Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Document of Resolution & Examiner Findings: What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:08Speaker: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:11Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:14your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:17The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:20Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:22If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:25team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:30and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:32com to find out more.
- 0:40Hey everyone.
- 0:40This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:44And recently the NCOA board at their quarterly share insurance briefing noted
- 0:50that camel codes continue to deteriorate.
- 0:53I did a podcast about it, short podcast about it recently, following up on
- 0:58their communication of this information.
- 1:00And what happens when camel codes get worse?
- 1:04Examinations get harder, examination reports get harder, and specifically,
- 1:11credit unions start getting more examiner findings, supplementary facts,
- 1:15document of resolutions, perhaps regional director letters, informal type of
- 1:21communications, informal enforcement actions from NCUA that That can make
- 1:27credit unions life's more complicated.
- 1:28So we're here today to start talking about all of those things I just mentioned,
- 1:33and I've got Steve Farr and Todd Miller of my team with me here today.
- 1:37Guys, how are you doing?
- 1:40Good morning.
- 1:41I'm doing great today.
- 1:43We have a day with no wind for a change.
- 1:45Glad to hear it.
- 1:46No wind.
- 1:46We'll try and wrap this up so you can go get out, get some yard work done
- 1:50there in the beautiful state of Montana.
- 1:52But guys, if Steve and Todd, let's go with Steve first.
- 1:55If you could give a little bit of background, maybe there's some new
- 1:58listeners who haven't heard you on the podcast before, if you could
- 2:02give a little bit of your background at NCUA and that'd be great.
- 2:06So Steve, fire away.
- 2:08Hello everyone.
- 2:09Yeah, Steve Farr.
- 2:09I spent 30 plus years at NCUA.
- 2:12Most of 'em I would say really great.
- 2:15And the first half of my career was in heavily involved in the examination
- 2:20function, primarily as a problem case officer on the west coast.
- 2:24But I was involved in Conservatorships throughout the nation.
- 2:28Then I moved into the central office.
- 2:30And I spent the last half of my career there working in the
- 2:33division of risk management.
- 2:35One of my accomplishments or duties that would particularly
- 2:38apply to this broadcast was.
- 2:41I wrote the enforcement manual, which was put out as an instruction and I
- 2:47just realized that was 20 years ago.
- 2:5020 years ago, time flies, man.
- 2:53Yeah, it seemed like yesterday when I was looking back at it.
- 2:57And then, spent my career there in the division of risk management and
- 3:02worked on the corporate resolution.
- 3:05And 1 of the last things worked on was the risk based capital role.
- 3:10Very good.
- 3:11Similar to Steve, I was around more than 30 years.
- 3:14Actually, I was just a couple short months, less than 35 years.
- 3:17I enjoyed my career a great deal too.
- 3:19And instead of breaking mine in two, like Steve, I could
- 3:22probably break mine in three.
- 3:24The first 10 years or so I was an examiner and problem case officer.
- 3:28The second 10 years, I spent it as a capital market specialist
- 3:32from 2000 through 2010.
- 3:34I do have a last year there where I was involved with a
- 3:38conservatorship at West Corp.
- 3:40And then the last decade or 11 years of my career, so I was the director of special
- 3:44actions in the western region supervising problem case officers and capital market
- 3:49specialists just a little sideline.
- 3:52I also spent time on N.
- 3:54C.
- 3:54U.
- 3:54A.
- 3:54Supervisory Review Committee.
- 3:57I chaired a couple of appeals, sat on another appeal.
- 4:00So that was an interesting little sidelight to my career, but like Steve,
- 4:04I enjoyed almost all my years with NCUA.
- 4:07COVID was a little less fun when you couldn't talk to people, but
- 4:11for the most part, I enjoyed working with credit unions a great deal.
- 4:16Very good.
- 4:16I would echo that remark in my 34 years.
- 4:19And now in this new This new thing that we're all doing I'm having
- 4:23even more fun helping credit union.
- 4:24So a lot of credit union conversations we've had has been based around.
- 4:30The examination reports in the issue in the enforcement manual related
- 4:35items tied to the examination report.
- 4:38And whether it's, getting draft documents that they don't quite
- 4:42understand why it might be placed in a certain part of the examination report.
- 4:46A lot of questions around that arena.
- 4:47So I thought it would be good to just do a little bit of education on the particular
- 4:52parts of the examination report.
- 4:53Yeah, I'm thinking that maybe the first item to discuss
- 4:58would be the examiner findings.
- 5:01So let's chat a little bit about examiner findings and or pivot,
- 5:04from that any which way you think based on your vast experience on
- 5:09exam reports and examiner findings.
- 5:15Go ahead, Todd.
- 5:16Examiners findings, they reflect problems that examiners find during the exam that
- 5:21they think credit union should address.
- 5:24But there are problems that don't threaten the viability of the credit union.
- 5:28They don't represent systemic violations for the most part.
- 5:32They're treated as items that management can correct in the
- 5:36normal course of business.
- 5:38They don't require the timeliness that some of the other things do
- 5:41that we're going to talk about later.
- 5:43But they're just items that the examiners believe need to be
- 5:47corrected, but they can be corrected in the normal course of business.
- 5:50Examiners don't usually spend a lot of time documenting them in the report.
- 5:55The descriptions of them are fairly brief.
- 5:58There's a short action deal with this over the course of the next year in general.
- 6:06And I think one of the important things on those is is, as a, if you were a board
- 6:11member looking at the exam report, that looking at the volume that you have of
- 6:16examiner findings, it may be that the NCOA is trying to send you a message.
- 6:23Because we've had cases where the problems weren't real horrible, horrible, and that
- 6:28it wasn't going to get to where it was.
- 6:29It costs the insurance fund, something and not quite to level the door.
- 6:33There's just a lot of little, little things.
- 6:36And when you get a laundry list of just examiner findings covering multiple
- 6:42areas, the minor things that's that's a clear indication that he's trying
- 6:48to send to the board of directors that they need to pay attention to is what's
- 6:51the root cause of all those issues is that breakdowns at multiple levels?
- 6:56Is that a breakdown at the top?
- 6:57Is a breakdown and internal controls, but pay attention to what could be.
- 7:03An overarching message.
- 7:08Great points guys.
- 7:09We'll probably get into this again in different discussions, but
- 7:13citation of a regulation citation of safety and soundness citation of.
- 7:19A letter to credit unions and an examiner finding anything you want
- 7:23to share relative to what I just said there, as opposed to contrasting
- 7:28it with a document resolution.
- 7:31I guess the ultimate question is if something's in the examiner
- 7:34findings, should the examiner be able to tie it to a written into
- 7:40a product as a reference point?
- 7:43Yes, yes.
- 7:47They're supposed to cite a regulation, for any of these informal administrative
- 7:51remedies, whether it's an examiner's finding a door, a preliminary warning
- 7:57letter, an LUA, regional director letter, those citations should be there.
- 8:03They should include regulations, your examiners findings and doors.
- 8:06They, in addition to the regulations, they may include other guidance
- 8:10letters at the carding that is issued.
- 8:13So letters to credit unions and issue a supervisory guidance documents.
- 8:17It could cite 1 of those, it could cite the exam guide, but in general, all of
- 8:23these informal actions when examiners are asking you to take action, there
- 8:28should be citations to a regulation.
- 8:31Very good.
- 8:32Very good.
- 8:33Steve, anything else on that topic you would like to add on the examiner finding?
- 8:38Yeah, just a reminder, our listeners and that it's easy to use the tools on
- 8:44the internet to look up the regulations.
- 8:46That I use the ECFR and you can negotiate and navigate around that really easily.
- 8:52And then just focus on that one area so that, that's the quick and easy.
- 8:56The other advantage on that is, It has the links to the kind of
- 9:01the history of that regulation.
- 9:04You can go in and you can read the preamble if you're really want to
- 9:07get into the details of what happened with that regulation, what's its
- 9:11history, you can get to it that way.
- 9:13And when we are faced with something like that, we spend a great deal
- 9:18of time in those preambles to make sure that we understand what NCOA's
- 9:22intent was with certain regulations.
- 9:25That's a great point on the preamble actually always have enjoyed the
- 9:27preamble more than the actual regulation.
- 9:29You can probably read that and know what you need to know.
- 9:32And I think in a previous podcast, I might have made a statement such as that.
- 9:38It's a regulation is almost a 3 act play.
- 9:40There's the preamble of the proposal.
- 9:43There's the preamble of the final and then there's the actual regulation
- 9:47and to really understand the entirety of what is trying to achieve.
- 9:52It's important to understand.
- 9:53I think all 3 of those documents.
- 9:57So
- 10:00negotiating with NCUA, Todd, you mentioned in a perfect world, it
- 10:04would cite a regulation, right?
- 10:06And you could argue that any regulation.
- 10:09In and of itself if an NCWA examiner wanted to take a position that a
- 10:13regulation was violated, that that could rise to the level of document resolutions.
- 10:18Oftentimes, it doesn't.
- 10:20But let's say, for example, you've got a situation where there are a
- 10:24volume of examiner findings, and they decided maybe with negotiations with
- 10:30the credit union that they would it.
- 10:32Put them in the examiner finding instead of a document resolution.
- 10:36Next exam comes around.
- 10:38What happens to the, what does the examiner do relative to the 10,
- 10:4210 examiner findings that were out there coming into the next go round?
- 10:46What should the credit union expect to happen, particularly
- 10:49if maybe there is noncompliance?
- 10:52It's somewhat interesting because, I used to teach and Steve also taught a
- 10:56lot of examiners classes and examiners would ask questions like this.
- 11:00And the answer to them was, it depends.
- 11:04There is no black and white answer to this, and it really depends
- 11:08on the nature of those examiners findings, to elevate them to a door.
- 11:14There has to be some evidence that if they're not corrected, it's going to
- 11:18cause financial or operational damage to the credit union or continued
- 11:22noncompliance with the regulation.
- 11:26as Steve alluded to earlier, sometimes if there's a significant number
- 11:30of findings not being addressed, it represents a widespread problem
- 11:34throughout the credit union.
- 11:36Sometimes they get elevated to a door just to send a message to the board
- 11:40that there's significant numbers of internal control problems here that.
- 11:45Are not being addressed.
- 11:46So sometimes findings just get left as findings for a couple years.
- 11:51Sometimes the findings are not addressed.
- 11:53And like I said, the examiner's judgment, those unaddressed findings
- 11:58can lead to operational problems or violations of regulation or
- 12:03internal control deficiencies.
- 12:05then they can rise to a document of resolution.
- 12:08For most credit unions, they should probably operate on the assumption that
- 12:13if they don't resolve findings in a material way, they probably will find
- 12:17their way to a document of resolution.
- 12:21I would agree.
- 12:21I would agree with that sentiment.
- 12:23And I'm thinking of a quote, commit no minor blunders, right?
- 12:26You've been told this is an issue you can expect and see a way to look at it
- 12:32when you come back and the best way to make sure it doesn't go to a document
- 12:36resolution is to resolve the issue.
- 12:39And of course that that presumes that you're comfortable that the issue
- 12:44needs to be resolved and you can, have discussions with the court.
- 12:48The credit union around that topic.
- 12:50So any last words on examiner findings before we pivot
- 12:55perhaps to supplementary facts?
- 12:57No, very good.
- 12:58Okay.
- 12:58So the supplementary facts portion of the examination, back in the day
- 13:03long time ago, back even before the 20 years ago, when Steve wrote the
- 13:07enforcement manual I remember utilizing the supplementary facts for compliance
- 13:13with a letter of understanding.
- 13:14And that was really where I, got my teeth wet as an examiner
- 13:17was the an LUA was outstanding.
- 13:19We, as a problem case officer, you typically would have those.
- 13:23So you'd give an update in that form, but it over time, it's morphed
- 13:27into being utilized a lot more.
- 13:30And if you would like to describe the purpose of the super supplementary facts
- 13:35and maybe some advice for credit unions in that, on that top on that document.
- 13:41Thank you.
- 13:42Examiners use supplementary facts for a number of different ways, and sometimes
- 13:47they're tied to document a resolution.
- 13:48Sometimes they're tied to examiner's findings.
- 13:51Sometimes they're just general information.
- 13:54But in general, it gives criteans alternatives to address the problem.
- 14:00Here's some deficiencies.
- 14:02In your commercial lending program.
- 14:05Here's options.
- 14:06A, B, C, D, E suggestions that might address that.
- 14:11So it gives credit unions a broader explanation of what the
- 14:17examiner sees an issue and perhaps alternatives to address it.
- 14:21They put a lot of suggestions in supplementary facts nowadays.
- 14:25Because the overview is supposed to be condensed, but maybe there's an issue
- 14:29that doesn't rise to an exam finding, but could in the future, and examiners
- 14:34will use supplementary facts to explain that and some of these issues, especially
- 14:38with information security some of the consumer compliance type regs.
- 14:44Some of the intricate credit risk management type things.
- 14:49There are long discussion items that really don't belong in the overview.
- 14:53The overview is tied to the officials.
- 14:55Here's the main things.
- 14:57The supplementary facts can be used.
- 14:59Here's other important things that management needs to pay attention to.
- 15:03It doesn't rise to the board level.
- 15:06So that supplementary facts has become a multiple use document.
- 15:10Yeah, in many different ways, and examiners have a lot of
- 15:14discretion as to when they choose to use the supplementary facts.
- 15:19Nowadays, NCUA has so many specialists.
- 15:21They have the information security specialist, the
- 15:24payment systems specialist, the regional lending specialist.
- 15:27The regional capital market specialists.
- 15:29A lot of times you'll see those specialists will use that supplementary
- 15:33fax to convey information to the credeans.
- 15:36And here's how you can mature your program in these respective areas.
- 15:40So you see the specialists use the supplementary fax quite often.
- 15:45No, that makes sense.
- 15:46Do you have any thing to add on supplementary fax and the
- 15:49use of them in the exam report?
- 15:51No, that was just to add written down to make sure we cover the specialist thing.
- 15:55And Todd just covered it really well.
- 15:57Todd hit another grand slam.
- 15:58So we'll I didn't even have that in my notes.
- 16:02You mentioned supplementary facts.
- 16:03You don't comply with it or something maybe deteriorates.
- 16:06And this is, I think your answer is depends.
- 16:08You're going to give me the lawyer answer, but it could then
- 16:11rise to an examiner finding.
- 16:13So really, in the hierarchy of pain for a credit union, the lowest pain to have
- 16:18something discussed in his supplementary facts, the next highest level of pain
- 16:23would probably be the examiner finding.
- 16:25Which we've discussed so let's pivot to see, I even turned it.
- 16:29I'm not going to give you the opportunity to say it depends.
- 16:32I'm just going to paraphrase that.
- 16:33Let's pivot to the document resolution.
- 16:36And, we've.
- 16:39We had a conversation.
- 16:40All of us were had some conversations with the credit union recently
- 16:44that had a substantial volume of document resolutions, north of a
- 16:49really big number and to the point of prioritization becomes an issue.
- 16:55But before we maybe dive into that particular nuance of a document
- 16:59resolution, what's the purpose?
- 17:01What's your.
- 17:02Your vast experience about with document resolutions would you like
- 17:07to communicate here with the operator?
- 17:09Audience today,
- 17:12I think this one, maybe we will just read from N.
- 17:15C.
- 17:15U.
- 17:16A.
- 17:16's national supervision policy.
- 17:18So you understand exactly what examiners are how they're supposed to be using
- 17:23document a resolutions, from their own national supervision policy.
- 17:29Items that elevate themselves to a document or resolution must be
- 17:32significant enough that an examiner would recommend escalating to the next
- 17:36level of elevated enforcement actions.
- 17:40That being an RDL, an LUA, preliminary warning letter.
- 17:45One of the things the examiners are supposed to consider when they decide
- 17:49they're going to write a door is if left unresolved, could the violation
- 17:54or problem cause a pretty serious financial or operating damage?
- 17:59Does the problem result in fundamental noncompliance with laws or regulations?
- 18:05Is the problem something that would need to be escalated to the next
- 18:09level of enforcement if unresolved?
- 18:11And is the problem a result of management's inability or
- 18:15unwillingness to properly identify, measure, monitor, control risk?
- 18:20And then Steve talked about this earlier, the last item is is the problem
- 18:25widespread throughout the credit union?
- 18:27So that's one of those if you have, 30 minor findings, is it really
- 18:33an indication of a widespread problem with internal control?
- 18:37So those are words specifically straight out of the National
- 18:42Supervision Policy Manual.
- 18:45Documents of resolution should be significant issues.
- 18:50That if left uncovered presents a risk to the insurance fund or the
- 18:54reputation of the credit union.
- 18:57That's a good summary right from the words of NCUA and of course the NSPM,
- 19:02the National Supervision Policy Manual.
- 19:05There is a redacted version of that out live for credit unions.
- 19:11There is what appears to be an increasing tendency of NCUA to redact more and
- 19:18more of that and It's something I haven't really talked about a lot
- 19:21here, but it's something that I.
- 19:24I have on my list to potentially talk with NCOA down the road,
- 19:28especially if it keeps getting worse.
- 19:29But Steve, anything relative to what Todd said, I'm sure that document
- 19:34resolutions, you've got a lot of experience on these both at NCOA
- 19:38and recently, what are your thoughts on the document resolution process?
- 19:43Oh, one of the things that crossed my mind is that.
- 19:46You talked about the volume of them.
- 19:49We've had some of our recent clients that were getting like
- 19:51their first document or resolution.
- 19:54And, that one was a really big deal.
- 19:57And then we have some of those that have pages and pages of document or resolution.
- 20:02And it's so they can run the whole gambit.
- 20:04And, the thing is, how you react is, is everything to do with it.
- 20:08One of the things Todd has wanted to talk about while we're on that subject is.
- 20:12I can't recall if it's inside supervision and, what would you call a
- 20:15well, written document of resolution?
- 20:19I know that we used to is, do they have still the smart principle in there?
- 20:23I know the uses a thing that called the 5 C's format is used to communicate.
- 20:29What essentially is there, they call it matters requiring attention.
- 20:33We call them doors, but there's was he had to address concern cause consequence.
- 20:38Mainly of inaction corrective action and commitment.
- 20:42I think ncaa within we used to is it in the regulation, but we used to teach
- 20:46the smart principle Todd, you want to touch on it still in the supervision
- 20:49manual the smart principle it's more the smart is geared to that corrective
- 20:54action piece Not those other pieces that the occ uses and see where they do have
- 20:59to describe the problem But the smart principle is The actions that they ask
- 21:04the credit union to do, or that the credit union agrees to do, and we'll talk about
- 21:08negotiating doors, I think, before we're done, but the SMART principle is those
- 21:12actions that we're asking of the credit union, or NCUA is asking of the credit
- 21:17union, they should be specific in nature.
- 21:20They should be measurable.
- 21:22So are they achieving the results intended in a very concrete, measurable way?
- 21:27They should be achievable.
- 21:29And sometimes this is where examiners run afoul and why people hire us
- 21:33is because they're given doors that are perhaps not achievable in the
- 21:37manner that the examiners request.
- 21:40They should be result oriented.
- 21:41So they should address the root causes of the problems.
- 21:45And That's a difficult one, especially for newer examiners who like to
- 21:49address symptoms of problems rather than the actual problem and root
- 21:53causes, and they should be timely.
- 21:55So to reiterate that just in the SMART letters, specific, measurable, achievable,
- 22:01results oriented, and timely is how those corrective actions should fit in that box.
- 22:08When you walk through the SMART principle to pop out at me, achievable,
- 22:12because we've had some situations.
- 22:14Where
- 22:18NCUA's expectations we're, I want to say not in touch with
- 22:23reality, but that's a little harsh.
- 22:24We're a little aggressive.
- 22:26And the other one that pops into my head is timely.
- 22:28And, I've been, we've been experiencing, credit unions have been experiencing, and
- 22:33NCUA's board members have actually talked about it, that the timeliness of reports
- 22:38Can complicate the ability to achieve it.
- 22:41For example, if when the examiner is on site, they're saying I want something
- 22:45done by September and then August 15th.
- 22:52They actually give me the final report where they go through all the nuances
- 22:56and they talk about it in the overview.
- 22:58And I see some things in there that I don't really like.
- 23:01And then by the way, they, depending on code, they might
- 23:04be coming back pretty quickly.
- 23:07So you can see some of these things colliding where the smart principle.
- 23:11Isn't necessarily followed whether it's because of staffing issues or just
- 23:18having an expectation of what, what can be achieved in a, a time period.
- 23:23I remember when we were all out on the West Coast, there was a guy that worked
- 23:27in the office named Eric Jacobson.
- 23:29And I remember him saying, Mark, only so much water is going to go down
- 23:32the sink at one point in time, right?
- 23:34There's only so much that can be done with the resources that you have.
- 23:38Any thoughts on achievable or timely and any advice to
- 23:42credit unions in that regard?
- 23:44I think when we see those doors that you are perhaps not achievable,
- 23:53perhaps not timely, perhaps not really.
- 23:57results oriented.
- 23:58I think it comes down to how examiners negotiate those doors because what should
- 24:03happen throughout the exam process is that if examiner has an issue and they
- 24:07feel it's a material issue like this, they should sit down with management,
- 24:11discuss the issue, get management's agreement that it is an issue and that
- 24:16management actually understands the issue, and then it becomes a negotiation.
- 24:21Management should say, this is what we're able to do with our
- 24:25resources to address this problem.
- 24:28And I think a lot of the ones where we run into problems with our clients, or
- 24:32where they run into issues with DOORS not being smart, it's because that whole
- 24:36negotiation discussion process hasn't occurred, the examiners are under time
- 24:41pressure, they write the door, they throw it in front of management space without
- 24:45management having time to say that this is what we're able or unable to do.
- 24:50There hasn't been this whole agreement that this is even a problem.
- 24:54And there is a lot of disagreements out there, especially around interest
- 24:58rate and liquidity in this environment.
- 25:01So when examiners shortcut the process, that's when you start
- 25:05ending up with doors that are not achievable results oriented or timely.
- 25:11And this is really important that when accrediting gets a door, especially at
- 25:16the board and management level, that they truly understand the examiner's concern.
- 25:22There's always more than one way to address a problem.
- 25:25And I think what we're seeing quite often with our clients is.
- 25:28There hasn't been a discussion of these multiple ways to address a problem and
- 25:33the examiner is just, here's my solution, credit you can follow it, and they're
- 25:37not given that opportunity to say, wait, here's other ways we can address this.
- 25:43That's not always the case.
- 25:44A lot of examiners are really good about writing open ended doors that
- 25:48examiner or credit you can give us a plan to address this issue by the
- 25:53state and we'll assess it there.
- 25:56But.
- 25:57In many instances, we do see this where they're given a door by Fiat.
- 26:02They're given goals and timelines, and there hasn't been that upfront discussion
- 26:07with management or that agreement that this is a significant problem that
- 26:13jeopardizes the credit union's future.
- 26:18Great point, Steve.
- 26:19Yeah, 1 of the items I know that we've been dealing with our clients
- 26:22on is, the timeliness of when they get the exam report and it has the
- 26:27door in there and then when they start looking at what it'll take to fix it,
- 26:31the cost of some of these door items is a really great in some cases, and
- 26:37probably not much of a consideration than when it was put together.
- 26:42And I think, my, that's where I think when you get into 1 of these, and it's
- 26:47going to be really, really costly.
- 26:49Before you really tie into that, make sure that you're you and your examiner
- 26:54are on the same boat, because it'd be terrible to put a bunch of resources
- 26:57into something that you thought had marginal benefit to you, but you thought
- 27:00was going to take care of the door.
- 27:02That might not be a good decision that could have been
- 27:05taken care of a communication.
- 27:06The other thing that can happen.
- 27:08And I used to see this a lot when I came into cases as a problem case officer
- 27:12was doors that were inconsistent.
- 27:14One part of it would say reduce operating expenses.
- 27:18And the timeframe was that kind of immediately.
- 27:20And then on the other parts of the door where all of these items that we're going
- 27:23to acquire more resources and people and be like, well, that's inconsistent there.
- 27:29So you guys have any thoughts on how to deal with those issues.
- 27:33The one thing that jumps into my head and it related to the priority,
- 27:38but the cost is prioritizing.
- 27:40We'll, we'll often advise credit unions to, you got, you've got six I.
- 27:45T.
- 27:45findings.
- 27:46Which one does NCUA think is the most important?
- 27:51Typically, when you were training examiners, presumably there was
- 27:57discussions about, putting document resolutions in priority order, putting
- 28:00examiner findings in priority order to the extent you can, and, we've advised
- 28:05credit unions to try and establish that point so that then they could maybe have
- 28:10some discussions about if there's five that are saying I need to add expenses,
- 28:16And you're at the meantime, you're saying I'm, my, my profitability isn't enough
- 28:20for my, for where I want my capital to be.
- 28:23That's one way to approach it.
- 28:25But Todd, what are you, what are your thoughts on that?
- 28:27The NSPM still says DOORS should be issued to the credit union in priority order.
- 28:33I don't think it says that about exam findings anymore.
- 28:36A lot of the exam findings, examiners tend to organize those
- 28:40around subject areas, and it's which examiner turned in their work first.
- 28:44That, that capital market specialist or that regional lending specialist.
- 28:48But those are items correctable in the normal course of business and
- 28:51don't rise to the priority level.
- 28:53Doors do.
- 28:54Doors should be in priority order and cost should be a consideration of that.
- 29:01I remember back in the 90s, we used to look at credit operating expenses
- 29:05and then we had a board that came in and said, examiners, you don't
- 29:09get to look at operating expenses.
- 29:10Stay away from them.
- 29:11That's the credit decision.
- 29:13So it goes back to Steve's thing, when Examiner says, improve your
- 29:18risk management program, hire a chief risk officer, develop an ERM program.
- 29:24I don't think examiners quite understand that those asks are
- 29:29potentially millions of dollars.
- 29:31They're not something you do in the normal course of business, like an exam finding.
- 29:35Those are significant.
- 29:37Resources and you start asking people for third party consultants.
- 29:41Those things are not cheap and examiners don't dig into expenses
- 29:46and I haven't for a couple decades.
- 29:47Those are then maybe some of the problem case officers.
- 29:50So a lot of times I don't think examiners like Steve said they don't
- 29:54understand what these things cost.
- 29:56And the cost is maybe a bigger problem than.
- 30:00Problem they're trying to fix.
- 30:02So parties need to push back and examiners with that is wait, this is
- 30:06the resources this is going to take.
- 30:08And is it really going to achieve the results intended?
- 30:12That's why you should be given the opportunity.
- 30:15Is there another way we can address this issue?
- 30:21So I took some notes during this conversation and I want to circle back to
- 30:28The NSPM portion where you talked about the purpose of the document resolution.
- 30:34And I wrote down a circle, three things, inability or unwillingness,
- 30:40fundamental noncompliance
- 30:43in widespread.
- 30:46So
- 30:50what caught my attention on inability or unwillingness was it linked
- 30:54in my head that the definition.
- 30:58Of a code three is the management may be unwilling or
- 31:03unable and the operative word.
- 31:05There is may oftentimes and we're we'll do some podcasts coming up here on camel.
- 31:10But it really caught my ear that.
- 31:14When they're talking about if you need a door, it's because you're in a
- 31:17management's inability or unwillingness.
- 31:19And that's very similar to language about the code.
- 31:22Any thoughts relative to document resolutions and how they.
- 31:29Relate how they should relate to the camel code.
- 31:36I had that written down as a question also.
- 31:38So I guess I'll throw it to Todd.
- 31:41What?
- 31:41Why do I get picked on here?
- 31:43There is a feedback loop between the 2, for instance, in a code 1,
- 31:48you're almost never going to see a document or resolution code twos.
- 31:51You might see 1 or 2.
- 31:53usually, they're going to be compliance or BSA related.
- 31:56There are certain regulatory things that Might not be significant, but because
- 32:00there are violations of the law they rise to a document of resolution when
- 32:06otherwise they would be a finding.
- 32:07You can correct these in the normal course of business.
- 32:10And you see a lot of those with BSA issues and FinCEN related issues, because we have
- 32:15agreements with other agencies that these items will be a document of resolution.
- 32:20Our NCUA has agreements.
- 32:21I keep throwing we in there.
- 32:23I'm not with NCUA anymore.
- 32:24Just seems like it.
- 32:27Yeah it's after 35 years of being with an organization
- 32:31and probably working for them.
- 32:33There's a little bit of, it feels like an old family.
- 32:36But there is feedback related to the doors and the camel rating
- 32:40should be congruent with each other.
- 32:42And, there's a three camel rating.
- 32:44Those are crediting that, they're not in imminent danger of failure today, but if
- 32:49they don't address things, they could be.
- 32:52You expect more doors there to address those root causes to make
- 32:56sure that the direction that credit moves is to a two not down to a four.
- 33:01So there should be some relationship between camel codes and Your exam
- 33:08reports and doors and findings.
- 33:10It's very rare that you're going to see a camel three that doesn't
- 33:13have a door unless it used to be a four and addressed everything.
- 33:17That's maybe the one exception, but it's a very rare situation as you get down
- 33:22into that camel four rating you're almost always going to have the next topic
- 33:27of discussion for us and An LUA or a preliminary warning letter type of action.
- 33:34There is a step in between there The unwillingness and inability to
- 33:40address problems, if that is truly a foundational issue, it's almost
- 33:46always going to get beyond a door.
- 33:48Eventually, what good point fundamental noncompliance when I see that the
- 33:54word I key in on is fundamental and, violating the loans to 1
- 33:58member violating a commercial loan.
- 34:01A principal tenant of a commercial loan rule.
- 34:04I think you mentioned BSA.
- 34:06Because of the agreements they have fund, anything on BSA is going to, would fit
- 34:11into fundamental noncompliance almost.
- 34:14And then widespread we've had lots of conversations.
- 34:21Thought on the podcast about situations where it almost appears as if corporate
- 34:30governance is is rising in importance in credit unions from an NCUA perspective.
- 34:38And when I think widespread, I don't know why I'm linking that to this topic in my
- 34:44mind, but I am where maybe an NCUA has.
- 34:48eight examiner findings, and they have a few things in the document resolution.
- 34:52We're seeing document resolutions being grouped into corporate governance.
- 34:58Any thoughts and I know this is a little off topic, but based on our
- 35:02recent conversations we've had, any thoughts on document resolutions?
- 35:08Being widespread and corporate governance and how NCOA is doing that right now.
- 35:18I think it's NCOA catching up and maturing their own level of knowledge
- 35:24about root causes of issues.
- 35:27Before they dealt with the symptoms of it, I was always a proponent that we should
- 35:32have specific training classes at N.
- 35:35C.
- 35:35U.
- 35:35A.
- 35:35Just on risk management and corporate governance.
- 35:38N.
- 35:38C.
- 35:38U.
- 35:38A.
- 35:38Really doesn't do that.
- 35:40Based on what we're seeing with our clients, maybe they are starting to do
- 35:43that because we're starting to see a lot of doors and findings that are under
- 35:48that guise of corporate governance.
- 35:51But realistically, corporate governance is important.
- 35:55I think MCUA over the decades have left it alone because they didn't want to scare
- 35:59volunteer board members away from serving.
- 36:02Now it's become somewhat critical to the safe and sound operation of organizations.
- 36:09So I think just as an agency, their understanding of corporate governance has
- 36:14improved and that's why we're seeing those types of language in these documents of
- 36:21resolution and findings today is they're getting better at identifying root causes.
- 36:27Now sometimes it does go astray, but overall I would see it as a
- 36:33positive and something that perhaps needed to happen a long time ago.
- 36:38Just one person's take.
- 36:40Yeah, I agree.
- 36:41I'm a big proponent of corporate governance because it takes care of all
- 36:45those little issues that used to, Todd drive us crazy when it would be a matter
- 36:50of ethics and those types of things.
- 36:52It would just infuriate us and they were hard to overcome.
- 36:571 thing I'm seeing, though is there's this creeping that's occurring in the
- 37:03levels of corporate governance is out there because there's a lot of guidance
- 37:06out there for institutions, not just credit unions above the 10Billion dollar.
- 37:11Mark all of which is good advice, but I think I'm seeing, that's
- 37:15requirement is like, creeping down to apply it in more than an intended
- 37:20level to the smaller institutions.
- 37:22It's something that.
- 37:24be wary of and know that, this is the appropriate corporate
- 37:28governance for our size.
- 37:30But if we're shooting to be much bigger, what does our corporate
- 37:33governance need to look like?
- 37:35Going forward, go ahead, Todd.
- 37:40NCUA's knowledge is maturing in this process and rightfully
- 37:43they're still stumbling blocks.
- 37:45We still see examiners Perhaps putting burdens on boards of directors to
- 37:50get involved in daily operations and daily committees, which is very much
- 37:55misplaced in larger credit unions.
- 37:57There's clear separations of what is boards responsibility versus
- 38:02management's responsibility and how management demonstrates compliance
- 38:06with things, five, 10 years ago, you would never see an exam report that
- 38:11talked about risk appetite statements.
- 38:13We're starting to see those and rightfully but I also think sometimes
- 38:17examiners don't have their hands around what that all means yet.
- 38:24From my perspective, so I think NCOA is still taking baby steps
- 38:28down the right path, but their knowledge level still needs to mature
- 38:32along the way, and they have a lot of employees to get up to speed.
- 38:37Credence, you can hire us.
- 38:38We'll help you out with that.
- 38:39If you got an examiner, that is misplaced along their journey.
- 38:44You're very good.
- 38:45And Todd, the catching up concept.
- 38:47It was a conversation.
- 38:48The three of us were involved in, I think, last week.
- 38:52It might have been an after conversation, but you said
- 38:55something that resonated with me.
- 38:57It was like back 20 years ago, 15 years ago, whenever capital market specialists
- 39:02came into existence and NCUA elevated the expectations on liquidity and asset
- 39:07liability management and income simulation and all those things, it was much needed.
- 39:12And we, the agency and credit unions were behind where banks were.
- 39:16And there was this This maturity process within the agency and then
- 39:20within the credit unions, I think we're at the beginning stages
- 39:23of that in corporate governance.
- 39:25And then I'll pivot to say, the office of national exam and supervision has
- 39:30highlighted as corporate governance and a lot of the initiatives
- 39:33that came out in their guidance.
- 39:35And then, Ones used to be over 10 billion, then they shifted it
- 39:39to 15 billion, yet they have the capital planning for the 10 billion.
- 39:44And then Steve, you alluded to other guidance sets out there, which
- 39:49there's this great document that you've pointed out to some of our
- 39:52clients and to me, the FDIC proposed guidance on corporate governance,
- 39:57which, quite frankly, is fantastic.
- 40:00But it's for 10 billion credit unions, but that creeping effect is, we see that we
- 40:06pointed out to clients, NCUA sees it, they look at it and go, wow, this is better
- 40:11than anything we've got in our NSPM.
- 40:13And we don't have a letter to credit unions on it.
- 40:15And you can start to see examiners taking on some of those
- 40:19tenants, which is a good thing.
- 40:20But you can have, depending on who gets assigned to, you can have
- 40:25the expectations of a 10 billion.
- 40:28Guidance that's not even final for banks that ends up being part
- 40:32of a discussion for a 1 billion or a 500 million credit union.
- 40:36Same thing being said, if you're at a billion dollars and you get corporate
- 40:40governance brought up, what you want to do is look at what's out there, what,
- 40:45how you can mature your systems and there might be some things there that do
- 40:51make sense for you at your asset size.
- 40:53Any, anything I triggered there or should we move on to regional director letters?
- 40:57Go ahead, Todd.
- 40:58I spent two decades dealing with troubled credit unions.
- 41:02I spent, a couple, a decade as an examiner problem case officer
- 41:06and then call it another decade as a director of special actions.
- 41:09And even my time as a regional capital market specialist, there was dealing
- 41:13with a lot of troubled credit unions.
- 41:15When you go through the whole process of resolving issues in troubled credit
- 41:20unions, there's almost always was corporate governance at the root.
- 41:24It's a failure of corporate governance that got them into trouble.
- 41:28Most of the time, not all the time, but most of the time it was never in writing.
- 41:33And CUA said, Hey, credit unions don't need ERM programs.
- 41:37When I was the director of special actions for a billion dollar credit union, if
- 41:41they got The code for rating came into special actions I wasn't letting them
- 41:46out until they were well down the path with a fully established erm program
- 41:51Because those are the things to make sure they don't ever come back into special
- 41:54actions again And I found over my career over the 2000s like even you go through
- 41:59the last recession in 2008 and stuff The credit unions in california and on
- 42:04the west coast washington, oregon that had erm programs in place before that
- 42:09recession You None of those guys ended up as code fours or troubled credit unions.
- 42:13Those programs are successful at mitigating and managing risk.
- 42:18They're almost essential in this competitive environment.
- 42:22Once credit unions start hitting that 1, 2, 3, 5 billion.
- 42:26I don't think they're optional anymore.
- 42:30I think of accrediting wants to survive and compete those risk management
- 42:35processes in governance processes.
- 42:38They have to be in place if you're going to survive long term.
- 42:42Great.
- 42:43Great point.
- 42:44I had one more topic on, on the document of resolution because it is an item
- 42:48that at the end of the exam and the joint conference, the the regulator
- 42:53usually asks for the board to accept or approve the document or resolution.
- 42:59Sometimes there's an uneasiness there.
- 43:01I thought maybe we should discuss, what is the board's options
- 43:04when they're faced with that decision, at the joint conference.
- 43:11It's a great point.
- 43:12I think we're both going to look to Todd for his take on that.
- 43:16And then we'll have had some comments.
- 43:18I think it comes back 1st from a board level perspective is do you really
- 43:23understand the examiner's concerns and.
- 43:28A lot of times board members are reluctant to ask the examiners
- 43:31questions, when they get a document or resolution, they're supposed to
- 43:35get that exam report ahead of time.
- 43:37They should be discussing things with management, even lay out the questions
- 43:41that they might have with the examiners and make sure they truly understand what
- 43:45the examiners concerns and issues are.
- 43:49And you get that examiner quite often their supervisor is there
- 43:53well at that joint conference.
- 43:54Don't be scared to ask them questions and make sure you have
- 43:58an understanding of the issues.
- 44:00At the end of the day, the examiners are actually trying to do what's best
- 44:04for the credit union, even if some of their suggestions and guidance might
- 44:08be a little bit misplaced, or there's alternatives to ways to address it.
- 44:13But That's the root piece right there is board members.
- 44:17Make sure you understand what the examiners are really asking.
- 44:21There is provisions.
- 44:22The examiners are always going to ask you to approve that document
- 44:26or resolution and agree to it.
- 44:28And most of the time it's in creating his best interest to do sometimes it's not.
- 44:32And if it's not crediting, they're allowed 30 days to respond to it.
- 44:36We disagree with this.
- 44:39Here's what we're willing to do.
- 44:40Here's what we're able to do.
- 44:42There's a whole appeal process.
- 44:44If they think the examiners have gone astray to a great deal,
- 44:48there's a lot of costs and time and energy involved in appeals,
- 44:52so it's not always your best path.
- 44:54But having an open door and a two way communication so you truly understand
- 45:00each other, that's step one in the whole thing for board members, is
- 45:06make sure you understand what the examiners are really telling you.
- 45:11And this is another thing to the timeliness and some of the issues
- 45:14we're seeing the examiners are taking.
- 45:16Two, three months to get a report finalized after
- 45:20they're done with field work.
- 45:22And then the board members are getting, 24 hours or less notice to digest it.
- 45:29And that's not a timely way to address the problem.
- 45:33These are volunteers.
- 45:34They need a little bit of time to adjust, especially complex
- 45:38doors that are asking a lot.
- 45:40I think NCOA is sometimes not giving them the time they need to do that.
- 45:45And I think it's perfectly fine for management to say, We need another
- 45:49five days to think about this and truly understand it and digest it.
- 45:54So credit unions shouldn't be scared to ask for that additional time.
- 45:59We had a client the other day that the examiners wanted to meet with
- 46:03the board with no documentation at all, no agenda, nothing.
- 46:08And of course that management team was right in saying we're
- 46:12uncomfortable doing that.
- 46:14And, we even told them don't do it until they give you something.
- 46:18And it's just not necessarily a good idea.
- 46:22We did indeed, the.
- 46:24That issue of the reports coming in late and getting dropped on the board.
- 46:29It's a real issue out there.
- 46:30It's, we're seeing it too much.
- 46:33For it not to be and I know NCUA is trying to deal with it because of some
- 46:37statements from the NCUA board vice chairman, but that that's been frustrating
- 46:41recently for credit unions, and I think there's pressures on the examiners
- 46:47to get it done, which is why they end up, dropping on them and they want
- 46:50to write in the closed section of the report, by the way, the closed section,
- 46:54Is what the credit union doesn't see.
- 46:57It's a little summary of, things that aren't worthy of going in the report.
- 47:01Here's the hotel you should stay at, those kind of internal items where NCA
- 47:06will say yes, they voted on doing the document resolution in the perfect world.
- 47:09That's what the examiner Wants to have happen.
- 47:11The other thing, the other word that you mentioned that I had written down
- 47:15and Steve had said it and you said it and I want to say it here communication.
- 47:19Everything we're talking about here comes back to communication on both sides.
- 47:23All the documents we've talked about will be better in final form if communication
- 47:29is working optimally on both sides.
- 47:34Regional director letter.
- 47:36Anybody want to chat about our, also known as an RDL, any thoughts on a
- 47:41regional director letter from where you sit today versus where you sat at NCUA?
- 47:51Steve's nodding.
- 47:51I think he's waiting for me to talk first again.
- 47:54Regional director letters, they're quite often seen in when you
- 47:58get that code three, they sit in that slot somewhat in between a
- 48:02document or resolution and before.
- 48:05in a letter of understanding and agreement.
- 48:08It's usually a way for the regional director, because they're personal,
- 48:12the regional director signs them to tell the credit union's board that I
- 48:16have concerns about these doors here.
- 48:19These are the items you need to fix.
- 48:21They tend to mirror the doors that the credit union has been given.
- 48:25Quite often they're tied to issues that have been persistent.
- 48:31And have not been resolved for a period of time that's typically where they occur.
- 48:36So you've got a repeat type door a longstanding code three that doesn't
- 48:41seem to improve to a code two.
- 48:43It's just the regional director's way to tell the board of directors.
- 48:48You need to pay a little bit more attention here because issues are not
- 48:51being addressed in a timely manner and the real directors will say, I expect you to
- 48:56address these issues in a timely manner.
- 48:59Credit unions should take them pretty serious because they're a prelude to
- 49:04a higher level of informal action if you're not addressing these issues.
- 49:11Excellent, excellent points.
- 49:12You alluded to a higher level of informal which would be preliminary
- 49:17warning letters and letters of understandings that are not published.
- 49:23You can argue that's a gray area where you're starting to get more formal
- 49:28because when a board member is asked to put their signature on it, something,
- 49:32it seems formal, but it might not meet the definition of a legal formal.
- 49:36I think what we'll do here today is leave those discussions to to record another
- 49:41day and that those might be a good primer to the more draconian formal formal
- 49:49actions such as cease and desist orders.
- 49:52Which are rare removal of officials, which are not existent.
- 49:56It's a, as I've said to a lot of people in conversation, they it's something
- 50:01that's never done unless they're all done unless it's a conservatorship.
- 50:04So N.
- 50:05C.
- 50:05U.
- 50:05A.
- 50:05doesn't go halfway into removing officials.
- 50:08They either conserve or they don't remove officials.
- 50:10And we'll talk about those another day.
- 50:13Any last thoughts here before we before we wrap on a discussion of Most of
- 50:18the informal actions that NCWA has.
- 50:21You hit it in so much of the issues that we deal with, they all come down
- 50:25to communication and people slotting in the time that it takes to do
- 50:32communications and that's always seems to be the root cause of a lot of the
- 50:36problems that we end up dealing with.
- 50:39Good point.
- 50:41Todd, any last thoughts?
- 50:43The communication breakdowns can happen on both sides, too.
- 50:47Freddie is you need to make some efforts to communicate with their your
- 50:51examiners on an ongoing basis, get to know them and let them get to know you.
- 50:58And I think maybe the code years were examiners were totally off
- 51:02site has led to some of this.
- 51:04There's no face to face conversations.
- 51:07Even today, a lot of the staff are remote.
- 51:09Some credit unions are choosing to be remote and not sit down and
- 51:13meet with their examiners, because that's the model that they've
- 51:16developed coming out of COVID.
- 51:18But communication needs to be intentional on both sides.
- 51:22I know NCA Historically, has spent a lot of time on examiner
- 51:27training with communications.
- 51:29But like Steve said, quite often there is a breakdown and
- 51:33quite often it's on both sides.
- 51:35So credit unions, you need to make a conscious effort to make sure
- 51:39your under your examiners understand you and what you're doing and why.
- 51:43And sometimes a short conversation is better than the examiner
- 51:50spending, three days looking at your ELCO and board minutes.
- 51:53Sit down and talk to them.
- 51:55Tell them what's behind this business plan and your challenges.
- 52:01Very good.
- 52:02You gave me the opportunity to end with that quote that you
- 52:05guys have heard far too much.
- 52:06Familiarity breeds consent.
- 52:08The more familiar you are with them and the more familiar they are with you,
- 52:12you start to understand each other.
- 52:13When you understand each other, It's because of the
- 52:15communications have been better.
- 52:17This has been a lot of fun guys, as always.
- 52:19I want to thank you for your time, Steve and Todd.
- 52:24Have a great day, Mark Steve and listeners.
- 52:26I want to thank you for listening.
- 52:28I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 52:30We've got we've written down a lot of topics that we want to record podcasts
- 52:34on here coming up the rest of 2024.
- 52:37So stay tuned for those.
- 52:39I think you'll enjoy them.
- 52:40Perhaps as much as you'll enjoy this one.
- 52:42This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 52:51Speaker 2: Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors,
- 52:54subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 52:58experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 53:03If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 53:06out our services at marktreichel.
- 53:09com.