime rule of what's called permissive
- 8:43access. Like an honor system.
- 8:45Kind of. You could paddle out, land on a
- 8:47pretty island, camp for the night, clean up after yourself
- 8:50and leave. It was sort of the Wild West of
- 8:52coastal camping. And I'm guessing that started to
- 8:54change. It did.
- 8:56As kayaking got more popular, and especially as coastal land
- 8:59values just went through the roof, land owners got nervous.
- 9:02They didn't want people trashing their pristine islands, and they
- 9:05really didn't want people suing them if they got hurt.
- 9:07So access started to shut down, gates went up, no trespassing
- 9:11signs appeared. And that's where Mati comes in.
- 9:14Exactly. Mighty stepped in to be the
- 9:16intermediary. They went to these private land
- 9:19owners, you know, families who owned an island for a century,
- 9:22timber companies, conservation trusts, and they made a deal.
- 9:25They said if you let us put your island on our official trail, we
- 9:31will steward it for you. We will have volunteers who go
- 9:34out and clean it. We'll build sustainable
- 9:36campsites. We will insure it.
- 9:38So it's basically like the Appalachian Trail but for boats?
- 9:41That's the perfect analogy, and it completely unlocked the coast
- 9:44again. Now if you're a member of
- 9:46Ivatia, you get a guidebook and an app that shows you exactly
- 9:49which islands are open for camping.
- 9:51It's an incredible system. You can literally camp on a
- 9:53private island that might be worth $5,000,000 all for the
- 9:57cost of a $50 membership. That's an amazing deal, but
- 10:00there has to be a flip side to that kind of organization.
- 10:03Right there is it's the double edged sword of concentration,
- 10:06because now everyone has the same guidebook, everyone has the
- 10:09same app, so everyone knows about and goes to the same best
- 10:12island. The secret spots aren't secret
- 10:14anymore. Exactly 10 years ago, you might
- 10:17have just explored until you found a cool spot to camp.
- 10:20Now you are actively competing for the one campsite on Jewel
- 10:23Island or the 310th platforms on Hills Half Acre.
- 10:27So you need a Plan A and a Plan B, and probably plan C.
- 10:30You absolutely do. You cannot just wing it anymore
- 10:33on a holiday weekend. The beautiful spontaneity of the
- 10:36old days has been replaced by, well, by logistics.
- 10:40Speaking of logistics, let's shift to the sensory experience.
- 10:44The source material describes what it calls a tale of two
- 10:47arrivals, which I thought was just a brilliant way to capture
- 10:50this vibe shift we're talking about.
- 10:52It's the contrast that defines the entire trip.
- 10:55Let's start with arrival #1 Bar Harbor.
- 10:58You've just driven 5 or 6 hours from Boston or New York.
- 11:01You finally crossed that bridge onto Mount Desert Island.
- 11:04What hits you? The very first thing that hits
- 11:07you is the traffic on Route 3. It's just bumper to bumper.
- 11:10But then, as you get into town, it's the smell.
- 11:13If you roll down your car window in downtown Bar Harbor in July,
- 11:16you are not smelling pine trees. What are you smelling?
- 11:19You are smelling fried dough. You're smelling diesel exhaust
- 11:22from the tour buses and the RV's.
- 11:24You're smelling sunscreen and hot asphalt.
- 11:27It sounds like a State Fair or a carnival.
- 11:29It feels like a cruise ship terminal because functionally
- 11:33that's what it is. The dominant emotion you feel
- 11:35isn't peace, it's anxiety. Specifically, parking anxiety.
- 11:40Every single driver is just scanning, scanning, scanning for
- 11:43a spot. They're aggressive, they're
- 11:45tense. It sets this incredibly frantic
- 11:47tone for your whole trip. OK, so that's a rival one.
- 11:50Now let's cut to arrival #2 the launch site.
- 11:54The source mentions places like Stonington or Seal Cove.
- 11:57These are maybe an hour's drive away from Bar Harbor, but they
- 12:00sound like they're on a different planet.
- 12:02A different planet entirely. It's a total sensory reset.
- 12:05You drive down one of these long peninsulas, away from the
- 12:07T-shirt chops and the neon signs.
- 12:09You pull into a working harbor or a little gravel landing.
- 12:12You step out of the car and the first thing that hits you is
- 12:15that smell. And what does that smell like?
- 12:17It smells like low tide mud. Now, some people might think
- 12:20that's a gross smell, but to a paddler, that is the smell of
- 12:23life. It's sulphurous, it's salty,
- 12:26it's organic and rich, and it's mixed with the smell of spruce
- 12:30resin from the trees right at the water's edge.
- 12:33That sharp, Piney scent. It just smells clean and wild.
- 12:37And there's a physical shock that comes with it, too.
- 12:39The temperature drop. This is wild to experience.
- 12:43You can be in Bangor, just an hour inland, and it's 85° and
- 12:48humid. You step out of your car onto
- 12:50the dock in Stonington, right next to that massive body of 55°
- 12:54water, and the air temperature plummets to 65.
- 12:57It's breezy. It's crisp.
- 12:59The source says you have to layer up almost immediately.
- 13:01You do. You get out of your nice air
- 13:03conditioned car and the first thing you do is reach for a
- 13:05fleece or a windbreaker. And that simple physical act?
- 13:09Putting on a jacket in the middle of August, it signals to
- 13:11your brain that the rules have changed.
- 13:13You are not in the summer vacation world anymore.
- 13:16You are in the maritime world. The whole visual landscape
- 13:19shifts too. It's not just pretty water
- 13:20anymore. No, the water itself looks
- 13:23serious. It looks heavy.
- 13:25It's as deep, dark green or sometimes Gray.
- 13:29It doesn't invite you to just jump in and splash around.
- 13:31It demands respect. And then you see the industry.
- 13:34We're talking about the lobster buoys.
- 13:36The working coast. This is such a crucial concept.
- 13:40You are not entering A sterile, manicured park.
- 13:43You are entering a factory floor.
- 13:45The entire surface of the ocean is this incredible minefield of
- 13:49thousands and thousands of colorful Styrofoam pot buoys.
- 13:53Every color of the rainbow. Every color and every single one
- 13:56of those is attached to a heavy lobster trap on the bottom with
- 14:00a rope. Navigating through that must be
- 14:02tricky. It's like a constant slalom
- 14:03course, but also has this huge psychological impact.
- 14:06You see the lobster boats out there hauling their traps.
- 14:09They are working, you are playing, and it makes you feel
- 14:11small. It makes you realize that this
- 14:13place does not exist for your entertainment, it exists for a
- 14:15livelihood. You are a guest, and a very
- 14:18small one at that. Let's talk about the economics
- 14:20of being a guest in this place, because usually when we think of
- 14:23outdoor adventure or dirtbag style trips, we think cheap, but
- 14:27the source suggests the Acadia extension has this really
- 14:31extreme cost. Variant It's massive.
- 14:34You can do this trip for almost nothing, or you can spend a
- 14:37small fortune, and it depends almost entirely on one thing,
- 14:42your skill level. OK.
- 14:43Let's breakdown the cost. Let's start with accommodation.
- 14:45If you're that scrappy dirtbag and you're trying to do this on
- 14:48a shoestring budget, where are you sleeping?
- 14:51If you are the scrappy dirtbag, you are camping, and ideally
- 14:54you're camping on the E main tea islands.
- 14:56If you have your $50 membership. Many of these incredible islands
- 15:00are free or maybe donation based.
- 15:02So you were sleeping on a private island with $1,000,000
- 15:05view for $0.00 a night? That sounds incredible, but what
- 15:09if you can't get to the islands? Or what if you don't have the
- 15:11skills yet? Then you're in trouble
- 15:12financially. The public camping in the park
- 15:15at places like Blackwoods or Seawall.
- 15:17It's about $30 a night, which is reasonable.
- 15:21But, and this is a huge morning, it books out six months in
- 15:25advance. The minute the reservation
- 15:28window opens on the website, every single spot for July and
- 15:31August is gone. So if I decide today that I want
- 15:34to go to Maine next week, I am not camping in the National
- 15:37Park. Not a chance.
- 15:39So now you're pushed out into the private market.
- 15:41You're looking for motels and because of the insane demand, a
- 15:44basic, run-of-the-mill two star motel in Ellsworth or Trenton.
- 15:48It's going to run you 150 to $250 a night.
- 15:52For a roadside motel. For a totally unremarkable
- 15:54roadside motel, and if you want that classic New England bed and
- 15:57breakfast experience right in Bar Harbor, you should start
- 16:00your budget at $400.00 a night and expect it to go up to 800
- 16:03pretty quickly. OK, that's just a place to
- 16:05sleep. What about the kayaking itself?
- 16:07The gear. This is where the hidden costs
- 16:10really bite the casual traveler. Let's say you've kayaked a few
- 16:13times on a lake. You're comfortable, you think
- 16:16I'll just rent a boat for a few days and go do some island
- 16:18camping? Sounds like a reasonable plan.
- 16:20It's an impossible plan. Most reputable Outfitters in
- 16:23Maine will not rent you a proper sea kayak for a solo multi day
- 16:27trip unless you can prove you have rescue skills.
- 16:31So they're gatekeeping the boats?
- 16:32They have to. It's a liability and safety
- 16:34issue. They will want to see a
- 16:36certification like from the American Canoe Association or
- 16:40they will literally ask you to get in the water at their dock
- 16:43and demonstrate a wet exit and a self rescue.
- 16:46If you can't do it, you don't get the boat.
- 16:49Period. So what's the alternative then
- 16:51for the person who can't do a self rescue but still wants to
- 16:53get out there? You have to hire a guide and
- 16:56that changes the entire financial equation of the trip.
- 16:59A guided half day trip is maybe $150.00 per person.
- 17:03A full multi day expedition where the guide is providing the
- 17:07food, the tents, the boats, the navigation, the safety.
- 17:11You're going to be spending between 800 and $1200 per
- 17:14person. So let's put that in
- 17:15perspective. The scrappy dirtbag with their
- 17:18own gear and skills pays maybe $300.00 for a whole week.
- 17:22Gas, food fees, and the unskilled but enthusiastic
- 17:27traveler is paying $1500 for that same week.
- 17:30Exactly. Skill is currency in this
- 17:33environment. Knowing how to rescue yourself
- 17:35from a capsize literally save you $1000.
- 17:38There's one other economic indicator we absolutely have to
- 17:41discuss. The source calls it the Lobster
- 17:44Roll Benchmark. The Big Mac Index of New England
- 17:47coastal travel. So what are we looking at for
- 17:49prices right now? Lay it on me.
- 17:51It is genuinely shocking to people who haven't been in a few
- 17:53years. The current market price for a
- 17:55lobster roll, which is, let's be honest, a hot dog bun with some
- 17:59meat and mayonnaise, is hovering between 30 and 45 dollars. 40 $5
- 18:05for a sandwich. It's a perfect storm of supply
- 18:07and demand. The lobster catch fluctuates,
- 18:10the fuel prices for the boats are way up, and frankly, the
- 18:12tourists are willing to pay it. But what that means is a simple
- 18:15lunch for a family of four can easily hit $200.
- 18:18Even the grocery stores on the islands, they mark things up
- 18:21right. Yeah, you'll see about a 10 to
- 18:2315% markup. It's the island tax.
- 18:25Getting goods out there on a ferry costs money.
- 18:28So when you Add all this up, is the value actually there?
- 18:33It depends on your approach. The source argues pretty
- 18:36convincingly that the scrappy dirtbag approach is maybe the
- 18:39highest value travel experience in all of North America.
- 18:43I mean, think about it. You have a private island, you
- 18:46have silence, seals, incredible sunsets, all for the cost of a
- 18:50tank of gas and some groceries. It feels like you're cheating
- 18:53the. System for the guided client
- 18:55paying top dollar. The value is different.
- 18:58It's not about saving money. You are paying for stress
- 19:00reduction. You're paying so that you don't
- 19:02have to worry about the fog rolling in or what the tide is
- 19:05doing or trying to cook dinner in a howling wind.
- 19:07You are buying safety and expertise and given the
- 19:10environment we're talking about, that is a very, very valid
- 19:12purchase. Let's talk more about why you
- 19:14might need to buy that safety. The source outlines this
- 19:17logistical gauntlet in the form of what it calls the Three
- 19:20Traps. These are the specific things
- 19:22that can turn a dream trip into an absolute disaster.
- 19:26Yeah, these traps are very specific to the coast of Maine.
- 19:28If you aren't ready for them, they will ruin your week.
- 19:30Guaranteed. OK, trap #1 the tide trap.
- 19:34We mentioned the 12 foot swing, but walk me through a specific
- 19:38scenario of how this actually traps a kayaker.
- 19:41OK, so imagine this. It's noon, it's high tide.
- 19:44You paddle into this beautiful, picturesque little Cove.
- 19:47There's nice gravel beach at the back of it.
- 19:50You pull your kayak up, say 5 or 10 feet from the water's edge.
- 19:54Seems safe enough. You get out, grab your lunch.
- 19:57Maybe you hike into the woods a little bit, take a nap in the
- 19:59sun. You come back at 2:00 PM.
- 20:01Just two hours later. Just two hours later, the tide
- 20:03has started to go out. But because that Cove has a very
- 20:06shallow, gentle slope, the water hasn't just dropped vertically,
- 20:10it is receded horizontally. The water's edge is now 300,
- 20:15maybe 400 yards away from your boat.
- 20:17That's three or 4 football fields.
- 20:20Exactly, and the ground between you and the water isn't nice
- 20:23hard packed sand. It's what's called mudflats.
- 20:27It is this thick, sucking glacial silt covered in seaweed.
- 20:32It will pull your boots right off your feet.
- 20:33Since you can't just drag the boat.
- 20:35I mean you could try a fully loaded sea kayak can weigh 100
- 20:39lbs or more. Trying to drag that thing 300
- 20:41yards through knee deep stinking mud is one of the most
- 20:45exhausting and demoralizing things you can do.
- 20:47You can pull a muscle, twist an ankle so effectively you are
- 20:51stranded. You have no choice but to sit
- 20:53there for four or five hours until the water comes back to
- 20:55you. That completely ruins the day.
- 20:57It's but the reverse scenario is actually much more dangerous.
- 21:01You arrive at low tide, find a nice flat spot for your tent
- 21:04near the water. You go to sleep.
- 21:05You wake up at 2:00 AM floating inside your tent.
- 21:08That's a genuine hypothermia situation.
- 21:10And the fix for this trap is. You have to have to have to be
- 21:14able to read a tide chart. It's not optional.
- 21:16And practically, you ask the locals, you ask your outfitter,
- 21:20where is the high watermark? Where is the storm line?
- 21:23If you look for the line of dried seaweed and driftwood way
- 21:26up on the beach, you never ever guess.
- 21:29OK, trap #2 the launch site trap.
- 21:32This is all about access. People look at Google Maps, they
- 21:35see a little Rd. that ends at the pretty blue water and they
- 21:38think, perfect, I'll just launch my boat there.
- 21:40Seems logical. I would probably do that.
- 21:42In Maine, that is a trap. You drive down that long winding
- 21:45road and you find a gate with a chain across it, or a no parking
- 21:48sign, or a town residence only sign.
- 21:51Maine has very very strong private property rights.
- 21:54Just because you can see the water does not mean you're
- 21:56allowed to touch it. And I'm guessing parking is
- 21:59scarce even at the public spots. Incredibly scarce, even at the
- 22:02designated public landings, the parking lot might only hold 6
- 22:05cars. If you arrive at 9:00 AM on a
- 22:08Saturday in July, it is already full.
- 22:10So now you're stuck driving around with a 17 foot boat on
- 22:13your roof, getting more and more frustrated.
- 22:15So the advice from the source is basically just pay the money.
- 22:19Just pay the money. Use a verified commercial launch
- 22:21site like Old Quarry in Stonington.
- 22:23Pay the 10 or $20. You get safe parking.
- 22:26You get advice, you get clean bathrooms.
- 22:28Don't try to be clever and find some secret free spot.
- 22:32You'll just get towed or waste half your day.
- 22:34All right, that brings us to trap #3 the fog trap.
- 22:38This goes back to our earlier contrarian point.
- 22:41But before we talk about why it's good, let's explain the
- 22:44danger. The danger is total sensory
- 22:47deprivation, and the fog in Maine is not some gentle mist.
- 22:52It is a wall of white. You can launch in bright,
- 22:54beautiful sunshine at 10 in the morning.
- 22:57Then the wind shifts just slightly, pulls that cold, moist
- 22:59air from the ocean over the warmer land, and boom, by 1:00
- 23:03PM, you can't see the front of your own kayak.
- 23:05So visibility is basically 0. It's 50 feet if you're lucky.
- 23:09Landmarks you're using to navigate completely disappear.
- 23:12Islands vanish and sound gets really weird and distorted.
- 23:15You hear a lobster boat engine, but you can't tell where it's
- 23:17coming from. It sounds like it's on your left
- 23:19and on your right. It's incredibly disorienting.
- 23:21And this is where people get into trouble by relying on their
- 23:24phones. This is the tech trap inside the
- 23:26fog trap. People think it's fine.
- 23:28I have Google Maps but 2 miles offshore there is no cell tower.
- 23:32Your GPS signal might be weak, or your screen gets wet and it
- 23:36won't register your touch, or the cold just drains your
- 23:39battery in 20 minutes. If your phone is your only
- 23:42navigation tool, you're effectively blind and lost.
- 23:45So you need the old school analog skills.
- 23:48You absolutely need them. You need a proper deck mounted
- 23:51compass, you need a paper chart and a waterproof case on your
- 23:54deck. And you need to have practice
- 23:55using them before you go. And a foghorn the source
- 23:58mentioned. Non negotiable.
- 24:00If you hear a boat engine getting louder but you can't see
- 24:02it, you blast that horn. It's the universal signal for a
- 24:06tiny plastic boat here. Please don't run me over.
- 24:08So with all that real palpable danger, why on earth did the
- 24:12source claim that the fog bug is the best part?
- 24:15Because when you do have the skills, when you're not
- 24:18panicking, because you trust your compass in your chart, the
- 24:21fog changes the entire world. The wind usually dies down
- 24:25completely. The water becomes oily and calm.
- 24:29The world shrinks to a 50 foot circle around your boat.
- 24:32It's incredibly quiet and peaceful.
- 24:35It sounds very atmospheric, almost meditative.
- 24:38It is. It feels like you're paddling
- 24:40through a cloud. It forces you to be completely
- 24:43present in a way that bright sunshine just doesn't.
- 24:45It's a so profound experience, but only if you're not terrified
- 24:49of being lost. Let's move into what the source
- 24:52calls the grit. We've talked about these
- 24:54external traps, but now let's talk about the physical reality
- 24:57of living out of a tiny boat in Maine.
- 24:59The source is pretty blunt about safety and comfort.
- 25:02Yeah, it doesn't sugarcoat it at all.
- 25:03The number one killer out there isn't sharks, it's not getting
- 25:05run over by a boat, It's the cold.
- 25:07Ropathermia, we have to keep hammering this point home. 55°
- 25:11water. Walk me through what happens to
- 25:13the human body at that temperature.
- 25:15OK, so the moment you fall in unexpectedly, your body goes
- 25:19into something called cold water shock.
- 25:22The first thing that happens is an involuntary gasp reflex.
- 25:26You just suck in air. If your head happens to be
- 25:29underwater at that moment, you suck in water.
- 25:31You can drown instantly without even taking a breath.
- 25:33And if you survive that initial gasp.
- 25:36Then you have about 10 to 15 minutes of what's called
- 25:38functional disability. The cold water makes the blood
- 25:41rush from your extremities, your hands and feet to protect your
- 25:43core organs. Within minutes, your fingers
- 25:46stop working. They become useless claws.
- 25:48You can't zip a zipper. You can't hold onto a rescue
- 25:51line. You can't climb back into your
- 25:52boat, even if you know how. That is just terrifying.
- 25:55You become completely helpless. In a matter of minutes, you do.
- 25:58And that is why the right gear is absolutely non negotiable.
- 26:02You must wear a wet suit or a dry suit if you are doing any
- 26:05kind of open water crossing. If an outfitter tries to rent
- 26:08you a kayak and says it was a nice day I would just wear
- 26:10shorts and AT shirt. You should turn around and walk
- 26:12away. They are being negligent.
- 26:15The rule is you dress for the water temperature, not the air
- 26:18temperature. Let's lighten the mood slightly
- 26:20if we can. Let's talk about bugs, the
- 26:24biological hazards. Ah yes, the green head fly.
- 26:27The source makes them sound like something out of a horror movie.
- 26:30They are legitimately nasty. A mosquito is annoying.
- 26:33It sort of pokes you with a needle.
- 26:35A green head fly has these mandibles that work like tiny
- 26:39serrated scissors. They literally saw a chunk of
- 26:43skin out of you to get the blood flowing.
- 26:45Ouch, that's vivid. And they are fast.
- 26:48They're relentless. And here's the kicker, your
- 26:50standard chemical repellents like D eat or citronella, they
- 26:54couldn't care less. They're visual hunters.
- 26:56So you can't just spray them away.
- 26:58No, the only real defense is physical barriers.
- 27:01Long sleeve shirts, long pants, thick socks, preferably light
- 27:05colored clothing. So let's get this picture
- 27:07straight. You're on a stunningly beautiful
- 27:08island. It's the middle of August, but
- 27:10you're bundled up in a wet suit or heavy canvas pants because
- 27:13you're either freezing or you're being eaten alive.
- 27:15It is definitely not the bikini and board shorts vibe you get in
- 27:18the Caribbean. You are essentially wearing
- 27:20armor against the elements at all times.
- 27:22And finally, let's talk about the ultimate filter, the one
- 27:26thing that truly separates the casual tourist from the
- 27:28committed traveler in this environment?
- 27:31Sanitation. The Wag bag.
- 27:34Please explain what a wag bag is for those who are blissfully
- 27:37unaware. OK, so these beautiful granite
- 27:40islands have very, very thin soil.
- 27:43It's mostly just rock with a little bit of Moss and Duff on
- 27:46top. You cannot dig a proper cat hole
- 27:49to bury your human waste like you would in a deep forest.
- 27:52It just won't decompose, it'll just sit there.
- 27:54So leave no trace means you have to pack it out.
- 27:57Leave No Trace taken to its most literal extreme use what's
- 28:01called a WAG bag. It stands for waste Alleviation
- 28:03and gelling. It's a specialized double bag
- 28:05system with a gelling powder inside that neutralizes the
- 28:09smell for the most part and solidifies the waste and.
- 28:11Then what? Do your business in the bag.
- 28:13You seal it all up, you put it inside a hard plastic tube
- 28:15called the poop tube to protect it, and you carry it in your
- 28:18kayak hatch with your food and your tent for the rest of the
- 28:21trip. That is an intimate travel
- 28:23experience. It's a huge reality check.
- 28:26The source is very clear. If you are grossed out by the
- 28:29idea of carrying your own poop in a bag for three days, this
- 28:33trip is probably not for you. It's a major, major filter.
- 28:36So let me recap. We have dangerously cold water,
- 28:39disorienting fog, sucking mud, flesh eating flies and poop
- 28:44tubes. Why in God's name does anyone do
- 28:47this? Because of the magic.
- 28:49Because the highs are so incredibly high.
- 28:51Let's talk about those highs. The source gets almost poetic
- 28:54when it describes these magic moments.
- 28:57The biggest one, the one that everyone talks about, is the
- 28:59bioluminescence. The source mentions a specific
- 29:02campsite, Hell's Half Acre. It's a famous spot for it.
- 29:06In the late summer, the water in Maine fills with these tiny
- 29:09microorganisms, dinoflagellates, and they emit light whenever
- 29:12they're disturbed. Like fireflies, but in the
- 29:14water. So much better than fireflies.
- 29:16The source describes going out at night in a kayak when there's
- 29:19no moon. Every single time you dip your
- 29:21paddle into the water, the water just explodes in a swirl of neon
- 29:24blue-green light. You can run your hand through
- 29:26the water and it looks like you were painting with blue fire.
- 29:29And you can't take a picture of it.
- 29:30And that's the best part. It's too faint for an iPhone
- 29:32camera. You can't put it on Instagram.
- 29:35It is a purely ephemeral, personal experience.
- 29:39You have to be there in the dark, probably shivering a
- 29:42little from the cold, to see it. It feels like actual, real
- 29:46magic. There's also the satisfaction of
- 29:48navigation. We talked about the fear, the
- 29:50fog, but there's a flip side to that coin.
- 29:52It's the feeling of pure competence.
- 29:55Imagine you are in that thick, disorienting fog.
- 29:58You can't see anything, but you've done your homework.
- 30:01You take a bearing off your chart.
- 30:02Let's say it's 270° W You put your boat on that bearing and
- 30:05you just stare at your compass. You paddle for 45 minutes,
- 30:09trusting the math, trusting the needle.
- 30:11And then out of the Gray mist, a dark shape starts to
- 30:15materialize. And it's the dock.
- 30:17It's the island, exactly where it was supposed to be.
- 30:19That must feel incredible, like a superpower.
- 30:22It makes you feel so capable. You weren't just a passive
- 30:25observer looking at nature, you are actively surviving in it.
- 30:29You're navigating through it using your own skill that build
- 30:32this deep, primal kind of confidence that you just don't
- 30:36get from sitting on a tour bus. But the trip has an emotional
- 30:40arc, and it seems to end with a crash.
- 30:42The source talks about the culture shock of returning to
- 30:45the mainland. This hits everyone and it hits
- 30:48them hard. You've just been on an island
- 30:50for three or four days. The only sounds you've heard are
- 30:52waves and gulls and wind. You paddle back to the launch.
- 30:56You load your car and then you decide to drive into Bar Harbor
- 31:00to get a celebratory burger. And the noise just hit you like
- 31:02a wall. The noise, the smell of diesel
- 31:04exhaust again, the crowds of people, the rampant consumerism.
- 31:08It feels jarring. The source describes it as
- 31:10feeling like a physical blow. You suddenly realize how loud
- 31:13and frantic and stressful or normal lives are.
- 31:16You can actually ruin the relaxation of the whole trip if
- 31:18you're not mentally prepared for that reentry.
- 31:20One last disappointment the source mentions and it's a
- 31:22quirky 1. Purple paint.
- 31:24This is a legal quirk specific to Maine.
- 31:27Yeah, if you are walking or paddling and you see a vertical
- 31:30purple stripe painted on a tree or a post, it is the legal
- 31:34equivalent of a no trespassing sign.
- 31:36So it replaces a sign. Exactly.
- 31:39And in Maine, land owners are very serious about it.
- 31:42So you might be paddling along and you see this stunningly
- 31:44beautiful Cove. The perfect spot for a lunch
- 31:46break. But then you see that little
- 31:48slash of purple paint on a tree at the edge of the beach.
- 31:51And you can't land there. You have to keep paddling.
- 31:53It can be really frustrating to see miles and miles of beautiful
- 31:57coastline that you are legally barred from ever setting foot
- 32:00on. It's a constant reminder that
- 32:03you are a visitor and that access is a privilege, not a
- 32:07right. OK, let's get into the practical
- 32:10how to section. The source was very clear, the
- 32:13best kayaking isn't actually in Acadia.
- 32:15So if I want to plan this trip properly, where should I be
- 32:17looking? We have three main alternatives.
- 32:19These are the big three alternatives to paddling right
- 32:21around the main park loop on Mount Desert Island.
- 32:24Let's start with option 1, Stonington and Deer Isle.
- 32:27The source calls this one the better Acadia.
- 32:30Stonington is the lofter capital of the state of Maine.
- 32:33It's about an hour's drive South of Bar Harbor, and the geography
- 32:36here is just spectacular. It's home to an archipelago
- 32:39called Merchant Row. What exactly is merchant row?
- 32:43It's this incredibly dense cluster of dozens and dozens of
- 32:46islands. The granite there is this
- 32:48beautiful pink color. The spruce trees are a deep
- 32:50green. The water is this dark, clear
- 32:53blue. It is visually stunning, like
- 32:56the platonic ideal of The Maine coast.
- 32:58And why is it better for kayaking than, say, Bar Harbor?
- 33:02Because while it's a busy harbor, it's busy with working
- 33:04lobster boats, not giant cruise ships and tourist ferries.
- 33:08The logistics are infinitely easier because of the old quarry
- 33:11launch site. It's a commercial hub that is
- 33:12specifically designed for kayakers.
- 33:15If your main goal is pure island hopping and camping, Stonington
- 33:18is the absolute gold standard. OK, option 2, Muskongas Bay.
- 33:23This is a bit further South in what's called the Mid Coast
- 33:25region. This is the historical
- 33:27birthplace of the main Island Trail.
- 33:29The vibe here is much, much quieter.
- 33:31There are no ferries. There are no cruise ships.
- 33:34The water is a little bit more protected from the open ocean.
- 33:37The source specifically mentions Crow Island, which has these
- 33:40incredible wildflower meadows in the summer.
- 33:43If you want deep silence and solitude, and you're maybe an
- 33:46intermediate paddler, Muskongas Bay is the place to find it.
- 33:49And option 3, Casco Bay. The source called this the light
- 33:53version. Right.
- 33:54This is the area right off of Portland, and it's great because
- 33:57it's so accessible. You can actually take a public
- 33:59ferry with your kayak out to some of the outer islands like
- 34:03Cliff Island or Long Island. That sounds a lot easier
- 34:06logistically. It is.
- 34:07And because you're so close to Portland, you feel a bit safer.
- 34:10There's more boat traffic, you're closer to civilization.
- 34:13If you run out of coffee, you're just a short paddle away from a
- 34:15town where you can get a latte. It's a great safety net location
- 34:19for beginners or families with older, capable teenagers.
- 34:23The source also offered an ideal combo itinerary if I have 5 days
- 34:27for a trip. How do I do this right?
- 34:29The advice is brilliant. I think it says don't mix the
- 34:33streams. You need to split the trip into
- 34:35two distinct parts. Break that down for me.
- 34:37Days one and two. Stay in or near Bar Harbor.
- 34:41Be a tourist. Embrace the tourist vibe.
- 34:44Go hike the Beehive Trail, Eat the famous popovers at Jordan
- 34:47Pond House. Drive your car up Cadillac
- 34:50Mountain for sunrise. Get that classic National Park
- 34:53checklist Done. Get it out of your system.
- 34:55Exactly. Then on the morning of day
- 34:57three, you leave, you drive the hour S to Stonington, you rent
- 35:01your kayak or you meet your guide, and you spend days 3-4
- 35:05and five on the water in Stonington in that better
- 35:09Acadia. So you get the best of the land
- 35:10based park and the best of the water based adventure without
- 35:13compromising either one. And you completely avoid the
- 35:16stress and the danger of trying to kayak in the crowded boat
- 35:20filled harbors of Acadia proper. It really does maximize the
- 35:24strengths of both locations. I love that strategy.
- 35:27OK, we have arrived at the moment of truth, the final
- 35:29verdict matrix. We need to look at our four
- 35:31traveler types and give them a definitive yes or no.
- 35:34Is the Acadia extension worth the money and the hassle?
- 35:38Let's do it. Traveler Type 1 The backpacker
- 35:41or the budget traveler? The verdict here is a resounding
- 35:44yes, but, and this is a big but, it comes with a caveat, High
- 35:50effort. Explain that.
- 35:51If you are willing and able to embrace the dirtbag lifestyle,
- 35:55you know, sleeping on the ground, dealing with the bugs,
- 35:58eating oatmeal for breakfast, managing all your own logistics
- 36:00and safety, this is arguably the best value trip in the entire
- 36:04country. You get a world class $1,000,000
- 36:06experience for pennies, but you absolutely have to have the
- 36:09skills to do it safely on your own.
- 36:11OK Traveler Type 2 the mid range couple you know they're looking
- 36:15for a unique romantic getaway. The verdict for them is also
- 36:19yes. In fact, the source calls this
- 36:21the sweet spot. But they recommend spending some
- 36:23serious money here. They do.
- 36:25The advice is don't skimp. Hire a private guide for a three
- 36:30day two night trip. It's going to cost you maybe
- 36:32$2500 for the two of you. That's a lot of money for a
- 36:35camping trip. It is, but you have to compare
- 36:38it to the alternative. You could spend that same $2500
- 36:42on a mediocre hotel and a few nice dinners in Bar Harbor.
- 36:47The guided kayaking trip will create memories that will bond
- 36:50you together for years. You overcome challenges
- 36:53together. You see things that almost no
- 36:55one else gets to see. It is an investment in the
- 36:58relationship itself. Or it breaks you U.
- 37:00That's true too. If you can't handle a little
- 37:03adversity together, you will find that out very, very quickly
- 37:06on a foggy island with no cell service.
- 37:09Traveler Type 3 The family specifically with kids under,
- 37:13say, the age of 12. The verdict here is a very hard
- 37:16NL. That seems harsh.
- 37:18I mean, kids love boats. They love camping.
- 37:20Kids love boats when it's warm and fun and they can jump in the
- 37:23water. They do not love 55° water, a
- 37:25cold wind that's been blowing for three hours and no
- 37:28bathrooms. It really comes down to being a
- 37:30liability issue. It's a massive liability.
- 37:32Managing a potentially hypothermic 7 year old 2 miles
- 37:35offshore is a parent's absolute worst nightmare scenario.
- 37:39It is just too dangerous and too stressful for everyone involved.
- 37:43The source is to stick to the inland lakes or take them on the
- 37:45big harbor tour boats where there are bathrooms and snacks.
- 37:48Wait until they are capable, resilient teenagers.
- 37:51Finally, Traveler type 4, The luxury traveler.
- 37:54For this one, the verdict is IT. It depends.
- 37:58Depends on what? It depends entirely on your
- 38:00personal definition of luxury. If your idea of luxury is 1000
- 38:04thread count sheets, 24 hour room service, and perfect
- 38:07climate control, this is a hard no.
- 38:09You will absolutely hate this trip.
- 38:11You're pooping in a bag and sleeping in a tent.
- 38:13But if luxury means something else?
- 38:15Exactly. If luxury to you means
- 38:17exclusivity and silence. If it means privacy.
- 38:20If it means access to places no one else can go, if it means
- 38:23having a private guide who is also a gourmet chef cook you a
- 38:26fresh lobster dinner on an uninhabited island where you are
- 38:29the only two human beings for miles around, then yes, it is
- 38:32the ultimate luxury. It is experiential luxury, not
- 38:35comfort luxury. So to wrap all of this up, what
- 38:39are the key takeaways for someone listening who is now
- 38:42ready to book this trip? I'd say there are three main
- 38:45things. One, respect the logistics.
- 38:48The ocean is the boss, not you. Do your homework on the tides
- 38:51and the fog. Two, pay for expertise.
- 38:55If you don't have the skills, hire a guide.
- 38:57It is worth every single penny. And three, learn to embrace the
- 39:01cold. It's part of the package.
- 39:03It's what makes it Maine. And.
- 39:04What about timing? Is there best time to go?
- 39:06Yes, the source calls it the Goldilocks window and it is
- 39:09September 5th to September 20th. Why that specific two week
- 39:13period? It's the sweet spot.
- 39:16The ocean water is at its warmest point of the entire
- 39:18year, which is still cold, but it's relatively warmer.
- 39:21The bugs, especially the green heads and mosquitoes, are mostly
- 39:23gone after the first cold nights, and the big summer
- 39:26crowds have thinned out because schools are all back in session.
- 39:29It is the absolute perfect time. I want to leave our listeners
- 39:31with one final thought from the source.
- 39:33It was about the ultimate vibe of this trip, what it really
- 39:36feels like. Yeah, that was a great line.
- 39:39The ultimate vibe isn't that sunny, easy, picture perfect
- 39:43paddle. That's not the core memory
- 39:45you're going to take away. The real core memory is waking
- 39:48up on a slab of granite. The fog is so thick you can't
- 39:51see the water, but you can hear it lapping just a few feet away.
- 39:55You're holding a mug of hot coffee and you feel very, very
- 39:59small. You feel like a guest in a wild,
- 40:01powerful world. And that is a feeling that is
- 40:03getting harder and harder and harder to find.
- 40:05Well, there you have it, the definitive guide to the Acadia
- 40:08Extension. Whether you're ready to pack
- 40:10your dry suit and your Wag bags, or you've decided to stick to
- 40:13the popovers and the comfort of the land, now you know.
- 40:16See you out on the water. Or maybe in the parking lot.
- 40:19Thanks for listening.