Latest / Surrounded / Tim Pool vs Progressives | Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00This is the weirdest thing.
- 0:01I criticized Donald Trump.
- 0:02I referred to him as a developmentally disabled individual.
- 0:05I argued with Joe Roden that ivermectin did not work.
- 0:08You know,
- 0:08you say you don't think either sides will ever meet in the middle.
- 0:11They're never going to agree.
- 0:12We're talking about the fact that there's a
- 0:13top-down approach by Republicans like Donald Trump.
- 0:16Can I ask you the question again?
- 0:17Can you answer the question and allow it to happen,
- 0:19foment violence in this country?
- 0:21Can you answer you're running cover for it.
- 0:22If you are only getting sound bites on.
- 0:25Shorts,
- 0:25TikTok,
- 0:25Instagram,
- 0:26you're gonna think I'm sitting here banging on the
- 0:28table with a hammer screaming the end is nigh,
- 0:30which is just not true.
- 0:31From Jubilee Media,
- 0:32this is the Surrounded podcast.
- 0:34I'm Paris Rose filling in for John Regalado,
- 0:36and we've got another follow-up episode for you today.
- 0:39And quick reminder,
- 0:40we have new releases every Sunday.
- 0:42So if you want to get more surrounded,
- 0:43be sure to like,
- 0:44subscribe,
- 0:45and follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:47Thanks so much.
- 0:50All right.
- 0:51Well,
- 0:51hello,
- 0:52Tim.
- 0:52Good to see you again.
- 0:53Likewise,
- 0:54thanks for having me.
- 0:54Well,
- 0:55thanks for jumping into the circle to debate 20
- 0:57progressives and thank you for joining us for this round of podcast.
- 1:00So I'm really curious,
- 1:02what made you interested in joining the show?
- 1:04Have you done anything like this before?
- 1:07I mean,
- 1:07I've done debates.
- 1:08Uh,
- 1:09we,
- 1:09we've done,
- 1:09um,
- 1:10a show we have called the Culture War where we'll have,
- 1:12you know,
- 1:1254 or 5 people up on stage and then we let the audience kind of interact.
- 1:17But
- 1:17I don't know,
- 1:18I've,
- 1:18I've,
- 1:18obviously,
- 1:18I've seen the Surroundings before and,
- 1:21uh,
- 1:21I thought it's a great opportunity to
- 1:23dispel some misconceptions,
- 1:25have a conversation,
- 1:26meet some new people.
- 1:26I think
- 1:27we accomplished all of these things.
- 1:29Whether or not anybody agrees with me,
- 1:31you know,
- 1:31you got to hear me a bit,
- 1:32I suppose.
- 1:33Now for those of us who don't know,
- 1:35can you give us a little bit more about your background and how you got into politics?
- 1:39Well,
- 1:39I've always been,
- 1:40since I was a kid,
- 1:41uh,
- 1:41the internet got me involved in politics just cause,
- 1:44uh,
- 1:44my family had the internet before I was born.
- 1:46We had CompuServe on DOS.
- 1:48Most people probably know,
- 1:49don't even know what that means.
- 1:50But,
- 1:50uh,
- 1:51getting on AOL when I'm like 9 or 10 and playing video games,
- 1:55news headlines every time you log in.
- 1:57And so I just started paying attention and reading news at a very early age,
- 2:00but
- 2:01right around the time I was 1314,
- 2:02I started listening to punk music,
- 2:04mostly pop punk,
- 2:05which then turns into
- 2:07real punk,
- 2:08which is very political.
- 2:10And then with the,
- 2:11the Iraq War,
- 2:12the protests,
- 2:13you know,
- 2:13growing up in Chicago,
- 2:14we're just surrounded by it the whole time.
- 2:16So I started paying attention quite,
- 2:17uh,
- 2:17quite a bit.
- 2:18And I actually worked for a handful of big nonprofits when I was,
- 2:22uh,
- 2:222021 years old,
- 2:23actually fundraising for,
- 2:25say,
- 2:25the ACLU Greenpeace and all that.
- 2:27So then by the time I'm
- 2:2925,
- 2:2926,
- 2:30and Occupy Wall Street is happening,
- 2:31I'm down there,
- 2:32I'm filming
- 2:33and
- 2:34There you go.
- 2:35From there it's uh working for Vice,
- 2:37working for ABC
- 2:39then eventually starting my own company and launching my own podcast.
- 2:42Yeah,
- 2:42I think a lot of people might recognize you from Occupy Wall Street in in that era.
- 2:47Now,
- 2:47I know you haven't watched the episode yet.
- 2:49You haven't seen any of the clips.
- 2:50So,
- 2:51uh
- 2:51we're gonna get into that today.
- 2:53I really want to start with one of your surrounding claims,
- 2:56which was the United States is tracking towards civil war.
- 2:59Because that one got everyone in a tizzy.
- 3:01So I'm going to play that clip
- 3:03and see how you guys interacted with Costanza.
- 3:05I don't want to live in a country where people
- 3:07are attacking each other without trying to understand each other.
- 3:09Right,
- 3:09but the rhetoric that you're spewing is leading towards that.
- 3:12You want Trump
- 3:14again,
- 3:15which means the rhetoric that you're spewing online,
- 3:17the political
- 3:18commentary that you're spewing online
- 3:21is
- 3:21teasing.
- 3:21I don't want Donald Trump.
- 3:23Will they,
- 3:23won't they,
- 3:23will they,
- 3:24won't they?
- 3:24I don't want Donald Trump for a third term.
- 3:25No,
- 3:26but I would,
- 3:27I would prefer,
- 3:28uh,
- 3:28you know,
- 3:28JD Vance,
- 3:29maybe Rubio,
- 3:30but
- 3:31that's still MAGA
- 3:32and indeed,
- 3:33and understand that Trump won the plurality of the vote in 2024 and
- 3:36he has a large support base despite his polls being very low.
- 3:39He does,
- 3:40and we'll see what happens with the Republican Party in 2026 and 2028.
- 3:44But you can't just
- 3:45wish away the existence of a polar of a of a another political faction
- 3:49with a polarized worldview compared to yours.
- 3:51I do not see a reality
- 3:53where Republicans accept the worldview of the of the
- 3:56progressives who are gaining ground in multiple places,
- 3:58namely in New York,
- 3:59and I don't see the progressives accepting
- 4:01the,
- 4:01the,
- 4:02the Trump worldview as you've described it.
- 4:03And the reason
- 4:04that we're not going to
- 4:06accept
- 4:06it is because people like you and the reason we don't accept it is people like you.
- 4:10So,
- 4:11in that clip,
- 4:12you,
- 4:12uh,
- 4:13you said you don't see Republicans accepting
- 4:15the progressive worldview and vice versa.
- 4:18So what specific trends make you think that divide
- 4:20is becoming irreconcilable rather than just another cycle of,
- 4:24you know,
- 4:24political polarization?
- 4:26Well,
- 4:27uh,
- 4:28if we go back to 2021,
- 4:29the issue of immigration
- 4:31is particularly pronounced even today,
- 4:32I think,
- 4:33um,
- 4:34I'll just preface this by saying,
- 4:36we had the ICE
- 4:37shootings in January
- 4:392 people died.
- 4:40And neither side is going to accept
- 4:43what that was.
- 4:43If you go back to 2021,
- 4:45we saw a very,
- 4:46uh,
- 4:46heated circumstance where
- 4:48the Texas State Guard
- 4:49was in a physical confrontation with
- 4:51federal authorities under the Biden administration.
- 4:54The Biden administration had filed a lawsuit
- 4:55to allow them to remove the physical barriers
- 4:58from the southern border to allow people to illegally enter the country.
- 5:02The,
- 5:02the entry of,
- 5:03uh,
- 5:03non-citizens,
- 5:05uh,
- 5:05outside of a port of entry is actually a violation of,
- 5:08of codified US law.
- 5:09For the Biden administration to use federal law enforcement to remove the barriers
- 5:13allowing these people to come in
- 5:15would be to facilitate a criminal activity.
- 5:17Whether or not you believe those people deserved asylum after the fact is,
- 5:20is different.
- 5:21So you have armed Texas State Guard
- 5:24in a standoff with federal authorities in 2021.
- 5:27Now I can't say
- 5:28fortunately since then,
- 5:29we have seen things calm down in that capacity a little bit.
- 5:32I mean,
- 5:33it's pretty shocking.
- 5:34When you're you're coming off January 6th,
- 5:37and then 7 or 8 months later,
- 5:39you have the Texas,
- 5:40Texas deploying State Guard,
- 5:42you had multiple states deploying National Guard to other states,
- 5:45specifically to confront federal authorities.
- 5:48But now we're still dealing with,
- 5:50you know,
- 5:50Trump has largely secured the border,
- 5:52but now you have ICE and CBP going through various cities.
- 5:56They're arresting people.
- 5:57We had a viral video just recently where a woman was trying to board a plane,
- 6:01I believe it was in Denver,
- 6:02and she was,
- 6:04she had overstayed her visa,
- 6:05so she was illegally remaining in the country.
- 6:08CBP or I believe it was a CBP,
- 6:10it might have been ICE,
- 6:10they arrest her,
- 6:11and the narrative that we get from the progressives
- 6:13is that she was here legally
- 6:15and she was being kidnapped.
- 6:17And the narrative that we get from the conservatives is that
- 6:20she had overstayed her visa,
- 6:21was here illegally,
- 6:22and was being deported.
- 6:24Well,
- 6:24I'll just say this.
- 6:24Obviously I have my biases,
- 6:25but
- 6:26when you look at the facts of the case,
- 6:27the woman,
- 6:28uh,
- 6:28came here,
- 6:29overstayed her visa by about a year,
- 6:31and was
- 6:32being arrested and deported for overstaying her visa.
- 6:35If you don't like the laws of this country,
- 6:37then Congress needs to change those things.
- 6:39But to characterize it as a legal individual
- 6:41being kidnapped is,
- 6:42it's hyperpartisan.
- 6:44And so ultimately it doesn't matter if,
- 6:45if my,
- 6:46if I'm correct or incorrect as to the assessment of what happened.
- 6:48What matters,
- 6:49what matters is
- 6:50you have
- 6:51two factions,
- 6:52as it's described by uh Stephen Marsh and various other academics and journalists.
- 6:57You have a
- 6:58multicultural democracy
- 7:00and a constitutional republic
- 7:02existing within the borders of one country.
- 7:05These are diametrically opposed worldviews as to the structure of governance,
- 7:09as to the,
- 7:10the moral framework of,
- 7:12of our judicial system.
- 7:13They're never going to agree.
- 7:14It's,
- 7:15it's not possible.
- 7:15This,
- 7:16this divergence started
- 7:1720 or so years ago.
- 7:19You could argue it,
- 7:20it started in academia in the 60s and 70s,
- 7:22but becoming pronounced with political factions
- 7:25in the late 2000s and the 2010s,
- 7:27I don't see a reality where
- 7:29You are going to convince
- 7:32an American constitutional republicanist
- 7:35that we should abolish the Senate the way the DSA is proposing,
- 7:38and I don't see a scenario where you're going to convince
- 7:41Democratic Socialists of America or Progressives
- 7:43that the founding of this country was
- 7:46legitimate.
- 7:47The worldviews are just
- 7:48the antithesis of each other.
- 7:49Costanza,
- 7:50your opponent,
- 7:51you know,
- 7:51she suggested that.
- 7:53Commentators like you are contributing to this polarization.
- 7:58You know,
- 7:58you say you don't think either sides will ever meet in the middle.
- 8:00They're never going to agree.
- 8:02Do you think political commentators have any responsibility
- 8:06to lower this temperature and work towards
- 8:09this middle ground?
- 8:11I don't think that that is possible.
- 8:13So she is absolutely correct when she says,
- 8:16I as a political commentator contribute to the atmosphere in this country,
- 8:20but
- 8:21I'll put it like this,
- 8:21this is the weirdest thing.
- 8:23I criticized Donald Trump as I,
- 8:25I do fairly often.
- 8:26I mean,
- 8:26I voted for him,
- 8:27I,
- 8:27I wanna see him succeed,
- 8:28but I absolutely
- 8:29Uh,
- 8:30ragged on him over the Iran war and things of that nature,
- 8:32and the media still characterizes it as though I'm a,
- 8:35a hardcore mega far-right Trump supporter,
- 8:37despite the fact
- 8:38I referred to him as a developmentally disabled individual
- 8:41in a more crass manner,
- 8:43and they still refer to me as like some far-right die-hard Trump guy.
- 8:47I guess cause I voted for him.
- 8:48If I go on my show and I say something like,
- 8:50I don't think we should have initiated this war with Iran,
- 8:53I don't think Trump is legitimately trying to solve this problem.
- 8:56If
- 8:57If
- 8:58taking those positions
- 9:00never reach the progressive audience,
- 9:02then the only thing they have is,
- 9:04is assumptions about me based on fake content they've seen from somewhere else.
- 9:08So let,
- 9:08let me,
- 9:08let me phrase it like this.
- 9:09Well,
- 9:10I certainly think I have opinions,
- 9:12biases,
- 9:13and I am going to say things that they will not like.
- 9:16I think the reality is to use,
- 9:18uh,
- 9:18this,
- 9:19this,
- 9:19this surrounding.
- 9:19As a perfect example,
- 9:20there was one individual who claimed that I was shoving ivermectin up my,
- 9:24you know,
- 9:25I'll,
- 9:25I'll refrain from being too uncouth.
- 9:27But I have never promoted ivermectin one time.
- 9:30In fact,
- 9:30I argued with Joe Roda that ivermectin did not work,
- 9:34and to this day I've maintained,
- 9:35I do not believe there's
- 9:36conclusive evidence of this.
- 9:38Why is it then
- 9:39that these progressives come in
- 9:41under the assumption
- 9:42that I would be,
- 9:43say,
- 9:44promoting ivermectin or something of that nature,
- 9:46because they don't actually know who I am.
- 9:48And so I would say this,
- 9:49while,
- 9:50while every political commentator contributes to the atmosphere,
- 9:53there is a surface level to the way social media algorithms work,
- 9:57that's making sure
- 9:59these young people,
- 10:00not necessarily all young,
- 10:01but these progressives,
- 10:02are never going to actually watch my show and
- 10:05hear my real opinions on what's going on.
- 10:08Instead,
- 10:08what they're going to get is
- 10:10some other progressive commentator cherry-picking the most
- 10:13shocking thing they can out of context
- 10:15to try and generate views.
- 10:17There's a really funny example of this.
- 10:19There's a series of videos on YouTube that are titled
- 10:22Joe Rogan Shocked,
- 10:24and what they'll do is
- 10:25they will edit a fake clip of any political commentator.
- 10:29Put a clip of Joe Rogan being shocked in front of it,
- 10:32and they get millions of views from this.
- 10:34And there are people who genuinely believe
- 10:37that I was sitting on Joe Rogan's show talking to
- 10:39him about immigration in the UK which never happened.
- 10:42But if your worldview is built on social media
- 10:45algorithms convincing you this is what I believe,
- 10:47you're gonna come into a debate
- 10:49totally confused,
- 10:51thinking that I believe incorrect things.
- 10:54Well,
- 10:54I think another issue that the progressives were having
- 10:57with you is feeling that you weren't taking accountability.
- 11:00They were saying that
- 11:01they felt like you were really fueling this fire of there's gonna be a civil war,
- 11:05there's gonna be a civil war.
- 11:06And so,
- 11:07kind of what you're saying,
- 11:08they already have this idea of you that you are MAGA no matter what you say,
- 11:12even if you call out Trump,
- 11:14they feel like no matter what,
- 11:15you're MAGA.
- 11:16So,
- 11:17you know,
- 11:17what has to happen
- 11:19for you to say,
- 11:19you know,
- 11:20I was wrong,
- 11:20the country isn't headed in that direction at all.
- 11:23I take those words back.
- 11:25Well,
- 11:25it's fascinating because my,
- 11:26my actual position is that we are in a period of civil strife
- 11:30for which the next phase would be civil war.
- 11:32We have no guarantee that this actually would lead to a civil war.
- 11:36The civil rights era in the 1950s into the 1960s was considered
- 11:39a period of civil strife that did not result in civil war.
- 11:42So what I would argue is they're mischaracterizing my opinion
- 11:46because they don't actually listen to what I say,
- 11:48nor actually watch my show,
- 11:50and they're being fueled by grifters who are
- 11:52trying to make money through shock content.
- 11:54That's definitely a possibility
- 11:56for sure.
- 11:57I'll stress it again.
- 11:59Every single time I've done a
- 12:01I've done a show talking about the prospect of civil war,
- 12:03it's been in reference to articles from the mainstream press,
- 12:06from The Atlantic,
- 12:07The New York Times.
- 12:08I've never just fabricated a whole cloth and argument
- 12:12that I think we're drifting in this direction.
- 12:13My show is based on pulling the top news stories of the day,
- 12:17and then we opine on them,
- 12:18either on my morning show where I do it as a
- 12:20monologue or with Tim Cast IRL with 3 other guests.
- 12:23So if the New York Times writes an article saying,
- 12:25Barbara F.
- 12:26Walter,
- 12:26former CIA warns the US is headed towards civil war,
- 12:29and then we opine on that.
- 12:32That is not to say I decided to push this narrative,
- 12:35but again,
- 12:35these people don't actually look at what I'm saying,
- 12:38and I'm not trying to blame them.
- 12:39I think that the mechanisms of social media,
- 12:41the monetization structures result in this.
- 12:44But every single conversation we've had on this,
- 12:46I have said,
- 12:47There is no guarantee we actually go into a civil war.
- 12:50For all we know,
- 12:51this is just one hot moment,
- 12:52it's a blip on the radar.
- 12:54Things will calm down.
- 12:55If you are only getting soundbites on shorts,
- 12:58TikTok,
- 12:59Instagram,
- 13:00you're gonna think I'm sitting here banging on the
- 13:01table with a hammer screaming the end is nigh,
- 13:03which is just not true.
- 13:05Yeah,
- 13:05I do think that's an issue with
- 13:07whatever.
- 13:07Whoever
- 13:08side you agree with
- 13:09that
- 13:10social media is just feeding you what you want to hear,
- 13:12what you want to see,
- 13:13and people are only watching clips
- 13:15just to reconfirm and validate what they already had in mind.
- 13:19So
- 13:19I do feel like we are stuck there.
- 13:21Let me give you a good example.
- 13:22I think one of the individuals said something to the effect of,
- 13:25you have 40 videos talking about civil war.
- 13:29I would just like to stress,
- 13:30we have 1570 or so episodes of Timcast IRL.
- 13:34Or if he's talking about the inclusion of my morning show,
- 13:37interview show,
- 13:38and Timcast IRL,
- 13:39we're looking at somewhere around,
- 13:41in just terms of full podcast episodes,
- 13:44perhaps around 4500.
- 13:46But if we're looking at
- 13:47every clip,
- 13:48every segment we produce,
- 13:50because we produce about from Timcast IRL,
- 13:52which is a 3 hour long show,
- 13:54we will produce 5 segments from the show that are between 10 and 20 minutes long.
- 13:58Now we're looking at around 30,000 different clips.
- 14:01I think 40 is a rather small percentage if that's the case.
- 14:04Yeah,
- 14:04I mean,
- 14:05whether you
- 14:06think it's we're heading toward,
- 14:07we're in a political strife right now,
- 14:09we're headed toward a civil war,
- 14:11we're headed toward a revolution.
- 14:12Do you feel like
- 14:14something is necessary
- 14:16for change at this moment?
- 14:18Or do you feel like,
- 14:19you know,
- 14:19a revolution wouldn't be helpful,
- 14:21civil war wouldn't be helpful?
- 14:22What are you none of it's helpful.
- 14:24I had a gentleman,
- 14:25a liberal on my show and we we were debating the issue.
- 14:28And,
- 14:28and,
- 14:28and again,
- 14:29it's always from the pretext of Tim Poole saying it's gonna happen.
- 14:32And then as soon as I clarify,
- 14:33no,
- 14:33I'm saying,
- 14:34you know,
- 14:34we had a former CIA,
- 14:36uh,
- 14:36uh,
- 14:37analyst.
- 14:37She wrote a book about this,
- 14:38Barbara F.
- 14:38Walters saying
- 14:40that in her experience tracking all these other countries,
- 14:42the United States is in a similar vein.
- 14:44All of a sudden they're like,
- 14:45well,
- 14:45what am I supposed to debate now?
- 14:47But,
- 14:47uh,
- 14:48what I,
- 14:48what I always say to them is,
- 14:49let me ask you this question.
- 14:50They always say it's not possible,
- 14:51a civil war can't happen in the United States.
- 14:53And I say,
- 14:53OK,
- 14:53fine,
- 14:53yeah,
- 14:54whatever,
- 14:54whatever you think.
- 14:55But let me ask you this question.
- 14:57Do you believe Donald Trump will use the military
- 15:00to round up
- 15:01migrants in this country?
- 15:03To which,
- 15:04at the time,
- 15:04the answer was,
- 15:05yes,
- 15:05I do think he will.
- 15:06OK,
- 15:06well,
- 15:07Trump actually did.
- 15:08Marines were deployed to California,
- 15:09they went to marijuana farms,
- 15:11and they were pulling migrant children working
- 15:13on marijuana farms from those farms,
- 15:15as well as arresting older individuals for
- 15:17deportation who were working on those farms.
- 15:19So that did happen.
- 15:20The question I have for the progressives is,
- 15:22will you do anything about it?
- 15:25And invariably the response is,
- 15:27yes.
- 15:27So,
- 15:28so this is,
- 15:28this is my point.
- 15:29We had a,
- 15:30we had a narrative in 2024 that Donald Trump would use the military against,
- 15:33uh,
- 15:33migrants in this country
- 15:35that were here,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:36that were not authorized to be here.
- 15:38I'm trying to be light in my political language.
- 15:40And the response from progressives is they would do whatever they had to,
- 15:43to stop Trump from doing that.
- 15:46Well,
- 15:46I don't know what
- 15:47you can do to stop
- 15:49a marine being deployed
- 15:51to California
- 15:52to physic to to assist physically
- 15:54in the apprehension
- 15:55of these,
- 15:56of these immigrants,
- 15:57unless you're referring to some kind of violent escalation.
- 16:00So again,
- 16:01my,
- 16:01my perspective on this is not based on what I think I would do,
- 16:05or anyone in my neighborhood would do.
- 16:06It's based on what we see from the willingness
- 16:08of conservatives in terms of the use of,
- 16:11uh,
- 16:11legitimate government power,
- 16:13whether it's used legitimately or illegitimately,
- 16:15I'm saying,
- 16:16federal law enforcement,
- 16:17duly sworn in
- 16:18and dispatched by the president versus
- 16:21what progressive activists,
- 16:23organizations,
- 16:23NGOs are willing to do to counter that.
- 16:25The,
- 16:25the argument ultimately becomes this.
- 16:28You either get what the progressives would view as a fascist dictatorship,
- 16:32a revolution,
- 16:33or what the conservatives would describe as the
- 16:36dissolution of our borders and a communist revolution.
- 16:39If
- 16:40nobody fights.
- 16:41So if the conservatives simply just say we're
- 16:43gonna turn everything down and we're gonna stop,
- 16:45and we're gonna,
- 16:46we're gonna let them do what they're doing as they march to the streets,
- 16:49as they,
- 16:50you know,
- 16:50shoot and kill individuals like Aaron Danielson or Charlie Kirk,
- 16:53well then the end result,
- 16:54based on that arithmetic is
- 16:56you will get a,
- 16:57a,
- 16:57a democratic socialist,
- 16:58ultimately a socialist or communist revolution in this country.
- 17:01And from the argument of the progressives,
- 17:03if Trump is going to deploy the military to round up his political enemies
- 17:06and arrest
- 17:07migrants with the use of military force,
- 17:10then you'll get a fascist dictatorship.
- 17:12Now you can choose to fight,
- 17:14in which case you'd get a civil war.
- 17:15So I don't know what will happen.
- 17:17It's entirely possible
- 17:18that,
- 17:19uh,
- 17:19you know,
- 17:19I,
- 17:20I don't think we're gonna have a communist revolution or a fascist dictatorship.
- 17:23I think
- 17:24both of the,
- 17:24of the politically entrenched
- 17:26view it a bit more
- 17:28extreme than I think what we're actually witnessing.
- 17:31But I do think we are facing a dramatic transformation.
- 17:33And I don't know how it can be reconciled with the current
- 17:37existence of two distinct body politics.
- 17:40That is,
- 17:40Zoran Mamdani engaging in foreign affairs when
- 17:43he threatened the arrest of Netanyahu,
- 17:45overtly violates the Logan Act.
- 17:47Of course we're not going to see any law enforcement pertaining to the Logan Act
- 17:50against the mayor of New York,
- 17:52but it's
- 17:52pretty
- 17:53crazy to see a mayor.
- 17:54Threatened to arrest a foreign dignitary,
- 17:57which it's very strange.
- 17:58I don't,
- 17:59I don't see how with New York,
- 18:00Colorado,
- 18:00the rise of the DSA,
- 18:02I mean,
- 18:03the DSA is talking about abolishing the Senate,
- 18:05which is firmly in the Constitution and
- 18:07can only be abolished if the Constitution itself
- 18:10is,
- 18:11is,
- 18:11uh,
- 18:11uh,
- 18:12removed as the supreme law of the land.
- 18:14You have a
- 18:16political faction saying they wanna do that.
- 18:18No,
- 18:18I wanna uh kind of stop you there because I,
- 18:20I wanna move on
- 18:21to another claim that you had.
- 18:23I think it really will tie in to what you're saying now.
- 18:26Um,
- 18:26this claim of yours was that the mainstream political left commits more violence
- 18:30than the mainstream political right.
- 18:32Um,
- 18:32so,
- 18:32I'm gonna play a clip from a conversation you had with Mason.
- 18:35I think
- 18:36it really ties into what you're saying.
- 18:38There seems to be like a broader implication
- 18:40with your prompt that there's this domestic threat
- 18:42from mainstream left politicians
- 18:44like do you really think Hillary Clinton's
- 18:46like leading the Vanguard Revolution Party?
- 18:48Like
- 18:48what what what is your take?
- 18:50When you look at the violence that we do see
- 18:52uh there's it's it's.
- 18:53It's from,
- 18:54I,
- 18:54I,
- 18:55I describe it as from blunt to acute,
- 18:56which is
- 18:58with the fringe extreme right,
- 18:59you'll see extreme,
- 19:00uh,
- 19:00mass shootings.
- 19:01You'll see,
- 19:02you know,
- 19:02someone will show up and unload on people,
- 19:04things like that.
- 19:05On the left though,
- 19:05you'll see riots,
- 19:06vandalism that you don't see from the right,
- 19:08but
- 19:09The point I'm making is that when you break down
- 19:11the ideology that motivates individuals that commit political violence,
- 19:15there is more often an overlap
- 19:17between what the Democratic Party espouses ideologically
- 19:20and what we see in street level violence as well as maybe assassinations.
- 19:23What is what the Republicans would espouse.
- 19:25I mean,
- 19:25I couldn't disagree more.
- 19:27What,
- 19:27what ideologies that the Democratic Party is promoting
- 19:30that leads to these types of violence?
- 19:31Anytime you see an act of violence that's typically attributed to the left,
- 19:35it is immediately condemned.
- 19:36By every Democrat politician,
- 19:37you couldn't point to one that actually endorses that
- 19:40where you have somebody like Donald Trump who's literally the president of the
- 19:42United States saying that we should call for the death of congressional members
- 19:46who are fulfilling their civic duty and saying,
- 19:48hey,
- 19:49maybe you shouldn't,
- 19:50uh,
- 19:50fulfill illegal orders if you're in the military
- 19:52and Donald Trump's asking for them to be put to death.
- 19:54How is that not inciting violence?
- 19:57No,
- 19:57that is,
- 19:57that's absolutely terrifying.
- 19:58I completely disagree with that.
- 19:59My,
- 20:00my point more so is that when you see,
- 20:01say,
- 20:02The George Floyd or the BLM riots,
- 20:04you end up with
- 20:06Biden and Kamala themselves promoting fundraisers for
- 20:08those accused of committing these crimes.
- 20:10So
- 20:11you drew a distinction between what you called acute violence
- 20:15on the right and more sustained violence
- 20:17like riots and vandalism on the left.
- 20:19So why do you think that distinction matters?
- 20:22There are very few
- 20:25high profile
- 20:26right wing attacks relative to left.
- 20:29One is too many.
- 20:31Uh,
- 20:31so you see somebody,
- 20:32um,
- 20:33you know,
- 20:33go into a church and,
- 20:35you know,
- 20:35shoot up a,
- 20:35a,
- 20:35a black congregation.
- 20:37And I call that acute,
- 20:38meaning
- 20:39it is a singular instance of some of
- 20:41the most extreme violence and most detestable and evil
- 20:45that we could see.
- 20:46We want those to stop,
- 20:47obviously.
- 20:48On the left you'll see something like 3000 instances of
- 20:52people getting punched in the face,
- 20:53bashed over the head.
- 20:55Fires set,
- 20:56buildings destroyed.
- 20:57So blunt is,
- 20:59you get a lot of a little bit,
- 21:01which these stories typically don't individually make national news.
- 21:04And then with what we would call right-wing,
- 21:07you get
- 21:08rather extreme,
- 21:09a guy showing up with a gun and shooting a lot of people.
- 21:10However,
- 21:11there's a,
- 21:11there's a more important distinction,
- 21:12which was the,
- 21:12the,
- 21:13the core of the claim,
- 21:15is that
- 21:16I don't believe it's meaningful to tell a voter,
- 21:18the right is more violent.
- 21:20Because if we look at the Cato Institute
- 21:23or even the FBI,
- 21:24They're not referring to Charlie Kirk,
- 21:26they're not referring to Steven Crowder or Ben Shapiro.
- 21:29They're referring to an unnamed Grand Dragon of the Klan that no one's ever heard of.
- 21:34In one particular instance that got a lot of attention,
- 21:37I believe it was the Cato Institute that claimed
- 21:39a,
- 21:39a white supremacist who punched his wife and got arrested for it was an instance
- 21:43of white supremacist violence.
- 21:45Well,
- 21:46look,
- 21:46if the Republican Party says white supremacy is bad,
- 21:49and Charlie Kirk was kicking out white nationalists from his events,
- 21:52and Nick Fuentes was barred from,
- 21:54uh,
- 21:54he was barred from the RNC,
- 21:56from CPAC,
- 21:57from all these organizations,
- 21:59it's not meaningful to a voter to put
- 22:01those ideologies alongside the Republican Party.
- 22:04So when we talk about left and right,
- 22:06by all means you can include whatever elements you think are left and right,
- 22:09but I think when we're coming to a midterm in voting,
- 22:11We,
- 22:12we want to draw the distinction between the mainstream
- 22:15liberal and left and the mainstream conservative and right,
- 22:19in which case,
- 22:20You see almost no violence.
- 22:22There,
- 22:23there's,
- 22:23there's zero
- 22:24instances of Charlie Kirk's supporters following his death going around
- 22:27smashing windows,
- 22:28setting fires or murdering people.
- 22:30In fact,
- 22:30there's an estimate of between 24 and 34 murders
- 22:34that took place following the killing of George Floyd,
- 22:37who was not even a prominent political activist.
- 22:40It is an objective fact,
- 22:42and this is what's,
- 22:43what's fascinating to me in,
- 22:44in the whole debate.
- 22:45When you look at just news articles.
- 22:47So,
- 22:48uh,
- 22:48my company,
- 22:48we did an analysis tracking just
- 22:50ABC,
- 22:51New York Times,
- 22:52NBC,
- 22:52CBS,
- 22:53and we found over 465 instances of high profile,
- 22:58what one could describe as terrorism
- 23:00over the past 10 years coming from the left,
- 23:02and one
- 23:03coming from the right.
- 23:04Now I,
- 23:04I wanna clarify what that means.
- 23:06I'm not talking about fringe anti-government communist revolutionaries,
- 23:10and I am not talking about fringe white nationalists and ultra-nationalists.
- 23:14I am talking about individuals who are motivated by an
- 23:17ideological cause espoused by the Democrat or Republican Party.
- 23:21That is
- 23:22who comes out
- 23:23and says Elon Musk
- 23:24is,
- 23:25is,
- 23:25is,
- 23:25is bad,
- 23:26he's got to be stopped,
- 23:27he should not have this money,
- 23:29and then people take guns and go and unload on Tesla vehicles.
- 23:32That is motivated by an overlapping ideology.
- 23:35But we have not seen free speech activists wearing Charlie Kirk
- 23:38shirts going around and shooting up campuses or setting fires.
- 23:43Would you say that one of the biggest,
- 23:46uh,
- 23:47riots in modern history was at our nation's Capitol
- 23:50on January 6th,
- 23:51uh,
- 23:51where government officials.
- 23:53And police officers and anyone who got in their way
- 23:55were under attack by the right and then pardoned by Trump.
- 23:58So do you feel that,
- 24:00you know,
- 24:00him pardoning those people kind of embolden the right and
- 24:05has been one of the most violent
- 24:06riots in our modern history?
- 24:09Well,
- 24:09the January 6th was not.
- 24:11One of the most violent riots in our,
- 24:12in our history
- 24:13by the numbers in
- 24:14modern,
- 24:15in modern.
- 24:16No,
- 24:16it,
- 24:16it still isn't.
- 24:17First of all,
- 24:17obviously January 6th is abhorrent and it's,
- 24:20I think if you,
- 24:21if you line up,
- 24:22uh,
- 24:23if you compare January 6th
- 24:24to 90+% of what we've seen from progressives,
- 24:27it's just worse.
- 24:28Right?
- 24:28You had,
- 24:29uh,
- 24:29an estimate of,
- 24:31I think you had between 1000 and
- 24:322000 individuals who actually entered the building.
- 24:34You had an estimate of around 800 to 1000 who
- 24:37were engaged in some kind of violence against the police.
- 24:40All of that is very,
- 24:42very bad.
- 24:42I don't think when you compare this to what we've seen going back 10 years
- 24:47in modern history,
- 24:47it's
- 24:48It's gonna fall somewhere,
- 24:50uh,
- 24:50in the middle of the bulk of the riots,
- 24:52if we're just,
- 24:53uh,
- 24:53uh,
- 24:53comparing riots.
- 24:54But the reason why I say it's worse is because it was at our Capitol,
- 24:56it obstructed our,
- 24:58our,
- 24:58our constitutional processes,
- 25:00and that makes it substantially worse.
- 25:01In terms of damage,
- 25:02violence,
- 25:03injuries,
- 25:05it's actually not.
- 25:06In,
- 25:06in fact,
- 25:06uh,
- 25:07one thing that's often overlooked,
- 25:08which is
- 25:09I find it to be frustrating is the M29
- 25:12insurrection that we saw in DC.
- 25:14We had several 1000
- 25:16far leftists
- 25:17beating police,
- 25:19over 100
- 25:20federal officers
- 25:22injured.
- 25:23They tore the barricades down at the White House,
- 25:25threw firebombs on the White House grounds,
- 25:28and set fire to Saint John's Church.
- 25:30The president was forced into an emergency bunker where he,
- 25:34I,
- 25:34I,
- 25:34I would describe it as embarrassingly pretended like he wasn't.
- 25:38But he was called in the media bunker boy,
- 25:41having been forced into the emergency bunker.
- 25:43Now nobody breached the White House,
- 25:45but they did set fire to a historic American church,
- 25:47which is terrifying.
- 25:49Had they actually breached the,
- 25:50the,
- 25:50the fencing,
- 25:51we would call that one of the darkest days in American history.
- 25:54Now,
- 25:54now the question is,
- 25:55why did we not get any hearings on this?
- 25:58There were substantially more injuries on that day than we saw on January 6th,
- 26:01but don't get me wrong,
- 26:02it's not to excuse January 6th,
- 26:03it's all bad.
- 26:05It's just,
- 26:05for whatever reason,
- 26:07Progressives
- 26:08don't care
- 26:09about the M29 insurrection at the White House.
- 26:12I'm going to stress this.
- 26:13They ripped the barricades down.
- 26:14They threw firebombs on the White House grounds
- 26:16and set fire to the church across the street.
- 26:18This was terrifying
- 26:20for me and my,
- 26:20my,
- 26:21my friends and family who live
- 26:22just outside of DC,
- 26:24but it's remarkable that
- 26:25the Republicans don't seem to care
- 26:27and the Democrats don't seem to care and the progressives,
- 26:29I think,
- 26:29supported it.
- 26:30Now as for the pardons,
- 26:31there's a very important distinction here.
- 26:34What we were looking at with the criminal charges on January 6th is,
- 26:38first,
- 26:39let me just say anybody who attacked a cop,
- 26:40tore the barricades down,
- 26:41and stormed the Capitol deserved prison.
- 26:44And they got it.
- 26:45In fact,
- 26:45many of these people got solitary confinement on and off for 3 years.
- 26:50The question that I ask for anybody who's concerned about those pardons is simple.
- 26:54How much time in prison
- 26:56should an individual
- 26:57who rioted at the Capitol and attacked a police officer get?
- 27:01This is not a gotcha.
- 27:02This is not a,
- 27:03it's a legitimate question.
- 27:05Now I think
- 27:06reasonably what I would argue is
- 27:08if you were one of the leftist rioters at the White House on May 29th,
- 27:122020.
- 27:13And you were one of the people who injured one of these officers,
- 27:15I would argue that a year or two in federal
- 27:17prison probably is enough time for the crime you committed.
- 27:22For the J-6ers,
- 27:23you had individuals who actually never even fought police,
- 27:26who got 1 to 2 years in prison.
- 27:28So herein lies the problem.
- 27:30The Capitol Police set up offices around the country,
- 27:32they wrongly raided innocent individuals' home.
- 27:35There was a woman in Alaska,
- 27:36they raided her home and and arrested her even though she was not even in the Capitol,
- 27:40only to later realize their mistake.
- 27:42Now you had hundreds of those cases.
- 27:45So the challenge presented on the right
- 27:47is that first,
- 27:48the rioters who attacked police were already in prison for 3 years,
- 27:52probably long enough.
- 27:54The rest of these people who got misdemeanor trespass charges,
- 27:57some were put in solitary and some were in prison for over 1 year.
- 28:01My opinion is
- 28:02when you have a process this tainted,
- 28:04the pardons are warranted.
- 28:06And if there is a complaint over some of these bad
- 28:08people being parted to later on got arrested for other crimes,
- 28:11the issue is
- 28:12when you blanket over 1000 to 2000 people,
- 28:16some of whom were peaceful and entered the building
- 28:18from the other side where there was no riot.
- 28:21You've created a serious conflict in this country
- 28:24to lower the temperature,
- 28:25I believe a mass pardon is warranted,
- 28:27just like we saw in the early days of this country.
- 28:31When there were many individuals
- 28:32who fought in an early war,
- 28:33I believe it was Jefferson,
- 28:34issued a blanket pardon
- 28:36for a bunch of farmers who were rebelling against the government,
- 28:39the argument being,
- 28:40OK,
- 28:41we've arrested these people,
- 28:42we've taken from them.
- 28:43If we are going to lock up thousands of people,
- 28:46you are going to turn the temperature way up.
- 28:48I would make the same argument for those
- 28:50on May 29th and 2020
- 28:52that had they been in prison and many
- 28:54of them in solitary confinement for three years,
- 28:56I would also advocate for their release.
- 28:59Well,
- 29:00where do you draw the line between,
- 29:01you know,
- 29:02a politician expressing support
- 29:04for a movement or
- 29:06a riot insurrection
- 29:08and then being responsible for the violence committed by the people
- 29:12in that movement?
- 29:13Yeah,
- 29:13I don't,
- 29:14I don't hold any of these,
- 29:15uh,
- 29:15uh,
- 29:16you know,
- 29:16all these Democrats,
- 29:17you know,
- 29:17Elizabeth Warren being a great example.
- 29:19She is allowed to express her opinion,
- 29:21and I appreciate that she does.
- 29:23She holds no responsibility if someone who agrees with her worldview
- 29:27decides to be violent.
- 29:28Because all of these Democrats have denounced violence,
- 29:30and I'm glad that they do,
- 29:32and I don't respect Donald Trump coming out and threatening the death penalty,
- 29:36uh,
- 29:37against these,
- 29:37these Democrats who are saying do not,
- 29:39uh,
- 29:40you know,
- 29:40do not obey illegal orders.
- 29:41There are a lot of,
- 29:42uh,
- 29:43political arguments,
- 29:44but I,
- 29:44I don't think this country has served with what Trump said.
- 29:48Uh,
- 29:48that being said,
- 29:49The point I'm making is that
- 29:51mainstream
- 29:52run of the mill conservatives and moderates are not picking
- 29:55up guns and Molotovs because of the things Republicans say
- 29:59for the most part.
- 30:00January 6th involved,
- 30:01I think there were a couple of individuals who were arrested on gun possession in DC.
- 30:05Most of them did not have firearms or explosives.
- 30:08But then we see with the left.
- 30:10I mean you can see the motivations
- 30:12for the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 30:14By all means there are many people who are
- 30:16claiming that Israel or the government killed him,
- 30:18but
- 30:19if we're going just by positive evidence,
- 30:20this is a guy who said he was hateful,
- 30:22and so he killed him.
- 30:23I think a better example is the he wasn't necessarily tied to the left,
- 30:27progressives or
- 30:29Tyler Robinson was motivated according to the evidence released by
- 30:32by uh Charlie Kirk having spread hate.
- 30:35To put it simply,
- 30:36if you are in a relationship with a non-binary individual,
- 30:39uh,
- 30:40a claim Charlie Kirk is a is is spreading hate and then decide to go and end his life,
- 30:44I don't think we can say that person is a moderate or conservative.
- 30:46This is,
- 30:46this is,
- 30:47this is an ideology that is,
- 30:49let me put it very simply.
- 30:50If all Tyler Robinson ever said was this man
- 30:54spreads hate and that's all we knew about him,
- 30:56I could say,
- 30:57OK,
- 30:58AOC said the exact same thing in the halls of Congress after Charlie was murdered.
- 31:02That is an
- 31:03ideological overlap.
- 31:04I'm not suggesting AOC wanted Charlie Kirk dead or advocates for violence.
- 31:08I am saying that when Charlie Kirk came out and said
- 31:10we should defend free speech,
- 31:12no one showed up and shot
- 31:14an Antifa protester
- 31:16for advocating against it.
- 31:17We don't see those instances.
- 31:19So I'll put it like this
- 31:21the George Floyd riots or the BLM riots,
- 31:23however you want to describe it,
- 31:24in 2020 were considered to be some of the worst riots we had seen
- 31:27in 50 years.
- 31:29There's an estimated 24 to 34 deaths depending on how people want to calculate
- 31:33these murders.
- 31:34One was
- 31:36David Dorn,
- 31:36a retired police officer.
- 31:38He went to his friend's pawn shop and took a bullet to the chest.
- 31:41These were rioters that were out in the street for an ideological cause.
- 31:44I know many of them were just exploiting that cause,
- 31:46but here's the issue.
- 31:47As many of these individuals set fire to buildings and were arrested for it,
- 31:51Kamala Harris and Joe Biden,
- 31:54Personally
- 31:55solicited donations on their behalf.
- 31:58Now you've got to hold people responsible
- 32:00if they are providing money
- 32:03for those who committed these crimes.
- 32:05And absolutely
- 32:06when,
- 32:06when you have people on the right
- 32:08that were advocating that people who are beating
- 32:11cops on January 6th shouldn't go to jail,
- 32:13they should be called out all the same.
- 32:15But
- 32:15I will just stress in this capacity,
- 32:18we have,
- 32:19uh,
- 32:19some 465 tracked incidents over the past 10 years,
- 32:22and a consistent
- 32:24defense from Democrats
- 32:26over the individuals accused.
- 32:27While I'm not going to accuse any Democrats of coming out and saying explicitly,
- 32:30go be violent,
- 32:32we have numerous instances where they have,
- 32:34they have,
- 32:34they have a famous quote,
- 32:35It is,
- 32:37respect the diversity of tactics.
- 32:39And what that means is
- 32:41the,
- 32:41the surface level term that most people would take it to mean is
- 32:45if somebody is going to engage in violence.
- 32:48For the benefit of a left cause,
- 32:50we have nothing to do with it,
- 32:51and we are going to stay out of it.
- 32:53At
- 32:54worst,
- 32:55what we see in these protests are that organizers who claim to be peaceful
- 32:59will instruct their facilitators to respect the diversity of tactics,
- 33:03which means stand down and allow them to be violent.
- 33:07It's their
- 33:08diverse tactic.
- 33:09We don't see
- 33:10any of that among conservatives.
- 33:12I hear you.
- 33:12I kind of want to pivot a little bit into our next clip
- 33:16for the next your next claim.
- 33:18It was that the Democratic Party has embraced authoritarianism.
- 33:22Um,
- 33:23because I also think it ties in nicely to what you are talking about.
- 33:26You had a conversation with David.
- 33:28Support to recognize that
- 33:29a simply I condemn is not sufficient when
- 33:31the Republican Party has created a permission structure
- 33:34for individuals to go out and do violence
- 33:36against,
- 33:36I'm about to tell you with impunity.
- 33:38Immigration and Customs Enforcement is a good example.
- 33:40Trump
- 33:41administration.
- 33:41The Trump administration,
- 33:43you know,
- 33:43they lost in the courts 10,000 times,
- 33:45right?
- 33:45That's not true.
- 33:46It is true.
- 33:47Politico actually released a report on it.
- 33:48Yeah,
- 33:48they lost 10,000 times
- 33:49like 10,000
- 33:50murdered numerous American citizens,
- 33:52and guess what happened to the individuals that carried out those killings?
- 33:54What happened to them?
- 33:55What happened to them?
- 33:55Have they been prosecuted in any investigations,
- 33:57do you know?
- 33:57I believe they have not.
- 33:59Why?
- 34:00It's almost as if when you commit violence,
- 34:02you're going to be protected.
- 34:04That's what's going on.
- 34:05That's why Christie No went out and said
- 34:06that Alex Freddy was a domestic terrorist.
- 34:08That's why Stephen Miller said the same thing.
- 34:09And everybody in the entire Republican Party apparatus is
- 34:11echoing those talking points because whenever there's violence,
- 34:14they,
- 34:14they don't condemn it.
- 34:15They condone it.
- 34:16They,
- 34:16they congratulate it and they pardon it.
- 34:18Law enforcement duly elected by a by a population that voted in
- 34:22plurality for ICE to go out and engage in these kill American
- 34:24citizens,
- 34:25which sometimes,
- 34:25yes,
- 34:26absolutely.
- 34:26And oh,
- 34:27they voted for ICE to kill American citizens,
- 34:28really?
- 34:29Yes.
- 34:31Do you,
- 34:31do you,
- 34:31do you,
- 34:32the,
- 34:32the average Republican,
- 34:33I don't think they're that who said the average Republican would vote,
- 34:35but do you not believe that there are people in
- 34:36this country that would vote for ICE to harm people?
- 34:38Is that your,
- 34:39is this your argument?
- 34:40Do you believe this is terrible.
- 34:42So you think not a single person in this country wants to harm illegal relevance.
- 34:45We're talking about the fact that there is
- 34:47a top-down approach by Republicans like Donald Trump.
- 34:49Can I ask you the question again?
- 34:51Can you answer?
- 34:51Can you answer the question and allow it to happen,
- 34:53foment violence.
- 34:54Can you,
- 34:54can you answer you're running cover for it.
- 34:56Can you
- 34:56actually,
- 34:57you just did.
- 34:57No,
- 34:57I didn't.
- 34:58See,
- 34:58I'm,
- 34:59I'm pointing at ICE violence.
- 35:00You're saying that people vote for it or whatever.
- 35:02You don't think that there are white supremacists
- 35:03voting for ICE to go and harm migrants.
- 35:05Are you saying that white supremacists voted for
- 35:07Donald Trump so they could kill migrants?
- 35:08Yes,
- 35:09I am.
- 35:10OK,
- 35:10good to know that white supremacists make up part of
- 35:12the Republican Party and Donald Trump's doing their bidding.
- 35:14Yes,
- 35:14I,
- 35:14I,
- 35:15I certainly believe they do.
- 35:16OK.
- 35:17So here in this clip,
- 35:18David,
- 35:19your opponent argued that Republicans have created a permission structure
- 35:23for political violence.
- 35:25So what's your response?
- 35:26I know we've been talking.
- 35:27About this,
- 35:27but what's your response to that?
- 35:29And not only in this debate?
- 35:31Well,
- 35:31it's actually the best argument.
- 35:33The,
- 35:33the right doesn't engage in street level vigilante or um terroristic violence.
- 35:39They vote for it,
- 35:40implement a system by which they can engage in the violence.
- 35:44Uh,
- 35:45Democrats do the exact same thing,
- 35:46which is,
- 35:47which,
- 35:47which is my counter.
- 35:48And,
- 35:48uh,
- 35:49under Barack Obama,
- 35:50we saw substantially more deportations.
- 35:52There were different kinds of deportations,
- 35:54largely at the border,
- 35:55but,
- 35:55uh,
- 35:55we also saw the indefinite detention provision
- 35:58under the National Defense Authorization Act under Barack Obama.
- 36:01To,
- 36:01to claim that the Republicans
- 36:03are unique,
- 36:05is silly.
- 36:06But if you want to argue that the,
- 36:08the structure by which people can vote to empower an executive,
- 36:11who will then dispatch law enforcement
- 36:14controlling the.
- 36:14Having a monopoly on violence and harming people,
- 36:17I think we all agree we have concerns about an unaccountable police force.
- 36:20I have,
- 36:21I have a few counters.
- 36:22I think that when I pointed out
- 36:24there are white supremacists in this country,
- 36:26ultranationalists,
- 36:28and even,
- 36:28you know,
- 36:29non-white individuals that do want
- 36:32ICE to kill migrants.
- 36:34The way
- 36:35this man acted,
- 36:36he immediately said it's not true,
- 36:38and people around me laughed,
- 36:40and my only thought is,
- 36:42No matter what I say,
- 36:43they will claim the inverse,
- 36:45because even when I say something they should completely agree with,
- 36:49they act like I'm wrong.
- 36:51There are people in this country that have gone
- 36:53on social media and they do every single day
- 36:56saying they want
- 36:58machine guns on the border.
- 37:00They want
- 37:00ICE to mow people down.
- 37:02You see that they're voting for Trump.
- 37:04Now that being said,
- 37:06There's a distinction between
- 37:08Whether those people are just going to talk big online and have horrifying views
- 37:12and whether or not we'll actually see that implemented in terms of law enforcement.
- 37:15I just think you,
- 37:16you have a serious challenge in a few capacities.
- 37:19Alex Peretti,
- 37:19for instance,
- 37:20was armed
- 37:21and,
- 37:22uh,
- 37:22had shown up to confront federal law enforcement.
- 37:25This is not a protest.
- 37:26This is a federal law enforcement enforcement operation.
- 37:29You run very serious risks
- 37:32because we are not talking about,
- 37:34say,
- 37:34a police line outside of a building.
- 37:36Which is community response or riot control.
- 37:39We are talking about an individual who said,
- 37:41I am going to obstruct federal law enforcement
- 37:43actively pursuing lethal threats.
- 37:46This does not justify anything the cops did.
- 37:48I think the police in that regard made terrible mistakes.
- 37:51However,
- 37:52This is a guy who showed up armed to confront federal law enforcement,
- 37:55which resulted in a tragedy.
- 37:57I'm shocked that you would find progressives advocating
- 38:00for the right to carry a concealed weapon
- 38:03to confront federal law enforcement.
- 38:04I'd imagine the progressive argument would be,
- 38:07we should have gun controls and permits,
- 38:08and you shouldn't be able to conceal your
- 38:10weapons like this or something to that effect,
- 38:11but
- 38:11I certainly understand there are many on the left that
- 38:14do agree
- 38:15with,
- 38:15uh,
- 38:15you know,
- 38:15having guns.
- 38:17And I also think
- 38:18you can't simultaneously argue for democracy
- 38:21and then condemn the result of your democracy.
- 38:25Donald Trump won the second biggest issue according to Gallup
- 38:29throughout the 24 cycle was illegal immigration.
- 38:32This helped Trump secure the plurality and win,
- 38:35and he didn't just win the presidency,
- 38:38but the Senate and the House.
- 38:40The Republicans took.
- 38:41Everything
- 38:43and the second biggest issue was immigration.
- 38:46So if you believe in democracy and the right of the people to vote,
- 38:50and when they do,
- 38:51they say please enforce the law against
- 38:54people who have come to this country illegally,
- 38:56you can't come out after the fact and say,
- 38:58well,
- 38:59you've done it wrong and you've created a permission structure
- 39:01because unfortunately that permission structure is part of your democracy.
- 39:05All right,
- 39:05but do you think that political leaders have any responsibility,
- 39:09especially when
- 39:10extremists interpret their messaging as
- 39:13we're gonna get them,
- 39:14these illegal immigrants are the worst of the worst,
- 39:17they're criminals,
- 39:18and so they're taking that messaging and they're committing acts of violence
- 39:22and then
- 39:23I want,
- 39:24I want to say that it's on a
- 39:25bigger scale,
- 39:26but there are small.
- 39:28instances where people are saying
- 39:29he looks like he's an illegal immigrant and
- 39:32they're harassing people and there's even many fights.
- 39:34Now,
- 39:35this is not on a,
- 39:35this is not a huge issue,
- 39:37but if none of that is getting denounced,
- 39:39maybe Trump is not seeing these side little issues happening,
- 39:43but if he is and he's aware
- 39:44that his messaging is that
- 39:46these illegal immigrants are the problem,
- 39:49they are dangerous,
- 39:50we need
- 39:50out by any means necessary.
- 39:52Do you feel like that he has
- 39:54any responsibility to condemn people who are taking it upon themselves
- 39:58to say,
- 39:59hey,
- 39:59I think that person's illegal
- 40:00and attack them or harass them?
- 40:02I,
- 40:02I don't think we've seen any substantial incidents
- 40:06where a private individual has confronted a man wrongly,
- 40:09accusing him of being an illegal immigrant.
- 40:11I,
- 40:11I do agree it does happen.
- 40:13There have been a few videos where there's a,
- 40:15you know,
- 40:16you'll see like a guy yelling racial slurs or something.
- 40:18And,
- 40:19you know,
- 40:19at another guy or,
- 40:20you know,
- 40:21migration-based slurs at an individual.
- 40:24But we have not had an instance,
- 40:26uh,
- 40:26uh,
- 40:26the example that I use would be,
- 40:28uh,
- 40:28Aaron Danielson's,
- 40:29uh,
- 40:29murder,
- 40:30in which a man named Michael Reinold with a Black Lives Matter tattoo on his neck,
- 40:34walked up to a Trump supporter who was minding
- 40:36his own business and shot him twice in the chest
- 40:38for no reason other than he was a Trump supporter.
- 40:40So I absolutely believe
- 40:43political leaders must condemn.
- 40:46Immediately individuals who act in accordance
- 40:49with their ideology to violent ends.
- 40:51And do you think the right has been condemning individuals like that?
- 40:55It hasn't happened.
- 40:56Maybe I'm wrong.
- 40:57I read hundreds if not thousands of articles,
- 41:00uh,
- 41:00I read hundreds of articles a day,
- 41:01maybe thousands per week,
- 41:02and there have not been any
- 41:04notable instances
- 41:06where a private right-wing individual has engaged
- 41:09in lethal force against a person wrongly
- 41:12for being,
- 41:13uh,
- 41:13uh,
- 41:13uh,
- 41:14perceived as an illegal immigrant.
- 41:15It just doesn't happen.
- 41:16And
- 41:17I think it's very easy to just say,
- 41:19it shouldn't happen,
- 41:20nobody should do it.
- 41:21And any right-leaning individual,
- 41:23nationalist,
- 41:24American conservative,
- 41:25libertarian,
- 41:25or otherwise,
- 41:26who believes for a second they should engage
- 41:28in violence against someone they think is,
- 41:29is an illegal immigrant,
- 41:30they would be wrong for doing that.
- 41:33But it's just not happening.
- 41:34And,
- 41:34and that being said,
- 41:35the amount of assassinations we see from progressives is also very small as well.
- 41:39We have a couple individuals politically targeted just in the past couple of years.
- 41:42I mean they've tried to kill Trump,
- 41:44but it's not like we are seeing people go out every day and murder individuals,
- 41:49you know,
- 41:50on strong pronounced national level issues.
- 41:53So I would just say,
- 41:54We get massive riots from left aligned progressives,
- 41:58uh,
- 41:58uh,
- 41:58you know,
- 41:59uh,
- 41:59liberals.
- 42:00We see this
- 42:01all the time,
- 42:02and on the right we don't.
- 42:04Uh,
- 42:04we don't see,
- 42:05uh,
- 42:06Dave Rubin leading marches,
- 42:08no,
- 42:08he,
- 42:09we don't see,
- 42:10uh,
- 42:10uh,
- 42:10you know,
- 42:11Steven Crowder
- 42:12organizing big rallies where people firebomb buildings or,
- 42:15or vandalize cars.
- 42:17But we see this from the left
- 42:18regularly.
- 42:19We call it riot season.
- 42:20I've covered riot season for 15 years.
- 42:22Every single year there's a riot season.
- 42:25Some kind of left aligned violent group goes out,
- 42:27and I've been documenting it for 15+ years.
- 42:31So I'd appreciate it
- 42:32if,
- 42:32uh,
- 42:33anybody who engaged in these,
- 42:34in these,
- 42:35these,
- 42:35uh,
- 42:35uh,
- 42:35these tactics would be condemned.
- 42:37But what I would argue is,
- 42:39back to the point being made by this individual,
- 42:41the best argument is that the right uses
- 42:44what would be described as legitimate democratic authority
- 42:48to empower law enforcement to engage in violence.
- 42:51That being said,
- 42:52the Democrats do the same too,
- 42:54so we can condemn all of it,
- 42:56but you can't just pick and choose which party
- 42:58at the time.
- 42:59Well,
- 42:59you also mentioned how Trump has,
- 43:02you know,
- 43:02white supremacists and ultra
- 43:04white supremacists
- 43:05backing him and supporting him and identifying with
- 43:09his movement or the MAGA,
- 43:10the MAGA movement.
- 43:11So even if they're a small minority,
- 43:14do you feel that Trump
- 43:16or Republicans have a responsibility to,
- 43:20you know,
- 43:20denounce these extremist groups that
- 43:22identify with it?
- 43:23And if they since they haven't,
- 43:25is that encouraging these?
- 43:28I haven't,
- 43:29from what I know,
- 43:29I haven't heard Trump denounce
- 43:33the KKK or these Christian white nationalist groups or the Proud Boys.
- 43:37And you do a simple YouTube search of the
- 43:39compilation of Trump denouncing white supremacy because I believe
- 43:42there's like an 1 hour and 40 minute
- 43:44compilation showing Trump repeatedly denouncing white supremacy,
- 43:47white nationalists.
- 43:48Perhaps my favorite quote of all.
- 43:50Time is,
- 43:51there are very fine people on both sides,
- 43:53and I am not talking about the neo-Nazis and
- 43:55the white nationalists because they should be condemned totally,
- 43:58which is a direct quote from Donald Trump,
- 43:59I believe it was 2017
- 44:02when he said that.
- 44:03So I want to look into this last clip,
- 44:05and it's an interaction that you had earlier
- 44:07about fascism and is Trump a fascist,
- 44:10so I want to play that back.
- 44:11I think we should just get to the heart of it.
- 44:13Donald Trump is a fascist.
- 44:15He has Nazis in his administration.
- 44:17His entire messaging
- 44:19was resonating with Nazis from the very beginning.
- 44:22Donald Trump,
- 44:23when rallying for 2024,
- 44:26had a massive rally in Madison Square Garden.
- 44:28What was the significance of that rally?
- 44:31You tell me,
- 44:31yeah,
- 44:32it's the same place,
- 44:33same date as the Nazis
- 44:35in the 1940s.
- 44:36Literally,
- 44:37um,
- 44:39Donald Trump said that,
- 44:40uh,
- 44:41immigrants are poisoning the blood of America.
- 44:44And their varmint.
- 44:45Who also said that?
- 44:47You tell me.
- 44:47Hitler.
- 44:49Literally
- 44:50Donald Trump has openly
- 44:52said things as dog whistles,
- 44:54so you may say that it's not mainstream,
- 44:56but the entire ideology of the right
- 44:59speaks to those people.
- 44:59Let me ask you,
- 45:00what,
- 45:00what do you mean by fascist,
- 45:02uh,
- 45:02far right,
- 45:03authoritarian,
- 45:04ultra nationalistic.
- 45:0514 sins of fascism,
- 45:07all that,
- 45:07but there's a specific definition of fascist.
- 45:08Do you just mean that
- 45:10he's he's an authoritarian?
- 45:11No,
- 45:12I mean that he meets all 14 tenets of fascism.
- 45:14So when Santana called Trump a fascist,
- 45:17you immediately asked him to
- 45:19define the word.
- 45:20Were you trying to clarify his argument or did you find this label to be unfair?
- 45:25Oh,
- 45:25no,
- 45:25no,
- 45:25I clarify,
- 45:27and the reason why is because there's like 3 colloquial definitions of fascist,
- 45:31and I don't want to improperly argue what he may not be arguing.
- 45:35So there's one very prominent argument that fascism
- 45:38is the lucrative merger of corporation and state.
- 45:41If that's the argument,
- 45:42you're referring to crony capitalist structures,
- 45:44which sometimes progressives do because they're anti-capitalist.
- 45:48But it seems like he was arguing something different.
- 45:50I did not quite grasp which position
- 45:53he was actually taking on,
- 45:55uh,
- 45:55what it means to be a fascist.
- 45:57One,
- 45:57argument is,
- 45:59uh,
- 45:59natio,
- 46:00you know,
- 46:00ultra-nationalist doesn't really mean anything.
- 46:01You're either a nationalist or you're not,
- 46:03it's,
- 46:03it's rather binary.
- 46:04So,
- 46:05it would be,
- 46:05uh,
- 46:06traditionalist nationalist is one definition that people use for,
- 46:10for fascism.
- 46:11So I'm,
- 46:12I'm,
- 46:12I think that might be what he's,
- 46:14he was trying to accuse
- 46:16Donald Trump of.
- 46:17I just think for the most part,
- 46:18people say fascist to mean,
- 46:20you know,
- 46:20bad guy,
- 46:21authoritarian.
- 46:22I,
- 46:23I would also add,
- 46:24uh,
- 46:24Trump did not say that immigrants are poison in the blood of America.
- 46:27I mean,
- 46:27these things are fabricated.
- 46:28He did mention
- 46:30criminal cartels,
- 46:30gang members,
- 46:31you know,
- 46:31rapists are poison in the blood.
- 46:33I think if you misinterpret his intention,
- 46:35you could try and liken him to be,
- 46:36to,
- 46:36to be like Hitler.
- 46:37I also think it's silly to claim that because he had a rally at Madison Square Garden
- 46:41on a particular date,
- 46:42it was significant because the Nazis did as well.
- 46:44I,
- 46:44I'm not gonna
- 46:45claim
- 46:46Tony Hinchcliffe is a Nazi for having a show at Madison Square Garden.
- 46:49I think that's,
- 46:51that's a silly,
- 46:52uh,
- 46:52comparison.
- 46:53Well,
- 46:54what definition of fascism do you use and
- 46:57which parts of Trump's record do you feel clearly
- 47:00fits that definition or clearly does not fit it?
- 47:04Yeah,
- 47:04I,
- 47:04I don't think it does.
- 47:05I think,
- 47:06um,
- 47:07I think the way most people try to use fascist is just going to be flat authoritarian,
- 47:11which
- 47:12just doesn't really mean much.
- 47:13But I think when you go to the next level,
- 47:15the next layer of the definition,
- 47:17it's a reference to traditionalist nationalism.
- 47:19So if you take a look at the fascists,
- 47:21which was Italy largely,
- 47:23They wanted strong national identity,
- 47:25they wanted a strong ethnic identity,
- 47:27and it was based on a traditionalist worldview,
- 47:30so
- 47:31aligning with more conservative values than progressive.
- 47:34Typically what we saw with the communists would be,
- 47:37I would describe as uh authoritarian globalist progressivism.
- 47:42People like to claim that communism on a surface,
- 47:44they'll say,
- 47:44oh,
- 47:45it's uh,
- 47:45it's,
- 47:45they want everything owned by the people,
- 47:47that's not actually
- 47:48how it's used,
- 47:50uh,
- 47:50uh,
- 47:51colloquially by people who are making the argument.
- 47:53So if you're trying to understand what
- 47:54someone is saying when they're saying fascist,
- 47:56right,
- 47:56they're saying they want,
- 47:58you know,
- 47:58marriage to be between a man and a woman.
- 48:00They're,
- 48:01they don't like LGBTQIA.
- 48:03They want secure borders,
- 48:05a strong national identity,
- 48:06and if you take that to its extreme,
- 48:09You can accuse someone of being a fascist if they
- 48:13polidify this,
- 48:14if they turn it into a party
- 48:16by which corporations adhere to the party's message with single party control.
- 48:20We don't really have that with Donald Trump,
- 48:21and,
- 48:22uh,
- 48:22Donald Trump actually is very pro H-1B,
- 48:25much to the chagrin of the conservative base and Trump's own supporters.
- 48:28He's been a big fan of,
- 48:30you know,
- 48:31he,
- 48:31he,
- 48:31he's the one who ignited Operation Warp Speed for vaccination.
- 48:34His supporters aren't big fans of that.
- 48:36So I think when you look at,
- 48:37uh,
- 48:38Trump supporters,
- 48:39I can actually,
- 48:40I'll just throw it to Vox.com,
- 48:42who wrote in 2016 that Donald Trump was the moderate candidate at the time.
- 48:46And,
- 48:47uh,
- 48:47he's often compared to Bill Clinton's policies of the 1990s.
- 48:51In fact,
- 48:51much of what Trump says about border security and illegal immigration
- 48:54is just,
- 48:55to be honest,
- 48:56a rip off from Barack Obama and,
- 48:58you know,
- 48:58Hillary and Bill Clinton going back.
- 49:00What changed in the Democratic Party,
- 49:02where their rhetoric shifted,
- 49:03I'm not entirely sure.
- 49:04But a lot of what Trump says is just 90s and 2000s Democratic Party rhetoric.
- 49:09So I,
- 49:09I don't think I would take that and claim he's a fascist,
- 49:12because if you did,
- 49:13you'd have to argue that Bill Clinton was too.
- 49:15I don't think that's true.
- 49:16OK,
- 49:17so you said that you don't remember this
- 49:19quote of Trump saying that immigrants are poisoning,
- 49:22you know,
- 49:22the blood
- 49:23of America.
- 49:25But even if you
- 49:27don't think that happened,
- 49:29do you feel like his rhetoric,
- 49:30even saying and speaking really broadly that immigrants are the violent ones,
- 49:35they're the ones committing crimes,
- 49:37do you feel like that rhetoric is dangerous and dehumanizing?
- 49:41You see,
- 49:41this is,
- 49:41this is the problem is that,
- 49:43uh,
- 49:43you know,
- 49:44specifically Donald Trump referred to MS-13 as animals.
- 49:48What we ended up getting from a variety of large corporate news outlets
- 49:51was that instead of quoting him,
- 49:54they paraphrased that Trump called immigrants animals.
- 49:57This is where this,
- 49:58this rhetoric emerges.
- 49:59If you go to Donald Trump,
- 50:01you walk up to him and look him in the face
- 50:02and say,
- 50:03how do you feel about immigrants to this country,
- 50:05he'll say they're great,
- 50:06we love our immigrants,
- 50:07we want to bring in more,
- 50:08but they got to come legally.
- 50:09In fact,
- 50:09that's a quote from Trump.
- 50:11He said at almost all of his rallies.
- 50:13What ends up happening is Trump will say,
- 50:15you've got rapists and cartel members and coyotes.
- 50:17These criminals can't be allowed in this country.
- 50:19They're animals and they're poisoning the blood of this nation.
- 50:22And I don't think any reasonable person
- 50:24would disagree that a
- 50:26child sex trafficking cartel member
- 50:29is poisoning this country
- 50:31and they should be arrested.
- 50:32It's a problem then when people for
- 50:34political reasons misrepresent what Trump said.
- 50:36The best example possible I believe was,
- 50:38would be what's now known as the very fine people hoax.
- 50:42It is remarkable.
- 50:43I had on a liberal journalist from Brooklyn.
- 50:47Uh,
- 50:47I believe this was last year,
- 50:48who still,
- 50:49after 10 years,
- 50:51did not know that Trump condemned neo-Nazis and white nationalists back in 2017.
- 50:57Because what happened was,
- 50:59when Trump said there are very fine people on both sides,
- 51:01and I am not talking about the Nazis and the white nationalists,
- 51:04because they should be condemned totally,
- 51:06media outlets cut the back portion of his quote off
- 51:09and ran a fake version
- 51:11to manipulate people into thinking
- 51:13that he was suggesting white supremacists were somehow good.
- 51:17You know,
- 51:17I,
- 51:17I would argue with many of these progressives,
- 51:18and the reason why I think it's important to come and sit down in these,
- 51:21in these debates,
- 51:22they don't
- 51:23actually know what Trump said,
- 51:25they don't actually know what I believe.
- 51:27They assume that because I voted for Donald Trump,
- 51:30I agree with everything he's done.
- 51:32I'm pro-life,
- 51:33which I'm not,
- 51:34I'm pro-flat tax,
- 51:35which I'm not,
- 51:36or that I'm anti-immigration,
- 51:37which I'm not.
- 51:38They,
- 51:39they,
- 51:39if you only follow the likes of CNN or MS now,
- 51:43You are not getting accurate representations of what Trump is actually saying.
- 51:47And don't get me wrong,
- 51:47if you're watching Fox News,
- 51:49you're getting the inverse problem.
- 51:51But I think what we see here politically,
- 51:52and we can go back to 2016,
- 51:559 million individuals
- 51:57who voted for Barack Obama
- 51:59chose to vote for Donald Trump over
- 52:01Hillary Clinton.
- 52:03I was a Bernie supporter,
- 52:04and when Bernie was iced out from the DNC,
- 52:07and it happened twice by the way,
- 52:08I said,
- 52:08well then Trump's my guy.
- 52:10I'm not gonna vote for Hillary Clinton.
- 52:11I think she's a terrible candidate.
- 52:13I think she's a warmonger,
- 52:14not that Trump's earned any Brownie points in that regard.
- 52:16But then with 2020,
- 52:17when Bernie Sanders has another opportunity and I fully backed
- 52:20the Democratic Party with maximum donations on numerous occasions,
- 52:23what did they do?
- 52:25They coordinated everyone to drop out to make sure Joe Biden got the nomination,
- 52:28and I said,
- 52:29I'm not voting for these people.
- 52:30This is not a legitimate primary process.
- 52:32I wanted
- 52:33Bernie Sanders,
- 52:34we didn't get it.
- 52:35I'm done.
- 52:36And,
- 52:36and I'll fully admit I'm not a big fan.
- 52:37of Bernie these days.
- 52:39Come 2024,
- 52:40I vote for Donald Trump because of his first term and because
- 52:42we were living under a nightmare administration
- 52:45in with,
- 52:45with Joe Biden.
- 52:47I don't think Trump has done everything perfectly these days,
- 52:50but,
- 52:50uh,
- 52:51you know,
- 52:51I,
- 52:51I think it's still the,
- 52:52the,
- 52:53it's still been the better choice.
- 52:54Overall,
- 52:55do you feel like debates like this spend too much time
- 52:59You know,
- 52:59arguing over intent and not enough time discussing the impacts of
- 53:04these kind of messages and,
- 53:06you know,
- 53:07the power that they can have.
- 53:08Well,
- 53:08look,
- 53:09one guy
- 53:10showed up with a beanie in his back pocket because I think too many of these young
- 53:14people are just trying to get notability on social media in any way that they can.
- 53:18And I don't feel that it,
- 53:20uh,
- 53:21it serves the betterment of mankind
- 53:24to just be enemies for the sake of being enemies.
- 53:27So,
- 53:27in essence,
- 53:28I would agree with you.
- 53:30Many of these conversations aren't genuinely trying
- 53:33to understand the issues at hand,
- 53:34they're just trying to clip farm
- 53:37so that it can look like they're standing
- 53:39up to a representation of what oppresses their,
- 53:42their tribe.
- 53:43We see this
- 53:44in every political group.
- 53:46You know,
- 53:46my most viral clips are when I'm debating someone and angry.
- 53:49And uh that's
- 53:510.001% of the content that I produce.
- 53:55You know,
- 53:55for instance,
- 53:55we had Brian Shapiro on several times,
- 53:58and though we disagreed,
- 53:58we were laughing the whole time.
- 54:00Cause I,
- 54:01you know,
- 54:01I,
- 54:01I've come to realize this and,
- 54:02and,
- 54:02and I,
- 54:03I agree with the assessment.
- 54:05You know,
- 54:05I'll,
- 54:05I'll get frustrated or angry when someone,
- 54:07uh,
- 54:08lies,
- 54:08misrepresents facts or otherwise,
- 54:10but I'm just sick and tired of these
- 54:13angry clips that get produced,
- 54:15you know,
- 54:15we're all angry all the time,
- 54:16and I don't feel it's actually helping any
- 54:18of us understand how to solve these problems.
- 54:21So,
- 54:22in the future,
- 54:22I'm gonna try to avoid
- 54:24instances where an individual,
- 54:25actually this,
- 54:26this happened on the show,
- 54:27when the dude began to do his performance,
- 54:29I just got out of the chair and walked off.
- 54:31Waited for him to finish and then came back and sat down.
- 54:33You wanna do a,
- 54:34a clip farming thing where you put on a beanie and then just insult me,
- 54:38do it on your own time.
- 54:39If you wanna have a conversation,
- 54:40I'm here,
- 54:40I'll sit down.
- 54:42Well,
- 54:42lastly,
- 54:43before we wrap up,
- 54:44you said that,
- 54:44you know,
- 54:45you can't only get your news from Fox,
- 54:46you can't only get it from CNN.
- 54:48Where do you recommend people getting their news and getting their information?
- 54:51Because like you said,
- 54:53a lot of it is just clickbait and just looking for,
- 54:56you know,
- 54:56vari variety.
- 54:58And so,
- 54:59where are people supposed to get their news and information that they can trust?
- 55:03That's a big challenge.
- 55:04I,
- 55:04I,
- 55:04there,
- 55:05there is no one location.
- 55:06You can't,
- 55:07you,
- 55:07you can't even just look.
- 55:09If
- 55:09someone did an analysis on my shows and found that there is a theme
- 55:14to the shows that we produce,
- 55:15the content that we cover,
- 55:16obviously,
- 55:17cause there are things that I care about and things that I don't.
- 55:19If I cared more about
- 55:21the World Cup,
- 55:22we would have produced a dozen big breaking news around the World Cup,
- 55:24but
- 55:25I'm focused on electoral politics,
- 55:26cultural issues,
- 55:28sometimes movies.
- 55:29So my recommendation for people is check out Allsides.com,
- 55:32because all they do is
- 55:34show you a story.
- 55:36And different articles from left,
- 55:38lean left,
- 55:38center,
- 55:39lean right and right.
- 55:40It's imperfect,
- 55:41because what constitutes right wing or left wing is,
- 55:43is,
- 55:43is fairly nebulous.
- 55:45But if you get your news
- 55:47through,
- 55:47uh,
- 55:48all sides,
- 55:48you can see
- 55:49when it's a left
- 55:50interpretation or a right interpretation,
- 55:52and then read them both.
- 55:54And they may that still may not guarantee you're getting accurate information.
- 55:58I,
- 55:58I like to read left,
- 55:59center,
- 55:59and right on every story to see what I may be missing.
- 56:02Uh,
- 56:03I would just stress that the difficulty for most people is,
- 56:06you know,
- 56:06every day when I'm going through the news,
- 56:07I'm actually checking source material to verify claims.
- 56:10It's not something the average person can do,
- 56:12so
- 56:13I don't even believe that there's a news service that can get it right,
- 56:15but I,
- 56:16but I think all sides,
- 56:17uh,
- 56:17gets as close as you can.
- 56:19All right,
- 56:19well,
- 56:19Tim,
- 56:20thank you so much for joining us today and thank you everyone at home for watching.
- 56:24Be sure to tune in to the next surrounded episode.