Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Three Marks of Existence
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the meditation and attachment
- 0:02podcast with George Hoss. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medicare.gov, org talking
- 0:11about the knowledge of comprehension and the
- 0:16understanding of the three characteristics and not
- 0:19nietzschean dukkha anata is not self, Nietzsche's impermanence
- 0:27and Dukkha is. Commonly translated as suffering
- 0:35shins and translates it as unsatisfactoriness.
- 0:38And Dan as reactivity. And we typically talk about it
- 0:45in three levels. The Human Condition is to be
- 0:51born to grow old, to get sick, and to die.
- 0:54And there's nothing you can do about that.
- 0:57The second level is that you may get what you want but then lose
- 1:02it. You may not be able to get what
- 1:04you want and then you may have to put up with things that you
- 1:07don't want. And the third level is a subtle
- 1:12ongoing nearly constant irritation.
- 1:15That nothing is actually the way that you would have it.
- 1:17If you were actually in control of everything, this has a dual
- 1:23or two-sided sword. One is, it's not the way that
- 1:26you wanted and to you're not in control of anything.
- 1:32I think it's an interesting thing in the middle of the
- 1:34pandemic to, to really take on that third aspect of this, that
- 1:40irritation that the conditions are such that that if you have
- 1:43the resources, you can stay in shelter.
- 1:49And and be at less risk of the infection and if you don't have
- 1:53resources, you can't do that. But I don't know that we would
- 1:58have really chosen a pandemic to happen right now.
- 2:07One of the things about the investigation of these is that
- 2:12intellectually we can grab them pretty well or at least most of
- 2:17us can and we don't necessarily consider them deeper than that.
- 2:24And so in the meditation side of the practice, we really do want
- 2:27to come into a place where we are.
- 2:32Ardently investigating these different aspects so that we can
- 2:39really have a direct experience of the nature of these things.
- 2:46The search for it. And the frustrated search, the
- 2:52complete search that leads to the conclusion, that there is no
- 2:59solid ongoing, continuous experience of self that I can
- 3:02find. And I've ardently searched for
- 3:05it and have searched for it to the point that I'm actually
- 3:09willing to give up on it. Is the is the place that opens
- 3:14the freedom from the confine confining self experience.
- 3:22It also opens it up to this fluid movement between the
- 3:26selfing experience arising and passing in each moment, often as
- 3:31householders because we need the self experience the so often we
- 3:35need the self experience. So often I think of it
- 3:38sometimes, is that as a dimmer rather than on Off switch the
- 3:43sense of self is very low. The sense of self is very
- 3:46bright. when the Buddha talked about it, he talked about it in
- 3:56some sense in the witness of it, which Whi ch That discernment of
- 4:05which is it, is it there? Is it not there?
- 4:11It has an emergent quality to it.
- 4:14This is one of the things that's harder to get into He used the
- 4:21metaphor of a chariot for instance, in talking about the
- 4:24nature of self. That if you took a chariot apart
- 4:28in late all the pieces on the ground, nowhere, in all of those
- 4:33pieces, would there be a chariot but that when you assemble them,
- 4:38what emerges from that is the chariot.
- 4:44Which is actually a thing that you can attach horses to and
- 4:48ride someplace. With the sense of self or the
- 4:53experience of self, you have all of these pieces of bones and
- 4:58meat and skin that when they're all assembled.
- 5:04And it's living the the self experience experience emerges
- 5:10from that. But in examining each of those
- 5:15pieces of meat skin and bones, there is no self piece that if
- 5:24you held up separately from that would be ongoing substantial
- 5:29continuous. So how do we understand this
- 5:36emergent quality of self? That arises.
- 5:42And so what we want to begin to do is have a direct experience
- 5:46of it, like a lot of these things.
- 5:51It isn't an understanding from the view of self.
- 5:55It is a getting used to the nature of the emergent quality
- 5:58of self that it arises in moments and it passes away and
- 6:01moments. We all know this.
- 6:04I think from what happens to us in the, the experience of being
- 6:11alive, but what we need to do, is in the meditation, practice
- 6:15really pursue these. Explorations.
- 6:21To see if we can Discover it. The idea then with the
- 6:28exploration of self and not self is to see that in each moment,
- 6:32self arises based on the conditions of the present
- 6:35moment, it passes away. And as the conditions of the
- 6:39present moment, change, the conditions of the self
- 6:43experience change and that it comes and goes, and that we can
- 6:48move in a very fluid way between the arising and passing of the
- 6:55self. Experience.
- 6:58This also is a way into understanding the nature of
- 7:03impermanence where anicca that all things, arise and pass the
- 7:08self experience, arises and passes, the perception of the
- 7:11moment, arises and passes. All of the activations that we
- 7:16can track sensorially, arise and pass.
- 7:20And again cognitively, we can understand this fairly easily
- 7:24but what we need to do is this Ardent investigation so that we
- 7:29have the direct experience of this being true so that we give
- 7:34up on the idea that it might there might be something that we
- 7:39can actually hold onto. And then with these aspects of
- 7:49the self sorry, with these aspects around suffering. if
- 7:58you're older than 30, you have the experience of the body aging
- 8:04and if you're under 30, probably have the experience of the body
- 8:08growing, and it's quite different The older you get.
- 8:12Of course, the more pronounced the experience of Aging is But
- 8:18it's very difficult to contemplate for most people that
- 8:21death is. One of the things, one of the
- 8:24aspects of this Human Condition. We have a tendency to think that
- 8:29even though things are changing, and that we are aging that it
- 8:35will just go on forever. There, of course, is no evidence
- 8:43for this. There is no one that has gone on
- 8:45forever, at least that I've encountered, many of us have had
- 8:54parents or grandparents who have died.
- 8:57Many of us have had friends who have died in this time of the
- 9:01pandemic, the the That may be quite a common experience for
- 9:08most people. But have you ardently
- 9:17investigated the possibility of your own death?
- 9:24And can you touch into that? It tends to create a fork in the
- 9:30road in One Direction is Neil ISM.
- 9:32If you're not going to survive, if nothing lasts, then nothing
- 9:38really matters. So, why engage in anything and
- 9:42in the other direction, is this engagement idea that you fully
- 9:47engage in each moment you have because you have it and the
- 9:52experience of it is what's available, what you can really
- 9:55do. In Buddhism, we have the idea of
- 10:00reincarnation and that may have preceded Buddhism in the
- 10:05animistic and different religious practices that were
- 10:10present in India at the time. What?
- 10:17I went to Miramar, the they have a pagoda in downtown Yangon
- 10:21called the shwedagon pagoda, and most of the iconic iconography
- 10:29of the Buddha is depicted as for Buddha's because one of the
- 10:35visions that was recorded by the shock to Muni Buddha, was that
- 10:41there had been three previous Buddha's before him and in the
- 10:46shwedagon Pagoda they claimed to have relics from the three
- 10:51previous Buddhas. And that we are in a time of
- 10:56waiting for the fifth Buddha to arise.
- 11:01Often in the west were not invested in The Narrative of
- 11:07traditional Buddhism. But they are certainly in
- 11:12Miramar. So the idea of reincarnation
- 11:21helps with this idea that this life like all things are
- 11:24impermanent and comes and goes but in the west often with the
- 11:29judeo Christian traditions, we think of this as one life and
- 11:34then eternal life is either Heaven or Hell.
- 11:43Unless you've been turned on to science and enough that the
- 11:50mysticism becomes something that's impossible to consider
- 11:54seriously and you move into this kind of atheistic idea, then
- 12:00there's this one life and then nothing follows it. and then, at
- 12:10the end of that betterly path into science, of course, you end
- 12:14up in the quantum world where everything is connected and this
- 12:27whole understanding is a piece and But even with those salves,
- 12:39if you will, in a way, how easily can you sit into the
- 12:43experience of this life? This collection of conditioning,
- 12:50this experience coming to an end.
- 12:57And so for that, we have these meditations where you sit into
- 13:01the contemplation of your own death, one of the texts that I
- 13:07was, Working with said, the instruction was to sit and
- 13:13imagine all the ways that you could be killed until you are
- 13:17shaking with fear. That your life will be lost.
- 13:25And having done it. I can tell you that you can
- 13:28actually imagine. I don't know my mind having been
- 13:33conditioned by the the entertainment of extreme
- 13:38violence can imagine many gruesome ways in which I can be
- 13:42killed. But actually after six hours of
- 13:46meditating on that it was terrified that this life would
- 13:50go would come to an end and that there wouldn't be some Next
- 13:55moment to go into. But I tend to find that that
- 14:00pushes me in the direction of Engagement.
- 14:03That each moment is precious and that each moment should be
- 14:06engaged with. It's an interesting conundrum to
- 14:11be in in the shelter in place mode.
- 14:15That many of us are in There's no end to things that I would
- 14:24like to do and and to be able to organize it in such a way that I
- 14:28can do them here as opposed to having to go out in the world.
- 14:34I have largely organized my life so that I never have to leave
- 14:38home anyway, but it is a kind of confining structure.
- 14:45That comes in place, which in some sense will also end and
- 14:50then we'll be able to move out into the world in a cautious
- 14:55way. And again this is an Ardent
- 15:03investigation, not just a conceptual cognitive
- 15:07understanding of this to come into this through direct
- 15:13experience experience of meditation.
- 15:19The self experience arises and creates the sense of Duality
- 15:24where the self pulls out of the sensing experience.
- 15:27And it's as if there were separate experience viewing the
- 15:33sensing arising and passing an author and owner a doer, a
- 15:39controller, the creator of that experience which is separate men
- 15:46unchanging. In each moment arises and we
- 15:50have this sense of the self. We have the sense of the world
- 15:54outside as being separate and the Insight.
- 15:59Is that actually the sense of self is made up of the same.
- 16:03Sensing experience that the world that we're experiencing is
- 16:09made out of they are the same activity of sensing and making
- 16:14the sensing experience into something. so, Absolute reality
- 16:21into conceptual reality. And the conceptual reality
- 16:27forms, with the experience of the viewing self.
- 16:31And the thing that's being viewed, even though they are of
- 16:35One Piece, And so that's the investigation to see that that
- 16:42the that's one piece of it and that this merging of the sense
- 16:47of this emerging of the sense of self from the various sensing
- 16:52activity, can be very pronounced and can be very subtle.
- 16:57And that it's useful. We need to be able to manifest
- 17:01that activity in order to communicate verbally.
- 17:06To navigate the world. And so it is into demonization
- 17:11of the sense of self or a suggestion that we should move
- 17:16into the place of no self and never come out of it but that we
- 17:20should be able to move fluidly. From the sense of self back and
- 17:26forth. We develop through our
- 17:30conditioning, this working model of the experience of self and
- 17:33the experience of the world that in the moment of sensing
- 17:37activity. When it arises, The conditioning
- 17:41that's associated with the sense of self is there.
- 17:45So you may notice that you have different reactions to the
- 17:48experience of self as it arises. If in the working model, there
- 17:54are a lot of negative mind States or negative emotions
- 17:59embedded in that framework. When the sense of self arises,
- 18:04there can be an aversive reaction to it.
- 18:07We tend to think of that as self-hatred.
- 18:10The sense of self arises and rather than it being a very
- 18:13pleasant experience. That we enjoy having.
- 18:17We have an aversive reaction to the experience of self and this
- 18:21comes directly from the conditioning of our early
- 18:25experience of the self arising and our caregivers response to
- 18:31it. And depending on how they
- 18:33respond to it, we tend to embed the experience of those
- 18:37responses into the working model of self.
- 18:41And so when it arises and we've had adverse experiences, and
- 18:47this is particularly true of our early conditioning with her
- 18:51family group, however, that was created did They have an
- 18:59expressed sense of delight and being with you.
- 19:03So that in, in your working model, the way that you create
- 19:07the sense of self. There's that expectation of
- 19:10being delighted in or in you delighting, in the selfing
- 19:15experience. Which is quite Pleasant.
- 19:18And so each time, the self experience.
- 19:20Arises you have this Pleasant response to it?
- 19:25Or were they critical or harmful or judgmental or, or indifferent
- 19:31to the experience of you as it arose in childhood when it was
- 19:36uninhibited and just that that easy flow of the experience of
- 19:42self and then as you collected those experiences and And embed
- 19:47them into the sense of self as it arises.
- 19:51Do you find that the sense of self arises and because it's
- 19:55filled with so many adverse emotional, so much adverse
- 20:00emotional content that you don't want it to arise so there's an
- 20:04aversive response to it. and, Can you see that clearly and
- 20:15understand that that's actually what's happening and then be
- 20:18able to affect the nature of the self as it comes and goes.
- 20:23If the self were solid and ongoing and unchanging you would
- 20:28never be able to affect any of that and it would be continuous.
- 20:33He wouldn't have a different perspective of your early life
- 20:36to the way that your life is now.
- 20:39And be able to view and understand coherently the nature
- 20:43of the experience as it unfolded for you.
- 20:50If things aren't going well and you have the idea that
- 20:53everything is permanent and never it lasts, then the the
- 20:58sense of Despair that can arise from that.
- 21:02That solidness than that, unchanging.
- 21:04As can be overwhelming. And and actually limit Your
- 21:10Capacity to respond to the constantly changing experience
- 21:16of the present moment. And again, that isn't something
- 21:23that you understand intellectually and are able to
- 21:27solve intellectually. We really do need to explore
- 21:31this in an Ardent sincere. Way getting to the end of the
- 21:38exploration having exhausted every possibility.
- 21:43So that we are really at this deep level convinced of these
- 21:48things, which then changes our perspective about it.
- 21:55So we sit in meditation, typically with this kind of
- 21:58practice we searched for an experience of self that is
- 22:07continuous and unending. In the see here, field technique
- 22:12that we'll use to explore this Insight space.
- 22:18Whereas the self in here space, where is the self?
- 22:22In the felt sense of the body, whereas the sense of self.
- 22:27When you notice the sense of self arising, what sensing
- 22:30experiences are arising, that caused the sense of self to
- 22:35arise. And if you, if you take the
- 22:38experience apart, Where is it? It emerges from the pieces of
- 22:47see hear feel. But in each of these aspects, it
- 22:52isn't residing there. So you have that that experience
- 22:56of the pieces and then the emerging of the sense of self
- 23:01and the passing away of the sense of self and the the pieces
- 23:05themselves not The piece that is a solid and and separate
- 23:14experience of self is unfindable.
- 23:20In the search of. Permanence, we look in the
- 23:24sensing experiences for something that is lasting and
- 23:28ongoing and doesn't change. That is constant.
- 23:36So when we find something that arises and passes, we move on
- 23:41from that and look for something that is lasting.
- 23:47So if you were to find something but that was lasting, you would
- 23:50simply stay with it continuously for the entire meditation
- 23:54process, because it would be unending and you would have
- 23:58found the thing that's permanent. and then in the, in
- 24:05the nature of Unsatisfactoriness their reactivity.
- 24:12One of the reasons that I like Dan's use of the word reactive
- 24:17is that even if you get the Deep insight into the nature of
- 24:25nothing lasting, everything changes and the self not lasting
- 24:30and even this human Incarnation, not lasting, even if you come to
- 24:36complete Equanimity with all of that, you're Amane reactive.
- 24:42Whereas with unsatisfactoriness idea if you come to a place of
- 24:48deep Equanimity with the nature of the human condition that it
- 24:51becomes less unsatisfactory, or even not even an unsatisfactory,
- 24:56but the reactivity is still there.
- 24:59The the senses each of the sense experiences remain activated one
- 25:06day one, they're contacted by the sense object.
- 25:13Is that all making sense pretty well?
- 25:19Any questions about that? Have you all already discovered
- 25:33that there's no no self. Nothing lasts.
- 25:41And that we're all going to grow old.
- 25:43Get sick and die. And you're all fine with it,
- 25:48Sean. I can unmute you.
- 25:54Alright, yeah, there we go. Can you just talk a minute about
- 26:01how the sense of self and view are intertwined?
- 26:08Okay, I'll give it a shot. View is often controlled by a
- 26:24mind State experience. Or distorted by a mind State
- 26:29experience. So you have the object that can
- 26:31be sends the capacity to sense it when they meet a
- 26:33consciousness of that sensing experience arises, which is
- 26:37Pleasant unpleasant or neutral. And then it's compared to the
- 26:40perceptual database and if the conditions are right for the
- 26:43experience of self to rise, the perceptual database will supply
- 26:48the working model of self which will arise in the present
- 26:51moment. And then, depending what the
- 27:01experience of the of that arising is, you may be totally
- 27:06equanimous with the present moment.
- 27:08You may be craving something different.
- 27:09In the moment, you may be aversive to what is in the
- 27:12moment, you may not be interested in what it is in the
- 27:14moment. And so, depending on which sense
- 27:17of self arises and what your relationship to it is that can
- 27:22affect the kind of view that arises.
- 27:25So that if an incompetent sense of self arises, you may believe
- 27:29that you are or incompetent, which will create a view.
- 27:33And so that when you explore the potentiality is of the present
- 27:37moment, you'll be distorted by that particular, arising of the
- 27:41experience of Self in the potentiality is of the present
- 27:47moment. Everything is available to you
- 27:51every possibility that that moment has is available to you.
- 27:57But if your view is distorted and you can't see a range of the
- 28:00possibilities because the view precludes you from seeing them,
- 28:06then it doesn't matter whether they're there or not because you
- 28:09can't see them to choose them. Once you choose something of
- 28:14course, then all of the potentiality is except for the
- 28:17thing that you've chose and is lost because you've fixated the
- 28:23present moment in that way. And then all of the potentiality
- 28:28is that are linked to that particular choice that you made
- 28:32in the present moment presents itself.
- 28:34And again, if the view is distorted, Then you may not see
- 28:41the full range of potentiality. And then as you pick one of the
- 28:48choices that are there in front of you, of course, all of the
- 28:52potentiality is except for the one that you pick fall away and
- 28:55then the potentiality is that are connected to the choice that
- 28:58you made open before you pick. Of course, all of the
- 29:03potentiality is of the next moment are there.
- 29:06And then all of the potentiality is that are linked to whatever
- 29:09choice you make are there. And all of the potentiality is
- 29:13that are linked to all of the potentiality.
- 29:15He's that Link to the present moment, our there.
- 29:19So anything anything that's available to you is available
- 29:24for you to choose in the moment. If you can see clearly, One of
- 29:30the things about that is that it's so complex that you can't
- 29:34predict when you take an action, what the outcome of the action
- 29:39is going to be, you can make sense of it in reverse pretty
- 29:43easily. but in moving forward, in a sense, you, there's no way
- 29:49to know And so in Buddhism, we say you make a good intention
- 29:57for the action that you take and then you don't cling to the
- 30:01result of it. You then immediately go into the
- 30:05potentiality, is of the next moment in pick.
- 30:08And then into the next in this, this kind of flow of experience.
- 30:16You can get of course quite fixated on a particular way that
- 30:21you want something to happen. And again this could be the
- 30:25sense of self arising in this fixating that sense of self and
- 30:30imagining that it's real. So that it needs defense or it
- 30:33needs protection in a way that it doesn't because it isn't
- 30:38substantial in that way. That in the next moment as it
- 30:42arises, a whole new experience of self could arise in
- 30:48relationship to it. And so the fixating with the
- 30:55holding in English, the word is attachment.
- 31:00You attached to a particular experience and make it solid and
- 31:05make that the thing that you want.
- 31:07And so then a great deal of suffering comes from that
- 31:10because you know nothing is the way that you want it necessarily
- 31:17everything changes nothing lasts the experience of self.
- 31:20Elf is unsatisfied or slide it because it isn't the way that
- 31:26you had imagined or that you would wanted it to be.
- 31:32This is an interesting thing in terms of attachment because the
- 31:35attachment views are quite distinct from each other.
- 31:39A secure person walks into a room and they think that people
- 31:43will greet them with delight and that they'll be interested in
- 31:48what they say. And so they go about the room as
- 31:52if those are the choices for them.
- 31:55And when we look at the early conditioning, that causes that,
- 31:59to happen, what that, what happened to them, was that their
- 32:03caregivers expressed Delight, in seeing them without them, really
- 32:07having to do much other than be the, the little child that they
- 32:12were this expressed experience of delight of care of interest,
- 32:19but if you didn't have that, of course, when you begin to
- 32:21construct this model of yourself, you don't construct it
- 32:24that way. it doesn't mean you can't reconstruct it later and
- 32:28condition yourself to expect those things, but if you're
- 32:34disorganized because there was some kind of trauma the view is
- 32:37that you're not capable of getting your needs met in and
- 32:42that actually if you allow people to see and experience you
- 32:46that they're going to exploit and harm you, And then if you
- 32:51can imagine an array of potentiality is that arise in
- 32:54the present moment in one view, you're thinking people will be
- 32:58really interested. In me, they'll be excited to
- 33:00hear what I have to say that they really would like to meet
- 33:02me. What are the choices that you
- 33:04might make from that? Or if you thought that if I'm
- 33:08Not Invisible I'm going to be exploited in harmed and what
- 33:13choices than might you make out of the same collection of
- 33:18possibilities. And so that that's one of the
- 33:24reasons why this incited to the nature of self is so important
- 33:28to really be able to see and pull apart that working model
- 33:32and understand that it's insubstantial.
- 33:34It is it's simply a framework out of which the experience is
- 33:39constructed and that it's changeable.
- 33:42You can make it differently by affecting the the the nature of
- 33:50your conditioning. Is that making sense?
- 33:55Is that a good enough answer? if you believe that, you're
- 34:02unworthy, even if the choices are there for you to take, And
- 34:08you think that they're only for worthy people to take?
- 34:10You are the one who doesn't take them those potentiality is you
- 34:15don't take you take different potentiality 's And then what
- 34:20opens up in the next moment, of course, are the potentials that
- 34:23are linked to the, to the, to the choice that you did make and
- 34:27you move through these possibilities in that way in
- 34:32this flow of choosing over and over again.
- 34:38One of the images that I like quite a bit is that you're on
- 34:42the floor, picking up crumbs that fall off the table because
- 34:46you can't see that there's a place card for you and a chair
- 34:50that's empty waiting for you to sit in it.
- 34:55So that's this thing of opening it up and really being able to
- 34:58see clearly How that happened? This is the coherent narrative
- 35:06part of this process of understanding.
- 35:17For instance, when the scent, when your sense of self strongly
- 35:21arises, what is the response that you have to it?
- 35:26Is it a pleasant delightful experience?
- 35:30Is that an unpleasant experience?
- 35:32Are you indifferent to yourself? And can you, can you understand
- 35:39that? The that because the working
- 35:41model is Created from actual experiences that you had and
- 35:45that it began quite early that you may be playing the
- 35:49indifference of a depressed mother or father who couldn't
- 35:52respond to you. And that when the sense of self
- 35:57arises the the sense that there's nothing you can do to
- 36:01get people to respond to arises, then that you know, that as
- 36:05yourself and you fixated into a solid self.
- 36:09That is real. And that completely, distorts
- 36:13the view of the potential of the present moment.
- 36:18And that if you could see that, oh, there's the conditioning
- 36:22arising and move through, that sense of self, and just be in
- 36:30the experience of the present moment.
- 36:33And the the and because the view is clear, see the full
- 36:40potentiality is that are there and then choose or not choose.
- 36:47There's no need really to fixate a sense of self or fixate
- 36:51anything in the present moment and then you just move from one
- 36:54field of potentiality into another in a an experience of
- 36:59flow, which is timeless. And you can operate from that
- 37:07place. Too many of us will have known
- 37:09this. Have you ever been highly
- 37:12concentrated on a task that you are engaged in and looked up and
- 37:17notice that two hours had gone by because you were so engaged
- 37:22in it. You didn't notice that that was
- 37:24happening, and yet you were totally engaged in the activity.
- 37:28So, the sense of self not arising in that That particular
- 37:33scenario. Any other questions before we
- 37:40meditate? So we're going to do a see, hear
- 37:51feel meditation and part of it will do as an Ardent
- 37:54investigation of whether the self is present or not.
- 37:57And then the second part of it will be focused on exploring
- 38:02impermanence to see if you can find something.
- 38:09If you can find a self that lasts and experience that lasts,
- 38:25I had a happy sense of self for most of the meditation.
- 38:31A kind of beaming sense of a proud self.
- 38:40And I was having trouble Discerning it from the flatness
- 38:45of awareness. So I noticed that my mind was
- 38:49was bridging that sense of self over and over again.
- 38:52So it tended to expand in that way.
- 38:56But then when I zoomed into a particular sensing activity, it
- 39:00wasn't there, or if I just did two instead of the whole thing,
- 39:04then I couldn't find it in that. And I think that that was one of
- 39:09the insights that I think that it's important to notice that
- 39:14when you've zoomed out and focus in space is active, all at the
- 39:19same time. So internal visual thinking,
- 39:22internal, auditory thinking and internal the felt sense of
- 39:28emotion in the body that tends to create the selfing
- 39:32experience, particularly the aspect of visual thinking, which
- 39:35is the outline of the body and its Position, the kind of a
- 39:39subtle aspect of that this is me and it feels substantial but
- 39:46it's the emotion that really pushes the substantial feeling.
- 39:54If you ask me to describe what my sense of self is, I would
- 39:58have to use some combination of internal image with words are
- 40:04used with just thinking, use my thinking, and images, in my mind
- 40:08and culminate, these things together to try to describe what
- 40:13this important book sensor, self-absorbed.
- 40:15You say the opinion of yourself, right?
- 40:18And that's the sense that the selfing experience, but it isn't
- 40:22permanent and it's based on On the activations of all of those
- 40:26different sense. Kate's coming together in a
- 40:28moment of that experience arising, and as soon as the
- 40:32activations of those sense, Gates change the, so the sense
- 40:35of self changes, And awareness knows.
- 40:42All of that awareness is just neutral.
- 40:46I mean we awareness is almost always there, there are a few
- 40:50times when it isn't in a, if you have a period of deep sleep at
- 40:55night, there's no sense of awareness.
- 41:01But if you're not in a, in a deep state of sleep, then there
- 41:04is awareness, if you're aware of your dreams, that awareness is
- 41:10present knowing that the dreaming activity is there. the
- 41:15other common time when people don't have a sense of awareness
- 41:18has, when you've taken anesthesia, anesthesia of
- 41:23course, doesn't kill pain it, kills awareness and so So, the
- 41:30body is still reacting to the pain Sensations.
- 41:33There's just no awareness knowing it. and don't get mad at
- 41:37me if I've over simplified So, in the moment, when when you
- 41:51have the self experience arising and then you, you investigate
- 41:55each of the different sense, Gates, you can have the self
- 41:59experience and see in the sense gate, that there's no self
- 42:02there. And so then you be can see can
- 42:05become sensitive to the emergent quality of that.
- 42:11That when the one the right sensory activations are present
- 42:15the experience of self arises, even though when you examine the
- 42:20individual pieces, it isn't there.
- 42:23And that's one of these really interesting things about the
- 42:26nature of human consciousness, how that happens and how it's
- 42:33constantly changing. But if you don't pay attention
- 42:38to that then and the mind is skipping back and forth between
- 42:42awareness and activations and awareness in the activations
- 42:46that it can create this idea that the sense of self is
- 42:50continuous and ongoing, and has never changed from the moment.
- 42:54We were born until now And because it's solid and something
- 42:59that that you need to protect so that you have it, you can get
- 43:03very defensive about about the experience of it.
- 43:08Do you notice when anger arises in a rush to defend a perceived
- 43:14slight or attack on the experience of self?
- 43:17What's that? Like but what actually are you
- 43:20defending in that that moment? That making sense.
- 43:43As if you remember talking about the development of spiritual
- 43:48awareness spiritual maturity, the first is understand that you
- 43:53have a mind State and that other people have a mind State, and
- 43:58that they're not the same. And that that's the nature of
- 44:03The Human Condition. And and that you can affect your
- 44:09mind State and other people can affect their minds date.
- 44:13And that your mind state has an effect on other people on other
- 44:16people's mind. State has an effect on you.
- 44:22And if the sense of self is something that that becomes
- 44:25solid and believable as a real thing, then that interactivity
- 44:31with the other person's mind, State can cause you to become
- 44:36defensive of your imagined self experience and there's really no
- 44:43way to prevent that other than completely block the connection
- 44:48to other people. But if you can hold that sense
- 44:54of self is a coming and going reactivity to the experience of
- 44:59the present moment, then it can be a kind of easy experience of
- 45:06the self rising and the indignation, or the Joy, or
- 45:09whatever it is that arises in the present moment and you can
- 45:13be open and curious about your own activity of self without
- 45:19needing to defend it. It Harley.
- 45:26I wasn't me flushing a toilet. Sorry.
- 45:33The sense of self is willing to give up, right?
- 45:38But as you talked about, it will demonstrate that it's there.
- 45:53Actually, the closest I get to no self is is gone or rest,
- 46:00right? But what you did with the
- 46:03reverse engineering was really helpful because it it doesn't
- 46:09like that probate. Okay, you're there on CN.
- 46:15Well, where are you really, right?
- 46:20How do you do that and still go out and about in the world and
- 46:29people know you as a circle self?
- 46:33Well what what you're noticing there is that the sense of self
- 46:37arises in relationship to that other person.
- 46:40Yeah that sense of self arises. but if a third person comes in,
- 46:47a different sense of self arises, And I like to be quite
- 46:54open and curious about what sense of self arises where and,
- 47:00and really to understand that there's this unconscious
- 47:02exchange of detection, really? Or I don't know what word to use
- 47:09for it. There's data coming in from the
- 47:12other people, and there's data going out and you're actually
- 47:15tracking the interaction between those exchanges.
- 47:19And then the of self is a rising based on all of this
- 47:22information, which you may not be sensitive to be getting
- 47:25right. Remember when we walk into a
- 47:28room, we create a social hierarchy and then we Peg
- 47:32ourselves as where we think we fit into it, because this
- 47:36information is being exchanged on an unconscious level about
- 47:40about the other person in our perception of them.
- 47:47And so rather than fixating and defending, if you become open
- 47:53and curious about what this thing is happening, then what
- 47:58you get from it is the insight into the nature of your
- 48:00conditioning. Which I think is actually it's
- 48:06it makes the experience of your own self very enjoyable because
- 48:14you're constantly curious about what's happening with you rather
- 48:21than than not experiencing that or just getting caught up in the
- 48:26different fixated senses of self.
- 48:29Particularly if you're aversive to yourself in some way.
- 48:32Way. Which is because dissociation is
- 48:39pulling out of the present moment.
- 48:42Inwardly and disappearing. And this is pushing out into the
- 48:47experience of the present moment, and being bright there,
- 48:50as it as it's happening. So, in some sense is the
- 48:54opposite of dissociation. You know, the Buddha described
- 49:01this in the satipatthana suttas mindfulness of inside
- 49:04mindfulness of outside in mindfulness of inside and
- 49:07outside that you're tracking all of this.
- 49:10It's not that you don't have a sense of self.
- 49:13It's that there isn't a permanent one that it arises in
- 49:17relationship to the conditions of the present moment and as the
- 49:21conditions of the present moment, the self experience
- 49:25changes. And it comes and goes, sometimes
- 49:28it's intense, sometimes it's subtle.
- 49:32Sometimes, it's absent. You may believe that you need a
- 49:37sense of self to operate but you don't you can operate perfectly
- 49:41well from no self. And in fact people often remark
- 49:46with people who operate mostly from no self is that they're
- 49:50much more present in much more in tune with what's happening
- 49:54but then you won't create autobiographical memories of
- 49:57what happened. And so it isn't as useful in
- 50:04social groups where we mostly live But to be able to come and
- 50:10go from that that completely flowing and fixated sensing
- 50:15experience, which is very expansive and then fixating
- 50:20momentarily into these very efficient.
- 50:24Brilliant senses of self is another way of describing what
- 50:30enlightenment is that he's to move between total, no self flow
- 50:37into fixating a Ian sense of self.
- 50:41As Trans Am first. I've never been a good Snapper,
- 50:46but anyway, you get the idea snap.
- 50:50There's the brilliant sense of self and you don't need it
- 50:52anymore and you don't cling to it in anyway, so it just Falls
- 50:57away. Are you the same person you
- 51:01were? When you were five years old?
- 51:03Can you even really imagine what that perspective was like?
- 51:10I mean, it's next to Impossible because you don't have the
- 51:12equipment, your brain is completely different than it was
- 51:15then. You don't see anything the same
- 51:18way. You can recreate a memory of
- 51:22from them, but you're not actually recreating a very
- 51:26accurate memory of that, you're because you're using this body
- 51:30that you have now with all of the capacities of this body and
- 51:34you're playing. You know, old record.
- 51:41Did you ever? Maybe you live to the experience
- 51:46of, I don't know why this comes to mind, but it is my dad had a
- 51:50whole collection of 78. And whenever we tried to play
- 51:55them on the 33, it really didn't work out that well right.
- 52:05And there used to be a time when all record players had a switch
- 52:08where you could go from 33 to 45 to 78.
- 52:14And then gradually that that was less and less available.
- 52:20And so you're playing a memory that you made, that's pretty
- 52:22well intact at five year old 5 years old on a, on a 33 when
- 52:28it's a 78. It's just not the same
- 52:30experience. Even though it though we can, if
- 52:34we fixated believe that it's actually an accurate, an
- 52:39accurate retelling of what happened to us.
- 52:45And so you really want to move into this place of this flow of
- 52:50conscious awareness and understand that it's a rising.
- 52:55And it's it is a pretty accurate picture of what it means to us
- 53:05in this moment. And beyond that, the accuracy is
- 53:10not. Dependable.
- 53:14And then, how do you navigate the world from that place,
- 53:18right? Because that's actually the
- 53:20accurate place. Not you did this to me because I
- 53:26remember it. That is actually not.
- 53:30You can't make a factual statement like that because that
- 53:33isn't even how we work. We don't remember what happens.
- 53:37We remember what it means to us. and then we play what it meant
- 53:44to us in the body of what it means to us now, which is, which
- 53:50is layer after layer of difference.
- 53:56I'm in that it's when you get Bridget and fixate these things
- 54:00that you tend to amplify the suffering because it isn't not
- 54:05only is it, it is an accurate isn't really the way that The
- 54:11whole experience of being alive, is that making sense trying to
- 54:18articulate this? If you can move into this place
- 54:24of this is what I'm perceiving, this is the sensing, I'm this is
- 54:27the conceptual reality that I'm making.
- 54:30And you can be open to other people and inquire of them.
- 54:33What is it? They're making on of it.
- 54:36What comes back to you, is not an accurate reflection of what's
- 54:39happening, but an insight into the nature of their
- 54:42conditioning, and how they're experiencing things, and
- 54:46creating from the same experience of the present
- 54:49moment, their response. Which is, which can be endlessly
- 54:57fascinating in terms of navigating this, this traveling
- 55:04together with someone else we really don't.
- 55:07And this might be quite punctuated because of the
- 55:10pandemic. If particularly I know for
- 55:13myself because I live alone, I'm I don't usually spend so much
- 55:18time alone and it has an effect in terms of the body.
- 55:24There's a kind of sluggishness that comes from that an adult -
- 55:28that comes from that because we're meant to be engaged in
- 55:32these interactions with other people.
- 55:36We're built for it. so, How's everybody doing, okay?
- 55:46So, I want to thank you for coming.
- 55:50I'm offering the teacher on a Donna basis if you'd like to
- 55:53contribute Donna, if you go to the website, there's a link for
- 55:56the Donna. I wanted to say that I'm I'm
- 56:00teaching a day long on Saturday meditation and attachment for
- 56:06relationships. So I'm going to be talking about
- 56:11the Dynamics of secure functioning collaborative
- 56:14relationships and Doing some practice, you can come as a
- 56:19single person or as a couple will do some dyads.
- 56:23I hope that that works and if you come as a couple you can
- 56:27work together. And if you come individually,
- 56:29you'll be assigned to somebody to work with so that we can
- 56:33begin to look at the nature of conditioning and how it affects
- 56:39the way that we respond in relationships.
- 56:42And then I also have an inquiry. We have a retreat, scheduled a
- 56:4810-day event of a passenger Retreat scheduled for July and
- 56:54I'm curious. Whether if they do, lift the
- 56:57shelter in place in California, and the retreat center is still
- 57:01open. A lot of big ifs.
- 57:04Weather coming out of two or three months of sheltered home.
- 57:11You the the First thing that comes to mind is rushing to a
- 57:14silent meditation, Retreats or whether, you think it would make
- 57:21more sense to push it to the fall.
- 57:25Many people are expecting the the summer to slow the infection
- 57:30and then it to restart in the fault or whether or not
- 57:36something I've never done before is to do a virtual retreat.
- 57:45Where it is actually a retreat where we're sitting all day
- 57:49long. And you have the same number of
- 57:51Dharma talks in this and interviews and all the rest of
- 57:54it. So if you have thoughts of that
- 57:57and would be happy to send me a note about it.
- 58:00I would really appreciate that George at met a group dot-org so
- 58:04we can figure out our planning for the retreat.
- 58:12Thank you. So if you have thoughts of that
- 57:57and would be happy to send me a note about it.
- 58:00I would really appreciate that George at met a group dot-org so
- 58:04we can figure out our planning for the retreat.
- 58:12Thank you.