Latest / The So What? / The Achilles Heel of South Africa: Local Government
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26Hello, and as always, a very warm welcome to
- 0:29another episode of the So What podcast, which
- 0:33always accompanies JP's newsletters. This one
- 0:37is dated June 2026, and the heading, The Achilles'
- 0:42Heel of South Africa, Local Government. We're
- 0:47coming up to elections in, what is it, just under
- 0:50five months? And it is a problem. Is it possible
- 0:56to summarize the core of that problem? Yes, I
- 1:02think it is possible to summarize the core. It
- 1:05is basically about people and institutions. Now,
- 1:09whether you allocate 50 % to people and institutions
- 1:14or 90 -10, that doesn't really matter. It comes
- 1:17down to people, having the wrong people in the
- 1:20wrong places. But it also comes down to institutions
- 1:23not functioning optimally. So the one, people,
- 1:28can be fixed in November with the elections,
- 1:30and that's beyond the scope of this note. But
- 1:33the other one, how institutions function, that
- 1:36is what this note will focus on and what I would
- 1:39like to talk about, because that's where the
- 1:40change can come from. Let's just sketch the background.
- 1:45How many municipalities do we have? In South
- 1:49Africa at large, we have 257. And they basically
- 1:53carpet the country. The whole territory of South
- 1:56Africa is covered by municipalities. Of the 257,
- 2:00eight of them are metros or metropolitan councils,
- 2:03basically in eight big cities. Then there are
- 2:0644 district municipalities and 205 local municipalities.
- 2:11Now, the difference between local and district
- 2:14is that A district consists of a number of local
- 2:17municipalities, and they deliver services, normally
- 2:21bulk services, bulk water, bulk electricity,
- 2:24for a number of municipalities, and then the
- 2:28local municipality is responsible for service
- 2:31delivery in a particular town. So it's local,
- 2:34district, metro. That's the sequence. The metros
- 2:39generate about two -thirds of our GDP and they
- 2:42are home to, what is it, roughly 40 % of the
- 2:45population. Correct. Yet you say most are severely
- 2:49dysfunctional. Absolutely. Why doesn't national
- 2:52or provincial government just step in? That's
- 2:55a very interesting point. And the point is that
- 2:57in terms of our constitution, local government,
- 2:59including metros, enjoy a very particular position
- 3:03and therefore also protection. Local government
- 3:06is not an implementing arm or an administrative
- 3:09agent of national or provincial government. The
- 3:13constitution grants them their own inherent rights
- 3:16of holding elections, of passing legislation
- 3:20and taking decisions. So you can't just barge
- 3:24in and tell them do this or do that. They will
- 3:27tell you to get lost. So when you want to do
- 3:30reform, which is what we're talking about here,
- 3:32you've got to operate within this constitutional
- 3:35constraint. So it's a sphere of government. It's
- 3:38not just an organ of government. That's the status
- 3:42the Constitution gives it. But you say that there
- 3:45is a redesign of the system in the works. Absolutely.
- 3:49Government has published a draft white paper
- 3:51for public comment. Comments, I think, closed
- 3:54at the end of May. And it's now in the process
- 3:57of being finalized. Now, we can't talk in this
- 4:00particular podcast about all the proposals in
- 4:03the draft white paper. But essentially, they
- 4:06want to redesign the entire system. Because I
- 4:08think there's realization that the current system
- 4:11doesn't work. And therefore, you have to change
- 4:13it. It's as simple as that. And that is possible
- 4:16within the Constitution. And it is possible within
- 4:19the Constitution. So the Constitution puts a
- 4:23constraint on national government, but not a
- 4:26complete ban. And you've got to navigate between
- 4:29these two. So in Maine, what are the proposals
- 4:33contained in the draft white paper? First of
- 4:36all, to move to a single -tier system outside
- 4:38the metros. In other words, do away with local
- 4:41government, local municipalities and district
- 4:44municipalities. Abolish that. Move to a one -tier
- 4:47system. Secondly, move away from the one -size
- 4:50-fits -all model which we currently have and
- 4:53allocate different powers to different municipalities
- 4:56depending on their ability to handle functions
- 4:59and to handle responsibilities. So you take,
- 5:03for example, two national functions. The one
- 5:06is housing, the other one is police. In terms
- 5:09of the white paper, it would be possible to delegate
- 5:11some of those functions. to strong enough local
- 5:14municipalities. So do away with one size fits
- 5:18all. Who will determine that? Well, that will
- 5:21have to be a process of negotiation and talking.
- 5:24Indeed, you can't just sit in Pretoria and say
- 5:26you are capable and you're not. So factors like
- 5:30population, income, capacity and so on will all
- 5:34have to be... The way they handle their budget.
- 5:36The way they handle their budgets and so on will
- 5:38all have to be considered. I think the most important
- 5:41suggestion in the draft white paper is that all
- 5:45trading services of municipalities, metros and
- 5:49municipalities, must be ring fenced. Now, what
- 5:52are the trading services? It's water, it's electricity,
- 5:55it's sanitation and waste removal. The things
- 5:59for which municipalities charge a fee. Ring fence
- 6:02those operations. Now, what does ring fencing
- 6:05mean? It simply means that the money, first of
- 6:07all, goes back into those services. You first
- 6:11use it for maintenance, you use it for capital
- 6:13expenditure, you use it to appoint the right
- 6:15people, qualified people who can run those services.
- 6:19And then whatever money is left over after that,
- 6:22that can go into the general pool of municipal
- 6:25income. At the moment, it's the other way around.
- 6:28At the moment, all that money goes into a general
- 6:30pool and it's spent on all kinds of things. Since,
- 6:34what was it, since 2016, we've seen coalitions
- 6:38in more and more of these local governments,
- 6:41and often that seems to be the problem. Is anything
- 6:45happening there? We have, of the 257 municipalities
- 6:49and metros, 66 are run by coalition governments.
- 6:54And as you point out, since 2016, but particularly
- 6:57since 2021, the last time we had local government
- 7:00elections, Our experience with coalitions has
- 7:04not been a happy one. They fall apart, there's
- 7:08constant bickering, people bring motions of no
- 7:11confidence in mayors and speakers, and there's
- 7:15a constant change of leadership. So at the moment
- 7:18there is legislation in Parliament, it's going
- 7:21through the parliamentary processes, to regulate
- 7:23how coalitions must be run. And I think there
- 7:26are a couple of important changes. The first
- 7:29one is, at the moment you have to call the first
- 7:32council meeting and constitute a council within
- 7:3514 days after an election. Now that's a very
- 7:38short period of time. So that's being lengthened
- 7:41to 30 days to enable parties to negotiate a coalition
- 7:45agreement. That coalition agreement must be in
- 7:48writing and it must specify specifically what
- 7:52the coalition government would like to achieve
- 7:55in the next five years of their... for which
- 7:59they've just been elected. And there the thinking
- 8:03is that you want to move parties from an informal
- 8:06political agreement to more of a rules -based
- 8:09order. Now, this has been used by the DA and
- 8:14IFP in KwaZulu -Natal, in coalitions where they
- 8:18share power. And it seems to have worked, not
- 8:21100%, but it seems to have worked reasonably
- 8:23well. It does move parties away from political
- 8:27agreements to rules, which helps. And does it
- 8:31also tie them into the whole five years? They
- 8:35can't decide the week after tomorrow, we don't
- 8:37like you anymore, we're going to choose a new
- 8:39partner. Yes, in a way it does, because there's
- 8:42a limitation on the number of times that no confidence
- 8:45motions can be brought against the mayor or a
- 8:49speaker or a member of the mayoral committee.
- 8:51As we know, in the last five years particularly,
- 8:54motions of no confidence have been abused to
- 8:57a huge extent to keep on changing the leadership
- 9:00as parties swing from one alliance to the other.
- 9:03So the idea is to stop that by having a ban on,
- 9:08or a restriction rather, on no confidence motions.
- 9:11But that doesn't mean that you can't get rid
- 9:13of anybody. There is a provision in the legislation
- 9:16that councils can appoint an independent panel.
- 9:19to consider whether such a motion should serve
- 9:22a little bit equivalent to the impeachment committee
- 9:25process that we now have in the national parliament
- 9:28same kind of story and lastly lastly there are
- 9:31transparency requirements for council meetings
- 9:34regulating when meetings must be held and also
- 9:38giving the power to provincial members of the
- 9:41executive committee provincial ministers basically
- 9:44to intervene in local local government meetings
- 9:48where things don't go well, particularly when,
- 9:51for example, a speaker would block meetings from
- 9:53being held. Then the MEC can intervene and can
- 9:57change the arrangement. So it gives a specific
- 10:00authority to the province. What happened to the
- 10:03idea of a minimum threshold? Yeah, unfortunately,
- 10:07the idea has fallen by the wayside. The original
- 10:10proposal was that parties must achieve 1 % of
- 10:14the vote before they can serve in the council.
- 10:18I think it's a very good idea. It would have
- 10:20cut down the number of small parties in councils
- 10:23considerably. Even in a stable council like Cape
- 10:27Town, you would have seen quite a dramatic reduction
- 10:29in the number of parties. So that would have
- 10:32been good for stability and consistency. But
- 10:37that has fallen by the wayside and it's not part
- 10:39of the current legislation which is now before
- 10:41Parliament. And that's because the DA and the
- 10:43ANC couldn't come to an agreement. Yes, they
- 10:46came to an agreement around the 1%, so that was
- 10:49easy, that was done. But then the ANC wanted
- 10:52to put forward or did put forward a proposal
- 10:54that where one party doesn't have the majority,
- 10:58then the executive of the council, the executive
- 11:02of the local government. must comprise on a proportionate
- 11:06basis from all the parties in the council. Now,
- 11:09what that would mean is that if you get, say,
- 11:1140 % of the vote in Johannesburg, that's not
- 11:1450, then you must share the executive positions
- 11:17with MK, with the EFF, and with all other parties.
- 11:21Now, that's not workable. So, for that reason,
- 11:26the idea was then dropped, and the 1 % died in
- 11:30the process. Water has been an enormous problem.
- 11:36And you're saying that there has been a response,
- 11:40that water as such is actually forcing a change?
- 11:44Yeah, it's a replay for me of what we saw with
- 11:48load shedding. Load shedding from when was it,
- 11:502019, a little bit earlier, actually forced the
- 11:54country to change the way in which our electricity
- 11:58system operates. And we've seen dramatic changes
- 12:01in electricity and we've now had no load shedding
- 12:03for more than a year. Now, the same kind of fundamental
- 12:07reform, I think, is spurred on by the water crisis.
- 12:12And it comes out in basically two big reforms.
- 12:16The first one is licensing and the second one
- 12:18is ring fencing. And both these reforms are being
- 12:21driven by the Department of Water and Sanitation
- 12:24with Operation Wooden Glela, which, as you know,
- 12:27is the joint. National Treasury Presidency Initiative
- 12:31to effect reform in the country, in the economy.
- 12:34And they're driving these two changes of licensing
- 12:37and ring fencing. So what is the changes with
- 12:42regards to licensing? What does that entail?
- 12:45At the moment, there are amendments before Parliament
- 12:48to the Water Services Act. And what the amendments
- 12:51say is that a municipality has got two... The
- 12:56one is it's a water services authority. And the
- 13:00authority is responsible for providing water
- 13:02to its citizens in its area. It must set the
- 13:06policy and it must set the price. Then there's
- 13:08a water service provider, which is responsible
- 13:11for operating things. That's how it currently
- 13:14stands. But part of how it currently stands is
- 13:17that the municipality perform both those functions.
- 13:19They're the authority and they're the provider.
- 13:22What the amendments to the Water Services Act
- 13:24are doing is to split those two. And to be a
- 13:29water services provider, you need a license.
- 13:33And the license will stipulate minimum requirements.
- 13:36And if you don't, as a provider, meet those requirements,
- 13:40you will lose your license. The license can be
- 13:43taken away and given to somebody else. And that
- 13:46somebody else can be somebody outside the municipality.
- 13:50It's a very, very important change. It looks
- 13:53like a small administrative thing. It is not.
- 13:56It basically breaks the monopoly hold that municipalities
- 14:00have had for as long as we had municipalities,
- 14:03that they are the sole providers of water. You
- 14:07break that monopoly. And that opens the door
- 14:10for private sector companies, for profit and
- 14:12not for profit, to come in and to do the water
- 14:15provision function. So the municipality remains.
- 14:19responsible for price and for making sure that
- 14:23all citizens get water. But the provider is responsible
- 14:27for maintenance, for making sure the water flows
- 14:29in the pipes, that the taps work and that the
- 14:32money is collected. Has it been done? Has it
- 14:34been tried? Not as a result of these changes,
- 14:38no, but we do have two places in the country,
- 14:41two municipalities of the 257, where an outside
- 14:46party, in both cases a private company, are responsible
- 14:50for water delivery. That's in KZN on the Dolphin
- 14:54Coast at Belito and in Pumalanga in Bombella.
- 14:59And in both those two municipalities, you've
- 15:01seen a dramatic improvement in water delivery
- 15:04by those private providers. So, yes, there are
- 15:08examples, and I think the success of those two
- 15:11examples tell you that this system, if it's applied
- 15:14nationally, can make a huge, huge difference.
- 15:17Okay, so that's licensing. The other change,
- 15:21you said, was ring fencing. Correct. And as I've
- 15:25already explained, it's about forcing all municipalities
- 15:28to take their trading services, water, electricity,
- 15:32sanitation and waste removal, those three, for
- 15:36which they charge a fee to ratepayers. to ring
- 15:40fence that income and separate it from general
- 15:43municipal income, but also from general municipal
- 15:46expenditure. That's the important part. Now,
- 15:49ring fencing can really make a big difference
- 15:52to the way our local governments operate. This
- 15:55is also in line, it's now being proposed by legislation,
- 16:00but it's also in line with what is suggested
- 16:02in the draft white paper. Now, linked to that
- 16:05is... I think what is important to note is what
- 16:09National Treasury has done in respect of the
- 16:13eight metros we have in the country. They've
- 16:15put together a 54 billion rand incentive, financed
- 16:19by local and foreign money, over a six -year
- 16:23period. And what they basically say is, if you
- 16:26as a metro can prove to us in Treasury that you
- 16:30have ring -fenced your operations, you run them
- 16:32as a commercial operation, you've appointed qualified
- 16:34people, We will allow you to get some of this
- 16:3854 billion for infrastructure and investment.
- 16:42You've got to match it rand for rand. Every rand
- 16:45that you contribute, we will give you a rand
- 16:47and the money must go to infrastructure upgrades
- 16:49and renewal. This can make a huge difference
- 16:52to municipal infrastructure in the eight metres.
- 16:56So they are being offered a huge carrot. Is there
- 16:59a stick in the works as well? There are sticks
- 17:02being employed, absolutely. It's a process of
- 17:04carrot and sticks. And what are the sticks? The
- 17:07main one is the National Treasury is withholding
- 17:10what is called the equitable share. Now, what
- 17:13is the equitable share? It's simply a formula
- 17:16in the Constitution to make sure that a part
- 17:19of the national tax take is paid over to municipalities,
- 17:23also to provinces, but we're not talking about
- 17:25municipalities. Now, this year, for example,
- 17:28municipalities will get 110 billion rand from
- 17:32the national tax pool, so to speak. And what
- 17:36Treasury has started doing is to say, if you
- 17:38owe money, if you as a municipality owe money,
- 17:41we're not going to pay this equitable share over
- 17:44to you. You must first settle your debts and
- 17:47then you can have the check. At the end of 2024,
- 17:52there were, I think, 34 municipalities that were
- 17:55punished in this way. By the end of December
- 17:582025, that number has increased to 75. So clearly
- 18:02Treasury is very willing to yield this big stick.
- 18:06And it looks as if it is curbing the amounts
- 18:09of money that municipalities just don't pay.
- 18:14You would have noticed that the city of Johannesburg
- 18:17has been in the news lately with the Minister
- 18:20of Finance saying you can't go ahead with a three
- 18:23-year wage agreement with your unions about salaries.
- 18:26because it's unfunded, and we're not going to
- 18:28give you equitable share unless you revoke that.
- 18:32Now, the minister and the council are still fighting,
- 18:34and we will see where that goes. But it illustrates
- 18:37the same kind of willingness to withhold the
- 18:40equitable share from local governments who don't
- 18:42manage their finances properly. Just as an aside,
- 18:47almost, what about... The other way, they are
- 18:49also government entities who owe money to municipalities.
- 18:53Very important point. Across the country, government
- 18:57entities across the country owe 28 billion to
- 19:00local municipalities. And that obviously is a
- 19:04big amount of money. So if you can get all government
- 19:06entities who is funded by the taxpayer to actually
- 19:10pay their debt to local municipalities, it will
- 19:13make a big difference. But I must also point
- 19:15out, local municipalities owe about R161 billion,
- 19:20mainly to ESCOM and to water boards, but also
- 19:23to other creditors. But against that R161 billion
- 19:28is R467 billion, which is owed to municipalities.
- 19:34R28 billion of that, as we discussed, are organs
- 19:37of state. R100 billion, more or less, are private
- 19:41sector companies. And then 335 billion are private
- 19:46households who owe money to municipalities. So
- 19:49there are two sides to this story. Municipalities
- 19:52owe money, but they also owed a lot of money.
- 19:55Now, households or businesses owing money to
- 19:59municipalities is quite often a function of poor
- 20:01collection. And if you can up your collection
- 20:05and you're taking in your debt, then you can
- 20:08solve a lot of these problems. And enforcement.
- 20:12Enforcement, that's really the word that I was
- 20:13looking for. What about the people, the individuals?
- 20:17Are they being held responsible at all? No, not
- 20:20yet. What we have at the moment is that the Department
- 20:23of Water and Sanitation has laid criminal charges
- 20:25against municipalities for not meeting their
- 20:28water or particularly sewage and sanitation minimum
- 20:32standards. And what we found is that the courts
- 20:36have levied fines from 10 million to as much
- 20:38as 200 million. Now, of course, that fine must
- 20:42be paid by the municipality, which again means
- 20:45the taxpayer. But there's a nice case that recently
- 20:49played out in Nijsla, where the municipality
- 20:52was fined 10 million rand after they pleaded
- 20:55guilty to various counts of sewage spills into
- 20:59the Nijsla estuary. So they got a 10 million
- 21:02rand fine suspended for five years under condition.
- 21:06that they spend 10 million rand on clean up and
- 21:09fixing the situation in a shorter period than
- 21:12five years. But they were also given an order
- 21:15by the court that they must spend 630 million
- 21:18over the next five years on infrastructure and
- 21:21environmental rehabilitation. And thirdly, they
- 21:25must contribute 500 ,000 rand towards better
- 21:28law enforcement by the province on environmental
- 21:32issues. So that's quite a hefty clap that the
- 21:36court gave to the NYSA municipality. And I think
- 21:39we can expect to see much more of that. And it's
- 21:43quite an intricate sentence, if I can put it
- 21:47that way, that it's not just pay a fine. Indeed.
- 21:51No, indeed. Other things that need to happen.
- 21:53Other steps must be taken to improve the situation
- 21:56that led. to define in the first place. One must,
- 22:00of course, ask the question here, is it possible
- 22:02that in due course we can change the law so that
- 22:05the municipal councillors and officials who are
- 22:08responsible for the neglect are held personally
- 22:11responsible? I would like to see that develop.
- 22:14It's not the position yet, but it can happen.
- 22:17Recently in the Northwest Province, the Auditor
- 22:20General held a civil servant responsible for
- 22:234 .6 million rand, which was not collected. by
- 22:27the municipal official. And all of the journalists
- 22:30said, you've got to pay it personally. So that's
- 22:33the kind of stick that we need to install discipline.
- 22:36So in summary, this Achilles heel, what is your
- 22:41so what? I think the first biggest so what is
- 22:44that everybody now accepts that the worst problem
- 22:47we have in the country is that local government
- 22:50is not functioning and it's got to change. It
- 22:52can't carry on like this. That's number one.
- 22:56Secondly, there is a wholesale reorganization
- 22:58that is being proposed in the draft white paper,
- 23:02on which the public have now had the opportunity
- 23:05to comment, and that will probably become the
- 23:08policy over the next while. So the new governments,
- 23:11local governments that will be elected in November,
- 23:13will increasingly operate in a very different
- 23:16system from the one that we've seen the last
- 23:1925, 30 years. There are big changes. Thirdly,
- 23:25the fact that we're going to ring fence water,
- 23:28electricity and waste income and manage that
- 23:31money differently can make a very, very big change
- 23:34in real life. The other big consequence that's
- 23:38flowing from ring fencing and particularly licensing
- 23:41is that we break the monopoly that local governments
- 23:45have enjoyed on delivering those services. People
- 23:48want to work with a model where every household
- 23:50must look after itself. Well, that obviously
- 23:52can't work. What you need is for a non -municipal
- 23:57provider to step in and do what the municipality
- 24:00is supposed to do. And that becomes possible
- 24:02under this arrangement. Then there's also legislation
- 24:06to force coalition governments to operate with
- 24:09more responsibility. Whether it'll have that
- 24:11effect, we will see. But it's certainly a reaction
- 24:15to the abuses and neglect that we've seen in
- 24:18the last five years. And that reaction is good.
- 24:21But in the end, I have to say, you can reform
- 24:24the institutions and you can write laws, but
- 24:27it's equally important that voters in November
- 24:29elect the right people. And that will, of course,
- 24:32vary from municipality to municipality. But it's
- 24:35very important that people step up, make sure
- 24:38who they want to vote for and cast their votes
- 24:40for people who can help to improve the system.
- 24:43What is the most important characteristic that
- 24:47you would look for in a candidate? willing to
- 24:52serve the citizens in an honest and diligent
- 24:55manner. He must have something in his track record
- 24:58to indicate that he's an honest worker and he's
- 25:02a conscientious worker. That for me will determine
- 25:05whether I would vote for him or not. Thank you
- 25:09very much. We will speak soon. Thank you for
- 25:14listening to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy
- 25:16this content, please don't forget to leave a
- 25:19review and a rating, and please consider subscribing
- 25:22so you don't miss any future episodes. Also,
- 25:25tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written
- 25:28version of all JP's content at jplandman .co
- 25:32.za.