Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / What Causes A Dismissive Avoidant Attachment Style?
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, December 12th at 7 fourty PM Pacific Time 2024
- 0:30and I thought tonight that I would talk about how you develop
- 0:36a dismissing attachment strategy and take a look at that.
- 0:41We often talk about the development of emotional
- 0:45regulation as this series of things that happen starting in
- 0:48early childhood. We're born, we're largely auto
- 0:53regulators. Our brain stem is intact, our
- 0:57right brain is partially formed, our left brain is not that well
- 1:00developed. And so in the beginning, the
- 1:05first few months or so, we are really sort of in this
- 1:10experience of our cells without much capacity to to discern or
- 1:17distinguish the environment too well.
- 1:22And so in that stage, we're all auto regulators.
- 1:26We regulate ourselves independent of a sense of the
- 1:31world around us. And then as we develop to say
- 1:36three to five months in there, somewhere in that range, we
- 1:39begin to reorient toward people that come to take care of us.
- 1:44If they come reliably enough that we make sense for us to
- 1:50move out of the auto regulating into the external regulator.
- 1:54And then the external regulator takes care of us.
- 1:58And if they take care of us consistently enough that we
- 2:02don't worry about whether we can receive care from them, we begin
- 2:06to move into a collaborative experience of emotional
- 2:11regulation. The child, the infant, presents
- 2:15themselves in a completely authentic manner.
- 2:19The caregiver sensitively attunes, understands what the
- 2:23child is trying to communicate, and then provides the care that
- 2:27the child is requesting. And if the caregiver and the
- 2:30child can attune and sync up without a lot of misattunement,
- 2:35the child demonstrates what it is that they need.
- 2:38The caregiver learns what that expression is like and responds,
- 2:43and so the caregiver and infant enter into this collaborative
- 2:48exchange of the requesting for care and then the responsiveness
- 2:53of the caregiver. As the caregiver provides the
- 2:57care consistently, the child learns what it is that is
- 3:03regulating for them and then they begin to develop the
- 3:06capacity to do that for themselves.
- 3:09When you have a whole series of these capacities to regulate
- 3:15yourself in different kinds of circumstances, the child begins
- 3:20to take on a self mastery in terms of regulating themselves.
- 3:25The reason that this is important is because that
- 3:29capacity to regulate yourself independent of the caregiver is
- 3:35the the in some sense, the, the, the space in which you can begin
- 3:41to develop your skills as an explorer of the world and a
- 3:45seeker of meaning. You can go out into the world,
- 3:52you can discover the things that you need to know.
- 3:55If something happens and you get emotionally dysregulated, you
- 3:58have a reliable source of emotional regulator regulating
- 4:02in your caregiver and you can come rushing back to them.
- 4:04And you don't worry about whether you'll have access to
- 4:07them or that they'll be able to help you or not, because they've
- 4:10demonstrated over and over again their reliability.
- 4:15But if that doesn't happen, you have a caregiver who comes
- 4:19enough that you reorient into an external relationship with them
- 4:25for emotional regulation, but they're not reliable enough that
- 4:28you don't worry about whether they'll be available to you and
- 4:32whether they can help you. Then you become oriented toward
- 4:35them. This is the the origin of the
- 4:38preoccupied mind that you're constantly having to track the
- 4:42location of the caregiver so that you can and constantly
- 4:45having to seek proximity with the caregiver in order to be
- 4:49able to emotionally regulate. But if nobody comes reliably
- 5:00enough that you reorient toward an external source of emotional
- 5:05regulation, you stay in that auto regulating position.
- 5:10And that's really the origin of the dismissing attachment
- 5:14strategy in adults, a profound neglect for the child, the
- 5:22child's needs. Now, that doesn't mean that the
- 5:25child is uncared for necessarily.
- 5:30Sometimes in, in, in rigid forms of parenting, the the child is
- 5:35put on a schedule or things are provided for the child.
- 5:40But what's missing in that equation is the actual needs of
- 5:45the child. And the child is then put into a
- 5:47position of having to adapt to the care that they're receiving,
- 5:52rather than the care being oriented around what they might
- 5:57need. Neglect, of course, could also
- 6:06mean that a child is not cared for particularly well.
- 6:11But in order for a child to survive, you need to have basic
- 6:16sustenance, but you don't need to have the nurturing aspect of
- 6:20that. The other thing that happens to
- 6:24children that are profoundly neglected or put into these
- 6:27binds where really they have to perform for the the caregivers
- 6:34and they learn a process of idealization.
- 6:37So idealization is a process of amplifying the the appearance of
- 6:44goodness. Often the terms of that are are
- 6:48prescribed by the caregiver, what they think is useful, what
- 6:52they think is good. The child learns to perform in
- 6:55that way and at the same time it's an absence of anything
- 7:01negative. That's what the idealizing
- 7:03equation is. The child presents an ideal
- 7:08view, an ideal version of reality, and the caregivers
- 7:13reward them for that. And if they don't present an
- 7:16idealized view, they're not rewarded.
- 7:21Usually that is accompanied by withdrawal of affection.
- 7:28So here is a child that has to suppress their attachment needs,
- 7:35suppress their emotional needs, and put themselves in a place
- 7:40where they can perform an idealized version of the
- 7:44experience that the caregiver wants to have.
- 7:49And in order to do that, the attachment system is suppressed
- 7:56and the emotional system is suppressed.
- 8:00And if they do that, of course, then they get their needs met.
- 8:05So what you'll notice in people who grow up to be dismissing,
- 8:11they're quite transactional in the in, in the way that they
- 8:14conduct relationships. It's not collaborative in the
- 8:17sense that where in a collaborative relationship you
- 8:23would take on the whole care of a person, in the dismissing
- 8:28thing, it's quite a transactional.
- 8:30You do this for me, I'll do that for you.
- 8:32You do this for me, I'll do that for you.
- 8:36Actually, it's probably better if, if you get into a
- 8:39relationship with a dismissing person, when you understand what
- 8:43the transaction is going to be, you get the payment first.
- 8:48Because if you do that for them and they don't have to provide
- 8:51for you, they, they tend to not do it because it keeps the
- 8:55resources that they need to transact for later care.
- 9:01Now we sometimes think with dismissing adults that they're,
- 9:05it's a volitional, right, that they understand how a
- 9:09collaborative relationship might work and they just simply tune
- 9:13that out and decide instead to do a transactional based
- 9:18relationship. But actually they never really
- 9:20had the experience of somebody coming and attending to them
- 9:25without them having to present this idealized view.
- 9:29And so they don't think of it that way.
- 9:33They think what I have to do is learn from you what it is that
- 9:37you need me to present to you so that I can present it to you so
- 9:42that you'll give me what I want. So, and remember, it's an
- 9:48idealized version. So if they think that you want
- 9:52the sun, the stars and the moon, they will promise the delivery
- 9:56of the sun, the star and the stars and the moon.
- 10:01And as soon as you accept that and provide for them what they
- 10:04want in their mind, the transaction is complete.
- 10:09You might think, well, I'm going to get the sun, the stars and
- 10:13the moon, but it's never delivered.
- 10:17And you then might have some contest about that.
- 10:22But to the mind of the dismissing person, you wanted an
- 10:27idealized version. I gave you the idealized version
- 10:31and you gave me what I wanted. And so the transaction is
- 10:35complete in some sense. In the adult version of this,
- 10:41dismissing people most commonly form relationships with
- 10:45preoccupied people. And you may remember in the
- 10:48descriptions of preoccupied people, preoccupied people
- 10:52pretend to have a problem. They tend to be pretend to be
- 10:57helpless so that you can solve a problem for them.
- 11:01Which works really well with an idealizer because you pretend to
- 11:07have a problem which isn't really a real problem.
- 11:10They pretend to solve the problem, which isn't really a
- 11:14solution. But it's not a problem in the
- 11:17dynamics of the relationship, because the the problem that you
- 11:21needed solved in the 1st place wasn't a real problem.
- 11:24And so though the dynamic in that relationship is really the
- 11:28pretend problem, the pretend solution when you're talking
- 11:37about children or infants, you know, at 10 months old, we can
- 11:42test a child in the strange situation and understand what
- 11:47their attachment strategy is. And 70% of people will use the
- 11:53attachment strategy that they have at 10 months old for their
- 11:56entire lives. So attachment conditioning is it
- 12:00happens early and it and it's very stable.
- 12:06So a child who is neglected, their needs, the needs of the
- 12:14individual, those authentic experiences that they need are
- 12:19profoundly neglected. And instead they're put in a
- 12:23situation where they have to provide an idealized version of
- 12:27what the reality of that experience is in order to get
- 12:31the care that they want. Suppressing the attachment
- 12:36system means that the exploration system is left on in
- 12:42in in a secure dynamic. Of course, you're out exploring
- 12:46exploring that. If something dysregulates you,
- 12:49the attachment system turns on, which deactivates the
- 12:53exploration system so that you can come back to the people that
- 12:57will help you regulate. But because dismissing people
- 13:00suppress the attachment system, their exploration system remains
- 13:06on, so they tend to be able to explore pretty well.
- 13:13We might talk about primary and secondary exploration in this
- 13:17way because dismissing people use a transactional basis for
- 13:24acquiring the needs that they have.
- 13:28They're oriented around gathering the the time, energy
- 13:31and resources off in the social position or the power position
- 13:36that will allow them to be able to negotiate and transact the
- 13:41care that they need. So that their exploration is
- 13:47really oriented around the secondary exploration, the
- 13:50gathering of time, energy and resources.
- 13:53And they have the same difficulty of a truncated
- 13:59primary exploration that preoccupied people and
- 14:03disorganized people had. They don't see the value of it
- 14:06enough to pursue it because they also suppress the conscious
- 14:15experience of emotion. They have a hard time
- 14:19understanding what it is that really is a source of meaning
- 14:24for them, and really are much more focused on social status
- 14:30and power and resources in order to transact for the care that
- 14:34they want. Because you suppress awareness
- 14:47of your emotions consciously does not mean you don't have the
- 14:50emotions, and does not mean the emotions aren't informing the
- 14:55decision making process. You just don't have the
- 14:59conscious information that that's what's happening, and so
- 15:03you often don't have the brakes that you might need to have in
- 15:07order not to cause suffering in in the people around you.
- 15:16When we talk about empathy, we talk about it in a number of
- 15:19levels. The first level is this visceral
- 15:24response to the witnessing of somebody's physical or emotional
- 15:28pain. We talk about being able to read
- 15:33facial expressions in body language and interpret the
- 15:36emotional meaning of that. The third is the empathetic
- 15:40experience of with the empathetic experience of
- 15:45compassion, where you feel in your body that the emotional
- 15:50state of someone else and we really do use the comparison
- 15:56between the 2nd and the third level of empathy to understand
- 16:00whether somebody is telling us the truth or not.
- 16:04If the second level, the external presentation of facial
- 16:07expressions and body language matches the felt sense of the
- 16:12the person, then we tend to think that they're telling us
- 16:16the truth. Secure people also have a fourth
- 16:20aspect that they pay attention to, which is whether you do what
- 16:23you say you're going to do and whether you don't do what you
- 16:26say you're not going to do. But dismissing people,
- 16:29preoccupied people, disorganized people don't really track that
- 16:33because in the childhood experiences they had, the
- 16:36caregivers never really did what they said said they were going
- 16:41to do it in order to reduce the pain of that.
- 16:45Most people in childhood split that off.
- 16:47And so they don't really monitor whether if somebody does what
- 16:50they say they're going to do, they rely more the, the, the
- 16:55explanations that people provide, the narratives that
- 16:59people provide. Dismissing people because they
- 17:03shut down the embodied sense of emotion are really blind in
- 17:09terms of being able to determine whether or not somebody is
- 17:13telling the truth in that way. In fact, it's hard for them to
- 17:16understand what's going on with another person without it being
- 17:20offered to them in words. And depending on how profound
- 17:26the neglect was and how early it happened, many dismissing people
- 17:30are unable to read facial expressions in body language to
- 17:37understand what what representation the person that
- 17:41they're dealing with is making. How do we understand facial
- 17:49expressions in body language? We learn it from the experience
- 17:54of the caregiver empathetically attuning to us.
- 17:57So we're an infant, We're making an expression.
- 18:01The caregiver sensitively attunes, empathetically connects
- 18:05to us, and then they mirror back to us in their facial
- 18:09expressions the experience that they're understanding we're
- 18:13having. And so we begin very early to
- 18:17associate the body sensations that we have with the facial
- 18:22expressions of the caregiver that they're reflecting to us.
- 18:25And they're probably narrating the experience.
- 18:30Or which is to say, oh, you seem sad, Oh, you seem happy, you
- 18:37seem frightened, you seem glad, whatever it is the experience is
- 18:41having. But kids that are profoundly
- 18:43neglected actually don't have that experience of the
- 18:46caregivers narrating. They don't have the care.
- 18:49The experience of the caregivers, reflecting back to
- 18:53them what their experiences and tying it to the sensations in
- 18:59the body so that they can learn to map that second aspect of
- 19:08empathy. And depending on the degree of
- 19:11the shutdown and the degree of the neglect, some distressing
- 19:17people are completely blind in terms of recognizing the subtle
- 19:24facial expressions and body language that people offer as
- 19:28part of communication. And they rely strictly on the
- 19:33narrative, on the words and they're, they're actually fairly
- 19:40easily manipulated because they don't have any way of validating
- 19:44what people say Christian. George, I wonder if like in the
- 19:52sense that dismissing people have maybe certain deficits
- 19:56around recognizing emotions, but can have like can be in touch
- 20:02with maybe anger and certain emotions.
- 20:07Do they? Despite maybe having not a great
- 20:10attunement to the emotions and others, there are certain
- 20:13emotions, like anger perhaps, that they are pretty good at
- 20:18recognizing. You know, you often have the
- 20:22experience of a distressing person yelling at you in a very
- 20:26angry manner. And when you say something like,
- 20:29why are you so angry that they're just as often would say
- 20:32I'm not angry. So it really depends on how
- 20:37complete the the suppression is consciously.
- 20:44Now some charismatic and capable manipulators that are dismissing
- 20:51actually have a highly developed second level.
- 20:53They can read facial expressions in body language, but most of
- 20:58the time the the method that they use is to elicit from you
- 21:01without you really noticing the things that you would like, but
- 21:06that that then they can wrap it up in an idealized version and
- 21:09feed it back to you. I remember I, I was dating
- 21:14somebody in the the 80s and I just kept having the experience
- 21:20of over and over again him saying to me the things that I
- 21:24had been longing my entire life to hear somebody say to me,
- 21:28right? It was just absolutely
- 21:31intoxicating, the one of the great love bombers of my life.
- 21:40But my roommate said what the what are you talking about?
- 21:43He 1/2 an hour ago he was asking you all these questions about
- 21:47all this stuff. He just fed it back to you and
- 21:50I, I had done it so skillfully. I hadn't noticed that he was
- 21:54eliciting from me the the things that I had wanted to hear.
- 21:57So he was quite skilled at that, but but he didn't, when I
- 22:06confronted him about it, he didn't have a problem with it.
- 22:08He said yes, of course I did. That's what you're supposed to
- 22:11do, right? That's how the world works.
- 22:16I elicit from you the things that you want.
- 22:18I buff them up and shine them up and I present them in this
- 22:22golden fashion and you feel fantastic.
- 22:26And then you give me what I want and that's a complete exchange.
- 22:33And no, there was no follow through on any of it.
- 22:35But there was never the intention for the follow through
- 22:38because they didn't think follow through was part of the the the
- 22:42bargain because it wasn't in the family system that they grew up
- 22:50in the family system they grew up and they do the idealizing
- 22:54thing and they get the reward and that's complete.
- 22:58And when you're in that kind of family system, nobody, I guess,
- 23:01is really expecting there to be delivery of what you actually
- 23:04say is going to be delivered because it's never delivered.
- 23:10But it's when you have the expectation that actually
- 23:13they're going to do something, what they're going to do, what
- 23:17they say they're going to do, they have a problem with it.
- 23:22But of course, if you're not monitoring whether somebody does
- 23:25what they say they're gonna do, it takes a long time to figure
- 23:28out that they're not actually delivering on anything that
- 23:32making sense. I I had AI had something happen
- 23:38like 10 or so years ago. I was at a bar with friends and
- 23:42friends of friends, and a friend of a friend knew that I played
- 23:47violin but had never heard me play.
- 23:50And he turned to someone else that we're just meeting for the
- 23:54first time. And he's like, he's like,
- 23:57Christian is like one of the best violinists that I he's like
- 24:01a great violinist. And I was like, I was totally
- 24:06turned off by that. But it didn't work.
- 24:09It didn't work that time. But I was like, OK, when you
- 24:12were saying that, it made me think of that story.
- 24:14I was like, OK. So you have an expectation that
- 24:18that there's a little more reality in the narrative.
- 24:22Maybe, maybe I could be seduced, but that one was just too
- 24:25blatant. Well, let's just chalk it up to
- 24:33the, the lack of skill in, in the dismissing person not
- 24:37eliciting what it was that he needed to feed to you and just
- 24:41assuming what it was right. The you know, for a lot of us,
- 24:54and when you encounter somebody who's dismissing and good at
- 24:57being dismissing and, and, and good at idealizing, it's quite
- 25:04shocking. When there's no delivery and and
- 25:13we often can get into a mind state of it's volitional that
- 25:16they know that they're they're misrepresenting, they know
- 25:21they're lying, that they didn't intend to deliver.
- 25:25But it really is important I think to understand that
- 25:28delivery is not part of idealizing.
- 25:32Idealizing is the presentation. They present idealized view and
- 25:39you have the emotional experience of it, which is very
- 25:43intoxicating. And that's their contract
- 25:48completed. And then you're supposed to
- 25:49provide for them the thing that they're they're going for.
- 25:55So that if you're not willing to be in a, in a, in a relationship
- 26:00where it really is the this sort of suspended from reality
- 26:06exchange, it's disconcerting. So that's why these patterns of
- 26:19relationship begin to form, dismissing people with
- 26:21preoccupied people. I pretend to have a problem, you
- 26:24pretend to solve it. And so there's no real friction
- 26:28in that exchange while you're pretending to solve it.
- 26:31I get the proximity I like and I get from you that elevation that
- 26:37the that juice of what a commanding capable person I am.
- 26:45And the reason that dynamic is important is because at the core
- 26:50of the dismissing person is the terrible sadness of a childhood
- 26:56where nothing they offered of their authentic experience was
- 27:00ever acceptable or valued. Nothing they they tried nothing
- 27:09that they could do could get the caregivers to respond to their
- 27:13authentic needs. And so those needs were never
- 27:16met. And that the so those attachment
- 27:24needs arising over and over again and being presented to the
- 27:27caregivers are are often simply either never attended to, which
- 27:33is the neglect aspect, or they're actively rejected.
- 27:38So you also notice in dismissing people is a an extreme
- 27:44sensitivity to rejection. This is actually abandonment
- 27:48fear, but they don't experience it as abandonment fear, they
- 27:52experience it as rejection. And So what you may, Christian,
- 27:56as you were describing the anger that is often expressed by
- 28:00dismissing people rather than being genuine anger is again a
- 28:07strategy for getting the thing that they want.
- 28:13And you'll notice that there's a pattern of seduction and
- 28:16bullying, I like to call it, but idealizing and derogating, it's
- 28:20very common dismissing people, they try to seduce you with the
- 28:25idealizing. And if that doesn't work, then
- 28:27they they come at you with the derogating anger, Christian.
- 28:33So I'm curious if there's kind of dismissing people get really
- 28:39dunked on in the in the sort of attachment discourse.
- 28:42But I'm curious if they don't do this with secure people, they
- 28:49kind of figure out who who this would work on the kind of
- 28:52idealization or the derogation or if they just are like are
- 28:59willing to kind of turn off secure people that are tracking
- 29:02this more more carefully. I don't you're you're again
- 29:06thinking that it's volitional and it's not.
- 29:09They don't have the skill set for secure functioning
- 29:12relationships and secure people will not accept a A1 sided
- 29:17exchange and so they don't really relate too well with
- 29:20secure people. I guess I mean, I, I don't mean
- 29:24it to be volitional, but in the sense that we're kind of, we're
- 29:28always getting cues from the outside world and making small
- 29:31adjustments and maybe that's the sort of unconscious or
- 29:34subconscious process. They're really not good at
- 29:39picking up cues, OK. So it's kind of throw up, throw
- 29:44stuff out and just whatever sticks, they proceed in that
- 29:47direction. And that's usually with
- 29:49insecurely attached people. Well, dismissing people are
- 29:54insecurely attached, so they don't, they're not
- 29:59empathetically attuned to people.
- 30:02They have the capacity to sometimes they have the capacity
- 30:08for the the second level of empathy.
- 30:11They read people pretty well, but most of the time they're
- 30:15soliciting it in language. They're very cognitively
- 30:21oriented. They're very language oriented.
- 30:24They, they want you to tell them what it is that they need to
- 30:29know about you so that they can push it out in an idealized
- 30:34form. And the ones that are really
- 30:38capable of that are really good at eliciting the material that
- 30:41they need from you without you really noticing it and then
- 30:44feeding it back to you in a way that's intoxicating.
- 30:52They never deliver on it, on what they provide, but what they
- 30:55are providing is the intoxication.
- 30:57And that's that, that idealized intoxication.
- 31:02The colloquial term for it in our culture is love bombing.
- 31:06I don't know if you've heard that before, but that's what
- 31:08really that mechanism is. And in in that state of
- 31:12intoxication, you tend to be generous in giving them what
- 31:16they want, which is this inflation, right?
- 31:22And the reason they want to be inflated is at the core of their
- 31:26authentic experiences, the terrible sadness that nothing
- 31:30they've ever been able to do could get anyone to be
- 31:33interested in them, to see them, to value them, to take care of
- 31:37them. They've always had to pump up
- 31:40this false sense of self in order to get the care that they
- 31:46needed. But it's always been
- 31:47transactional. It's never been freely offered
- 31:51to them. And because they don't have the
- 31:52experience of that, that delight, even they don't have
- 31:58the experience of delight in the the secure sense of that, where
- 32:01you simply delight in the beingness of somebody.
- 32:05It's always been transactional. They have had to produce this
- 32:11idealized version in order to get a response, but it's a
- 32:15response to the idealization, not a delight that comes freely,
- 32:22that's freely offered. You know, most of the time we've
- 32:31learned the relationship to the terrible sadness, and each of
- 32:35the different attachment strategies has a terrible
- 32:39sadness, but the elements of the terrible sadness are different.
- 32:43The terrible sadness in the preoccupied person is really
- 32:49around the abandonment of self in order to pretend to be what
- 32:53somebody else wants, and the abandonment of self in the
- 32:57dismissing a person. It's different in the sense that
- 33:02at the core of it is this belief that that that you're incapable
- 33:08of getting people to take care of you, that there's something
- 33:11fundamentally wrong with you that nobody would want to, that
- 33:15that is a terribly painful thing.
- 33:18And yes, dismissing people tend to get a bad rap in in the adult
- 33:23world. But if you really pay attention
- 33:27to the experience of the childhood, the profound neglect
- 33:30that they've experienced in many of them, this terrible rejection
- 33:35over and over and over again that they experience, it's easy
- 33:40to find compassion, I think, for the dilemma.
- 33:45And the strategy of shutting down the attachment experience
- 33:49means that you don't actively attempt to form intimate
- 33:53relationships, which results in a loneliness that's almost
- 33:58unbearable. One of the reasons why they move
- 34:02in that track transactional way is to try and address the
- 34:06loneliness that comes from being disconnected from everyone and
- 34:11they're not feeling. So they they, it's very
- 34:14difficult for them to identify what a meaningful experience is
- 34:18consciously and to enjoy that because they don't have that
- 34:24feeling sense. And, and really, it can be quite
- 34:30disconcerting to a dismissing person if the only way that they
- 34:34know what's going on with you is be able to elicit you telling
- 34:38them and you get mad at them and you stop talking to them.
- 34:43They go into a terrible state because they're completely
- 34:49disconnected and completely blind to what's going on.
- 34:53And they don't don't know how to respond to that.
- 35:03So what is the way out of that? If you find that you're
- 35:08dismissing, what we suggest is that you begin by pulling the
- 35:15filter of the embodied emotional states out of that process of
- 35:23making conceptual reality so you have the capacity to sense the
- 35:28the object that can be sensed. When there's contact, the
- 35:31consciousness of the sensing experience arises.
- 35:35It's evaluated for urgency. Does it need immediate
- 35:38attention? Does it not matter?
- 35:39Is there time for a pleasant experience?
- 35:42And then it's mapped on to the perceptual database and these
- 35:45meaning threads are attached and between the rolling of ultimate
- 35:50reality and defining meaning and creating the, the, the tableau
- 35:54of conceptual reality is where these filters go.
- 35:57And if you have a filter that doesn't allow any emotional
- 36:01experience consciously, when you create conceptual reality, it's
- 36:05without emotion. And So what we, through the the
- 36:10practice of meditation, pull out the the filter and allow the
- 36:16conscious experience of emotion. Then what happens of course is
- 36:22you have the conscious experience of emotion, which you
- 36:24have no skills to regulate consciously because you've never
- 36:27really had those experiences before.
- 36:30So there's a kind of rough period between not feeling
- 36:33anything, feeling things, but not having good strategies to
- 36:38regulate them, and then beginning to develop the
- 36:41strategies to regulate them. Once you have that feeling life
- 36:47back and conscious experience of it, you can really begin
- 36:53orienting away from an exclusive secondary pursuit of the
- 36:58gathering of resources into things that might be meaningful
- 37:02to you. And then you can begin to attend
- 37:06to activating the attachment system so that you can begin to
- 37:14form relationships. Once you have the capacity to
- 37:18feel consciously again, the the value of having reliable
- 37:24regulators comes up more. And so you can begin to see why
- 37:29it would be useful to you as a dismissing person to have these
- 37:35reliable relationships. Now remember that just because
- 37:40you're not consciously experiencing emotion doesn't
- 37:44mean that you don't need to be regulated.
- 37:47And one of the, the experiences that dismissing person has in
- 37:51relationship to a preoccupied person is that the preoccupied
- 37:56person experiences the empathetic emotional experience
- 38:01of someone else's, the primary experience.
- 38:04And they spend a lot of effort in regulating the empathetic
- 38:08experience of someone else. So in a relationship between the
- 38:12dismissing and a preoccupied person, the preoccupied person
- 38:15is emotionally regulating the dismissing person.
- 38:20And so the the trade for proximity, the a preoccupied
- 38:25person has physical closeness, but what the dismissing person
- 38:29gets out of that is emotional regulation.
- 38:31So they're, they really like to have that kind of relationship
- 38:36happening. They like the preoccupied person
- 38:39there because preoccupied people tend to be quite emotionally
- 38:43dysregulated. This is not a drawback for
- 38:46dismissing people because they don't feel it.
- 38:49They don't have an empathetic experience.
- 38:51So you could be a raving preoccupied person completely in
- 38:56tantrum mode and it wouldn't be a problem for a dismissing
- 38:59person because they don't feel it, but it would be a problem
- 39:03for anybody else who has a capacity for empathy because the
- 39:09the the experience of your dysregulation over time would be
- 39:13off putting. But once of course you allow the
- 39:17experience of emotion consciously, you can't do that
- 39:22piece anymore. So it's one of the one of the
- 39:25challenges to renegotiating relationships.
- 39:38You need to change your mind about the value of attachment in
- 39:42order to enter into an attachment relationship.
- 39:44But you know, dismissing. People are good at exploring and
- 39:47once they understand that actually they can take bigger
- 39:50risks emotionally if they have somebody who regulates them
- 39:55well, then suddenly having a reliable relationship takes on
- 40:02more value. The other piece that needs to
- 40:11change in a dismissing person is in.
- 40:14This is also part of seeing the value of an attachment
- 40:17relationship is an interest in someone else.
- 40:22This is a particularly challenging for dismissing
- 40:25people because they never experienced people being
- 40:28interested in them. The end when when their
- 40:34emotional life comes back on, they often experience longing
- 40:38for that. But in dismissing people, that
- 40:41belonging experience is often a sadness, or if there's a lot of
- 40:45rejection, sadness and shame. And so it's a converting of that
- 40:50sadness and that shame back into a longing for for somebody to be
- 40:55able to see them. And if they pick somebody who
- 40:59actually is interested in in them and interested in seeing
- 41:02and knowing them, they begin to learn the value of that.
- 41:07And that opens up the possibility of a collaborative
- 41:10exchange where they allow themselves to express
- 41:15authentically who they are and the other person is interested
- 41:19in that. And then do they exchange that
- 41:23with the other person by being interested in them?
- 41:28In a, in a typical dynamic between a dismissing person and
- 41:33someone else, the dismissing person does not provide that
- 41:38kind of interest or care. It's it's really the reason that
- 41:42they don't is it's unknown to them.
- 41:44They never think of doing that. They never think of asking you
- 41:47how you're doing. Was no one ever asked them how
- 41:49they were doing. They don't know the value of
- 41:52what that is. Nobody ever saw them, so they
- 41:55don't know the value of being seen.
- 41:59So they don't think to offer that to anyone else.
- 42:02And so that's part of the the changing of your mind about that
- 42:07to pick people that are at actually interesting to you now
- 42:11in that view of the dismissing person where they're elevated,
- 42:14they're the great person. And often that a point of view
- 42:19is I would be totally happy to be in a reciprocal relationship
- 42:24with you if you were up to my standard.
- 42:27But since you're so clearly not up to my standard, I feel
- 42:32comfortable taking from you what it is I need and not
- 42:36reciprocating. Now mind you, there was no
- 42:40reciprocation in their early experience.
- 42:43They simply performed what they had to in order to get the care
- 42:47that they want to. And so there's a change of mind
- 42:50there. You have to take on the care of
- 42:52somebody else in order to open up the the world of secure
- 42:57functioning because secure people won't accept A1 sided
- 43:04relationship. The reason that dismissing
- 43:09people often ended up with preoccupied people is
- 43:12preoccupied people will accept that they'll provide all of the
- 43:16care that you need in exchange for proximity and be content
- 43:20with that until they burn out. And then they often make demands
- 43:27or some kind of reciprocal care. And what you'll find in the
- 43:32dismissing person is sometimes there's a limited amount of care
- 43:36that's offered until the preoccupied person is resettled.
- 43:41But as soon as they think it's back to normal, all of that care
- 43:46goes away and they're back to just receiving the care.
- 43:50Or they simply move on to somebody else because they don't
- 43:54really do that kind of Christian.
- 44:03Would you describe? Like working with a client a
- 44:05long time ago that was really dismissing that kind of had a
- 44:09breakthrough in terms of recognizing his own emotions,
- 44:13doing a lot of maybe noting feeling states practice and that
- 44:16he he really took had a lot of umbrage for you with what what
- 44:21resulted the dam bursting. And I'm, I'm curious if you kind
- 44:29of have some thoughts on like what, what would be an entry
- 44:31into the, the shallow end of the pool for someone that's
- 44:36dismissing, that's trying to explore, you know, their own
- 44:40emotional range in a way that wouldn't be overwhelming.
- 44:45So you heard me describe this earlier, which was you're going
- 44:51to have the experience of drawing into consciousness your
- 44:54emotional experience. And then you're going to have
- 44:56this difficult period of not having conscious skills to
- 45:00regulate your emotions that you're going to have to then
- 45:04learn the skills to regulate your emotion, which is what I
- 45:08learned from that particular person where I thought that I
- 45:14don't know why I thought this, maybe just not thinking clearly
- 45:17or, or some kind of idealized sense of emotion, but that once
- 45:25the emotion became conscious, that he would enjoy the
- 45:29experience of it since it had been absent for so long.
- 45:33And in the beginning he did, but then when he got into
- 45:36experiencing difficult emotions and had no way of, of
- 45:39suppressing them any longer, he got quite dysregulated by that.
- 45:46And so now I'm just very upfront about letting people know that
- 45:51there's going to be a period where you're going to have
- 45:55motions and, and, and the regulation of them is going to
- 45:58be challenging you, but not for so long.
- 46:03You learn the skills pretty quickly that you need to, to, to
- 46:07regulate the noting feeling states.
- 46:11Technique is the way into that because it's a way of bringing
- 46:15your attention into the body and looking for emotional
- 46:20sensations. Most dismissing people have the
- 46:22sensations in the body, but they're misidentified as
- 46:26physical sensations and not emotional sensations.
- 46:31It's not uncommon for instance, or dismissing person to present
- 46:35at the hospital with a heart attack only to be told that
- 46:38they're having an anxiety attack, but they don't have any
- 46:41emotional experience of the pain in the body.
- 46:44They just have the physical sensation of intense experience.
- 46:54So you can of course, regulate the amount of practice that you
- 46:58do to slow down the the experience of emotion arising
- 47:05consciously and identifying it in the body.
- 47:09And there often is a period where you are, you're able to
- 47:13discern emotional sensation from not emotional sensation, but you
- 47:17have no further discernment than that.
- 47:20And so part of it is how do you identify what the pattern of
- 47:24emotion is? Remember that most of us who can
- 47:27do that learn that in the dyadic relationship with the caregiver,
- 47:30right? We present something and they
- 47:32mirror back to us what their empathetic understanding is.
- 47:38And then we identify the facial expressions that they make that
- 47:42maps on to the emotional experience, and we begin to
- 47:46associate the facial expression with the body experience.
- 47:51And then they tell us what those emotions are.
- 47:54So there isn't a a universal understanding of what emotions
- 47:58are, there's the understanding of what emotions are in your
- 48:01family system. So depending on how skilled your
- 48:05caregiver was. But for instance, in in my
- 48:09family, my mother was not clear as a modeling of emotion.
- 48:17So telling the difference between sadness and anger is it
- 48:21was a real challenge in the beginning because they were so
- 48:24often coupled in the expressions or fear.
- 48:30Anger were often one expression as my mother offered it to us.
- 48:38And so somebody would be sad, but I would be bracing for the
- 48:41anger part of the sadness, right?
- 48:44Not not softening, but defending because I because of the way
- 48:49that it was expressed. And it took quite a while to to
- 48:54learn a broader map of emotions. If you can't identify the
- 49:02emotions intuitively and and media doesn't help you do it.
- 49:07We often watch TV shows or movies and they elicit a
- 49:14response in us, and we see on the screen the response of the
- 49:19actors, and they identify with the emotional experiences.
- 49:23Then we can learn to consciously identify them that way.
- 49:27But often what we're going to end up having to do is ask
- 49:35somebody who's empathetically capable to attune to us and then
- 49:41tell us what the experience of emotion they're having that is
- 49:46ours so that we can begin to identify them that way.
- 49:50Now remember, of course, they're not offering you a universal
- 49:55emotional lexicon. They're offering you the the
- 49:59emotional map of their family system.
- 50:03So if you do that with several people, you'll begin to have a
- 50:05sense of what the emotions are. And then also we'll be engaged
- 50:10in this empathetic exchange with someone else, which is the the
- 50:15best way to emotionally regulate by Co regulating with someone
- 50:19else. And once you get a, a strong
- 50:21taste of that, then it for dismissing people.
- 50:25It makes total sense that this is a much better way to do it.
- 50:30And so they learn quite rapidly to do it.
- 50:34They already have the, the skill set of exploration and so they
- 50:38they can figure these things out pretty rapidly, which is
- 50:41different from preoccupied people who don't explore very
- 50:45well and whose mentalizing is much lower.
- 50:48Typically that making sense. So really, if you find that
- 50:58you're dismissing or you find that you're in a relationship
- 51:01with somebody who is, the way out of that is to tune into your
- 51:06own emotional States and begin to bring that into
- 51:12consciousness. Because empathy is an emotional
- 51:15experience. If you if you allow yourself a
- 51:18conscious experience of your own emotions, you open up the
- 51:23possibility of a conscious experience of the empathetic
- 51:29experience of someone else, which then opens up the capacity
- 51:34to learn facial expressions and body language and and understand
- 51:41gather a whole bunch more data about other people, which is the
- 51:47thing that opens you up to the possibility of other people
- 51:50dismissing. People tend to be very
- 51:52cognitively oriented and very internally oriented.
- 51:56And because they're not empathetic, they don't see the
- 51:59value of collecting data about other people that isn't
- 52:02something that can be processed cognitively, which is the the
- 52:06narratives usually. But if you open up your capacity
- 52:10for your own emotional experience and then you that
- 52:13opens up the capacity for an empathetic experience, Then
- 52:17suddenly there's this whole rich source of data of other people
- 52:23that you can then use in in your understanding of experience
- 52:31that'll making sense. And then beginning to see the
- 52:34value of attachment. And this comes from the shift
- 52:40from secondary exploration into primary exploration and the
- 52:44exchange of primary exploration with someone else is the and the
- 52:49synergy that can come from that. So using that basic formulation
- 52:56of relationship, is somebody a good regulator for you if you if
- 53:01you suddenly have an awareness of your emotions and do you find
- 53:06people who can regulate you, this is valuable suddenly where
- 53:09it wasn't valuable if you didn't have the experience of emotion.
- 53:14And then in order to get them to do that for you, you have to be
- 53:17a good regulator for them. So there's the trade there that
- 53:20begins the experience of collaboration.
- 53:23And then you have to take care of them in a way that's useful
- 53:27to them so that they'll put the energy into the relationship
- 53:31with you. And then you have to see whether
- 53:34they'll take care of you in the way that you need.
- 53:36You may, for the first time, be exploring what it is that you
- 53:40actually need in a relationship that you can attain to a
- 53:45collaborative exchange rather than a transactional exchange.
- 53:50Touching into the terrible sadness and being able to hold
- 53:53that experience allows that whole false self to just
- 53:59collapse because you no longer need the defense from touching
- 54:03into the sadness. And then as you move into the
- 54:08primary exploration and you align your primary exploration
- 54:11with someone else, there's a synergy that forms.
- 54:14They go out and explore and come back in and their expression of
- 54:17that to you, You learn things that are actually useful in your
- 54:22exploration and you got an explorer.
- 54:24And when you come back and you express it to them, they learn
- 54:29things that are valuable to their exploration and that
- 54:32synergy of each other's primary exploration is really the energy
- 54:36that supports these long relationships that are very
- 54:40beneficial. Makes sense.
- 54:47Why don't we do a little practice some, let's do some
- 54:53noting feeling states techniques since that's the the Hi Mary
- 54:59technique for opening up emotional experience.
- 55:02So we'll do a few minutes of concentration practice and then
- 55:06some noting feeling states technique.
- 55:09So go ahead and set it. Settle into your meditation
- 55:12posture, right? Let go of the meditation.
- 55:22So thanks for your practice. Saturday.
- 55:25I'm going to give an artist talk about my photography.
- 55:29The last exploration workshop we did around photography where I
- 55:36use it as an example, it was really mainly a discussion of
- 55:40advanced mentalizing. I'm not going to do any of that
- 55:43with this particular one. I'm just going to really talk
- 55:46about the the evolution of the work.
- 55:49So if that's of interest to you, come along and in support of the
- 55:55magazine that I have started, which is called Place, which is
- 55:59available if you want to subscribe to it on the website.
- 56:02Actually you can sign up for the workshop by subscribing.
- 56:06Cause all of the, the workshops on photography I'm doing, if
- 56:11you're a subscriber, you can come to for free.
- 56:14So it's our perk for subscribers.
- 56:19What else is coming up sort of the end of the year?
- 56:24In the new year, we'll begin our our regular schedule of level
- 56:31ones and level twos on both the attachment side and on the
- 56:35addiction side. So take a look at that.
- 56:40Really appreciate your practice. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 56:43I do hope that if you're able to make a donation of any amount
- 56:47you can, all of it's appreciated.
- 56:49It helps support me and also the work that a group is doing.
- 56:53Thank you for your practice and I will see you soon.
- 56:57Bye.