Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: GB Energy questions, Liebreich laments, and 'bespoke' permits
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week, GB Energy answers its
- 0:15biggest question to date. Michael Lebrake joins us and we
- 0:21discuss Aberdeen University and the opportunities of tiebacks in
- 0:26the North Sea. I'm Aberdeen features leader
- 0:28Ryan Duff, and joining me this week is our tenacious Newshound
- 0:32reporter, Matthew Perry. How are you doing today, Matt?
- 0:35I'm doing well. It's been a while since I've
- 0:37been on the podcast, I feel, so it's good to be back.
- 0:39It's always nice to have you back.
- 0:41Welcome back. And there you might have heard
- 0:44the person that keeps Matt and I in check, the person that makes
- 0:47sure that we do what we need to do as news editor.
- 0:50Erica Askel. And how are you today?
- 0:53Well, I'd just like to say that it's a very easy and an
- 0:57enjoyable part of my job to get the people who file for Energy
- 1:02Voice to do what they do. But to keep them in check,
- 1:04that's a different thing together.
- 1:06We try to make that part of the job as difficult as possible.
- 1:09But yeah, thank you very much for joining us today.
- 1:12And Erica, well, we're going to stick with you for this opening
- 1:16section because you've been hearing from GB Energy CEO Dan
- 1:21McGrail. And there's been one question on
- 1:24everyone's lips since even the Labour manifesto when it said
- 1:28that they were going to start a state owned energy company.
- 1:30And that's what the hell is GB Energy And he was addressing
- 1:36that kind of right. Yeah.
- 1:38Well, see, I'll just admit to it right now.
- 1:41I was at a party, well, it was a party for an awards event, the
- 1:47Scottish Green Energy Supply Chain Awards, which took place
- 1:51at the P&J live in Aberdeen. And that's a scheme, you know,
- 1:55that Scottish Renewables has launched because they basically
- 2:01realized that they need to have the supply chain awards in
- 2:05Aberdeen because, hey, guess what?
- 2:07Guess where the supply chain is? It's up in the northeast of
- 2:10Scotland on the shores of the North Sea.
- 2:13And, you know, that's going to be important for delivering, you
- 2:16know, our green energy stuff. So as a result, Dan Mcgray was
- 2:21there. He was giving a little speech.
- 2:24And you know what, it was such a useful, interesting speech.
- 2:28And, you know, it was kind of funny because basically he said
- 2:31the question he gets asked very often is what is GB energy?
- 2:35So it was interesting he gave a stab at it.
- 2:39So, you know, he basically was talking about his first approach
- 2:45to GB energy because of course, everyone remembers it was a
- 2:50Labour manifesto proposal when, you know, they were first
- 2:53initially trying to get elected. They got elected.
- 2:57And of course, Dooley, you know, kind of brought this thing in.
- 3:00Then of course comes to GB Energy.
- 3:04He was made its permanent chief executive after running it for
- 3:09six months on an interim basis. He came over from Renewables UK,
- 3:13but of course his background is from Siemens UK, where he was
- 3:19closely working with GB Energy's chairman Jurgen Meyer.
- 3:23So it's a bit of a Siemens takeover this GB Energy, but
- 3:26that wasn't the reason. So he basically said as his role
- 3:30as an energy professional, he liked the idea of GB Energy as a
- 3:37publicly owned activist investor that will catalyze parts of the
- 3:43market that aren't moving at the pace we want them to.
- 3:47So and then, you know, he said, you know, it's been 6 months and
- 3:51they've had conversations with developers of over 50 gigawatts
- 3:56of projects that have been in touch.
- 3:59He said more than half of those were in Scotland and that
- 4:02they've got still these dozens of potential energy production
- 4:06schemes on the cards. But the most important thing is
- 4:11we will get to find out what the priorities are for GB Energy
- 4:17Investment in October. So that's when we are going to
- 4:23be hearing from, oh, I know, like we wanted a big deep dive
- 4:26into it at the award ceremony in PNG Live, but we didn't actually
- 4:30quite get to see it, but we just had these lovely hints.
- 4:33But in October we'll get this strategic review.
- 4:36So this will be in addition to what we've seen already coming
- 4:42out. So we know that they've invested
- 4:44200 million in rooftop solar schemes in England and Wales and
- 4:48that's been great. That's low hanging fruit.
- 4:51You know, you put solar on these build things, you save shed
- 4:54loads of money and heating hospitals and libraries and
- 4:57schools and stuff like that. So that makes a lot of sense.
- 5:00Of course, they're now also tied into, you know, the big UK
- 5:04project now to shift everything towards nuclear because of
- 5:08course GB Energy now also takes in GB Energy nuclear.
- 5:13They are also going to be focusing on whether or not they
- 5:17are going to be doing an investment in Green Volt.
- 5:20So I don't know if Matt wants to weigh in on anything like that,
- 5:23you know, coming up. But you know what he also said,
- 5:26and this is interesting, GB Energy is a publicly funded
- 5:31investor. They need to make a return, but
- 5:35that isn't the only thing. Financial return isn't their
- 5:38only thing. They also want to kind of
- 5:41deliver benefits, economic benefits.
- 5:44So, hey, you know, maybe this is a good thing, right?
- 5:46Yeah. I thought that was a really
- 5:47interesting thing because obviously up until now we've
- 5:50kind of been referring to GB Energy as a state owned energy
- 5:54company. And we had this conversation
- 5:56around the wording of that yesterday, Erica, because in
- 5:59your copy you referred to as the body throughout, which makes a
- 6:04lot more sense in light of this kind of we, we could make money,
- 6:08we'd be quite happy to make money, but it's not our top
- 6:11priority. We're obviously if you're a
- 6:13business, your top priority is returning profit, right.
- 6:15So I thought that was quite interesting.
- 6:18Well, it should be. And you know what, honestly, I
- 6:21kind of think like, maybe, you know, we should be kind of also
- 6:24having a profit imperative because, you know, Jurgen Meyer
- 6:27has previously said he won't sit to be a little bit like Orsted.
- 6:31And you know what shit hits the fan of Orsted doesn't make
- 6:33money. We've already seen actually some
- 6:35of the problems that Orsted is having when they don't make
- 6:37money, right? You know, sucks.
- 6:40He wanted to make money anyway. Sorry, Matt, you were going to
- 6:42say, Oh, I. Was just going to say because it
- 6:44ties into, you know, is this starting to feel more like, like
- 6:47an, an agency in the, in the realm of Scottish Enterprise
- 6:50Oregon, something like that with a focus on the energy sector
- 6:52because you're seeing these supply chain funds handing out
- 6:57300,000,000 lbs and a further £700 million.
- 7:00It's, it's coming forward as well in the form of grants.
- 7:03As far as I'm aware, most energy companies in the private sphere
- 7:06don't hand out grants. They hand out contracts.
- 7:09They hand out, you know, things like that, whereas GB Energy is
- 7:13handing out grants. We'll kind of get to see the
- 7:15detail on whether they're expecting some kind of return
- 7:18for those grants. I mean, you know, reading
- 7:20through your your story, Erica, Dan McGrail said that GB Energy
- 7:24will be joining as an equity partner in some.
- 7:26That's kind of more what we we think of when we think of what a
- 7:29company would do. But they do seem to be
- 7:31straddling that line of, of both at the moment of kind of in some
- 7:36ways they're acting like an enterprise agency and in other
- 7:38ways, they're kind of dipping their toes into acting like a
- 7:41company. And we're kind of, I guess we'll
- 7:43wait and see for this strategic review in, in October to see
- 7:47which way they're, they're leaning more.
- 7:48But you know, it's it is interesting.
- 7:51Nail on head, nail on head. You know, honestly, I kind of
- 7:55wonder though, if when GB Energy kind of first launched with the
- 7:59fanfare, you know, there was a big event down in London where
- 8:03the government was kind of hailing all the investment that
- 8:05it was going to be coming into the UK as a result of their
- 8:09focus on, you know, renewable energy.
- 8:12And then of course, they launched GB Energy, but then
- 8:14they also relaunched the National Wealth Fund.
- 8:17And I wonder if they're the ones holding the purse strings.
- 8:19And as you say, GB Energy is just going to be, you know,
- 8:23here's a here's a few bongs, you know, towards here.
- 8:25He was saying that it is going to be working with National
- 8:28Wealth Fund and Crown Estate, Scotland Crown Estate.
- 8:31Now those are big investors with a lot of cash deployment.
- 8:35And in December, apparently he promised us this, you know, when
- 8:39he was in Aberdeen did Dan McHale, he said, uh, that fund,
- 8:44the 300 million supply chain fund is opening up in December.
- 8:48But yeah, you know, like if it 300 million very welcome.
- 8:52Love it it. Does seem to be a bit of a bit
- 8:55of overlap as well within the National Wealth fund.
- 8:57As you say, because they've been investing they've they've have
- 8:59been opening up the purse strings a bit in the last few
- 9:01weeks. They've invested in the the Peak
- 9:03cluster carbon capture project they've invested in.
- 9:06Just this week, the National Wealth Fund has put in
- 9:08200,000,000 lbs as part of a £500 million consortium to
- 9:12invest in the battery storage assets across the UK, alongside
- 9:15a Australian pension funded and infrastructure manager.
- 9:19They've done a big investment into grid expansion using a
- 9:22consortium of like US and other international banks, right?
- 9:27It's that sort of thing that maybe galvanizes it.
- 9:29Yeah, there is some money being spent there.
- 9:31Just it's curious to me as to why, you know, again, kind of
- 9:35what is the point of GB Energy if the National Wealth Fund is
- 9:38doing these big £500 million equity investments?
- 9:40Why is GB Energy not kind of thing?
- 9:43You know, I would have thought given that there's been so much,
- 9:46I guess confusion or, or a real kind of call from the industry
- 9:50to kind of explain what GB Energy is doing, that you'd have
- 9:53GB Energy making these big equity investments rather than
- 9:56the national wealth fund. But yeah, it it, it kind of.
- 10:00I guess we'll wait and see for October for a bit of a clearer
- 10:03picture, hopefully. Yeah, a clearer picture.
- 10:05You know what, it's always like this timing, right?
- 10:07So, you know, October is going to be clear of SPE Offshore
- 10:12Europe. So don't expect any, you know,
- 10:14kind of big, you know, strategic announcements maybe for when the
- 10:18entire offshore energy industry is in Aberdeen.
- 10:23I want her 'cause you know what Dan Mcgrill didn't say is like,
- 10:26where's the office? So we're still, maybe we're
- 10:29still waiting for that one. That would be a big review.
- 10:31Maybe that's the big announcement.
- 10:33We're going to move into a broom covered in the Nsda's offices.
- 10:36It might be the the announcement, I'm sure Europe,
- 10:39but well, interestingly, you know, the, the budget is in
- 10:42October as well. So who knows, we might be
- 10:44waiting for further announcements from government
- 10:46around GP energy, who knows, But that's just speculation.
- 10:49And I think that wraps up this segment quite nicely.
- 10:52But stick around because after this, our editor Mark Selby has
- 10:56been speaking to Michael Lebrick.
- 11:36Long term listeners of Energy Voice Out Loud may have heard
- 11:39from our editor Mark Selby. I'm sure he's been on a couple
- 11:42of episodes in the past, but you've probably not heard of
- 11:45Michael Lee Brakes voice on this program.
- 11:48Now for those of you who don't know, he was the founder of
- 11:51Bloomberg New Energy Finance and he is still a senior
- 11:55contributor. He is a clean energy expert and
- 11:58he has had a lot of interesting things to say lately.
- 12:02So Mark sat down and had a yap with them.
- 12:04So why don't we hear what he had to say?
- 12:06Welcoming Michael Lee Brake, renowned energy analyst and
- 12:12podcaster of Cleaning Up and welcome to the interview.
- 12:17Lovely to have you and lovely to meet you.
- 12:19Mark, it's a great pleasure to be here.
- 12:21Thank you for inviting me. I think the main thing that
- 12:24caught my attention over the last few weeks off the back of
- 12:27actually the FT Hydrogen conference where I think you
- 12:31gave a bombastic performance to the crowd.
- 12:34I understand a fairly incendiary commentary on, on the, on the
- 12:40outlook for for hydrogen. And I was really interested just
- 12:43to kind of probe that a bit deeper and, and understand like
- 12:46your perspective on hydrogen. I think you you were at one
- 12:49point something of a hydrogen advocate, or were or were you
- 12:52not? We've all, we've all been there.
- 12:55We've all had our sort of love affair with green hydrogen.
- 12:59Mine probably lasted, I'm gonna say a month or two back in 2003
- 13:04where funnily enough, I nearly joined a start up with a very
- 13:08innovative fuel cell, hydrogen fuel cell technology.
- 13:12But you know, really I, I don't, I suppose, you know, I get
- 13:15accused of hating hydrogen and now you're suggesting that I
- 13:19love hydrogen. But actually it's, it's neither,
- 13:22it's neither, you know, it's, it's, it's, I'm interested in
- 13:25tools that do jobs. And of course, then when you
- 13:28start to probe in, then you find that green hydrogen is just not
- 13:32a very good tool. It's just a very, very poor and
- 13:35expensive fuel. So I have neither love nor hate.
- 13:38I just think, well, you know, the economics are what the
- 13:41economics are and, and, but you've got to go with that.
- 13:44Yeah, this goes back a bit for me.
- 13:46It goes back a bit further since I started in the role of energy
- 13:51voice editor around a year and a half ago, which is when I really
- 13:54started getting my head into the hydrogen space and I went to the
- 13:59Rotterdam World Hydrogen Conference.
- 14:02I'm not sure if you were out that one yourself.
- 14:04And it was just really striking, certainly on the first day to
- 14:08hit to sense the level of, well, it was considerably lower energy
- 14:14than I was expecting and a very so subdued vibe generally.
- 14:19I mean, a lot of people, they're trying to do deals, get business
- 14:22done, network and so on. But from an actual conferencing
- 14:25perspective, I felt I was really surprised just to hear how
- 14:28negative the outlook was. Yes, I was invited to give a
- 14:33keynote by the chap who created the World Hydrogen Congress,
- 14:38Nadeem Chaudji, who's a mate of mine going back, you know,
- 14:41decades of doing this sort of, you know, working in clean
- 14:44energy. And and he gave me this slot.
- 14:47I think it was kind of create a bit of a buzz and a bit of
- 14:49controversy. And, you know, knowing that I
- 14:52was going to, I don't want to call it say call bullshit, but I
- 14:56was going to inject real data-driven, you know, sort of
- 15:01analysis about all these different use cases.
- 15:04And it was around the time that I was developing the hydrogen
- 15:08ladder, I think one or two versions to maybe 3, maybe 3
- 15:11versions had already come out. And, you know, I stood up and I
- 15:15said, look, you know, we need a reset here.
- 15:17We need to rethink because it's just not hydrogen is just not
- 15:21the best way of doing a whole bunch of things.
- 15:25And I went through and explained why.
- 15:27And it's just a very bad fuel and it's very difficult to move
- 15:30around and it's difficult to store and it's difficult to
- 15:33distribute and so on. And I think that was possibly
- 15:38the first time that somebody had done that in that sort of
- 15:40environment. And subsequently Eric Raku, who
- 15:44actually sort of popped up at the end and gave me a copy of
- 15:46his book and thanked me. Subsequently, he told me that
- 15:50that my presentation was like being punched in the nose
- 15:53because there had been such a kind of, you know, go go spirit
- 15:58until then. And that was the first time that
- 16:01that got challenged. And I had people come up to me
- 16:03afterwards with tears in their eyes, absolutely tears.
- 16:06And, and some of them had tears of anger.
- 16:08You know, the the lobbyists, the marketing people, the policy
- 16:11people, you know, they were just angry that somebody would dare
- 16:15to challenge the wonderful vision of the hydrogen economy.
- 16:19And then some other people who came up to me with tears of
- 16:22gratitude in their eyes. And those were the engineers
- 16:25saying, I've been trying to tell my boss this and nobody listens.
- 16:30And so I think that that was a bit of a cusp point.
- 16:33And so I, I was invited once more, I think to that 2024, I
- 16:38was invited, but I was sort of poked away in a side room.
- 16:41I wasn't allowed to take the mainstage.
- 16:43And then this year I was simply not invited.
- 16:46I'm interested to hear your impression.
- 16:47I think you described it somewhere else as people feeling
- 16:50a little lost. Yeah, exactly.
- 16:52So I mean, that was that was literally word for word what I
- 16:56heard at one of those keynote speeches, that people within the
- 16:59industry are feeling a bit lost industry, some industry critics,
- 17:03possibly you, you, you may have been among them that have
- 17:06described the industry as dead. You know, it's kind of drifting
- 17:08along. People are trying to keep it
- 17:10going. Look, I've described it as
- 17:12undergoing A souffle moment, you know, because when you have a, a
- 17:16bubble pops, you know, just something happens.
- 17:19There's a Minsky moment and everybody goes, what were we
- 17:21thinking? And there's a pop.
- 17:23That's not what's happening within the industry.
- 17:27What's happening is the, the souffle is deflating.
- 17:31So it's a sort of slow exhalation, a slow loss of, of,
- 17:35of the air in the industry. And the reason it's slow is that
- 17:38there's an enormous amount of inertia.
- 17:41There's still these sort of 60 hydrogen strategies.
- 17:44There's an extraordinary number of politicians.
- 17:46There are whole departments within civil services around the
- 17:49world that do nothing but make up, you know, regulations and,
- 17:54and, and, you know, talk to the industry and rewrite their
- 17:56strategies and hone and tinker. But fundamentally the projects
- 18:01are not going ahead for really, really basic economic reasons,
- 18:04which is exactly what I predicted and, and talked about
- 18:07back then. So it's, you know, it, it must
- 18:11feel, I mean, it must, I hate to say it, but it must feel pretty
- 18:14awful for a lot of the people in the industry because they just
- 18:18see this kind of, you know, the souffle deflating and, and
- 18:24probably are not quite sure what to do about it.
- 18:27You know, should they jump ship, should they pretend it's all OK
- 18:31and so on. I think that's probably what's
- 18:32happening with that lost feeling.
- 18:35Yeah. So I guess rather than that, as
- 18:38you say, rather than the bubble bursting, it's more of a souffle
- 18:41sinking and a subsiding feeling, sinking feeling even.
- 18:45And and that that really did come across at that conference.
- 18:48And it was just so interesting to hear that as such a major
- 18:51global conference environment like that.
- 18:53The movie is a little bit better the following day when there
- 18:55were a huge amount of oysters, free oysters and beer going
- 18:58around. But yeah, like.
- 19:01Oysters and beer will always help, but I think can I, can I
- 19:04suggest that, you know, that there's a sort of challenge
- 19:07within that lost feeling and that kind of, you know, groping
- 19:10around for, you know, where are we as an industry?
- 19:13And I've, I've been through a lot of bubbles, right?
- 19:15I mean, the moment I started work, that was just before, I
- 19:18think it was Black Monday when the stock market crashed in the
- 19:211980s. And I've then seenthe.com boom
- 19:24bust and I've seen the emerging markets boom bust and I've seen
- 19:27a couple of clean tech boom busts and I've seen the great
- 19:30financial crisis. And but the the challenge, I
- 19:34think, for the hydrogen industry is to understand whether this is
- 19:39just a Gartner cycle. You know, you get the hype
- 19:41cycle, then you get the kind of you know, you get the the hype
- 19:44disappears. And then there's the hard yards
- 19:46of actually having to build an industry, but it's a real
- 19:49industry. And you know, outofthe.com bust.
- 19:52We got Amazon, we got Facebook, then we got Snapchat, then we
- 19:55got this, that and the other, you know, the real businesses
- 19:58that were built. And the question for the
- 20:00hydrogen industry is? Are there going to be real
- 20:03industries built, real businesses built?
- 20:06And I'm afraid that's where I'm kind of on the on the negative
- 20:11side because the economics are just so not just challenging the
- 20:17physics drives the economics and the economics are terrible.
- 20:21So you know, you can come back as when you've been when you're
- 20:24in that through of Gartner lack of hype, you can say ah, but you
- 20:28know, keep the faith. And in fact, that's what a lot
- 20:31of people in hydrogen are saying.
- 20:33They say things like, but we need green hydrogen and green
- 20:37hydrogen will inevitably be part of the a lot of key parts of the
- 20:41solution. And green hydrogen, the IEA says
- 20:44that it's going to be 14% of energy.
- 20:46And they're all sort of, you know, now starting to kind of
- 20:50postulate that there's a future that there is a pot of gold at
- 20:54the end of the rainbow of hydrogen colours for them.
- 20:58Well, I don't think there is. And I think that's the message
- 21:01just recently at the the most recent FT live hydrogen Summit.
- 21:06I was saying, look, I mean, well, I said the one a year ago,
- 21:11you really need a reset. And at the one this year I said,
- 21:14look back of envelope calculations.
- 21:17Why are you not doing them? Why are you not doing these
- 21:20calculations that show that it there's no pot of gold at the
- 21:24end of this rainbow, you cannot get the economics to work in
- 21:27almost all of the use cases that you're talking about.
- 21:30From Lee Brake to Underhill, Next up we're going to be
- 21:32speaking about near field opportunities in the North Sea.
- 22:33So for this final section on Energy Voice Out loud this week
- 22:37I'll be having a wee yap about Aberdeen University's John
- 22:41Underhill. Now he's a well Kent face in
- 22:44this part of the world and he had some interesting things to
- 22:47say after an independent review that he conducted regarding the
- 22:52future of licensing in the North Sea.
- 22:55Now you may be you may be aware that licensing is in a bit of a
- 23:01stalemate at the moment in the North Sea.
- 23:04The UK government is waiting to reveal the results of a
- 23:08consultation that it had on how it's going to dish out licenses
- 23:12for oil operators and the country's waters.
- 23:15Now because of that, the regulator, the NSTA, can't hand
- 23:19out any licenses at the moment. It can't conduct a licensing
- 23:22round and it can't hand any licenses out with of rounds.
- 23:26So with all this in mind, John Underhill writes essentially
- 23:32suggesting that the UK government should incentivize
- 23:37what he described as bespoke oil and gas permits.
- 23:42And this was mainly relating to projects that are nearby
- 23:45existing pipelines or, you know, within tie back distance to
- 23:50existing fields. And that's particularly
- 23:54interesting because if you compare that data to to the
- 23:59report released by Offshore Energies UK and Westwood last
- 24:04just a couple of months ago, we saw that essentially 7.3 billion
- 24:10barrels of the forecast, 7.5 billion available in UK waters
- 24:16are within tie back distance to existing fields to operate in
- 24:21infrastructure. So I guess on that's our broad
- 24:25stroke, broad stroke thinking, you could argue that Underhill
- 24:29is arguing in favour of carte blanche just to approve pretty
- 24:34much anything that's nearby and it should be fine.
- 24:36And you can see why he's suggesting this.
- 24:39Now, obviously there's there's A to and throw kind of argument
- 24:42here, but you can see we can see what he's suggesting.
- 24:46It's the same arguments we've heard industry show about for
- 24:49some time now. Energy security, you know, we,
- 24:53if we're producing here, then we're sort of shielded from
- 24:55international markets. Now the the interesting thing
- 24:59for me in this, this debate is usually the counterpoint that
- 25:03while oil and gas is sold on international markets, there's
- 25:05no guarantee that gas operated in this part.
- 25:08You know, them produced in this part of the world is going to UK
- 25:11homes, it might go to to Europe or wherever else.
- 25:15You know, it's, it's not necessarily coming out here.
- 25:18So it, it, it's an interesting argument.
- 25:21Energy security. However, the one that I think's
- 25:24possibly more interesting is the energy transition and carbon
- 25:29reduction side of things, which kind of more focuses on, well,
- 25:34we operate oil and gas very cleanly.
- 25:36We know from official NSTA documents that it's the the
- 25:41second cleanest way to get gas is to operate it in the UK.
- 25:45The cleanest is to pipe it in from Norway, not ship it
- 25:48pipelines in from Norway is the cleanest.
- 25:51But being able to sort of cover at least some of our demand and
- 25:55produce it in a cleaner way than imports, well that that might
- 25:59suggest, you know, a positive argument for oil and gas.
- 26:03Don't forget there's another very important aspect to the
- 26:06potential for going for all the tie backs and and issuing new
- 26:11licenses for those is maximizing tax revenues.
- 26:15Yes. And jobs and jobs, yes, OK.
- 26:18But like you know, I mean we need more jobs, we need to
- 26:20retain those jobs, I guess, but tax revenues and.
- 26:23That's something that's quite interesting.
- 26:24The jobs thing in particular is interesting because under Hill's
- 26:30kind of counterpart at Robert Gordon University, Paul de Lou,
- 26:33I like to think of them as two sides of the the same coin.
- 26:36You know, both being energy experts at the the 2 Aberdeen
- 26:39universities. They'd have great chats, I'm
- 26:42sure. Yeah, I'd.
- 26:43Love to hear how they reacted to me describing them that way.
- 26:46Paul de Lou earlier in the year spoke about how essentially one
- 26:51in six jobs in Aberdeen specifically are tied to the
- 26:55energy sector and energy production.
- 26:57And he pointed out that if you look at the INTOG and Scotland
- 27:03licenses and the, the job creation, you know, that's
- 27:07forecast in the energy transition in the North Sea.
- 27:11Well, the jobs in this region aren't coming till next decade
- 27:15or so, you know, 20-30 and beyond, which means if, if
- 27:19investment in oil and gas tumbles, then jobs are lost.
- 27:23And then you've got like a, you know, 5 to 10 year stopgap of
- 27:28mass unemployment and in the region.
- 27:31And I guess this speaks to that balancing act that we often
- 27:35discuss within the energy transition.
- 27:37So essentially that was a, you know, that's that's his big
- 27:41talking point. He also touched on zero routine
- 27:44flaring did under hell, but that was something that the NST is
- 27:48already looking to enforce now. You know, I think in the past
- 27:50we've kind of said that any regulator that the industry's
- 27:54that chummy with does it enforce strongly enough?
- 27:57Well, you know, that's that's up to individuals to decide, but.
- 28:00They're getting more teeth. They're getting more teeth.
- 28:02I'm, I'm, I'm happy with the progress that the NST is making
- 28:05towards kicking the ass of the North Sea.
- 28:08Matt, you wanted to come in here.
- 28:09Well. I just, I think coming back to,
- 28:11I guess the, the language being used, I think it's quite
- 28:13interesting, you know, with this terminology of bespoke permits
- 28:16for these strategic resources in, in near field.
- 28:19And I think it, it is interesting that it does seem to
- 28:21tie into a way a lot of the Labour politicians, particularly
- 28:24Michael Shanks has been speaking about their, their licensing
- 28:27policy. You know, earlier this year he
- 28:30was appearing before a committee at Westminster and like in a lot
- 28:33of other of his public comments, they were very clear or kind of
- 28:38at pains to point out that their manifesto commitment was for no
- 28:41new licenses for new fields and instead focus on managing
- 28:45existing fields. And that's the language they've
- 28:46really been using for the past sort of, you know, six months in
- 28:50particular quite, quite clearly and, you know.
- 28:53Do you think this gives them a little weasel way in then?
- 28:55Because it's not really I. Think that's what they've been
- 28:57trying to to angle for is to give them a bit of a bit of
- 29:01leeway, a bit of room, a bit of, you know, if they can shift the
- 29:04conversation from wholesale exploration licensing to bespoke
- 29:08strategic permits. I think that ties into because
- 29:12as much as Shanks did say during that committee hearing that he
- 29:14didn't see that there was any material difference between
- 29:16North Sea oil and gas and imports, which certainly riled
- 29:19up a lot of people in the industry.
- 29:22He didn't say that there may be scope for fringe cases.
- 29:25I believe his wording was the production from near field work
- 29:28that for all intents and purposes you would perhaps
- 29:30consider was already related to a field that's already
- 29:33extracting. So they're trying to be quite
- 29:36specific in their language, but that does seem that that's
- 29:40potentially the direction that we're heading is kind of more of
- 29:43this focus on tie backs and, and I guess gas rather than oil,
- 29:47because we know that most of the oil produced in North Sea is, is
- 29:49exported to to refineries overseas anyway.
- 29:52So I think that will kind of be what we see coming from this
- 29:56consultation. And we're already seeing
- 29:58companies, you know, Parenco just this, this week has
- 30:00launched permits with, with operand to do some survey work
- 30:04near the Platypus field, which I, you know, will wholesalerly
- 30:07admit. The only reason I looked into
- 30:09this was because it was called Platypus.
- 30:11Who doesn't love a platypus? Yeah.
- 30:13And it's an interesting one. That's one that Dhana Petroleum
- 30:16and Parkmead Group and Cal Energy Resources, I think all
- 30:19had a various stakes in, back in.
- 30:22But they relinquished the license in 2021 amidst the COVID
- 30:25pandemic and obviously all the uncertainty that was going on in
- 30:28the oil and gas sector. Then Perenko's that was meant to
- 30:33originally plan was to tie that back to Perenko's Cleaton
- 30:36platform. They've picked that license up
- 30:38in the 33rd licensing round. It looks like Perenko's going to
- 30:41potentially go and do it themselves now.
- 30:43So this is I guess the sort of projects that ties into that
- 30:46Goldilocks zone that that Paul Delue often speaks about where
- 30:50if we can keep enough investment in these sort of smaller tie
- 30:53back projects, potentially that will tide industry over until
- 30:57the the floating wind and and the other projects are ready to
- 31:00kind of get on the March. I do think it's quite
- 31:03interesting, but I feel like if we're speaking about tie backs,
- 31:05we probably also need to. And I'm realizing we're nearly
- 31:08the end of the show, so it's probably a bad time to bring up
- 31:10such a big topic. I mean, let's face it, based on
- 31:14the remaining reserves in the North Sea, it is the the future
- 31:17of fields. If we're going to have more
- 31:18production and new, new projects come online, they will be tie
- 31:22backs. But the Griffin FPSO
- 31:26decommissioning thing that you know, came out just a couple of
- 31:28weeks ago, well that that has its own ramifications, right?
- 31:32It, it was operating as a production hump to tie back
- 31:35fields around it. And, you know, you're looking at
- 31:38Noble Oil saying, well, we're, we're now stranded and we can't,
- 31:42you know, we think that there's still recoverable reserve
- 31:45reserves here. And the NSDA isn't, you know,
- 31:47doing its job of maximizing economic recovery and so on and
- 31:50so forth. With that, it sort of throws up
- 31:53whole new questions about the the future of tiebacks and hub
- 31:56operations in the North Sea. Oh, Erica wants to dive in
- 32:00before we wrap up. I think, you know, just to wrap
- 32:02this up, I want to give my thanks to Sheena McGinnis at
- 32:06RSM, who, you know, kind of gets in touch with us and says, to
- 32:11paraphrase, Rachel Reeves is hooped.
- 32:14She needs the North Sea and the taxpayer needs the North Sea
- 32:19because, you know, the current policy towards the North Sea is
- 32:23squeezing the golden goose and killing the golden goose.
- 32:27And actually what we need is to kind of revive the golden goose
- 32:31because what we're seeing is tax receipts falling bad for the
- 32:33country, bad for anyone who wants to go to a hospital or
- 32:36drive on a nice Rd. I mean, this is, this is
- 32:39important. So I think, I think Professor
- 32:41Underhill from Everdeen University, Matt hit it spot on
- 32:44the nose. He's given them license, you
- 32:47know, maybe to think about something, or at least, you
- 32:50know, I'm a hopeful person. That's what I hope.
- 32:53There we are. That's that's a hell of a way to
- 32:55end an episode where normally when I'm cheering, I end on doom
- 32:59and gloom, but Erica ends on optimism and hope, which I'm I'm
- 33:04glad to hear. Well, that does it for this
- 33:06episode. But if you'd like to hear more
- 33:08from us, well, next week we will be at Offshore Europe.
- 33:13Well, if you need to find out a little bit more about that, you
- 33:15might as well listen to last week's episode and Offshore
- 33:17Europe Takeover when we spoke to read exhibitions and David
- 33:22Whitehouse about the event. But I think all that's left to
- 33:25be to say is come see us on our stand.
- 33:28You won't be able to miss us. And we've got games and stuff.
- 33:31So, I mean, what else could you possibly want?
- 33:34See you there.