Latest / Building A Zoo / Thomas Goltz
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Michael P. Hayman's I'm here to talk to you all about
- 0:20law on society, Loss of Society. We're on WCCF News Radio fifteen eighty
- 0:25on AM dial one hundred point nine on the FM dial. We're out of
- 0:29claw across the worldwide web on an iHeart platform, WCCFAM dot com, and
- 0:34we're on Facebook live at Michael P. Hayman's page and at Scott Zane Bickerstaff's
- 0:39page. However you got here, Thanks for being here. This is uh
- 0:44August the third, twenty twenty three. Uh, it's a today I've been
- 0:55thinking about as we were coming up to the show, thinking about people in
- 0:59my life who have been important, who have who have passed the I read
- 1:06an obituary a concerning Thomas Caufield Goltz, who was born October eleventh, nineteen
- 1:14fifty four and died July twenty eight, twenty twenty three, the age of
- 1:19sixty eight. I'm sure Scott McMillian had had a heavy hand in the in
- 1:26the writing of the obituary. You can feel his voice through uh through it.
- 1:37It's someone who lived big life, Thomas Goltz. He uh, he
- 1:42was a huge personality he was a hunting buddy of mine and Parks Reeese and
- 1:53Scott mcmillion, Sam Kirby those of us Frank Deskan tho those of us who
- 2:00hunted out on the eastern Great Plains, the eastern part of Montana, near
- 2:08Bohemian Corner, near roy Up in the Brakes area of that part of Montana.
- 2:16And uh, I'll just let the story tell its own U. The
- 2:24obituary tell its own story in great detail right now. I have been working
- 2:30on the Turkey Diary, which was the last of the books published by Thomas
- 2:38Goltz, and he had he also other books by Thomas Goltz was the Azure
- 2:44Bajan Diary and back in nineteen eighty eight, the Chechena Diary, uh in
- 2:52two thousand and three, Assassinating Shakespeare in two thousand and six, and the
- 2:58Georgia Diary in two thousand and nine. I've read the Chechen Diary, Assassinating
- 3:05Shakespeare and the Georgia Diary, and I've just started. I hadn't read the
- 3:09Azurebaijan Diary, and I was just working into the Turkey Diary. The early
- 3:16praise for the Turkey Diary a towering achievement. Thomas Goltz is a suburb storyteller.
- 3:25As he recounts his experiences from his travels throughout Turkey and surrounding regions,
- 3:30you feel you're right there experience in the journey with him. You see the
- 3:34colors that he observes here, the people he engages, and most of all,
- 3:38since the ambiance of the moment that's by Art mcahalf, fewer as fluent
- 3:45in Turkey as Golts. I don't mean the cuisine, or the history or
- 3:47the culture, though he's indeed an expert in those matters too. What I
- 3:52mean is his full blown immersion to understand a region that may matter more today
- 3:57than any time since the peak of the Ottoman rule. Take a deep dive
- 4:00with Golts and emerge with a grander appreciation and empathy for the people of the
- 4:04Anatolian Plateau. As doctor Jerry Johnson, Montana State University so. Thomas Goltz
- 4:19died peacefully at his Livingston home on Friday July twenty eight after a long illness.
- 4:26Born in Japan to doctor Neil F. Goltz, an ear nose and
- 4:29throat physician, and Deborah Donnelly, Goltz, A classically trained pianist. Thomas
- 4:34was a proud North Dakota by upbringing, but became a citizen of the world,
- 4:40especially the Middle East in Central Asia. He spent many years as a
- 4:44war correspondent in countries that were once part of the USSR, documenting their bloody
- 4:49struggles through his books, journalism and films. Survival in those places called for
- 4:56clever tricks, bribing an airloft pilot with a handful of Cuban cigar ours to
- 5:00get a free seat, leading a sixty minutes crew to obscure petroleum baths in
- 5:04Azerbaijan, surviving in Assyrian prison by telling jokes in Arabic, supporting himself all
- 5:12across Africa with a one man Shakespearean puppet show. A student of theater,
- 5:17languages and foreign affairs, he never lost as thespian ambitions, nor is love
- 5:23of the spotlight. If there was a stage, he climbed on it.
- 5:27If there wasn't a stage, he created one around him and filled it with
- 5:30stories, yarns, songs and oratory and various languages, all of it imbued
- 5:35with deep compassion for the suffering of his friends and bitterness for their persecutors.
- 5:42He was intently loyal, intensely loyal. He wrote assassinating Shakespeare about his adventures
- 5:48as a bard in the Bush, and other books about Egypt and Syria,
- 5:53chechnin Turkey, and Georgia, the country, not the state, and most
- 5:57importantly about Azerbaijan, which was suffering a brutal war with neighboring Armenia when he
- 6:02arrived. That book led to his status as a national hero in Azerbaijan,
- 6:09which later wanted to build a pipeline to ship its oil to a port in
- 6:13Turkey. Thomas wanted to help, so he found sponsors think international oil companies
- 6:18and other questionable outfits. Gathered a couple of dozen Russian motorcycles with sidecars,
- 6:24and hauled the first symbolic barrel of oil hundreds of miles. If he couldn't
- 6:29find a road, he used a cowpath. He drew mass of international attention
- 6:33to the pipeline, which was built a few years later, enriching Azerbaijan,
- 6:39but not Thomas. Prosperity was never a motivator for him. About nineteen ninety
- 6:46he bought a rambling house in Livingston and dubbed it East Goals Stand where He
- 6:50hosted many parties, book readings, concerts, and film screenings, as well
- 6:57as unfortunate souls who needed a place to flop. He would vacate for long
- 7:02periods of his travels. For his travels and especially for jobs at the University
- 7:06of Montana and Montana State University, where he was a dedicated and enthusiastic teacher.
- 7:13Many students have testified about the life changing nature of a professor Goltz class.
- 7:19Though he had teacher's heart and soul, he had too much personality and
- 7:26bombasted for academic bureaucracy or faculty socials. He put bumps in that road and
- 7:30the system eventually ran him off. Given that experience, he was especially satisfied
- 7:36to earn an honorary doctorate degree from Adia University in Baku, Azerbaijan, which
- 7:43specializes in diplomacy and foreign policy. Other honorees include Presidents of Nations and Ivy
- 7:48League professors. Thomas married doctor Hicronog in nineteen eighty four in Istanbul, Turkey.
- 7:57Though they lived apart for years, they remained voted to each other and
- 8:01she served as his primary caregiver over the past couple of years, along with
- 8:05his siblings. Especially Vince, who uprooted his life to escort Thomas on recent
- 8:09five week trip to Turkey and Azerbaijan, where Thomas met with the president of
- 8:13that country, showed clips of his latest film, and toured the war torn
- 8:18areas that Azerbaijan reclaimed after yet another war with Armenia. That journey was his
- 8:24last hurrah. Thomas was preceded in death by his father. He survived by
- 8:31his wife, Hicron, his mother, Deborah of Bozeman, and seven siblings,
- 8:35Neil of Bozeman and Florida, Eddie of Taiwan, Marty of Bozeman,
- 8:41Julie of Spokane, Washington, stan A Duluth, Minnesota, Vince of Mosier,
- 8:48Oregon and Baja Mexico, and Charlie of Detroit Lakes, Minnesota. Other
- 8:54survivors include numerous in laws, niece's, nephews and cousins. Thomas a lot
- 9:00of miles on his battered chassis. His passions included hunting, music, feeding
- 9:05people, exotic food, delivering lengthy toasts, enthusiastic dancing, and jumping over
- 9:11camp fires, often after a glass of tooth cleaner. He inspired love and
- 9:16exasperation and equal measures. A celebration of his life what we called at three
- 9:24pm on August twentieth at the Shane lain I Lalani Center for the Arts at
- 9:30four fifteen East Lewis in Livingston, Montana, brings stories. Yeah, we've
- 9:41had too many of our hunting buddies have passed. He was a a hunting
- 9:52buddy, was at his house for some parties that were described when the geese,
- 10:00when geese were in on the river, Uh they were, they flew
- 10:05near his back porch and he would have friends over for a geese goose hunt
- 10:09off of his back porch. He was a professor at the University of Montana
- 10:18and Missoula while my son Dylan was studying there, and UH and the young
- 10:26men from Livingstone who were at the University of Montana at the time took classes
- 10:31from him. Uh were treated to dinners at his house and two stories continuously.
- 10:41As Scott mcmillion said, the world is a smaller place today because of
- 10:46the passing of Thomas I. Also as learning about Thomas I also was reminded
- 10:54and remembered the passing of John Cole and Lorette, his fiancee and and Bud
- 11:03Cole's dad and Maureen's step mom. They died in a plane crash on July
- 11:09thirty first, back in nineteen ninety one. It's been so long ago,
- 11:15it's hard to imagine. I still have guitars that John and I that John
- 11:20played. We've written many songs together, some of which I've played on this
- 11:26radio. The songs include Ode to Punta Gorda, for the Love of Kids,
- 11:37and we were working on a song about a buddy of his who had
- 11:41died that was just in the early stages, and then Zelen Wilson and I
- 11:46worked on it and we ended up with a Forever Johnny that I got to
- 11:52play, got to play I played at his funeral. He was a man
- 12:03of the world and a man of his word, a reflection of his time.
- 12:15He met a woman, fine and smart, Loretta was her name.
- 12:26He went to college, and he went to work, made his way.
- 12:48Johnny Sword, make a difference, to seek truth, help ride prevail.
- 12:56When he ran into me in You Apathy, it melt. Some folks came
- 13:09to hear him, some two thrust stones. But dignity and respect was what
- 13:20he said to what he lived, and Road said, open your eyes,
- 13:31listen, ears, there's beauty all around. Damn hard work and people who
- 13:41hurt helped them. We're all in this together now. And he sang about
- 13:48the family of man. He sang about the family of man. He was
- 13:58no god, he was man alone, changing, be changed, holding his
- 14:07family well and close. He sang about the family of man. Sang about
- 14:16the family of man. When he died, we cried and cried. Here
- 14:30we cried, cried, cried, cried, cried and cried. Then someone
- 14:48said, he's only dead in a physical way. His spirit live song.
- 15:01He's with us today. Sing the song. Help him carry on and on.
- 15:16Live, live the song, and carry on. Open your eyes,
- 15:26listen, Ears, there's beauty all around. Damn hard work and people who
- 15:35hurt help them. We're all in this together now, and sing about the
- 15:43family of man. Sing about the family of man, Sing about the family
- 15:52of man. And sun rise. Let's listen to Steve Blackwall sing about the
- 16:04chain. All my ancestors stand in a line, Who would I wrack,
- 16:23ignize and know that they are mine? Ah, Sometimes I think I think
- 16:36it's a shame how few I would know, How few I could name my
- 16:48line of ghosts d push on me, line up in head spins as far
- 17:02as you can't see. Oh, I put these thoughts back on the shelf,
- 17:15because soon I'll be in that line myself. Oh, I won't forget
- 17:59you, though I don't know your face. You wants breathe this air and
- 18:10live in this place. You wants view the sunsets that blessed your soul.
- 18:23You sang, and you prayed, friends and family, pay your whole in
- 18:33love. It is answered, love, prayer and vine, a prayer to
- 18:41the old ones, all standing in a line. Oh, I won't forget
- 18:51you, And it's plain to see. I won't forge get you. You
- 19:02won't forgive me. Oh, how can I thank you? All legs in
- 19:11a chain, Oh, you ain't and ones and known and I name.
- 19:23More precious than gold and jewels and fine wine are the ones from the past,
- 19:36all standing in a line. More precious than gold and jewels and fine
- 19:47wine are the ones from the past, all standing in a line. Yeah,
- 20:10Steve Blackwell, standing in line, chains, links in a chain.
- 20:15The line. Couldn't do the show without folks that helped me pay for it,
- 20:19people like Gene Gorminado Sales. Gene Gorminado Sales. You've seen the billboards,
- 20:25You've seen the size I'd give them away, but my wife won't let
- 20:27me. I'd fix them for free, but my wife won't let me.
- 20:30It's because their family own an operated business twenty six years as Charlotte County's number
- 20:36one volume independent used car dealer. It's a fact, not an opinion.
- 20:41Have three locations to serve everyone. One in Charlotte Harbor, Premiere there in
- 20:45Punta Gorda across from the police Department, and Jean's Dirt Cheap Cars just south
- 20:51of Aquaiesta on forty one. All of the vehicles have a certification process and
- 20:57come with a nationwide warranty. Owen is the general manager and the and the
- 21:07vice president general manager of it all. And Jean has a memoir out about
- 21:11his times in Vietnam to psychiatric hospitals to the boardrooms of Corporate America. It's
- 21:18a good book for anyone to read that's battled addiction or know someone that has
- 21:22or is. So. They're a fine community, upstanding family. They support
- 21:27the community and the youth athletics of all sorts, wrestling in particular, very
- 21:33deeply involved in that. Supporting that go buy a car, sell a car
- 21:38to gene Woman Auto Sales, the Boca Green and Marina. Boca Green and
- 21:45Marina and beautiful Boca Green is on Gasparol Island of Barrier Island between the Gulf
- 21:48of Mexico and the Charlotte Harbor Estuary System. To get there by boat,
- 21:52you go into that south entrance to the Boka Bayou and turn south into the
- 21:56basin. It's a refurbished marina, a basin and channel redredged to minus seven
- 22:03feet. Doc Master's office commands the basin to help you tie up safely.
- 22:07Fuel docks open from eight in the morning to five in the evening, seven
- 22:10days a week, all year round. If the fuel docks open, so
- 22:12is the ship's store, where you can get bait and tackle, sundry's those
- 22:17kinds of things. You can also rent a golf cart and tool around the
- 22:19rest of the island. Make sure you're back from eleven thirty on Miller's dock
- 22:23side has got fuller, full bar, cold beer, delicious food, great
- 22:30menu, friendly service in a beautiful setting overlooking the marina and gasp roll of
- 22:36Sound. Whether you get there by seaplane like Capt. Mark Futts used to
- 22:41do, or by by boat, by car, golf cart, bicycle,
- 22:47run, walk, crawled both Grand Marina. You'll be happy to be there
- 22:51and they'll be delighted to see you. Parks Rees Parks Rees p A r
- 22:56K s r e c e and Livingston, Montana as a spa sort of
- 23:00this show. Uh he's uh. So when you go to uh to uh
- 23:07to Thomas Golt's funeral, make sure you get by and see Parks Reese while
- 23:11you're in town. Uh, he'll give you a tour of his gallery.
- 23:15He's been working on some things. He might even be painting some around that
- 23:19time. Although uh you got to stop in and see go online and take
- 23:25a look at his stuff as as fabulous as artwork as uh as uh his
- 23:33control and use of images and negative space and colors and such a U he
- 23:41can Uh. He's a fantastic drawer. He believes that artists, that painters
- 23:45should also be able to draw and uh and his stuff is imbued with uh
- 23:52with his perspective on the world and the humor that he brings to things.
- 23:56Some of the stuff will make you laugh out loud. Uh. Take a
- 24:00look at the stuff Parks Reis p A r K s r e ce.
- 24:06Uh. Yeah. Michael P. Hayman's attorney at law. I've been practicing
- 24:11for right coming on forty years now. Last thirteen years i've been a single
- 24:18practitioner, sole practitioner. My secretary and I are at two fifteen West Olympia
- 24:25UH in downtown Punta Gorda, next to Men's Asian Cuisine. It's just up
- 24:30the road Sullivan Street from Unwind. UH. Take take a look at our
- 24:37office as you swing by. As you go by, you'll see the cats
- 24:41in the window. Those kinds of things. UH. Give us a call.
- 24:44If we can't help you, We'll try to get you to someone who
- 24:45can. UH. Nine four one, five seven five triple seven. Thanks
- 24:52for tuning in here. My buddy Frank Deskin writes a column for the for
- 24:59the Sun, and it's every other week or so. And last week I
- 25:04read to you about the part one about Kelly Harvey, and so here's part
- 25:11two from the Kelly Harvey's story, Good day at all? Did you know?
- 25:17Kelly Harvey, after leading a charge to incorporate and rename his adopted town,
- 25:22abandoned it after weeks of public notice. The meeting to debate and vote
- 25:26on the town of Tributes in corporation occurred in early December eighteen eighty seven.
- 25:32Thirty four men registered to vote in the matter, thirty white and four black.
- 25:37Significant I believe, since the reconstruction of the South had ended a decade
- 25:41earlier, many of the voters were carpenters or laborers working on the new hotel.
- 25:47After much discussion, Harvey was successful in his effort in his affront to
- 25:52Trebute, changing the town's name and filing Punta Gorda's incorporation documents at pine level
- 25:57the DeSoto County what is now Charlotte County, was still a part of DeSoto
- 26:03County at that time. Just over a year later, Trebeaux and the railroad
- 26:07company unsuccessfully sued to have the city dissolved. As the new city's largest landowners,
- 26:14they were most affected by potential property taxes. Harvey's willingness to stand up
- 26:18to tribue made him a community hero. He served on the first city council,
- 26:25and in eighteen ninety one was president of the city's Board of Trade.
- 26:29In eighteen ninety two, he was appointed postmaster, serving for about a year.
- 26:33Harvey became Puntagorda's collector of port fees in eighteen ninety three, also serving
- 26:38as an observer for the Weather Bureau and dabbled in ship in real estate sales,
- 26:44all the while maintaining his services as a surveyor and draftsman. He also
- 26:49remained very active on the local music scene, performing in Puntagorda's town band and
- 26:55entertaining guests from across southwest Florida at private social functions in wrestling. Lee.
- 27:00All this time he remained a bachelor. However, that changed in October eighteen
- 27:07ninety six, when he married Mattie Lee Hinckley from Mobile, Alabama. Mattie
- 27:14had moved to Puntagorda with her husband, Sumner in late eighteen eighties, and
- 27:18they had two children. A successful businessman in town was shipping banking his Cicar
- 27:23manufacturing interests. Sumner had died sixteen months earlier, just thirty years of age.
- 27:30Four years after her marriage to Harvey. Mattie took ill and returned to
- 27:34Mobile, where she died. Harvey's stepchildren and his daughter with Hattie, Marianna,
- 27:41were then sent to live with relatives. In nineteen oh one, Harvey
- 27:45remarried Marianna Marina. Not Marianna Marina returned to Puntagorda as a teenager, attending
- 27:52local schools and eventually obtaining her teaching degree from Stetson University in DeLand. The
- 27:59Hickley Harvey home, considerably expanded by Harvey, still stands at five sixty five
- 28:04West Ratta Esplanade. For some reason, Kelly Harvey, so influential in Puntiger's
- 28:11beginnings, left town and his family. Left town and his family in the
- 28:15early nineteen twenties, never to return. In May nineteen twenty three, he
- 28:19was in New York City when awarded a patent for his auto table and formed
- 28:25the Auto Table Company. Somewhat similar today's hydraulic lifts, but stationary, the
- 28:30table was basically a rack cars could be driven on to, allowing mechanics to
- 28:33get under the vehicle. At some point he moved to California, where he
- 28:38died in Los Angeles November five, nineteen forty one. Frank says you can
- 28:44visit Charlotte County's website to view Kelly Harvey related photographs. Select Community Services,
- 28:49then libraries and history. Click on physical items, then archive search, and
- 28:56in the subject of your search on the search line. Photographs can also be
- 29:00reviewed on the Puntagorda History Center's website, select online collection and then keyword search
- 29:06and enter the search criteria. So thanks for the explanation about Kelly Harvey and
- 29:15Hunt and early Puntagorda. We support historic preservation and the education of children of
- 29:25all ages about the history of our region and Puntagorda. UH. One of
- 29:30the ways that we do that is we participate in a Kickback that happens the
- 29:34second and fourth Wednesdays of each month UH during the during the winter. The
- 29:41their outdoor events concerts at the History Park are on Shreve Street. UH.
- 29:48It's free concerts. UH. Donations are appreciated because that's what the purpose of
- 29:53that those concert is to bring awareness and UH and raise funds to maintain the
- 30:00various buildings that are are owned by the by the Historic Group. They own
- 30:06the Women's Club, they own the train depot, and they own the four
- 30:11buildings that are on the History Park. So Kickback is a musical concert every
- 30:18second and fourth Wednesday of the month from five until seven. Right now,
- 30:26they're being held in the Women's Club because it's hot outside and it rains in
- 30:30the afternoons, and so rather than rescheduling or canceling and rescheduling the outdoor concerts.
- 30:37They've been moved into the Women's Club, which is a beautiful buildings on
- 30:41the National Register of Historic Places. It was built in the nineteen twenties.
- 30:45It's got a wooden floors and high ceilings and has a great stage with great
- 30:49acoustics in there has a small kitchen area and and so the events are a
- 30:57byob brings a snack to eat on that kind of thing, whatever you'd like.
- 31:03Uh. And and there's a free concert. The musicians donate their time
- 31:08and energy talent to it, and appreciation is appropriate for with donations to the
- 31:18to the historical society that's taking care of these buildings. So we all need
- 31:25to make a habit. This is a really cool uh event for a very
- 31:30good purpose and uh and so so we should all in order to continue it,
- 31:37to make it grow and thrive. We all ought to get in a
- 31:41habit of showing up at on the fourth at second and fourth wednesdays of each
- 31:45month at the kickback, which right now through October is going to be at
- 31:49the Women's Club and during the winter will be at the History part. Get
- 31:55that on your calendar, Go ahead and get it out and put it on
- 31:57your calendar, please, I like to read from the Dow to Ching,
- 32:05as you know if you listen, and the one for today is verse sixty
- 32:19five. The ancient ones were simple hearted and blended with the common people.
- 32:28They did not shine forth, They did not rule with cleverness, so the
- 32:32nation was blessed. Now the rulers are filled with clever ideas, and the
- 32:37lives of people are filled with hardship, So the nation is cursed. He
- 32:43who knows the play of Tao, and Tay knows the nature of the universe.
- 32:47Dao brings forth day from its own being. Tay expands in all directions,
- 32:53filling every corner of the world, becoming the splendor of all creation.
- 32:59Yet it every moment Tay seeks down. This is the movement that guides the
- 33:04universe. This is the impulse that leads all things back home. So I
- 33:16read that because I think it's also important on today, not only to think
- 33:21about the folks that have passed, that filled our world with richness by their
- 33:27u by their integrity, by their honesty, by their ability to to be
- 33:37leaders through example and teachers through contemplative uh approach, seek truth, help right,
- 33:52prevail. That kind of thing well, we've in thinking about that and
- 33:58reading about the the ancient ones that were didn't do the clever things. Well,
- 34:06there's an indictment against a former president, Donald Trump, and people are
- 34:10are very divided about what that means and what it should mean to our society.
- 34:20I personally think that it's, uh, it's an appropriate reaction to horrific
- 34:27set of of behaviors and attitudes that have been exhibited by Donald Trump, and
- 34:35that everything that comes from these investigations and indictments are because his behavior was so
- 34:43bad and and as far as the rule of law goes, it requires an
- 34:50appropriate response. And this isn't politics. It's the Abso it's the absolute reverse
- 34:57of that. It is the The notion that someone is above the law,
- 35:04that he can do things without regard for decorum, without regard for the law,
- 35:08without regard for the truth, is unacceptable to me. So this is
- 35:15in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, United States of
- 35:19America versus Donald J. Trump. This grand jury original the violations or count
- 35:27one eighteen USC. Section three seventy one, Conspiracy to defraud the United States,
- 35:32Count two, eighteen USC. Section fifteen twelve k conspiracy to obstruct an
- 35:38official proceeding, Count three eighteen USC. Section fifteen twelve C two to obstruction
- 35:46of an attempt to obstruct an official proceeding, and Count four eighteen Usc.
- 35:52Number Section two four one, conspiracy against rights. The grand jury charges that
- 36:00all times material of this indictment honor about the dates and at the appropriate and
- 36:04approximate times stated below. The defendant, Donald J. Trump, was the
- 36:09forty fifth president the United States and a candidate for re election in twenty twenty.
- 36:15The defendant lost the twenty twenty presidential election. Despite having lost, the
- 36:21defendant was determined to remain in power, so for more than two months following
- 36:25election day on November three, twenty twenty, the defendants spread lies that there
- 36:30had been outcome determinative fraud in the election and that he had actually won.
- 36:37These claims were faults, and the defendant knew they were false, but the
- 36:40defendant repeated and widely disseminated them anyway to make his knowingly false claims imperial legitimate,
- 36:47create an intense national atmosphere of mistrust and anger, and erode public faith
- 36:52in the administration of the election. The defendant had a right, like every
- 36:58American to speak publicly about the election, and even to claim falsely that there
- 37:02had been outcome determinative fraud during the election and that he had won. He
- 37:07was also entitled to formally challenge the results of the election through lawful and appropriate
- 37:13means, such as by seeking recounts or audits of the popular vote in states,
- 37:17or filing lawsuits challenging ballots and procedures. Indeed, in many cases,
- 37:22the defendant did pursue these methods of contesting the election results. His effort to
- 37:29change the outcome in any state through recount, audits, or legal challenges were
- 37:34uniformly unsuccessful. Shortly after election day, the defendant also pursued unlawful means of
- 37:40discounting legitimate votes and subverting the election results. In so doing, the definant
- 37:46perpetrated three criminal conspiracies. A conspiracy to defraud the United States by using dishonesty,
- 37:53fraud, and deceit to impair, obstruct, and defeat the lawful federal
- 37:58government function by which the results of the presidential election are collected, counted,
- 38:02and certified by the federal government in violation of eighteen USC. Section three seven
- 38:08one. A conspiracy to corruptly obstruct and impede the January sixth Congressional proceedings at
- 38:15which the collected results of the presidential election are counted and certified the certification proceeding
- 38:22in violation of eighteen USC. Section fifteen twelve K, and a conspiracy against
- 38:29the right to vote and to have one's vote counted in violation of eighteen USC.
- 38:32Section two forty one. Each of these conspiracies, which built on the
- 38:37widespread mistrust of the defendant that the defendant was creating through pervasive and destabilizing lies
- 38:45about election fraud, targeted a bedrock function of the United States Federal government,
- 38:50the nation's process of collecting, counting, and certifying the results of the presidential
- 38:54election at federal government function. Count one conspiracy to defraud the United States.
- 39:04The allegations contained in paragraph one through four of this indictment are re alleged fully
- 39:07incorporated here by reference the conspiracy from honor about November fourteen, twenty twenty,
- 39:15through honor about January twenty twenty one, in the District of Crump, Columbian
- 39:20Elsewhere, the defendant, Donald J. Trump did knowingly combine, conspire,
- 39:24confederate, and agree with co conspirators known and unknown to the grand jury,
- 39:30to defraud the United States by using dishonesty, fraud, and deceit to impair,
- 39:35obstruct, and defeat the lawful federal governmental function by which the results of
- 39:39the presidential election are collected, counted, and certified by the federal government.
- 39:45The purpose of the conspiracy was to overturn the legitimate results of the twenty twenty
- 39:51presidential election by using knowingly false claims of election fraud to obstruct the federal government
- 39:57function by which those results are collected, counted in s. The defendant enlisted
- 40:01cost conspirators to assist him in his criminal efforts to overturn the legitimate results of
- 40:07the twenty twenty presidential election and retain power. Among these were co Conspirator one,
- 40:13an attorney who was willing to spread knowingly false claims and pursue strategies that
- 40:16the defendant's twenty twenty re election campaign attorneys would not. Co Conspirator two,
- 40:22an attorney who devised and attempted to implement a strategy to leverage the Vice president's
- 40:29ceremonial role overseeing the certification process to obstruct the certification of the presidential election.
- 40:36Co Conspirator three an attorney whose unfounded claims of election fraud the defendant privately acknowledged
- 40:40others sounded crazy. Nonetheless, the defendant embraced and publicly amplified co conspirators threes
- 40:47disinformation Co Conspirator four adjusted Department official who worked on civil matters and who with
- 40:53the defendant, attempted to use the Justice Department to open sham election crime investigates
- 41:00and influenced state legislatures with knowingly false claims of election fraud. Co Conspirator five
- 41:07an attorney who assisted in devising and attempting to implement a plan to submit fraudulent
- 41:12slates of presidential electors to obstruct the certification proceeding. Co Conspirator six a political
- 41:19consultant who helped implement a plan to submit fraudulent slates of presidential electors to obstruct
- 41:24the certification proceeding. The federal government function by which the results of the election
- 41:30for president of the United States are collected, counted, and certified was established
- 41:35through the Constitution and the Electoral Account Act, which was a federal law and
- 41:38acted in eighteen eighty seven. The Constitution provided that individuals called electors select the
- 41:45president, and that each state determined for itself how to appoint the electors a
- 41:49portion to it through state laws, each of the fifty states and the District
- 41:53of Columbia choose to select their electors based upon the popular vote in the state.
- 42:00After election day, the ECA that's the Election Count Electoral Count Act required
- 42:06each state to formally determine or ascertain the electors who would represent the state's voters
- 42:12by casting electoral votes on behalf of the candidate who had won the popular vote,
- 42:15and required the executive of each state to certify to the federal government the
- 42:20identities of those electors. Then, on a date set by the Electoral Account
- 42:24Act, each state's ascertained electors were required to meet and collect the results of
- 42:30the presidential election, that is, to cast electoral votes based upon their state's
- 42:35popular vote, and to send their electoral votes, along with the state executives
- 42:38certification that they were the state's legitimate electors, to the United States Congress to
- 42:44be counted and certified in an official proceeding. Finally, the Constitution and the
- 42:51Electoral Count Act require that on the sixth of January following election day, the
- 42:59congressman meet in a joint session for a certification proceeding presided over by the Vice
- 43:02President as President of the Senate, to count the electoral votes, resolve any
- 43:08objections, and announce the result, thus certifying the winner of the presidential election
- 43:13as president elect. This federal government function, from the point of ascertainment to
- 43:19the certification is foundational to the United States democratic process, and until twenty twenty
- 43:23one, had operated in a peaceful and orderly manner for more than one hundred
- 43:29and thirty years. The defendant's conspiracy to impair, obstruct, and defeat the
- 43:35federal government function through dishonesty, fraud, and deceit included the following manner and
- 43:39means. The defendant and code conspirators use knowingly false claims of election fraud to
- 43:45get state legislators and election officials to subvert the legitimate election results and change electoral
- 43:52votes for the defendant's opponent, Joseph R. Biden Junior, to electoral votes
- 43:57for the defendant. That is, on the pretext of baseless fraud claims.
- 44:01The defendant pushed officials in certain states to ignore the popular vote, disenfranchised millions
- 44:07of voters, dismissed legitimate electors, and ultimately caused the ascertainment of and voting
- 44:13by illegitimate electors in favor of the defendant. The defendant and co conspirators organized
- 44:21fraudulent slates of electors in seven targeted states Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada,
- 44:25New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, attempting to mimic the procedures that
- 44:30the legitimate electors were supposed to follow under the Constitution and other federal and state
- 44:36laws. This included causing the fraudulent electors to meet on the day appointed by
- 44:40federal law in which legitimate electors were to gather and to cast their votes,
- 44:45cast fraudulent votes for the defendant and science certificates falsely representing that they were legitimate
- 44:51electors. Some fraudulent electors were tricked and participating based on the understanding that their
- 44:55votes would be osed only if the defendants succeeded in outcome determinative lawsuits within their
- 45:01state, which the defendant never did. The defendant and co conspirators then caused
- 45:07these fraudulent electorers to transmit their falsest certificates to the Vice president and other government
- 45:14officials to be counted at the certification proceeding on January sixth, the defendant and
- 45:19co conspirators attempted to use the power and authority of the Justice Department to conduct
- 45:23sham election crime investigations and to send a letter to the targeted states that falsely
- 45:29claimed that the Justice Department had identified significant concerns that may have impacted the election
- 45:35outcome that sought to advance the defendants fraudulent elect or plan by using the Justice
- 45:38Department's authority to falsely present the fraudulent electors as valid alternative to the legitimate electors,
- 45:46and that urged on behalf of the Justice Department the targeted electors states legislators
- 45:53to convene to create the opportunity to choose the fraudulent electors over the legitimate electors.
- 46:00The defendant and co conspirators attempted to enlist the Vice President to use his
- 46:05ceremonial role at the January six certification precedings to fraudulently alter the election results.
- 46:12First, using knowingly false claims of election fraud, the defendant and co conspirators
- 46:15attempted to convince the Vice President to use the defendants fraudulent electors reject legitimate electoral
- 46:22votes or send legitimate electoral votes to state legislators for review rather than counting them.
- 46:29When that failed, on the morning of January sixth, the defendant and
- 46:31co conspirators repeated knowingly false claims of election fraud to gather supporters, falsely told
- 46:37them that the vice president had the authority to and might alter the election results,
- 46:42and directed them to the capital to obstruct the certification proceeding and exert pressure
- 46:45on the Vice president to take the fraudulent actions he had previously refused. After
- 46:52it became public on the afternoon of January six that the Vice President would not
- 46:55fraudulently alter the election results, a large and angry crowd, including many individuals
- 47:00whom the defendant had deceived into believing the vice president could and might change the
- 47:05election results, violently attacked the capital and halted the proceeding. As violence ensued,
- 47:10the defendant and co conspirators exploited the disruption by redoubling efforts to levy false
- 47:16claims of election fraud and convinced members of Congress to further delay the certification Based
- 47:22upon those claims, The defendant, as co conspirators and their agents made knowingly
- 47:28false claims that there had been outcome determinative fraud in the twenty twenty presidential election.
- 47:32These prolific lies about election fraud included dozens of specific claims that there had
- 47:37been substantial fraud in certain states, such as that large numbers of dead,
- 47:43nonresident, non citizen, or otherwise ineligible voters had cast ballots, or that
- 47:46voting machines had changed votes for the defendant to votes for Biden. These claims
- 47:52were faults, and the defendant knew that they were false. In fact,
- 47:54the defendant was notified repeatedly that his claims were untrue, often by the people
- 48:00on whom he relied for candidate advice on important matters and who were best positioned
- 48:04to know the facts, and he deliberately disregarded the truth. For instance,
- 48:10the defendants Vice president, who personally stood to gain by remaining in office as
- 48:14part of the defendants ticket, and whom the defendant asked to study fraud allgations,
- 48:19told the defendant that he had seen no evidence of outcome determinative fraud.
- 48:23The senior leaders of the Justice Department, appointed by the defendant and responsible for
- 48:28investigating credible allegations of elected crimes, told the defendant on multiple occasions that various
- 48:34allegations of fraud were unsupported. The Director of National Intelligence, the defendants principal
- 48:38adviser on intelligence matters related to national security, disabused the defendant of the notion
- 48:45that the intelligence communities findings regarding foreign interference would change the outcome of the election.
- 48:52The Department of Homeland Security cyber Security and Infrastructure Security Agency, whose existence
- 48:57the defendant signed into law to protect the nation cyber security infrastructure from attack,
- 49:00joined an official multi agency statement that there was no evidence any voting system had
- 49:07been compromised and that declared the twenty twenty election the most secure in American history.
- 49:12Days later, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency director, whom the definitant
- 49:20had appointed, and announced publicly that election security experts were in agreement the claims
- 49:24of computer based election fraud or would were unsubstantiated. The defendant fired him.
- 49:30Senior wife's house attorney, selected by the defendant to provide him candid advice,
- 49:35and formed the defendant that there was no evidence of outcome determined of election fraud
- 49:39and told him that his presidency would end on inauguration day in twenty twenty one.
- 49:45Senior staffers on the defendants twenty twenty re election campaign, whose sole mission
- 49:52was the defendant's re election, told the defendant on November seven, twenty twenty,
- 49:54that he had only five to ten percent chance of prevailing in the election,
- 49:59and that success was contingent on the defendant winning ongoing vote counts or litigation
- 50:04in Arizona, Georgia, and Wisconsin. Within a week of that assessment,
- 50:07the defendant loss in Arizona, meaning he had lost the election. State legislators
- 50:15and officials, many of whom were the defendant's political allies, had voted for
- 50:19him and wanted him to be re elected, repeatedly informed the defendant that his
- 50:22claims of fraud in their states were unsubstantiated or faults, and resisted his pressure
- 50:28to act based upon them. State and federal courts, the neutral arbiters responsible
- 50:32for insuring the fair and even had an administration elected of election laws, rejected
- 50:37every outcome determined of post election lawsuit filed by the defendant, his co conspirators
- 50:43and allies, providing the defendant real time notice that his allegations were meritless.
- 50:47The defendant widely disseminated his false claims of election fraud for months, despite the
- 50:53fact that he knew and in many cases, had been informed directly that they
- 50:57were not true. The defendants knowingly fault statements were integral to his criminal plans
- 51:01to defeat the federal government function, obstruct the certification, and interfere with others'
- 51:07rights to vote and have their votes counted. He made these knowingly false claims
- 51:12throughout the post election time period, including those below that he made immediately before
- 51:17the attack on the Capitol. On January sixth, the infinite insisted that more
- 51:23than ten thousand dead voters had voted in Georgia just four days earlier. Georgia's
- 51:28Secretary of State had explained the defendant that that was false. The defendant asserted
- 51:32that there had been two hundred and five thousand more votes than voters in Pennsylvania.
- 51:38The defendant's acting Attorney General and acting Deputy Attorney General had explained to him
- 51:43that this was faults. The defendant said that there had been a suspicious vote
- 51:47dump in Dedroit, Michigan. The defense attorney General had explained to the defendant
- 51:52that this was faults, and the defendant's allies in the Michigan state legislature,
- 51:57the Speaker of the House representative, as a majority leader the Senate had publicly
- 52:00announced that there was no evidence of substantial fraud in the state. The defendant
- 52:05claimed that there had been tens of thousands of double votes and other fraud in
- 52:07Nevada. The Nevada Secretary of State had previously rebutted the defendant's fraud claims by
- 52:13publicly posting of facts versus Myth's document, explaining that Nevada judges had reviewed and
- 52:19rejected them, and then Nevada Supreme Court had rendered a decision denying such claims.
- 52:23The defendant said that more than thirty thousand non citizens and voted in Arizona.
- 52:28The defense owned campaign manager explained to him that such claims were faults,
- 52:31and the speaker of the Arizona House of Representatives, who had supported the defendant
- 52:36in the election, had issued a public statement that there was no evidence of
- 52:38substantial fraud in Arizona. The defendant asserted that voting machines in various contested states
- 52:45had been switched votes from the defendant to Biden. The defendant's attorney general,
- 52:50acting Attorney General, and acting Deputy Attorney General all had explained to him that
- 52:53this was faults and numerous recounts and audits had confirmed the accuracy of voting machines.
- 53:00Only on page nine of a forty five page indictment. Uh, it's
- 53:04damning the We we got to watch him say these things on TV. This
- 53:12isn't some twist of some kind of liberal media or conservative media. We got
- 53:17to say the thing. We got to see all of these things already on
- 53:22TV. This is this is not the politicization weaponization of the federal government against
- 53:30Donald Trump. Donald Trump had weaponized the federal government or attempted to weaponize it
- 53:36against all of the voters of the United States of America, and he should
- 53:40answer to and be accountable for that. And that's why he's been arraigned for
- 53:45this indictment today. Thanks for helping me build this zoo. We'll see you
- 53:53next week or out of here on the drums.