Latest / Insights Now / The economic implications of generative AI
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Insights now,
- 0:02a series of conversations designed to shine a light of clarity on the complex world of investing.
- 0:07This season is a special summer series entitled Market Movers.
- 0:10As we will focus on key themes that have the potential to move markets today.
- 0:13And over the long term,
- 0:15if you're listening to the audio version of this podcast,
- 0:18you can watch along on youtube by tuning into our JP Morgan Asset Management channel.
- 0:23Hello,
- 0:24I'm David Kelly,
- 0:25chief Global strategist here at JP Morgan Asset Management and welcome to Insights now.
- 0:30So let's get started.
- 0:32There are a lot of questions surrounding A I and its potential to change both the economy and society.
- 0:37So I'm here with Michael Albrecht and Stephanie Aliaga,
- 0:40who have both been doing a lot of research into what A I might mean for the workforce,
- 0:44for productivity and for economic growth.
- 0:47Uh And,
- 0:47and you're actually putting this out in a forthcoming research publication.
- 0:52Um So Mike is a strategist with our Multi asset solutions team here at JP Morgan Asset Management.
- 0:57And Stephanie is a research analyst in my team who spends a lot of time focusing on the US economy.
- 1:02She's also helped a ton with these podcasts.
- 1:03So thank you for that,
- 1:04Stephanie.
- 1:05Um So it's great to have you both at this table here.
- 1:07So let me start with you,
- 1:08Mike.
- 1:09Why?
- 1:10A I now,
- 1:10I mean,
- 1:11a I has been around for a while.
- 1:12So why is there so much excitement about A I right now?
- 1:14Yeah,
- 1:14that,
- 1:14that's really the question of the day right there.
- 1:16There's a lot of excitement in the market right now and,
- 1:19and really what,
- 1:19what sets us apart from,
- 1:21from the,
- 1:22the prior waves of,
- 1:23of A I excitement that we've had in the past is that the generative nature of,
- 1:27of A I?
- 1:27So it's,
- 1:28it's really generative A I uh as it's known that,
- 1:31that people are excited about the,
- 1:32the best example of this,
- 1:33the most obvious one is Chat G BT,
- 1:36the,
- 1:36the product from open A I that,
- 1:38that Chat bot that you can ask any kind of question it applies to you in a very natural language way.
- 1:43Now that that's text based,
- 1:44but there's also other technologies similar that,
- 1:48that work with images,
- 1:49like,
- 1:49like dolly and can really generate images uh based on a text prompt.
- 1:53Um Now,
- 1:54if you compare that to,
- 1:55to where we were,
- 1:56you know,
- 1:56several years ago,
- 1:58uh thinking back to,
- 1:59to 1997 I,
- 2:00I grew up playing chess.
- 2:01Uh and I remember when,
- 2:03when Gary Kasparov got,
- 2:04got defeated by,
- 2:05by the,
- 2:06the IBM computer.
- 2:07Uh you know,
- 2:07that was a very primitive example.
- 2:09A I but,
- 2:11but A I nonetheless.
- 2:12Um and,
- 2:12and we've come a long way since then,
- 2:14there's been progress on machine learning.
- 2:17So,
- 2:17you know,
- 2:18when,
- 2:18when I,
- 2:19when I open up my phone,
- 2:20um I can,
- 2:21I can search bumble bee within Google photos and I'll come up with a,
- 2:25with the result of the pictures that I took a few weeks ago.
- 2:27Um And,
- 2:28and that's because Google has gone and,
- 2:31and,
- 2:31and tagged my picture with,
- 2:33with all the,
- 2:33the the contents of,
- 2:35of uh what they understand is in that picture.
- 2:37Um And,
- 2:38and um,
- 2:39so that,
- 2:39that's really cool,
- 2:40right?
- 2:40And a lot of resources goes into this every time you go on the internet and,
- 2:44and you have to verify you're a human and very annoyingly and you have to pick the,
- 2:48the images of the fire hydrants in them.
- 2:49You,
- 2:50you're training a model and,
- 2:51and,
- 2:52and that,
- 2:52that's very useful,
- 2:53right?
- 2:54The,
- 2:54the difference now with,
- 2:55with generative A I is that I can,
- 2:57I can actually ask it to,
- 2:59to show me a picture,
- 3:01a photorealistic picture of a bumblebee wearing a hat.
- 3:04I can,
- 3:05I can ask,
- 3:06uh you know,
- 3:06uh to do that or I can ask uh chat G BT to write me a story about a bumblebee learning to fly.
- 3:13So there,
- 3:14there,
- 3:14there's a lot of differences here and,
- 3:16and maybe silly as it sounds,
- 3:18it is very important because you,
- 3:20you're not just writing a story,
- 3:21you could potentially write a movie script,
- 3:23right?
- 3:23And that,
- 3:23that's why the,
- 3:25the,
- 3:25um,
- 3:25the screenwriters in America are on strike right now now,
- 3:29to be sure there,
- 3:30there's only about 10,000 screenwriters in the US.
- 3:33Uh,
- 3:33but if you can write a movie script or at least help to do that,
- 3:36then you probably write computer code and,
- 3:39and help uh help software engineers to bug their code.
- 3:42You can probably help lawyers draft contracts and write legal opinions.
- 3:45So there's a,
- 3:46there's a lot that you can potentially do just in that text space.
- 3:50And then if you think about the,
- 3:51the visual components,
- 3:52you can imagine that the graphic designers,
- 3:55video editors,
- 3:56a lot of their work can be automated as well.
- 3:59Ultimately.
- 4:00Um And,
- 4:00and so what,
- 4:01ultimately,
- 4:02when,
- 4:02when we imagine what generative A I can do across the whole economy,
- 4:06the impact can really be,
- 4:07be massive.
- 4:08Sometimes it's actually easier to imagine what,
- 4:11what generative A I can't do.
- 4:13And the biggest category there is that,
- 4:15that it can't do physical things,
- 4:16it can't pick up a glass of water and,
- 4:18and give it to somebody,
- 4:18right?
- 4:19Um But,
- 4:20but it,
- 4:21it,
- 4:21it,
- 4:21in our,
- 4:21in our information economy,
- 4:23in our,
- 4:23our desk jobs that there's a lot that,
- 4:26that we do that that could potentially be,
- 4:29be automated.
- 4:30Uh So,
- 4:30so the the bottom line to your question I think is,
- 4:33is that,
- 4:34you know,
- 4:34what really sets generative A I apart is that there,
- 4:37there's so much that it,
- 4:38it can do that,
- 4:40that,
- 4:40uh,
- 4:40that we do today and,
- 4:42and um,
- 4:43and ultimately being able to automate that much can have a really big impact on our daily lives and the economy.
- 4:49So,
- 4:49do,
- 4:49do you agree with that?
- 4:51Yeah.
- 4:51And I mean,
- 4:51I think the other main reason for excitement is that this has been able to become suddenly so mainstream.
- 4:58And the reason that this technology has,
- 5:00you know,
- 5:00the adoption has really been able to take off is because unlike the advent of the computer,
- 5:05where first for everyone to use computers,
- 5:07you needed to build,
- 5:08you know,
- 5:09these expensive computer labs and teach everyone how to use a computer.
- 5:12Now everyone already has computers,
- 5:14smartphones,
- 5:15they can just search up open A I on,
- 5:18on their mobile phone and begin using the technology right away.
- 5:20So that's how there's that statistic that chat G BT broke records are reaching 1 million users in just five days.
- 5:27I mean,
- 5:27that's really,
- 5:28you know,
- 5:29the key here is that it's approachable to the average nontechnical human and then businesses are also catching on,
- 5:35right.
- 5:36There are a lot of exciting things that this can do for businesses and making their processes more efficient.
- 5:41Um And so we've seen this wave of investment dollars flowing into A I in recent years.
- 5:47So just in the five years ending in 2021 you saw global business investment increase by six times on A I technologies.
- 5:55Um A I startups are also exploding,
- 5:58but it's not just startups,
- 6:00right?
- 6:00It's also the largest companies in the sc 500.
- 6:03So we actually looked through earnings transcripts of the first quarter earnings calls this um this year and about 30% of S and P 500 management teams were talking about A I and that's up from 13% last year compared to the,
- 6:17you know,
- 6:18the last hype wave around crypto that really only ever got to 7% of sc 500 companies.
- 6:23So the business focus on this has been really impressive too and it shows how,
- 6:29you know,
- 6:29A I is really well positioned to grow and scale in the coming years.
- 6:32So,
- 6:32so it sounds to me like it's not just the generative part is really important because it can actually almost think which is really what,
- 6:40what's bizarre about it.
- 6:41But also,
- 6:42you know,
- 6:42to Stephanie your point,
- 6:43the fact it's accessibility of the masses because I remember when I started with computers and now I'm dating myself,
- 6:48you literally have to write in do for disk operating system at the first prompt in order to get the thing going and,
- 6:55and,
- 6:55but it was really,
- 6:56it was behind a very obscure wall in terms of using these,
- 7:02but now anybody can use them because the A I is not just good at coming up with ideas,
- 7:05it's also good at understanding humans.
- 7:07So this,
- 7:10it could have a lot of productivity implications obviously.
- 7:12But,
- 7:13but what do you think?
- 7:13I mean,
- 7:13how,
- 7:14how can you can you quantify what those productivity implications might be?
- 7:17Yes,
- 7:17there's a lot of estimates out there.
- 7:19Um I mean,
- 7:20just starting at a firm level right there,
- 7:22there's a range of empirical studies that have looked at this and they've observed that companies adopting A I technologies can experience something like 10 to 20% uh and labor productivity gains,
- 7:33you know,
- 7:33just in,
- 7:33in,
- 7:33in their one company.
- 7:35Um And then there's estimates that kind of expand on an aggregate productivity level for the US economy.
- 7:41And uh Goldman Sachs thinks that that could potentially contribute to 2 to 3% in productivity growth every year for the next 10 years.
- 7:49Mckinzie also has done their own analysis.
- 7:51They found,
- 7:52you know,
- 7:52similar numbers and to put that into context like productivity growth has been pretty lackluster in the past 10 years.
- 7:58I mean,
- 7:59you have done a lot of work on this,
- 8:00one of the more frustrating things when when forecasting economic growth,
- 8:03we're just not getting productivity and that's grown at like 1.4% since 2005.
- 8:09So we're talking about an incremental gain of about 2 to 3% just from generative A I and A I technologies.
- 8:15It said a different way.
- 8:16I mean,
- 8:16this could add trillions to the global economy in terms of total output,
- 8:21right?
- 8:22So mckenzie has added this up and they think this could add between 2 to 2 to $4 trillion to global GDP globally.
- 8:29That's like adding an entire,
- 8:31you know,
- 8:31economy,
- 8:32the size of the UK each year.
- 8:34And this is just from hope it operates better than the UK economy.
- 8:38I hope that too.
- 8:41Um uh So that,
- 8:43you know,
- 8:43we're really talking about some really major impacts here from A I potentially.
- 8:47Yeah.
- 8:47Might you have some thoughts on?
- 8:49Yeah.
- 8:49Yeah.
- 8:50So,
- 8:50so a couple of things,
- 8:51I mean,
- 8:51first of all,
- 8:51I think there,
- 8:52there's a tremendous amount of uncertainty here.
- 8:54Uh So we have to really be humble when we're talking about any of these numbers and,
- 8:56and really trying to,
- 8:57to quantify anything.
- 8:58It's,
- 8:58it's hard to pin down exact numbers and you'll hear a lot of very,
- 9:02very wide ranges and,
- 9:04and we have those ourselves,
- 9:05uh the uncertainties come from the technology itself.
- 9:08You know,
- 9:08we see what chat GP T is able to do today.
- 9:10We don't know what it's going to be able to do.
- 9:12And in 10 years from now,
- 9:13it's going to be able to advance significantly from,
- 9:15from where it is.
- 9:16Now,
- 9:17there is some,
- 9:17some uh uncertainty about the,
- 9:19the willingness and ability of,
- 9:20of businesses to really adopt that.
- 9:22And,
- 9:22and then if that is the case,
- 9:24um you know,
- 9:25how,
- 9:25how,
- 9:25how do societies respond ultimately and,
- 9:27and governments respond?
- 9:28Do people go and,
- 9:29and that they,
- 9:30they find uh different kind of,
- 9:32of work.
- 9:33Um,
- 9:33a after,
- 9:34after they,
- 9:34they've,
- 9:35they've maybe been displaced from their job because of automation.
- 9:37That's something I'm sure we'll get into.
- 9:39Um,
- 9:39but,
- 9:39but then on,
- 9:40on top of that,
- 9:41finally,
- 9:41um there's all these complementary innovations that,
- 9:43that we don't even know yet what they're going to be.
- 9:46Um So that that would be kind of the,
- 9:48the,
- 9:48the first thing that,
- 9:49that I'd add.
- 9:49But uh you know,
- 9:50we,
- 9:50we've done a lot of these calculations ourselves and,
- 9:53and I think just,
- 9:54just one thing to,
- 9:55to kind of set the stage here.
- 9:57So we know what we're talking about.
- 9:58A lot of people tend to think about,
- 10:00you know,
- 10:00this job is going to be automated by A I and,
- 10:03and this job is not,
- 10:04but really what,
- 10:05what the work that's being done is looking at um more at a task level.
- 10:10So there's databases out there that look at every single task that you can,
- 10:14you can possibly imagine for every single job,
- 10:17you can cross reference that with some other databases to look at at the,
- 10:20the amount of uh those jobs in the economy and they come up with the,
- 10:24the task content,
- 10:25every single task in the economy and you can go one by one and say,
- 10:29hey,
- 10:29I can do that A I can probably do that and so on.
- 10:31And at the end of the day,
- 10:32you get a number that I think in our,
- 10:34in our view,
- 10:35um you know,
- 10:36probably we think that some of these estimates out there are a little bit ambitious but,
- 10:40but something like 5 to,
- 10:42to 20% of the economy uh could probably be automated at the end of the day over the next 10 years or so.
- 10:48Yeah.
- 10:48And,
- 10:48and I mean,
- 10:49you talk about auto automation,
- 10:50but productivity isn't just about automating existing tasks.
- 10:54I mean,
- 10:54there's more to it than that.
- 10:55Yeah,
- 10:55exactly.
- 10:56And that's the other,
- 10:57you know,
- 10:57major point when it comes to A I is that when we think about the past,
- 11:02you know,
- 11:02transformative technologies that are really shaped the way we live today.
- 11:06So things like the steam engine,
- 11:08when you know,
- 11:09the actually the steam engine was first made to help pump water out of coal mines.
- 11:14Um And then people realize,
- 11:15oh,
- 11:15wow,
- 11:16this technology is really neat.
- 11:17We can use this to build railroads in,
- 11:20in steam ships which then gave way to innovations and supply chains.
- 11:24Um You know,
- 11:25and,
- 11:25and really created the industrial revolution um more wholly um similar to the computer,
- 11:30right?
- 11:30It sparked a whole bunch of,
- 11:32of innovations digitally that populate our lives today.
- 11:35So when it comes to A I,
- 11:36I mean,
- 11:37I think what we're dealing with is is there's a number of complementary innovations that can come out of this.
- 11:42So we can only begin to imagine.
- 11:44And the other thing that actually gets you really excited is is the potential to accelerate innovation itself from A I.
- 11:51So A I can help automate right?
- 11:53A lot of time consuming tasks well through the research and development process is quite long because of a lot of those time consuming tasks.
- 12:00Um A I can also analyze vast amounts of data and in doing so,
- 12:05it can uncover new insights,
- 12:07better ways of doing things.
- 12:09Provide us with those insights,
- 12:11create a more seamless um environment for human collaboration and creativity.
- 12:15We can get our own like smart assistant in all of our team meetings um to help take notes and suggest ideas.
- 12:22And when you hear from the leaders in A I I mean,
- 12:24this is what they're really excited about.
- 12:26Bless so much of the automation of of tasks.
- 12:28It's it's the ability to,
- 12:30to really help solve a lot of important real world problems.
- 12:33It,
- 12:33it sort of reminds me of DNA,
- 12:35which not only is the product of evolution,
- 12:38but it is an amazing evolution machine by the very frequency with which it makes mistakes and replicates.
- 12:44So you know,
- 12:44it it truly magnificent evolutionary process is not just one that evolves but actually speeds the pace of evolution.
- 12:50This seems like very much sort of a parallel thing that A I can actually speed the rate of innovation of A I very interesting but,
- 12:57so this is all very positive.
- 12:59But the,
- 12:59but the downside of course is we're going to take our jobs.
- 13:02I mean,
- 13:02are you,
- 13:03are you worried about the,
- 13:05um,
- 13:05you know,
- 13:05the employment impact of a,
- 13:07I,
- 13:07there's definitely a,
- 13:08a tendency to think about that,
- 13:10that risk and,
- 13:11and if,
- 13:11if there,
- 13:11there,
- 13:12there is a risk that,
- 13:13that's definitely one of the,
- 13:14one of the bigger ones.
- 13:16Um,
- 13:16it,
- 13:17I,
- 13:17I think,
- 13:18you know,
- 13:19um,
- 13:19that there,
- 13:19there's a lot,
- 13:20there's a lot of,
- 13:21of work out there that,
- 13:22that involves,
- 13:23you know,
- 13:23repetition,
- 13:24very,
- 13:25very uh boring work that,
- 13:26that we don't like to do.
- 13:27And,
- 13:27and it's,
- 13:28it's a fortunate thing actually that,
- 13:30that,
- 13:30that a I can,
- 13:31can maybe automate a lot of that stuff.
- 13:33Um But,
- 13:33uh,
- 13:33you know,
- 13:34you can imagine for,
- 13:35for us,
- 13:35for instance,
- 13:36kind of reading through a lot of the,
- 13:37the research that that tends to be,
- 13:39uh saying the same thing is kind of coming away with some summary reports can help us do our jobs a lot better,
- 13:43right?
- 13:43And save us a give us a lot of time and,
- 13:45and,
- 13:45and open up opportunities to do to do more interesting things.
- 13:49I suppose that the downside to that is that if,
- 13:51if we've got a whole bunch of other time on our hands,
- 13:54uh we,
- 13:54we can spend that doing,
- 13:55doing other things and,
- 13:57and uh ultimately that,
- 13:58that can mean a few things um in,
- 14:00in a perfectly optimized world,
- 14:02perhaps we,
- 14:03we could all go out and,
- 14:05and have a lot,
- 14:05a lot of leisure time,
- 14:07you know,
- 14:07the,
- 14:07the,
- 14:07the key ZN 15 hour work week,
- 14:09if you will uh really gets materialized.
- 14:11Um Whether that happens,
- 14:13I think is a big question,
- 14:14probably the,
- 14:14the more likely kind of result is is that uh some of us um are needed to do jobs but,
- 14:21but not,
- 14:21not quite as many people.
- 14:23Um,
- 14:23and,
- 14:24and ultimately,
- 14:25that,
- 14:25that means you don't need a,
- 14:26a team that's quite as big.
- 14:27Uh,
- 14:28the other possibility is that their clients are wind up,
- 14:31uh,
- 14:31wind up asking us to do a little bit more and we,
- 14:34we end up delivering much more,
- 14:35more interesting,
- 14:36uh,
- 14:36wholesome work and,
- 14:38and that,
- 14:38that's,
- 14:39uh,
- 14:39that,
- 14:39that's kind of the,
- 14:40the other possibility.
- 14:41So the reality is probably AAA mixture of both of these.
- 14:45Um,
- 14:46the,
- 14:46the one thing that,
- 14:47that,
- 14:47that kind of maybe a related point that,
- 14:49that I would add to this is that there,
- 14:51there's really a lot that,
- 14:53that,
- 14:54uh,
- 14:54that,
- 14:54that the likes of chad G BT can't do yet.
- 14:56Right.
- 14:57So,
- 14:57you,
- 14:57you,
- 14:58you've got,
- 14:58um,
- 14:59the,
- 14:59the way I kind of think about it and,
- 15:01and I've used it a lot in,
- 15:02in,
- 15:03in like my own writing and try to help me.
- 15:05Um,
- 15:05but,
- 15:06you know,
- 15:06sometimes it,
- 15:07it,
- 15:07it doesn't,
- 15:08doesn't quite seem to to understand what you're asking it to do.
- 15:12Um,
- 15:12it,
- 15:13it's,
- 15:13um,
- 15:13in many cases,
- 15:15it,
- 15:15it kind of hallucinates some,
- 15:16some information that,
- 15:18that isn't quite true and,
- 15:19and,
- 15:19uh,
- 15:19when it does do what you want it to do,
- 15:21it can be a little bit wordy.
- 15:23So it,
- 15:24it,
- 15:24it's,
- 15:24it's not quite a refined product in some ways.
- 15:26It kind of reminds me of,
- 15:27of sort of the,
- 15:28the new person on the team who's,
- 15:30who's uh kind of coming up and,
- 15:32and,
- 15:32and figuring out how to do things,
- 15:34you know,
- 15:34so they'll,
- 15:35they'll hand you a piece of work,
- 15:36which is very useful.
- 15:37It saves me a lot of time,
- 15:38but at the end of the day,
- 15:40it,
- 15:40it needs another layer of,
- 15:41of expertise on top of that.
- 15:43And,
- 15:43and I,
- 15:43I think that that's essentially what a lot of us can continue to do.
- 15:47The,
- 15:47the bottom line though is that,
- 15:48that you just don't need as many people to,
- 15:50to perform that.
- 15:51That really interesting work.
- 15:53I think we're still ironing out some of the kinks with Chat G BT and generative A I.
- 15:56But the net result is that,
- 15:58you know,
- 15:59yes,
- 15:59a large swath of workers will be exposed to automation in their job.
- 16:03I mean,
- 16:03automation isn't a new phenomenon.
- 16:04It's not necessarily something to be wholly scared of um in its entirety.
- 16:08But I do think it's going to challenge workers to particularly hone in on those skills that humans are uniquely good at complex problem solving,
- 16:18collaboration,
- 16:19creativity.
- 16:20And then there's a swath of,
- 16:21of jobs too that we don't really think we'll see much automation anytime soon.
- 16:26Um It looks like the use of robotics,
- 16:28at least on a broad scale is still a long ways away.
- 16:30So,
- 16:30I mean,
- 16:31a lot of the jobs that require manual labor to make sure earlier point will still be there.
- 16:34So you'll still need to mow your lawn or hire someone to do it.
- 16:37And then there's a bunch of jobs where we just simply the human,
- 16:40the human value,
- 16:41the human component of that job is so valuable,
- 16:44it likely won't be automated.
- 16:46So when you think about,
- 16:47um,
- 16:47you know,
- 16:48day care providers,
- 16:49celebrities hopefully market strategist.
- 16:54Well,
- 16:54yeah.
- 16:54And I suppose part of it is,
- 16:56you know,
- 16:56and the economy generate enough demand for new stuff to make up for the,
- 17:00uh,
- 17:00for some of the older stuff that's being done more efficiently,
- 17:03which is really what the economy has really done.
- 17:05I mean,
- 17:05I've always believed particularly in America that people actually don't want to spend more time with their relatives.
- 17:10So they will find something to do something they want and something to do.
- 17:14So,
- 17:15you know,
- 17:15I think,
- 17:16you know,
- 17:16over the,
- 17:17as I think you both alluded to over the years,
- 17:20people have often talked about how some technology is going to kill jobs and somehow the economy always managed to find the demand for new stuff,
- 17:27new services,
- 17:28new things uh which,
- 17:29which keeps us,
- 17:30keeps us employed.
- 17:31Exactly.
- 17:32I mean,
- 17:32history shows this too,
- 17:33over 80% of the employment growth that we've seen in the US economy since the 19 eighties is explained by this tech driven creation of new jobs.
- 17:44So yes,
- 17:45we've already displaced a lot of the farmers and textile workers that we used to have.
- 17:50And,
- 17:50you know,
- 17:50back in the 18 hundreds,
- 17:51over 80% of the US workforce was working in the fields,
- 17:55right?
- 17:55But then the agricultural revolution did,
- 17:57it lead to mass unemployment.
- 17:59No,
- 17:59it actually um well,
- 18:01first it created it,
- 18:02it made the cost of a lot of those agricultural goods cheaper.
- 18:06So people had more money to spend on other things and spend.
- 18:09They did,
- 18:09right?
- 18:10So that created the birth of all of these new industries which then needed new uh to employ new people and so forth.
- 18:17So this long history of tech innovation that we've experienced in the US has been associated with the birth of new jobs that have offset a lot of that labor creation.
- 18:26But,
- 18:26but one of the downsides in,
- 18:28in prior,
- 18:30you know,
- 18:30technological revolutions has been occasionally a widening of the,
- 18:34of the income gap.
- 18:35And I mean,
- 18:35certainly that was true of the industrial revolution where there were a lot of factory workers who were bare,
- 18:39you know,
- 18:39on starvation wages,
- 18:41even as some in society really lived very well off the,
- 18:45the productivity gains of,
- 18:46of the industrial revolution.
- 18:48So I'm wondering,
- 18:49do you worry that the A I revolution could lead to even greater inequality?
- 18:54Yeah.
- 18:55II,
- 18:55I think that that's a very fair concern and it's,
- 18:57it's probably the,
- 18:58the,
- 18:58the,
- 18:58the biggest thing in,
- 19:00in the next several years that,
- 19:01that we would be concerned about and,
- 19:03and,
- 19:03and some in terms of something that could actually threaten the,
- 19:06the uh the strength of,
- 19:07of economies globally and,
- 19:09and,
- 19:09and societies and the individuals in them.
- 19:12Uh You know,
- 19:12you mentioned the industrial revolution that has certainly been true of that growing inequality over the last few decades,
- 19:18that you've had a lot of economic growth,
- 19:20but it really hasn't accrued to the,
- 19:22to the masses.
- 19:23And ultimately,
- 19:24the,
- 19:24the same could be true for artificial intelligence.
- 19:27Uh Just kind of thinking about this maybe a little bit conceptually here,
- 19:31if you have a robot taking a human job,
- 19:34um that,
- 19:35that uh that robot is going to earn those wages that,
- 19:38that the human was,
- 19:39was uh was earning before,
- 19:41except those wages are accruing to capital,
- 19:43right?
- 19:44That someone owns the,
- 19:45the robot at the end of the day.
- 19:46So ultimately,
- 19:48we would think that that probably A I and,
- 19:51and automation in general is probably more attractive to,
- 19:54to capital holders than it is to labor overall.
- 19:57Um The,
- 19:58the other thing to consider maybe is,
- 20:00is that,
- 20:00that the the jobs that are,
- 20:02maybe the,
- 20:02the most exposed tend to be a little bit more,
- 20:04more middle class,
- 20:05kind of like paralegals if you will.
- 20:07And,
- 20:07and,
- 20:08and so you might have more of a hollowing out and,
- 20:10and,
- 20:11you know,
- 20:11sorting people into to more extremes,
- 20:13uh,
- 20:13on,
- 20:14on the,
- 20:14the low and the,
- 20:15and the high side.
- 20:16Um,
- 20:17the last thing I'd add here,
- 20:18David is,
- 20:18is just that,
- 20:18that as we transition to the,
- 20:21the this new world and,
- 20:22and,
- 20:22and um and a as there's potentially an excess supply of labor in,
- 20:27in certain sectors that,
- 20:28that could put kind of downward eli downward pressure on the equilibrium wages in those sectors.
- 20:35I will say that there might be some countervailing forces when it comes to A I in particular,
- 20:39I mean,
- 20:39I think the long,
- 20:41you know,
- 20:41era of computerization definitely led to this hollowing out of the middle.
- 20:45But what's unique about A I is that it could potentially like lend expertise to those novice or less skilled workers um that they haven't,
- 20:53you know,
- 20:54gone through the lived experience or gained the credentials to attain those.
- 20:58And it can make,
- 20:59you know,
- 20:59it can actually empower that,
- 21:01that,
- 21:02you know,
- 21:02cohort of workers to provide,
- 21:05you know,
- 21:05better services drive rate or value add.
- 21:07So for example,
- 21:08if you had a junior analyst that wanted to pitch a new,
- 21:11you know,
- 21:11digital app or interface for their company,
- 21:14right,
- 21:14you'd first need to hire a really expensive computer programmer to write the code for you and an expensive graphic designer.
- 21:20Now,
- 21:21like Google already has as a service where you can kind of,
- 21:24you keep all of the customization tools to build out an app yourself.
- 21:28And so now that,
- 21:29you know,
- 21:29analyst is actually empowered to,
- 21:32to,
- 21:32to do a lot more than,
- 21:34than it could have before,
- 21:35maybe could do it for those skills and such.
- 21:37So,
- 21:37so,
- 21:37so it makes tech,
- 21:38you know,
- 21:39the power of tech accessible to those who really are pretty non techie.
- 21:42Yeah,
- 21:42it actually feels really good to me.
- 21:44When I,
- 21:45when I applied for this job,
- 21:46there was a Python assessment.
- 21:47So maybe we don't have that,
- 21:51maybe I'll skip Python altogether.
- 21:54So,
- 21:55but there are other downs,
- 21:56you know,
- 21:56more nefarious outcomes from A I do.
- 21:59Do you worry a little bit about some of the more doomsday how it comes from A I?
- 22:04Yeah,
- 22:04I,
- 22:04I think that that's,
- 22:05that's a long way off in terms of,
- 22:07of maybe A I being able to take all of our jobs or,
- 22:10or,
- 22:10or resulting in some kind of terminator situation where it gains,
- 22:14you know,
- 22:14free will and consciousness and all of that.
- 22:17Uh I think in the near term,
- 22:18you know,
- 22:19going back to the,
- 22:20the for thinking about the downsides here,
- 22:22going back to the,
- 22:23the point about inequality that that's probably the,
- 22:25the biggest one that,
- 22:26that we're,
- 22:27we're really focused on.
- 22:28Um we,
- 22:29we think that,
- 22:30that uh progressive automation is,
- 22:32is going to,
- 22:32to gradually erode the the ability of people to,
- 22:37to find uh jobs that pay well.
- 22:40And,
- 22:41and uh for that,
- 22:42uh I think governments have,
- 22:44have a big role to play,
- 22:45right,
- 22:45in terms of kind of,
- 22:47first of all,
- 22:48very actively redistributing some of,
- 22:50of the the income shares.
- 22:52It sounds like people have to be pretty flexible themselves in,
- 22:56in just understanding how technology is changing the,
- 23:00you know,
- 23:00the workplace landscape and adapting to it.
- 23:03Yeah,
- 23:03I think that's the other main risk.
- 23:05I mean,
- 23:05I think I kind of talked about maybe a more sanguine outcome,
- 23:09right?
- 23:09For labor,
- 23:10but the risk is that this is just happening so fast that it doesn't give labor time to adjust.
- 23:15So I think the potential for,
- 23:18you know,
- 23:18large frictional unemployment is very real and there's a lot of questions that we have to answer to as a society,
- 23:24right?
- 23:24Is,
- 23:25you know,
- 23:26now that we're kind of automate a lot of the routine tasks that a lot of workers,
- 23:29you know,
- 23:30only know they've only been doing that for years.
- 23:32Um Can everyone be a great problem solver?
- 23:35Um How do we kind of train people for that or are we teaching that in classrooms?
- 23:40So these are all kind of big questions um that I think the speed at which this this technology is taking off uh really makes more urgent for business leaders and governments to address and maybe just picking up on,
- 23:52on that,
- 23:53that last point,
- 23:53I think this is,
- 23:54this is the first time in,
- 23:56in at least a,
- 23:57a few decades where it,
- 23:59it's,
- 24:00it's hard to imagine what the most popular jobs of the next 10,
- 24:0310,
- 24:0415 years are gonna be.
- 24:05Is it makes our long-term capital market forecasting a very,
- 24:08very difficult process.
- 24:10I mean,
- 24:10you,
- 24:10you mentioned uh coding and,
- 24:12and,
- 24:12and so forth and,
- 24:13and it,
- 24:13it's,
- 24:13it's hard to know is the world of tomorrow?
- 24:15Is that gonna be one where we need more coders to help with all this,
- 24:18this A I or is that something that A I can do on its own?
- 24:21And,
- 24:21and you don't need those coders or is the job of coding just going to be something completely different?
- 24:26So I I think what if there's maybe one takeaway from all this is the importance of,
- 24:30of flexibility and people's being adaptable to new environments and also being,
- 24:35being uh you know,
- 24:36very active from,
- 24:37from a society perspective of retraining people.
- 24:39And,
- 24:40and yeah,
- 24:40and policymakers also have to have a very clear eye and clear view of what A I is doing doing to the society and to the economy.
- 24:47Um Well,
- 24:48listen,
- 24:48thank you so much,
- 24:49Mike and Stephanie.
- 24:50This is,
- 24:50this has been fascinating and thank you all for tuning in.
- 24:53Our team will be hosting webcasts and producing more A I content in the coming weeks,
- 24:57you can find links and additional information in the description box below the next episode of the Market Movers series.
- 25:03Uh We'll discuss the demographic shifts of this decade that are shaping the investment environment with my colleague,
- 25:09Jack Ma.
- 25:10Until next time,
- 25:11thank you all for tuning in.
- 25:15This content is intended for information only based on assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change.
- 25:21No warranty of accuracy is given this content does not contain sufficient information to support investment decisions.
- 25:27It is not to be construed as research,
- 25:29legal regulatory tax accounting or investment advice,
- 25:33investments involve risks.
- 25:35Investors should seek professional advice or make an independent evaluation before investing the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate including loss of capital,
- 25:44past performance and yield are not indicative of current or future results forecasts and estimates may or may not come to pass.
- 25:51Jpmorgan Asset Management is the asset management business of JP Morgan Chase and company and its affiliates worldwide.