Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Navigating Liability and Litigation in the Driverless Era
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Navigating, Liability, and Litigation
- 0:06in the Driverless Era. I am Nada Sgafi. I am
- 0:11vice chair of BHBA's litigation section. I am
- 0:16delighted to introduce our speaker, Kenneth Williams.
- 0:19Kenneth P. Williams is a partner at Siegel, McCambridge,
- 0:24Singer, and Mahoney and a seasoned trial attorney
- 0:27who defends corporations nationwide and complex
- 0:30coverage property product liability, and commercial
- 0:34litigation. He represents insurance carriers,
- 0:37corporations, and private individuals in high
- 0:41stakes matters, including employment discrimination,
- 0:44civil rights, and wrongful death claims. Ken
- 0:47is also a nationally recognized speaker and trusted
- 0:51advisor on emerging industry trends, risk management,
- 0:56and litigation best practices. And now let's
- 1:00get started. Thank you, Ken. Thank you. So good
- 1:13afternoon, everyone. And thank you for joining
- 1:16us for this very helpful, very interesting topic.
- 1:20And typically, I've started out this presentation
- 1:24in the past by discussing obviously my background,
- 1:27which you now have, and diving right into where
- 1:31we will go, scope of issues today, what is an
- 1:35autonomous vehicle, what is the driverless ecosystem,
- 1:39the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration,
- 1:41what is their criteria or level of automation,
- 1:45what are the key areas to be impacted by the
- 1:48driverless ecosystem, how does this impact data
- 1:50privacy and cybersecurity, which could be its
- 1:53own standalone webinar one day. And then we look
- 1:56at autonomous driving. and digital disruption,
- 1:59cloud and satellite issues, and data considerations.
- 2:03But before we do any of that, how about a real
- 2:06life example that impacts virtually everything
- 2:09that I will discuss today? Hopefully many of
- 2:11you are aware that back in August of 2025 this
- 2:16year, it was reported that Tesla had experienced
- 2:19the first trial in its history concerning autopilot
- 2:25safety system. And this was the first trial that
- 2:28actually proceeded to verdict. The trial focused
- 2:32on a 2019 crash involving a 2019 Tesla Model
- 2:38S, a vehicle hopefully some of you are aware
- 2:40or familiar with. This particular vehicle was
- 2:45featured with autopilot driver assistance software.
- 2:49And the driver who was utilizing the autopilot
- 2:53software was behind the wheel of the vehicle,
- 2:56however he was distracted and he was doing other
- 2:58things behind the wheel of the vehicle, when
- 3:01the vehicle, per the plaintiffs in the trial,
- 3:04malfunctioned and struck a parked Chevy Tahoe
- 3:08and killed two individuals who were standing
- 3:14outside of the Chevy. Interestingly this case
- 3:18resulted in the jury concluding that the driver
- 3:21Which in normal jurisdictions, in a normal accident
- 3:24case, where a jury comes back and finds the driver
- 3:2867 % at fault, that would be very significant.
- 3:33In many jurisdictions, they would consider that
- 3:35a win as to the negligence of the driver. But
- 3:38they found the driver 67 % at fault for compensatory
- 3:43damages. But the problem in the case is that
- 3:45the driver was a non -party, was not a defendant
- 3:48in that case. Tesla, of course, denied any wrongdoing.
- 3:53They pointed the finger specifically at the driver,
- 3:56the driver error, the driver misuse of the system.
- 4:00And obviously the trial, the jury came back and
- 4:04awarded a significant high nuclear verdict against
- 4:08Tesla as a result of that. So I wanted to throw
- 4:12that out as a real life example. And you may
- 4:14ask, well, why start with that? Tesla vehicles,
- 4:18like many other vehicles, contain advanced driver
- 4:22assistance systems involved. In your vehicle
- 4:26that you may have, it could be as simple as lane
- 4:28departure warning, cross traffic warning behind
- 4:33you. That little dot in the mirror, if you're
- 4:36going to signal your blinker and change lanes,
- 4:38and that little dot. goes off. Some of our vehicles
- 4:41have systems where if you veer out of the lane
- 4:44that you're in your steering wheel starts to
- 4:47vibrate. Perhaps you get a message on the dash
- 4:50right in front of your eyes that you're veering
- 4:52out of the lane. Some vehicles that you may have
- 4:55have autonomous driving or semi -autonomous driving
- 4:59where for moments in time on the freeway you
- 5:01can take your hands off the steering wheel and
- 5:03the vehicle will maintain itself in its lane
- 5:07I know that some systems, if your hands are off
- 5:10the vehicle too long, the vehicle will alert
- 5:13you to reengage. In this trial, at the heart
- 5:16of this trial that I referenced, the driver did
- 5:19not reengage and was relying 100 % allegedly
- 5:23on the autonomous nature and systems of the Tesla
- 5:28vehicle, and obviously a fatal accident resulted.
- 5:32So let's dive in. What is an autonomous vehicle?
- 5:37And many of you may have thoughts out there.
- 5:40Over the course of presenting this over the last
- 5:42eight years, I've gotten a variety of answers
- 5:45on what is an autonomous vehicle. Some say, oh,
- 5:49it's Waymo. I've taken a Waymo at the airport,
- 5:52and I've experienced a Waymo. I get in, it's
- 5:55a taxi, it's an Uber without a driver. And I
- 6:00can program in, obviously, my location and the
- 6:03Waymo will take me to my location with no driver
- 6:06in the driver's seat. I'm in the backseat and
- 6:09there is no ability for me to alter the path
- 6:11of the Waymo. Some have said in jest in the past
- 6:15that autonomous vehicles aren't those the flying
- 6:17vehicles, aren't those the vehicles that'll just
- 6:20zip around and barely touch the road and they've
- 6:22got all this technology and loaded into them.
- 6:26Others typically fall in the middle. You know,
- 6:29there's autonomous vehicles that are loaded with
- 6:32sensors and cameras around them. In fact, as
- 6:36manufacturers today are developing what will
- 6:40later be known as fully autonomous vehicles,
- 6:43there are vehicles on the road that are learning
- 6:46and relearning and learning the environment.
- 6:49And what these vehicles are doing with all of
- 6:51their sensors and all of their cameras, they're
- 6:54trying to predict the environment in trying to
- 6:58learn the environment in such a way that one
- 7:01day vehicles will be able to react like humans
- 7:04would react, but the goal is to have the vehicles
- 7:06react better than a human driver would react.
- 7:11And so modern day, when you say autonomous vehicles,
- 7:15at least in terms of the systems and the technology,
- 7:19what we experience now with driver assistance
- 7:23systems in our vehicles, That is a precursor
- 7:26to what will later come to when the vehicles
- 7:28can fully operate and take you akin to a Waymo
- 7:32from point A to point B with no interaction and
- 7:36no engagement by the driver. So if we were doing
- 7:40this live, I would open up the chat now to hear
- 7:43what your thoughts on a fully autonomous vehicle.
- 7:48Some of this data dates back to what we were
- 7:52looking forward from back in 2019. Back in 19,
- 7:56which seems pre -COVID. Google and its spin -off
- 8:00Waymo and Uber and GM all planned to have fleets
- 8:03of autonomous vehicles at that time deployed
- 8:07in various US cities to provide on -demand rides
- 8:11for passengers. The goal was to eliminate the
- 8:14cost of the driver, and these rides were expected
- 8:17to be far cheaper than what we now know as Uber
- 8:20or Lyft rides. The hope back in 2019 was that
- 8:25these vehicles would be in mass production and
- 8:28on the roads in 2030. The reality is between
- 8:332019 and 2025, with the vast introduction of
- 8:38electric vehicles, the furthering technology
- 8:41of Tesla vehicles, 2030 is no longer an achievable
- 8:47target. And now industry experts are looking
- 8:50at 2035 or perhaps 2040, because many of the
- 8:55things that have to happen to accommodate these
- 8:58vehicles on the road is not happening and is
- 9:01not poised to happen right now. One of which
- 9:04has nothing to do with the vehicles, but has
- 9:06everything to do with the vehicles, and that's
- 9:09infrastructure. Imagine predicting a world where
- 9:13it's going to be announced in a few days on New
- 9:15Year's Eve that starting in 2026, on your local
- 9:19highway in your town, there's going to be autonomous
- 9:22vehicles and there's going to be self -driving
- 9:25vehicles. One of the challenges immediately would
- 9:28be for January 1st, 2026. Well, wait a minute,
- 9:31you know, are the drivers of the self -driving
- 9:33vehicles? How are they going to know and recognize
- 9:37the autonomous vehicles? And conversely, how
- 9:39will the autonomous vehicles know and react to
- 9:42the self -driving vehicles with various individuals
- 9:45with various driving habits? And how can the
- 9:48two vehicles coexist within our current infrastructure
- 9:52and within our current roadways? It would be
- 9:55very challenging. And the difficulty is when
- 9:57you pair a self -driving vehicle driver, and
- 10:01I would venture to say all of us on this webinar
- 10:03have very different driving skills and driving
- 10:06aptitudes in terms of how we employ our vehicles
- 10:09on the road. When you match those with fully
- 10:12autonomous vehicles, the autonomous vehicles
- 10:14have to be able to act. and react in real time,
- 10:19not only to the roadway, not only to road conditions,
- 10:23not only to traffic patterns, not only to weather,
- 10:26not only to when the school bell rings and now
- 10:29there's greater traffic on the road because of
- 10:31schools letting out, not only to mornings and
- 10:35evenings and night weather, not only to mountain
- 10:38roads and everything else, but autonomous vehicles
- 10:40would have to, by nature, be able to react in
- 10:43real time to a drunk driver. a speeding driver,
- 10:47a careless driver, a driver who's eating while
- 10:50driving and not paying attention to the road,
- 10:53a driver that fails to stop at an intersection
- 10:55or races through an intersection because that
- 10:57driver believes that he or she can make it through
- 11:00the intersection. So the reason that those two
- 11:05drivers, the fully autonomous driver and the
- 11:09self -driving driver cannot occupy the road right
- 11:12now is because the infrastructure would need
- 11:14to essentially have a separate lane, a separate
- 11:18area for autonomous vehicles, separate from self
- 11:22-driving vehicles, meaning where there's a driver
- 11:25engaged behind the wheel of the vehicle attempting
- 11:29to operate the vehicle. All of that, in addition
- 11:32to infrastructure cost, The advent of electric
- 11:37vehicles, the decline of the public's desire
- 11:40to fully engage in the electric vehicles, all
- 11:43of that has resulted in a pushback of the onset
- 11:47of what will be coming and what will be later
- 11:50known as fully autonomous vehicles. And this
- 11:55slide addresses some big picture concerns. The
- 11:58personal automobile powered by internal combustion
- 12:00engine. As you know, ushered in decades long
- 12:03area of personal freedom and collective prosperity.
- 12:06But with that freedom came a number of challenges,
- 12:09including pollution, congestion, and accidents.
- 12:13The World Health Organization back in this published
- 12:16study resulted in more than 1 .3 million people
- 12:21based upon their research die each year in traffic
- 12:25accidents across the globe. according to the
- 12:27National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration.
- 12:3094 % of crashes, based upon this study at this
- 12:34time, were caused by human error. What's behind
- 12:38the potential push towards fully autonomous vehicles?
- 12:43That 94 % right now that ranges from distracted
- 12:47driving, drunk driving, just flat out inattentive
- 12:51driving, people driving when they're tired, people
- 12:54driving when they're buzzed. that 94 % contributes
- 12:59to crashes and that 94 % constitutes human error.
- 13:04So the one day, the anticipated day is that one
- 13:07day there will be no human to result in human
- 13:11error and all of the vehicles that we are in
- 13:14are fully autonomous and when you reduce the
- 13:17human error down to zero and now you leave it
- 13:20basically into the computer car, as I sometimes
- 13:23call them, without the human error there's less
- 13:27crashes and there's less incidents on the road.
- 13:30Electric vehicles was one way to attempt to address
- 13:35pollution and other issues related to vehicles.
- 13:40Electric vehicles were also an attempt to fast
- 13:44forward the public, the general public, into
- 13:46all of the advanced driving systems that are
- 13:51out there to let the public start to learn that
- 13:54the one -day autonomous vehicle has a lot more
- 13:57than lane departure warning. The one -day autonomous
- 14:00vehicle will have computers and computer systems
- 14:02so that you can do that Zoom call. You could
- 14:05attend this Zoom conference on your way to your
- 14:08next destination because you're in a vehicle.
- 14:11akin to a modern -day Waymo that can operate
- 14:14itself, does not need a human to interact, and
- 14:17then, well, what's the human to do in there?
- 14:18They can do their office calls, their Zoom calls,
- 14:21they can multitask. That's what's coming. The
- 14:25problem with electric vehicles is that the public
- 14:27did not react the way many manufacturers had
- 14:31hoped the public would react in. General Motors
- 14:34in the last 10 days has elected to disband some
- 14:40of their fully electric fleet goals for some
- 14:44of their vehicles, and they're now going to move
- 14:46to much more of a hybrid goal in terms of some
- 14:50gas, combustion, and also some electric technology
- 14:55in the vehicles as well. Why? Because the public
- 14:58demand for fully EV vehicles is not what manufacturers
- 15:03across the board, in addition to General Motors,
- 15:06hope that they would be. This slide dates back
- 15:11to 2017, and this was the shared mobility market
- 15:16size, if you will, for the United States, Europe,
- 15:20and China. This is an important slide, even now
- 15:24in 2025, if you were to look at the updated numbers,
- 15:28because the appetite for certain vehicles in
- 15:31China varies very differently than in the United
- 15:35States. And that varies very differently for
- 15:39the appetite in Europe. Europe has a lot of very
- 15:43strict rules and regulations that have been promulgated
- 15:47in the last five years concerning combustion
- 15:50engine vehicles and other types of vehicles.
- 15:55The noise that sports cars, if you will, can
- 15:57emit from their engine, the amount of gas consumption
- 16:01by vehicles. Europe has some very strict rules.
- 16:04those rules have affected vehicle production
- 16:08and vehicle technology that's come out in both
- 16:11the United States and China. China has a higher
- 16:14aptitude for fully electric vehicles than the
- 16:18United States, than Europe. So there's a very
- 16:21different shared mobility market that exists
- 16:24across the globe that is only relevant to your
- 16:28consideration when a manufacturer is looking
- 16:30at spending billions and billions of dollars
- 16:33to market and invest in and develop what will
- 16:36later be known as fully autonomous vehicles.
- 16:41And I've touched on this, the current tension
- 16:43with electric vehicles. So for brevity of time,
- 16:45I will move past that. As you know, sales of
- 16:49electric vehicles in the United States, despite
- 16:51all the technology, despite all the neat things
- 16:54they can do, initially there was a spike and
- 16:56there was a high aptitude for consumer consumption
- 17:01of electric vehicles. but then the decrease and
- 17:04the decrease has continued down and down and
- 17:07downward trend to where auto manufacturers are
- 17:10struggling with just how do we do it? Do we go
- 17:13all in on electric vehicles or do we pause and
- 17:17go towards hybrid vehicles? Even some of your
- 17:20higher end sports car manufacturers like Porsche
- 17:23had at one time two years ago announced that
- 17:25they were going to be moving to a fully electric
- 17:28fleet as they began to slow down the production
- 17:33of internal combustion engine vehicles. That
- 17:38has even been paused by companies such as Porsche
- 17:41and other high -end manufacturers because again
- 17:44what drives their motivation to come out with
- 17:49electric vehicles and then autonomous vehicles
- 17:52is what does the public want and what will the
- 17:54public currently pay for. And as of 2024, the
- 17:58public's response to manufacturers all along
- 18:02was that not now, not yet, we're not ready. So
- 18:06what are we left with? Because this discussion
- 18:08has surrounded electric vehicles. What are we
- 18:11left with? We are left with vehicle technology
- 18:14and driver assistance systems in vehicles that
- 18:19are semi -autonomous. And that is leading us
- 18:22up to the challenge faced by the National Traffic
- 18:27and Highway Safety Administration. And I'll go
- 18:30to this slide now so we can have a discussion.
- 18:34This is the current scale for the National Highway
- 18:37Traffic and Safety Administration, autonomous
- 18:40vehicle scale. And I will shortly tell you why
- 18:43there's a missing number and a missing scale
- 18:46from this current chart. Level zero, Many of
- 18:50you on the webinar may currently have or you've
- 18:54experienced a vehicle with no automation. You
- 18:56get in, you turn the key, you start it up. Maybe
- 18:59you like driving a manual, maybe you like driving
- 19:01automatic, but there is no automation. Some vehicles
- 19:05that some drivers like, there's no ABS, there's
- 19:08no lane departure warning. There's no backup
- 19:11camera. Maybe some of you learned on those vehicles.
- 19:14And maybe some of you on this webinar have never,
- 19:16ever experienced a vehicle and wonder why would
- 19:19a human being ever drive such a vehicle? Well,
- 19:22level one, according to the National Highway
- 19:25Traffic Safety Administration, is a vehicle that
- 19:27is controlled by a driver. So there is a driver
- 19:30that has responsibility for controlling the vehicle.
- 19:33But this vehicle has some driving assist features.
- 19:39Cruise control. The advent of cruise control.
- 19:42The advent of radar cruise control where the
- 19:44vehicle while it's in cruise control has a camera,
- 19:48has a radar, and it can detect a vehicle ahead
- 19:50of it and alter the speed without the driver
- 19:53having to engage. But level one, the driver is
- 19:56still fully engaged and fully responsible. Level
- 20:00two, partial automation. The vehicle has combined
- 20:04automated functions like acceleration and steering.
- 20:07But the driver must remain engaged while the
- 20:10driving task is being operated. And the driver
- 20:13must monitor the environment at all times. Let
- 20:18me fast forward while we're looking at this together.
- 20:22And let me switch hats and put on my litigation
- 20:25hat. Whenever you see in any of these particular
- 20:29categories or stages that the driver remains
- 20:34with the opportunity to control or engage the
- 20:39vehicle. The litigation result of that is, if
- 20:44there is an opportunity for driver error, then
- 20:47there is opportunity for litigation against the
- 20:50driver, the trucking company, the manufacturer,
- 20:53the owner, operator of the vehicle itself. Level
- 20:58three, conditional automation. The driver, as
- 21:02you can see there, remains a necessity. but here
- 21:05the driver is not required to monitor the environment.
- 21:09You could imagine that being a jury question
- 21:11on the verdict form. Was the driver, was a reasonable
- 21:15person in the position of this driver with a
- 21:17level three vehicle required to monitor the environment?
- 21:22Question number two on that verdict form. Did
- 21:24the driver in this case who had the option of
- 21:27monitoring the environment fail to monitor the
- 21:30environment in a way that a reasonable person
- 21:32would have monitored the environment. But again,
- 21:35level three, the driver must be ready to take
- 21:37control of the vehicle at all times. If we were
- 21:41in a classroom together, now is the time that
- 21:44I would do a mini poll question and ask for a
- 21:46showing of hands and get some thoughts on, do
- 21:49you think that level 0, 1, 2, and 3 covers a
- 21:54Tesla vehicle being operated in full autopilot?
- 21:57And I'm saying that hopefully with enough of
- 22:00the majority here having heard of autopilot and
- 22:03having an understanding of how it functions in
- 22:05a Tesla vehicle. But we're not in that, so I'll
- 22:08move on to level four. Level four is a vehicle
- 22:11with high automation. The vehicle itself is capable
- 22:16of performing all driving functions. Here's the
- 22:19kicker, under certain conditions. the driver
- 22:22may have the option to control the vehicle. Again,
- 22:26from a litigation standpoint, you're thinking
- 22:28of what is the jury going to be asked when that
- 22:32driver who had the option of controlling the
- 22:36vehicle failed to do so in a school zone, failed
- 22:40to do so while operating in semi -autonomous
- 22:45mode, but failed to reengage the vehicle as the
- 22:48vehicle was approaching a school bus. that had
- 22:50its stop sign out. And that stop sign was to
- 22:53signal to drivers that you need to bring your
- 22:55vehicle to a stop because children could be crossing
- 22:58the road. So did the driver who had the option
- 23:00to control the vehicle fail to do that? That's
- 23:03a consideration for a level four vehicle. Level
- 23:06five, that's the highest level according to the
- 23:10National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration
- 23:12at this time. Let's look at that together. The
- 23:16vehicle is capable. of performing all driving
- 23:19functions under all conditions. Many of you may
- 23:23think, well, this must be a Waymo vehicle. Not
- 23:25so fast. The driver, again, may have the option
- 23:30to control the vehicle. The moment you see under
- 23:33any of these from level zero, where the driver
- 23:36performs all driving tasks, up to the current
- 23:39highest level, only which a small percentage
- 23:42of vehicles Could even dare approach and the
- 23:46Tesla vehicle does not approach level five at
- 23:49best the current highest technology of Tesla
- 23:52fall somewhere between levels two three and four
- 23:57depending on the software package and depending
- 23:59on the various modes that the vehicle can be
- 24:02placed in but modern -day Tesla's which are viewed
- 24:05as the highest among autonomy and having an autonomous
- 24:09nature or semi autonomous nature Tesla vehicles
- 24:12are not to the level five. Level five has, again,
- 24:18the option of the driver having the option to
- 24:22re -engage the vehicle. For litigation standpoint,
- 24:26that becomes the jury question. And that becomes
- 24:30where you will see future trials involving the
- 24:32driver, the product manufacturer, the distributor,
- 24:37and everyone in the chain of putting this vehicle
- 24:41in this driver's hand and leaving the option
- 24:44open to the driver to control the vehicle. I
- 24:48previewed earlier what will be Level 6, and Level
- 24:526 hasn't been authored yet, has not been promulgated
- 24:56yet by the National Highway Traffic and Safety
- 24:58Administration, but Level 6 will be akin to your
- 25:02experience if you go to Arizona, some places
- 25:05in California, or Nevada, where you can experience
- 25:11the Waymo vehicle. And that is where you book
- 25:14the Waymo, the Waymo pulls into the airport stall,
- 25:18you enter the Waymo, you don't enter the driver's
- 25:21seat, and you as the passenger or occupant, you're
- 25:25not a driver and you'll never be the driver of
- 25:28a Waymo vehicle for a lot of liability reasons
- 25:30akin to Waymo as you could imagine. But level
- 25:34six will be the description as follows. The vehicle
- 25:38is capable of performing all driving functions
- 25:41under all conditions. The driver will not exist
- 25:46or there will be no driver and it will have no
- 25:50language of a driver having the option to control
- 25:53the vehicle. That future vehicle which will be
- 25:56a level six fully autonomous vehicle will have
- 26:02the ability to drive in the snowy mountains of
- 26:05Colorado. Imagine that. Are you going to trust
- 26:07a Waymo in a snowstorm on a two -lane mountain
- 26:11in Colorado? Are you going to trust that same
- 26:15Waymo in heavy traffic downtown Los Angeles?
- 26:19Are you going to trust that Waymo deep in Arizona
- 26:23when you're getting in mountainous areas where
- 26:25there's a lot of wildlife on the road? But that
- 26:28future level six will eliminate driver involvement.
- 26:33And when level six reaches the opportunity for
- 26:39us to utilize, that will cause the biggest shift
- 26:43if ever in litigation, where no longer will the
- 26:46driver and the driver's conduct, the principles
- 26:49of negligence will all change, and the focus
- 26:51will be upon the manufacturer of essentially
- 26:55what is the product. And the user or the occupant
- 26:59will become an unnecessary target, if you will,
- 27:03at trial. What are some current advanced driver
- 27:07assistance systems that exist? As I previewed,
- 27:11adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning,
- 27:14lane keeping assistance, a Tesla autopilot is
- 27:17another advanced system, if you will, forward
- 27:21collision warning, automatic emergency braking,
- 27:24blind spot monitoring. What's interesting about
- 27:27this is that many among our group that's viewing
- 27:29this webinar right now, Perhaps you have such
- 27:32a vehicle and what what's one of the things that
- 27:34you do that I won't make you confess to our Sophisticated
- 27:37group on the webinar But what's one of the things
- 27:39you do when you enter the vehicle you turn off
- 27:42the lane departure warning? You just don't like
- 27:45it You don't like the steering wheel vibrating
- 27:47and letting you know that how hazard of a driver
- 27:50you are that you're always drifting into the
- 27:52other lane and the lane keeping assistance That
- 27:56turning off that warning imagine your future
- 28:00Auto policy that has an exclusion for intentional
- 28:05acts. One of the things I present on are intentional
- 28:08act exclusions under homeowner policy. But imagine
- 28:12your future auto policy where driver gets into
- 28:16the vehicle, driver turns off the lane departure
- 28:19warning intentionally, driver then starts his
- 28:23or her way to get from point A to point B, driver
- 28:27is involved in a fatal accident. Where driver
- 28:30allowed the vehicle to enter the lane of another
- 28:33caused a chain reaction accident and there was
- 28:37a fatality Could you imagine then presenting
- 28:40that claim to your insurance carrier only to
- 28:43receive not only a reservation of rights letter?
- 28:46but ultimately a denial letter a denial letter
- 28:49that says because you the driver engage in an
- 28:52intentional act by turning off the lane departure
- 28:56warning and because our forensic engineer has
- 28:59noted that had your lane departure warning been
- 29:01on, you would have been alerted not to drift
- 29:03into that lane, which resulted in a chain reaction
- 29:06accident of other vehicles that you didn't see
- 29:08that you weren't paying attention to. We're now
- 29:11going to deny coverage to you. under your future
- 29:13auto policy. That would be a very significant
- 29:16discussion. If those types of denial letters
- 29:19existed today in 2000, the remainder of 2025
- 29:23into 2026, the entire litigation atmosphere would
- 29:27change. The amount of coverage lawsuits, coverage
- 29:31investigations, the retention of driver A or
- 29:34driver B of a forensic expert. to defend the
- 29:38driver's conduct against his or her own carrier,
- 29:41the scope of litigation would change. That's
- 29:44all a preview of the type of litigation that's
- 29:46coming. But the type of litigation that's coming,
- 29:49different from the Tesla lawsuit earlier this
- 29:52year, is going to be heavily focused solely against
- 29:55the manufacturer and less focused against the
- 29:59user, what we now know as the driver of the vehicle.
- 30:04What are the implications for using these particular
- 30:08systems? Well, this is very interesting because
- 30:10bullet point number six down, researchers at
- 30:14the AAA Foundation collaborated with Virginia
- 30:18Tech Transportation Institute to analyze video
- 30:20of on -road behaviors of two groups of drivers
- 30:24using advanced driver assistance technology.
- 30:28Individuals in one group owned a vehicle equipped
- 30:30with, let's say a high level, of ADAS systems
- 30:34and had more experience using the systems while
- 30:36driving. The other group was given a vehicle
- 30:40equipped with the ADAS systems to use during
- 30:43a four -week period, but they had less experience
- 30:46with the technology. What the results of this
- 30:49study found is that the drivers who had more
- 30:52familiarity with the technology were more likely
- 30:56to drive in a distracted capacity when the systems
- 31:01were active. That may seem very interesting as
- 31:05just the results of a study, but the trial lawyer
- 31:07in me says that's gonna be an entire discussion
- 31:11in front of a jury when you have a case against
- 31:14the product manufacturer where the driver engaged
- 31:18in distracted driving, more prone to look at
- 31:22that email. more prone to look at that text message
- 31:26because, hey, after all, they had the vehicle
- 31:28in semi -autonomous mode. The vehicle would alert
- 31:31them if they were going to veer out of their
- 31:33lane. The vehicle would alert them if they were
- 31:35driving too close to the vehicle ahead of time.
- 31:39The future litigation surrounding this will be
- 31:42essentially whether or not the product manufacturer
- 31:45failed to warn the user of the vehicle, of the
- 31:51propensity for distracted driving while using
- 31:55the technology. And the various experts that
- 31:58I can envision who will be called to the stand,
- 32:00not just forensic experts familiar with vehicle
- 32:03technology, but this will bleed into experts
- 32:08that can address the psychology of drivers. And
- 32:12the human factors experts who can talk about
- 32:15the habitual tendencies of drivers utilizing
- 32:21ADAS technology and those not utilizing ADS technology.
- 32:26So the reason I included that on this slide is
- 32:28because I believe that's fascinating and how
- 32:31that will play out in the litigation context.
- 32:34Because the plaintiffs bar, if you will, and
- 32:37if there are plaintiff counsel on this webinar,
- 32:40welcome and feel free to weigh in at some point
- 32:44later on down the road with me. But my vision
- 32:46is that the plaintiffs bar will be looking at
- 32:48the failure of the manufacturer to warn the user
- 32:54who will be the driver of the level five vehicle,
- 32:58not level six, because level six, in my opinion,
- 33:01will have no driver engagement, but fail to warn
- 33:04the user of the vehicle of the propensity for
- 33:08things like distracted driving. And if you have
- 33:12a jury that concludes that that manufacturer
- 33:15should have had better warnings, better instructions,
- 33:19Better training classes before you take home
- 33:22your level six or your I'm sorry your level five
- 33:25Tesla You attend multiple training classes. You're
- 33:29educated on the psychology of distracted driving
- 33:32Until you have a jury that's willing to give
- 33:35a manufacturer a pass Which is rare nowadays
- 33:39and is going to be rare in the future That's
- 33:43going to be heavy in the litigation space. So
- 33:45I offer that to you for your consideration in
- 33:48this atmosphere. The driverless ecosystem, the
- 33:52best way to boil that down is this. Ultimately,
- 33:58the level six cars in all of the data that they
- 34:02consume while they're being operated autonomously
- 34:06upon the road, they must essentially send to
- 34:10a hub. a data center if you will, all of their
- 34:15experiences on the road. Here's the roadway downtown
- 34:19Los Angeles during 4 p .m. traffic through 6
- 34:23p .m. traffic, during this type of season of
- 34:26the year with this particular glare from the
- 34:29sun. That data center will then in turn re -communicate
- 34:33that information to other autonomous vehicles
- 34:36on the road. So what will happen over time is
- 34:39that the vehicles themselves not only through
- 34:42their sensors, through their cameras, have to
- 34:45learn the environment, but there's going to be
- 34:47shared communication among vehicles for the learning
- 34:51of their environment. That's going to impact
- 34:54cities. That's going to impact city government,
- 34:57state government, federal government. Will there
- 35:00be a federal government? Will the National Highway
- 35:03Traffic and Safety Administration become now
- 35:06a separate wing of the government that governs
- 35:09the data shared between future level six vehicles.
- 35:13Why will that data be important? Why will that
- 35:17information be important? Because the day when
- 35:20a level six vehicle fails, it fails from a product
- 35:26liability standpoint, and it fails by causing
- 35:29an accident. It fails by veering into the lane
- 35:32of a semi -truck, and that semi -truck then spins
- 35:37out of control and causes a massive accident.
- 35:39on a snowy road, on a dry road. The push for
- 35:45the data and the push for the information from
- 35:48the product manufacturer is going to be huge.
- 35:51And so looking at bullet point number three,
- 35:57government regulation. This is as of 2023. There
- 36:04was no central governance over driverless cars
- 36:07and standards and regulatory frameworks. Those
- 36:11are still being evolved to ultimately make the
- 36:14one -day implementation as smooth as possible.
- 36:17California had a rule back in 23 that driverless
- 36:21cars, and that's not level six. I want you to
- 36:24remember that that's not level six, but driverless
- 36:26cars still needed to have a steering wheel so
- 36:30that a human driver can take over at any time.
- 36:34Why is that? Because in 23, going forward, the
- 36:39concept of driverless cars was not level six,
- 36:43but the concept of driverless cars, if I were
- 36:45to go back to the level zero to level five scale
- 36:50of the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration,
- 36:53there was still a desire that a driver can reengage
- 36:57to prevent harm and prevent damage to infrastructure.
- 37:01to other humans, to other vehicles on the roadway.
- 37:05So the coming infrastructure changes will create
- 37:08challenges. It'll create challenges to states.
- 37:12It'll create challenges to how much states seek
- 37:16to invest state money, roadways, traffic lights,
- 37:20smart lanes, sensors on the roads, traffic cameras.
- 37:24Will that be a state function? Will that be a
- 37:27federal function? If it's a state function, it's
- 37:30going to be left to the state to regulate and
- 37:32to dive in with all of the heavy regulations
- 37:35once you cross the roadway into California versus
- 37:38crossing the roadway into Nevada. If this becomes
- 37:42a federal issue, like the FAA over planes, then
- 37:49who should bear the costs? Who should bear the
- 37:52costs? So that's just an interesting question
- 37:54at this time. on this side of the scale where
- 37:57we don't have level six. Who should bear the
- 38:00cost? And when level five vehicles starting to
- 38:03go into mass production, again, the thought process
- 38:06now among manufacturers, that's somewhere between
- 38:102035 and 2040. When level five vehicles are out,
- 38:16the question will be how much responsibility,
- 38:20how much residual responsibility in a level five
- 38:24vehicle will still spill into the driver's hands.
- 38:29That's going to be the litigation question. That's
- 38:32going to be the insurance question. That's going
- 38:35to be the reservation of rights discussion in
- 38:38the reservation of rights letter. That's going
- 38:40to be very germane to the coverage denial issue
- 38:45for this particular accident on this particular
- 38:47roadway with this particular vehicle. Those are
- 38:50very heavy considerations. And again, state governments,
- 38:53insurance carriers, alike need to get out in
- 38:58front of what's coming and need to get out in
- 39:00front actively in what's coming because the technology
- 39:04is moving so fast now, the infrastructure being
- 39:08slow to respond, government mandates and government
- 39:11restrictions being slow to respond, the last
- 39:14thing you would want are level five and level
- 39:17six vehicles on the road with very minimal regulation
- 39:21in terms of how that's going to all play out.
- 39:23which in the end will result in juries passing
- 39:27massive nuclear verdicts against product manufacturers
- 39:30and anyone else that the plaintiff's bar can
- 39:33seek, rightfully so with no regulation and no
- 39:36standards against any other pocket that would
- 39:39have to contribute to payment for such a verdict.
- 39:47This is an article back from 2018 where General
- 39:51Motors was looking forward to developing self
- 39:55-driving vehicles But they knew back in 2018
- 39:59and 19 that there was a significant long road
- 40:03ahead and General Motors like other corporations
- 40:06the hope was that Stage one would be the mass
- 40:11production of electric vehicles stage two would
- 40:16be moving to level four or five autonomous vehicles.
- 40:21The goal was to get the public very comfortable
- 40:25with and very reliable on electric vehicles with
- 40:30all of the technology. And then the electric
- 40:33vehicles at their height would simply be a software
- 40:37update away from being fully autonomous, akin
- 40:41to how your Tesla that you pick up is a software
- 40:45update away from being a fully autonomous vehicle
- 40:48or, better put, able to operate in some circumstances
- 40:53in an autonomous or semi -autonomous mode. So
- 40:58how does all of this impact insurance, data privacy,
- 41:02and cybersecurity? I'll tackle insurance because
- 41:06the second area, data privacy and cybersecurity,
- 41:10again, that could be its own breakout webinar.
- 41:13In that future vehicle, when you have a user
- 41:16and now your cell phone and your vehicle and
- 41:20your home systems are all in sync with the same
- 41:22passwords and their shared data among all, you
- 41:26can imagine what happens when there's a breach,
- 41:28when there is a data breach, when there is a
- 41:32theft of passwords. And now the vehicle data
- 41:35that contains your personal data, your banking
- 41:38data, perhaps one day your medical data for reasons
- 41:42that will come in the future. If there's a breach
- 41:46and your data is now exposed, where will the
- 41:49liability fall? Will your traditional future
- 41:52auto liability policy cover a data breach when
- 41:57you are a user of a level five or level six vehicle?
- 42:00Very challenging and interesting question. But
- 42:04let's look at current auto liability policies,
- 42:08personal and commercial lines. What are the coverage
- 42:11implications? What are the exposure implications
- 42:14for using when a driver becomes a user or a driver
- 42:19thinks they're a user because they put the vehicle
- 42:22in semi -autonomous mode? After one conference
- 42:26that I presented at, I got a very interesting
- 42:29question from a claim manager from a company.
- 42:32And she discussed a claim where there was an
- 42:37allegation that their insured was driving drunk
- 42:40and resulted in an accident. The drunk driving
- 42:44resulted in an accident. It turns out that the
- 42:48insured's defense was this. He knew he was drunk
- 42:51when he left the bar, but he had engaged from
- 42:55the bar the full autonomous mode of his vehicle,
- 43:01of his Tesla vehicle, to take him from point
- 43:03A to point B. So his goal in knowing that he
- 43:07was intoxicated was not to drive the vehicle,
- 43:10but it was allow the vehicle to drive him from
- 43:13the bar establishment to his desired destination.
- 43:19It was his defense that the vehicle somehow failed,
- 43:22resulting in the accident. When officers arrived
- 43:24on the scene, found the condition of the driver,
- 43:27who again in his mind was claiming that he was
- 43:30only a user and did a breathalyzer. He was arrested
- 43:33for drunk driving. The carrier paid the claim
- 43:36without investigating the potential issues that
- 43:39the driver was attempting to raise, rightfully
- 43:43or wrongfully. How successful will you be as
- 43:47an intoxicated driver to program your vehicle
- 43:49to take you from point A to point B to engage
- 43:52the significant technology that your vehicle
- 43:55has? That's probably another jury question for
- 43:58another webinar for another day. The point of
- 44:02the discussion after this conference was that
- 44:05this claim manager knew that with the coming
- 44:08changes in technology, there had to be part of
- 44:12the investigation by her liability team had to
- 44:14be in to whether or not the user, the driver
- 44:20had engaged any of the technology systems in
- 44:23the vehicle or any of those systems in operation
- 44:27at the time of the collision accident. And if
- 44:30so, How much residual responsibility rests with
- 44:34the driver versus did the driver engage in anything
- 44:38where the driver could actively and truthfully
- 44:41rely upon the vehicle system? And what are the
- 44:45coverage implications for that under the policy?
- 44:47So it's a very fascinating, interesting discussion
- 44:50that I think will implicate a different layer,
- 44:54if you will, of claim investigations. Another
- 44:58highlight in this area that I think is important
- 45:01is that in the future litigation, I raise the
- 45:05question, what will be the future auto policy?
- 45:09When you look at level five, and then you look
- 45:13at what I've advanced to be level six, will you
- 45:16be able to go to any of the major carriers? Will
- 45:19the commercials on TV even remain the same? And
- 45:22will you have a future personal auto liability
- 45:26policy? If you're just a user of what's essentially
- 45:31a computer vehicle, will your traditional auto
- 45:35policy apply? I think if your level is one through
- 45:39five currently, and if there's an opportunity
- 45:43for the driver to reengage, then the driver obviously
- 45:46has to have some type of liability policy for
- 45:49protection in the event of an accident. But what
- 45:52happens when level six becomes promulgated? If
- 45:56you go to your, Audi has a commercial that they've
- 46:00long had for the last four years on their future
- 46:03fully autonomous vehicle that you can simply
- 46:06program to show up at your house, take you from
- 46:10point A to point B and do other things while
- 46:12you are at point B, return to you and take you
- 46:16and any passengers back to your home or any other
- 46:19desired location. If you're simply a user, Will
- 46:23you need a personal auto liability policy? Or
- 46:27will that policy completely change and become
- 46:31almost akin to a homeowner policy in the sense
- 46:35that it covers you in the event of any product
- 46:38failure, it covers you and your data against
- 46:41any cybersecurity issues, and it covers you in
- 46:45a different format than it would cover you if
- 46:49you were a driver. of the vehicle and what will
- 46:52be the pricing of that policy and how will that
- 46:54be competitive? Those are all very significant
- 46:57questions I think that insurance carriers will
- 46:59face hopefully very aggressively in the next
- 47:03five years and well ahead of 2035 to the 2040
- 47:08territory. We've discussed infrastructure, the
- 47:15digital disruption issue, is the data from the
- 47:20vehicles going up and down from this ultimate
- 47:23cloud where the vehicles learning and learning
- 47:27of environments, learning of driving habits,
- 47:31and shared communication with other autonomous
- 47:33vehicles. What happens if that system were to
- 47:38get compromised? Or what happens if there's a
- 47:41failure from the communication of data from the
- 47:44cloud? back to the vehicles. So just so that
- 47:47you're not thinking that this is too far in our
- 47:52thinking, if I'm in a level six and I'm downtown
- 47:57LA going to an event and you're in a level six
- 48:01vehicle, and let's say that you are eight to
- 48:0410 vehicles ahead, I absolutely want whatever
- 48:07your vehicle is learning on the road that could
- 48:10be a hazard, I absolutely would want your vehicle
- 48:14to somehow communicate to the cloud, which then
- 48:17somehow communicates in real time to my vehicle,
- 48:20that there's a hazard on the road, that there's
- 48:23something to avoid, that there's a dangerous
- 48:25condition that should affect the vehicle speed.
- 48:28So that is a later discussion when we start to
- 48:32get into level six, but it will impact level
- 48:35five as well where you still have drivers engaged.
- 48:39What is the data sharing? Another Issue concerning
- 48:44data is when you get into the territory of litigation.
- 48:48How easy will it be for the major auto insurance
- 48:51carriers under their present posture to secure
- 48:56information from manufacturers such as Tesla,
- 48:59Volvo, General Motors, so to speak. One of the
- 49:03issues that I didn't go into on purpose concerning
- 49:07the Tesla trial that reached a verdict through
- 49:10the jury, where the jury again found the driver
- 49:1367 % at fault for his conduct, but the remaining
- 49:17percentage, they really returned a nuclear verdict
- 49:20against Tesla, the product manufacturer. One
- 49:24of the issues that the plaintiff bar, plaintiff
- 49:27attorneys advanced in that case was that Tesla
- 49:30did not turn over in the due course of discovery,
- 49:34all of the relevant data for the autonomous driving
- 49:37features of their vehicles. And that that blockage
- 49:40during discovery prohibited the plaintiffs from
- 49:45making certain additional assertions against
- 49:48the failures of the Tesla self -driving mode.
- 49:52Like any discovery battle in any litigation that
- 49:55later becomes important, it's always highlighted
- 49:58during trial. But that was a consideration in
- 50:01that trial. And that will absolutely be a consideration
- 50:05when insurance carriers are filing subrogation
- 50:08lawsuits and they're seeking to recoup damages
- 50:11paid out to their insured in the event of what
- 50:14essentially is a product failure. So I offer
- 50:17that for your consideration as well as a part
- 50:19of this discussion. The history of the vehicle
- 50:23industry, no need to really engage in that today.
- 50:25Early technology advances. No need to get engaged
- 50:29in that today. And then the impact of driverless
- 50:32vehicles. We've touched on that through a number
- 50:35of avenues. Again, looking forward to levels
- 50:38four, five, and six vehicles. And again, level
- 50:42six is my term of art. The highest two levels
- 50:45according to the National Highway Traffic and
- 50:47Safety Administrations are level four and five.
- 50:51I would argue that Tesla, even in its best, Software
- 50:58download, partially self -driving mode falls
- 51:02somewhere between level three and four. I would
- 51:05love to have a discussion with any of you later
- 51:07on that because I think even that discussion
- 51:09is fascinating and has a lot of implications,
- 51:12if you will. We discussed briefly how vehicles
- 51:16drive autonomously. We discussed the scale. I
- 51:19think the scale remains very important and levels
- 51:23three, four, and five are going to be the focus
- 51:26of vehicle production and also litigation and
- 51:31also how to price your future auto policy and
- 51:35how to redraft and retool what a future auto
- 51:38policy will be. I think it will implicate insurance
- 51:42brokers, commercial policies. It was in 2017
- 51:49that I first saw a Cummings motor display where
- 51:55you could have two semi -trucks, one semi -truck
- 51:59being controlled by a driver, and the second
- 52:04semi -truck following the first semi -truck could
- 52:07be autonomously controlled to link to truck number
- 52:12one, link to the patterns, and the technology
- 52:17that was operated by a driver in truck number
- 52:20one. So essentially, you could ship two truckloads
- 52:24by one driver down the road. And obviously, what
- 52:28will come later? Self -driving commercial trucks
- 52:33on the roadway, which will impact workers' compensation,
- 52:37which will impact how many drivers do we hire
- 52:40on startup companies. That was in 2017, and this
- 52:44is now the end of 2025. I can only imagine how
- 52:48that technology and what will later be introduced
- 52:52to the commercial trucking world is going to
- 52:54be very, very interesting. The cloud issues,
- 52:59who controls the vehicles upon the road. Where
- 53:02does responsibility lie? Where will liability
- 53:05lie versus trucking company versus product manufacturer?
- 53:09There will be an interplay of all of those issues
- 53:12in that context as well. We discussed data usage
- 53:16and privacy infrastructure implications as well.
- 53:22So to the audience, how will autonomous vehicles
- 53:27levels four, five, and six I say five and six
- 53:31affect driver liability. What will the future
- 53:34jury be asked? We could spend another breakout
- 53:39session just discussing jury selection in this
- 53:43context. And you can imagine how your future
- 53:46jury is going to vary greatly on those who absolutely
- 53:50would use an Uber in a new town or absolutely
- 53:54have no problem getting in a Waymo vehicle and
- 53:57going from point A to point B. versus the jurors
- 54:00that want nothing to do with autonomous vehicles,
- 54:02don't want anything to do with the advanced systems
- 54:05in vehicles, and simply want to be a full -time,
- 54:08fully engaged driver in the car. That's going
- 54:10to be a challenge for future trial counsel in
- 54:13picking juries in this space. What will happen
- 54:16to traditional negligence principles? Who will
- 54:21retain the duty if the driver is not a driver,
- 54:24but the driver is a user? or if the driver only
- 54:27has limited circumstances when the driver can
- 54:29re -engage. What will constitute a breach of
- 54:32that duty and if so by whom? Causation and damages.
- 54:37The issue of fault and causation. Do we need
- 54:40to rethink the concept of liability? Obviously
- 54:43everything that I've voiced thus far I think
- 54:45we do. Liability of manufacturers. Essentially
- 54:50when you have a user of a level five, six vehicle.
- 54:54If I say level six, liability will shift from
- 54:58the driver focus to the manufacturer focus. So
- 55:01now you have product liability principles applying
- 55:04in the context of autonomous vehicles and autonomous
- 55:08vehicle litigation. Will liability shift from
- 55:11the driver to the manufacturer due to the autonomous
- 55:14nature of the vehicle? Absolutely so. Another
- 55:17breakout session would be a discussion of product
- 55:20liability law. States adopting strict liability,
- 55:23states rejecting strict liability, jurisdictional
- 55:26differences in case law among judges across the
- 55:30United States. What will happen? Will strict
- 55:33product liability claims eliminate negligence?
- 55:38Negligence is the failure to warn. Will that
- 55:40only fall under strict product liability principles?
- 55:45Defects and defectiveness, human -computer data
- 55:49interaction, and then Another breakout session
- 55:52would be government regulations in this context.
- 55:57And that's what we've just touched on, the liability
- 55:59of the manufacturers, product liability law.
- 56:05Government regulations, just touched very briefly
- 56:08on this. It's going to be very interesting. Will
- 56:11there be government regulations that will govern
- 56:15product manufacturers before the level six vehicle?
- 56:20makes its way into your hands and minds where
- 56:23we become users and we are no longer considered
- 56:27drivers. Again, California's current law is that
- 56:31a driverless vehicle must still have some sort
- 56:34of steering wheel to allow the vehicle, the driver
- 56:38to reengage that doesn't apply to a Waymo because
- 56:41there is no driver outside of the computer in
- 56:45a Waymo type vehicle. Will there be state statutes?
- 56:48They'll have to be. Will federal law trump state
- 56:52law in this context? Very interesting discussions.
- 56:56That's why that would be its own separate breakout
- 56:58session in the future. Coverage issues for insurance
- 57:03carriers, the driver. Will there be a driver?
- 57:07The owner. Will you and I simply lease a commonly
- 57:13owned vehicle from a product manufacturer? the
- 57:17vehicle itself, who will insure the vehicle?
- 57:20Will Volvo General Motors offer their own insurance
- 57:23policy that insures the vehicle in the event
- 57:26of a product failure? And the data, the sharing
- 57:30of data in the context of litigation, but will
- 57:33the, if General Motors, for example, were to
- 57:36be the owner of the vehicle and you and I are
- 57:40simply users, does General Motors have a right
- 57:43to access our data in the event of a product
- 57:45failure? Again, another loaded topic could be
- 57:48a breakout session as well. So these are future
- 57:52questions defining exposures for drivers, for
- 57:55users, data privacy. Will the homeowner policy,
- 58:00will there be a standalone cyber policy when
- 58:03you are a user of a fully autonomous vehicle?
- 58:07How does underwriting going to rate these cars
- 58:10separately from the driver? How will underwriting
- 58:13help insurance carriers draft policies? And again,
- 58:16the question I've asked, will this be goodbye
- 58:18to the traditional auto liability insurance policy?
- 58:23Tons of challenges for the insurance industry.
- 58:25We are up against it as it is one minute before
- 58:30the end of our hour. So I will conclude our presentation
- 58:36this afternoon. I want to thank everyone for
- 58:40engaging. My contact information is in the materials
- 58:44you receive. Happy to just engage in discussion,
- 58:48happy to engage in litigation trends, happy to
- 58:51engage in trial strategy and other considerations.
- 58:55As I do practice across the US, there's a lot
- 58:58of different types of considerations depending
- 59:02where you are in these United States. So I thank
- 59:05you. everyone for attending for this full hour
- 59:08and I thank the future viewers of this on a recorded
- 59:13webinar. Thank you everyone.