Latest / The Vegan Report / The Future of Animal Rights. With Cat Kerr | Ep. 105
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:03and have you ever watched a nature documentary
- 0:06in which a wild animal was filmed struggling
- 0:10for survival? That's usually a very common trope.
- 0:15Maybe running from a predator, desperately foraging
- 0:18for food, or braving bad weather. Well, what
- 0:23if I told you that we had a moral imperative
- 0:27to help that animal? In fact, to help all wildlife
- 0:33creatures, to play an active role in their welfare
- 0:37even when their sufferings are not traced back
- 0:41to us. There is an organization called Wild Animal
- 0:45Initiative that studies this very question. Their
- 0:50communication director Kat joined me to talk
- 0:53about the implications of that revolutionary
- 0:56idea. We discussed how wild animal initiatives
- 1:00work could be a cure for vegan misentropy, the
- 1:05deadly risk of feeding birds, my awesome story
- 1:08of squirrel rescue, contraception for rodents,
- 1:13and much more. Visit the episode notes to connect
- 1:17with wild animal initiative. Their work truly
- 1:21deserves our support and fascination. Wild Animal
- 1:25Initiative is one of the 10 animal charity evaluators
- 1:30recommended charities. I committed to interviewing
- 1:34every charity on that golden list because I'm
- 1:38really curious to learn who is behind the most
- 1:42effective efforts to advance the cause of animal
- 1:46rights. So follow the show and don't miss out
- 1:50on those conversations. Also, make sure to share
- 1:54this episode with the vegans you know. Leave
- 1:57a good review. Thank you. areas that they focus
- 2:23on is cost -effectiveness, so how many animals
- 2:26can possibly be helped per dollar. And Wild Animal
- 2:31Initiative ultimately exists to improve the lives
- 2:35of wild animals, and so there are so many wild
- 2:38animals out there, many, many more than there
- 2:42are farmed animals or anything else. And we have
- 2:47enough evidence to believe that there's a good
- 2:49possibility. Many of them are suffering immensely.
- 2:52And so if we can invest in research to understand
- 2:55this and ultimately invest in interventions to
- 3:00improve their lives, then there's so much potential
- 3:02to do good in the wild that ACE recognizes that
- 3:06and wants to see that grow. I was so intrigued
- 3:11by your mission statement and the fact that you
- 3:17highlights something that we all understand,
- 3:19which is that wildlife is, of course, suffering.
- 3:22But, you know, we accept that as if it's the
- 3:26natural order of things. I think that people,
- 3:30if they saw like, I don't know, a duck in a bad
- 3:35situation, like stuck in a fence or something
- 3:39like that, they would intervene and help that
- 3:41creature. But they would not, you know, think
- 3:45actively about the suffering of other creatures
- 3:49that are not on, you know, in their field of
- 3:52vision. So it's kind of a very counterintuitive
- 3:58idea. It's a very revolutionary idea in a way.
- 4:02Right, right. And even for a lot of vegans, I
- 4:05think this idea persists of let the wild be wild
- 4:10and let nature take its course. But If you really
- 4:14think about it with this dog example, physiologically
- 4:18and psychologically, there's not much difference,
- 4:21if any, between a dog and a fox or a coyote or
- 4:26something like that. All these animals, they
- 4:32experience fear, they experience pain. To me,
- 4:37it feels rather cold to say, well, just because
- 4:40the fox or the coyote is designated as a wild
- 4:43animal that we should let nature happen, whatever
- 4:47that means and whatever suffering that might
- 4:49entail. Rather than stand by and let that happen,
- 4:56we're interested in figuring out what we can
- 4:57do to help any sentient animal in the wild. I
- 5:01also think about this sometimes in a lens of
- 5:05humanitarian aid because it would sound terrible
- 5:10if we said to those who suffer from like maybe
- 5:13a flood happens in their area and puts a bunch
- 5:17of people in poverty or people in a certain area
- 5:20of the world are suffering from diseases that
- 5:23maybe we don't really deal with in the West anymore
- 5:25or something like that. And it would be terrible
- 5:27to say, well, nature led to that flood or nature
- 5:31led to those diseases circulating. And so we'll
- 5:34just let nature run its course. Instead we employ
- 5:39technologies and medicines and things, and rescue
- 5:42efforts to help people who suffer from natural
- 5:45things. So in the same way, why not extend that
- 5:49compassion to wild animals? Yes. You know, do
- 5:56you? Are you, you know, talking about all wildlife,
- 6:01you know, for instance, insects? Do we include
- 6:05them in in that list? There is some evidence
- 6:09that they are sentient, but it's not as evident
- 6:14as mammals, for instance. So what do you mean
- 6:17by wildlife? So right now, most of what wild
- 6:23animal initiative is researching is on vertebrates.
- 6:27So we're nearly confident or confident that all
- 6:31vertebrates can feel pain and have these kinds
- 6:35of emotional and subjective experiences that
- 6:38to improve their welfare would be a benefit to
- 6:41them. But we're not exclusively interested in
- 6:45vertebrates and we are interested in invertebrates
- 6:48like insects that exhibit some signs of even
- 6:53possibly being sentient. We're hoping that other
- 6:55groups will continue that research to confirm
- 6:59which species are sentient or not. But in the
- 7:02meantime, we're thinking about this at least.
- 7:05So we have funded a project about bumblebees
- 7:09and another one about crickets. So we are interested
- 7:14in this kind of thing, but until we have more
- 7:18confirmation of the sentience of the different
- 7:20insects or different invertebrates, it's not
- 7:23our primary focus. That's really fascinating.
- 7:27You mentioned how the vegan community thinks
- 7:32about you know, wildlife and it's true that we
- 7:36are mostly focused on animals that are suffering
- 7:40from, you know, the hands of human beings. How
- 7:45do you explain, you know, that bias and, you
- 7:49know, the difference that we make between animals
- 7:53that might be suffering from natural causes versus
- 7:57animals that are suffering from our hands as
- 8:01a consequence of our presence. We only feel responsible
- 8:05for the animals that are suffering because of
- 8:09us. So what do you make of that? How do you address
- 8:12that bias? Well, I think it's natural that that
- 8:15bias exists. We feel this sense of our own kind
- 8:21has caused this evil. if it's factory farming
- 8:23or something. Therefore, we are responsible for
- 8:27advocating to the members of our own kind to
- 8:29stop doing that thing and make this evil stop.
- 8:32So it's very expected that that would exist.
- 8:38I also think it's just a lot easier to stop the
- 8:42human caused harms because we know exactly what
- 8:45they are. We know they're net negative and we
- 8:48can just say, stop doing that. whether that's
- 8:50factory farming or something else. But in the
- 8:53wild, when we're talking about things that wild
- 8:56animals suffer from that are not directly caused
- 8:58by humans, it's a lot more complex and it's a
- 9:01lot harder to figure out what exactly to do.
- 9:05Because let's say you see a certain type of suffering
- 9:11that affects one species, you can't just jump
- 9:14in and intervene without having a lot of research
- 9:19done on like, well, if I help the members of
- 9:22this species, how does that affect other species
- 9:24in their ecosystem that they interact with? Is
- 9:27it going to be net positive for welfare across
- 9:30the species in their ecosystem? Or maybe it helps
- 9:33this one species, but it's actually net negative
- 9:34for all the species involved. So it's not the
- 9:39kind of thing. where you can just jump in. And
- 9:41that's why at Wild Animal Initiative, we are
- 9:43not yet advocating for any specific interventions
- 9:46because right now we're still in the research
- 9:48stage and we're cultivating the growth of this
- 9:52field to get all these scientists working on
- 9:56this and get a lot more answers before we just
- 9:59step in. So we want to do this carefully and
- 10:02responsibly. Yeah, there's so much we don't know
- 10:04about wildlife. It's just crazy. There are so
- 10:10many of them out there, you know, when you're
- 10:12doing vegan activism, and you're in the animal
- 10:16rights space, it seems like animals in factory
- 10:20farming that are like 10 folds more animals in
- 10:25factory farms than in the wild, but it's not
- 10:29true. One activist said once in my podcast, a
- 10:34billion animals are slaughtered every minute.
- 10:37I thought, no, this is not right. This does not
- 10:41sound very truthful. But how many wild animals
- 10:47are there? Well, according to animal charity
- 10:50evaluators, currently, there are about 112 billion
- 10:56farmed animals in the system at a given time.
- 11:00Meanwhile, there are 10 to the 15th power wild
- 11:05animals out there at a given time. And I'm pretty
- 11:08sure these numbers only include the sentient
- 11:11vertebrates in the wild. They're not including
- 11:13all insects. That would be even a vastly larger
- 11:16number. So to give you an idea, it's something
- 11:19like that. And one reason that the farmed animal
- 11:24number is as large as it is and why you hear
- 11:27these figures like a billion are killed per day
- 11:30or whatever it was, is because of fish and small
- 11:34animals like shrimp in the system. And so if
- 11:37you think about it, naturally there are more
- 11:41fish and shrimp in the oceans that are wild than
- 11:44there are being farmed, because if there were
- 11:46more being farmed than there were wild, we would
- 11:49be on track to extinction of all those species.
- 11:51And in some certainly are, but probably not the
- 11:54species that are being farmed. So that kind of
- 11:56helps people get a gauge on this. work toward
- 12:01visualizing it, but these numbers are so large,
- 12:03it's like, it's very hard to really wrap our
- 12:05minds around it. I think going back to that bias
- 12:09that we have towards wildlife, they're also,
- 12:14you know, and I mentioned that they're not in
- 12:17our field of vision, you know, most vegans live
- 12:20in cities or maybe suburbs, there isn't much,
- 12:26you know, wildlife to see. in those places. And
- 12:30so it's easier to ignore them and not think about
- 12:34them. I saw a picture recently of a tuna fish
- 12:39that was featured in a Japanese fish market.
- 12:44And that fish was gigantic. And you think this
- 12:49was just roaming the oceans. It's not even, you
- 12:54know, easy to conceptualize. because we only
- 12:58know our surroundings and the world feels very
- 13:03much small that way. For sure. I think definitely
- 13:09when you ask somebody to visualize a wild animal,
- 13:13what comes to mind is often a big charismatic
- 13:16animal like that. Maybe not necessarily a tuna.
- 13:18If a tuna came to mind for somebody, I'd be...
- 13:20really interested to know why. Maybe they're
- 13:22working in an industry or something. But for
- 13:24a lot of people, it's like a lion or an elephant
- 13:27or something. And that's often because as we're
- 13:31growing up, these are the animals that we see
- 13:33in a zoo or we learn about in school, we read
- 13:36about in children's books. And so that kind of
- 13:38imprints this idea on us that it's always these
- 13:41large, really impressive, kind of majestic animals.
- 13:45But the vast majority of animals in the wild
- 13:48are much smaller. So working in this field and
- 13:53this movement, when I ask myself now to visualize
- 13:57a wild animal, I think of like a sparrow or a
- 14:01mouse. And these kinds of animals do live in
- 14:05cities. And to get people to see that like the
- 14:10pigeon outside your window or the rat that your
- 14:14landlord is constantly trying to trap or something,
- 14:17those are wild animals too. they deserve our
- 14:20consideration. And so if you're sharing a habitat
- 14:22with those kinds of animals, those are the ones
- 14:25to think about, you know, maybe we can't all
- 14:28change the entire world, or we can't all save
- 14:30every single animal that's out there. But we
- 14:33all live with some in proximity. Okay, you mentioned
- 14:37some of the sufferings that those animals encounter.
- 14:43And I would love to dive into what kinds of sufferings
- 14:48that are not caused by humans, those wild animals
- 14:53experience. You know, I think, you know, top
- 14:58of mind, I can think of wildfires. That's one.
- 15:04But are we also including like suffering from
- 15:08predators? Are we also including, you know, suffering
- 15:14caused by epidemics, you know, maybe parasites,
- 15:18all of that. Yeah, just to give you kind of a
- 15:21sense of the kinds of suffering that we're thinking
- 15:23about. Disease is a big one. So for example,
- 15:29in the southern US where I live, the government
- 15:33distributes rabies vaccines to wild animals,
- 15:36they it's like an edible biscuit that has this
- 15:39vaccine. enclosed and they just drop them out
- 15:41of helicopters. And the point of this program
- 15:44is they don't want wild animals to have rabies
- 15:47because they don't want rabies to spread to pets
- 15:49and farmed animals. They don't really care about
- 15:52the individual experiences of the raccoons or
- 15:55something like that. But we look at a program
- 15:57like this and we're like, well, this already
- 15:59exists. How could we scale this up? How could
- 16:01we make this more efficient? What other diseases
- 16:04could we developed vaccines for. And so this
- 16:09is a really promising area of research would
- 16:12be vaccines and disease alleviation. Possibly
- 16:16parasites like you mentioned as well. The elimination
- 16:20of the new world screw worm is a case study we
- 16:23point to a lot where it's pretty much been eliminated
- 16:28from North America. And we don't know everything
- 16:31about what that meant for the welfare of these
- 16:33insects themselves, but we can definitely say
- 16:36that at this point, it was net positive for the
- 16:40vertebrates involved in this interaction because
- 16:43they no longer suffer from that parasite in North
- 16:45America. I think there was a case or two where
- 16:48they found some evidence that maybe these insects
- 16:52were coming back, but largely they've been eradicated.
- 16:54So maybe there's other programs like that that
- 16:56we can do. Other kinds of suffering could be
- 17:02just starvation. A lot of animals just starve.
- 17:05It's hard to find food out there, especially
- 17:08in the winter and colder parts of the world.
- 17:11It's just hard. I think we believe that they're
- 17:16somehow supernaturally equipped to deal with
- 17:19this, but they're not. They often starve because
- 17:22they can't find food, so what could we do to
- 17:24help solve that problem for them? Like you said,
- 17:29forest fires or wildfires, but there are other
- 17:33kinds of natural disasters as well. There's flooding
- 17:35in certain parts of the world that could be cyclical.
- 17:39And for example, in like Northeast India, the
- 17:43monsoons come, the national parks flood. Many
- 17:48animals migrate out of the parks during that
- 17:50time, but like juveniles often get left behind
- 17:53or they get stuck or something. So what needs
- 17:56to be done there? And then you mentioned predation.
- 18:01So that's an interesting one because we definitely
- 18:06can't just say, let's end predation. That would
- 18:10be negative for many animals who are predators.
- 18:14We don't have an answer to this yet, certainly.
- 18:16And I do not think the answer would be universal.
- 18:19It would be like, here's an intervention that
- 18:21we can just do anywhere for any predator -prey
- 18:25interaction. And it's going to be good for welfare.
- 18:28I think there's so many different factors that
- 18:30we would have to look at. It would be probably
- 18:33really localized, whatever might happen. But
- 18:37because that one is so difficult, and it's so
- 18:40obviously depends on ecological interactions,
- 18:42it's just not the one we're starting with. There's
- 18:45so much more to do in the meantime, that that
- 18:48was kind of on the back burner. How do people
- 18:51react when you mentioned all of that, you know,
- 18:55that we can play a positive role in the lives
- 18:58of wildlife, that all of those sufferings should
- 19:02not be seen as necessary or part of a natural
- 19:07balance, and that we can avoid them and improve
- 19:11the lives of so many sentient beings. How do
- 19:14people respond to that? There are different reactions.
- 19:18I think some people are really excited about
- 19:22it. And to have this to learn that you might
- 19:28actually be able to play a positive role in the
- 19:31lives of wild animals when for your whole life
- 19:33you thought there was nothing that you could
- 19:35do. And all we can do basically is manage populations
- 19:39and make sure the ecosystem is quote balanced,
- 19:43whatever that might even mean. It's very subjective
- 19:45when you boil it down to the data we actually
- 19:49have. But to learn that maybe you can do something
- 19:52and maybe there are improvements that we can
- 19:54make is really exciting and inspiring for some
- 19:56people. And then there are others who respond
- 20:02with resistance and sometimes it comes from fear
- 20:07of unintended consequences happening as we intervene
- 20:13and without knowing those answers things can
- 20:17go terribly wrong and they are correct which
- 20:19is exactly why we're advocating for so much.
- 20:22research to be done and for this scientific field
- 20:24to grow. Other times, I think people react out
- 20:28of defense in a way. Like, they have always believed
- 20:34in this idea of a balanced ecosystem. They've
- 20:37always believed that animals can handle whatever
- 20:40has come to them. They've evolved to be able
- 20:43to handle it. And to have your beliefs challenged
- 20:46can feel not so great at times. But I've seen
- 20:50plenty of people who hold that response initially
- 20:53to continue learning about this, approach it
- 20:58with an open mind and with curiosity and over
- 21:00time change their minds and decide that maybe
- 21:04in fact there are ways we can intervene that
- 21:06are net positive and we don't have to know all
- 21:09of the answers before we start but we should
- 21:11know some answers and we can do this really carefully
- 21:14and So it's, it's encouraging to me to see people
- 21:18who were initially resistant start to open up.
- 21:23Yeah, I mean, there is a in the vegan community,
- 21:28at least there's a lot of misentropy, you know,
- 21:32humans that are seen as the source of all evil
- 21:36and the ultimate predators and the sadistic creature
- 21:41that is doing so much harm to all of the rest,
- 21:45all other beings on the planet. And I love how
- 21:49your mission casts such a positive light on humanity
- 21:54as this possible asset for all other species
- 21:59on earth. They can depend on us to protect them
- 22:05against so much harm that they have not evolved
- 22:08to address. And so I love the positivity of that
- 22:14message going against that negative misentropy
- 22:18that is present in this community. Yeah, I do
- 22:22too. Um, that makes me feel encouraged as a vegan
- 22:26in this space, you know, as well. This reminds
- 22:28me of something I read about, I think last year
- 22:31there was a research team in Antarctica and this
- 22:37was not a team that had anything to do with wild
- 22:39animal initiative. they might not even have been
- 22:42aware that our field is in existence. But they
- 22:47were studying penguins, and a few penguins got
- 22:52stuck on some kind of embankment of snow or something
- 22:56like that, and the rest of their group was able
- 22:59to get out, but these few were still stuck there.
- 23:03And the scientists were trying to decide what
- 23:06to do. Should we just watch and let them remain
- 23:09trapped and probably starve or maybe get eaten
- 23:11by one of the predators who go after penguins
- 23:15in this area or something, or should we intervene?
- 23:18And they ended up deciding to intervene. It was
- 23:20easy enough for them to just rescue these penguins
- 23:23out of that situation. And when they wrote about
- 23:26this later, they got some critique from people
- 23:28saying that was unethical to intervene. You're
- 23:31just there to observe your scientists, whatever.
- 23:34But they pushed back on that. They wrote this
- 23:36essay that said, We are humans of this earth.
- 23:41We're part of nature too. And so our compassion
- 23:45for the penguins was not unnatural. It was just,
- 23:49it was part of our nature. And we took advantage
- 23:52of that to do some good. And that really stuck
- 23:55with me because I don't think we have to think
- 23:57of this as humans versus nature. It's just that
- 24:01we're part of it too. And we have technology
- 24:04and we have the cognitive abilities and Especially
- 24:08as AI is advancing, we're going to have way more
- 24:11that we can do for them. So I try to think of
- 24:14our compassion as just a natural part of the
- 24:17human experience. That's that's beautiful. And
- 24:21it's, you know, it inspires me to share a story.
- 24:25And I might sound crazy, but I'll share it anyway.
- 24:29I was once, you know, just You know at home doing
- 24:32whatever it was summer and all of a sudden there
- 24:36was this blue Jay that just perched itself on
- 24:42you know near the window of my home, which was
- 24:45unusual and Started just screaming at me or you
- 24:51know, I felt this way anyway and When when I
- 24:56paid attention to what was happening Um, he kept,
- 25:01you know, flying away. Um, and then there was
- 25:05a pool nearby, um, and, and just circling around
- 25:09the pool. And I felt like he was guiding me to
- 25:13that pool, like just check what's happening.
- 25:17And I did, and there was a squirrel just drowning
- 25:20in the water. And I was able to rescue that squirrel
- 25:24out of the water. And I thought. am I imagining
- 25:28stuff? Did that blue jay really used me, like
- 25:33collaborated with me to save the life of that
- 25:35squirrel? Is that possible in nature? Well, that's
- 25:39an amazing story. Thank you for paying attention
- 25:42and, and considering the possibility that that
- 25:45was a message. I definitely think this is possible.
- 25:49I don't want to get sort of like mystical and
- 25:53say that all the animals want to communicate
- 25:57with us or something. I don't believe that. But
- 25:59blue jays particularly are corvids, and corvids
- 26:04easily imprint on humans. So there's a good chance
- 26:06that this particular blue jay had been maybe
- 26:09fed by a human in a backyard or something, or
- 26:12maybe So I volunteer at a wild bird rehabilitation
- 26:17center and we have to be really careful with
- 26:19the blue jays because they will imprint. So maybe
- 26:21this one had been released from a rehabilitation
- 26:24center at some point and understood that humans
- 26:27are sort of there to help or we have hands and
- 26:30we can do more than the blue jay can do. So there's
- 26:33a good chance that this one in particular had
- 26:35some experience in their life that they understood.
- 26:39the abilities of humans to some extent and maybe
- 26:42they were trying to come get you. It's definitely
- 26:44possible. Well, I'm that's reassuring to hear
- 26:48that, you know, I'm not insane. I'm not going
- 26:50insane. Okay, you we mentioned a few times that,
- 26:55you know, word intervention and how people were
- 27:00hesitant to intervene in and you know that that
- 27:05word gives a sense that there's this division
- 27:08between their world and ours. Yet we don't see
- 27:14building a highway or building a new neighborhood
- 27:17in a city as an intervention inside the ecosystems.
- 27:24We don't have the same worry about that. How
- 27:30do we explain this double standard? If you are
- 27:35only concerned about wild animal populations,
- 27:39then you can build a highway, build a neighborhood
- 27:44in an area where wild animals live and you can
- 27:47demonstrate it won't alter the populations, therefore
- 27:51it's fine. And this is typically what happens.
- 27:54There is often some kind of review process when
- 27:57a new development is proposed or some kind of
- 27:59approval process where they have to consult some
- 28:03kind of local authority on ecology, whether that's
- 28:07the Department of Natural Resources, the Fish
- 28:10and Wildlife Service, whatever it might be in
- 28:12that area. And typically what happens is they're
- 28:17like, well, all the animals in this area are
- 28:19just really common species. There's nothing of
- 28:23conservation concern. So it doesn't really matter
- 28:26what happens to them. Or they might say, there
- 28:29are some species of conservation concern, so
- 28:32we know they like oak trees, and we'll just make
- 28:35sure that we put some oak trees in this development
- 28:37so that they still have some habitat. And it's
- 28:42insufficient, in my opinion. There are so many
- 28:46other things that could be going on with this
- 28:48development that could be positive or negative
- 28:50for welfare. It could be positive if, for example,
- 28:55all of these houses have yards and all of those
- 28:58yards are going to have bird feeders and bat
- 29:01houses or something like that. Perhaps that's
- 29:03better for welfare on net than if nothing was
- 29:06in that spot before. Obviously, it could be negative
- 29:09for welfare if everyone in this neighborhood
- 29:11has a cat that they let outside and that cat
- 29:15is going to be predating on birds. Maybe that's
- 29:19bad for welfare. When you shift your mindset
- 29:23from thinking about populations to thinking about
- 29:26individual welfare, it just opens up this whole
- 29:28other set of questions. I'm presenting some examples,
- 29:32but I don't even know whether any of those things
- 29:34is net positive or net negative until we have
- 29:37studies on those things. to your question what's
- 29:43what's often happening is they're looking at
- 29:45population effects they're predicting there won't
- 29:48really be any or at least won't be bad and so
- 29:51they're going ahead with that project but what
- 29:53we want to see happen is that they're also asking
- 29:55questions about welfare effects and that's like
- 29:59our our vision for the world is that in any situation
- 30:02where decisions are being made that involve wild
- 30:05animals Um, first of all, that the wild animals
- 30:08are being considered in the decision. And that
- 30:11second, their welfare specifically is being considered
- 30:13and not only their population sizes. Yeah. I
- 30:17mean, even when I hear like diehard environmentalists
- 30:22talk about, um, conservation and, you know, keeping
- 30:27a forest intact, they never talk about the welfare
- 30:31of animals. It's always about safeguarding the
- 30:34forest. Okay, what for? You know, for the benefit
- 30:39of... Like, mention the welfare of animals and
- 30:43they don't seem to make that connection. How
- 30:46do you explain that? It's often equated with
- 30:51survival. A lot of people just think if you care
- 30:56about wild animal welfare, that means you care
- 30:59about wild animals surviving. They are not the
- 31:01same thing. You can survive, you can live a very
- 31:05long time, but you can be completely miserable
- 31:08as you're going through that life. So welfare
- 31:11is not just surviving and it's not just avoiding
- 31:14an early death or something like that, but it's
- 31:15having a good life, a life that is net positive.
- 31:20You're having more positive experiences than
- 31:22negative ones. So that's one thing that happens
- 31:26a lot is they're just conflating this idea of
- 31:27welfare with the idea of survival. Another thing
- 31:31that happens is I think some environmentalists
- 31:36who might label themselves that way, but maybe
- 31:39they're not coming at it from necessarily a vegan
- 31:41mindset or something like that, they truly value
- 31:45aesthetics of nature. And they have in their
- 31:48heads some ideal of this pristine landscape and
- 31:52the animals that live there and what that looks
- 31:56like. I don't think that's inherently wrong or
- 32:01unethical, but if it's coming from a place where
- 32:05that's what you want because you want to see
- 32:07that and you want to enjoy it, I think that's
- 32:10not the best motivation. I think we should just
- 32:13be thinking first about what the animals actually
- 32:15want. And it's definitely possible that there
- 32:18could be this beautiful landscape with these
- 32:20incredible species that inspire us and are beautiful
- 32:23to see, but all of the animals in that landscape
- 32:27are unhappy. And so then you have to decide who
- 32:30you're serving when you decide what to do about
- 32:32that. Are you going to serve yourself and other
- 32:36people who value this aesthetic, or are you going
- 32:38to serve the wild animals who are actually living
- 32:41in that environment? So that's a couple of things
- 32:44and a couple of reasons I think that tension
- 32:47comes up. Yeah, I love that, you know, the concept
- 32:53of, you know, focusing only on aesthetics. It's
- 32:56true. It's like the animal has been melted into
- 33:00the environment, like it's one of the same. And,
- 33:06you know, it's it's difficult to even when the
- 33:10wild animal is in front of you to consider their
- 33:14welfare to consider their sentence. I've I love
- 33:20hiking, and I've met plenty of deers in my hiking
- 33:26adventures. And it's only now that I'm thinking,
- 33:31you know, I would look at them and see how they
- 33:36were full of mosquitoes or like, insects and,
- 33:42you know, it felt like they would they were having
- 33:44a bad time, you know, trying to get rid of all
- 33:47of those insects, their ears always, you know,
- 33:51moving. And it's only now that I'm thinking,
- 33:55well, we could have done something about it,
- 33:57we could have, you know, alleviate that, that
- 34:00suffering. But at the time, I was just looking
- 34:03at that as if, you know, yeah, it's part of nature,
- 34:06that's, there's nothing we can do. It's just,
- 34:09you know, tragic way life unfolds. And yeah,
- 34:19it's interesting that you were able to see like
- 34:21what your mindset was in the past and how it
- 34:23has changed. I think that's what we hope will
- 34:26continue to happen for a lot of people. This
- 34:29also just kind of brings me back to the example
- 34:32I gave earlier of if you saw people suffering
- 34:36from like you know, swarms of mosquitoes or some
- 34:41other insect, um, you would never just say that's
- 34:46fine. Like those, those insects live in that
- 34:49area. That's what you have to deal with. If you're
- 34:51out there, you know, we, we look for ways to
- 34:53alleviate this for people. So hopefully the same
- 34:57can happen for wild animals. Okay. I want to
- 35:00go back to your organization and the good work
- 35:03you're doing. Uh, so as you said, right now you're
- 35:07focusing on research. And one research has been
- 35:12featured by ACE a lot. They mentioned it a lot
- 35:16in your in the page where they go into descriptions
- 35:21of what you're doing, which is let me go find
- 35:25my notes back. I think it was a contraception
- 35:30for mouse, something like that. What's the exact
- 35:33title? Well, yeah, um, rodent. contraception.
- 35:38Rodent contraception. Thank you. Uh, so what
- 35:41is this all about? So there are some interventions
- 35:45that we think we're pretty close to being able
- 35:48to confirm whether it would be net positive for
- 35:51the welfare of the animals involved. And there
- 35:54are others that we think are much farther off.
- 35:56We need much, much more information before we
- 35:59can say, but rodent contraception is one of the
- 36:02ones that we think we're pretty close to and
- 36:04pretty close could be like five to ten years.
- 36:08This could be a situation where we have enough
- 36:11research done, we have enough pilot studies done,
- 36:14and maybe some municipalities actually start
- 36:17to employ this on a larger scale. There have
- 36:20been some pilot studies in the past, but there
- 36:24are issues with the way the studies were done,
- 36:27or they didn't have sufficient data to make a
- 36:31call one way or the other. So we're still having
- 36:34to do some research here. So it's a big area
- 36:37of interest for us because there are many, many,
- 36:39many mice and rats in the world that live in
- 36:43cities or live in other areas with proximity
- 36:46to people, and people consider them pests. And
- 36:50so right now, the standard solution is to use
- 36:53these anti -coagulant poisons, which are just
- 36:58a terrible, terrible way to die, it seems like.
- 37:03I think the average person believes that the
- 37:07rat just kind of like eats this poison and like
- 37:09drops dead on the spot. And that is not what
- 37:12happens at all. Instead, they eat the poison
- 37:15and they go on with their life for several days
- 37:18up to potentially like a week or more. And throughout
- 37:22that whole time, they are bleeding out because
- 37:25that's what these poisons do. And so it's like
- 37:28this terrible way to go and it causes neurological
- 37:33problems as well. So we would love to see these
- 37:38poisons just be phased out and instead some other
- 37:43way of managing rodent populations that's actually
- 37:46good for their welfare. Maybe not even simply
- 37:49neutral for their welfare, but actually better
- 37:52for their welfare than if there was no intervention
- 37:54at all. So contraception seems like a great way
- 37:59to go because there are no animals suffering
- 38:03or dying. There are simply fewer animals being
- 38:06born. And it's also possible that there are certain
- 38:11things about not having to expend energy as a
- 38:15parent or not having to deal with conflicts between,
- 38:20especially with mice, like the male mice often
- 38:24attack juveniles that they believe are from another
- 38:27litter like that weren't their own children or
- 38:28whatever. So there could be some like welfare
- 38:31implications there. So if we can prevent many
- 38:36rodent births from happening, there are several
- 38:38ways that perhaps this could be positive for
- 38:41welfare for all involved. So we've done some
- 38:46preliminary studies just on the viability of
- 38:48this. We haven't done any. field studies yet
- 38:51at Wild Animal Initiative. But the studies we've
- 38:54done so far have shown that, yeah, we're pretty
- 38:58confident this could be a good thing. So our
- 39:01next step is right now we are trying to fundraise
- 39:04for an open innovation competition, which is
- 39:08going to be in collaboration with a group called
- 39:10Conservation X Labs and also the Bot Steber Institute
- 39:15for Wildlife Fertility Control. Both of those
- 39:18groups have expertise in relevant areas as well.
- 39:21And so we're all teaming up to host this competition
- 39:24where researchers can pitch their projects in
- 39:28this area, and they can win a large prize, essentially
- 39:33a grant, to move forward with their project.
- 39:36So what we're fundraising for is that prize money
- 39:39right now. And we're hoping it would be substantial
- 39:42enough to make a lot of progress on this. So
- 39:45Wild Animal Initiative has given out many grants
- 39:48before. It's like one of our core programs and
- 39:50we'll continue doing that. Our grants are typically
- 39:53up to $200 ,000 per project depending on the
- 39:56need, but we're expecting this to be a prize
- 39:59of like a million dollars or more so that we
- 40:01can just like make this exponentially faster
- 40:06than our typical route. So hopefully that competition
- 40:10can happen later this year if we're able to finish
- 40:13our fundraising for it and then we'll see where
- 40:16it goes, but we think this is not too far off
- 40:19as an intervention. That's amazing. This has
- 40:23the impact of, you know, changing the lives of
- 40:28like millions and millions of creatures all around
- 40:31the world. This is, and you know, it's striking
- 40:34how you'll have to, at some point you'll have
- 40:38to sell that to the general public, you know,
- 40:41can we launch this contraception, you know, propagation
- 40:46campaign. And it's weird how I feel that, you
- 40:52know, the public would be more open to an extermination
- 40:55campaign of all the rodents in their city, then
- 40:58you know, a contraception campaign. But yeah,
- 41:02that's extraordinary. Can we can we participate
- 41:05in that fundraiser and help raise funds? Of course,
- 41:09yeah, anybody listening, if you're interested,
- 41:12can contact us and we can talk about if you want
- 41:16to lead fundraising efforts for this or if you
- 41:18want to give directly to support it. We'd love
- 41:21to hear from you, of course. So for sure, check
- 41:24that out. And hang on, because you just said
- 41:28something I was going to respond to. What did
- 41:31you say? And as for what you were saying about
- 41:39public perception, I worry about this as a communications
- 41:44professional, I worry that do we need to do some
- 41:47messaging first to change public perception of
- 41:51rodents? But we might not have to, because in
- 41:55most cases, a city is going to set policies for
- 42:00how, quote, pest control is done in their city
- 42:04and what products are available and what products
- 42:06are banned and things like that. So it's possible
- 42:09that We only need to change the minds of key
- 42:12stakeholders like that. And that can be done
- 42:15without them caring about rats at all. If we
- 42:19can show that economically, this is a better
- 42:22thing for their city and for property managers.
- 42:26So that's really the key part of this that we
- 42:28need to show. This is cost effective or it's
- 42:31on par with the products they already use or
- 42:34something like that. Yeah, because we don't look
- 42:36at wild creatures. true, you know, neutral lens,
- 42:43some of them have like a positive value and others
- 42:45and negative ones. And rodents have a clear negative
- 42:50value, you know, in in our eyes, like, I remember
- 42:54being a kid and wanting a rat, a pet rat. And
- 42:59my mom just being against it, like having visible
- 43:04disgust for that idea, not even the creature,
- 43:09just the idea of having that creature in the
- 43:11house as a bet. So yeah, any strategy to not
- 43:18face that is, I think, a good strategy. people
- 43:28don't necessarily despise farmed animals, but
- 43:31they see them as separate somehow. They see them
- 43:33as those are for eating. And so they also see
- 43:39rats as those are for exterminating. And so it's
- 43:42a similar barrier of changing some minds. But
- 43:46maybe in this case, the only minds we have to
- 43:49change are the stakeholders, which is a big difference
- 43:51from farmed animal advocacy. where I think to
- 43:55end factory farming, you do actually have to
- 43:57change public opinion. Interesting. What other
- 44:04studies are right now in the conception phase
- 44:11that we haven't heard of yet and that you find
- 44:16exciting? We have funded a project in the UK
- 44:20where they're studying backyard bird feeding.
- 44:27And most people who love birds, myself included,
- 44:30might assume that feeding birds is just a good
- 44:33thing. Especially in the winter, food is scarce,
- 44:36but food out there, that's surely good for them.
- 44:40But actually, bird feeding, if you're not doing
- 44:42it well, if you're not cleaning out your feeders,
- 44:45if you're not careful, can be negative for them
- 44:48if it's leading to a situation where they can
- 44:51spread disease more quickly. because they're
- 44:53all coming to the same food source. It's like
- 44:56if you were eating from a buffet where someone
- 44:59who was sick had just sneezed all over the food
- 45:01or something like that. It can be kind of bad.
- 45:05And especially with bird flu running rampant
- 45:07in the wild right now, it's not so much a problem
- 45:10among songbirds. It's mostly birds of the water,
- 45:13but all birds are included. And so what if you
- 45:17accidentally spreading bird flu by trying to
- 45:22feed the birds in your backyard or something
- 45:23like that. That would be really bad. So this
- 45:26team in the UK is studying, has been collecting
- 45:30data over like the past 10 years on more than
- 45:3550 backyard -like sites where there are bird
- 45:39feeders set up. And so they're collecting many
- 45:44different kinds of data in these sites and they
- 45:46have this large data set. So the project we funded
- 45:49is for them to try to validate the use of eye
- 45:53temperature as an indicator of the welfare of
- 45:57several common bird species in the UK. And so
- 46:01if they can find that indicator to be useful
- 46:04as they're hypothesizing, then they can use their
- 46:10new findings together with the data they've been
- 46:14collecting for the past 10 years and try to figure
- 46:20out some insights about how bird lovers can set
- 46:27up their gardens to be more enjoyable for the
- 46:30birds that visit them or in other words, they
- 46:33can set them up to be positive for the welfare
- 46:36of the birds that visit them. So this isn't the
- 46:42biggest issue facing wild animals for sure, but
- 46:46it's a really cool practical use case and hopefully
- 46:51we'll be able to see more of those things over
- 46:53time. So after the research portion of that is
- 46:58done, they're planning to kind of like disseminate
- 47:02some information among the general public in
- 47:04the UK to let people know what they can do in
- 47:06their own backyards to improve welfare for wild
- 47:08birds. The vast majority though of the studies
- 47:12that we funded or that we're doing internally
- 47:14are at a really basic level of like we don't
- 47:17even know yet how to measure welfare for most
- 47:20animals, or what that means, or how to observe
- 47:25whether an animal is actually happy or not. So
- 47:29a lot of the studies are in the early stages
- 47:32of validating indicators of welfare, and sometimes
- 47:36those indicators are behavioral. So if you see
- 47:39an animal sleeping more than usual, what might
- 47:43that mean about their welfare? Or They are trying
- 47:48a different foraging technique than you've seen
- 47:50before. What might that say about their welfare?
- 47:55If they're showing more stress than usually,
- 48:00it could be a physiological measurement as well
- 48:02of their stress levels. Does that say anything
- 48:05about their welfare? It doesn't always. Sometimes
- 48:08stress is not necessarily bad. So there's a lot
- 48:11of things that we're looking at to try to figure
- 48:14out. we have to be able to measure this in some
- 48:17way before we can make any conclusions. So Wild
- 48:22Animal Initiative's current field study is trying
- 48:26to do this for house sparrows, which are super,
- 48:29super common species all over the world. If you
- 48:33live in... Europe or North America, definitely
- 48:36you've seen them. So look up a picture and you'll
- 48:38recognize it immediately. It's this bird that
- 48:40is usually in small groups hopping around in
- 48:43a parking lot or something trying to steal your
- 48:46french fries. They thrive in urban environments.
- 48:51So we're interested in them partially because
- 48:53there are just so many of them in the world.
- 48:55They're one of the most common bird species that
- 48:58if we could figure out something that we can
- 49:00do for their welfare, then there are many individuals
- 49:02that could be helped by that. But we're secondly
- 49:05interested in them because they are often used
- 49:09as an indicator species in scientific studies,
- 49:12which means whatever you find out in a study
- 49:15about house sparrows, you can reasonably extrapolate
- 49:21to other kinds of sparrows or other kinds of
- 49:23songbirds. And because they're so common, they're
- 49:25just really easy to find and study. So many scientists
- 49:29study house sparrows, even if they're not necessarily
- 49:32interested in specifically house sparrows. So
- 49:36our study, hopefully, will be able to validate
- 49:39some indicators of their welfare, which could
- 49:42be certain vocalizations that they make, or other
- 49:45behavioral things that they are demonstrating
- 49:49in a backyard situation. I also feed birds outside
- 49:54and I never thought about you know, disease control.
- 50:00I should have, you know, I'm aware that there
- 50:02are, you know, diseases going on, avian flu and
- 50:08all of that. And I wash my hands after, you know,
- 50:13handling the food thing for the birds. But I
- 50:20never thought that I could be participating in
- 50:23spreading those diseases by by feeding the birds.
- 50:29Earlier, you also mentioned cats and how cats
- 50:32can predate on local bird species. And that's
- 50:39also something we don't talk much about in the
- 50:44vegan community, but also outside. You have a
- 50:47bunch of cats. First of all, you're feeding them
- 50:50the products of... factory farming, that's a
- 50:53problem. But the other problem is you're letting
- 50:57them go out of the house and just terrorizing
- 51:01the local FUNA. And so, yeah, there needs to
- 51:05be an organization addressing that and making
- 51:09us aware of those problems. Right. So personally,
- 51:16I love cats. I have two. Their names are sparrow
- 51:19and wren. I named them after birds specifically
- 51:21because of this I want to show like I love both
- 51:25sides of this ecological interaction And one
- 51:29is not more important than the other but What
- 51:33can we do as cat owners right to cat? That's
- 51:37a standard term. I guess what can we do as cat
- 51:39caretakers? To ensure the welfare of our cats
- 51:43and also the welfare of the birds or mice that
- 51:45are outside so I do think it's important for
- 51:48cats to get some outside time. It's like part
- 51:51of their desire of just their natural drive to
- 51:55be outside and see prey animals. So I am lucky
- 52:00enough that mine. took to the harness really
- 52:03easily. So I take them on walks and we watch
- 52:05birds, but we will never come close enough to
- 52:08catch a bird. Other people have screened in porches
- 52:12or they can build a structure outside for their
- 52:15cats to be there safely or something like that.
- 52:17It definitely takes work. It is not easy. And
- 52:21cats are not, they're not like a passive animal
- 52:24to have in your household. It requires a lot
- 52:26of work to make sure that they're happy. But
- 52:31yes, I think from my experience working in the
- 52:36bird hospital, volunteering there, the top three
- 52:40reasons that birds come in are they were caught
- 52:42by a cat, they hit a window, or they were hit
- 52:46by a car. And so it's a lot more common than
- 52:51I realized even as a cat lover until I see so
- 52:54many birds coming in who have been caught. So
- 52:57it's a big issue for sure. Thank you for the
- 53:02reminder. One last question. This time about
- 53:09what you're doing on a macro level. So I have
- 53:13this mental framework in terms of the welfare
- 53:19of animals, but also humans. I think that as
- 53:23humans, how we start caring about our family
- 53:27and our tribe and then, you know, it's a concentric
- 53:30circles. And then at some point we decided to
- 53:35care about animals, but not all animals. And
- 53:38so there was the vegetarian movement and now
- 53:42it's veganism. And I really feel like you're
- 53:45the next chapter. You're the next like concentric
- 53:48circle. Now it's time to talk about wildlife
- 53:52as a whole. not just the animals that we have
- 53:59domesticated for animal exploitation, but also
- 54:05those that we don't necessarily interact with
- 54:08that are far away in some forests or, as you
- 54:11said, in the city, but hidden from us, like rodents.
- 54:21Do you feel that way that you're really the next
- 54:25chapter in that movement towards including more
- 54:30and more creatures in our circle of compassion?
- 54:34In a way, definitely. I do see it that way. And
- 54:39what I hope is not the case is that we must end
- 54:46factory farming before we actually do things
- 54:48for wild animals. So I think it's not linear
- 54:50in that sense of what we're actually going to
- 54:52do. But in the way you're describing it about
- 54:56the order in which we're expanding our moral
- 54:58circles, I do think that is the case. I read
- 55:04a paper that came out toward the end of 2025
- 55:07about the history of conservation and the driving
- 55:13values that were kind of guiding conservation
- 55:17efforts through the decades. And it went back
- 55:20more than a century. And early on in conservation,
- 55:27the primary interest was like, we want to make
- 55:29sure that the animals we would like to hunt are
- 55:31still around. And so we're going to conserve
- 55:34the habitat that those animals need. And we're
- 55:36going to manage populations in a way that makes
- 55:39sure we still have animals that we want to hunt.
- 55:41And then that mindset was dealt away with. And
- 55:44then it became over time more about the aesthetics
- 55:49of conserving habitat. And then it was more about
- 55:52biodiversity and maintaining this kind of like
- 55:58ecosystem balance that we somehow believe in,
- 56:01even though we don't often know what that means
- 56:03exactly. But we want to see all the different
- 56:05butterfly species and we want to see all the
- 56:06different bird species. And so biodiversity was
- 56:08really big. And then as climate change became
- 56:11more of an issue, it was like, you know, kind
- 56:14of like combating climate change and conserving
- 56:17nature and protecting it from climate change.
- 56:19But what this paper concluded was that the next
- 56:22circle of motivation, it was like this chart
- 56:25of circles on a timeline. And the next one is
- 56:29welfare. And these people cited a paper by Wild
- 56:34Animal Initiative, but they had never contacted
- 56:36us. We don't know them. They're not in our own
- 56:39little network. And so they had concluded based
- 56:41on what they were seeing at large across the
- 56:45field that the next driving motivation for conservation
- 56:49could be welfare. And this is a huge deal that
- 56:54these external scientists were seeing this as
- 56:57well. And so it's not only the vegan movement,
- 56:59I think, but it's also possibly the general public,
- 57:03possibly scientists who have this on their minds.
- 57:06And to see where we might go with this is really
- 57:09exciting. It is that's exciting. But you know,
- 57:14do you feel like by pushing forward your agenda,
- 57:21positive, amazing agenda, sometimes, you know,
- 57:23agenda has this negative connotation. Do you
- 57:28feel like, you know, you're the next extreme
- 57:32radical people so vegans were considered radical
- 57:35but now let's talk about rodent contraception
- 57:39and that's you know the next which makes veganism
- 57:42less you know radical of an idea um but at the
- 57:47same time we don't want you to take the role
- 57:49of that marginal uh actor i would worry about
- 57:54that Especially as a comms person, as I've said
- 57:57earlier, I think about these kinds of things,
- 58:00these messaging and branding issues, but I haven't
- 58:04seen that to be the case. I haven't seen scientists
- 58:06perceiving us that way. So far, overwhelmingly,
- 58:11there's been a positive response. Some are resistant,
- 58:14especially in ecology because I think a lot of
- 58:16what we do brings up big questions about the
- 58:21actual effects of their work when they have subscribed
- 58:24to these ideas of balance and biodiversity for
- 58:28their whole careers. But the vast majority of
- 58:32scientists we've interacted with are really open
- 58:34to this, and many of them are saying they always
- 58:37wanted a place to do this kind of research, but
- 58:39it didn't exist before. And so they're excited
- 58:42that now it does. And so they're the ones who
- 58:45are really going to take this and run with it.
- 58:48And so they're opinions are the ones that I'm
- 58:51most concerned about right now. And they're largely
- 58:54looking at this positively. So we'll see what
- 58:58happens next. And it's possible that a portion
- 59:04of the general public would see us as radical
- 59:06or extreme or something. But I think if we stick
- 59:11to our values of curiosity and questioning our
- 59:17assumptions and using the scientific method and
- 59:21involving many, many people who are not vegan,
- 59:25who are not animal advocates. You know, it's
- 59:27a really inclusive kind of movement. I think
- 59:30those kinds of things can help us keep those
- 59:33opinions at bay. Amazing. Kat, did you want to
- 59:37add something before we stop the recording? I
- 59:40don't think so. Yeah, I think we're good. That
- 59:43was an incredible conversation. I'm so happy
- 59:46to have met you and thank you so much for your
- 59:52insights, for the answers to my questions and
- 59:56for having taken the time to discuss your incredible
- 59:59work. Thank you so much for all that you're doing.
- 1:00:02Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 1:00:05you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 1:00:08know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:00:12Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will
- 1:00:15see you next Tuesday for a new episode.