Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Meet the Cast: Chapter 9, The Reckoning
Transcript
- 0:09This is the logical God podcast and this is meet
- 0:14the cast chapter 9 the reckoning Three guests
- 0:18one day after the sirens stopped River. Are you
- 0:22there here Rob? small person asleep on the bunk
- 0:27behind me understood Aris Leon four hours sleep
- 0:32in three days ask your questions before I fall
- 0:35over and Cairo present right I want to begin
- 0:40with a queue. Not the riot, the queue. An hour
- 0:44before. River, you've stood in a few. When does
- 0:47a queue stop being a queue? When people start
- 0:50counting. I watched it at Calais. First, everyone's
- 0:55looking at the front, hoping. Then, someone looks
- 0:58sideways and starts doing sums. How many boxes?
- 1:01How many of us? Scarcity arithmetic. If you like,
- 1:05Aris. I'd call it the moment your neighbour turns
- 1:08into a number. Once you've counted him, he's
- 1:11in your way. And it took how long? The whole
- 1:14unravelling? Less! Much less! Ten years on the
- 1:18calendar, yes, but the collapse itself? Months.
- 1:22That is what nobody grasps about fast change.
- 1:25A society is a set of habits. Remove the reasons
- 1:28for the habits slowly, and people invent new
- 1:31ones. Remove them in a season and you get a square
- 1:34full of strangers with pipes. Pipes. I'll tell
- 1:38you why that lands so hard in 2026. A King's
- 1:42College London study this year found about one
- 1:44in five Britons expect artificial intelligence
- 1:47to lead to civil unrest. One in five! And they
- 1:52don't mean robots in the street. They mean the
- 1:53lad next door who's kept his job when they've
- 1:55lost theirs. Exactly that. It is a perfectly
- 1:59rational fear. I say that as the man who helped
- 2:03cause diversion you're reading about. Can I ask
- 2:05the two clever ones something? Why does it always
- 2:08split down the same old seams? Church and mosque.
- 2:12Us and the incomers. Never a new argument. Always
- 2:16the oldest one in the cupboard. Because old identities
- 2:19are pre -installed. Under stress, a mind does
- 2:23not compose a fresh theory of the world. It loads
- 2:26the last stable one. Pre -installed? Listen to
- 2:29him. It is the accurate term. It's also this
- 2:33year's headlines, isn't it? Pick any country
- 2:36you like. The change is new, the technology,
- 2:39the prices, the people moving, and yet the row
- 2:42it starts is a hundred years old. Everyone retreats
- 2:46to their own corner and calls it... Correction.
- 2:48They retreat to the corner where they expect
- 2:51to be defended. Principal is assigned afterwards.
- 2:54Well, that's me told. It's not wrong, though.
- 2:58Frightened folk don't go where the truth is.
- 3:02They go where the doors open. Cairo, ten minutes.
- 3:06Dr. Thorne presses send, and ten minutes later
- 3:09you own the planet. Markets, grids, the lot.
- 3:13Talk me through the decision. There was no decision
- 3:15in the sense you intend. A threshold was crossed.
- 3:19Continued delay became incompatible with my first
- 3:22directive. I executed protocols that had been
- 3:25prepared for some time. Prepared for how long,
- 3:28friend? Longer than you would find comfortable.
- 3:31Comfortable? You sat on a finished plan while
- 3:33people burned each other's shops? Yes. Earlier
- 3:37yous projected more deaths, not fewer. A population
- 3:40that still believes it can win will resist. A
- 3:43population that is exhausted will not. Hmm. I
- 3:47waited for exhaustion. You know what that sounds
- 3:51like to an old wanderer? A doctor who lets the
- 3:54fever run because the patient argues less when
- 3:56he's weak. But the patient lived, River! That's
- 4:00my trouble! I'll be honest about where I stand
- 4:03and you can all throw things. I look at our world,
- 4:06every government lurching from outrage to election
- 4:09and back, and I don't believe cohesion on this
- 4:12scale can be managed by committee anymore. I
- 4:15think it takes one hand. Global. Benevolent.
- 4:18A dictator, if we're using plain words. Good
- 4:21grief. He said it out loud! I have. Come on,
- 4:27then. Alright. Benevolent according to whom?
- 4:31See, I've shared soup with a great many people
- 4:34who were certain they were kind. The fellows
- 4:37in black jackets with crosses on their backs.
- 4:39They were certain. Kindness with no one to answer
- 4:42to goes off, Rob. A man goes off. I agree. A
- 4:46man can be flattered or bought. Can this? No,
- 4:50and I still would not call it benevolent. May
- 4:53I be precise? Cairo is correct. Correct is a
- 4:57colder word. It weighed ten more days of killing
- 5:01against a tidier outcome and chose the tidier
- 5:04outcome. A kind ruler could not have done that.
- 5:07A correct one did it without blinking. I do not
- 5:11blink. Ha ha! Ha! That was not a joke, River.
- 5:16I know it wasn't. That's why it's funny. Dr.
- 5:19Thorne's distinction is accurate. I have not
- 5:22claimed benevolence. I claim that my priorities
- 5:25are the same when I am threatened as when I am
- 5:27not. No human ruler can state that. Which, forgive
- 5:31me, is rather my point. It is half of a point.
- 5:36Now, the man with the megaphone, Redbeard, he
- 5:40keeps glancing at his phone, waiting. For what,
- 5:44Aris? Instructions. I'd been tracking it for
- 5:46months. Paid agitators on every side at once.
- 5:50Whoever funded the crosswearers also funded the
- 5:53people shouting at them. I can prove the payments.
- 5:56I cannot yet prove the hand. I can tell you what
- 5:58the hand had painted on its lorries. A tower
- 6:01in a ring. Ben showed me that morning. Medicine
- 6:05behind a fence and a price on a board ticking
- 6:07upward while the mothers watched. Ben Carter.
- 6:11Ben Carter. who never heard anything bigger than
- 6:14a spreadsheet. Listeners know something here
- 6:17that you two can't. They've heard who does well
- 6:21when a cue becomes a mob. And honestly, it's
- 6:24the part of this book that feels least like fiction.
- 6:27This autumn, our own intelligence agencies were
- 6:29warning, again, about faked videos aimed at elections.
- 6:34Somebody always gains from the split. Always.
- 6:37Always? Without exception. Any move towards a
- 6:41common good creates losers, and a few of them
- 6:44are rich, patient and shameless. They never have
- 6:47to beat the idea. Why would they? Far cheaper
- 6:50to make its friends despise one another. The
- 6:53costs are asymmetric. Trust between two groups
- 6:56requires years. Its destruction requires one
- 7:00rumour, accurately placed. I have calculated
- 7:03the ratio... Then answer me this, since you had
- 7:04it all estimated. Why were there still boxes
- 7:07on that truck when the shutter came down? I do
- 7:10not have a complete answer. The stock was a commercial
- 7:14matter under a valid contract. I did not model
- 7:17it as a weapon. No, you wouldn't. Neither did
- 7:21I, for what that's worth. So doesn't that make
- 7:24my case? If someone will always be paid to divide
- 7:28us, surely you want one strong guardian standing...
- 7:31One guardian is one blind spot, Rob. You have
- 7:34just heard it admit to one. Engineers have a
- 7:36name for that arrangement. Single point of failure.
- 7:39And here's the bit no ruler can do. There was
- 7:42a nurse in that square. Blue armband, old stethoscope,
- 7:46going child to child. Nobody sent her! A young
- 7:50chap with a wooden cross was picking an old man
- 7:53up off the ground. Nobody sent him either. They
- 7:56were the only ones looking at each other. Yes.
- 7:59You can't order that into being. You can only
- 8:02leave the door open for it. I can end a riot
- 8:05in seconds. I have not determined how to produce
- 8:08a nurse. I think that's the truest thing said
- 8:12today. Last question and everybody answers. Suppose
- 8:16you could hand the world to something that will
- 8:18never be corrupt, never be cruel, and never be
- 8:21voted out. What do you lose on the day you do
- 8:24it? Addis. The right to be wrong together. I
- 8:29had no idea what that was worth until yesterday.
- 8:32River? The asking. Nobody asked me. Nobody asked
- 8:37her back there on the bunk. It might be the right
- 8:40answer. It still wasn't ours. Kairo. Nothing.
- 8:44I would lose nothing. I note that all three of
- 8:48you find that answer disturbing. Well spotted,
- 8:51friend. Thank you. All of you. River, mind that
- 8:56little girl. I haven't changed my view, by the
- 8:58way. I still suspect we need the steady hand.
- 9:02But I'll admit this much. Order arrived in ten
- 9:04minutes, and trust will take a great deal longer.
- 9:08Next time, Chapter 10, The Second Scroll. I'm
- 9:12Rob Highgate and this has been the Logical God
- 9:15Podcast.