Latest / Sleepy Facts About History / How Did a Hired Cossack Band Open Siberia to Russian Expansion? - Sable Furs and Wooden Forts: The Mechanism of Russian Expansion | Sleepy Facts About History
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Sleepy Facts About History. In the
- 0:12late 16th century, a family of salt merchants
- 0:15on the western slopes of the Ural Mountains hired
- 0:19a band of armed Cossacks to solve a commercial
- 0:22problem. The Stroganoffs wanted access to richer
- 0:26fur grounds blocked by the Khanate of Sibira,
- 0:29a functioning Tatar Turkic state ruled by Kuchum
- 0:33Khan. The resulting expedition led by Yermak
- 0:38Timofeevich, did not conquer Siberia in a single
- 0:41campaign. Instead, it established a replicable
- 0:45pattern of merchant capital, river mobility,
- 0:49wooden fort construction, and fur extraction
- 0:52that would carry Russian power across 9 ,000
- 0:55miles to the Pacific over the next two centuries.
- 0:59This episode examines the true mechanics of the
- 1:02Russian advance into Siberia. It explores how
- 1:06armed bands traveling in shallow -draft strugi
- 1:09boats imposed the Yarsak tribute system on indigenous
- 1:12communities, demanding sable pelts as a marker
- 1:16of political subjection. It also details the
- 1:19varied responses of peoples such as the Khanty,
- 1:22Mansi, Yakuts and Chukchi who negotiated, resisted,
- 1:27or adapted to the scattered network of Ostrog
- 1:30forts built along Siberian river systems. I wanted
- 1:34to understand why the rapid expansion of Russian
- 1:37control across a map actually represented a thin,
- 1:41precarious network of extraction points rather
- 1:44than a unified territorial conquest. Some questions
- 1:48sound simple until you try to answer them, and
- 1:51the reality of how Siberia entered the Russian
- 1:54state reveals a complex history of private violence,
- 1:58indigenous agency, and gradual state absorption.
- 2:05In the late 1570s, a family of salt merchants
- 2:09in the western Urals hired a band of armed drifters
- 2:13to solve a commercial problem. The Tatar -Turkic
- 2:17state, blocking their access to richer fur grounds,
- 2:20stood in their way. The expedition they funded
- 2:24did not conquer Siberia. Its leader drowned within
- 2:27three years, and his forces scattered. but it
- 2:31demonstrated a mechanism of private violence
- 2:33and extraction that would carry Russian power
- 2:36across 9 ,000 miles to the Pacific, one river
- 2:39and one wooden fort at a time. In the late 1570s,
- 2:44on the western slopes of the Ural Mountains,
- 2:47a family of salt merchants faced a problem that
- 2:50would reshape the map of northern Asia. The Stroganovs
- 2:54held vast concessions from Tsar Ivan IV to mine
- 2:57salt and trade furs along the Kama River. Their
- 3:01operations brought wealth, but also vulnerability.
- 3:04To their east lay the Khanate of Sibir, a functioning
- 3:09Tatar -Turkic state ruled by Kuchum Khan. His
- 3:14territory blocked access to richer fur grounds.
- 3:18The Stroganovs needed protection for their caravans,
- 3:21and a way to expand their commercial reach. They
- 3:25found it not in the Tsar's armies, which were
- 3:28consumed by the Livonian War, and internal turmoil
- 3:31but in a mobile armed labor force that was already
- 3:36drifting along russia's southern and eastern
- 3:38frontiers these were bands of cossacks veterans
- 3:42of frontier warfare men with firearms and river
- 3:46craft who hired themselves out to whoever could
- 3:49pay this is where yermak timofievich enters the
- 3:53story not as a national hero sent by moscow to
- 3:57claim siberia for russia But as the leader of
- 4:00a hired band, contracted by merchants for a commercial
- 4:04raid, the distinction matters profoundly. It
- 4:09is the key to understanding how Siberia entered
- 4:12the Russian state. It did not happen through
- 4:15a single decisive conquest. It happened through
- 4:19a replicable pattern of private venture, river
- 4:23-based fort construction, fur extraction, and
- 4:27gradual state absorption. This pattern would
- 4:30carry Russian power across 9 ,000 miles to the
- 4:34Pacific over the next two centuries. To understand
- 4:38what happened, we need to picture the world these
- 4:40men inhabited. The Khanate of Sibir was no wilderness
- 4:45chiefdom. It was a successor state of the Golden
- 4:49Horde, centered near the confluence of the Itaish
- 4:52and Tobol rivers. Kushum's capital was at Koshlik,
- 4:57also called Iskar. The Khanate commanded tribute
- 5:01from surrounding peoples including the Khanty
- 5:03and Mansi. It maintained political and trade
- 5:07networks across the forest and steppe. Khushum
- 5:10himself was a Muslim ruler in a multi -ethnic
- 5:13polity, capable of fielding substantial forces
- 5:16and negotiating with neighboring powers. This
- 5:20was not empty land awaiting discovery. It was
- 5:24governed territory with its own hierarchies.
- 5:27economies and military capacities. The Stroganovs,
- 5:31meanwhile, were operating at the edge of effective
- 5:34Russian state power. Their concessions from Ivan
- 5:38IV gave them rights to salt deposits and fur
- 5:40trading. They also obligated them to develop
- 5:44and defend these holdings. The fur trade was
- 5:47already a major source of wealth for the Russian
- 5:49state and its elites. Sable, Fox and other pelts
- 5:54commanded high prices in European and Ottoman
- 5:57markets. The demand was inexhaustible and the
- 6:01best sources lay east of the Urals, in Kuchum's
- 6:04domain or beyond. The Stroganovs had commercial
- 6:07motive, capital, and Tsar -granted legitimacy.
- 6:11What they lacked was military force capable of
- 6:15projecting power across the mountains and rivers
- 6:18that divided their operations from the Siberian
- 6:21fur grounds. The Cossacks supplied that force.
- 6:25In this period, The word Cossack described a
- 6:29social military condition rather than an ethnic
- 6:32identity. These were armed, mobile communities,
- 6:36often multi -ethnic, frequently fugitives from
- 6:39state service or serfdom. They were experienced
- 6:42in river travel, frontier warfare, and the use
- 6:46of firearms. They lived by raiding, trading,
- 6:50fishing, and hiring out their services. Yermak's
- 6:54band was one such group. operating in the Volga
- 6:57and southern Ural regions before entering Stroganoff
- 7:00employ. The exact terms of their contract remain
- 7:04unclear. The sources that describe it were compiled
- 7:08decades later by chroniclers with interests to
- 7:11advance. But the essential nature of the arrangement
- 7:14is not in doubt. Merchant capital hired military
- 7:18labor for a commercial expedition against a neighboring
- 7:20polity. Around 1581, Yermak's force began moving
- 7:25eastward. It may have numbered 500 to 800 men,
- 7:30though even this figure comes from later, interested
- 7:34sources. They travelled by river, using shallow
- 7:38draft boats called strugi. These were wooden,
- 7:41flat -bottomed vessels, roughly 30 to 40 feet
- 7:44long, built to carry 20 to 30 men with their
- 7:48supplies and weapons. The strugi's flat hulls
- 7:52rode high in shallow water, but their real advantage
- 7:55was portage. When a river system ended and another
- 7:59began, the Cossacks dragged these boats overland
- 8:03on felled log rollers or carried their cargo
- 8:06in stages across the divide. Then they relaunched
- 8:10on the next waterway. The sound of wooden hulls
- 8:14scraping over logs, the weight of firearms and
- 8:17powder barrels shifted by hand, the cold water
- 8:21at the portage landings. These were the sensations
- 8:24of moving a small army across a mountain range.
- 8:28The Urals are not a single impassable wall, but
- 8:32a complex of ridges and valleys with river corridors.
- 8:35The Cossacks found their way through, carrying
- 8:38their boats, supplies, firearms and trade goods
- 8:42across the divides that separated European Russia
- 8:45from the Siberian river networks. This movement
- 8:49by river and portage would become the fundamental
- 8:51pattern of Russian expansion. The rivers were
- 8:55the highways. The portages, where one river system
- 8:59gave way to another, were the junctions that
- 9:03determined where Russian presence could advance.
- 9:06The expedition's military encounter with Kuchum's
- 9:10forces revealed both the capabilities and the
- 9:13limitations of this mode of warfare. The Cossacks
- 9:16possessed firearms, including muskets and perhaps
- 9:20small cannon these gave them advantage in set
- 9:23piece engagements against forces relying on bows
- 9:27and melee weapons but they were also vastly outnumbered
- 9:31operating at the end of tenuous supply lines
- 9:33they depended on local knowledge and on the willingness
- 9:38of some indigenous groups to provide guidance
- 9:40food or alliance against kuchum the chronicle
- 9:44tradition compiled later by the stroganoff's
- 9:48associates and by imperial scribes emphasizes
- 9:51divine favor and russian courage the archaeological
- 9:55and administrative evidence suggests something
- 9:58more contingent a small heavily armed group used
- 10:02surprise mobility and the psychological shock
- 10:05of firearms to overcome larger but less coordinated
- 10:08forces in 1582 yermak's band seized koshlik Kuchum's
- 10:16capital on the Irtysh. This was the expedition's
- 10:19apparent climax. Kukum himself escaped, and his
- 10:24forces dispersed rather than being destroyed.
- 10:26The Cossacks now held a fortified settlement
- 10:29in the heart of the Khanate, but they held it
- 10:32precariously. They were hundreds of miles from
- 10:35any Russian settlement, surrounded by peoples
- 10:38whose loyalties were uncertain. They depended
- 10:42on whatever supplies could be brought up the
- 10:44river system or extracted from the surrounding
- 10:46country. The seizure of Karshlek was not conquest.
- 10:51It was the creation of a temporary foothold whose
- 10:54survival was anything but assured. What transformed
- 10:59this precarious military foothold into a colonial
- 11:01project was the imposition of Yasak. This fur
- 11:05tribute system was the central mechanism by which
- 11:08Russian presence in Siberia became economically
- 11:10sustainable and politically meaningful. Yassak
- 11:14was not ordinary taxation in the Russian or European
- 11:18sense. It was a tribute paid in furs, imposed
- 11:23on indigenous communities as a marker of political
- 11:26subjection and a source of commercial wealth.
- 11:29The demand was specific. Sable pelts came first.
- 11:34But fox, squirrel and other valuable furs were
- 11:37also required. They were delivered to Russian
- 11:40authorities at specified times and places. The
- 11:45sable was the engine of the entire system. Its
- 11:48fur is dark, dense and improbably soft. It is
- 11:53thicker and more uniform than fox or squirrel,
- 11:55with a sheen that held its depth even in candlelight.
- 11:59A single prime sable pelt could be sewn into
- 12:02the collar of a nobleman's winter coat, or traded
- 12:06across the Ottoman world as a store of portable
- 12:08wealth. The animal itself is small, no larger
- 12:12than a house cat, living in the deep taiga where
- 12:15winters are brutal and hunting requires patience
- 12:18and skill. The value was not arbitrary. Sable
- 12:23fur repels water, retains warmth, and resists
- 12:26matting in ways that made it superior to other
- 12:29furs for both practical use and status display.
- 12:32This was the commodity that drew merchant capital
- 12:35across the Urals. This was what armed Cossack
- 12:39bands were hired to secure, and this was what
- 12:43indigenous hunters were compelled to produce.
- 12:46Refusal or failure to pay brought punishment.
- 12:50Violence, hostage -taking, and destruction of
- 12:54food stalls were common. Compliance brought not
- 12:57protection or representation in any modern sense,
- 13:00but a grudging recognition that might reduce
- 13:03the immediate threat. The imposition of Yasak
- 13:07around the Irtys and Turbol after 1582 marks
- 13:11the moment when Yermak's expedition ceased to
- 13:15be merely a raid and became a colonial extraction
- 13:18system. Armed bands moved through the surrounding
- 13:22territory, identifying communities. assessing
- 13:25their capacity to pay and establishing schedules
- 13:28of tribute. The process was neither uniform nor
- 13:32universally successful. Some communities negotiated
- 13:35terms, seeking to minimize their obligations
- 13:39or to play different Russian factions against
- 13:41each other. Others fled deeper into the forest
- 13:45or northward, beyond the immediate reach of the
- 13:48tribute collectors. Still others resisted violently.
- 13:52attacking isolated Cossack parties or refusing
- 13:56to deal with the newcomers at all. The chronicles
- 13:59record the successes. The administrative documents,
- 14:03read carefully, reveal the persistent difficulty
- 14:06of collection. Where chronicles speak of willing
- 14:09submission, the bureaucratic record shows repeated
- 14:13expeditions sent to the same territory. It shows
- 14:16complaints of populations that had moved beyond
- 14:19reach. It shows assessments revised downward
- 14:23when communities could not or would not meet
- 14:26the demanded quotas. The documents were written
- 14:29to serve the system, not to expose its failures.
- 14:33That they reveal difficulty even in their own
- 14:36terms suggests how incomplete Russian control
- 14:39actually was. The physical infrastructure of
- 14:42this system was the Ostrov. Picture a small wooden
- 14:46fort, perhaps 80 to 100 feet on each side. Its
- 14:51walls were formed of sharpened pine logs set
- 14:54upright in the earth and tied with rawhide or
- 14:57wooden pegs. At the corners, raised platforms
- 15:00allowed sentries to watch the river and the surrounding
- 15:03forest. Inside, there were a few rough buildings.
- 15:08A barracks for the Cossack or state garrison.
- 15:12A storehouse for Yassak pelts. Perhaps a small
- 15:17chapel with a wooden cross. The ground around
- 15:20the walls was cleared of trees for perhaps a
- 15:23hundred yards, creating a killing field where
- 15:26any approaching force would be visible. These
- 15:29forts were built in a single season from local
- 15:32timber, often rebuilt after fire or rot. They
- 15:37were small, housing a few dozen men, rarely more
- 15:40than a hundred. They were not grand fortresses
- 15:44but functional nodes in an extraction network.
- 15:47They served multiple purposes. They were defensive
- 15:51positions protecting the Russian presence from
- 15:54attack. They were collection points where Yassak
- 15:57pelts were gathered and stored for transport
- 15:59westward. They were bases for further expeditions
- 16:03launching armed parties deeper into new territory.
- 16:07And they were symbols of Russian claim, however
- 16:10thin the actual control might be beyond the palisade
- 16:13walls. Yermak himself did not live to see this
- 16:17system develop. In 1585, Three years after the
- 16:22seizure of Koshnik, he drowned in the Irtai during
- 16:26an ambush by Kuchum's forces. The chronicles
- 16:29describe his death variously. The essential fact
- 16:33is that the private venture lost its leader and
- 16:36its military coherence. Kuchum, far from being
- 16:41definitively defeated, continued to resist Russian
- 16:44incursion for years afterward. The Cossack band
- 16:47that had seized Koshlik was largely destroyed
- 16:50or dispersed. By any immediate measure, the expedition
- 16:54had failed. Yet the failure of the private venture
- 16:58opened the door to something larger. The Stroganovs
- 17:03and their associates had demonstrated that the
- 17:05Siberian fur grounds were accessible. They had
- 17:08shown that firearms and river mobility could
- 17:11overcome indigenous state resistance. They had
- 17:15proven that Yassak could yield substantial returns.
- 17:18The Russian state, preoccupied though it remained
- 17:22with European wars and internal crisis, took
- 17:24notice. Beginning in the mid -1580s, Moscow began
- 17:29sending military governors, called voivode, to
- 17:33organize and regularize the frontier. In 1586,
- 17:38Russian forces founded Tyumen. In 1587, they
- 17:42founded Tobolsk. which would become the administrative
- 17:45center of Western Siberia. These were state projects,
- 17:50not private ventures, though they built directly
- 17:53on the Stroganoff -Yermak precedent. The pattern
- 17:57established in these years would repeat across
- 17:59the entire Siberian landmass. Armed bands, sometimes
- 18:04state -sponsored, sometimes semi -autonomous,
- 18:07moved up the river systems. They traveled the
- 18:11Ob, the Yenisei, and the Lena. They built Ostrogs
- 18:16at strategic confluences and portages. They imposed
- 18:20Yasak on the communities they encountered. And
- 18:24they sent furs westward to enrich the Tsar's
- 18:26treasury and the merchants who handled the trade.
- 18:29The advance appeared rapid on a map. By the mid
- 18:33-17th century, Russian outposts had reached the
- 18:37Pacific. But this apparent speed conceals the
- 18:40true nature of what had occurred. The Russians
- 18:43had not conquered and occupied a continuous territory.
- 18:47They had established a chain of small, isolated
- 18:50forts, connected by river travel but surrounded
- 18:53by vast regions where Russian authority was nominal
- 18:56or non -existent. The Ostrog -Yasak system was
- 19:00not conquest in the Roman or Chinese sense of
- 19:03territorial incorporation and administrative
- 19:05integration. It was something more commercial
- 19:09and more precarious. It was a network of extraction
- 19:13points whose operation depended on the continued
- 19:16flow of furs, the maintenance of river transport
- 19:19and the varying responses of indigenous peoples.
- 19:23Some communities became regular tribute payers,
- 19:27integrated into the Russian system through coercion
- 19:30and adaptation. Others resisted persistently,
- 19:34attacking forts, killing collectors and retreating
- 19:37beyond Russian reach. The Chukchu of the far
- 19:40northeast, for example, maintained effective
- 19:43independence well into the 18th century. They
- 19:47defeated Russian expeditions and forced negotiated
- 19:49arrangements that recognized their autonomy.
- 19:52Even where Yasak was imposed, its collection
- 19:56required constant effort. The administrative
- 19:59records are filled with complaints about flight,
- 20:02evasion and violence. The indigenous experience
- 20:06of this expansion was thus neither uniform nor
- 20:09passive. The Kanti and Mansi of the western Siberian
- 20:14lowlands were among the first affected by Yasak
- 20:17after Yermak's expedition. They faced the full
- 20:21weight of the extraction system. Their communities
- 20:24were assessed for tribute. Their hunters were
- 20:27compelled to direct their labor toward fur procurement
- 20:30rather than subsistence. Their social hierarchies
- 20:34were disrupted by Russian demands and by the
- 20:37epidemics that followed Conte. Disease accompanied
- 20:40and perhaps exceeded violence as a cause of demographic
- 20:43catastrophe. Smallpox, measles and other infections
- 20:48to which Siberian peoples had no immunity spread
- 20:51through communities. The exact scale of population
- 20:55loss in the early decades is difficult to establish.
- 20:58Russian administrative sources were concerned
- 21:01with tribute -paying capacity. not with census
- 21:04accuracy. Indigenous oral traditions preserve
- 21:08memories of disruption that the official records
- 21:11do not capture. Other peoples experienced Russian
- 21:15expansion differently. The Yakuts of the Lena
- 21:19Basin, encountered in the 1620s and 1630s, possessed
- 21:24their own political organization and initially
- 21:27resisted Russian demands. Some Yakut groups negotiated
- 21:32agreements that preserved considerable autonomy.
- 21:35Others fought and fled. The Evenki, spread across
- 21:40the vast taiga, were more difficult to fix for
- 21:43tribute collection, and Russian control remained
- 21:46patchy. Each people, each region, each river
- 21:50valley presented distinct conditions. The Russian
- 21:54advance was less a uniform conquest than a series
- 21:57of local encounters whose outcomes varied with
- 22:01indigenous capacity to resist, negotiate or adapt.
- 22:05The state that gradually followed the frontiersmen
- 22:08was not a unified colonial administration. It
- 22:12was a developing system of regulation and extraction
- 22:15built piece by piece. Tsarist officials sought
- 22:19to bring order to the chaotic early period. They
- 22:23tried to standardize yasak rates. They tried
- 22:27to prevent excessive violence that might drive
- 22:29populations away. They tried to ensure that furs
- 22:33reached Moscow rather than being diverted by
- 22:36private traders. They tried to establish orthodox
- 22:40missionary presence. And they tried to create
- 22:43a judicial framework for frontier disputes. This
- 22:47regulation was always incomplete. The distances
- 22:50were vast. communication slow and the frontiersman
- 22:54cossacks traders escaped serfs adventurers often
- 22:58operated beyond effective control the state needed
- 23:02their initiative and their violence it also needed
- 23:06to contain their autonomy this tension between
- 23:09mobile frontier society and centralizing bureaucracy
- 23:13would characterize siberian administration for
- 23:17centuries The historiographical tradition that
- 23:21has come down to us carries its own distortions.
- 23:25The Stroganoff Chronicle, compiled in the 17th
- 23:28century from family records and local memory,
- 23:31naturally emphasizes the Stroganoff's foresight
- 23:34and legitimacy. The Remesov Chronicle, produced
- 23:37at the end of the 17th century with elaborate
- 23:41illustrations, reflects the imperial ideology
- 23:44of a later period. By then, Siberia's incorporation
- 23:50into Russia was presented as a natural and glorious
- 23:53achievement. These sources are invaluable for
- 23:57narrative detail but require critical reading.
- 24:00They tend to magnify Russian success, minimize
- 24:04indigenous agency, and present contingent events
- 24:08as inevitable outcomes. Modern scholarship, drawing
- 24:12on administrative archives, archaeology, and
- 24:15indigenous perspectives, has gradually constructed
- 24:17a more complex picture. But gaps remain, and
- 24:22some aspects of the early period may never be
- 24:24fully recoverable. What we can say with confidence
- 24:28is that the mechanism established in Yermak's
- 24:31time proved extraordinarily durable and expansive.
- 24:46Fur tribute. These elements created a replicable
- 24:50template that carried Russian power across the
- 24:53continent. But we must also recognize what this
- 24:57mechanism was not. It was not a swift unified
- 25:00conquest by a superior civilization. It was not
- 25:05an empty land awaiting occupation. It was not
- 25:09a state -planned expansion directed from Moscow.
- 25:12And it was not a process in which indigenous
- 25:14peoples figured merely as obstacles or beneficiaries.
- 25:18They were active participants. They resisted,
- 25:22forcing Russian adaptation. They negotiated,
- 25:26shaping the terms of tribute. They traded, supplying
- 25:30the newcomers with food and guidance. They fled,
- 25:34limiting the reach of extraction. And they suffered
- 25:38through violence and epidemic disease. The apparent
- 25:43speed of Russian expansion across Siberia has
- 25:45long obscured these complexities. On a map, the
- 25:49leap from the Urals to the Pacific in less than
- 25:52a century looks like conquest. In reality, it
- 25:56was a thin network of fortified points connected
- 25:58by river travel, surrounded by territories where
- 26:02Russian authority was contested or absent. The
- 26:06Yazak system extracted wealth. It did not create
- 26:09settled colonial society. The Ostrogs provided
- 26:13defense and collection points. They did not administer
- 26:17populations. The state followed and regulated.
- 26:22It did not lead the initial advance. And indigenous
- 26:26peoples, Kanti, Mansi, Tatars, Yakuts, Ivenki,
- 26:31Chukchu, and dozens of other nations maintained
- 26:34their presence, their cultures, and their resistance
- 26:37long after the first Russian forts appeared on
- 26:40their rivers. Ermak Timofeevich remains a figure
- 26:44of fascination, but we should understand him
- 26:48precisely. He was not the conqueror of Siberia.
- 26:52He was the leader of one precarious private venture
- 26:56among many that would follow. He was a hired
- 26:59commander who seized a capital, imposed tribute,
- 27:03and died in an ambush within three years. His
- 27:07expedition mattered not because it accomplished
- 27:09a permanent conquest. It did not. It mattered
- 27:13because it demonstrated a mechanism that others
- 27:16could replicate. Merchant sponsorship. Cossack
- 27:20manpower. Firearms. River mobility. Fort construction.
- 27:27Fur extraction. This mechanism would carry Russian
- 27:31power to the Pacific and beyond. But its success
- 27:35depended on conditions that Yermak and his contemporaries
- 27:38did not control. It depended on the responses
- 27:42of indigenous peoples, the ecology of fur -bearing
- 27:45animals, the economics of long -distance trade,
- 27:49and the gradual, uneven extension of state authority.
- 27:54Siberia entered the Russian state through this
- 27:57chain of small armed outposts. Each sought furs.
- 28:02Each depended on river routes and local knowledge.
- 28:06Each was surrounded by peoples who negotiated.
- 28:10resisted, fled, traded, and suffered. The apparent
- 28:14speed of the advance on a map conceals the centuries
- 28:17of indigenous agency and the negotiated contingent
- 28:20nature of Russian rule. The harsh geography did
- 28:24not make resistance impossible. It shaped the
- 28:27forms that resistance and accommodation could
- 28:29take. The state did not conquer Siberia in one
- 28:33campaign. It absorbed a frontier that private
- 28:37venturers had opened. regulating and extending
- 28:40a system whose origins were commercial rather
- 28:43than imperial, and the indigenous peoples of
- 28:46Northern Asia were never an empty backdrop to
- 28:49exploration. They were active agents in a long,
- 28:53uneven, and still unfinished history of encounter.