Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / CANCELLED!
Transcript
- 0:01The sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to My Sister's a Therapist and Nearly said My
- 0:13Sister's a therapist.com. That's where you can find out
- 0:15more about the podcast My Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:18You're just pretty welcoming people to our podcast and our
- 0:21website, yes. My name is Virginia Jones.
- 0:24I am a Co host. My sister Laura Ryan is also a
- 0:27Co host and she's a therapist. Hello, I'm Laura Ryan, licensed
- 0:31marriage and family therapist, but my sister is punchline
- 0:35prodigy Virginia Jones, and that's also my main credit
- 0:40hashtag. Punchline Prodigy, I understand
- 0:42that we have a listener topic this week.
- 0:44Laura, what are we talking about?
- 0:46Today's topic is cancel culture. Oh.
- 0:49That is interesting. It is an interesting one and
- 0:51this is a personal story from our listener, Kay.
- 0:55Hello Kay, and thank you for your contribution.
- 0:57It really does mean a lot. Anyone who's listening, if you
- 1:00want to contribute to our show, we love the feedback as long as
- 1:04it's positive. Drop us a line at
- 1:06hellomysisters@therapist.com. Hey guys, I love this pod so
- 1:11much. I love seeing y'all kick butt on
- 1:13the ratings and downloads. It's so helpful and funny.
- 1:16I would love to hear your thoughts on publicly shaming
- 1:18people, bullying, and maybe even cancel culture in general.
- 1:21I just read the book So you've been publicly shamed by Jon
- 1:24Ronson. I read this after I got cyber
- 1:26bullied myself and I'm still getting my confidence back from
- 1:29it all. Thanks for being such awesome,
- 1:31insightful people. These pods help me with my own
- 1:33therapy session sometimes so I thought why not.
- 1:36It makes me happy to hear two sisters to get along so well.
- 1:38I love y'all's energy and laugh and it really keeps me going
- 1:41even through this insanely hard rough patch.
- 1:43You guys are doing something really cool and authentic.
- 1:45First of all, Kay, I'm so sorry this happened to you.
- 1:47But secondly, you're welcome for the free therapy.
- 1:50That is something that Laura offers.
- 1:52I had the feedback from other people that they wish that their
- 1:55relationships with their sister were like our relationship and
- 1:58if I didn't have this, I'd want it to.
- 1:59In the words of Maui from the film Moana, you're welcome.
- 2:03So Kay said I had a friend's ex-boyfriend reach out when they
- 2:06were breaking up and he was kicking her out and needed me to
- 2:09quote just get her. And when I told him he needs to
- 2:12work it out with her amicably and give her a minute to move
- 2:15out he shamed me. So I made a joke about him on my
- 2:18IG story. I cropped his name out and he
- 2:20had called me AC list comedian at best lol.
- 2:24So I said I will be giving you my best C list material tonight
- 2:27at this show. And because I did that he went
- 2:30and dug up posts from when I was in high school that had slurs in
- 2:33them. Which is like still bad on my
- 2:35end, but it was 16 years ago and I was 16 years old and then all
- 2:39these male comedians that already hate me saw it and
- 2:42reposted it and honestly it was a horrible experience.
- 2:45I owned it and apologized for my ignorance at that time.
- 2:47But I still had a really hard time and it was a week before my
- 2:50album came out. I had to do a Wellness check and
- 2:53everything. As I'm writing this, I know as
- 2:55I'm writing this I'm thinking what if they get this e-mail and
- 2:57they're like uh oh, Kay is cancelled.
- 2:59Well. Well, I'm stoked to be able to
- 3:03cancel you on an international stage.
- 3:06We have at least one listener in every European country.
- 3:10And Australia, we're very big in Australia.
- 3:12You basically can't go there anymore.
- 3:14Like Tenacious D, we're big in Australia.
- 3:18Virginia, have you ever been cancelled?
- 3:20I don't think that I've been cancelled.
- 3:21Like I don't think that there's been a campaign, but I've
- 3:24definitely seen it happen to others.
- 3:25I've had moments where something I have said has been not very
- 3:30popular and people have had feelings about it.
- 3:33Usually what happens is this, I spout off about a male comic
- 3:37being in some way crummy, and then they circle the wagons and
- 3:41I get in trouble. And then years later people
- 3:43actually come back to me and go, you know, you were right about
- 3:45that. That's what I mostly get in
- 3:47trouble for. That sounds like a bummer.
- 3:49I've never been officially canceled because I'm not famous
- 3:52at all, but I guess my version of being cancelled is people
- 3:55writing nasty things about me on Yelp.
- 3:58And that's hurtful. And it's hurtful and it brings
- 4:01my ratings down and it stinks because I also feel like I can't
- 4:05really do anything about it because I'm a therapist.
- 4:08I can't actually defend myself. It's not like being a plumber or
- 4:11you can say, look, I plumbed the plumbing.
- 4:13The plumbing was plumbed. Right.
- 4:15I can't talk about the specifics of our relationship.
- 4:18I can't even acknowledge that we have a relationship.
- 4:20It's very tricky. I I remember I had a Yelp review
- 4:22for a long time from a lady who I'd never met.
- 4:25I was out of town when she was trying to reach me and she
- 4:27didn't like my answering service so I did reply to her.
- 4:30And said sorry I we never met. I'm sorry you didn't like the
- 4:33way they took your message. But I have one former client who
- 4:37really has a problem with me and has reported me to my board
- 4:41twice and has now written a nasty review.
- 4:43And the feeling that I get is I just feel powerless and I feel
- 4:48misunderstood and I feel this story is absolutely 1 sided and
- 4:53I really can't do anything about it.
- 4:55Since I've been in this biz for a minute.
- 4:57I've gotten better at handling it when it happens, but it's
- 5:01terrifying I guess is the word I would use.
- 5:03Well, a disadvantage that you have specifically as a therapist
- 5:06is that most of your clients have some sort of mental
- 5:11unwellness. That's why they're seeing you.
- 5:13And so you are specifically dealing with a section of the
- 5:16population that is likely to act out Ryan Nasty Yelp review
- 5:20attack you publicly. And you have a much bigger
- 5:22percentage than you would if you were, say, a hairdresser or
- 5:25worked in a tire shop. And I think the other piece is
- 5:28that folks who are trying to find out more about me who don't
- 5:31know me, if you get a bad haircut, you can kind of take
- 5:34your chances of bad haircut. But having a really, really bad,
- 5:37scary, manipulative monster of a therapist, that's a huge risk.
- 5:41So it's just so much worse, I think, for my profession than
- 5:45maybe others. And that carries through to
- 5:47stand up comedy as well. We are not the most mentally
- 5:51well people on earth. And we did a whole podcast about
- 5:53it. And men in comedy can really be
- 5:56hot garbage the way they can circle their wagons because
- 5:58they've made the assessment that we don't belong there.
- 6:00Refer to the Imposter Syndrome episode.
- 6:03They will stick together. I've definitely been shamed and
- 6:05manipulated by men in comedy. So you're supporting your former
- 6:09assessment that male comics shouldn't be dated?
- 6:12With very, very few exceptions, if you are thinking about dating
- 6:15a male comic, write me at hello@mysisterstherapist.com.
- 6:19Let me know who they are. Let me make a call.
- 6:21I'll make it. Do you ever wonder where the
- 6:24term cancel comes from? Let me know.
- 6:26Well, let me tell you. According to Madeleine Lo Booth
- 6:30in Vice Australia, the lyrics of Sheik's song Your Love is
- 6:34canceled off. Their 1981 album Take It Off is
- 6:36a sparse track punctuated by slap bass in an undeniable 80s
- 6:41flute synth, where Nile Rogers sings the titular phrase and
- 6:45gives birth to the metaphor that would culturally peak years
- 6:48later. Now, Rogers and Chic have
- 6:51affected our culture in more ways than you can shake a potato
- 6:55at. More ways than 15.
- 6:57Then it was in New Jack City. One of the characters was saying
- 7:01that he was going to cancel his girlfriend.
- 7:03It's just evolved from there. Here's some examples of people
- 7:06who have quote UN quote been cancelled in our culture.
- 7:08After decades of essay allegations, Hashtag mute R
- 7:12Kelly led to a successful financial boycott of the now
- 7:15convicted musician, who was handed a 20 year prison sentence
- 7:18for child stuff earlier this year.
- 7:21But also there is that documentary.
- 7:22Like it wasn't just a Twitter phenomenon.
- 7:25But I think it may have started with the Twitter stuff and then
- 7:28that led to the the documentary and LED to all the things that
- 7:31have happened ever since. So other examples of quote UN
- 7:34quote cancel people are Woody Allen, Louis CK, Kevin Spacey.
- 7:39They've been cancelled by various groups over abuse
- 7:42allegations. This is my main problem with the
- 7:45idea of cancellation. When we started saying cancelled
- 7:48and we started talking about hashtag me too and all of the
- 7:51sexual abuses that famous men had been getting away with for
- 7:54decades, it was kind of like regular people became judge and
- 7:58jury. There was no justice in the
- 7:59court. Courts, some of these things, no
- 8:00one had ever decided how to take them to trial.
- 8:03In Woody Allen's case, his wife, who is his daughter, wasn't
- 8:07taken to court stepdaughter. So there's no way for the courts
- 8:10to get involved really. It's just that he's taking
- 8:12advantage of a power differential that is gross.
- 8:15I think that everyone can make the case that you didn't just
- 8:18wake up on your stepdaughter's 18th birthday, say, oh.
- 8:22No, I find her attractive. Exactly, to me, based on other
- 8:26stuff that's happened to him, I'm guessing that there was
- 8:28childhood essay for a long time. He's still not cancelled.
- 8:32He's still not cancelled because he's still working.
- 8:33Louis CK is not cancelled. His clients just changed.
- 8:37He was no longer A list, but he's never gone below B list.
- 8:42He still has a career, it's just that his audience is a little
- 8:45more right wing. Not friends to women, right?
- 8:47Because I think a lot of his shtick was like, oh, you know, I
- 8:51love women, I respect women, I care about women.
- 8:53But then his actions showed otherwise.
- 8:55I think that that was why that one stung, especially for women
- 8:59in comedy. There'd been rumors around him
- 9:01for a long time. The version that I heard years
- 9:04and years ago was that his kink was touching himself in front of
- 9:08women and it was his way of having a sexual activity that he
- 9:11didn't consider to be unfaithful to his wife.
- 9:13That of course oversteps the the fact that there was not
- 9:16consensual for the women. It adds a different layer when
- 9:19there's no consent involved. I've been hearing stuff about
- 9:22it, but yes, because he was like this feminist hate for that word
- 9:26to come out of my mouth in connection with him because he'd
- 9:29always, always talk about how great women were.
- 9:31It was especially hurtful. But he's not cancelled.
- 9:33He's still working the improv. He lost distribution of a movie.
- 9:37He definitely had losses, but his career still happens.
- 9:40Kevin Spacey's career has come back.
- 9:42He's not where he was. But they're not cancelled.
- 9:45And there's a naivete or optimism of people thinking that
- 9:49because of their opinion about someone, they can just stop
- 9:51existing. You keep living even after
- 9:54you've been cancelled, right? And Madeleine Labouf says
- 9:57without being held accountable, is some really ever cancel?
- 10:01Yeah, my argument about cancel culture currently is that it's
- 10:04not fair, it's not equal. Extremely famous people will get
- 10:09away with things for years and years and years.
- 10:11Ella Ashton Kutcher, Why has everyone forgotten about that?
- 10:15Like, he's all good again? And Mila Kunis, they're both
- 10:18just like, OK. People at me and Kay's level
- 10:21will get cancelled by their local scene for relatively small
- 10:25things. When you go to trial, you get a
- 10:27sentence, You perform that sentence.
- 10:29You've paid your debt. When you're just cancelled
- 10:32because people say you did something crummy.
- 10:34There is no opportunity for redemption.
- 10:37Exactly why do we cancel people? So here are some of the reasons
- 10:41that people cancel. This is from the article by
- 10:44Lindy Toller, The Mental Effects of Cancel Culture.
- 10:47Some of the top reasons cited for cancelling include serving
- 10:50as a teaching moment to get the person to consider the
- 10:53consequences of their statements, to expose racism or
- 10:56sexism, to get people to think before they speak, to hold
- 10:59someone accountable for their statements or behaviors.
- 11:02I think the intent is good. Yes, I want people to understand
- 11:07that this was a bad move. You made an error of judgement
- 11:10and so let's try to course correct.
- 11:12But also, if I wrote some questionable tweets 20 years ago
- 11:18and that's not even my life anymore, how am I supposed to
- 11:21fix that? After you've apologized, there's
- 11:23nothing else to do. I mean, you can apologize and
- 11:26then also show that you are not doing things like that anymore.
- 11:31What Louis CK did was he said I'm going to think about this
- 11:34for a long time. And he's still thinking about
- 11:37it. Sit back and listen.
- 11:38He was quiet for nine months and then he just came back and
- 11:40turned the machine that is his career back on.
- 11:43There's no evidence that he went to therapy, that he did
- 11:46restitution for any of the women he'd abused.
- 11:49He's like, well, that's that. When I say it's unfair, I mean,
- 11:52there's also this segment of population that is not famous
- 11:55enough to truly be canceled. So you've got the ground level
- 11:58council where it's that I know and you know, and everybody we
- 12:01know knows and we all just say that guy's out, we're not going
- 12:05to talk to him anymore. And they can be.
- 12:06I mean, that person can be canceled their career and
- 12:09whatever The thing is will be over at that.
- 12:11Point. And then there's super
- 12:13celebrities, a couple people come forward with allegations
- 12:16and they slip off Chris D'elia's had capital R allegations
- 12:21against him for years and just keeps on working.
- 12:24So my attitude has has wound up being when people have come to
- 12:27me with we have to stop booking this guy, talking to this guy,
- 12:31whatever. If nothing has happened to
- 12:33people who are out and out sexual assaulters, I don't have
- 12:36the power to do anything on my level.
- 12:37I'll do what I want to do. But if there were no
- 12:40repercussions for Louis CK, how can there be any repercussions
- 12:43for this person? After a couple years not working
- 12:46in LA comedy, the improv comedy club brought Louis CK back.
- 12:50Me and a couple people did a protest across the street.
- 12:53The shows had sold out. It didn't affect anybody who was
- 12:56going in. It was just crazy making that
- 12:59this institution had let him back in because when the word
- 13:03first came out about Louis, they took his portrait off the wall.
- 13:05But then two years later, we're just like going along as if
- 13:07nothing happened. And it was really aggravating
- 13:09because it sold out. The word on the street was, Oh
- 13:12well, people are over it. Like the people have spoken.
- 13:15If there's a market for this comedy, we're going to have it.
- 13:19Well, I think it's the the people have forgotten because I
- 13:21also feel like in the culture we live in, there's so much
- 13:25information coming all the time. Even if you just look at trends
- 13:29on TikTok, every week it's a new thing and you just the rest kind
- 13:32of goes out the window. A comic out of Seattle, Jeff
- 13:35Dye, who used to be kind of an ineffectual pretty boy comic.
- 13:39He wore a lot of American an apparel low V T-shirts and had a
- 13:44an OK act. That was what he traded on,
- 13:45unfortunately. Did he shave his chest?
- 13:47That's what I want to know. Now he's become a button pusher
- 13:51alt righty guy. He's got a great joke about how
- 13:55Kamala Harris is Jamaican because he says Jamaican.
- 13:58Me Republican. Wow.
- 14:00We were talking about him in my lady chat and he had a drunk
- 14:03driving hit and run that's just been forgotten.
- 14:06That joke is so old. Jamaican Me Crazy was a T-shirt
- 14:10that my dad bought for me in 1994 coming.
- 14:14All of his jokes are awful except for the one he stole from
- 14:17Laurie Kilmartin. Something happens, you say, Oh
- 14:19my gosh, that person's a piece of crap.
- 14:21But then fifty other people there's a story about there's a
- 14:24royal wedding and a celebrity dies and you have to find out
- 14:27what the bass player from a proto punk band died from.
- 14:31It just gets lost in the mix. I don't think our brains have
- 14:33the capacity to hold on to everybody who's cancelled.
- 14:36No, I remember that thing, he said.
- 14:38How much information does a medieval peasant take in?
- 14:41Right. If you get a Sunday edition of
- 14:42the New York Times, the information in that newspaper is
- 14:46more than a medieval peasant would have learned their entire
- 14:49life. That's more literature, that's
- 14:51more data than that person would have come across their entire
- 14:54life and don't have the brains to take it in.
- 14:57Hello when I log in in the morning I'm getting that amount
- 15:00of information in about 30 seconds.
- 15:02We're not equipped to put up with it, and that's why cancel
- 15:05culture is kind of bogus, because we're not able to be
- 15:08consistent with it. We're not able to apply it even
- 15:11and we forget about it anyway. I'm going to thank Kay ahead of
- 15:14time because she reminded me about the book So You've Been
- 15:17Publicly Shamed by Jon Ronson, which I have but have never
- 15:20cracked. So she's given me an opportunity
- 15:22to look at this book that I have not read.
- 15:24So here's some quotes. We know that people are
- 15:26complicated and have a mixture of flaws and talents and sins.
- 15:30So why do we pretend that we don't?
- 15:32I think that part of the reason we love to cancel people, it
- 15:36makes us feel better about the things that we've done, and it
- 15:38makes us forget that we've done things that we're not proud of.
- 15:41The treatment of people as if they are all good or all bad is
- 15:45childish. Well, there's no nuance because
- 15:47people are complicated. I try to say this a lot when I'm
- 15:51working with couples. Neither one of you is right.
- 15:53You were both wrong for different reasons.
- 15:56You both made a lot of errors of judgment.
- 15:59I remember a friend of mine was talking about how she had this
- 16:03revelation that her entire marriage she'd been keeping this
- 16:07little tick boxes and she put a tick every time he made a
- 16:10mistake big, but she was not giving herself the.
- 16:14Same. And I was in that marriage and
- 16:16I, I just listened to a Mark Manson book about relationships.
- 16:20And he said, when you're in this kind of toxic relationship where
- 16:22you're each trying to prove who's the better partner, you
- 16:25have to look at what the driving force is because you can't win
- 16:29at being a good partner. Because if I'm keeping score,
- 16:32that means I'm not considering a big part of the pie.
- 16:36I do feel like it is a natural sentiment to say, well,
- 16:39everybody has to reach the standard.
- 16:42Even if I don't, especially if you make money off of being
- 16:45famous, you definitely have to reach this level of standard.
- 16:48When Kay was talking about going back 16 years, I shudder to
- 16:52think. I can't imagine if I had 16 year
- 16:55old stuff. I have no idea.
- 16:56I was thinking about that this morning.
- 16:58I used to have a pair of shorts that I thought were Dukes of
- 17:02Hazzard shorts, but it turned out that they were the Dixie
- 17:06flag. Somebody saw those today that
- 17:08wouldn't. Go over.
- 17:09Well, this is hard, Laura, because I have to cancel you
- 17:12today. There's not much to cancel.
- 17:14You're gonna have to stand in line.
- 17:16That Lady who keeps reporting me to the board?
- 17:19This comes up in comedy a lot. Someone will get in trouble for
- 17:22this or that, and then someone will find like a 20 year old bit
- 17:24and say, oh, and they were using this word.
- 17:27Yeah, everyone was all of friends was one big gay joke.
- 17:30Culture is progressing. We cannot judge comedy of the
- 17:34past with the morals of today. Comedy is the first thing to
- 17:38change because it's always right up against the edge of what is
- 17:41acceptable. And in 1989, it was not common
- 17:44knowledge that the Dixie flag was a sign of racism in the
- 17:48South. I did not know that it wasn't.
- 17:50Common for suburban white girls. Of course, yes, OK, it was
- 17:54common knowledge to many, many subgroups, but not the one that
- 17:58I'm going to. No one was coming up to you and
- 18:01saying don't you think your shorts are offensive?
- 18:04This is how I found out this was actually quite terrible.
- 18:06I had a friend who was kind of a punk rock girl, and she asked me
- 18:10if she could borrow them. And I said sure.
- 18:13And she's like, yeah, they're, they're so cool.
- 18:16And this is when I realized, oh, this woman has turned into the
- 18:19white supremacy track of of the skinheads.
- 18:23There were the non racist skinheads and there were the
- 18:25racist skinheads. Where?
- 18:27There's the working class British influence skinheads, and
- 18:30then there's the skinheads that were created into a white power
- 18:33movement in America. So I lent her these shorts, not
- 18:36realizing anything was going on. And then later I backtracked and
- 18:39I was like, oh, that is a racist symbol.
- 18:43That's why she wanted to borrow. Oops, I never got them back.
- 18:47If anyone's wondering. Don't cancel me.
- 18:49Did you want that? No, not after I found out.
- 18:51I remember her saying where did you get those?
- 18:53And I told her I got them at Moda and they were in the sale
- 18:56pile. I said they're funny.
- 18:58You know, it's like the Dukes of Hazzard.
- 18:59I love that show when I was a kid.
- 19:00Which also is extremely SUS. Yep, as I review it as an adult
- 19:05again, I was 13 years old. I didn't have the knowledge that
- 19:08I have now. If the Internet existed I would
- 19:11be in deep Doo Doo JK. Rowling for example, she has
- 19:14been cancelled more times than you had hot dinners, but it
- 19:17doesn't matter. None of her books have gone out
- 19:19of publication. Nothing has changed in her
- 19:22career, it's just the bunch of people are mad at her.
- 19:25Just yesterday I met a woman who was telling me about this
- 19:28incredible book series, and she gave me the name of the person.
- 19:32And I looked it up and I was like, oh, this is a pseudonym
- 19:35for JK Rowling, so she's still making money hand over fist.
- 19:39This week she finally had legal proceedings against her where
- 19:43she has to for a second. Stop tweeting the most awful
- 19:47transphobic stuff you've ever read.
- 19:48Nothing was going to stop her before that.
- 19:51Now she's very mad about Olympic boxing.
- 19:55It's amazing the amount of attention people will pay to
- 19:58women's sports. In order to be transphobic, who
- 20:02never really followed women's sports before and talk about
- 20:05time. Yeah, I said some things that I
- 20:08did not realize were transphobic in my comedy 15 years ago
- 20:12because I was a baby and I didn't know very much about it.
- 20:15One of the great gifts of comedy for me has been knowing trans
- 20:19women comics and learning about that perspective.
- 20:22It's incredibly helpful. The story I make up is that as a
- 20:26person what I try to do is I ask myself do I need to say anything
- 20:31right And what I find is 99% of the time I don't.
- 20:35And as white women, I think we've both developed a little
- 20:37voice in the back of my head that says, is this something you
- 20:40should be talking about? The only people who I've known
- 20:43in the public eye who've been truly cancelled are people who
- 20:47had a pretty low level comparatively career.
- 20:50Like JK Rowling is probably too famous to really be cancelled,
- 20:54but Graham Lineman, the guy who wrote the IT Crowd and other
- 20:59popular British comedies? He's been ousted from the
- 21:01industry for being super transphobic and for doubling
- 21:05down and doubling down and doubling down.
- 21:08And again, it's terrible because I like some of the things he's
- 21:10done. Yeah, IT crowd is great.
- 21:12Here are some other quotes from Jon Ronson.
- 21:14A life has been ruined. What was it for?
- 21:16Just some social media drama. I think our natural disposition
- 21:19as humans is to plod along until we get old and stop.
- 21:23But with social media, we've created a stage for constant
- 21:26artificial high drama. Every day, a new person emerges
- 21:30as a magnificent hero or a sickening villain.
- 21:33It's all very sweet and not the way we actually are as people.
- 21:37Ultimately what I've decided about this person, that person
- 21:40being cancelled, is it has to come down to the individual.
- 21:42Like I cannot say what you should do.
- 21:45There's musicians that I cannot enjoy their music because of
- 21:48what I know about them, like Michael Jackson.
- 21:50Everyone has forgotten about Michael Jackson because he has
- 21:53done the very smart thing of being dead.
- 21:55I think in many crowds it's dead and cancelled.
- 21:58Yeah, many. Crowds he is not.
- 22:00People talk about him with no rancor with is it just a trial?
- 22:04Didn't happen. It's very weird.
- 22:05It makes you feel crazy. PYT came on the radio the other
- 22:08day and that's like my favorite Michael Jackson song.
- 22:10And so I'm listening to it and I'm excited.
- 22:12And then I start thinking about stuff that I heard in the
- 22:15documentary and I had to turn it off.
- 22:16So it comes down to there's things that I cannot enjoy
- 22:20because I know that the artist did something terrible.
- 22:22If they are dead, I find it easier to do.
- 22:26Me listening to a dead person's music is not putting any money
- 22:29in their pocket ever. If anything it's for their
- 22:31estate, which is OK with me. He had kids, so I want his kids
- 22:35to have money. The artist Chuck close was super
- 22:38cancelled. Now that he's dead, can we look
- 22:41at his art again? I don't know that you can
- 22:43separate the art from the artist.
- 22:45Well, that's another great question.
- 22:47I saw something the other day about visual art that basically
- 22:50said we can't cancel people anymore because there will be no
- 22:56art left because every famous male artist, even if he didn't
- 23:00throw his wife out a window, Carl Andre has done something
- 23:03awful. Pablo Picasso.
- 23:05Salvador Dali loved fascism. Under your breath, muttering
- 23:09horrible things. You know it.
- 23:12We can't pretend to be in a world where these things do not
- 23:15influence us, where these artists did not pave the way and
- 23:18lead to other artists. You can't just excise them from
- 23:21the culture. Egon Sheely was a slut.
- 23:23Egon Sheely was a straight up essayer and Pederas, Oh yes,
- 23:28we're we're doxing. I'm cancelling a man who's been
- 23:32dead for 1930 or something. He was my entire thesis project
- 23:37for my my junior year. He had to keep moving his studio
- 23:41because every time he started a painting studio, runaways and
- 23:46underage sex workers started just hanging out and modeling.
- 23:50And then there'd be allegations and then he would pick up and go
- 23:52like, oh, I have to go to another place.
- 23:55I knew he moved around a lot. I just thought he liked.
- 23:58I thought it was because it was a bipolar disorder.
- 24:00But there's a whole lot suss about Igon Sheila.
- 24:02There's a whole lot suss about Paul Gauguin.
- 24:05Nobody's hands are clean in history.
- 24:08Everybody's just got to make up their own mind.
- 24:10Like I can't listen to the Swans anymore because.
- 24:13Don't tell me why I'm still listening to.
- 24:16Them well, I'll tell you later, but that's my decision.
- 24:19But also someone who's a big influence on my life who've I've
- 24:22always bought everything they've ever done.
- 24:24Neil Gaiman is at allegations and God bless.
- 24:28He did the exact wrong thing and he said Oh no, I've never done
- 24:32anything wrong and and those women are lying.
- 24:34So I have to reckon with myself like can I enjoy this writing
- 24:39knowing that he has crossed the line of consensuality and I
- 24:43personally can't. I got bored one day and I was
- 24:45looking to see how many US presidents have allegations.
- 24:49Oh God, and it's a lot. It's not all of them, but it's a
- 24:53lot. What Jon Ronson says is we've
- 24:55created a culture where people feel constantly surveilled,
- 24:58where people are afraid to be themselves.
- 25:00We've created a world where the smartest way to survive is to be
- 25:03bland. Why do people do it?
- 25:05The positive impacts of cancel culture Cancel culture can help
- 25:09combat wrongdoings and address inequalities.
- 25:12In 2016, for example, many members of the film community
- 25:15boycotted the Oscars because of the lack of diversity among
- 25:18nominees. This helped promote social
- 25:20change, and in 2019, the Oscars set a record for the most
- 25:23nominations for Black directors ever.
- 25:25The community that unites for a common cause can be empowering.
- 25:28It can also make people think twice before behaving
- 25:31inappropriately or posting potentially offensive thoughts
- 25:34and opinions. That goes out to you, JK
- 25:36Rowling. So we're going to talk about
- 25:38shame because I think a lot of what we're trying to do when we
- 25:41quote, UN quote, cancel people is we're trying to make them
- 25:44feel ashamed. What are the evolutionary roots
- 25:48of shame? Shame has likely played a part
- 25:50in long term survival for our species and other species.
- 25:53Shame makes people behave in ways that allow them to coexist
- 25:57with others and it makes people adhere to cultural norms and
- 26:00laws. I think what we're trying to do
- 26:02is what we used to do by putting people in the stocks for the
- 26:05day. Jerry did some stuff.
- 26:08We put him in the. Stocks.
- 26:09We put a sign on his back letting everybody know what he
- 26:12did. And then after a week, he was
- 26:15back in society. If we don't have those stocks,
- 26:18there is no way for retribution. The idea that someone can just
- 26:22stop existing. They lost their job, they'll
- 26:25never get another job. They'll never be married again.
- 26:27They'll never have friends again.
- 26:28That's childish. People do continue to live.
- 26:31Well, that's the thing. You don't become stone dead the
- 26:34second somebody cancels you. Have you ever seen the Robbie
- 26:37Coltrane television series National Treasure?
- 26:40No. But tell me all about.
- 26:41It the plot is that a man who is a children's presenter and the
- 26:47national treasure has allegations put against him.
- 26:51One thing that I noticed is this man has still got to go to the
- 26:54bathroom every day. He still needs eggs in the
- 26:56morning. He still has to be alive.
- 26:59And he's trying to do it in the midst of all of this energy.
- 27:03Would that we could cancel someone to death, but that's
- 27:06that's not fair either and bringing up Robbie Coltrane,
- 27:09he's spent a lot of ink defending JK Rowling because JK
- 27:13Rowling did immense things for his career.
- 27:15That's the problem is none of this is in a vacuum.
- 27:18The host of At Midnight was cancelled after an ex-girlfriend
- 27:22came forward with some some grim allegations.
- 27:24I had friends in the comedy community who were trying to
- 27:27protect him or lobby for him because he gave them work.
- 27:30They got jobs through him. So it becomes very complicated
- 27:32very quickly. If this person has buttered your
- 27:35bread morning, noon and night for 30 years and you found out
- 27:38that he killed 1 underage prostitute, the temptation is to
- 27:42overlook. It I hear that.
- 27:44So what do you do when you've been cancelled?
- 27:47Carlo University asked counselors how to protect your
- 27:50mental health from cancel culture and found that the best
- 27:53solution is to unplug from social media, apologize, and
- 27:56refrain from posting online. When feeling emotional, consider
- 27:59the feelings of others and talk to others about your feelings.
- 28:03A gradual sense of acceptance and forgiveness should develop
- 28:05thereafter, and sooner rather than later, you'll be rid from
- 28:08the torturing dread that follows you.
- 28:10Hopefully. Well-being cancelled is such a
- 28:13commonplace everyday thing that there's there's PR firms where
- 28:16that's their whole gig is getting you on cancelled.
- 28:20There are steps to follow in Hollywood, Mel Gibson was 100%
- 28:24cancelled after saying just awful things.
- 28:27But he apologized, he groveled, he started taking extremely low
- 28:31level work and I feel like his name has kind of been cleaned
- 28:34now. He made a Christmas movie.
- 28:36Well, Hugh Grant, he immediately admitted to what he did.
- 28:40He didn't try to lie about it like Neil Gaiman, and he took
- 28:43responsibility for it. I feel like that goes a long
- 28:46way. So we see time and time again
- 28:48that people's reputations and livelihoods remain firmly intact
- 28:52even after their wrongdoings are exposed.
- 28:55People in groups can and often are called out, yet they remain
- 28:58protected by the structures of our society, like the
- 29:00patriarchy, enough to hold on to their high profile jobs or get
- 29:04booked for gigs. I saw commercial for a new Matt
- 29:08Damon Casey Affleck show. Do you remember what Casey
- 29:11Affleck did? No, he was sexually harassing
- 29:14his staff and this was a couple years ago.
- 29:17And now Casey Affleck gets a show because his brother is best
- 29:20friends with Matt Damon. That's The thing is it's not
- 29:22fair. None of it is fair.
- 29:24There's certain people, there's always allegations about them
- 29:27and nothing ever happens. They seem to be made of Teflon.
- 29:30Bill Cosby, it took years and years and years and years, and
- 29:33he has been released from prison because of problems with this
- 29:37trial. There is no justice in cancel
- 29:40culture. It gives us the fantasy that
- 29:42there is justice. It gives us the illusion that
- 29:45there is a street level justice that I can participate in.
- 29:48Two minimizes for me, things that I've done.
- 29:52When you're busy pointing the finger at somebody else, you can
- 29:55forget about stuff you've done you're not proud of.
- 29:57Well, you can miss the four fingers that are pointing back.
- 30:00Yeah, I think we don't want to be judge ourselves because we
- 30:02want to be on the right side of the mob.
- 30:04It's very tricky. Yes, and I think if you've been
- 30:07wrongly accused like me and probably Kay, it feels like
- 30:11everyone's given up on you before you've even had the
- 30:14chance to apologize, let alone change your behavior.
- 30:17And Kay wasn't wrongly accused, but she apologized and she said
- 30:20I wouldn't do it now. And that's all she can do.
- 30:23I guess my thought is when I say wrongly accused, it's not like
- 30:26she said it last night. It's not like she made a video
- 30:29elucidating all these points and doing all these things.
- 30:32I feel like somebody took the things she said out of context
- 30:35and wasn't considering a lot of details.
- 30:37But if you're cancelled, it feels like everyone's giving up
- 30:39on you. Instead of creating a dialogue
- 30:41to help you understand how your actions hurt others, oftentimes
- 30:44counselors just shut off all communication, essentially
- 30:47robbing you of an opportunity to learn and grow from mistakes.
- 30:50And I feel like to me that's the the problem because I am going
- 30:54to make mistakes. I'm going to make bad calls, I'm
- 30:57going to have bad judgement. I need to not have my entire
- 31:00life ruined by a casual comment that I made or a mistake that I
- 31:04made. Basically, unless you go to
- 31:06prison, showbiz will continue to employ you.
- 31:10If you're someone who's making money, you will have work.
- 31:13Charlie Chaplin. It doesn't matter what people
- 31:17say about you, what public opinion is, so long as you are
- 31:21street legal, you will keep working.
- 31:23So in that way, cancel culture is a fiction.
- 31:26It only applies to certain populations.
- 31:28And women are, guess what, much more cancellable than men.
- 31:31Ellen DeGeneres has been cancelled for being a bad boss
- 31:34and having a toxic atmosphere at work.
- 31:36When now rapist Kevin Spacey is making movies.
- 31:40Yes, Linda Zu talks about it. She's quoting Kimberly Wilson,
- 31:43the psychologist and author of How to Build a Healthy Brain.
- 31:46And she says cancel culture often denies the canceled
- 31:49individual the most basic of human opportunities to apologize
- 31:52and to be absolved, because the road to redemption is blocked by
- 31:56an indignant mob. So even if the mistake is not
- 31:59considered small, pitting what seems like an entire population
- 32:02against one person in a short span of time can destroy an
- 32:06individual's mental health. This is because it prevents them
- 32:08from believing that they can recover or fix their mistakes.
- 32:11The repercussions that males suffer from mistakes of similar
- 32:14even higher degrees are often lower than that of females.
- 32:17Yet it tends to be easier for males to recover from being
- 32:20cancelled than females. Kathy Griffin has been cancelled
- 32:23for years, has had her life threatened because of AI.
- 32:27Think great photograph she took and she didn't kill anybody with
- 32:32her car. She didn't do anything illegal.
- 32:34She just did something that some people considered to be in bad
- 32:36taste. Speaking of people who didn't
- 32:38understand what the Confederate flag was, a group that has been
- 32:41cancelled a lot is the Dixie Chicks, who are now just the
- 32:43Chicks. I heard that the other day.
- 32:47Oops. Cancel culture continues to
- 32:49affect women disproportionately, not only due to the longer
- 32:53recovery time to be forgiven for their mistakes, but also the
- 32:56sexism of facing larger repercussions for their actions
- 32:59than men. So how do we avoid being
- 33:01cancelled? I have some ideas.
- 33:03Avoid posting on the Internet when your emotions are
- 33:06heightened. Try not to post when you're
- 33:09feeling overly emotional. If someone says or does
- 33:11something that pushes your buttons, don't rush to your
- 33:13keyboard. Instead, take a few deep breaths
- 33:16and give yourself time to calm down.
- 33:18While you may forget what you said or wrote a day, week, or
- 33:21month from now, the Internet never forgets.
- 33:24I remember being in a relationship with a man.
- 33:26Always a mistake. Yeah, would often say horrible
- 33:29things while drunk and so when we were together I would stand
- 33:34behind him when he got near a keyboard and monitor what he was
- 33:39writing. Have others review your post
- 33:41first. Sometimes it's hard to recognize
- 33:44when your own words may come across as offensive or
- 33:46aggressive. Having someone else review your
- 33:48posts first can help bring any potential issues to your
- 33:51attention. This gives you the opportunity
- 33:53to avoid sharing thoughts or opinions that could
- 33:55inadvertently hurt someone else. If I have a hot take, I try to
- 33:59sit on it for a day or two before I share it.
- 34:02People who've been uncanceled. James Franco had an acting
- 34:05school that women just said was a tool for sexual abuse.
- 34:09He took four years off of acting and then came back.
- 34:12He said I did sleep with students and that was wrong.
- 34:15It didn't matter that he was hitting on a 17 year old
- 34:18Scottish girl. He just took a little time off
- 34:20of work, apologized and came back.
- 34:22But there has to be a path to that, as gross as it is.
- 34:25If you're a white male, you'll never truly be cancelled.
- 34:29If you're a white male who's making people money, you won't
- 34:31be cancelled. You're uncancelable.
- 34:32If I get cancelled, what can I do to help myself?
- 34:35Some exercises may include writing a compassionate letter
- 34:39to yourself, which research shows can lower shame, self
- 34:43criticism, and anxiety, or writing a compassionate letter
- 34:46to yourself from the point of view of someone in a position of
- 34:49power over you, since shame often involves feeling like
- 34:52others are evaluating you negatively.
- 34:54Another tool is a loving kindness meditation.
- 34:58It's OK. You may want to practice that in
- 35:00which you imagine loving yourself and others, and imagine
- 35:03being open and receiving love. Yet another approach is learning
- 35:07to forgive yourself in the past and in the present.
- 35:10We've talked about this many times because it's really hard,
- 35:14but you have to remember that other people's opinion of you
- 35:17doesn't actually matter. There's shows that I'll never be
- 35:20on, like comedy shows just because one person doesn't like
- 35:22me. Or sometime someone got upset
- 35:25with me and I just have to let go of that and say, well, that's
- 35:28not for me. Every door is not going to be
- 35:30open to me. Right.
- 35:31And you are not for everyone. You can't please everyone.
- 35:35But I think also it's really important to realize, I really
- 35:37do think this has to do with our brain capacity.
- 35:40I think this culture is good for our brains.
- 35:43Yes, I think you're right. The story that I make up about
- 35:45it is when this was all resolved by being in the stocks for a
- 35:49couple of days and wearing a bell around your neck or
- 35:51whatever. I think it was just simpler.
- 35:53And I think when we didn't have the sense of anonymity, when we
- 35:57saw our neighbors and knew them closely, I think that's another
- 36:00piece that needs to probably be looked at.
- 36:03It's just very, I don't know, all of it's very tricky.
- 36:06So when? We when we escalated from
- 36:08stockade to witch hunt, that's when that's.
- 36:10When the deal troubles began, I think it's always been a part of
- 36:16human nature to want to do this sort of thing.
- 36:19You couldn't just tap, tap, tap on your keyboard and ruin
- 36:21somebody's life. You had to do a lot more than
- 36:24that. So, Virginia, in closing, what
- 36:26are your final thoughts on the topic of cancel culture?
- 36:30Well, I want to thank Kay for bringing it up.
- 36:31Although I will say that moving to a community like LA, none of
- 36:37your local beef matters. No one really cares outside of
- 36:40your zip code. And so as much as it it's
- 36:43painful, you got to shake it off and say no one with any power in
- 36:46this industry gives a crap about what happened in Spanky's
- 36:51nightclub in Duluth, in Duluth. I do think we all as individuals
- 36:55need to examine what is my participation in cancel culture?
- 36:58What do I think it's going to get?
- 37:00What do I think that this person is going to learn and engage
- 37:03with it accordingly? You've made attempts to cancel
- 37:06people and it didn't really work out so good.
- 37:09These days, if someone comes to me and say I want you to stop
- 37:11talking to this person, that person, I have to say, is there
- 37:14a crime involved? Because I can't engage if
- 37:17there's not an actual crime because I've gotten caught up in
- 37:21it too many times. In comedy, a person says, I'm
- 37:23mad at this person, I want you to be mad at them with me.
- 37:26And I go, OK, great. I'll unfriend them.
- 37:28I'll be mad at them. And then I see those two people
- 37:30start being friends again. And then I'm still on the outs
- 37:33with the one. Like, what was this for exactly?
- 37:35Who did this help? I think it's important to really
- 37:37think about these things and think about our motivation, what
- 37:40we're looking for out of it. What do we think this is going
- 37:42to resolve? Laura, what are your thoughts
- 37:44about cancer culture? I understand at the heart of it
- 37:47what it's for, and I do feel like there's sort of a
- 37:50biological imperative for us to engage in this way.
- 37:53But I guess my thought is, I think the same thing you said
- 37:56when you're thinking about slandering someone on the
- 37:58Internet. What is your hashtag goal?
- 38:01What do you hope to accomplish here?
- 38:02And as Andy Warhol once said, in the future everyone will be
- 38:06cancelled for 15 minutes. He was a jerk too.
- 38:09Oh, for sure. Every person I think on some
- 38:12level is a jerk. And I remember hearing someone
- 38:14on the Internet say, you know, we always say, well, man, it's
- 38:16men, men, men. But it's just because women have
- 38:18never had any power. We've never had any power.
- 38:21We've never had any ability to get away with anything.
- 38:23So we don't. My final thoughts are my
- 38:25apologies to Kay. I have sort of been in this
- 38:28position on some level. I feel like when I was fighting
- 38:31for my license, I felt every bit of this.
- 38:35I was up all night writing my letters and talking to lawyers
- 38:39and doing all the things. And it's terrifying because
- 38:42that's your whole career, right? It's my whole career.
- 38:44I've worked really hard for it. I've I've done everything I can
- 38:48to like make it work and all of my eggs are so far in this
- 38:51basket. So I kind of need it.
- 38:53So I understand when someone is trying to cut you off from your
- 38:56income. That's a pretty scary thing.
- 38:59And I do feel like I know Virginia, you were saying, well,
- 39:02it doesn't matter if it happens in Duluth, but if Duluth is my
- 39:05only income providing place, it does matter because that's all
- 39:08I've got. I don't have other.
- 39:10I don't have other options. I'm talking specifically about
- 39:12comedy. All the shows that are happening
- 39:15now are mad at you. Half of them will die.
- 39:18New shows will spring up. Those people won't even know you
- 39:20like it just continues. It's just frustrating because
- 39:23there's people in comedy who've had out and out essay
- 39:25allegations and then they just move cities and and nobody
- 39:27cares. And so I guess that's my other
- 39:29point. Time heals all wounds.
- 39:31I feel like when it comes to anything, I've had clients have
- 39:35beef with me. I've had clients say nasty
- 39:37things about me, and I just keep on chugging and keep it moving.
- 39:42And eventually I will have enough positive clout to
- 39:46counteract that wave. Virginia, if anyone's interested
- 39:50in following your comedy career, how would they go about doing
- 39:53that? You can check me out on Woah
- 39:55Woah Woah dot badinia BADINI. A.com Virginia is also my
- 39:59TikTok. And my Instagram and I wish you
- 40:02would. You can contact us at hello at
- 40:04my sisters at therapist.com. And you can check out our
- 40:07website, as I was mentioning before, at
- 40:09wowoadoptmysisters@therapist.com. You can hire us if you write us
- 40:12at Hiris, at my sisters, at therapist.com, or honestly, if
- 40:15you contact us in in any of the myriad ways of doing it, we're
- 40:18not going to be. Strict shout out to Waterloo
- 40:21Target brand Triple. A at Liquid Death AAA, we'd love
- 40:26it. We love your products, Laura.
- 40:29Where can people find you online?
- 40:31If you have nice things to say about me and don't intend to
- 40:35smear my name, you can find me at lauraryan.org.
- 40:38You can also find me at I Am Laura Ryan on TikTok.
- 40:42If you're interested in following the show on Instagram,
- 40:45you can go to My Sister's A Therapist on Instagram.
- 40:48Laura, now's the time of the show where you sometimes read a
- 40:50nice review that someone has left for us.
- 40:52Do you have one to share this week?
- 40:54Yes, our review is from a Wells T Thank you Wells in advance.
- 40:58Wells wrote us an Apple podcast review if anyone else wants to
- 41:01write one please do be sure to please give us five stars and we
- 41:05will read it on this podcast. The title is Billy Ray Valentine
- 41:09Capricorn. Love this pod and these ladies
- 41:12especially enjoy the episodes on fame, Cluster B's, manifesting
- 41:16and parasocials. Indulging my own parasocial
- 41:19relationship with the sisters by binge listening while I do
- 41:22chores around the house. You 2 are great company.
- 41:25Thank you, Wells. We appreciate you.
- 41:27And as we just said in the words of Billy Ray Valentine,
- 41:30Capricorn, we can make it, baby. Me and you.