Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Putting Together An Ohio State All-Decade Team From The 1990s
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the buck Eye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony
- 0:03Gerdeman here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony?
- 0:10This is going to be a really fun show because we had a listener
- 0:13question a couple of weeks ago that was like, that shouldn't be a five
- 0:18minute conversation and a listener question show, that should be its whole show itself.
- 0:21And then we talked about it and we're like, it should be two
- 0:23shows itself. Might maybe maybe even more than two shows itself. So this
- 0:29was a great one. Isaac back and Tire asked us to put together.
- 0:31Are all ninety nineties Ohio State team? Are all two thousands Ohio State team?
- 0:36Are all twenty tens Ohio State team? And then if you combine those
- 0:40three teams and do like one big voltron of nineteen ninety through twenty nineteen Ohio
- 0:44State football, what would that team look like? Tony? I'm always willing
- 0:48to talk a little nineteen nineties Ohio State football. So this one is right
- 0:52in my whalehouse, as I'm sure it is for you as well. Oh
- 0:54yeah, and it was fun to go through and pick all of the team
- 1:00teams and the amount of names that get left off because this is you know,
- 1:06this is just eleven offensive players eleven defensive players. Now, I did
- 1:11go the extra mile and put the special teamers on their kickers, punters,
- 1:15punt returner, and kick returner. I can even go long snapper, though
- 1:19I did not do that, and I apologized to the long snappers out there.
- 1:23Did you go special teams as well? Tom Of course I did.
- 1:26I put punt gunners on there too, Did you not? Did you know?
- 1:27I thought you respected the audience, Tony, No, I did not.
- 1:30I did not do punt punt gunners. Who what I did do?
- 1:32Kicker, punter, kick turn, punt return Yes. I should also say
- 1:36we didn't discuss this beforehand, but the nineties into two thousands, I have
- 1:38a fullback. The two thousand and tens, I have a third receiver.
- 1:42Yeah. I did a fullback for the nineties, and I did two tailbacks
- 1:49for the two thousands, and then I went to three receivers for the twenty
- 1:53tens. I feel like that's cheating, but we'll get to that show.
- 1:57When we get to that show. Today, we were talking about the best
- 2:01decade of all time, the nineteen nineties, and it was the glory years
- 2:07of Ohio State football. John Cooper brought the Buckeyes back from the brink of
- 2:12rope Roustom and returned the Buckeyes to the glory of America's Team. If I
- 2:20think that's what we called them back then, it was. It was a
- 2:23good decade for America's team. Although unlike the other America's team, Ohio State
- 2:28has continue to play football into the current century, unlike unlike others in the
- 2:34DFW metroplex. Now, so let's begin. Let let's start this because again,
- 2:38my lineup is just it's eleven guys. It's not like the Pro Bowl
- 2:43where it's like your quarterback, two running backs, three receivers. Like I've
- 2:46got eleven guys on offense, eleven guys on defense. And the quarterback situation,
- 2:52I think there's an argument for two guys basically Joe Germain and Bobby Hoying.
- 2:59And I think Bobby Hoying was a two year starter, but he was
- 3:04bailed out a lot in ninety four, or actually he was almost a three
- 3:07year starter, wasn't it, because Brett Powers bailed him out in ninety three.
- 3:12Then he was okay in ninety four, and then he was really good
- 3:14ninety five. Sorry, And of course Joe Jermaine was only a one year
- 3:17starter at ninety eight, but he was the the guy in ninety six and
- 3:22ninety seven to come off the bench. With Stan Jackson given the win over
- 3:28Michigan in ninety eight to win in the Rose Ball, I went with Joe
- 3:31Jermaine. Even though Bobby Hoying has a win over Michigan in ninety four,
- 3:35I went with Joe Germain. I did as well. I think, you
- 3:38know, these are those are two quarterbacks who at the time we're putting up
- 3:42just unthinkable passing numbers for Ohio State, which now you look at it and
- 3:46it's like, wow, they passed that at Halloween again this year. But
- 3:51you know, at the time it was you know, Walt Harris coming in
- 3:53in the in the mid nineties, and you know Bobby Hoying. You know
- 3:58that ninety five seasons where really felt like ninety three they had a good year.
- 4:01They went ten one in one and and you know what, shared the
- 4:05Big Ten championship and it was like, okay, they Cooper has them going
- 4:09in the right direction. Ninety five was the first year that they looked like
- 4:11a real Juggernaut for most of the season, and you know, through eleven
- 4:16games, that was a team that just dominated everyone they played and put you
- 4:21know, put up just explosive offensive numbers. But yeah, overall, I
- 4:26think that ninety eight team when it went in doubt, you kind of go
- 4:30with the You go with the guys who had the biggest seasons and the best
- 4:33seasons on the biggest stages, and that was Joe Jermaine won the Rose Bowl
- 4:38with that big come from behind against against Arizona State. Joe Germaine won the
- 4:44Sugar Bowl with the big win over Texas A and m he beat Michigan in
- 4:48ninety eight. So yeah, I wont Joe Germaine. The only other person
- 4:51I really considered there was Michael Wiley, but I felt like he probably did
- 4:55not hit the minimum passing numbers to qualify for the team. That's a great
- 4:59point. Um certainly had the completion percentage of Tate Martellian, if you will,
- 5:04that outstanding the best throwing running back in Ohio state football history. So
- 5:10let's move to running back, and there's one Heisman Wittner Heisman Trophy winner among
- 5:15the group. I do have a very special place in my heart for Raymont
- 5:18Harris. I did also have Michael Wiley listed here because he is one of
- 5:24the top running backs of the nineties for the Buckeyes. Robert Smith, of
- 5:27course, began his career in the nineties. But the answer here is,
- 5:31Eddie George, what nineteen hundred and twenty seven yards rushing in in nineteen ninety
- 5:35five fourteen hundred yards the year before? UM ninety five rush for one hundred
- 5:42yards in every single game except for the season opener against Boston College where he
- 5:45was held to ninety seven in a comfortable Yes, yeah, and obviously could
- 5:51have had it then, but this is the the only answer here, Eddie
- 5:56George. Yeah, this is one of those things where I think, when
- 6:00you're starting to fill this stuff out, you first fill in the Heisman Trophy
- 6:03winners and go, okay, if you were the best player in college football
- 6:05in this year, then okay, you're you get it. And Ohio State
- 6:11has only had three players who qualified for that over this span Eddie George,
- 6:15Troy Smith, and Orlando Pace because I don't recognize the foolishness of the Heisman
- 6:17voters in nineteen ninety five. So you put those three in and then you
- 6:20kind of start going through the All Americans and fill some of those guys in
- 6:24and then you kind of go from there. But yeah, this was this
- 6:26was an easy one to me. Ohio State had plenty of great running backs
- 6:29in the nineteen nineties, but they only had one Heisman Trophy winner. Eddie
- 6:32George had the you know, the record for most yards in a season for
- 6:36a long time. That was, you know, a dominating a dominating season,
- 6:41ended up having a great pro career. You know that that was a
- 6:45pretty easy one for me. Now comes a very difficult one time fullback and
- 6:50this is where you know, Raymond Harris started his career at fullback. Nikki
- 6:55Suelua, Jeff Coffin, Scottie Graham is still one of my all time favorites.
- 6:58He's early ninety's running the ball at him and Carlos Snow, Matt Keller
- 7:02in the mid to late nineties. But there is just this There's there's a
- 7:08legend around Nikki Sulu and I don't know if um if I'm choosing him because
- 7:15of that legend or because he was that legend, Like has the legend grown
- 7:19since he played or was this an accurate Are we giving him an accurate portrayal
- 7:26of what he was as a fullback. I think that's a little bit of
- 7:30a legend grows because he was the first name I thought of, but then
- 7:34I kind of I had him for a minute, and then I thought,
- 7:38no, Matt Keller out of the backfield, catching all those passes like that,
- 7:42he was so good, And I ended up settling on Jeff Catherine.
- 7:46I think he's I think there's a viable defense for just about any of them.
- 7:50I think the only name we have, you know, Scotty Graham was
- 7:54dominant as well. I think there's been a good argument for him. I
- 7:57think the only nineties fullback we haven't mentioned here is Matt cal Hounds or there
- 8:00we go, and now he's completed the set. But yeah, I ended
- 8:03up going with Jeff Catherine. But I think you could make a very compelling
- 8:07case for any of about three or four guys. And I'm not really going
- 8:11to fight you on it. Yeah, it just depends do you want your
- 8:15fullback to run the ball or do you just want him to block. If
- 8:18you're going to use him in the in the offense, then Jeff Catherine would
- 8:22be a fantastic full back. I think Scotty Graham restaurbout nine hundred and thirty
- 8:26five yards one year when he was a fullback and a tailback. But I
- 8:31think he can't go wrong with with any of those guys. Now, let's
- 8:33move to receiver because we can just do this bang bang, because there are
- 8:37two answers here and if you'd like to share them with class, Terry Glenn
- 8:41and David Boston. Next question, please, the two best single season performances
- 8:50for wide receivers maybe ever. I'm, you know, just trying to think
- 8:54of recently what's been done obviously Jackson Smith and Jigba, but like back then,
- 9:00and Terry Glenn was amazing in ninety five, missed a couple of games
- 9:03in there. David Boston was the best receiver in collegehooball, I think as
- 9:07a sophomore and a junior, and was a dominated guy. So those two
- 9:11guys, that's that's the simplest thing. I think, maybe a top five
- 9:16simple answer in this entire exercise. And I think if if you went with
- 9:20three wide receivers on this team, there's a pretty simple answer for the third
- 9:24one as well. In my opinion, we're going to get to him in
- 9:28the kick returning punt returning section of this exercise. But you know, I
- 9:33think those two guys are clearly head and shoulders above some of the others.
- 9:37What's interesting to me is you have a couple of guys there who are clearly
- 9:41head and shoulders for the whole decade at twenty of the nineteen nineties. I
- 9:46think you could make a very compelling case that there are four guys from the
- 9:50twenty twenties who would be you know, at least kind of in the conversation
- 9:54with those two guys right now already, and it's only we've we've only seen
- 9:58three seasons of the tw twenties, So I think that's a good indication exactly
- 10:01how far above the historical norm Ohio State is at wide receiver right now.
- 10:07Yeah, moving to tight end again, I think this is a pretty easy
- 10:11one. I didn't really look past Ricky Dudley because he's it's a standard bearer
- 10:16that always stands out. Nineteen ninety five, the offense was amazing Ricky Dudley,
- 10:20you know, thirty some odd catches and it seems like so much more
- 10:24back then, But he was a viable weapon. It's just they're also throwing
- 10:28the ball like forty seven times to Eddie George, so like, there are
- 10:31only so many passes to go around, and they didn't throw it all over
- 10:35the place. You know, they still ran the ball pretty much sixty five
- 10:39percent at a time, I'd say sixty percent at a time. But Ricky
- 10:41Dudley, I don't know who else is John Lumpkin. Honestly, I could
- 10:46not even mentioned too many others. DJ Jones, there's just kind of no
- 10:52point, no offense, Darnell Sanders and maybe like ninety nine or something like
- 10:54that, but this is this is Ricky Dudley. Yeah. I mean,
- 11:00if you are a top ten NFL draft pick out of the tight end position
- 11:03and there's not a real obvious All American anywhere else on the list, then
- 11:09yeah, that makes it a real easy pick. And you know, he
- 11:11was the one that immediately jumped to mind. And then you can you can
- 11:13build a case around stats, you can build a case around you know,
- 11:18NFL, you know, NFL Draft spot, you can build a case around
- 11:20whatever you want, and I think you kind of end up in the same
- 11:22place. And yeah, that that was definitely Ricky Dudley. So now again
- 11:26we can just go ahead and knock two out here. Let's go with the
- 11:30tackles and what I what the way I did it? I did go left
- 11:33tackle, left guard, center right. I didn't just go like two tackles,
- 11:35two guards. I'm talking, we're playing your position. If I'm going
- 11:39to call on you to play my right tackle, yeah, you can't have
- 11:43been a left tackle. I need you to be a right tackle. And
- 11:45so it's a Orlando Pace and it's Quary Stringer that that's and honestly, put
- 11:52them on every other team as well, and just just go from there and
- 11:54you're going to be fine. Orlando Pace, they the best Ohio State football
- 12:00player of all time, the best player in college football history, Corey Stringer
- 12:03maybe maybe arguably that the second best offensive tackle in Ohio state history. There
- 12:07obviously some other you know, John Hicks and things like that, but a
- 12:11top five tackle in Ohios to history, I think. And so you put
- 12:13those two together in boom, you're set. Yep, that was a real
- 12:16easy one as well. That was you know, Orlando Pace was the absolute
- 12:20free space on the Bengo card and Corey Stringer was again a just incredibly talented
- 12:24He probably gets a little overshadowed because he was. He shared the field with
- 12:30Orlando Pace during his final season, and then you know, Orlando Pace then,
- 12:33you know, exceeded everything he did immediately, where you know, he's
- 12:37a little bit you know, you know, you just kind of get you
- 12:39kind of don't appreciate him because he wasn't the greatest at that position for that
- 12:45long of a period. He's not remembered as the greatest at tackle because he
- 12:48was immediately uh, you know, succeeded by Orlando Pace. But yeah,
- 12:52I think those two guys are both very very easy choices that the two tackle
- 12:56spots. Then the last easy answer here for me, left guard is Rob
- 13:01Murphy, All American, maybe two time All American, and so I feel
- 13:05like that one is pretty set. Center and right guard center. I think
- 13:15you've got two answers here because you got two three year starters. Well,
- 13:18I went with or did you have the ninety nine I went with Now,
- 13:22I didn't go in nineteen ninety nine, and I thought about it, but
- 13:26you know that that was you know, nineteen ninety nine would have been Lea
- 13:28Charles Bentley, and but he wasn't necessarily quite as dominant that year as he
- 13:35was, you know in two thousands. So I ended up going with Dan
- 13:39Baity. He was All Conference in nineteen ninety but he's that's honestly before I
- 13:43really started watching Ohio State football. So I kind of defaulted to, well,
- 13:48here's what the awards voters said. So, okay, I will I
- 13:50will trust your judgment there, but I mean, there are other viable options
- 13:56there. But there is definitely not a clear cut answer there. The way
- 13:58they were was at the other the first three spots, no, And I'm
- 14:01just looking at the OsO starters by year, and at ninety nine they actually
- 14:05have LeCharles Bentley at guard and Kurt Murphy his third third year at center,
- 14:09and so he had wand Porter as a three year starter, Kurt Murphy as
- 14:13a three year starter. This was not an easy one. And whoever you
- 14:18want to take, I'm I'm not going to pound a table for anybody thought.
- 14:20Juan Porter was very very solid though in the mid nineties with Orlando Pace
- 14:26and and um Corey Stringer. So that's where I went right guard again.
- 14:33Ben Gilbert Lashaw Daniels is basically the two guys that I'm trying to choose from.
- 14:37And I had Jason I hate Jason win Roe in the mix as well.
- 14:43Um, and I couldn't swear to you that he played right guard instead
- 14:46of left guard. I think he did, but you know, he's someone
- 14:48who got drafted by the Giants and was it was. It was a solid
- 14:52player, but not all American or anything like that. So I would be
- 14:58fine and with any of those choices, maybe maybe Lashawn Daniels. Maybe,
- 15:05but again, I'm not gonna kick in the scream if you pick one of
- 15:09the other ones. Well in time, I just gotta break this to you.
- 15:13In nineteen ninety three it's listed Jason Winrow as a left guard, So
- 15:16all right, well then I'm gonna go with Leshan Daniels. Then. So
- 15:20now we moved to defense where I went, and this is how I've done
- 15:28it in the nineties. I went for you know, two defense ends,
- 15:31two defensive ends, two defensive tackles, three linebackers, two corners, and
- 15:35two safeties. I have not moved into any hybridization at this point, but
- 15:37we can go ahead my defensive ends, and I just I just went with
- 15:43the defensive ends. I went to college with Mike Rabel and Matt Finkus,
- 15:48and you're leaving some serious, some pretty good names on the table, when
- 15:54when you just go with those two, which I have, like Jason Simmons
- 15:58was at one point the all time sax leader for Meg Vrabel, Alonzo Spellman,
- 16:03Rodney Bailey is beneath those, is below those those those guys, but
- 16:07um, and then what could have been with Jason Gwinn, you know,
- 16:11something like that. But I went with Rabel and Fincas. I went with
- 16:15Rabel and Jason Simmons just because Simmons was, as you said that, you
- 16:18know that the all time sack leader and he's still very very high and a
- 16:22lot of those lists. If you look at the OSU record book, he's
- 16:25another guy who was just like a little before I started really paying attention to
- 16:29Oestate football, So that was not not someone I have a memory of,
- 16:33but he's if you go through the record book, it's like, well,
- 16:36this guy was obviously extremely good at what he did. So, you know,
- 16:38I think there's a perfectly viable argument to make think us the other guy.
- 16:44But yeah, I think you've got to kind of if you were the
- 16:47if you were the guy who was setting all the records when you were playing,
- 16:49I think you're probably got to be you know, got to be in
- 16:52that conversation. So, yeah, Frabel and Simmons were the defense vans for
- 16:56me. Yeah, I have no problem with that at all because like Mike
- 17:00Rabel was the new Jason Simmons basically. Um so then defensive tackle. This
- 17:07is very easy with big Daddy, and I didn't go maybe I did a
- 17:15nose tackle three tech. I just went two defensive tackles. So you throw
- 17:18Dan Wilkinson in there. My other guy is Ryan Pickett. I did the
- 17:25same thing. Okay, he was he was. He was I don't want
- 17:29to say the poor man's big Daddy, but he had moments where he was
- 17:32very a dominating player, a very quick guy for being such a big guy.
- 17:37And I knew Luke Fickle was a four year starter at nose tackle.
- 17:40I argue that Greg Smith earlier than just a couple of years before Luke Fickle
- 17:45was maybe more disruptive than Fickle Pickle. I don't think it was ever an
- 17:48all Big ten player. Greg Smith, I think was. But to me,
- 17:52this is Dan, Dan Wilkinson and Ryan Pickett and I did the same
- 17:56thing. And Pickett had nine tackles for loss in two in nineteen ninety nine,
- 18:00So Yeah, it felt like that was a, you know, enough
- 18:03of a defensible choice because he was he ended up getting drafted in the twenty
- 18:06two thousand and one NFL draft because he had another year after that, but
- 18:10really had a really really good year on a very very forgettable nineteen ninety nine
- 18:14Ohio State team and was a first round pick for the Rams. And you
- 18:18know, I think he's someone who you could you could certainly make an argument
- 18:22for Fickle just based on career longevity, just because of I mean, he
- 18:26was a very very good player for a very long time for Ohio State,
- 18:30but was not an All American, was not a first round draft pick anything
- 18:34like that. So I'm not gonna I'm not gonna fight you if you want
- 18:38to put Luke Fickle on that team. But I'm I'm going with I'm with
- 18:42you. I went with Ryan Pickett, and I thought that was gonna be
- 18:45one where you went, oh really, but no, Apparently apparently it is
- 18:49a the safe conservative choice. Yes, uh no, Tom, it's bold.
- 18:56If we both agree on it, we can make it bold. Oh
- 18:59there you go. Yeah, three points Ryan Pickett. The linebackers here and
- 19:10spanning the decade of the ninety there aren't a lot, but there's more than
- 19:15three. But is there a big three? I don't know. I think
- 19:19there's I think there's a big two. And I'll give you my first one
- 19:23because he was three time All Big ten and a two time All American,
- 19:26and that's Steve Tovar and big number fifty eight was a very very good player
- 19:33for the Buck guys. I think I think he got got got to Ohio
- 19:37State when Ohio State was still playing like a three four and then became a
- 19:40four three middle linebacker. But that was my first guy. I know a
- 19:45lot of other people are going to chime in with a nineteen ninety six freshman
- 19:48here in time, if you would like to go ahead, but I went
- 19:52with Steve Tobar was my first linebacker just because of the accolades. Yeah,
- 19:55and Steve, you know you're a multi time All American. You're probably going
- 19:59to be on this teams. Yes, I had him on there as well,
- 20:02nineteen ninety six freshman, Yes, Michael Wiley, Yes, No,
- 20:04it's Andy Katzenmoyer. This was another easy one for me. I think if
- 20:08you ask, if you just ask the random Ohio State fan on the street,
- 20:12who was the best Ohio State linebacker in the nineteen nineties, they're going
- 20:15to say Andy Katzenmoyer, and he was a combination of production but also hype,
- 20:22but also backed it up on the field. He you know, he
- 20:25had the know. He came to Ohio State in ninety six as a true
- 20:27freshman. They put him at middle linebacker, and you know, Greg Belisari
- 20:33I think at times was just basically like pointing him and just saying, go
- 20:36hit that guy, and and he did. And he you know, he
- 20:38didn't have time to really get up to speed on everything before they threw him
- 20:41out there, but he was still extremely effective as a true freshman in that
- 20:45role and then just kind of continued to be a dominant player after that.
- 20:49I think everyone remembers the the Corby Jones hit from the Missouri game and all
- 20:53that. But he was you know, he was on the cover of Sports
- 20:56Illustrated when the question was was he going to be was he going to be
- 21:00able to pass all his classes to play the games because he was such a
- 21:03big part of what was the dominant nineteen ninety eight Ohio State team. So
- 21:07yeah, he is a I think he's an easy inclusion here as well.
- 21:12The third one Tony for me at least, was someone who only ended up
- 21:17at Ohio State because someone else couldn't send it facts correctly. How about you?
- 21:21That's that is my third one. I just want to get back to
- 21:23Andy Kattimore for one second. Just go over some freshman numbers. Okay,
- 21:27five tackles for loss in the Rose Bowl, three sacks in that game.
- 21:32His freshman year, he finished with twelve sacks, which is still tied for
- 21:36fifth all time. He had twenty three tackles for loss in nineteen ninety six
- 21:41as a true freshman. I don't even know how many tackles he had that
- 21:45year, but it was I think it was around ninety or so. But
- 21:49that's just I mean it was. It was incredible and if you're too young
- 21:55to have witnessed any of that, I mean he was overnight a superstar.
- 22:02They were there was I think he was the first buck Eye. I remember
- 22:04people talking about should he just he would be the number one draft pick this
- 22:07year? And then you know, he ends up he was eventually a first
- 22:11rounder, but um, some neck injuries and he just kept getting bigger and
- 22:15pickers a sophomore and junior. But that freshman year there there was. It
- 22:19was just incredible. So yes, my third linebacker Tom like you Nil Diggs,
- 22:27and I I feel like he got overshadowed by LeVar Arrington who was around
- 22:34the same time making incredible plays. Nile Diggs would also make some great plays.
- 22:38I think Nil Diggs was a first team All American at least once.
- 22:44Um. I do want to give a shout out to Lorenzo Styles, Craig
- 22:47Powell, other guys, but the three here, I think, um,
- 22:49those three are are pretty set. And Nile Diggs was. He played some
- 22:53defensive endor early in his career, Like he could have played anywhere on the
- 22:56defensive, you know, and any of the linebacker position. He was a
- 23:00really, really talented athlete. Yeah, he was someone who, like you
- 23:04said, I think he the fact that he was, you know, towards
- 23:07the end of his career, that was some of those like the nine.
- 23:11Wasn't nineteen ninety nine one of his last seasons. I believe it was,
- 23:14And you know, like nineteen ninety nine and those teams just sort of get
- 23:18forgotten because you remember the ninety six team, you remember the ninety five team,
- 23:22you remember the ninety eight team. You might you know, the ninety
- 23:23seven team is kind of in the conversation as well. But you know,
- 23:26ninety nine, two thousand, those teams just kind of get forgotten because they
- 23:30weren't they didn't do anything memorable. They didn't, you know, pull the
- 23:33shocking win over Michigan like the two thousand and one team did or the ninety
- 23:37four team did. They didn't win the Big Ten. They didn't, you
- 23:40know, and the standard had, right, it had risen enough at that
- 23:42point that those were like grossly unacceptable seasons to Ohio State fans and people probably
- 23:48kind of pulled the rip cord halfway through the season. But yeah, there
- 23:52were some really outstanding individual performances on those teams. And I'd put Nile Diggs
- 23:56right at right at the top of those lists because I think he was he
- 24:00get picked by the Packers. Was he a first round pick? I think
- 24:02I think he ended up being like a second or third rounder actually, and
- 24:06then he stuck with him for a little while. Yeah. And then I
- 24:08mean you mentioned Craig Powell. Craig Powell I think was a first round pick
- 24:11for the Browns. I mean, there's there were some really talented linebackers on
- 24:15those those teams. Yeah, I went with nil days ahead of the other
- 24:18guys, and maybe the best of all would have been Rodell Dupree, but
- 24:22he just couldn't just couldn't stay in school. Well, and Preston Harrison too.
- 24:26Preston Harrison was recruited as a quarterback. They moved him to defense and
- 24:30he was someone who just he got picked by the Chargers like shockingly early second
- 24:37third round something like that, just based on just the absolute freak athleticism,
- 24:41but just couldn't stay healthy. He had just like a series of injuries that
- 24:45kept him off the field. And you know, he's another one of those
- 24:48great what ifs for Ohio State. Now, if they were going to play
- 24:52some hybrid, I might go with the name here that might just be a
- 24:55little before your time, Tom Roger Harper who um big six foot three,
- 25:00two hundred and twenty pound two hundred and twenty five pound safety, whom would
- 25:04be you know, like a star type of position. Um. But let's
- 25:10move to corner now, because they're there are a lot of corners, but
- 25:15they are I think there are two two correct answers here, the arguably the
- 25:18two greatest cornerbacks in Ohio State football history. Tom, they are Sean Springs
- 25:23and Antoine Winfield. And I know Antoine Winfield is a personal favorite for you.
- 25:27John Springs was the third overall pick to the Seahawks and the ninety what
- 25:32seven draft. I mean, that's those are those are two players who were
- 25:36just you know, you could you could, you could list a bunch of
- 25:38really good corners at Ohio State over that decade, but there were there were
- 25:44two that this was These were two of the ones that I filled in first
- 25:45because it was like, well, you're not You're not going to beat these
- 25:48two. So you know, if you want to, if you want to
- 25:51time travel and put a you know, put a Nickel out there or something,
- 25:53and that's fine. We could we could add someone else out there.
- 25:56But yeah, those those were two very easy ones to me. Well,
- 26:00and you say Nicol like Nate Clements started his career as Nicol Sodfield, you
- 26:03know they were they were Nichols. Nate Clements a first rounder. I'm at
- 26:07Plumber a first rounder, Ty Howard a second rounder, the coast the starter
- 26:11next to Antoine Winfield when those guys were playing. So there's some other good
- 26:15guys there. Safety is interesting, I think, I mean Damon Moore is
- 26:19the that's the first answer. Yeah, yes, and he was. I
- 26:26think I believe he was an All American at least one year and was a
- 26:30playmaker and uh intercept passes and tackling, was a big hitter. Tom.
- 26:37Who is your second safety? I tried to split this into strong and free
- 26:41safety, and I had two names down and I don't feel particularly strongly about
- 26:48either one. Can I gets him? Sure? Gary Berry and Rob Kelly.
- 26:53I had Gary Berry and Walter Taylor. Walter Taylor was someone who and
- 26:57he's he's again like earlier, so I kind of I'm reading up on Walter
- 27:00Taylor and he sounded impressive. But you know, Rob Kelly was Rob Kelly
- 27:07is one of the first people I think of a Newark Catholic star. Rob
- 27:11Kelly who ended up you know it was a real, real big hitter and
- 27:15has had a has had some health issues I think as a result that that
- 27:21have been reported as a result of being a big hitter. But yeah,
- 27:25he I think was someone who a lot of people will probably think of there.
- 27:30But yeah, this is this is one where I think I would accept
- 27:34any of those three answers and not really give you any brief about it.
- 27:38Yeah. I also had Chico Nelson, who was a three year starter,
- 27:41but more of a strong safety kind of guy I think is what he played.
- 27:44Roger Harper again but also a big guy. So if you want to
- 27:48throw Gary Berry out there, he was a three year starter, never quite
- 27:51lived up to the five star hype, but was still pretty solid kicker and
- 27:56punter. Tom. I went with Dan Stults and Brent Bartholomew. Bartholomey is
- 28:00the all time putting yardage leader at Ohio States. Dan Stults was I maybe
- 28:06maybe you would just disagree, but I think he was the most he was
- 28:11the most, the most productive and and the best of the nineties kickers.
- 28:15And I don't know that it was a great decade for Ohio State kickers,
- 28:18but he was productive. Yeah. I went with Tim Williams and Brent Bartholomy.
- 28:22Tim Williams, like the first year early followed Ohio State football was nineteen
- 28:25ninety three, and I just remember Tim Williams just feeling just automatic when he
- 28:29was out there. Stults, I don't, I mean Stults I think missed.
- 28:33Maybe maybe this is just my memory being unfair to him, but I
- 28:37just I don't remember feeling as confident in him as I did in Tim Williams
- 28:41when he was out there. But you know, multi year starter, very
- 28:45good kicker, I don't you know. I think that's uh. The thing
- 28:49I remember most about Dan Stults is his extremely enthusiastic celebrations after kicks, which
- 28:56I think would go over great in the Twitter era. But yeah, he
- 28:59was he was someone who like he was a little bit of a character,
- 29:02but yeah, he was a very very solid kicker as well. I do
- 29:04also remember somebody from that special team's unit saying he was the head case.
- 29:08But it's like, isn't that all kickers? Um kick return punt return I
- 29:15went with Joey Galloway as my kickoff returner because he's got to be somewhere on
- 29:19this team of the nineties. I well, David Boston is mad punt returner.
- 29:22He I think it is. He still the all time punt returning yardage
- 29:26leader at Ohio State. I kind of forgot about that, but obviously he
- 29:30returned to punt with eight guys on the field against Pitt Was it was a
- 29:34pretty dangerous returner. Aside from that, as Andy, he kept doing it
- 29:40year after year for a couple of years there, But Joey Galloway. I
- 29:42got to put him somewhere. He was a dangerous returner in the in the
- 29:47nineties, and that's what I've got. Yeah, I had Joey Galloway as
- 29:51my kick returner. I actually had Joey Galloways my punt returner too. But
- 29:55I think you've talked me into David Boston. He is still the punt return
- 29:57career yardage leader ninety eight returns, nine hundred and fifty nine yards um.
- 30:03You know, he's he's a I think he's he's a really, really good
- 30:08underappreciated That was a big and underappreciated part of his game. It's also one
- 30:14of those things where you know, that's a lot of punt returns for a
- 30:17guy who's also your number one receiver. I don't think that's I don't think
- 30:19that's a guy who would be returning punts for multiple years now, with the
- 30:22game being the way it is. He finished with two career touchdowns on punt
- 30:26returns. I don't remember the second one. Do you remember the second one?
- 30:32No, I don't the first one. The first one is obviously the
- 30:37pit nineteen ninety six one at the end of the seventy two nothing game where
- 30:41they had eight guys on the field, like you mentioned, but I don't
- 30:44remember the second one. But you know, he's he's someone who you know
- 30:48he was. He was so dominant as a receiver that I think the punt
- 30:52return piece of his game kind of gets a little bit overlooked. And Galloway
- 30:56Galloway, I think Gallowe is one of those guys who might be on this
- 31:00team if he was playing with better quarterbacks during the time he was there.
- 31:03You know, you put Joey Galloway on that nineteen ninety five team. You
- 31:07know, he was another top he was. He went to the Seahawks as
- 31:10I think at top ten pick in that ninety five draft, yet number eight.
- 31:12So and that that ninety five draft, you put him on that ninety
- 31:17five Ohio state team across from Terry Glenn, like what does what does that
- 31:22look like? Good? Good luck defending that. But instead he was on
- 31:26that ninety four team with you know, the sophomore Bobby Hoying or I guess
- 31:30with second second year starting Bobby Hoying and that ninety three team where they kind
- 31:36of yo yoed back and forth between Brett Powers and and Bobby Hoying and Galloway
- 31:41missed time. He had something where he sat out that ninety four season oper
- 31:45against Fresno State with you know, something that wouldn't even be remotely illegal today,
- 31:48but was an extremely big deal then, like you know, taking seventeen
- 31:52dollars from an agent or something stupid like that. So you know it.
- 31:56You know, he's someone who you put him much like you'd love to see
- 32:00Ted Ginn on at you know, on a Ryan Day passing offense. You
- 32:05know, Ted Ginn and Santonio Holmes put those guys on a on a Ryan
- 32:08Day offense. I'd love to see Joey Galloway on a Ryan Day offense.
- 32:12Yeah, he's usually my number one pick. In terms of who would you
- 32:15like to see in the modern day, I will say Kenyon Rambo led led
- 32:19them. And he's the second all time leading kickoff return yardage guy. And
- 32:23and yet four other guys in the nineties return kickoff for touchdowns for Ohio State.
- 32:30Can you name them? As we're trying to wrap up the show,
- 32:32oh boy kickoff returns for touchdowns in the nineteen nineties, Well, I know
- 32:37Sean Springs did it in the Boston College game in nineteen ninety six. That
- 32:40the ninety five that's the first Ohio State game I ever saw in person,
- 32:43and the meadow Lands in New Jersey. Uh, let's see other kickoff returns
- 32:49in the nineties. Oh boy, it has been a minute since I've had
- 32:52to think about a lot of these plays. Um boy, Jonathan Wills almost
- 32:59did it against Michigan in nineteen ninety nine, and then they got zero points
- 33:01out of the drive. How did that season go? Well? There,
- 33:04I just told you. Did Robert Smith do it at some point? No?
- 33:12All right? Um, did Terry Glenn do it at some point?
- 33:17Nope? Not according to not according to the OSCE records books. By the
- 33:21way, when you ask me these questions, what do they know, You're
- 33:23gonna have to You're just gonna have to be I have I have no specific
- 33:27memory of any kickoff return for a touchdown and then nineteen nineties, other than
- 33:30the Sean Springs won against Boston College, So help me out. Michael Wiley
- 33:35and ninety seven had one against Bowling Green, Joey Galloway nineteen ninety four at
- 33:39Indiana, Butler Benotte nineteen ninety three at pitt Yeah, so I think My
- 33:45big takeaway with from there was Ohio State did not have any kickoff returns in
- 33:50any games that were in doubt beyond about the second quarter is probably my big
- 33:53takeaway there. All right, So there you go. Our a team of
- 33:58the nineties. I think it's a pretty good squad. If you want to
- 34:01share your own thoughts, feel free to hit us up. Find us on
- 34:05Twitter, find us at bucket Huddle, yell at us on the message board,
- 34:08leave a comment, leave a five star rating review on this podcast,
- 34:13and then go ahead and click the like on this video if you're watching it
- 34:15on YouTube, So that will do it for us. Want to thank you
- 34:19all for joining us, and we'll talk to you guys later.