Latest / Newcomer Pod / A Very Stable “Coin” GENIUS
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everybody, it's your newcomer for the week.
- 0:02It's Tom Doughton here, joined by Eric newcomer Madeline
- 0:06Renberger. We got Eric pretending to be at
- 0:09his home. He's got a fake background, but
- 0:12I know the real truth, which is that he's in San Francisco.
- 0:15I love how Tom has this like great deep voice but then his
- 0:18intro voice is like two octaves up.
- 0:22Yeah, that's called the energy. I I I bring that high pitched
- 0:26energy that people like, none of that monotonous low tone stuff.
- 0:31How? Brings the shrill energy we need
- 0:33more of on this podcast. You can't describe men's voice
- 0:35as shrill. It's deeply.
- 0:36It's. It's just not allowed.
- 0:39There's a whole TV show about it.
- 0:41I think we got a lot to get through in this episode here.
- 0:44But I, I have to start off for those of you not watching on
- 0:46video, Eric is joining us, as I mentioned earlier, pretending to
- 0:50be at his home, Although I know the truth, which is that he's in
- 0:52Union Square at a hotel with cement floors, but he's got a
- 0:56flat brim hat on. He's a flat brim guy and he
- 0:59recently just came from an exclusive conference that gave
- 1:02him this flatburn hat that marks the beginning of conference
- 1:06season and actually good dimension conferences because we
- 1:08have the newcomer Breaking the Bank conference coming up next
- 1:12week. And before we even get into your
- 1:14private excursion conference, Eric, can you just give us some
- 1:17details on on breaking the bank? Why should we?
- 1:20Why should we get people excited about it?
- 1:22Breaking mega, we're going to have the CEO of Gusto Plaid,
- 1:26we're going to have the founder of Bridge, which you know, is
- 1:30bringing stable coins to Stripe. The topic of the day.
- 1:33We're very fortunate that Chime filed to go public this week and
- 1:37we had a tech IPO and E Toro. So I think people will have some
- 1:43enthusiasm. So yeah, we're going to have
- 1:45some most of the top private fintech companies in the same
- 1:48room in San Francisco on Tuesday.
- 1:51Yeah, I believe the slogan of the summit is Fintech is back
- 1:54baby. So.
- 1:56Right, which we will get to later in the episode as you just
- 1:58recently Madeline wrote a whole article about the backness of
- 2:01fintech. But Eric, I got to hear about
- 2:04this hat. I got to hear about your
- 2:06conference. So the the conference I was in
- 2:08Park City, UT at like very bougie retreat.
- 2:12The event was under Chatham House rules.
- 2:15So I am somewhat restricted in what I can say fundamentally,
- 2:18I'm allowed to talk about the ideas, but not exactly who was
- 2:23there. The event was, it's the first
- 2:25year blue sky put on by the venture capital firm Dimension
- 2:30and the biotech company Recursion.
- 2:34And you know, it was attended by sort of a who's who of biotech,
- 2:38pharma and tech people. Honestly, it was sort of a new
- 2:41crowd for me. I knew some of them, but you
- 2:45know, I'm not deep in like the biotech world at all.
- 2:48And then I I moderated 2 panels that were super interesting and
- 2:54shot some clay pigeons and you know.
- 2:58You shot clay pigeons? Yeah.
- 3:00It was actually pretty good. My team in our our little bit 1.
- 3:03So yeah, clay pigeons. Congrats.
- 3:06Yeah, that's that's work. You know, I was hard to hard at
- 3:08work networking while shooting clay pigeons.
- 3:11You're allowed to describe that. Chatham Health Rules allows you
- 3:14to describe your pigeon victories, but in terms of
- 3:17specific attendees in your group.
- 3:19No, no, no, OK, I can talk about it.
- 3:21So the big idea is, I think honestly one thing that I
- 3:23thought was super interesting to come out of it is that, you
- 3:27know, people in biotech are genuinely concerned about Trump
- 3:31cutting all this funding to universities because all that
- 3:34research funding is, is the beginning of, you know, bio and
- 3:38pharma companies. It's all sort of nice research
- 3:42that then, you know, the corporate world uses to come up
- 3:46with their ideas. So there was, there was genuine
- 3:48concern. Well, yeah.
- 3:50And, and so what's, what's their response to that, though?
- 3:52Are they just hoping that, like, wealthy philanthropist donors
- 3:54are going to fill in those gaps and like they can keep the money
- 3:57trained for biotech startups rolling?
- 3:59Or like what's? Well, I think there, you know,
- 4:01there's one attitude, which is just like we play the, you know,
- 4:04the game on the field and sort of they'll adjust.
- 4:06I think there's some belief that schools like Harvard, despite
- 4:11their stance, will ultimately sort of cut a deal and this
- 4:15situation won't go on forever. But I think people were pretty
- 4:20clear that the cuts are going to be damaging and have a long term
- 4:25effect. So I don't think there's getting
- 4:27around it. But yeah, there's going to have
- 4:29to be more private research. And, you know, I guess it's a
- 4:33win for the likes of what Microsoft Research and DeepMind
- 4:38and sort of the corporate academia is, is going to be more
- 4:41important than ever. Do people discuss much?
- 4:43I mean, the the talent risk also with the policy crackdowns
- 4:46around immigration, I mean, was that a topic that came out much?
- 4:50China was a big theme. I, I continue, this wasn't set
- 4:54on stage, but I continue to be confused by the China tensions
- 4:58overall because everybody, everybody's clearly getting the
- 5:00cues that like we, we have to be very hostile to China.
- 5:05And there's this breakup. But at the same time, every
- 5:07business basically wants to work with China as much as they can.
- 5:11People don't really seem to understand the intellectual
- 5:15nature. I mean, I, I think there was a
- 5:17sentiment on stage that China is a self-sustaining economy.
- 5:20Even if we cut them off from our own economy, they are going to
- 5:23continue to develop and make progress.
- 5:25So do we really cut them off at the knees if if we block them?
- 5:30So I, I don't think people really sort of understood how
- 5:33we're supposed to block China in that way.
- 5:36And yeah, I mean, American labs depend on Chinese talent, so
- 5:40that that's going to hurt our research capacity.
- 5:42China is also making it difficult for Chinese
- 5:45researchers to stay here. You know, AI is a super
- 5:48important area to them. And so I think they literally
- 5:50call back some of their people. I wonder where like the American
- 5:53dynamism thesis fits into that though.
- 5:56Right. Like theoretically more
- 5:57homegrown talent, more companies developing biotech or
- 6:01pharmaceuticals in the US should be part of that.
- 6:03But I haven't seen any of the end recent people stepping up
- 6:06and saying the crackdown universities is like
- 6:09antithetical to the American dynamism.
- 6:12I know well they want to build new institutions.
- 6:15Right. They want to build the next
- 6:17American wave. Yeah.
- 6:19The University of Austin is not so far like a beacon of success,
- 6:23from what I can tell on the outside.
- 6:25That's the yeah, sort of Joe Lonsdale school.
- 6:28Well, just some quick other bullets.
- 6:30Biotech is obviously in a terrible downturn.
- 6:32I think in tech world, we don't see it.
- 6:34But like, if tech feels like there's been a downturn, biotech
- 6:37is like, oh man, got destroyed. So that's been brutal.
- 6:41I think people are really excited like in tech world about
- 6:44artificial intelligence. And there's certainly a lot of
- 6:47companies running, you know, AI transcription, but also drug
- 6:52discovery using generative models.
- 6:54Yeah, how is how are people feeling about AI boosted drug
- 6:57discovery right now? Because that was a pretty hot
- 6:59space that even generalist investors were getting into.
- 7:02You know, we wrote about that last summer.
- 7:03Well, it felt like every drug discovery company was AI to some
- 7:08degree. You know, it's like, oh, you're
- 7:09old generation, but we're powering up, or you're the brand
- 7:12new company and you're like, oh, we're gonna do it from the very
- 7:15beginning. So I think everybody's saying
- 7:17it. I don't think anybody can claim
- 7:18that they've fully discovered a drug.
- 7:20You know, these companies take forever.
- 7:22Drug discovery companies take forever to build.
- 7:24And so people will get very excited about companies that
- 7:27still don't have, you know, a drug that they're actually
- 7:30selling to consumers. The final bullet is obviously
- 7:34Ozempic looms large. You know, Ozempic, is that a
- 7:37metaphor for longevity drugs overall?
- 7:40You know, when you see a drug that's successful, people are
- 7:42like, oh, should we be staging out our drugs like that?
- 7:45Should we have a more, you know, whereas Ozempic, you're getting
- 7:47different doses, sized doses over time.
- 7:50And also this sense that it's a drug that sort of helps people
- 7:54in lots of ways is not necessarily targeting disease,
- 7:57which and feeds into the overall longevity conversation.
- 8:01So, you know, people are certainly watching the success
- 8:05of Ozempic and Wagova and everything and thinking how does
- 8:09that affect our companies? I like the idea that something
- 8:12like Ozempic or Wagovi like that.
- 8:14The lesson to be taken from it is like, it's the way that they
- 8:17measure out the doses and like it's the, it's, it's the
- 8:20recurring, recurring product model of it, not that it's like
- 8:24having actual tangible impact on people's health.
- 8:26No, it's, it's the weight loss as a subscription service where
- 8:29we're really. Making a difference, yeah, I
- 8:31call it the fat shot drug, by the way.
- 8:33That's my thing. But that's a classic tech
- 8:35mindset. LinkedIn, LinkedIn brain is like
- 8:38looking at something like that. What can you learn from Ozempic
- 8:40success that isn't its actual functionality, but in fact it's,
- 8:45you know, meeting out doses? In their defense, that's, you
- 8:48know, the business, the strategy part is the part of the part
- 8:51this podcast probably understands better, right?
- 8:53I'm they were also talking about, you know, types of
- 8:57treatments and stuff. And some of that honestly goes
- 9:00over my head. So I'm going to come to their
- 9:02defense a little and say there was plenty of talk of, you know,
- 9:05pathways and approaches to treatment stuff that pour me
- 9:09without an MD can't distill for you here.
- 9:11More MD's than a typical VC conference sounds.
- 9:14Oh. My God.
- 9:15Oh, tons of people. Lots of professors you know.
- 9:17Mini former but definitely well credentialed and educated Crown.
- 9:22So, so, so if, if, if biotech is in this kind of inexorable
- 9:26downturn, fintech has actually been looking really strong in
- 9:30the last year, really strong a couple of years ago.
- 9:32Really strong. Is a that's too.
- 9:34Too much. Relatively strong.
- 9:36We have, we have an event next week, but even us, we're not
- 9:39going to say really strong, but I think it's coming up from a
- 9:43lot it. Is fintech is back baby but.
- 9:46It's an aspirational marketing copy.
- 9:49What is the the journalist Madeline that digging into this
- 9:53as the journalist How back baby is fintech?
- 9:57It's mixed. I would say the backness of
- 9:59fintech is decidedly mixed. On the one hand, you have E
- 10:04Toro, the stock and crypto trading platform going public
- 10:07this week, which you know, end of IPO drought.
- 10:10In a sense, Chime filed its S 1, so two major fintech
- 10:14powerhouses, Deca corns like testing the public market.
- 10:18That's really exciting. One week out from our fintech
- 10:20conference, we didn't plan that. We promised we didn't collude,
- 10:23but we did. Talk about the influence.
- 10:25I'd love people to believe that we could plan that.
- 10:28Wait, yeah, record. Scratch.
- 10:29Scratch that, it was all according to plan.
- 10:32So things are looking up. Investors that I spoke to were
- 10:35seeing those as bull signals. That being said, interest rates
- 10:38are still pretty high. So any company that's in the
- 10:41lending space is not doing too hot right now and is not really
- 10:45predicted to come back. And we're not going to be really
- 10:47hitting that sort of, you know, 2021 boom anytime soon.
- 10:52I mean, things pretty much fell off as soon as interest rates
- 10:54ticked up in 2022 for a lot of these companies.
- 10:57And that's going to stay pretty low.
- 10:59And the excitement has really come around both two key areas
- 11:03like Chime style consumer plays and banking companies that are
- 11:07more like neo banks that provide financial services maybe in
- 11:10emerging markets or for mobile first customers or I would say
- 11:14stable coins and facilitate payments and card payments that
- 11:18can be back to your stable coin wallet.
- 11:20So that's right. Bridge deal, obviously last year
- 11:23was a big exit for the space. So we've got neo banks, you've
- 11:28got stable coins. I would add the stick AI on it.
- 11:32I mean, but obviously much more sincerely, I'm excited to have
- 11:35Rogo there who's reinventing the sort of banking analysts with
- 11:40generative AI. So you have sort of we're going
- 11:43to have, you know, they're a bunch of companies that are
- 11:44looking at old guard sectors and saying how do we rethink it now
- 11:49that we have the power of foundation models.
- 11:51Now a fourth sort of category represented by Gusto is just
- 11:55sort of the non fintech fintech, right?
- 11:58I mean it's a payroll company, but you have these sort of big
- 12:00companies that sort of do a lot of business in money paying
- 12:04people and and other things, but offer sort of a broader range of
- 12:08services that I think people are still pretty excited about.
- 12:12Investors have been telling me that this space of, you know,
- 12:14accounts receivable, something that you never think would be
- 12:17like a sexy space, is doing incredibly well.
- 12:20And there's lots of early stage fintech companies that are using
- 12:24AI agents to automate a good deal of this.
- 12:26It's work help pump out things similar to kind of the legal
- 12:29tech boom that we saw a few months ago too.
- 12:30Like just any kind of service, business can be automated and
- 12:34agentified, and people are hype about that.
- 12:36A sub category of our AI story is the take a services business,
- 12:40put AI on it and like make make an AI startup out of it.
- 12:44Yeah. I'm always intrigued in the
- 12:46fintech space of the targets that a lot of these startups
- 12:48have. You know, so like for the, you
- 12:50know, accounts receivable, it's basically a bunch of investors
- 12:53and executives who are like, it's time we took down ADPA
- 12:58company that you otherwise don't think about.
- 13:00You know, these poor guys just like in Arizona that own like
- 13:03whatever 80% of the accounts receivable market.
- 13:05I guess it's like prime for the taking.
- 13:08Like that's who like a gusto was going after, right?
- 13:10Right. Oh my God.
- 13:11Well, you know, all the startup reporters, myself included,
- 13:14wanted to ripling versus Gusto, you know, or, you know, the
- 13:18payroll versus payroll. But but yeah, ADP looms so
- 13:22large. Most companies just use this
- 13:24sort of super old fashioned tech that there's a lot of
- 13:28opportunity. There's plenty of room for these
- 13:30startups to kind of coexist right now because the incumbents
- 13:33are so large and unchanged. Over the last 40 years, there's
- 13:37been a lot of opportunity and also, you know, some companies
- 13:40are targeting doing the the leap to mobile, but for payments.
- 13:44So for mobile banking and also, you know, building stable coin
- 13:49wallets and cards. I mean, we can get into stable
- 13:51coins. Let's let's that's a whole other
- 13:53sector people are excited about. But you know, kind of doing the
- 13:55skipping to mobile connection story where people didn't have
- 13:58landlines, but they went straight to cell phone, right in
- 14:00the mobile era, like that's happening with banking too,
- 14:03because all of these, you know, digital only rails are setting
- 14:06up payment. Systems.
- 14:07Yeah, yeah, you're, we can tell you're deep in fintech.
- 14:09You're like, Oh, yeah, I'm excited about the mobile first
- 14:12banking, the stable coin thing. You know, we we talked about,
- 14:17you know, the IPOs, which I think are good for the timing of
- 14:20this event. The other thing is there's
- 14:22legislation working its way through Congress trying to
- 14:26formalize how we treat stable coins in the United States,
- 14:29right? Or Madeline, what's, what's the
- 14:31latest on that? Yes, that would be the Genius
- 14:34Act which is making its way through the Senate so.
- 14:38What does genius stand for? They're always good at coming up
- 14:40with those reverse engineered backronym names.
- 14:44What do you do? You know it.
- 14:45Guiding and establishing national innovation for US
- 14:48stable coins. That's the one I'm talking
- 14:50about. Guiding and establishing
- 14:52national innovation for US stable coins.
- 14:54So that's that's the backronym for it.
- 14:55So basically the Genius Act is currently in the Senate and it's
- 14:59basically exists to establish federal safeguards that protect
- 15:03stable coin holders, kind of like the FDIC insurance of
- 15:05stable coins. So that and the rails can get
- 15:09more standardized within our existing financial system.
- 15:11So it basically further legitimizes and integrates
- 15:14stable coins into our system. They're already legal.
- 15:17It's just, you know, making them a little bit more stable for
- 15:21stable if you will, for trading and you know, being an asset
- 15:24that people can hold and exist within the rails of our
- 15:27financial system that's regulated.
- 15:29And stable coins are the crypto for people who don't like
- 15:32crypto, right? I mean, it's like you don't
- 15:34need. To use their pitch.
- 15:35Right. It's like it's not about the
- 15:37speculation. We're not trying to get
- 15:38consumers to buy random coins. It's like move money easily cut
- 15:43out fees. For sure.
- 15:45And and it's also key distinction for staple coins is
- 15:49that they are tied to a Fiat currency.
- 15:53Most of the ones that we're hearing about with this act are
- 15:56tied to the US dollar, but they can be back to other currencies
- 15:58too. So, so that's supposed to add
- 16:00sort of a another level of stabilizing for them.
- 16:04Of course, with the tariffs and how monetary markets are doing
- 16:06right now, it's not looking as stable, but that's, you know,
- 16:12not something that the boosters are really advertising front and
- 16:15center right now. I'm.
- 16:16Probably the crypto dullard on this, this podcast, I know the
- 16:19least of three of us. Like my understanding, like you
- 16:22mentioned of the stable coins is that they're pegged to a Fiat
- 16:25currency and it provides like a level of or it's a, it's a hedge
- 16:30against the volatility of crypto.
- 16:32And we're at a time now, I mean, I guess things have stabilized a
- 16:36bit, but like the dollar has never been more in flux.
- 16:39Like the tariffs have been a disaster for the value of the US
- 16:42dollar. I mean, I guess they're happy to
- 16:44get this bill passed regardless, but like, it's not exactly like
- 16:47the strongest case that like pegging something to the US
- 16:50dollar suddenly makes crypto like a more reliable investment.
- 16:54Yeah. Like talk about timing for this
- 16:56bill. It's really, you know, coming in
- 16:59at this moment of great financial uncertainty.
- 17:01Despite the sort of fluctuation with the dollar, it does seem
- 17:05like a lot of both startups and existing mainstream financial
- 17:10institutions and banks are jumping into the staple coin
- 17:13space when it comes to issuing cards that can link to staple
- 17:16coin accounts for payments, especially overseas.
- 17:19So MasterCard made an agreement this week with Moon Pay to
- 17:23launch staple coin cards for customers.
- 17:26Obviously there's Bridge and Stripe have this service with
- 17:29Visa as their partner there, and then Ramp is also doing this as
- 17:33well, which was announced in the last couple weeks.
- 17:35So everyone's going full steam ahead on stable coins, dollar
- 17:38insecurity be damned. That's what people voted for.
- 17:41That's what that's what. This was the vote.
- 17:43The stable coin coalition was strong and mighty.
- 17:47I voted for a wild fluctuation in the dollar and also
- 17:51stablecoin act. A lot of Silicon Valley's
- 17:53support for Trump, I do think, was rooted somewhat in crypto
- 17:57support. And so the Silicon Valley crowd
- 18:00throwing their money at Trump in it, this is sort of what they
- 18:02voted for. Oh yeah, I wasn't joking.
- 18:05I was not joking. Listen, if you're excited to
- 18:07understand what's going on in fintech right now, there's one
- 18:10place you should be breaking the bank on Tuesday.
- 18:14If you go to breakingthebanksummit.com, you
- 18:17can apply for a ticket will be pretty last minute, but if
- 18:20you're a founder, we will try to get you there.
- 18:23Or you can e-mail This is the real.
- 18:25If you're listening now, I'll say we're small enough podcasts.
- 18:28I can say an e-mail address on air.
- 18:31E-mail rileyriley@newcomer.co and he's the person to beg for a
- 18:38ticket if you're going to try and sneak your way in on
- 18:41Tuesday. Well, we will be burning a bank
- 18:44in effigy at the end of breaking the Bank, Burning Man style to
- 18:47get people reminiscing about. All right.
- 18:50So one thing that we mentioned earlier in the podcast during
- 18:52Eric's take on the Chatham House Rules biotech, you know, what
- 18:56have you, was the fact that there's been a loss of a brain
- 18:59drain, would you call it, or a concern about where the talent
- 19:03within the biotech worlds is going to go in a more combative
- 19:07immigration environment? And Madeleine, you had a great
- 19:10piece the other week that talked all about the worries among
- 19:12startups and the the status of their immigrant workforce.
- 19:17What did you learn there? Yeah, I mean the crackdown that
- 19:21sort of happened around the first Trump administration on
- 19:23immigration did cause a slowdown in the startup and tech
- 19:27ecosystem around H1B visas, which a lot of tech employees
- 19:31for bigger tech companies, either the largest startups or
- 19:35public tech companies are on, or O1 and EB1 visas, which are more
- 19:39common for startup founders and early startup employees to get.
- 19:42So people, you know, like in the founding team have equity.
- 19:45That tier of early stage would probably go for an O one or an
- 19:48EB qualifier. Green card isn't.
- 19:51The core, the core problem that I took away from your story is
- 19:54just Trump is scaring the shit out of every immigrant in the
- 19:58United States. And so if you have any ambiguity
- 20:01about your immigration status, you're not going to go home to
- 20:04India for your cousin's wedding. You're going to stay here.
- 20:07You're not going to go, you know, and and you're sort of
- 20:10worried. And if you have a choice
- 20:11between. Going to work for, I don't know,
- 20:15Klarna in Europe or in the United States.
- 20:17You're going to go in Europe because it's like they seem to
- 20:20want you more. There are a lot of rules and
- 20:22there will be changes, but a lot of it is even for the people who
- 20:25are legitimately here, they don't know if you know the rules
- 20:28are going to change. If we're seeing students, you
- 20:31know, get hassled for their for op eds that they're writing and.
- 20:35It's kind of like an ugly resurfacing of that fight that
- 20:39played out at the end of last year when, you know, Sri
- 20:42Ramakrishnan was being called out by, you know, some of the
- 20:45more intense MAGA types claiming that someone who looks like him,
- 20:49AKA, you know, not white, shouldn't be the face of, you
- 20:53know, the MAGA right policy. And you have this huge fight
- 20:56between tech and you know, you know, the MAGA hardcore, which
- 21:01it seemed like it was resolved when Trump kind of came out in.
- 21:04The white nationalist wing of the Magas.
- 21:07Right. Well, I was going to say that
- 21:09the more openly racist part of the coalition, and that's more
- 21:12extreme, is not a fan of this and it's very at odds with the
- 21:16tech community's support of the current administration.
- 21:20I would say to your point, Eric, there's been a slowdown in
- 21:23visas, but the real shift is cultural and how people feel
- 21:27about practicing their business or, you know, taking the risks
- 21:31of hiring a new employee that's also an immigrant.
- 21:33They may not want to do it because of 1.
- 21:35The paperwork getting complicated and the risk of
- 21:37their employee, you know, getting stuck somewhere or
- 21:40deported. We saw this happen with an open
- 21:43AI researcher who was pretty senior within the company, just
- 21:46had her visa denied. And the administration said, you
- 21:49know, it was for paperwork irregularities, but she had to
- 21:52leave the country and is working remotely out of Vancouver.
- 21:55And obviously, they're accommodating her right now.
- 21:57But if this happens in mass, it has a chilling effect for any
- 22:00talent that wants to come here. I mean, when Vinod Khosla
- 22:04actually shared the story on X, which was, you know, great,
- 22:08great to get that reach out there.
- 22:10But, you know, and it kind of fit into his message and what
- 22:12he's been in support of making immigration easier for startup
- 22:15founders and employees. But to his point, you know,
- 22:18scaring qualified immigrants away is not what we need in our
- 22:22technology race with China. If that's really important for
- 22:24you, an American minimism, a lot of you know, to this point here,
- 22:27biotech point earlier, a lot of qualified researchers come to do
- 22:31this work from overseas. It's and they're choosing to be
- 22:34here, but. I mean, so much of the MAGA, the
- 22:36MAGA movement is help Americans at the expense of everyone else,
- 22:40right? And, and I don't even think
- 22:42that's a hostile way of putting it.
- 22:44It's like we're not trying to do USAID, we're trying to help help
- 22:48Americans. And so I think a lot of them
- 22:50sincerely don't want, you know, the talented, the top engineer
- 22:56in sort of Bangalore to come here.
- 22:58Obviously, I don't know, I, I feel the opposite and, and most
- 23:02of Silicon Valley does that. The whole engine of Silicon
- 23:05Valley and why American exceptionalism works is that
- 23:09America has a very expansionist identity and you can join it if
- 23:14you're hungry and ambitious. And that's the way we stay on
- 23:17top. So I think it's good for
- 23:19business and I think it's a moral good and certainly a
- 23:23theme. We'll, we'll keep watching and
- 23:25hopefully the situation doesn't get any worse, but I suspect
- 23:28that it will. Look, Eric, on that note of, of
- 23:30optimism, you know, I, I really have nothing more to add.
- 23:33I'll only bring the mood down. So I'm I'm glad we're able to,
- 23:36to go through all that stuff and see everyone back here next
- 23:39week.