Latest / The Counter Momentum of Spin, with Dr. Franco Musio / Enduring the storm: The search for meaning in suffering
Transcript
- 0:03Good day.
- 0:04Welcome to the Midday Report on the America
- 0:06Out Loud News Talk Radio Network, the countermomentum
- 0:08of spin.
- 0:10I am your host, Dr.
- 0:12Franco Musio.
- 0:13To our friends listening in the United States
- 0:16and around the world, I always mention this,
- 0:18there is no lack, definitely no lack of
- 0:21hard news items to keep our adrenaline going.
- 0:24Our aim, though, on this show is to
- 0:27dissect out the nuances and underlying causes and
- 0:31foundations of the events, the events which we
- 0:34come into contact with now continuously and form
- 0:37our daily lives.
- 0:41So a continuing break from geopolitical and workplace
- 0:44issues.
- 0:46Last week we talked about the China, the
- 0:50uh Trump Xi uh summit, uh, and uh
- 0:53all these massively massively important issues.
- 0:56But here's one that is really key governing
- 0:59all of our lives.
- 1:02And two weeks ago, we spoke uh the
- 1:05show was titled Weathering the Storm of Suffering.
- 1:08Is there a silver lining?
- 1:10It's a very, very heavy topic.
- 1:13And this will be a sequel, and I'm
- 1:15going to call it flourishing through the trials
- 1:17of life.
- 1:19It's been an issue really near and dear
- 1:22to my heart, not only the suffering aspect
- 1:25that really is inherent in, for example, striving
- 1:29for success, but even not even personal suffering
- 1:32that's uh part and parcel of our day-to-day
- 1:35lives, our mundane lives, uh, and uh the
- 1:39stressors uh leading to our suffering, attacking us
- 1:42like sniper fire from many different directions.
- 1:46So it's not only uh part of uh
- 1:48success, if you will, if you look at
- 1:51it in that fashion, but but part of
- 1:53our you know, the fabric of our lives.
- 1:56The key though is how to handle and
- 1:57deal with it.
- 1:59And as per the umbrella title of the
- 2:03show, uh uh meeting suffering with countermomentum.
- 2:07Yeah, we're gonna study this subject even more
- 2:09in depth from various other angles other than
- 2:11what we did before.
- 2:14And I will do my best in providing
- 2:17insight, uh, insights into its management.
- 2:20So a little bit of a recap.
- 2:22Uh, the last time we spoke about different
- 2:24angles, and I want to recap a little
- 2:26bit as kind of a foundation of uh,
- 2:28for example, the meaning, or is there meaning
- 2:30of suffering?
- 2:32So we talked about the famous 19th century
- 2:35German philosopher and a psychologist, Friedrich Nietzsche, uh
- 2:38coining the phrase, quote, what does not kill
- 2:42us makes us stronger.
- 2:45And he was approaching this more from a
- 2:48non-religious standpoint, a more uh, oh, you know,
- 2:52day-to-day standpoint, if you will.
- 2:55Uh, but suffering can basically make us more
- 2:57resistant, resilient.
- 3:00This is what he was saying to the
- 3:02hardships of life.
- 3:04So he wrote the maxim, uh, this maxim
- 3:06in a short masterpiece, The Twilight of the
- 3:09Idols, it was written in 1988, and this
- 3:12was shortly before he suffered uh a terrible
- 3:15mental collapse, basically dying as a thinker.
- 3:18And he himself suffered not only through his
- 3:22mental um mental issues, but uh ill health,
- 3:26uh ill health physically, um his difficult existence
- 3:30really uh informed his ideas about overcoming, overcoming
- 3:34challenges.
- 3:38So uh Nietzsche pointed out that while living
- 3:41is suffering, living is suffering, yes, surviving is
- 3:45finding meaning in suffering, and not only surviving,
- 3:48but flourishing through that.
- 3:52So um meaning is the means by which
- 3:54we endure.
- 3:56Nishi went further to suggest that great accomplishments
- 3:59are exchanged for great suffering.
- 4:01It's very, very true.
- 4:03Um, so he a very, very wonderful quote
- 4:06quote examine the lives of the best and
- 4:10most fruitful people and peak poles, and ask
- 4:13yourself whether a tree that is supposed to
- 4:16grow to a proud height can dispense with
- 4:20bad weather and storms, weather, misfortune, and external
- 4:23resistance, some kinds of hatred, jealousy, stubbornness, mistrust,
- 4:26hardness, avarice, and violence do not belong among
- 4:30the favorable conditions without which any great growth,
- 4:33even of virtue is scarcely possible.
- 4:37End of quote.
- 4:38Now, as a segue, Victor Frankel, he is
- 4:41another, he's a Jewish Austrian uh was a
- 4:44psychologist and holocaust survivor who died in 1997,
- 4:47and he noted that his fellow inmates in
- 4:50German concentration camps were more likely to survive
- 4:53if to derived a sense of meaning.
- 4:56Uh, he uh he wrote Man Searching for
- 4:59Meaning in 1946.
- 5:02The English version uh was in 1959 translator
- 5:04was a best seller.
- 5:07And the bottom line is um he founded
- 5:10the third Vietnamese I am sorry, Viennese, Vienne's
- 5:13school, what's called locotherapy, um, which uh it
- 5:17countered Sigmund Freud's pleasure principle and uh Alfred
- 5:20Adler striving for superiority, which really uh, in
- 5:24my humble opinion, it it puts their theories
- 5:27to uh to shame.
- 5:31So basically, uh uh searched out that there
- 5:34is meaning.
- 5:38There is meaning in suffering, and that meaning
- 5:40will overcome the pain, the emotional pain in
- 5:43suffering.
- 5:46So yes, we we we also looked at
- 5:49the angle of courage and wisdom, and and
- 5:52before that, right before that, uh I want
- 5:55to say a couple of other things about
- 5:59Frankel, Victor Frankel's approach, is that really you
- 6:02can't change the situations out.
- 6:05The vast, vast majority of life is out
- 6:08of our control, particularly the the suffering aspect.
- 6:11But but if meaning is found, then we
- 6:15it takes courage to interpret it in certain
- 6:19ways and to transform the suffering into purpose,
- 6:23purpose slash meaning.
- 6:28So basically, suffering can be a stepping stone
- 6:31for something greater, such as helping others, starting
- 6:34a foundation, creating art, uh um coming with
- 6:38coming up with with incredible theories, and not
- 6:41only theories, but further resilience in our own
- 6:45lives to future suffering.
- 6:49So he basically both of them, Nietzschean and
- 6:53uh Frank will reframed pain, uh suffering as
- 6:56growth, and as for opportunities for growth.
- 7:00And a hard road to a good life,
- 7:00And a hard road to a good life,
- 7:02yes, that's true.
- 7:02yes, that's true.
- 7:04You you can't really have a good life
- 7:05You can't really have a good life without
- 7:08challenges, in my opinion, and without suffering.
- 7:08without challenges, in my opinion, and without suffering.
- 7:12It doesn't come on a silver platter.
- 7:12It doesn't come on a silver platter.
- 7:14Even even the uh, you know, the aristocracy
- 7:14Even the uh, you know, the aristocracy in
- 7:16in England, and they have their own challenges,
- 7:16England, and they have their own challenges, believe
- 7:18believe me, they do, maybe more than so
- 7:18me, they do, maybe more than so many
- 7:21many other people.
- 7:21other people.
- 7:23We talked about courage and wisdom, and the
- 7:23We talked about courage and wisdom, and the
- 7:26the necessity of
- 7:27necessity of both.
- 7:30You need to have courage first in order
- 7:32to develop wisdom.
- 7:35And so many people, very, very great people,
- 7:37hope took a hold of that.
- 7:40Courage, what does it mean?
- 7:42Well, some say the ability to act rationally
- 7:45in the face of fear, other say, well,
- 7:48it's a mental or moral strength to venture,
- 7:52persevere, withstand danger, fear, or difficulty.
- 7:55Uh, famously Nelson Mandela, who I adore in
- 7:58terms of his writings and what he what
- 8:02he went through, define courage as not the
- 8:05absence of fear, but the overcoming and the
- 8:08dealing with the fear that comes along with
- 8:11trials in our lives.
- 8:15So I think that's a great, great definition.
- 8:18Um, but you we really need to start
- 8:23with courage in handling and affronting, affronting suffering.
- 8:27It enables individuals to act decisively, despise uh
- 8:31despite fear, and moving towards problems rather than
- 8:34avoiding them.
- 8:38And then from there, there's deeper perspectives, much
- 8:42deeper perspectives into, and hence the wisdom, uh,
- 8:46into um what suffering is all about.
- 8:50Yeah, it disrupts our daily routines for sure,
- 8:53but it forces reflection and a deeper understandings
- 8:57of life's really true, true priorities.
- 9:00It helps to foster emotional maturity.
- 9:05And um, yeah, and as I said, it
- 9:08was uh my understanding and just thinking about
- 9:12this for so long, is that wisdom is
- 9:15a result of courage, i.e., courage is a
- 9:19requirement for wisdom by acting is a very,
- 9:22very powerful, albeit painful by definition, painful catalyst
- 9:26that breaks down illusions, it forces introspection, it
- 9:29fosters deep emotional and intellectual shifts that comfort
- 9:33cannot produce.
- 9:36So, you know, you know, the saying, uh,
- 9:39don't stay in your comfort zone, or or
- 9:42this has pushed me or pushed you or
- 9:45pushed us out of our comfort zone.
- 9:47What does that mean?
- 9:48Well, comfort zone is exactly that, but out
- 9:52of the comfort zone means something, some some
- 9:56type of suffering, some type of discomfort, some
- 9:59type of uh challenge, challenge, if you will.
- 10:03So that is a long introduction.
- 10:07I know it is, but let me go
- 10:10into the Christian angle, because we were uh
- 10:13we were talking about this the last time.
- 10:17We'll talk about the Jewish angle too in
- 10:18a little bit.
- 10:20So Pope John Paul II, uh, he wrote
- 10:24uh a treatise, an apostolic uh letter, entitled,
- 10:27quote, The Christian Meaning of Human Suffering, end
- 10:30of quote.
- 10:34Uh this was delivered at Rome four decades
- 10:38ago in 1984, and he extremely eloquently, I
- 10:42think, wrote and stated, quote, human suffering has
- 10:46reached its culmination in the passion of Christ.
- 10:50And at the same time, it has entered
- 10:54into a completely new dimension and new order.
- 10:58It has been linked to love, that love
- 11:01which creates good, drawing it out by means
- 11:04of suffering, just as the supreme good of
- 11:07the redemption of the world was drawn from
- 11:10the cross of Christ and from that cross
- 11:13constantly takes its beginning.
- 11:17End of quote.
- 11:18So the interpretation of that statement for myself,
- 11:21and I would say that this is uh
- 11:24again a Christian as opposed to purely uh
- 11:27Catholic angle, um, that um for myself, it's
- 11:31that we're invited to share in the suffering
- 11:34of Christ.
- 11:38And uh, by our will and through our
- 11:40own suffering, through our own suffering, sharing in
- 11:43the suffering that Christ did uh as he
- 11:46as he was murdered.
- 11:49Therefore, uh, as for Frankel and she meaning,
- 11:51meaning is found in suffering in this particular
- 11:54sense.
- 11:57So uh he wrote, or in the Bible
- 12:00from Peter chapter one, verse 6, 7.
- 12:03Now for a little while, if necessary, ye
- 12:06have been distressed by various trials, that the
- 12:09proof of your faith being more precious than
- 12:12gold, which is perishable, even though tested by
- 12:15fire, may be found to result in praise
- 12:19and glory and honor at the revelation of
- 12:22Jesus Christ.
- 12:25So my interpretation, just as precious metals uh
- 12:28need to be purified by heat, uh heat
- 12:32of a fire and dramatic heat.
- 12:35Uh so life's trials as an analogy here.
- 12:38Life's trials in general and suffering for Christ
- 12:42in particular, build strength into our soul.
- 12:46So noble characters, it doesn't happen, a noble
- 12:49character doesn't happen by accidents.
- 12:53Rather, it's built, it's a process.
- 12:56And out of the fires of suffering, the
- 12:59human spirit really will emerge as precious as
- 13:02gold and as strong as steel.
- 13:05And it's really, really true.
- 13:07Just think about that.
- 13:08I I think it really is.
- 13:11So from a Christian viewpoint, uh, Jesus' suffering
- 13:15on the cross directly, directly parallels human suffering
- 13:19by oh my goodness, by assuming it's physical,
- 13:23it's emotional, it's spiritual weight, it transforms transforms
- 13:27suffering from a meaningless consequence, if you will,
- 13:31of sin into a redemptive act that connects
- 13:35humanity with God.
- 13:40And that's really the Christian interpretation.
- 13:43So Jesus experienced physical torture.
- 13:47He definitely experienced emotional torture, social betrayal, humiliation,
- 13:52and abandonment, abandonment by God, spiritual abandonment.
- 13:58And he had a Calvary, Calvary Road, and
- 14:00Calvary, Calvary Road, and so the Christians or
- 14:03um so the Christians or a Christian myself
- 14:04a Christian myself believe this offers companionship in
- 14:08believe this offers companionship in our own pain.
- 14:08our own pain.
- 14:13That is paralleling it to the pain of
- 14:13That is paralleling it to the pain of
- 14:15Jesus.
- 14:15Jesus.
- 14:17So suffering is a union, not punishment.
- 14:17So suffering is a union, not punishment.
- 14:20But instead of seeing suffering merely as a
- 14:20But instead of seeing suffering merely as a
- 14:22result of a broken world, um, Christian believers,
- 14:23result of a broken world, um Christian believers,
- 14:25not only Catholics, but Christians are invited to
- 14:26not only Catholics, but Christians are invited to
- 14:27see it.
- 14:28see it and to be honest with you
- 14:31all, all individuals, no matter what the religion,
- 14:34uh to see it as an intimate connection
- 14:37with Christ's own agony and allowing them to
- 14:40know him deeply rather than just academically or
- 14:43tangentially.
- 14:46So is the cross a prototype of love?
- 14:48I would say yes.
- 14:50Suffering is portrayed as a profound opportunity to
- 14:54uh imitate Jesus and to be with Jesus.
- 14:58Um trials occur, the Christian response can shift
- 15:02from fear to love, dreading to love, offering
- 15:05pain, the pain of the suffering for others,
- 15:09and giving it to Jesus.
- 15:13So solidarity with a suffering God, uh Jesus
- 15:17as God, God the Son, uh yes, the
- 15:21transformative power of taking up the cross.
- 15:25So active faith transforms daily struggles into redemptive
- 15:27suffering.
- 15:30Um and this was has been taught and
- 15:34has been written about for ages now.
- 15:37Uh and what it means is choosing to
- 15:41act with love and perseverance, even when circumstances
- 15:44are painful and stressful and challenging.
- 15:48Uh uh that's the key, rather than being
- 15:50passively defeated by them and being the victim,
- 15:53so to speak.
- 15:56So is suffering part of God's plan and
- 15:58stewardship?
- 16:00Yeah, it is, yes.
- 16:02Pain is presented, but on the other hand,
- 16:05the angle that that Christians take, and we
- 16:08should take, all of us, even non-Christians, as
- 16:11is presented as a gift.
- 16:14I as ironic as that sounds, uh, but
- 16:17it can be used for spiritual growth for
- 16:21all types of growth, strengthening uh one's ability
- 16:24to confront others and situations.
- 16:28So it's transformative, in fact.
- 16:30Um Christ did not remove suffering.
- 16:34He did not ask for suffering.
- 16:37He knew that he would have to suffer,
- 16:40but he entered into it and he transformed
- 16:43it into a path towards resurrection and ascension
- 16:46into heaven and an eternal life.
- 16:50So uh I am going to go to
- 16:52other more mundane uh aspects of suffering in
- 16:55just a bit at the other end of
- 16:57our commercial.
- 17:00So stay with us, and we will be
- 17:01with you shortly.
- 17:03I cannot tell a lie.
- 17:04My sinuses are blocked.
- 17:06George, you crossed the Delaware.
- 17:08You can cross congestion here.
- 17:11Try clear.
- 17:14Freedom smells like victory, my fellow Americans.
- 17:19You are formally invited to join us in
- 17:22a nationwide celebration of freedom, unity, and the
- 17:24American spirit.
- 17:28Mark your calendars and join the America Out
- 17:32Loud 25010 celebration by visiting WW DotomaticaOutloud.news slash
- 17:36live 250 as we celebrate America together.
- 17:40Right from your home.
- 17:41That's WWW.
- 17:44America Outloud.news slash live 250.
- 17:49Successful weight loss is about changing the gut
- 17:51brain relationship with food.
- 17:53I'm Dr.
- 17:54Kelly Victory with the wellness company.
- 17:56If you don't like needles, you'll love oral
- 17:58dissolving terzepitide RX.
- 18:00Works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors
- 18:03that influence appetite and metabolism.
- 18:06And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing sublingual
- 18:09tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an
- 18:12energy boost of B6 and B12.
- 18:15Visit TWC.
- 18:26Using cellular absorption technology, we put vitamins A,
- 18:29C, D, Zinc, and Quircetin together with a
- 18:33multi-mineral complex for complete protection.
- 18:36The Daily V stack is basically an oral
- 18:38IV of six products all in one at
- 18:40an affordable price.
- 18:43Go to ChemicalfreeBody.com forward slash out loud, get
- 18:45the Daily V stack, protect yourself, boost your
- 18:48immune system, and save 20% on your first
- 18:51order.
- 18:55Never before has our American cultural, economic, spiritual,
- 18:59and political fabric been more threatening.
- 19:03Well, the America most of us have grown
- 19:05up with love under a relentless and pernicious
- 19:08siege from those carrying the banners of socialism,
- 19:11communism, and Marxism.
- 19:14America outlaw.
- 19:21America out loud dot news is that place
- 19:23to awaken your heart, soul, and mind to
- 19:26the outlook truth.
- 19:34Welcome back to the countermomentum of spin.
- 19:38We've been talking about different aspects of suffering.
- 19:41We just finished with uh the prior side
- 19:45here on uh Christian interpretation of it.
- 19:48But there are many other angles in terms
- 19:51of viewing it, interpreting it in terms of
- 19:54uh understanding it, taking it in, uh looking
- 19:57at the good of it, the meaning, the
- 20:00purpose, etc.
- 20:03So as a physician, it's really important for
- 20:07me to grasp not only the physical part
- 20:11of a disease and particularly either a painful
- 20:15disease or um very serious disease that may
- 20:18end in death or often does, uh, but
- 20:22treating the emotional aspects of serious diseases.
- 20:26So the angle, what I'm getting at is
- 20:29the angle of cultural differences.
- 20:32So cultures and religions around the world define
- 20:36and interpret suffering in different ways.
- 20:40And this is really, really interesting.
- 20:43It's actually fascinating.
- 20:44So the ancient leaders of all religions have
- 20:47their unique understanding of suffering for the from
- 20:50their own prisms, if you will.
- 20:53As an example, Buddha uh from the Buddhist
- 20:57religion taught that suffering is quote, the first
- 21:00Suffering is quote the first rule of life,
- 21:00rule of life, end of quote.
- 21:02end of quote.
- 21:04So as an example here, the terrible 9.0
- 21:05So as an example here, the terrible 9.0
- 21:08earthquake uh on the Richter scale and subsequent
- 21:08earthquake on the Richter scale and subsequent tsunami
- 21:11tsunami that stroke uh struck Japan in March
- 21:11that stroke uh struck Japan in March 2011,
- 21:142011.
- 21:14it was awful.
- 21:17It was awful.
- 21:18Over 2,000, no, I'm sorry, 20,000, 20,000 dead,
- 21:18Over 2,000, no, I'm sorry, 20,000, 20,000 dead,
- 21:212,500 lost, and ultimately deceased, and over 6,000
- 21:212,500 lost and ultimately deceased, and over 6,000
- 21:24injured.
- 21:24injured.
- 21:28It highlighted an example of.
- 21:28It highlighted an example of the Buddhist tenets
- 21:30of interdependence.
- 21:33So the suffering of one is the suffering
- 21:36of everyone.
- 21:38And the suffering of everyone is the suffering
- 21:39of one.
- 21:41Just think about that.
- 21:43So in terms of language of pain, if
- 21:46you look at still, we're going to talk
- 21:50about the Stoics of the ancient Greek culture,
- 21:53versus versus outright expression.
- 21:57So keep calm and carry on.
- 21:59Remember that?
- 22:00Keep calm and carry on.
- 22:01Where does that come from?
- 22:02So the British, the British throne, in fact,
- 22:04uh, I was going to say uh Prince
- 22:07Charles, no, King Charles mentioned that in his
- 22:09speech at the White House, keep calm and
- 22:11carry on, versus audible grief.
- 22:14So contrasting cultures, the value of being a
- 22:17stoic, so Eastern Asia, typically, typically, not always,
- 22:20but Eastern Asia and British are considered to
- 22:24be very stoic.
- 22:27Uh uh with those that, although, although, and
- 22:31especially in comparison with those that encourage public
- 22:36emotional expression, Mediterraneans, Middle Easterns, for example.
- 22:40So this is I I don't want to
- 22:43call it DNA, but it's the uh the
- 22:45nurture part, uh, that is that uh it's
- 22:48learned by seeing, learned by doing.
- 22:51It's it's a cultural thing.
- 22:53How do we describe pain?
- 22:55Well, different cultures use different metaphors to describe
- 22:56pain.
- 22:58How how can alter, which can really alter,
- 23:01I'm sorry, how it's treated and how it's
- 23:04looked at and how it's felt.
- 23:07So suffering is karma.
- 23:10We look at uh Hindu, Hindu tradition, suffering
- 23:13is karma versus social injustice.
- 23:15So some cultures view suffering as a personal
- 23:18test or a karma.
- 23:20We did something bad and we're getting punished.
- 23:24So it's something to be endured, while other
- 23:26while others see it as a an external
- 23:28problem to be solved.
- 23:31So that has its inherent problems too.
- 23:35Looking at it mathematically, looking at it, I
- 23:38mean sometimes it's okay, sometimes it's okay.
- 23:42There's certain types of suffering, true, but looking
- 23:45at it totally pragmatically, um, yes, it takes
- 23:48away the religious aspect, or can you can
- 23:51you mix somehow both of them?
- 23:54Uh I think you possibly can, being pragmatic
- 23:57and being being religious too.
- 24:00But if you look at it in a
- 24:03completely worldly way, an a Christian or a
- 24:07religious way, all right, non-religious, non-Christian, non-anything, but
- 24:10but look at it only in terms of
- 24:13um the day-to-day activities and and again, worldly
- 24:17kind of mindset.
- 24:20It's not, I don't think it's gonna get
- 24:22us very far.
- 24:23So the Buddhist perspective, let's get back to
- 24:24that.
- 24:26The Buddhist perspective on suffering as an accepted
- 24:29part of existence.
- 24:32I think that's very important versus the the
- 24:35typically, typically, or at least stereotyped Western view
- 24:37of suffering as kind of an unnecessary interruption
- 24:40to life.
- 24:43Well, do all Westerners look at it that
- 24:45way.
- 24:46No, not at all.
- 24:47Not at all.
- 24:48But at least the reputation is there, especially
- 24:51among Chinese and the Asians, that this is
- 24:55how Westerners, although now if you look at
- 24:58Asia, it's becoming pretty West or Western.
- 25:02But but at least that's the depiction as
- 25:05to how Westerners um deal with it.
- 25:08Now, we mentioned the cultural differences.
- 25:12We're talking about that, but it's a human
- 25:15experience, it's a universal human experience, the way
- 25:19it's perceived, expressed, managed.
- 25:22It's heavily shaped by our cultural worldviews, how
- 25:26we were brought up, our values, our traditions.
- 25:29So culture also provides the tools, the tools
- 25:33to make sense of suffering.
- 25:36Believe it or not, it does, no matter
- 25:38where we come from.
- 25:40So it influences whether it's seen as a
- 25:42crisis to be avoided, or an accepted part
- 25:45of life, or or sometimes uh a mix,
- 25:48if you will.
- 25:51So positive versus negative construct, some cultures, so
- 25:55Chinese via uh Confucian interpretation, and then you
- 25:59add the Buddhist influences, they perceive suffering.
- 26:04Actually, you extend it out as an opportunity
- 26:07for spiritual growth and self-improvement, or the balancing
- 26:10of karma.
- 26:13And I like that, even as a Christian,
- 26:15I like that.
- 26:17Conversely, again, the more mundane secular Western modern
- 26:20cultures view suffering as solely as a negative,
- 26:23a negative experience that should be minimized or
- 26:27removed.
- 26:30Well, yes, many look at it that way,
- 26:33but as I said before, I don't think
- 26:35that's going to be very fruitful.
- 26:38I really, really don't.
- 26:40We'll talk about ways of dealing, dealing with
- 26:42suffering uh a little bit later.
- 26:45So collectivist cultures, they view suffering as a
- 26:49shared, some of them, a shared social experiences.
- 26:53So that's interesting, and many do, but while
- 26:57individualist cultures, like like here in the United
- 27:00States, focus on an individual's subjective experience of
- 27:03pain.
- 27:07And uh, yes, we're here to help each
- 27:10other, but much less than in other countries
- 27:13and other other cultures.
- 27:16So cultures differ sometimes tremendously when they look
- 27:19at the cause of pain, uh, whether it's
- 27:22it's inside the body, biomedical model, or broken
- 27:25social relationships, or then you bring in the
- 27:28religious aspect.
- 27:31So I like this a lot, stoicism versus
- 27:33expressivism.
- 27:36Stoicism, the Stoics were a group of philosophers
- 27:39in ancient Greece, and um a lot of
- 27:43what they said was was interesting, and you
- 27:46would say, well, England, the the stereotype England,
- 27:50UK, took from them, or many, many Americans
- 27:53as well, as opposed to expressivists who uh,
- 27:57you know, uh what is the term?
- 28:00What is the term?
- 28:01You you hang yourself on your sleeve or
- 28:01You hang yourself on your sleeve or your
- 28:03your emotions on your sleeve, kind of with
- 28:03emotions on your sleeve, kind of with the
- 28:05expressivist.
- 28:05the expressivists, and could there be an intermingling
- 28:08And could there be an intermingling of the
- 28:08of the two?
- 28:09two?
- 28:10No, usually not.
- 28:10No, usually not.
- 28:12But some cultures, as we mentioned, those in
- 28:12But some cultures, as we mentioned, those in
- 28:14East Asia or parts of Europe.
- 28:15East Asia or parts of Europe, yes, parts
- 28:16Yes, parts of Europe, if you look particularly
- 28:18of Europe, if you look particularly at Eastern
- 28:20at Eastern Europe, uh, and again, England and
- 28:20Europe, uh, and again, England and UK, may
- 28:23emphasize stoicism, that is enduring pain silently and
- 28:24UK, may emphasize stoicism, that is enduring pain
- 28:26bravely.
- 28:27silently and bravely as a virtue.
- 28:31So you remember the adage here that little
- 28:33children, little boys, you know, you're a man.
- 28:37Take it, take it as a man, even
- 28:38though you're a little boy.
- 28:40Um, well, it partly goes along with the
- 28:42with stoicism.
- 28:44Now, the Mediterranean cultures, or or yes, the
- 28:48Mideast for sure, uh, are much more open
- 28:51and encouraging the expression of pain.
- 28:56Well, there's problems with that too, but through
- 28:58vocalizations, through crying, yeah, that crying is good,
- 29:01and sharing with others.
- 29:04The thing is that you don't want to
- 29:06be a victim and then uh or act
- 29:08as a victim because that's gonna that's gonna
- 29:09backfire on you.
- 29:12So uh somatization, certain cultures like yes, Mediterranean,
- 29:15uh Eastern uh or Middle East and Latin
- 29:19American cultures, they express these emotional and emotional
- 29:23distress through physical well, yeah, sometimes, and I
- 29:26see this through physical symptoms.
- 29:30That's not good either.
- 29:31That's very, very unhealthy healthy somatization rather than
- 29:34verbally expressing the emotional pain.
- 29:37So it's better than verbally express it rather
- 29:40than internalize it to the point that it's
- 29:42gonna physically make you sick.
- 29:45Now, active versus passive coping.
- 29:50Yes, there's differences.
- 29:52Some groups, like Hispanics and African Americans may
- 29:55rely more heavily on prayer and spirituality, uh
- 29:57to cope.
- 30:00I uh, you know, I'm I'm categorizing, I
- 30:04am uh profiling different cultures, and I I
- 30:07really don't mean to do that.
- 30:10These are again vast, vast, vast generalizations, okay.
- 30:17Uh, but so yeah, the Hispanics and African
- 30:20Americans, prayer and spirituality, while others typically caucasian
- 30:24Americans that they may prefer relying on medical
- 30:28professionals, you know, and and interventions and medications.
- 30:32Sometimes that's worthwhile to do at times, but
- 30:35not always.
- 30:38Now, we have the no pain, no gain.
- 30:40I do martial arts, and my instructor always
- 30:42tells me, I don't know if he's listening
- 30:44here, no pain, no gain.
- 30:46Well, got to be careful with that, because
- 30:49you could have pain, physical pain when you're
- 30:51working out, and and it could be counterproductive,
- 30:54and in fact, hurt you for the rest
- 30:56of your life.
- 30:59So, no pain, no gain versus relief.
- 31:01So, some societies normalize, they even romanticize suffering.
- 31:06We talked about this a little bit, but
- 31:09the Buddhists, yeah, the Buddhists, um, but in
- 31:12the context of of relationships, work, fate, other
- 31:15uh prioritize rapid pain, relief, the opposite of
- 31:18that.
- 31:22So, so there's differences, and health care practitioners,
- 31:25me, physicians and physician assistance, and there's practitioners,
- 31:29etc.
- 31:34Really, it's important for us to provide culturally
- 31:36sensitive care to avoid undertreating or misinterpreting a
- 31:39patient's pain.
- 31:42And not only that, you don't have to
- 31:45be a healthcare provider on anyone who deals
- 31:47anyone in life, and and you're dealing with
- 31:50other individuals, and in terms of interpreting and
- 31:53helping them, helping them through that, uh, and
- 31:55I think it's it's extremely important to do
- 31:58that.
- 32:01You need to put the lens of culture
- 32:03as well when you're in when you're trying
- 32:05to help them.
- 32:07So that is how are they interpreting this?
- 32:10So this kind of it dovetails and the
- 32:15segue is for good versus evil.
- 32:20Good versus evil, good being good, evil being
- 32:23is evil equivalent to suffering.
- 32:26Well, suffering in many ways can be evil,
- 32:30or at least the evil can result in
- 32:33suffering, and how do we how do we
- 32:36deal with that?
- 32:40How do we study that?
- 32:41How do we internalize that?
- 32:43So it's plagued humankind since we as humans
- 32:46have been on this earth and even prehistoric
- 32:50times, uh in terms of our cavemen and
- 32:54such, thinking, thinking things through, in my opinion.
- 32:58So grasping the meaning of horrible acts, tragedies,
- 33:02violence, etc.
- 33:05etc.
- 33:07It's beyond our comprehension.
- 33:10And are they our quote-unquote cross as individuals
- 33:14or large groups of individuals, um, and situations
- 33:17that we cannot understand, nor are we supposed
- 33:21to understand?
- 33:26Why do tragedies happen, especially to very good
- 33:28people?
- 33:30How do we reconcile a positive or strengthening
- 33:35in the face of true tragedy?
- 33:40So let me go back to religion, Judeo-Christian
- 33:44theology, God allows evil to exist, not because
- 33:48he caused it, but as a temporary permitted
- 33:51consequence of granting humans free will, and to
- 33:55ultimately manifest his glory through redemption.
- 33:58Now, if you will, that's the party line,
- 34:02and I don't want to be blasphemous, but
- 34:05uh uh how do you console a poor
- 34:08parent who's lost their child by a drunk
- 34:11driver or by uh by a criminal murdering,
- 34:14causing rampant murder, you know, uh it it
- 34:17doesn't make sense, does it?
- 34:21But sitting down and thinking, um, you know,
- 34:24evil, uh, some theologians would say it's understood
- 34:28not as a created entity, but as a
- 34:31deficiency or a rot in a created good,
- 34:34created good, being the kingdom of God.
- 34:38So um this allows for the existence of
- 34:41love, compassion, and grace.
- 34:44Now, I personally have trouble with this, but
- 34:47free will and genuine love, God created humans
- 34:51with free will, yes, yes, and it's necessary
- 34:54for genuine love and relationships, but this capacity
- 34:57for choice inherently includes the potential for turning
- 35:00Inherently includes the potential for turning away from
- 35:01away from good, and which is the root
- 35:02good and which is the root of moral
- 35:04of moral evil.
- 35:05evil.
- 35:08So, yes, I understand that.
- 35:08So yes, I understand that.
- 35:10I do understand that.
- 35:10I do understand that, but again, getting back
- 35:11But again, getting back to these terrible tragedies
- 35:12to these terrible tragedies which can occur, does
- 35:14which can occur, does it explain them?
- 35:14it explain them?
- 35:17No.
- 35:17No.
- 35:17I in my estimation.
- 35:17I I, in my estimation.
- 35:19So many theologians believe God allowed evil to
- 35:19So many theologians believe God allowed evil to
- 35:21exist because he can ultimately bring a greater
- 35:21exist because he can ultimately bring a greater
- 35:24good out of it, such as mercy, forgiveness,
- 35:24good out of it, such as mercy, forgiveness,
- 35:26salvation.
- 35:26salvation.
- 35:29So that.
- 35:29So that makes more sense to me.
- 35:32And God's glory is displayed through his acts
- 35:35of redemption, yes, in the face of suffering,
- 35:37yes.
- 35:41So without evil and aspects of God's character,
- 35:44we talked about grace, mercy, and compassion, they
- 35:47could not be demonstrated, some experts say.
- 35:51So the Bible and many of the great
- 35:54holy books describe evil as kind of an
- 35:58intruder or a parasite, if you will, that
- 36:01corrupts, it corrupts once good creation through human
- 36:04rebellion.
- 36:08So the human rebellion is the intruder of
- 36:10the parasite.
- 36:12So it leads to a fallen world where
- 36:13suffering exists.
- 36:15But does that explain, is that a good
- 36:18explanation?
- 36:21Um, it's a partial explanation.
- 36:24Do I buy it?
- 36:25I don't.
- 36:27But it is an explanation.
- 36:30So the cross and the resurrection.
- 36:33Uh and notice, notice that we're talking about
- 36:36religion, because to be very honest with you,
- 36:38uh, how else do you deal with these
- 36:40terrible, terrible, terrible tragedies in my in my
- 36:43mind?
- 36:46Uh I don't know how else.
- 36:48But so Christianity teaches that that God does
- 36:51not remain detached from suffering, especially tragedies, but
- 36:54rather entered it through Jesus Christ.
- 36:57Jesus Christ, God the Son, God the Father,
- 37:00and God the Holy Spirit.
- 37:02So it demonstrated victory over evil and promising
- 37:06its ultimate uh elimination by being by resurrecting
- 37:11and ultimately ascending into heaven.
- 37:15So, yeah, that's an interpretation is part of
- 37:17the story part, and we're gonna at the
- 37:20other side, boy, time goes by fast, doesn't
- 37:22it?
- 37:24Um, we're gonna keep on with this and
- 37:27try to get to these foundations and try
- 37:29to wrap our our brains around it in
- 37:31just a couple of minutes.
- 37:34So hold tight.
- 37:35Moral hygiene hasn't changed in 50 years, but
- 37:38our diet and the way we eat has
- 37:41creating an environment in your mouth for bacteria
- 37:44to wreck havoc on your teeth and gums
- 37:47for better oral health, get sprayed, dental defense,
- 37:49an oral care line designed to combat acid
- 37:52creating bacteria, the toothpaste, mouthwash, mints, and gum,
- 37:55all contain xylitol, and natural ingredients shown to
- 37:58dramatically improve oral health.
- 38:01Sprite can be found online and at all
- 38:03fine natural retailers.
- 38:07Welcome back.
- 38:08Welcome back.
- 38:08We've been talking about some not so simple
- 38:11issues here, but uh you know, trying to
- 38:14take a bull by the horns, if you
- 38:17will, we're just finishing about Judeo-Christian theology and
- 38:20good versus evil, and yeah, it's explained as
- 38:23a fundamental moral dichotomy where good is defined
- 38:25by the character and will of an absolute
- 38:28sovereign God, while evil is a distortion, a
- 38:31privation, a rebellion against that goodness, if you
- 38:34will, the devil, the devil uh uh coming
- 38:37in.
- 38:40So evil is not viewed as an independent
- 38:43force in the Judeo-Christian theology, co-equal with God,
- 38:47but rather a corruption of what was uh
- 38:50created good, what was created good, and stemming
- 38:54from that misuse of free will by spiritual
- 38:57and human agents.
- 39:01So God is the supreme standard of goodness.
- 39:06Everything created was originally declared as quote, very
- 39:09good, Genesis 131.
- 39:12Goodness promotes life, harmony, and obedience to divine
- 39:14commands.
- 39:16Evil, on the other hand, is a severe
- 39:18corruption.
- 39:20It's rather rather than a physical thing created
- 39:23by God, evil is often understood as the
- 39:26absence or spoiling of good, similar to how
- 39:29darkness is the absence of light or sickness
- 39:32is the absence of health.
- 39:35Now, are there subtleties between Judaism and Christianity?
- 39:41Yeah, yes, traditional Jewish thought, evil is often
- 39:45understood through uh evil inclination.
- 39:49So, which is not an external demonic force,
- 39:52but an internal instinct that misuses good things.
- 39:56So turning turning the need for food into
- 39:58gluttony as an example.
- 40:00Satan is used uh viewed not as God's
- 40:03enemy, but as a heavenly prosecutor who tests
- 40:05humanity.
- 40:08Christianity, on the other hand, places a stronger
- 40:11emphasis on Satan as a personalized force of
- 40:14evil and uh opposing God.
- 40:17So sin is seen as a condition that
- 40:20separates humanity from God, requiring redemption, uh, which
- 40:23is found through Jesus Christ, who died to
- 40:26destroy the power of evil.
- 40:29So in summary, Judeo-Christian perspective, it's not dualistic,
- 40:33meaning uh good and evil are not co-equals,
- 40:37if you will, or competing powers.
- 40:42Instead, it's monotheistic.
- 40:44There's one God.
- 40:45God, uh, at least from the Christian standpoint,
- 40:48God the Father, God the Son, God the
- 40:51Holy Spirit, but believing that God is supreme
- 40:54and that evil, while very powerful, uh is
- 40:57present, it's will be defeated and will one
- 40:59day be fully eliminated.
- 41:03Now, tips to handle suffering.
- 41:08So what do I do?
- 41:10What do others do?
- 41:11Or what would be advice from psychologists, from
- 41:14philosophers, from theologians?
- 41:18Vincent van Gogh, Vincent Van Gogh, this is
- 41:20a good example.
- 41:22He's the epitome, was the epitome of suffering.
- 41:25Um I think one of his most beautiful
- 41:28paintings called Alum, uh Almond Blossom, 1980, one
- 41:32of the most beautiful.
- 41:35Uh he was describing while he was painting
- 41:38it, that despite his mental anguish, um, so
- 41:41he he himself was mentioning that he's produced
- 41:44so many works, and they were not considered
- 41:46famous works.
- 41:49And most artists, you know, they become famous
- 41:51after they die.
- 41:53So the um this painting that I mentioned,
- 41:57the almond blossom, it was produced when um,
- 42:00And blossom it was produced when um or
- 42:01or painted the year that he shot himself.
- 42:02painted the year that he shot himself and
- 42:04And his last words were famous last words
- 42:05his last words were famous last words la
- 42:08la trites, tristesse dura toujours in French.
- 42:08tritesse tristesse durera toujours in French.
- 42:11So the sadness will go on forever.
- 42:11So the sadness will go on forever.
- 42:13Yes, he did have emotional psychiatric issues, meaning
- 42:13Yes, he did have emotional psychiatric issues, meaning
- 42:16severe depression, but that which led, of course,
- 42:16severe depression, but that which led, of course,
- 42:20to severe suffering.
- 42:20to severe suffering.
- 42:24But did Van Gogh produce great art because
- 42:24But did Van Gogh produce great art because
- 42:25of his suffering, or did he produce great
- 42:26of his suffering, or did he produce great
- 42:27suffering?
- 42:28suffering, a great uh art because uh in
- 42:31spite of it?
- 42:34Um, don't know.
- 42:36But why is bad luck slash suffering so
- 42:39indiscriminate?
- 42:42Why do people, good people in particular suffer?
- 42:45So Boethas was a Christian philosopher in the
- 42:47late Roman world.
- 42:50Uh he was born in 480 AD, died
- 42:52in uh boy, he was young, he died
- 42:55at the age of 42 at 524 AD.
- 42:58He saw suffering as being an ultimate good.
- 43:03He was a philosopher, senator, historian, counsel.
- 43:07Um, but he went, he came across very
- 43:09bad luck, if you will.
- 43:11He he was wrongly accused of treason, condemned
- 43:14to the fate of torture and execution.
- 43:18But he wrote a book while in jail,
- 43:22the consolation of philosophy, the consolation of philosophy.
- 43:26And he could not reconcile senseless suffering with
- 43:28a benevolent and all-knowing God, just as we've
- 43:31been talking about.
- 43:34So he theorized that bad fortune exists, but
- 43:37it exists to either test good people or
- 43:40punish bad people, and therefore has an intrinsic
- 43:43and cosmic meaning.
- 43:47So that that is interesting.
- 43:49So everything that happens, Boethas reasoned, happens for
- 43:51the better.
- 43:54The the quote-unquote consolation that Bohethas offers himself
- 43:57and to everyone else is that suffering is
- 44:00part of that ultimate good.
- 44:05So good and bad is not a matter
- 44:07of circumstance, it's driven by a divine plan,
- 44:09what we call providence.
- 44:11So he wrote, since all fortune, whether sweet
- 44:15or bitter, has as its purpose the reward
- 44:18or trial of good men, or the correction
- 44:22and punishment of the wicked.
- 44:25It must be good because it is clearly
- 44:28either just or useful.
- 44:30So that's interesting.
- 44:33That's an interesting view, I think, a very
- 44:35interesting view.
- 44:37So tips to handle and temper suffering.
- 44:42There are.
- 44:50Suffering is optional.
- 44:52Uh no, no, but pain is inevitable.
- 44:56Suffering is is we talked about in the
- 44:59first show is our interpretation, our reaction, our
- 45:03emotional and physiologic reaction.
- 45:07But we need to acknowledge that while pain,
- 45:09be it heartbreak, illness, loss, it happens to
- 45:12everyone.
- 45:14Suffering is the prolonged, compounding mental resistance to
- 45:18that pain.
- 45:22So, yes, we can temper suffering somewhat by
- 45:24keeping that in mind.
- 45:26So the takeaway is that how to separate
- 45:29the raw emotion of the event from the
- 45:32destructive ongoing uh stories or uh that they
- 45:35tell themselves about it.
- 45:39So that these other people or ourselves that
- 45:41we ruminate, if you will, over it.
- 45:44So another one is acceptance of suffering as
- 45:47a starting point.
- 45:50So the power of radical acceptance, facing reality
- 45:54exactly exactly as it is.
- 45:57So rather than fighting it, and that's a
- 45:59good, I think a good point.
- 46:01So you can't learn from or heal a
- 46:04situation over which you have no control, and
- 46:07you refuse to accept.
- 46:10So that acceptance does not mean agreeing with
- 46:13or or condoning a painful situation, but modifying
- 46:17it and and understanding as much as you
- 46:20can, and basically dealing with it.
- 46:24So another one is seek the silver lining.
- 46:26So that was the title of our first
- 46:27show.
- 46:28And uh, so we want to encourage ourselves.
- 46:33How can I make triumph out of this
- 46:35situation?
- 46:37So the meaning, the purpose and meaning of
- 46:39suffering that Nietzsche was talking about and Frankel
- 46:42was taught they were talking about.
- 46:45Um, what does this experience uh require me
- 46:48to do to deal with this?
- 46:51Um now the teaching points are their teaching
- 46:54points, yeah, reframing suffering as a teacher rather
- 46:57than a punishment.
- 47:01So um what lessons can we uncover?
- 47:05How can hardships teach um expose remaining blind
- 47:08spots that we have and and lead to
- 47:11courage?
- 47:14We talked about and wisdom uh to share
- 47:16with others.
- 47:18Uh yes, would the suffering teach empathy?
- 47:21It definitely, definitely can.
- 47:24Um post-traumatic growth.
- 47:27So there is, yes, post-traumatic stress disorder, and
- 47:31that's very, very real, which became even more
- 47:35highlighted from um military activities in uh Afghanistan,
- 47:39well, Iran, yes, it will, but uh, I
- 47:43don't think is as horrible as Iraq and
- 47:47Afghanistan and prior to that, Vietnam.
- 47:51Can there be post-traumatic growth?
- 47:53Yes.
- 47:54Uh we can emerge from trauma.
- 47:58There's millions of infinite numbers of ways that
- 48:01we as humans can be traumatized, um, with
- 48:04a deeper appreciation for life and strengthening our
- 48:07personal uh values.
- 48:10So, and and getting away from the shell
- 48:13of our ego, getting away from the shell
- 48:15of our ego, I think uh is incredibly
- 48:18important.
- 48:21So, is it that easy to transform suffering
- 48:25into uh into good?
- 48:28No, it's not easy.
- 48:29No, nothing is easy.
- 48:31Uh it's very hard.
- 48:34And asking for a lesson is that easy?
- 48:38No.
- 48:39Investigating the why, no, no, the the why,
- 48:42uh, yeah, that goes along with finding meaning
- 48:45in adversity, and which is a key to
- 48:48resilience and survival.
- 48:52The why we're gonna have a lot of
- 48:55difficulties with that, as for example, Alch and
- 48:59the German concentration camps for the Jews.
- 49:00German concentration camps for the Jews.
- 49:02Now, how can I grow from this?
- 49:02Now, how can I grow from this?
- 49:05Shift from what's happening to me, you know,
- 49:05Shift from what's happening to me, you know,
- 49:08me, but how can I deal with it
- 49:08me, but how can I deal with it
- 49:11and also grow from it?
- 49:11and also grow from it?
- 49:14And I think that's that's a wonderful way.
- 49:14And I think that's that's a wonderful way,
- 49:17I really do of dealing with adversity, dealing
- 49:18I really do, of dealing with adversity, dealing
- 49:20with um with suffering.
- 49:22with um with suffering, and channel our experiences
- 49:24And channel our experiences into helping others, mentoring,
- 49:25into helping others, mentoring, advocacy, uh
- 49:27advocacy, uh, offering empathy, turns uh from the
- 49:30suffering, from what we've learned from the suffering,
- 49:33or as a catalyst for good in the
- 49:37world, as a catalyst for good in our
- 49:40professions, good in our uh, you know, our
- 49:43continuing through life.
- 49:47So I'm gonna share some things which are
- 49:51fascinating, and to uh what others have suffered,
- 49:55the people that we know very well.
- 50:00Have others suffered?
- 50:02My goodness, yes, my goodness, yes.
- 50:06As an example, history's greatest achievers, they've faced
- 50:10profound suffering and setbacks, and uh many of
- 50:14them used adversity to build resistance and drive.
- 50:18So let me give you an example.
- 50:20Oprah Winfrey.
- 50:22She was poor, very poor as a child.
- 50:27She was also fired from her early television
- 50:29jobs.
- 50:31She had uh, I remember she was doing
- 50:33the news in Baltimore years and years ago,
- 50:36as a I don't know if she was
- 50:39an anchor, but uh, but but she turned
- 50:42that around and ultimately gained international and continues
- 50:44to success.
- 50:48Thomas Edison.
- 50:50So he was labeled by his teachers, quote,
- 50:53too stupid to learn.
- 50:56And that's what they wrote on his report
- 50:58card.
- 50:59And uh he was fired from his first
- 51:02two jobs, but famously he failed a thousand
- 51:04times before inventing the light bulb.
- 51:07And then he invented so many other things.
- 51:11And he also took that, you know, he
- 51:13took that countermomentum and he was asked by
- 51:15a reporter.
- 51:16I think I I said this once before,
- 51:18uh, Mr.
- 51:20Edison, uh you've tried so many times on
- 51:23this particular project.
- 51:26I forgot what they were talking about.
- 51:28Um, so you're failing repeatedly.
- 51:32What say you about that?
- 51:34And he says, No, no, I haven't failed.
- 51:37I've just found hundreds and hundreds of ways
- 51:39that it would not work.
- 51:42I think that's excellent, actually.
- 51:44Um Stephen King, you know, the author Stephen
- 51:47King, his first novel, Carrie, it was rejected
- 51:5130 times by many different publishers.
- 51:54And he actually threw it away before his
- 51:56wife.
- 51:58I actually it was not finished, but it
- 52:00was he was about to finish it, but
- 52:02she encouraged him to finish it.
- 52:04And later it sold 350 million copies.
- 52:08Steve Jobs, Stephen Jobs, poor Stephen Jobs, he
- 52:11was fired from Apple.
- 52:14Uh he, the company he founded before returning
- 52:17back to it, making it one of the
- 52:20most valuable corporations in the world.
- 52:23Abraham Lincoln.
- 52:24So I didn't know this, but Abraham Lincoln,
- 52:28uh, he experiences the deaths of his mother,
- 52:32sisters, his girlfriend, sweetheart, along with multiple, multiple
- 52:36business failures, and lost bids for public office
- 52:40before becoming president of the United States.
- 52:44Ronald Reagan, likewise, I remember he he was
- 52:47uh, oh, he was governor of California, but
- 52:49he was trying to get the nomination for
- 52:52the Republican Party, God knows how many times.
- 52:55And ultimately he did.
- 52:57Jeff Bezos, we know him.
- 53:00He's had uh with well, he bought the
- 53:02Washington Post, but he also also Amazon.
- 53:05So he had many, many hardships.
- 53:09He actually um the early days of Amazon,
- 53:11uh, he was trying to raise money, capital,
- 53:14and it he being interviewed, he said it
- 53:17was the hardest thing he's ever done.
- 53:20So he had to convince 60 angel investors,
- 53:2340 of whom said no, then he would
- 53:26near bankruptcy, and Amazon faced a massive crisis,
- 53:30stagnating revenues, etc., family health crisis, his mother
- 53:33passed away, uh after a long fight with
- 53:37Louis Body Dementia.
- 53:40Uh there are there are others, Elon Musk,
- 53:43so we all know Elon Musk.
- 53:46We all know Bill Gates, and but I
- 53:48don't think everyone knows their story.
- 53:51So their stories, Elon Musk fade faced childhood
- 53:53trauma.
- 53:55It was in his book, um, painful professional
- 53:59crises, but he learned from all of them.
- 54:02And lastly, let me talk about uh Albert
- 54:04Einstein.
- 54:06Albert Einstein, he was rejected after graduating in
- 54:091900.
- 54:12He struggled to find academic work.
- 54:15In fact, uh he was not recommended by
- 54:18his professors because he tended to skip classes
- 54:21a lot.
- 54:24So he was working on his theories of
- 54:27relativity, and uh, but yeah, yeah, he skipped
- 54:30uh classes, he had chronic health issues, he
- 54:32was persecuted as a German Jew, and his
- 54:35safety was threatened by the rise of Nazism.
- 54:38Uh he uh of course became the most,
- 54:42if not one of the most famous physicists
- 54:45in in history, along with Stephen Hawking.
- 54:48He faced immense, immense physical and personal suffering
- 54:52throughout his life with ALS, got to a
- 54:56point that he was um paralyzed, completely paralyzed.
- 55:00But his intellectual achievements were absolutely absolutely overwhelming.
- 55:05So I'm gonna conclude.
- 55:08I could talk a lot more, but I'm
- 55:09gonna conclude with this.
- 55:11So the Stoic tradition, we talked about uh
- 55:14it's a philosophy from ancient Greek school of
- 55:16philosophy.
- 55:19It's divided into three really interconnected branches of
- 55:22study, logic, physics, and ethics.
- 55:25But according to the Stoics, the universe is
- 55:27part of God.
- 55:29And as such, the universe and everything that
- 55:31happens within it is perfect.
- 55:34So our understanding is very partial of the
- 55:35universe.
- 55:37It prevents us from seeing the greater good
- 55:40of all things that pass, even things that
- 55:42seem irredeemably awful and terrible.
- 55:45And so they're saying the very similar way
- 55:48that suffering is given a cosmic meaning.
- 55:51Suffering, uh, and if you can take it
- 55:53the analogy of the cross that Christ had
- 55:55to bear.
- 55:57So they taught that what was uh out
- 56:00Was uh out of our control is what
- 56:00of our control is what is least important.
- 56:01is least important.
- 56:03It's our attitude to suffering.
- 56:03It's our attitude to suffering, it's our attitude
- 56:05It's our attitude to suffering, which we can
- 56:06to suffering, which we can control, not the
- 56:07control, not the suffering itself, which we can
- 56:08suffering itself, which we can control.
- 56:09control.
- 56:12So Marcus Aurelius, who's one of the famous
- 56:12So Marcus Aurelius, who's one of the famous
- 56:15Stoics, wrote that the obstacle is the way.
- 56:15Stoics, wrote that the obstacle is the way.
- 56:18What causes us grief can be the source
- 56:18What causes us grief can be the source
- 56:21of valuable lessons.
- 56:21of valuable lessons.
- 56:24And lastly, Jesus also spoke to this too.
- 56:24And lastly, Jesus also spoke to this too.
- 56:28Um, so he said the
- 56:28Um so he said that those who receive
- 56:31the gospel impulsively and for a while endure,
- 56:34but eventually, though, tribulation and persecution arise.
- 56:37And rather quickly the superficial fade away.
- 56:41So as not everyone, or no, no one
- 56:43actually seeks to suffer, honesty compels us to
- 56:46admit that hardships do have value and great
- 56:48value.
- 56:51So thank you so much for listening.
- 56:54I enthusiastically look forward to being with you
- 56:57weekly on the countermomentum of spin, where we
- 57:00will endeavor to address and work towards solving
- 57:03the problems of the world.
- 57:06Please note that this show and all the
- 57:08shows on America Loud Talk Radio, go to
- 57:11your favorite podcast network within 24 hours.
- 57:13Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora, TuneIn, Amazon, iHeartRadio, and
- 57:16among others, many of them.
- 57:19Have a great day, and God bless you.