Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Spielworxx Bulletin-Conflicts of Interest
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the most informed board game news show on the Internet with the beating
- 0:04heart of the German board game industry, Julie Bleeman and Sam Bloki found slammed
- 0:09outside of a pub in a pool of his own offerings, Ben Meadows.
- 0:13This is the spiel Works world, all right, So here we are again
- 0:18this month spiel Works Bulletin with me and the King, the undisputed heavyweight champion
- 0:27of the German board gaming world, Uli Blenheman, Uli, Welcome to this
- 0:31month's Spielworks Bulletin. Yeah, thank you for having me and I'm looking forward
- 0:35to it. And maybe not heavyweight, but maybe paperweight or is there a
- 0:40category of cardboard weight, then it is maybe my class. Well you could
- 0:47be plastic weights because you now print in China, so yes, sir,
- 0:51right, so we are we are cheap, so that's what it is.
- 0:56So the opening sections where we talk about a game that we've played recently,
- 1:00we find interesting. So do you have a game this month earlier? Have
- 1:03you been too busy drinking booze? Ah? Yeah, that needs time,
- 1:08right, But no, I played a game and if you know me,
- 1:15that is really a game. You would not expect that I'm playing it and
- 1:19I'm enjoying it. It's Detective by Portal Games. Ah, right, so
- 1:26it's not a new release. I think it's from twenty eighteen and I and
- 1:30I bought it, bought the German version at that time because i'd heard very
- 1:37good things. But I do not like these normally this type of game at
- 1:45all, so I'm not playing it. I don't want to solve criminal cases.
- 1:49Also, I do not like escape room games. I do not like
- 1:53exit games, although of course I've played them, and I think Inca and
- 1:59Marcus Brand with the Exit series for Cosmos, they did a wonderful, tremendous
- 2:05and made a lot of money. I say, aoh, yes, they
- 2:07are selling like hotcakes. But I think the ones I think. I played
- 2:14two Exit games. They were wonderful, great puzzles, and I was always
- 2:19surprised and in a way I was also entertained. But I had this Detective
- 2:24here, put it into storage, never looked at it, and I looked
- 2:30at it recently and actually I wanted to make a room for another game.
- 2:36So I got it out, put it on the table with my wife,
- 2:39and she loves criminal novels. She's enjoying this type of stuff. And she
- 2:47wanted to play, so we are in it. It's the first The Detective
- 2:52base box has five cases. We are only in case one. We are
- 2:55finishing it this night, and she's enjoying it tremendously, and I must say
- 3:04I'm also enjoying it, so because I think it is very well done.
- 3:10The story is goodbye, I g Nazi. And also I'm also not a
- 3:16fan of the game types where you are using an app. To me,
- 3:23it is of more a distraction than a benefit something added. But here I
- 3:30think there is a database so you can log into it. There are fingerprints,
- 3:36some background materials on suspects and other people involved, So I think it
- 3:43if you have your netbook there on the table and are looking at this from
- 3:46time to time, I think it's it's fine. And I must say the
- 3:52work behind Detective must be tremendous, so it is. It is really very
- 3:59well done in my opinion. So if you like this type of game,
- 4:03this is a high recommendation for me, and even if you are normally not
- 4:09playing this type of game, you should definitely check out Detective. And I
- 4:13think there is a Bad Man a game based on Detective on Dune, or
- 4:18if you are more in that stuff. You can also use these titles,
- 4:24but very well done. Yeah, yeah, I played it in the There
- 4:29was a preview with the UK Games Expo and I played it there and I
- 4:31find the computer integration is brilliant. Yes, and the story was good.
- 4:35And you know, I played Chilock Holmes Consulting Detective. Yes. And the
- 4:40fundamental problem with Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is it has a goal that is unachievable.
- 4:46You will never beat Chilock Holmes. He solves the case in three.
- 4:51I remember once have it playing it with someone and the thing is you're never
- 4:57going to beat Chilock Holms, so you do it until you solved the case.
- 5:00And we played with one guy and he just said, I'm not contributing
- 5:02anymore because I think I've sold it and I want to beat Sherlock Holmes.
- 5:06And it was just the douchiest thing I can imagine. And I've tried with
- 5:12Sherlock Holmes and I just basically don't enjoy Exit is the same thing. My
- 5:17mind does not work in that way. I find it more frustrating than I
- 5:21do enjoyable. Yea, but I was surprised at how good Detective was and'
- 5:28do you think you'll go on to play it more? Yes? So,
- 5:31to be honest, if it would be me with my local gaming group,
- 5:36So every couple of weeks, I probably stop because I've seen it. I
- 5:43like it, but I don't have to continue. But because my wife is
- 5:47enjoying it, we are spending a great time together. And it's definitely not
- 5:51that I'm bored. It's so I feel amused, I feel entertained. And
- 6:00when you said exit, your mind isn't working in this way. I'd agree
- 6:02on exit, And in exit games even stress me because I feel dump which
- 6:10I am, Yes, but I'm feeling dumb in this type of game.
- 6:15In Detective, this is not the case, I think because of the cards,
- 6:18because of the database, you feel you think you are part of a
- 6:25team of detectives. Yeah, and so how what do you think of the
- 6:30writing? Do you think that the story is good? Do you think that
- 6:32the writing is good? Do you think it immerses you because you're a wargamer?
- 6:38Right, It attrits me that wargamers are all about theme, they're all
- 6:42about immersion. Yeah, they're very strict about that sort of stuff. How
- 6:46does it strike you? Yeah, I think it is. It was surprisingly
- 6:51it is surprisingly well. So first thing, I played the German edition of
- 6:57the game. German version, so it has to be localized. It's a
- 7:00ton of work to translate this stuff, to localize it. And when I
- 7:04opened the box and I saw that in English it's probably something like case booklet.
- 7:11It is it says in German Falbourg. When I said, oh,
- 7:15no, oh, how horrible is this because this means falling book or case
- 7:23book But I'd never term this booklet Falbourg, but bourch der Fele or something
- 7:30like this. And I said, wow, this can be bad. But
- 7:33I have to say I think it's Benjamin Schuwenheider who did the translation. He
- 7:39did a very good job and general level is good, in my opinion,
- 7:46good to very good. Yeah. All right, So the game I'm going
- 7:48to talk about is causing some controversy over at the five g Ford Discord,
- 7:55and this is the new Carl Chudduck game G and C. And I love
- 8:01Glory to Rome, I love Matynae. I think Red seven is good.
- 8:05What I like about Carl Chudduck is his games feel like nothing else. Yes,
- 8:11he doesn't feel like he has taken any influence from any other game designer.
- 8:18He is wholly unique, and I think the quintessence of that is Glory
- 8:22to Rome. Glory to Rome is just wild and brilliant and fragile, and
- 8:30the game can sometimes last five minutes, it can sometimes last an hour,
- 8:33and that is not bad within the context of Glory to Rome, because it's
- 8:37just so much fun. It is a card game that makes you think,
- 8:41but it's also outrageous in many ways. Matynae is a kind of distillation of
- 8:46that and a more sober version. Matina is much more stable as a game
- 8:50than Glory to Rome. I never played that one, so would you recommend
- 8:54it if you like a Glory to Rome. I think it's wonderful. Yeah,
- 8:58I think it's wonderful, and it is as I say, it's well,
- 9:01it's I only play it two player. I think it's brilliant two player,
- 9:05and it's much more stable. You're much more able to sort of say
- 9:09the game's gonna last twenty to twenty five minutes, and within that it's a
- 9:13super deep game that gives you loads of thought. They're a bastard to learn
- 9:16because his games are so counterintuitive, but once you learn it it's it's great
- 9:22and the G and C. I was eager to play it because I like
- 9:24Carl Chuddock right, and the G and C made me so angry. This
- 9:33is a game and I don't know why. This is a game that has
- 9:37had all of the fun developed out of it. So you see its sort
- 9:45of relation to his other games. And there's also tucking cards under sheets and
- 9:48all of that sort of stuff. But the rules, just the rules do
- 9:54two things. One they limit your ability to do anything, and they do
- 9:58that thing that I absolutely detest in games where your incentive is not to do
- 10:07the interesting thing. Your incentive is to do the boring thing because it's the
- 10:13thing that delivers you points, and so it's very frustrating. This should be
- 10:18a game of attacking and moving and essentially, essentially it's one thing. You
- 10:24build something, you take it back. You build something, you take it
- 10:26back it And like Carl Chaddick, each card has a special power and each
- 10:33card is unique. But the conditions under which you can this should be a
- 10:37game in which you're playing combos and banging out really crazy swingy stuff like Glory
- 10:45to Rome. But the conditions under which you can play the special powers are
- 10:50so arcane and so difficult to navigate that you end up just not being able
- 10:54to do it. Essentially you and I was playing it and it felt like
- 10:58at every time I was being hugely frustrated. And it's a very frustrating play
- 11:05experience. I found. And what is the talk of playing time of this
- 11:09game? Thirty to forty minutes. Again, it's not a long game,
- 11:13but you can't bloody doing anything. And I find it as a as a
- 11:20multiplayer experience, it's awful. It takes much too long. We played it
- 11:24with four players, and with four players it was a sort of two two
- 11:28and a half hours. Wow. Wow. With two players it was forty
- 11:33minutes. And you know that's a good play length. But if it's forty
- 11:35minutes of being frustrated and annoyed and given all of these I mean, the
- 11:39big forgiving, unforgivable sin for me is that you're given all of these wonderful
- 11:43options, you think, oh, I can do that, and then you
- 11:46go to play it and you go, no, I can't, because because
- 11:50in a two play game, it's all to do with whether you control island,
- 11:56and taking control off another player is so easy, easy that you set
- 12:01up something, and then by the time it gets back to you because you
- 12:05don't control, because the person is because not taking over someone's island or taking
- 12:11the island out of someone's control is the you have to do it, and
- 12:15so it gets back to you set something up, and then it gets back
- 12:16to your turn, and you can't do it because it's so easy to do
- 12:22the thing that takes the initiative out of your hand. It's it's very frustrating.
- 12:26It's a very frustrating game. Interesting, but also a good recommendation to
- 12:31stay away maybe from this title and move to Matina, because, as I
- 12:37said, I haven't ever played it, so maybe take a look at that
- 12:41one. I mean, when you're developing games, right, how often do
- 12:45you come up against that that you're playing a game and you think, Okay,
- 12:48the game works, but what you're asking the players to do is fundamentally
- 12:54not fun, and the path to victory is fundamentally not fun. It's difficult
- 13:01to say, because of course fun is a very difficult term in gaming.
- 13:05What is fun? What does it mean? But if I see on the
- 13:09table, if I observe that the people are bored or that they are distracted,
- 13:15putting out their smartphones, and then something is wrong with the game is
- 13:22something the people, the players have to be engaged and if this, of
- 13:30course frustration is even worse. It can be although this is a wrong term.
- 13:35It can be a good thing on the table, but not for the
- 13:41full play lengths and not all players. Let's say you are attacking me in
- 13:46a war game and I lose an important combat battle. I may be frustrated,
- 13:54but there is maybe a reason for it. I should have defended better
- 13:58or whatever. So in that con text, I may be frustrated, but
- 14:01everything's fine. But if all players are frustrated because they are setting something up
- 14:07but then they cannot cannot get it afterwards because they lost the initiatives, then
- 14:13something is wrong. But on the other hand, I'm not seeing this too
- 14:20often in games, because on the contrary, often I have games that are
- 14:28polished very well, but they have lost all flavor, they have lost all
- 14:35edges, and I do not like this. And this may be this,
- 14:39in my opinion, is often in German games too. This feels like a
- 14:43G and C feels like it was a crazy game and they've developed the fun
- 14:48out of it, and that's too bad. That's too bad. Yeah,
- 14:54because I think I think the thing with eurogames is they're beautifully put together and
- 14:58they're very balanced, and I think you're right. Sometimes German games can go
- 15:03for balance above all else Where Basically you want something that's a bit crazy and
- 15:09a bit swingy. Yeah. Yeah, this could be a topic for a
- 15:13future a bulletin maybe, because balance and replayability is an important issue, of
- 15:20course, but I think way too many people are concentrating too much on this
- 15:26and excellent, all right with that, let's move on to you shamelessly shilling
- 15:33your product in act cross self promotion. Uli blenem Guts. The German board
- 15:39game industry will tell you what's happening in Yeah, not too much has change.
- 15:48We are still working on apos Are a little bit of againest game by
- 15:52Stefan Ristaus. We are a little bit behind schedule, but hopefully everything will
- 15:56work out. It's a huge project, a ton to do. It is
- 16:03to repeat this. It has a base game, it has eight scenarios,
- 16:07and their scenarios are full games each a plus a campaign game where you are
- 16:12connecting all these scenarios or four out of the eight scenarios in a shorter campaign,
- 16:21and you can even take some stuff from one game to the next one.
- 16:25So it is a beast to test two and to develop well because it
- 16:30has cards, it has pieces on the board. Each and every item is
- 16:36connecting to the other, so it's difficult. But Stefan, in my opinion,
- 16:41he did a wonderful job, and in a couple of days we should
- 16:47have a special lending page ready for that game only for a pos against games,
- 16:52So please check this one out when it's out there, and you will
- 16:56even may get something that is exclusive via that page for the game, a
- 17:02minor item you should get me and Steve with a crack promo designers, you
- 17:08should get us to design another promo for it. Yes, and anything else,
- 17:15Raising Chicago anything, So Raising Chicago is basically done. It will move
- 17:22to pre order, probably a little bit earlier even so not May so probably
- 17:26also April and Adolchima Vita by John Simon and Migauny Italy. In the fifties.
- 17:34They had also a kind of economic miracle a vichats Wunda, so that
- 17:38is also moving up, probably from an August pre order to a July pre
- 17:45order from Shweedwork. So I'm very excited about these games, and also I
- 17:52love the graphics. So yeah, these are the items I'm really excited right
- 17:57now for and when they go for pre order, where do people go to
- 18:02pre order? So right now it's most probably for the German edition it's Spielworks
- 18:08dot D and it could be but this is undecided right now that it is
- 18:15a Spiedish media at the same time, but definitely not game found It would
- 18:19be website plus Spelish media maybe so Spanish media. For the listeners, is
- 18:26the German game Fund basically exactly. It is run by Happy Shops and spiel
- 18:32Offense either by by these guys and so it is a kind of crowd for
- 18:38funding funding for the crowdfunding for the German language people. Excellent, Well,
- 18:45let's move on to our topic of the month. Then, do you like
- 18:49informed opinions on board game topics that are important to you, then don't listen
- 18:55to Ben. It's our topic of the all right. So the reason I
- 19:00wanted to do this topic only is because I released a tweet. I released
- 19:06a tweet. God that's pompous. I. I tweeted out when one of
- 19:10the Spielworks bulletins went out and I said, this week's Spielworks bulletin and I
- 19:14explained it and at the bottom I put this is sponsored content, right,
- 19:18and I'm mentioning no names. But someone sent me a rather snotty direct message
- 19:25saying what you've got content sponsored on your feed? And I explained the deal
- 19:33that you know, this is a sponsored show. And as a result,
- 19:37there are certain limits that I have. I e. I can't review Spielworks
- 19:41games. For instance, I'm also sponsored by I said sponsored. Then I'm
- 19:47picking up too much German. I'm also sponsored by Grand Gamers Guild, and
- 19:51as a result, I can't review their stuff either because it's for me an
- 19:56obvious conflict of interest. And so I thought you'd be interesting to talk to
- 19:59a PubL was sure about your view on the sort of murky world of board
- 20:04game media and sort of where you see the state of media, but also
- 20:08your relation to content creators and all of that sort of stuff. So first
- 20:14thing I want to ask you, because you know you're a man of years
- 20:18uli you've been yes, you know, you've seen clay tablets, you've seen
- 20:25coracles, and you've seen steam trains, you know all that sort of stuff.
- 20:29And so when Spielworks was founded, what was the state of board game
- 20:33media at that time definitely different, definitely different. So of course I was
- 20:41already BGG, but way less people, way less games of course, so
- 20:49very different. But you were already checking BGG for content, for rules and
- 20:56other stuff uploaded to it. But especially in Germany, hardly anyone was using
- 21:02BGG or just really the core of the core gamers. And in Germany we
- 21:08had Spielbox magazine, which is still around printed magazine, and we had fair
- 21:15Play and some other more amateurish magazines, and of course because they only appeared
- 21:22that many times a year, you got it and the people and most of
- 21:26the games that were reviewed in there I'd already known about. I'd already played
- 21:33them or heard about them or determined for whatever reason, this and not gained
- 21:37for me. So because yeah, if you print something, the reviewer has
- 21:42to play the games and all this, you are always months too late,
- 21:47in my opinion, unless you want to have background articles or interviews with the
- 21:55designer. But this, in my opinion, by the way, to digress
- 22:00a little bit, this has become way better in a spearbox magazine now,
- 22:04but at that time they were really dependent on reviews, so reviewing games,
- 22:11so in a way, it was an easier environment because you basically knew everyone
- 22:18who was who was a reviewer, so very different. And so you know,
- 22:26spiel Works is a small publisher that has a very dedicated fan base.
- 22:32I assume you know you're always kind of looking for new people to be aware
- 22:37of who you are and what you do. So what's been your relationship with
- 22:41board game media over the time of Spielworks existence. One thing is I'm way
- 22:48too passive, that's for sure. So I should be. I should be.
- 22:52I should be more active going out and ask reviewers, so do you
- 22:56want to review a speed Works title? And pont and be more in touch.
- 23:00But this takes time, so it is something that I do not feel
- 23:10that I have enough time to. So I still know lots of people who
- 23:15are doing this, reviewing games or doing videos or audio podcasts, but I
- 23:25must I should be more proactive. But often people are coming towards me and
- 23:30asking me to review a game, and sometimes I'm sending out review copies,
- 23:36sometimes not because often I look at the page or that they are hardly doing
- 23:44gamers games. And sometimes it's also frustrating for me because in August September and
- 23:52this is no joke I get from all around the world. I get about
- 23:56five hundred requests for review for simple games. Ah, no worries, you
- 24:02do not have to send them. I pick the game up at Asen right,
- 24:06and then you look into the text I want to I'm interested in this
- 24:10title, and I'm telling them, yeah, well this title is coming out
- 24:12next year, or this game is sold out for three years, and I
- 24:17see they have spent no effort to look what is shpiel Works. And that
- 24:23is frustrating for me to so because I expect a standard level of information or
- 24:36of quality. And yes, I have a bad day myself. Sometimes my
- 24:44answers are too short, too rude, or whatever. I'm not responding at
- 24:48all because I'm forgetting it. This happens. But if you get in late
- 24:53September right in front of Asen, ten of these males a day, and
- 24:59not one is meant for Speedworks, but it's a male sent out to anybody
- 25:07on a mailing list at exactly, then I'm feeling, wow, this is
- 25:15now strange. So now I don't want to cast dispersions on my fellow members
- 25:22of the media, but I'm part of a Facebook group. It's called the
- 25:26Board Game reviewers and media group and I'm struck. I mean considering the lack
- 25:33of kind of craft within the board game media sphere when it comes to producing
- 25:38work right that there are never there are never tips on how to construct a
- 25:45review, or how to write a good sentence, or how to produce a
- 25:48podcast, or how to write a podcast outline or any of that sort of
- 25:52stuff. It's always constant posts about how to form relationships with publishers, which
- 25:59is mode for how to get free games right? And so to what degree
- 26:03do you think when you get these emails before ESA, it's just people trying
- 26:10to get free games out of you. Yeah, I think this is for
- 26:17generation. Generalizations are a bad thing, but to generalize here a little bit,
- 26:22it's often the case and I feel not well afterwards. So, in
- 26:27my opinion, considering the media right now, we have some brilliant reviewers,
- 26:34some brilliant media people in the gaming tabletop gaming is fear but we do not
- 26:42have let's say one hundred a little bit behind because they do not have the
- 26:48experience yet and they will maybe at the top in three or five years,
- 26:56because it's not easy to do this well. But I think we have a
- 27:00few people at the top, and then there is a thousand people or more
- 27:06in languages that do the same thing, and I'm bored. It may be
- 27:11me as you said, I saw the Steam locomotives and this maybe I'm just
- 27:18bored and grumpy. And so what gave you the ide because you approached me
- 27:26with the idea to do this show. What prompted you to approach me and
- 27:30why did you think this would be a good idea. Yeah, I think
- 27:34Shpielworks should be as I said initially, I should be more active there.
- 27:41So a day has only twenty four hours. I do my work and then
- 27:47I want to do something else in the evening, although I'm playing games in
- 27:51the evening of course too. So often I forget being in touch with people
- 27:57who could be very good for speedworks to reviewing the games. So I need
- 28:06something and a vehicle that tells something about Spearworks and about me out there.
- 28:14But I'm not trusting this to all people out out there. I want to
- 28:19talk to someone who I know. This is always important for me, and
- 28:29I tried this with my Twitch channel, which I still have. But I
- 28:33was very active during the pandemic. I had weekly shows and in twenty two
- 28:38only bi weekly shows, although it was a little bit more. But it
- 28:45also was a little bit too much for me because it was always I think
- 28:51this is important to have a fixed date for if you have a channel show.
- 28:56But it basically destroyed my Tuesday evenings. I couldn't do anything else.
- 29:00And as you know, although it was a spielworks Chat, was very informal,
- 29:06really very informal, and maybe people thought I'm switching on a Twitch and
- 29:12let's start. No. I prepared for this for each and every week.
- 29:17I prepared for it. And even although I did not even really edit the
- 29:22videos, you have to edit them a little bit, you have to upload
- 29:25them. It's a ton of work. And the good thing here and that
- 29:29is the main reason, of course is Ben, you are doing all the
- 29:30work. Well, that's true, but I'm very angry about spielworks Chat.
- 29:37I talked about this on another podcast because I came on spielworks Chat. And
- 29:41then a couple of weeks later you had famed board game designer Isaac Shalev on
- 29:45the chat. Yes, and when the show came to the end and I
- 29:48quote you said, this was the best episode of spielworks Chat we've ever had.
- 29:56Yeah, who am I Who am I? Julie? Am I bloody
- 29:59Choplive? Yeah, it's absolutely disgraceful. No, no, and let's be
- 30:03realistic. Of course, I asked Isaac too to do the podcast with him,
- 30:10and he said no, So you are my second choice. I mean
- 30:14being second place to fame Board Games. Isaac Shalev is not the worst thing
- 30:18in the world, right, so when you so so. Part of the
- 30:25reason I also wanted to do this is because I got a comment on a
- 30:27YouTube video and they were talking about a famous sport game personality who was dealing
- 30:37with a Spielworks game. And I don't mind saying who it was. It
- 30:41was Rado, and I can't remember what game it was, but it was
- 30:45fairly recently and whether this I didn't see the video, but I only got
- 30:48the comment, and the comment was that Rado said in his video dealing with
- 30:52the Spielworks game that he bought the copy of the game rather than contacted you
- 30:56for a copy because he wasn't sure whether he would like the game, and
- 31:02if he was going to do a negative review, he would fear the repercussions
- 31:07of saying something bad about the Shpielworth game that you would refuse to work with
- 31:11him in the future. So firstly, I assume that's bullshit, right,
- 31:15And secondly, bad reviews a part of the bargain, right, Surely you
- 31:23want reviewers to be trusted so that when they do recommend a game, you
- 31:27can be sure that the game they recommend is something that is good. Right,
- 31:33absolutely, First, yes, this is bullshit. So if there is
- 31:38a negative review, and if it's well done, I like to read this
- 31:45or like to listen to this, because I can learn. This is important
- 31:48and negative reviews are part of the life. If you're doing any creative work.
- 31:56There will be negative reviews in books, in movies, in games.
- 32:00That is one thing. And I listen to all criticism, but it does
- 32:07not mean that all criticism bothers me, not at all, because I know
- 32:15that ninety percent I could have an answer and I could respond to this and
- 32:21tell no, we did it because of this, but it takes way too
- 32:23much time. But the other ten percent, that is great criticism because I
- 32:30know, wow, this is from a people, from a person who really
- 32:34has some input there or some insights. So this is good in my opinion.
- 32:39It's a good thing. And if you're always getting great positive reviews.
- 32:45Yeah, on one thing, it's of course great. But on the other
- 32:49hand, I think are they honest? Are they always honest to me?
- 32:52And yeah? I mean that's always been my recommendation to people who are consuming
- 32:58board game content that if you watch a board game media creators content and they're
- 33:04always if they're always positive, they're lying to you. Because you can't possibly
- 33:09like every game and like and you can't also think every game is good.
- 33:14I think there's a difference between liking a game or not, or thinking a
- 33:19game is good or not. Sometimes they often overlap, of course, but
- 33:22you can I think you can legitimately say, Okay, this game isn't for
- 33:27me, but I think it's good. But that's not the same as saying
- 33:30I genuinely think this is a poor game, right absolutely. For example,
- 33:36I play some games where from a professional point of view because I want to
- 33:43learn something about them, So why is there that hype? And I know
- 33:49in advance that it's probably not my type of game? For example, a
- 33:52Zoul it's not my type of game, but I played it and I think
- 33:57it's brilliant. It's just not my type of game. So and I would
- 34:00not say, well, this is a zool is bad and nobody knows anything
- 34:06about it, so let's be fair. But to be fair, you need
- 34:13to know your craft already. Sure, and it is definitely not enough to
- 34:17play one game a day or two games a day. So many people play
- 34:22way more games than I do. But still, if you talk to them,
- 34:28or if they if you ask them, please tell me something about the
- 34:30game. Why is it good, why is it bad? Or what?
- 34:32What did did it bother you about the game? You know? Ah,
- 34:37Now, this is not really criticism. This is personal opinion or prejudice,
- 34:45prejudice because he they like that type of game or dislike it. Strange.
- 34:51So how is your now you've gone on to crowdfunding, how is your relationship
- 34:54with content creators changed? Not that much? Not that much because I'm doing
- 35:00modest campaigns, so I'm not in touch with one hundred people And can you
- 35:05please review this or I'm paying you this X amount of money for this?
- 35:12So you know, it's very easy in a crowdfunding campaign to spend fifty zerousand
- 35:19just for marketing. It's very easier, and you still could do more.
- 35:22Ask Jamie Stagmayer about his budget for this. So not too much has changed.
- 35:34I'm looking into a few videos, a few I'm trying to be in
- 35:38touch with a few so called content creators. And let's still or I did
- 35:45not say today. I hate the term content creator because, in my opinion,
- 35:52a creative person is diminished by that term, because we are all always,
- 36:00all the type creating content. If it's good content, that's a different
- 36:05thing. But I hate the term. I hate. It's an unfortunate thing
- 36:07though, because regardless, entertainment on the Internet is incredibly disposable. Yeah,
- 36:16I mean, of course. So for me, the reason I started this
- 36:21podcast in the way it was the Five Games to Do is because it's not
- 36:27entirely disposable. I think you can go back and listen, listen to the
- 36:31Ryan Knittzier episode and it's still relevant even though it's five years old. Right,
- 36:36yes, although although what I'm thinking of doing to keep it super relevant
- 36:39is after I interview someone for the podcast, killing them so they don't develop
- 36:44anymore, and so that's the last snapshot you have of them, which I
- 36:49think is a good thing. Yes, right, So when you look at
- 36:53so I think Instagram is the worst for this, but when you look at
- 37:00a lot of I was looking to see a review for a game about a
- 37:06year ago. And again I'm not mentioning any names, but I typed in
- 37:09the name of the game into YouTube and I got a number of reviews,
- 37:13reviews, and they're from organizations that I know for a fact do not do
- 37:20negative coverage of games, which instantly means they can't be trusted. You can't
- 37:25watch your review of that and get a decent perspective on what that is because
- 37:30they will always turn it to the positive. And I think it's for fear
- 37:35of losing money, or for fear of losing free games or whatever. I
- 37:38mean, why is it important that we have honesty within this sphere? I
- 37:45think, Again, getting back to the wider field of reviewers, I think
- 37:50it is a standard in movies and in books. Two, you need to
- 37:55have trusted, honest opinions. So otherwise, if I can't trust a person
- 38:02in reviewing it, I won't get back. But in my paper movie reviews,
- 38:07I have two or three persons. So if there's a movie review,
- 38:12I look at the name. I know them from their reading, from their
- 38:15writing, from their writing of course, and so I'm trusting them and I'm
- 38:20getting back to them. But if I know that so called content creator does
- 38:28only unboxing videos and only of the from the hype games, then I'm I
- 38:35do not like it anymore, or I won't get in touch. I also
- 38:39very much dislike after Essen on Twitter or now x or wherever the so called
- 38:46loot photos, because why are you doing this to show how important you do?
- 38:58You are that fifty publishers gave you seventy games and so this is the
- 39:04thing, right, I think it's interesting. I think normal gamers doing it
- 39:07is one thing. Yeah, absolutely, people who have gone round Essen and
- 39:10hoovered up free copies of games doing it just strikes me as rather distasteful.
- 39:15Mane. It is very distasteful in my opinion. And sometimes sometimes I exchange
- 39:24I scop a game at Essen with somebody and I do a photo because I'm
- 39:28really proud that I got the photo. So sometimes I know somebody is proud.
- 39:32But if you're doing this in the evening in your hotel room and on
- 39:37your bed, there are fifty games and I'm a day one loot at from
- 39:43Essen or Indianapolis Jenko, and I think, why why are you showing it?
- 39:47Is it to show your importance also to the publishers that maybe the ones
- 39:53that do not give you games in the future are giving you game too.
- 40:00And on top of that, if I see somebody with twenty or fifty games,
- 40:04why should I add to that pile? Because I know they cannot review
- 40:07these games anyway. So it is impossible. And so the ballgame industry is
- 40:15very small and a successful content creator. Part of that is knowing a lot
- 40:24of people within the industry. When I go to Essen, I meet a
- 40:28lot of people I know. Right, can you be neutral and authentic when
- 40:36you have friendly relationships with people in the industry? Do you think? I
- 40:40think so. I think so. Of course, it's a personality thing.
- 40:44Some people probably cannot do this, but I think it should be the norm.
- 40:54Yeah. So some reviewers I personally like more than others. That is
- 41:00one thing. It's a personality thing and a human thing. But still I
- 41:06think do you hate? Come on? Only tell us live on the podcast
- 41:08who do you Hate? There is this podcast that is in Berlin run It
- 41:17is called wife Chief for d I think, oh, it's the one that's
- 41:22hosted by that male supermodel. Right, no, right, But I think
- 41:34it is possible and it should be possible. And if you are thinking that
- 41:39a negative review is unfair. You can still get in touch and tell that
- 41:45person. I think this is met by this way, and normally they should
- 41:51respond to this. So you are suddenly in a dialogue that can be very
- 41:57fruitful for the future and for a future your game. So but I think
- 42:02some so called content creators think if they are doing a negative thing, this
- 42:08will end the contact with actual publisher and which is which may be actually true?
- 42:15I know some I know some publishers who've actually declared that on Twitter,
- 42:21which blows my mind. But I think for the most cases it's most people
- 42:24are mature enough, right, yeah, right, you should be mature about
- 42:28it and know this is the way of living. You're doing something great,
- 42:34creative, somebody will criticize you, if it's a friend, a friend or
- 42:39somebody you know. Well, they will criticize you for different things too,
- 42:43and you're not normally ending the relationship completely. So yeah, like I criticize
- 42:50you for the amount of you know, head are you use all the time?
- 42:54It is so called it is actually based on the stuff. Put buckets
- 43:00of the stuff. If you go get into your booth and essence, there's
- 43:02just buckets of hair dye. There's no room. There is actually people thinking
- 43:10I have a fridge in my room. It's not a fridge. I'm putting
- 43:15that stuff into that so called fridge so that I can grab a free box
- 43:22all the time. So it's mandatory, all right. So let's move on
- 43:27then to tails from the industry. Now, the big toe of the German
- 43:30board gaming industry, Uli Blade them will regale you with. So here we
- 43:39are tales from the industry, and I want to talk about We were talking
- 43:44just in the last section about relationships between reviewers and publishers, which can be
- 43:51beneficial or some can sometimes be antagonistic. But I want to talk to you
- 43:57about your relationship with other publishers because there would be an assumption that publishers on
- 44:05natural enemies because they're trying to sell to the same market. Yet, when
- 44:10we have gone to the Deutsche Schpiel Prize awards ceremony together in the past,
- 44:19it's very clear to me that you know everybody within the German gaming industry.
- 44:23I mean, none of them liked you, but you know all of them,
- 44:28right. It seems to me within gaming that publishers have very a very
- 44:34sort of collegiate relationship. So first you kind of explain your relationship with other
- 44:38publishers, and secondly, why you think it's nice in board gaming and what
- 44:44benefit that gives you. Yeah, so first, as we said several times,
- 44:50bort gaming still is a small industry. So and quite a few people
- 44:57are in this industry for quite a few years, especially if they are heading
- 45:01a publishing company. So yeah, after a while, you know quite a
- 45:07few of them. And because the industry is so small, at editing and
- 45:15developing and designing level, you know quite a few people and you are friendly
- 45:22with others because this can be very beneficial. So I may get a phone
- 45:28call, I have this game here, It's not for us, it's too
- 45:30complex, what do you think about it? Shall we send it to them?
- 45:34And of course I know if I have something, if I see something,
- 45:38I will do the same thing for this developer or editor. So I
- 45:43think at that level this is one hundred percent sure, true, true.
- 45:51I think this is great because it helps to build the industry and to make
- 45:59better for better games. But I think that Spielberg's is so small that I'm
- 46:05not on the radar on most publishers here in Germany at all. At the
- 46:10publishing level, they simply do not, And this is fine. This is
- 46:15not that I'm angry about this. They simply do not care what I'm doing.
- 46:22So I can talk to a publisher to do They had the CEO of
- 46:25a company, and this is great. They do not see me as competition
- 46:31at all, which is true, which is true, But do not think
- 46:38that at the publishing level asthmod Germany or Pigazzos or whatever, Cosmos let's name
- 46:46all of them or not or not. There is a high level of competition,
- 46:53a very high level of competition, because, as you said, they
- 46:59areting for shelf space. They want to sniff the trends of next year first,
- 47:06they want to set of trends. It is becoming more and more competitive
- 47:12each year. And of course the bigger boys with a bigger, larger muscles,
- 47:17they try to try to remove the smaller guys from their turf. And
- 47:24this is happening all the time. So I think this view that some people
- 47:30have all at essen everybody loves each other. Yeah, it's true, but
- 47:38it's also not true on other levels. And so you've developed business working relationships
- 47:45with especially American localizers. How do you do that? Yeah? Again,
- 47:53if you are along in this industry. You know quite a few, and
- 47:57I normally do this by writing if there is a new one or they are
- 48:01approaching me, and I try to talk to them so by skype, zoom
- 48:07or whatever, so that I get a general feeling. And in contrast to
- 48:13most small publishers, I try to attend some convention. So, of course,
- 48:17during the pandemic, I did not see the US. I'm not sure
- 48:23if I should see the US after Trump is God beware you know, yeah,
- 48:30I'm not sure if I want to travel to the US in twenty five
- 48:35Steven Cyrec's favorite president. So don't say anything, you're just making very angry.
- 48:42But I will travel to the US this year twice, and I will
- 48:47talk to lots of people over there, so to get a good relationship,
- 48:52to learn a little bit about the person behind it, about the attitude of
- 49:00this company. Is it just business business business, And now I need another
- 49:05half point percentage of a discount, otherwise I'm not interested? Or do we
- 49:10maybe have something in common? So I try to do it in this way
- 49:15because human relationships are still the core in gaming. We are sitting around the
- 49:22table, we are talking, we are not just playing a game, and
- 49:25so you're going to gathering of gathering of friends. Yes, is that a
- 49:30business trip or is it a pleasure trip? Or is it both? In
- 49:36truth, it is bos, but it is a business trip. It's definitely
- 49:39a business trip. I seeing a lot of people over there that are or
- 49:45maybe important for spielworks, and some I haven't seen four years, which makes
- 49:52it also from a friend perspective, very important. And of course I will
- 49:59I will get aim a lot, way more than over a year, and
- 50:04probably fifty percent of my pure game time is on games that I just want
- 50:09to play, just because I'm thinking, oh, this is interesting, let's
- 50:13play this. So, in truth it's both, but it's a business trip.
- 50:17And so just to wrap up, then, do you ever see a
- 50:20day where game studios are rivals like video game studios or tech companies or do
- 50:30you think board games will inherently always be collegiate and friendly. Again, I
- 50:37think at the levels I mentioned it will stay for the next decade or longer.
- 50:45But I do not know the video games industry well enough. I'm just
- 50:49a player there. And maybe in the video games industry at the editorial or
- 50:57design or development level, people are talking a lot as well, and maybe
- 51:05it's more from at the head of studio a level that there is a fears
- 51:10competition. I simply do not know. But I think if we stop in
- 51:15the gaming industry, in the board gaming industry, we stop talking to other
- 51:22editors, developers, or try to have designers just for us. So let's
- 51:29have them sign a contract for the next fifteen years and they always have to
- 51:34design for us. This will hurt the whole industry. Excellent, So let's
- 51:39move on to the final sections. I always do this every week. I
- 51:43realize. I always think, oh, we've got a bumper here, and
- 51:46so I'll do a bit that leads into the bumper, but there's no bumper
- 51:50here. Really, every month I do this, so just to wrap up.
- 51:52Then, first of all, where can we find spiel works on the
- 51:55internet? So easiest the thing is by male Uli U l I at Spielworks
- 52:02dot d E, which is also the web address w w W Spielworks dot
- 52:07d. Then you still find me at these wonderful platforms called X and Blue
- 52:15Sky. I mean, when you've declared that you're a great fan of F.
- 52:20Kennedy Junior, I mean fairly often in the past. It is simply
- 52:24wonderful now X of course is nightmarish is al musk. I'm ulli blaye so
- 52:32U l I b l e at both platforms if you want to talk to
- 52:37me. Excess is is horrible. Blue Sky is this cozy room where everybody
- 52:45hugs each one and you have no discourse at all, Which is which?
- 52:53Which is which? May be even worse? It can it may change because
- 53:00you'd probably know. Blue Sky is no open for everyone. It's not invitation
- 53:04only. So millions of people are streaming over to to to Blue Sky,
- 53:12but so far I haven't noticed any difference. And of course the final thing
- 53:17is we should blow up X blue Sky, Instagram meta, these have to
- 53:22disappear. I one thing we shouldn't blow up, though, uly is Patreon,
- 53:28and you can support five games for Doomsday by going to patreon dot com
- 53:31forward slash five g f D. And just to wrap up, OUI tell
- 53:36us in one minute what you have for spiel Works and what's coming up for
- 53:39spielworks. So what's coming up for spiel Works is IPOs raising Chicago and Vita.
- 53:49So please take a look at www. Shpeedworks dot e. You can
- 53:53even subscribe to the newsletter over there, which is very unfrequently infrequently, but
- 54:01please do so if you're interested. And right now I still have Matias Karma's
- 54:06wonderful Vima. I have the German edition of Root, which is still going
- 54:10very strongly after all these years, and a couple of other games. Look
- 54:15at products in my web store and hopefully you'll find something excellent. So Ulie
- 54:21Blaneman, thank you very much. I thank you Ben so thank you for
- 54:25listening, and come back next month for another Spielwerk